welcome to blue hill ave station design meeting · pdf fileblue hill avenue / cummins highway...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATIONDESIGN MEETING
![Page 2: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
MBTA / MATTAPANCOMMUNITY MEETING:
15 September 2014Public Libra 5:30 PM
ATBLUE HILL AVE & CUMMINS HIGHWAY
• INTRODUCTIONS• WHY MATTAPAN• COMMUNITY CONCERNS AND COMMUNITY BENEFITS• BLUE HILL AVE. STATION DESIGN• PROJECT STATUS & SCHEDULE/NEXT STEPS• Q & A
![Page 3: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
Mattapan Neighborhood - Aerial Photograph
![Page 4: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Area - Aerial Photograph
![Page 5: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
Why Mattapan ?• Existing Central Artery mitigation obligation
• The State Implementation Plan (SIP) TransitSystem Improvement regulations (310 CMR7.36)
• In 2003, the Conservation Law Foundationsued the Commonwealth (EOT, MBTA, MTA,MHD, and DEP) for failure to comply with theregulations
• Existing Central Artery mitigation obligation
• The State Implementation Plan (SIP) TransitSystem Improvement regulations (310 CMR7.36)
• In 2003, the Conservation Law Foundationsued the Commonwealth (EOT, MBTA, MTA,MHD, and DEP) for failure to comply with theregulations
![Page 6: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
Why Mattapan ? (cont’d)
• Settlement negotiations - new set of transit projects• The settlement mandates new station in
DORCHESTER, ROXBURY and MATTAPANNew Opened Stations to date:
• Talbot Ave• New Market Station• Four Corners
• Settlement negotiations - new set of transit projects• The settlement mandates new station in
DORCHESTER, ROXBURY and MATTAPANNew Opened Stations to date:
• Talbot Ave• New Market Station• Four Corners
![Page 7: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
REASONS FOR A STATION BETWEENBLUE HILL AVENUE AND CUMMINS HIGHWAY
• NO PERMANENT RESIDENTIAL LANDTAKINGS
• SUFFICIENT MBTA PROPERTY (RIGHT-OF-WAY WIDTH)
• CENTRAL LOCATION WITHIN THEAREA
• MULTIPLE BUS ROUTES FOR EASYTRANSFER (28, 29, 30 & 31)
• NO PERMANENT RESIDENTIAL LANDTAKINGS
• SUFFICIENT MBTA PROPERTY (RIGHT-OF-WAY WIDTH)
• CENTRAL LOCATION WITHIN THEAREA
• MULTIPLE BUS ROUTES FOR EASYTRANSFER (28, 29, 30 & 31)
![Page 8: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
REASONS FOR A STATION BETWEENBLUE HILL AVENUE AND CUMMINS HIGHWAY
• APPROXIMATELY ¼ MILE FROMMATTAPAN SQUARE and LOCALBUSINESSES
• 20 MINUTES – ACCESS TODOWNTOWN BOSTON
• APPROXIMATELY ¼ MILE FROMMATTAPAN SQUARE and LOCALBUSINESSES
• 20 MINUTES – ACCESS TODOWNTOWN BOSTON
![Page 9: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
CURRENT TRIP to SOUTH STATIONat min: 40 or 45mins
![Page 10: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
COMMUNITY BENEFITBLUE HILL AVE STATION FARE =
COMMUNITY BENEFIT
• One seat ride to downtown Boston• Connection to other neighborhoods
along the corridor• Neighborhood residents to benefit
from the lower fare - projectsridership to be 290/day
![Page 11: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
COMMUNITY BENEFITBLUE HILL AVE STATION FARE =
COMMUNITY BENEFIT
• Residents will receive service atregular transit price
• FARES: Zone 1A fare at this locationinstead of a Zone 1 fare:
$2.10 (Zone 1A) vs $5.75 (Zone 1)
![Page 12: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
COMMUNITY CONCERNS
• POTENTIAL CONSTRUCTIONIMPACTS– HOME / PROPERTY DAMAGE: Pre-
construction survey of adjacentproperties (approx. 40)
– NOISE: No increase in existinglevels. Within federal guidelines
• POTENTIAL CONSTRUCTIONIMPACTS– HOME / PROPERTY DAMAGE: Pre-
construction survey of adjacentproperties (approx. 40)
– NOISE: No increase in existinglevels. Within federal guidelines
![Page 13: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
COMMUNITY CONCERNS
• PARKING / POSSIBILITY OFADDITIONAL TRAFFIC
• DESIGN ISSUES-Two platforms-Proximity to existing property lines
• PARKING / POSSIBILITY OFADDITIONAL TRAFFIC
• DESIGN ISSUES-Two platforms-Proximity to existing property lines
![Page 14: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
DESIGN CHANGES MADE BASED ON COMMUNITY INPUT- YOU’VE SPOKEN, WE’VE LISTENED AND ACTED
Original Design
• TWO PLATFORMS –ONE EACH SIDE OFTHE TRACKS
• FOUR ACCESSRAMPS
• TWO SETS OFCANOPIES ANDPLATFORMAMENITIES
Original Design
• TWO PLATFORMS –ONE EACH SIDE OFTHE TRACKS
• FOUR ACCESSRAMPS
• TWO SETS OFCANOPIES ANDPLATFORMAMENITIES
Current Design
• ONE CENTER ISLANDPLATFORM BETWEENTRACKS: LESS ROCKTO DISTURB
• TWO ACCESS RAMPS• ONE SET OF CANOPIES
AND PLATFORMAMENITIES
Current Design
• ONE CENTER ISLANDPLATFORM BETWEENTRACKS: LESS ROCKTO DISTURB
• TWO ACCESS RAMPS• ONE SET OF CANOPIES
AND PLATFORMAMENITIES
![Page 15: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
DESIGN CHANGES MADE BASED ON COMMUNITY INPUT- YOU’VE SPOKEN, WE’VE LISTENED AND ACTED
Original Design
• CLOSER TOPROPERTY LINES:WITHIN 5FT
• MORE VISUALOBSTRUCTIONS
• TRACKS REMAIN INPLACE
• 26 PARKING SPACES
Original Design
• CLOSER TOPROPERTY LINES:WITHIN 5FT
• MORE VISUALOBSTRUCTIONS
• TRACKS REMAIN INPLACE
• 26 PARKING SPACES
Current Design
• FARTHER FROMRESIDENCES:30FT to CLOSESTPROPERTY LINE
• FEWER VISUALOBSTRUCTIONS
• OUTBOUND APPROX 6ft• COMBINATION PARKING
SPACES – DROPOFF/PICKUP (TBD )
Current Design
• FARTHER FROMRESIDENCES:30FT to CLOSESTPROPERTY LINE
• FEWER VISUALOBSTRUCTIONS
• OUTBOUND APPROX 6ft• COMBINATION PARKING
SPACES – DROPOFF/PICKUP (TBD )
![Page 16: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
WHY BLUE HILL AVENUE / CUMMINS HIGHWAY- Based on the Site Alternatives Study (2009)
• Alternative 1: River Street• Too close to residences
• Extensive rock outcroppings
• Curvature of the track (south of the bridge)
• Alternative 2: River Street and Cummins Highway• Inbound side was close to and in some locations encroach onto
abutting properties
• Interference with railroad spur – limits rail operations
• Alternative 3: Current Alternative
• Alternative 1: River Street• Too close to residences
• Extensive rock outcroppings
• Curvature of the track (south of the bridge)
• Alternative 2: River Street and Cummins Highway• Inbound side was close to and in some locations encroach onto
abutting properties
• Interference with railroad spur – limits rail operations
• Alternative 3: Current Alternative
![Page 17: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
• Alternative 4: North of Blue Hill Avenue(Primary access at Blue Hill Ave. – Alt at Babson St.)• Too close to residences• Need construction easements from all
abutting properties• Rock outcroppings• Very close to Morton Street Station:
Approx. 1,250 feet from the southerly endof the platform
• Alternative 4: North of Blue Hill Avenue(Primary access at Blue Hill Ave. – Alt at Babson St.)• Too close to residences• Need construction easements from all
abutting properties• Rock outcroppings• Very close to Morton Street Station:
Approx. 1,250 feet from the southerly endof the platform
WHY BLUE HILL AVENUE / CUMMINS HIGHWAY- Based on the Site Alternatives Study (2010)
![Page 18: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
• South of River Street Alternative – near Riverwood &Agnes Ave• Extensive Track Realignment• Land Takings Required• New Bridge Required over Neponset River• Land Required at Neponset River are Protected Open Space
• South of River Street Alternative – near Riverwood &Agnes Ave• Extensive Track Realignment• Land Takings Required• New Bridge Required over Neponset River• Land Required at Neponset River are Protected Open Space
WHY BLUE HILL AVENUE / CUMMINS HIGHWAY- Suggested in the POLARIS
![Page 19: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
POLARIS PEER REVIEW FINDINGS
• Current location most appropriate to theoverall alternatives: Good overall trackalignment and no conflict with bridges
• Only two potential temporary easements vs16 temporary and 3 permanent takingsassociated with the other alternatives
• Most cost effective
![Page 20: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
POLARIS PEER REVIEW FINDINGS
• MBTA will consult with communityon pre and post-construction
• Closeness of the current station toMorton Station
• Possible cost saving from previousdesign
![Page 21: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
WORKING DISTANCES
CUMMINSHIGHWAY
ENTRANCEBLUE HILLAVENUE
ENTRANCE
![Page 22: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
PLAN WITH CENTER ISLAND PLATFORM
CURRENT DESIGN
Limits of MBTA Property
![Page 23: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
Cummins Highway Station Entrance Ramp(From Cummins Highway Looking North towards Blue Hill Avenue)
![Page 24: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
Center Island Platform Current Design(From Platform Looking towards Blue Hill Avenue)
![Page 25: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
PROJECTED SCHEDULE
• TRAFFIC STUDY (performed July2014)
• PRECONSTRUCTION GENERALCONDITION SURVEY(HOME SURVEYS) (IN PROCESS2014)
• SOIL BORINGS (October 2014)
• TRAFFIC STUDY (performed July2014)
• PRECONSTRUCTION GENERALCONDITION SURVEY(HOME SURVEYS) (IN PROCESS2014)
• SOIL BORINGS (October 2014)
![Page 26: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
PROJECTED SCHEDULE
• 90% DESIGN (December 2014)• 100% DESIGN (March 2015)• CONSTRUCTION (September
2015)• STATION OPEN (June 2017)
• 90% DESIGN (December 2014)• 100% DESIGN (March 2015)• CONSTRUCTION (September
2015)• STATION OPEN (June 2017)
![Page 27: WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN MEETING · PDF fileBlue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway Station Fairmount Corridor Improvements Project WELCOME TO BLUE HILL AVE STATION DESIGN](https://reader031.vdocuments.mx/reader031/viewer/2022030509/5ab8b25c7f8b9ac1058cf5fb/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Blue Hill Avenue / Cummins Highway StationFairmount Corridor Improvements Project
QUESTIONS