where is the porn?
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
1/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
W!"#"$S %!" & #'(-A)U! ) 'F"#"')" S"SS* ' +
%he Uni ersit o/ Western ntario
0onda 0a 1, 22
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
2/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
S"SS* ' 3"#3*"W
Welcome and Background *n/ormationA mini-debate on 4e *ssues - Adam and Bob
Small Grou5 DiscussionsSummar o/ Discussions%he U.W. . Strateg
Wra5-u5 and " aluations
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
3/30
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
4/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Background *n/ormation - er ie7
!o7 this all started ...&ornogra5h de/initions
Se6ual !arassment and &oisoned "n ironment)anadian )harter o/ #ights and FreedomsDi//erent % 5es o/ /ile sharing
%hen 8et the Debate Begin9
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
5/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Background *n/ormation
*t started 7ith in/ormal discussion in the /all on7hat to do i/ sta// ran across 5ornogra5hic materialon the net7ork.%his blossomed into length meetings in ol ing!ousing management, #e 'et management,";uit Ser ices and Uni ersit legal counsel.We disco ered that this 7as a hot to5ic that tuggedat the emotions and alues o/ 5artici5ants.
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
6/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Background *n/ormation cont$d
%here 7as little hard data and case la7 that 7ecould re/er to, to make an eas decision.
%he /ocus shi/ted to include all students in residence%here 7ere 5lent o/ o5inions on the issues9ne o/ the goals o/ this seminar is to recreate as
best 7e can the ma
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
7/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Background *n/ormation cont$d
&ornogra5h = is 5re alent 7ithin our societ
> maga ines and ideos at corner stores> readil a ailable on %.3.
> the *nternet is a 7ell kno7n and 5o5ular source = anecdotall it a55ears that a signi/icant number o/ students
ha e 5orn on their com5uters and in man ?most@ cases aresharing it through our net7orks
What o/ our students ha e 5orn on their com5uters(
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
8/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Background *n/ormation cont$d
%7o Basic t 5es o/ &ornogra5h : = . )riminal
> co ered under )riminal )ode Sections such as S. C .> &ertains to obscene material such as child 5ornogra5h
and se6 crimes, cruelt and iolence> 5ossession itsel/ canEis a crime
> our 5olic is clear: it is illegal, it is not tolerated, and7e 7ill noti/ andEor 7ork 7ith 5olice authorities
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
9/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Background *n/ormation cont$d
%7o Basic t 5es o/ &ornogra5h : = . 'on-criminal
> not co ered b an criminal statutes> concerns that it ma Edoes a//ect the residence
communit ad ersel> concerns that the ntario !uman #ights )ode could
be iolated> concerns that legal liabilit could occur > the /ocus o/ our discussion toda
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
10/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Se6ual !arassmentSe6ual !arassmentH includes someone botheringou b sa ing or doing un7anted or un7elcome
things o/ a se6ual or gender-related nature. %hisincludes dis5la ing se6uall o//ensi e 5ictures.
*ncludes beha iour that a 5erson kno7s or oughtto kno7 is un7elcome.Usuall in ol es beha iour that ha55ens/re;uentl o er a 5eriod o/ time.
Source: Go . o/ nt. htt5:EE777.ohrc.on.caE
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
11/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
&oisoned "n ironment
Se6ual harassment can ha e a bad e//ect on, or5oisonH the 5lace 7here ou li e, 7ork or
recei e ser ices. " en i/ the harassment is notdirected at ou, it can still 5oison theen ironment /or ou or others.*/ un7anted or un7elcome things o/ a se6ual orgender-related nature make ou or others /eel
uncom/ortable, this could indicate a 5oisonedHen ironment.
Source: Go . o/ nt. htt5:EE777.ohrc.on.caE
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
12/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
)anadian #ights and Freedoms
%he )anadian )harter o/ #ights andFreedoms ?section b@ guarantees thate er one has the /undamental /reedoms o/
thought, belie/, o5inion and e65ression,including /reedom o/ the 5ress and othermedia o/ communicationH
Source: De5artment o/ Justice )anada - )anadian )onstitution Act I , )harter o/ #ights and Freedom
htt5:EEla7s.
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
13/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Go ernment o/ )anada &ublication*llegal and //ensi e )ontent on the *nternet - %he
)anadian Strateg %o &romote Sa/e, Wise And#es5onsible *nternet Use ? 22 @ states: = A55roaches to addressing ina55ro5riate *nternet content
must balance the need to 5rotect our citi ens 7ith the need
to res5ect democratic rights and /reedoms that )anadianshold dearH = )anadian 5arents understand their res5onsibilit to teach
their children to be sa/e, 7ise and res5onsible *nternetusers.H
Source: htt5:EE777.connect.gc.caEc ber7iseE
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
14/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
15/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
'otes on 4a aa, 0or5heus etc.
Sharing and retrie ing o/ /iles is usuall anon mousAn one on the *nternet can 5otentiall get access to
/iles shared /rom our com5uter 3ast ma
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
16/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
'otes on 'et7ork 'eighborhood
Kou are sharing s5eci/icall 7ith the other students inour residence communit
*/ ou retrie e /iles, the are /rom our residenceKou ma kno7 7ho has made the /iles a ailable" er com5uter is named b the o7ner, /or e6am5le:Bob$s com5uter, room 1, 5orn5lace, etc.
'et7ork neighborhood comes 7ith the Windo7so5erating s stem
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
17/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Debate )a eats
%he 5ositions taken in the debate do notnecessaril re/lect the true o5inions, ie7sand arguments o/ the 5artici5antsWe are tr ing to ca5ture the discussion and
ie7s o/ a55ro6imatel 2 5eo5le 7ho 5artici5ated in the ob
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
18/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Do We !a e Jurisdiction to#egulate &ornogra5h in
#esidence(
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
19/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
What are the "//ects o/&ornogra5h in ur #esidences(
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
20/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Are We #es5onsible andEor 8iable/or the &ornogra5h on ur#esidence 'et7ork(
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
21/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Small Grou5 Discussion
S5lit into -L discussion grou5s.Muickl identi/ a s5okes5erson.
%r to come to a consensus on ho7 to ans7er thethree ;uestions.*/ there is not consensus, identi/ the dis5uted issue
and mo e on.We 7ill ha e grou5s re5ort back a/ter 2- Nminutes.
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
22/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Small Grou5 Discussion
Who isEshould be res5onsible /or handling 5ornogra5h com5laints that arise( Will ou act
u5on a com5laint( What 7ill ou doEnot do(Should ou look /or 5ornogra5h 5roacti el (Who 7ill look /or it(
Who is liable /or 7hat( )an !ousing and theUni ersit be held liable /or non-criminal
5ornogra5h (
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
23/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Grou5 #esults:
Who isEshould be res onsible /or
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
24/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Grou5 #esults:
Should ou look /or 5ornogra5h
5roacti el ( Who 7ill look /or
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
25/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
Grou5 #esults:
Who is liable /or 7hat( )an!ousing and the Uni ersit be
-
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
26/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
U.W. . Strateg on !andling &orn
Widen the a55roach to include other ob
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
27/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
!andling )oncerns%he 5rocess is com5laint dri en.%he com5lainant needs to be o//ended.We are most concerned 7ith someone 7ho mightinad ertentl ha55en u5on 5ornogra5h .
We /ocus on sharingH that is targeted s5eci/icall in theresidence ?'et7ork 'eighborhood@.#e 'et 7ill send the o//ending indi idual a letter re;uestingthat sEhe cease sharingH the ob
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
28/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
!andling )oncerns cont$d
#e 'et Securit sta// 7ill discusstoughEborderline issues 7ith the #esidence8i/e 0anagement %eam*/ the o//ender does not cease sharing theo//ensi e material, the case is handed o erto the #esidence 8i/e %eam /or /ollo7 u5)ases 7here indi iduals ha e gone out o/their 7a to be o//ended, ma be handleddi//erentl
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
29/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin, Bob Gough, Adam Schieman - U.W. .
S"0*'A# BJ")%*3"S
%o e65lore 5ro and con arguments related tohandling net7ork 5ornogra5h issues in residence.
%o e6amine the legalities and 5ossible liabilitiesrelated to 5ornogra5h in residence%o share the strateg 7e ha e decided to im5lement
at %he Uni ersit o/ Western ntario
-
8/19/2019 WHERE IS THE PORN?
30/30
Facilitators: Jim Dunkin Bob Gough Adam Schieman - U W
%!A'4 K U9