vibration reduction in x -ray capillary optic fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · lepp reu final...

16
LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP CHESS & LEPP CHESS & LEPP CHESS & LEPP CHESS & LEPP CHESS & LEPP CHESS & LEPP CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X Vibration Reduction in X - - ray ray Capillary Optic Fabrication Capillary Optic Fabrication Justin Hugon 1,3 , Tom Szebenyi 1 , Heung-Soo Lee 1 , Donald Bilderback 1,2 1 Cornell High Energy Synchrotron Source, 2 School of Applied and Engineering Physics, 1,2 Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, 3 Departement of Physics, Rhodes College, Memphis, Tennessee email: [email protected] Designed Slope Measured Slope

Upload: others

Post on 20-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Vibration Reduction in XVibration Reduction in X --ray ray Capillary Optic FabricationCapillary Optic Fabrication

Justin Hugon1,3, Tom Szebenyi1, Heung-Soo Lee1, Donald Bilderback1,2

1Cornell High Energy Synchrotron Source, 2School of Applied and Engineering Physics, 1,2Cornell University, Ithaca, New York, 3Departement of Physics, Rhodes College, Memphis, Tennesseeemail: [email protected]

Designed Slope

Measured Slope

Page 2: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Capillary Optics

Advantages:• Work with any X-ray Energy• Optically & Mechanically

Robust• EfficientDisadvantages:• Not Imaging Optics

Page 3: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

X-ray Science Application: Art History

N.C. Wyeth “Mildest Mannered Man” ca. 1919

N.C. Wyeth “Family Mural Study” ca. 1945

On Top

Underneath

Confocal X-ray Fluorescence: Analyze Buried Layers Non-

Destructively

Page 4: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Capillary Puller

Capillary

Tension Stage

Air Stage(Furnace)

Page 5: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Capillary Evaluation

Optical Metrology Beam Line Evaluation

Far Field X-ray ImageOptical Micrometers

Page 6: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Status of Capillary Fabrication Quality

Profile Errors: 0.5-2 µm rmsSlope Errors: 20-80 µrad rms

Page 7: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Structural Bracing

To Anchor in Floor

Aluminum Cross Bar

Green Bar

View From Above

Tension Stage Support

(Holds Capillary on a String)

Air Stage Support

(Holds Furnace & Metrology)

Capillary in Furnace

Furnace

y

x

Capillary Puller

Page 8: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Structural Bracing, Continued

Improved Puller Structural Bracing

Steel Unistrut

Aluminum Bar

Page 9: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

“Ping Tests in Y-direction”

τ

1/e

τ ~ 10s

τy = 13 s

In General:

Page 10: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPPinged Tension Stage Amplitudes

0

5

10

15

20

25

x y x y x y x y

No-bar Cross-bar Green-bar Green & Cross-bar

Max

imum

Am

plitu

de (µ

m)

Experiment #1 ping tension stage in x

Experiment # 2 ping tension stage in y

Pinged Air Stage Amplitudes

02468

101214161820

x y x y x y x y

No-bar Cross-bar Green-bar Green & Cross-bar

Max

imum

Am

plitu

de (µ

m)

Experiment # 3 ping air stage in x

Experiment # 4 ping air stage in y

“Ping Tests” Continued

Page 11: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

“Ping Tests” ContinuedPinged Tension Stage Amplitudes

0

5

10

15

20

25

x y x y x y x y

No-bar Cross-bar Green-bar Green & Cross-bar

Max

imum

Am

plitu

de (µ

m)

Experiment #1 ping tension stage in x

Experiment # 2 ping tension stage in y

Pinged Air Stage Amplitudes

02468

101214161820

x y x y x y x y

No-bar Cross-bar Green-bar Green & Cross-bar

Max

imum

Am

plitu

de (µ

m)

Experiment # 3 ping air stage in x

Experiment # 4 ping air stage in y

Page 12: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Fundamental Frequency Cantilever Prediction

4

2

2 AL

EIf n

n ρπκ=

12

3bdI =

875.11 =κ

Air Stage: f1 = 100 Hz

Tension Stage: f1 = 45 Hz

Capillary as a String: f1 = 30 Hz

Page 13: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Predictions v. Observations

•Predicted Frequencies Too High

•Maximum Measurable Frequency 5 Hz

•Source of Vibrations Not Air or Tension Stage Supports

Page 14: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Present Capillary Status

Page 15: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Suggestions for Further Improvement

New Structural Bracing

•Further stiffen the mechanical stages against vibrations

•Does ‘string mounting’ of capillary amplify the vibrations?

•Need improved metrology—Need more sensitive on-board optical equip.Off-line viewing of Capillary Interior profile?

Page 16: Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic Fabrication · 2014. 5. 21. · LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008 CHESS & LEPP Vibration Reduction in X -ray Capillary Optic

LEPP REU Final Presentation August 7, 2008

CHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPPCHESS & LEPP

Acknowledgments

Sterling Cornaby

National Science

Foundation

Heung-Soo Lee, Tom Szebenyi (top)Justin Hugon, Don Bilderback