1b opportunity evaluation
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
1/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
1b Opportunity SpottingFrank Martin
Hunter Centre for Entrepreneurship
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
2/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Opportunity Spotting
Is it about finding anopportunity . . . or theability continuallyspotopportunities?
Can firms be opportunityseeking?
Enterprising
Approaches to OpportunitySpotting
Why nothing isimpossible.
Faint hearted neer wonfair lady attributed to Miguelde Cervantes 1574 in DonQuijote
2
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
3/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Why produce a Plan?
"Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?""That depends a good deal on where you want to get to," saidthe Cat."I dont much care where--" said Alice."Then it doesnt matter which way you go," said the Cat.
"--so long as I get SOMEWHERE," Alice added as anexplanation."Oh, youre sure to do that," said the Cat, "if you only walk longenough."
(Alices Adventure in Wonderland)
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
4/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
On Spotting Opportunities
In business . . .
there is no such thing as a threat onlyopportunities disguised as treats . .
So where others see a problem entrepreneurs see a chance todo something different and better
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
5/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Stages of Starting a Business 1
Validating the Idea
Technical testing of Product or Service Market Acceptance
Finding an Idea
Getting a raw idea for further investigationAlternatives forgetting into business, e.g.,
franchising or buying a going concern.
Acquiring Motivation
Finding the stimulus and commitment Building the Support Network
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
6/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Stages of Starting a Business - 2
Birth and Survival
Business processes, regulationRelationship with customers and
suppliers
Negotiating to get into Business
Legal Structure, Ownership Funding, Premises Contracts
Identifying the Resources
Determiningthe scale Resources needed.
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
7/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
9 Steps into Business (Non-Recursive)
Generate and refine the business idea
Gauge demand for the product/service
Produce detailed Business Plan
Arrange Resources
Adopt legal structure
Make tax and legal arrangements
Confirm sales Potential in BusinessPlan
START BUSINESS
Get thefirst stepright andthenfollowthrough?Tooeasy!
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
8/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Approaches to Start-Up
Intuitive
Opportunistic, go for it, strong personal belief, minimal planning. Sometimes seen (by outsiders!) as the true entrepreneurial approach. Has the advantages of speed but tends to be very high risk.
Methodical
Clear goals and plans methodically pursued. Minimises risk.
Maximises chances of support. Can lead to paralysis by analysis.
Incremental
A clear intention to go into business, but step-by-step. Steps related to risk reduction or maintaining existing commitments. e.g.
working in spare time to develop product/service leads to self employment,
to forming partnership or company, to taking on staff. Often involves some degree of planning, but can be highly pragmatic.
Which
isbest?
BeingOp
portunist
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
9/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
An opportunity is a business concept that if turned intoa tangible product or service offered by a businessenterprise will result in a financial profit
Entrepreneurial opportunity
is about seeing an opportunity AND
Talking the talk
Exploiting that opportunity
Walking the walk
9
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
10/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Crash and Burn . .
BUT Opportunities arise from experienceHigh potential/high risk - the breakthrough technologies (Schumpeter)
Lower potential/lower risk - the steady as she goes opportunities (Kirzner)
AND personal goals and objectives important in shaping what is
and what is not an opportunity for the individual.
This is what gives risk profiles
Individual Risk Profiles
Comfort Zones
Organisational Risk profile
10
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
11/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Approaches? Being Intuitive
Opportunistic, go for it, strong personal belief, minimalplanning.
Sometimes seen (by outsiders!) as the true entrepreneurialapproach.
Has the advantages of speed (fads and fashions, secrecyetc.)
Tends to be very high risk business.
Evolutionary rather than revolutionary ideas
Source: Richardson and Clarke (1993)
The Cheshire Cat
11
http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/opportunistichttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheshire_Cathttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheshire_Cathttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Cheshire_Cat_Tenniel.jpghttp://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/opportunistic -
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
12/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Entrepreneurial Opportunities
12
What makes a truly successful entrepreneur is notintelligence, education, lifestyle or background. The principalfactor that seems to determine success is the entrepreneursability to effectivelydeal with opportunitiesthrough thedynamics of an organizational setting, thereby enabling the
people concerned to be actively and enthusiasticallyinvolved and successful.
Entrepreneurs who strive to establish a setting that issupportive . . . help to instil within those individuals a loyaltythat will serve to enhance the continued achievement of
organizational excellence and the operational success of theorganization. Darling et al 2007
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
13/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
How to Evaluate an opportunity?
Opportunity(rather than just a good idea)
Attractive Timely
Creates value Sustainable
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
14/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
What is an opportunity?
A new or improved product A new service A new means of production A new way of distributing the product or service
An improved service New combinationsOr a hybrid of the above
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
15/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Best ways to create opportunities?
Combining resources Solving problems/eradicating pain Satisfying unmet needs
Using existing knowledge/skills in a different way Taking advantage of new trends
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
16/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Assessing the opportunity
Assessing theopportunity
Investment(20)
Timescale(20)
Impact ofchange (20)
Risk(20)
Return (ROI)(20)
The pentagon model of opportunity assessment (Rae, 2007)
Different
entrepreneurs different
perspectives
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
17/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Investment
Resources are a key dimension of any opportunity. Key issues
include:How much is required and over what period? Is staged investment
required?
Tangible
IntangibleWhat proportion of your own resources does this represent and what
additional resources are required?
If so, who will contribute them and on what terms?
What does the investment actually buy?
Is it tangible assets that have disposal value or it is intangible resources
such as knowledge, information, expertise, networks, IPR?
Is Franchising cheaper than a newstart?
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
18/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Risk and uncertainty
Essential to evaluate risks involved arising from uncertainty
surrounding the opportunity. These may include:
Knowledge:Lack of information about market factors and likely demand
The economy:Fluctuations in macro-economic conditions such as marketstability, currency exchange and interest rates
Technology:Will the technology work as planned?
Financial factors:Are the financial costings realistic and achievable?
Competition:How will they respond?
Customers:Will they buy and pay as expected?
Supply chain:Will supplier and distributors deliver as expected?Human elements:Does the venture team have the managementskills, experience, credibility and expertise to manage the venture?
Risk is the risk of loosing
money
Professional gambler??
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
19/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Return and value added
Also vital to assess the acceptability of the return which shouldtake into account the following factors:
The amount invested:It may be acceptable to lose a small amount completely
Return in relation to risk:The higher the risk, the higher the return will normally b
Timescale over which return will come:Risk tends to increase further ahead in timThe form of return:e.g. As capital growth in the investment or as a flow of income
The exit strategy:e.g. As liquidation of assets, sale as a going concern, flotation,
value anticipated and timescale
The size of return:What profits will be generated? What are the costs?What prices can be set? What will be the margin?
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
20/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Impact of innovation and change
It assessing the impact of change caused by the opportunity,important to examine the extent to which it will either drive and leada change process
Strategic and disruptive innovations can reduce competitor's powerand create new markets. The following key factors are vital to assess:
How far does the opportunity create or develop a new market, identify unmetdemand, or meet customer requirements in a new way?
Does the opportunity apply innovation to offer customers new benefits or meet thneeds more effectively?
Does the opportunity use a new distribution method to communicate and sell to
customers?
Will the opportunity lead to significant change in the structureof the industry e.g. for competitors and suppliers?
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
21/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Timescale
Achieving the right timing is crucial factor in the viability of anopportunity. Creating an entirely new market or product can createhigh rewards but also high risks
Some opportunities can be ahead of their time or take too long toestablish customer acceptance. Key issues to consider include:
Is the timing of entry 'leading' the rest of the market, which may give an advantagbut also require greater time and investment? Is it entering the market at the samtime as competitors, or trailing behind in a mature or declining market?
What is the duration of the opportunity from short to long term?
What is the lead time needed to enter the market?
When will the investment achieve a return?
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
22/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
The Idea or the Individual?
Timmons (1994) emphasises fit;
fit between the individuals, and the opportunity, and between the individualsand their abilities to resource and exploit the opportunities.
Other fundamentals are:
the founders are the drivers of the entrepreneurial process:the quality of the lead entrepreneur and the team are vital
a team grows a business while a solo entrepreneur makes a living (Timmons,1994, p.20),
a business idea is not necessarily an opportunity,
entrepreneurs seek access and control of re sources rather than ownership,
timing is a vital component of good fit
Timmons, cited in Scott, 1999
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
23/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Types of opportunity
Personal risksfinancial - can you afford to lose your investment
career - can you return to your previous job
family and social - how will it affect your reputation
psychic - how afraid are you of failure
Business risks
market - will the product sell?
credit - will the customers pay, and when?
operational - are the right control systems in place?
resources - are the resources (people, finance) adequate?
reputational - does the market believe this can be done
23
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
24/33
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
25/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Its about Adding Value . . .
25
Nilson (1992) defines value added as:
constantly looking for ways to improve the perceived value-for-money of products and services.
Compared with reactivemarketing, value-added marketing
means constantly seeking out new opportunities to exceedcustomer expectation and beat the competition.
Value added market relies on continual research to spotemerging opportunities that others are missing.
So a good Business (Idea) is distinctive, no-one else is brave(or stupid) enough to do it!
Being average (me-too) is not special but it is safe!
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
26/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
SEARCHING FOR OPPORTUNITIES
Meet already articulatedneeds better (by an orderof magnitude or marginally)
niches and market gaps
customer complaints
exploitation of enablingtechnologies
Define a new need andmeet it by creating themarket (changing theworld, history making)
Disruptive innovation
26
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
27/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Forward Looking Organisations(not Individuals)
Having a good product or service is not distinctiveDo not compete on price, compete on focuseddifferentiation (Porters Generic strategy)
Market orientated means putting customer value first?
Understanding what buyers want and achieving that profitably.
Look for a sustainable and differential competitive advantage
Formal bureaucracies are the antithesis of the market opportunityseeking enterprising organisation.
entrepreneurship and marketing are focused on innovationand change.The really skilful entrepreneur sees things in a way no one else does.They perceive opportunities in the market place which perhaps are notyet fully formed but are currently no more than shapes and patternsarising from a new technology and fashion or trend, a possible culturalshift. Carson (1995)
27Hunter Centre for Entrepreneurship; New Venture Creation
http://www.quickmba.com/strategy/generic.shtmlhttp://www.quickmba.com/strategy/generic.shtmlhttp://www.quickmba.com/strategy/generic.shtmlhttp://www.quickmba.com/strategy/generic.shtmlhttp://www.quickmba.com/strategy/generic.shtml -
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
28/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Forward Looking Organisations
Is it about the person (entrepreneur) or the organisation(enterprise)?
Formal bureaucracies are the antithesis of the marketopportunity seeking enterprising organisation.
entrepreneurship and marketing are focused on innovation andchange. The really skilful entrepreneur sees things in a way noone else does. They perceive opportunities in the market placewhich perhaps are not yet fully formed but are currently no morethan shapes and patterns arising from a new technology andfashion or trend, a possible cultural shift. Carson (1995)
Forward looking organisations are alwayslooking for newopportunities new ways to add value.
28Hunter Centre for Entrepreneurship; New Venture Creation
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
29/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Opportunity evaluationPurpose of opportunity evaluation is to assemble all known information
about the opportunity and use it to investigate essential, strategic decisions
Aims to reduce risk of project failure and to ensure opportunity offersattractive rewards
Critical factors:
Reasons for perceived opportunity solving a problem, meeting a need
Market opportunity for business size, value, durationKey market segments and customer groups, preferences and distributionchannelsBarriers to entry and protecting the opportunityIndustry structure, driving forces and competitionRoutes to market
Who may support or invest in the businessOptions, resources and key success factors for theprojectDynamic effects of change on the industry
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
30/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
However...
'While information reduces risk, the entrepreneur cannot expect to eliminate allriskand sometimes they must make a step in the dark. The entrepreneur must walk anarrow path between making ill-informed and ill-judged decisions, and inertiacaused bybecoming more interested in gathering and analysing informationthan in taking direct action' (Wickham, Strategic Entrepreneurship, 2006).
'It is easy to get carried away with enthusiasm for the potential of an opportunityand to neglect the risks representing the downside, only to discover these later.On the other hand, over-analysis can lead to very slow decision-making or evenfailure to act at allIn some situations, it may be better to act and learn quicklyfrom what happens, and then modify the strategy, than to fail to act at all'(Rae, Entrepreneurship: From Opportunity to Action, 2007).
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
31/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Spotting Opportunities
InformationMarket CharacteristicsProduct CharacteristicsBuyer Characteristics
AnalysisCritical relationshipsKey Success Factors
SynthesisRefine Criticalrelationships
New Opportunity
The heuristic approach.
Process is interactiveeachcycle refines the opportunity
Wickham, Strategic Marketing, Pitman, p158, 1998
31
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
32/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
Opportunities: Wood and trees
Opportunities are about creating value not reducing cost by doingsomething cheaper.
Most people fail to pursues opportunities, even when they areobvious
Opportunity rarely found in well-documented markets (but look out
for disruptive innovations)
Opportunities are not necessarily the result of inventions the bestone may not be innovations . .
So why do some people discover opportunities?
Superior opportunity recognition capabilities, given access to the sameinformation.
It a way of viewing the world.
-
7/31/2019 1b Opportunity Evaluation
33/33
1b Opportunity Evacuation New Venture Creation 2012
The best Opportunities
The greater the number of entrepreneurs searching in agiven area, the lower the probability that any givenone of them will be first to make a discovery. If eachentrepreneur is basically as well equipped for searchas the others, then his probability of obtaining a
reward from search varies inversely with the numberof entrepreneurs in the field Casson (1982)
Hence Competition sucks! and the best opportunities areunique but not so unique that NO-ONE has done it before.
That is just plain stupid
Quick in and quick out!
33