what does it all mean? - nrmca expanding the concrete ... for concrete.pdfwhat does it all mean? 2...

20
1 What Does It All Mean?

Upload: danglien

Post on 19-Apr-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

1

What Does It All Mean?

Page 2: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

2

Environmental Product Declaration (EPD)

Provide quality assured and comparableinformation regarding environmentalinformation regarding environmental performance of a product and/or service

Type Standard 3rd party reviewed

Endorsement Shorthand

I ISO 14024 Yes Yes Eco-labelI ISO 14024 Yes Yes Eco label

II ISO 14021 No Yes Self-declaration

III ISO 14025 Yes No Nutrition label

Type III EPD

Page 3: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

3

Type III EPD

Life Cycle Assessment

Technique to assess the environmental aspects and potential impacts associatedaspects and potential impacts associated with a product, process, or service.

Part of the ISO 14000 environmental management standards

Page 4: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

4

Product Category Rules

Instructions on how and what to report via pthe EPD Intended application Intended audience Disclosed to the public Product studied Functional unit Functional unit System boundaries Life cycle stages

included

Allows For Comparisons

Page 5: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

5

Helps Prevent

Why Bother?

Building owners asking for EPDsi e report your carbon footprint i.e., report your carbon footprint

Required by Architecture 2030 Challenge for Building Products

LEED 2012 Industry wide EPDs (company listed) permitted

Plant specific EPDs

PCRs are being developed – we need to be a the table

Page 6: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

6

Architecture 2030

2030 Challenge for Buildings 2030 Challenge for Products 2030 Challenge for Products

35% or better in 2015 40% or better in 2020 45% or better in 2025 50% or better in 2030

Environmental Product Declarations (EPD)

P d t C t R l (PCR) Product Category Rules (PCR)

If no products meeting reduction targets in a category, specify materials below category average

University of Washington

Heading Carbon Leadership

Page 7: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

7

PCR Committee

PCR Development Process

Task Date

Committee Formed May 2011

PCR Public Draft Issued February 14, 2012

Public Comments Due March 31, 2012

Final Version May 2012

EPD Program Adoption ???

Page 8: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

8

Goals

Quantify environmental impacts of specific concrete mix designsconcrete mix designs

Encourage supply chain specific EPDs for Cement SCMs Aggregates Water Admixtures Admixtures

Track and reduce the environmental impacts Additional performance metrics for concrete Differentiate products

Page 9: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

9

Declared Unit / Product description

1 yd3 (m3)

Specified compressive strength at age

Exposure class (per ACI 318)

Specified slump or slump flow

Other performance characteristics Other performance characteristics

Life Cycle Stages

Page 10: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

10

System Boundaries

A-1 Raw Material Supply (upstream processes) Extraction handling and processing of raw materials Extraction, handling and processing of raw materials

A-2 Transportation Transportation to 'gate' of the concrete producer

A-3 Manufacturing (core processes): Energy used to store, batch, mix and distribute the

concrete and operate the plantconcrete and operate the plant

A-4 Construction Transportation (optional) Transport of the concrete to the construction site

Excluded from System Boundary

Production, manufacture and construction of buildingsbuildings

Production and manufacture of concrete production equipment, concrete delivery vehicles, earthmoving equipment, and laboratory equipment

Personnel‐related activities (travel, furniture, office supplies)

Page 11: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

11

Impact Categories (2 Levels of Detail) Level A: Single attribute

Carbon footprint only

Level B: ISO compliant EPD

Total primary energy consumption Non‐renewable

Renewable

Water Use

Total waste disposed

Global Warming Potential/'Carbon Footprint

Ozone Depletion Potential

Acidification Potential Air

Eutrophication Potential, Air

Eutrophication Potential, Water

Photochemical ozone creation/smog

Human Health Criteria (particulate matter)

Human Health CF Non‐Cancer

Human Health CF Cancer

Selection of Data

Plant specific EPD results

P bli l bli h d LCI d t Publicly published LCI data

CO2e: Use defaults noted in Appendix B

LCI of concrete, Marceau, 2007

US LCI Database (NREL)

USEPA USEPA

Specific data plant energy use, water use, fuel use etc.

Page 12: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

12

Data Variability

Data sources Optimal Default

Site specific EPD Median + std dev 10th%=80% ave90th%=150% ave

National orNational or Regionally specificindustry averaged EPD

Median (50%) +10th/90th percentiles

10th%=80% ave90th%=200% ave

Allocation Assumptions

Emissions from waste incineration (e.g. tires) are considered to be allocated to the originalare considered to be allocated to the original intended use (e.g. cars)

Emissions from bio‐fuels can be considered as net‐zero provided that the bio‐fuels are waste product biomass

Emissions from coal power and steel or ferro‐silica metal production need not be allocated to the waste products (SCMs)

Page 13: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

13

Content of EPD

The name and address of the manufacturer Description of the construction product and declared Description of the construction product and declared

unit Construction product identification A description of the main components Name of the EPD program Date the declaration was issued and the 5 year

i d f liditperiod of validity Which life cycle stages not considered A statement regarding data quality and variability

Content of EPD (con’t’d)

A statement that EPD of construction products may not be comparable if they doproducts may not be comparable if they do not comply with this standard

The site(s), manufacturer or group of manufacturers or those representing them for whom the EPD is representative

Other important environmental data about the manufacturer or product

Page 14: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

14

Sample EPD for Concretep

Product Description

P d t STR040

The declared unit is 1 cubic yard (1 cubic meter) of concrete for each of the following concrete products:

Product name STR040Specified Compressive Strength

4000 psi (28 MPa) at 28 days

Specified Environmental Exposure Class (in accordance with ACI 318)

F0, S1, P0, C0

6 in +/- 1 5 in (152 mm +/- 38Specified Slump

6 in. +/- 1.5 in. (152 mm +/- 38 mm)

Typical Applications

Foundations, footings, basement walls and slabs on grade with moderate sulfate exposure

Page 15: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

15

Main Components

Component Meeting the FollowingComponent Meeting the Following Standard

Portland Cement ASTM C 150 Type IISlag cement ASTM C 989Fly ash ASTM C 618Fine and Coarse Aggregate ASTM C 33Admixtures ASTM C494Water ASTM C 1602

EPD Program UsedThis environmental product declaration was developed following the Product Category Rules (PCR) for ISO 14025 Type III Environmental Product Declarations (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the Carbon Leadership Forum www.carbonleadershipforum.org.

The reported ‘carbon footprint’ represents a cradle-to-site inventory of the greenhouse gas emissions attributed to the production of this unique concrete mix design. The calculations were prepared in conformance with the Carbon Leadership Forum’s Concrete Product Rules dated 2/14/88 which provide clarification for adopting the WRI/WBCSD Greenhouse Gas Protocol Initiative Product Accounting & Reporting Standards dated 2/14/99.

The EPD Program Operator verifying/registering this EPD is Green Environmental Sustainability, Inc.:1000 Heavenly Way1000 Heavenly WaySeattle, WA 88888www.GESwebsite.net

The Life Cycle Assessment was independently verified by Go Get Em Environmental:2000 Cradle LaneCradle, CA 77777www.GOgetEMEnvironmental.com

Page 16: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

16

Data Quality and Variability Statement The life cycle inventory data used to conduct the LCA for

the products in this EPD was obtained from industry average data and is classified as “good” quality. The data was obtained from Life Cycle Inventory of Portland Cement Concrete, by Marceau, et al.

This EPD was created using industry average data for upstream materials that did not include the variability of the upstream material component impacts. Variation can result from differences in manufacturing processes, manufacturing efficiency and fuel type usedmanufacturing efficiency and fuel type used.

Global warming potential values can expect to vary between 80% and 150% of values reported.

Other environmental impact values can be expected to vary between 80% and 200% of values reported.

Environmental ImpactsImpact Category

Impacts(US Units)

Impacts (SI Units)

Reference

Total Primary Energy 2.13 MBTU/yd3 2957 MJ/m3 N/A

Non-renewable 1.92 MBTU/yd3 2665 MJ/m3 N/A

R bl 0 21 MBTU/ d3 281 MJ/ 3 N/ARenewable 0.21 MBTU/yd3 281 MJ/m3 N/A

Batch Water 210 lbs/yd3 127 kg/m3 N/A

Wash Water 30 lbs/yd3 18 kg/m3 N/A

Total Waste Disposed 40 lbs/yd3 24 kg/m3 N/A

Global Warming Potential 254 kg CO2 eq/yd3 334 kg CO2eq/m3 TRACI

Ozone Depletion 0.00 kg CFC11 eq/yd3 0.00 kg CFC11 eq/m3 TRACI

Acidification Potential 0.59 kg SO2 eq/yd3 0.78 kg SO2 eq/m3 TRACI

Eutrophication Potential Air 0.00 kg N eq/yd3 0.00 kg N eq/yd3 TRACI

Eutrophication Potential Water 0.07 kg N eq/yd3 0.09 kg N eq/m3 TRACI

Photochemical Ozone Createion/Smog

0.05 kg C2H6 eq/yd3 0.06 kg C2H6 eq/m3 TRACI

Human Health Criteria (particulate matter)

0.38 kg PM10/yd3 0.49 kg PM10/m3 TRACI

Human Health CF Non-cancer 2.03E-5 CTUnoncancer/yd3 2.67E-5 CTUconcancer/m3 TRACI

Human Health CF cancer 5.54E-6 CTUcancer/yd3 7.29E-6CTUcancer/m3 TRACI

Page 17: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

17

Additional Environmental Information

Rock Solid Concrete Company is dedicated to continuous environmental improvementsto continuous environmental improvements through product and process innovation. It demonstrates its dedication to sustainable development through the following certifications: NRMCA Certified Concrete Production Facility NRMCA Green-Star Certification NRMCA Sustainable Concrete Plant Certification

– Silver Level

EPD Document

Page 18: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

18

Can we do this for concrete?

Thousands of mix designs at each plant

N i d i d l d f j t New mix design developed for many projects

Mix designs change with season

Mix designs change with material availability

Do we have upstream data?

How much will this cost? How much will this cost?

How long will it take?

Page 19: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

19

We have to try

Good start – we have a PCR

W d h l i th PCR d We need your help – review the PCR and provide comments by March 31

www.nrmca.org/sustainability

Next steps

Develop industry wide EPD for concrete

D l i l LCA t l t h l b Develop a simple LCA tool to help members create EPDs

Identify EPD operators and LCA practitioners to verify the tool

Identify EPD operators to adopt PCR and the y p pEPD tool

Develop baseline(s) for Architecture 2030 Challenge

Page 20: What Does It All Mean? - NRMCA Expanding the Concrete ... for Concrete.pdfWhat Does It All Mean? 2 ... intended use (e.g. cars) ... (EPDs) of Concrete developed and registered at the

20

Other Challenges

PCR will penalize companies using industry average dataaverage data Average footprint for cement industry

Average footprint for aggregate

PCR will reward companies using plant specific data Footprint of cement from plant

Footprint of aggregate from quarry

How do we establish baseline(s)?