what is new in immunotherapy, biomarkers and side effects€¦ · pd-l1 scoring on digital images...

32
What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects Prof Dr Christian Rolfo, MD, PhD, MBA Director of Phase I – Early Clinical Trials Unit Director of Clinical Trial Management Program Oncology Department Antwerp University Hospital Center for Oncology Research (CORE) Antwerp University Belgium

Upload: others

Post on 01-Sep-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects

Prof Dr Christian Rolfo, MD, PhD, MBADirector of Phase I – Early Clinical Trials UnitDirector of Clinical Trial Management Program

Oncology DepartmentAntwerp University Hospital Center for Oncology Research (CORE)Antwerp UniversityBelgium

Page 2: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Disclosures

• Novartis:International Speaker Bureau for Lung Cancer • Mylan: Scientific advisor for Lung Cancer Products• Biocept: Reserch grant for Liquid Biopsy in NSCLC• Boeringher Italy spearker bureau• MSD speaker bureau• OncoDNA: Research collaboration exosomes project• Guardant Health Speaker Bureau and Clinical Research Project.

Page 3: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

PDL-1 may vary inside the same tissue section

Page 4: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

PDL-1 status

4

Page 5: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

The IASLC Blue Print Study

• 39 NSCLC tumor stained with four PD-L1 assays

• Independent review by three expert pathologists

• Similar PD-L1 expression for three assays

Page 6: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

1. Blueprint phase 2A involving real-life clinical lung cancer samples and 25 pathologists largely affirms the results of Blueprint phase 1

2. 22C3, 28-8 and SP263 are comparable, SP142 detects less, while 73-10 stains more PD-L1 positive tumor cells

3. PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability

Page 7: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Mutational Tumor Burden

Page 8: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate
Page 9: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Checkmate 227 patients with hight TMB (>10)

NEJM 3/2018

Page 10: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Liquid Biopsy in IO. The new frontier… CD8+ T cells that express PD-1

Ton N Schumacher & Wouter Scheper, Nature April 2016

Page 11: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Image from Nishino et al, Nature Reviews Clinical Oncology, June 2017

Potential Utility of Liquid Biopsy in Immunotherapy

•Diagnostic•Prognostic•Predictive of Response•Monitoring•Mechanisms if Resistance

Current tools:• Calculation of circulating TMB• Detection of bPDL1• Alellic Fraction Variation Dynamic

Unmeet Medical Need:

Validated Biomarkers in Blood!

Liquid Biopsies in Immunotherapy

Liquid Biopsy in Immunotherapy is challenging!

A complex microenvironment

Page 12: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

1295O: Blood-based biomarkers for cancer immunotherapy: Tumor mutational burden in blood (bTMB) is associated with improved atezolizumab (atezo) efficacy in 2L+ NSCLC (POPLAR and OAK) – Gandara DR, et al

Key results

Atezolizumab PFS benefit in bTMB subgroups: OAK

Gandara DR et al. Ann Oncol 2017;28(suppl 5):Abstr 1295O

00 2 4 6 28

Time, months

PFS,

%

8 12 20

Atezolizumab (n=216)Docetaxel (n=209)

bTMB ≥16 bTMB <16100

80

60

40

20

00 2 4 6 24

Time, months

PFS,

%

10 14 18

Atezolizumab (n=77)Docetaxel (n=81)

10 16 24 0.2 1.0 1.5

HR

Favours atezolizumab Favours docetaxel

Population

bTMB ≥16

bTMB <16

BEP

ITT

PFS HR (95%CI)

0.65 (0.47, 0.92)

0.98 (0.80, 1.20)

0.87 (0.73, 1.04)

0.95 (0.82, 1.10)

n (%)

158 (27)

425 (73)

583 (100)

850

208 12 16 2214 18 2622

90

70

50

30

10

100

80

60

40

20

90

70

50

30

10

Interaction p=0.036

BEP, biomarker-evaluable population

211/273 samples from POPLAR and 583/797 samples from OAK were biomarker-evaluable

Page 13: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

In patients undergoing therapy with IO a higher amount of mutations was associated with a better PFS and OS

Khagi (Kurzrock) et al. 2017 Clinical Cancer Research

HR 0.52

HR 0.39

Hypermutated Circulating Tumor DNA

Variable All Patients % (N, if applies)

VUS > 3% (N, if applies)

VUS < 3% (N, if applies) P valuec

Disease Control Rate[SD/CR/PR] (% (N))b 24% (16/66) 45% (9/20) 15% (7/46) P = 0.014

Median PFS, monthsb 2.3 (95%CI: 0.7-5.0) 3.84 2.07 P = 0.019

(HR 0.52; 95% CI 0.31-0.87)

Median OS, monthsb 15.3 (95%CI: 6.80-15.68) Not Reached 10.72 P = 0.042

(HR 0.39; 95% CI 0.18-0.83)

Page 14: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

CORRELATION OF PD-L1 FROM PLASMA WITH CLINICAL RESPONSE IN PATIENTS WITH LUNG CANCER

Raez L. et al. J Clin Oncol 35, 2017 (suppl; a11550)14

No overlap in relative PD-L1 expression between patients showing response to Nivolumab in (p = 0.0073, Wilcoxon Rank Sums)

In two patients with stabilized disease (SD) treated with Nivolumab, PD-L1 became undetectable upon treatment. An increase in PD-L1 ctRNA was predictive of resistance to therapy approx. 1.5 months before progression was seen on CT scans.

Page 15: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

No Change in Overall Survival with I/O in 2nd Line EGFR Mutated Lung Cancer: A Meta-Analysis

Lee (Yang) et al. 2017 Journal of Thoracic Oncology

Key:Checkmate 057 (N=582) NivolumabKeynote 010 (N=1034) PembrozulimabPOPLAR (N=287) Atezolizumab

Lee (Yang) et al. 2017 (Oct 2016) Journal of Thoracic Oncology

Page 16: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

EGFR Mutated or ALK Fusions as Negative Predictors of Response to I/O in 2nd+ Line in Lung Cancer

Gainor (Mino-Kenudson) et al. Clin Cancer Res; 22(18); 4585–93. 2016

Response

N=28 N=30

PFS

Low rates of concurrent PD-L1 expression and CD8+ TILs within the tumor microenvironment may underlie these clinical observations.

Page 17: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Poor Response to Immunotherapy in NSCLC Patients with MET Exon14 Skipping Mutations

ORR 6.7%95% CI (0-32%)

Adequate Genotyping Identifies Patients Unlikely to Benefit from Immunotherapy

Note: PD defined as > 20% growth or appearance of new lesions

Sabari et al, J Clin Oncol 35, 2017 (suppl; abstr 8512)

Page 18: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Conclusions: Which mutations may be best for PD-(L)1 monotherapy?<br />

Presented By Ben Creelan at 2017 ASCO Annual Meeting

Page 19: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Pseudoprogression: a new concept in cancer immunotherapyKwak et

Kwak et al, Radiographics, 2015

Page 20: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Pseudoprogression in NSCLC

Sarfaty et al, Medicine: January 2017 - Volume 96 - Issue 4 - p e5951

Response of a subcutaneous metastatic lesion to nivolumab, by week of treatment.

Page 21: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

SPSLIDES/SPEXIB/ONCOBU/563495/04/05/2016

Durvalumab + Osimerinib: TATTON trial(NCT02143466)

European Lung Cancer Conference (ELCC), Geneva, Switzerland, 13 to 16 April, 2016

Page 22: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

SPSLIDES/SPEXIB/ONCOBU/563495/04/05/2016

Durvalumab + Osimertinib: adverse events

European Lung Cancer Conference (ELCC), Geneva, Switzerland, 13 to 16 April, 2016

The study has been suspended

Page 23: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Combination with cytokine-analogues : AM0010

Aung Naing, et al Clin Oncol 34, 2016 (suppl; abstr 3018)

Page 24: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Gut microbiome influences efficacy ofPD-1–based immunotherapy against epithelial tumors

Culturomics-based analyses of fecal samples in 16 R and 16 NR NSCLCpatients before therapy, each commensalcolony having been

identified by mass spectrometry.

Routy et al.,Science359, 91–97 (2018)

Page 25: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Antibiotics prescription decreases progression-free survival (PFS) and overall survival (OS) in patients with advanced cancers treated with PD1/PDL1 immune checkpoint inhibitors

Page 26: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate

Slide 4

Page 27: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate
Page 28: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate
Page 29: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate
Page 30: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate
Page 32: What is new in Immunotherapy, Biomarkers and Side Effects€¦ · PD-L1 scoring on digital images and glass slides show comparable reliability. Mutational Tumor Burden. Checkmate