warm mix asphalt (wma) furse wma.pdf · (stone mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant...

50
Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Melinda Furse

Upload: vokhue

Post on 20-Jun-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Warm Mix Asphalt(WMA)

Melinda Furse

Page 2: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

2

What is WMA?

121.1C

Page 3: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

3

What is WMA?

True Warm Mix Asphalt:

• It’s HMA produced at a lower temperature and it compacts at a lower temperature.

WMA produced at any temp:

• It’s HMA with a wider compaction window

Page 4: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Warm Mix Production Temperatures

120ºC

90ºC

175ºC

Conventional

Hot Mix

150ºC

Foamed Asphalt

Chemical

Additives and Wax

Often used as a coating aid.

Not a true warm mix.

Page 5: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Advantages of WMA

1. Improved compaction

2. Reduced thermal segregation

3. Extended hauls and paving season

4. Longer binder life

5. Reduced emissions and fuel consumption – Improved

worker conditions – lower impact on the environment

Page 6: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Compaction and

Workability

Page 7: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

NCAT Test Track Pavement Densities

Page 8: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Case Study

Page 9: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

9

Initial Paving of HMA - SMA Mix76-28 PMA

•HMA at 170 to 175ºC

•Had Tried Foam at 150ºC on an Earlier SMA Project (Stone Mastic, for studded tires)

–Tried To Go Lower

–Could Not Achieve Density

Page 10: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

10

Hot Mix – Stone Mastic

Page 11: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

11

Page 12: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

12

Page 13: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

13

Very Stiff Mix

Page 14: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

14

Some Extra Hand Work

Page 15: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

15

HMA

•170º to 175ºC

•1350 – 1550 Tonnes/Day (190 Tonnes/Hr)

•Struggling With Density

–92.0 to 93.0

–Plenty of 91.5s to 92.0s

Page 16: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

WMA

Page 17: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

17

WMA

Page 18: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

18

WMA

Page 19: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

19

133°C

133

Page 20: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

20

No More Chunks

Page 21: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

21

WMA

•130 to 143C

•2250 Tonnes/Day (250 - 370 Tonnes/Hr)

45% Increase in Production

•No Density Struggles

94.0+ Density

Full 5% Density Bonus

$2 per Ton Bonus

Page 22: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

22

WMA Mix

•Cut 1 Roller from the Project

•Less Waste (Plant & Road)

•Less Wear on the Plant

•Less Time Cleaning Up the Paving Equipment

•Tonnes per Man Hour Went Up

•Dramatically improved compaction on a stiff SMA/PMA mix

Page 23: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Longer Life Binder

Page 24: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Binder hardening

Page 25: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

4 Years Later – The Hot Mix

WMA / May 17, 2011

Page 26: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

HMA

WMA / May 17, 2011

Page 27: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

HMA

WMA / May 17, 2011

Page 28: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

WMA

WMA / May 17, 2011

Page 29: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Side by Side – HMA vs. WMA

WMA / May 17, 2011

Page 30: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

HMA vs. WMA

Page 31: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Reduced Thermal

Segregation

Page 32: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

32

24 Deg Difference

Page 33: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

33

7 Deg Difference

Page 34: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Hotter WMA

Page 35: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

80km

40%

increaseDoubles

market area

Longer hauls

120km

Page 36: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Cool weather paving

Idle paving crew cost: $1000/hr

One hour incremental paving

• 250 tons

• $12,500 incremental revenue

Increase in hours for seasonal workers

• Improved employee retention

• Improved paving quality

Page 37: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Reduced Emissions

Page 38: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

HMA vs. WMA

HMA (150°C) WMA (120°C)

Page 39: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Lower emissions

HMA WMA

Page 40: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

How to get WMA

Page 41: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

How do you get Warm Mix Additives into your Asphalt?• #1 easiest way: Terminal blended

• #2: Plant add

Page 42: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Evotherm pump systems

Page 43: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Evotherm pump

Self contained

Fits anywhere

Simple operation

Low maintenance

Manual or plant integration

Any power supply

—4 to 20mA or 0 to 10 VDC input

—4 to 20mA or 0 to 10 VDC output

Any plant type or terminal

Page 44: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Evotherm tank telemetry system

Page 45: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Technical Support Team

QA/QC based approach to supporting the Warm Mix

Industry experienced technicians

• Mix design

• Production lab

• Plant setup of WMA equipment

• Roadway density

• Overall best paving practices

• Other WMA technologies

Capable of support on any mix or plant types

Regional approach to support

Services provided at no added cost

Page 46: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Why not WMA?

Page 47: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Why not WMA?

Page 48: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Why not WMA?

• Changes the binder grade ?

• Concerns about performance ?

• No Spec

• Cost

Page 49: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

Spec. Language

“All SUPERPAVE Hot Mix Asphalt Mixtures shall be modified using a WMA additive capable of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt additives reduce compaction effort and permit lower production temperatures than conventional hot mix asphalt. The WMA additive shall be a product listed on the Northeast Asphalt User Producer Group (NEAUPG) website (http://www.superpave.psu.edu/NEAUPG.html)...”

Page 50: Warm Mix Asphalt (WMA) Furse WMA.pdf · (Stone Mastic, for studded tires) ... of lowering plant production temperatures to below 260°F [125°C]. Warm Mix Asphalt

[email protected]

(843)329-2225