11095-eng-01-a checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residential...

Upload: marijanmustac

Post on 04-Jun-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    1/8

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    Checking ground

    electrode impedance for

    commercial, industrial

    and residential buildings

    Most facilities have grounded electrical systems, so that in the event of a lightning strike

    or utility overvoltage, current will find a safe path to earth. A ground electrode provides the

    contact between the electrical system and the earth. To ensure a reliable connection to

    earth, electrical codes, engineering standards, and local standards often specify a minimum

    impedance for the ground electrode. The International Electrical Testing Association specifies

    ground electrode testing every three years for a system in good condition with average

    up-time requirements. This application note explains earth/ground principles and safety in

    more depth and then describes the principle testing methods: 3 and 4 pole Fall-of-Potential

    testing, selective testing, stakeless testing and 2 pole testing.

    Why Ground?

    The US National Electrical Code(NEC) gives two principle reasonsfor grounding a facility. Stabilize the voltage to earth

    during normal operation. Limit the voltage rise created

    by lightning, line surges or

    unintentional contact withhigher-voltage lines.Current will always find and

    travel the least-resistance pathback to its source, be that a utilitytransformer, a transformer withinthe facility or a generator. Light-ning, meanwhile, will always finda way to get to the earth.

    In the event of a lighting strikeon utility lines or anywhere inthe vicinity of a building, a low-impedance ground electrode willhelp carry the energy into theearth. The grounding and bonding

    systems connect the earth nearthe building with the electricalsystem and building steel. In alightning strike, the facility willbe at approximately the samepotential. By keeping the potentialgradient low, damage is minimized.

    If a medium voltage utility line(over 1000 V) comes in contact

    with a low voltage line, a drasticovervoltage could occur fornearby facilities. A low impedanceelectrode will help limit the

    voltage increase at the facility.A low impedance ground canalso provide a return path forutility-generated transients.Figure 1 shows a groundingsystem for a commercial building.

    Ground ElectrodeImpedance

    The impedance from thegrounding electrode to theearth varies depending ontwo factors: the resistivityof the surrounding earthand the structure of theelectrode.

    Resistivity is a propertyof any material and itdefines the materialsability to conduct current.The resistivity of earth iscomplicated, because it:

    Figure 1: A grounding system combining reinforcing steeland a rod electrode

    Application Note

    Depends on composition of thesoil (e.g. clay, gravel and sand)

    Can vary even over smalldistances due to the mix ofdifferent materials

    Depends on mineral (e.g. salt)content

    Varies with compression andcan vary with time due to

    settling Changes with temperature,freezing (and thus time of year).Resistivity increaseswith decreasing temperature.

    Can be affected by buried metaltanks, pipes, re-bar, etc.

    Varies with depthSince resistivity may decrease

    with depth, one way to reduceearth impedance is to drive anelectrode deeper. Using an arrayof rods, a conductive ring or agrid are other common ways ofincreasing the effective area of

    an electrode. Multiple rods shouldbe outside of each others areasof influence to be most effective(see Figure 2). The rule of thumb isto separate the elements by morethan their length. For example:2.5 meter rods should be spacedmore than 2.5 meters apart to bemost effective.

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    2/8

    15A

    TRUERMS

    HOLD

    OFF

    mA

    A

    Ground Loop Tester

    The NEC specifies 25 ohms asan acceptable limit for electrodeimpedance. The IEEE Standard142 Recommended Practicefor Grounding of Industrial andCommercial Power Systems(Green Book) suggests a resis-tance between the main groundingelectrode and earth of 1 to 5 ohmsfor large commercial or industrialsystems.

    Local authorities including theauthority having jurisdiction (AHJ)and plant managers are respon-

    sible for determining acceptablelimits for ground electrode imped-ance.Note: Power distribution systemsdeliver alternating current andground testers use alternatingcurrent for testing. So, youd thinkwe would talk about impedance,not resistance. However, at powerline frequencies, the resistivecomponent of the earth impedanceis usually much bigger than thereactive component, so you will seethe terms impedance and resistanceused almost interchangeably.

    How do groundresistance testers work?

    There are two types of groundresistance testers. Three and fourpoint ground testers and clamp-onground testers (see Figure 3).Both types apply a voltage onthe electrode and measure theresulting current.

    A three or four-pole groundtester combines a current sourceand voltage measurement in alunch box or multimeter-style

    package. They use multiple stakesand/or clamps.

    Ground testers have thefollwing characteristics:

    AC test current. Earthdoes not conduct dc

    very well. Test frequency that is

    close to, but distin-guishable from thepower frequency andits harmonics. Thisprevents stray currentsfrom interferring withground impedancemeasurements.

    Separate source andmeasure leads tocompensate for thelong leads used in thismeasurement.

    Input filtering designed to pickup its own signal and screenout all others.

    Clamp-on ground testers arevery different because clamp-onground testers have both a sourcetransformer and a measurementtransformer. The source trans-former imposes a voltage on theloop under test and the measure-ment transformer measures theresulting current. The clamp-onground tester uses advancedfiltering to recognize its ownsignal and screen out all others.

    Ground Testing SafetyAlways use insulated gloves, eyeprotection and other appropriatepersonal protective equipmentwhen making connections. It isnot safe to assume that a groundelectrode has zero voltage or zeroamps, for reasons given below.

    To perform a basic ground test(called Fall-of-Potential) on anelectrode, the electrode must bedisconnected from the build-ing. New selective methods allow

    accurate testing with the electrodestill connected. See SelectiveMeasurements.

    A ground fault in the systemmight cause significant current toflow through the ground conduc-tor. You should use a clampmeter to check for current beforeperforming any impedance testing.If you measure above 1 amp (ruleof thumb) you should investigatethe source of the current beforeproceeding.

    If you must disconnect anelectrode from an electrical

    system, try to do so during amaintenance shutdown when

    you can de-energize the system.Otherwise, consider temporarilyconnecting a backup electrode tothe electrical system during yourtest.

    Never disconnect a groundelectrode if there is a chance oflightning or other system failure.

    A ground fault in the vicinity cancause voltage rises in the earth.The source of the ground fault maynot even be in the facility you aretesting, but could cause voltagebetween the test electrodes. Thiscan be especially dangerous nearutility substations or transmissionlines where significant groundcurrents can occur. (Testinggrounding systems of transmissiontowers or substations requires the

    use of special Live Earth proce-dures and is not covered in thisapp note.)

    Ground impedance testers usemuch higher energy than yourstandard multimeter. They canoutput up to 250 mA. Make sureeveryone in the area of the testis aware of this and warn themnot to touch the probes with theinstrument activated

    Figure 2: Ground electrodes have areas of influence thatsurround them

    2 Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings.

    Figure 3

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    3/8

    I

    V

    EP2 C2

    Source

    Measure

    Measure

    ElectrodeUnder test

    PotentialSpike

    CurrentSpike

    MeasuredResistance

    Electrode/EarthImpedance

    Distance of P2 from E

    E

    valid resistance

    Figure 4: Schematic for Fall-of-Potential

    Figure 5: A plot of measured impedances versus position of the potentialstake allows us to see the earth impedance

    The connections are made to: E/C1 the ground electrode

    being tested S/P2 A voltage (potential)

    measurement stake driven intothe earth some distance awayfrom the electrode. Sometimescalled the potential auxiliaryelectrode

    H/C2 A current stakedriven into the earth a furtherdistance away. Sometimescalled the current auxiliaryelectrode

    Figure 4 shows this sche-matically and Figure 5 shows thethree connections made using atypical ground tester.

    The ground tester injects analternating current into the earth

    between the electrode under test(E) and the current stake (C2).The ground tester measures thevoltage drop between the P2stake and E. It then uses ohmslaw to calculate theresistance between P2 and E.

    To perform the test you positionthe C2 stake at some distancefrom the electrode under test.Then, keeping the C2 stake fixed,you move the P2 stake along theline between E and C2, measuringthe impedance along the way.

    The tricky part comes in

    determining where to drive thestakes to get a true reading of theresistance between the electrodeand the earth.At what point does the dirtsurrounding the electrode stopbeing a contributor of resistanceand become the vast earth?Remember that we are not inter-ested in the resistance betweenthe electrode and our stakes. Weare trying to measure the resis-tance that a fault current wouldsee as it passes through the massof the earth.

    Checking ConnectionResistance Leading Up tothe Electrode

    Before testing the electrode, startby checking its connection tothe facility bonding system. MostFall-of-Potential testers have theability to measure 2-pole, lowohms and are perfect for the job.You should see less than 1 ohm: At the main bonding jumper Between the main bonding

    jumper and the ground elec-trode conductor

    Between the ground electrodeconductor and the groundelectrode

    Along any other intermediateconnection between the main

    bonding jumper and the groundelectrode

    The Fall-of-PotentialMethod

    The Fall-of-Potential method isthe traditional method for testingelectrode resistance. The procedureis specified in the IEEE-81 standardGuide for Measuring Earth Resis-tivity, Ground Impedance and EarthSurface Potentials of a GroundSystem and in numerous other

    national standards.In its basic form, it works well forsmall electrode systems like oneor two ground rods. We will alsodescribe the Tagg Slope Techniquewhich can help you draw accurateconclusions about larger systems.

    Remember: for this method, theground electrode must be discon-nected from the building electricalservice.

    How it worksThe Fall-of-Potential methodconnects to the earth at three

    places. It is often called thethree-pole method. You maywant to use a fourth lead forprecise measurements on low-impedance electrodes, but for ourinitial discussions we will considerthree leads.

    Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings. Fluke Corporation 3

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    4/8

    Table 1: Approximate Distance to Auxiliary Stakes usingthe 62 % Rule (in meters)

    Depth of Electrodeunder Test (E)

    Distance from E toPotential Stake (P2)

    Distance from E toCurrent Stake (C2)

    2 15 25

    3 19 30

    6 25 40

    9 31 50

    Table 2: Approximate Distance to Auxiliary Stakes forElectrode Arrays (in meters)

    Widest Dimension(Diagonal, diameteror Straight-line) of

    Electrode Array underTest (E)

    Distance from E toPotential Stake (P2)

    Distance from E toCurrent Stake (C2)

    20 30 50

    25 50 80

    30 70 100

    50 100 17070 130 200

    Measure-

    ment Tips

    Bring a good, long tapemeasure.

    Finding the horizontal

    part of the curve will

    require at least

    5 measurements.

    Its a good idea to take

    three of your resistance

    readings with the P2

    stake at 20%, 40% and

    60% of the distance

    between E and C2. This

    will allow you to use the

    Tagg Slope Technique.

    When placing the stakes

    make sure the current

    stake, the potential

    stake and the electrode

    under test form

    a straight line.

    If you get a very high

    impedance measure-

    ment or over-range,

    try pouring some water

    around the test stakes

    to improve their contactto earth. This isnt

    cheating since our inten-

    tion is not to measure

    the resistance of our

    stakes, but to measure

    the resistance of the

    electrode.

    Keep the potential and

    current leads separated

    to avoid signal coupling

    between the two.

    At a new constructionsite, you may want to

    take multiple sets of

    measurements. Resis-

    tance may drop over

    time as the earth settles

    The current probe generates avoltage between itself and theelectrode under test. Close to theelectrode, the voltage is low and

    becomes zero when the P stakeand electrode are in contact. Closeto the electrode, the potential

    probe is said to be within theinfluence of the electrode. Closeto the current probe the voltageis almost the full voltage outputby the tester. But somewhere inthe middle, something interestinghappens.As we move from the influence ofthe electrodes and into the massof the earth, the test current nolonger causes significant changein potential. If you plot a seriesof measurements, moving thepotential stake away from theelectrode under test, and towardsthe current stake you will noticea flattening of the curve. An idealcurve is shown in Figure 5 (seeprevious page). The flattest partof the curve is where we read

    the earth resistance. In reality,the curve never goes entirely flatbut reaches a very gentle slopewhere changes in resistance aresmall.

    The extent of the influence of theelectrode depends on its depth andit area. Deeper electrodes requirethat the current stake be drivenfarther away (see Table 1). Forlarge ground rings, grids or arraysthe influence of the electrode mayextend for hundreds of meters.Table 2 gives suggested startingpoints for current and potential

    stake placement. Because of thepossibility of interaction betweenan electrode rings, grids or arrays,

    and the measurement stakes youshould not take shortcuts plot theFall-of-Potential graph to be sureyou are getting accurate results.

    In testing a bonded array ofelectrodes the combined resistanceof the array will be less than thelowest reading you measure forany individual electrode. If, forexample, you have two 2.5 meterrods spaced more than 2.5 meterapart you can be confident thatthe combined resistance will besubstantially less for the combinedsystem.

    The three-wire measurement willdeliver good results if you use ashort C1 lead, or if you dont mindhaving a fraction of an ohm of leadresistance in your reading. For

    ground resistance measurementsover 10 ohms, the effect of the resis-tance of the C1 lead will be small.But for very precise measurements,especially at low resistances, a four-wire tester allows you add a fourthlead to eliminate the contribution ofthe C1 lead. By running a separatepotential lead (P1) to the electrodeunder test you can take the dropalong the C1 current lead out of themeasurement.

    4 Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings.

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    5/8

    Distance From Electrode Under Test

    Fall-of-Potential Plot

    P2 Distance from Electrode Under Test (meters)

    R(Ohms)

    Resistance

    (m) (m) (ohms)

    100100100

    100100100100100100

    102030

    405060708090

    15 30 45 60 75 90

    d

    62 % d

    E

    P2 C2

    ElectrodeUnder test

    PotentialSpike

    CurrentSpike

    Figure 7: Earth impedance can be found from this curve by usingthe Tagg Slope Technique

    The 62 % Rule

    You may be able to use a shortcutif your test meets the followingcriteria: You are testing a simple elec-

    trode (not a large grid or plate) You can place the current stake30 meters or more from theelectrode under test

    The soil is uniformUnder these conditions you can

    place the current stake 30 metersor more from the electrode undertest. Place the potential stake at62 % of the distance between thecurrent stake and the electrodeunder test and take a measure-ment. As a check, take two moremeasurements: one with thepotential probe 1 meter closer to

    the electrode under test, and one1 meter farther away (see Figure6). If you are on the flat portion ofthe fall-of-potential curve then thereadings should be roughly thesame and you can record the firstreading as your resistance.

    The Tagg Slope Technique

    Large electrodes or groundingsystems require some specialconsideration. If youve plot-ted resistance readings for nine

    different P2 locations and there isno clear flattening on your graph,then the Tagg Slope Technique(also called the slope method) canhelp establish the earth imped-ance. Figure 7 shows an exampledataset for which there is noobvious flat section. This curve ischaracteristic of a test in whichthe current and potential probesnever get outside the influenceof the electrode under test. Therecan be a number of reasons for acurve like this: For electrode systems that cover

    large areas it may be difficult toplace stakes far enough away You may not be able to place

    the C1 stake at the center ofthe electrode

    The area you have to placestakes may be limited

    If you have resistance read-ings at the 20 %, 40 % and 60 %points between E and C2, thenyou can apply the procedure tothe data youve already taken.

    Calculate the slope coefficient ()using three resistance measure-ments from 20 %, 40 % and60 % of the distance from theelectrode under test to the C2current stake.

    Then go to the table in the back ofthis application note and look upthe P2/C2 ratio that correspondsto your . This will tell you whereto look on your graph to ascertainthe earth resistance. For thesample data in Figure 7:

    If we go to the table, for = 0.71the corresponding P2/C2 percent-age is 59.6 %. So the approximateearth resistance would bemeasured at (59.6 % X 100 m), orat 59.6 m. This is very close to our60 % point at 60 m, where weread 6.8 ohms. So it would be safeto say the earth resistance for theelectrode under test is roughly6,8 ohms.

    Figure 6: Stake positions for the 62 % rule.

    ( R60 %

    R40 %

    )

    ( R40 %

    R20 %

    ) =

    ( 6.8 5.8

    )

    ( 5.8 4.4

    )

    = = 0.71

    Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings. Fluke Corporation 5

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    6/8

    U

    I

    C2

    H

    P2

    P1

    C1

    S

    E

    ext

    START

    DISPLAY

    CHANGE

    OFF 3R A R

    42

    SELECT

    p o l e p o le

    pole

    GroundResistance300k

    ACResistance300k

    SATURNGEO

    NORMAEarth / Ground Tester

    C2

    H

    P2

    P1

    C1

    S

    E

    ext

    START

    DISPLAY

    CHANGE

    OFF 3RA R

    4

    2

    SELECT

    p o le p o le

    pole

    GroundResistance300k

    ACResistance300k

    SATURNGEO

    NORMAEarth / Ground Tester

    Probe Aux earth electrode

    Electrode

    under test

    More than 65 ft More than 65 ft

    Grounding

    Electrode

    Conductor

    >10 cm

    Voltage

    Current

    Equivalent Circuit

    ACVoltageSource

    Rn-1Rx R1 R2 R3RnR2R1Rx Rn-1

    U

    I

    Figure 9: Connections for selective Electrode Impedance Mesaurement Figure 10: Connecting the Saturn GEO X for a stakeless measurement

    The Selective Method

    The Selective Method is avariation of the Fall-of-Potentialmethod, available on high-endground testers like theFluke 1625. Testers with thiscapability can measure theground impedance of a specificground electrode without discon-necting it from an array or fromthe electrical system. This meansyou dont have to wait for a shut-down to test or risk the safetyhazards of disconnecting theelectrode from a live system.

    The same rules for current stakeand potential stake placementapply as with Fall-of-Potential. Ifthe conditions are met for the 62 %

    rule (see previous page) then itcan help reduce the number ofmeasurements. Otherwise its agood idea to build a completeFall of-Potential plot. You can usethe Tagg Slope Technique if yourcurve does not flatten out.Both the Fall-of-Potential methodand the Selective Method usestakes to inject current and

    measure voltage drop. The bigdifference is that selective testingcan accurately measure the testcurrent in the electrode under test.

    The utility neutral, buildingsteel and ground electrode areall bonded and grounded. Whenyou inject a current into thissystem of parallel ground connec-tions the current will divide. Ina traditional Fall-of-Potentialtest you have no way of know-ing how much current is flowingbetween any particular electrodeand the C2 current stake. Selec-tive testing uses an integrated,high sensitivity clamp-on currenttransformer to measure the testcurrent in the electrode undertest. Figure 8 shows how the

    current transformer fits into thetest circuit. The selective groundtester digitally filters the currentmeasurement to minimize theeffects of stray currents. Beingable to accurately measure thecurrent in the electrode undertest effectively isolates theelectrode and allows us to test itwithout disconnecting it from thesystem or from other electrodes.

    Stakeless or Clamp-on Method

    The stakeless or clamp-on method allows you tomeasure the impedanceof a series loop of groundelectrodes. The test issimple and it may beperformed on an elec-trode that is connected toa working electric service.To make the measure-ment the tester usesa special transformer

    to generate a voltage on theground conductor at a uniquetest frequency. It uses a secondtransformer to distinguish the testfrequency and measure the result-ing current through the circuit,which is determined by the loopresistance.

    This method is available in someFall-of-Potential testers (like theFluke 1625 or Fluke 1623) or ina single clamp on unit like theFluke GEO 30. Figure 10 showsthe connection of the source andmeasure clamps of the Saturn GEO X.

    Figure 9 (see next page) showsthe equivalent test circuit for thestakeless method. When you testa building ground electrode usingthis method, you are actually test-

    ing a loop including: Electrode under test Ground electrode conductor The main bonding jumper The service neutral Utility neutral-to-ground bond Utility ground conductors

    (between poles) Utility pole grounds

    Because this method uses theservice as part of the circuit, itmay be used only after the servicehas been completely wired, thatis, it cannot be used prior to hook-up to the utility. In this method

    the clamp checks the continuity ofthe interconnections of all of thecomponents above. An abnor-mally high reading or an opencircuit indication on the instru-ment points to a poor connectionbetween two or more of the afore-mentioned critical components.The ground electrode of most facil-ities is in parallel with numerousutility ground electrodes. Theseelectrodes can be pole electrodes,

    Figure 8: Connections for selective ground electrodemeasurement

    6 Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings.

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    7/8

    C2

    H

    P2

    P1

    C1

    S

    E

    ext

    START

    DISPLAY

    CHANGE

    OFF 3RA

    R42

    SELECT

    p o l e p o l e

    pole

    Ground

    Resistance300k

    ACResistance

    300k

    SATURNGEO

    NORMAEarth / Ground Tester

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    OFF

    ON

    C2

    H

    P2

    P1

    C1

    S

    E

    ext

    START

    DISPLAY

    CHANGE

    OFF3

    RAR

    4

    2

    SELECT

    pole pole

    pole

    Ground

    Resistance300k

    ACResistance300k

    SATURNGEO

    NORMAEarth / Ground Tester

    ElectrodeUnder test

    Source

    Measure

    Current Paths

    Figure 11: Test current paths in the stakeless method

    pole butt plates or un-insulatedneutral conductors. The impedanceof the utility ground electrodesusually combines into a very lowimpedance.

    Lets take an example. Say youhave 40 pole electrodes of roughly20 each, and these electrodesare connected together by a low-impedance ground wire from poleto pole. The equivalent resistanceof the 40 electrodes in parallel is:

    Since half an ohm is smallcompared to the resistance weexpect for our electrode under test,we can assume that most of the

    measured resistance is due to theearth resistance of the electrodeunder test.There are some potential pitfallsfor this method: If you measure in the wrong

    place in the system, youmight get a hard-wired loopresistance, for example on aground ring or on a bondedlightning protection system.If you were intending to readearth resistance, measuringthe conductive loop would giveunexpectedly low resistance

    readings. You may get low readings dueto the interaction of two veryclose, bonded electrodes, likeburied conduit, water pipes, etc.

    The quality of the measurementdepends on the availability ofparallel paths. If a building issolely supplied by a generatoror transformer that has only asingle electrode, the assump-tion of multiple paths wontwork and the measurement

    will indicate the earth resis-tance of both electrodes.Thismethod will not measure earthresistance.

    A problem with the utilitygrounding system might inter-fere with readings.

    In general, if you get readingsbelow 1 ohm, double-check tomake sure you are not measuringa hard-wired conductive loopinstead of the earth loop.

    Two-pole MethodThe two-pole method uses anauxiliary electrode such as awater pipe. Figure 12 shows theconnections. The tester measuresthe combined earth resistance of

    the electrode under test, the earthresistance of the auxiliary elec-trode, and the resistance of themeasurement leads. The assump-tion is that the earth resistanceof the auxiliary electrode is verylow, which would probably betrue for metal pipe without plasticsegments or insulated joints.The effect of the measurementleads may be removed by measur-ing with the leads shortedtogether and subtracting thisreading from the final measure-ment.

    Although its convenient, bevery careful using the two-polemethod: A water pipe may have PVC

    components, which couldgreatly increase its earthresistance. In this case thetwo-point method would givean excessively high reading.

    The auxiliary electrode maynot be outside the influenceof the electrode under test. Inthis case the reading might belower than reality.

    Because of the unknowns involvedin this technique, it is recom-mended only when the groundingsystem and auxiliary electrode arewell known.

    Figure 12: Equivalent circuit for two-point

    measurement

    1

    40 x 1/20R

    eq= = 1/2

    Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings. Fluke Corporation 7

  • 8/13/2019 11095-Eng-01-A Checking Ground Electrode Impedance for Commercial, Industrial and Residential Buildings

    8/8

    Summary of Ground Electrode Test Methods

    Advantages Drawbacks

    Fall-of-Potential Widely accepted When you see the characteristic

    curve you know youve got a good

    measurement.

    You have to disconnect the ground The stakes may not be easy to

    drive

    There may not be space around

    the ground electrode to drive the

    stakes

    Selective Method Dont have to disconnect electrode

    Widely accepted

    When you see the characteristic

    curve you know youve got a good

    measurement.

    The stakes may not be easy to

    drive

    There may not be space around

    the ground electrode to drive the

    stakes

    Stakeless Method Convenient

    Saves time

    No disconnections No stakes

    Assumes a low-impedance paral-

    lel path

    Possible to get very low readingsby mistakenly measuring on a

    hard-wired loop

    Two-pole Method Convenient

    Saves time

    No disconnections

    No stakes

    Impossible to judge the integrity

    of the auxiliary electrode.

    Cant be sure you are outside the

    area of influence

    Table for the Tagg Slope Technique(for 2 decimal places)

    Fluke CorporationPO Box 9090, Everett, WA USA 98206

    Fluke Europe B.V.PO Box 1186, 5602 BDEindhoven, The Netherlands

    For more information call:In the U.S.A. (800) 443-5853 orFax (425) 446-5116In Europe/M-East/Africa (31 40) 2 675 200 orFax (31 40) 2 675 222In Canada (800) 36-FLUKE orFax (905) 890-6866From other countries +1 (425) 446-5500 orFax +1 (425) 446-5116Web access: http://www.fluke.com

    2005 Fluke Corporation. All rights reserved.Printed in The Netherlands 06/20062550440 A-EN-N Rev APub_ID: 11095-eng

    0.40 64.3

    0.41 64.2

    0.42 64.0

    0.43 63.9

    0.44 63.7

    0.45 63.6

    0.46 63.5

    0.47 63.3

    0.48 63.2

    0.49 63.0

    0.50 62.90.51 62.7

    0.52 62.6

    0.53 62.4

    0.54 62.3

    0.55 62.1

    0.56 62.0

    0.57 61.8

    0.58 61.7

    0.59 61.5

    0.60 61.4

    0.61 61.2

    0.62 61.0

    0.63 60.9

    0.64 60.7

    0.65 60.6

    0.66 60.4

    0.67 60.2

    0.68 60.1

    0.69 59.9

    0.70 59.7

    0.71 59.6

    0.72 59.4

    0.73 59.2

    0.74 59.1

    0.75 58.90.76 58.7

    0.77 58.5

    0.78 58.4

    0.79 58.2

    0.80 58.0

    0.81 57.9

    0.82 57.7

    0.83 57.5

    0.84 57.3

    0.85 57.1

    0.86 56.9

    0.87 56.7

    0.88 56.6

    0.89 56.4

    0.90 56.2

    0.91 56.0

    0.92 55.8

    0.93 55.6

    0.94 55.4

    0.95 55.2

    0.96 55.0

    0.97 54.8

    0.98 54.6

    0.99 54.4

    1.00 54.21.01 53.9

    1.02 53.7

    1.03 53.5

    1.04 53.3

    1.05 53.1

    1.06 52.8

    1.07 52.6

    1.08 52.4

    1.09 52.2

    1.10 51.9

    1.11 51.7

    1.12 51.4

    1.13 51.2

    1.14 50.9

    1.15 50.7

    1.16 50.4

    1.17 50.2

    1.18 49.9

    1.19 49.7

    1.20 49.4

    1.21 49.1

    1.22 48.8

    1.23 48.6

    1.24 48.3

    1.25 48.01.26 47.7

    1.27 47.4

    1.28 47.1

    1.29 46.8

    1.30 46.5

    1.31 46.2

    1.32 45.8

    1.33 45.5

    1.34 45.2

    1.35 44.8

    1.36 44.5

    1.37 44.1

    1.38 43.8

    1.39 43.4

    1.40 43.1

    1.41 42.7

    1.42 42.3

    1.43 41.8

    1.44 41.4

    1.45 41.0

    1.46 40.6

    1.47 40.1

    1.48 39.7

    1.49 39.3

    1.50 38.91.51 38.4

    1.52 37.9

    1.53 37.4

    1.54 36.9

    1.55 36.4

    1.56 35.8

    1.57 35.2

    1.58 34.7

    1.59 34.1

    P2/C2

    %

    P2/C2

    %

    P2/C2

    %

    P2/C2

    %

    P2/C2

    %

    Fluke. Keeping your worldup and running.TM

    8 Fluke Corporation Checking ground electrode impedance for commercial, industrial and residental buildings.