13 th december 2007 d d rathi d d rathi * director & cfo grasim industries limited – aditya...
TRANSCRIPT
13th December 2007
D D RathiD D Rathi *Director & CFODirector & CFO
Grasim Industries Limited – Aditya Birla GroupGrasim Industries Limited – Aditya Birla Group
ICAI International ConferenceICAI International Conference
Corporate GovernanceCorporate Governance- Fact or Myth- Fact or Myth
(* Views expressed are personal)
2
Corporate Governance – Fact or Myth
A bold theme – spanning to two extremes The obvious answer is that “it cannot be a Myth” Point to be debated is the level of governance achieved Key background issues -
Governance generally What is corporate governance and what are its essentials Growing significance and benefits Corporate Governance initiatives and enactments
Current status of Corporate Governance, bench marking and challenges
3
Governance generally
Governance concept applicable to every entity and every individual
Good Governance essential in every walk of life Well defined Governance Practices more critical to Corporates
as they are “Artificial legal entities”
4
What is Corporate Governance ?
Many definitions have been articulated Difficult to define comprehensively in few sentences Corporate Governance is about commitment to values and
ethical business conduct Good Corporate Governance is reflected in fair, equitable,
transparent and responsible interaction between a Company’s - Management Board of Directors Shareholders Other Stakeholders
5
Essentials of good Corporate Governance
Corporate Governance is first about values and then about structure, system and processes
Should not be just ‘check list’ concept, but should be a way of life
Four pillars of good Corporate Governance Fairness Transparency & Disclosures Accountability, and Role Clarity
Responsibility of the Board, Chairman, CEO, CFO & Other Executives
Key Principles of Corporate Governance Respect right of minority shareholders Equitable treatment of shareholders Rights of other stakeholders Social Responsibility (CSR - as a caring corporate citizen)
Trusteeship culture
6
Growing significance of Corporate Governance
Corporate Governance has acquired greater significance in India Globalisation and large Capital requirements Increasing complexities of the organizational structure Gradual distancing of Ownership from Management Geographical expansion of Investor Base Emergence of Large Institutional Investors, foreign & domestic
both
A series of global financial and corporate crisis Indian Corporates very well recognise linkage of Corporate
Governance to Valuations of the Companies Attracting capital at lower cost Attracting & retaining talented human capital
7
History of Corporate Governance Initiatives and Enactments
Initiatives and Regulatory enactments – International examples Cadbury Committee (UK) – 1991 HAMPEL Committee (UK) - 1997 Blue Ribbon Commission (US) - 1999 Ad hoc Task Force OECD Sarbanes Oxley Act - 2002
8
Initiatives and Regulatory enactments - India Concept not new to India – Trusteeship culture is age old
Ram Rajya - Role of King, Society & Priest Appropriating part of profit for charity (social responsibility)
Constitution of SEBI in 1992 National Task Force of CII – 1996 – Chairman Mr. Rahul Bajaj
(Voluntary measure) Kumar Mangalam Birla Committee - 1999
(Resulted in Introduction of Clause 49, first structured regulation) Naresh Chandra Committee - 2002 Narayan Murthy Committee – 2003
Companies Act Amendments
JJ Irani Committee on Company Law
December 2005 - Amendment to Listing Agreement Amended Clause 49 - A landmark step
History of Corporate Governance Initiatives and Enactments – contd.
9
Can Regulation alone ensure good governance ?
We do need basic regulatory frame work But we need even much large body of self regulation and
spirit of voluntary compliance Good governance practices will evolve through blend of
regulatory frame work and voluntary compliance
10
Should Corporate Governance be just restricted to compliance of law ?
“Corporate Governance” is not a “Tick Box” concept but has to be a way of life
Governance frame work should focus on “Substance” and not merely on “Form”
You do it because it is the right thing to do … and not just because the law commands you to do it
Good Governance goes beyond legal compliance
Compliance
Value Creation
Excellence
Benefits of Good Governance - leading to excellence in management
11
Indian Corporates - Current Corporate Governance Status
Indian Corporates have come a long way on Governance practices Improving Structures & Functioning of the Board and its Committees Code of Conduct for Board & Senior Management Disclosure practices - continuous and timely disclosure High quality of Accounting Policies and Accounting Standards Clause 49 requirements Investor Relations practices - transparency & uniform dissemination of
information Insider Trading codes Quality of Annual Report
Consolidated Financial Statements Segmental Reporting Management Discussion & Analysis
Reporting on compliance and its certification Corporate Governance has started to percolate to mid level corporates
as well Comparison of Corporate Governance Practices with China, Other Asian
Countries and Sarbanes Oxley Act
12
Some CG parameters – Comparative Status
India USA UK China Japan Singa-pore
Hong Kong
Austr-alia
Board Composition - Independent Directors
Required separation of chief executive and chairman of the board roles
X X
Compensation Committee - Independent Directors
X
Code of ethics for senior financial officers required
Audit Committee - Authority to engage outside advisers
Management required to forfeit bonuses or other compensation if a restatement occurs
Management required to certify internal control structure and/or disclose controls
Restriction on loans to officers and directors
Required rotation of audit partners $ Rules regarding disclosure of off-balance sheet transactions and contractual obligations
$
Rules regarding disclosure of forward looking earnings guidance
Source: Deloitte Haskins & Sells X - Non Mandatory XX - Encourages / prescribes alternate $ - Under consideration
13
Asian Countries Scorecard - %
CountriesCG Rules & Practices
Enforcement
(public/private)
Political / Regulator
y
International GAAP
CG Culture
Hong Kong 60 56 73 83 61Singapore 70 50 65 88 53India 59 38 58 75 50Taiwan 49 47 60 70 46Japan 43 46 52 72 44Korea 45 39 48 68 43Malaysia 43 35 56 78 33Thailand 58 36 31 70 39China 43 33 52 73 25Philippines 39 19 38 75 36Indonesia 39 22 35 65 25
Source: ACGA Research
14
Country Rank 2005 Rank 2007Hong Kong 2 1Singapore 1 2India 3 3Taiwan 5 4Japan - 5Korea =6 =6Malaysia 4 =6Thailand =6 8China 9 9Philippines 8 10
Indonesia 10 10
Source: “CG Watch 2007”, ACGA & CLSA
Corporate Governance - Ranking
High Ranking of India among Asian Countries ; Corporate Governance not a myth in India
15
Corporate Governance Standards in India Vs Averages of Asian Countries Good financial reporting among top 100-200 companies, but
sharp fall off among rest of market (> 6,000 listed companies) Public enforcement improving, but private enforcement
limited and obstructed (e.g., by legal system) SEBI more independent than many Asian Securities
Commissions Media freedom much higher than Asian region Noticeable gap between accounting standards and
international norms - but gap narrowing
Source: “CG Watch 2007”, ACGA & CLSA
Average
16
Challenges in Corporate Governance
Large unlisted corporates not covered by Corporate Governance norms
Stronger Boards and Committees Independent and Professional Directors Audit Committee with right composition
Defining roles of Board, Committees and Executives Compensation policy for Directors and Senior Executives Risk Management Sustainability Reporting Independence of Auditors (Statutory and Internal) “Tick box” approach vs. “Letter and Spirit” compliance. Be a
step ahead of Regulation
Those who call Corporate Governance a myth are looking at the gaps,
which we need to collectively fill
17
Challenges in Corporate Governance - Contd..
Disclosures of Off Balance Sheet Transactions Disclosures of substantial risks being carried in Balance
Sheets (e.g. Sub Prime mortgage) Define processes to achieve compliance
CEO and CFO certification Compliance certificate from Auditors
Enhanced commitment at all levels of Corporate ladder needed – should not be treated as responsibility of finance functionaries and CEO only
Multiplicity of Regulators and compliance Cost
Those who call Corporate Governance a myth are looking at the gaps,
which we need to collectively fill
18
We have come a long way in improving corporate governance practices,
but yet to reach pinnacle - march to excellence continues
Summary
Regulatory framework in place Value of good governance and its benefits well recognised by
Indian Companies Significant move seen towards voluntary compliance, i.e. from
legal compliance to conscience Indian Corporates ahead of China and other Asian Countries Improve governance standard for mid size companies coming
to capital markets Simplified and unambiguous regulations will encourage high
standards of Governance and help reduce compliance cost
THANK YOU
20
Why has CG become so topical ?
The main causes in recent times have been a series of financial and corporate crisis Asian financial crisis (1997 / 98) Dotcom boom & bust (2000) Enron, Worldcom and Tyco scandals in the United States (early
2000s) Parmalat earnings mis-statement scandal in Italy in 2002/03,
as well as similar events at Ahold in Holland and Alstom in France
Economic downturn over 2001-03 Non-performing loans among state banks in China Problems associated with family and state ownership in Asia
(not all bad, but abuses have occurred) Sub-prime crisis in USA - 2007
6A
21
Corporate Governance is not new to India
Ram Rajya KING – enjoys power but is responsible for deliverables too SOCIETY – well defined behaviour norms PRIESTS – acts as independent check on King as
Intermingles with society & get feedback Don’t get paid by King, hence independency ensured Enjoys courage of conviction
Appropriating part of profit for charity (Social Responsibility)
8A
22
Tentative Conclusions
There appears to be a broad link between the ranking of most markets in our “CG Watch 2007” survey and the size of their “gross national income” (GNI) per capita
Exceptions are clearly India and Japan. Each has certain particular and unusual characteristics
India : A large populations (hence low GNI per-capita); economic reforms started much later than China (1991 vs 1978); yet corporate governance reforms started early by regional standards (1998) and the country has some pockets of world-class
corporate governance Japan : Began industrializing in the 19th century, hence a big
headstart on GNI per-capita; high levels of wealth and economic success in the 1970s and 80s may well be a factor in Japan’s insularity to global norms of corporate governance
Source : CG Watch Survey 2007
15A
23
Benefits of Corporate Governance
Enhances the long-term value of the company, its shareholders and other stakeholders
Provides easy access to large capital Lowering of Cost of Capital (Debt & Equity both) Recognition of Indian corporate globally and increased
investments in Indian corporates Protects the investors and accelerates growth of Capital
Markets Brings excellence in systems and control procedures Attracts talented Human Capital Board / Committees help strong & transparent decision
making process Focus on accountability of key executives (CEO / CFO
Certification) Acceptability of takeovers / acquisition of overseas corporate
by Indian companies Standardisation of Risk Management process
Good Corporate Governance facilitates improved & sustained performance10A
24
Regulatory Environment and Compliance Cost - changes needed
Multiple Regulations Company Law SEBI / Stock Exchanges Conflicting provisions
Some over-regulation issues Composition of the Board
Fifty percent as Independent Directors Retirement age Reservation for different classes Stringent qualification for independent directors
Excessive disclosure eg. Audit Reporting Compliance cost increase, a cause of concern
Simplified and unambiguous single point regulation –Flexible/ Dynamic
Balanced disclosure practices
17A