vtt technical research centre of finland …...fir1 research reactor (triga mark ii, 250 kw)...

11
VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND LTD FiR 1 TRIGA research reactor decommissioning project Current and Emerging Methods for Optimising Safety and Efficiency in Nuclear Decommissioning, Sarpborg, Norway. 7.2.2017 Antti Räty ([email protected])

Upload: others

Post on 03-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND LTD

FiR 1 TRIGA research reactordecommissioning project

Current and Emerging Methods for OptimisingSafety and Efficiency in Nuclear Decommissioning,Sarpborg, Norway. 7.2.2017Antti Räty ([email protected])

Page 2: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

227/01/2017 2

Contents

FiR1 TRIGA reactorProject road map and recent progressWaste characterisationPlanned dismantling techniquesLicence applicationChallenges and lessons learned

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 3: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

327/01/2017 3

FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW)

Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh.Early operation: intensive neutron beam research,activation analysisIn-core irradiations for isotope production (82Br, 24Na,140La etc.), activation analysis and irradiation testingFacility for Neutron Capture Therapy constructed

BNCT treatments (> 200 patients) in 1997–2012Special materials to be managed indecommissioning

Operating license valid until 2023Final shutdown 30.6.2015

License to be amended for decommissioningInventory estimates (excluding fuel):

Mass 75 tons (mainly concrete)Volume 40 m3

Activity ~5 TBq (BNCT moderator and steel > 1 TBq)

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 4: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

427/01/2017 4

Decommissioning project road map

Amendment tooperatinglicense

SNF removal &transport Dismantling

LILW storageDecontamination

Etc.

2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022Indicative time scale

Applicationto State Council

Safety caseCompletion of

inventory estimatesDismantling andpackaging plan

AgreementsSNF (US)

LILW interim storage (domestic)Various services

Procurements

etc.

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 5: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

527/01/2017 5

Recent progress and on-going work

Fuel inspection by Idaho National Laboratories in 4/2016Technical dismantling plan and work instruction finalised in1/2017Decommissioning licence application to be send in spring2017On-going negotiations on options for SNF and dismantlingwaste intermediate and final disposal.Material characterisation by measurements to validatecomputational estimates.

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 6: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

627/01/2017 6

Radionuclide inventory calculation at VTT

Component-wise calculations. Altogether around 200 cases.

REACTOROPERATIONALHISTORY

REACTORGEOMETRICSAND MATERIALDISTRIBUTION

MATERIALCOMPOSITION

INPUT FORNEUTRON FLUXCALCULATIONS

CALCULATIONOF NEUTRONFLUXES ANDSPECTRA

INPUT NEUTRONACTIVATIONCALCULATIONS

POINT-DEPLETIONCALCULATIONOF NEUTRONACTIVATION

INVENTORY OFACTIVATEDCOMPONENT

MCNP ORIGEN-S

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 7: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

727/01/2017 7

Measurement scheme

Samples

-spectrometry Chemical sepation forhard-to-measure nuclides

ICP-MS LSC Other specialmethods

Material-wise nuclide vectors

Packeddismantlingwaste

-spectrometry Activity in awaste package

Data on hard-to-measure nuclides

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 8: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

827/01/2017 8

Dismantling planning by BNG

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Phase Work Duration(weeks)

1 Preparatory measures 42 Dismantling of reactor than internals (high activity) 83 Dismantling of cooling circuits and heat exchangers 44 Dismantling of beam tubes and active concrete 135 Dismantling of rest of the systems (low activity) 66 Concluding measures 47 Clearance measurements 13SUM 52

• Remove active parts and continue with normal industrialdismantling

Page 9: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

927/01/2017 9

Decommissioning licence applications

First nuclear facility to be decommissioned in FinlandEnvironmental Impact Assessment was carried out in2014-15Decommissioning licence application to state council inspring 2017. Evaluation takes about a year.Application requires reports e.g. on dismantling plan, riskanalysis, safety & security, decommissioning organisation etc.

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 10: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

1027/01/2017 10

Challenges and lessons learned

Project requires several agreements on SNF anddecommissioning waste. Keep all the options open.SNF nuclear fuel still in the reactors restricts many actions.Lack of operational and material data. Prepare for suprises andpay attention to documentation.Research reactors are also nuclear facilities, same requirementsfor licencing and documentation as for NPP’s.Waste activities and masses are small, but research reactorsoften include special materials. Especially important in wastefinal disposal planning.Train personnel for waste characterisation methods, clearancemeasurements etc. before starting the dismantling.

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor

Page 11: VTT TECHNICAL RESEARCH CENTRE OF FINLAND …...FiR1 research reactor (TRIGA Mark II, 250 kW) Operation for years 1962-2015. Around 11500 MWh. Early operation:intensive neutron beam

1127/01/2017 11

Thank you for your attention!

http://www.vttresearch.com/services/low-carbon-energy/nuclear-energy/decommissioning-of-finlands-first-nuclear-reactor