waite - nietzsche's baudelaire

7/29/2019 Waite - Nietzsche's Baudelaire

1/39

*(2)) :$,7(

1LHW]VFKHV%DXGHODLUHRUWKH6XEOLPH3UROHSWLF6SLQRI+LV3ROLWLFR(FRQRPLF7KRXJKW:ULWWHQYHUZLWKKHLJQVIKHDVWQGHYHQKHVHLJQVDLQWHGYHUZLWKHZVLJQVKXVDYH\RXRQFHDOHGRXUVHOYHVHOOIURPOOVHPLRWLFLDQV)ULHGULFK1LHW]VFKH

%XWVLPXODFUDUHQRWQO\JDPHOD\HGZLWKLJQVKH\PSO\RFLDOUDSSRUWVQGVRFLDOSRZHU -HDQ %DXGULOODUG,WZDVZHOODLGRIFHUWDLQHUPDQRRNKDWHVODVVWLFKQLFKWHVHQLWGRHVQRWHUPLWWVHOIREHUHDG7KHUHUHRPHHFUHWVKLFKRQRWHUPLWKHPVHOYHVREHWROG 1RZQGWKHQODVWKHRQVFLHQFHIPDQWDNHVSDEXUWKHQRKHDY\QKRUURUKDWWFDQEHWKURZQRZQQO\QWRKHUDYH$QGWKXVKHVVHQFHIOOFULPHLVXQGLYXOJHG (GJDU $OODQ3RH

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


2/39

:LWKLQIRXU\HDUVQODWHDVKLVFRQVFLRXVPLQGZDVXQUDYHOLQJZHHNVEHIRUHKLVILQDOFROODSVHLQ7XULQDQGDVKLVUKHWRULFDOGHIHQVHPHFKDQLVPVWKUHDWHQHGRHYDSRUDWHDORQJZLWKW1LHW]VFKHZDVGUDIWLQJOHWWHURKLVVLVWHUOLWHUDU\[HFXWRUQGZRPDQRIWKH5LJKW(OLVDEHWK)RUVWHU1LHW]VFKH+LVGHIHQVHVSSDUHQWO\ZHUHVWLOOXIILFLHQWO\WURQJKDWKHGLGQRWPDLOWKLVSDUWLFXODUH[WWKRXJKKHZDVWRZULWHLPLODUKLQJVJDLQZKLFKUHDGLQSDUW:KDW,KDYHWRGRLVKRUULILFIXUFKWEDU@QHYHU\HQVHRIWKHZRUG,FKDOOHQJHQRWQGLYLGXDOVFKDOOHQJHKXPDQLW\VDZKROHZLWKP\WHUULI\LQJHQWVHW]OLFKHQ@FFXVDWLRQQRPDWWHUKRZWKHGHFLVLRQPD\IDOORUPHRUDJDLQVWPHLQDQ\FDVHDQXQVSHDNDEOHDPRXQWRIGHVWLQ\QGGLVDVWHUGKHUHVWRP\QDPH$JDLQWKHSUHFLVHQDWXUHRIWKLVHUULI\LQJUKRUULILFFWFKDOOHQJHGHVWLQ\QGGLVDVWHUUHPDLQVKURXGHGLQVHFUHF\HUKDSVWFDQEHVDLGRIWKHUHVXOWLQJRG\RI1LHW]VFKHVZRUNOOXGLQJWR(GJDU$OODQ3RHHVODVVWLFKQLFKWHVHQLWGRHVQRWSHUPLWWVHOIREHUHDGHYHQ DVLWVEHLQJUHDGLQVRPHHYLGHQWIRUP:HVHHPFORVHWRZKDWPLJKWEHFDOOHGWKH1LHW]VFKHDQSUREOHPDWLFIVXEOLPLW\7KHXQUHSUHVHQWHGXEOLPHVQRWQSULQFLSOHRUH[K\SRWKHVLQUHSUHVHQWDEOH1HYHUWKHOHVVRPHZULWHUVU\RUHYHDOWKHLUGHHSHVWPHDQLQJVRQO\WRVRPHUHDGHUVDQGFRQFHDOWKHPIURPWKHPDQ\7KH\FDQDOVRDWWHPSWRFRPPXQLFDWHEHQHDWKWKHWKUHVKROGIFRQVFLRXVQHVVQIOXHQFLQJKHUHDGHUEXWQRWDWWKHOHYHORIFRQVFLRXVUHFHSWLRQQWKLVFDVHWKHVXEOLPHEHFRPHVVXEOLPLQDO7KHVXEOLPHLVDOVRDUDGLFDOO\PELYDOHQWGGLFWLRQXQWRGHDWKQDPHO\WKDWDHVWKHWLFDWLVIDFWLRQKLFKQFOXGHVDVRQHRIWVPRPHQWVQHJDWLYH[SHULHQFHDVKRFNDEORFNDJHDQLQWLPDWLRQIPRUWDOLW\LQFHEHIRUHKLVGHDWKLQLWKDVEHHQFRPPRQIRUUHDGHUVWREHFRPHDGGLFWHGWR1LHW]VFKHVZRUNVRWKH1LHW]VFKHDQXEOLPH7RGD\KRZHYHUKHUHVDOVRDYLUWXDORQVHQVXVWKDW1LHW]VFKHSUDFWLFHGDIRUPRIVHPLRWLFVSOD\ZLWKVLJQV


3/39

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

2QHWKLQJWKDWVNHSWVLOHQWE\WKLVQRQGLDORJXHLV1LHW]VFKHVWDFLWXSSRUWIRUWKHUHTXLVLWHVRFLRHFRQRPLFV\VWHPOOXGHGWRE\WKHLPDJLQDU\QWHUORFXWRUZKLFKVDFNLQJQKLVPRGHUQ*HUPDQ\WKRXJKPHUHQDWLRQDOTXHVWLRQVDUHQRWRIXOWLPDWHRQVHTXHQFH%XWMXVWDVLPSRUWDQWVWKHSHUIRUPDWLYHVSHFWRIVXFKSDVVDJHVWKDWVWKHVSHFLILFPHDVXUHV1LHW]VFKHVZULWLQJQFOXGLQJKLVQRQGLDORJXHHPSOR\VWRUHSURGXFHEHJLQQLQJZLWKKLVUHDGHUVWKHVRFLRHFRQRPLFV\VWHPIOHLVXUHIRUWKHUHILQHGJDLQVWWKHFUXGH7KLVSURMHFWZRXOGORJLFDOO\UHTXLUHWHFKQLTXHVRISHUVXDVLRQWKDWZRXOGWKHPVHOYHVKDYHWRZRUNVLOHQWO\QGKHQFHHYHQLQDQDXGLEOHDQGYLVLEOHWH[WXDOIRUPUHPDLQWRDFHUWDLQH[WHQWQDXGLEOHDQGLQYLVLEOHWPDNHVOLWWOHHQVHPHUHO\WRWDONDERXWVRPHWKLQJLNHVXEOLPLQDOLJHWLFVZLWKRXWWWHPSWLQJRSUDFWLFHW7KHUHLVQR 5(35(6(17$7,216


4/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


5/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


6/39

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

,,/DWH)HEUXDU\IRXQG1LHW]VFKHZULWLQJURPSHQVLRQQ1LFHWRKLVVHFUHWDU\QGIULHQGKHPXVLFLDQQGFRPSRVHUNQRZQV3HWHU*DVW1LHW]

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


7/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


8/39

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

7KHSKLORVRSKHUVISHVVLPLVPSK\VLRORJLFDOHFDGHQWVHJ%DXGHODLUH6FKRSHQKDXHU/HRSDUGLH[XDOGHYLDQFHQWKHEHJLQQLQJLPSRWHQF\IIQGRQDVUHVXOW.*:

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


9/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


10/39

UHVSHFWWRLQGXVWULDOLVPRUZKDWLVXOWLPDWHO\WVWDNHIRU1LHW]VFKHLQ:DJQHUQ%DXGHODLUHDQGLQKLVRZQZRUNVDQDULVWRFUDWLFUDGLFDOQRWWRVD\DOVRDUFKSDWULDUFKDOQGSKDOOLFPRGHIURGXFWLRQ

,,,,WLVODWHDERXWWZRPRQWKVEHIRUH1LHW]VFKHVRZQGHILQLWLYHPHQWDODQGSK\VLFDOROODSVHLQ7XULQ1RZ%DXGHODLUHLVIRU1LHW]VFKHSULYDWHO\MXVWRQHFOLQLFDOIRRWQRWHRUVLJQLQWHUOLDLQWHUDUHVQWKHJOREDOVZDPSRIPRGHUQLVWHOIKDWUHGWKHFDVHRI%DXGHODLUHLQ)UDQFHWKHFDVHRI(GJDU$OODQ3RHLQ$PHULFDWKHFDVHRI:DJQHUQ*HUPDQ\QGVRRQ%XWWKLVUHPDUN

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


11/39

XQSXEOLVKHGSDSHUVRI%DXGHODLUHKLV2HXYUHVRVWKXPHVLHW]VFKHKDVGLVFRYHUHGDFRPPXQLFDWLRQURP:DJQHUWR%DXGHODLUHFLWHGQIXOOE\*DXWLHUQKLVLQWURGXFWLRQ:DJQHUZDVUHVSRQGLQJWRDQDUWLFOHRQKLPWKDW%DXGHODLUHKDGSXEOLVKHGLQWKH$SULOHGLWLRQRI/DUHYXHHXURSHHQH7KLVZDVRQHRIDKDQGIXORIRXUQDOVDWWKHWLPHSRVLWLYHO\HFHSWLYHR%DXGHODLUHVZRUNZLOOUHWXUQRWKHVLJQLILFDQFHIWKHGDWH1LHW]VFKHZKRLVLQUHFLWHV:DJQHUVHWWHUR*DVWDGGLQJ:DJQHUZDVWKHQ\HDUVROG%DXGHODLUHWKHHWWHUVWRXFKLQJKRXJKQPLVHUDEOH)UHQFK.*%:DJQHUVHWWHUODLPVWKDWKHKDGWULHGWRPHHW%DXGHODLUHLQSHUVRQPDQ\WLPHVQ3DULVEXWIDLOHGWRGRVR:DJQHUDOZD\VHDJHUIRUFXOWXUDOLPSHULDOLVWWULXPSKVQWRQHVWKHLPPHQVHDWLVIDFWLRQKDW%DXGHODLUHVDUWLFOHQ/DUHYXHHXURSHHQHDVJLYHQKLPDQGDGGVUDWKHUGLVLQJHQXRXVO\KDWWKDVJLYHQKLVRZQSRRUWDOHQWPRUHHQFRXUDJHPHQWKDQQ\WKLQJOVHKHKDVHYHUUHDGDERXWKLPVHOI+HJRHVRQWRLGHQWLI\LPVHOIVDQHQWKXVLDVWRU%DXGHODLUHVSRHWU\KRSLQJWRFDOOKLPVHOIIULHQG1LHW]VFKHVSDUWLFXODUO\DVFLQDWHGWWKLVSRLQWLQ:DJQHUVHWWHUQWHUMHFWLQJR*DVWWKDWLIDPQRWWRWDOO\HFHLYHGDOHWWHUZLWKKLVNLQGRIJUDWLWXGHQGHYHQHQWKXVLDVP:DJQHUZURWHRQRQO\RQHRWKHURFFDVLRQ.*%2IFRXUVH1LHW]VFKHPHDQVDOHWWHURKLPVHOIQDPHO\RQHZULWWHQIWHU:DJQHUKDGUHFHLYHGDSHUVRQDOO\QVFULEHGRS\RI1LHW]VFKHVILUVWRRNDOVRGHGLFDWHGWR:DJQHU7KH%LUWKI7UDJHG\XWRIWKHSLULWI0XVLFZD\EDFNLQ6R)ULHGULFK1LHW]VFKHVHHPVDW OHDVWIRUDPRPHQWQWR KDYHSRVLWLYHO\GHQWLILHGUHWURDFWLYHO\VZHOODVSUHVHQWO\KURXJKWKHPHGLDWLRQRI5LFKDUG:DJQHUZLWK&KDUOHV%DXGHODLUH


12/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


13/39

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

9$QRWHERRNXVHGE\1LHW]VFKHGXULQJWKHSHULRGH[WHQGLQJIURP1RYHPEHUWR0DUFKFRQWDLQVVRPHVHYHQW\SDJHVRIH[FHUSWVIURP%DXGHODLUHV2HXYUHVRVWKXPHVWFRUUHVSRQGDQFHVQHGLWHV7KHVHSDUWLFXODUH[FHUSWVZHUHEHJXQDWWKHWLPHRIKLVOHWWHUR*DVWLQ)HEUXDU\ZKHQRQHPLJKWKDYHWKRXJKWKHKDGIDUPRUHSUHVVLQJKLQJVRGRZLWKKLVWLPHRZULWH

VHYHUHO\LPLWHGVLWZDVE\KLVPHQWDODQGSK\VLFDOKHDOWK7KLVODUJHQRWHERRNZDVWKHRQHVWLOOHLQJXVHGE\1LHW]VFKHQHDUO\-DQXDU\ZKHQDOOKLVVFUHZV 5(35(6(17$7,216


14/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


15/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


16/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


17/39

DPD]LQJO\GHWDLOHGDQGSUHFLVHPDWHULDOLVWK\VLRJQRPLHVIWKHVRPQDPEXOLVWLFVRFLHW\RIHDUO\FDSLWDOLVPKHQFHPXFKRI%HQMDPLQVIDVFLQDWLRQZLWK%DXGHODLUH

9,)RUKLVSDUW1LHW]VFKHKLPVHOIKDGEHHQJURSLQJWRZDUGDUXGLPHQWDU\DQDO\VLVRIFDSLWDOLVPDOOKLVPDWXUHOLIH+HKDGEHHQLQWURGXFHGWRWKHWKHPHRIDHVWKHWLFUHVLVWDQFHWR$PHULFDQLVPEHOLHILQSURJUHVVZRUVKLSRIPRQH\DVDJRGWKHFRPPRGLILFDWLRQIDUWWKHVRRQWREH7D\ORUL]HGLYLVLRQRIQWHOOHFWXDOQGPDQXDOODERUWKDWRFNHGRXWWKHUHWXUQI5HQDLVVDQFHPDQHWFZKHQKHKDGUHDGDVKHKDGGRQHLQWHQWO\DXWLHUVSUHIDFHWR/HVILHXUVXPDOEDFNLQZKHUHGLVFXVVLRQWXUQVQRWRQO\WR%DXGHODLUHDQGKLVWDNHRQ

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


18/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


19/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


20/39

DWOHDVWRIWKHYXOJDURUWYHQWXDOO\YDSRUDWHGRXWRI1LHW]VFKHVKLQNLQJLVPLVRJ\Q\HFRPLQJPXFKPRUHFRPSOH[

9,,%\1LHW]VFKHVWXUQWRWKH5LJKWKDGORQJVLQFHEHHQDFFRPSOLVKHG,QRWKHUZRUGV1LHW]VFKHVUHHQFRXQWHUZLWK%DXGHODLUHZDVKDUGO\UHTXLUHGWRFDXVHWKLVSLQ5DWKHUKLVQFRXQWHUUHLQIRUFHGWDQGPRUHPSRUWDQWPDNHVLWPRUHYLVLEOHQRZWKDQLWRWKHUZLVHZRXOGEH7KH SUREOHPLQPDNLQJWKHSROLWLFRHFRQRPLFSLQRI1LHW]VFKHVKRXJKWIXOO\YLVLEOHKRZHYHULVWKDWWZDVWRDVLJQLILFDQWHJUHHSURJUDPPHGQGKDQGLFDSSHGE\KLPWREHSRVWKXPRXVUROHSWLF

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


21/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


22/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


23/39

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`KHUHIRUHWVILOWK\7KHHDVWYLOODLQRXVPRQJOOWKRVHGRLQJRPPHUFHVKHZKRVD\VHWVEHYLUWXRXVQRUGHURJHWPXFKPRUHPRQH\KDQKHIRROVZKRUHYLFLRXVRUKHUDGHVPDQGHFHQF\WVHOIVVSHFXODWLRQRUSURILW&RPPHUFHV6DWDQLFHFDXVHWLVRQHRIWKHIRUPVIHJRLVP@@

6WULSSHGRIWKHPHUHO\FRQWLQJHQWDULVWRFUDWLF&KULVWLDQQGDHVWKHWLFUHYXOVLRQJDLQVWWKHERXUJHRLVLHDQGLWVILOWK\IIHPLQDWHXFUHDQGWKHQYLHZHG 5(35(6(17$7,216


24/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


25/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


26/39

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

1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


27/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


28/39

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

,;,QPRUHWKDQ\HDUVVLQFH1LHW]VFKHVELUWKKHXU\LVVWLOO

RXWRQERWKWKHH[LVWHQFHQGVXFFHVVRIKLV:DU3DUW\0\RZQEHVWJXHVVLVWKDW1LHW]VFKHVDXGHODLUH


29/39

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

5(35(6(17$7,216


30/39

WKRXJKLWZRXOGEHQRWKLQJILWZHUHQRWDOOWKLVDVZHOOEXW DOVRSROLWLFRHFRQRPLFQWKHDVWQVWDQFH

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


31/39

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


32/39

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


33/39

DQGLH5HOLJLRQHQHUQLHGHUHQDVVHGHUUDXHQHUNODYHQHU1,&+79251(+0(16WGQGH1LHW]VFKH1)1RYHPEHU0GU].*:7KHUHDUHPDQ\UHIHUHQFHVR(SLFXUHDQSKLORVRSK\WKURXJKRXW1LHW]VFKHVZULWLQJZKLOHVRPHDUHPRUHH[SOLFLWO\SLVWHPRORJLFDOQQDWXUHKLVSDVVDJHLVLQGLFDWLYHIZKDWQWHUHVWHGKLPPRVW 6HOHFWLRQVURPKHULVRQ1RWHERRNVI$QWRQLRUDPVFLGDQGWUDQV4XLQWLQ+RDUHDQG*HRIIUH\RZHOO6PLWK1HZ


34/39

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

1LHW]VFKHV%DXGHODLUH


35/39

LQWKHERG\RIP\HVVD\IURP1LHW]VFKHVH[WFFRUGLQJWRWKHSDJLQDWLRQRIKLVRULJLQDOPDQXVFULSWSDJHVPRVWRIZKLFKDUHFROODWHGE\1LHW]VFKHVHGLWRUVLQ.6$ 6HHIRU[DPSOH/XFH,ULJDUD\0DULQHRYHUIULHGULFKLHW]VFKHUDQV*LOOLDQ&*LOO1HZ


36/39

RIFDSLWDOGLYLVLRQIDERXUZDJHODERXUHWFDSSHDU DVGLVKDUPRQLRXVRKLPZKHUHWKH\DSSHDU LQWKHLUPRVWGHYHORSHGIRUPLQ WKHLUZRUOGPDUNHWIRUPDV WKHLQWHUQDOUHODWLRQVZKLFKSURGXFHWKH(QJOLVKGRPLQDWLRQRQWKHZRUOGPDUNHWQGZKLFKVGHVWUXFWLYHQIOXHQFHVUHWKHFRQVHTXHQFHRIWKLVGRPLQDWLRQ.DUO0DU[*UXQGULVVHRXQGDWLRQVIWKH&ULWLTXHI3ROLWLFDOFRQRP\UDQV0DUWLQ1LFRODXV1HZ


37/39

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


38/39

DQG


39/39

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

waite - nietzsche's baudelaire

Documents