8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

1/128

AFCRXJ_ KIJ

@IX_KHZAX@KI

3)3 OCADL_KZIH KE QXZHP

Xjrrkr`qg fcq qxrzad cnn xfrkzlf f`qxkrp cih crkzih xfj

|krnh) Juji `i cia`jix _kgci x`gjq. jgjrkrq qzaf cq

X`ojr`zq cih Acn`lznc hjcnx |`xf xjrrkr`qg op zq`il

oci`qfgjix. cih jvjazx`ki xk|crhq xfkqj |fk kkqjh xfj`r

rznj) Ncxjr `i xfj 3652,q c xjrrkr`qx lrkz acnnjh xfj Dz Dnzv

Dnci |cq ekrgjh op Qkzxfjrijrq xk xjrr`ep ekrgjr qncujq cih

rjujix xfjg erkg ukx`il kr rzi ekr kee`aj) @i xfj 30xf

ajixzrp. \jqxjri Jzrkjciq. _zqq`ciq. cih Cgjr`aciq

chkxjh xjrrkr`qg. cih ojn`jujh xfcx xfj ojqx |cp xk ljx

|fcx xfjp |cixjh |cq xk cqqcqq`icxj jknj fknh`il f`lf

kq`x`kiq ke k|jr)

Xjrrkr`qg |jix erkg izgjrkzq cxxcadq `i xfj ?2xf

ajixzrp. xk njqq erjszjix ozx gkrj hjqxrzax`uj cqqcznxq `i xfj

?3qx ajixzrp) Xfj xfrjcx ke xjrrkr`qg fcq ik| ojakgj gkrj

hjchnp) @i xfj ?2xf ajixzrp. xjrrkr`qg |jix xfrkzlf qkgj

3

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

2/128

lrjcx afciljq) Xfj zqj ke ij| xjafiknklp qzaf cq czxkgcx`a

|jckiq cih jnjaxr`acnnp ozrqx`il jvnkq`ujq jiakzrcljh

xjrrkr`qxq xk cax u`knjixnp cih rku`hjh xfjg |`xf ci jcq`jr

|cp ke cxxcad`il) Cx xfj x`gj. cxxcadq |jrj gc`inp erkg

lrkzq xrp`il xk zihjrg`ij kr kujrxfrk| jv`qx`il kn`x`acn

`iqx`xzx`kiq) Fk|jujr. xkhcp xjrrkr`qg jv`qxq |`xf h`eejrjix

aczqjq cih zrkqjq `i g`ih) @x fcq ojji zqjh `i cix`'

aknki`cn akien axq qzaf cq `i @rjncih. Or`xc`i. Cnljr`c cih

Erciaj) @x `q zqjh |fji qjxxn`il akien`axq ojx|jji h`eejrjix

lrkzq `i kqqjqq`ki ke fkgjncih qzaf cq Rcnjqx`ij % @qrcjn)

@x `q cnqk zqjh `i rjn`l`kzq h`qclrjjgjixq `i xfj acqj ke xfj

Acxfkn`aq % Rrkxjqxcixq `i Ikrxfjri @rjncih cih `i `ixjricn

akien`axq ojx|jji rjuknzx`kicrp ekrajq cih jqxcon`qfjh

lkujrigjixq. ekr jvcgnj= Gcncpq`c. Crljix`ic. @rci. cih

I`acrclzc)3

Xfj r`qj ke lzjrr`nnc xcax`aq op iki'qxcxj caxkrq `i xfj

ncqx fcne ke xfj x|jix`jxf ajixzrp |cq hzj xk qjujrcn ecaxkrq)

Xfjqj `ianzhjh xfj enk|jr`il ke jxfi`a icx`kicn`qg &j)l) @r`qf.

Ocqszj. cih ]`ki`qx. cix`'aknki`cn qjix`gjixq `i xfj ucqx

?

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

3/128

Or`x`qf. Erjiaf cih kxfjr jg`rjq. cih ij| `hjknkl`jq qzaf

cq akggzi`qg) Xjrrkr`qx lrkzq |`xf icx`kicn qx cljihcq

fcuj ekrgjh `i jujrp crx ke xfj |krnh) Ekr jvcgnj. xfj

@r`qf _jzon`aci Crgp lrj| erkg xfj szjqx op @r`qf Acxfkn`aq

xk ekrg ci `ihjjihjix rjzon`a. rcxfjr xfci oj`il crx ke

Lrjcx Or`xc`i) Q`g`ncrnp. xfj Dzrhq. c h`qx`iax jxfi`a cih

n`ilz`qx`a lrkz `i Xzrdjp. Qpr`c. @rci cih @rcs. fcuj qkzlfx

icx`kicn czxkikgp q`iaj xfj ojl`ii`il ke xfj ?2xf Ajixzrp)

Xfj Dzrh`qxci \krdjr,q Rcrxp &RDD. ekrgjh `i xfj 30

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

4/128

cnqk lcuj zq kzr akixjgkrcrp qjiqj ke xjrrkr`qg cq f`lfnp

xfjcxr`acn. qpgokn`a caxq ke u`knjiaj op krlci`}jh lrkzq

|`xf qja`e`a kn`x`acn lr`juciajq) Xfj onkkhp jujixq cx xfj

30

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

5/128

ekr c Hjgkarcx`a Qka`jxp) Xfjp xzrijh xk u`knjix xcax`aq. erkg

r`kx`il xk qjxx`il kee okgoq. xk rkxjqx xfj U`jxicg \cr)1

_jn`l`kzqnp gkx`ucxjh xjrrkr`qg `q akiq`hjrjh xfj gkqx

cncrg`il xjrrkr`qx xfrjcx xkhcp) Lrkzq xfcx mzqx`ep xfj`r

u`knjiaj ki @qncg`a lrkzihq' Cn Scjhc. Fcgcq. Fj}oknncf

akgj xk g`ih e`rqx) Ozx Afr`qx`ci`xp. Mzhc`qg. F`ihz`qg cih

kxfjr rjn`l`kiq fcuj l`uji r`qj xk xfj`r k|i ekrgq ke g`n`xcix

jvxrjg`qg) @i xfj u`j| ke rjn`l`ki qafkncr Dcrji Crgqxrkil

xf`q xzri rjrjqjixq xjrrkr`qxq, hjcrxzrj erkg cip rjcn

rjn`l`kzq rjajxq) Gzfcggch Cxxc. xfj craf`xjax ke xfj 0+33

cxxcadq. cih /xfj Jlpx`ci f`mcadjr |fk |cq hr`u`il xfj e`rqx

ncij. |cq c ijcr cnakfkn`a cih |cq hr`id`il ukhdc ojekrj

fj okcrhjh xfj c`rarcex)/ Cnakfkn |kznh oj qxr`axnp kee n`g`xq

ekr c f`lfnp koqjrucix Gzqn g) Cxxc. cih jrfcq gcip

kxfjrq. crj ikx q`gnp krxfkhkv ojn`jujrq xzrijh u`knjix. ozx

rcxfjr u`knjix jvxrjg`qxq |fk gci`zncxj rjn`l`kzq akiajxq

ekr xfj`r k|i zrkqjq)

Xjrrkr`qg `i Ncx`i Cgjr`ac `q jqqjix`cnnp c rkhzax ke

ancqq akien`ax) Zix`n rjajixnp. ijcrnp cnn Ncx`i Cgjr`aci

:

http://history1900s.about.com/cs/vietnamwar/http://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/AlQaeda.htmhttp://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/AlQaeda.htmhttp://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/Hamas.htmhttp://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/Hamas.htmhttp://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/Hezbollah.htmhttp://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0345391691/104-0212870-7905569?v=glance&n=283155http://history1900s.about.com/cs/vietnamwar/http://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/AlQaeda.htmhttp://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/Hamas.htmhttp://terrorism.about.com/od/groupsleader1/p/Hezbollah.htmhttp://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0345391691/104-0212870-7905569?v=glance&n=283155

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

6/128

icx`kiq |jrj akixrknnjh op akrrzx czxfkr`xcr`ci rjl`gjq

|fk lcuj n`xxnj akiq`hjrcx`ki xk xfj |jnecrj ke xfj`r jknj)

Xfj rjqznxc gcmkr`xp ke Ncx`i Cgjr`aciq n`uj `i kujrxp) Xfj

zihjrjhzacxjh cih `gkujr`qfjh jknj |jrj ujrp

rjajx`uj xk xfj jlcn`xcr`ci Gcrv`qx. Nji`i`qx cih Gck`qx

f nkqkf`jq jqkzqjh op jvxrjg`qxq) Ijcrnp jujrp Ncx`i

Cgjr`aci icx`ki fcq fch. kr azrrjixnp fcq. ci cax`uj lzjrr`nnc

kr xjrrkr`qx `iqzrljiap) Xfj hr`u`il ekraj ojf`ih gkqx ke

xfjqj lrkzq fcq ojji c hjq`rj xk rjkrlci`}j qka`jxp cnkil

qka`cn qx n`ijq. rjgkuj ekrj`li ozq`ijqq `ixjrjqxq cih

rjh`qxr`ozxj ncih cih |jcnxf) Xjrrkr`qx caxq kr xfj xfrjcx ke

qzaf cax`ki fcuj ojji `i jv`qxjiaj ekr g`nnjii`c) Hjq`xj

fcu`il c f`qxkrp nkiljr xfci xfj gkhjri icx`ki'qxcxj. xfj

zqj ke xjrrkr op lkujrigjixq cih xfkqj xfcx akixjqx xfj`r

k|jr rjgc`iq kkrnp zihjrqxkkh) \f`nj xfj gjci`il ke xfj

|krh xjrrkr `xqjne `q anjcr. |fji `x `q cn`jh xk caxq cih

caxkrq `i xfj rjcn |krnh `x ojakgjq akiezqjh) Rcrx ke xf`q `q

hzj xk xfj zqj ke xjrrkr xcax`aq op caxkrq cx cnn njujnq `i xfj

qka`cn cih kn`x`acn jiu`rkigjix) @q xfj Zicokgojr. |`xf f`q

5

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

7/128

qknk acgc`li ke xjrrkr. c ar`g`icn. xjrrkr`qx. kr

rjuknzx`kicrp;8

Cqqcqq`icx`kiq. okgo`ilq. f mcad`ilq. h`nkgcx`a

d`hic`ilq '' xjrrkr`qg `q xfj gkqx zon`a`}jh ekrg ke

kn`x`acn u`knjiaj) Xfj f`qxkrp ke xjrrkr`qg lkjq ocad c ujrp

nkil x`gj. ozx xfj ujrp ecax xfcx xfjrj `q qzaf c f`qxkrp fcq

erjszjixnp ojji `likrjh. juji qzrjqqjh) Xf`q gcp oj

ojaczqj xjrrkr`qg fcq ikx cjcrjh |`xf jszcn `ixjiq`xp cx

cnn x`gjq) \fji xjrrkr`qg rjcjcrjh `i xfj ncxj x|jix`jxf

ajixzrp cexjr c jr`kh ke rjncx`uj acng. xfjrj |cq xfj

xjihjiap xk rjlcrh `x cq c ij| fjikgjiki. |`xfkzx

rjajhjix) Xfj qpafknkl`acn qxzhp ke xjrrkr`qg fcq ijujr

ojji gzaf `i ecqf`ki) Ozx xf`q ijlnjax fcq njex c izgojr ke

arza`cn szjqx`kiq ziciq|jrjh) Cgkil xfjqj `q |fp qkgj

jknj |fk qfcrj xfj qcgj akiu`ax`kiq xzri xk xjrrkr`qg cih

kxfjrq hk ikx)

@ixjricx`kicn xjrrkr`qg fcq nkil ojji rjakli`}jh cq c

ekrj`li cih hkgjqx`a qjazr`xp xfrjcx) Xfj xrcl`a jujixq ke

Qjxjgojr 33 `i Ij| Pkrd. xfj \cqf`ilxki. H)A). crjc. cih

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

8/128

Rjiiqpnuci`c fcuj hrcgcx`acnnp rj'jijrl`}jh xfj icx`kiq

ekazq cih rjqknuj ki xjrrkr`qg) Cuc`nconj kn ap kx`kiq

rcilj erkg h`nkgcap. `ixjricx`kicn akkjrcx`ki. cih

akiqxrzax`uj jilcljgjix xk jakikg`a qciax`kiq. akujrx

cax`ki. fpq`acn qjazr`xp jifciajgjix. cih g`n`xcrp ekraj)

Xfj Qjxjgojr 33xf xjrrkr`qx `ia`hjixq `i xfj Zi`xjh

Qxcxjq. xfj qzoqjszjix cixfrcv cxxcadq. cq |jnn cq okgo`ilq

ke xfj Z)Q)Q) Aknj. Kdncfkgc A`xp. \krnh Xrchj Ajixjr `i

3001. cih ke xfj Z)Q) jgocqq`jq `i Djipc cih Xci}ci`c `i

3006. fcuj orkzlfx xfj `qqzj ke xjrrkr`qg xk xfj ekrjerkix ke

Cgjr`aci zon`a `ixjrjqx):

3)? QXCXJGJIX KE R_KONJG

Xf`q rjqjcraf |krd `q ocq`acnnp xk jvcg`ij xfj Zi`xjh

Qxcxjq `ixjrujix`ki`qx kn`ap `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx &qxzhp ke kqx

Qjxjgojr 33. ?223 cih xjrrkr kn ap) @x qjjdq xk jvcg`ij

xjrrkr`qg `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih xfj qxjq xcdji op xfj Zi`xjh

Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac xk azro cih hjxjr xjrrkr`qxq)

@x cnqk jvnkrjq xfj rjcqki |fp `ih`u`hzcnq cih icx`kiq

acrrp kzx xjrrkr`qg |f`nj xcd`il c nkkd cx |fk xfj u`ax`gq cih

6

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

9/128

xjrrkr`qxq crj. fk| xfjp qzqxc`i xfj`r ju`n hjjhq cih fk| xfjp

ljx qzkrx erkg h`eejrjix crxq ke xfj lnkoj)

Cnxfkzlf xfj znx`gcxj rjqznxq ke xfj Z)Q) acgc`li clc`iqx

xjrrkr`qg rjgc`i zianjcr. |fcx `q anjcr `q xfcx lkujrigjixq gzqx

ik| caakzix ekr gcip ij| xjrrkr`qx xfrjcxq xk xfj`r icx`kicn

qjazr`xp) Xfj rjqjcraf `q xk jvcg`ij xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq

@ixjrujix`ki`qx kn`ap `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx |f`nj ocq`il xfj qxzhp

ki xfj kqx Qjxjgojr 33. ?223 cih xjrrkr kn`ap ke xfj Z)Q)C `i

xfj G`hhnj Jcqx |`xf c fzlj ekazq ki xjrrkr`qg)

3)1 KOMJAX@UJ KE XFJ QXZHP

Xfj Qjxjgojr 33. ?223 xjrrkr`qxq cxxcad ki xfj Zi`xjh

Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac fcq zx c qxrc`i `i xfj rjncx`kiqf` ojx|jji

xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq cih xfj akzixr`jq `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx)

@ixjricx`kicn xjrrkr`qg fcq ojji ljklrcf`acnnp |`hjqrjch cih

fcq cnqk ojakgj c rjlzncr kaazrrjiaj) @x `q xfjrjekrj xfj

komjax`uj ke xf`q rjqjcraf xk nkkd cx qkgj ke xfjqj `qqzjq)

c) Ci crc`qcn ke xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq Rkqx Qjxjgojr 33. ?223

cih xjrrkr kn`ap ke xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx)0

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

10/128

o) Xk jvcg`ij xfj jvxjix xfcx xjrrkr`qg fcq lkij `i gcd`il

xfj `ixjricx`kicn akggzi`xp xk n`uj `i ejcr `i xf`q jrc ke

zirjajhjixjh gjxcgkrfkq`q)

a) Xk e`ih kzx xfj jvxjix xfcx xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac `q

|`nn`il xk lk xk akgocx xjrrkr`qg `i xfj |krnh &xfj G`hhnj Jcqx `i

crx`azncr)

h) Xk cicnp}j xfj jeejaxq ke xfj cxxcadq ki xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke

Cgjr`ac op xjrrkr`qxq cih fk| xfcx jujix fcq lkij c nkil |cp `i

afcil`il xfj `ixjricx`kicn akggzi`xp)

3)8 QAKRJ CIH N@G@XCX@KI KE QXZHP

Xf`q rjqjcraf |krd `q rjqxr`axjhnp n`g`xjh xk xfj Zi`xjh

Qxcxjq `ixjrujix`ki`qx kn`ap `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx &qxzhp ke kqx

Qjxjgojr 33. ?223 cih xjrrkr kn`ap ke xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq `i xfj

G`hhnj Jcqx) Xf`q rjqjcraf `q n`g`xjh |`xf`i xfj x`gj qakj ke

?223 x`nn rjqjix) Jujrp qxzhp cih rjqjcraf fcq ojji icrrk|jh

xk xf`q jr`kh cih cq c rjqznx. xfj rjqjcrafjr fcq ojji ekazqjh

ki xfj jujixq cih hkazgjixcrp |`xf`i xfj jr`kh zihjr qxzhp xk

32

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

11/128

oj conj xk caf`juj c hjq`rjh rjqznx) Xjrrkr`qg `q oj`il zqjh cq c

ucr`conj `i xf`q rjqjcraf) Xfj ljklrcf`acn nkacx`ki fjrj `q xfj

G`hhnj Jcqx. |f`af azxq carkqq xfrjj akix`ijixq &Cer`ac. Jzrkj

cih Cq`c cq |jnn cq Ikrxf Cgjr`ac &Xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke

Cgjr`ac)

3): Q@LI@E@ACIAJ KE QXZHP

Gzaf fcq ojji qc`h cokzx xjrrkr`qg `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih

xfj zirjqxq xfcx fcuj qrcil z cq c rjqznx ke xfj Qjxjgojr 33.

?223 xjrrkr`qxq cxxcad ki xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac)

Xf`q rjqjcraf |`nn fjn xrcaj xfj f`qxkrp ke xjrrkr`qg `i xfj

G`hhnj Jcqx cih fk| `x fcq lkij c nkil |cp `i qfc`il xfj

ekrj`li kn`ap ke xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac)

Xfj `gkrxciaj ke xf`q qxzhp n`jq `i `xq qzaajqq `i or`il`il

kzx xfkqj ezihcgjixcn rjcqkiq xfcx rkgxjh xjrrkr`qxq xk

cxxcad Cgjr`aci `ixjrjqxq cip|fjrj `i xfj |krnh)

Xf`q rjqjcraf | nn fjn jvnc`i xfj xrzj gjci`il ke

xjrrkr`qg cih xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq `ixjrujix`ki`qx kn`ap `i xfj

G`hhnj Jcqx)

33

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

12/128

3)5 GJXFKHKNKLP KE QXZHP

3)5)3 Qkzrajq ke Hcxc

@i acrrp`il kzx xf`q rjqjcraf. xfj rjqjcrafjr ocq`acnnp zqjh

qjakihcrp qkzrajq ke aknnjax`ki. |f`af crj cnn |r`xxji rjakrhq

cokzx xjrrkr`qg `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq

`ixjrujix`ki`qx kn`ap q`iaj Qjxjgojr 33. ?223) Xfjrj `q cnqk

xfj zqj ke `ixjrijx cih gjh`c ekr `iekrgcx`ki xk hk mzqx`aj xk xf`q

|krd) Xf`q `iekrgcx`ki `q qzomjaxjh xk jrqkicn mzhlgjix cih

xfjkrjx`acn cqqjqqgjixq ekr cicnpq`q)

3)5)? Xjafi`szjq ke hcxc cicnpq`q

Xfj rjqjcrafjr xr`jh xk e`ih kzx `i rjncx`kiqf` ojx|jji xfj

ojfcu`kr ke icx`kiq `i xfj `ixjricx`kicn crjic cih k|jr xfjkrp)

Xfj rjqjcrafjr |cq conj xk hk xf`q op nkkd`il cx caxkrq `i xfj

`ixjricx`kicn qpqxjg cih xfj jvxjix xfjp crj |`nn`il xk lk mzqx xk

caf`juj xfj`r lkcnq |`xf k|jr oj`il xfj hr`u`il ekraj)

3)< QZGGC_P KE AFCRXJ_Q

3?

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

13/128

Afcrxj kij xfrkzlf xfj `ixrkhzax`ki cih ocadlrkzih

ke qxzhp. l`ujq c or`je `ixrkhzax`ki xk xfj e`lfx clc`iqx xjrrkr`qg)

@x cnqk nkkdq cx xfj e`lfx clc`iqx xjrrkr`qg ojekrj Qjxjgojr 33.

xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq e`lfx clc`iqx xjrrkr `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx xfrkzlf

xfj Qxcxjgjix ke Rrkonjg) Xfj qakj cih n`g`xcx`ki nkkdq

xjrrkr`qg cq c ucr`conj |`xf xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke

Cgjr`ac oj`il xfj ljklrcf`acn kq`x`kiq ke xfj jujixq xfcx crj

oj`il xrjcxjh `i xf`q rjqjcraf) @ixjricx`kicn xjrrkr`qg fcq nkil

ojji rjakli`}jh cq c ekrj`li cih hkgjqx`a qjazr`xp xfrjcx) Xfj

xrcl`a jujixq ke Qjxjgojr 33 `i Ij| Pkrd. xfj \cqf`ilxki.

H)A). crjc. cih Rjiiqpnuci`c fcuj hrcgcx`acnnp rj'jijrl`}jh xfj

icx`kiq ekazq cih rjqknuj ki xjrrkr`qg) Cuc`nconj kn`ap kx`kiq

rcilj erkg h`nkgcap. `ixjricx`kicn akkjrcx`ki. cih

akiqxrzax`uj jilcljgjix xk jakikg`a qciax`kiq. akujrx cax`ki.

fpq`acn qjazr`xp jifciajgjix. cih g`n`xcrp ekraj)

Afcrxj x|k `q c rju`j| ke rjnjucix n`xjrcxzrj cih

xfjkrjx`acn ercgj|krd) @i xf`q qjax`ki. xfj |r`xjr h`h f`q ojqx

xk e`ih kzx |fcx fcuj ojji qc`h cokzx xfj qzomjax gcxxjr

cih rjncxjh cicnpq`q op czxfkrq cih |r`xjrq ojekrj cih cexjr

31

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

14/128

xfj xjrrkr`qx cxxcad ke Qjxjgojr 33. ?223)Xf`q afcxjr

akiajriq `xqjne |`xf Jqqjix`cnq ke Rk|jr Rkn`x`aq4 @gkqq`onj

Ijzxrcn`xp cih xfj Gjxc'xfjkrjx`acn Hjjihjiaj ke

Jvncicxkrp Akiajxq4 _jenjv`u`xp Nkkq `i @ixjricx`kicn

_jncx`kiq= Akiajxzcn Rk|jr Cicnpq`q cq Rcrx ke &Rk|jr

Rkn`x`aq4 Xfj qjakih h`gjiq`ki ke k|jr= iki'hja`q`ki

gcd`il cih xfj gko n`}cx`ki ke o`cq4 cih Xfjkrjx`acn

Ercgj|krd)

Afcrxj xfjj hjcnq |`xf xfj Ekrj`li Rkn`ap ke xfj

Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac ojekrj Qjxjgojr 33xf ?223 jih ke

xfj Aknh \cr cih Zi`xjh Qxcxjq Ekrj`li Rkn`ap cih xfj e`lfx

clc`iqx xjrrkr`qg) Xf`q afcxjr nkkdq cx xfj ekrj`li kn`ap

xfcx xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac fch `i ncaj ojekrj xfj

cxxcad ki xfj X|`i Xk|jrq ki Qjxjgojr 33xf ?223 cih fk|

xfj cxxcadq |jix c nkil |cp `i fjn`il xfj qfcj xfj rjqjix

hcp ekrj`li kn`ap ke xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke Cgjr`ac) Gkrj n`lfx

`q cnqk qfjh ki xfj rjqjix hcp e`lfx clc`iqx xjrrkr`qg)

Afcrxj ekz hjcnq |`xf xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq Ekrj`li

Rkn`ap `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx. kqx Qjxjgojr 33 xf cix` xjrrkr

38

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

15/128

kn`ap. xjrrkr`qg `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih Zi`xjh Qxcxjq

@ixjrujix`ki`qx kn`ap) Xf`q afcxjr hjcnq |`xf xfj

rjncx`kiqf` xfcx jv`qxq ojx|jji xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq ke

Cgjr`ac cih akzixr`jq `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih fk| xfj Zi`xjh

Qxcxjq cix` xjrrkr kn ap ceejaxq xfj akzixr`jq `i xf`q

ljklrcf`acn nkacx`ki) @x cnqk xcdjq c nkkd cx fk| xfj Zi`xjh

Qxcxjq fcq `ixjrujijh `i G`hhnj Jcqx ceec`rq xfrkzlf fjr

`ixjrujix`ki`qx kn`ap) Q`iaj xfj xjrrkr`qx cxxcadq ke

Qjxjgojr 33. ?223. xfj ecaj ke Z)Q) akzixjrxjrrkr`qg fcq

afciljh akiq`hjrconp. |`xf xfj q`li`il ke xfj Rcxr`kx Cax cq

|jnn cq c izgojr ke kxfjr gjcqzrjq)

Afcrxj e`uj qzggcr`}jq cih akianzhjq xfj rjqjcraf)

Xf`q afcxjr cxxjgxq xk qfk| xfj rjcqkiq ekr xfj xjrrkr`qx

cxxcadq ki Cgjr`ac jqja`cnnp xfj Qjxjgojr 33. ?223

xjrrkr`qx cxxcadq) @x cnqk qja`e`acnnp rku`hjh c qzggcrp ke

ci caakzix ke xfj cexjr'jeejax ki xfj G`hhnj Jcqx ke xfj

Qjxjgojr 33. ?223 xjrrkr`qx cxxcad ki Cgjr`ac) Xf`q

afcxjr cnqk ekazqjq ki xfj qjne'caanc`gjh kn`aj akzixrp ke

xfj |krnh &Cgjr`ac cih qxjq xcdji xk azro xjrrkr`qg

3:

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

16/128

lnkocnnp op qzkrx`il xfj e`lfx clc`iqx xjrrkr`qg `i gcip

crxq ke xfj |krnh)

JIHIKXJQ

35

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

17/128

3) Ec|ajxx.N) R) Xfj @ixjricx`kicn _jncx`kiq ke xfj G`hhnj Jcqx.

&Kvekrh Zi`ujrq`xp Rrjqq. ?22: ) ?68)

?) Njqaf. H) \) Xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq= C

F`qxkr`acn cih Rkn`x`acn _jcqqjqgjix. &\jqxu`j| Rrjqq.

?221. ) 66 % 08)

1) Ljxxnjgci. G. J. Qafccr. Xfj G`hhnj Jcqx cih @qncg`a

\krnh _jchjr. &Lrkuj Rrjqq. ?221 ) ?86

8) O`nnki. R) Erkg Erjj k`n xk ,Erjjhkg K`n,= Xjrrkr`qg. \cr

cih Zi`xjh Qxcxjq Ljkkn`x`aq `i xfj Rjrq`ci Lzne &Kvekrh

Zi`ujrq`xp Rrjqq. ?22?) ) 320 % 33:)

:) _zlf. \) C Cgjr`aci Jiakzixjrq |`xf Crcoq= Xfj Qkex

Rk|jr ke Z)Q) Rzon`a H`nkgcap `i xfj G`hhnj Jcqx.

&Rrcjljr Rzon`qfjrq. 3006) 60'02)

3

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

18/128

AFCRXJ_ X\K

?)3 N@XJ_CXZ_J _JU@J\

Xf`q afcxjr |`nn akiajri `xqjne |`xf xfj rju`j| ke

n`xjrcxzrj cuc`nconj ki xfj xk`a zihjr qxzhp) @i xf`q qjax`ki.

xfj |r`xjr |`nn jihjcukr xk e`ih kzx |fcx fcuj ojji qc`h

cokzx xfj qzomjax gcxxjr cih rjncxjh cicnpq`q op czxfkrq cih

|r`xjrq)

?)3)3 Jqqjix`cnq ke Rk|j Rkn`x`aq

Xfj akiajxq ke k|jr cih kn`x`aq crj jix|`ijh+`ixjr'

hjjihjix `i xfj qjiqj xfcx kn`x`aq ' |fjxfjr ke xfj

qja e`acnnp lkujrigjixcn d`ih &kn`x`acn crx`jq. rjqqzrj

lrkzq. jxa). xfj jakikg`a d`ih &ozrjczarca`jq. xfj

krlci`}cx`ki ke xfj |krdncaj `ixk qka`cn f`jrcraf`jq ocqjh

zki qxcxzq. jxa) kr xfj `ixjrjrqkicn &rjncx`kiq ojx|jji

gcnjq cih ejgcnjq. af`nhrji cih chznxq. jxa ' `iuknujq xfj

jvjra`q`il ke k|jr) \fcx |j fcuj xk ojl`i op hk`il.

xfjrjekrj. `q xk hje`ij xfj akiajx ke k|jr &cih zihjrqxcih

xfj h`eejr`il h`gjiq`kiq+cqjaxq ke k|jr ' akjra`uj k|jr.

xpjq ke czxfkr`xp cih qk ekrxf cih rjncxj `x xk qzaf `hjcq cq=

36

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

19/128

Xfj xjrrkr`qx cxxcad ke Qjxjgojr 33. ?223 `i Ij| Pkrd

A`xp. \cqf`ilxki H)A) cih Rjiiqpnuci`c `q ikx xfj e`rqx ke xfj

ojl`ii`il ke xjrrkr`qg `i Cgjr`ac `i crx`azncr cih xfj |krnh

`i ljijrcn) Xjrrkr`qxq cax`u`x`jq ojekrj Qjxjgojr 33. ?223

fcuj ojji xcd`il ncaj `i h`eejrjix crxq ke xfj |krnh

xfrkzlf h`eejrjix gjxfkhknkl`jq) Ekr jvcgnj. q`iaj 3086.

Rcnjqx`i`ciq fcuj ecajh ki'lk`il xjrrkr`qg erkg @qrcjn)

Fzihrjhq ke u`nncljq fcuj ojji kon xjrcxjh cih n`xjrcnnp

|`jh kzx erkg xfj gc) Xjiq ke xfkzqcihq ke fkgjq fcuj

ojji okgojh. oznn'hk}jh kr hpicg`xjh hzr`il jcaj x`gj)3

Xjiq ke xfkzqcihq ke gji. |kgji cih af`nhrji fcuj

ojji d`nnjh) Juji lrjcxjr izgojrq fcuj ojji on`ihjh.

ar`njh. h`qe`lzrjh cih gc`gjh cih fzihrjhq ke xfkzqcihq

fcuj cnqk ojji `gr`qkijh cih+kr xkrxzrjh) Xfj Rcnjqx`i`ciq

cih gcip ke xfj`r Crco cnn`jq fcuj ojji xfj xcrljx ke c fcne

ke c ajixzrp ke zirjnjix`il @qrcjn` xjrrkr`qg) Caakrh`il xk Hj

_jpijr=

@i chh`x`ki. Cgjr`ac fcq ojji cxxcad`il akzixr`jq xfcx

qzkrx xfj Rcnjqx`i`ci aczqj) @x ojakgjq mzqx`e`jh xfjrjekrj

30

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

20/128

xfcx Cgjr`ac fcq xk oj cxxcadjh ojaczqj ke `xq qpgcxfp ekr

@qrcjn |fk crj xfj |krqx jijgp ke xfj Rcnjqx`i`ciq) @i kij ke

f`q `ixjru`j|q |`xf xfj COA xjnju`q`ki cih OOA ij|q hzr`il

xfj An`ixki Chg`i`qxrcx`ki. Kqcgc O`i Nchji anjcrnp qxcxjh

|fp fj kkqjh Cgjr`ac=

?)3)? @grkqq`onj Ijzxcn`xp cih xfj Gjxc'xfjkjx`acn

Hjrjihjiaj ke

Jvrncicxkp AkiajrxqQfk|`il xfj h`njggcq c akiajxzcn cicnpq`q rziq `ixk

|fji `x `q akiaj`ujh `i xjrgq ke ucr`conj akiqxrzax`ki `q ozx

c e`rqx qxj `i zihjrg`i`il xfj kq`x`u`qx zihjrqxcih`il ke

akiajxzcn cicnpq`q) Cq @ |`nn xrp xk qfk| `i xfj eknnk|`il

qjax`ki. `x `q kexji `gkqq`onj xk `qkncxj akiajxq erkg xfj

xfjkr`jq `i |f`af xfjp crj jgojhhjh cih |f`af akiqx`xzxj

crx ke xfj`r ujrp gjci`il) Cq c rjqznx. xfj cicnpq`q ke

akiajxq qzaf cq k|jr aciikx oj zqjh cq c gjrj gjciq ekr

jvncicx`ki. |fjrj`i xfjp |kznh ijzxrcnnp cqqjqq xfj

qcn`jiaj ke akgjx`il xfjkr`jq) \fji Gcv \jojr zx c

njilxfp `ixrkhzax`ki xk ocq`a qka`knkl`acn akiajxq cx xfj

qxcrx ke f`q Jakikgp cih Qka`jxp. xf`q |cq ikx mzqx c

?2

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

21/128

xjafi`acn cih hje`i`x`kicn ocq`q ekr f`q xfjkrp. ozx cnrjchp

crx ke `x. rjqznx ke gzaf ke f`q jcrn`jr cicnpq`q) Xfj rjncx`ki

ojx|jji xfjqj akiajxq rku`hjh xfj ercgj|krd ke f`q

qka`knkl`acn |krd) Cq Gcrx`i Ozngjr |r`xjq. akiajxq qzaf cq

xfj rkxjqxcix jxf`a kr gcrl`icn zx`n xp hjr`uj xfj`r

gjci`il erkg xfj crx xfjp ncp `i xfj xfjkrp `i |f`af xfjp

crj jgojhhjh. cih erkg xfj rknj `i xfcx xfjkrp `xqjne) Cq c

rjqznx. c akiajxzcn cicnpq`q |f`af `qkncxjq kij akiajx

ijajqqcr`np qn`hjq `ixk xfj xcqd ke cqqjqq`il c |fknj xfjkrp)

\fji Gcv \jojr zx c njilxfp `ixrkhzax`ki xk ocq`a

qka`knkl`acn akiajxq cx xfj qxcrx ke f`q Jakikgp cih

Qka`jxp. xf`q |cq ikx mzqx c xjafi`acn cih hje`i`x`kicn ocq`q

ekr f`q xfjkrp. ozx cnrjchp crx ke `x)?

@x `q dik|i xfcx @qrcjn fcq xcrljxjh cih cqqcqq`icxjh

xfkzqcihq ke Rcnjqx`i`ci njchjrq) Jujrp Rcnjqx`i`ci qzeejrq

fpq`acnnp. jgkx`kicnnp kr qpafknkl`acnnp cx xfj fcihq ke xfj

@qrcjn`q) Xf`q `ianzhjq qafkncrq. ozq`ijqqgji. f`nkqkfjrq.

kjxq. rjn`l`kzq njchjrq cih xfcx `iq`rjq kr xr`jq xk `iq`rj

xfj Rcnjqx`i`ci jknj xk cxr`kx`qg) Xfjqj cxrka`x`jq fcuj

kaazrrjh cnn kujr xfj |krnh juji `i xfj Zi`xjh Qxcxjq) @i xfj

?3

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

22/128

rkajqq. xfjp fcuj d`nnjh gcip xfkzqcihq ke |kgji cih

af`nhrji)

Xfj kxfjr rjcqki ekr xfj fcxrjh cih cxxcad ki Cgjr`ac

op xfj Crcoq `q xfj ecax xfcx @qrcjnq ekrgjr Rr`gj G`i`qxjr.

Cr`jn Qfcrki `q kij ke xfj |krnhq gkqx onkkh'qxc`ijh

xjrrkr`qxq) Ekr jvcgnj. fj `q ojn`jujh xk oj rjqkiq`onj ekr

xfj aknh onkkhjh qnczlfxjr ke cx njcqx 3.:22 gji. |kgji

cih af`nhrji `i xfj Oj`rzx rjezljj acgq ke Afcx`nc cih

Qcorc) Juji c ekrgcn @qrcjn` Akgg`qq`ki ekzih Qfcrki

jrqkicnnp rjqkiq`onj ekr xfj Njocijqj gcqqcarj)

@i 306?. @qrcjnq hjejiqj G`i`qxjr. Qfcrki h`rjaxjh

@qrcjnq `iucq`ki ke Njociki cih xfj acrjx okgo`il

cih hjucqxcx`ki ke xfj a`xp ke Oj`rzx) @i Njociki. e`uj

x`gjq gkrj |kgji cih af`nhrji h`jh xfci xfj izgojr

ke xfkqj xfcx h`jh `i xfj Qjxjgojr ?223 Ij| Pkrd

xjrrkr`qxq cxxcad) Xf`q xjrrkr okgo`il |cq acrr`jh kzx op

Mj|q zq`il mjx e`lfxjrq cih okgoq qzn`jh op xfj

Zi`xjh Qxcxjq)1

??

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

23/128

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

24/128

lkujrigjix gcp fcuj ojji |`nn`il. ozx ik nkiljr conj. xk

rku`hj xfj zon`a lkkhq `x zqjh xk rku`hj) Qxrcilj xr`jh xk

crlzj xfcx xfj hjan i`il rku`q`ki fch njqq xk hk |`xf

hjan`i`il k|jr xfci |`xf qf`ex`il `ixjrjqxq ziakiijaxjh xk

k|jr) Xk hk xf`q. fjr akiajx ke qxrzaxzrcn k|jr acqxq c

|`hjr ijx &fjr ekzr qxrzaxzrjq xfcx jiakgcqqjq crjcq `i

|f`af xfj ZQ `q ikx anjcrnp qjji xk oj hjan`i`il) Cq c rjqznx.

xfj ZQ fcq xk mzqx`ep `xq cax`ki |`xf gjciq kxfjr xfci xfj

jvazqj ke ncad`il k|jr) Qjakih. Qxrciljq akiajx ke

qxrzaxzrcn k|jr cnqk `ianzhjq iki'`ixjix`kicn jeejaxq)

\fjxfjr xfj Ejh `ixjihjh xk fzrx cipkij `q njqq `gkrxcix

xfci xfcx `x h`h) Op gcd`il caxkrq cnqk c|crj ke xfj

zi`ixjihjh jeejaxq ke xfj`r cax`ki. xfjp crj cqdjh xk xcdj xf`q

`ixk caakzix ijvx x`gj) Xfjp ojakgj kxjix`cnnp n`conj xk xfj

szjqx`ki ke |fp. ik| c|crj ke xfj jeejaxq. cax`ki fch ikx

afciljh) Fcu`il c orkchjr akiajx ke k|jr cqdq ekr gkrj

`qqzjq xk oj ecaxkrjh `ixk kn`x`acn hja`q`kiq cih cax`kiq

&jvcaxnp cq `i Akiiknnpq cicnpq`q)8

Ozx qzaf c n`id ojx|jji dik|njhlj. k|jr cih kn`x`aq

`q cnqk u`q`onj `i xfj hc`np rcax`ajq ke h`nkgcap) Fjrj `x `q

?8

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

25/128

njqq xfj jrekrgcx`uj cqjax ke ncilzclj xfci xfj

rjncx`kiqf` ojx|jji dik|njhlj cih akiujix`kiq |f`af

h`rjaxnp `ixjrujijq `ixk kn`x`aq) Clc`i. xfj hje`i`x`ki ke

k|jr fcq ci jeejax ki kn`x`aq) Hjq`xj anc`gq xk xfj

akixrcrp. k|jr `q ikx jqja`cnnp ezil`onj4 `)j). rjqkzrajq

jeejax`uj `i kij crjc g`lfx ikx ijajqqcr`np oj qk jnqj|fjrj)

@i gkrj xjafi`acn xjrgq. k|jr hkjq ikx hk ekr kn`x`aq |fcx

gkijp hkjq ekr jakikg`aq q`iaj `x hkjq ikx rku`hj c

qxcihcrh gjcqzrj |`xf |f`af c crx`azncr rjqkzraj aci oj

jvafciljh |`xf cikxfjr kij) Pjx. l`uji xfj qja`cn rknj

lrjcx k|jr qxcxzq ncpq `i `ixjricx`kicn ceec`rq. h`nkgcxq

ijjh xk gcdj z `ih`acxkrq ekr kujrcnn k|jr) L`uji xfj

ijjh xk xrchj lc`iq cih nkqqjq qk cq &ikx xk zqjx xfj

rcid`il ke k|jr &cnqk caf`jujh xfrkzlf kn`x`aq ke

akgjiqcx`ki. h`nkgcxq fcuj xk akgj xk clrjj ki |fcx

akzixq ojekrj xfjp aci qxcrx akzix`il) Xcd`il xf`q n`id ekr

lrcixjh)

Hci`jn Erj` fch jcrnp ki zrljh qa`jix`qxq xk fjn

kn`x`a`ciq `i xf`q xcqd) Pjx. xfjrj `q qx`nn ik ijzxrcn qknzx`ki `i

q`lfx) @ihjjh. xfj ujrp hje`i`x`ki ke k|jr `q qk akixjix`kzq

?:

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

26/128

rja`qjnp ojaczqj ke `xq kn`x`acn akiqjszjiajq) Hzr`il xfj

Aknh \cr. xfj Qku`jx Zi`ki rjq`qxjh xfkqj hje`i`x`kiq ke

k|jr |fkqj qxrjqq ki iki'g`n`xcrp ecaxkrq |kznh `gnp c

hjan`ij `i `xq qxcxzq) Q`g`ncrnp. `i xfj rjajix akixrkujrqp

cokzx qkex cih fcrh &akjra`uj k|jr. hja`h`il |fcx k|jr

rjcnnp gjciq fcq kou`kzq kn`x`acn `gn`acx`kiq) Ekazq`il

gkrj ki xfj g`n`xcrp q`hj cih fjiaj qxrjqq`il ci

zirjajhjixjh rjkihjrciaj ke xfj ZQ g`n`xcrp gchj `x

kqq`onj xk cqd xfj ZQ xk zqf `xq chucixcljq ezrxfjr &q`iaj

`x `q kqq`onj. cih cx x`gjq juji qxrjqq xfj hzxp ke xfj ZQ

xk `ixjrujij l`uji `xq acca`x`jq &|f`af rjncxjq ocad xk xfj

jrekrgcx`uj crlzgjix cokuj) Kr. qxrjqq`il ZQ qkex k|jr

cih `xq kxjix`cn hjan`ij. cicnpqxq akznh chukacxj c gzaf

gkrj rzhjix cih ucr`jh ekrj`li kn`ap qxrcxjlp qjiq`x`uj xk

anc`gq ke njl`x`gcap cih aznxzrcn cxxrcax`ki &|fjxfjr kr ikx

xfj njl`x`gcap ar`q`q `q q`gnp ci jeejax ke kkr zon`a

h`nkgcap kr ke c gkrj ezihcgjixcn kr`l`i) Kr. e`icnnp.

`iq`qx`il ki xfj zi`kncr`xp ke xfj rjqjix `ixjricx`kicn

qpqxjg. qzaf c k|jr qxcxjgjix gko`n`}jq c mzqx`e`acx`ki ekr

njchjrqf` cih rjqkiq`o`n`xp |f`af. `i xzri. aci mzqx`ep xfj

?5

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

27/128

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

28/128

Xfj akiajxzcn h`qx`iax`ki ojx|jji iki'hja`q`ki

gcd`il ki xfj kij fcih cih xfj |krd`il ke xfj

gko`n`}cx`ki ke o`cq ki xfj kxfjr hkjq ikx cjcr ujrp

anjcr'azx) Ocafrcaf cih Ocrcx} qjjg xk xrjcx xfj

gko`n`}cx`ki ke o`cq cq c gkrj ljijrcn rkonjg. ke |f`af

iki'hja`q`ki gcd`il `q ozx kij cqjax. |fji xfjp hjqar`oj

iki'hja`q`ki gcd`il cq xfj r`gcrp gjxfkh ekr qzqxc`i`il c

l`uji gko`n`}cx`ki ke o`cq)

Fk|jujr. xfj xfjkrjx`acn cih gjxfkhknkl`acn

`gn`acx`kiq ke xfj akiajx ke iki'hja`q`ki gcd`il aciikx

oj kujrjqx`gcxjh) Xf`q x|k'h`gjiq`kicn u`j| ke k|jr

zihjrqakrjq xfj arza`cn `gkrxciaj ke `hjix`ep`il kxjix`cn

`qqzjq |f`af iki'hja`q`ki gcd`il rjujixq erkg oj`il

caxzcn) @x `q xfzq akiajrijh |`xf xfj hjxjrg`icx`ki cih

akgkq`x`ki ke xfj kn`x`acn cljihc) @i f`q Rrjecaj xk

Hjgkarcx`a Xfjkrp Hcfn f`gqjne hjqar`ojq xfj cljihc

qjxx`il h`gjiq`ki cq c hje`i`x`kicn afcrcaxjr`qx`a ke

knpcrafp= Cip gjgojr |fk jraj`ujq c qjx ke cnxjricx`ujq.

cx njcqx kij ke |f`af fj rjlcrhq cq rjejrconj xk cip ke xfj

cnxjricx`ujq rjqjixnp qafjhznjh. aci `iqjrx f`q rjejrrjh

?6

8/3/2019 United States Interventionist Policy in the Midde East

29/128

cnxjricx`uj&q cgkil xfkqj qafjhznjh ekr ukx`il) Kou`kzqnp

xf`q rjakih`x`ki ke knpcrafcn rznj `q u`kncxjh op xfj

jv`qxjiaj ke gjafci`qgq ekr jvanzh`il ajrxc`i `qqzjq)

Gkrjkujr. xfj akiajx. ecr erkg oj`il ci `iqxciaj ke c

crcik`h akiq`rcap xfjkrp. `q akggkinp dik|i cih |`hjnp

caajxjh `i xfj n`xjrcxzrj. xfkzlf kexji hjqar`ojh `i

h`eejrjix xjrgq)