wti westview taskforce, inc. tenant’s meeting march 8, 2006 “the future is in our hands”
TRANSCRIPT
WTIWestview
Taskforce, Inc.
Tenant’s MeetingMarch 8, 2006
“The Future is in Our Hands”
3 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Welcome
Welcome Westview Tenants Exciting Times, Major Accomplishments
Formula For Success
Key Objective’s for Tonight’s Meeting Ratification of the “By-Laws Of Westview Taskforce, Inc” Communicate Westview Privatization Progress Meet the Westview Legal Team Address Tenant Questions We Have to be Out of Here By 10 PM!
Meeting Policies Stick to the Agenda Address All Tenant Questions Aligned with the Agenda
• Q& A Session’s – By-Laws, Legal, Post Meeting• After the meeting Taskforce members will remain to answer any questions
Show Respect to Those Who Have the Floor• Taskforce Members and Tenants• Keep Discussions Constructive
4 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Agenda
Sign In 7:30 – 8:00 PM Tenants
Ratification of Westview By-Laws M. Katz
Westview Taskforce Introduction O. Pail
Privatization Update O. Pail, J. Marfey
Fundraising I. Stanton
Meet the Legal Team Introducing Carol Ule, Esq. and Jack Rose, Esq.
WTI How Can You Help? F. Santella
Meeting Close F. Santella
5 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Ratification Of By-laws
Ratification of Westview By-Laws
The Taskforce Has Spent A Significant Amount of Time Drafting the By-laws
Tonight’s Objectives are to Address Any Questions You Have regarding the By-laws and Vote on the By-Laws As They Stand
Vote Will Be Conducted at 8:00 PM Sharp!
6 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Westview Taskforce Introduction
Here are your Taskforce Members
Co-ChairsOpher Pail Johan Marfey
Secretary Real Estate AdvisorsLaurence Brodsky Natalia Chin
Dimitri GavrilevTreasurerTeri Sheridan
Production TeamFinance Advisor Sainjargal EnhSaihanIvens Stanton Alima Amarsaihan
Architecture ConsultantEngineering Director Tad SudolSanja Zlatanic
RI Advisory BoardPolitical Liaison Matthew KatzDierdre Breslin Sherie Helstein
Legal Liaison MembersPhilip Groner Petra Kaizer
Zakie WazaniMaintenance Director Jember Asfaw ZewdieDejan Kovacevic Nicholas Ghattas
Felix SantellaEvent Coordinator Nirmala NarineFay Christian Anya Wiecek
7 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Westview Taskforce – Major Accomplishments 2000 – 2005
YEAR 2000 Blocked 31% Rent Hike Application
• Rent increase was reduced to 4% annually over 2 years
YEAR 2003 Blocked 11% rent Hike Application
• Rent increase was reduced to 2% annually over 2 years
Tenant Apartment Condition Survey Conducted• Detailed Conditions Are Alarming!
YEAR 2005 Blocked Unilateral M-L Dissolution Blocked Ground Lease Extension Created Affordable opportunities to Own and Rent
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Year 1 Year 2
APPLIED
ACTUAL
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Year 1 Year 2
APPLIED
ACTUAL
8 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Westview Taskforce – Major Accomplishments 2006
NORTH TOWN PHASE III ASSOCIATES, L.P. c/o CHARLES A. LUCIDO, ESQ.
P.O. BOX 673 GENEVA, NY 14456-0673
315-789-2081 FAX-781-2814
March 3, 2006 Kenneth A. Leitner, Esq. VP & General Counsel RIOC 591 Main Street Roosevelt Island, NY 10044 RE: Westview Task Force Dear Mr. Leitner: As you may know, the Westview Task Force ("WTF") represents the tenants of the Westview apartments located at 595 and 625 Main Street. WTF is interested in the tenants purchasing the buildings from North Town Phase III Houses, Inc., as a tenant sponsored cooperative, in order that the tenants can own their apartments and maintain affordable housing on the Island. An important consideration in their progress towards this goal is RIOC's position concerning the extension of the ground lease. We confirm that our negotiations with WTF are in earnest and consent to its meeting with RIOC for this purpose. Please accept my apology for the delay in responding to RIOC's request for the past due legal reimbursements incurred by Sheldrake, and for future legal costs. I will be out of the country next week. When I return I will contact you and Jay Neveloff to reach an agreement on these matters. Very truly yours, Charles A. Lucido President Westview Houses, Inc. Managing General Partner CC: Gerald Goldstein, Esq. Jay Neveloff, Esq. Jacques Rose, Esq. .
A letter from Charles Lucido to RIOC stating that the Owners are negotiating “In Earnest” with the Taskforce so that the tenants can own their apartments and maintain affordable housing on the Island.
9 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Westview Building Snapshot
Westview 595/625 Main Street
13 Studio Apartments
Rental Income $ 6.5 M annually 97 One Bedroom Apartments
167 Two Bedroom Apartments
84 Three Bedroom Apartments
361 Total Apartments
10 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Current Building Expense Structure – What You Rent Covers!
Maintenance 60.5 % - $ 900
Real Estate Taxes 8.5 % - $ 128Ground Lease Rent 1 % - $ 15Miscellaneous Expense 8% - $ 120
Interest/Mortgage 22% - $ 330
100%
50%
Average Monthly Rent Per Apartment = $ 1,500
11 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Westview Building – 2003 Apartment Condition Survey- Engineers Estimate $8 - $10M in Immediate Repairs
90% of All Apartments Reported…
Problem Categories: Floors/Walls/Ceiling 40% Intercom 28% Repaired Windows/Doors 32% Faucets/Piping/Leaks 32% Air Conditioners 27% Kitchen Appliances 23% Quality of Water 21% Kitchen Cabinets 19% Heating 16% Electrical/Lighting 13% Locks/Knobs 11% Closets 9%
Other (Ventilation, Plumbing, etc.) 34%
12 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Meet the Legal Team
Meet the legal Team from Hartman, Ule, Rose & Ratner, LLC
Successfully Supported the Successful West Village Apartments, Tenants Sponsored Mitchell – Lama Privatization
Welcome…
Carol Ule, Esq.
Jack Rose, Esq.
13 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Fundraising
Fundraising
Past Tenant Contributions Been the Key to Our Success To-Date!
Your Contributions Are Considered Investments
We Estimate Today that the Total Expense to Privatization Will be Approximately…
• $300,000
This Will Require Each Apartment to Invest One months Rent• 50% NOW• 50 in the Summer
A Fundraising Packet Will be Distributed to All Tenants in the Next Week
14 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
WTI – How Can You Help?
WTI Opportunities
We Need Your Continued Commitment and Participation in all Privatization Activities
We Build Strength in Unity and Numbers• The Bigger and Stronger the Taskforce the More Support and Attention Owners,
Politicians, State and City Agencies, the Press, Financier’s, etc. Will Pay Us
Specific Skills We Need ASAP• CFO (CPA preferred)
Please fill out the index cards provided with skills or expertise you are interested in contributing to the Taskforce efforts
15 WTI Tenants Meeting March 8, 2006
Meeting Close
Meeting Close Taskforce Members are Available to Address any Questions Thank You, Good Night and Good Luck!