wrecking ball rept. foreclosure costs losangeles_web

Upload: martin-andelman

Post on 06-Apr-2018

235 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    1/14

    Wall Street

    The

    SEPTEMBER2011

    WRECKINGBALL

    What Foreclosures

    Are Costing Los Angeles

    Neighborhoods

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    2/14

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    3/14

    The California Reinvestment Coalition (CRC) advocates for fair and equal access

    -income communities

    and communities of color. CRC is a membership organization of over 300

    nonprofits and public agencies including housing counselors, consumer

    advocates, community organizations, legal service providers, and economic

    development practitioners. Founded in 1986, CRC advocates with policymakers

    - particularly in

    lending, financial products and services, and investments- to California's low-income communities and communities of color.

    Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) is a multi-racial,

    democratic, non-profit community organization building power in low tomoderate income neighborhoods to stand and fight for social, economic and

    racial justice. ACCE has chapters in eleven counties across the State of California.

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    4/14

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    5/14

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    6/14

    The Wall Street WRECKING BALL4

    Foreclosures undermine an economic recovery and cost jobs.Another alarming impact of the housing crisis is the overhang of underwater mortgage debt, which is

    now one of the primary drags on economic recovery. Negative equity, often referred to as

    -- that means almost a

    third of homeowners are underwater on their mortgages.

    California homeowners are underwater by $200 billion as a result of the Wall Street-created housing

    crisis. That means as homeowners overpay on their mortgages, Wall Street devours $20 billion annually.

    This is money that would otherwise go into our economy in the form of consumer spending if banks

    wrote down means banks

    would write down mortgages to market value and refinance homeowners into 30-year fixed loans at

    current market interest rates.

    California has over 2 million homes underwater (30% of all mortgages) by $200 billion.

    Fixing the underwater crisis by writing down mortgages would save California homeowners$810 every month and pump $20 billion annually into local economy. xv

    With the extra $810 per month, homeowners could start spending again, making purchases theyhave been putting off. The increase in consumer demand would in turn help spur 300,000 jobs

    in California.

    Los Angeles has 79,029 homeowners underwater (27%) by $7.3 billion. If banks wrote downthose mortgages, it could pump $768 million into local economy and spur 11,353 jobs. xvi

    Fixing Underwater Mortgages Would Spur Economic Recovery

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    7/14

    SEPTEMBER 2011 5

    olutions:Wall Street Should Pay Their Fair Share: The banks collapsed the economy and created the housing

    crisis with their recklessness and predatory lending practices. Currently, taxpayers are being forced to

    absorb the losses to home values and the costs to local governments. California should institute a

    Foreclosure Fee, making the banks pay $10,000 to $20,000 per foreclosure to partially reimburse local

    and state governments for the costs of this crisis. This fee would raise roughly $2 billion to $4 billionover the next year.

    California Needs a Strong AG Settlement. The current multi-state Attorneys General investigation into

    robo-signing and other servicing abuses needs to provide meaningful relief for California families and

    neighborhoods. Any agreement must include 1) a large settlement award that is commensurate with the

    harm caused by bank practices; 2) limited releases of liabilities so banks are not let off the hook for

    uninvestigated claims; 3) mandated principal reductions that are fairly distributed to communities

    hardest hit by predatory lending and foreclosure; and 4) restitution to homeowners who lost their

    properties due to bank's irresponsible and illegal foreclosure practices.

    Wall Street Banks Must Stop Preventable Foreclosures: Reducing foreclosures is good for families,

    communities and the economy. Banks should be subject to court-based mandatory mediation programs

    to give homeowners a fair shot at getting a loan modification. Banks must also be forced to fully end the

    dual track process, a controversial practice whereby homeowners negotiating a loan modification in

    good faith find that the bank has nonetheless proceeded with foreclosure and taken their homes.

    Wall Street Must Clean Up and Pay for Foreclosure-Related Blight: Vacant foreclosures unattended by

    banks have become a magnet for blight and illicit activity that further destabilizes neighborhoods

    already decimated by foreclosures. Banks must maintain and pay for the cleanup of blighted, vacant

    homes in neighborhoods.

    pushed

    homeowners into high-cost loans they couldn't afford and then promptly cashed out by selling the loans

    to investment banks that turned them into mortgage-backed securities (MBS). This widespread practice,

    which started among subprime lenders but was quickly adopted by the big banks, created and inflated

    the housing bubble. Bankers and brokers raked in mega-bonus checks making homeowners vulnerable.

    When W

    bonuses but Californians lost billions in savings in their homes.

    -documented and continues to have devastating consequences as they

    use flawed-and, in some cases, fraudulent--procedures to flood the housing market with foreclosuresthat are throwing hundreds of thousands of California families out of their homes. The total disregard

    for mortgage laws and standards is the latest example of a predatory industry that continues to

    devastate families already hit hard by the economic crisis.

    Currently, the five largest mortgage companies in the U.S. are under investigation by all 50 state

    Attorneys Generals for foreclosure fraud. They may be on the hook for more than $20 billion in

    damages. However, this amount is not nearly enough to compensate communities for the harm that

    has been done, as this report documents.

    Who is Responsible for this Mess?

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    8/14

    The Wall Street WRECKING BALL6

    y lending practices have devastated California. Lenders pushed homeowners into high-cost

    taxpayers and got to keep their bonuses but Californians lost billions in savings in their homes.

    BANK OF AMERICA

    CEO Brian MoynihanFederal taxpayer bailout funds received:xvii $230.1 billionxviiiProfits since bailout (2009-2010): $4.0 billion2010 CEO Brian Moynihan bonus: $9.05 million

    xix2010 CEO Brian Moynihan total pay: $10 millionxx2010 bonuses and compensation: $35.1 billion

    JP MORGAN CHASE

    CEO Jamie DimonFederal taxpayer bailout funds received: xxi $100.7 billionxxiiProfits since bailout (2009-2010): $29.1 billion2009 CEO Jamie Dimon pay:

    xxiii$17.5 million

    xxiv

    2010 bonuses and compensation: $28.4 billion

    WELLS FARGO

    CEO John StumpfFederal taxpayer bailout funds received: xxv $43.7 billionxxviProfits since bailout (2009-2010): $24.6 billion2010 CEO John Stumpf bonus: $14.3 millionxxvii2010 CEO John Stumpf total pay: $17.1 million

    xxviii

    2010 bonuses and compensation: $27.2 billion

    CITIGROUP

    CEO Vikram PanditFederal taxpayer bailout funds received: xxix $414.9 billionxxxProfits since bailout (2009-2010): $9.0 billion2008-2010 CEO Vikram Pandit pay: 10.8 millionxxxi2010 bonuses and compensation: $24.4 billion

    GOLDMAN SACHS

    CEO Lloyd BlankfeinFederal taxpayer bailout funds received: xxxii $53.4 billionxxxiiiProfits since bailout (2009-2010): $21.7 billion2010 CEO Lloyd Blankfein bonus: $12.6 million

    xxxiv

    2010 CEO Lloyd Blankfein total pay: $13.2 million

    xxxv

    2010 bonuses and compensation: $15.4 billion

    MORGAN STANLEY

    CEO James GormanFederal taxpayer bailout funds received: xxxvi $36.3 billionxxxviiProfits since bailout (2009-2010): $6.0 billion2009 CEO James Gorman pay: $15.0 millionxxxviii2010 bonuses and compensation: $16.0 billion

    Who is Responsible for this Mess?

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    9/14

    SEPTEMBER 2011 7

    The Cost of the Foreclosure Crisis in Los Angeles by Zip Code (2008-2012)

    Zip CodeForeclosures

    2008-12Foreclosed Home

    Value LossImpacted Homes

    Value LossTotal Home Value

    LossProperty Tax

    Loss Local Gov't Cost

    90001 3,125 $404,954,409 $828,315,837 $1,233,270,246 $7,522,949 $20,044,310

    90002 4,006 $519,133,771 $1,061,864,532 $1,580,998,303 $9,644,090 $26,905,217

    90003 5,929 $768,358,417 $1,571,642,217 $2,340,000,634 $14,274,004 $37,938,817

    90004 1,143 $148,109,166 $302,950,566 $451,059,732 $2,751,464 $6,987,819

    90005 1,045 $135,485,931 $277,130,313 $412,616,244 $2,516,959 $5,291,821

    90006 1,612 $208,866,583 $427,227,102 $636,093,685 $3,880,171 $10,368,277

    90007 939 $121,696,278 $248,924,205 $370,620,483 $2,260,785 $5,341,816

    90008 1,419 $183,905,238 $376,169,805 $560,075,043 $3,416,458 $6,964,744

    90010 96 $12,493,633 $25,555,158 $38,048,791 $232,098 $423,038

    90011 5,701 $738,886,922 $1,511,359,614 $2,250,246,536 $13,726,504 $32,077,818

    90012 834 $108,062,148 $221,036,211 $329,098,359 $2,007,500 $5,434,115

    90013 469 $60,783,338 $124,329,555 $185,112,893 $1,129,189 $3,222,780

    90014 302 $39,191,645 $80,164,728 $119,356,373 $728,074 $2,042,120

    90015 720 $93,339,360 $190,921,419 $284,260,779 $1,733,991 $4,707,259

    90016 2,737 $354,772,515 $725,671,053 $1,080,443,568 $6,590,706 $15,813,930

    90017 469 $60,809,258 $124,382,574 $185,191,832 $1,129,670 $3,238,164

    90018 2,634 $341,397,588 $698,313,249 $1,039,710,837 $6,342,236 $15,702,401

    90019 2,573 $333,414,105 $681,983,397 $1,015,397,502 $6,193,925 $13,514,141

    90020 935 $121,177,870 $247,863,825 $369,041,695 $2,251,154 $6,195,584

    90021 246 $31,830,251 $65,107,332 $96,937,583 $591,319 $819,155

    90022 2,266 $293,704,052 $600,758,289 $894,462,341 $5,456,220 $11,871,985

    90023 1,469 $190,437,179 $389,530,593 $579,967,772 $3,537,803 $8,126,175

    90024 738 $95,698,117 $195,746,148 $291,444,265 $1,777,810 $3,192,014

    90025 804 $104,174,088 $213,083,361 $317,257,449 $1,935,270 $4,049,627

    90026 1,833 $237,612,307 $486,025,173 $723,637,480 $4,414,189 $10,418,272

    90027 718 $93,054,236 $190,338,210 $283,392,446 $1,728,694 $4,061,165

    90028 532 $68,896,423 $140,924,502 $209,820,925 $1,279,908 $2,326,709

    90029 618 $80,042,195 $163,722,672 $243,764,867 $1,486,966 $3,661,202

    90031 1,332 $172,578,023 $353,000,502 $525,578,525 $3,206,029 $7,764,670

    90032 2,219 $287,612,758 $588,298,824 $875,911,582 $5,343,061 $13,979,483

    90033 1,321 $171,256,083 $350,296,533 $521,552,616 $3,181,471 $8,245,395

    90034 644 $83,463,688 $170,721,180 $254,184,868 $1,550,528 $3,465,066

    90035 534 $69,155,627 $141,454,692 $210,610,319 $1,284,723 $1,719,073

    90036 471 $60,990,701 $124,753,707 $185,744,408 $1,133,041 $2,103,653

    90037 3,555 $460,709,190 $942,359,706 $1,403,068,896 $8,558,720 $20,386,586

    90038 389 $50,467,019 $103,227,993 $153,695,012 $937,540 $1,865,213

    90039 987 $127,917,174 $261,648,765 $389,565,939 $2,376,352 $5,487,957

    90040 383 $49,585,725 $101,425,347 $151,011,072 $921,168 $1,776,760

    90041 899 $116,564,039 $238,426,443 $354,990,482 $2,165,442 $4,495,740

    90042 2,733 $354,228,186 $724,557,654 $1,078,785,840 $6,580,594 $16,040,832

    90043 3,422 $443,523,964 $907,208,109 $1,350,732,073 $8,239,466 $20,048,155

    90044 6,591 $854,180,862 $1,747,188,126 $2,601,368,988 $15,868,351 $40,261,680

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    10/14

    The Wall Street WRECKING BALL8

    The Cost of the Foreclosure Crisis in Los Angeles by Zip Code (2008-2012)

    Zip CodeForeclosures

    2008-12Foreclosed Home

    Value LossImpacted Homes

    Value LossTotal Home Value

    LossProperty Tax

    Loss Local Gov't Cost

    90045 987 $127,865,333 $261,542,727 $389,408,060 $2,375,389 $6,076,364

    90046 1,338 $173,433,396 $354,750,129 $528,183,525 $3,221,920 $7,433,931

    90047 4,560 $590,933,279 $1,208,727,162 $1,799,660,441 $10,977,929 $28,620,444

    90048 469 $60,731,497 $124,223,517 $184,955,014 $1,128,226 $2,234,41090049 726 $94,039,211 $192,352,932 $286,392,143 $1,746,992 $2,892,042

    90056 492 $63,738,264 $130,373,721 $194,111,985 $1,184,083 $2,345,938

    90057 575 $74,495,230 $152,376,606 $226,871,836 $1,383,918 $3,872,721

    90058 166 $21,539,852 $44,058,789 $65,598,641 $400,152 $946,067

    90059 3,689 $478,101,778 $977,935,455 $1,456,037,233 $8,881,827 $25,997,608

    90061 1,931 $250,313,303 $512,004,483 $762,317,786 $4,650,138 $12,260,410

    90062 2,524 $327,063,607 $668,993,742 $996,057,349 $6,075,950 $15,225,522

    90063 2,531 $328,074,503 $671,061,483 $999,135,986 $6,094,730 $15,798,546

    90064 429 $55,651,099 $113,831,793 $169,482,892 $1,033,846 $2,326,709

    90065 1,940 $251,427,880 $514,284,300 $765,712,180 $4,670,844 $12,041,200

    90066 791 $102,567,023 $209,796,183 $312,363,206 $1,905,416 $4,418,824

    90067 304 $39,399,008 $80,588,880 $119,987,888 $731,926 $1,699,844

    90068 1,082 $140,255,284 $286,885,809 $427,141,093 $2,605,561 $6,303,266

    90069 1,168 $151,426,977 $309,736,998 $461,163,975 $2,813,100 $6,330,187

    90071 31 $4,069,503 $8,323,983 $12,393,486 $75,600 $276,898

    90077 316 $41,006,073 $83,876,058 $124,882,131 $761,781 $1,838,292

    90089 1 $129,602 $265,095 $394,697 $2,408 $19,229

    90094 399 $51,659,357 $105,666,867 $157,326,224 $959,690 $2,411,317

    90095 3 $336,965 $689,247 $1,026,212 $6,260 $0

    90210 581 $75,298,762 $154,020,195 $229,318,957 $1,398,846 $2,861,275

    90211 212 $27,501,544 $56,253,159 $83,754,703 $510,904 $1,088,361

    90212 193 $24,987,266 $51,110,316 $76,097,582 $464,195 $480,725

    90230 1,056 $136,885,632 $279,993,339 $416,878,971 $2,542,962 $5,591,79390232 247 $31,985,774 $65,425,446 $97,411,220 $594,208 $1,211,427

    90245 225 $29,186,370 $59,699,394 $88,885,764 $542,203 $1,053,749

    90247 2,059 $266,850,518 $545,830,605 $812,681,123 $4,957,355 $12,710,369

    90248 368 $47,745,377 $97,660,998 $145,406,375 $886,979 $2,045,966

    90272 400 $51,866,720 $106,091,019 $157,957,739 $963,542 $1,926,746

    90290 242 $31,337,764 $64,099,971 $95,437,735 $582,170 $999,908

    90291 599 $77,605,678 $158,738,886 $236,344,564 $1,441,702 $2,380,550

    90292 828 $107,336,376 $219,551,679 $326,888,055 $1,994,017 $4,472,665

    90293 545 $70,684,931 $144,582,813 $215,267,744 $1,313,133 $3,272,776

    90302 1,958 $253,734,796 $519,002,991 $772,737,787 $4,713,700 $12,648,836

    90402 171 $22,213,783 $45,437,283 $67,651,066 $412,672 $980,679

    90501 1,105 $143,210,210 $292,929,975 $436,140,185 $2,660,455 $7,053,197

    90502 1,558 $201,919,916 $413,018,010 $614,937,926 $3,751,121 $9,641,421

    90710 1,119 $145,050,558 $296,694,324 $441,744,882 $2,694,644 $6,134,051

    90717 541 $70,114,682 $143,416,395 $213,531,077 $1,302,540 $2,615,144

    90731 1,948 $252,412,855 $516,299,022 $768,711,877 $4,689,142 $11,395,105

    90732 1,002 $129,809,363 $265,519,152 $395,328,515 $2,411,504 $5,930,224

    90744 1,962 $254,279,124 $520,116,390 $774,395,514 $4,723,813 $12,160,420

    90810 2,044 $264,958,329 $541,960,218 $806,918,547 $4,922,203 $13,148,790

    91040 1,328 $172,111,456 $352,046,160 $524,157,616 $3,197,361 $7,918,502

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    11/14

    SEPTEMBER 2011 9

    The Cost of the Foreclosure Crisis in Los Angeles by Zip Code (2008-2012)

    Zip CodeForeclosures

    2008-12Foreclosed Home

    Value LossImpacted Homes

    Value LossTotal Home Value

    LossProperty Tax

    Loss Local Gov't Cost

    91042 1,726 $223,641,211 $457,447,932 $681,089,143 $4,154,644 $9,422,210

    91214 1,214 $157,336,828 $321,825,330 $479,162,158 $2,922,889 $5,518,723

    91303 1,066 $138,103,891 $282,485,232 $420,589,123 $2,565,594 $6,907,057

    91304 2,444 $316,747,288 $647,892,180 $964,639,468 $5,884,301 $14,840,94291306 3,278 $424,783,515 $868,875,372 $1,293,658,887 $7,891,319 $20,763,474

    91307 1,332 $172,655,784 $353,159,559 $525,815,343 $3,207,474 $6,918,594

    91311 2,242 $290,567,684 $594,342,990 $884,910,674 $5,397,955 $13,875,646

    91316 1,813 $234,942,506 $480,564,216 $715,506,722 $4,364,591 $11,083,596

    91324 1,326 $171,852,252 $351,515,970 $523,368,222 $3,192,546 $7,407,011

    91325 1,499 $194,299,318 $397,430,424 $591,729,742 $3,609,551 $8,360,769

    91326 1,676 $217,187,032 $444,246,201 $661,433,233 $4,034,743 $8,829,957

    91331 6,049 $783,962,498 $1,603,559,655 $2,387,522,153 $14,563,885 $39,219,468

    91335 4,819 $624,577,958 $1,277,545,824 $1,902,123,782 $11,602,955 $29,558,819

    91340 1,939 $251,324,198 $514,072,224 $765,396,422 $4,668,918 $12,648,836

    91342 7,009 $908,354,498 $1,857,997,836 $2,766,352,334 $16,874,749 $46,388,040

    91343 3,788 $490,958,296 $1,004,232,879 $1,495,191,175 $9,120,666 $24,974,625

    91344 3,005 $389,454,010 $796,610,475 $1,186,064,485 $7,234,993 $16,894,599

    91345 1,367 $177,114,093 $362,278,827 $539,392,920 $3,290,297 $8,549,213

    91352 2,207 $285,979,773 $584,958,627 $870,938,400 $5,312,724 $13,544,908

    91356 2,037 $264,025,194 $540,051,534 $804,076,728 $4,904,868 $11,625,853

    91364 1,638 $212,236,235 $434,119,572 $646,355,807 $3,942,770 $9,222,228

    91367 2,446 $317,058,333 $648,528,408 $965,586,741 $5,890,079 $14,498,666

    91401 1,365 $176,880,810 $361,801,656 $538,682,466 $3,285,963 $7,341,632

    91402 4,272 $553,633,824 $1,132,432,821 $1,686,066,645 $10,285,007 $29,497,286

    91403 1,000 $129,602,000 $265,095,000 $394,697,000 $2,407,652 $5,749,471

    91405 2,162 $280,147,683 $573,029,352 $853,177,035 $5,204,380 $13,775,656

    91406 2,856 $370,195,153 $757,217,358 $1,127,412,511 $6,877,216 $18,990,56091411 766 $99,301,052 $203,115,789 $302,416,841 $1,844,743 $3,907,333

    91423 1,081 $140,073,842 $286,514,676 $426,588,518 $2,602,190 $5,218,751

    91436 479 $62,131,199 $127,086,543 $189,217,742 $1,154,228 $1,811,372

    91504 936 $121,307,472 $248,128,920 $369,436,392 $2,253,562 $4,284,221

    91505 921 $119,415,283 $244,258,533 $363,673,816 $2,218,410 $5,061,073

    91601 1,149 $148,912,698 $304,594,155 $453,506,853 $2,766,392 $6,926,286

    91602 654 $84,785,628 $173,425,149 $258,210,777 $1,575,086 $3,138,173

    91604 1,027 $133,049,413 $272,146,527 $405,195,940 $2,471,695 $5,468,728

    91605 2,452 $317,810,024 $650,065,959 $967,875,983 $5,904,043 $13,556,445

    91606 1,801 $233,465,043 $477,542,133 $711,007,176 $4,337,144 $10,237,520

    91607 917 $118,870,954 $243,145,134 $362,016,088 $2,208,298 $4,914,932

    Total: 199,894 $25,906,610,347 $52,990,793,892 $78,897,404,239 $481,274,166 $1,190,405,857

    *Foreclosure data from RealtyTrac. Data is for zip codes fully or partially within city boundary. 2011 - 2012 numbers are projections

    based upon recent trends.

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    12/14

    The Wall Street WRECKING BALL10

    MethodologyDirect impact to foreclosed homes was calculated using methodology from the U.S. Joint Economic Committee

    Report (Sheltering Neighborhoods from the Subprime Foreclosure Storm) using median county home value from U.S

    Census, decline estimate of 22%, and number of foreclosures from RealtyTrac. The 22% decline estimate is based on

    the most conservative property value decline ranging from 22% to 28% based on The Value of Foreclosed Property,Anthony Pennington-Cross, Marquette University and RealtyTrac 2010 sales report.

    Neighboring homes value decline was calculated using methodology from the U.S. Joint Economic Committee Report

    (Sheltering Neighborhoods from the Subprime Foreclosure Storm) using median county home value from U.S.

    Census, decline in value of 0.9%, and number of foreclosures from RealtyTrac. The decline estimate is based on a

    conservative decline estimate of 0.9% on one-eighth mile radius (approximately 50 homes) based on The External

    Costs of Foreclosure: The Impact of Single-Family Mortgage Foreclosures on Property Values. Dan Immergluck,

    Georgia Institute of Technology and Geoff Smith, Woodstock Institute . Higher estimates are put the decline at 1.4%

    in low to moderate income communities and others double the impact radius to a quarter of a mile.

    Property tax losses were estimated using lost home values (foreclosed and impacted homes as described in prior

    section) and California effective property tax rate of 0.61% from the U.S. Census and Tax Foundation.

    Impact to local governments based on The Municipal Cost of Foreclosures: A Chicago Case Study. Many experts,

    including the U.S. Joint Economic Committee Report, use the $19,229 cost from the Chicago study as an approximate

    cost of foreclosure. The Chicago study was published in 2005 and may not capture the full post-crisis level of impacts

    and level of costs in California . The cost is conservatively calculated us-owned properties).

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    13/14

    SEPTEMBER 2011 11

    Endnotes:

    i RealtyTracii Ibid.iii Home Wreckers: How Wall St Foreclosures Are Devastating Communities. March 2011.iv CoreLogic press release.07 Jun 2011. http://www.corelogic.com/uploadedFiles/Pages/About_Us/ResearchTrends/CL_Q4_2010_Negative_Equity_FINAL.pdf v The Value of Foreclosed Property, Anthony Pennington-Cross, Marquette University.vi Direct impact to foreclosed homes was calculated using methodology from the U.S. Joint Economic Committee using median county home value from U.SCensus, decline estimate of 22%, and number of foreclosures from RealtyTrac. The 22% decline estimate is based on the most conservative decline ranging from22% to 28% based on The Value of Foreclosed Property, Anthony Pennington-Cross, Marquette University and RealtyTrac 2010 sales report.vii The External Costs of Foreclosure: The Impact of Single-Family Mortgage Foreclosures on Property Values. Dan Immergluck, Georgia Institute of Technologyand Geoff Smith, Woodstock Institute.viii Neighboring home value decline was calculated using methodology from the U.S. Joint Economic Committee using median county home value from U.S.Census, decline in value of 0.9%, and number of foreclosures from RealtyTrac. The decline estimate is based on a conservative decline estimate of 0.9% to one-eighth mile radius (approximately 50 homes) based on The External Costs of Foreclosure: The Impact of Single-Family Mortgage Foreclosures on Property

    Values. Dan Immergluck, Georgia Institute of Technology and Geoff Smith, Woodstock Institute . Higher estimates are a 1.4% decline in low to moderate incomecommunities and others double the impact radius to a quarter of mile.ix Consumer Finance: Tapping Home Equity in Retirement. Amy Hoak, Wall St. Journal. March 17, 2011. http://www.marketwatch.com/story/tapping-home-equity-in-retirement-2011-03-17 x Property tax losses were estimated using lost home values (foreclosed and impacted homes as described in prior section) and effective tax rate of 0.61% from theU.S. Census and Tax Foundation.xi Methodology based on The Municipal Cost of Foreclosures: A Chicago Case Study. Many experts, including the U.S. Joint Economic Committee, use the$19,229 cost from the Chicago study as an approximate cost of foreclosure. Also, the Chicago study from 2005 likely does not capture the full post-crisis level ofimpacts and level of costs in California . We used a conservative method of only calculating those cost fo r REOs (bank-owned properties).xiihttp://www.nw.org/network/neighborworksprogs/foreclosuresolutions/reports/documents/7ForeclosureImpacts.pdfxiii Cost per foreclosure of $19,229 based on U.S. Joint Economic Committee report using estimates The Municipal Cost of Foreclosures: A Chicago Case Study.xiv CA Board of Equalization, CA Property Tax Oveview. http://www.boe.ca.gov/proptaxes/pdf/pub29.pdfxv The New Bottom Line. The Win/Win Solution. Aug 2011.xvi CoreLogic underwater data and methodology from The Win/Win Solution. The New Bottom Line. Aug 2011.xvii Includes bailouts that BofA has paid back and federal guarantee programs it has exited.xviiihttp://nomiprins.squarespace.com/storage/bailouttallyoct2010.pdf xixhttp://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/bank-of-america-c-e-o-gets-9-05-million-stock-bonus/ xxhttp://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/01/31/bank-of-america-c-e-o-gets-9-05-million-stock-bonus/ xxi Includes bailouts that the bank has paid back.xxiihttp://nomiprins.squarespace.com/storage/bailouttallyoct2010.pdf xxiii 2010 not yet availablexxiv http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/01/28/blankfein-gets-13-2-million-for-2010/xxv Includes bailouts that the bank has paid back.xxvihttp://nomiprins.squarespace.com/storage/bailouttallyoct2010.pdf xxvii WFC DEF 14A, 21 Mar 2011, http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/72971/000119312511072275/ddef14a.htm xxviii WFC DEF 14A, 21 Mar 2011, http://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/72971/000119312511072275/ddef14a.htm xxix Includes bailouts that the bank has paid back.xxxhttp://nomiprins.squarespace.com/storage/bailouttallyoct2010.pdf xxxihttp://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704115404576096473337115378.html xxxii Includes bailouts that the bank has paid back.xxxiiihttp://nomiprins.squarespace.com/storage/bailouttallyoct2010.pdf xxxivhttp://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/01/28/blankfein-gets-13-2-million-for-2010/ xxxvhttp://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/01/28/blankfein-gets-13-2-million-for-2010/ xxxvi

    Includes bailouts that the bank has paid back.xxxviihttp://nomiprins.squarespace.com/storage/bailouttallyoct2010.pdf xxxviiiAaron Luccheti and Randall Smith. As Street Rebounds, So Does Top Pay. Jan 22, 2011.http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704115404576096473337115378.html

  • 8/3/2019 Wrecking Ball Rept. Foreclosure Costs LosAngeles_web

    14/14