what is integrative medicine? - pcos challenge · supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with...

29

Upload: others

Post on 24-Jun-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL
Page 2: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL
Page 3: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

WHATISINTEGRATIVEMEDICINE?

“Integrativemedicineisanapproachtocarethatputsthepatientatthecenterandaddressesthefullrangeofphysical,emotional,mental,social,spiritualandenvironmentalinfluencesthataffectaperson’shealth.

Employingapersonalizedstrategythatconsidersthepatient’suniqueconditions,needsandcircumstances,itusesthemostappropriateinterventionsfromanarrayofscientificdisciplines tohealillnessanddiseaseandhelppeopleregainandmaintainoptimumhealth.”

Page 4: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

WHYINTEGRATIVEMEDICINEFORPCOS?

Lifelongcondition

Adjustmentofcarerequiredatdifferentstagesoflife.

Affectsentirebodyincluding:• Endocrinesystem• Mental/emotional• Reproductivesystem• Skin• Cardiovascular• Metabolism• Immunesystem

Impactedbyexternalfactorssuchasstress,environmentalagents,nutrition/diet,exercise/activity

Page 5: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

WHATDOWEKNOWABOUTTHEROOTOFPCOS?

Genetic

InsulinResistance

Inflammation

Page 6: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

Sciencephotolibrary.com

Page 7: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

AdaptedfromTrayhurn,P.(2013).HypoxiaandAdiposeTissueFunctionandDysfunctioninObesity.PhysiologicalReviews,93(1).

Page 8: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

AdaptedfromTrayhurn,P.(2013).HypoxiaandAdiposeTissueFunctionandDysfunctioninObesity.PhysiologicalReviews,93(1).

Page 9: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

Healthy IL6TypeInflammation

IL6TypeInflammation(closeup) IL8TypeInflammationBesteretal2016.EffectsofIL-1β,IL-6andIL-8onerythrocytes,plateletsandclotviscoelasticity,6,32188.

Page 10: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL
Page 11: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

ANTI-INFLAMMATORY DIET:DoesItHelp??

THEN:

A2013ASRMcommitteeopiniontitled"Optimizingnaturalfertility"statedthat"thereislittleevidencethatdietaryvariations,vitamin-enricheddiets,antioxidants,orherbalremediesimprovefertility

NOW:

“Thereareemergingepidemiologicdatademonstratingthat…dietmayinfluencereproductivehealthoutcomes.Furthermore,translationalworkwithhumanspecimensandanimalmodelslendsbiologicplausibilitytotheepidemiologicdata,particularlyinthecontextoffemalereproductivediseasesassociatedwithinflammation,includingpolycysticovarysyndrome(PCOS)andobesity.

“Weoutlineepidemiologicandtranslationalworkdemonstratingapotentialrolefordietintheregulationofinflammatoryprocessesassociatedwiththesedisorders.”

Rileyetal2016.Istherearolefordietinamelioratingthereproductivesequelaeassociatedwithchroniclow-gradeinflammationinpolycysticovarysyndromeandobesity?FertilityandSterility,106(3),520–527.

Page 12: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

Sciencephotolibrary.com

Page 13: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

Supplements:N-Acetyl-CysteineMyo-InositolD-Chiro-InositolResveratrolOmega3FattyAcidsVitaminD

COMMONINTEGRATIVEMODALITIESINPCOS

Exercise/LifestylePsychology/CounselingAcupuncture/Electro-Acupuncture

Nutrition/DietKetogenicdietMediterraneandietLowGlycemicindexdiet(orFoodInsulinDemand)LowCarbohydrate

Page 14: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

HOWQUICKLYDOWELEARNNEWINFORMATION?

Searchforallnewintegrativeinterventions

This does NOT include research on integrative medicine for mechanisms such as insulin resistance which could be applied to PCOS!

Totalof398Studies

SEP

1ST 2016 SEP

11TH 2017From To

106StudiesonPCOSandnutritionordiet91NewStudiesonPCOSandComplementaryMedicine88NewStudiesonDietarySupplements33NewStudiesonPCOSandExercise56NewStudiesonPCOSandMood15NewStudiesonPCOSandAcupuncture

Page 15: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

VITAMINDDOSINGISIMPORTANT

60Participantswererandomlyallocatedinto3groupstoreceiveeither4 000IUofvitaminD(or1 000IUofvitaminDorplaceboperdayfor12weeks.VitaminDsupplementation(4 000IU),comparedwithvitaminD

(1 000IU)andplacebo.

VitaminDsupplementationatadosageof4 000IU/dayfor12weeksininsulin-resistantpatientswith PCOS benefittedglucosemetabolismandlipidprofilescomparedto1 000IU/dayandplacebogroups.

Foroozanfard etal.2017.EffectofTwoDifferentDosesofVitaminDSupplementationonMetabolicProfilesofInsulin-ResistantPatientswithPolycysticOvarySyndrome:ARandomized,Double-Blind,Placebo-ControlledTrial.HormoneandMetabolicResearch,49(8),612–617

Page 16: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

VITAMINDANDEVENINGPRIMROSEOIL

RCT,DoubleBlind,Placebo-controlled

60vitaminDDeficient womenwithPCOS

Comparedwiththeplacebogroup,womeninvitaminDandEPOco-supplementationgrouphadsignificantincreasesinserum25-hydroxyvitaminDandplasmatotalglutathione,whilethereweresignificantdecreasesintriglycerides,VLDLcholesterollevels,total/high-densitylipoproteincholesterolratio,andmalondialdehydeconcentration.

Nasri etal.TheeffectsofvitaminDandeveningprimroseoilco-supplementationonlipidprofilesandbiomarkersofoxidativestressinvitaminD-deficientwomenwithpolycysticovarysyndrome:Arandomized,double-blind,placebo-controlledtrial.Endocr Res.2017Jul25:1-10.

Page 17: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

MAGNESIUM-ZINC-CALCIUM-VITAMIND

Sixty PCOS womenwererandomizedintotwogroupsandtreatedwith:

Afterthe12-weekintervention,comparedwiththeplacebo:

magnesium-zinc-calcium-vitaminDco-supplementationresultedin:significantreductionsinhirsutismserumhighsensitivityC-reactiveproteinandplasmamalondialdehyde,andasignificantincreaseinplasmatotalantioxidantcapacityconcentrations

100 mgmagnesium,4 mgzinc,400 mgcalcium,200 IUvitaminDORPlaceboTwiceadayfor12 weeks.

Maktabi etal2017.Magnesium-Zinc-Calcium-VitaminDCo-supplementationImprovesHormonalProfiles,BiomarkersofInflammationandOxidativeStressinWomenwithPolycysticOvarySyndrome:aRandomized,Double-Blind,Placebo-ControlledTrial.BiologicalTraceElementResearch.

Page 18: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

REDUCINGCARBOHYDRATES,REPLACINGWITHFATREDUCESHYPINSULINEMIAINPCOS

StanfordUniversityClinicalResearchCenter: TwodietsgiventotwogroupsofwomenwithPCOS

Daylongglucosedidnotdifferaccordingto diet.Daylonginsulinconcentrationswere30%loweronthe low Carbohydrate/higherfat diet.

Beneficialchangesinlipidprofilewerealsoobserved.

40% CARBOHYDRATE / 45 % FATGROUP2

60% CARBOHYDRATE / 25% FATGROUP1

SAMENUMBEROFCALORIESGIVENDAILYFOREACHGROUP

Perelman,D.(2017).Substitutingpoly- andmono-unsaturatedfatfordietarycarbohydratereduceshyperinsulinemiainwomenwith polycysticovarysyndrome,33(4).

Page 19: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

OMEGA3FATTYACIDSANDVITAMINECO-SUPPLEMENTATION

68womenwithPCOS

Omega-3fattyacidsandvitaminEco-supplementationfor12weeksin PCOS womensignificantlyimprovedindicesofinsulinresistance,totalandfreetestosterone.

1 000 mgomega-3fattyacidsconplus 400IUvitaminEsupplementsOrplacebofor12weeks

Ebrahimi etal.(2017).TheEffectsofOmega-3FattyAcidsandVitaminECo-SupplementationonIndicesofInsulinResistanceandHormonalParametersinPatientswithPolycysticOvarySyndrome:ARandomized,Double-Blind,Placebo-ControlledTrial.ExperimentalandClinicalEndocrinology&Diabetes,125(6),353–359.

Page 20: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

Control HighCholesterol&Diabetes HighCholesterol&DiabeteswithFishoil

OMEGA3ANDHAIR

El-Sayyadetal2015.HairGrowthDefectsofDiabeticandHypercholesterolemic WistarAlbinoRatsandAmeliorationofFishOil-Treatment.JNutriHealth.JNutriHealthAugust,1(61).

Page 21: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

PROBIOTICSUPPLEMENTATIONDoubleBlindRCT

Supplementationfor12weeksin60womenwithPCOS.

Favorableeffectsonweightloss,insulinresistance,triglyceridesandVLDLconcentrations

Ahmadietal.2017.Probioticsupplementationandtheeffectsonweightloss,glycaemiaandlipidprofilesinwomenwithpolycysticovarysyndrome:arandomized,double-blind,placebo-controlledtrial.HumanFertility,1–8.

Page 22: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

COMBINEDLIFESTYLEANDHERBALMEDICINEINPCOS:RCT

Allparticipantswerehelpedtoconstructapersonalizedlifestyleplan.Bothgroupsimplementedthelifestyleintervention.Onegroupimplementedtwotabletsofherbalmedicineandtheotherplacebo.

At3 months,womeninthecombinationgrouprecordedareductioninoligomenorrhoeaof32.9%comparedwithcontrols.

Othersignificantimprovementswerefoundfor:

bodymassindexInsulinLH

bloodpressurequalityoflifedepression,anxietyandstress

Tablet1:Cinnamon,Licorice,St.John’sWortandWhitePeony.Tablet2:Tribulus terrestris.

Arentz etal.2017.CombinedLifestyleandHerbalMedicineinOverweightWomenwithPolycysticOvarySyndrome(PCOS):ARandomizedControlledTrial.Phytotherapy Research:PTR,31(9)

Page 23: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

CHROMIUMANDPCOS

Systematicreviewandmeta-analysis

7RCTs

Thissystematicreviewandmeta-analysisshowsthatusingCrpicolinatesupplementationhasbeneficialeffectsondecreasingBMI,fastinginsulinandfreetestosteronein PCOS patients.

Fazelian etal.2017.Chromiumsupplementationandpolycysticovarysyndrome:Asystematicreviewandmeta-analysis.JournalofTraceElementsinMedicineandBiology,42,92–96.

Page 24: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

GREENTEAANDPCOS

DoubleBlindRCT

60womenwithPCOS

500mgcapsulesofGreenTeaExtracttwiceperdayfor12weeks

Theconsumptionofgreenteaextractbywomenwithhighbodymassindexand PCOS leadstoweightloss,adecreaseinfastinginsulin,andadecreaseintheleveloffreetestosterone.

Mombaini etal.(2017).TheImpactofGreenTeaSupplementationonAnthropometricIndicesandInflammatoryCytokinesinWomenwithPolycysticOvarySyndrome.Phytotherapy Research,31(5),747–754.

Page 25: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

VITEXVSMETFORMINONOLIGOMENORRHEAINPCOS

DoubleblindRCT60PCOSWomen

3.2-4.8mgofChasteberry DryExtractoncepermealfor3monthsvs500mg3x/dayofMetformin

Thetwodrugshadsimilareffectsonmenstrualcycleregulation,menstruationlengthandthenumberofpadsused.MoresideeffectswerereportedinthegroupusingMetformin.

Shayan etal.2016.ComparingtheEffectsofAgnugol andMetforminonOligomenorrheainPatientswithPolycysticOvarySyndrome:ARandomizedClinicalTrial.JournalofClinicalandDiagnosticResearch:JCDR,10(12)

Page 26: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL
Page 27: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL
Page 28: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

Thankyou!

Page 29: WHAT IS INTEGRATIVE MEDICINE? - PCOS Challenge · Supplementation for 12 weeks in 60 women with PCOS. Favorable effects on weight loss, insulin resistance, triglycerides and VLDL

drfionand.com/2017show

GrabaGuidetoPCOSTesting