Weber County

Judge

Overview

Second District - Weber

Unanimous JPEC recommendation to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administrative Skills Pass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending retention

David Hamilton

District Court

LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Robert Dale

District Court

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Noel Hyde

District Court

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Jennifer Valencia

District Court

LA: 4.1 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

98%

96%

95%

87%

Michelle Heward

Juvenile Court

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 99%

• JPEC 2020 Evaluation Results • Second District Judges •

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Printer friendly version

https://judges.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/33/2020/07/Retention-Judge-Overview-Printer-Friendly.pdfhttps://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/district-court/dale-robert-j/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/district-court/hyde-noel/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/district-court/hamilton-david-r/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/district-court/valencia-jennifer/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/juvenile-court/michelle-e-heward/2020-2/

Second District - Weber

Robert NeillJuvenile Court

LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

Unanimous JPEC recommendation to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administrative Skills Pass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending retention

0% 100%

Jeffrey Noland

Juvenile Court

LA: 4.9 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

0% 100% 96%

Michael Junk

Justice Court - Ogden

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Clay Stucki

Justice Court - Ogden

LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.4

AS: 4.5 PF: Pass

0% 100%

Bryan Memmott

Justice Court - Basic

Plain City Justice court judges who receive a basic evaluation are required to meet four minimum performance standards.*

92%

97%

85%

Trent Nelson

Justice Court - Midlevel

Roy PF: Pass Justice court judges who receive a mid-level evaluation are required to meet five minimum performance standards. In interviews with court-users, Judge Nelson receives positive reviews from nearly all respondents.*

• JPEC 2020 Evaluation Results • Second District Judges •

*For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Printer friendly version

https://judges.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/33/2020/07/Retention-Judge-Overview-Printer-Friendly.pdfhttps://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/juvenile-court/jeffrey-j-noland/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/juvenile-court/neill-robert/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/justice-court/nelson-trent/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/justice-court/junk-michael/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/justice-court/memmott-bryan/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/justice-court/stucki-clay/2020-2/

Appellate

David Mortensen

Utah Court of Appeals

Ryan Harris

Utah Court of Appeals

Jill Pohlman

Utah Court of Appeals

Gregory Orme

Utah Court of Appeals

Diana Hagen

Utah Court of Appeals

Michele Christiansen Forster

Utah Court of Appeals

John Pearce

Utah Supreme Court

• JPEC 2020 Evaluation Results • Appellate Judges •

LA: 4.5 IJT: 4.7

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass

LA: 4.3 IJT: 4.5

AS: 4.7 PF: Pass LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

LA: 4.4 IJT: 4.6

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.9

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.6 IJT: 4.8

AS: 4.8 PF: Pass

LA: 4.2 IJT: 4.5

AS: 4.6 PF: Pass

0% 100%

81%

0% 100%

93%

0% 100%

96%

0% 100%

90%

0% 100%

88%

0% 100%

100% 0% 100%

91%

Unanimous JPEC recommendation to retain

1-5 ScaleLA Legal Ability IJT Integrity & Judicial Temperament AS Administrative Skills Pass/Fail PF Procedural Fairness

% of survey respondents recommending retention

For more info visit judges.utah.gov

Printer friendly version

https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/supreme-court/pearce-john/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/court-of-appeals/christiansen-michele/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/court-of-appeals/mortensen-david/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/court-of-appeals/hagen-diana/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/court-of-appeals/gregory-k-orme/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/court-of-appeals/harris-ryan/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/reports/judges/court-of-appeals/pohlman-jill/2020-2/https://judges.utah.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/33/2020/07/Retention-Judge-Overview-Printer-Friendly.pdf