xeus and strong gravity from black holes -...

38
XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge UK With help from Giovanni Miniutti, Jon Miller, Chris Reynolds, Rubens Reis and Randy Ross

Upload: hakhuong

Post on 26-Apr-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

XEUS andStrong Gravity from

Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge UK

With help from Giovanni Miniutti, Jon Miller,Chris Reynolds, Rubens Reis and Randy Ross

Page 2: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Accretion makes massive blackholes

2

1)1( cz •

!=+ "

#

#$

Soltan 82

Mean redshift Radiative efficiency

Light Mass density in BH

η > 0.1Observations

Much of the radiation originates within 6Rg

Page 3: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Strong Gravity Effects

• Gravitational redshift• Gravitational light bending• Dragging of inertial frames in

Kerr metric (ISCO depends onBH spin)

Page 4: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Information from spectra andvariability

• X-ray ‘reflection’ givesimportant clues in thespectrum

• Variability timescalesand spectral changesshow differentspectral components

Page 5: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Reflection from photoionized matter(Ross & Fabian 93, 05)

Also see Young+, Nayakshin+, Ballantyne+, Rozanska+, Dumont+

Page 6: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Schwarzschild

Kerr

Fabian+89, Laor 90…Dovciak+04; Beckwith+Done05

Page 7: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Suzaku

Strength and behaviour of line impliesGRAVITATIONAL LIGHT BENDING

MCG-6-30-15

Red wing due to largegravitational redshift

implying BH rapidly spinning

Page 8: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Incidence of broad lines in XMM database Guainazzi+06 (see also Nandra+06)

Emphasises needfor good data

Broad lines found in>50% of spectra with

>150,000 counts

Page 9: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge
Page 10: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Not just a line but wholereflection spectrum

Add relativistic blurring

Soft excess – broad iron line – Compton hump

Page 11: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Crummy+05 22 PG QSO +12 Seyf1

Soft Excesses

Page 12: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

MCG-6 Suzaku: Miniutti+06

Observed reflection requires strong iron emission line

Page 13: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Probing Black Hole Spin

Page 14: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Assumption: measurements of rms determine (or constrain) a

Page 15: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

ISCO conjecture• Measure Rin from spectra ⇒ RISCO ⇒ spin?• B decreases Rin (Begelman & Reynolds, Gammie,

Krolik, Hawley…)??• BUT low ionization ⇒thin, slowly accretion disc,

which is not plunging, so Rin ~ RISCO

Computations show that Rin measured from iron lineis within ~0.5rg of Risco (Reynolds & Fabian 07)

Page 16: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Density

Azimuthal field

Reynolds & Fabian 07 in press

Page 17: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Reynolds & Fabian (ApJ in press)

Page 18: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Assume illumination bysource on symmetry axis

of accretion disk atDs=6rg

Reynolds & Fabian (ApJ in press)

Page 19: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Primary method… measure black hole spinusing the width/profile of the broad iron

line…Non-spinningRapidly-spinning

KERRDISK modelBrenneman & Reynolds (2006)

Page 20: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

GX339-4 Miller et al 04,07

LSVHS

Page 21: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

J. MillerSuzaku J Miller submitted

GX339-4

Page 22: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Galactic BH:Disk hot, so line

Comptonized

Ross+Fabian07

GBH

AGN

Page 23: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

GX339-4withXMM

R Reis

Page 24: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

• Main point here is to demonstratethat we are seeing the accretion flowat ~2rg in several objects.

• This requires a rapidly spinning blackhole.

• Precise determination of spin requiresmodelling of flows and systematics.Current work suggests

~5%.

Page 25: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

XEUS z=0.5

Page 26: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

How does it vary?

Iwasawa+ Shih+ Fabian+ Vaughan+ McHardy+ Uttley+ Reynolds+

Page 27: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Variable power-law

Quasi-constant reflection-dominated component

Schematic picture of the two-componentmodel

Data consistent withhighly variable power-law + quasi-constant reflection

spectrum

Page 28: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Difference spectrum: (High flux)-(Low flux)

is a power-law modified by absorption

1 keV 10 keV

So we know which large scale features are due to absorption

Ratio to power-law

Page 29: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Light bending model in Kerrspacetime

Miniutti et al 03; Miniutti & Fabian 04; earlier work by Matt+see also Tsuebsuwong, Malzac+06

Page 30: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

MCG-6 XMM 2000+2001 dataLarsson+06

Page 31: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Variability

RMS fractional variability spectrum

Page 32: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Mkn 335 2007 low state Grupe+07submitted

Page 33: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

• Broad iron lines enable the determinationof black hole spin

• Also enables study of the accretion flowand strong gravity effects (redshift andlight bending) of extreme gravity – howgravity works and powers quasars

• Next stage requires more photons fromAGN (which are relatively MUCH brighterthan GBH on a “per-light-crossing-time”basis)

• This implies next generation X-raytelescopes

Page 34: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Armitage & Reynolds

Page 35: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Arcs trace orbits ofdisk material aroundblack hole… can be

compared withpredicted GR orbits

Iron line intensity as function of energy and time.

Theoretical

Orbiting hot spots

Page 36: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Andy Young andChris Reynolds

M=107 MsunF2-10=5×10-11

a=0.998

Reverberation

Page 37: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge

Brightest lines are about 2 ph m-2 s-1

Need sources with high L/LEdd for broad lines(NLS1/GXRB)

Typically means•BH mass of 106-108 Msun•or timescales of 100s to 104s.

Therefore to study such BH on theirintrinsic variabilitylight crossing timescalesinner orbital period

⇒ effective collecting area at 6 keV in m2 class

XEUS has have the potential tomaker MAJOR advances

Page 38: XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes - sci.esa.intsci.esa.int/Conferences/xeus/13_Strong_Gravity_Fabian.pdf · XEUS and Strong Gravity from Black Holes AC Fabian IoA Cambridge