united states district court eastern district of …...exhibit 1 case 1:11-cv-05632-dli-rr-gel...

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK -----------------------------------------------------------X MARK A. FAVORS et al.,

Plaintiffs, No. 11 Civ. 5632 (RR) (GEL) (DLI)

v. ANDREW M. CUOMO et al., Defendants. -----------------------------------------------------------X

DECLARATION OF ERIC HECKER, ESQ.

ERIC HECKER, an attorney licensed to practice before this Court, declares the

following to be true under penalty of perjury, pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746:

1. I am a member of Cuti Hecker Wang LLP, and am counsel to Defendant-

Cross-Claimants Senate Minority Leader John L. Sampson and Senator Martin Malavé

Dilan (the “Senate Minority”) in the above-captioned action.

2. I write this Declaration in opposition to the Senate Majority’s motion for a

protective order on the basis of legislative privilege.

3. Attached hereto as Exhibit 1 is a true and correct copy of the Senate

Majority’s privilege log and its supplemental privilege log.

4. Attached hereto as Exhibit 2 are true and correct copies of some of the

emails included in the Senate Majority’s logs that were either sent to or written by my co-

counsel Jeffrey M. Wice, or by either of two Senate staffmembers: Matthew Trapasso,

Senator Dilan’s Policy and Legislative Director, or Dr. John Flateau, who worked (and

later volunteered) for the Senate Minority in various capacities.

Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 428 Filed 07/02/12 Page 1 of 2 PageID #: 8811

5. I declare the foregoing to be true under penalty of perjury.

/s/ Eric Hecker ERIC HECKER

Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 428 Filed 07/02/12 Page 2 of 2 PageID #: 8812

EXHIBIT 1

Case 1:11-cv-05632-DLI-RR-GEL Document 428-1 Filed 07/02/12 Page 1 of 686 PageID #: 8813

No. Author(s) Addressee(s) Copyee(s) Date Privilege Assertion General Subject Matter

1 Debra Levine 3/13/2012 Legislative Privilege Presentation reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

2 Bruce Ruiz Debra Levine

Marisa Vallvé; Eric Wienckowski; Lewis Hoppe; Isaac Fefer 1/10/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

3 Bruce Ruiz Jami-Ann KeithDebra Levine; Lewis Hoppe; Isaac Fefer 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege

Email with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

4 Bruce Ruiz Debra Levine 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

5 Bruce Ruiz

Jami-Ann Keith; Lewis Hoppe; Debra Levine; Roman Hedges

Isaac Fefer; Jeff Wice; Linda Robins; Mike Dubiac; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson; Darren McGeary 1/4/2012 Legislative Privilege


6 Bruce Ruiz

Jami-Ann Keith; Lewis Hoppe; Debra Levine; Roman Hedges

Isaac Fefer; Jeff Wice; Linda Robins; Mike Dubiac; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson; Darren McGeary 1/4/2012 Legislative Privilege


7 Bruce Ruiz Debra LevineDaniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Mark Burgeson 1/3/2012 Legislative Privilege


New York Redistricting LitigationPrivilege Log

1 of 167




8 Bruce Ruiz Mike Dubiac

Lewis Hoppe; Debra Levine; Isaac Fefer; Roman Hedges; Roman Hedges; Linda Robins; Linda Robins; Martin Dilan; Matthew Trapasso; Robert Oaks; Darren McGeary; Michael Nozzolio; John McEneny; David Schaefer; Jeff Wice; Ann Hess 12/29/2011 Legislative Privilege


9 Bruce Ruiz

Roman Hedges; Mike Dubiac; David Schaefer; Lewis Hoppe; Debra Levine; Isaac Fefer; Linda Robins; Andres Ledesma; Darren McGeary; Jeff Wice 12/22/2011 Legislative Privilege


10 Bruce Ruiz Debra Levine 12/22/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

11 Bruce Ruiz Debra Levine 12/12/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

12 Bruce Ruiz Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 1/6/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

13 Kelliann Cummings Debra Levine 3/13/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

14 Thomas Dunham Debra Levine 3/16/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

15 Linda Robins Lewis Hoppe; Debra Levine 7/13/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 16 Linda Robins Debra Levine 7/14/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 17 Meagan Fitzgerald Debra Levine 9/26/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 18 Meagan Fitzgerald Debra Levine 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

2 of 167




19 Linda Robins Lewis Hoppe; Debra Levine 7/11/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

20 Debra LevineAndres Ledesma; Robert Oaks; Debra Levine 7/14/2011 Legislative Privilege

Email with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

21 Andres Ledesma Debra Levine 7/14/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

22 Dina Weissman Debra Levine; Lewis Hoppe 8/30/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

23 Isaac Fefer Debra Levine 6/7/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 24 Isaac Fefer Debra Levine 6/7/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 25 Meagan Fitzgerald Debra Levine 6/14/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

26 Linda RobinsLewis Hoppe; Debra Levine; Dina Weissman 6/28/2011 Legislative Privilege


27 Linda RobinsLewis Hoppe; Debra Levine; Dina Weissman 6/28/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

28 Linda RobinsLewis Hoppe; Debra Levine; Dina Weissman 6/28/2011 Legislative Privilege


29 Lewis HoppeDebra Levine; Daniel Hennessy 6/28/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

30 Lewis Hoppe Debra Levine 6/29/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

31 Lewis Hoppe Debra Levine 6/30/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

32 Meagan Fitzgerald Debra Levine 7/7/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

33 Meagan Fitzgerald Debra Levine 7/7/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

34 Debra LevineLewis Hoppe; Daniel Hennessy; Bruce Ruiz 3/15/2012 Legislative Privilege


35 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 3/15/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 36 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 3/15/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

37 Debra Levine Daniel Hennessy 3/15/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

3 of 167




38 Debra Levine Kyle Miller 3/13/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

39 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 3/13/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

40 Debra Levine Debra Levine 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

41 Debra Levine Kyle Miller 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

42 Debra Levine Kemp Hannon 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

43 Debra Levine George Maziarz 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

44 Debra Levine Michael Ranzenhofer 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

45 Debra Levine Mark Grisanti 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

46 Debra Levine Patrick Gallivan 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

47 Debra Levine Thomas Omara 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

48 Debra Levine Catherine Young 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

49 Debra Levine Joseph Robach 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

50 Debra Levine James Alesi 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

51 Debra Levine Michael Nozzolio 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

52 Debra Levine David Valesky 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

53 Debra Levine Thomas Libous 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

4 of 167




54 Debra Levine James Seward 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

55 Debra Levine John Defrancisco 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

56 Debra Levine Hugh Farley 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

57 Debra Levine Patricia Ritchie 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

58 Debra Levine Elizabeth Little 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

59 Debra Levine Roy Mcdonald 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

60 Debra Levine John Bonacic 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

61 Debra Levine Stephen Saland 3/12/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

62 Debra Levine Gregory Ball 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

63 Debra Levine David Carlucci 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

64 Debra Levine Jeffery Klein 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

65 Debra Levine Andrew Lanza 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

66 Debra Levine Diane Savino 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

67 Debra Levine Martin Golden 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

68 Debra Levine Dean Skelos 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

69 Debra Levine Charles Fuschillo 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

5 of 167




70 Debra Levine Jack Martins 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

71 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

72 Debra Levine Owen Johnson 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

73 Debra Levine Lee Zeldin 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

74 Debra Levine John Flanagan 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

75 Debra Levine Kenneth Lavalle 3/12/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

76 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 3/10/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


78 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 3/10/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

79 Debra Levine James Maisano 3/9/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

80 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 3/9/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 81 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 3/9/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 82 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 3/7/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

83 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 3/7/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


85 Debra LevineDebra Levine; Debra Levine; Debra Levine 3/6/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


6 of 167




87 Debra Levine David Schaefer 3/2/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

88 Debra LevineDavid Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy 3/2/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

89 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 3/2/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 90 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 3/2/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

91 Debra LevineDaniel Hennessy; David Schaefer 3/2/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

92 Debra LevineDaniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Bruce Ruiz 3/2/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


95 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz 3/1/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

96 Debra LevineLinda Robins; Darren McGeary 3/1/2012 Legislative Privilege


97 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 2/28/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 98 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 2/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 99 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 2/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

100 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz; Dina Weissman 2/27/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

101 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 2/23/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

102 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 2/21/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


104 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz 2/21/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



7 of 167




107 Debra Levine Debra Levine 2/21/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

108 Debra LevineRoman Hedges; Linda Robins; Mike Dubiac 2/10/2012 Legislative Privilege


109 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


111 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

112 Debra LevineDaniel Hennessy; David Schaefer 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege



114 Debra Levine Marisa Vallvé 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 115 Debra Levine Marisa Vallvé 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

116 Debra LevineMeagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege


117 Debra Levine David Schaefer 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 118 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 119 Debra Levine Carole Maddalla 2/8/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 120 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 2/1/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 121 Debra Levine Eric Wienckowski 2/1/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 122 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 2/1/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 123 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 2/1/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 124 Debra Levine Kemp Hannon 1/31/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

125 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz; Jami-Ann Keith 1/31/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 126 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/31/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

127 Debra Levine

Roman Hedges; Mike Dubiac; Linda Robins; Bruce Ruiz 1/31/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

128 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

8 of 167





130 Debra LevineCarl Marcellino; Mary Anne Hicks 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege


131 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 132 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

133 Debra Levine Kelliann Cummings 1/27/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

134 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 135 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 136 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 137 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 138 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 139 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 140 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 141 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 142 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

143 Debra Levine

David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson; Meagan Fitzgerald 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

144 Debra Levine Kemp Hannon 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 145 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 146 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 147 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 148 Debra Levine Kemp Hannon 1/27/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 149 Debra Levine Debra Levine 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 150 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

151 Debra LevineBruce Ruiz; Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

9 of 167




152 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 153 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 154 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 155 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


157 Debra Levine George Maziarz 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

158 Debra Levine Michael Ranzenhofer 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

159 Debra Levine Mark Grisanti 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

160 Debra Levine Patrick Gallivan 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

161 Debra Levine Thomas Omara 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

162 Debra Levine Catherine Young 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

163 Debra Levine Joseph Robach 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

164 Debra Levine James Alesi 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

165 Debra Levine Michael Nozzolio 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

166 Debra Levine Thomas Libous 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

167 Debra Levine James Seward 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

168 Debra Levine John Defrancisco 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

10 of 167




169 Debra Levine David Valesky 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


171 Debra Levine Jeffery Klein 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

172 Debra Levine Diane Savino 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

173 Debra Levine David Schaefer 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

174 Debra Levine Martin Dilan 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

175 Debra Levine Martin Dilan 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

176 Debra Levine Martin Dilan 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


178 Debra Levine Martin Dilan 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

179 Debra Levine Hugh Farley 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

180 Debra Levine Patricia Ritchie 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

181 Debra Levine Joseph Griffo 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

182 Debra Levine Elizabeth Little 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

183 Debra Levine Roy Mcdonald 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

184 Debra Levine John Bonacic 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

185 Debra Levine Stephen Saland 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

11 of 167




186 Debra Levine Gregory Ball 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

187 Debra Levine William Larkin 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

188 Debra Levine Andrew Lanza 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

189 Debra Levine Martin Golden 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

190 Debra Levine Dean Skelos 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

191 Debra Levine Charles Fuschillo 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

192 Debra Levine Jack Martins 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

193 Debra Levine Kemp Hannon 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

194 Debra Levine Carl Marcellino 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

195 Debra Levine Owen Johnson 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

196 Debra Levine Lee Zeldin 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

197 Debra Levine John Flanagan 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

198 Debra Levine Kenneth Lavalle 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


201 Debra LevineMeagan Fitzgerald; Debra Levine 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

12 of 167




202 Debra Levine Beatrice Armony 1/26/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

203 Debra Levine Beatrice Armony 1/26/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



206 Debra Levine Kelliann Cummings 1/25/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

207 Debra LevineDina Weissman; Janylyn Merkur 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege


208 Debra LevineLinda Robins; Jami-Ann Keith; Roman Hedges 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege


209 Debra LevineRoman Hedges; Linda Robins 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

210 Debra Levine Carole Maddalla 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 211 Debra Levine Kyle Miller 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

212 Debra Levine Kyle Miller 1/25/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

213 Debra LevineKyle Miller; Meagan Fitzgerald 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege








13 of 167




219 Debra Levine Lewis Hoppe 1/25/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.




222 Debra Levine Janylyn Merkur 1/25/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.




226 Debra Levine Janylyn Merkur 1/25/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

227 Debra LevineLinda Robins; Roman Hedges; Mike Dubiac 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege


228 Debra Levine Carole Maddalla 1/25/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

229 Debra LevineMeagan Fitzgerald; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege


230 Debra Levine Carole Maddalla 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 231 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/25/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 232 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/24/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 233 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/24/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

234 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/24/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

235 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac; Isaac Fefer 1/24/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

14 of 167




236 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac; Isaac Fefer 1/24/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


238 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/24/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

239 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/24/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 240 Debra Levine Carole Maddalla 1/24/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 241 Debra Levine Roman Hedges 1/24/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

242 Debra LevineCarole Maddalla; Dina Weissman 1/24/2012 Legislative Privilege



244 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald Debra Levine 1/24/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


247 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/23/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


249 Debra LevineRoman Hedges; Mike Dubiac 1/23/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

250 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/20/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 251 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/20/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 252 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/20/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 253 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz 1/20/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 254 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/19/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 255 Debra Levine Daniel Hennessy 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 256 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 257 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 258 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

15 of 167




259 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 260 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 261 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 262 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/18/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 263 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/13/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

264 Debra Levine Beatrice Armony 1/13/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

265 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 1/13/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 266 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz 1/12/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



269 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz 1/11/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

270 Debra Levine

Isaac Fefer; Bruce Ruiz; Marisa Vallvé; Eric Wienckowski 1/11/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



273 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 1/9/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 274 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/9/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 275 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/9/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 276 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/6/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

277 Debra LevineLinda Robins; Roman Hedges 1/6/2012 Legislative Privilege


278 Debra Levine Eric Wienckowski 1/6/2012 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


16 of 167




280 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 281 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 282 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 283 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 284 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 285 Debra Levine Linda Robins 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 286 Debra Levine Roman Hedges 1/5/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 287 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/4/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

288 Debra LevineMike Dubiac; Jami-Ann Keith 1/4/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

289 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/3/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 290 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 1/3/2012 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

291 Debra LevineMike Dubiac; Isaac Fefer; Lewis Hoppe 12/22/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

292 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 12/22/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 293 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 12/21/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 294 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 12/21/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 295 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 12/20/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.





299 Debra Levine

Roman Hedges; Lewis Hoppe; Mike Dubiac; Linda Robins 12/19/2011 Legislative Privilege


300 Debra Levine Roman Hedges 12/19/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


17 of 167




302 Debra Levine

Meagan Fitzgerald; Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Mark Burgeson 12/19/2011 Legislative Privilege




305 Debra Levine

Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Mark Burgeson; Thomas Dunham 12/8/2011 Legislative Privilege


306 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 12/7/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

307 Debra Levine David Schaefer 11/21/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

308 Debra Levine

Meagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy 11/21/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

309 Debra Levine Beatrice Armony 11/17/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 310 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 11/17/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 311 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 11/17/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 312 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 11/17/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 313 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 11/17/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

314 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 11/16/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

315 Debra Levine Darren McGeary 11/16/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


317 Debra Levine Lewis Hoppe 11/16/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

318 Debra Levine Lewis Hoppe 11/16/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

18 of 167




319 Debra Levine Jeff Wice; Andres Ledesma 11/16/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

320 Debra Levine Jeff Wice; Andres Ledesma 11/16/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.





323 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 11/16/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

324 Debra Levine

Thomas Dunham; Meagan Fitzgerald; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy 11/16/2011 Legislative Privilege


325 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 11/16/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

326 Debra Levine Thomas Dunham 11/16/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

327 Debra Levine

Thomas Dunham; Meagan Fitzgerald; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy 11/16/2011 Legislative Privilege


328 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 11/16/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 329 Debra Levine David Schaefer 11/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 330 Debra Levine David Schaefer 11/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

331 Debra Levine

Meagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham; Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer 11/15/2011 Legislative Privilege


19 of 167




332 Debra Levine

Meagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham; Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer 11/15/2011 Legislative Privilege





336 Debra Levine

Meagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham; Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer 11/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

337 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer; Bruce Ruiz 11/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



340 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 11/14/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 341 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 11/14/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 342 Debra Levine Linda Robins 11/14/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

343 Debra Levine Debra Levine 11/10/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

344 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 11/10/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 345 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 11/10/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 346 Debra Levine Linda Robins 11/10/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


348 Debra Levine Linda Robins 11/7/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 349 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 11/7/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

20 of 167




350 Debra Levine

David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson; Thomas Dunham 11/1/2011 Legislative Privilege


351 Debra Levine Thomas Dunham 11/1/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

352 Debra LevineIsaac Fefer; Bruce Ruiz; Scott Smith 11/1/2011 Legislative Privilege


353 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 10/31/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 354 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac Darren McGeary 10/28/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

355 Debra LevineRoman Hedges; Mike Dubiac; Linda Robins 10/28/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

356 Debra LevineRoman Hedges; Mike Dubiac; Linda Robins 10/28/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

357 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 10/26/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 358 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 10/25/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

359 Debra LevineDavid Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy 10/24/2011 Legislative Privilege





362 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 10/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

363 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac; Lewis Hoppe 10/21/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

364 Debra Levine David Schaefer 10/20/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

365 Debra Levine

Mark Burgeson; Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Thomas Dunham 10/19/2011 Legislative Privilege


366 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 10/18/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

21 of 167




367 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 10/18/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 368 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer 10/18/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 369 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 10/18/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 370 Debra Levine Janylyn Merkur 10/18/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 371 Debra Levine Janylyn Merkur 10/18/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

372 Debra LevineDaniel Hennessy; David Schaefer 10/17/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

373 Debra LevineDaniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Mark Burgeson 10/12/2011 Legislative Privilege



375 Debra LevineJami-Ann Keith; Mike Dubiac 10/6/2011 Legislative Privilege




377 Debra LevineDarren McGeary; Andres Ledesma 10/6/2011 Legislative Privilege


378 Debra LevineAndres Ledesma; Darren McGeary 10/6/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



380 Debra LevineDavid Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson 10/6/2011 Legislative Privilege



382 Debra Levine Dean Skelos 10/6/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

383 Debra Levine James Maisano 10/4/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

384 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 10/4/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

385 Debra LevineMeagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham 10/4/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

22 of 167




386 Debra Levine

Bruce Ruiz; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson 10/4/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


388 Debra Levine Isaac Fefer; Bruce Ruiz 10/4/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


390 Debra Levine

David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson; Thomas Dunham 10/4/2011 Legislative Privilege


391 Debra Levine Mike Dubiac 10/4/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 392 Debra Levine Lewis Hoppe 10/4/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 393 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 10/4/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.







398 Debra Levine Debra Levine; Debra Levine 9/28/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

399 Debra Levine Debra Levine; Debra Levine 9/28/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

400 Debra Levine

Meagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy 9/28/2011 Legislative Privilege


23 of 167






402 Debra Levine

Meagan Fitzgerald; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Thomas Dunham 9/28/2011 Legislative Privilege







408 Debra LevineDavid Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Thomas Dunham 9/28/2011 Legislative Privilege


409 Debra LevineDavid Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Thomas Dunham 9/28/2011 Legislative Privilege



411 Debra LevineDaniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Mark Burgeson 9/27/2011 Legislative Privilege


412 Debra Levine Debra Levine 9/27/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

413 Debra LevineMeagan Fitzgerald; Thomas Dunham 9/27/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

414 Debra Levine Linda Robins 9/27/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

415 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 9/27/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

24 of 167




416 Debra Levine Linda Robins 9/27/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

417 Debra Levine Lewis Hoppe 9/23/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


419 Debra Levine Linda Robins 9/23/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



422 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 9/23/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 423 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 9/23/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 424 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/21/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 425 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/20/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.







431 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 9/19/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 432 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/19/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 433 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 9/19/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 434 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

435 Debra Levine James Maisano 9/15/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.


25 of 167





438 Debra Levine Linda Robins 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 439 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 440 Debra Levine Linda Robins 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 441 Debra Levine Linda Robins 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



444 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 445 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 446 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/15/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 447 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/14/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

448 Debra LevineDina Weissman; Isaac Fefer; Lewis Hoppe 9/14/2011 Legislative Privilege


449 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz; Isaac Fefer 9/13/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

450 Debra LevineDavid Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Mark Burgeson 9/13/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

451 Debra Levine Jeff Wice 9/12/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 452 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/12/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 453 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/12/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 454 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/12/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 455 Debra Levine Jami-Ann Keith 9/9/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

456 Debra LevineLinda Robins; Mike Dubiac; Jami-Ann Keith 9/9/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.




26 of 167








462 Debra Levine Lewis Hoppe 9/1/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 463 Debra Levine David Schaefer 9/1/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

464 Debra Levine

Linda Robins; David Schaefer; Daniel Hennessy; Meagan Fitzgerald 9/1/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

465 Debra Levine

Debra Levine; Daniel Hennessy; David Schaefer; Meagan Fitzgerald 9/1/2011 Legislative Privilege


466 Debra Levine Linda Robins 9/1/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 467 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 9/1/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 468 Debra Levine James Maisano 9/1/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 469 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/31/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.



471 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 8/31/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 472 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/31/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 473 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/31/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.




27 of 167





478 Debra LevineJami-Ann Keith; Linda Robins 8/30/2011 Legislative Privilege


479 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 8/30/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 480 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 8/30/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 481 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 8/30/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 482 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 8/26/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

483 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/26/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachments reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

484 Debra LevineLinda Robins; Roman Hedges Lewis Hoppe 8/26/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

485 Debra Levine Bruce Ruiz Lewis Hoppe 8/25/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

486 Debra Levine Robert Oaks 8/25/2011 Legislative PrivilegeEmail with attachment reflecting confidential information relating to redistrictingissues.

487 Debra LevineAndres Ledesma; Robert Oaks Meagan Fitzgerald 8/25/2011 Legislative Privilege


488 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/25/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 489 Debra Levine Dina Weissman 8/25/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 490 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/25/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 491 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 492 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 493 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 494 Debra Levine Janylyn Merkur Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 495 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 496 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.


498 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 499 Debra Levine Meagan Fitzgerald 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues. 500 Debra Levine Linda Robins 8/24/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to redistricting issues.

28 of 167





502 Debra Levine Jessica Hill 8/22/2011 Legislative Privilege Email reflecting confidential information relating to re

united states district court eastern district of …...exhibit 1 case 1:11-cv-05632-dli-rr-gel...

Documents