PUBLIC

UNITED STATES OF AMERICAFEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION

OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGES

In the Matter of

Tronox Limited,a corporation,

National Industrialization Company(TASNEE)

a corporation, DOCKET NO. 9377

National Titanium Dioxide CompanyLimited (Cristal)

a corporation, and

Cristal USA Inc.a corporation,

Respondents.

ORDER ON RESPONDENT CRISTAL'S IN CAMERA DOCUMENTS

Pursuant to Rule 3.45(b) of the Commission's Rules of Practice and the Scheduling Orderentered in this matter, Respondent National Industrialization Company (TASNEE), the NationalTitanium Dioxide Company Limited, and Cristal USA Inc. (collectively, "Cristal") filed motionsfor in camera treatment for certain materials that the parties listed on their exhibit lists.

The motions were resolved by the Orders issued May 15, 2018, May 30, 3018, and June21, 2018 ("Cristal In Camera Orders" ). Attachment A of this Order lists all Cristal documentsfor which in camera treatment has been granted by the Cristal In Camera Orders, thecorresponding PX or RX numbers, and each document's in camera treatment expiration date.

ORDERED;D. Michael ChappellChief Administrative Law Judge

Date: June 28, 2018

06 28 2018 591382

= aKxhibit Io Cumero Exbibi>t !is „'Cameru~ Ãamber Ex iration Number Ex iration Number Ex iration PX0001 June I, 2028 PX2070 June I, 2023 PX2158 June I, 2023 PX0002 June I, 2028 PX2077 June I, 2023 PX2162 June I, 2023 PX0005 June I, 2028 PX2088 June I, 2023 PX2163 June I, 2028 PX0012 June I, 2028 PX2089 June I, 2028 PX2164 June I, 2028 PX0013 June I, 2023 PX2090 June I, 2023 PX2165 June I, 2028 PX0014 June I, 2023 PX2091 June I, 2023 PX2167 June I, 2023 PX0015 June I, 2028 PX2092 June I, 2023 PX2171 June I, 2028 PX0016 June I, 2028 PX2094 June I, 2023 PX2172 June I, 2028 PX0019 June I, 2028 PX2098 June I, 2023 PX2173 June I, 2023 PX0020 June I, 2028 PX2100 June I, 2023 PX2174 June I, 2028 PX0024 June I, 2023 PX2102 June I, 2028 PX2175 June I, 2028 PX2000 June I, 2028 PX2105 June I, 2023 PX2177 June I, 2028 PX2002 June I, 2028 PX2106 June I, 2023 PX2178 June I, 2028 PX2004 June I, 2023 PX2108 June I, 2023 PX2179 June I, 2028 PX2006 June I, 2023 PX2109 June I, 2023 PX2180 June I, 2028 PX2007 June I, 2023 PX2110 June I, 2023 PX2181 June I, 2028 PX2008 June I, 2028 PX2112 June I, 2028 PX2183 June I, 2028 PX2009 June I, 2028 PX2113 June I, 2023 PX2184 June I, 2028 PX2011 June I, 2028 PX2116 June I, 2028 PX2187 June I, 2028 PX2014 June I, 2023 PX2121 June I, 2023 PX2189 June I, 2028 PX2016 June I, 2023 PX2122 June I, 2028 PX2190 June I, 2028 PX2020 June I, 2023 PX2123 June I, 2023 PX2193 June I, 2028 PX2021 June I, 2023 PX2124 June I, 2028 PX2196 June I, 2023 PX2025 June I, 2023 PX2125 June I, 2028 PX2197 June I, 2023 PX2026 June I, 2023 PX2128 June I, 2023 PX2198 June I, 2028 PX2027 June I, 2023 PX2129 June I, 2028 PX2199 June I, 2028 PX2029 June I, 2023 PX2130 June I, 2023 PX2200 June I, 2028 PX2031 June I, 2028 PX2132 June I, 2028 PX2201 June I, 2028 PX2036 June I, 2023 PX2133 June I, 2028 PX2202 June I, 2028 PX2038 June I, 2028 PX2134 June I, 2028 PX2204 June I, 2028 PX2039 June I, 2028 PX2135 June I, 2023 PX2205 June I, 2028 PX2041 June I, 2028 PX2137 June I, 2023 PX2206 June I, 2028 PX2042 June I, 2028 PX2138 June I, 2023 PX2207 June I, 2028 PX2046 June I, 2023 PX2140 June I, 2023 PX2208 June I, 2028 PX2047 June I, 2028 PX2142 June I, 2028 PX2209 June I, 2023 PX2049 June I, 2023 PX2143 June I, 2028 PX2210 June I, 2028 PX2050 June I, 2023 PX2144 June I, 2028 PX2211 June I, 2028 PX2054 June I, 2023 PX2147 June I, 2023 PX2217 June I, 2028 PX2055 June I, 2023 PX2149 June I, 2028 PX2218 June I, 2023 PX2059 June I, 2023 PX2151 June I, 2028 PX2219 June I, 2023 PX2060 June I, 2023 PX2152 June I, 2028 PX2220 June I, 2023 PX2061 June I, 2023 PX2153 June I, 2028 PX2221 June I, 2028 PX2062 June I, 2023 PX2154 June I, 2028 PX2227 June I, 2023 PX2065 June I, 2023 PX2155 June I, 2028 PX2228 June I, 2023 PX2068 June I, 2028 PX2156 June I, 2023 PX2234 June I, 2028 PX2069 June I, 2023 PX2157 June I, 2023 PX2236 June I, 2028

exhibit Exhibit Ia Caraara< ln Camera Y umber Ex irntion" 'Wuntber iration i%umber ~ Ex irstion PX2239 June I, 2028 PX2316 June I, 2023 PX2401 June I, 2028 PX2244 June I, 2023 PX2318 June I, 2028 PX2402 June I, 2028 PX2245 June I, 2028 PX2322 June I, 2028 PX2404 June I, 2028 PX2246 June I, 2028 PX2328 June I, 2023 PX2406 June I, 2028 PX2247 June I, 2028 PX2329 June I, 2023 PX2407 June I, 2028 PX2248 June I, 2028 PX2330 June I, 2028 PX2408 June I, 2028 PX2249 June I, 2028 PX2331 June I, 2028 PX2410 June I, 2028 PX2250 June I, 2028 PX2338 June I, 2028 PX2411 June I, 2028 PX2251 June I, 2028 PX2340 June I, 2023 PX2412 June I, 2028 PX2252 June I, 2028 PX2343 June I, 2023 PX2413 June I, 2028 PX2253 June I, 2028 PX2345 June I, 2028 PX2415 June I, 2028 PX2254 June I, 2028 PX2346 June I, 2023 PX2416 June I, 2028 PX2257 June I, 2028 PX2347 June I, 2023 PX2418 June I, 2028 PX2258 June I, 2023 PX2356 June I, 2028 PX2420 June I, 2028 PX2259 June I, 2028 PX2357 June I, 2023 PX2423 June I, 2028 PX2262 June I, 2023 PX2358 June I, 2023 PX2425 June I, 2028 PX2270 June I, 2023 PX2360 June I, 2028 PX2426 June I, 2028 PX2271 June I, 2023 PX2363 June I, 2028 PX2427 June I, 2028 PX2274 June I, 2028 PX2364 June I, 2023 PX2428 June I, 2028 PX2275 June I, 2028 PX2365 June I, 2023 PX2431 June I, 2028 PX2281 June I, 2028 PX2366 June I, 2023 PX2433 June I, 2028 PX2282 June I, 2028 PX2367 June I, 2028 PX2435 June I, 2023 PX2283 June I, 2023 PX2368 June I, 2028 PX2438 June I, 2028 PX2284 June I, 2028 PX2369 June I, 2023 PX2439 June I, 2028 PX2286 June I, 2028 PX2370 June I, 2028 PX2440 June I, 2028 PX2287 June I, 2023 PX2371 June I, 2028 PX2441 June I, 2023 PX2288 June I, 2028 PX2372 June I, 2028 PX2446 June I, 2028 PX2289 June I, 2023 PX2373 June I, 2023 PX2447 June I, 2023 PX2291 June I, 2028 PX2376 June I, 2028 PX2452 June I, 2028 PX2292 June I, 2023 PX2377 June I, 2028 PX2453 June I, 2028 PX2293 June I, 2023 PX2378 June I, 2028 PX2454 June I, 2023 PX2294 June I, 2028 PX2380 June I, 2028 PX2455 June I, 2023 PX2295 June I, 2028 PX2381 June I, 2028 PX2456 June I, 2028 PX2299 June I, 2028 PX2382 June I, 2028 PX2457 June I, 2028 PX2300 June I, 2023 PX2383 June I, 2023 PX2458 June I, 2028 PX2301 June I, 2023 PX2385 June I, 2028 PX2459 June I, 2028 PX2303 June I, 2028 PX2386 June I, 2023 PX2460 June I, 2028 PX2304 June I, 2028 PX2387 June I, 2028 PX2461 June I, 2028 PX2305 June I, 2023 PX2390 June I, 2028 PX2462 June I, 2028 PX2307 June I, 2028 PX2392 June 1,2028 PX2466 June I, 2028 PX2310 June I, 2028 PX2393 June I, 2028 PX2467 June I, 2023 PX2311 June I, 2028 PX2394 June I, 2028 PX2470 June I, 2028 PX2312 June I, 2028 PX2396 June I, 2028 PX2471 June I, 2028 PX2313 June I, 2028 PX2398 June I, 2028 PX2472 June I, 2028 PX2314 June I, 2028 PX2399 June I, 2028 PX2474 June I, 2028 PX2315 June I, 2028 PX2400 June I, 2028 PX2475 June I, 2028

~F.xhibit ~ln Catoero la, Caxoora = iNumberJ Kx irafion Number ~Ex iration '%imber. Vx iration

PX2476 June I, 2028 PX6040 June I, 2028 RX0672 June I, 2028 PX2478 June I, 2028 PX6042 June I, 2028 RX0674 June I, 2028 PX2479 June I, 2028 PX6043 June I, 2028 RX0675 June I, 2028 PX2480 June I, 2028 PX6044 June I, 2028 RX0676 June I, 2023 PX2482 June I, 2028 PX6045 June I, 2028 RX0679 June I, 2028 PX2484 June I, 2028 PX6046 June I, 2028 RX0680 June I, 2023 PX2485 June I, 2028 PX6047 June I, 2028 RX0681 June I, 2023 PX2486 June I, 2023 PX6049 June I, 2028 RX0683 June I, 2028 PX2487 June I, 2028 PX6050 June I, 2028 RX0684 June I, 2028 PX2488 June I, 2028 PX7000 June I, 2028 RX0685 June I, 2023 PX2489 June I, 2028 PX7004 June I, 2028 RX0686 June I, 2028 PX2490 June I, 2028 PX7006 June I, 2028 RX0688 June I, 2028 PX2492 June I, 2028 PX7008 June I, 2028 RX0690 June I, 2023 PX2493 June I, 2028 PX7009 June I, 2028 RX0692 June I, 2023 PX2495 June I, 2023 PX7010 June I, 2028 RX0693 June I, 2028 PX2496 June I, 2028 PX7017 June I, 2028 RX0694 June I, 2023 PX5000 June I, 2023 PX7018 June I, 2028 RX0695 June I, 2028 PX5 001 June I, 2028 PX7032 June I, 2028 RX0697 June I, 2028 PX6000 June I, 2028 PX7037 June I, 2028 RX0698 June I, 2028 PX6001 June I, 2028 PX7042 June I, 2028 RX0699 June I, 2028 PX6002 June I, 2028 PX7043 June I, 2028 RX0701 June I, 2028 PX6004 June I, 2028 PX7048 June I, 2028 RX0702 June I, 2028 PX6005 June I, 2028 RX0108 June I, 2028 RX0703 June I, 2023 PX6006 June I, 2028 RX0606 June I, 2023 RX0704 June I, 2023 PX6007 June I, 2028 RX0607 June I, 2028 RX0705 June I, 2023 PX6008 June I, 2028 RX0608 June I, 2028 RX0706 June I, 2023 PX6010 June I, 2028 RX0609 June I, 2023 RX0707 June I, 2023 PX6011 June I, 2028 RX0611 June I, 2028 RX0708 June I, 2023 PX6012 June I, 2028 RX0614 June I, 2028 RX0709 June I, 2028 PX6013 June I, 2028 RX0627 June I, 2028 RX0710 June I, 2028 PX6014 June I, 2028 RX0628 June I, 2028 RX0711 June I, 2028 PX6016 June I, 2028 RX0630 June I, 2023 RX0712 June I, 2028 PX6017 June I, 2028 RX0631 June I, 2023 RX0713 June I, 2028 PX6018 June I, 2028 RX0632 June I, 2023 RX0714 June I, 2023 PX6019 June I, 2028 RX0634 June I, 2023 RX0715 June I, 2023 PX6020 June I, 2028 RX0635 June I, 2028 RX0716 June I, 2028 PX6023 June I, 2028 RX0636 June I, 2023 RX0717 June I, 2023 PX6026 June I, 2028 RX0637 June I, 2028 RX0718 June I, 2023 PX6029 June I, 2028 RX0645 June I, 2023 RX0725 June I, 2023 PX6030 June I, 2028 RX0646 June I, 2028 RX0726 June I, 2028 PX6033 June I, 2028 RX0647 June I, 2028 RX0728 June I, 2028 PX6035 June I, 2028 RX0663 June I, 2028 RX0760 June I, 2028 PX6036 June I, 2028 RX0667 June I, 2028 RX0772 June I, 2023 PX6037 June I, 2028 RX0668 June I, 2023 RX0773 June I, 2023 PX6038 June I, 2028 RX0670 June I, 2028 RX0776 June I, 2028 PX6039 June I, 2028 RX0671 June I, 2028 RX0777 June I, 2023

r axExh~ibit in Crrm era I;xhibit4 In< CameraExhibit'untber

Number Ex iratjon a Numb eire Ex iration Ex >tration RX0779 June I, 2028 RX0854 June I, 2028 RX1348 June I, 2028 RX0780 June I, 2028 RX0856 June I, 2028 RX1349 June I, 2028 RX0781 June I, 2028 RX0857 June I, 2028 RX1350 June I, 2028 RX0786 June I, 2028 RX0858 June I, 2028 RX1351 June I, 2028 RX0788 June I, 2028 RX0860 June I, 2023 RX1361 June I, 2028 RX0790 June I, 2023 RX0861 June I, 2023 RX1362 June I, 2028 RX0791 June I, 2023 RX0862 June I, 2028 RX1363 June I, 2028 RX0792 June I, 2023 RX0863 June I, 2028 RX1364 June I, 2028 RX0800 June I, 2023 RX0864 June I, 2023 RX1365 June I, 2028 RX0801 June I, 2023 RX0865 June I, 2028 RX1366 June I, 2028 RX0802 June I, 2023 RX0867 June I, 2023 RX1367 June I, 2028 RX0804 June I, 2023 RX0869 June I, 2023 RX1368 June I, 2028 RX0805 June I, 2023 RX0870 June I, 2028 RX1369 June I, 2028 RX0806 June I, 2023 RX0896 June I, 2028 RX1370 June I, 2028 RX0807 June I, 2023 RX1019 June I, 2028 RX1371 June I, 2028 RX0808 June I, 2023 RX1022 June I, 2028 RX1373 June I, 2028 RX0809 June I, 2028 RX1023 June I, 2028 RX1375 June I, 2028 RX0816 June I, 2028 RX1024 June I, 2028 RX1376 June I, 2028 RX0817 June I, 2028 RX1025 June I, 2028 RX1377 June I, 2023 RX0818 June I, 2028 RX1026 June I, 2028 June I, 2023

RX1399'X1594 RX0819 June I, 2023 RX1027 June I, 2028 June I, 2028 RX0820 June I, 2023 RX1028 June I, 2028 RX1601 June I, 2023 RX0822 June I, 2028 RX1029 June I, 2028 RX1602 June I, 2023 RX0824 June I, 2028 RX1030 June I, 2028 RX1603 June I, 2023 RX0825 June I, 2028 RX1031 June I, 2028 RX0827 June I, 2023 RX1032 June I, 2028 RX0828 June I, 2023 RX1034 June I, 2028 RX0829 June I, 2028 RX1035 June I, 2028 RX0831 June I, 2028 RX1036 June I, 2028 RX0832 June I, 2023 RX1037 June I, 2028 RX0833 June I, 2023 RX1038 June I, 2028 RX0834 June I, 2023 RXI039 June I, 2028 RX0835 June I, 2028 RX1040 June I, 2028 RX0836 June I, 2023 RX1115 June I, 2023 RX0837 June I, 2023 RX1116 June I, 2023 RX0838 June I, 2023 RX1117 June I, 2023 RX0839 June I, 2028 RX1118 June I, 2023 RX0840 June I, 2023 RX1119 June I, 2028 RX0841 June I, 2023 RX 1120 June I, 2028 RX0842 June I, 2028 RX1173 June I, 2028 RX0845 June I, 2023 RX1254 June I, 2023 RX0847 June I, 2028 RX1331 June I, 2028 RX0848 June I, 2028 RX1343 June I, 2028 RX0849 RX0851 RX0853

June June June

I, 2023 I, 2028 I, 2028

RX1344 RX1345 RX1347

June June

June

I, 2023 I, 2023 I, 2023

'X1399 is afforded partial in camera treatment, consistent with the redacted public version of the Complaint in this matter.