2017 brooklynk year-end report final · 2017 final report rebecca gilgen executive director the...

54
BrookLynk Youth Employment Program 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Luis Salado-Herrera BrookLynk Youth Employment Coordinator Jolene Rotich BrookLynk Youth Outreach Specialist September 29, 2017

Upload: others

Post on 21-May-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynk Youth Employment Program

2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Luis Salado-Herrera BrookLynk Youth Employment Coordinator Jolene Rotich BrookLynk Youth Outreach Specialist September 29, 2017

Page 2: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 2

TableofContentsExecutiveSummary……………………………………………………………………………3Introduction………………………………………………………………………………….……7

Background……………………………………………………………………………………7ProgramDescription………………………………………………………………………7ProgramGoals………………………………………………………………………………..8ProjectDescription…………………………………………………………………………8ProjectGoals…………………………………………………………………………………...8ResearchFrameworkforBuildingPathwaystoCollege&Career………9

EvaluationPurpose………………………………………………………………...………….9CoreEvaluationQuestions…………………………………………………………………10EvaluationMethods……………………………………………………………………………10Results………………………………………………………………………………………………..11

YouthParticipation…………………………………………………………………………11 YouthOutreach…………………………………………………………………………12WorkReadinessTraining………………………………………………………..…14InternshipsandCheck-ins…………………………………………………………15YouthJobFair…………………………………………………………………………...15

CommunityParticipation………………………………………………………………..16QualityAssessment……………………………………………………………………….. 19YouthOutcomes……………………………………………………………………………..21

CareerSkills……………………………………………………………………………..22Finances………………………………………………………………………………… 23SocialNetworks……………………………………………………………………… 24InternCustomerSatisfaction…………………………………………………… 24Long-termOutcomes…………………………………………………………………27

BusinessOutcomes…………………………………………………………………………28CapacityBuilding……………………………………………………………………………30

DegreeofSupports……………………………………………………………………30ProgramCost……………………………………………………………………………32PoliticalWill…………………………………………………………………….…….…33

ProcessEvaluation…………………………………………………………………..….… 34ProgramDevelopment………………………………………………………..….…34Outreach…………………………………………………………………………….….…35WorkReadinessTraining……………………………………………………….…37Matching……………………………………………………………………………….…38YouthJobFair…………………………………………………………………………..40InterviewsandOnboarding………………………………………………………43Internships……………………………………………………………………………....45Check-insandEnrichmentOpportunities…………………………………. 47Celebration………………………………………………………………………………49Evaluation……………………………………………………………………………… 50

Discussion………………………………………………………………………………………….51NextEvaluationQuestions…………………………………………………………….. 51RecommendationsforImprovingBrookLynk…………………………………. 52

FurtherInformation………………………………………………………………….……... 54Appendix……………………………………………………………………………………..……. 54

Page 3: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 3

2017BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramFinalReportExecutiveSummary

DATE: September29,2017TO: AllianceBoardofDirectorsSteeringCommittee BrookLynkFundingPartnersFROM: RebeccaGilgen–ExecutiveDirector

IvanLui–DataandQualityCoordinatorLuisSalado-Herrera–YouthEmploymentCoordinatorJoleneRotich–BrookLynkSpecialist

ExecutiveSummaryInNovemberof2014theBrooklynBridgeAllianceforYouthBoardofDirectorsapprovedthelaunchofa2-yearprojectwithtwogoals:1)CustomizetheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodelforthecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkand2)BuildcapacityamongsttheAlliancepartnerstosustainthisprogram.ThefollowingisacomprehensiveinternalevaluationofboththeBrookLynkprogramandcapacitybuildingeffortsfromthissecondyearofimplementation.DataindicatethatinYear3,continuedcustomizationoftheSTEP-UPprogrammodelhasbeensuccessfulandthatlocalcapacityforoperatingtheprogramattheCityofBrooklynParkandCityofBrooklynCenterhasbeenbuilt.Whatfollowsisasummaryofresultsfromthetwomajorgoalareas1)Programimplementationand2)Capacity-buildingactivities.ProgramResultsSummaryThesuccessofBrookLynkhingesonparticipationfromemployersandyouth.Inthethirdyeartheprogramwasclosetoreachingparticipationgoals.Additionaldataonprogramqualityandtheimpactonparticipantssuggestthatwhilethereareareasforprogramqualitytoimprove,bothemployersandyouthwerepositivelyimpacted.YouthParticipationBrookLynkservesyouth14-21wholiveorgotoschoolintheBrooklyns,haveatleastonebarriertoemployment,and/orareOpportunityYouth(outofmainstreamschoolorcountyinvolvedyouth).

• 529youthappliedforGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining• 189youthcompletedtheGetReady!training,whichisa39%increasefrom2015.• 104youthwerematchedtointernshipsand96begansummerinternship

opportunities.Thisyear’sgoalwas100.• 91youthcompletedtheentiresummerinternship(a95%completionrate).

92%ofsupervisorswouldparticipatein

BrookLynkagain

99%ofinternswouldrecommendBrookLynktoa

friend

Page 4: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 4

CommunityParticipationTherewere14education,business,andcommunitypartnerswhoofferedinternshipsandsupervisors/employmentmentorsforyouth.BusinessPartners

• AllenPropertyServices,LLC• Amplifon,Inc.• BostonScientific• CumminsPowerGeneration• ToplineFederalCreditUnion

EducationPartners

• Anoka-HennepinAreaSchools• BrooklynCenterCommunity

Schools• HennepinTechnicalCollege• NorthHennepinCommunityCollege• OsseoAreaSchools• RobbinsdaleAreaSchools

CommunityPartners

• HennepinCountyo BrooklynParkLibraryo CenterofInnovationand

Excellenceo HumanServicesandPublic

HealthDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment

CommunityPartners(continued)

• CityofBrooklynParko CommunityDevelopment

Departmento CommunityEngagement

Departmento InformationTechnology

Departmento OperationsandMaintenance

Departmento PoliceDepartmento RecreationandParksDepartment,

YouthServices• CityofBrooklynCenter

o AdministrationandOfficeoftheClerk

o BuildingandCommunityStandardsDepartment

o BusinessandDevelopmentDepartment

o CommunityActivities,Recreation&Services

o FinanceDepartmento FireDepartmento PoliceDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment

QualityAssessmentTheYouthProgramQualityAssessment(PQA)®avalidatedyouthprogramqualityinternal-assessmentwascompletedduringoneoftheworkreadinesstrainings.Intheassessmentofthetraining,theprogramscoredhigheralldomainsduetochangesmadetothedesignanddelivery.InternshipswerealsoassessedusinganInternshipQualityAssessment,andscoresremainedhighinallofthedomains.YouthOutcomesParticipatingyouthgainedworkreadinessandsocial-emotionallearningskills,financialbenefits,andsocialconnections.Themajorityofyouthweresatisfiedwiththeirinternshipexperiences.

• 99%ofinternswouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend• 86%ofinternsagreedthattheyreceivedenoughtrainingandsupportto

successfullycompletetheirinternships• 77%ofinternsstatedthattheirinternshiphelpedthemincreasethenumberof

professionalsintheirsocialnetwork

Page 5: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 5

• InternsratedtheBrookLynkprogram4.3outof5(1beingpoor,5beingexcellent)

• Internsratedsupervisors4.5outof5(1beingpoor,5beingexcellent)

• 76%ofinternswereratedbytheirsupervisorsashavinggainedall14assessedcareerskills

• Themedianinternshipsalarywas$2400• Alumnifromtheyears2015and2016whoresponded

toourrequestforanupdateontheirlifesuccesswelearnedthat:

o 96%ofeligibleseniorsgraduatedo 88%ofthosethatgraduatedwillbeincollegeo 87%wereemployedthissummer

BusinessOutcomesEmployersweresatisfiedwiththeprogramandtheirintern(s).

• 92%ofsupervisorswouldliketoparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramagain• Over92%ofsupervisorsreportedthattheyweresatisfiedwiththesupportthey

receivedfromBrookLynk• 82%statedthattheirinternsweregoodmatchesfortheirorganizations• 81%ofsupervisorsreportedthattheirinternsmetorexceededtheirexpectations

ofjobresponsibilitiesandworkload• 68%ofsupervisorsrespondedthattheirinternswerethebestpartoftheir

internshipexperiencesCapacityBuildingResultsSummaryCapacitybuildingwasmeasuredbyidentifyingprogramcosts,assessingthedegreeofsuccessincustomizingMinneapolisSTEP-UPandidentifyingthesupportsBrookLynkwillneedtooperatelong-termembeddedwithinourcitypartnersorganizations.ResultsindicatethatthedegreeofsupportforBrookLynkishigh.BrookLynkimplementedtwokeychangestotheSTEP-UPmodelthathadapositiveeffectonprogramoutcomes1)Weeklyinterncheck-insand2)IntegratingMeasuresofHumanAchievement(MHA)asharedframeworkfor21stCenturyskill-building.DegreeofSupports

• Thedegreeofsupportfromemployerswashigh.Therewasincredibleinterestfromthebusinesscommunity:BrookLynkwasabletosecure106internships,whichis6overourgoalof100forYear3.

• Alliancefacilitatedahighdegreeofsupportfromcommunitypartners.Threedozenorganizationsprovided:

o In-kinddonations:useoffacilities,vanandbustransportation,andmarketingandprintingsupport

o Volunteers:financialliteracyandpublictransitworkshops,interviewsforthemockinterview,workreadinessandjobfairworkshoptrainers

o Funding:hiringaBrookLynkSpecialisttomanageReferralPartners,implementtheYouthJobFair,andlaunchanAlumniNetworkandJobBoard

“Sheprovidedneweyesandafreshperspective.Herquestionsledstaff

workingwithhertothinkinanewwayabouthowwedowhatwedo.”

Page 6: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 6

ProgramCosts• Theprogramcostsnecessarytooperatetheprogramareprimarilyrelatedtostaff

whocoordinatetheprogramandstrategicoversight/dailymanagement.• Astheprogramdoubledinyouthserved,thebudgetalsoexpandedtohirea2ndFTE.• TheBrookLynkmulti-yearbudgethasbeencreatedandwasacriticalstepin

creatingthecooperationagreement.PoliticalWill

• ThecooperationagreementtotransitionBrookLynktotheCitiesin2018isanimportantindicationthatpoliticalwillishighamongourpartners,andthattheprimarygoalofbuildingcapacityhasbeenreached.

• TheAllianceprovidedaplaceforBrookLynktogrowthispoliticalwill.ThisismeasuredbythreeyearsofcontinuousaffirmationfromyouthandemployerswhoexpresscontinuedinterestandneedforBrookLynk.

ProgramCustomization

• BrookLynkdevelopedacustomizedlogicmodel,programprocessmapandacomprehensiveevaluationplanforeachyearoftheincubationprocess.

• TheReferralPartnerprogramwaslaunchedwithschoolandorganizationalpartnerstorecruitandsupportmorestudentsfromtargetpopulations.

• TheGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainingandSupervisorTrainingwerebothredesignedandimprovedthequalityandimpactofboth.

• Thematchingprocesswasscaledandcontinuedtobesuccessfulforover100internsmatchedtointernships.Nearly82%ofthesupervisorsagreedtheirinternwasagoodmatch.

• TheYouthJobFairdidnotmeetthegoalsofgettingyoungeryouthemployedattheevent.Itwillberedesignednextyeartobettermatchjobseekerswithlocaljobs.

• Theweeklycheck-ins,andcollegeandcareersitevisitswerecontinuedduringtheinternship.Throughtheseevents,internsreportedasenseofbelongingandmutualsupport,theopportunitytoshareandreflectontheirexperiences,discusssolutionstoproblemstheywerefacing,andworkonimprovingcareerskills.

SummaryResultsindicatesignificantprogresshasbeenmadeincustomizingSTEP-UPfortheBrooklynsandinbuildingcapacitytosustainBrookLynk,especiallyasevidencedbythetransitionoftheprogramtotheCitiesinJanuaryof2018.Thenextstepsinevaluatingthisprogramincludebetterunderstanding(1)whatspecificcharacteristicsofsupervisorsleadtoahigh-qualityinternship,(2)whatthebenefitsaretoemployersandtheyouthworkforce,and(3)thevalueofthisprogramtotheCitiesanditspartnersingrowingeconomicvitality.Finally,asBrookLynkentersitssecondyearofoperation,staffwillprioritizeandimplementsuggestionsforprogramimprovementidentifiedinthisevaluation.Theseimprovementsrangefrombuildingthecapacityofemployerstoimproveinternalprocessesandsupportsupervisors,tocreatingdeeperengagementwithschoolandcountypartners,tolaunchingtheAlumniNetworkandJobBoardtoredesigningtheYouthJobFair.

Page 7: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 7

INTRODUCTIONBackgroundIn2014,theAlliancestaffwastaskedwithdevelopingayouthemploymentprogramformiddleandhighschoolagedyouthwholivedinorgotoschoolintheBrooklynsthatpreparesthemwithskills,ignitestheirmotivations,andcreatessocialconnectionstoemploymentandcollege.Thisprogramhasthreecomponents:21stcenturyskillbuilding,experientialemploymentopportunities,andlocalcoordination.Initsinauguralsummer,the2015BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramhad234applicants,80youthcompletedworkreadinesstraining,and29internsininternshipswithemployers.Inyeartwo,the2016BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramexpandedto399applicants,136completedtraining,and62interns.Thisyeartheprogramcontinuetoexpand.BrookLynkwasdesignedtoprovideopportunitiestoyouthwithbarrierstoemploymentand/orwereatriskofbecomingdisconnected:thoseexperiencinghomelessness,whowerenolongerenrolledinmainstreamhighschools,teenparents,andyouthinvolvedinthecountyfostercare,teenparentingorjuvenilecorrectionssystems.TheAllianceoperatedBrookLynkin2015and2016,andincollaborationwiththecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkin2017.Thiswasanintentionalcollaborationtocreateasmoothtransitiontothecitiestotakeownershipoftheprogramsolelyin2018.Thisevaluationwillhelpanswerkeyquestionsaboutcapacitybuildingandprogramdevelopmenttofacilitatethattransition.ProgramDescriptionTheBrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramhasseveralmaincomponentsthatarealldeliveredwithapositiveyouthdevelopmentpractice:workreadinesstraining,ayouthjobfair,internships,andlocalcoordination.Youthparticipateinworkreadinesstraining,mockinterviews,andinternshippreparationtraining.Someofthosestudentsarethenmatchedwithalocalemployerandsupervisortoparticipateinapaidsummerinternshipprogram.Studentsattendregularcheck-in’storeflectandlearnabouttheirexperiences.Localcoordinationinvolvespromotionofthetrainings,recruitmentofbusinesses,continuousimprovementefforts,anddevelopingpartnershipswithinthecommunity.For2017thegoalsweresetat500youthapplyingfortraining,300attendingworkreadinesstraining,and100internships.TherewereseveraldifferencesforthisthirdyearofBrookLynkcomparedtothelastcoupleofyears.BrookLynklaunchedayouthjobfairinthespringtofollowcloselyaftertheBrookLynkGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining.ThiswouldallowyoungeryouthwhoareineligibleforBrookLynkinternships(onlyforyouthaged16-21)andyouthwhodonotchooseorarenotselectedforinternships,togettheirfirstjob.Thetargetinthefirstyearwastohave50businessesandorganizations,and500youthinattendance.Afull-timeprogramassistantwashiredtohelptheprogramcoordinator.AndanalumninetworkandonlinejobboardwillbedevelopedinFall2017.ThealumninetworkwillallowBrookLynktostayconnectedtoalumni,providesupportandresources(includingLinkedIn

Page 8: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 8

networking)onyouth’spathwaytocollegeandcareer,andprovideemployerswithadiversetalentpool.Thealumninetworkwillalsocreateausergroupforthejobboardthatwillhelpyouthandbusinessestoconnect.Businesseswillbeabletoaddopenpositions,andyouthwillbeabletosearchavailablepositionsandconnecttojobswhenevertheychoosetoenterthejobmarket.Formoreinformation,pleaserefertotheYouthEmploymentProgramLogicModelandProcessMapintheAppendix.ProgramGoals

1. Short-termOutcomesa. Increaseinschoolpersistenceandcareerawarenessfortargetedyouthb. Increasedincome(wealthcreation)fortargetedyouthc. Increaseintargetedyouthwithworkreadinesstrainingandearlyinternship

experiences(STEM,IT,government,education,manufacturing,service,etc.)d. Increaseinamoreskilledanddiverseworkforcee. Increaseofnewjobsinthecommunity(jobcreation)

2. Long-termOutcomesa. Increasedopportunitiesforemploymentforyouthb. Increaseinyouthgraduatingfromhighschoolc. Increaseinyouthpursuingpost-secondaryeducationtosupportcareer

developmentProjectDescriptionTheBrooklynBridgeAllianceforYouthBoardauthorizedtheAlliancestafftoimplementathree-yearcapacitybuildingprojectthatwouldutilizebestpracticesandtechnicalassistancefromStep-UpinMinneapolistocreateaYouthEmploymentProgram,tobemanagedandfundedbytheAlliancein2015and2016,jointlymanagedandfundedin2017bytheAllianceandCitypartners,andbetransferredtocompletelytoCitypartnerstomanageandfundin2018.ProjectGoals1. CapacityBuildingProject

a. DeterminethedegreeofsupportfromtheprivatesectorandAlliancepartnerswhowillcontributekeyresourcestowardsimplementation.

b. DetermineexactcostsofthisprogramasimplementedintheBrooklynstodeterminefeasibilityfortheCitiesabsorbingtheprogram.

c. Understandtheresults,benefits,andvalue-addtotheCommunityandifthisisdirectionpolicymakersshouldsupport.

d. Alignlocalmunicipalitiesandcountyresources,bothpolicyandpractice,tosupportthiswork.

2. CustomizetheStep-UpmodeltotheBrooklynsa. Createaclearpathwaytocareerandcollegeandensuretheconnectionbetween

earlyemploymentexperiencesandeducation.b. Buildinternshipswithlocalbusinesses.c. Developpre-employmenttrainingandcoordinatealreadyexistingtrainings.

Page 9: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 9

ResearchFrameworkforBuildingPathwaystoCollege&CareerOneofthegoalsoftheAllianceistoincreaseyoungpeople’spathwaystocollegeandcareer.Usingresearchaboutcollegeandcareerreadinessframeworks,includingthosefromtheEducationalPolicyImprovementCenter(EPIC)andMHALabs(MeansandMeasuresofHumanAchievement),theAlliancedevelopedaPathwaytoCollegeandCareerFramework.Inadditiontothetraditionalacademicbenchmarks(highschoolgraduation,ACT/SAT,collegeprerequisitecourses)ourframeworkincludes3additionalcomponents:

• 21stCenturySkillso PersonalMindseto PlanningforSuccesso SocialAwarenesso VerbalCommunicationo Collaborationo ProblemSolving

• CollegeTransitionalSkillso College-CareerAwarenesso ProceduralIssueso FinancialIssueso CollegeCulturalNormso AcademicSkills

• CareerSpecificTransitionSkillso Career-CollegeAwarenesso ProceduralIssueso WorkNavigationSkillso WorkplaceCulturalNorms

Theseconceptsarelearnedbestbyyoungpeopleusingbothclassroomandexperientiallearningopportunities(e.g.PostsecondaryEnrollmentOptions,internships).ThisframeworkwasusedtoinformthedesignanddevelopmentofBrookLynk.

EVALUATIONPURPOSEThepurposeofthisdocumentistoreportontheevaluationandmeasurementofvariouscomponentsoftheBrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgram.TheresultsofthisevaluationwillbedisseminatedtoAlliancemembersandfunderstoreportparticipationandoutcomeinformation,andsuccessofmodelingourprogramafterSTEP-UPMinneapolis.Theevaluationwillalsobeusedtoimprovetheprogramexperienceforstudents,employers,thecommunity,andstaff.Theevaluationwillemploybothformativeandsummativeevaluationmethodstoanswerthecoreevaluationquestionsinordertoinformtheongoingrefiningandimprovementoftheprogram,aswellasreviewlong-termprogressonmajorprogramgoalsandobjectives.Andfinally,theevaluationwillinformtheAlliance’seffortstohelpthetwocitiestakeownershipoftheprogramin2018.

Page 10: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 10

Thegoalsoftheevaluationareto:• Tracknumber,participation,anddemographicsofyouthserved• Documentprogramactivitiesandprocesses• Establishtoolsandmethods,andcollectdataforprogramcontinuousquality

improvement• Measureprogram,youth,andcommunityoutcomesandimpacts

COREEVALUATIONQUESTIONSThecoreevaluationquestionsweredevelopedwithguidancefromAllianceExecutiveLeadershipTeam’sRecommendationsforYouthEmploymentProgramImplementationandfromstakeholderreportingrequirements.

• YouthParticipation:Didtargetedyouth(liveorattendschoolintheBrooklyns,underserved,withemploymentbarriers,OpportunityYouth)participateintheprogram?

• CommunityParticipation:Dideducation,business,andothercommunitypartnersparticipateintheprogram?

• QualityAssessment:Whatwasthelevelofqualityforourprogramservices?• YouthOutcomes:Inwhatwaysdidtheparticipatingyouthgainthenecessarywork

readinessskills,financialbenefits,andsocialconnectionsasanoutcomeoftheprogramtopreparethemforjobs?Weretheysatisfiedwiththeirinternshipexperiences?

• BusinessOutcomes:Wereemployerssatisfiedwiththeirexperienceswiththeprogramandtheinterns?

• CapacityBuilding:Whatarethedegreeofsupports,programcosts,andpoliticalwillnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?

• ProcessEvaluation:WhatdidwedotocustomizetheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodelfortheBrooklyns?Howwelldidthecustomizedprocesswork?

AndsincethisisthelastyearthattheAlliancewilloperateBrookLynktherearetwoadditionalquestionswewillbeanswering:

• Whatimprovementsandlessonslearnedoccurredinthe3yearsbetweenlaunchingBrookLynkandnow?

• Inwhatwayswilltheprogramevaluationchangenextyear?

EVALUATIONMETHODSThefollowingdatacollectionmethodsandassessmentswereusedduringevaluationofeachphaseoftheprogram.

• Applications:ApplicationsfromparticipantswillbeacceptedonlineviaSurveyMonkeyatthebeginningoftheprogramtocollectparticipationanddemographicdata.

Page 11: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 11

• Attendance:AttendanceatGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainings,MockInterviews,InternshipPreparationTrainings,YouthJobFair,InternOrientation,SupervisorTraining,andCheck-Inswillbecollectedbyprogramstaff.

• WorkReadinessTrainingSurveyo YouthSurvey:Programevaluationswillbecompletedbystudentsonthe

trainingstocollectoutcomedataandprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.

o TrainerSurvey:Programevaluationswillbecompletedbytrainerstocollectprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.

• YouthJobFairSurveyso Asampleofyouthattendeeswillbesurveyedtocollectoutcomeand

programexperiencedata.o Allemployersandorganizationswillbesurveyedtocollectoutcomeand

programexperiencedata.• CommunityParticipation:BrookLynkparticipationdatabycommunitypartnerswill

becollectedbytheprogramstaff.• InternPerformanceReviews:Attheendoftheprogram,supervisorswillrateinterns

ontheMHALabsCompetenciesandtheresultswillbecollectedforuseinoutcomeevaluation.

• InternshipSurveys:o Internswillbeaskedtocompletesurveysattheendoftheprogramontheir

internshipstotrackoutputandoutcomedata,andprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.

o Supervisorswillbeaskedtocompletesurveysattheendoftheprogramontheirinternshipstotrackoutputandoutcomedata,andprogramexperiencedataforqualityandprocessevaluation.

• YPQASelf-Assessment:AmodifiedYPQAassessmentwillbecompletedforinternshipsusingdatacollectedduringsitevisitsandinternshipsurveys.

• ProcessEvaluationQuestionnaire:TheprogramstaffwillbeaskedtoanswerprocessevaluationquestionsduringandontheentireBrooklynkProgram.

• CapacityBuildingQuestionnaire:Theprogramstaffwillbeaskedtocompleteacapacitybuildingevaluationquestionnaireonthedegreeofsupport,programcosts,andpoliticalwillnecessarytooperateBrookLynk.

RESULTSThefollowingsectiondetailstheresultsforeachcoreevaluationquestion.YouthParticipationDidtargetedyouth(youthwholiveorgotoschoolintheBrooklyns,withemploymentbarriers,and/orareCountyInvolved/OpportunityYouth)participateintheprogram?InthisthirdyearoftheBrookLynkprogram,529youthappliedtoparticipateintheGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining.Ninety-fourpercent(94%)werestudentsofcolorand39%werefromimmigrantfamilies.Onehundredeighty-nine(189)youthcompletedworkreadinesstraining.Allofthestudentshadaleastonebarriertoemploymentand/orwere

Page 12: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 12

recruitedthroughourReferralPartnerandBrookLynkAmbassador(alumni)recruiters.BrookLynkhad96studentinternsthisyearanda95%completionrate.

“Ilikedhowmyinternshipwassortoflikeaboosterforme.IsaythisbecausewithoutthisopportunityIwouldn'thaveknownorhowIwouldwanttopursueacareerinthetechnologyfieldorifIevenwantedtogointothecareerinthefirstplace.WorkinginITmademerealizehowmanycareeropportunitiesthereareoutthere.”–BrookLynkIntern

_____________________________YouthOutreach

2015 2016 2017Applicants 234 399 529

BytheendofMarch,529youthappliedtoparticipateintheBrookLynkGetReady!WorkReadinessTraining,whichmetthe2017goal.Theyouthwhoappliedrepresentedatotalof33middle,juniorhigh,andhighschoolsintheNorthwestMetroArea,mostlyinBrooklynCenterandBrooklynPark.Otheroutputdataissummarizedbelow:

Grade 2015 2016 20178th 10% 3% 3%9th 20% 22% 15%10th 28% 27% 24%11th 22% 28% 30%12th 16% 18% 26%Graduated,nocollege 2% 1% 1%Notcurrentlyenrolledinschool 2% 1% 0%Race/Ethnicity 2015 2016 2017Asian 7% 24% 20%HispanicorLatino 6% 14% 10%BlackorAfricanAmerican 56% 45% 40%African 7% 23% 23%AmericanIndianorAlaskanNative 4% 3% 2%WhiteorEuropeanAmerican 13% 13% 8%Other 2% 1% 2%

Notes:Duetoanerrorintheapplicationprocess,applicantsfor2017wereunabletoselectmorethanonerace/ethnicityunlesstheywroteintheirselectionson“Other”.EstimatesfromtheAmericanCommunitySurvey(5-YearEstimates2010-2014)forRace/EthnicityfortheBrooklynsforYouthUnder18:Asian19%,Hispanic/Latino11%,African-American18%,African16%,Other7%,White29%.

CityofResidence 2015 2016 2017BrooklynPark 56% 50% 57%BrooklynCenter 36% 34% 32%Minneapolis 3% 6% 4%Other 5% 10% 7%

Page 13: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 13

School 2015 2016 2017ParkCenterSeniorHigh 22% 25% 23%BrooklynCenterSecondary 17% 21% 19%OsseoSeniorHighSchool 3% 15% 17%ChamplinParkHighSchool 10% 16% 15%BrooklynCenterAcademy 9% 3% 4%RobbinsdaleCooperHighSchool 2% 4% 3%RobbinsdaleArmstrongHighSchool 0% 1% 3%GatewaytoCollege-HTC 5% 2% 3%Other 32% 14% 15%

Note:Inordertobeinvitedtothetraining,applicantshadtoliveorattendschoolintheBrooklyns.Outofthoseapplicants,35%livedorwenttoschoolinBrooklynCenterand65%livedorwenttoschoolBrooklynPark.Inordertocalculatethosepercentages,applicantswerefirstmatchedtotheircityofresidence.Iftheylivedinneithercity,thentheywerematchedtothecitywheretheyattendedschool.

BarrierstoEmployment 2015 2016 2017QualifyforFree/ReducedLunch 74% 85% 80%Immigrant(FamilyorYouth) 26% 46% 39%FirstinFamilytoAttendCollege 22% 22% 18%HaveanIEPorDisability 9% 15% 12%FirstinFamilytoGraduatefromHighSchool 12% 12% 9%DroppedoutofHighSchool 7% 1% 5%HomelessorHighlyMobile 6% 10% 5%EnglishLanguageLearner 5% 5% 5%JuvenileProbation 5% 3% 4%ParentingTeen 1% 1% 2%FosterCareSystemInvolvement 2% 1% 1%OpportunityYouth 17% 13% 17%

Thedemandfortheworkreadinesstrainingincreasedfromlastyearaccordingtothenumberofapplicants.Thepercentageof8thgradersremainedlowthisyearduetodecreasedoutreachtothatgradelevelsincethereisnotadevelopedinternshippathwayfortheyoungerstudentsatthistime.Therace/ethnicitydemographicsremainedsimilartothepreviousyear,againmirroringtheBrooklynspopulationwearetargeting.Thetoptwobarriersstudentsreportedwerequalificationforfreeorreducedlunch(81%),andimmigrantfamilies(39%)whomayhavelimitedexperienceinnavigatingnewworkcultures.Wehadincreasednumbersofopportunityyouth(disconnectedyouth)andcounty-involvedyouthreachedfrom2016.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Considernewstrategiestomeettheneedsofandattract(Opportunity)youthdisconnectedfromeducationalandcareerpathways,andcounty-involvedyouth.

• Revisitthegoalof30%ofyouthservedbeingOpportunityYouthandreframeitintermsofpercentageofOpportunityYouthintheBrooklynsserved.

Page 14: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 14

Three-YearSummaryThenumberofapplicantsfortheGetReady!Trainingincreasedfrom234youthin2015to399youthin2016andfinally529youthin2017.Thepercentagesof9ththrough12thgradersshiftedmoretowardsthejuniorsandseniorsoverthethreeyears,andtheracialandethnicmake-upoftheapplicantsshowedthediversityrepresentedinourcommunities.ThepercentagesofstudentsfromthevariousschoolsaretobeexpectedconsideringthepopulationsofstudentslivingorgoingtoschoolintheBrooklynsateachlocation.Finally,youthwiththespecificbarrierstoemploymentwerereached,exceptforonegroup:theBrookLynkprogramdidnotreachthegoalofserving30%OpportunityYouth.WorkReadinessTraining 2015 2016 2017Numberofyouthinvitedtoworkreadinesstraining 200 334 430Numberofyouthwhocompletedworkreadinesstraining 80 136 189Retentionratefrominvitationtocompletion 48% 42% 44%Numberofyouthwhoattendedmockinterviews 55 84 116Numberofyouthwhoattendedtheinternshiptraining N/A* 68 102

*Internshiptrainingwasnewfor2016.Lessthan50%oftheyouthwhowereinvitedtothetrainingsattended,eventhoughBrookLynkstaffcontactedeachapplicantbyphonetheweekofthetrainings.AlhtoughBrookLynkdidincreasethenumberofyouthcompletingtrainingfromlastyearby40%,wedidnotreachourgoalof300students.Thisretentionratemaybeduetothefactthatitiseasytosignupfor,isfree,andthereisnopenaltyfornotshowingup.WehavelearnedfromourSTEP-UPpartnersthattheyhaveasimilarretentionrateforthissegment.Aftereachtrainingyouthwhodidnotshowupwerecontactedbyphoneinordertounderstandwhathadoccurredtocausethemtomisstheevent.Somestudentsinformedstaffthattheywerenotinterestedinattendinganymore.Themajorityofstudentsrespondedthatresponsibilitiesathomecameup,transportationtotheeventwasunavailablelastminute,orthattheyhadforgotten.Someofthestudentswhohadmissedthefirstweekendandwerecontactedafterwardswereabletorescheduletoattendthesecondweekend.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Scheduleadditionaltrainings,atalternativestimes.• Workwithschooldistrictstoofferworkreadinesstrainingduringschool-dayor

afterschoolprogramming,andinvestigateofferinghighschoolcredittotakingpart.Three-YearSummaryThenumberofyouthwhowereinvitedtoandcompletedworkreadinesstrainingincreasedeachyear.Similarly,thenumberofyouthparticipatinginthemockinterviewsandinternshippreparationtrainingalsoincreased.Theretentionrateremainedrelativelyconstantoverthe3yearsevenafterattemptstoincreaseitbyremindingyouththeweekoftrainingsviaemails,phonecalls,andtexts.

Page 15: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 15

InternshipsandCheck-Ins

2015 2016 2017Numberofyouthwhoappliedforinternships 39 84 129Numberofinternshipopportunitiespledgedbyemployers 32 65 106Numberofyouthwhowerematchedwithinternships 29 65 104Numberofyouthwaitlisted 10 18 25Numberofyouthwhobeganinternships 29 62 96Numberofyouthwhocompletedinternships 25 58 91Completionrate 86% 94% 95%Percentageofyouthwithnopriorworkexperience 86% 64% 49%Numberofbuspassesprovided 6 24 22Averagepercentageofyouthwhoattendedeachcheck-in 58% 60% 62%Averagenumberofyouthwhoattendedcollege/companyvisits 9 18 23Thenumbersofyouthwhoapplied,internshipspledged,youthmatchedtointernships,youthwaitlisted,andyouthwhobeganinternshipsallincreasedfrom2016’sprogram.Ninety-one(91)internssuccessfullycompletedtheirinternshipfromthe96whostartedforacompletionpercentageof95%.Five(5)internsdidnotcompletetheirinternshipduetofamilychallenges,lifecircumstances,andtermination.Three-YearOutlookTheplannedincrementalgrowthwassuccessful.BrookLynkgrewfrom29internshipsin2015to62internshipsin2016and96thisyear.ThiswasmoreimpressivewiththefactthatBrookLynkmaintainedaveryhighcompletionratewhilestilltargetingyouthwithbarrierstoemployment.Thecompletionrateisstillveryhighandhasslightlyincreasedsince2015.Thepercentageofyouthwithnopriorworkexperiencehasbeendecreasingthepastthreeyears.ThismightbeduetothenumberofBrookLynkthisyearwhoparticipatedininternshipsagain(19%),orthattheprogramisattractingmoreyouththanbeforewhohavesomeworkexperience.Thepercentageofyouthwhoareattendingcheck-insisstillnear60%.ToincreaseBrookLynkmayneedtoconsidernewstrategies.Morestudentsareattendingthecollegeandcompanysitevisitsin2017thaninpreviousyears.YouthJobFair

2017Numberofyouthwhoattendedjobfair 159Numberofemployerswhoattendedjobfair 14Numberoforganizationsofferingservices 4Numberofyouthwhovisitedeachemployerbooth(range) 23to75Numberofapplicationsreceivedbyeachemployer(range) 0to50

Page 16: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 16

NumberofinterviewsgivenduetoYouthJobFair(total) 11NumberofjoboffersgivenduetoYouthJobFair(total) 1

Aswithanylaunchofanynewprogramelement,severaliterationsareoftenrequiredtoaccomplishgoals.AlthoughBrookLynkaimedhigh,itfellshort.Initialgoalswere500youthattending(159attended)and50employers(18employersandorganizationsattended).AmorecompleteevaluationoftheeventisdetailedintheProcessEvaluationsectionbelow.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Ensuretherearejob,volunteer,andsummeropportunitiesfor14-15yearolds.• Considernewstrategiestorecruitmoreyouthandbusinessestoattend,andto

matchjobseekerstoemployerswithjobopeningsattheevent.

CommunityParticipationDideducation,business,andothercommunitypartnersparticipateintheprogram?Six(6)educationpartners,5businesspartners,and3communitypartners(18departments)offeredBrookLynkinternshipopportunities.ForthefirsttimesinceallAlliancemembersparticipatedinofferinginternships.OurAlliancemembersandcommunitypartnersprovidedin-kinddonationsformanyofourfacility,transportation,andmaterialneeds,andstafforanorganizationalpresenceatourevents.

“IlovedandreallyenjoyedtheworkIdidthissummer.Initially,whenIfirstreceivedtheemailaboutwhereIwouldbeworkingIwasquestioningitinregardstoifitwastherightmatchforme.Iwasn'tsureifitwaswhereIwantedtobe,butIendeduplovingitsomuch.IwasexposedtothingsIneverthoughtI'dseeandexperience.Ilearnedalotandlearnedthatthereisreallyaproblemoutthereinourcommunitiesinregardstohowthegovernmentworksandequityforourunderrepresentedcommunities.MyinternshipthissummerhelpedmefindsomethingI'mpassionateabout.”–BrookLynkintern

_____________________________

Alliancemembersandcommunitypartnersprovidedin-kinddonationsforfacility,transportation,andmaterialneeds,andstafforanorganizationalpresenceatourevents.FundingfortheprogramwasalsoprovidedbygrantsfromtheBremerFoundation,theUnitedWay,PohladFoundation,andHennepinCountyStateEquityfunds.Inadditiontotheinternships,BostonScientificandCumminsPowerGenerationprovidedtransportation(viaSafeTreeTransportation)totheirinternsintheArdenHillsandShoreviewlocations.

Specifically,ourcommunitypartnersprovidedthefollowingsupportsduringtheprogram:

GetReady!WorkReadinessTrainings,MockInterviews,andInternshipPreparationTraining:HennepinTechnicalCollegeprovidedthespaceforthetrainingsandtheYMCA

Page 17: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 17

TwinCitiesprovidedoneofthetrainers.TheCityofBrooklynParkprovidedaroomattheCommunityActivityCenterforthemockinterviews.Representativesfrommanycommunitypartnersvolunteeredasinterviewers,includingToplineFederalCreditUnion,YellowTreeTheatre,Nilfisk,CumminsPowerGeneration,BostonScientific,theCityofBrooklynPark,theCityofBrooklynCenter,OsseoAreaSchools,Anoka-HennepinSchoolDistrict,HennepinCounty,theLionsClub,andtheRotaryClubofBrooklynPark.YouthJobFair:AgrantfromtheBremerFoundationfundedtheYouthJobFair.TheAlliancemembersprovidedstafftoparticipateintheplanningcommittee.NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesfortheYouthJobFair.OsseoAreaSchoolsprovidedbustransportationandfoodandbeverages.Hy-Veeprovidedfinancialsupport.BrooklynParkRec-on-the-Gocametoproviderecreationactivitiesforyoungersiblings.Participatingemployersandorganizationsprovidingjobsandsupportsincluded:HennepinCounty,Anoka-HennepinSchools,MinnesotaUnitedFC,McDonald’s,UPS,Fed-Ex,theUSArmy,OsseoAreaSchools,theYMCATwinCities,MinnesotaDepartmentofEducationandEconomicDevelopment,JobCorps,EnglishRoseSuites,TreeTrust,BrooklynParkFireExplorers,HennepinTechnicalCollege,NorthHennepinCommunityCollege,BrooklynsYouthCouncil,andComunidadesLatinasUnidasServicio(CLUES).TheYMCATwinCitiesstaffedthecomputerlabtohelpstudentscreatearesumeandapplyforjobsonline.InternandParentOrientation:TheCityofBrooklynParkprovidedaroomattheCommunityActivityCenterfortheorientation.MetroTransitandFireflyCreditUnionledworkshopsonhowtotakepublictransportationandfinancialliteracy,respectively.SupervisorTraining:NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesfortheSupervisorTraining.TheYMCATwinCitiesprovidedstafftohelptrainthesupervisors.Check-insandEnrichmentOpportunities:NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesfortheweeklyinterncheck-ins.CollegevisitswerehostedbyConcordiaUniversityandtheUniversityofMinnesota,TwinCities.AcompanysitevisitwashostedbyGeneralMills.Internships:Thefollowing14employersprovidedinternshipopportunitiesthisyear(includingnumberofinternships):

EducationPartners

• Anoka-HennepinAreaSchools(5)• BrooklynCenterCommunitySchools(8)• HennepinTechnicalCollege(5)• NorthHennepinCommunityCollege(6)• OsseoAreaSchools(15)• RobbinsdaleAreaSchools(3)

BusinessPartners• AllenPropertyServices,LLC(2)• Amplifon,Inc.(2)• BostonScientific(8)• CumminsPowerGeneration(6)

Page 18: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 18

• ToplineFederalCreditUnion(1)CommunityPartners

• CityofBrooklynCenter(17)o AdministrationandOfficeoftheClerko BuildingandCommunityStandardsDepartmento BusinessandDevelopmentDepartmento CommunityActivities,Recreation&Serviceso FinanceDepartmento FireDepartmento PoliceDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment

• CityofBrooklynPark(13)o CommunityDevelopmentDepartmento CommunityEngagementDepartmento InformationTechnologyDepartmento OperationsandMaintenanceDepartmento PoliceDepartmento RecreationandParksDepartment,YouthServices

• HennepinCounty(5)o BrooklynParkLibraryo CenterofInnovationandExcellenceo HumanServicesandPublicHealthDepartmento PublicWorksDepartment

Year-EndCelebration:NorthHennepinCommunityCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesforthecelebration.

SuggestionsforImprovement

• Createan“engagementladder”forcommunitypartnerstogetinvolvedwithincreasingprogressionofcommitment,e.g.donatingfinancialorin-kindsupport,participatinginatrainingorevent,providinginternships,orjoiningabusinessadvisory.

Three-YearSummaryIn2015,BrookLynkhad8partnersprovide29internships,andafewAlliancemembersandotherpartnerscontributedin-kinddonationsandstaffforthemockinterviews.In2016,therewere16partnersproviding62internships,andaboutadozenAlliancemembersandotherpartnerswhoparticipatedinmockinterviews,providingworkshopsandenrichmentopportunities,andin-kinddonations.Andin2017,therewere14partners(includingallofourAlliancemembers)providing96internships,and36organizationscontributedfundingandin-kinddonations,andparticipatedinBrookLynktrainingsandevents.BrookLynkhasgrowninthenumberandbreadthofpartnershipswithorganizationsinthecommunity.

Page 19: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 19

QualityAssessmentWhatwasthelevelofqualityforourprogramservices?TheYouthProgramQualityAssessment(YPQA)®self-assessmentwascompletedduringoneoftheWorkReadinessTrainings.Significantchangesweremadetothedesignofthetrainingtoaddressthelowerscoresfrompreviousyears,andthescoresshoweddramaticimprovement.Theinternshipswereagainassessedthisyearusingamodifiedqualityassessment,andtheyscoredhighforqualityacrosstheboard.

“IlikehowIwasbeingchallengedbydoingthingsIusuallydon'tdo.I'velearnedhowtotalktostrangersandcomeoutofmycomfortzone.Ilikegoingtomeetingsandhearinghoweachsituationwillbesolvedandthebestpossiblesolution.SometimesIlikeputtingpaperworktogetheranddoingregistrationforpeopleeventhoughI'mnotgoodatit.Ilikerunningsmallerrands.Ilikegoingalongwithmyco-workerandseehowtheygiveatourtotheroom.Ilikeguidingwheretheroomsareandhavingsmallconversationswiththestaffsandpeople.”–BrookLynkintern

_____________________________TheYPQAisavalidatedinstrument(grades4-12)designedtomeasurethequalityofyouthprogramsandidentifystafftrainingneeds.TheYouthPQAevaluatedthequalityofyouthexperiencesasyouthattendworkshopsandclasses,completegroupprojects,andparticipateinmeetingsandregularprogramactivities.Domaincategoriesarebrokendownintoindividualscales,whicharerated1,3,or5(1beingthelowestand5beingthehighest).TheYPQASelf-AssessmentwascompletedduringthesecondweekendoftheGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainingsessions.Asummaryoftheresultscomparingtheassessmentontheworkreadinesstrainingsfromall3yearsispresentedbelow.

YOUTHPQASCORES2015

GetReady!Training

2016GetReady!Training

2017GetReady!Training

SafeEnvironment 4.7 4.7 4.8EmotionalSafety 5.0 5.0 5.0HealthyEnvironment 5.0 5.0 5.0EmergencyPreparedness 4.0 4.0 4.0AccommodatingEnvironment 5.0 5.0 5.0Nourishment 4.3 4.3 5.0

SupportiveEnvironment 3.4 4.1 4.8WarmWelcome 4.3 5.0 5.0SessionFlow 4.6 4.6 4.6ActiveEngagement 3.0 3.0 5.0Skill-Building 2.0 3.5 5.0Encouragement 3.7 4.3 4.3ReframingConflict 2.5 4.0 N/A

Page 20: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 20

Interaction 2.7 2.5 4.4Belonging 4.0 4.0 4.5Collaboration 2.3 2.3 5.0Leadership 2.3 1.7 3.0AdultPartners 2.0 2.0 5.0

Engagement 1.8 1.8 4.0Planning 1.0 1.0 4.0Choice 1.0 2.0 4.0Reflection 3.5 2.5 4.0

ThebiggestimprovementswereintheInteractionandEngagementdomains.Thoseareasscoredlowestforthetraininginpreviousyears,consideringthelecture-styleclassesusedintheWorkReadinessTraining,andthelackofchoiceforyouth.BrookLynkstaffaddedthreenewaspectstothetrainingthisyear.First,studentsweregivenachoiceofthreetracks:beginner,intermediate,andadvanced.Thesetrackswerestructuredforstudentswithnopreviousworkexperience,studentswithsomeexposure,andstudentswithextensiveworkexperienceoralumnioftheinternshipprogram.Second,someoftheinternshipalumniwereaskedtoco-teachthetrainingwiththeadulttrainers.Thisofferedmoreopportunitiesfor(some)youthtoleadinpartnershipwithadults.Finally,innotingthatpreviousyears’trainingslackedofopportunitiesforyouthtoreflectontheirlearningaswellasanactivecomponentintheclass,staffspecificallyprovidedoptionsforhowtheycouldincorporatemorereflectionquestionsandactivities.SincetheinternshipsareacorepartofprogramtheevaluationteamcreatedanInternshipQualityAssessmentthatwasinformedbytheYouthPQA.OfthefourdomainsintheYouthPQAseveralwereassessedduringthesitevisitswhiletheremainingareaswereratedbysurveyinginternsattheendoftheirsummerexperience.

INTERNSHIPQUALITYASSESSMENTSCORES

2016Internships

2017Internships

SafeEnvironment 5.0 4.8EmotionalSafety 5.0 4.5HealthyEnvironment 5.0 5.0EmergencyPreparedness 5.0 4.4AccommodatingEnvironment 4.7 5.0Nourishment 5.0 5.0

SupportiveEnvironment 4.5 4.5WarmWelcome N/A 4.6SessionFlow 4.1 4.4ActiveEngagement 4.5 N/ASkill-Building 4.5 4.4Encouragement 4.6 4.6ReframingConflict N/A N/A

Interaction 4.6 4.6Belonging 4.6 4.4Collaboration 4.6 4.5

Page 21: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 21

Leadership N/A N/AAdultPartners N/A 4.8

Engagement 4.3 4.3Planning 4.3 4.4Choice 3.9 4.3Reflection 4.6 4.2

Thescoreswereverysimilartothepreviousyear.Cautionshouldbeusedintryingtomakeanydirectcomparisonsbetweenyears,sincethemodifiedassessmentthisyearwastweakedtoaddslightlydifferentquestionstotrytoimproveonlastyearassessmenttool.SuggestionforImprovement

• Fine-tunethedifferenttracksofferedduringthetrainingtobetterfittheworkreadinessneedsofthestudentsattending.

• Continuetoimproveandvalidatetheprocessofassessingqualityintheinternshipexperiencesatemployerlocations.

Three-YearSummaryEachyear,theGetReady!WorkReadinessTraininghasbeenassessedandanactionplanhasbeenputintoplacetoimprovethequality(specificallywiththeInteractionandEngagementdomains),withhigherscoresthefollowingyears.Theinternshipmodifiedqualityassessmentwasaddedin2016,andhasbeenusefulinourunderstandingofwhataqualityinternshiplookslikeandhowtotrainsupervisorsaccordingly,butitvalidityisstillunclear.

YouthOutcomesInwhatwaysdidtheparticipatingyouthgainthenecessaryworkreadinessandsocial-emotionallearningskills,financialbenefits,andsocialconnectionsasanoutcomeoftheprogramtopreparethemforjobs?Weretheysatisfiedwiththeirinternshipexperiences?Attheendoftheinternship,76%ofinternswereratedbytheirsupervisorsashavinggainedall13workreadinessskillstheywereassessedon.Seventy-sixpercent(76%)ofsupervisorssaidtheywouldhiretheirinterniftheyhadajobopening.Themedianamountofnetsalaryearnedduringthesummerwas$2400.Seventy-sevenpercent(77%)ofinternsthoughtthattheinternshipshelpedthemincreasethenumberofprofessionalsintheirsocialnetwork.Onaverage,theinternsratedtheirinternshipexperiencea4.3outof5,andtheirsupervisorsa4.5outof5.Eighty-sixpercent(86%)oftheinternsagreedthattheyreceivedenoughtrainingandsupporttosuccessfullycompletetheirinternships,98%saidtheywouldparticipateinBrookLynkagainnextyear,and99%respondedthattheywouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend.

“(Ilikedgettingtheopportunitytoexperience)helpingotherinternswiththeirjobslikecollectingattendance,doingsnacktable,helpingteachers,helpingstudents,respondingtocompanies,andorderingfoodonline.ItreallyhelpedmeexploremypossiblecareeroptionslikeIcanbeateacher,aleader,acompanyowner,andetc.Thisisbyfarthebestaspectsoftheinternship.AlsoIdoenjoythecompanyofotherinternsbecauseitreallyhelpedmebondwith

Page 22: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 22

themandgetthingsdonequickerinateam.IdowishIcanhaveTHISexactinternshipnextyear.”–BrookLynkAmbassador

_____________________________CareerSkillsBrookLynkisusingtheMeasuresofHumanAchievement(http://mhalabs.org)asatooltogaugeworkreadiness.TheMHAframeworkisanexcellentframeworkthatgivesbothadultsandyouthsharedlanguageabout21stcenturyworkreadinessskills.Staffhaveinvestedsignificanttimetolearn,research,andintegrateMHAtoolsintoourprogramdesign.Thishashelpedtoensurethatsupervisorsprovidinginternshipsareusingastrengthsapproachforinternspersonalandskilldevelopment.TheMHALabs’HireabilitySkillsPerformanceReviewaskedthesupervisorsattheendoftheinternshipstoratetheirinterns’competencyin13basicskillsin5separateskillsetslistedbelow:

• ProfessionalAttitudeo Bringsenergyandenthusiasmtotheworkplaceo Takesresponsibilityforhisorheractionsanddoesnotblameotherso Stayscalm,clearheadedandunflappableunderstresso Graciouslyacceptscriticism

• TeamWorkEthico Activelylooksforadditionaltaskswhenownworkisdoneo Activelylooksforwaystohelpotherpeople

• ProblemSolvingo Unpacksproblemsintomanageablepartso Generatesmultiplepotentialsolutionstoproblemso Identifiesnewandmoreeffectivewaystosolveproblems

• TimeManagemento Managestimeanddoesnotprocrastinateo Getsworkdoneontimeo Arrivesontimeandisrarelyabsentwithoutcause

• VerbalCommunicationo Communicatesprofessionally

TheHireabilitySkillsframeworkincludesbasicworkreadinessskillsthatwillallowyoungpeopletogethiredandmaintainanentry-levelposition.InternswhoscoredStandard,Skilled,orExpertinaskillareaweredeemedcompetent.ThescoringoptionsbelowStandardareNovice(lowest)andEmerging.

NumberofMHALabsWorkCoreSkillsInternsRatedCompetentIn

%ofInternsRatedCompetentWithThoseNumberofSkills

2016 2017

Under10CareerSkills 8% 5%10-12CareerSkills 23% 18%13CareerSkills 70% 76%

Page 23: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 23

Overall,76%ofinternsratedcompetentinall13outof13careerskillsbytheirsupervisors.Theinternsseemedtoagreewiththoseassessmentsas82%answeredMostlyTrueorCompletelyTruetothestatement“Myinternshipexperiencetaughtmevaluablecareerskills.”Relatedmeasuresofwhetherinternsarework-readyincludethreestatementsalsoonthePerformanceReviews(CompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue).

2016 2017 IfIhadajobopening,Iwouldhirethisperson 70% 76% Iwouldrecommendthispersontoacolleague,forasimilarposition 73% 82%

Iwouldseekoutthispersontobeonmynextproject 68% 73%

Three-YearReviewThepercentageofinternswhowereratedbytheirsupervisorstobecompetentinall13oftheCareerSkillsincreasedfrom2016to2017.Onepossibleexplanationfortheseimprovementswasimprovedtraining.Inboththeyouthandsupervisortrainings,therehasbeenincreasedtimespentonlearningabouttheMHALabsframeworkandhowtogaintherelevantskills.Andthenthisisrefreshedduringthecheck-insandinemailstosupervisorsduringthesummer.FinancesStudentsreportedtheirnetearningsaftertheirpaidinternshipsthissummer.

NetEarnings 2015 2016 2017NotSure 9% 7% 5%$0-$999 41% 16% 15%

$1000-$1999 50% 57% 20%$2000-$2999 0% 22% 25%$3000-$3999 0% 9% 25%$4000+ 0% 0% 11%

2015 2016 2017Mediannetearnings $1000 $1500 $2400Putmoneyinbankorcreditunionaccount 82% 84% 92%Hadpaychecksdepositedbydirectdeposit 64% 68% 72%

ThemediannetearningamountforBrookLynkinternsin2017was$2400(thisdoesnotincludeanytaxesorotherdeductions,orbenefitsoffered).Thisnumberissubstantiallyhigherthanpreviousyearsmostlylikelyforseveralreasons.Inthepast,wesurveyedinternsattheendofthesummertoaskthemtoself-reportthetotalamountearned,whichwesuspectwasunderreported.Thisyear,weaskedinternstoreporthowmanyweekstheyworked,howmanyhoursperweektheyaveraged,andwhattheirhourlysalarywas(whichwewereabletoconfirmwiththeemployers).Wethencalculatedforthemwhattheirtotalearningswere,whichisprobablymoreaccurate.Second,sinceseveralofourinternships

Page 24: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 24

werefundedorsubsidizedviaaHennepinCountygrantwhichrequiredsalariestobe$15/hr.,thosesalarieswerehigherthantheywouldhavebeennormally.Lastly,althoughtheinternshipswereoriginallyintendedtobefor6-8weekslong,someorganizationshostedtheirinternsforupto10weeks,whichincreasedthehoursworked.Wealsosurveyedthestudentsabouttheirfinancialpracticesandfoundoutthat92%oftheinternsputtheirsavingsintoabankorcreditunionaccount,and72%hadtheirpaycheckssubmittedviadirectdeposit.Thesenumberswerehigherthanpreviousyears’.Three-YearReviewThemediannetearningamounthasincreasedoverthethreeyearsoftheprogram.Asexplainedabove,partofthismightbeduetomoreaccuratedatacollection,butinternsareearningmoreintheprogramnowthantheyhaveinpreviousyears.Alsomoreinternsaredepositingtheirpaychecksintoabankorcreditunionandareusingdirectdeposittodoso.SocialNetworksResearchshowsthathavingaccesstoprofessionalsocialnetworksincreasesthechancesoflandingajob.Manyofourinternshavelimitedprofessionalsocialnetworks.OneofBrookLynk’sgoalsthroughtheinternshipswastoincreasethenumberofprofessionalsintheyoungperson’snetwork.

2015 2016 2017Myinternshiphelpedmeincreasethenumberofprofessionalsinmysocialnetwork 96% 82% 77%

Seventy-sevenpercent(77%)ofinternsreported(CompletelytrueorMostlytrue)thattheinternshipshelpedthemincreasethenumberofprofessionalsintheirsocialnetwork.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Designadditionalprogramactivitiestoengageyouthindevelopingtheirsocialnetworks,e.g.theAlumniNetwork

Three-YearReviewThedatashowthatsocialnetworkdevelopmenthasdecreasedovertime.Staffreportthatotherprogramimprovementprioritieshaveneglectedtheimplementationofintentionalactivitiesthatwouldsupportthedevelopmentofsocialnetworks.InternCustomerSatisfaction 2015 2016 2017RatingforBrookLynkinternship(onascalefrom1to5) 4.4 4.3 4.3Ratingfortheirsupervisors(onascalefrom1to5) 4.4 4.5 4.5WouldparticipateinBrookLynkagain,ifpossible 86% 95% 98%WouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend 100% 100% 99%ReceivedenoughsupportfromBrookLynkstaff 100% 95% 86%

Page 25: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 25

WhenaskedabouthowtheywouldratetheirBrookLynkinternships,theinternssurveyedratedtheirexperiencesanaverageof4.3outof5.0.Ninety-eightpercent(98%)ofinternsreportedthattheywouldparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramagainifpossible.And99%ofinternssaidthattheywouldrecommendBrookLynktoafriend.WhenaskedaboutthesupporttheyreceivedfromBrookLynkstaff,86%ofrespondentsstatedthattheyreceivedenoughsupportduringtheinternship,13%answered“Somewhat”,and1%saidtheydidnotreceiveenoughsupport.Astheprogramhasscaledupinsizeeachyear,theamountofsupportthatinternsreceivefromstaffalsodecreased,althoughthisdidnotimpactcompletionrates.Suggestingthatwhilesupportmaybehelpfulitisnottheprimaryreasoninternscompletetheirsummerinternship.Internsratedtheirsupervisorsanaverageof4.5outof5.0(with1beingpoorand5beingexcellent).Theyalsoratedtheirsupervisorsinthesespecificareasbelow.

Mysupervisor:%ofInternsAnswering“MostlyTrue”

or“CompletelyTrue”2015 2016 2017*

Tookmeseriouslyandtreatedmefairly 78% 76% 90%MademefeeltheworkIdidwasimportanttotheorganization 65% 80% 76%

Askedforandlistenedtomyopinions 70% 71% 82%Gavemefeedbackonmyworkthathelpedmedobetter. 61% 67% 78%

Genuinelycaredaboutmeasaperson. 70% 73% 84%Introducedmetopeoplewhocanhelpmegrow 61% 62% 69%

IssomeoneIcantrust 83% 69% 80%Introducedmetonewideas,experiences,and/orplaces. 65% 69% 71%

Helpedmeseefuturepossibilitiesformyself. 52% 56% 75%

Helpedmesetandachievegoals. 44% 47% 64%*For2015and2016,internswereaskedtoratehowtruevariousstatementsabouttheirsupervisorswereona5-pointscale(NotTrue,ALittleTrue,SomewhatTrue,MostlyTrue,CompletelyTrue).For2017,itwaschangedtoa3-pointscaletobemoreconsistentwithourqualitymeasures(NotTrue,SomewhatTrue,MostlyTrue).Thepercentagesfrom2015and2016wereadjustedtobecomparedto2017results.BrookLynkwasselectedtoparticipateinaregionalfellowshipwithMHALabs.Stafffocusedtheirfellowshipdiscoveryprojectonlearningwhatimpactsupervisorswouldhaveonthequalityoftheinternshipexperience.TheSupervisorTrainingwasrevampedtobettersupporttheneedsofsupervisor’s.Newcontentwasdevelopedtoteachadultshowtoworkwithandrelatetohighschoolinterns,howtobeagoodsupervisor,andhowtoprovidefeedback.Datashowthatthereisarelationshipbetweenchangestothesupervisortrainingandincreasesinhowinternsratedtheirsupervisors.

Page 26: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 26

BrookLynkstaffarefundamentallyinterestedintwoongoingresearchquestions:WhatmakesagoodsupervisorinaBrookLynkinternship?AndhowcanBrookLynkstaffsupportsupervisorstobepreparedtoofferhigh-qualityinternships?Higherresponseratesuponcompletionprovidedenoughdatatobeginuncoveringtheanswers.Someoftheinternshipqualityratingsweredisaggregatedbywhetherornottheintern’ssupervisorattendedtheSupervisorTrainingornot.(Ratingsareona5-pointscalewith1beingNotatAllTrueand5beingCompletelyTrue.)

AverageRating(SupervisorAttendedTraining)

AverageRating(SupervisorDidNotAttendTraining)

Ifeelasenseofbelongingtomyworkplace 4.5 4.0

IfeelthattheworkIdoisimportanttotheorganization 4.7 4.0

Thereisanappropriate(+/-)amountotimeforallofmywork 4.5 4.0

Mysupervisorengagesmeinanintentionalprocessofreflection 4.1 3.8

OverallSupervisorRating 4.5 4.3

OverallBrookLynkRating 4.4 4.1Seventy-threepercent(73%)ofinternshadsupervisorswhoattendedthetraining,27%didnotattendthetraining.Itseemsthatsupervisorsattendingtrainingincreasedtheinterns’ratingofthesupervisors,andalsoincreasedtheratingoftheinternshipexperienceingeneral.Atthispoint,nocorrelationcanbedrawnbutthisquestiondoesmeritmorestudy.Theaspectoftheinternshipsthatinternslikedthebestwastheworkenvironmentthattheyexperienced.Internslikedbeingapartofdoingmeaningfulwork(andbeingpaidforit).Theytalkedabouthowtheirinternshipshelpedpreparethemforthefutureworkincludingtheopportunitytolearnandpracticenewskills,networking,andbeingexposedtodifferentcareers.Internsalsobenefitedfromthenewrelationshipstheydevelopedwithco-workers,mentors,supervisors,andotherinterns.Manyoftheinternswhoworkedinschoolsettingslovedtointeractwiththechildrenundertheircare.Theaspectoftheinternshipsthatinternslikedtheleastwasnothavingenoughtodo.Otheraspectstheyreportedwerehavingtodoworktheydidn’tlikeorthoughtwasboring,havingtodopaperwork,workinginacubicle,havingtogetupearly,dealingwithunrulychildrenanddisagreeableco-workers,workingbythemselves,andspecificjobresponsibilitiestheydidn’tenjoy.Somestudentsweredisappointedthattheycouldnotworkmorehoursduringtheweekormoreweeksduringtheinternship.Anotherleastfavoriteaspectoftheprogramwasrelatedtocheck-insandenrichmentopportunities.Somestudentswerenotinterestedbeinginthecheck-insorhavingtotaketimeoffofworktogotothefieldtrips.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Considerwhatotherdatashouldbecollectedandanalyzedthatmayhelptounderstandthecharacteristicsofahigh-qualitysupervisor.

Page 27: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 27

• Considertoanalyzeandstudythe2017datasettounderstandthecorrelationsbetweenqualityandsupervisortrainingandbehavior.

Three-YearReviewInterns’satisfactionwithBrookLynkhasalwaysbeenhigh,asindicatedbytheratingstheygivefortheprogramandsupervisors,andthefactthatcloseto100%wouldparticipateintheprogramagainandrecommendittotheirfriends.Therehasbeenaslightdecreaseinsatisfactionofsupportsfromprogramstaffandthelevelofsupervisionprovided.Whilesatisfactioninsomeaspectdecreased,itdidnotdecreaseoverallsatisfactionorcompletionrates.AstheprogramhasscaledBrookLynkhasfoundtherightmixofeffortstoensureyouthsuccess.Long-TermOutcomesEighty-three(83)internsparticipatedinthefirsttwoyearsoftheBrookLynkprogram.BrookLynkstaffreachedouttoallofthealumnitotracktheiracademicandjoboutcomesandwereabletofollow-upwith74ofthem.Theremaining9eitherdidnotrespondtoemailsandphonecalls,ortheircontactinformationwasout-of-date.Forthealumniwhoshouldhavegraduatedafter4yearsofhighschool,96%hadearnedtheirdiplomaorGED,and4%werecontinuingwithschool.Oftheremainingalumniwhoshouldstillbeinhighschool,all(100%)areinschoolforFall2017.TheaveragehighschoolgraduationrateforBrooklynshighschoolsin2016was85%,sothegraduationrateforBrookLynkalumni(96%)isexcellent,especiallyforourtargetedpopulationofyouthwhohavebarrierstopathwaystocollegeandcareer.Ofthe51studentswhohadgraduatedfromhighschoolorreceivedtheirGED,45(88%)wereattendingcollegeduringthe2017-2018schoolyear.Additionally,2studentswereenrolledinthePost-SecondaryEnrollmentOptions(PSEO)programtotakecollegeclasseswhilestillinhighschool.TheaveragecollegeenrollmentrateforBrooklynshighschoolsin2015was78%,sotheenrollmentrateforBrookLynkalumniwhograduatedhighschool(88%)ismuchhigher.Seventy-fivepercent(87%)ofthealumniwhowereinthelaborforcewereemployedthissummer.Twenty-twopercent(22%)ofalumniparticipatedinBrookLynkagainin2017.Ofthoseworking,55%workedsummerjobs,19%workedyear-roundfulltimejobs,17%workedpart-timeyear-roundjobs,and2%wereinschoolinternships.WhenaskedhowBrookLynkcouldcontinuetosupportthem,thealumniwantedtobekeptinformedaboutinternshipandjobopportunitiesavailablelocally,toreceivecontinuedsupportandguidancetheirpathwaystoacareer,andnetworkingevents.Notethatmanyofthealumniwhodidnotrespondtousorhadchangedtheircontactinformationwereopportunityyouth.Ifwehadincludedtheirdata,thereportedoutcomespotentiallywouldbedifferent.

Page 28: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 28

SuggestionsforImprovement• Developandlaunchanalumninetworktokeepincontactwithalumniandprovide

ongoingsupportandnetworkingopportunities.• Developandlaunchajobboardprovideinformationaboutlocalinternshipandjob

opportunitiesforyouth.• Inthefuture,oncethereisalargeenoughsampleofyouthwhorespond,considera

morerigorousresearchdesigntocomparealumniwithyouthofsimilarbackgroundstodetermineifBrookLynkmadeadifferenceintheirlifeoutcomes.

BusinessOutcomesWereemployerssatisfiedwiththeirexperienceswiththeprogramandtheinterns?Ninety-twopercent(92%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheywouldliketoparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramagainnextyearwithanotherstudent.Over90%ofsupervisorsreportedthattheyweresatisfiedwiththesupporttheyreceivedfromBrookLynktobeeffectivesupervisorsfortheinterns.Inresponsetofeedbackwereceivedlastyearfromsupervisors,thisyearweinformedthemearlieroftheirmatchessotherewouldbeenoughtimeforthehiringandonboardingprocesses.Eighty-eightpercent(88%)saidtheyhadenoughtimethisyear.And85%believedthattheirinternsweregoodmatchesfortheirorganizations.

“Theinternshipprogramisagreatwayforareabusinessesandorganizationstocollaborateforthegoodofthecommunityandprovideyoungadultswiththeopportunitytolearnandnetworkwithprofessionals,andlearnabitaboutvariouseducationandcareeroptions.Theinternwasvaluabletoourorganizationasshefilledagapwhereweneededhelponvariousprojects,insightsgleamedfromthecapstoneproject(greataddition)andotherbeneficialfeedbackfromayoungadult’spointofview.”

_____________________________ 2015 2016 2017SupervisorTrainingwashelpful 70% 85% 89%Therewasenoughtimetoprepareforanintern N/A 88% 80%Receivedtherightsupportfromcompany/organization N/A N/A 79%ReceivedtherightsupportfromBrookLynk 90% 92% 92%Expectationsofinternshipmatchedwhathappened N/A 77% 81%Internwasagoodmatchformycompany/organization 85% 85% 82%WouldparticipateinBrookLynkagainnextyear 100% 92% 92%

Aboutaquarter(23%)ofthesupervisorssurveyeddidnotattendtheSupervisorTraining.Eighty-ninepercent(89%)ofthesupervisorsthatdidattendtheSupervisorTrainingthoughtitwashelpfulbecausetheylearnedhowtounderstand,setexpectations,andworkwithyouthasinterns,learnedaboutBrookLynkbasics,andpickeduptipsandtoolsonhow

Page 29: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 29

tobebettersupervisorsthroughtheworkshops.Somesupervisorsthoughtthetrainingwastoobasicorrepeatedinformationtheywerealreadyfamiliarwithasanexperiencedmanager.Thepasttwoyears,manysupervisorsexpressedthattheywishedtheyhadmoretimetopreparefortheirinterns,mostlybecauseofHRhiringprocesses.Theapplication,training,andmatchingwascompletedearlierinordertoaccommodatethem.Weaskedsupervisorsiftheyhadenoughtimethisyearand80%respondedCompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue.Seventy-ninepercent(79%)ofthesupervisorsrespondedthattheyfelttheyreceivedtherightsupportfromtheircompanies/organizationstobeaneffectivesupervisor.Ninety-twopercent(92%)ofthesupervisorssaidthattheyfelttheyreceivedtherightsupportandresourcestobeeffectivesupervisorsfromBrookLynk.Whenaskedaboutsupervision,24%ofsupervisorsprovideddirectsupervision,10%delegatedthatresponsibilitytosomeoneelse,and66%respondedthatacombinationofthemselvesandothersprovidedsupervision.Whenaskedhowmuchhoursofsupervisionwereprovidedperweek,3%said0hours,16%said1-2hours,24%said3-4hours,10%said5-6hours,and47%said7+hours.Eighty-onepercent(81%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheirexpectationsofinternjobresponsibilitiesandworkloadmatchedorwereexceededbywhatactuallyhappened.Eighty-twopercent(82%)ofthesupervisorsansweredthatatleastoneoftheirinternswasagoodmatchfortheirorganizationsandpositions.Sixty-eightpercent(68%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheinternswerethebestpartoftheinternships.Supervisorssaidthatinternswerepreparedtoworkwithvaluableskillsandprofessionalattitudes,gainedvaluableworkexperience,madesignificantcontributionstothecompany,workedhard,andweregreattoworkwith.Alsomentionedby27%ofsupervisorswashowBrookLynkwasoverallwellorganized,matchedinternswell,andprovidedgoodsupportfromtheprogramcoordinator.Finally,7%ofsupervisorssaidthatthebestpartoftheinternshipforthemwashowmuchtheylearnedandbenefitedfrommentoringtheinterns.Whenaskedaboutproblemstheyfaced,30%ofsupervisorssaidthatthelevelofskillsthatthehighschoolinternshadwaslowerthantheyhadexpected.Seventeenpercent(17%)saidthattheircompanyororganization’sinternalpoliciesorproceduresneededtobeadjustedtobetteronboardorworkwithstudentinterns.Fifteenpercent(15%)wishedtheirinternswerewiththemforalongerperiod.Another13%reportedthattheydidn’thavethetimetheyhadhopedtoproperlysupervisetheintern.Afew(9%)supervisorsmentionedthathadproblemswiththeinternsnotbeingmotivatedorwithnotshowingupforwork.And9%wouldhavelikedbettercommunicationwithBrookLynk.SupervisorssuggestedthatweprovideassistancetotheircompaniesororganizationstoimprovetheirinternalstructuresorproceduresaroundhiringandworkingwithaBrookLynkintern.Supervisorswouldalsolikemoreassistancearoundtheinternshipitself(suchasthecapstoneproject,expectationsofmentors,toolstousewithinterns,etc.).Somesupervisorswouldliketobemoreinvolvedwithselectingtheirinterns.Providinginternswithmoretrainingaroundbasicofficeskills(Outlook,Excel,preparingformeetings,etc.)

Page 30: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 30

wasanothersuggestion.Otherimprovementssuggestedincludeallowinglongerinternships,providingmoresupportsforinternswithspecialneeds,helpingtogetinternstorespondtofillingoutpaperworkanddrugscreeningduringtheonboardingphase,andsyncingcommunicationsbetweenBrookLynkandinternalcoordinators.Ninety-twopercent(92%)ofthesupervisorsrespondedthattheywouldliketoparticipateintheBrookLynkprogramnextyearwithanotherstudent.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Communicatetheimportanceofthesupervisor’srole(andtrainingaroundthat)increatingahigh-qualityinternshipexperience;sharethisevaluationwiththem.

• Increaseoptionsforsupervisorstoattendtraining.• Providetechnicalassistancetoemployerstoimprovetheirinternalprocessesfor

hiringyouthandforsupportingsupervisors.• Considerwaystoprovideinternswithmoretrainingaroundjobskillsemployers

need(Outlook,Excel,etc.)includingworkingwithschoolsandhaveemployersprovideOn-The-JobTraining.

Three-YearReviewThepercentageofsupervisorswhothoughttheSupervisorTrainingwasusefulhasincreasedinthe3years.ThehighlevelofsupportthatBrookLynkstaffhasofferedtosupervisors,settingtherightexpectationsforemployers,theperceptionthatinternmatcheshavebeengood,andcompaniesandorganizationswantingtoparticipateinBrookLynkagain,havenotchangedoverthatsametimeperiod.Wehavelearnedthatweneedtokeepmonitoringthetimingbetweenmatchingandthestartofinternshipstoallowforcompanies’andorganizations’internalhiringprocessesenoughtime,tohelpeachemployertoprovidetherightsupportsforsupervisors,andtoimprovethetrainingpotentialinternsreceivetomeettheneedsoftoday’sworkforce.

CapacityBuildingTheevaluationofcapacitybuildingisseparatedintothefollowingthreesections:degreeofsupports,programcostsandpoliticalwill.DegreeofSupportsWhatisthedegreeofsupportsnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?Wedefinesupportstoincludeourinternshipbusiness(includingeducationalandcommunity)partners,ourAlliancepartnerswhoprovidedin-kinddonations,andorganizationspartneredwithtoimplementvariouscomponentsoftheBrookLynkprogram.Overallwefoundanincreasinglyhighlevelofsupporttooperate,customizeandmanagetheprogram.Therewasincreasedinterestfromourbusinesscommunityevidencedby106pledgedinternships,whichsurpassedthegoalof100forthisyear.FundingpartnersprovidedresourcesneededtohireaBrookLynkSpecialisttoassistinthecoordinatingmoreinternships.Alliancepartnersalsoshowedahighdegreeofsupportinprovidingresources

Page 31: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 31

tosupportprogramoperations.ThecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkhavetakentheleadinpreparingforthetransitionoftheprogramtotheirorganizations.Withallofthissupport,staffrecognizedthatstrongerpipelinesneedtobeestablishedbetweennon-profitsandpublicagencieswhodirectlyworkwithcounty-involvedyouth(CIY)inordertoconnectthoseyouthtoBrookLynkopportunities.

_____________________________Keyresourcesrequiredforimplementationarepledgedinternshippositions,andfundingthecoordinationwork.Therewasasignificantincreaseinpledgedinternshipsduetothreereasons.First,diligentworkoftheProgramCoordinatorandExecutiveDirectortoengagebusinesses.Second,fundingprovidedbytheHennepinCountyEquityGrantallowedforpartialsubsidiesforinternshipwages.Third,privatesectoremployershaveincreasedtheircommitment.Thereareseveralkeystakeholdersthatinvestincollaborativeworktodevelopandsupporttheprogram.TheBrookLynkSteeringCommitteemetmonthlyandprovidedoversightfortheprogram.Youthwereapartofafewofthesemeetingsandincludedinotherdecision-makingsessions.Programpartnersalsohaveprovidedsignificantin-kindresourcestosupportprogramoperations,whichincludephysicalspacefortrainings,check-ins,jobfair,andmeetings.Andmovingforward,thecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkwillbemakingequalcontributionstothebasebudgetofBrookLynk.BrookLynkstaffhavealsobeenintentionalwithkeepingvariousstakeholdersengagedinthereporting,planninganddecision-makingprocess,forexample,thegroundworkthattheBBAhasdonewithfosteringanongoingrelationshipwithCumminsPowerSystemsandhavingsupportfromBostonScientifictopresenttoCityCouncil’sduringtheco-operationagreementnegotiationswaskey.KeyleadersfromthecitieshavebeendeeplyengagedincreatingacooperationagreementthatprovidesthelegalarrangementneededtotransitionBrookLynkintotheoperationsofthecities.TheirleadershiphasbeenengagedinthemanagementconversationswithcurrentBrookLynkstafftounderstandtheprogrammingelementsandhaveparticipatedinin-depthnegotiationsregardinghowtheprogramwillbemanagedandpaidfor.Staffreflectionsnotethatalthoughpartnershipstoreachcounty-involvedyouth(CIY)youthhaveimproved,wearestillunderourperformancegoalof30%ofyouthservedwillbeopportunityyouthorcountyinvolved.Movingforward,staffrecommendedstrongerpipelinestobeestablishedbetweenBrookLynkandnon-profitsandpublicagencieswhodirectlyworkwiththeseyouth.Additionalprofessionaldevelopmentmaybeneededforstaff,andforemployers,toeffectivelyengageandplacetheseyouthinsuccessfulinternshipandemploymentopportunities.Asonestaffstated,“Ifthisisnotanintentionalaspectofgrowth,itwilleasilybecomeapopulation‘toodifficult’fortheprogramtoeffectivelyserve.”AnotherchallengeinaccessingprivatesectorfundraisingsupporthasbeenthelimitationsinfundraisingcapacitywiththeExecutiveDirector.Moresupportisneededtothoroughlyleverageresourcesasasteptocreatingamoreefficientandeffectiveprocessforbringingresourcestotheprogram.

Page 32: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 32

NextSteps• ContinuewiththeBrookLynkSteeringCommittee,andputenergyintoestablishinga

newadvisoryduringthetransition.• Establishstrongerpipelinestonon-profitsandpublicagencieswhodirectlyworkwith

county-involvedyouth(CIY),torecruitandsupportthemintheirBrookLynkinternship.• Determinehowtostrategicallybuildresourcescollaboratively.Staffidentifiedtheneed

todevelopacollaborativetimeline,expectations,andclarityregardingfundraising.• Explorehowtorecovercostsrelatedforcoordinationefforts.• CreateaBrookLynkoperationsmanualsothatthevariousprogrammingelements,

fundraisingstrategies,marketing/communicationsplans,andstrategicplanningofBrookLynkcanbeeffectivelycommunicatedandtaughttonewstaff/partners.

ProgramCostWhataretheprogramcostsnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?Insummaryprogramscostsareprimarilyrelatedtostaffwhocoordinateandsupervisetheprogram.Thismodelisdesignedforonefulltimeemployeeforevery60youthmatched.Astheprogramnearlydoubledinyouthserved,thebudgetalsoexpandedtohirea2ndFTE.TheBrookLynkmulti-yearbudgethasbeencreatedandwasacriticalstepincreatingthecooperationagreement.

_____________________________Theexactcostsoftheprogramfluctuatedin2017.Withtheadditionofanewfull-timestaffmemberandasignificantincreaseinthenumberofinternsthatwereserved,thisyear’scostsweregreaterthaninyears’past.Costsarenotlikelytoexpandnextyearsincenosignificantprogramexpansionisplanned.TheBrookLynkmulti-yearbudgethasbeencreatedandwasacriticalstepindevelopingthecooperationagreement.Citypartnershaveagreedtosplitcoreprogramexpenses,aswellasjointlyfundraisefortheprogramwithsupportfromtheAlliance.ThecooperationagreementhadunanimouscitycouncilapprovalfrombothcitiesinAugustof2017.Withthisinagreementinplace,theprogramhasmadeasignificantstepforwardinlong-termfinancialsustainability.Asstaffreported,theexpansionoftheprogram,bothinthenumberofyouthservedandthetypesofservicesbeingoffered,mademanagingthedaytodayexpensesandthebudgetsetbytheboardchallenging.Programstabilitywillmakeitpossibleforstafftobettermanageresources,andmoreimportantly,makeiteasiertobuildpartnerships,in-kindcontribu-tions,anddonationsforvariousaspectsoftheprogram.(e.g.findingsponsorsfortheendofyeareventorbettermanagingexpensesfortraining).DatacollectionfortheBrookLynkevaluationhasundergoneathoroughautomationthankstosupportfromtheBremerFoundation.Theautomationoftheevaluationdatacollection

Page 33: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 33

hasreducedcollectionandanalysistime.Thiswillsavecostsrelatedtoevaluationworkneededfornextyear.NextSteps

• Programcostsforstaffingaretopfundraisingpriority:thecitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynParkwillimplementthecooperationagreementandtherebyapprovethecityfundingtosupport40%oftheprogramcosts.

• TherewillbeseveralopportunitiesforreportingtoBremer,UnitedWayandothersthatshouldbeseenashighpriorityfundraisingopportunitiesthatbothmanagementandstaffshouldbeengagedin.

PoliticalWillWhatisthepoliticalwillnecessarytooperatethiscustomizedmodeleffectivelyandefficientlyfortheBrooklyns?PoliticalwillisdefinedasbuildingthedesireandinterestinoperatingtheBrookLynkprogram.Itincludesabroadbaseofstakeholderswhosupporttheprogramanddesiretoseeitsuccessful.Insummary,thecooperationagreementtotransitionBrookLynktotheCitiesin2018isanimportantindicationthatpoliticalwillishighamongourpartners.TheAllianceprovidedaplaceforBrookLynktogrowththatbuiltpoliticalwill,primarilythroughhighlightingthatbothyouthandemployersexpresscontinuedinterestandneedforBrookLynk.

_____________________________Staffnotethattheeffortsmadetoincludeabroadsetofstakeholdersindevelopingtheprogramhascreatedsharedownership.Overthelastyearstakeholdersweredirectlyorindirectlyinvolvedinthefollowingprocesses:

• CreatingtheBrookLynkmission,vision,andvalues• DesigningtheAlumniNetworkthroughparticipatoryprocesses• Automatingtheevaluation• Implementingaparticipatoryprocessfortheyouthledjobfair• CreatingagreatBrookLynkwebsite• CraftingformalMemorandumsofUnderstandingwithreferralpartners

Thecommunitysupportforthisprogramwasevidencedbythelettersofsupportprovidedfortheprogramtocitypolicymakers.TheselettersweregatheredbytheAlliancetosharewithcitycouncilmemberspriortoagreeingtothetransitionoftheprogram.Theselettersprovidedtestimonialsfrombusinesses,communityleaders,andyouthwhodescribedthepowerfulimpactBrookLynkhashadontheirlife.TheAlliance,asayouthdevelopmentintermediary,hasplayedakeyroleincreatingtheconditionsforthegrowthandexpansionoftheprogramwhilesupportedwithprogramdesignandsupportforstaffduringchange.RegionaleconomicconditionshavealsobuiltpoliticalwillforBrookLynk.Theincreasedregional,nationalattentionontheworkforceshortagehascreatedaneconomiccontext

Page 34: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 34

whereeffortslikeBrookLynkarevaluable.ThecitiesofBrooklynParkandBrooklynCenterrecentlycompletedtheirstrategicplanswhichfocusonincreasingeconomicvitalityaswellasyouthengagement.Alsooutlinedintheseplansareeffortstostrengthenthelocalworkforceandbetterconnectresidentstolocalemployers.ThisalignmenthascreatedabroaderandveryimportantopportunityforBrookLynktocontributetothemissionforbothcities.Thecities’capacitytomanagethistypeofprogramhasdevelopedsignificantly.Therehasbeentremendousinvestmentfromleadershipinbothcitiestomeetbi-monthlytolearnthemanagementprocessandtobeapartofdecision-making.CityleadershiphasalsoincreasedtheirparticipationinregionalmeetingsrelatedtoBrookLynkandhasjoinedtheExecutiveDirectorinseveralmeetingswithfunders,includingtheUnitedWayandthePohladFoundation.TheHennepinTechnicalCollegestaffhasbeenamajorsupporttotheprogram,andisnowfullysustainedbyafederalPerkinsgrant.HennepinCountyhasamissionaroundyouthworkforcedevelopmentandthisyearprovidedtheEquityGranttosupportourwork.Thisyear,manyAlliancepartnershaveputBrookLynkinternshipsintheirbudgets.NextSteps

• ContinuetogrowtheBrookLynkprogramtorespondtocommunityneed.• Simplifytheevaluation.• Createauniqueandengagingrecruitmentpiecesforfunders,employers,andpolicy

makers.• Continuetogrowstrategicpartnerships.• Continuetoidentifyandengagenewstakeholders.

ProcessEvaluationWhatdidwedotocustomizetheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodelfortheBrooklyns?Howwelldidthecustomizedprogramwork?ProgramDevelopmentMinneapolisSTEP-UPprovidedtheirlogicmodelandevaluationsoftheirprogram,whichhelpedBrookLynktorefineourownlogicmodelandcreateourownprocessmap.Acomprehensiveevaluationplanwascreatedtocollectandmeasureprogramoutputs,processes,quality,andoutcomes.

_____________________________TheBrooklynBridgeAllianceforYouthcustomizedtheSTEP-UPSummerJobsProgrammodelfromMinneapolisforthecommunitiesofBrooklynCenterandBrooklynPark.WithtechnicalassistancefromSTEP-UP,weconsideredtheirlogicmodelandevaluationsoftheirprogramtorefineourownlogicmodelandcreateourownprocessmap.Acomprehensiveevaluationplanwascreatedtocollectandmeasureprogramoutputs,processes,quality,andoutcomes.Allthreehavebeenupdatedforthe2017programandcanbefoundintheAppendix.

Page 35: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 35

OutreachAnewoutreachstrategyfor2017,theReferralPartnerprogramrecruitedpointsofcontactsat8differenthighschoolsand5youth-servingorganizationstogetyouthtoapplytoBrookLynkandattendthetrainings.Thisyear’sapplicationwashostedonlinewithSurveyMonkey.Themobilefriendlywebsitemadeoutreacheasierasstaffcouldstudentsregisteronthespot.BrookLynkreacheditsgoalof500applicantstotheprogram.

_____________________________Anewoutreachstrategyfor2017wastheReferralPartnerprogram.BrookLynkstaffrecruitedcontactsat8highschoolswithBrooklynsstudents(BrooklynCenterAcademy,BrooklynCenterSecondary,ChamplinParkHighSchool,OsseoAreaLearningCenter,OsseoSeniorHigh,ParkCenterHighSchool,RobbinsdaleArmstrongHighSchool,andHTCGatewaytoCollege)and5otheryouth-servingorganizations(YMCA,MNWorkforceCenter,AvenuesforHomelessYouth,BrooklynParkZanewoodCommunityCenter,andHennepinCountyJuvenileProbationandExtendedFosterCareServices).MemorandumsofunderstandingwerecreatedbetweenBrookLynkandtheseorganizationstosetgoalsforrecruitment,outreachstrategies,andschedules.Atotalof16BrookLynkAmbassadors(alumni)activelyreachoutattheirownschoolsalsohelpedwithrecruitingefforts.

SchoolReferralPartnersReferralPartnerGoals

Applicant TrainingCompletion

InternshipPlacement

BrooklynCenterAcademy 15 10 6BrooklynCenterSecondary 105 105 16ChamplinParkHighSchool 100 70 16OsseoAreaLearningCenter N/A N/A 3OsseoSeniorHigh 70 35 10ParkCenterHighSchool 125 100 35RobbinsdaleArmstrongHighSchool N/A N/A 3HTCGatewaytoCollege 10 5 3Total 425 325 89TheReferralPartnerswerekeyinhelpingBrookLynkreachthe500applicantsaimedfor.Eachreferralpartnershiphelpedtoinformandmarkettopotentialyouthparticipantsindifferentways.Schoolpartnersallowedstafftouseinternalcommunicationsuchasnewsletters,Schoology(anonlinelearningmanagementsystem),andotheronlineplatformstomarketBrookLynk.Staffwereablecomeoncampusanduseschoolfacilitiestohostinformationalsessionsandtableduringschoolevents,whichoftenresultedinhighernumbersofapplicantsduringthosetimes.Rightbeforethetrainings,thereferralpartnerswouldhelpsetupfollow-upsessionswithBrookLynkstaffandapplicantstoansweranyquestionsandasanotherremindertoattend.InschoolsthatwerelocatedoutsideoftheBrooklynsitwashelpfulwhentheReferralPartnerpointofcontactgottogetherstudentswholivedinBrooklynParkandBrooklynCenter(andthuseligiblefortheprogram)fortheinformationalsessions.AvenuesforHomelessYouthwasonceagainabletorefermanyoftheirresidentstoourprogram.

Page 36: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 36

Thisyear’sapplicationwashostedonlinewithSurveyMonkey.Havinganonlineregistrationthatwasmobilefriendlymadeoutreacheasierasstaffcouldstudentsregisteronthespot.Theapplicationwasdesignedtoweedoutyouthwhoweren’teligiblefortheprogram,butmanyapplicantsdidnotreadtheeligibilityquestionscarefullyandthuswouldapplymultipletimes.ThiscausedmoreworkfortheBrookLynkstafftoclearoutthepartiallyfilledoutapplications.Outreachtoemployerswentwellasstaffwereabletoleverageexistingrelationshipswithemployersandotherpartnerstogetinternshipspledged.TherewasasignificantincreaseinthenumberofinternshipsbeinghostedbylocalemployersbutwealsowelcomednewemployerslikeCumminsPowerSystemsandRobbinsdaleAreaSchools.TheHennepinCountyWorkforceEquityGrantallowedforourpublicsectorpartnerstoincreasethenumberofinternshipstheywereabletohost,allowingBrookLynkstaffcapacitytobemaximized.BrookLynkworkedwithChannel12tocreatevideosaboutregisteringfortraining.Inoneofthevideos,aBrookLynkAmbassadorwasfeatured.BrookLynkalumniwerekeypartnersintheoutreachprocessandingivingpresentationstobothemployersandpotentialyouth.Itwasdifficultgainingtractionwithfaithcommunitiesandcountyserviceproviders.ManyoftheOpportunityYoutharecounty-involved,sothelackofconnectionwiththecountyserviceprovidersmadeitdifficulttorecruitthatpopulation.SuggestionsforImprovement

• CreateatargetedandsupportedoutreachstrategytoengageOpportunityYouth,includingmoreconnectionstocountyserviceprovidersandotherorganizationsservingthatpopulation.

• Attendprofessionaldevelopmentforprogramstafftoeffectivelyengageandsupportcountyinvolved/opportunityyouththroughouttheBrookLynkexperience.

• OutreachtorecruitsimilarnumbersofyouthfromBrooklynCenterasBrooklynParktomeettheBrookLynkCooperationAgreement’sgoalofequalnumberofyouthfromeachcity.

• Createreferralpartnershipswiththecountyserviceprovidersandfaith-basedcommunityorganizations.

• AllowtheAmbassadorstotakeagreaterleadonmarketingattheirschoolsandhavingtwoAmbassadorsorstudentpointsofcontactforeachschoolifpossible.Ambassadorshavethecapacitytotableatschooleventsandtakeonotheroutreachinitiatives.

• WorkwithBrooklynParkstafftocreatemarketingmaterialinthefallthateachschoolpointofcontactcansendoutwhenrecruitingbegins.

• Createasinglepageapplicationsothatallofastudent’sinformationiscollected.• Haveamorecomprehensivecommunicationsplan/pitchtoemployerswith

supportingmaterialsthatincludebrochures,evaluationsummaries,testimonials,andinfographics.

• HavetheBrookLynkAmbassadorsleadasocialmediacampaignthroughamoreorganicinitiativethatcreatesbuzzearlieron.

• Leveragesocialmediamoretobeontheradarofemployersandyoungpeople,suchasusingLinkedIntopublishsuccessstoriesandnewsaboutBrookLynk.

Page 37: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 37

• Betterusetraditionalmedia(Channel12,theSunPost,andothernewsoutlets)torecruityouthandcommunicatetheworkBrookLynkdoesinthecommunity.

WorkReadinessTrainingBrookLynkadoptedMinneapolisSTEP-UP’sworkreadinesstrainingandmockinterviews,builtupontheirtraininghandbookandaddedtheMHALabsSkillBuildingBlocksandWorkCoreSkills.Onaverage,studentsratedtheworkreadinesstraininga4.3outof5.0.Onlyabout44%oftheyouthwhoappliedfortheprogramattendedtheGetReady!WorkReadinessTrainings,similartothe42%attendanceratefromlastyear.AfterscoringlowintheYPQAfortwoyearsaroundyouthinteractionandengagement,participantsweregivenachoicethreedifferenttracks,andyouthalumniandadulttrainerswereco-trainers.

_____________________________GetReady!WorkReadinessTrainingconsistedof7.5hours(includinglunch)ofinstructiononcommunication,networking,professionalism,emailandphoneetiquette,resumes,applications,andinterviews.StudentsweregiventheoptionofattendingoneoftwoSaturdays(March25thandApril1st).HennepinTechnicalCollegeprovidedtheirfacilitiesforthetraining.TransportationwasofferedtostudentsviaMetroTransitbustokens.OneachoftheWednesdaysfollowingtheGetReady!Training,mockinterviewswerescheduledatBrooklynParkCommunityActivityCenter.VolunteerinterviewerswererecruitedfromAlliancepartnersandthecommunity.Eachstudentwasaskedtobringacurrentresume,andsatthroughashortinterviewfollowedbyfeedbackprovidedbytheinterviewer.Anadditional7-hourtrainingforyouthages16andoverwhowereinterestedinapplyingforinternshipswasheldonApril8thatNorthHennepinCommunityCollege

Year AttendanceRate2015 48%2016 42%2017 45%

Onaverage,studentsratedtheworkreadinesstraininga4.3outof5.0.Whenaskedwhattheylikedmostaboutthetraining,participantsrespondedwithmeetingotherpeople(68%),Learningaboutapplications,resumes,andinterviews(68%),theinstructors(63%),theinformationsharedaboutgettingandkeepingajob(63%),andtheactivities(37%).AfterscoringlowintheYPQAfortwoyearsaroundyouthinteractionandengagement,severalprogramdesignchangesweremadetothetraining.First,therewerethreedifferenttracks(beginning,intermediate,andadvanced)thatstudentscouldchoosefrom.Eachofthelevelsweregearedtothelevelofexperiencethatstudentshadwiththeskillsthatweretaughtduringtraining.Uponfurtherreflection,thetrainingtracksforGetReady!couldhavebeenexecutedbettertoprovideamoreseamlessprocessforparticipants,staff,andtrainers.Whenusing

Page 38: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 38

HennepinTechnicalCollege,BrookLynkmustcontractwithaspecificcatererfortheeven,whichcausedasignificantstrainonthefoodbudget.Transportationtotrainingcontinuedbeinganissueassomeyoungpeoplewereunabletofindaridethedayof.Someretuningprogramparticipantscomplainedthattheydidnotlearnanythingnewatthetrainings.Thereneedstobefurthertrainingwithadulttrainerstoeffectivelyengageyouthasco-trainers,sincesometrainerswerenotasgoodatitasothers.Attheendofthefirsttraining,thecertificateswerenotreadytohandoutsonoteverystudentsreceivedtheirsatthetraining.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Havingthestudentschoosewhatlevelofworkexperiencetheyconsiderthemselvesinwhentheyregisterinitiallysotheydon'thavetodosopriortotraining.

• RefinetheBrookLynkGetReady!andInternshipTrainingtobereflectiveoftheneedsofyouthanddemandsofemployers.ThisrefinedversionshouldalsoaddressthequestionaboutyouthparticipatingBrookLynkformultipleyearsandtheirneedtotakepartintraining.

• AskMetroTransitorapartneringtransportationcompanytoprovidetransportationservicesforyoungpeople.

• HostGetReady!atamorecentrallylocatedspaceandthatisaccessiblebythevariousbusroutes.

• PilotGetReady!atoneofthealternativelearningcentersintheBrooklynsandgaugethelevelofparticipationandcompletionofBrookLynkbytheparticipatingcohort.

• Completethreeseparatetrain-the-trainersessionswithtrainersthat1)allowthemtounderstandthecurriculumandBrookLynk,2)buildarelationshipwithco-trainers,and3)practicecurriculumimplementationwithfeedbackfrompeers.

MatchingThematchingprocesswassimilartoMinneapolisSTEP-UP’s,althoughwithfarfewerapplicantsandinternshipopportunities.BrookLynkmatchedthestudentsbasedontheirage,transportationoptions,skilllevel,workexperience,careerinterest,andtheirattendanceattrainingevents.Additionally,BrookLynkonlyhadonetierofinternshipscomparedtothethreethatSTEP-UPusestoseparatelevelsofinternships.Thematchingwaseasierthisyearsincethiswasthethirdtimethatstaffhadgonethroughthisprocess.BrookLynkstafftookalmostafullworkdaytomatch104youthtointernships.Eighty-twopercent(82%)ofthesupervisorsansweredthatatleastoneoftheirinternswasagoodmatchfortheirorganizationsandpositions.Sixty-sixpercent(66%)ofinternsexpressedthattheirinternshipshelpedthemfocusonspecificcareerpathwaysthatalignedwiththeirlifegoals.

_____________________________InthemiddleofApril,Alliancestaffmettogethertomatchstudentstointernships.Thiswascompletedaweekearlierthanlastyearsothatemployerswouldhaveextratimetoonboardtheirinternsandalsotoallowforyouthtoknowtheirmatchstatusbeforetheyouthjobfair.Ascorecardforeachinternwascreatedwithdemographicinformation,

Page 39: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 39

opportunityyouthstatus,transportationoptions,availability,trainingandmockinterviewattendance,trainerevaluations,andpersonalinterests.Similarscorecardswerecreatedforeachpositionusingthejobdescriptionssentinbyemployers.Thesewereallconsidered,alongwithjobrequirementsanddescriptionssubmittedbyemployers.Theprioritiesformatchingwereasfollows:

• OpportunityYouth• Internshipswithagerequirements• Internshipsinlocationswithnopublictransportationoptions• Skill-levelexpectationfromemployersandskill-levelofinterns• Workexperience• Careerinterestsofstudentsmatchedwithcareerfieldsofinternshipsand/or

employers• Attendanceattrainingsandmockinterview,andtrainerandinterviewratings• Overallmixofethnicity,gender,school,andcityofresidencearebalanced

OncematchedInterncandidateswerecontactedbyphonetoexplainthejobstheywerematchedtoandaskediftheywouldaccept.Ifso,thecorrespondingsupervisorsweregiventhecandidate’scontactinfotosetupaninterview.Aftertheinterviewsoccurred,bothinternsandsupervisorsmadeafinalchoiceatwhichtimetheemployerstartedthehiringprocess.Thematchingwaseasierthisyearsincethiswasthethirdtimethatstaffhadgonethroughthisprocess.Knowingsomestudentsandsupervisorsfrompreviousyears,andmeetingthenewstudentsatthetrainingsallowedstafftobemoremindfulabouttheyoungpeoplethatwerebeingmatched.Thisyear,OpportunityYouthwerenotrestrictedonlytospecificinternships,whichallowedthemtobematchedtocareerfieldsthattrulyinterestedthem.Theamountoftimebetweenmatchingandinterviewswasstillanissue.Therewasonlyaone-weekwindowtomatchandcontactallofthestudentsandsupervisors.Andsomeemployersturnedintheirjobdescriptionslatesofinalmatchesforthosepositionsdidn’thappenuntilalmosttheinterviewtime.Callingstudentsindividuallytodoanoverviewoftheirmatchpositionwastimeconsumingandnotalwayseffectiveinexplainingthenecessarynextsteps.Bothinternsandsupervisorswerenotalwaystimelyinrespondingtocommunications,whichmadeitdifficulttobeginthehiringprocess.Youthwhoweren’tmatchedwithaninternshiphadtransportationissues,conflictswiththeirsummerschedule,ordidn’twantthepositionsoffered.Employerswhohadpledgedinternshipsbutwerenotultimatelymatched,decidedlateronthattheyhadnocapacitytoofferaBrookLynkinternship.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Considergivingatwoorthreeweekwindowbetweenmatchingstudentsand

contactingtheemployers,whichwillallowtimeforinternstothinkabouttheirmatchdecision.

Page 40: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 40

• Requirealljobdescriptionstobesubmittedbysupervisorspriortomatching.Also,eachdescriptionformneedstoberevisedbyprogramstafftoensureithassufficientdetailstoensureahigh-qualitymatch.

• Potentiallyhosttheinternshiptrainingafterstudentshavebeenmatchedtotheirinternships.Thiswaytheyknowwhatisneededoftheminordertosuccessfullylandtheinternshipandtoeffectivelycommunicatethenextstepsandwhattheirinternshipwillentail.

• Youthshouldberequiredtoattachacopyoftheirresumetotheinternshipapplicationtostreamlinetheprocesswhensharingcontactinformationandresumesofcandidateswithsupervisors.

YouthJobFairMinneapolisSTEP-UPDiscoverprovidesjobopportunitiesforyoungeryouth(usually14-15yearsold)whoarenewtotheworkforceandlookingfortheirfirstjob.AtthistimeBrookLynkonlyoffersinternshipsforyouth16yearsandolder.Inresponsetothelackofjobopportunitiesforyoungeryouth,aYouthJobFairwasstartedthisyeartotrytoconnectthemwithlocalemployerslookingtohire.AscanofsuccessfulyouthjobfairsaroundthecountryincludedinterviewswiththeorganizationsthatrunsomeofthemoresuccessfuleventsinSanFrancisco(UnitedWay)andBoulder(WorkforceBoulderCounty).BrookLynklearnedthatmakingtheeventsyouth-centerediskeytohavingyouthattend.Totargetyouthmeansfocusingontheirinterests(funandengaging)andspecificemploymentneedswhendesigningtheevent,workingwithschoolstomarket,providingtransportationtotheevent(and/ormakingiteasilyaccessiblebypublictransportation),andprovidingadditionalworkreadinesssupports(includingmockinterviews,resumebuilding,professionalnetworking,applicationlab,etc.)attheevent.Youthwereincludedontheplanningcommitteeofthosejobfairs.Understandingthatmostyouthhavenoideahowajobfairworks,providingon-siteorientationsforyouthastheyfirstarrive,canhelpthemfeelmoreconnected.Gettingtherightemployerstoshowupisalsokey.Bothorganizationswetalkedtotargetedemployerswhohadactualjobopeningsforyouth(andespeciallyforthoseages14-15)andwhowereabletointerviewandhireon-siteatthejobfair.Thishelpeddecreaseahugebarrieringettingdisconnectedyouthconnectedtojobs.Althoughtheyweremarketedasyouthjobfairs,theyalsoincludedvolunteeropportunities,internships,andasmentionedpreviously,workreadinesstrainingsandresources.Finally,inordertogaugesuccess,theysurveyedyouthandemployersaftertheeventstounderstandhowmanyreceivedjobsduetothejobfairs.BrookLynktooktheselearningsandattemptedtoimplementthemforthisfirstYouthJobFaironApril29,2017.AplanningcommitteeconsistingofBrookLynkalumniandrepresentativesfrommanyoftheAllianceandyouth-servingorganizationpartnersmetevery3weeksbeginninginFebruary2017.Threesubcommitteeswereorganized:VolunteersandSponsors,MarketingandYouthEngagement,andLogisticsandEmployers.Asidefromtheplanningcommitteemeetingsthesubcommitteesalsometontheirown.

Page 41: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 41

Themarketingteamcreatedarecruitingvideo.Itwaswellproducedbutunfortunatelynotmanypeopleviewedit.Attheevent,14employersand4organizationsprovidingworkforcedevelopmentrelatedservicesattended.Twoemployersdroppedoutoftheeventatthelastminute.SeveralbusesprovidedbyOsseoAreaSchoolspickedupstudentsatvariousschoolsintheareatobringthemtotheYouthJobFairandreturnthem.WorkshopswereofferedtwiceanhourtoprovideanintroductionforyouthontheJobFair.ThecomputerlabwasavailableforyouthandstaffedbytheYMCAtoprovidesupportinresumebuildingandfillingoutonlineapplications.BrooklynPark’sRec-on-the-Govanwasoutsidetoproviderecreationactivitiesforanyyoungersiblingswhowereattendingwithyouth.RefreshmentswereprovidedbyOsseoAreaSchools.Duringtheevent,therewasmusic,aselfiephotobooth(withalivefeedofpicturesandtweetsprojectedontoascreen),andadrawingforprizeseveryhour.BrookLynksampledyouthandemployersatthejobfairtounderstandwhattheirexperienceswereandtogetpreliminarydataonhowsuccessfulthejobfairwasatmatchingyoungpeoplewithjobopportunities.Youthratedthejobfaira3.5(outof5.0)andemployersgaveita4.6rating.Ninety-sixpercent(96%)ofyouthsaidtheywouldrecommendittoafriendand100%ofemployerssaidtheywouldattendanotheryouthjobfair.Employerssaw23to75visitorstotheirboothsandreceivedupto50applicationsfortheirpositions.However,only5interviews(allattheirbooths)weregivenandonly1jobofferwasactuallyextendedonsite.Staffalsofollowedup6weeksaftertheeventwithemployerstoaskthemhowmanyyouththeyinterviewedandhired.Itwasdifficulttofollow-upwithmostemployersandevenwhenreached,theyhaddifficultyrecallinghowmanyinterviewsandjobofferswereextendedtoyouthcontactedinitiallyattheyouthjobfair.Bestestimatesarethat6interviewsoccurredfromthoseinitialcontacts,butnoneresultedinanactualjob.Althoughhalf(51%)ofyouthfeltthatthejobfairmettheirexpectations,all(100%)employerswhoparticipatedfeltthismettheirexpectations.Duringfollowupwiththeemployersoveramonthlaterthatitwashardforthemtoseparateoutwhichapplicantshadcomefromthejobfairspecifically.Thehopewasthatemployerswouldcomewiththerightstafftointerviewandhireonthespot,butonlyafewinterviewshappenedatthebooths,andnoneintheroomswehaddesignatedforsuch.Thereseemstobeafundamentaldifferenceinhowtheemploymentsystemcurrentlyworks,andwhatwethinkdisconnectedyouthneedinordertogettheirfootinthedoor.Forthemostpart,humanresourcedepartmentstaffsenttojobfairshavenodecision-makingcapacitywhenitcomestohiring.Theyaremostlytheretoraiseawarenessabouttheircompaniesandtheemploymentopportunitiestheyoffer.Theymostlyencourageapplicationthroughonlineportals,oratthemost,collectresumesforwhenthereareopenings.Youngpeoplewhoaren’tconnectedtothejobmarketneedamorestraightforwardpathtogetthatfirstjobonthedayoftheevent.Workingwiththepublicpartnerswasessential.Howeverthereisalsoalearningcurveforeveryonetounderstandhowayouthjobfairisdifferentfromajobfairtargetingadults

Page 42: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 42

(whichmosthadmoreexperiencewith).BrookLynkwillneedtogetschools,libraries,workforcedevelopmentcenters,andotherpublicinstitutionstothinkdifferentlyabouthowtosupportyoungpeopletogettingtheirfirstjobs,andreachingouttotheyoungpeopletheyareconnectedto.Manyyoungpeoplethinkoftheirnextstepsasafewweeksaway.Companieshiringseveralmonthsoutmeansthatthosejobsarenotevenontheradar.Asemployerswerebeingrecruitedforthejobfair,manywhohireyoungeryouthsaidthatajobfairinAprilwastoolate.Theyhirehundredsofyouthforsummerjobsatschoolsandrecreationprograms,buthiremanyoftheminMarch.Thus,toparticipatetheywouldliketheJobFairtobeheldearlierintheyear.Foryouth,itisclearfromexperiencethatdoingthejobfairinMarch,orApril,wouldbeachallengeforyouthtoplanthatfarahead.Developmentally,youthtakeactiononwhatisneedednow.Theyarelessplanfulthanadults,andoftentimeslifecircumstancesandresponsibilitiesrequiredofthemfromparentschangeplanstheymaymake.Thisisespeciallytrueforyouththathavesignificantbarriers.Structurally,thereweresomelessonslearnedaswell.Theplanningcommitteewasmissingsomekeypartners,includingrepresentativesofculturalgroupsandsomeoftheAlliancepartners.Afeworiginalcommitteemembersleftthegroupmidwaythroughtheplanning.Fewerteammeetingswouldhaveallowedthesubcommitteestomeetseparatelyandgetmoreworkdone.TheVolunteerandSponsorsgroupwaslessclearabouttheirrole,maybewasresponsibleforareasthataretoodifferent,andneededtowaitforothergroupstofinalizetheirpartsfirst.Regardingsponsorshipstwokeyquestionsemerged:Whatistherightwaytoengagesponsorship,whatarethelevels,whataretheneeds?TheBusinessOutreachandLogisticsgroupneededmorepeopletodooutreachthanjusttheProgramCoordinator.CreatingthemarketingmaterialtookupalotofthetimeoftheBrookLynkspecialist.Therewasascramblerightbeforetheeventtoorganizetheworkshopsbecausenoonewasassignedtoitoriginally.Only$1900outofthe$5000budgetedwasspent(notincludingin-kinddonationsforbuses,roomrental,food,etc.).Onthedayoftheeventtherewasadeafstudentwhoattended.Therewerenointerpretersscheduled;thankfully,oneoftheparentsknewASLandcouldinterpret.ThebusdriversdroppedstudentsoffattheotherendoftheNorthHennepinCommunityCollegecampusfromwheretheeventwasheld.Nodatawascollectedonhowmanyyouthtookadvantageofthebuses.Sincethisisthefirstyearoftheevent,thereweremanyshortfallsandlessonslearned.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Recruitemployershiringforpositionsandtrainthemtohireonthespot.• Settleoncertaindetailsbeforemeetingwithplanningcommittee,suchasdates,

budget,andlocation.• Reachouttoemployersandyouthworkforcedevelopmentorganizationsyear-

roundtoplanforthisevent.• Reconfiguresubcommitteesbasedonlessonslearnedfromthisyearaboutwhich

tasksarealigned:VolunteerswithLogistics,andSponsorswithMarketing

Page 43: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 43

• Createamarketingrolloutprocess,startingwitha“savethedate”or“keepaneyeout”notice.Makesurethemarketingistimedearlyenoughsoeveryonehasenoughadvancenotice.

• Attendotherjobfairsduringtheyeartomeetrecruitersandorganizations.• ConsiderpartneringwiththeCityofMinneapolis’TeenJobFair.• Scheduleinterpreters(includingASL)foryouthwhoneedlanguageservicesand

considerotherwaystoensureaninclusiveevent.• Havevolunteersonthebusestocounthowmanyyouthusethem,andtoprovide

supportoranswerquestions.• Askforcontactinformationofbusdriverstomakesurethatstudentsgetpickedup

anddroppedoffatthecorrecttimesandlocations.• Createanevaluationplantobetterassessthejobfair.

InterviewsandOnboardingTheinterviewingandonboardingprocesswasadoptedfromtheMinneapolisSTEP-UPmodel.BrookLynkalsoprovidedamorecomprehensivesupervisor’strainingtoincludeMHALabsSkillBuildingBlocksandparentswereinvitedtotheinternorientation.For66%ofsupervisors,itwastheirfirsttimeemployingahighschoolstudent.Eighty-ninepercent(89%)ofthesupervisorsthoughttheSupervisorTrainingwashelpful,especiallyinhelpingthemunderstandhowtoworkwithandrelatetohighschoolstudents.However,someemployersstillhadissueswithonboardingtheirinterns.

_____________________________Employersandstudentswerenotifiedofthestaff’smatchesattheendofApril,afterwhichinterviewswereconducted.Employersweregivenafewweeksfortheirinternalhiringprocessestoonboardtheirinterns.OnMay26th,supervisorsgatheredatNorthHennepinCommunityCentertoreceiveSupervisorTrainingonwhattoexpectwiththestudentstheywouldbeworkingwith,theMeasuresofHumanAchievement(MHA)tooltheywouldbeusingtoprovidecareerskillfeedbackwith,andotherlogisticalissuesrelatedtothesummerinternships.AnInternOrientationwasheldatBrooklynParkCommunityActivityCenteronJune9thasafinalpreparationforstudentsandparents.ForthoseinternswhoneededhelpwithtransportationMetroTransitprovidedaworkshoponhowtotakepublictransit.FireflyCreditUniongaveanotherworkshoponfinancialliteracy.Oneofthebigchangestothisyear’sprogramwashavinghiringcoordinators(atemployerswith4ormoreinterns:Cummins,BostonScientific,CityofBrooklynCenter,CityofBrooklynPark,OsseoAreaSchools,BrooklynCenterSecondary,RobbinsdaleAreaSchools,HennepinTechnicalCollege,NorthHennepinCommunityCollege,andAnokaHennepinSchoolDistrict)playakeyroleinprovidinginformation,relayingcommunications,andmakingsuretheonboardingprocesswasgoingsmoothlyasasupportfortheirorganization’sinternsandsupervisors.For66%ofsupervisors,itwastheirfirsttimeemployingahighschoolstudent,sotheyneededsomesupportbeforestartingtheinternships.Eighty-ninepercent(89%)ofthesupervisorsthoughttheSupervisorTrainingwashelpful.

Page 44: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 44

Therewasfeedbackfromsupervisorsthattheywereimpressedbythelevelofpreparednessthatinternsdisplayedduringtheirinterviews.Contactingtheinternspriortotheirinterviewstogivetheminformationthattheywouldneedfortheirinterviewandonboardingprocess.Forthemostpart,studentsandsupervisorswereresponsivetothecommunicationsbeingsenttooneanother.MostoftheinterviewsandonboardingtookplaceinthetimeframethatBrookLynksuggested.However,someinterviewstookplaceclosetothestartingdatesoftheinternships,sotherewasalonggapforstudentswaitingtohearbackforaninterview.Somesupervisorsandinternswerenotresponsivetoemailandphonecommunications,ortheybothhadconflictingschedulesthatmadeitdifficulttoorganizeatimetomeet,whichcausedsomeinterviewstobeconductedmuchlaterintheprocess.Afewstudentsdidn’thaveproperdocumentationforworkingortheywereintheprocessoforderingthem,whichsloweddowntheonboardingprocess.Somestudentshaddifficultywithhavingaccesstotransportationtotheirinterviewsiteduringbusinesshourswhileothersfacedchallengeswithsettingupabankaccount.Asignificantpercentageofopportunityyouththatwerematchedtoaninternshipdidnotcompletetheinterviewing/hiringprocess.Afterschoolwasletouttheseyouthnolongerhadsupportfromschoolstafftoencouragethemtoparticipate.SomestudentsdidnotrespondtocommunicationsfromsupervisorsandBrookLynkstaff.Thereseemedtobealotofuncertaintyandquestionsfromsupervisorsabouttheinternalhiringpracticesatvariousemployers,forexample,wherewillinternsbeofficed,dotheygetaccesstotechnology,whenaretheyexpectedtostartandfinishtheirinternships,andiftheyareeligibleforbenefitsandvacation.Forthoseemployersthathadmappedoutanonboardingandhiringprocess,theprocessitselfwasefficientandeffective.Itallowedfortheemployerandtheinterntounderstandwhattheyneededtocompleteandbywhenanditprovidedatrackerforprogress.TheconsistentcommunicationbetweenBrookLynkstaff,studentsandsupervisorsprovedtobeeffectiveinsupportingeachthroughtheinterviewingandonboardingprocess.InternsandsupervisorscontactedtheBrooklynkstaffiftheyneededadditionalsupportorhadquestions.Withtheexceptionofa5-7students,theinitialmatchesprovidedtosupervisorsweresuccessful.Eighty-twopercent(82%)ofsupervisorsagreedthattheirinternswereagoodmatchfortheircompanies.SuggestionsforImprovement

• MeetingalloftheworksitehiringcoordinatorspriortomatchingandinterviewingtogothroughBrookLynkinternshipprogrammingsteps.Thecoordinatorswouldthenrelaythisinformationtothesupervisorsattheirworksite

• Lookintowaysthatstudentscanaccessfreebankingapps.• Askinternsintheinternshipapplicationwhethertheyhavetheproperwork

documents.

Page 45: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 45

• Scheduleaninterviewdateaheadoftimeforsupervisorsandinternsatthevariousemploymentlocationstoreduceconfusionastowhentheinterviewswillbetakingplaceandhowtocoordinate.

• Haveeveryinternshipcandidatesubmitacopyofhisorherresumepriorwhencompletingtheinternshipapplication;thiswillhelpstreamlinetheinterviewingprocess.

• HaveprogramstaffworkwiththevariousinternshiplocationstooutlineanddetailtheinternalhiringprocessofBrookLynkinterns.Andthen,coordinateamandatoryworksessionwitheverysupervisorattheirlocationthatwilloutlinetheprocess,policies,andanswerlogisticalquestionsthattheymayhave.

• Keepacopyoftheonboardingproceduresforeveryemployerworksitesothatjobcoachescanfollowupwithstudentsasnecessary.

InternshipsAsmentionedpreviously,BrookLynkdiffersfromMinneapolisSTEP-UPinthatBrookLynkinternshipsarenotseparatedintothreetiers(Achieve,Discover,andExplore).Otherwise,theinternshipsaremodeledoffoftheSTEP-UPprogram:theyarepaid,supervisorsfromtheemployersmentortheinterns,therearesitevisits,andemployersandinternsreceiveweeklyupdatesfromBrookLynkstafftosupportlearning.Ninety-one(91)outoftheoriginal96internssuccessfullycompletedtheirinternships.Averyhighpercentage(93%)ofsupervisorsexpressedthattheirinternprovidedgreatvaluetotheirorganization,department,andwork.Trainingandprovidingongoingsupportforboththeinternsandthesupervisorswaskeytoasuccessfulinternship.Internsbelievedtheylearnedimportantworkskillsthroughtheirinternshipexperiences(with84%answeredCompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue).

_____________________________Internshipsbeganmid-Juneandwerecompleted8-11weekslater,dependingontheemployer.Supervisors,orsomeonetheydelegatedto,wereresponsibleformentoringthestudentsandhelpingthemlearnaboutcareerpathsandworkskills.TheinternshipswerethecoreexperientiallearningopportunityoftheBrookLynkprogram.Allinternshipsbeganasplanned.Ninety-one(91)internssuccessfullycompletedtheirinternship.Fiveinternsdidnotcompletetheirinternshipbecausetheywereterminatedforjobperformancerelatedissues,familychallenges,andlifecircumstances.Internswereplacedinavarietyofdifferentindustriesandpositionsintheircompanies.Theworksitesvisitedwerewelcomingandaccommodatingspaces.Newforthisyear,eachinternhadacapstoneprojectthattheyworkedonduringthesummer.Thisprovideddirectionfortasksthattheycouldcompleteduringtheirinternship.SomeinternshiplocationssuchasCumminsPowerSystems,BostonScientific,CityofBrooklynCenter,andOsseoAreaSchoolsorganizedtheirsupervisorstoworkcollaborativelyontheirintern’scapstoneprojects.Internsbelievedtheylearnedimportantworkskillsthroughtheirinternshipexperiences(with84%answeredCompletelyTrueorMostlyTrue).Internswereabletohaveabetter

Page 46: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 46

understandingoftheirinterestsandhaveexposuretodifferentrolesandpositionswithinandoutsidetheirworksite.However,someinternsexpressedthattheydidn’tfeelchallengedattheirinternshiporthattherewasnotenoughtodo.Andsomeinternshipsdidn’tseemtobemeaningfulorimpactfulfortheintern.Eighty-onepercent(81%)ofsupervisorssaidthattheirexpectationsofinternjobresponsibilitiesandworkloadmatchedorwereexceededbywhatactuallyhappened.Almosthalf(47%)ofthesupervisorsrespondedthattheyspentover7hoursaweeksupervisingtheirinterns.Sixteenpercent(16%)spentonly1-2hoursinsupervision.Somesupervisorsexpressedchallengesinfindingtimetoadequatelysupervisetheirinternsastheyjuggledotherworkresponsibilities.Therewereseveralreturningsupervisorsthatwereabletosupporttheirpeersandbeon-sitementors.Supervisorswereintentionalaboutcoordinatingopportunitiesfortheirinternstomeetnewindividualsandexpandtheirexperiences(growtheirsocialcapital)On-siteinternshipcoordinatorsplayedakeyroleinsupportingBrookLynkstaff,youth,andsupervisorswithissuesandquestionsrelatedtotheorganization.Supervisorsdidnotalwayscommunicateearlywhentherewereconcernsabouttheirinterns.Thisinformationgenerallycameupduringthesitevisitswhenitwasalmostattheendoftheinternships.Afewoftheinternsalsodidn'texpresstheirconcernsuntiltheendoftheirinternships.Someworksitesdidnothaveenoughtasksfortheirinterns,consideringtheamountoftimethatwasavailable.ThiswasmosttrueinworksitesthatwereparticipatinginBrookLynkforthefirsttime.Someinternalprocessesandculturesoforganizationslimitedinternsexperience.Itappearedasifsomeinternshippositionswerenotcreatedoroutlinedbythedirectsupervisor,butbysomeoneelse,andthiscausedsupervisorstonotbeclearonwhattheirintern’sscopeofworkentailedorwhattheirspecificresponsibilitywas.Thereprovedtoberacial,religious,andotherformsofinequitiesatsomeemployersthatdirectlyimpactedyoungpeople.TheHennepinWorkforceGrantdatareportingrequirementswerenottimely,noradequatelycommunicated.ThismadeitdifficultforBrookLynkstafftocommunicatedetailstoemployers,collectWorkforceOneinformationfrominterns,andtoultimatelyexecutethegrantrequirementsinatimelyandeffectivemanner.HavingtwoJobCoachesallowedforstafftoallocatemoretimetomeetwithyouthandprovidesupport.Staffcapacitiestocheck-inwitheveryinternandsupervisorwerestillstretchedthinandcompromisedthedepthofengagementwitheach.Thereweresomeinternsandsupervisorsthatfeltdisconnected.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Createreferralpartnershipswithserviceprovidersthatcanofferresourcesforstudentsthroughoutthesummer.

• Targetnewsupervisorsandinternswithhigherneedsformoregreatersupport.Establishongoingcommunicationbyemailingorcallingbothinternsandtheirsupervisorstocheck-inshortlyaftertheon-boardingphase.

Page 47: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 47

• Encouragesupervisorstohavealeastoneweeklycheck-inwiththeirinterntogoovertasks,discusschallenges,andestablishsummergoals.

• Providemoreclarityforsupervisorsabouthowtoplancapstoneprojects.• Hireapart-time,seasonaljobcoachwhocanprovidesupportsforinternsand

supervisorsduringthemonthsofMay–August,includingsendingoutandmanagingcommunicationswithinternsandsupervisors,conductingsitevisitsandfacilitatingweeklycheck-inswithacohortofinterns.

• Whenreviewinginternshipdescriptionforms,confirmtheaccuracyoftheinformationwiththesupervisorsandmentors.Thiswillallowfortheretobelessconfusionaboutwhattheinternshipentailsandwhattheyarecommittedto.

• MakeitclearduringsupervisortrainingthatBrookLynkshouldbeinformedassoonaspossibleaboutupdatesaroundchangedenddates,changedsupervisorroles,andanyotherrelevantinformation.

• Facilitategroupcheck-insforBrookLynksupervisorsandmentors.Thiswillallowforstafftohavemorefrequenttouchpointswiththemandtohelpmediateanyissuesandprovidesupportswhereneeded.

• Ifsupervisorscannotallocateenoughtimetoactuallysupervisetheintern,ortocoordinateameaningfulinternship,BrookLynkshouldstronglysuggestthatanothersupervisorbeassignedtotheintern.

Check-insandEnrichmentOpportunitiesMinneapolisSTEP-UPofferssomeadditionaltrainingopportunities(e.g.financialliteracy).BrookLynkStaffwantedtoaddamoreinvolvedcomponentwhichallowedtheinternstomeettogetherregularly,developasenseofbelonging,allowforreflectionontheinternshipexperience,andworkoncareerdevelopmentandskills,andpostsecondaryawareness.Aweeklycheck-induringtheinternshipperiodwasaddedtotheBrookLynkprogram,similartowhatwasdevelopedintheCityofSt.PaulRightTrackyouthemploymentprogram.Sixty-twopercent(62%)ofinternsonaverageshowedupfortheweeklycheck-ins.Internswhoattendedreportedthattheydevelopedasenseofbelongingandmutualsupport,wereabletoshareandreflectontheirexperiences,discusssolutionstoproblemstheywerefacing,andworkonimprovingcareerskills.Stafffoundthecheck-insavaluableplacetoconnectwithinternstobettersupportthem.Theinternswhoparticipatedinenrichmentopportunitieswereabletobetterunderstandtheirowncollegeandcareergoalsafterthevisits.

_____________________________Weeklyinterncheck-insoccurredonsevenFridaysduringtheinternshipatNorthHennepinCommunityCollege.Internswereassignedtooneofthree1.5hourlongsessionsdesignedtoprovideadditionalsupportforinterns.Internshadtimetoreflectontheirexperiences,discussproblemstheyfacedandpossiblesolutions,learnmoreaboutMHALabsBuildingBlockskills,andbuildcommunityamongeachcohortthroughactivitiesandcollaborativework.Check-insprovidedanopportunityforyouthtobuildacommunitywithoneanotherandalsoforstudentsmeetnewpeople.Thecheck-insincludedopportunitiesformultiplecommunicationstyles:internshadtheir

Page 48: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 48

ownpersonalreflectiontime,discussedtopicswithinsmallgroups,andsharedoutwiththelargergroup.Planningwasmadeeasierbystaffcompilinganongoinglistofactivitiestododuringcheck-inssothatitwasonhandeachweektoeasilyputintotheagenda.Separatingintothreeinterncohortscreatedagoodgroupsizethatwaslargeenoughtodoavarietyofactivitieswhilealsosmallenoughwhereeachinternhadachancetoshareabouttheirexperience.Havingtwostafftocoordinatetransportationandfacilitatethecheck-insprovedtobemuchmoreeffectivethaninyearspast.Onecouldset-upwhiletheotherwouldtransportthestudents.However,coordinatingandfacilitatingthreeback-to-back-to-backcheck-insonFridaysalongwithprovidingvantransportation,wasdrainingforBrookLynkstaffandmadeforlongdays.Onaverage62%ofinternsshowedupfortheweeklycheck-ins.Internsatfirststruggledwiththeaccountabilityandresponsibilitythemethatstaffhadexpressedatthebeginningofthesummer.But,theybecamebetteratbeingresponsiblewithcommunication.Newandyoungerstudentsattendedcheck-insmorefrequentlyandparticipatedmorewillingly.Manyreturningandolderstudentsattendedwithlessfrequencyandstatedthattheyweren’tfindinganyvalueinthecheck-ins.Therewerefewerinattendanceatcheck-inseachweek.ThisisespeciallytrueofstudentsthatmighthaveneededmoresupportfromBrookLynkstaff.SomemovedoutoftheBrooklynsareasduetounforeseencircumstancesandhaddifficultycomingtocheck-ins.Eighty-one(81%)ofstudentswhoattendedrespondedthattheythoughtthecheck-inswerevaluable.Theyreportedthattheydevelopedasenseofbelongingandmutualsupport,wereabletoshareandreflectontheirexperiences,discusssolutionstoproblemstheywerefacing,andworkonimprovingcareerskills.Studentsfeltcomfortablesharinginthelargegroupandprivatelywithstafftheissuesthattheymayhavebeenfacing.Thisallowedstafftobeawareofwhatsupportstheymayneedtoprovideeithertotheinternorthesupervisor.Inadditiontothecheck-ins,BrookLynkofferedenrichmentopportunities,includingvisitstotheUniversityofMinnesota—TwinCities,ConcordiaUniversity,andGeneralMills.Anaverageof23youthattendedtheenrichmentopportunities.Studentswererespectfulandengagedinthediscussionsandactivitiesonallthreeenrichmentevents.TheUniversityofMinnesotavisitwasparticularlynotableasstudentswereabletohearabouthowtoprepareforcollege,atypicalcollegeschedule,andresourcesthattheycanuseoncampus.TheGeneralMillssitevisitallowedthestudentstotourthefacilityandhearfromdifferentemployeesontheirpathwaytotheirparticularroles.Theemployeeswerefromdiversebackgroundswhichallowedthestudentstoseerepresentationamongthepanelists.Byfar,theGeneralMillssitevisitwasthemostpopulareventforthoseinternswhotookadvantageoftheenrichmentopportunities.Theyvaluedseeinghowalargecorporationfunctionedandtheinsightthevisitprovidedtotheirowncareergoals.Eventbritewasusedtosigninternsupforenrichmentopportunities.Sincethewebsiteisopentothepublic,therewereafewnon-BrookLynkparticipantsthatsignedup.The

Page 49: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 49

campusvisittoConcordiaUniversitywasgenericandmaybedidn’thavetheimpactitcouldhaveifitwerecoordinatedwithastudentgrouporotherofficeatthecollege.SuggestionsforImprovement

• DividethegroupincohortsbasedonBrookLynkexperiencelevel.Thiswaycontentcanbetailoredtotheneedsoftheinterns.

• Createtheagendaitemsforcheck-inbeforetheinternshipbeginssothatthereisgreaterdepthofthoughttowardshowlessonswillbecommunicatedandwhatactivitieswilltakeplace.

• Makecheck-insmandatoryforeveryonesothatinternsmakethemostoftheirinternshipexperiencebygainingprofessionaldevelopmentskills.Jobcoacheswouldalsohavegreaterawarenessofhowinternshipsarefairingandcouldaddressissuesmorereadily.

• Engageyouthtofreshen-upthecheck-incurriculumaroundtheirownneeds.Forexample:hostanetworkingsession,aLinkedInsession,MicrosoftOutlook101,orothertechnicalsessionsthatallowthemtowalkawaywithimmediateskills.

• Incorporatemorechallengingsessionswhereeachsessionbuildsoffoftheprevious.Identifysomethingthatstudentsshouldhavewalkedawaywithafterattendingeachcheck-insession.

• Useanelectronicsign-upsheetonGoogleDrive,whereinternscansign-upforvanpick-upanddrop-offfromcheck-in.

• Sendingoutaweeklyupdatestosupervisorsaboutthecontentthatisgoingtobediscussedatcheck-inandprovidingwaysthattheycanengagetheirinternindiscussingaboutit.

• Coordinatesitevisitstonon-traditionalemployerslikegovernmentagencies,non-profits,orcommunity/technicalschools.

• Requirethateachattendeecomepreparedwithanotecardthathasquestionstheywouldliketoasktheschoolortheemployerduringsitevisits.

CelebrationBrookLynkendedthesummerprogramwithacelebrationfortheinternsandsupervisors,andtheirfamilies.Internssharedamazingstoriesabouthowtheirexperiencesimpactedtheirlives.SomeBrookLynkstakeholderswerepresent,butweweren’tabletogetmembersofthemediatoattend.

_____________________________OnAugust11th,interns,theirfamilies,andsupervisorsgatheredattheGrandHallatNorthHennepinCommunityCollege(NHCC)tocelebratetheendoftheinternships.Theeventstartedoffwithdinner,followedbyareviewofthehistoryofBrookLynkandalookintothefutureoftheprogram,presentationsfrominternsandsupervisorsabouttheirexperiencesandtheimpactBrookLynkhad.InternswhohadparticipatedinBrookLynkfor3yearswererecognizedalongwiththoseadultswhohavebeenchampionsoftheprogram.Aportionofthetimewasalsodedicatedtorecognizealltheinternsandsupervisorsfortheirwork.

Page 50: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 50

Agroupof8BrookLynkinternsmetduringthecourseofthesummertocreatethevision,organize,decorate,andspearheadtheevent.Thedatewasselectedbecausemostinternshipshadbeencompleted,yetbeforestudentsstartingcollegeouttownhadtoleave.Unfortunatelywiththeincreasednumberofinternsthisyear,themaximumsizecapacityoftheroomlimitedthenumberofguestsallowed.Similartolastyear,therewasnomediapresenceattheevent.Thefoodandawardexpenseswentoverbudget.SuggestionsforImprovement

• Findalocalbusinessororganizationwhowouldbewillingtofundtheevent.• Sendoutcalendarinvitestobothstudentsandsupervisorsatthebeginningofthe

programaboutthecelebration.• Sendapressreleasetomediaoutletsatleastonemonthpriortotheevent.• Findaneventspacewhereweareabletohostalargereventwithmoreattendees.

EvaluationMinneapolisSTEP-UPusesMHALabsSkillBuildingBlockstoassesstheirinterns’skilldevelopment,buttheframeworkisnotasembeddedintheprogrammingaswithBrookLynk.STEP-UPmeasuressomelong-termoutcomes(e.g.highschoolattendance,graduationrate,behaviorandgradesandtestscores,andcollegeenrollment/persistence).Surveysaregivenouttostudentsbeforeandafterworkreadinesstraining,andthereisanformalprogramevaluationprocess(asevidencedbythisreport).Mostoftheevaluationframeworkwasalreadyinplacefromlastyear.However,significantworkwasdonetoautomatethedatacollectionandanalysistodecreasetheamountofworkrequiredtoevaluatetheprogram.Thisyear,100%ofsupervisorsfilledoutaperformancereview(comparedto65%lastyear.)

_____________________________ForthethirdyearofBrookLynk,mostoftheevaluationframeworkwasalreadyinplacefromlastyear.However,effortwasputintoautomatingthedatacollectionandanalysisinanticipationthetransitiontotheCitiesnextyearandadecreaseinthehoursscopedfortheevaluation.Alloftheapplicationsandsurveysweremovedtoanonlineplatform(SurveyMonkey),whichallowedustotrackandidentifywhereapplicationsandsurveyswerecomingfrom.Thenumberofqualitativequestionswasdecreased,sincetheyrequiremoretime-intensiveanalysis.Towardstheendoftheinternships,supervisorswereaskedtoevaluateandprovidefeedbacktotheinternsoncareerskillsviaanMHALabsassessmenttool.Thisyear,100%ofsupervisorsfilledoutaperformancereview(comparedto65%lastyear.)Yet,performancereviewswerenotalwaysbeingcompletedpriortotheinterns’enddates.Thismaymeanthatsupervisorswerenotusingthefinalperformancereviewtohaveaclosingconversationwithinterns,whichisconsideredacriticalpieceofahigh-qualityinternshipexperience.Youthandsupervisorsprovidedhonestandtransparentfeedbackintheirsurveysandperformancereviews.However,collectingsurveysandperformancereviewsfrom

Page 51: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 51

supervisorswaschallenging.Thiswaspartiallyduetothefactthatsomesupervisorsthatwerelistedonthepositiondescriptionwereactuallynotthesupervisorsduringtheinternships.BrookLynkstaffwereonleavewhileafewinternshipswrappedup,whichmadecollectingyear-endsurveysandperformancereviewsdifficultfortheevaluator.SuggestionsforImprovement

• IncludeperformancereviewandsurveydeadlinesonthesheetdetailingimportantBrookLynkdatesthatispassedoutatthebeginningoftheprogram.

• Communicatemid-Julywithsupervisorsonhowtocompletetheperformancereviewandprovidealinktothesupervisorsurvey.Makesuretotalkaboutperformancereviewsandsurveysduringsitevisits.

• Havethestudentstaketheirinternsurveyatthelastcheck-intoensureagreaternumberofresponses.

• CreateprofilesontheBrookLynkwebsitewhereinternsandsupervisorscantracktheprogressoftheirperformancereviewsandsurveys.

DISCUSSIONNextevaluationquestionsandrecommendationsforimprovingtheBrookLynkprogramarediscussedbelow.NextEvaluationAsBrookLynktransitionsfromincubationtooperationattheCities,theevaluationwillchangeaswell.Thisthirdyearevaluationuncoveredadditionalquestionsforfurtherstudy.

• Whatspecificcharacteristics(program,staff,supervisor,employer,orintern)leadtoahigh-qualityinternship?

• WhatarethebenefitsoftheBrookLynkprogramtoemployers?• WhatarethebenefitsoftheBrookLynkprogramtotheyouthworkforce?• Whatisthevalueofthisprogramtothecityanditspartnersingrowingvitalityinthe

community?Thescopeoftheevaluationwilldecreasebytwo-thirdsnextyear.Astheprogrammaturestheevaluationwillshifttowardsprimarilyperformancemeasurement.Theevaluationwillstillincludereportonoutputstotrackyouthandcommunitypartnerparticipation.Thequalityassessmentwillonlyfocusontheinternships.Ashasbeendiscussed,thequalitymeasureswillbecross-tabbedwithotherdatatoidentifywhatleadstoahigh-qualityinternship.Performancereviewswillbeusedtomeasureyouthoutcomesregardingcareerskills.Theend-of-the-yearsurveysforinternsandsupervisorswillbeusedtomeasureyouthoutcomesandbusinessoutcomesaroundqualityandsatisfactionofthosestakeholders.Thecapacitybuildingandprocessevaluationswillbereplacedbypost-eventdebriefsthatwillcapturewhatworked,didn’tworkandsuggestionsforimprovements.Thiswillbereportedminimally.Forexample,fornextyear,thismayspecificallyincludethealumninetwork,thejobboard,andthejobfair.

Page 52: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 52

RecommendationsforImprovingBrookLynkTheevaluationreportgeneratedover100suggestionstoimprovetheBrookLynkProgram.Theserecommendationsaresummarizedbelow.

1. LaunchtheAlumniNetworkandJobBoard.DeveloptheAlumniNetworktokeepincontactwithalumniandprovideongoingsupportandnetworkingopportunities.Designprofessionaldevelopmentaroundsocialnetworks.Developthejobboardtoprovideinformationaboutlocalinternshipandjobopportunitiesforyouth.

2. ConsidernewstrategiestomeetwithneedsofandattractOpportunityYouth.

CreateatargetedandsupportedoutreachstrategytoengageOpportunityYouth.Establishstrongerpipelinestonon-profitsandpublicagenciesthatdirectlyworkwithcounty-involvedyouth(CIY),torecruitandsupportthemintheirBrookLynkinternship.Attendprofessionaldevelopmentforprogramstafftoeffectivelyengageandsupportcountyinvolved/opportunityyouththroughouttheBrookLynkexperience.CreatereferralpartnershipswithserviceprovidersthatcanofferresourcesforstudentsthatmayhavefurtherneedsthanwhatBrookLynkcanprovide.

3. Buildthecapacityofemployerstoimproveinternalprocessesandsupport

supervisordevelopment.Providetechnicalassistancetoemployerstoimprovetheirinternalprocessesforhiringyouthandforsupportingsupervisors.MeetingalloftheworksitehiringcoordinatorspriortomatchingandinterviewingtogothroughBrookLynkinternshipprogrammingsteps.

4. Continuetoengageyouthinco-creatingtheBrookLynkprogram.Refinethe

BrookLynkGetReady!andInternshipTrainingtobereflectiveoftheneedsofyouthanddemandsofemployers.ThisrefinedversionshouldalsoaddressthequestionaboutyouthparticipatingBrookLynkformultipleyearsandtheirneedtotakepartintraining.Engageyouthtofreshen-upthecheck-incurriculumaroundtheirownneeds,forexample:hostanetworkingsession,aLinkedInsession,MicrosoftOutlook101,orothertechnicalsessionsthatallowthemtowalkawaywithimmediateskills.

5. RedesigntheYouthJobFair.Considernewstrategiestorecruitmoreyouthand

businessestoattend,andtomatchjobseekerstoemployerswithjobopeningsattheevent.Recruitemployershiringforpositionsandtrainthemtohireonthespot.Outreachforemployersandyouthworkforcedevelopmentorganizationsyear-round.

6. Createdeeperengagementwithschoolpartnersasstrategicpartners.Consider

newstrategiestoimprovethepercentageofinvitedyouthwhoattendworkreadinesstraining,includingworkingwithschooltoofferworkreadinesstrainingduringschool-dayorafterschoolprogramming.Considerwaystoprovideinternswithmoretrainingaroundjobskillsemployersneed(Outlook,Excel,etc.)includingworkingwithschoolsandhaveemployersprovideOn-The-JobTraining.

7. ContinuetorefinetheyouthoutreachstrategywiththeReferralPartners.Create

referralpartnershipswiththecountyserviceprovidersandfaith-basedcommunity

Page 53: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 53

organizations.AllowtheAmbassadorstotakeagreaterleadonmarketingattheirschools.WorkwithBrooklynParkstafftocreatemarketingmaterialinthefallthateachschoolpointofcontactcansendoutwhenrecruitingbegins.HavetheBrookLynkAmbassadorsleadasocialmediacampaignthroughamoreorganicinitiativethatcreatesbuzzearlieron.Betterusetraditionalmedia(Channel12,theSunPost,andothernewsoutlets)torecruityouthandcommunicatetheworkBrookLynkdoesinthecommunity.

8. CompletethetransitionofBrookLynkfromtheAlliancetotheCities.Continue

withtheBrookLynkSteeringCommittee,andputenergyintoestablishinganewadvisoryduringthetransitiontoensurepositiveyouthoutcomesduringthischange.

9. Continuetoexpandbusinessoutreachtoengagemoreemployers,andinmore

typesofcareerfieldsandopportunitiesfor2018.Createauniqueandengagingrecruitmentpiecesforfunders,employers,andpolicymakers.Continuetogrowstrategicpartnerships.Continuetoidentifyandengagenewstakeholders.Haveamorecomprehensivecommunicationsplan/pitchtoemployerswithsupportingmaterialsthatincludebrochures,evaluationsummaries,testimonials,andinfographics.

10. EngagemorecommunitypartnerstosupportBrookLynk.Createan“engagementladder”forcommunitypartnerstogetinvolved,fromdonatingfinancialorin-kindsupport,toparticipatinginatrainingorevent,toprovidinginternships,tojoiningabusinessadvisory.FindalocalbusinessororganizationthatwouldbewillingtofundtheBrookLynkcelebration.

11. Determinehowtostrategicallybuildresourcescollaboratively.Staffidentified

theneedtodevelopacollaborativetimeline,expectations,andclarityregardingfundraising.Refinetheunderstandingofthebudget,andbuildadetailedplanforfundraising,partnership,andwaystomanageexpenses.

12. Simplifytheevaluationfurtherfocusonthedatapointsthatmostdirectly

answerthepoliticalandperformancemeasurequestionsthatwillarise.Createasinglepageapplicationsothatallofastudent’sinformationiscollected.Havethestudentstaketheirinternsurveyatthelastcheck-intoensureagreaternumberofresponses.Sendearlierandmoreconsistentcommunicationstosupervisorsandhiringcoordinatorstoensurethattheycompletethesurveysandperformancereviews.Continuetoimproveandvalidatetheprocessofassessingqualityintheinternshipexperiencesatemployerlocations.Considerwhatotherdatashouldbecollectedandanalyzedthatmayhelptounderstandthecharacteristicsofahigh-qualitysupervisor.

Page 54: 2017 BrookLynk Year-End Report FINAL · 2017 FINAL REPORT Rebecca Gilgen Executive Director The Brooklyn Bridge Alliance for Youth Ivan Lui Data and Quality Coordinator The Brooklyn

BrookLynkFinalEvaluationReport 54

FURTHERINFORMATIONForfurtherinformationontopicsanddatadiscussedinthisreport,pleaserefertotheYouthEmploymentProgramwikisiteatthefollowingaddress:

https://sites.google.com/site/bbayouthemploymentprogram/APPENDIX

• BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramLogicModel

• BrookLynkYouthEmploymentProgramProcessChart

• 2017BrookLynkEvaluationPlan

• 2017BrookLynkOutputs