x]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

11
DOI!"10.3969 j.issn.1672884x.2016.01.002 XY%XZ[\)$%%X]^'( FGH IJP KLM N O 1. |)P/Qk./78/32. RS./78T/33. }UVW./78/34. ØXYZ./2/39:[T\8TF]^_`µ788TaOFe±²vT\bcFdeàfg µ788TF¨hd£ PEL T\iajkaOµ788TFiajkADEL jk),  lµseòBAmF788T(nopqvrs8TFdeà*tµ788T aOFbcuvý/w³´788TaO*x;<=011LwL1L1L >?@ABCC93 DEFGHDI!C1672884X 2016 01000711 犕犪狀犪犵犲犿犲狀狋犜犺犲狅狉狔犅狌犻犾犱犻狀犵犳狉狅犿狋犺犲犘犲狉狊狆犲犮狋犻狏犲狅犳犃狉犵狌犿犲狀狋犪狋犻狅狀犜犺犲狅狉狔 JIANG Hongbing LIUYuewen SUNYonghong MAJian 1.UniversityofScienceandTechnologyofChina Hefei China 2.ZhengzhouUniversity Zhengzhou China 3.Xi anJiaotongUniversity Xi an China 4.CityUniversityofHongKong HongKong China 犃犫狊狋狉犪犮狋 Clearlyandcompletelypresentingmanagementtheoriesiscrucialforbuildingmanage menttheoriestoexplain managementphenomenoninChina guide managementpracticesinChina andmakehighinternationalacademicimpacts.Fromtheperspectiveofargumentationtheory were definetheconceptofmanagementtheorybasedontheconceptof argument ”, buildanADELmodel basedonPEL modeltoclearlyandcompletelypresentthecomponentsofmanagementtheories and proposeaconceptualframeworktobuildmanagementtheories basedonresearchcontributiontheory. 犓犲狔狑狅狉犱狊 managementtheorybuilding argumentationtheory assump tion JKLM20150806 NOPQ.2{x56789:;<71331005 71301128 -.016ef^Îk[äÏX -.7UJ$ äϾ ¸» M°á©, ¾ ¸ JqV016¡~d; YM011 L w vÌV[ 2005 @ ^_,《 01ÁP 3K¯¼K>ÏÐKºÓÙ^01 Í ef6OeA 4H h Í efJvÌ w 011LMHñrx ¦ Vh . k -J6¡ 016¡d ? ( uv56 k 6r å Ô-.\]'(J+ x WcùM w 1LºJ ()àÛ ”, ÆþWJàM6Ow|K ð q / Vh ÿ k-J6¡ -.016¡ ² 34ðÆ56+op1 Í Ô 6Ow| ¨efî[L 1LJ à À tYZ$äϪ- ¡ 341LJ¨¢(w, ¾J£©w:“ ¤W¥¦ÊM²uv346 LWWJX1LLW(yJ7¨ Ê d § K Ñ/LU¸Xcù6 ¨ Ô1 uv346 = /J.ÓÉN J ªcù³ % uv 3462'zòT¦ª;õ ÏÐ « J\ ¬ÂJ=/ E ? G - Ýh Z ²cùiX ® ®¯(¥h¼ùGH°JefÔ òJ ± kkNBô N ¤ ²³´ ¥ O 6T µ ¢£Òh¤niÜ(t 6 Æ ¤£ J)tçùJÜUû7{Xgh § O”。  ¡ ·40X6 ¨ ,l 2 dJ1LÛX wD1L±1LJT Î w · , Ï Ó ¸ )B BCCMá°J01ef-k ¡³ 4 , · · =13>=? 2016@A 0 1 6 B ChineseJournalofManagement Vol.13No.1 Jan.2016

Upload: others

Post on 11-Mar-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

DOI!"

:10.3969/j.issn.1672884x.2016.01.002

XY%XZ[\)$%%X]^'(

FGH

1,2 IJP

3 KLM

3 N O

(1.|)P/Qk./78/3

;2.RS./78T�/3

3.}UVW./78/3

;4.ØXYZ./2/3

  9:

:[T\8TF]^_`µ788TaOF3e±²

:①vT\bcFdeà

,fg

µ788TF¨h

;②d£PELT\iajk

,aOµ788TFiajk

(ADELjk

),Â

lµseòBAmF788T(nopFöq

;③v��rs8TFdeà

,*tµ788T

aOFbcuv

,ý/w³´788TaO*x~â

;<=

:011L�w

;L�1L

;1L��

>?@ABC

:C93 DEFGH

:A DI!C

:1672884X(2016)01000711

犕犪狀犪犵犲犿犲狀狋犜犺犲狅狉狔犅狌犻犾犱犻狀犵犳狉狅犿狋犺犲犘犲狉狊狆犲犮狋犻狏犲狅犳犃狉犵狌犿犲狀狋犪狋犻狅狀犜犺犲狅狉狔

JIANGHongbing1,2 LIUYuewen

3 SUNYonghong

3 MAJian

(1.UniversityofScienceandTechnologyofChina,Hefei,China;2.ZhengzhouUniversity,

Zhengzhou,China;3.Xi’anJiaotongUniversity,Xi’an,China;

4.CityUniversityofHongKong,HongKong,China)

犃犫狊狋狉犪犮狋:Clearlyandcompletelypresentingmanagementtheoriesiscrucialforbuildingmanage

menttheoriestoexplainmanagementphenomenoninChina,guidemanagementpracticesinChina,

andmakehighinternationalacademicimpacts.Fromtheperspectiveofargumentationtheory,were

definetheconceptofmanagementtheorybasedontheconceptof“argument”,buildanADELmodel

basedonPELmodeltoclearlyandcompletelypresentthecomponentsofmanagementtheories,and

proposeaconceptualframeworktobuildmanagementtheories,basedonresearchcontributiontheory.

犓犲狔狑狅狉犱狊:managementtheorybuilding;argumentationtheory;assumption

JKLM

:20150806

NOPQ

:.2{x56789:;<

(71331005,71301128)

  -.016ef^Îk[

“�äÏ

”XjÙ

-.7UJ

“$äÏ

”¾¸

,»M°á©,¾¸

J�qV

,016¡~d�;

。�Y

,M011

L�wvÌV

,[2005@^_

,《01ÁP

》�

�3K¯¼K>ÏÐKºÓÙ�^�01Í�

ef6OeA4

,H�h�efJv�w

011L

;MHñr�x¦V

,h��.

[1]k�

-J6¡��016¡d?]¥�(

、���

�uv56k6råÔ-.\]'(J+

x

[2,3],�WcùM�w1LºJ

“()àÛ

”,

�ÆþWJà�

;M6Ow|K�ðq/V

,h

��ÿ

[4]k�-J6¡��-.016¡�²

��34�ð

,�Æ56+�

,op1ÍÔ��

6Ow|

[5]。¨efî[L�1LJà��À

tYZ

“$äÏ

”J±ª-

 ¡ 

[6]2M¯

《341LJ¨¢(�w

》,

¾J£©-½w

:“¤W¥¦ÊM²uv346

LW

(WJX1LLW

)(yJ7¨Êd§�K

Ñ/L

,U¸Xcù6¨Ô1�uv346=

/J.ÓX©

。ÉNJª

,cù³�¶%uv

3462'?ÎzòT¦ª;

、õÏЫJ

、\

�¬ÂJ=/E?G­Ý

,hZ²cùiX®

®¯(¥h¼ùGH°JefÔ��òJ±�

kkNB

,ôN¤²³´¥�O6�T

。�µ

,¢£�Ò�h¤n

,iÜ(t6�Ƥ£

�J

,)�tçùJÜUû7

,{Xgh§O

”。

 ¡ ·4

,�0X6¨,l2dJ1LÛX

�wD1L

,±1LJTÎw·,ÏÓ¸)B

BCC

,Má°J01ef-

,k¡³4�,

·7·

  =13>=1?

2016@1A

          0 1 6 B

ChineseJournalofManagement          

Vol.13No.1

Jan.2016  

Page 2: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

l1Lþ�)¹�BC

。BACHARACH[7]

Y

Zt1L�w¡³6³©¼ùG�w1LJ�

;WHETTEN[8]½w

:“á°-

,ݲ,l1

LJ��³6%³5¥-ãIT

,ë?

,&�©

l1LJçd�𺫥r¹Ô0©l1LJ

7UÔí�©l1LJ7U

”;̄¼³Â6¡

YSHOEMAKERà

[9]Ô NKWAKE

[10]à

,î

-��JY\

ë?

,YZ9B»

、9¢5¥-ã1L

,W

JX1LJ��

,±²

“$äÏ

”�¼)êk;

Ó

。?á

,ݲ01efJ,l�IW\�X

6½É�

、Y\¾¿

,ÂñefÀ/ûºMd

M6Oþÿ-

,Y3�³5¥

、¢5¥-ã~{

JY\

,�����d?ÁØ

、_'ÂE

、KÒ

�

。Gh

,M1L�w©ñ{�J±ê�#

-

,B»J

、¢£W^J1L-ã�9¼)l¹

ÄÅ

k�B»ô¢5¥-ã1L

,>�L�1

L-

“L�

”JefÔL�j�Æ¿

,�²aÇ

011LJÏ�ÔÏh a

,mHI011L

J�wef./

1 DE)F(67GH

1.1 $%&)&_`a

016P±

“016

”©lefJPÏÊM

uÂ&ß

。M©uÂ&ß-

,̈efÈ�01

6Pãh,úJ a

[11]kk±016JPÏ

“016ÉÊÏÐí�JËÌ

,ÍÎãhÏÐ<

}JÎ\K=/

”。§B016JÏ�

,016

ef.1ÏÐÏÐJ�M�#W^

,ÏÐäÏ

ÐJ7¨Ó,W^

[12]。ݲ①ÊMÂñ¤J

ÏÐ

,Yüý

、 "

、ññà

;②ÊMÂñ651

�ÏЬ¯7¨Ó,

,Y+16

、ç«6

、34

;③ÊMÂñefÀ/

,Y°���

、Ñ¥

��à

,.h�016¿áIÂ+(J65W

\

。§B01efJà��ûA���û8h

�ÒÂJ016ÿ½

ë?

,M��6Oþÿº

,ÓÓC�efG

7²Jà�A¡��þ�BC

。Ôùà

[13]Ð

I

,0161LefJ�¢z

,¯7ÕòXÝ

016efGNÖJ��Æ×GÙúJ

。ë

?

,B»ô¢5¥-ã011L[a.Ó

1.2 $%%X]^DEbc

1L�wefXØä°���Xy°��

�J¾¸ôÙÚW^J

。¸56k6Ý°��

�¾ky°���

,5l56�#JÛ\îÝ

±�J°�¾Üt�1L�wV

。20ÁÝ70

~80@�Þá�,ß>²1L�wJdeà

k

。{?hy

,>²1L�wJAL¼I�á

,#tá 

,1L�wef9xâã�ê

M01ef´Û

,1LJ�

、1LJj

、1LvÉJÏ�Ô�fJw�¬äChk

'B�åJef��

。BACHARACH[7]

±1

LG�JÏ�¸æ�kçèé�¦g

:“1LX

Ý�fÔ¸CÏhJ?]

,MV?]-�fK

�f¦­Ø·±�Ój

,̧CK¸C¦­Ø·

��Ój

,5l?]=M~«1L��G�h

JêPJ�Ï-

”。WHETTEN[14]

±1L�h

Ó , J i j µ D Î �

:“1 L � �

,¤ £

(What)、¢¤

(How)、k¤£

(Why)Ô­

/Z

¥

/Zº

(Who/Where/When)4lÏh a

”。

BAGOZZI[15]

HIJ1Lj�J5EÆ¿N�

k$�01ef°N

。ëÅL¬1LvÉ

,N

©.DDAVIS[16]

HIJdSÍ

。6¡ùî,

#M·4 � f J B » Í

[17,18]Ô ä C J ¬ 5

Í

[15]。

Mº»AL©Æ\]ef��Jûº

,�

Æ@

,>²011L�wJDRef��î^

s�cùJàì

,~AÍíxhî

,�Ó-áI

Yò4lvâJèÞ

(1)!"##$%&'()*+,- 1

L��XM,Ä

(AÂÄ

)1L�w-

,kkï

1!HJÄÆbW

,©ÆbWJÙ1Í®ªM

¨Ä1L�w-)t�h

。³5¥-ã1L�

,±1L�wZ>;Ó

,�XU�1LÔ/W

1LJ.Óïi

。HEô©

,Y3ÊdðBC

,l1LJ1L��

,N①��U�©l1

L

[19]51,ëk�=w,láÖXÉ�kV1LG

©ñ

;②��Ø·�RV1LJ1L��T/

WV1L

[20],ëk��ñò©Æ��XÉÙ1

③MÂl1LMdJ7Õò

,��طM1L

­W^°9ÍJ±ªT/W~l1L

[21,22],î

��ط1LchT/W1L

[23,24]。³5¥-

ã1L��~ZXMw|V±1L�w¡J,

lÓ Æ

,ë k � X , ñ 6 O � ° J - á 8

/

[9]39。Ó0Y?

,���t³5-ã1L��

JefÛXCk6O

[7,8,20]。

(2)#$./01*+234 1L�w

óôXÐÙ1J

、7²º©Jr�Æ/Ôï1

;M1L�w-

,��kk!HJ��ÔÎ

\�BÙ1¥ÓjM,O

,)IjL

[25]128。1

L�wJóô¿Â¤Í/W$Þ

,Îk�Ý5

ÏÍ�°t}�°Í5�

、ÝÏÍ5�tÏC

5�

、ݽ+5�>?tÀ+5�>?

、Ýóô

·8·

016B=13>=1?2016@1A

Page 3: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

aÇtóôKÎ\],aÇJ·)

(3)564#$./789:; 7U(

1L�w·47Uë,

(Yº­

、ö­

、'(à

M1L�w-Jk�

。7Uë,XÐÏÐef

áÖmõ±efáÖ/õä#$A­$QRJ

�¥ë,

,A¡WÐñ²ádef-aǼÄ

J�¥ë,

[8]。7U(1L�wJ<JM²ö

B1LJk�ÀÏÔÉÊ9{�Jí�æì

,vâ

,1å7Õò

,GdJ1LÒU¸÷d,

l¯Ê}ø

:“V1Ld¯Ì�JWÏ7U

,ù

6¯Ì�ÀϳÊYò

……”;l,vâ

,�7

Uë,kk{¸C

、4ú¸CA-߸CÇK

t1L�w-

,��ÉÊ9{�Jí�æì

,Y

,lnaǼÄJ1L��ÉÊñ¼Ä7Uë

,XYZK×¼Äë,KÒQRJ

(4)<=>?@ABCBD M01ef

1Lk�ÙJ()ò

,�66¡-ãI©¤J

¶û

:¼ùÑk�UV·²�ÆDü

、dSJ1

L

,WJXÄÆýþ,á�Lî®ç�ÿJ1

L

,UV­!°¥"\ÍÎ�wJ1L

[26],â"

¥#WdSJáÖ

,Í$Î\�B

[27],9%�¥

í�Î\�B

[28],©¤9�¶�w0±ê9·

J1L

1.3 de'()fghiD)'(jk

�0X±1L��J��

,AX�Ƥ

Ù1J1L�wóô

,AXöB1LJk�À

Ï

,&AX�1Lw�M9�°JÎ\�B¦

V

,̄¨9ÒXk��Æ,l¢£W^J1L

HETÏ

,©Æ>²011L�wJ!'ef

MhòY\VX,úJ

:k�9�¥�w01

1L

,Ó³5,l¢£W^J1LX¤£¤

J

———©l1LX7²¤£¤J��

、U�²

¤£¤J7U

、w�M¤£¤JÎ\�B¦V

h¬N¤£¤Jóôôw�OTJ

,<!'É-ÛÊd?]¥(W¢£

W^J1LJef

。ádJ'ÉH°�,ÆF

)

,,ßdeJ1L�w¡

,Y KETOKIVI

à

[29],VANDEVEN[30]

Ô HART[31]

à

,ÒH�

�*Ì+Æ¿TaÇ,l56L�

。*Ì+Æ

¿XL�1L-J,l�²aÇL�j�JØ

�ƿ

。¸U�²56ef´Ûº

,efçb

7²*Ì+Æ¿�ø�PELÆ¿

。xô

,PEL

Æ¿±1LJ�� aG©~6

。¨efk�

aÇ011L

,WJX�I011LJ�� 

a

,MPELÆ¿J7]V

,9�,®¥HI�

ADELÆ¿

(�� Assumption(��

)、Deriva

tion(ÙI±�

)、Evidence(�B

)Ô Logic(ó

ô

)),mh ADELÆ¿kXH

,[L�1LJ

à�T?]¥(W¢£W^J011L

。HE

ô©

,̈'Jef����

:①[L�1LJà

�A

,¤£X011L

?②[L�1LJà�

A

,,l¢£W^J011L��KÆÓ,

③[L�1LJà�A

,YZ��011L�

w

2 67IJ

2.1 XY%X

L�

(argument)XL�1L-�ú+Jh

z C H & ß J e f

。L � , � ä · )

(process)、j3

(product)、�#

(act)、±Ö

(ob

ject)àÂ;��

。©ª�±L�Jefk·²

«úJ>a

,È�~lL�1L6½Ò7¨$

×JÏ�

[32]:L�X,lº©

、bWA±�Jc

Ù

,mWák,ñ!HÔjLJj�

。cÙ-

J,ƺ©

、bWA±�kk!H

,kl,º

©

、bWA±�

(kkjL

)H°,5

(sup

port)、-.

(defense)A�h

(justification)。Y

®WJ�³

,̈ef-J

“L�

”]]k¿!

,k

k#!J

“L�

”NÝ

“�h

”�/

L�1LXhL�JaÇÔë0k�Óe

f��J~ñ1LJiD

。kk,ln65J

ef´Û

,̧�L�1LÍÎ8h�óô6

、-

LO

、1263ñ�ÓJ1L�ð

[33,34]。L�

1LefJóô6�ðzgak8/óôÔ�

8/óô�ð

。8/óô�8/(?]"²L

�-J3Ïj�Ôï1ËN

。�8/óôúê

²�waÇÔë04`²{xº©JL�J1

LÔvÌ

。L�1LefJL-O�ðåû

“h&ßÍY\¬L�J±Ü��ßñÍ56

JW\

,efL-ÍALJ)£ÔËNAL�

h3JæÍKW9

[34]。L�1LefJ126

�ðh

“d?�ݶÒ

”kL�J�7¨ô�

7A°t

、�wÔ-ãL�J1LÔvÌ

ݲ1Lò©�ÆjL

,m�!HT,5

©ÆjL

[35],ë?1LîX,ñL�

。BROM

MEà

[36]Ñk561LXÝÅ8L�ÏhJÔ

9

;TOMASZ[37]

ÐI*Ì+Æ¿

(�8/óô

�ðL�1LJ,ñÆ¿

)r8/óôJÆ¿

9ÌÙ(³56/áÔ56L�J¨9

;OS

BORNE[38]

NM

《Science》V:'

,H�h*Ì

+Æ ¿ T � � ß ñ / J 5 6 1 L 6 ¨

BOOTHà

[39]116ÐI WILLIAMSÔCOLOMB

M*Ì+Æ¿7]V�,®¢zJL�Æ¿9

��;56efJ°9

·9·

L�1Là�òJ011L�wef

———<=> ?@' �ÇA à

Page 4: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

M01ef´Û

,6¡ùîÙÚq/t�

L�1LaÇ011LJ;ÓÍ

。HART[31]88

��6¡±,l56L��*Ì+Æ¿��ß

ñÍaÇ

,,ßdeJ011L�w¡

,YKE

TOKIVIà

[29]ÔVANDEVEN

[30]130à

,îUê

H��*Ì+Æ¿TaÇ56L�

2.2 XYlm

ÓaÇ,l¢£W^J011L��KÆ

Ó,

,ªÓ7²ÙÌJL�Æ¿

*Ì+Æ¿XQR¹UJL�j�Æ¿

§B * Ì + Æ ¿

,, l L � Z 6 � � j L

(claimorconclusion)、̄ B

(data)Ô^¸1Ý

(warrant),{�,\JL�g���,B

(backing)、äÏ!

(qualifier)Ô�C

(rebut

tal)[40]90~92。

jLXL�-åÓ×Ò�éK*

J,l±�

;̄BXL\Dhh�Jj°9E

(Facts);̂ ¸1Ýk[¯BtjLJ·FH°

GHÔ�N

;̧^¸1Ý×t9Iº

,,B�T

·(^¸1ÝJâJÍ

;äÏ!X[¯BÔ^

¸1ÝtjLJK@êCJäÏÍbW

;�C

X��[¯BÔ^¸1ÝK@tjLJbW

&jL¬�MdäJÀÏ�hdäJv/&

GAUCH[25]124~134

M*Ì+Æ¿J7]VH

I�U�²56ef´ÛJPELÆ¿

,�²#

W,l¢£W^J56L�

,�Ý3lÿ'¿

!

(Presupposition(§ �

)、Evidence(� B

)、

Logic(óô

))J!mLÏÙôh

。PELÆ¿-

J�BÔ*Ì+Æ¿-J¯B��,ú

,ô

PELÆ¿-[¯BtjLJGHÔ�Nô�

Nݧ�Ôóô��

。§BPELÆ¿

,,l¢

£W^J56L�Xݧ�

、�B

、óôÔ56

jLÏh

,�Ñ/-ã�X

:§�+�B+ó

ô=56jL

。-1ÅI�PELÆ¿J,l

°�

。K*Ì+Æ¿Kr

,PELÆ¿�I�§

�J>Sk�

n1 PELlm)+opq

PELÆ¿+, °�

!H1[§�

]AO�¥q´ä�¥ÊM

!H2[�B

]cùAOMNªd,OPQ

!H3[óô

]ÊÏ!iX^5JRSï1ËN

jL MNªd,OPQ

  M©ª

“§�

”Xl>Sef

,§�X,ñ

��J7Õ

,ghÝ©ñ��ãt,lWÏJ

jL

,x ô

,¸ ! Û � � � ³ © ñ � �

GAUCH[25]133

�§�ak««

:£ü§�Ôü

 §�

。£ü§�MðZ,lL�-Ò���

³¯^5ATE

,�Y

,¥9ÁPXd£J

、g

h1�J

,ÜU=(ËUgVà

,̈,l!ºT

#W£ü§�

,�X

“*W

”;ü §�M¸!

ÅÏJL�-)�t�³

,»XghMhyJ

L�-)t�³

。>²£ü§�Kü §�J

>J

,XY�

[41]ÅI�©¤J#W

:“56§�

[£ü§�

]X561LDh^_J

、U][©

³JO\

,îX561LDh�¹J

、�¶Z(

J⼧7

,ëôXC¯{xJÔ�g#$J

ôõM³U)�VX@\JÔcE®q/J

……56§���

:56ÁPY

,56*f

,5

6\]

,56vÌ

,567n

,ÐÙtNà

。ë

?

,56§���56Ñ1

[ü §�

]ĤX

�l1LJ7¨efÔ7¨��

,ôX�l6

5

(rY�¥16A0¥6

)JGd1L

、ZZ

£ 561LJÑ[7]A[û�Ï

”。

GAUCH[25]

m[±§���9k\«JA

L

。xô

,§�±²(W,l¢£W^J01

1Lô©�ö;Ó

。ë?

,̈efMPELÆ¿

J7]VHI� ADELÆ¿T(³,l¢£

W^J011LJÓ,

3 KLMN/MOP.//M

3.1 $%%X)rs

56_²��

[42]155,��XØí,¸=/

J�q

[43]357。ef��Xï#1L�wJ�;

ÓJ#ê

,X1L�wJ>SGM

[44]362,GdJ

1L�w�#Ò[8hef��^_

[19]1。5

61LX±ef��J¤WÍo]

[42]222。,l

ef��ØöÝ,l{�J56L�JjLT

o]

,,l{�J56L�z��Å8C¿J

56L�

。ML�1LJà�ò

,011Lg

h%àkÝ,ÏKÒÓ?J56L��hJ?

]

,�²o],lAÂl01ef��

。§B

PELÆ¿

,,l¢£W^J56L�Xݧ

、�B

、óôÔ56jLÏhJ

。ë?

,,l

¢£W^J011LîXÝ~ñ§�

、�B

、ó

ôÔ56jLGÏhJ

3.2 $%%X):tAu

ݲ011LÎöduÂ��

,z�¶×

t~ñ7Uì^

,ë?¯§�ñ«§Â

,Y±ç

ÍJ~ñ7¨��

、±ÏÐJ~ñ«r��

、~

ñefvÌJ7¨��à

;ôPELÆ¿±§�

__k�£ü§�Ôü §�J>a

,Êd9

\«JAL

,³4B»¥-ã011L

。ë?

cùMPELÆ¿J7]V

,«(�§�©le

f

,HI�ADELÆ¿

·01·

016B=13>=1?2016@1A

Page 5: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

ªÓ�³JX

,ADELƿm[�

Ҥ

”JuÌ

。ëk

,“§�

”©lu̳g�&c

ù`Àóô6Ôº©6->²§�J�¶aç

bcJAL-

,©±011L�wô©dn®

。ë?

,È��016ÔÎX6-ËU$×

JuÌ

:“��

”。

3.2.1 !"

KPELÆ¿-J

“§�

”Kr

,“��

”J�

�7¨,ú»9çè,Æ

。��X,lL�

-

,cùdºK*k�JÄÆ*f

。©Æ*f

M¸!L�-ed�×�RJâf

,M¯¼J

L�-Ng�%1^

。î�X�

,,lL�J

��dg�Xl,lL�JjL

。K

“��

”�

�K�J,Æ¿Dd§�

、�Ï

、ïä

、_\

、@

\*f

、Ñ1

、!H

、=,t1

、=,k6

、=,

�1

、óôO\à

。©Æefööb�ô��

«ú¥>J

KGAUCH[25]

«�

,cù6��MiEV

ah�««

(O*1),,«XK1L�w¡G

È�JefÀ/J¸K>J��

,D¦kef

À/K>��

;l,«XK1L�w�#GÓ

o]Jef��J¸K>J��

,D¦kef

��K>��

?1 vwxy)$%%X)]z:t

 

efÀ/K>���Ó�;1L�w¡

GMJ56[ûEM��1L�wºG5dJ

*f

,ØöX>²¨EL

、Ñ/LÔvÌLvâ

J*f

。�Y

,w���J��

[13]Z6��h

òÐ\

:①j°®Ìg-1L

,w���¡M�

Î,l01ef��º

,iXMQh-§�,

l>²V��JYf

;01ef¡[T��X

<YJA0i-�J

,��¢£þ�²ef�

;②ef�EÔ<EJa-X�g�J

;③0

1efÔ0²M[û5dJ��7]V��±

ª

、þÿJ6OdE¦­

。§B ALVESSON

à

[19]JY\

,efÀ/K>��jÌ�ÀÏ[

GtU

,ghNÄak1L6½��

(inhouse

assumptions)、7¨,k��

(rootmetaphor

assumptions)、À / � �

(paradigm assump

tions)、q/8$��

(ideologyassumptions)、

´Û��

(fieldassumptions)。

ef��K>���Ó�;1L�w¡¨

çG5dJd>ef��J*f

。Mij�>

²1L�wJÎ�àk

[14,30,45~48]¦y

,/á©Æ

deJ1L�w¡Ò·43lÓ,

:�f

、>?

ÔêPïi

。K©3lÓ,K±U

,REYN

OLDS[45]

HI�3«��Ja«vÌ

,�ef

��K>��ak

:���

(definitional

statements)、> ? Í � �

(relationalstate

ments)ÔÊMÍ��

(existencestatements)。

Ï�Í��г��wJ1LXk��¥

K a34áÖ

[47]40~41,�zg«akqÖJ�

fÔ��²ÐÙ�cÎ\¯BJ¸C

。�fA

efX561LJ,l;ÓÏh a

。dJ6

¡��fÔefk�ñq�VJ>a

,îd³

Â6¡±½¡�k>a

,̈efÈ_y¡J�

Ì

,]Dk�f

。56�fJaÇXØ·!;

��J

。,l!;g�dÂñ��

,�,lb

Wk¯lÏ,ñ��

,©lbW�XÏ�Í�

[49]533。UVÐI

,cù��k,l1L-G

dJ!;ÒÅI³5JÏ�

[50]137。d6¯J!

;1��ÅI³5Ï�

,»56[ûEhb±

¯���ãh,úqO

,©¤J!;uã_!

;

。ã_!;�²Ï�¯¼J!;

,¾ÙI!

;

[50]183。� f � ² - m , « j ¥ J � l æ

Í

[48]。�ûJ�fØöHd�ûJqÖ)�

qÖJ�fþ�²HEJº­Ôö­

,HEJ

�fNK,ÏJº­Ôö­KÓ?

[45]49。Y3

,l�f��Ml,l�fJ��-

,Ny¡

9kqÖ

。ghn«lA«lhViJ�fu

�¸C

[9]16。¸CXh,Ï"�¸(T�;�

fJÐ}

。Øö�fX�g#$YZJ

[7],̧

CNXg#$YZJ

[51]168。

ÊMÍ��

,îDkêPïi��

,г�

>?Í��U�J7UAÀÏ

。Y3,l1L

%U�M�JÊMÍ��¦á

,�öö4d�

ûJ-á

[52]72。Z6ghØ·3lë,TÏ�

,l1LJÊMÍ��

:ö­

、º­Ô0i

Y

[7]。ÊMÍ��K¸² WHETTEN

[14]HI

J,l1LJ

“When/Where/Who”+,

。Y

ûTURNER[53]17

#WJĤ

,“i4d,?g

JÊMÍ��г�1L-J±�ÔefJU

·11·

L�1Là�òJ011L�wef

———<=> ?@' �ÇA à

Page 6: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

�7U

”。B»¥(³,l1LJÊMÍ��

Xñ9C1LJ,lW\

[48]。

>?Í��N�h�1L�ú+J a

�г«ñA«ñhV34áÖXYZKÒk

�J

。>?Í��zg«akÑ1Í��Ô±

U��

。Ñ1Í��X-W�f¦­7¨>?

J±�

[54]。“Ñ1Í

”�ÓEáM1L-,l±

�%no�®ª��¯§BJâf

,�m�q

´äV±�.x^5

,î�q´ä1L-JG

d±�ÓhÑ1(?]J8/Wá

。Ñ1Í�

���[1L-¯¼º©ÙI

,��TÙI1

L±�

,K¸² WHETTENHIJ,l1L

J

“Why”+,

。,l1LJÑ1Í���hJ

cÙXM1L-��óôï1JO\

[55]。Ñ1

Í��cJ�ÓðÞXMóôJÐéòÙI1

L±�A¡p"Î\±�

[47,56],îööH°æ

1VJ�¥

>²±U��

,�û6¡ÅI��ûJ¿

m

。CARNAP D ¦ k ± U Ë N

[57];BRIDG

MAND¦k3kÍÏ�

[58];CAMPBELLNu

�2�

[59];HEMPELD¯kG$t1

[60]169;�

�¨tj�v)Æ¿JºUòîuäCÆ¿

©ÆuÌJ��1�ÓKû

,»Uq,ú

,̈'

-cùÒDk±U��

[61]147。±U��

[15,62]°

NVX,ñq:Í��

[63]103,��TÓjqÖ

J�fÔ��²�cÎ\¯BJ¸C

,K1L

±�,OÙIp"Î\±�

。�Y

,Xkãq

[13]X,lqÖJ�f

,®ÌØ·çJÜU#

$r_

,»XghØ·­$JÐ}TEáXk

ãq�

,YXk9C

、-sý

、tuýà

。±U

��©,ef[,^_��òv×ßë

,»X

M56J/W·)-

,562Ôk62Ò�Ñ

©ñ��ÊMJq�

,mÎöAL�ùJÍ

9

[61]174。±U��(y,w䩤Jóô

:#

$gYZJj¥��ÅçhÑ/Lq�VJx

£Ü

,¾ðOk°

,ô�g#$YZJj¥íí

�¹h&çyd©ñx£Ü

。�h1LJÑ1

Í��Ô1L±�ÒXÝqÖJ�fKóô!

;

,M©ÌËN^zò8hJº©

,X�g#$

YZJ

。Y3ghMqÖJ�fKgYZJ¸

C¦­w�gVJÓj

,Ä£©ñÝgYZÍ

noJÑ/Lq�VJx£Ü�gh\{ÅÑ

1Í��Ô1L±�

,�ô\{Å5l1L

[64]。

§BBORSBOOM[65],

³5¥ÐI±U��

,�

XÓ(³�gYZJ�fJ¸#XYZéOg

YZJ¸CJ¸#J

。»X

,M01ef-©

¤³5JbWÛXr¹6O

3.2.2 #$%&

ADELÆ¿J=½l+,XÙI±�

。,

l1 L - Ø ö d « « Ù I ± �

,1 L ± �

(propositions)Ôp"Î\±�

(hypotheses,î

u��

),�ùØöX>?Í��

、Ï�Í��

Ôóô[ûk�Jj3

。�Ñ/-Ê>?Í�

、Ï�Í��

、óôÔÙI±�J>?Øö-

áYò

:Ï�Í��+Ñ1Í��+óô=1

L±�

;Ï�Í��+Ñ1Í��+±U��

+óô=p"Î\±�

;Ï�Í��+1L±

�+±U��+óô=p"Î\±�

3.2.3 '(

ADELÆ¿-J=3l+,X�B

。�B

X>²j°JbW

,�ÎöX�cJ¯BAL

�XJ¯B

。¯BX56ef·)-JYZó

|

。�BØöªÓ§B},5JjLJÓÆ

±¯B��aÇÔ~Ù

,&¯B8h,ÏJj

[66]。�B�X561L

[67],»X�BX56

1LJ.ÓÏh a

。hí±561LÏhÓ

,JLWC6��BgÀ¯-

,ô¨efN³

5���BX561LJÏhÓ,

。,vâ

[L�1LJ��A

,�BXL�J,lú+

Ó,

,561LX,ÏÒKÓ?JL�

,ë?�

B1¸X561LJÏhÓ,

。lá

,,ß6

¡

,Y PICKETT à

[68],LEAVITT à

[69]Ô

BOXENBAUMà

[70],³5-Ê�BX1LJ

Ïh a

,SHOEMAKERà

[9]641[³©�B

X1LJ.ÓÏh a

,»X·4�BJ¿á

v/X1L�gAtJ+,

,�BK1LJ>

?�öæJ

[71]。

3.2.4 )*

ADELÆ¿-J�y,l+,Xóô

。ó

ôXÐÙ1J

、7²º©Jr�Æ/Ôï1v

Ì

,ML�-

,��kk!HJ��Ô�BÙ1

¥ÓjM,O

,)IjL

[25]128。�Y

,kkÏÍ

5�óôJ��RSÆ¿JÎ����Yò

“YZ�BE5��� H,̧ õ_¸

,①Ek�

x�

;②H├ E”。óôX,ñXH

,��±�

óô

、,�Õ!óô

、ñ�óô

、Æ$óô

、Âi

óô

、Æ×óôàà

。MªÓJº»

,gh,.

DJóôkkXH

。óôöökkL�}¬I

áML�ë0·)-

。56L�}¬=²�ò

R(¸-

,ë?dº4ÊMÂlL�}¬

[72]。

�Y

,KETOKIVIà

[29]ef�Ýp��£Íé

OJ011L�w�U

:Y3«l1LMóô

VÒÔÎ\�B���

,YZ°t¯-,l1

L

?¼ùHI�1å(Ô7U(«ñï1�S

·21·

016B=13>=1?2016@1A

Page 7: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

�²�Ωl��

。SANDBERGà

[73]Ñk0

1°��Ö°�1ÍJóô./

,̧!J01

1LÒXM561ÍJóô./ò�wJ

,G

h��³�¥ÐÙ01°�

,mHI�M°�

1Íóô./ò�w1LJ��

hVALJADELƿJ��gh�*2

GÊJ�åJ�nT-Ê

。éq*2-JÙI

±�g�d«ñ

:1L±�A¡p"Î\±�

¸±�JbW8/k

:X′Ùú Y′/0

,Ä£V

±�ÎöX1L±�

;̧±�JbW8/k

:X′

KY′d^K>>?

,Ä£V±�ÎöXp"Î

\±�

?2  ADELlm{q

 

3.2.5 ADEL+,-./0

*3X,l�åJ°�

。ªÓéqJX

*3GÊJ__X,lÆ¿

,X,l¢51L

(D¦kT1L

)J, a

。*3h*8Jv/

WÊ�«l1L±�

:①,lbXJÏÐ��

KVbXJÏÐÑ��kHd^K>>?

;②

,lbXJÏÐ��KVbXJ�0Ôê�k

Hd�K>>?

。cù6��T�³YZ&�

ADELÆ¿aÇ,l011L

?3 T%X)+olm

 

(1)EFT#$G'HIJ%& *3-

Z6�¬3lÏ�Í��

(�f

):ÏÐ��

、Ï

ÐÑ��kÔ�0Ôê�k

。ݲ@�Gä

hòJAL__ÏÐÏÐ��KÏÐÑ��k

W^

。ÏÐ��%Ï�k

“bX±ÏÐJ,ñ

$�ÔÊÏÍJ�+�X

,XbX±ÏÐMÜ

7VJN�ÔÇKtÏÐJK±)�

”。ÏÐ

��k%�k

“bXI²±ÏÐJÀ�

、±

ÏÐJ�ðÔ�M1`JÓÆô{/-áJf

¼�k

”。�� T1L-¬d©«lÏ�

,Ä

£T1L-J

“bX

”、“ÏÐ

”、“$�

”、“ÊÏ

Í

”、“�+�X

”、“Ü7V

”、“N�

”、“ÇK

”、

“K±)�

”、“À�

”、“�ð

”、“�M1`

”、“Ó

Æ

”、“{/-á

”Ô

“f¼�k

”ÒXã_!;

�ù�TÏ�ÙI!;

,¾ÏÐ��ÔÏÐ

��k

(2)EFT#$G'K#J%& Ñ1Í

��öö�²ÙI1L±�

,©ª¬aÇK1

L±�①K>JÑ1Í��

。�Y T1LJ

Ñ1Í����

:①ÏÐ���;JXbX±

ÏÐJÍC$�

;②Y3,lç±�,j¥5

dÍCJ$�

,N©lç4±Vj¥�IÍC

J�k

;③ÏÐÑ��kXbX±ÏÐ�IJ

ÍC�k

。Ä£

,§BÑ1Í��①、②Ô③,

cù��ïÙI1L±�①:,lbXJÏÐ

��KVbXJÏÐÑ��kHd^K>>

?

(3)EFT#$G'!L%& �Y1L

±�①o[%¹�JÎ\ef5�

,Ä£ªÓ

�cÎ\¯BT±�5�A¡É�

(dõ�È

û56k6-J�âaÎÏͱ�

)。»X

,Ï

Ð��KÏÐÑ��kÒXqÖJ�f

,®Ì

#$�cÎ\¯B

。�Y��Ø·�,lbX

hò«l��

,��¢£r)VbXJÏÐ�

�*Ã

:��①�4�.�GMÏÐJJ�Ô

,�ûq�

?��②�()�GMJÏÐ

X��JXkdG

,�ûq�

?(©«l��Ò

h5\X�WC-o]

:5�öûq

,1³�û

q

),Ä£

,cù�M

“ÏÐ��

”©l�fÔ�

�①、��②©«l¸C¦­w��,ñ±U

��

。����①、��②©«l¸CM�;

“ÏÐ��

”©l�fº

,ã¹K�>?

,Ä£

©ªJ±U��

,D¯k±U��①,�gh³

5-ãk

:gh&�,lbXM��①、��②

©«l¸CVJiJ�iT�/VbXJÏÐ

��)�

。Y3j�BORSBOOM

[65]Jwß

©ªJ±U��Ûgh-ãk

:̧,lbXJ

ÏÐ��)��ñJº»

,VbXM��①©

l¸CVJi4�U

,M��②©l¸CVJ

iî4�U

(��

“5�öûq

,1³�ûq

”X

N�GJ5li

)。

û1

,�YghØ·�bXhòJ��

,T

r_VbXJÏÐÑ��k)�

:��③�Î

·31·

L�1Là�òJ011L�wef

———<=> ?@' �ÇA à

Page 8: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

öHIdw�ÍJwß

,�ûq�

?��④�

ÎöN.ÏÐJ�Ô

,�ûq�

?��⑤�Î

ö�:ÏÐJDbX

,�ûq�

?(©3l��

Òh5\X�WC-o]

:5�öûq

,1³�

ûq

)。Ä£

,±U��②�gh³5-ãk

gh&�,lbXM��③、��④Ô��⑤

©3l¸CVJiJ�iT�/VbXJÏÐ

��k)�

(4)EFT#$G'MNOP §B!3

®JaÇ

,T1LJÙI±�Z6��

,1L±

�①,lbXJÏÐ��KVbXJÏÐÑ�

�kHd^K>>?

,p"Î\±�①,lb

XJÏÐ��KVbXJÏÐÑ��kHd^

K>>?

。éq

,1L±�①Ôp"Î\±�

①X�¢£KûJº©��-ãJ

,»X

,½¡

J°N��X�,¤J

(O*4)。

Ñ1Í��①   1L±�①

Ñ1Í��②   ±U��①

Ñ1Í��③   ±U��②

∴ 1L±�①  ∴p"Î\±�①

?4 %X|kh}~/�|k)��

  Y*4GÊ

,1L±�①XÝ3lÑ1Í

��ïÙITJ

;ôp"Î\±�①X1L±

�①�V«l±U��ïÙITJ

。½¡J�

û¦=M²

,1L±�①-J«l!;

(ÏÐ�

、ÏÐÑ��k

)ÒX�f

,ôp"Î\±�

①-J©«l!;¨9VX¸C

。kk¸CJ

“ÏÐ��

”JiX��①、��②©«l¸

CJiJ�i

;kk¸CJ

“ÏÐÑ��k

”X

��③、��④Ô��⑤©3l¸CJiJ�

i

(5)EFT#$G'QRJ%& �ÓX

aÇT1LJÌ�ÀÏA¡Ì�7U

。©l

<JghØ·B»¥PÏÏ�Í��T��

�Y

,³5ÐIT1L-JÏÐÑ��k__

X��á�k

,�XXk�³¾-³5ËÏJ

bX.1��Js��k

。©l<JÛghØ

·B»¥PϺ­

、ö­

、0iYàv/ãt

rY

,³5ÐIT1L__Ì�²uv.2à

à

(6)EFT#$'>? Ø·�>46r

)J

,M=

(3)、(4)®aÇ-kk¸CJ��

①、��②、��③、��④、��⑤、ÏÐ��

ÔÏÐÑ��kJi

,h¬±©Æ¸C��¯

BaÇ=1yG)tJ

、h,Ïj�¿áJj

3�X�B

。�Y

,Ø·C¿JK>aÇ

,)t

ÏÐ��

(kk¸C

)KÏÐÑ��k

(kk¸

C

)¿á^K>>?

(7)EFT#$G'01 T1L-�¬

tJóôd

:MÙI1L±�Ôp"Î\±�

º�tJ,�Õ!óô

;M��¯BaÇ¿á

�Bº�tJ¯1óô

;Mñò1L±�K�

B>?º�tJ5�óô

(8)EFT#$STU'VWXYZ[%

& �YT1LXMóôÎ\��JÀ/ò

�wJ

,Ä£1L�w¡�Ó5d,ñ©ÌY

A¡ÑÑY\

[63]T5àT1LJ°9

。ô¸

!56k6P±561LJº�YAL)9k

À�

ªÓ�³JX

,>²hV8l aJaÇ

�ùJÄ£�XlÏJ

,ghØADELÆ¿&

�çbJRSôÏ

3.3 ����$%%X]^

Óo]YZ��011L�wJ��

,!

@Ó±

“1L�w

”J���k�³

。,l�J

1Lm��¶�w

,�ííXηÒÂ6¡J

råþ��ò¹�ô8hJ

。ë?

,#$Jk

k·)J1LYr�$Jkkj3J1LY9

�Ù°N

。Ý?

,1L�w%Ï�kÔ0

、"\

Ô¹�1LJ·)

[74],î�X�Id1LvÉ

JefJ·)

。�I,Äd1LvÉJef

�gD¦k,Ä1L�w

。Ä£

,YZ��0

11L�wJ���¾¸kYZ�Id1Lv

ÉJ01ef

k�o]YZ�Id1LvÉJ01ef

©,��

,cùÈ� WHETTEN

[14]Ô MA

CINNIS[75]

Jrð

:!@�011LahÅ8ó

ôVK±þ�JÓ,

,xy±~lÓ,��¹

。ADELÆ¿gh�:cù¢h=,®

,�

011LJ~lÓ,WáIT

,$òTJ=½

®� X È û Y Z ± © Æ Ó , � � ¹ �

LOCKEà

[76]Ô GOLDENBIDDLEà

[77]HI

JefvÉ1LÐI

,ghØ·±!çJef

�ÀvâJßñTJ³efvÉ

。①ghJD

!çJef�¢5

,ªÓM�Æv⺻ef

②ghJD!çJef�âa

,��l;

ÓJefà�

,ªÓ[©lefà���ef

③ghJD!çJefM�ñ)�V�^5

ªÓ�DJefà��/iJefà�A#$

�^!çJTE

。-2HI�011L�we

f./

,ghØ·JDád011LJ��

、Ù

I±�

、�BAóôX�¢5J

、�âaJA�

^5JT��1L�w

·41·

016B=13>=1?2016@1A

Page 9: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

n2 $%%X]^����

��

efÀ/

K>��

Ï�Í

��

ÊMÍ

��

Ñ1Í

��

±U

��

ÙI

±�

�B óô

�¢5

�âa

�^5

4 QM

¨efW*k011L�w�#H°,û

B»ô¢5¥-ãY\JþÿXH

(ADELÆ

¿

),<JXk�011L�w¡KÒ1�

、K

ÒßñÔ[ûh'

。kefçb

、5�ç

、?�

!ôà=/Xk¡Më01L�w�#ºH°

ÇÈ

。�Y

,ÅÏ,l1L�wef

,gh�

ADELÆ¿Të0¯XÉd,wJ��Êd-

ãIT

。zY

,§B¨efHIJ011L�

wef./

,efçbgh¹k�¶¥JD¯

MKÆ¥v�I�efvÉ

Y3-.J016åÓ

“�gÜ�K�X

JÍb

”,!@Ó�`{|Jßñ�êKq7

ôB»K¢5¥-ãY\X�`ßñ�ê�;

ÓJ��

。^Y HUNT

[78]4G©

,“B»ô¢5

JaÇ���U(JçÐIcùTEJæý

¸,lk¡JaÇX�¢5JÔÆ×Jº»

â±JçÐIJTE

,¼Îöh

‘�E��cJ

qr

’̂_k{|-.

”。B»ô¢5¥-ãY

\X6OPJ.N��

,H�B»ô¢5¥

-ãY\K¸òc.016PÀßJ011L

�w¨¢(

、011Lk6ŧ

、Í�ef

、�

�6O�ðàXKqKhJ

。�Y

,�0-.

016¡U�

“-.011L

”(M-.017

U"\uv1L

),ÛX�

“01J-.1L

( ±-.áÖÔ��HI{|J1L

),ÒÓ

B»ô¢5¥WáIG�wJ1L

ªÓÐIJX

,1x ADELÆ¿±011

LJ�hÓ,k�¹«J¡a

,©m�q´ä

uÄ1L�wÒÓ�GdJÓ,]]WÊI

T

,ĤJª�¼)��%�

。ADELÆ¿J

�qM²Ã&efçb±{|JåÌ�,l?

]JT1

、ßñ

,/áÄÆ{|�¶Z(J

,»

zJ5&��J>S��

,Ó�Ueê&¯-

ãB»ô¢5

5 RM(BC

¨ef[L�1LJà�

,¾>��L�

1L-

“L�

”JÏ�Ô,l¢£W^J56L

�Jj�ƿ

(PELÆ¿

),;Da�011

LJW\

,MPELÆ¿J7]V�w�011

LJADELÆ¿

,mHI�011L�wJe

f./

。¨efk-.016YZ

“$äÏ

”J

±ª-�¢�YZ9B»ô¢5¥��1L-

ãJª�

¨efX[�$JvâTaÇ011L

J

。î�X�

,ÅÏ,l011L

,̈ef&�

ADELÆ¿aÇV1LJ��

、ÙI±�

、�B

Ôóô

。»X

,©Æ��

、ÙI±�

、�BÔó

ôXYZw�OTJ

,©¸-�¬t¤£¤J

ï1·)

,dÊd,ÏJËÌ

,©X[#$Jv

âTef011L�wG�¬tJ�Ó��

Xò,®JefvX

� � D E

[1]��..“�/<±�

”K

“ çÙ,

”:016ef-J

yá�±²

[J].016B

,2013,10(7):937~948

[2]X£.-.\]k6K¨¢01ef

:ALK�r

[J].016B

,2013,10(10):1425~1433

[3]¤OL.¨¢01efJk67]rÈ

———±X¦

X£J,ÆY\JAL

[J].016B

,2015,12(5):

657~663

[4]��ÿ.56+�Ô±34��J6O

[J].01Á

P

,2015(1):156~163

[5]8¥³

,�¦

,?§à.016efJ1ÍopÔw|

��

———016M-.Jk¨Ká°

[J].016B

2014,11(7):937~943

[6] ¡ .341LJ¨¢(w�

[M].ý©

:ý©U6

I�3

,2006

[7]BACHARACHSB.OrganizationalTheories:Some

CriteriaforEvaluation[J].AcademyofManagement

Review,1989,14(4):496~515

[8]WHETTENDA.AnExaminationoftheInterface

betweenContextandTheoryAppliedtotheStudyof

ChineseOrganizations[J].ManagementandOrganiza

tionReview,2009,5(1):29~55

[9]SHOEMAKERPJ,TANKARDJW,LASORSA D

L.HowtoBuildSocialScienceTheories[M].SAGE

Publications,2004

[10]NKWAKEAM.WhatAreAssumptions?[M]//

WorkingwithAssumptionsinInternationalDevelop

ment Program Evaluation.New York:Springer,

2013:81~91

[11]¨�W^ëLb.W�016

———016M-.�

ß

[J].016B

,2007,4(5):549~555

[12]ªê'.L016JËÌͬ¯�w

[J].016B

2009,6(2):285~290

[13]Ôù

,b«.016ef-J����

:vÌLà�

òJÈZ

[J].016B

,2009,6(11):1430~1436

[14]WHETTENDA.WhatConstitutesa Theoretical

·51·

L�1Là�òJ011L�wef

———<=> ?@' �ÇA à

Page 10: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

Contribution[J].AcademyofManagementReview,

1989,14(4):490~495

[15]BAGOZZIRP.MeasurementandMeaninginInfor

mationSystemsandOrganizationalResearch:Meth

odologicalandPhilosophicalFoundations[J].MIS

Quarterly,2011,35(2):261~292

[16]DAVISMS.That’sInteresting[J].Philosophyof

theSocialSciences,1971,1(2):309

[17]ROYS.Editor’sComments:ConstructClarityin

TheoriesofManagementandOrganization[J].Acad

emyofManagementReview,2010,35(3):346~357

[18]YANIVE.ConstructClarityinTheoriesofManage

mentandOrganization[J].AcademyofManagement

Review,2011,36(3):590~592

[19]ALVESSONM,SANDBERG J.Constructing Re

searchQuestions:DoingInterestingResearch[M].

California:SAGEPublications,2013

[20]ALVESSONM,SANDBERGJ.GeneratingResearch

QuestionsthroughProblematization[J].Academyof

ManagementReview,2011,36(2):247~271

[21]HUBERGP,LEWISK.CrossUnderstandingand

SharedSocialTheories[J].AcademyofManagement

Review,2011,36(2):422~424

[22]DELBRIDGER,FISS P C.Editors’Comments:

StylesofTheorizingandtheSocialOrganizationof

Knowledge[J].AcademyofManagementReview,

2013,38(3):325~331

[23]OKHUYSENG,BONARDIJP.TheChallengesof

BuildingTheorybyCombiningLenses[J].Academy

ofManagementReview,2011,36(1):6~11

[24]MAYERKJ,SPARROWERT.IntegratingTheo

riesinAMJArticles[J].AcademyofManagement

Journal,2013,56(4):917~922

[25]GAUCHHG.Scientific MethodinPractice[M].

Cambridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2003

[26]MCKINLEYW.Organizational Theory Develop

ment:Displacementof Ends?[J].Organization

Studies,2010,31(1):47~68

[27]LOCKEEA.TheCaseforInductiveTheoryBuild

ing[J].JournalofManagement,2007,33(6):867~

890

[28]ALVESSONM,KRREMAND.ConstructingMys

tery:EmpiricalMattersinTheoryDevelopment[J].

Academyof ManagementReview,2007,32(4):

1265~1281

[29]KETOKIVIM,MANTERES.TwoStrategiesfor

InductiveReasoninginOrganizationalResearch[J].

Academyof ManagementReview,2010,35(2):

315~333

[30]VANDEVENAH.EngagedScholarship:AGuide

forOrganizationalandSocialResearch:AGuidefor

OrganizationalandSocialResearch[M].Oxford:Ox

fordUniversityPress,2007

[31]HARTC.DoingaLiteratureReview:Releasingthe

SocialScienceResearchImagination[M].California:

SagePubications,1998

[32]¬­.L�

,L-

,&L

———¸�L�1LàÛ-L

�efJ);���®

[J].{x-�Ìef

,2007,

23(4):26~30

[33]¬­.¸�uvL�1LeY

[J].k6#$

,2012

(8):102~108

[34]¬­.kk)£KæÍJL-O

———Ǹ�L�1

L-

“L-O

”à�J¯°�®

[J].óô6ef

2010,3(4):85~97

[35]MARKOVSKYB.GraduateTraininginSociological

Theoryand TheoryConstruction[J].Sociological

Perspectives,2008,51(2):423~445

[36]BROMMER,GOLDMAN S R.The Public’s

BoundedUnderstandingofScience[J].EducPsy

chol,2014,49(2):59~69

[37]TOMASZZ.Toulmin’sModelofArgumentandthe

‘Logic’ofScientificDiscovery[J].StudiesinLogic,

GrammarandRhetoric,2009,16(29):267~283

[38]OSBORNEJ.ArguingtoLearninScience:TheRole

ofCollaborative,CriticalDiscourse[J].Science,

2010,328(5977):463~466

[39]BOOTH WC,COLOMB G G,WILLIAMSJ M.

TheCraftofResearch[M].Chicago:TheUniversity

ofChicagoPress,2008

[40]TOULMINSE.TheUsesofArgument[M].Cam

bridge:CambridgeUniversityPress,2003

[41]XY�.56J8ôV67]

:56§�

[J].6O

P

,2008(2):15~34

[42]POPPERK.ConjecturesandRefutations[M].Lon

don:RoutledgeandKeganPaul,1963

[43]GADAMERHG.Truthand Method[M].New

York:ContinuumPublishingGroup,2004

[44]SMITHKG,HITT M A.GreatMindsinManage

ment:TheProcessofTheoryDevelopment[M].Ox

ford:OxfordUniversityPress,2005

[45]REYNOLDSPD.APrimerinTheoryConstruction

[M].New York:MacMillanPublishingCompany,

1971

[46]DUBINR.TheoryBuilding[M].FreePress,1978

[47]PAWARBS.TheoryBuildingforHypothesisSpec

ificationinOrganizationalStudies[M].California:

SAGEPublications,2009

[48]WEBERR.EvaluatingandDevelopingTheoriesinthe

InformationSystemsDiscipline[J].JournaloftheAsso

ciationforInformationSystems,2012,13(1):1~30

[49]ZETTERBERGHL.OnAxiomaticTheoriesinSo

ciology[M]//LazarsfeldPF,Rosenberg M.The

·61·

016B=13>=1?2016@1A

Page 11: X]^’( · j–– ° ‚ 。 † 。 。

LanguageofSocialResearch:AReaderintheMeth

odologyofSocialResearch.New York:TheFree

Press,1957:533~540

[50]COHENBP.DevelopingSociologicalKnowledge:

TheoryandMethod[M].Chicago:NelsonHall,1989

[51]LUNDBERGCC,YOUNG C A.Foundationsfor

Inquiry:ChoicesandTradeOffsintheOrganiza

tionalSciences[M].California:StanfordUniversity

Press,2005

[52]b±²

,��ÿ

,³)�.ÏÐK01efJ°�v

Ì

[M].ý©

:ý©U6I�3

,2012

[53]TURNERJH.TheNatureofSociologicalTheory

[M]//ContemporarySociologicalTheory.Califor

nia:SagePublications,2013:1~32

[54]XY�.56Ñ1

:7¨efÔ7¨��

[J].ù´3

456

,2007(5):19~26

[55]KANAZAWAS.InDefenseofUnrealisticAssump

tions[J].SociologicalTheory,1998,16(2):193~204

[56]JASSOG.PrinciplesofTheoreticalAnalysis[J].So

ciologicalTheory,1988,6(1):1~20

[57]CARNAPR.TheMethodologicalCharacterofThe

oreticalConcepts[M]//HerbertF,MichaelS.The

FoundationsofScienceandtheConceptsofPsychol

ogyandPsychoanalysis.Minneapolis:Universityof

MinnesotaPress,1956:38~76

[58]BRIDGMANPW.SomeGeneralPrinciplesofOper

ationalAnalysis[J].PsychologicalReview,1945,52

(5):246~249

[59]BUCHDAHLG.TheoryConstruction:The Work

ofNormanRobertCampbell[J].Isis,1964,55(2):

151~162

[60]ÉÏ�.56k6

:h��kÙXJ56vÌLÙL

[M].çµ

:-�U6I�3

,2009

[61]?U¶.56k6

[M].ý©

:-.ç�U6I�3

2011

[62]GRAYPH,COOPER W H.PursuingFailure[J].

OrganizationalResearch Methods,2010,13(4):

620~643

[63]SUPPEF.TheStructureofScientificTheories[M].

Illinois:UniversityofIllinoisPress,1979

[64]SUPPEF.Theories,TheirFormulations,andthe

OperationalImperative[J].Synthese,1972,25(1/2):

129~164

[65]BORSBOOMD,MELLENBERGH G J,VAN

HEERDENJ.TheConceptofValidity[J].Psycho

logicalReview,2004,111(4):1061

[66]CAVAGNETTOA,HAND B.TheImportanceof

Embedding Argument within Science Classrooms

[M]//KhineMS.PerspectivesonScientificArgu

mentation.NewYork:Springer,2012:39~53

[67]SUTTONRI,STAW B M.WhatTheoryIsNot

[J].AdministrativeScienceQuarterly,1995,40(3):

371~384

[68]PICKETTSTA,KOLASAJ.StructureofTheory

inVegetationScience[J].PlantEcology,1989,83

(1):7~15

[69]LEAVITTK,MITCHELL T R,PETERSON J.

TheoryPruning:StrategiestoReduceOurDense

TheoreticalLandscape[J].OrganizationalResearch

Methods,2010,13(4):644~667

[70]BOXENBAUME,ROULEAU L.New Knowledge

ProductsasBricolage:MetaphorsandScriptsinOr

ganizationalTheory[J].Academyof Management

Review,2011,36(2):272~296

[71]WEICKKE.WhatTheoryIsNot,TheorizingIs

[J].AdministrativeScienceQuarterly,1995,40(3):

385~390

[72]YASKEVICHY.TheDynamicsofArgumentation

StandardsinScience[J].StudiesinLogic,Grammar

andRhetoric,2008,13(26):85~98

[73]SANDBERGJ,TSOUKASH.GraspingtheLogicof

Practice:TheorizingthroughPracticalRationality

[J].AcademyofManagementReview,2011,36(2):

338~360

[74]GIOIADA,PITREE.MultiparadigmPerspectives

onTheoryBuilding[J].AcademyofManagement

Review,1990,15(4):584~602

[75]MACINNISDJ.AFrameworkforConceptualCon

tributionsin Marketing[J].JournalofMarketing,

2011,75(4):136~154

[76]LOCKEK,GOLDENBIDDLEK.ConstructingOp

portunitiesforContribution:StructuringIntertextu

alCoherenceand“Problematizing”inOrganizational

Studies[J].AcademyofManagementJournal,1997,

40(5):1023~1062

[77]GOLDENBIDDLEK,LOCKEK.ComposingQuali

tativeResearch[M].California:SagePublications,

2007

[78]HUNTSD.MarketingTheory:ThePhilosophyof

MarketingScience[M].Illinois:RichardD.Irwin,

INC.,1983

(!T ���

���"

:\]^

(1982~),·,�uEHç

。uxþØ

U6

(ux� 710049)016$�

,̧¹

。efvX

k0161L

,Ën#Þ

。Email:liuyuewen@mail.xjtu.

edu.cn

·71·

L�1Là�òJ011L�wef

———<=> ?@' �ÇA à