UY BAN NHAN DAN HU YEN EA KAR

CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM Doc lap - Ty do - Hanh phuc

Ea Kar, ngay ^-E thdngndm 2018S°: Y5-&f/C V-UBND

Ve viec tra lai dan cua 07 ho gia dinli, ca nhan thirdng tru tai. thon Cir An, xa Cir Hue,

huyen Ea Kar, t?nh Dak Lak

Kinh gui: Ho ong Pham Duy Ngoc, ong Bui Cong Kho, ong Nguyen Due Ngu, ong Hira Van Due, ong Thi Van Nghiep, ba Pham Thi Kim Thoa va ba Hoang Thi Peng (07 ho gia dinh, ca nhan) thuong tru tai thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar, tinh Dak Lak

UBND huyen Ea Kar nhan dirge Don kien nghi de ngay 18/7/2018 cua 07 ho gia dinh, ca nhan, gom: (ong Pham Duy Ngoc, ong Bui Cong Kho, ong Nguyen Due Ngu, ong Hua Van Due, ong Thi Van Nghiep, ba Pham Thi Kim Thoa va ba Hoang Thi Peng) cu tru tai thon Cu an, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar, tinh Dak Lak.

Noi dung kien nghi: Chung toi gom 07 ho gia dinh dang sinh song tai thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar, tinh Dak Lak. Tu khi thanh lap huyen Ea Kar den nay, da co con duong di lai thong thuong tu nha ong Chau den nha ong Khanh, tiep giap vai duong lien thon Cu An - thon Hap Thanh. Vay ma, UBND huyen Ea Kar cap giay chung nhan QSD dat cho gia dinh ong Doan Van. Kim, ngay 02/06/1991 chong len con dudng dan sinh cua 07 ho gia dinh chung toi. Theo quy dinh cua Luat dat dai khi cap GCNQSD dat phai co bien ban kiem tra hien trang thuc dia nhung vo tinh hay co y lai cap chong len con duong dan sinh do. Nam 2012, ong Doan Van Nhanh dugc anh trai la ong Doan Van Kim cho dat dien rich 1.000nr va ong Kim dong y cam ket hien dat de UBND xa cung ba con thon Cu An ma duong. Den nam 2013, UBND xa Cu Hue phot hap cung vai cac ban nganh doan the cua xa va Ban tu quan thon Cu An den de giai quyet ma rong duang thi ong Kim ngan can khong cho ma duang.

Tu thang 3 nam 2018 den nay, dac biet ngay 16/7/2018, gia dinh ong Kim da rao bit luon khong cho cac ho di lai. Mac du UBND xa Cu Hue da 05 Ian hoa giai tai UBND xa va 03 lan van dong tai nha ong Kim nhung khong thanh. Nav cac ho dan chung toi de nghi UBND huyen Ea Kar giai quyet thu hoi Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat da cap cho ho ong Doan Van Kim nam 1991 va dieu chinh tra lai phan duang dan sinh cho chung toi. (Con duang dan sinh do co tu truac nam 1986, truac khi Nha nuac cap giay chung nhan QSD dat cho gia dinh ong Kim).

Qua xem xet noi dung kien nghi cua cong dan, tren ca sa noi dung Bdo cao ngay 26/12/2018 cua To kiem tra, xac minh dugc thanh lap theo Quyet dinh s6: 783/QD-UBND, ngay 15/10/2018, UBND huyen Ea Kar nhan thay nhu sau:

I. Ket qua kiem tra, xac minh

y-'-'

.7• I

iV•« ' •V

'N <5

1

1. Kct qua giai quyet cua UBND xa Cir Hue.Ngay 03/3/2018, 07 ho gia dinh, ca nhan tai thon Cu an, xa Cir Hue co don kien

nghi ve viec nam 2012, ong Doan Van Nhanh la em trai ong Doan Van Kim dirge ong Kim cho dk lam nha o, dien tich 1.000m2. Ong Kim dong y cam ket voi UBND xa Cu Hue hien dat de nhan dan mo rong duong theo tieu chuan dirang giao thong nong thon. Din nam 2013, UBND xa Cu Hue cung Ban tu quan thon Cu An den de giai quyet md rong dudng thi ong Kim ngan can kliong cho md dudng. Tu do tqi-nay gia dinh ong Nhanh gay can trd cho cac ho gia dinh chung toi, do dat da va cac loai rac thai... Hien nay con dudng chi con lai hon 01m rat khd khan cho viec di lai sinh boat, gay nhieu buc xuc cho cac gia dinh chung tdi. Cac hd de nghi giai quyet de cd con dudng di thuan lai, khdng de tinh trang ngan chan dudng di.

Ngay 11/4/2018, UBND xa Cu Hue tien hanh hoa giai tranh chap dat dai. Tai buoi hoa giai UBND xa Cu Hue da ket luan de nghi ho gia dinh ong Doan Van Kim, ong Doan Van Nhanh phai de nguyen dudng di theo hien trang rong 2,2m, khdng duoc gay can trd cho cac ho, ket qua hoa giai khdng thanh. Sau do 07 hd dan tiep tuc cd nhieu don kien nghi gui den Sd Tai nguyen va Mdi trudng tinh, UBND huyen va cac phdng ban chuyen mdn de nghj giai quyet. Sau do don kien nghj cua edng dan tiep tuc duoc chuyen ve UBND xa Cu Hue giai quyet theo tham quyen.

Ngay 11/7/2018, UBND xa Cu Hue tiep tuc to chuc hoa giai tranh chap dudns di. Tai budi hoa giai, UBND xa da ket luan: Xet ve mat can cu phap ly, nhu ban do do

r * \ r f

dac nam 1987 da dirge cac cap cd tham quyen phe duyet va giay chung nhan QSD dat da dugc UBND huyen Ea Kar cap cho cac gia dinh dung theo quy dinh cua phap luat, trong do cd gia dinh dng Kim, thua dat khdng cd the hien dudng di qua. Do do, dng Kim cd quyen sir dung dat theo giay chung nhan da cap. Tuy nhien, xet ve mat thuc te, dudng di cd tu trude, nhimg do so xuat trong do-dac nen khdng the hien, ke ve trong ban do dia chinh nam 1987. Vi vay, phai de dudng di chung cho toan thon, chieu rong la 2,5m, nhimg vdi dieu kien, cac ben phai thda thuan vdi nhan sao cho hop ly, hop tinh. Tuy nhien cac ben khdng thda thuan dugc vdi nhau nen ket qua hoa giai khdng thanh. UBND xa Cu Hue de nghi gia dinh dng Doan Van Kim va dng Doan Van Nhanh trong thdi gian chd co quan cd tham quyen giai quyet thi phai giu nguyen hien trang dudng di, chieu rong mat dudng la 2,2m, din khi cd kit qua giai quylt cua co quan cd tham quyen. Hudng dan cac ben khdi kien tai tda an nhan dan huyen Ea Kar de dugc giai quyet theo tham quyen.

2. Ket qua kiem tra, xac minh ve hd so’ va trinh tir, thii tuc cap giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat cho ho dng Doan Van Kim.

Nam 1987, Chi cue quan ly dat dai tinh Dak Lak (nay la sd Tai nguyen va Mdi trudng) tien hanh do dac, lap ban do va phdi hgp vdi UBND xa Cu Hue to chuc ke khai, dang ky, hoan thien hd so va to chuc edng khai hd so theo quy dinh trinh UBND huyen Ea Kar phe duyet ky cap giay chung nhan QSD dat cho nhan dan theo Quyet dinh sd 28/QD-UBND, ngay 02/06/1991; Quylt dinh sd 57/QD-UB, ngay 09/10/1991 (trong do cd hd dng Doan Van Kim va vg la Le Thi Quyen) dugc cap GCNQSD dat

* ' r r i

cung dot. Ho so xin cap giay chirng nhan QSD cho cac ho thdi diem nam 1991 chi liru tru 01 ban tai So Tai nguyen va Moi trirong. UBND xa Cu Hue chi luu ban do dm chinh; so miic ke; so dang ky ruong dat (nay la so dia chinh), ngoai ra khong co luu tru ho so nao khac.

To kiem tra, xac minh da lien he voi Trung tam luu tru thuoc So Tai nguyen va Moi trubng de xin sao luc ho so cap GCNQSD dat nam 1991 va nam 1998 cho cac ho ong Doan Van Kim va vg la ba Le Thi Quyen (dugc cap GCNQSD dat nam 1991); Hg ong Thi Quoc Dinh (dugc cap GCNQSD dat nam 1991); Hg ong Hua Van Lim (dugc cap GCNQSD dat nam 1991); Hg ong Bui Cong Kho (dugc cap GCNQSD dat nam 1998); Hg ba Nguyen Thi Hue (dugc cap GCNQSD dat nam 1998) thi khong tim thay ho so cap GCNQSD dat cua cac ho ong Doan Van Kim, Ho ong Thi Quoc Dinh va Hua Van Lim dugc cap GCNQSD dat nam 1991 ma chi co ho so cap GCNQSD dat cua hg ong Bui Cong Kho va ho ba Nguyen Thi Hue dugc cap nam 1998 co ho so luu tru day du.

- Kiem tra ban do dia chinh:+ Ban do do dac nam 1987 dugc phe duyet ngay 06/05/1993 cho thay: To ban

do dia chinh so 11, tai cac thua dat: thua so 206b, dien tich 200m2 (ba Nguyen Thi Hue); thua 169b, dien tich 1.595m2 (ong Thuy); thua 169a, dien tich 930m2 (ong Doan Van Kim); thua 169, dien tich 1140m2 (ong Pham Duy Nggc); thua 201, dien tich 1070m2 (ong Thi Quoc Dinh); thua 202, dien tich 1.425m2 (ong Hua Van Due nhan thira ke tir ong Hua Van Lim); thua 206, dien tich 1365m2 (ong Doan Van Kim); thua 207, dien tich 1090m2 (ong Doan Van Kim); thua 210, dien tich 1232m2 (ba Pham Thi Kim Thoa); thua 211, dien tich 1470m2 (ong Vuong Van Thanh), doan tir nha ong

Thiiy den nha ong Kho khong the hien duong di qua cac thira dat.7A A***'+ Ban do do dac nam 1998: tuong dong voi ban do do dac nam 1987, nay la to

ban do so 31, tai cac thira dat: thira so 265, dien tich 405m2 (ba Hue); thira 259, dien tich 1710m2 (ong Thuy); thira 268, 269, dien tich 856m2 (ong Kim); thira 270, 271, dien tich 1417m2 (ong Nggc); thira 315, dien tich 815m2 (ong Due); thira 267, dien tich 1760m2 (ong Kim); thira 316, dien tich 1520m2 (ba Thoa); thira 320, dien tich 1410m2 (ong Kho), doan tir nha ong Thuy den nha ong Kho co the hien duong di, di qua thira

r 7 >

dat cua ong Kim. Vi thoi diem do dac ban do dia chinh ong Doan Van Kim tu mo duong rong 02m de di.

+ Ban do do dac nam 2013: tuong dong voi ban do do dac nam 1987 va 1998, nay la to ban do so 111, tai cac thira dat: thira so 256, dien tich 411m" (ba Hue); thira 238, dien tich 2038m2 (ong Thuy); thira 244, dien tich 852m2 (ong Kim); thira 243, dien tich 1525m2 (ong Nggc); thira 255, dien tich 1740m2 (ong Dire); thira 264, dien tich 2531m2 (ong Kim. Do hgp 2 thira 206, 207 do nam 1987 thanh 01 thira do nam 2013); thira 274, dien tich 1577m2 (ba Thoa) va to ban do so 115, thira 04, dien tich 1560m2 (ong Kho), doan tir nha ong Thuy den nha ong Kho co the hien duong di.

- Kiem tra so muc ke, so dia chinh nam 1987:

35i-r-A

«-

3

- So muc ke ruong dat (quyen pho to): Tai thua 206, dien tich 1.365m“, ghi ten Tong Dinh Anh; thua 207, dien tich 1090m2 ghi ten Lim Thi Loan; thua 169b, dien tich 654m2 ghi ten Doan Van Kim; thua 169a, dien tich 900m2 ghi ten Huynh Ngoc Thirng; thua so 206b khong ghi trong so; thua 169, dien tich 1.540 m2 va 850 m2, ghi gom nhieu ho (ong Dat, ong Thuy; ong Hoan); thua 202, dien tich 1.600m2 ghi ten Hua Van Lim; thua 210, dien tich 1.020m2 ghi ten Bui Cong Kho; thua 211, dien tich 995m2 ghi ten Tran Hai Dang; (thua 21 la, dien tich 1470m2 ghi ten Nguyen Thj Thinh);

•* r •> r r \ r

- So dang ky ruong dat (so dia chinh): ong Tong Dinh Anh, to ban do so 01, thua dat so 31, dien tich 850m2 dat khu dan cu va to ban do so 02, thua dat so 33; 49, dien tich 14.820m2 dat trong cay lau nam; ong Doan Van Kim, to ban do so 11, thua dat so 169a; 206, dien tich 2295m2 dat a va dat nong nghiep va to ban do so 02, thua dat so 32, dien tich 7884m2 dat trong cay lau nam; ba Luu Thi Loan, to ban do so 11, thua dat so 207, dien tich 1090m2 dat a; ba Le Thi Quyen khong co ten trong so dia chinh. Ong

Thi Quoc Dinh va Hua Van Lim co ten trong so dm chinh, dien tich dat nhu giay chung nhan da cap.

- Ve nguon goc va viec cap Giay chung nhan QSD dat cho ho ong Doan VanKim:

+ Ve nguon goc sir dung dat: Thira dat so 169a, 32, to ban do so 11, 02 dien7 • • ' ' ' *tich 8814m ho ong Doan Van Kim khai hoang sir dung; thira so 206, to ban do so 11,

dien tich 1365m“ ho ong Kim nhan chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat cua ong Tong Dinh Anh; Thira so 207, to ban do so 11, dien tich 1090m2 dat a, ba Le Thi Quyen (vo ong Doan Van Kim) nhan chuyen nhuong quyen sir dung dat cim ba Luu Thi Loan (vo ong Tong Dinh Anh).

Ngay 02/06/1991, ong Doan Van Kim dirge UBND huyen Ea Kar cap giay chung nhan QSD dat so A 088489, tai thira dat so 169a dien tich 930m2; thira so 206 dien tich 1365m2, to ban do so 11 va thira so 32 dien tich 7884m2, to ban do so 02, tong dien tich 10.179m2, muc dich sir dung: dat o va dat san xuat nong nghiep, dia chi thira dat thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar; Ngay 09/10/1991, UBND huyen Ea Kar cap giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so A 193432 cho ba Le Thi Quyen (vo ong Doan Van Kim) voi dien tich 1.090m2, tai thira dat so 207; to ban do so 11, muc dich sir dung: dat khu dan cu, dia chi thira dat tai thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar, tinh Dak Lak. Viec cap GCNQSD dat cho ho ong Kim, ba Quyen la theo ban do do dac nam 1987 dugc UBND xa Cu Hue, UBND huyen Ea Kar va Chi cue quan ly dat dai tinh Dak Lak phe duyet ngay 06/05/1993. Tren ban do va tren GCNQSD dat

r •»

dugc cap khong the hien duemg di.Ngay 04/5/2009, ba Le Thi Quyen co don xin cap doi, cap lai giay chirng nhan

A 193432 thira dat so 207; to ban do so 11, dien tich 1090m2, muc dich sir dung: dat khu dan cu, dat trong cay hang nam khac; dia chi thira dat tai thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar, tinh Dak Lak. Ly do cap doi, cap lai: ba Le Thi Quyen lap thii tuc tach thira dat so 207 thanh 02 thira va dugc UBND huyen Ea Kar cap lai Giay chirng nhan QSD dat so AP 4728745, ngay 06/10/2009, thuoc thira dat so 272, to ban do so 11,

4

dien tich 90m2, muc dich su dung: dat a nong thon, dia chi thua dc4t tai thon Cu An, xa

Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar, tinh Dak Lak va Giay chimg nhan QSD dat so AP 472874, ngay 06/10/2009, thuoc thua dat so 207, to ban do so 11, dien tich 1.000m2, muc dich su dung: 310m2 dat a nong thon, 690m2 dat trong cay hang nam khac, dia chi thua dat tai thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar, tinh B4k L4k. Tren GCNQSD dk dugc cap lai cung khong the hien dudng di.

Trong qua trinh lap thu tuc cap GCNQSD dk cho ho ong Kim, ba Quyln, UBND huyen Ea Kar khong nhan dugc bat ky don khieu nai, khieu kien ve trinh tu, thu tuc cap giay chung nhan va tinli trang tranh chap dat dai.

Nam 2009, ho ong Doan Van Kim lap giay tang cho ong Doan Van Nhanh (ong Nhanh la em trai ong Kim), mot phan dien tich cua thua dat so 207, to ban d6 so 11, theo giay chung nhan QSD dat s6 AP 472874, cdp ngay 06/10/2009. Tuy nhien din nay, ong Kim va ong Nhanh chua den co quan nha nuoc de lam thu tuc tang cho, dang ky bien dong QSD dat theo quy dinh cua phap luat.

Ngoai ho ong Kim thi co ho ong Hua Van Lim dugc c4p GCNQSD dk ngay 02/06/1991, tai thua dat so 202, to ban do s6 11, dien tich 1.425m2 (nam 2017 thua k! toan bo dien tich thua dat cho con la ong Hua Van Due); ho ong Vucmg Van Thanh, ba Ly Thi Hien (la con cua ba Ly Thi Peng), dugc UBND huyen Ea Kar cap giay chung nhan QSD dat s6 AG 858747, cdp ngay 29/12/2006, thua dlt s6 211, to ban d6 so 11, dien tich 1470m2 (nguon goc nhan thira ke theo ban do do nam 1987) theo ban

do do dac nam 1987 thi tren ban do va tren GCNQSD dat cung khong thi hien co duong di.x........................................................ ^ &&

D6i voi cac ho: ong Bui Cong Kho, ho ong Pham Duy Nggc, Hg ba NguyenThi Hue, ong Nguyen Due Ngu dugc UBND huyen Ea Kar cap giay chung nhan QSD dat theo ban do do dac nam 1998 thi tren ban do va tren GCNQSD dat co the hien • '/j^

dudng di qua thua dat. Rieng ba Nguyen Thi Kim Thoa chua dugc clp GCNQSD dat. W■ i"

X A a r3. Kiem tra ve hien trang sir dung dat va con dudng di.Theo ket qua kiem tra ve hien trang su dung dat cua ho ong Kim va con dudng

di do UBND xa Cu Hue va phdng Tai nguyen va Moi trudng xac dinh: Gia dinh ong Doan Van Kim dang su dung cac thua dat so 264; 244, td ban do so 111, do dac nam 2013 vdi tong dien tich 3857,5m2 (dien tich nay da tru dudng di 5m x 28m = 140m2). Hien khu vuc nay co 07 ho dang sinh song, dudng co chieu rong khong dong deu: doan dau rong 4,76m, doan giua 2,12m, doan cuoi giap dat ong Kim rong 3,95m). UBND xa Cu Hue xac dinh vi tri con dudng ma 07 ho dan kien nghi thuoc thua dat so 207; td ban do so 11, dien tich 1.090m2 dugc cap cho ba Le Thi Quyen nam 1991 nay la thua dat so 207, td ban do so 11, dien tich 1.000m2 cap ngay 06/10/2009. Hien

r

trang ong Nhanh, ong Kim da ke da, dao dat, chat hang rao dam but chan dudng di, long dudng con 0,5m. Doan dudng di qua thua dat cua ong Kim khong phai la 16i di duy nhat cua 07 ho dan ma tren thuc te da co dudng di ra thon Hgp Thanh.

5

II. Nhan xct, ket luanCan cu vao ket qua lam viec vai cac to chirc, ho gia dinh, ca nhan lien quan.

> r t

Tren co so ho so, chimg cu, tai lieu thu thap dirge den thdi diem hien tai, UBNDr

huyen Ea Kar nhan xet va ket luan nhu sau:

- Thiv nhdt: Can cu vao ban do dia chinh to ban do so 11 do nam 1987 dugc cac cap co tham quyen phe duyet nam 1993, tai cac thua dat so 206b; 169b; 169a; 169; 202; 206; 207; 210; 211 va tren Giay chimg nhan QSD dat da cap cho cac ho gia dinh, ca nhan, trong do co ho ong Doan Van Kim va vg la ba Le Thi Quyen dugc cap Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so A 088489, tai thua dat so 169a dien tich 930m2; thua so 206 dien tich 1.365m2, to ban do so 11 va thua so 32 dien tich 7.884m2, to ban

do so 02 cap cho ho ong Doan Van Kim ngay 02/6/1991 va Giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so A 193432 voi dien tich 1.090m2, tai thua dat so 207; tb ban do so 11

' r a

cap cho ba Le Thi Quyen (vg ong Doan Van Kim) ngay 09/10/1991 thi tren ban do var r i r

tren GCNQSD dat dugc cap khong the hien duemg di va tai trang 03 giay chung nhan quyen sir dung dat so AP 472874 dugc UBND huyen Ea Kar cap ngay 06/10/2009 cho ho ong Doan Van Kim va vg la ba Le Thi Quyen thi trich luc thua dat cung khong the hien duang di. Theo to ban do dia chinh so 31, do dac 1998 co the hien duang di la do ong Kim tu mo duong rong 02 m de di. Trong do co ca ho ong Hua Van Lim, ho ba Ly Thi Peng dugc UBND huyen Ea Kar cap GCNQSD dat cung thoi diem voi ho ong Kim, ba Quyen nam 1991 theo ban do do dac nam 1987 thi tren ban do va tren GCNQSD dat cung khong the hien co duang di.

- Thiv hai: Ve quy trinh thuc hien cac thu tuc hanh chinh ve dat dai doi voi viec cap moi giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat cho ho ong Doan Van Kim, ba Le Thi Quyen, trong do co cac ho: ho ong Hua Van Lini, ho ba Ly Thi Peng cap GCNQSD dat cung thoi diem nam 1991 da dugc UBND xa Cu Hue thuc hien va trinh UBND huyen phe duyet la dung, du trinh tu, thu tuc quy dinh cua phap luat. Trong qua trinh lap thu tuc cap GCNQSD dat cho ho ong Kim, ba Quyen, UBND xa Cu Hue, UBND

A AAA r r 'huyen Ea Kar khong nhan dugc bat ky don khieu nai, khieu kien ve trinh tu, thu tuc cap giay chimg nhan va tinh trang tranh chap dat dai. Doi vai cong tac dang ky bien dong dat dai (cap doi cap lai giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat) cho ho ong Doan Van Kim, ba Nguyen Thi Quyen dugc Van phong Dang ky quyen su dung dat thuc hien dung trinh tu, thu tuc quy dinh cua phap luat.

Thiv ba: Theo quy dinh tai khoan 6, Dieu 49 Luat dat dai nam 1987 nay la khoan 5, Dieu 166 Luat dat dai nam 2013 quy dinh Quyen chung cua nguai su dungdat:

\ r 1 a \ r ^ r. ... “5. Duac Nha nude bdo ho khi nguai khde xdm pham quyen, lai ich hop phap ve ddt dai ciia rninh ”...

Viec ho ong Kim lam giay cho tana phan dien tich 1.000m2 thuoc thua so 207,^t^AA ^ * * •> * #

to ban do so 11 cho em trai la ong Doan Van Nhanh, trona do co the hien viec ho ong Kim cam ket hien phan dien tich dat 42m“ (2m x 21m) de lam duang lien thon do ban do do dac nam 1991 khong the hien duang di den nam 1998 do dac lai thi co the hien

6

dirong di, nhung UBND xa Cir Hue chua lam ho so de nghi UBND huyen Ea Kar ra Quyet dinh thu hoi phan dien tich dat ho ong Kim hien de lam dudng di chung nen phan dien tich dat nay van thuoc quyen su dung cua ho ong Kim va den thoi diem nay ho ong Kim va ong Nhanh chua den co quan nha nuoc de lam thu tuc tang cho, dang ky bien dong QSD dat theo quy dinh cua phap luat.

Tu nhung can cu tren, ket luan: Viec 07 ho gia dinh, ca nhan de nghi UBND huyen Ea Kar thu hoi Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat A 088489, dupe UBND huyen Ea Kar cap ngay 02/06/1991 cho ong Doan Van Kim, tai thua dat so 169a dien tich 930m"; thua so 206 dien tich 1365m2, to ban do so 11 va thua so 32 dien tich

7884m", to ban do so 02, muc dich su dung: dat a va dat san xuat nong nghiep, dia chi thua dat thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen Ea Kar va Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so A 193432 dupe UBND huyen Ea Kar cap ngay 09/10/1991 cho ba Le Thi Quyen (vp ong Doan Van Kim) voi dien tich 1.090m2, tai thua dat so 207; to ban do

' r r

so 11, muc dich su dung: Dat khu dan cu, dia chi thua dat tai thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue,r r r t

huyen Ea Kar, tinh Dak Lak (dupe cap lai ngay 06/10/2009) de tra lai con duong dan sinh cho cac hp di lai la khong co co so de thu hoi GCNQSD dat theo quy dinh tai diem d, khoan 2 Dieu 106 Luat dat dai nam 2013. Vi dien tich dat nay thuoc quyen sir dung dat cua hp ong Doan Van Kim va vp la ba Quyen da dupe UBND huyen Ea Kar cap giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so A 193432 ngay 09/10/1991, thua dat so 207, dien tich 1090m2 (cap doi cap lai ngay 06/10/2009) theo dung, du trinh tu, thu

tuc quy dinh cua phap luat ve dat dai.r r r

Mat khac, dien tich con dudng dang tranh chap khong phai la loi di duy nhat cua 07 hp dan. Do do, neu 07 hp dan muon mb dudng di qua thua dat nha ong Doan Van Kim thi cac hp dan phai tu thoa thuan den bli, ho trp cho hp ong Doan Van Kim theo quy dinh cua phap luat. Truong hop khong thoa thuan dupe thi can cu vao Dieu 254 Bp Luat Dan su nam 2015 de nghi 07 hp gia dinh, ca nhan lam don khbi kien gui den Toa an nhan dan huyen Ea Kar de dupe giai quyet theo tham quyen. Vi UBND xa Cu Hue da to chuc hoa giai vu viec theo dung quy dinh tai Dieu 202, Luat dat dai nam 2013; Dieu 88, Nghi dinh 43/2014/ND-CP, ngay 15/5/2014 cua Chinh phu Quy dinh chi tiet thi hanh mot so dieu cua Luat dat dai 2013.

Tu nhung npi dung tren, UBND huyen Ea Kar tra Idi don cua 07 hp gia dinh, ca nhan vbi npi dung nhu sau:

- Viec 07 hp gia dinh, ca nhan, thudng tru tai thon Cu An, xa Cu Hue, huyen^ y r y r

Ea Kar de nghi UBND huyen Ea Kar thu hoi Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat A 088489, dupe UBND huyen Ea Kar cap ngay 02/06/1991 cho ong Doan Van Kim va Giay chung nhan quyen su dung dat so A 193432 dupe UBND huyen Ea Kar cap ngay 09/10/1991 cho ba Le Thi Quyen (dupe cap lai ngay 06/10/2009) de tra lai con dudng dan sinh cho cac hp di lai la khong co co sb de giai quyet, vi: UBND huyen Ea Kar cap GCNQSD dat cho hp ong Kim, ba Quyen la theo dung, du trinh tu, thu tuc quy dinh cua phap luat, khong co co sb phap ly de thu hoi GCNQSD dat da cap cho hp ong Doan Van Kim theo quy dinh tai diem d, khoan 2 Dieu 106 Luat dat dai nam 2013. Dien tich dat nay thuoc quyen sir dung dat cua hp ong Doan Van Kim va vp la

'll/

7

^ /\ , • A /i r yba Le Thi Quyen dirge cap GCNQSD dat theo ban do do dac nam 1987 dirge cac co quan co tham quyen phe duyet nam 1993 khong the hien dirdng di.

- Neu 07 ho dan muon md dirdng di qua thira dat nha dng Doan Van Kim thi cac ho dan phai tir thda thuan den bu, ho trg cho hg dng Doan Van Kim theo quy dinh cua phap luat. Truong hop khong thoa thuan dirge thi de nghi lam don khdi kien giri den Tda an nhan dan huyen Ea Kar de duoc giai quyet theo tham quyen theo quy dinh

••A /\A/\ ' ' ' • r y ^tai Dieu 254 Bo Luat Dan sir nam 2015 ve quyen 16i di qua bat dong san lien ke.Uy ban nhan dan huyen Ea Kar tra Idi cho 07 ho gia dinh, ca nhan dirge bie^ j^

Noi nhan:- Nhir tren (de biet);- UBND tinh (thay b/c);- Thanh tra tinh (thay b/c);- Sd TN&MT tinh (b/c);- TT. HBND huyen (b/c);- CT, D/c Chi4n PCT UBND huyen;- Thanh tra huyen, Phong TN&MT;- Chi nhanh VP DKDD huyen;- Ban tiep cong dan huyen;- UBND xaCu Hue;- Ho 6ng Doan Van Kim (biet);- Luu: ho so, Vt.

CHU TICH ,KTXHtiTlCH

CHI):»

>......

8