1. detailed description of the project area project baseline... · 1. detailed description of the...

39
1 1. Detailed description of the project area: The project area will cover three Pas of Dasanech Woreda (Lokoro, Ocholoch and Nayikaya). In times of drought in Dasanech woreda, competition over very limited natural resources (water and pasture) is high and constitutes a potential for conflict. This risk has increased due to population growth and effects of climate change. The communities of Dasanach, Gabbra and Hammar are very different in their cultures, which isolates them from each other. Past civil wars in Ethiopia and Sudan have brought in a large number of small fire arms, an automatic rifle can be acquired at a price of a cow. So many pastoralists are armed to protect their herds, to force access to the resources or even to raid livestock from their neighbors. Pastoralists cross borders in search of pasture and water, but they can also escape from getting arrested after a raid: for government officers the border constitutes a line not to cross without permission from the other side. The poor road infrastructure and very limited financial resources at government offices allow only irregular meetings of Ethiopian and Kenyan counterparts. In cross-border projects, NGOs can play a bridging role in bringing communities and government officers together. This has been practiced in our last ECHO interventions. PFS as such is still relatively new in Ethiopia and VSFG can bring in its expertise and experience from Kenya and had already chances to adjust it to the Ethiopian context through interventions financed by ECHO in Dasanech and Hamer Woreda. VSF G will support actively government structures in place in Ethiopia mainly at local/woreda and zonal/levels. The current government service structures in place are weak in terms of geographical coverage in the very remote areas, early warning systems (thresholds, harmonization), linking early warning and early response, coordination between various stakeholders, community level involvement and community-district interface. Strengthening of local mitigation capacities is more important than building capacities to handle outside support or to rely excessively on food aid interventions.

Upload: ngoque

Post on 08-Jul-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

1

1. Detailed description of the project area:

The project area will cover three Pas of Dasanech Woreda (Lokoro, Ocholoch and

Nayikaya). In times of drought in Dasanech woreda, competition over very limited

natural resources (water and pasture) is high and constitutes a potential for conflict.

This risk has increased due to population growth and effects of climate change. The

communities of Dasanach, Gabbra and Hammar are very different in their cultures,

which isolates them from each other. Past civil wars in Ethiopia and Sudan have

brought in a large number of small fire arms, an automatic rifle can be acquired at a

price of a cow. So many pastoralists are armed to protect their herds, to force access to

the resources or even to raid livestock from their neighbors. Pastoralists cross borders

in search of pasture and water, but they can also escape from getting arrested after a

raid: for government officers the border constitutes a line not to cross without

permission from the other side. The poor road infrastructure and very limited financial

resources at government offices allow only irregular meetings of Ethiopian and Kenyan

counterparts. In cross-border projects, NGOs can play a bridging role in bringing

communities and government officers together. This has been practiced in our last

ECHO interventions.

PFS as such is still relatively new in Ethiopia and VSFG can bring in its expertise and

experience from Kenya and had already chances to adjust it to the Ethiopian context

through interventions financed by ECHO in Dasanech and Hamer Woreda. VSF G will

support actively government structures in place in Ethiopia mainly at local/woreda and

zonal/levels. The current government service structures in place are weak in terms of

geographical coverage in the very remote areas, early warning systems (thresholds,

harmonization), linking early warning and early response, coordination between various

stakeholders, community level involvement and community-district interface.

Strengthening of local mitigation capacities is more important than building capacities to

handle outside support or to rely excessively on food aid interventions.

Page 2: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

2

Training on DRR, initiated in the past, will need to be deepened and harmonized.

Drought will remain a natural phenomenon in these areas, and due to changing global

weather conditions (i.e. La Nina), the frequency of drought is likely to further increase,

and the intensity of drought to be more severe. There is increasing evidence that

preventive non-food aid interventions and social protection instruments can provide a

more cost-effective and developmental approach to reducing poverty, social risk and

build the resilience of the pastoralist communities.

VSF-G is registered in Ethiopia and Kenya as INGO and therefore will put emphasis on

activities in Dasanach to develop the cross border dimension to its full potential.

2. Brief description of “Regional Initiatives In Support of Vulnerable Pastoralists

and Agro-Pastoralists in the Horn of Africa project (FAO-PASTORAL FIELD

SCHOOL PROJECT)

This project is funded by FAO-UN

3. Background on community dynamics:

In the arid and semi-arid lands of the Greater Horn of Africa, drought is the most

important natural hazard in terms of impact on lives and livelihoods. Droughts cause a

decline in food production, they change migratory patterns of pastoralists, exacerbate

resource-based conflicts, result in large losses of livestock assets and acute food

insecurity among vulnerable households. Its impact is greater for pastoralists and

subsistence farmers.

The vast majority of people within the project area are pastoralists, their livelihoods

depend on livestock. In times of drought, pastoralist households have been used to

applying a number of coping strategies including changing their consumption pattern,

switching to lower quality cheaper cereals, seeking forms of social support etc. But, in

the past decade, pastoralists‟ own ability to respond to drought has become increasingly

limited, due not only to increasing frequency and intensity of droughts leaving less time

Page 3: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

3

for recovery, but also due to increasing demographic pressure, dwindling resource

base, conflict, changes in access to land and water and other shocks like floods and

disease outbreaks. This has in many instances decreased livestock assets to

unsustainable levels and eroded traditional support mechanisms, forcing thousands to

depend on food aid. The livelihoods of some of the targeted communities are further

complicated by international borders which divide ecosystems and cut across traditional

boundaries restricting their mobility. Mobility is further constrained by the conversion of

the better watered land to agriculture and escalating inter-clan conflict.

Participatory assessments of the key problems faced by communities throughout the

project area consistently identify drought as one of the most significant livelihood

challenges along with general insecurity and access to food, water and grazing. These

challenges are experienced differently by region, age, gender and other socio-economic

status. The wealthier pastoralists are generally able to cope with the first and possibly

second consecutive failure of the rainy season provided they have access to fodder for

livestock. By the third consecutive season of rain failure, even the wealthier pastoralists

experience growing food deficiency. Considering vulnerability by age and gender,

especially the young and the old community members as well as women from poorer

and female headed households are most vulnerable.

4. Description of the organization:

Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) is an international non-governmental

organization whose mission is to improve the welfare of vulnerable populations in

developing countries, through improving animal health and production. VSF-G has 20

years experience implementing short/long-term projects with pastoralists as well as

responding to drought emergencies in the dry lands of Kenya, South Sudan, Somalia

and, more recently, Uganda and Ethiopia. Working together as a consortium for the past

ten years, members of the three VSFs have developed an effective and harmonized

approach. VSFs focus not only on animal health, production and marketing, but also

Page 4: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

4

tackle the broader issues of food security, livelihood diversification, income generation,

conflict mitigation, drought preparedness and advocacy.

Since early 2008, VSF-G has been involved in the Regional Drought Decision, as a

partner of both VSF-B and CORDAID in Northern Kenya (North Horn and Dukana

divisions, Chelbi district) and across the border in Southern Ethiopia. The cross border

aspect has been seen as a strong component of our past intervention ensuring

appropriate activities implementation and consolidation of previous community work.

While experience has shown the short term effectiveness of many livestock based

approaches, this project combines different approaches used with success in the past,

providing an innovative approach to drought preparedness. It offers a much longer term

sustainable approach to slow onset emergencies through investment in community level

capacities and clear exit strategies. This project adopts a holistic approach: it will

identify key areas of resource-based conflict, develop resource utilization maps as a

basis for reciprocal grazing agreements, maximize the use of dry season grazing

areas, facilitate the development of community drought contingency plans, link them

with the district plans and relevant stakeholders, enable access to veterinary services,

diversify livelihoods through Village Community Banks, empower communities through

Pastoral Field Schools, and disseminate lessons learnt to communities (through PFS

and interactive booklets) and development actors (through monitoring visits and

publications).

VSF-G‟s has over 10 year‟s presence in the area. This project fits completely with VSF-

G‟s regional strategy, which includes the improvement of delivery and access to

services by pastoralist communities, the promotion of preparedness rather than

response activities, the dissemination of the PFS approach, and a strong focus on

building on existing assets rather than responding to perceived needs.

5. Principal Objective

To contribute to reducing vulnerability of (agro) pastoral communities in Dasanech

Woreda

Page 5: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

5

5.1. Specific Objective

The specific objective of this project is to strengthen institutional and policy framework

affecting resilience of pastoralist and agro pastoral communities of Dasanach and the

diversification of their livelihoods.

5.2. Project Results:

Result 1: Target Communities are better prepared for disaster through community

planning and action

Result 2: Strengthened coordination of both development and humanitarian initiatives

in pastoral areas from community through national levels to regional institutions.

6. Objective and methodologies of the baseline Survey

6.1. Objective of the baseline survey

The main objective of this base line survey is to generate the current development

indicative variables (physical, social and economic) to be used as a measure or

standard for the changes brought in by the implementation of the project. The following

are the specific objectives:

To determine the relevance of the project goals, objectives, activities and outputs.

To obtain baseline information for the key project sectors prior to project

implementation.

To use the baseline findings as a bench mark information for project cycle

management and impact assessment.

The baseline survey covered five main sectors;

Section A: General Information of Households

Page 6: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

6

Section B: Social context, household livelihood and livelihood strategies

Section C; Livestock Production and Health

Section D: Water and Sanitation

Section E: Drought management, Natural resource and environmental

Conservation

Section F: Conflict management

Section G: Existing CBOs and other Agencies

6.2. Baseline Methodology

The survey adopted:

Selected sample frame as a representation of entire population.

Qualitative participatory interviews.

Observations

Focus group discussions with diverse community groups and individuals

consultation meetings with key stakeholders & agencies within the target frame

Participatory rural appraisal tools

Checklists

Use of primary and secondary data

7. Baseline findings

7.1. Section A: General Information & household Identification

7.1.1. General Information

Dasenech Woreda is geographically located at the southern corner of Ethiopia. Hammer

ethnic group at North East, Turkana of Kenya in the south and Salamago in the west

borders the pastoral communities of Dasenech Woredas. The total population of

Dasenech Woreda is estimated to 56,559 (29,282 male, 27,276 Female) in 2007

Administratively, Dasenech woreda has 30 kebeles. Almost all rural population of

Dasenech woreda belongs to Dasenech ethnic group. The Dasenech communities are

predominantly pastoralist and highly mobile in search of water and pasture, they

practice a complex system of livestock movements that provide a high degree of social

mixing. During the wet season, they move with their animals away from the banks of the

Omo River to interior places like Kibish, Fejej and Bubua areas. The Loriantom range is

a traditional dry season pasture area which is , crucial to the pastoral economy of the

Page 7: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

7

Dasenech. Ethnic conflict on water and grazing resource is one of the hot issues in the

area. According to different information sources heavy rains during July and August in

the highlands of Ethiopia and the increased flow in tributaries usually cause flash floods

in Omo River which burst in to rural villages located on the river delta. Dasenech

woreda is the most affected woreda by the flood from Omo River. This is mainly due to

its geographic location in which most kebeles are found in the middle of two divide

courses of Omo River which is the major source of livelihood for the communities. The

Omo River is naturally divided in to two courses, surrounding 9 kebeles of Dasenech

woreda, before reaching its final destination, the Turkana Lake.

7.1.2. Population Size of Nayikaya, Lokoro and Ocholoch kebeles of

Dasenech Woredas

Apart from secondary information which collected at Woreda level, household level

information and other lacking information were collected from selected kebeles and

households from each Woreda. A total of three sample kebeles of Dassanach woreda

were selected and studied deeply to collect primary information. From all three kebeles

a total of more than 176 households were approached and discussed through

community discussion sessions. The following table summarizes the total household

number and population distribution by sex and age across the three kebeles of the

Woredas: As the data obtained from the Dassanach Woreda Pastoralist Development

Office (PDO) indicated, the total population of the three Kebeles is estimated to be

10,280 people. The detail is shown below in the table

Table 1: Number of HH and population distribution by kebele

S/N Name of target

Kebeles from

Dassanach

Woreda

Number of

HH per

Kebele

Number of total

Population by sex and

age

Children

under 5

Total

Population

Number

M F

1 Ocholoch Kebele 445 1,150 1,053 257 2460

2 Lokoro Kebele 318 780 914 226 1920

3 Nayikaya Kebele 410 1,050 1,150 324 2524

Total HH 1173 3,480 3,817 1,007 6904

Page 8: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

8

8. Section B: Social context, household livelihood and livelihood strategies

8.1. Leadership, decision making and resource ownership

Dasenech community has its own traditional leadership structure which is selected by

elders drawn from the community. For Dasenech community, the criteria of electing a

leadership are: to be rich, to be old enough and had good human relation and respected

by most of the community member. Both men and women who can fulfill all the

criteria‟s will be elected as a leader of the community. Major decisions affecting

community are made by community elders. Females are given opportunity to contribute

on decision making processes at community level. The community is a bit liberal to

women‟s involvement which is evident in them selecting a woman as their area

Councilor.

At household level, all resources (farm land, livestock and other assets) are under the

control of the husband in Dasenech community. In Dassanach community, the head of

the household is the only decision maker over the control of resources; unless elected

as leader, women and children are not involved on any decision making on resource

control. This is because there is a prohibition which says women and children will

spiritually punish if they involved on the decision making.

In Dasenech community, all member of the household (husband, wife, and children) are

involved in livestock care and management, however, male youths are mostly the ones

in charge of livestock activities and most often migrate with livestock to the temporary

settlements (Foras) in search of pasture and water under the advice of elder‟s council.

In Dasenech culture women have a very limited role on animal health care activities

except some trained women CAHWs by VSF Germany. VSF Germany has provided

CAHWs training for two women together with men CAHWs.

The role of women on animal health care becomes very limited because according to

the custom and belief of Dassanach community a woman who is on her monthly

ministration period is not allowed to approach livestock hence few or none participate in

animal health system not even ethno-veterinary.

Page 9: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

9

However, this habit is changed from time to time since NGOs like VF Germany are

involved on providing training for Community Animal Health Workers both for men and

women CAHWs by considering gender equity. As a result the previous belief on women

to take part on animal health care is changed from time to time.

In Dasenech communities, grazing Land, pasture and water which are the main

resources, are communally owned by the community as a whole.

8.1.1. Livelihood

For Dassanach community, pastoralism is the dominant source of livelihood for the

majority of rural population in the Woreda. The main livestock species reared embraces

cattle, goats, and sheep and donkeys. Although the pastoral production system is the

major sources of livelihood of the people, crop production is also playing a significant

part in their daily survival where cereals such as maize and sorghum provide a portion

of the diet. In addition to these, the community living on these kebeles is engaged with

traditional fish production potential owing to the presence of different Omo River and

hence traditional fish production is important source of livelihood for many households

in the Woreda. The shares of these main livelihood sources are estimated as 55% of

the community is fully pastoralist and the rest 45% of the community is engaged on

pastoralism, very traditional crop farming as well as fishing activities and

handcraft/carpentry and other small scale business activities such as petty trading

activities such as bartering of cereal crops by shoats and cattle.

8.1.2. Natural resource and utilization

In Dasenech Woreda the major available natural resource are pasture land, farm land,

forest, water and wild life. The communities utilizes the forest for fire wood; shelter

construction; preparation of chair (Berkota) & stick, preparation of utensils including

traditional farm implements; for medicinal uses both for human and animal health care;

for edible wild fruit (Bedena and Kurkura) and plan roots; for gum and incense

Page 10: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

10

production and finally used for browsing/grazing by livestock. Water bodies such as

Omo River and other dry season and sandy rivers are used for traditional fishing,

irrigation and source of drinking water both for the human and livestock population.

Huge sand resource is also available on the dry season rivers and the sand is utilized

for construction of social infrastructures on all rural kebeles and towns.

8.1.3. House hold food and major livestock product

The main food for households in Dasenech Woreda is livestock and livestock products

such as milk, ghee, butter, meat and blood. In addition to livestock products cereal

crops such as Sorghum and maize are widely consumed in the form of porridge and

boiled grains.

Milk and ghee are mainly used for household consumption while butter is sold in local

markets found on the nearby town such as Omorate to generate cash incomes and

sometimes used as cosmetic cream for pastoralist women and other traditional

ceremonies.

Sorghum is the most important crop and maize is less important, mostly consumed at

green stage. Fish is also produced and widely consumed by Dasenech community. In

addition, various varieties of wild foods are also consumed, both in normal and dry

seasons throughout the year. Livestock and livestock product sales generate the bulk of

cash income.

Food aid through Productive Safety Net Program is the other source of household food

in Dassanach community. Food aid and cash is distributed for the community during

drought seasons relying on the monthly reports of the woreda early warning and

preparedness committee depending on the severity of the drought hazard.

Page 11: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

11

8.1.4. Crop Production

In Dasenech Woreda crop cultivation is done by the majority of the community following

the course of Omo River and seasonal rivers often by using very traditional irrigation

system. Sorghum, Maize and Soya been are the major crops produced by Dasenech

community. In this community crop production is mainly performed by women and youth

girls.

Women and youth girls of Dassanach community uses hand tools to dig the farm lands.

Since the land preparation is done by hand farm tools to prepare furrow at shallow

depth. Such farming system is time consuming and tiresome. Crops also do not develop

proper root system and most of the time crops face physical damage and remain

stunted which contributes a significant role for the reduction of crop production and

productivity.

This is in part contributed by poor seedbed preparation, weed infestation and as a result

sever competition among the crops and weed plants on soil nutrients.

The undeveloped working culture of the community to weed out harmful weeds on time

together with Wild animals, birds, stake borer, grasshopper, and sucking bugs also

damage crops significantly which significantly reduces production and productivity.

Generally, 25-30% of crop loss is estimated to appear annually at field level.

In addition to the above main problems of crop farming, the other problems related to

crop cultivation are lack of modern and efficient farm implements, inadequate rain for

sorghum and maize crops, pest infestation and crop disease. Over flooding of Omo

River has also a negative effect on the cultivated crop lands along the river course by

sweeping the grown crops from the farm lands. Over flooding of Omo River also affects

the traditional crop storages even after harvesting.

Generally the following serious challenges are observed widely on crop production in

the area.

- Even though rain fed crop production is not really new in Ethiopian context,

pastoralists and agro-pastoralists have probably less knowledge of crop

Page 12: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

12

farming/agriculture than highland farmers. These pastoralist and agro pastoralist

group of the community has been challenged by very minimum crop production

due to lack of sufficient knowledge on crop farming.

- Shortage of adequate rain fall which is unsuitable for crop production has been

always affecting crop farming/agriculture in pastoralist and agro pastoralist

settings.

- The introduction of modern agricultural technologies such as modern irrigation

system and modern farm implements including lack of farmers training has

contributed for the poor development of the sector in the area.

- The devotion of only few researches and extension approaches on arid and

semi-arid crop production system has also contributed its own impact for the poor

development of the sector in the area.

9. Mobility

Dasenech community practices seasonal movement with their livestock. Their

movement is towards the Turkana areas and Hammer areas during the rainy season

and towards the Omo River during the dry season. Dasenech Woreda is usually

affected by flood risks of Omo River. This is mainly due to its geographical location in

which most kebeles are found in the middle of two divide courses of Omo River which is

the major source of livelihood for the communities in the Woreda. The Omo River is

naturally divided in to two courses, surrounding 9 kebeles of Dasenech woreda, before

reaching its final destination, Lake Turkana. The prevalence of age old conflicts on

grazing and water resources with Turkana and Hammer ethnic group restricted the

traditional mobility of Dasenech community outside the river bank during rainy season/at

the time of over flooding of the Omo river.

10. Local markets

10.1. Dasenech community

The main local market place/area for Dasenech community is Omorate town which is

the head quarter of the woreda. Out of the total………households of the three kebeles

Page 13: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

13

(Nayikaya, Lokoro and Ocholoch), 75% of the household heads have sold a total of 756

heads of livestock in a year 2011/2012 by taking the animal to Omorate local market.

Livestock are sold mostly during drought and famine periods to earn income for several

reasons such as to buy foodstuffs to feed family members, to buy drugs/medicine both

for human and animal health care. Bartering system is practiced widely since local

traders have been delivered cereal crops such as sorghum and maize from Omorate to

the three survey kebeles of the woreda and as a result animals are used to be bartered

with cereals mainly during dry season.

Most livestock owners sell their livestock to traders in Omorate town. There is

undeveloped market structure in Omorate which is serving for livestock marketing.

Relative to the previous livestock market prices, the current price is fairly good,

Lack of transportation means to transport animals from the kebeles to Omorate have

contributed a lot to poor livestock prices exposing vulnerable pastoralist for price

exploitation brokers or middle men.

The price of various products for different seasons is shown in Table 7. A term of trade

between livestock and cereal is affected by seasons. During dry season when grains

are scarce, the price of animals decline radically and the pastoralists are forced to give

away many animals to get the grains.

Table 2: Types of Products and Prices under Different Conditions in Omorate Market

Type Unit average price

Livestock

Ox/ bull Birr 3,000

Cow Birr 2,800

Goat/Male Birr 1,000

Goat/Female Birr 500

Sheep Birr 540

Hen/cock Birr 80

2. Livestock Products

Page 14: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

14

Milk (all types) Birr/lit 10

Butter (cow) Birr/kg 90

Egg Birr/Pc 1.75

3. Crops

Sorghum Birr/qt. 460

Maize “ 380

Coffee husk “ 150

Source: Dassanach Woreda Cooperative Marketing Office (2012)

The main challenges of unfair marketing in the area are lack of adequate market

information and market infrastructure, lack of communities‟ awareness about marketing,

high expenditure on non-essential items during market days such as drinking more

alcoholic beverages by spending more money, the involvement of brokers and distance

of the market areas from the rural settlements, etc. The opportunities to develop the

market include development of grain banking system by organizing pastoral

cooperatives; development of marketing information, construction of well organized and

structured market infrastructures; limiting the role of brokers on price making process,

improving cross-border marketing; training of the community on marketing information

system and establishing community based communication media center for efficient and

effective marketing information dissemination.

11. Wealth ranking and wealth class

Wealth ranking was done for all HHs in the three kebeles such as Nayikaya, Lokoro and

Ocholoch of Dasenech Woreda. It was done by key informants from all villages in the

respective kebeles using the card-sorting method

11.1. Dasenech community

The criteria for wealth ranking were identified after the piling of cards was completed.

Households were grouped into four wealth groups based on the wealth scores. Key

Page 15: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

15

indicators for wealth are the number and type of animal owned (Cow, milking cow, oxen,

sheep, goat, and donkey). The criteria for differentiating wealth groups remain almost

similar across sample kebeles. The following table summarizes the criteria of identifying

various wealth groups across the sample kebeles in Dasenech Woreda.

Page 16: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

16

Table 6: Wealth ranking in Nayikaya, Lokoro and Dassanach Kebeles of Dasenech woreda

Wealth group by

Kebele

Livestock

Other

Percentage of

HH fall under

each wealth

group Cattle

No. of

goats and

sheep

Number of

donkeys

Number of milking

goats

Ocholoch kebele - HH - 345

Very rich 150 -300 140-200 70

30-35

able to feed his

family throughout

the year and owned

livestock kept by

other pastoralists 12%

Rich 70-150 70-100 35

15-20

able to feed his

family throughout

the year and owned

livestock kept by

other pastoralists 20%

Medium 35-75 70-100 15

5-10

28%

Poor 5-10 10-20 5

3-5 40%

Lokoro Kebele - HH : 245

Page 17: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

17

Wealth group by

Kebele

Livestock

Other

Percentage of

HH fall under

each wealth

group Cattle

No. of

goats and

sheep

Number of

donkeys

Number of milking

goats

Very rich 110 - 250 140-300 70 30-35 10$

Rich 70-150 70-100 20-30 20-25 25%

Medium 35-75 70-100 10-20 10-15 30%

Poor 10-15 20-30 5

5 35%

Nayikaya Kebele - HH : 310

Very rich 140 -300 140-200 20

20%

Rich 70-150 140-200 15 15%

Medium 10-20 20-30 5-10 25%

Poor 3-5

Keep others

livestock and

support from others 40%

Note: In Dasenech community the relative size of poor wealth group is --------% and significantly lowers than that of

Hammer Woreda.

Page 18: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

18

12. Problems Ranking

Table 10: Problem Ranking in Ocholoch Kebele (Dassanach woreda)

S. N Problems Score Rank Reason

1 Food shortage 18 1st Shortage of rainfall and

shortage of seed that

resist drought

2 Conflict 11 2nd Competition on pasture

and water

3 Animal disease 9 3rd Inadequate service

(shortage of medicines

and professionals),

disease outbreak during

flooding

4 Shortage of water 7 4th Far water source for

livestock and abscene of

clean water supply for

human

5 Pasture shortage 5 5th Drought

Table 11: Problem ranking in Lokoro Kebele (Dasenech woreda)

S. N Problems Score Rank Reason

1 Food shortage 16 1st Shortage of rainfall,

shortage of cultivable

land, shortage of farm

equipment

2 Shortage of water for

human and animal

14 2nd Lack of accessible water

supply

3 Animal disease 9 3rd Inadequate service

(shortage of medicines

Page 19: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

19

and professionals),

disease outbreak during

flooding

4 Shortage of pasture 7 4th Drought and inadequate

rain

5 Human disease 4 5th Lack of trained health

worker

Table 12: Problem ranking in Nayikaya Kebele (Dassanach woreda)

S. N Problems Score Rank Reason

1 Food shortage 25 1st Shortage of rainfall for

pasture and crop

production

2 Animal disease 13 2nd Inadequate service

(shortage of medicines

and professionals),

disease outbreak during

flooding

3 Shortage of water for

human and animal

8 3rd Water source dried

during dry season

4 Shortage of pasture 4 4th Drought and inadequate

rain

13. Seasonal Calendar

Dasenech Woreda has two rainy seasons with bi-modal rainfall pattern. The long rainy

season starts on February and ends June (belg) and the second/short rainy season

starts on mid September and ends on November. Cows give birth once every two years,

in February, and lactate for most parts of the year. Milking cows are generally kept close

to the homestead, while dry animals are kept in traditional grazing areas (forra).

Page 20: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

20

In a typical year, December to January ( hunger season) are the months of seasonal

migration, when cattle shift from homestead and joined with those in the forra/traditional

pasture land and all animals move to dry season grazing areas. Goats and sheep are

kept closer to home. Some households in the community get milk from goats; however;

the contribution of goat milk is not adequate to feed the entire family members with in

the household.

Crops are planted at the start of the belg rains. Major crops grown in the area in the

order of importance are intercropping of maize with haricot beans and sorghum. Though

inadequate for crop production, rain in September and October is essential for pasture

and browse re-growth for livestock as well as water for both human and animals.

During the dry season, prices of staple food increase until the start of the green maize

harvesting in May. In these months pastoralist will be forced to sell their livestock in

order to generate cash income for the purchase of grains for family food consumption.

Malaria peaks up following the belg rains (from April through June) in areas where there

are stagnant water points, which are conducive for breeding of mosquitoes.

Page 21: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

21

Table13: Seasonal calendar in Dasenech community

July Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Jan Feb March Apr May Jun

Rainfall Seasons dry season Short rain Dry season Main rain dry

Milk Availability Medium Medium Low Good medium

Cattle BIRTH HEAT PERIOD

Livestock Sale Medium High Sale

Livestock Migration Migration for

Dassanach

Shoats BIRTH BIRTH HEAT PERIOD

Maize production Harvest Land

Prep

Plant harvest

Sorghum Production Green Harvest Land Prep Plant

Hunger / stress

periods

Food

shortage(Hunger)seson

Wild food Eating During hunger season

Food Purchase High purchase

Malaria/Diarrhoea High malaria Diarrhoea malaria

Conflict conflict Conflict conflict

Page 22: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

22

Most conflict are caused by cattle rustling during drought period when pastoralist move

to dry season grazing and watering areas which are shared by other neighboring

communities.

The community mostly sells their livestock during drought when there is acute food

shortage and loss of animals live in order to meet their needs at very low prices as

opposed to rainy season when they hardly sell their livestock due to secured conditions

and the livestock prices also shoot up. Most livestock diseases are experience at the

beginning of rains and at the end of rains due to flooding effects.

14. Sector C: Livestock Production and Health

14.1. Livestock type, size, problems, copying strategy

14.1.1. Dasenech community

Livestock is the major source of livelihoods and Asset for a majority of the households in

Dasenech Woreda. The livestock kept and owned by individual and kinship members of

the community. The main livestock species reared embraces cattle, goats, and sheep

and donkeys in their order of importance. However during drought time they prefer to

keep goats and donkeys for they are resisting drought.

.

The major benefits from livestock are that it‟s the main source of food (Milk, Meat,

blood) and also provide hides and skins. Livestock is also used as the main investment,

determinant of wealth and power, used for cultural cleansing, sold to meet other

household needs and the only recognized bride price. Shoats are easily sold due to

their faster re-generation and quick monitory exchange.

The main problems affecting livestock population include; Poor road infrastructure to

access market, water shortage, lack of adequate pasture, over flooding of Omo River,

theft, conflict at grazing & watering points and livestock diseases. Acute water shortage

results in competition between livestock‟s and humans for the scarce water resources.

The shortage of water and pasture is mainly caused by the recurrent drought. Among

Page 23: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

23

all problem drought, disease and conflict are the major one which affect livestock

population. In one year alone, out of the total 78 sample households 70 households

(90%) have lost on average 14 heads of livestock due to recent drought. Similarly out of

the total 78 sampled households, 69 households (88%) have lost on average 11 heads

of livestock due to disease. On the other hand, out of the total 78 sampled households,

32 households (41%) have lost on average 14 heads of livestock due to conflict with

Hammer community.

The measures strategies adopted by the community to address the above problems

include:

- Migration in search of pasture and water by livestock owners to cope up

problems associated with drought which often leads to conflict with other

communities

- Leaving the area where the livestock disease happened

- Separation of diseased animal from those healthy

- Selling of animal: Out of the 78 sampled households in Dasenech Woreda, 64

(82%) have sold a total of 392 head of animal with 90,906 ETB in one year time.

Livestock are sold mostly during drought and famine periods for several reasons.

- Medication and vaccination

- Giving piper and ginger as a medicine

- Slaughtering animals

- Social support among members of the community: out of the 78 sampled

household, 46 household (59%) have given on average 2-3 heads of livestock to

relatives, destitute, and for those who have lost their stock due to disease,

drought and theft. Similarly out of the total 78 households, 49 households (62%)

have received on average 2 heads of animal from other as a social support.

15. Livestock disease and health service

Livestock diseases are among the major challenges of livestock production in Hammer

and Dasenech Woreda. The type of diseases and their prevalence vary across the

Page 24: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

24

Woredas within South Omo zone. This is attributed to the ecological makeup and

species of animals reared along sides. However, C.C.P.P., Tripanosomiasis, C.B.P.P.,

external (tick and mange) and internal parasites are the most common livestock

diseases spread over the two Woreda.

Table 5: Top-Ten diseases and classes of livestock affected in Dasenech

No. Disease type Season of occurrence Livestock species

affected

1 C.C.P.P. Dry Goats

2 Tripanosomiasis Rainy Cattle, goats, equines

3 C.B.P.P Dry Cattle

4 External parasite (tick,

mangi and biting flies)

Rainy Cattle, goats

5 Internal parasite Rainy Cattle, goats, sheep,

equines

6 Black leg Beginning of rainy

season

Cattle

7 Lumpy Skin Disease

(LSD)

Rainy Cattle, goats, sheep

8 Anthrax Dry Cattle

9 New castle Rainy Poultry

10 Streptotricosis All season Cattle

Source: South Omo Zone Veterinary annual report, 2001

In Dasenech Woreda, there are no regular modern animal health services except that

vaccination campaigns which usually conducted once a year and sometimes once in

two – three years. According to the interviewed households during the survey, the

objectives of most the vaccination campaigns were to protect the expansion of

communicable diseases to other parts of the country rather than saving the life of

Dasenech livestock. The last vaccination campaign was conducted in September 2012

Page 25: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

25

against bloody diarrhea and Tuberculosis. Pastoralists depend mainly on indigenous

ethno veterinary which is not enough to meet their day to day veterinary service

demand. The pastoralist in the area depend much on indigenous ethno-veterinary

drugs/herbs and other traditional methods of treatment. However some pastoralists buy

modern medicine from Omorate and sometimes from Kenya to treat their animal.

Most of the sampled households were not happy on the effectiveness of the modern

animal health delivery services. They pointed that the past animal health delivery efforts

were not effective and didn‟t show improvements through time because of lack drug

and health professionals.

16. Section D: Water and Sanitation

16.1. Dasenech community

The main sources of water for Livestock and domestic usage in Dasenech Woreda are

few hand pumps, pond, shallow wells/Chirosh, and River. The hand pumps are few in

number and not accessible by the majorities of the communities. Most of the shallow

wells/Chirosh in Dasenech are dug by the community and are available only for five

months, after that dried up. The temporary shallow wells are often used during the wet

seasons due to their proximity to the wet grazing lands while river is used during dry

season. Most of the water source (except Omo river) will not serve throughout the year.

They serve only for 2 – 6 months of the year. By the time these water sources dried up‟,

the communities are forced to migrate to Omo River. Some are used to transport water

once in 10 days by donkeys from far distance.

16.1.1. Consumption per day, transportation and management

In both Dasenech and Hammer, watering frequency in the dry season for the whole

animals is ranging between 2-3 days. During dry season, animals compete with the

households for water sources.

Page 26: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

26

In Dasenech Woreda, during the wet season, travelling time to fetch water Is 30

minutes. During dry seasons it takes on average three hours, but there are some places

which took even a day. In Dasenech Woreda, out of the total 78 sampled households,

85 % of them responded that they transport water by human beings while 15 % of them

responded that they use donkey for transportation.

In Dasenech Woreda, Chirosh are very few and are purely done on individual decision

though once completed are used communally. Most of the wells are unprotected and

repairs are done on voluntary basis which is tricky in terms of sustainability. However

some households pointed that some water sources are fenced and protected. Out of the

78 interviewed households in Dasenech Woreda 13% of they responded that they had

participated in fencing and guarding activities of water source on voluntarily bases.

There is no a committee to manage the water sources.

17. Section E: Drought cycle management, Natural resource and environmental

conservation

17.1. Copying with food and pasture shortage

The Dasenech community has various ways of coping with drought which are done by

the community. The copping strategies are mainly geared towards increasing the food,

income, and exchange options. The followings are some of coping strategies that are

commonly carried out among the households in the Dasenech Woreda.

- Increase in the consumption of wild foods, meat and blood

- Storing sorghum production for many years

- Slaughter of weak animals;

- The community also sale livestock through cash or barter trade to buy food and

other household items. Out of the 78 sampled households in Dasenech Woreda,

64 (82%) have sold a total of 392 head of animal with 90,906 ETB in one year

time. Livestock are sold mostly during drought and famine periods for several

reasons.

- They also reduce the number of meals a day.

Page 27: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

27

- Migration in search of pasture and water by livestock owners to cope up

problems associated with drought which often lead to conflict with other

communities

- Social support among members of the community: out of the 78 sampled

household, 46 household (59%) have given on average 2-3 heads of livestock to

relatives, destitute, and for those who have lost their stock due to disease,

drought and theft. Similarly out of the total 78 households, 49 households (62%)

have received on average 2 heads of animal from other as a social support.

17.2. Protection and conservation practices

In Dasenech community there is No clear water and pasture management system in

place, although livestock herders meet in the evenings in their “Foras” to discuss about

the pasture areas and thereafter individual herders make own decisions on where and

when to migrate next. However in general terms there is a practice of having a separate

dry and wet season grazing system /patterns. This system contributes for protection and

conservation of pasture, woodland forest and water catchments areas.

17.3. Water and grazing management institution

For both community, a local council of elders exists in the area who closely discusses

issues in regard to drought with re-known community prophets and foreseers who

slaughter Sheep to look at their intestines tell the fate of the community. The

information from the foreseers are then given to the council of elders to inform their

community members on the current situation and what plans need to be put in place.

Page 28: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

28

18. Section F: Conflict Management

18.1. Conflict prevalence mapping

Conflicts in Dasenech Woredas occur between an array of different ethnic groups.

They typically manifest themselves as sporadic events such as raiding and violent

attacks between groups who consider themselves as enemies. Enemies and allies may

change over time depending on the need for cooperation, and events in recent history.

Groups who previously existed together in harmony may now find themselves in conflict

as contexts change or one-off attacks escalate into clan war. For this reason conflicts in

this area are often regarded as recurrent, rather than continuous, with conditions of

relative calm punctuated by intermittent raids and attacks, which may or may not

escalate. The mapping above indicates the groups who considered themselves in

conflict with one another at the time of the study. Conflicts and relationships are

dynamic and as such the mapping indicates the situation at one specific time..

For hammer community, conflict is the second commonly occurring hazard next to

drought in almost all the PAs and sometime bounce to affect the neighboring ethnic

groups as well. The conflict in the area has made the communities' life to be filled with

fear and insecurity. This problem sometimes reaches at a point where the communities

could not manage their daily walk of life. Their life is always under treat. crops and crop

fields, abandonment of economic activities (livestock rearing), and destruction of

community properties. The Hammer community has occasional conflict with Borana of

Ethiopia and Kenya, with Bume and with Dasenech.

Dasenech community has serious conflict with Turkana of Kenya and internally) with

Hammer, Bume, and with) with Borana. The Gheleb (Dasenech) ethnic group has links

in Kenya. Such ethnic links could be instrumental to help alleviate the current conflict if

researched well. During conflicts helpless children are affected the most. If we invest

on these children today, they will be our allies tomorrow in the fighting against SALW.

Page 29: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

29

18.2. Types of conflict

The types of conflict associated with these areas included:

Conflict over grazing area - caused by competition over limited Pasture and

boundaries

Conflict over water resources Caused by competition over limited water and

boundaries

Conflict over Cattle Rustling - (Restocking to replace animals that died due to

drought or diseases and revenge or replacement of livestock earlier looted /stolen

by neighboring warring communities)

Conflict for cultural reasons – Heroism or wealth acquisition by organized youths

(bandits)

The major types of conflict prevailing in the area are conflict over grazing and water

resources. In Dasenech Woreda, out of the total 78 households, 78% of them indicated

that the conflict is due to competition on grazing and water resources. Conflicts over

cattle rustling are carefully planned and coordinated to attack in order to secure

possession of cattle using small arms, ranging from the lowest to the highest types of

fire arms. During such operation, a severe battle rages for at least two to three days.

The cross border conflict between Turkana and Ghelbi (Dasenech) is mainly focused on

cattle rustling and killing of human beings. In the conflict those who are involved in

fighting and even those who are not party to the conflict (innocent lives), especially

children and women would be victims of the conflict of the cattle rustlers.

The cattle rustling operation may not necessarily be successful all the time. The

robbers get killed and lose the ambition of taking back cattle, which do not belong to

their community. However, when they are successful in securing the cattle from the

other side and manage to come home safely, the robbers are not the direct

beneficiaries of that outcome. The father would get the entire share. If the father of the

Page 30: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

30

robber were not alive, then the share would go to the elder brother. If the community

leaders happen to meet the robbers on the way before they handed over to the father or

elderly brother they would get some of the cattle as a gesture of respect and

appreciation for their blessing. In addition the girls and women of that community would

play a role of encouraging the rustlers. The girls and women also get some of the cattle

that would be slaughtered right after they arrive home for the celebration of safe return.

18.2.1. Causes and nature of conflict

Conflict manifests itself as raiding or violent attacks between heavily armed young men,

from different ethnic groups. The general feeling within the majority of communities is

that it is a few „bad‟ individuals in each group who are causing the problem, and

violence is not community-wide. Unfortunately given the cultural traditions and histories

of the different tribal groups and the numbers of weapons in the area one violent

incident can easily scale-up into full clan warfare.

Previously raiding and attacks were well-organized events, sanctioned by the elders,

and accepted by most as suitable strategies for the pastoral system. With the increase

in levels of vulnerability and the ease in availability of deadly weapons however, these

attacks are becoming more individualized and opportunistic. Many no longer regard

these incidents as raids but as theft. These forms of violence are much harder to

predict and control, and require responses, which acknowledge that there may be some

within the communities who do not wish the insecurity to end. Interventions must not

only create disincentives for conflict but therefore also incentives for peace.

These violent raids and attacks are the visible manifestation of much deeper conflicts

and vulnerabilities, which lie beneath the surface of these societies.

Page 31: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

31

Root causes Proximate Causes Triggers

Culture of Heroism Proliferation of weapons Drought

Culture of dowry payment Weak state security Initiation ceremonies

Poverty and vulnerability Weak justice system –

cycles of revenge

Raids/attacks

Increasing scarcity and

competition over resources

Weakening of traditional

authority.

Flooding of the Omo

river.

Poor governance systems Histories of fear and

hatred

Inappropriate delineation of

boundaries

Ethnicity and identity

Lack of development or

employment opportunities

18.2.2. Effect or consequences of conflict

The conflict causes widespread loss of people‟s lives, displacement of people from their

residences, serious psychological and physical injuries, loss and looting of livestock,

loss of livelihoods, loss of water points and loss of grazing resources.

Out of the total 78 sampled households in Dasenech Woreda, 32 households (41%)

have lost on average 14 heads of livestock due to conflict with Hammer community

mostly at the watering points and grazing areas which were never recovered. Similarly

out of the 78 households, 38% of them responded that they experienced death/injuries

of family members due to conflict in the past few years. Most people confirmed that they

sought assistance from local administration in cases of conflict for resolutions. At the

moment they have formed a peace committee of 12 members that work together with

local administration in resolving conflict issues.

Page 32: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

32

18.2.3. Cycle of conflict

Due to the sporadic nature of the conflicts in these areas and the frequent lapses into

cycles of revenge, they are very difficult to predict. As they often occur around key

natural resource sites however it is possible to determine some trends.

Violence can occur on a seasonal basis when climatic and environmental conditions

push conflicting groups together. For example, annual flooding of the Omo River forces

Dasenech on the east of the Omo to move further towards the border with Hammer.

Those on the west side move away towards Mount Kuraz where they meet with the

Nyangatom. During the dry season the Nyangatom and the Hammer find themselves

moving closer together on either bank of the Omo river, and clashes may occur if one

group crosses for hunting or other illicit activities. Similarly smaller conflicts between

the Nyangatom and Mursi and the Nyangatom and Karo occur sporadically at times of

the year when both parties wish to try to cultivate around the Omo River.

Raids and attacks conducted during the dry season are said to be more opportunistic in

nature, as they occur when herders from different groups find themselves in closer

proximity, competing over the same resources. Conversely raiding in the wet season is

often well organized, longer in distance, and more effective. During this time young

men are strengthened by milk and meat and affects such as the „Pre-Harvest

Syndrome‟ provide incentives for counter-attack and reprisals1. CEWARN reports from

2004 indicate that the largest and most effective raids took place in September, October

and November during the rainy season. In one such raid over 8000 heads of cattle

were raided over the border by the Turkana. These raids are typically highly organised

involving large groups of men and sanctioned by the elders

Understanding the seasonality of these raids plus other triggers such as initiation

ceremonies, can help work towards preventing conflicts from erupting. Monthly data

1 CEWARN note that during the rainy season there is enough water and wild fruits to sustain young men undertaking

long distance raiding. In addition pre-harvest festivities may provoke and incite them to undertake counter-attacks and reprisals during this period.

Page 33: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

33

collected and analyzed by CEWARN, details common aggravating and mitigating

factors. Much better co-ordination and use of this data could provide a useful source of

early warning information for use by NGOs, government and local communities.

18.2.4. Conflict management

18.2.4.1. Traditional methods of conflict management and peace

building

Conflicts management in pastoral areas is often closely tied to that of natural resource

management. With livelihoods that require mobility and migration into other groups‟

territories, negotiating access to land is a form of maintaining good relations as well as

accessing resources. This helps explain the volatility of relations amongst many of the

ethnic groups in this area, as alliances are formed and broken largely dependent on

varying resource pressures. The breakdown of many NRM systems due to increasing

insecurity, coupled with deteriorating livelihood and resource conditions is thus

impacting on the ability of different groups to manage their relations with others.

The formation of alliances is also heavily influenced by other cultural attributes. All

groups cited their allies were those connected through systems of intermarriage or the

sharing of similar cultural and language attributes. Sharing of common ancestry also

has significant impact on whether a group is considered an enemy or an ally.

Traditional institutions within each group still have elders who take responsibility for

various areas of governance, such as natural resources, conflict management and

justice. Within ethnic groups, these traditional institutions remain somewhat effective,

and in many remote areas continue to be the only form of governance. With the

increasing influences of education and other external factors however, these forms of

traditional authority are eroding. Young people are losing understanding and respect for

the system, and elders are finding themselves unable to compete with the pull of

external forces.

Page 34: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

34

At an inter-tribe level the weakening of traditional governance is even stronger. The

Dasenech described how they used to maintain peaceful relations with Turkana and

Nyangatom, through symbolic ceremonies, which would manage and bring peace.

Elders from one village would send messages to the other, to request discussion and

conciliation. This group would come with a girl wearing an ostrich feather, a sign of

peace. A bull would be selected and slaughtered and the elders would meet, discuss

and exchange the skins of the bull to signify agreement and restoration of peace.

Whilst this still functions between some groups it is rapidly dying out. Most attribute this

to the increasing levels of hatred, fear and mistrust between groups, brought about by

the intensifying of levels of violence.

Whilst this is an important factor in understanding the continuing occurrence of violence

in the two Woredas, it is only part of the problem. To a certain extent the elders, when

supported by the government, are still relatively strong in restoring peace, albeit for a

short time. What is severely limited however is their ability to prevent violent forms of

conflict from erupting in the first place. Here the erosion of power that the elders face in

managing the behavior of their people plays a role, but equally importantly is their

increasing inability to deal with the ever more complex root causes of these conflicts,

and diversity of actors involved.

18.2.4.2. Formal conflict management system

In the same vein literally all forms of formal conflict management in the zone are

reactionary. The police force, the militia offices, the Special Forces, the peace and

security committees and the local courts all play a „fire fighting role‟, dealing with rapid

response, investigation and follow-up of specific crimes and acts of violence.

At present the government response to violent conflict is one of security and justice.

Whilst this is very important in cooling down violence, and removing criminals from the

communities, it does little to address the underlying tensions and vulnerabilities, which

Page 35: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

35

continually add fuel to the conflicts. The poor governance systems within the zone

result in very few channels of communication through which people can peacefully air

their grievances to a responsive body. Similarly the sole focus on security as a conflict

management tool provides little opportunity to focus on the environmental, political,

economic and cultural forces, which create the conditions for conflict.

There is also a major disconnect between the formal and traditional systems. As was

described above the former systems of maintaining relations such as alliances and

resource sharing have weakened, as vulnerability and conflict increases. Customary

systems of justice and settlement, such as ‘burying the spear’ have also disintegrated

as the traditional institutions weaken and mistrust between groups increases. Yet, at

present the formal justice system is little recognized and rarely accepted by the local

communities. All ethnic groups claim that in the state system criminals are taken to the

prison where they are fed and released after a few years. When they come out they are

proud and fat, more likely to recommit a crime and very bad examples for other

members of the community. This discrediting of the formal justice system results in

people taking justice into their own hands and so begin the cycles of revenge and

counter-revenge that often escalates into embedded clan conflict.

In this vacuum communities are looking for ways of maintaining justice in a way that will

discourage others from committing similar acts. At present all groups look to the

example of the Arbore, in handing over their criminals to the victim‟s tribe. They all

advocate for a justice system with capital punishment that will serve as a lesson to

would-be criminals. Whilst this has been effective for the Arbore, it is not in-line with

government strategies, or assisting the promotion of a culture of peace. There is a

need for the local and regional administration to deal with this issue, and find more

compatible forms of justice that are accepted and understood by the communities and

in-keeping with government policy.

Typical ways in which the government and NGOs have attempted to resolve conflicts in

this area is through peace meetings. There have been a number of meetings held

Page 36: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

36

between conflicting groups and at the time of the study one such meeting was between

the Hammar and the Borena was scheduled, although for reasons unknown it did not

materialize. Whilst peace meetings provide useful spaces to encourage debate and

analysis on conflicts, the history of the meetings held in South Omo have been

somewhat discouraging. Many feel that the meetings provide little more than temporary

solutions to the conflicts, which is evidenced by the continuation of violence between

the ethnic groups. Meetings are said to be too infrequent, with little follow-up and

excluding key stakeholders in the conflicts who may have capacities for conflict of

peace. This exclusion results in peace processes, which lack ownership and leaving

many members of the community who still wish to seek revenge.

The lack of focus on underlying causes of conflicts results in agreements for peace

based on very weak foundations. .The fragility of these agreements can have serious

impacts on the levels of violence and insecurity, which continue in the zone. Trust

between groups is further eroded as commitments are broken. Animosity and hatred

intensify and levels of violence escalate. These meetings do have value. They provide

useful spaces to enable communication and discussion between conflicting groups, but

they must be part of a process, which is owned by the communities and committed to by

external parties.

Peace committees established by local NGOs, such as EPaRDA, and the local

administration, are relatively new. At present they also function in a reactionary

capacity, and to a certain extent have replaced the functions of the elders, who are now

incorporated into the new structures. They are also only established in certain areas

and the support given to them until now has been limited and ad-hoc. This said with

support, they could play a very important role in helping to settle and to prevent future

conflicts. They have the ability to provide spaces for the discussion of wider issues, and

become effective channels of communication between different ethnic groups, and

between communities and the government

Page 37: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

37

19. Existing CBOs initiatives & Institutions

Development organizations in Dasenech Woredas

Name or title of institution/

organizations Major activities and responsibilities

Woreda government offices in Hammer and Dasenech Woreda

Woreda administration Governance, security, food aid, etc

Pastoral, Agricultural & Rural

Development

Livestock health, Cooperatives, crop protection,

fertilizer, etc

Health Vaccination, health care, malaria control

Education Secondary school, primary school, Alternative

Basic Education, etc

Finance and Economic

Development

Personnel recruitment, recurrent and fixed budget

allocation and disbursement etc

Capacity Building Trainings etc

Water Development Borehole, hand dug well, spring development,

maintenance of watering points etc

Women‟s Affairs Woman mobilization for development, woman

Cooperatives establishment etc

Information & Institutions Building Community mobilization et

Woreda Court Justice for criminal cases etc

Woreda Prosecutor

Woreda Police Security, etc

HIV office HIV/AIDS awareness, VCT, etc

Non Governmental and International Organizations

Ethiopian Pastoralist Research and

Development Association (

EPARDA)

Works and provides support in conflict

management, food security, human health and

knowledge development

FARM Africa Works and provides support in community

development, risk management, food security

Action For Development ( AFD) Cooperative development

Page 38: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

38

Name or title of institution/

organizations Major activities and responsibilities

Pastoral Community development

Project (PCDP)

PCDP is a World Bank and IFAD funded project,

implemented through the government. The

project is a 15- year project and it started

implementation in 2003. Hammer Woreda is one

the target Woredas in

Community Based organizations

Women cooperative with 52

member

Under establishment

Women cooperative with 21

member

Petty trade

Women cooperative Revolving fund

Women grain mill cooperative with

24 member

Grain mill business

Peace committee Peace building

20. Recommendations

To improve the livelihood base of the pastoral population in the area there is a need

to consider appropriate development interventions. The focus should be on primarily

on improving access to basic services of water, health and education in gender

focused manner and improving livestock production and productivity using

appropriate livestock packages

There is need to strengthen the existing peace building initiatives in order to

enhance inter-community (tribe) mutual resource sharing in order to maximize utility

of existing resources.

There‟s need to integrate Ethno-veterinary services and modern medicine through

PFS and establish community based veterinary service providers through additional

training of Community health workers and community based pharmacies. It would

also be important to facilitate linkages with the nearby Government departments.

Page 39: 1. Detailed description of the project area Project Baseline... · 1. Detailed description of the project area: ... Vétérinaires Sans Frontières Germany (VSF-G) ... 10,280 people

39

Decentralize the risk management system at local level (efficient Early Warning and

Flood Monitoring system, Contingency plan, Contingency Fund and resources)

Improve local capacity on risk management at woreda level (Put in place stand by

good capacity motor boats, Improve communication system between the community

and woreda, Monitoring and strengthening the omo river dike annually)

Improve the condition of access road and construct bridges to cross both seasonal

and perennial major river

Promote livelihood diversification of the pastoral community

The local Council of elders with a best target to be incorporated in the Natural

resource management in order the enhance water and grazing management in the

area. Even though, the system is in place, it requires some capacity building to

increase access to the avoided conflict prone areas. This will impact in reducing the

current environmental strain.

There is a Traditional post drought or conflict household livelihood support system

where those with more animals give those seriously affected some livestock to take

care of with incentives such as inheriting of the young stock and returning the parent

stock thereafter which would be best legitimized.