www.che-ranking.de the che research ranking of german universities sonja berghoff international...
Post on 18-Dec-2015
215 views
TRANSCRIPT
www.che-ranking.de
The CHE Research Ranking of German Universities
Sonja Berghoff
International Colloquium “Ranking and Research Assessment in Higher Education”
12 & 13 December 2007, Bruxelles
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 2
CHE ranking data
target groups:prospective students
target groups:HE sector
CHE-UniversityRanking CHE-ResearchRanking
Indicators on: teaching resources research
Detailed analysis of data/ indicators on research
CHE rankings
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 3
ResearchRanking: Top group in physics
absolute relative
University
Number of top group placements
(max. 7)
Comparison to 2003 Third
party funding
Publi-cations Phd's
Third party
funding
Publi-cations Citations Phd's
Repu-tation
RWTH Aachen 4 Uni Bochum 5 Uni Bremen 4 TU Dresden 4 Uni Göttingen 4 Uni Hamburg 5 Uni Heidelberg 6 Uni Karlsruhe 6 Uni Mainz 4 LMU München 6 TU München 5 Uni Stuttgart 4 Uni Würzburg 5
out of top group compared to 2003: FU Berlin 1 HU Berlin 3 TU Berlin 3 Uni Bonn 2 Uni Freiburg 1
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 4
CHE-UniversityRanking
Researchindicators
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 5
departments
professors
patent analysis /universities
bibliometric analysis
third party funding, number of Ph.D.‘s
number of students, professors
reputation
publications
citations
patents /inventions
Methods – sources of data
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 6
Quality assurance
Comparison to other data sources (e.g. German research council)
Data checks, control for outliers
Detailed categories for funding sources
Control by representatives of the ranked subjects
feedback loop of the controlled and commented questionnaires with departments and universitiesbefore publication, additionally a lot of one-on-one discussions
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 7
Third party funding physics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 7
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 8
Uni J enaT U München
Uni HeidelbergUni Hamburg
LMU MünchenT U Kaiserslautern
Uni MainzUni Karlsruhe
Uni BremenUni WürzburgUni Bochum
Uni KölnRWT H AachenUni Göttingen
Uni E rlangen-NürnberUni KonstanzUni S tuttgartT U Dresden
Uni OldenburgUni Duisburg-E ssen
FU Berl inUni Münster
Uni BonnUni Augsburg
Uni Frankfurt a.M.Uni HannoverUni T übingen
Uni LeipzigHU Berl in
Uni FreiburgT U Berl in
Uni P otsdamT U Darmstadt
Uni GießenUni Bielefeld
Uni RegensburgUni Marburg
Uni UlmUni WuppertalUni Dortmund
Uni RostockUni BayreuthT U Chemnitz
Uni DüsseldorfUni S iegen
Uni S aarbrückenUni Hal le-Wittenberg
Uni OsnabrückUni K iel
T U Braunschw eigUni P aderborn
Uni Grei fsw aldUni Kassel
T U ClausthalBT U Cottbus
Uni MagdeburgT U IlmenauIU Bremen
Third party funding per year (in Mio €)
121086420
Others
Industry
EU, (fed.) state
German RC
Third party funding physics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 8
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 9
Third party funding medicine
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 9
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 10
Chari té Berl in
LMU München
MH Hannover
Uni Heidelberg
Uni T übingen
Uni Freiburg
Uni Würzburg
Uni E rlangen-Nürnber
Uni Köln
Uni Frankfurt a.M.
Uni Hamburg
T U München
Uni Mainz
Uni Düsseldorf
Uni Münster
Uni Göttingen
Uni Ulm
Uni Bonn
Uni Marburg
Uni Duisburg-E ssen
Uni Regensburg
Uni Leipzig
Uni K iel
Uni Bochum
RWT H Aachen
Uni J ena
Uni Magdeburg
Uni Gießen
T U Dresden
Uni S aarbrücken
Uni Hal le-Wittenberg
Uni Lübeck
Uni Rostock
Uni Grei fsw ald
Uni Witten-Herdecke
Third party funding per year (in Mio €)
100806040200
Others
Industry
EU, (fed.) state
German RC
Third party funding medicine
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 10
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 11
Others
German AES
Foundations
Industry
EU
State
Fed. state
German RC
Third party funding mathematics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 11
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 12
Third party funding mathematics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 12
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 13
Bibliometric analysis
international perception
activity
number of citations
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 14
National publications per year
140120100806040200
Inte
rnat
iona
l pub
likat
ions
per
yea
r
50
40
30
20
10
0
LMU Münc hen
HU Berlin
Uni Bonn
Uni Mannheim
Publications: Economics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 14
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 15
Bibliometric analysis
Not all publications but samples
based on data banks
professors and researchers with a Ph.D.
Adjustment
number of pages/authors
type of publication
core journals
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 16
Databases
Articles Monographs
wisonet web of science
Electrical engineering
INSPEC, web of science
English studies AREAS
HistoryHistorische Bibliographie AHF
Mathematics MathSciNet Pedagogy FIS Bildung
Psychologyweb of science, PSYINDEX
Sciences web of science
Business/ Economics
Adjustment length
Core journals
CitationsSubject DatabaseTypes
Adjustment number of authors
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 17
3,8%
11,2%
5,9%
34,5%
31,2%
13,5%
> 500
200 bis 499
50 bis 199
20 bis 49
10 bis 19
< 10
History – Historische Bibliographie
Authors:1 82 %
2 13 %
3 3 %
4 and 2 %more
Pages
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 18
9,2%
6,7%
16,8%
31,1%
36,1%
> 200
50 to 199
20 to 49
10 to 19
< 10
Education Science – FIS Bildung
Authors:1 59
%
2 25 %
3 11 %
4 and more 6 %
Pages
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 19
Third party funding per year (in Mio €)
100806040200
Pub
licat
ions
per
yea
r
2000
1000
0
LMU Münc hen
Uni Heidelberg
Charité Berlin
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 19
Third party funding and publications: Medicine
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 20
Third party funding per year (in Mio €)
50403020100
Pub
licat
ions
per
yea
r
800
600
400
200
0
Uni Würzburg
Uni Tübingen
Uni Heidelberg
MH Hannover
Uni Freiburg
Uni Frankfurt a.M.
Uni Erlangen-Nürnber
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 20
Third party funding and publications: Medicine
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 21
Third party funding per year (in 1.000 €)
3210
Pub
licat
ions
per
yea
r
30
20
10
0
Uni Boc hum
TU Dresden
LMU Münc hen
Uni J ena
Uni Freiburg
Uni Würzburg
Uni Trier
Uni Heidelberg
Uni Tübingen
HU Berlin
Uni Marburg
Uni Düsseldorf
Uni K onstanz
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 21
Third party funding and publications: Psychology
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 22
Third party funding per year (in 1.000 €)
200010000
Nat
iona
l pub
licat
ions
per
yea
r
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
Uni K onstanz
LMU Münc hen
Uni Münster
HU Berlin
Uni Frankfurt a.M.
Uni Bonn
Uni Mannheim
Uni Hamburg
Uni Freiburg
Uni K öln
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 22
Third party funding and publications: Economics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 23
Third party funding per year (in 1.000 €)
200010000
Inte
rnat
iona
l pub
likca
tions
per
yea
r
50
40
30
20
10
0
Uni K onstanz
LMU Münc hen
Uni Münster
HU Berlin
Uni Frankfurt a.M.
Uni Bonn
Uni Mannheim
Uni Freiburg
Uni K öln
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 23
Third party funding and publications: Economics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 24
data
relative (per-capita)
absoluteare counted twice:
third party funding
publications/citations
number of Ph.D.‘s
CHE-ResearchRanking
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 25
top groups
relative indicators
absolute indicators:
the top group consists of the best universities which cover in sum at least 50% of the quantity regarded
upper quartile
CHE-ResearchRanking
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 26
Grouping of absolute indicators
Uni HamburgUni Jena
TU MünchenUni Karlsruhe
Uni MainzLMU MünchenUni WürzburgUni Hannover
Uni HeidelbergUni Erlangen-Nürnb.
Uni KaiserslauternRWTH Aachen
Uni BremenUni Bochum
Uni BonnFU Berlin
Uni Frankfurt a.M.TU Berlin
Uni GöttingenTU Dresden
Uni KonstanzUni TübingenTU Darmstadt
HU BerlinUni FreiburgUni PotsdamUni Marburg
Uni GießenUni Leipzig
Uni OldenburgUni Münster
Uni UlmUni Stuttgart
Uni WuppertalTU Braunschweig
Uni SiegenUni Bielefeld
Uni RegensburgUni Essen
Uni BayreuthUni DortmundTU ChemnitzUni Rostock
Uni Halle-WittenbergUni Saarbrücken
Uni KielUni Duisburg
Uni DüsseldorfUni Kassel
Uni AugsburgUni OsnabrückUni PaderbornUni Greifswald
Uni MagdeburgTU ClausthalBTU Cottbus
150001000050000
50% of funding20-25% of universities
10% of funding20-25% of universities
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 26
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 27
Department level
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
…
subject‘s top group
subject‘s top group
subject‘s top group
summarised presentation
at university level
……
… …
50%
50%
50% 50%
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 28
at least 50% top
research active
CHE-ResearchRanking
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 29
ResearchRanking: Top group in physics
absolute relative
University
Number of top group placements
(max. 7)
Comparison to 2003 Third
party funding
Publi-cations Phd's
Third party
funding
Publi-cations Citations Phd's
Repu-tation
RWTH Aachen 4 Uni Bochum 5 Uni Bremen 4 TU Dresden 4 Uni Göttingen 4 Uni Hamburg 5 Uni Heidelberg 6 Uni Karlsruhe 6 Uni Mainz 4 LMU München 6 TU München 5 Uni Stuttgart 4 Uni Würzburg 5
out of top group compared to 2003: FU Berlin 1 HU Berlin 3 TU Berlin 3 Uni Bonn 2 Uni Freiburg 1
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 30
ResearchRanking: Top group in medicine
absolute relative
University
Number of top group placements
(max. 7) Third party
funding
Publi-cations
Third party
funding
Publi-cations
Third party
funding
Publi-cations
Third party
funding
Reputation
Charité Berlin 5
Uni Erlangen-Nürnberg 4
Uni Frankfurt a.M. 5
Uni Freiburg 4
MH Hannover 4
Uni Heidelberg 6
LMU München 5
Uni Tübingen 6
Uni Würzburg 4
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 31
ResearchRanking: Top group in mathematics
absolute relative
University
Number of top group placements
(max. 6) Third party
funding
Third party funding
Third party funding
Third party
funding
Third party funding
Third party funding
Reputation
RWTH Aachen 5
HU Berlin 6
TU Berlin 6
Uni Bielefeld 4
Uni Bonn 6
TU Darmstadt 3
Uni Göttingen 5
Uni Heidelberg 4
TU Kaiserslautern 6
Uni Köln 4
TU München 4
Uni Münster 4
Uni Saarbrücken 4
Uni Stuttgart 3
Uni Tübingen 3
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 32
Subject level
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
…
subject‘s top group
subject‘s top group
subject‘s top group
summarised presentation
at university level
……
… …
50%
50%
50% 50%
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 33
Subjects
PsychologyElectrical engineering
Education Science
SociologyEnglish studies
History
Economics
Business administration
Dentistry
Mechanical engineering
Pharmacy
Physics
Biology
Chemistry
Medicine
Mathematics
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 34
University level
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
indicator
top group
…
subject‘s top group
subject‘s top group
subject‘s top group
summarised presentation
at university level
……
… …
50%
50%
50% 50%
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 35
Summarised presentation at university level
University Number of
subjects in CHE-ResearchRanking
thereof in top groups percentage Subjects in CHE-ResearchRanking
(bold: top group)
TU München 8 7 87,5% Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Elektro- und Informationstechnik, Mathematik, Maschinenbau/Verfahrenstechnik, Medizin, Physik
Uni Heidelberg 13 9 69,2% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Pharmazie, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
Uni Karlsruhe 6 4 66,7% Biologie, Chemie, Elektro- und Informationstechnik, Mathematik, Maschinenbau/Verfahrenstechnik, Physik
Uni Freiburg 13 8 61,5% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Pharmazie, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
Uni Stuttgart 10 6 60,0% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, BWL, Chemie, Elektro- und Informationstechnik, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Maschinenbau/Verfahrenstechnik, Physik, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft
LMU München 14 8 57,1% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Pharmazie, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
Uni Göttingen 13 7 53,8% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
Uni Frankfurt a.M. 14 7 50,0% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Pharmazie, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
FU Berlin 13 6 46,2% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Pharmazie, Physik, Psychologie, VWL, Zahnmedizin
HU Berlin 13 6 46,2% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
Uni Köln 13 6 46,2% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
Uni Tübingen 14 6 42,9% Anglistik/Amerikanistik, Biologie, BWL, Chemie, Erziehungswissenschaft, Geschichte, Mathematik, Medizin, Pharmazie, Physik, Psychologie, Soziologie/Sozialwissenschaft, VWL, Zahnmedizin
CHE Research Ranking - Brussels, 13th of Dec 2007 35
