united states district court...
TRANSCRIPT
MAR 8- 1991 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
-------------------------------x In re: clozapine Antitrust 90 civ. 8055, 8060, 8062-8065
Litigation 8067, 8069, 8071, 8073-8077, 8079-8082, 8084, 8086-8087, 8089, 8092; 91 civ. 244, 0921, 1043, 1165, 1219-1220, 1392 (JFK)
(See Attached Schedule of Actions)
-------------------------------x This Document Relates to All captioned Docket Numbers Return Date:
March 22, 1991 -------------------------------x
MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAEC VICE
Defendant Caremark Inc. ("Caremark") hereby moves under
Local General Rule 2(c) for the admission of the following
attorneys to argue and/or try the above captioned matter in whole
or in part as counselor advocate on behalf of Caremark:
Michael Sennett Michael A. Forti Rebecca C. Meriwether
The foregoing attorneys are all members of the law firm
of Bell, Boyd & Lloyd, Three First National Plaza, Chicago,
Illinois 60602 (312) 372-1121. All of the attorneys listed
above are members in good standing of their respective state
bars. A certificate of Good Standing for each applicant is
43\2015\PROHAEC1.MOT -1
annexed hereto as Exhibit A.
Respectfully submitted,
Pasquale A. Razzano CPR 7340) Theodore F. Shiells (TS 8592) CURTIS, MORRIS & SAFFORD, P.C. 530 Fifth Avenue New York, New York 10036 (212) 840-3333
Michael Sennett Michael A. Forti Michael J. Abernathy Rebecca C. Meriwether BELL, BOYD & LLOYD Three First National Plaza Chicago, Illinois 60602 (312) 372-1121
Attorneys for Defendant CAREMARK INC.
43\2015\PROHAEC1.MOT -2
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that true and correct copies of the
foregoing Defendant Caremark, Inc.'s Motion For Admission Pro
Haec Vice has been served this date upon all parties on the
attached service list by depositing same in the United States
Mail, first class postage prepaid, this 7th day of March, 1991.
43\2015\CERTIF.SRV -1
SERVICE LIST
Attorneys General:
Charles R. Johnson Assistant Attorney General Office of Attorney General 1275 west Washington Phoenix, AZ 85007
Thomas Greene Supervising Deputy Attorney General 1515 K Street, suite 511 P.O. Box 944255 Sacramento, CA 94244-2550
Barbara Motz, Deputy Attorney General Office of the Attorney General Department of Justice 3580 Wilshire Boulevard Los Angeles, CA 90010
James R. Lewis, Assistant Attorney General Business Regulation unit Enforcement Section 110-16th Street, loth Floor Denver, CO 80202
Steven M. Rutstein Assistant Attorney General 110 Sherman Street Hartford, CT 06105
John J. Polk Deputy Attorney General Department of Justice 820 North French Street Wilmington, DE 19801
Stuart Cameron Assistant corporation Counsel JUdiciary Plaza 450 5th Street, N.W., Rm. 8152 Washington, D.C. 20001
Jerome Hoffman, Assistant Attorney General Chief, Antitrust Bureau 2670 Executive Center Circle, W. sutton Building, suite 108 Tallahassee, FL 32301
Brett T. Delange, Deputy Attorney General Consumer Protection Unit statehouse Mail, Room 113A Boise, 1D 83720
John R. Perkins, Deputy Attorney General Hoover state Office Building Des Moines, 1A 50319
John W. Campbell, Deputy Attorney General Kansas Judicial Center, 2nd Floor Topeka, KS 66612
Francis E. Ackerman, Assistant Attorney General Consumer & Antitrust Division State House Station 6 Augusta, ME 04333
Ellen s. Cooper, Assistant Attorney General Deputy Chief, Antitrust Division 200 St. Paul Place, 19th Floor Baltimore, NO 21202
George K. Weber, Assistant Attorney General and Chief, Antitrust Division
Commonwealth of Massachusetts One Ashburton Place Boston, MA 02108
Thomas F. Pursell James Spencer Assistant Attorneys General 117 University Avenue 200 Ford Building st. Paul, MN 55155
Clayton S. Friedman, Assistant Attorney General Penntower Office Building 3100 Broadway, Suite 609 Kansas City, MO 64111
-2
Terry L. Robertson Senior Assistant Attorney General Consumer Protection and Antitrust Bureau 25 Capitol Street Concord, NH 03301
Laurel A. Price, Deputy Attorney General Division of Criminal Justice 25 Market Street -- CN 085 Trenton, NJ 08625
Robert Abrams, Attorney General Robert L. Hubbard, Assistant Attorney General Antitrust Bureau 120 Broadway, suite 2601 New York, NY 10271
James C. GUlick, Special Deputy Attorney General North Carolina Department of Justice P.o. Box 629 140 Fayetteville Mall Raleigh, NC 27602
Mitchell L. Gentile, Assistant Attorney General Antitrust Section 65 East State Street suite 708 Columbus, OH 43266-0590
Andrew E. Aubertine, Assistant Attorney General Oregon Department of Justice Financial Fraud section 100 Justice Bui~ding Salem, OR 97310 1
Eugene F. Waye, Chief Deputy Attorney General Antitrust Section Office of Attorney General Commonwealth of Pennsylvania 1435 strawberry Square Harrisburg, PA 17120
Jeffrey P. Hallem, Assistant Attorney General Office of the Attorney General 500 East Capitol Pierre, SO 57501-5070
-3
Perry Allan Craft, Deputy Attorney General 450 James Robertson ParkwayNashville, TN 37243-0485
Holly Lee Wiseman, Assistant Attorney General Antitrust Division Texas Attorney General's Office P.O. Box 12548 Austin, TX 78711-2548
Patrice M. Arent, Assistant Attorney General state of Utah 236 state Capitol Salt Lake City, UT 84114
Milton A. Marquis, Assistant Attorney General Antitrust and Consumer Litigation Section 101 North Eighth Street Richmond, VA 23219
Carol A. Smith, Assistant Attorney General 900 Fourth Avenue, Suite 2000 Seattle, WA 98164
Robert Wm. Schulenberg, III Senior Assistant Attorney General Antitrust Division 812 Quarrier Street, Fifth Floor Charleston, WV 25301
Kevin J. O'Connor, Assistant Attorney General 114 East, State Capitol Box 7857 Madison, WI 53707
Conse1 for Defendant Sandoz Pharmaceuticals:
Michael K. Murtaugh, Esq.Thomas R. Nelson, Esq. Donald J. Hayden, Esq. BAKER & MCKENZIE One Prudential Plaza 130 E. Randolph Drive Chicago, IL 60601
-4
-------- _ -- .. _~-_.
Dan Shulman, Esq.Quentin R. wittrock, Esq.GRAY, PLANT, MOOTY, MOOTY
& BENNETT, P.A. 3400 City Center 33 South sixth Street Minneapolis, MN 55402
Robert S. smith, Esq. PAUL, WEISS, RIFKIND,
WHARTON & GARRISON 1285 Avenue of the Americas 26th Floor New York, NY 10019
-5
STATE
Arizona
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
District of Columbia
SCHEDULE OF ACTIONS
NAME OF CASE
State of Arizona Grant Woods, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of California John K. Van de Kamp, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Colorado Duane Woodard, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
state of Connecticut Clarine Nardi Riddle, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
state of Delaware Charles M. oberly, III, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
District of Columbia John Payton, Acting Corporation Counsel v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
DOCKET NUMBER
91 CIV 0921
90 CIV 8060
90 CIV 8079
90 CIV 8062
91 CIV 1219
91 CIV 1220
.__.~_._--- --_.- ---_._-- _. -_._------
Florida
Idaho
Iowa
Kansas
Maine
Maryland
Massachusetts
State of Florida Robert A. Butterworth, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Idaho Larry Echohawk, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Iowa Thomas Miller, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Kansas Robert T. Stephan, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Maine James E. Tierney, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Maryland J. Joseph CUrran, Jr., Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
Commonwealth of Massachusetts James M. Shannon, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
90 CIV 8063
91 CIV 1043
90 CIV 8064
91 CIV 1165
90 CIV 8065
90 CIV 8067
90 CIV 8069
2
Minnesota
Missouri
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New York
North Carolina
Ohio
state of Minnesota Hubert H. Humphrey, III, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Missouri William L. Webster, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of New Hampshire John P. Arnold, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of New Jersey Robert J. Del Tufo, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of New York Robert Abrams, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of North Carolina Lacy H. 'I'hornburg, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Ohio Anthony J. Celebrezze, Jr., Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
3
90 CIV 8055
91 CIV 1392
90 CIV 8071
90 CIV 8073
90 CIV 8074
90 CIV 8092
90 CIV 8075
Oregon state of Oregon 90 CIV 8076 Dave Frohnmayer, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
Pennsylvania Commonwealth of 90 CIV 8077 Pennsylvania Ernest D. Preate, Jr. , Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
South Dakota State of South Dakota 91 CIV 0244 Mark Barnett, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
Tennessee State of Tennessee 90 CIV 8080 Charles w. Burson, Attorney General & Reporter v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
Texas State of Texas 90 CIV 8081 Jim Mattox, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and caremark Incorporated
Utah State of Utah 90 CIV 8082 I Paul Van Dam, Attorney
General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and caremark Incorporated
I
Virginia Commonwealth of 90 CIV 8084 Virginia Mary Sue Terry, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
4
Washington
West Virginia
Wisconsin
state of WashingtonKenneth o. Eikenberry, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals Corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of West VirginiaRoger W. Tompkins, Attorney General v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals corporation, and Caremark Incorporated
State of Wisconsin Don Hanaway, AttorneyGeneral v. Sandoz Pharmaceuticals corporation, and caremark Incorporated
90 CIV 8086
90 CIV 8087
90 CIV 8089
5
ATIORNEY REGISTRATION A\rn DISCIPLL~ARY COM1\USSION orlbe
SUPREME COURT OF ILLU'OlS
Michael Sennett Bell, Boyd , LloydThree First Nat'l Plaza 70 W. Madison st., .3200 Chicago, IL 60602
chicagoFebruary 6, 1991
In re: Michael Sennett Admitted october 29, 1977 Attorney No. 2550199
Dear Mr. Sennett:
The records of the Clerk of the Supreme Court of Illinois and of this office indicate that the attorney named above was admitted to the practice of law in Illinois; is currently registered on the Master Roll of Attorneys entitled to practice law in this state; and has never been disciplined.
Attached is a report reflecting any public matters and confidential pending investigations of the above named attorney. If further information is necessary regarding the status of pending investigation(s), please contact me.
Very JOHN
MTH:rt Enclosure
REQUEST DATE
BY GRUBISIC 02/06/91 FORM 2
ATTORNEY REGISTRATION AND DISCIPLINARY COMMISSION OF THE SUPREME COURT OF ILLINOIS
REGISTRATION AND DISCIPLINARY INFORMATION
ATTORNEY SENNETT, MICHAEL
LICENSE NAME SAME
DATE ADMITTED 10/29/77 LAST YEAR REGISTERED 1991
ATTORNEY NUMBER 02550199 ATTORNEY CODE 3
BUSINESS NAME BELL BOYD & LLOYD
BUSINESS ADDRESS
3 FIRST NATL PLAZA '3200
CHICAGO, IL
ZIP 60602
TELEPHONE (312) 372-1121
MATTERS PENDING
NUMBER COUNSEL BD
NONE
MATTERS TERMINATED
NUMBER BD EFFECTIVE TERM RULE DESCRIPTION
NONE
INVESTIGATIONS PENDING - 1979 TO PRESENT
NUMBER COUNSEL BD
NONE
-------~-- ----~- ---,------ -- -_. --- - -""- ._-- "-----
IJistrid of <!tolumbia <!tourt Df Appeals
I, RICHARD B. HOFFMAN, Clerk of the District of Columbia Court of
Appeals, do hereby certify that
REBECCA C. MERIWETHER
was on the _ll_t_h__ day of __S_E_P_T_EM_B_E_R , 19~
duly qualified and admitted as an attorney and counselor and entitled to prac
tice"before this Court and is. on the date indicated below, a member in good
standing of this Bar.
In Testimony Whereof, I have hereun
to subscribed my name and aflUed
the seal of this Court, at the City
of Washington, D.C. this 12th
day of FEBRUARY 19-!L
RICHARD B. HOFFMAN, Clerk.
Qronrt of App pals of :tIarylanb ~clis.JUb .'
'. ',~'
• .,j • '
'. . "B-.
. ,
,
CERTIFICATION
STATE OF MARYLAND, ss:
1, Alexander L. Cummings, Clerk of the Court of Appeals
of Maryland, de hereby certify that on the __t_w_en_t....;;,y_-_s_i_xt_h day
of J _un_ e , 19_8....;;.5_
REBECCA CALLCOTT MERIWETHER
having first taken and subscribed the oath prescribed by the Constitution
and Laws of this State, was admitted as an attorney of said Court, is now
in good standing, and as such is entitled to practice law in any of the
Courts of 'aid State, subject to the Rules of Court.
In UJrstimnnJ.J Blqrrrnf. 1 have hereunto set my
hand as Clerk, and affixed the Seal of the Court of
Appeal' of Maryland, thi, 7th day of
February , 19..;..9_1_
Clerk of the Court of Appeo.I.. of M4ry14t11l
AlTORNEY REGISTRATION AND D1SCIPLr\ARY CO~L\IlSSI0S of the
SUPREME COURT OF ILLl\OIS
Michael A. Forti Bell, Boyd' LloydThree First Nat'l Plaza 70 W. Madison st., '3200 Chicago, IL 60602
ChicagoFebruary 5, 1991
In re: Michael A. Forti Admitted October 29, 1980 Attorney No. 3127929
Dear Mr. Forti:
The records of the Clerk of the Supreme court of Illinois and of this office indicate that the attorney named above was admitted to the practice of law in Illinois; is currently registered on the Master Roll of Attorneys entitled to practice law in this state; and has never been disciplined.
Attached is a report reflecting any public matters and confidential pending investigations of the above named attorney. If further information is necessary regarding the status of pending investigation(s), please contact me.
Very truly JOHN C. OTJ'r.in.I~
MTM:rt Enclosure
I Nordl eN e:.,tiIlII ",... S,riIIl/WWU7fl-lWl 1'3 NonA tiI6uA AMI.". 0Jieq0 MMlI-U14 Ol7} sn..QJI ,.-.251-I0Il (311}U4-tJ6" 1~ IfZS
REQUEST DATE
BY GRUBISIC 02/05/91 FORM 2
ATTORNEY REGISTRATION AND DISCIPLINARY COMMISSION OF THE SUPREME COURT OF ILLINOIS
REGISTRATION AND DISCIPLINARY INFORMATION
ATTORNEY FORTI, MICHAEL A.
LICENSE NAME SAME
DATE ADMITTED 10/29/80 LAST YEAR REGISTERED !.ill
ATTORNEY NUMBER 03127929 ATTORNEY CODE 3
BUSINESS NAME BELL BOYD AND LLOYD
BUSINESS ADDRESS
THREE FIRST NATL PLAZA '3200
CHICAGO, IL
ZIP 60602
TELEPHONE (312) 372-1121
MATTERS PENDING
NUMBER COUNSEL BD
NONE
MATTERS TERMINATED
NUMBER BD EFFECTIVE TERM ROLE DESCRIPrION
NONE
INVESTIGATIONS PENDING - 1979 TO PRESENT
NUMBER COUNSEL BD
NONE
~ .--.-~-_._------ .._- ---- -_._---_.- - -,_