underground great wall

357
!"# %&'((') *# +,"-." /0 1.)2.3-." /455 !"#$%&&'(')* !"#$%&&'(')*

Upload: buikiet

Post on 03-Feb-2017

231 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Underground Great Wall

!"#$%&'((')$*#$+,"-."$

/0$1.)2.3-."$/455$

!"#$%&&'(')*+

!"#$%&&'(')*+

Page 2: Underground Great Wall

!"#$%&'((')$*#$+,"-."$

6'2&$,77'72,89.$:";3$<'3$=";68>$?.7$@";77>$A#B$C,D",E$,8F$2&.$72GF.827$;:$7.3'8,"7H$$

*"37$@;82";($I$BG(2');(,"'2E$,8F$$JKLM$*7',8$*"37$@;82";($%";7).927$JL0N$$

11 September 2011!

Georgetown University!Asian Arms Control Project!

Page 3: Underground Great Wall

O;"6,"F$!"#$%%&#'()#*+,)-'.,#./#'()#*)/)"0)#1(,)2'#3)45-6."#78)"-9#20:)4#'()#1(,)2'#3)45-6."#74;+0.,9#<.==+>))#?-+)"-)#@#1)-(".A.89#B2")A# '.# C.+"#D+'(# '()#*137#E5-A)2,#*)'),,)"-)#B2")A# '.#244,)00# +=F,.;)=)"'0#"))4)4# +"#4)')-6."G#=."+'.,+"8#2"4#;),+H-26."#,)A2')4#'.#/5'5,)#2,=0#-."',.AI!

J.AA.D+"8#'()#K29#$%%&#?+-(52"#)2,'(L52:)G#'()#<(+")0)#=)4+2#M)-2=)#=.,)#.F)"#2M.5'#'()#BN7O0#4)-24)0#A."8#)P.,'#'.#F,.')-'#'()+,#"5-A)2,#=+00+A)#/.,-)0#'(,.58(#'5"")A+"8I#!#-.==+00+.")4#?@1#F2")A#=)=M),#*,I#B(+AA+F#7I#Q2,M),#'.#-."45-'#2"#R.F)"#0.5,-)S#0'549#./#D(2'#'()#B3<#-2AA)4#'()+,#RT"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AAIS!

*,I#Q2,M),#D20#'()#,+8('#F),0."#/.,#'(+0#200+8"=)"'#8+;)"#(+0#/.5,#4)-24)0#)WF),+)"-)X#D+'(#'()#<."8,)00+."2A#Y.+"'#<.==+>))#."#7'.=+-# Z"),89[# 20# 4+,)-'.,# ./# '()#E26."2A# ?)-5,+'9# <.5"-+A# ")'# 200)00=)"'#F,.C)-'# \&][# 0',2')89#24;+0.,# '.# ?)-,)'2,9#./#*)/)"0)#V)+"M),8),[#2"4#M+F2,602"#,)F5'26."#+"#24;+0+"8#'()#<."8,)00#."#0)-5,+'9^2,=0#-."',.A#+005)0I#_)#0),;)4#."#'()#J.5,#B.D),#70+2"#?)-5,+'9#<.==+>))#`2FF.+"')4#M9#?)-,)'2,9#<2,A5--+aG#(24#2;+26."#)WF),+)"-)# +"#<(+"2G#20#D)AA#20#()240#U).,8)'.D"#T"+;),0+'9O0#70+2"# 7,=0# <."',.A# B,.C)-'# D+'(# 2# F..A# ./# ',2+")4# 0'54)"'# ,)0)2,-(),0# D+AA+"8# '.# -.=M# '(,.58(# '(.502"40# ./# F28)0# ./# =+A+'2,9#D,+6"80#2"4#(5"4,)40#./#(.5,0#./#<(+")0)#')A);+0+."#-.;),28)I!

!"#'()#=+44A)#./#'()#Q2,M),#F,.C)-'#b#."#\\#*)-)=M),#$%%c#dd#'()#B).FA)O0#N+M),26."#7,=9#.e-+2AA9#2"".5"-)4#'()+,#RT"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'# V2AAS# F,.C)-'# 2"4# F5MA+-A9# -A2+=)4# '(2'# +'# +";.A;)4# fG%%%# =+A)0# ./# '5"")A0# /.,# '()# -."-)2A=)"'# ./# "5-A)2,# D)2F."0I# 1()#U).,8)'.D"# ')2=# (20# 200)=MA)4# (5"4,)40# ./# F28)0# ./# 4.-5=)"'26."# 2"4# 2# gh#=+"5')# ;+4).# -.=F)"4+5=# ./# '5"")A# -.;),28)#0(.D"#."#<(+")0)#')A);+0+."I#1()+,#);+4)"-)#0588)0'0#2#=200+;)#2"4#=.4),"#)P.,'# '(2'# +"-A54)0#=.M+A)# !<iK0# +"#")D#-.=FA)W)0I#1(+0#,)F.,'#05==2,+j)0#'()#+=FA+-26."0#./#'()#BN7#=+00+A)#5"4),8,.5"4I!

1()#05,F,+0+"8#0-.F)#./#'()#)P.,'#-.=M+")4#D+'(#'()#209==)',+-2A#"2'5,)#./#'()#2FF,.2-(#5"4),0-.,)0#'()#+=F.,'2"-)#./#'()#Q2,M),#)P.,'#+"#A..:+"8#2'#'()#L5)06."0#./#0',2')8+-#-5A'5,)#M)(+"4#+'X#V(9#4+4#'()#<(+")0)#=2:)#'(+0#:+"4#./#)P.,'k#_.D#D.5A4#+'#/5"-6."#.F),26."2AA9k#V(2'# 2,)# '()# +=FA+-26."0# /.,# .5,# .D"# /.,D2,4# 4)FA.9)4# /.,-)# 05,;+;2M+A+'9G# 2AA+)4# 0)-5,+'9# 852,2"'))0# 2"4# 2,=0#-."',.A#0',2')89k#!

1()#*137#137<#F2")A0#(2;)#0+"-)#M))"#05F),0)4)4#M9#.'(),#."d8.+"8#)P.,'0G#M5'# '()#Q2,M),#3)F.,'# 0(.D0# '(2'#D)#"))4# '.#8+;)#<(+"2O0#);.A;+"8#"5-A)2,#F.0'5,)#=.,)#2>)"6."G#'(2'#'()9#(2;)#".'#."A9#(2;)#'2:)"#2"#2FF,.2-(#'.#"5-A)2,#/.,-)#05,;+;2M+A+'9#'(2'#+0#L5+')# 4+P),)"'# '(2"#.5,# .D"#)WF),+)"-)G# M5'# '(2'# /5,'(),# 0'2M+A+j26."#2"4# ,)45-6."#./#=2C.,# "5-A)2,# F.D),# +";)"'.,+)0#D+AA# ".'#05--))4#D+'(.5'#M,+"8+"8#'()#B3<#+"'.#2#F.0'5,)#./#")8.62')4#-."0',2+"'I!

Dr. Joseph V. Braddock !"#$%&'()*+',-)'!.//$0011''

23445634478'

Page 4: Underground Great Wall

!"#$%&'(()$*+,-,./$*((0,+%1((2%33$

contents!%,,-./01+2 !?+-(52"#)2,'(L52:)#15"")A#)WF.05,)#%,,-./01+3 #1D)"'9dH;)#_5"4,)4#l)2,0#./#<2;)#*)/)"0) !!%,,-./01+4+ !<+;+A#*)/)"0)#15"")A+"8#%,,-./01+5+ !B2>),"0#./#Z2,A9#E5-A)2,G#E2;2A#@#7+,#i20)#15"")A+"8#

%,,-./01+6 !$"4#7,6AA),9#T"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AA!# #B(20)#!X#\c&hd\cch#b#N+L5+4#3.-:)'#R,.AAd.5'S#! #B(20)#!!X#\cc]d$%\%#b#?.A+4#J5)A#?3iK^!3iK#R)"(2"-)4#=.M+A+'9S#

! #B(20)#!!!X#$%\\dkk#b#15"")A#i20)4#3.24^32+A#K.M+A)#K!3m)4#!<iK!%,,-./01+7 !nF),26."2A#<."-)F'X#_+4)G#?5,8)G#?',+:)G#K.;)G#_+4)#

%,,-./01+8 !i,)2:.5'#@#!"0'2M+A+'9!# #T"-),'2+"6)0#2"4#'()#B,.MA)=0#./#K."+'.,+"8#@#m),+H-26."#! !BN7#*)'),,)"-)#1().,9#b#K+"+=5=#;0I#V2,#J+8(6"8!! !!005)0#/.,#7,=0#<."',.A#

90/-:;+ #$"4#7,6AA),9#<.=)0#n5'#./#'()#<2;)!9:<=>-? !$"4#7,6AA),9#1,2"0A2')4#7,6-A)#<.AA)-6." !!

Page 5: Underground Great Wall

Implications of American Entropy:"

China’s Strategic Rocket Force "“Underground Great Wall”!

•  "#$$%&$!'&(#)*&#+!,!+-*.&/!01#!2%(+!3)*!4#!5.$$#+!678!%9!01#!:%;.#0!$0%<=>.(#?!.@#@!A7?777!4)*1#)+$!4#*#!&%0!)<<%-&0#+!9%*!)&+!>*#$-5#+!&%0!0%!#B.$0C!

•  D.$$#+!:./&.E<)&<#!FF!41.(#!01#!':!1)$!0*)<=#+!GH2!0-&&#(!<%&$0*-<I%&!9%*!J#)*$?!01#!$<%>#?!5)/&.0-+#!)&+!$0*)0#/.<!*)I%&)(!K#1.&+!01#!L'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!1)$!K##&!-&+#*!)>>*#<.)0#+C!

•  D.$$#+!O*#&+$!,!01#!21.&#$#!K-.(+->!%9!01#.*!O1#)0#*F:0*)0#/.<!H%<=#0!P%*<#!1)$!&%0!K##&!01#!9%<-$!)!<%5>*#1#&$.;#!)((!$%-*<#!)&)(J$.$!01)0!.&<(-+#$!0#<1&%(%/J?!+#>(%J5#&0?!%>#*)I%&)(!<%&<#>0$?!*#)+.&#$$?!(%/.$I<$?!0*).&.&/!)$!4#((!)$!>*%0#<I;#!+#<#>I%&?!+.$>#*$)(!)&+!-&+#*/*%-&+!+#>(%J5#&0C!

•  D.$$.&/!3)*1#)+$!,!>-K(.<!#$I5)0#$!%9!21.&#$#!&-<(#)*!4)*1#)+$!*)&/#!9*%5!Q77!0%!R77?!GH2!+)0)!.&!STT6!/);#!01#!E/-*#!)0!AQ67?!)&+!.9!01#!+%-K(.&/!%9!0-&&#(.&/!$.&<#!01#&!.$!*#U#<0#+!.&!01#!$.V#!%9!01#!>*%0#<0#+!9%*<#?!%-*!>-K(.<!&-5K#*$!<%-(+!K#!#)$.(J!%W!KJ!)!9)<0%*!%9!S7@!

•  D.$$.&/!X$$#$$5#&0!,!4#!1);#!&%0!01%-/10!01*%-/1!41)0!)((!01.$!5#)&$!9%*!':!9%*<#$!+#>(%J#+!.&!01#!*#/.%&?!(#0!)(%&#!01#!.5>)<0!%9!)!L$-*>*.$#N!*%((F%-0!.&!01#!5.++(#!%9!)!*#/.%&)(!<*.$.$!%9!)!5-<1!()*/#!Y2ZD!9%*<#!01)&!#$I5)0#+@!

7+

Page 6: Underground Great Wall

@AB-C+D-E-<FG:.+:H+3IIJ+

P1.9;8F$*"2'((."E$&,7$L>444Q3$;:$R8F."S";G8F$<G88.(7T$

@AB-C+D-E-<FG:.+:H+3IIJ

P1.9;8F$*"2'((."E$&,7$L>444Q3$;:$R8F."S";G8F$<G88.(7T$

������������������!

Second Artillery Missile Geography !

K=.L-M?N+O:=.AF0.?+F./+D0E-M?+%<<+PE-M+AB-+#:=.AMQ+R:?0G:.?!

Page 7: Underground Great Wall

S0?A:M0TF<<Q+AB-+RD#+BF?+U--.+)VWD)O)$X+GYBA+<0,,-/+FU:=A+AB-0M+.=T<-FM+H:MT-?Z+%+DF/0TF<+&B0[+0.+&AFA-+K-BFE0:M+ABFA+0?+"PW+F??:T0FA-/+\0AB+F,,FM-.A+-1A-M.F<+:M+0.A-M.F<+?G>=<0+MF0?-?+ABM--+?-M0:=?+]=-?G:.?;+

+^+ +'?+0A+D-F<_++++^ +`BQ+/0/+AB-Q+/:+0A_+++^ +`BFA+/:-?+0A+R:MA-./+H:M+(=A=M-+U-BFE0:M_+

<&.$@&,((.8S.!

<&.$U));"2G8'2E!PE-M+AB-+<F?A+-0YBA+Q-FM?+AB-M-+BF?+U--.+F.+-1,:.-.GF<+0.TM-F?-+0.+#B0.-?-+/0?T=??0:.+:H+!"#$%&'()*++"),;+

+^ +OFa:M+K::L?+b+!#-"%#"'$.'/%&'()0,'12342-5%67'8+$)-$96':)2'$.'/%&'()0,+^ +c:=M.F<+%MGT<-?+b+FTA=F<<Q+?FQ+?:>-AB0.Y+FU:=A;++

dd+RM:U<->?+0.+AMF0.0.YN+<:Y0?GT?N+>F0.A-.F.T-N+<-F/-M?B0,+0.0GFGE-N+RFMAQ+>-//<0.Ye+dd+)>-MY0.Y+TF,FU0<0G-?+0.+>:U0<0AQN+?,FT-+UF?-/+D&'N+FTT=MFTQ+F./+<-ABF<0AQe+dd+)1,-M0>-.G.Y+\0AB+0..:EFGE-+c:0.A+#:>>F./+F./+WB-FA-M+#F>,F0Y.+#:.T-,A?Z+

+^ +W9+T:E-MFY-+b+RM0>-+W0>-+&-M0-?N+\--L<Q+.-\?+T:E-MFY-+^ +%.+-1,<:?0:.+:H+'.A-M.-A+UF?-/+0.H:M>FG:.+F./+>0<0AFMQ+

U<:YY0.YZ+

WB0?+:f-M?+AB-+,:A-.GF<+:H+<::L0.Y+H:M+0.?0YBA+0.+.:.dAMF/0G:.F<+?:=MT-?Z+

Page 8: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$R8F."S";G8F$D".,2$?,(($V.:.".89.F$'8$@&'8.7.$B'('2,"E$C'2.",2G".$

%MGT<-?+,-M+Q-FM+

7!

S7!

A7!

Q7!

R7!

67!

[7!

\7!

]7!

T7!

S77!

STT6! STT[! STT\! STT]! STTT! A777! A77S! A77A! A77Q! A77R! A776! A77[! A77\! A77]! A77T! A7S7!

%..=F<+.=>U-M+:H+%MGT<-?+M-H-M-.T0.Y+@!

./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<C++

Page 9: Underground Great Wall

X+5.&.$0*)0%*$!)&+!<#&$%*$!1);#!0*%-K(#!=##>!->!4.01!#B>(%$.%&!.&!0*)^<C!Z)<=+%%*$!)*#!(#_!%>#&!,!>)*I<-()*(J!.&!(#$$!$%>1.$I<)0#+!*#/.%&)(!$.0#$!,!!

:0*.&/!<1)*)<0#*!$#)*<1#$!>)*I<-()*(J!-$#9-(!

P)($#!$#&$#!%9!$#<-*.0J!)K%-0!()<=!%9!3#$0#*&!)<<#$$!0%!01#!()&/-)/#!FF!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!<*#)0#+!01#!+./.0)(!<%+#!01)0!5)=#$!21.&#$#!5)<1.&#!*#)+)K(#!

D.(.0)*J!K(%//#*$!(.=#!0%!$1)*#!L<%%(N!$0-W!)&+!#B<1)&/#!<*.I<)(!<%55#&0$!%&!.0C!'&.`-#!0*%;#!K-0!5)$$.;#!%;#*(%)+!%9!0*#)$-*#!)&+!0*)$1!FF!!

a##+!9%<-$!)&+!)&;.(!0%!0#$0!.0!)/).&$0@!

W82."8.2$O(;67$-;2&$?,E7H$W%X5455!

��!X.*!P%*<#!��!a);J!��!X*5J!��!XK&bD)*!

!A&+!X*0J!

��������

H#;.#4#+!

'$#+!!

D.(.0)*J!K(%/!0%>.<$!a!c!SQ]?QA7!

Page 10: Underground Great Wall

!

d)*+!2%>J!%*!Y&0#*&#0!.&!D)&+)*.&!

e./.IV#+!:<)&&.&/!->!0%!S77!>>!>#*!1%-*!

f-0>-0!GeP!E(#!

21.&#$#!f2H!H#)+.&/!:%_4)*#!

DeMZ!D)<1.&#!O*)&$()I%&!g!h+.I&/!

:#)*<1)K(#?!e.$0*.K-0)K(#?!:0%*)K(#!h(#<0*%&.<!D#+.)!

Page 11: Underground Great Wall

%+DF/0TF<+&B0[+0.+K-BFE0:M+HM:>+O0.0>0h0.Y+A:+S0YB<0YBG.Y_++dd+'?+0A+D-F<_++`BQ+/0/+AB-Q+:+0A_+`BFA+/:-?+0A+R:MA-./_+

S0?A:MQ;+%++*--,+#=<A=M-+:H+&AMFA-Y0T+#:.T-F<>-.A++'Z  &T:,-;+#=MM-.A+RBF?-+i2JJ6d3IIJj+F?+&B:\.+A:+*:>-?GT+%=/0-.T-?+''Z  '>,<0TFG:.?;+P,-MFG:.F<+`FMkYBG.Y+'''Z  '>,<0TFG:.?;+(:MT-+*-?0Y.+'9Z  '>,<0TFG:.?;+&AMFA-Y0T+*-A-MM-.T-+l+WB-FA-M+*0??=F?0:.+9Z   !.T-MAF0.G-?;+`BFA+?B:=</+U-+-1,-TA-/+0.+AB-+"-1A+RBF?-_+

*8$YZ)."'3.82!

Page 12: Underground Great Wall

WB0?+0?+"PW+F.+'.A-<<0Y-.T-+RM:/=TA;+dd+"P+T<F??0k-/+>FA-M0F<+:.+AB0?+A:,0T+T:.?=<A-/e+dd+"P+T:MM-<FG:.+:M+T:MM-TG:.+UQ+:AB-M?e+dd+"P+T<F0>+:H+FTT=MFTQ+:M+AM=ABZ+

mmm+++++Warning!!!!

WB0?+0?+F+g-:MY-A:\.+!.0E-M?0AQ+?A=/Q+:H+#B0.-?-+&AMFA-Y0T+#=<A=M-+l+%>-M0TF.+%M>?+#:.AM:<+).AM:,Q;+dd+*WD%+&lW+,F.-<+AF?L0.Y+U=A+.:dY:E-M.>-.A+H=./0.Ye+dd+=G<0h0.Y+:M0Y0.F<+F./+:.<Q+:,-.+?:=MT-+>FA-M0F<e+dd+Y-.-MFG.Y+B-=M0?GT+BQ,:AB-?-?+A:+U-+A-?A-/Z++

Page 13: Underground Great Wall

@KFABA=U+:H+'Y.:MF.T-Cn+

d./1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"%4!

%TT=MFTQ+

W0>-+

o1(+0#+0#".'#2"#+"4+-'=)"'#./#.5,#+"')AA+8)"-)#090')=IIII#1()#p2DG#+"0')24G#+0#+"#.5,#4)-+0+."d=2:+"8#F,.-)00I#n5,#090')=#,)2-'0#F.0+6;)A9#."A9#D()"#-."/,."')4#D+'(#(2,4#);+4)"-)#dd#2#F(.'.8,2F(#./#H)A4)4#)L5+F=)"'#dd#2"4#")826;)A9#'.#2"#+"')AA+8)"-)#-.==5"+'9#qM2'('5Mq#F,.C)-6."I#E.#.")#+"#V20(+"8'."#+0#D+AA+"8#'.#=2:)#2#4)-+0+."#5"6A#0(.D"#2#F+-'5,)#./#2#H)A4)4#090')=#+"-.,F.,26"8#")D#')-(".A.89[#'()"#'(),)#D+AA#M)#2AA#0.,'0#./#4..=0429#2"4#q(.D#-.5A4#'(+0#(2;)#(2FF)")4#,)2-6."0Io#

M#&@!e%&&!X@!:0)**J?!iX!2%55#&0?i!"%$!X()5%$!:<.#&<#?!j:-55#*!ST]Tkl!>>@!6RF6[C!)&+!G*#$$!f&m!:#(#<0#+!3%*=$!%9!M#&#*)(!e%&&!X@!:0)**J?!n%(@!Y?!#+.0#+!KJ!"#4.$!:%*(#J?!jP%*0!"#);#&4%*01?!o:l!':!X*5J!2%5K.&#+!X*5$!2#&0#*?!2%5K)0!:0-+.#$!Y&$I0-0#!G*#$$?!A77Tkl!>>?!SA]FSAT@!

Page 14: Underground Great Wall

@KFABA=U+:H+'Y.:MF.T-Cn+

RM-,M:/=TG:.+)?G>FA-?+

*-,<:Q>-.A+0.+!.0A?+d./1!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"%4

!%TT=MFTQ+

&0<:?+

&=U?+

%0M+KF?-?+

O:U0<-+O0??0<-?+

W=..-<?+

&,0-?+

D=>:M?+

(FT0<0G-?+

W-?A?+

RM:A:AQ,-?+

;$5'$.'<%0"++-5"%#"'

W0>-+

D-<:F/?+

#:>,:.-.A+O:/?+

*-,<:Q-/+D-?-ME-+

#:.?=>,G:.+

`FM+D-?-ME-+

&A:MFY-+

RM:/=TG:.+D=.?+

*->0<0AFM0hFG:.+

o1(+0#+0#".'#2"#+"4+-'=)"'#./#.5,#+"')AA+8)"-)#090')=IIII#1()#p2DG#+"0')24G#+0#+"#.5,#4)-+0+."d=2:+"8#F,.-)00I#n5,#090')=#,)2-'0#F.0+6;)A9#."A9#D()"#-."/,."')4#D+'(#(2,4#);+4)"-)#dd#2#F(.'.8,2F(#./#H)A4)4#)L5+F=)"'#dd#2"4#")826;)A9#'.#2"#+"')AA+8)"-)#-.==5"+'9#qM2'('5Mq#F,.C)-6."I#E.#.")#+"#V20(+"8'."#+0#D+AA+"8#'.#=2:)#2#4)-+0+."#5"6A#0(.D"#2#F+-'5,)#./#2#H)A4)4#090')=#+"-.,F.,26"8#")D#')-(".A.89[#'()"#'(),)#D+AA#M)#2AA#0.,'0#./#4..=0429#2"4#q(.D#-.5A4#'(+0#(2;)#(2FF)")4#,)2-6."0Io#

M#&@!e%&&!X@!:0)**J?!iX!2%55#&0?i!"%$!X()5%$!:<.#&<#?!j:-55#*!ST]Tkl!>>@!6RF6[C!)&+!G*#$$!f&m!:#(#<0#+!3%*=$!%9!M#&#*)(!e%&&!X@!:0)**J?!n%(@!Y?!#+.0#+!KJ!"#4.$!:%*(#J?!jP%*0!"#);#&4%*01?!o:l!':!X*5J!2%5K.&#+!X*5$!2#&0#*?!2%5K)0!:0-+.#$!Y&$I0-0#!G*#$$?!A77Tkl!>>?!SA]FSAT@!

Page 15: Underground Great Wall

Study #1!

4#5"/%$(+%,1"6/%7+(8/$$+3(+9:.'/,+$

Page 16: Underground Great Wall

/44[$1'9&G,8$Y,"2&\G,Q.$.Z);7.7$<G88.(7!

p !2%F(%<)I%&!%9!A77]!#)*01`-)=#!#>.<#&0#*!)&+!-&+#*/*%-&+!&-<(#)*!L)*5%*JCNS!p !h)*01`-)=#!L;%(<)&%N!$>(.0!5%-&0).&!$>#4.&/!5)&5)+#!<%&<*#0#!K(%<$CA!p !H#>%*0$!01)0!G"Xq$!()*/#$0!-&+#*/*%-&+!&-<(#)*!4#)>%&$!<)<1#!<%(()>$#+CQ!p !M%;#*&5#&0!<%&<#*&!%;#*!L*)+.)I%&N!(#)=)/#CR!p !")*/#!$<)(#!5.(.0)*J!*#)<I%&!4.01!SQ\?777!0*%%>$!+.$>)0<1#+!0%!`-)=#!)*#)!,!.&<(-+.&/!

A&+!X*I((#*J!#&/.&##*!+.;.$.%&6!)&+!A?\77!*)+.)I%&!0#<1&.<.)&$C[!p !G%$0!,`-)=#!$<.#&IE<!<%&0*%;#*$J!41#01#*!#;#&0!4)$!L0*.//#*#+N!KJ!1-5)&!)<I%&C\!p !2(%$-*#!%9!#>.<#&0#*!0%!*#>%*0#*$!)&+!>*#$$!$->>*#$$.%&@]!

S  3.((.)5!r@!Z*%)+?!L3#$0#*&!hB>#*0$!D%&.0%*!21.&)q$!a-<(#)*!:.0#$!9%*!:./&$!%9!h)*01`-)=#!e)5)/#?N!!E)D#l.,:#1+=)0?!jA77]@76@S[k?!s!1t>lbb444@&JI5#$@<%5bA77]b76bS[b4%*(+b)$.)bS[&-=#@105(!u!!v)<<#$$#+!Q7!r)&@!A7SSw@!!

A  L大地震销毁中国军队最大兵库!vh)*01`-)=#!e#$0*%J#+!01#!21.&#$#!X*5Jx$!")*/#$0!X*5%*Jw?N!wĻ.!vZF.-(#1+=)0?!O).4)&w?!jA77]@7\@7Rk!)0!s!1t>lbb444@#>%<1I5#$@<%5b/Kb]b\bRb&AS\]\7S@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!r)&@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Q  2)01#*.&#!d#&&#$$J?!L21.&)q$!a-<(#)*!Z)$#!hB>(%+#+!.&!y-)=#CN!Lh)$0#*&!:.<1-)&?!21.&)l!SA!D)J!A77]!7[lA]l7S!MDO?!DF\@T?!e#>01!ST@7F=5?N!Z2,'(L52:)#_2j2,40#B,.8,2=G!jA77T@S7@A]k?!)0!s!1t>lbb#)*01`-)=#@-$/$@/%;b#)*01`-)=#$b$1)=#5)>b/(%K)(b$1)=#bA77]*J)&b!u!v)<<#$$#+!AS!r)&@!A7SSw@!

R  r)=#!d%%=#*?!L'&#)*01#+!.&!y-)=#l!P()4$!.&!21.&#$#!D.(.0)*J!2)>)K.(.0J?N!E)D#l.,:#1+=)0?!jA77]@7\@7Sk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@&JI5#$@<%5bA77]b7\b7Sb4%*(+b)$.)b7S.10F<1.&)@Q@SRSQTR\R@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!AT!r)&@!A7SSw@!

6  GH2!)&&%-&<#5#&0!%9!A\!r-&#!A77]!`-%0#+!in: “媒體爆料大地震造成北川地下核爆 vZ*%=#!01#!a#4$l!X!")*/#!'&+#*/*%-&+!a-<(#)*!hB>(%$.%&!2)-$#+!KJ!h)*01`-)=#!.&!Z#.<1-)&?N!wĻ.!vZF.-(#1+=)0?!O).4)&w?!jA77T@76@7\k!)0!s!1t>lbb04@#>%<1I5#$@<%5bTb6b\bSSS\]7/@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!r)&@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

[  LS6!D.((.%&!G#%>(#!O1*#)0#&#+!KJ!a-<(#)*!2%&0)5.&)I%&?N!70+2E)D0G#jA77]@76@QSk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@)$.)&#[email protected]&#4$F#&bS6F5.((.%&F+.$>()<#+F>#%>(#F01*#)0#&#+FKJF&-<(#)*F<%&0)5.&)I%&FSAQT6@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!AT!r)&@!A7SSw@!

\  LX!d-5)&!O*.//#*!9%*!01#!M*#)0!y-)=#!%9!:.<1-)&zN!?-+)"-)#K282j+")?!jA77T@7S@S[kl!>>@!QAAC!D)(<%5!D%%*#?!L21.&#$#!h)*01`-)=#!5)J!1);#!K##&!D)&F5)+#?!$)J!:<.#&I$0$?N!1)A)8,2F(?!jA77T@7A@7Qk?!s!1t>lbb444@0#(#/*)>1@<%@-=b&#4$b4%*(+&#4$b)$.)b<1.&)bRRQRR77b21.&#$#F#)*01`-)=#F5)JF1);#FK##&F5)&F5)+#F$)JF$<.#&I$0$@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!AT!r)&@!A7SSwC!)&+!L3)$!21.&)x$!#)*01`-)=#!0*.//#*#+!KJ!)!&-<(#)*!)<<.+#&0z!h>.$%+#!Al!G#*1)>$?N!i..:./Y.)!K(%/?!jA77]@7[@7Rk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@K%%=%{%#@<%5bA77]b7[b4)$F<1.&)$F#)*0@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!Q7!r)&@!A7SSw@!

]  r%1&!r@!O=)<.=?!r*@?!L:#.$5.<!:->>*#$$.%&l!21.&#$#!2#&$%*$1.>!)_#*!01#!:.<1-)&!h)*01`-)=#?N!d#*.0)/#!P%-&+)I%&!V)MK)=.?!&%@!ST\S?!jA77]@7[@A[k?!)0!s!444@1#*.0)/#@%*/b*#$#)*<1b)$.))&+01#>)<.E<b45ST\S@<95!u!vQS!r)&@!A7SSwC!!G#0#*!o4%&/!g!D.&/!|.)?!L21.&)q$!'&&)0-*)(!e.$)$0#*l!O1#!O#)*$!%9!:.<1-)&!G*%;.&<#?N!jdZf!+%<-5#&0)*JC!a#4!}%*=?!a}l!2'a}?!X$.)&bX5#*.<)&!X$.)&!H#$#)*<1!Y&$I0-0#?!S6!D)J!A77Tk!)0!s!1t>lbb4&@<%5b:.<1-)&~G*%;.&<#!!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!r)&@!A7SSw@!

Page 17: Underground Great Wall

@&'8.7.$]G9(.,"$O,9'('2'.7$'8$%";Z'3'2E$2;$/44[$Y,"2&\G,Q.$

L21.&)l!y-)=#F+)5)/#+!a-=#!$.0#$!)*#!:)9#l!X-01%*.I#$!H#(#)$#!a#4!.&9%!:)J.&/!QA!H)+.)I%&!:%-*<#$!4#*#!e)5)/#+!.&!e.$)$0#*?N!<i?#E)D0?!jA77]@76@A7k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@<K$&#4$@<%5b$0%*.#$bA77]b76bA7b0#<1b5).&RSS7\\6@$105(z$%-*<#cH::)t*c:<.O#<1~RSS7\\6!u!v)<<#$$#+!Q7!r)&@!A7SSw@!

Page 18: Underground Great Wall

B,^;"$]G9(.,"$O,9'('2'.7$'8$_G,Q.$`;8.$

L !vh)*01`-)=#!e#$0*%J#+!01#!21.&#$#!X*5Jx$!")*/#$0!X*5%*Jw?N!���!?!.%>!<.0@!

O0F.QF.Y;+&T0-.T-+F./+W-TB.:<:YQ+#0AQ+:H+&T=<,A=M-+o&,M0.Y+WB=./-Mo+F+?Q>U:<+:H+F+.=T<-FM+-1,<:?0:.Z++

=>1$)">'6-%#"'0?"'6-@*"6'$.'+260'#"%09),7''

0?"'%93A")'$.'09%%"+6'-%'!-#?92%'%""&-%5'

)"42-)B'C-D#9+0'0$'#$9%0EF'

Page 19: Underground Great Wall

||||!

Lg=F.YQ=F.+R<F.A+p32;+43+37q"+2I6+63q)2%(%*!5)>!9*%5!s!1t>lbb)*<1.;#@$>)<#.5)/.&/@<%5b.=%&%$bAb=>5$bA777b7\bK*%4$#@RATRR@<*$$~$)0@7@7@�>/!u!v)<<#$$#+!S\!f<0@!A7S7w@!

Page 20: Underground Great Wall

1'9&G,8$/44[$;<1+,'".57(

)FMAB]=FL-+T<:?-+A:+>Fa:M+R$%+.=T<-FM+A=..-<+T:>,<-1+E5-A)2,#)WF),'0#02+4#'(2'#-A.0),#'.#'()#)F+-)"'),#./#'()#)2,'(L52:)G#+"#,588)4#(+AA0#2#'D.d(.5,#4,+;)#D)0'#./#K+2"92"8G#<(+"2#,5"0#2#(+8(A9#0)-,)6;)#-)"'),#'(2'#(.50)0#2#F,.=F'd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

$FMY-M+#MFA-M+.-FM+),0T-.A-M+F??:T0FA-/+\0AB+!./-MYM:=./+)1,<:?0:.+7--.,4+"8#'.#2#<E?#,)F.,'#."#K29#f\G#6'A)4#o?50F+-+.50#ZF+-)"'),#./#'()#ZF+-)"'),#V20#J.5"4Go#."#K29#$fG#2#=)4+-2A#')2=G#-."0+06"8#./#F2,2=)4+-0#/,.=#'()#B).FA)q0#N+M),26."#7,=9#`BN7a#(.0F+'2A0#2"4#F09-(.A.8+0'0#/,.=#i)+C+"8G#/.5"4#."0+')#2#.")d#:+A.=)'),#`%I]$#=+A)a#D+4)#2"4#'D.#:+A.=)'),0#`\I$g#=+A)a#A."8#;2AA)9#."#2#(+AA#-A.0)#'.#'()#)F+-)"'),I#1()#A."8#,2;+")#D20#/.5"4#'.#(2;)#M))"#-.;),)4#D+'(#-."-,)')#4)M,+0#\%d$%#+"-()0#'(+-:#2'#+'0#M.>.=#20#+/#A2,8)#-)=)"'#MA.-:0#D),)#'.00)4#2M.5'#,2"4.=A9#05,,.5"4+"8#'()#+==)4+2')#2,)2I#

7#')2=#=)=M),#02+4G#RV(),)#4+4#'(.0)#-."-,)')#MA.-:0#-.=)#/,.=kS#?+"-)#'(),)#D),)#".#A2,8)#M5+A4+"80#")2,M9G#);),9M.49#D20#-5,+.50A9#'2A:+"8#2M.5'#+'#M5'#-.5A4#".'#H"4#2"#2"0D),I#7#A.-2A#,)0+4)"'rI#02D#2#(58)#(.A)#/.,=#2'#'()#'.F#./#'()#=.5"'2+"I#K2"9#'(+"80#D),)#F50()4#.5'#./#'(+0#(.A)#A+:)#'..'(F20')#M)+"8#0L5))j)4#.5'I#oV20#+'#=28=2ko#0.=)M.49#20:)4I#RE.G#'(.0)#D),)#-."-,)')#MA.-:0GS#02+4#_)I#R1()#),5F6."#A20')4#2M.5'#'(,))#=+"5')0GS#()#244)4I#

Z2,'(L52:)0#=29#0.=)6=)0#,)05A'#+"#2#;.A-2"+-#),5F6."G#M5'#".#-."-,)')#),5F6."#(20#);),#M))"#,)-.,4)4G#02+4#2"#)WF),'I#i20)4#."#'()#<E?#,)F.,'G#0);),2A#)WF),'0#(2;)#0588)0')4#'()#),5F6."#-.5A4#(2;)#M))"#-250)4#M9#2#(58)#)WFA.0+."#M)")2'(#'()#=.5"'2+"G#D(+-(#0(2>),)4#'()#-."-,)')#-.;),#./#'()#5"4),8,.5"4#/2-+A+6)0#2"4#F50()4#'()=#'.#'()#05,/2-)I#1()#'(+-:")00#./#'()#-."-,)')#MA.-:0#F50()4#'.#'()#05,/2-)#0))=)4#'.#=2'-(#'()#-.;),#A29),#50)4#+"#<(+"2q0#5"4),8,.5"4#=+A+'2,9#M20)0IA!

S  Z*%)+?!L3#$0#*&!hB>#*0$!D%&.0%*!21.&)q$!a-<(#)*!:.0#$!9%*!:./&$!%9!h)*01`-)=#!e)5)/#?N!!E)D#l.,:#1+=)0?!%>!<.0@!A  L大地震销毁中国军队最大兵库!vh)*01`-)=#!e#$0*%J#+!01#!21.&#$#!X*5Jx$!")*/#$0!X*5%*Jw?N!wĻ.!?!.%>!<.0@!

Page 21: Underground Great Wall

#<F0>?+:H+@9:<TF.0T+<0L-+-M=,G:.C+.-FM+X0.Y10=+

L !vh)*01`-)=#!+#$0*%J#+!01#!21.&#$#!)*5Jx$!()*/#$0!X*$#&)(w?N!%>!<.0@!2)>I%&l!LD%-&0).&$!.&!:.<1-)&?!5)&J!5.(.0)*J!9)<0%*.#$?!)*$#&)($!)&+!&-<(#)*!9)<.(.I#$?!K)$#$?!5.(.0)*J!.&9%*5#+!$%-*<#$?!01#!#)*01`-)=#!0*.//#*#+!4#)>%&$!)&+!)55-&.I%&!+#>%0!#B>(%$.%&?!)!+#;)$0)I&/!1.0!0%!01#!5.(.0)*J@!O1#!>.<0-*#!$1%4$!01#!$.0-)I%&!)_#*!01#!#B>(%$.%&!#)*01`-)=#!5%-&0).&@!"%<)(!;.(()/#*$!$).+l!01#!5%-&0).&!$##5$!0%!.0$!$0%5)<1!<-0!%>#&!4.01!01#!/*#)0#$0!#&#*/J@!

�������������������������������������������������������������������������������������€€�������!

Page 22: Underground Great Wall

1'9&G,8$/44[$;<1+,'".57$&=,,M-??0:.+:H+D-,:MA?+:H+*F>FY-+A:+"=T<-FM+(FT0<0G-?+

K29#\&G#$%%&G#2-6"8#-(2+,=2"#./#<(+"2#*)=.-,2-9#B2,'9#U5.#s52"#,)A)20)4#'()#o<(+"2#*)=.-,2-9#B2,'9#20#0.."#20#F.00+MA)#'.#5,8)#'()#<(+")0)#8.;),"=)"'#+005)4#'()#0)-5,+'9#./#"5-A)2,#/2-+A+6)0#+"#?+-(52"G#'()#,)F.,'Io#_)#-+')4#+"#'(+0#,)F.,'#2#0),+)0#./#?+-(52"#B,.;+"-)#)WF),+=)"'2A#,)0)2,-(#/2-+A+6)0#2"4#"5-A)2,#F.D),#F,.C)-'0#2t),#'()#)2,'(L52:)#-2052A6)0#./#'()0)#5"+'0G#2"4#20:)4#'()#<B<#2"4#'()#+==)4+2')#05,,.5"4+"8#2,)20#'(,.58(.5'#?+-(52"G#2AA#"5-A)2,#/2-+A+6)0#+"#?+-(52"G#,24+26."#4)')-6."#2"4#)2,A9#,)A)20)#./#"5-A)2,#/2-+A+'9#02/)'9#,)F.,'0I#_.D);),G#'()#'(+,4#429#2t),#'()#F5MA+-26."#./#'()#,)F.,'G#U5.#s52"#D20#2,,)0')4I#B.A+-)#02+4#".#-(2,8)0#U5.#s52"G#M5'#=50'#M)#4)'2+")4#/.,#\%#4290G#\%#4290#4.#F,.-)00+"8IS!

OFa:M+$:??+A:+#B0.Fq?+"=T<-FM+%M?-.F<_+Y5A9#gG#$%%&rI#2--.,4+"8#'.#(+8(d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u(."8"2"(2+#v2%55-&.$0!1#)+`-)*0#*!.&!Z#.�.&/wIA!

DF/0:<:Y0TF<+$-FLFY-+0.A:+!./-MYM:=./+`FA-M+&=,,<Q+oE.,'(#3+;),#M)A.D#'()#.,+8+"2A#"5-A)2,#0'.,28)#FA2-)0#III#3)05A'#./#5"4),8,.5"4#"5-A)2,#A)2:0G#".D#(20#2#0),+.50#'(,)2'#'.#8,.5"4D2'),#2"4#?+-(52"G#<(."8L+"8G#(5"4,)40#./#=+AA+."0#./#F).FA)#02/)ISQ#

1  Zhang Shan, “大地震销毁中国军队最大兵库 [News Media breaks story: A Large Underground Nuclear Explosion caused by the Earthquake in Beichuan ],” 大纪元 , (2009.05.07), at < http://tw.epochtimes.com/9/5/7/111780.htm > [accessed 31 Jan. 2011].

2  2008年5月18日,中國新民黨代主席郭泉發表了「中國新民黨敦促中共政府盡快發布四川核設施的安全報告」。他在該報告中列舉了四川境內的一系列核動力工程實驗研究設施及地震後這些單位的人員傷亡情況,並要求中共立即對四川全境及周邊地區所有核設施進行輻射檢測及盡快發布四川核設施的安全報告。但在該報告發表後的第三天,郭泉被拘捕。警方稱,郭泉沒有罪名,但必須拘留10天,10天後再做處理。Ibid.

3  2008年7月4日, 據中共軍方高層知情人士祕密透露,在汶川地震中中國軍隊最大的武器庫被完全銷毀,給中共軍隊帶來災難性的重創。消息稱,地震引發山區武器彈藥庫連鎖爆炸,中共幾十年經營的最大的兵器補給庫被完全銷毀,還包括新武器試驗基地及部分核設施、核彈頭都遭到摧毀。此事件作為最高軍事祕密,震動中南海。 Ibid.

4  2009年3月16日署名內幕人士本著良心、道德向博訊網「驚天大爆料」: 「北川下方是原來的核彈貯藏地 ... 造成地下核洩露,現已經嚴重威脅到川渝地下水和億萬人民的安全。」 Ibid.

Page 23: Underground Great Wall

3IIp+)FMAB]=FL-+O0<0AFMQ+#:.AF0.>-.A+

`-F,:.?+D-FTA:M+"-FM+g______+

`-F,:.?+D-FTA:M+"-FM+g______+

3#&!21#&/?!L"%<)(!H#$.+#&0$!2%&<#*&#+!4.01!:)9#0J!%9!:.<1-)&!a-<(#)*!P)<.(.I#$?N!ZF.-(#1+=)0?!jA77]@76@A\k?!)0!s!1t>lbb#&@#>%<1I5#$@<%5b&#4$b]F6FA\b\S7]7@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!r)&@!A7SSwC!LO1#!H.++(#!%9!01#!21.&#$#!G)*)0*%%>#*$l!21.&)!>)*)<1-0#$!S77!>)*)0*%%>#*$!0%!L<-0F%WN!`-)=#!)*#)?N!J+,)#Z2,'(?!jA77]@76@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb9#44@4%*+>*#$$@<%5bA77]b76bS[b<1.&#$#F>)*)0*%%>#*$F*#$<-.&/F$-*;.;%*$F%*F#(.5.&)I&/F>()/-#b!!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!r)&@!A7SSwC!)&+!:1)&?!L !va#4$!D#+.)!K*#)=$!$0%*Jl!X!")*/#!'&+#*/*%-&+!a-<(#)*!hB>(%$.%&!<)-$#+!KJ!01#!h)*01`-)=#!.&!Z#.<1-)&!w?N!%>!<.0@!h>.<#&0#*!5)>!9*%5l!Lh)*01`-)=#!.&!:.<1-)&!G*%;.&<#l!Y&0#*)<I;#!5)>!$1%4.&/!01#!#B0#&0!%9!01#!5%$0!+)5)/#+!)*#)$!9*%5!01#!\@T!5)/&.0-+#!#)*01`-)=#!.&!3#$0#*&!21.&)?N!E)D#l.,:#1+=)0?!jA77]@76@SAk?!s!1t>lbb444@&JI5#$@<%5b.&0#*)<I;#bA77]b76bSAb4%*(+b76SQA77]~2dYaX~DXG@105(z*#9c$.<1-)&>*%;.&<#<1.&)!u!!v)<<#$$#+!Q7!r)&@!A7SSwC!!

O-/0TF<+A-F>+:H+?,-T0F<0?A?+-.A-M+TMFA-M+FM-F+.-FM+X0.Yh0=!

2II+,FMFAM::,-M?+a=>,+0.A:+>:=.AF0.+

-,0T-.A-M+H:M+@?-T=M0AQC!

#B->0TF<+/-H-.?-+AM::,+:H+AB-+#B0.-?-+%M>Q+/-,<:Q-/+A:+#B-.a0FUFN+K-0TB=F.+#:=.AQN+FM-F+:H+

M-,:MA-/+YM:=./+\FA-M+MF/0:<:Y0TF<+T:.AF>0.FG:.++

Page 24: Underground Great Wall

C;9,2';8$;:$Y,"2&\G,Q.$I$$

V.9;872"G92';8$%";^.927$

L����������!vD)>!%9!h)*01`-)=#!H#<%&$0*-<I%&!G*%�#<0$w?N!21.&)5.(?!jA77T@76@SAk?!)0!s!1t>lbb>.<@<1.&)5.(@<%5@!!<&b<1)0bA77TF76bSAb<%&0#&0~S\6T\T]@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S]!:#>@!A77]C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 25: Underground Great Wall

B'('2,"E$!.)(;E3.827$2;$Y,"2&\G,Q.$`;8.$

L�����������������!v21.&)!E*$0!)&&%-&<#+!+#>(%J5#&0!%9!*#(.#9!0*%%>!$0*#&/01!+.)/*)5w?i!3)&/<1)%?!jA77]@76@S]k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@4)&/<1)%@&#0@<&b�-&$1.b+#0).(~QA]SA@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!P#K@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!'GFS7SSw@!

A77]!D)J!S]l!n.<#!D.&.$0#*!%9!01#!M#&#*)(!:0)W!9%*!f>#*)I%&$!D)!r.)&!&#4$!<%&9#*#&<#!$1%4#+!!01#!+#>(%J5#&0!%9!5.(.0)*J!*#(.#9!9%*<#!0%!01#!#)*01`-)=#!)*#)@!

3./+%MG<<-MQ+D:TL-A+(:MT-?+

Page 26: Underground Great Wall

*99'F.827$a,)).8$)&+!<)&!K#!*#;#)(.&/!

LSA!0)&=#*$?!>)*0!%9!)!R7F<)*!9*#./10!0*).&!0*)>>#+!.&!01#!a%!S7T!0-&&#(!KJ!()&+$(.+#$!9%((%4.&/!()$0!4##=x$!#)*01`-)=#Å@N!|.&!e.&/+.&/?!LP.&)(!M)$!O)&=#*$!2(#)*#+!9*%5!O-&&#(?N!<(+"2I-.=G!jA77]@76@ASk!)0!s!1t>lbb#&/(.$1@<1.&)@<%5bV1~<&b&#4$b<1.&)bSS7A7Q7\bA77]76ASbSR]6]7\[@105(!u!)<<#$$#+!6!D)J!A7S7w@!L".!21-&1%&/?!F+>0<0AFMQ+:rT-M+F??0Y.-/+A:+AB-+KF:a0d#B-.Y/=+T<-FMF.T-+:,-MFG:.?!$).+!01#*#!.$!)!$(.5!<1)&<#!01#!0-&&#(!<%-(+!*#%>#&!)0!01#!#&+!%9!&#B0!4##=!.9!4#)01#*!>#*5.0$@!G*#;.%-$(J?!>%.$%&%-$!/)$!#5.t#+!9*%5!01#!E*#!)&+!01#!+)&/#*$!>%$#+!KJ!01#!/)$%(.&#!1)+!>*#;#&0#+!E*#E/10#*$!9*%5!#&0#*.&/!01#!0-&&#(?!1#!$).+!0%!01#!AS$0!2#&0-*J!Z-$.&#$$!d#*)(+@!`B-.+AB-+FM>Q+A-F>+FMM0E-/!01#!+)J!)_#*!01#!#)*01`-)=#?!01#!0#5>#*)0-*#!)0!K%01!%9!01#!0-&&#(x$!#B.0$!1)+!*#)<1#+!S[7!2?!1#!$).+@!P#)*.&/!)&!#B>(%$.%&?!(%<)(!%^<.)($!1#(>#+!#;)<-)0#!5%*#!01)&!T77!9)*5#*$!(.;.&/!.&!04%!&#)*KJ!0%4&$!0%!)!$)9#*!>()<#![!=5!)4)J@N!

Z)%�.F21#&/+-!H).(!X<<.+#&0!A77]A!

U+;)"#?)-."4#7,6AA),9O0#(+8(#4)8,))#./#,)A+2"-)#."#'()#"26."O0#,2+A#2"4#(+8(D29#090')=#/.,#+'0#"5-A)2,#4)'),,)"'G#2#/2+A5,)#+"#'()#',2"0F.,'#")'D.,:#+0#-250)#/.,#-."-),"I#n")#)W2=FA)#./#2#,2+A#/2+A5,)#'(2'#F.')"62AA9#2P)-')4#D2,()24#A.8+06-0#.--5,,)4#45,+"8#'()#K29#\$G#$%%&#?+-(52"#)2,'(L52:)I#7#',2+"#(25A+"8#(2j2,4.50#=2'),+2A0#4),2+A)4#2"4#+8"+')4#+"0+4)#2#'5"")A#+"#s+"A+"8#K.5"'2+"0#+"#'()#;+-+"+'9#./#2#F,+=2,9#$$#i20)#D2,()24#,2+A#',2"0/),#F.+"'I#32+A#.F),26."0#."#'()#i2.C+d<()"845#A+")#D),)#0(5'#4.D"#/.,#\$#4290I#1()#_."8A+"8#<.==2"4#<)AA#-.==2"4),#,)0F."4)4#2"4#2,,+;)4#."#'()#0-)")#+"#C50'#.;),#'D.#(.5,0IS#

Page 27: Underground Great Wall

9#%0":;#<1'=;%$1>'0%#$?'.?'0"1'Z)%�.F21#&/+-!H).(4)J'''

L公安民警全力抢修宝成铁路S7T隧道!vG-K(.<!:)9#0J!G#*$%&&#(!*#/#&0!*#$<-#!%&!01#!Z)%�.F21#&/+-!H).(4)J!O-&&#(!S7Tw?N!腾讯?!jA77]@76@S\k?!)0!s!1t>lbb&#4$@``@<%5b)bA77]76S\b77QR6S@105!u!!v)<<#$$#+!A\!X-/@!A77]C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

'GGhH!"hPOl!O1#!(%<%5%I;#!4)$!$-<<#$$9-((J!K-*.#+!%-0!%9!01#!0-&&#(C!

'GGhH!HYMdOl!P.*#!K*./)+#!-&.&0#**->0#+!<%%(.&/!4)0#*!0%!01#!$%-01#*&!#&+!%9!01#!0-&&#(C!

"hPOl!P)I/-#!)&+!$(##>!.&!01#!K)t(#!$>)<#!%9!01#!E*#!K*./)+#@!

Page 28: Underground Great Wall

L:#.$5.<!$./&)(!%9!D)$$.;#!h)*01`-)=#!.&!:.<1-)&?!21.&)@N!L21.&)x$!h)*01`-)=#!X_#*!:1%<=?N!<2,")8+)#<.5"-+AG#jA77]@76@S6k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@>%(.<J.&&%;)I%&$@%*/b.+#)$bK*.#E&/$b+)0)b77776A!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!:#>@!A7S7w@!

&0TB=F.+&-0?>0T+D-T:M/+23+OFQ+3IIpN+D0TBA-M+?TF<-+s+8ZJ+?B:\?++];$]G9(.,"$!.2;8,2';8$-.:;".>$FG"'8S$;"$,:2."$Y,"2&\G,Q.+

Page 29: Underground Great Wall

Study #2!

=>?@@(A+%,'(.<(!%B+(C+<+$'+$

Page 30: Underground Great Wall

Study 1: 8D+$1EFG#B+(H/$*,+*(A+%,'(.<(!%B+(C+<+$'+$

•! 21.&)q$!5.(.0)*J!<-(0-*#!1)$!(%&/!;)(-#+!+#9#&$.;#!0-&&#(.&/!)&+!-&+#*/*%-&+!9%*IE<)I%&!,!$-<1!)$!01#!L<(.W!*%)+$N!%9!01#!()0#!3)**.&/!:0)0#$!>#*.%+!2@A35763B4C!8)&+!01#!LO#**)<%t)!3)**.%*$N!%9!D$?',"$'E;#?FGH'0%5K!2@A35763B4C!8I!

•! :#;#&!I5#$!.&!01#!1.$0%*J!%9!21.&)!01#!>1*)$#!L'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!1)$!K##&!-$#+!.&!01#!<%&0#B0!%9!5.(.0)*J!+#9#&$#l!

•! O1#!5%$0!*#<#&0!)>>(.<)I%&!%9!01#!0#*5!FF!L5J$0#*.%-$!-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!FF!4)$!$#<*#0(J!)>>(.#+!0%!01#!#W%*0!0%!K-.(+!$#<-*#!K)$.&/!9%*!01#!$0*)0#/.<!&-<(#)*!*%<=#0!9%*<#!.&!01#!ST]7$C!E*$0!)5K./-%-$(J!*#9#*#&<#+!.&!>*.&0!.&!01#!5.+FT7$?!)&+!%^<.)((J!#&$1*.&#+!)$!)!L&)I%&)(!>*%�#<0N!.&;%(;.&/!Q?777!5.(#$!%9!0-&&#($!%&!SS!e#<@!A77T@!

Page 31: Underground Great Wall

Y,"('.72$B'FF(.$+'8SF;3$<G88.('8S'

J!K$LL'*.#>HM'.L'0"1'K#01'N#%%$?F',0#01'O1%$.>'2@$%@#'475-221BC8'

M.G. Lay and James E. Vance, Ways of the World: A History of the World’s Roads and of the Vehicles that Used Them, (G.$<)0)4)J?!arl!H-0/#*$!'&.;#*$.0J!G*#$$?!STTTkl!!>@!A6\C!>1%0%$!9*%5l!LM-.()&/!O-&&#(?N!V29/2,+"8?!jA77Tb7]@7Qk!)0!s1t>lbb444@4)J9)*.&/@.&9%bA77Tb7]b7Qb/-%(.)&/F0-&&#(b!!u!)<<#$$#+!AQ!D)J!A7S7w@!X&+!L F z!v3%*(+!4%&+#*$!F!01#!M*#)0!3)((!'&+#*/*%-&+zw?N!UA.M2A#<.==."0^v5+') ?!jA77\@7A@STk?!)0!s!1t>lbbK(%/@B-.0#@&#0b9*)&=@1/$bMhbS7A67A6S!u!v)<<#$$#+!AT!X-/@!A7S7w@!

D%+#*&!#B)5>(#!j<.*<)!ST\Akl!S?A775!M-%(.)&/!O-&&#(?!O).1)&/!D%-&0).&$?!d-.B.)&!2%-&0J!

Chinese contribution was the provision of roads in precipitous regions by the use of cliff-face gallery roads. The four most famous were in Shaanxi Province, and work on the most notorious of these – the Shaanxi to Sichuan cliff road – began in the Warring States period in 475-221BC. #

Page 32: Underground Great Wall

R8F."S";G8F$DG,"F',87$;:$2&.$Y3).";"$'D$?',"$'E;#?FGH'兵马俑$)1%%#@.00#');??1K'N#%%$.%H'2@$%@#'35763B4C!8'

Jane Portal, Terra Cotta Warriors: Guardians of China’s First Emperor, (Washington, DC: a)I%&)(!M#%/*)>1.<?!A77]kC!:.5)!y.)&?!H#<%*+$!%9!01#!M*)&+!d.$0%*.)&G#;%(@!d)&!eJ&)$0J!Y?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!Z-*0%&!3)0$%&?!ja#4!}%*=?!a}l!2%(-5K.)!'&.;#*$.0J?!STTQk@

\77?777!4%*=#*$!$>#&0!Q[!J#)*$!<%&$0*-<I&/!01#!&#<*%>%(.$!4.01!&#)*(J!S?777!5#0#*$!%9!0-&&#($!)&+!%;#*!]?777!E/-*#$@!

Page 33: Underground Great Wall

��K�+b+@R8F."S";G8F$D".,2$?,((T$.$!)&!h$0)K(.$1#+!e#9#&$.;#!2%&<#>0!.&!21.&#$#!d.$0%*J!

:.B!I5#$!.&!01#!1.$0%*J!%9!21.&)!01#!>1*)$#!L'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!1)$!K##&!-$#+!.&!01#!<%&0#B0!%9!5.(.0)*J!+#9#&$#l!p !安徽+��K�R��+�+FF!Z%V1%-!-&+#*/*%-&+!5.(.0)*J!+#9#&$.;#!0-&&#(!

$J$0#5!K-.(0!KJ!2)%!2)%!,!>%(.I<.)&?!/#&#*)(!)&+!(.0#*)I!FF!j<.*<)!S66FAA7Xekl!p !���K�+,!:%&/!eJ&)$0J!L-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!(.&#)*!+#9#&$.;#!>%$.I%&$!

j<.*<)!T[7FSA\TkC!p !#A��K�!FF!G.&/!o%&/!".&/!-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((!4)$!K-.(0!.&!S]]T?!-&+#*!

X+5@!:-!}-)&<1-&!$->#*;.$.%&!KJ!01#!M-)&/B.!Z%*+#*!M-)*+$!:#*;.<#!j<.*<)!()0#!S]77$kC!!

p  .P'���K�+dd+o%*#)&!3)*!0-&&#(!<%5>(#B!K-.(0!&%*01!%9!01#!RA&+!>)*)((#(!j<.*<)!ST6AF6QkC!

p !2���K�+FF!d#K#.!M*#)0!3)((!'&+#*/*%-&+!<.;.(!+#9#&$#!<%5>(#B!.&!Z#.�.&/!)&+!%01#*!&%*01#*&!<.I#$!9#)*.&/!:%;.#0!)t)<=!jST[TFST\6kC!!

p !神秘的@��K�C!,!LDJ$0#*.%-$!Ç'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((qN!9%*!>*%0#<I%&!%9!A&+!X*I((#*J!5.$$.(#!-&.0$l!! ! !G1)$#!S!,!ST]6FSTT6 !!! ! !G1)$#!A!,!\cc&d$%%c## # #G1)$#!Q!FF!A7S7Fzz!

“h�Ɓm [Underground Great Wall],” Baidu, (2010) at < http://baike.baidu.com/view/163081.htm > [accessed 11 May 2010, translated by IP-1011].

Page 34: Underground Great Wall

R8F."S";G8F$D".,2$?,(($XX$ +���������++iT0MTF+266d33Ij+$

L2)%!2)%!'&+#*/*%-&+!O-&&#(!9%*!O*)&$>%*I&/!O*%%>$?N!1,2;)A#+"#7"(5+?!jA7S7k!)0!s!1t>lbb<1.&)+).(J@<1.&)+).(J@<%5@<&b5b)&1-.b0*);#(bA7S7F76bAQb<%&0#&0~T\\[\76@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!6!D)J!A7S7w@!

N9+"8#+"#'()#.A4#-+'9#./#i.j(.5G#+'#+0#2"#9%&")5)$9%&'3-+-02),'&"."%6-G"'09%%"+'A9-+0'A,'12$'12$#`\hhd$$%aG#2#/2=.50#F.A+6-+2"G#=+A+'2,+0'#2"4#A+'),26G#+"#(+0#(.=)'.D"I#!'#5"4),D)"'#,)F)2')4#)WF2"0+."#+"#'()#?."8#2"4#l52"#49"206)0I#7M.5'#fd&#=)'),0#M)A.D#'()#05,/2-)#./#'()#4.D"'.D"#2,)27'0?"'09%%"+'"@0"%&6'6$3"'HI'J3G#+'#+0#2#=+A+'2,9#'5"")A#D+'(#'()#A."8)0'#(+0'.,9G#=.0'#-.=FA+-2')4#0',5-'5,)G#A2,8)0'#0-2A)#2"4#-.=FA)')#/2-+A+6)0#);),#4+0-.;),)4#+"#<(+"2I#1(),)/.,)G#+'#+0#,)".D")4#20#'()#T"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AAI ##

1()#D(.A)#'5"")A#+0#-,+00-,.00)4#D+'(#-.=FA+-2')4#2"4#05M'A)#2,,2"8)=)"'0G#D+'(#=5A6A);)A#4+0',+M56."#2"4#-.=FA)W#-."0',5-6."I#1()#'5"")A#'2:)0#'()#0(2F)#./#2#R1S#D()"#+'#'5,"0I#1()#'D.#F2,2AA)A#A2")0#2,)#0F2-)4#$dfIh#=)'),0#2F2,'G#2"4#'(),)#2,)#0L52,)#(.A)0#/.,#F200+"8#."#2#=)0028)#."#'()#D2AA#M)'D))"#'()=I#

7A."8#'()#4))F#2"4#j+8j288+"8#'5"")AG#0.=)#=+A+'2,9#2"4#05FF.,6"8#/2-+A+6)0#D),)#M5+A'G#+"-A54+"8#/.W(.A)0G#.M0'2-A)#D2AA0G#0'5=MA+"8#M.2,40G#',2F0G#;)"'#(.A)0G#(.A)0#/.,#F200+"8#."#2#=)0028)#2"4#"+-()0#/.,#'.,-()0I#1()#-5A'5,2A#,)A+-0#./#'()#_2"G#12"8#2"4#?."8#49"206)0#5")2,'()4#+"#'()#'5"")A#+"-A54)#F+AA0G#0.A4+),q0#0D.,40G#A2=F0G#-.FF),#=+,,.,0G#F.>),9G#F.,-)A2+"#2"4#+":d0'.")0#A)t#M)(+"4#/,.=#0);),2A#49"206)0I#1()0)#2,)#2AA#./#8,)2'#+=F.,'2"-)#/.,#,)0)2,-(+"8#<(+"2q0#2"-+)"'#3-+-02),'A9-+&-%56'2%&'02#*#6'2%&'0?"'3-+-02),'0?$95?0'$.'12$'12$I ##

Page 35: Underground Great Wall

<G88.($?,":,".$:";3$2&.$];"2&."8$1;8S$!E8,72E$

“X!")*/#!X*#)!%9!X-01#&I<!H#(.<$!%9!O-&&#(!3)*9)*#!e.$<%;#*#+!9*%5!!Z#/.&&.&/!%9!01#!a%*01#*&!:%&/!eJ&)$0J.” #-(+"2I-.=I-", (9 December 2008) at < http://www.china.com.cn/v/2008-12/09/content_16921624.htm > [accessed 17 Mar. 2010].

Page 36: Underground Great Wall

1;8S$!E8,72E$B'('2,"E$<G88.($!'79;b."E$

*5,+"8#'()#?."8#*9"20'9#`c\]d\\$haG#+"#'()#9)2,0#M)'D))"#c]%#2"4#\\$wG#'(+0#2,)2#D20#2#M2>A)H)A4#M)'D))"#'()#0'2')0#?."8#2"4#N+2.I#N+2.#.--5F+)4#F2,'#./#'()#?."8#0'2')G#2"4#'()#?."8#M5+A'#2#=+A+'2,9#4)/)"0)#A+")G#D(+-(#D20#)WF2"4)4#45,+"8#2#$%%#9)2,#A."8#F),+.4#./#D2,I#1()#2"-+)"'#0',5-'5,)#D20#-.=FA)')A9#/.,8.>)"#5"6A#\cg&I#7#8,)2'#p..4#(2FF)"+"8#+"#l."8L+"8#;+AA28)G#_)M)+#F,.;+"-)G#D20#2M.5'#'.#4)0',.9#'()#D(.A)#;+AA28)G#D()"#+'#D20#0'.FF)4#D+'(#2#'(5"4),.50#".+0)I#1()#-.5,0)#./#'()#p..4#D20#-(2"8)4G#'()#D2'),#A);)A#02":G#20#'()#D2'),#D20#p.D+"8#+"'.#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#F20028)I#!"#\ch\#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#-2;)#0.=)#\h%=x#+"#0+j)#D20#4+0-.;),)4G#2t),#2#(.50)#$Ih:=#/,.=#l."8L+"8#(24#-2;)4#+"I#*.j)"0#./#0=2AA#4..,0#+"#'(+0#-2;),"#D),)#.F)"+"8#'.#2#F20028)D29#)2-(I#7"-+)"'#D2,#F20028)0#D),)#/.5"4G#0F,)24+"8#'(,.58(.5'#l."8L+"8#<.5"'9G#-.;),+"8#2"#2,)2#./#0.=)#f%%#0L52,)#:+A.=)'),0I#1()#5"4),8,.5"4#M5AD2,:#+0#./#)".,=.50#0+j)G#c%:=#./#'5"")A0#D(+-(#-.;),#2"#2,)2#]h:=#/,.=#)20'#'.#D)0'G#2"4#$h:=#/,.=#".,'(#'.#0.5'(G#D(+-(#+0#2"#2,)2#./#\G]%%=xI#K.0'#./#+'#+0#2#A."8#'5"")A#2A."8#'()#M.,4),G#0+=+A2,#'.#'()#U,)2'#V2AAG#'(2'#+0#D(9#+'#+0#-2AA)4#T"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AA#!'#-."0+0'0#./#2#D+4)#,2"8)#./#=+A+'2,9#/2-+A+6)0G#-2=.5p28)4#)W+'0G#-.;),0G#2"4#A.-:+"8#82')0I#7#/,."6),#F200#M)'D))"#'()#,+;2A+"8#0'2')0#D20#/.,6H)4#M9#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#/.,',)00I#i5'#+'#2A0.#(20#A+;+"8#")-)00+6)0G#D+'(#;)"6A26."#(.A)0G#2"4#A2=F#0'2"40#+"')8,2')4#+"'.#'()#D2AA0I#1(),)#D),)#M,+-:#M)40G#D+'(#0.=)#M20+-#-.=/.,'G#20#'()9#-.5A4#M)#()2')4#45,+"8#D+"'),I#

“Underground Great Wall,” Hubie website [PRC], (2009.08.30) at < http://www.showcaves.com/english/cn/misc/GreatWall.html > [accessed 30 May 2010].

Page 37: Underground Great Wall

!./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<+dd+�����+dd+F?+*-H-.?-+R:?0G:.+

L����!vM*#)0!3)((!'&+#*/*%-&+w?N!jG-K(.<!G1%0%!:1%4C!21%&/V-%?!GH2l!O%-*.$5!Z-*#)-?!A776k!)0!s!1t>lbb<1%&/V-%@/B0)@/%;@<&bG-K(.<bG1%0%b:1%4G1%0%@)$>zY5)/#~YecSR\[\!u!v)<<#$$#+!6!D)J!A7S7w@!

Y&!)&<.#&0!21.&#$#!1.$0%*J!.0!.$!*#<%*+#+!01)0!O1#!a%*01#*&!:%&/!eJ&)$0J!jT[7FSSA\!Xek!K)t(#+!9%*!A77!J#)*$!4.01!01#!".)%!)&+!r.&!eJ&)$I#$?!41.<1!)0!01#!I5#!4#*#!*-(#+!KJ!5.&%*.0J!*)<#$!9*%5!21.&)x$!a%*01#*&!O#**.0%*.#$?!01#!o1.0)&!)&+!r-*<1#&$!*#$>#<I;#(J@!O1#!a%*01#*&!21.&)!G().&!4)$!)&!#&+(#$$!U)0!/*%-&+?!4.01!&%!5%-&0).&$!%*!*.;#*$!01)0!<%-(+!K#!-$#+!0%!1#(>!+#9#&+!)/).&$0!01#!&%*01#*&#*$@!!'>%&!9-*01#*!.&;#$I/)I%&?!#B>#*0$!9%-&+!01)0!)&<.#&0!4)*!>)$$)/#$!4#*#!$>*#)+!01*%-/1%-0!}%&/`.&/!2%-&0J!.&!)&!)*#)!<%;#*.&/!)>>*%B.5)0#(J!Q77!$`-)*#!=.(%5#0#*$@!31%!Z-.(0!01#!X&<.#&0!3)*!G)$$)/#$!)&+!31#&z!hB>#*0$!+.$<%;#*#+!01)0!01#!}%&/`.&/!)&<.#&0!4)*!>)$$)/#$!4#*#!4.+#$>*#)+@!O1#J!4#*#!.&!9)<0!)!()*/#F$<)(#!<%&$0*-<I%&!-$#+!0%!1%-$#!0*%%>$!+-*.&/!I5#$!%9!4)*@!O1#!$0*-<0-*#$!%9!01#!<);#$!4#*#!<%5>(.<)0#+!)&+!<%5>(#0#?!>%$$#$$.&/!5.(.0)*J!9)<.(.I#$!$-<1!)$!<)5%-U)/#+!#B.0$?!<%;#*$?!)&+!(%<=.&/!/)0#$@!!

Page 38: Underground Great Wall

!./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<+dd+�����+dd+F?+"FG:.F<+D-/:=UA!

1()#-,)26."#2"4#=2+"')"2"-)#./#05-(#2#=200+;)#5"4),8,.5"4#")'D.,:#,)L5+,)4#2#8,)2'#"5=M),#./#'()0)#M,+-:0I#!'#+0#M)A+);)4#'(2'#'()0)#2"-+)"'#D2,#F20028)0#D),)#-."0',5-')4#20#F2,'#./#2#A2,8)#"26."dD+4)#F,.C)-'#-,)2')4#2"4#.;),0))"#2'#2#"26."2A#A);)A#M9#'()#8.;),"+"8#25'(.,+6)0#./#'()#6=)I#1()#B20028)0#?F,)24#n;),#\G]%%#?L52,)#Q+A.=)'),0I#

L ! !vd.++#&!P%*!X!O1%-$)&+!}#)*$!F!21.&)x$!i'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((w?N!1()#ZF.-(#1+=)0?!jA77[@7A@S\k!)0!s!1t>lbb444@#>%<1I5#$@<%5b/Kb[bAb]b&SAS6T6]@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!Q7!D)J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

ZWF),'0#(2;)#458#.5'#0+=+A2,#D2,#F20028)0#+"#l."8L+"8G#v+."8#-.5"'9G#2"4#i2j(.5I#1()#2"-+)"'#D2,#F20028)0#2,)#2M.5'#]h#:+A.=)'),0#/,.=#)20'#'.#D)0'G#$h#:+A.=)'),0#/,.=#".,'(#'.#0.5'(G#D(+-(#)W')"4#'(,.58(#\G]%%#0L52,)#:+A.=)'),0I#V()"#'()#M.,4),#M)'D))"#'()#?."8#*9"20'9#2"4#'()#N+2.#*9"20'9#D)"'#20#/2,#D)0'#20#3."8-()"8#-.5"'9#2"4#v50(5+#-.5"'9G#+'#+0#'(.58('#'(2'#=2"9#2"-+)"'#D2,#F20028)0#)W+0')4#+"#'(2'#2,)2I#_.D#/2,#'()#2"-+)"'#D2,#F20028)0#)W')"4)4#)20'D2,40#/,.=#l."8L+"8#+0#06AA#5":".D"I##

_+4+"8#?.A4+),0#+"#'()#7"-+)"'#V2,#B20028)0#'.#*)/)"4#'()#<.5"',9X#7=+40'#=2"9#A)8)"40#2M.5'#'()#5"4),8,.5"4#")'D.,:G#.")#0'2')0#'(2'#'()#2"-+)"'#D2,#F20028)0#D),)#M5+A'#M9#U)"),2A#l2"8#2"4#(+0#/2=+A9[#2#/2=+A9#'(2'#F,.45-)4#'(,))#8,)2'#8)"),2A0#.;),#'(,))#8)"),26."0I#7".'(),#A)8)"4#0588)0'0#'(2'#U)"),2A#l2"8#N+5A2"8#50)4#'()#5"4),8,.5"4#F20028)D290#'.#4)/)"4#'()#M.,4),I#7'#'()#6=)#`c]%d\\$w#7*aG#0.A4+),0#./#'()#N+2.#*9"20'9#0',+-'A9#852,4)4#'()#A2"40#".,'(#./#l."8L+"8#<.5"'9I#!'#+0#02+4#'(2'#l2"8#N+5A2"8#M5+A'#'()#F20028)0#'.#(+4)#(+0#0.A4+),0#5"4),8,.5"4#0.#'()9#-.5A4#L5+-:A9#4)/)"4#282+"0'#2>2-:0#A25"-()4#M9#'()#N+2.#0.A4+),0I#ZWF),'0#F.+"'#.5'#'(2'#'()#5"4),8,.5"4#F20028)0#=29#(2;)#M))"#50)4#20#M20)#/.,#A25"-(+"8#2>2-:0#45,+"8#D2,0#/.58('#+"#2"-+)"'#<(+"2I#70#2#=)2"0#./#4)/)"0)#'(,.58(.5'#'()#9)2,0G#F).FA)#(2;)#M5+A'#8,)2'#D2AA0#+"#=.5"'2+".50#2,)20#2"4#D2'),#H)A40#")2,#,+;),0#2"4#A2:)0#'.#MA.-:#-2;2A,+)0I#_.D);),G#+"#'()#.F)"#FA2+"0G#D(),)#+'#+0#4+e-5A'#'.#50)#'()#'),,2+"#20#2#=)2"0#./#4)/)"0)G#'()#'5"")A0#D.5A4#(2;)#2AA.D)4#0.A4+),0#'.#',2;)A#5"0))"#M)A.D#'()#)2,'(I#1()#2"-+)"'#D2,#F20028)0#(2;)#M)-2=)#/2=.50#/.,#'()#24;2"'28)0#'()9#F,.;+4)#D()'(),#'()#',..F0#2,)#2>2-:+"8#.,#4)/)"4+"8G#2"4#'()9#(2;)#M))"#"2=)4#'()#o5"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AAIo#

Page 39: Underground Great Wall

#A��K�+b+@R8F."S";G8F$D".,2$?,(($;:$DG,8SZ'T$

B+"8#Q."8#N+"8#R5"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2ASA#D20#M5+A'#+"#\&&c#M9#'()#A2')#74=+,2A#?5#l52"-(5"#05F),;+0+."#./#'()#U52"8W+#U52"8W+#i.,4),#U52,40#?),;+-)#M5+A'#45,+"8#'()#=+A+'2,9#4)/)"0)#090')=G#+'#+0#M20)4#."#'()#-,.00dM.,4),#,+;),#d#p2'#'),,2+"#2"4#'()#,+;),#)";+,."=)"'G#'()#-."0',5-6."#./#2#".,'(d0.5'(#F)2-)#Q."8#-.MMA)0#'D.#M2>),+)0G#)2-(#-.5"',9#Q,5FF#-2""."0#7"#l.54)#)2-(#.")G#'()#"5=M),#./#0=2AA#-2""."#4..,I##

!"#\c$\#2,6AA),9#/,.=#12+D2"#D20#=.;)4#'.#E2""+"8G#M9#U52"8W+#D2,A.,4#N5#3."86"8#'.#-,)2')#'()#ou()""+"8#i2>),9aIS#i)'D))"#".,'(#2"4#0.5'(#'()#8,2"4#M2>),9#D20#-."")-')4#M9#2"##5"4),8,.5"4#F20028)G#2"4#-,.00)4#'()#,+;),#'(,.58(#'()#A)"8'(#./#=.,)#'(2"#\%%%#=)'),0#b#M)-2=)#:".D"#20#'()#o5"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AAIS#

“h�Ɓm [Underground Great Wall],” op cit.

J)M,52,9#\ch%G#'()#BN7#7,=9#gh'(##4+;+0+."#+"#'()#B+"8#U2"8#2,)2#-5'#.P#'()#Q5.=+"'2"8#\c'(#2"4#\cw'(#4+;+0+."0G#D+'(#]w\h#',..F0I#7t),#'D.#4290#2"4#"+8('0#H8(6"8#+"#'()#U52"8W+#/.,',)00G#'()#BN7#D+F)4#.5'#'()#,)="2"'0#./#'()#QK1#/.,-)0I#1(+0#+0#'()#D2,#./#A+M),26."#+"#0.5'(),"#U52"8W+G#'()#A20'#M2>A)#:".D"#'.#(+0'.,9#B+"8q),852"#1()#-2=F2+8"#M2>A)I#

Page 40: Underground Great Wall

“War Tunnels Fortification in the Shunyi County of Beijing,” at “China In Peaceful Times Honors Chinese Fighters At War Tunnels.” blog, (no date) at < http://chinadan.com/index.html > [accessed 7 Mar. 2010].

=.'^'8S$<G88.(7$:";3$2&.$?,"$;:$A,),8.7.$*SS".77';8$

D%&-5#&0!0%!O-&&#(!3)**.%*$! P.*.&/!G%*0!

Z#.�.&/!O-&&#($l!STQTFSTR6!

Page 41: Underground Great Wall

O,3;G7$*"2$!.)'92'8S$!.:.87.$;:$2&.$<G88.(7$

L������L����N !vH#;.#4!01#!0-&&#(!4)*9)*#l!i'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((i!.$!1%4!0%!K-.(+!->w?N!v+"(52")'?!jA7S7@7\@Q7k?!)0!s!1t>lbb&#4$@B.&1-)&#0@<%5b5.(bA7S7F7\bQ7b<%&0#&0~SQTQ]A7S@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!e#<@!A7S7w@!!

D)%q$!%*./.&)(!0-&&#(!D)%q$!%*./.&)(!0-&&#(!

Page 42: Underground Great Wall

“i&!01#!0-&&#(!<%&&#<I&/!21).*5)&!D)%x$!<1.(+1%%+!1%5#!0%!01#!*#$0!%9!:1)%$1)&!;.(()/#@?N!K(%/!j&%!+)0#k?!at < http://chinadan.com/index.html > [accessed 7 Mar. 2010].

<G88.(7$:";3$2&.$?,"$;:$A,),8.7.$*SS".77';8$

LP.(5!iO-&&#(!3)*9)*#i!1)$!K##&!1).(#+!)$!)!*#+!<()$$.<!E(5$?!)$!)!<%55#5%*)I%&!%9!01#![601!)&&.;#*$)*J!%9!01#!;.<0%*J!%9!01#!21.&#$#!G#%>(#x$!X&IFr)>)&#$#!3)*!)$!)!0*.K-0#!0%!01#!iO-&&#(!3)*9)*#i!0-&&#(!4)*9)*#!$.0#!.&!d#K#.!G*%;.&<#Å@N!

LOn!;#*$.%&!%9!01#!iO-&&#(!3)*9)*#N!E(5!-$#$!!01#!i01*##F$0)/#i!$0*-<0-*#@!O1#!%*./.&)(!$.&/(#F>%*0?!+-)(!>%*0!1.+.&/!1%(#?!01#!+#;#(%>5#&0!%9!.&0#*(.&=#+!0%!#;#*J!1%-$#1%(+?!#;#*J!;.(()/#!<%&&#<0#+?!01#!0-&&#(!+-/!-&+#*!01#!+#;.($!$0*%&/1%(+$!)&+!9%*IE#+!0%4#*$Å@N!

LÅ01#!On!+*)5)!‚O-&&#(!3)*9)*#q!4.((!K#!(.5.0#+!0%!01#!%*./.&)(!1./1Fr.&�.)V1-)&/!%9!0-&&#(!4)*9)*#!)&+!01#!&#./1K%*.&/!;.(()/#$?!*.;#*$!)&+!()=#$?!*##+!5)*$1#$?!-*K)&!/-#**.(()!4)*9)*#!4.01.&!01#!#&#5Jx$!>%$.I%&$!F!5.&#!4)*9)*#?!5)1�%&/!4)*9)*#?!)5K-$1!4)*9)*#?!$)K%0)/#?!4)*?!$.#/#!4)*9)*#!0)<I<$Å@N!

01#!i01*##F$0)/#i!$0*-<0-*#@!O1#!%*./.&)(!$.&/(#F

���!L���N!On!+*)5)!LO-&&#(!3)*9)*#N!

On!+*)5)!LO-&&#(!3)*9)*#?N!?(.D<(+"2I.,8?!j&%!+)0#k?!at < http://www.showchina.org/zcr/yjdt/201001/t512229.htm> [accessed 14 Mar. 2010]. !

D)%q$!%*./.&)(!0-&&#(!

Page 43: Underground Great Wall

B,;c7$R2'('d,2';8$;:$@,b.7$FG"'8S$2&.$V.b;(G2';8$

M)%!d-)?!d%4!e.+!O1#!H#+!:-&!H.$#l!O1#!2)-$#!X&+!hW#<0!%9!ƒ1#&/!9#&/!Y&!})&x)&?!jZ#.�.&/?!GH2l!1()#<(+")0)#T"+;),0+'9#B,)00G#$%%%aI!

"hPOl!22G!d#)+`-)*0#*$!<%5>(#B!)&+!D)%q$!<%55)&+!<#&0#*C!XZfnhl!D)%!4%*=.&/!.&!1.$!<);#!%^<#C!HYMdOl!5)=.&/!)!$>##<1!0%!<)+*#$!+-*.&/!1.$!SQ!J#)*$!+4#((.&/!.&!})&q)&q$!<);#$@!

!})&x)&?!.&!&%*014#$0#*&!21.&)x$!:1))&B.!G*%;.&<#?!4)$!01#!1#)+`-)*0#*$!%9!01#!2%55-&.$0!G)*0J!%9!21.&)!9*%5!STQ6FSTR]?!$#*;.&/!)$!01#!#&+>%.&0!%9!01#!"%&/!D)*<1!)&+!)$!)!5.(.0)*J!K)$#!)/).&$0!01#!r)>)&#$#@!

Page 44: Underground Great Wall

+;".,$?,"$P����C$P!./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<C+

n%(-&0##*$!"%/.$I<$!+#>%0!<)**J!9%*4)*+!01#!*#;%(-I%&)*J!$>.*.0!%9!1)*+!$0*-//(#?!5%-&0).&$!K-.(+.&/!)!+)0)K)$#?!$0%*)/#!5)0#*.)(@!

n%(-&0##*$!5)=.&/!*)+.%!K*%)+<)$0$!0%!#&#5J!0*%%>$@!

���������������!L����N!

n%(-&0##*!$%(+.#*$!+#$>.0#!01#!+.^<-(I#$?!4#!5-$0!K-.(+!.&0%!01#!L=./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<@N!

“������“ [Korean War Memoir (photos)],” at �������: ��� [Higher Headquarters Forum: Army edition], (2009.07.14) at < http://lt.cjdby.net/viewthread.php?tid=648473 > [accessed 16 June 2010, translated IP-1011].

Page 45: Underground Great Wall

+;".,$?,"$12,(.3,2.H$$P!./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<C+

".&=.&/!->!01*%-/1!01#!0-&&#(?!01#!$%(+.#*$!L�%.&!9%*<#$@N!

n%(-&0##*!$%(+.#*$!.&!01#!0*#&<1#$!.&!01#!<->%()!%&!01#!$#(9F<%&$0*-<0#+!$#(9FK-.(0!0%%($!9%*!0-&&#(@!

r-&#!SQ?!ST6A!G)()<#!e).!".B.!d.((!K)t(#?!*#(J.&/!%&!;%(-&0##*$!r-&!SA!0*#&<1#$!)&+!E/10!01#!#&#5J!*#>#)0#+(J?!=.((!)&+!4%-&+!01#!#&#5J!5%*#!01)&!A?777!>#%>(#?!$5)$1!01#!#&#5Jx$!)t)<=!

Ibid.

a./10!)t)<=!%-0!%9!01#!>%$.I%&@!

Page 46: Underground Great Wall

+;".,$?,"H$!./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<+

:`-)+!)t)<=@!

D)!".)&/!:1)&!;%(-&0##*!-&.0!E/1I&/!.&!01#!.&9)&0*J?!)*I((#*J?!)*5%*#+!�%.&0!<%55)&+!>%$0@!

O%!<)**J!%-0!0*).&.&/!)<I;.I#$!.&!01#!0-&&#(@!

Ibid.

O-&&#(!K*.#E&/!g!%)01!K#9%*#!K)t(#@!

n%(-&0##*!$%(+.#*$!.&!01#!0*#&<1#$!#&�%J!K)01@!

Page 47: Underground Great Wall

R!"#;+)D#./#'()#i2>A)#./#'()#Q.,)2"#V2,#2#K2C.,#A)00."0#A)2,")4#!"#'()#$%'(#-)"'5,9G##<(+"2q0#"26."2A#4)/)"0)#F,.C)-'#M)82"#]%#9)2,0#./#5"4),8,.5"4#/.,',)00#M5+A4+"8IS(

Y((-$0*)I%&!9*%5l!i vG*%0#<I%&!G*%�#<0!)0!d%5#!)&+!XK*%)+!)&+!:0*)0#/.<!O1.&=.&/w?i!?(.D<(+"2?!jA77T@7Q@7[k?!)0!s!11t>lbb444@$1%4<1.&)@%*/bV/�K`=B(bV(41J�$V<bA77T7Qb0A\R[[6@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

+;".,8$?,"$.",$<G88.('8S$

Page 48: Underground Great Wall

Re-*.&/!01#!o%*#)&!3)*?!01#!21.&#$#!G#%>(#x$!n%(-&0##*$!)&+!01#!o%*#)&!G#%>(#x$!X*5J!X.*!P%*<#!<*#)0#+!)&!X.*!P%*<#!�%.&0!%>#*)I%&$!<%55)&+!$0*-<0-*#@!'&+#*!01#!:.&%Fo%*#)&!2%5K.&#+!P%*<#$!2%55)&+?!01#!

1#)+`-)*0#*$!4)$!$#0!->!KJ!01#!21.&#$#!G#%>(#x$!n%(-&0##*$!)&+!01#!+-)(!(#)+#*$1.>!%9!01#!G"X!X.*!P%*<#@S(

L Þı6ŅXW"ź!vo%*#)&!X.*!P%*<#!r%.&0!2%55)&+w?N!ıUļî,!jA7S7@7R@A7k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@>())9@&#0b!u!v)<<#$$#+!A7!P#K@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!M%%/(#!21*%5#w@!!

+;".,8$?,"$.",$<G88.('8S$

2%55)&+!O-&&#(!9%*!01#!r%.&0!2%55)&+?!e#<#5K#*!ST67!!

Page 49: Underground Great Wall

R8F."S";G8F$@G(2G".!LX&!#$I5)0#+!R7!5.((.%&!>#%>(#!.&!&%*01#*&!21.&)!

$I((!(.;#!.&!<);#!1%5#$!=&%4&!)$!J)%+%&/$@N!

LG#%>(#x$!H#>-K(.<!%9!21.&)?N!V+:+F)4+2G#jA7SS@7T@S]k?!)0!s!1t>lbb#&@4.=.>#+.)@%*/b4.=.bG#%>(#x$~H#>-K(.<~%9~21.&)!u!v)<<#$$#+!A!r-&#!A7SSw@!

Page 50: Underground Great Wall

Study #3!

!.3*(2%,(!#B#3(C+<+$'+(8/$$+3#$-(K '4M/+$0.-+#:.?AM=TG:.+dd+D-<:TFG:.+l+SFM/-.0.Y+:H+

'./=?AMQ;+2J75d2J8J+^ +K-0a0.Y+#0E0<+*-H-.?-+&B-<A-M+#:>,<-1+^ +RM:a-TA+242;+#O#+"FG:.F<+#:>>F./+K=.L-M+^ +RM:a-TA+p27;++D-?-ME-+`-F,:.?+RM:/=TG:.+#:>,<-1+^ +RM:a-TA+84p2+FA+SFMU0.;+!MUF.+*-H-.?-+H:M+"=T<-FM+`FM+^ +O:/-M.+&BF.YBF0q?+!./-MYM:=./+^ +O0<0AFMQ+DF0<+l+D:F/+W=..-<0.Y+^ +D-<FA-/+'??=-?+

Page 51: Underground Great Wall

%V@$@'b'($!.:.87.+

“PRC Defense Policy and Armed Forces,” (National Intelligence Estimate 13-76; Washington, DC: CIA, 1970): pp. 71-72.

1()#<(+")0)#(2;)#'2:)"#0.=)#+"+62A#0')F0#'.#F,.;+4)#F,.')-6."#282+"0'#'()#+==)4+2')#)P)-'0#./#2#A2,8)d0-2A)#"5-A)2,#2>2-:I#1()9#2FF2,)"'A9#/))A#'(2'#'()+,#-+;+A#4)/)"0)#(20#)"(2"-)4#-+;+A+2"#=.,2A)#20#D)AA#20#'()+,#2M+A+'9#'.#05,;+;)#2"#2+,#.,#=+00+A)#2>2-:I#

!"#-."',20'#'.#'()#V)0'O0G#<(+"2O0#-+;+A#4)/)"0)#=)205,)0#(2;)#'2:)"#."#2#")D#2"4#A2,8),#0',2')8+-#4+=)"0+."I#1()#)W')"0+;)#-."0',5-6."#./#0()A'),0#2"4#5"4),8,.5"4#'5"")A+"8#0),;)0#'D.#F5,F.0)0I#1()9#2,)#0))"#20#.P),+"8#0.=)#F,.')-6."#./#F),0."")A#45,+"8#M.=M+"8#2"4#20#F,.;+4+"8#A.-26."0#/,.=#D(+-(#'.#H8('#2"#+";24),#+"#'()#8,.5"4#4)/)"0)#./#2#-+'9I#

<(+"2O0#0()A'),#2"4#'5"")A#F,.8,2=#+0#.")#./#'()#=.0'#)W')"0+;)#+"#'()#D.,A4G#'(.58(#+'0#)P)-6;)")00#,)=2+"0#5"')0')4I#?+"-)#\c]cG#'()#=200+;)#)P.,'#'.#M5+A4#=.,)#2"4#M)>),#F,.')-6."#(20#,)05A')4#+"#'()#-."0',5-6."#./#2#=2j)#./#0()A'),0#2"4#'5"")A0#5"4),#=.0'G#+/#".'#2AAG#A2,8)#2"4#=)4+5=d0+j)4#-+6)0rI#y1z()#"2'5,)#2"4#L52A+'9#./#'()0)#5"4),8,.5"4#+"0'2AA26."0#;),9#/,.=#-+'9#'.#-+'9rI###

Page 52: Underground Great Wall

P<&'"FXC'8.$!.:.87.T$D-<:TFG:.+l+SFM/-.0.Y+:H+'./=?AMQ;+2J75d2J8J+

Map from: Lorenz Luthi, “The Vietnam War and China’s Third-Line Defense Planning before the Cultural Revolution, 1964-1966,” Journal of Cold War Studies, vol. 10, no. 1, (Winter 2008): pp. 26-51; and Z)**J!r@!a)-/10%&?!LO1#!O1.*+!P*%&0l!e#9#&$#!Y&+-$0*.)(.V)I%&!.&!01#!21.&#$#!Y&0#*.%*?N!21.&)!y-)*0#*(J?!a%@SS6!j:#>0#5K#*!ST]]k?!>>@!Q6S,Q][@

Page 53: Underground Great Wall

e"F$C'8.$@;872"G92';8$'8$2&.$5N047$

• Lòú�gST[R�Ģ��Žw7Ķƥ¢Šw�Ľ!vD)%!É#+%&/!.&!ST[R?!X!D)�%*!+#<.$.%&l!O1.*+!P*%&0!2%&$0*-<I%&w?N!đ�ġƕ|±ł?!jA7S7@SA@AQk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@).(.%(@<%5b&#4$b]7SSA@$105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!AA!D)*@!A7SSw@!

O0<<0:.?+:H+R-F?F.A+OF.dB:=M?+:H+$FU:M+

Page 54: Underground Great Wall

OF??0E-+'>,FTA+:H+@W$*C+D-<:TFG:.+:H+'./=?AMQ;+2J75d2J8J+

p !P*%5!ST[6!0%!ST\T?!SA6!()*/#F$<)(#!#&0#*>*.$#$!j>*%+-<.&/!<)*$?!(./10!)&+!1#);J!5)<1.&#*J?!5#<1)&.<)(!#`-.>5#&0?!*%((.&/!5.(($?!#0<@k!4#*#!<%5>(#0#+C!

p !P*%5!ST[T!.0!.&<(-+#+!'&+#*/*%-&+!(%<)I%&!%9!a-<(#)*!H#)<0%*$?!3)*1#)+!:0%*)/#?!2%55)&+!2#&0#*?!'*K)&!>%>-()I%&!<.;.(!+#9#&$#!j&%*01#*&!<.I#$k!)&+!K-&=#*$!9%*!ePFS!)&+!ePFA!5.$$.(#!$0%*)/#!K-0!<%$0!%9!01#!()t#*!afO!.&<(-+#+!.&!O"e!K-+/#0C!

p !]?777!=5!%9!*).(*%)+!0*)<=$!)&+!A67?777!=5!%9!*%)+$!4#*#!<%&$0*-<0#+!0%!$->>%*0!O"e!>*%�#<0$@!p !O"e!$##&!)$!$%-*<#!%9!#&%*5%-$!#<%&%5.<!+*).&!)&+!4)$!<)&<#((#+!.&!01#!>%$0FD)%!+#;#(%>5#&0!>%(.<J@!

Page 55: Underground Great Wall

Video screen shots from: @ C!jBeijing, PRC: Civil Defense Film, 2000), [accessed 1 Mar. 2010].

4M/+$0.-+*-H-.?-+RM:/=TG:.+!./-MYM:=./!

Page 56: Underground Great Wall

e"F$C'8.$@;872"G92';8$'8$2&.$5N047$

L��@$D;+tt�4G;E?':!=!!vO1.*+!P*%&0!2%&$0*-<I%&l!:->#*!M*)&+!P)*F*#)<1.&/!:0*)0#/.<!G*%�#<0w?N!?+"2?!jA77]@7]@ARk?!)0!s!1t>lbbK(%/@$.&)@<%5@<&b$bK(%/~6)6Q)9Q67S77)*)�@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!AR!D)*@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!!

O:?A+RM:a-TA?+0.E:<E-/+-1A-.?0E-+W=..-<0.Y+

*0?AM0U=G:.+:H+*0?,-M?-/+F./+W=..-<-/+(FT0<0G-?!7SS!Z)$#l!X&$1-&@!P./10#*!)&+!0*).&#*!).*<*)_!>*%+-<I%&!K)$#@!!

7SA!Z)$#l!d)&V1%&/@!Y&0%!)!E/10#*!>*%+-<I%&!K)$#!.$!#B>#<0#+!.&!ST\6?!01#!<#&0*)(!+#<.$.%&!+#;#(%>#+!KJ!|.x)&!X.*<*)_!e#$./&!$1.>>#+!#./10!).*<*)_!9*%5!01#!7SA!K)$#$!<%&I&-#!0%!+#;#(%>!01#!K)$#!.&0%!)!0*)&$>%*0!).*<*)_!5)&-9)<0-*.&/!K)$#@!O%&/!d-.!D)<1.&#*J!P)<0%*J!.&!ST\T?!r.&$%&/!D)<1.&#*J!G()&0!)&+!01#!7SA!).*<*)_!+#$./&!KJ!01#!$#>)*)I%&!%9!01#!#$0)K(.$15#&0!%9!)!$#>)*)0#!:1))&B.!X.*<*)_!D)&-9)<0-*.&/!2%5>)&J?!7SA!X;.)I%&!>)*0$!>*%+-<I%&!K)$#!.&0%!K)$#@!Y&!ST]7?!#./10!0*)&$>%*0!).*<*)_!.&!>*%+-<I%&@!!

7SQ!K)$#$!jd-&)&!);.)I%&kl!É1)&/�.)�.#!F!21)&/$1)@!r-*.$+.<I%&!%9!$#;#*)(!);.)I%&!>)*0$!>()&0!j5).&(J!|.)&/!".&/!D)<1.&#*J!P)<0%*J!P)<0%*J!Q7A]k!)&+!É1)&/�.)�.#!n%<)I%&)(!)&+!O#<1&.<)(!2%((#/#!);.)I%&!.&+-$0*J?!);.)I%&!)&+!01#!01.*+!)&+!e#$./&!Y&$I0-0#@!!

7SR!Z)$#!jD.$$.(#!Y&$I0-0#!%9!21.&)kl!"-%J)&/@!S6]!:%-01!G#)=!>()&0!5%;#+!0%!01#!<%5>)&J!9*%5!d)&V1%&/?!$>#<.)(.V#$!.&!5)&-9)<0-*.&/!).*!0%!).*!5.$$.(#$@!!

Page 57: Underground Great Wall

@&;8S\'8S$V,'($C'8.'Q*+!".&#!O-&&#(!2%&$0*-<I%&!

LŕÿƀŨ­�ƥSASY�Ľ�4g¢Š Ėĕ!v|.)&/J-!>)$0l!SAS!01*##F(.&#?!$0-+#&0$!)&+!$%(+.#*$!(%$0!01#.*!(.;#$!.&!01#!K-.(+.&/w?N!1)"-)"'#u(52"L5.G#jA77T@7]@A]k?!)0!s!1t>lbb&#4$@``@<%5b)bA77T7]A]b77A[6Q@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!A7!D)*@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!!

'>,FTA+:H+#0E0<0F.+W=..-<0.Y;+p !Z-.(0!K#04##&!ST\7FST\]C!p !".&#!(#&/01!%9!]T\!=5C!p !O%0)(!%9!\S[!K*.+/#$C!p !R76!0-&&#($C!p !:.B0J!L$0-+#&0N!<%&$0*-<I%&!<%5>)&.#$!4.01!S]?677!

1./1!$<1%%(!)&+!A6?]77!�-&.%*!1./1!$<1%%(!$0-+#&0$!0%!>)*I<.>)I&/!

p !3.01.&!)!01*##!J#)*!>#*.%+!SRS!$0-+#&0$!=.((#+!.&!<%&$0*-<I%&!)<<.+#&0$@!

Z*.+/#!)&+!0-&&#(!(#&/01!#`-)(#+!R68!%9!0%0)(!(.&#!(#&/01!%;#*!01#!21#&/+-Fo-&5.&/!(.&#@!!

Page 58: Underground Great Wall

e"F$C'8.$@;872"G92';8$'8$2&.$5N047$O:?A+RM:a-TA?+0.E:<E-/+-1A-.?0E-+W=..-<0.Y+

*0?AM0U=G:.+:H+*0?,-M?-/+F./+W=..-<-/+(FT0<0G-?+iT:.AZj!

•  7[S!Z)$#!j:%-01!$>)<#k!É-&J.@!X&IF).*<*)_!5.$$.(#!K)$#?!$-KF04%!1%5#$!K-.(0!).*<*)_@!!

•  7[A!Z)$#!jX#*%$>)<#!nYY!d%$>.0)(k!5.((.%&!:%-*<#!F!21#&/+-@!H%<=#0!b!5.$$.(#!>*%+-<I%&!K)$#@2%&$0*-<I%&!%9!)!1%$>.0)(!$-KF&);./)I%&@!!

•  7[Q!Z)$#!jX#*%$>)<#!9%-*!1%5#$kl!|.x)&@!!

•  7[R!K)$#$!j.&0%!7[A!K)$#kl!P(%*.+)@!!

•  7[[!Z)$#!j:)&�.)&/!:>)<#kl!}-)&x)&!F!|.)%/)&@!2*-.$#!D.$$.(#!K)$#!j*#+!K.*+k@!2%&$0*-<I%&!%9!d%$>.0)($!5.&-0#$!U./10@!!

•  7[\!Z)$#!jX#*%$>)<#!$.B!1%5#$kl!P#&/B.)&!F!|.x)&@!".`-.+!*%<=#0!#&/.&#!>*%+-<I%&!K)$#@2%&$0*-<I%&!%9!)!1%$>.0)(!$-KF&);./)I%&@!!

•  7[]!K)$#$!jd-&)&!X#*%$>)<#kl!:1)%J)&/!2.0J!R!2%-&0J!S!F!21)&/$1)@!:-K!&);./)I%&!K-.(0!04%!1%5#$@P%-&+#+!.&!ST\7?!ST\]?!$0%>!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!.&!STTR?!5%;#+!0%!21)&/$1)@!!

•  7]S!Z)$#!jo)4)=.0)!hkl!M-)&/J-)&@!O1#!%*./.&)(!7]AS!1#)+`-)*0#*$?!K-.(0!.&!ST[6?!01#!>*%+-<I%&!K)$#!9%*!01#!E*#!<%&0*%(!*)+)*@!!

•  7]A!Z)$#l!#)$0#*&!$-K-*K$!%9!21#&/+-?!01#!#(#<0*%&.<$!.&+-$0*J!K)$#@!!

•  7]Q!Z)$#!jÉ1#&1-)!h(#<0*%&.<$kl!e-J-&@!!

•  6RS!P)<0%*Jl!O)&=!5)&-9)<0-*.&/!K)$#?!)-01%*.I#$!3#&B.!O%4&$1.>?!01#!>()&0!(%<)0#+!.&!|.&�.)&/!2%-&0J?!}.<1#&/!)&+!}-)&`-@!!

L��@$D;+tt�4G;E?':!=?N!%>!<.0@!

Page 59: Underground Great Wall

e"F$C'8.$@;872"G92';8$'8$2&.$5N047$

L��@$D;+tt�4G;E?':!=?N!%>!<.0@C!)&+!>1%0%$!9*%5l!Lº#Ģw�Ľ!!vf-*!O1.*+!".&#w?N!V+A4),")00#V.A/?!!jA7S7@7R@Q7k?!)0!s!1t>lbb<=====F77\@K(%/@S[Q@<%5bK(%/b$0)I<bQA[RT[7[A7S7QQ7QQ7A7]SQb!u!v0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSC!)<<#$$#+!AS!D)*@!A7SSw@!

O:?A+RM:a-TA?+0.E:<E-/+-1A-.?0E-+W=..-<0.Y+

WB0M/+(M:.A+#:.?AM=TG:.+:H!DFa:M+%TB0-E->-.A?+!

21.&)!$0#)5!!j:1.J)&!2.0J?!d-K#.!G*%;.&<#k!!

21.&)q$!$#<%&+F()*/#$0!)-0%5%I;#!/*%->!!

f.(E#(+!jy.)&�.)&/!2.0J?!d-K#.!G*%;.&<#k!!

21)&/`.&/!f.(E#(+!j:1))&B.!G*%;.&<#k!21.&)x$!01.*+F()*/#$0!%.(!E#(+!!

r.-`-)&!Y*%&!)&+!:0##(!M*%->!jM)&$-!r.-`-)&k!!

a%*014#$0!)(-5.&-5!>()&0$!j")&V1%-k!!

G)&V1.1-)!Y*%&!)&+!:0##(!M*%->!j:.<1-)&!G)&V1.1-)k!!

21.&)x$!E_1!()*/#$0!:0##(!M*%->!

2%)(!K)$#!.&!01#!d#()&!D%-&0).&$!j:1.V-.$1)&!2.0Jk!!

r.-`-)&!:>)<#!")-&<1!2#&0#*!jM)&$-!r.-`-)&k!21.&)x$!()*/#$0!$>)<#!()-&<1!$.0#!!

|.<1)&/!:>)<#!")-&<1!2#&0#*!j:.<1-)&!|.<1)&/k!!

r.&<1-)&!a%&9#**%-$!D#0)($!2%5>)&J!jr.&<1)&/k!!

r.)(.&/!D%0%*<J<(#!M*%->!j21%&/`.&/k!01#!4%*(+x$!()*/#$0!5%0%*<J<(#!5)=#*!

".->)&$1-.!<%)(!.&+-$0*J!K)$#!j".->)&$1-.k!!

Page 60: Underground Great Wall

e"F$C'8.$@;872"G92';8$'8$2&.$5N047$

L��@$D;+tt�4G;E?':!=?N!%>!<.0@!

O:?A+RM:a-TA?+0.E:<E-/+-1A-.?0E-+W=..-<0.Y+WB0M/+(M:.A+#:.?AM=TG:.+:H!DFa:M+%TB0-E->-.A?+iT:.AZj!

e#J)&/!:#<%&+!d#);J!D)<1.&#*J!G()&0!j:.<1-)&!e#J)&/k!")*/#!5)<1.&#*J!5)&-9)<0-*#*!

"-%J)&/!M()$$!P)<0%*J!j"-%J)&/?!d#&)&!G*%;.&<#k!!

e%&/9)&/!:0#)5!O-*K.&#!3%*=$?!!

e%&/9)&/!h(#<0*.<)(!D)<1.&#*J!P)<0%*J!!

e%&/9)&/!Z%.(#*!3%*=$!!

21#&/+-Fo-&5.&/!H).(4)J!!j21#&/+-!F!o-&5.&/k!O%0)(!(#&/01!%9!S7TS!=5!

!d-&)&FM-.V1%-!*).(4)J!\\A!=5!jÉ1-V1%-!F!J%-!5)J!K#k!O%0)(!(#&/01!%9!T76!=5!!

|.)&/J-!H).(4)J!j|.)&/9)&!F!21%&/`.&/k!O%0)(!(#&/01!%9!S?RSS!=5!!

y.&/1).FO.K#0!H).(4)J!)!j|.&.&/!F!a)&$1)&!5%-01k!9-((!]SR!=.(%5#0#*$!!

".-�.)B.)!dJ+*%>%4#*!:0)I%&!O1#!0%0)(!.&$0)((#+!<)>)<.0J!%9!S?AA6?777!=.(%4)t$?!/#&#*)I&/!<)>)<.0J!%9!6@\!K.((.%&!+#/*##$!%9!e)&�.)&/=%-!dJ+*%>%4#*!!

X$.)x$!()*/#$0!)*IE<.)(!9*#$14)0#*!()=#!dJ+*%#(#<0*.<!jd-K#.!}.<1)&/!<.0Jk!O1#!0%0)(!.&$0)((#+!<)>)<.0J!%9!A?\S6?777!=.(%4)t$?!/#&#*)I&/!<)>)<.0J!%9!S[@S!K.((.%&!+#/*##$!.&!:%-014#$0!21.&)!!

H#$#)*<1!Y&$I0-0#!%9!21.&)!!

a-<(#)*!G%4#*!Y&$I0-0#!%9!G1J$.<$!

Page 61: Underground Great Wall

e"F$C'8.$@;872"G92';8$'8$2&.$5N047$

L��@$D;+tt�4G;E?':!=?N!%>!<.0@!

O:?A+RM:a-TA?+0.E:<E-/+-1A-.?0E-+W=..-<0.Y+

Page 62: Underground Great Wall

1 “Z#.�.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J!O1#!:#<*#0!O-&&#($!%9!01#!2)>.0)(?N!<(+"2#3)F.,'G#jSS!:#>0#5K#*!A77Tk?!at < http://www.drben.net/ChinaReport/Beijing/Landmarks-Hotspots/ChongWen/Underground_City-Beijing_Air_Raid_Shelters/Beijing_DixiaCheng-Beijing_Underground_City.html> [accessed 7 Mar. 2010].

I8"+(4+5,+1(8/$$+3'(.<(1"+(!%:#1%3C+

!"#$%&'"(#)*"+,$"-)%."/0#"1#0"02."+,$"34567"

+$27&)27"8$+9$$2"-,&20"02."+,$":);&$+"<2&)2=">2'$"0"

7$'#$+"0&#?#0&."7,$%+$#"2$+9)#@"$AB$'+$."+)"B#)+$'+"

C6D")("+,$"E$&F&2G"HI8%&'"&27&.$"I2.$#G#)I2."

JI22$%7"(#)*"0".$;07+0+&2G"2I'%$0#"0++0'@K"&+"($%%"

&2+)".&7I7$"0(+$#"+,$"%0+$"34L67=""

C/,#$-(1"+(C%E'(.<(1"+(!/31/,%3(J+B.3/1#.$(K@@>@@@(L+#M#$-(!"#$+'+(D+,+(N.O#3#P+*(1.(*#-(1"+'+(/$*+,-,./$*(1/$$+3'(1"%1(,/$(<.,(N#3+'(%$*(N#3+'(/$*+,(L+#M#$-Q"

!(+$#"+,$"-I%+I#0%"M$;)%I+&)2"02."9&+,"+,$"0.;$2+")("

*).$#2&+N"&2"-,&20K"&+"907"7))2"()#G)++$2"8N"*)7+"

E$&F&2G$#7"02."#$*0&2$."0"7&+$";&#+I0%%N"I2@2)92"+)"

+,$"-&+NO7"-&+&P$27"I2+&%"0+"%$07+"+,$"N$0#"Q666!R="

:&2'$"&+",07"8$')*$"0"*).$7+"+)I#&7+"0++#0'+&)2S="

E$&F&2G"<2.$#G#)I2."'&+N"'02"8$"()I2."&2"+,$"

-,)2G9$2"R&7+#&'+=S"

f&#!%9!T7!%*./.&)(!#&0*)&<#$@!!!!!!:0).*<)$#!+#$<#&+.&/!]FS]!5#0#*$@!

Y&0#*&)(!U%*#$<#&0!$.0#!5)>@!

*)()"&)+D)$%W)*+)V%OR$)++2;+K-0a0.Y+!./-MYM:=./+#0AQ++

D)%!O$#!O-&/!jST[Tk!

Page 63: Underground Great Wall

=.'^'8Sc7$R8F."S";G8F$@'2E$4I+L>+0.+<-.YAB+

Ri)")2'(#'()#2"-+)"'#-+'9#./#i)+C+"8G#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#-+'9#./#4)H"+')#F,.F.,6."0#(20#2A,)249#M)85"#'.#)=),8)I#1(),)#2,)#/2-'.,+)0G#0'.,)0G#85)0'(.50)0G#,)0'25,2"'0G#(.0F+'2A0G#0-(..A0G#'()2'),0G#,)24+"8d,..=0G#2#,.AA),#0:26"8#,+":G#2#8,2+"#2"4#.+A#D2,)(.50)G#2"4#2#=50(,..=#-5A6;26."#/2,=I#1()0)#5"4),8,.5"4#F,.45-6."#2"4#0),;+-)#/2-+A+6)0#-.;),#2#'.'2A#2,)2#./#LMI7III'6N92)"'3"0")6'2%&'32J"6'96"'$.'3$)"'0?2%'H7III'2%*O2-)')2-&'60)9#09)"6ISS!

#=MM-.A+%TGE0AQ;+p !h&0#*0).&5#&0l!R!5).&!>-K(.<!*#$0)-*)&0$?!A!-&+#*/*%-&+!01#)0#*$?!)&+!)!*%((#*!$=)I&/!*.&=@!p !d%0#($X#R!"#'()#A20'#/)D#9)2,0G#'()#"5=M),#./#5"4),8,.5"4#(.')A0#(20#-A+=M)4#'.#\%%G#D+'(#2#'.'2A#./#=.,)#'(2"#

\%G%%%#M)40I#1(+0#"5=M),#+0#,.58(A9#)L5+;2A)"'#'.#'()#(2A/#./#'()#'.'2A#.P),)4#2'#85)0'#(.50)0#+"#'()#i)+C+"8#K5"+-+F2A+'9IS#

p !H#0).(!)&+!(#)$#+!$0%*)/#l!R1()#0'.,)0#5"4),")2'(#'()#v+42"#0(.FF+"8#2,)2#".,'(#./#<(2"8q#2"#_.')A#'2:)#5F#2"#2,)2#./#.;),#hG%%%#0L52,)#=)'),0I#n/#'(+0G#0.=)#gG%%%#0L52,)#=)'),0#2,)#50)4#/.,#0'.,28)G#'()#,)0'#/.,#M50+")00I#P"%*+2*$%'"N9-43"%0'32-%02-%6'2'#$%602%0'/Q'℃''"%G-)$%3"%07'R-0?')"+2*G"'?93-&-0,'%"G")'2A$G"'QL'

4")#"%0ES#

R=U<0T+%TT-??;+p !G-K(.<!0%-*$!%>#*)0#+!K#04##&!A777FA77Tl!

R1(),)#2,)#,.58(A9#c%#)"',2"-)0#'.#'()#-.=FA)WG#2AA#./#D(+-(#2,)#(+44)"#+"#0(.F0#2A."8#s+2"=)"q0#=2+"#0',))'0I#7#p5.,)0-)"'#D2AA#=2F#,);)2A0#'()#,.56"8#./#'()#)"6,)#'5"")A#090')=I#l.5#-2"#;+0+'#2#0)-6."#./#'()#'5"")A0#2"4#r#9.5qAA#F200#-(2=M),0#A2M)A)4#'()+,#.,+8+"2A#/5"-6."#`-+")=2G#(.0F+'2AG#2,0)"2A#)'-a#20#D)AA#20#p..4dF,../#82')0I#l.5#-2"#2A0.#=2:)#.5'#0+8"F.0'0#'.#=2C.,#A2"4=2,:0#2--)00)4#M9#'()#'5"")A0#`1+2"2"=)"#?LG#'()#J.,M+44)"#<+'9aG#M5'#'()0)#,.5')0#2,)#+"2--)00+MA)IS#

p !:.&<#!r-&#!A77T?!1%4#;#*?!%01#*!01)&!<%55#*<.)(!(%<)I%&$!(.$0#+!)K%;#?!)((!0%-*!#&0*)&<#$!<-**#&0(J!<(%$#+@A#

*FML+&0/-;!

p !D-<1!%9!01#!<%5>(#B!&%0!5).&0).&#+!,!U%%+#+?!E((#+!4.01!0*)$1?!)&+!K%)*+#+!->@!

1  “The Underground City,” Beijing: A Guide to China’s Capital City, (2009?) at < http://www.china.org.cn/english/features/beijing/30836.htm > [accessed 15 Jan. 2010]. 2  “Beijing Underground City,” Lonely Planet Review, (20 April 2010) at < http://www.lonelyplanet.com/china/beijing/sights/368621 > [accessed 5 May 2010]: Stephan Curran,

(posted: 11 June 2009) “Current Access to Underground City -- Y!0*.#+!0%!)<<#$$!01#!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J!%&!r-&#!S7!A77T!)&+!<%-(+!E&+!&%!4)J!.&Å@!O1#!<.0J!.$!$I((!01#*#?!1.+.&/Å@N! Andy Degraeve, (posted: 20 April 2010) “Y!1);#!K##&!0%!01#!-&+#*/*%-&+!<.0J!#&0*)&<#!)0![A!3#$0!e)5%<1)&/!:0*##0!.&!y.)&5#&@!O1)0!#&0*)&<#!.$!)+;#*I$#+!0%!K#!<(%$#+!>#*5)&#&0(J@N!

Page 64: Underground Great Wall

Video screen shots from: @ C!jBeijing, PRC: Civil Defense Film, 2000), [accessed 1 Mar. 2010].

@WB-+&-TM-A+W=..-<?+:H+AB-+#F,0AF<C+=./-M+T:.?AM=TG:.!

D)%!>#*$%&)((J!*#;.#4.&/!>()&$!9%*!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J! R77?777!<.;.(.)&$!>)*I<.>)0#+!.&!<%&$0*-<I%&!

R77?777!<.;.(.)&$!>)*I<.>)0#+!.&!<%&$0*-<I%&! G)*0!%9!.&0#*.%*!(.&#+!4.01!01#!%(+!<.0J!4)(($!%9!Z#.�.&/!

Page 65: Underground Great Wall

“'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J?N!<(+"2#!"'),")'#!"/.,=26."#<)"'),#dd#1,2;)AG#jS6!X>*.(!A776k?!at < http://www.drben.net/ChinaReport/Beijing/Landmarks-Hotspots/ChongWen/Underground_City-Beijing_Air_Raid_Shelters/Beijing_DixiaCheng-Beijing_Underground_City.html> [accessed 7 Mar. 2010].

@WB-+&-TM-A+W=..-<?+:H+AB-+#F,0AF<C+F?+F+T=<A=MF<+FTB0-E->-.A

G()`-#!9*%5!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J! :0)5>!2%55#5%*)I&/!hW%*0!

P)5%-$!G).&I&/!

Page 66: Underground Great Wall

Video screen shots from: @ C!jBeijing, PRC: Civil Defense Film, 2000), [accessed 1 Mar. 2010].

@WB-+&-TM-A+W=..-<?+:H+AB-+#F,0AF<C+=,:.+T:>,<-G:.!

X<I;#!1%$>.0)(!.&!-&+#*/*%-&+!<.0J! :0%*)/#!<%5>)*05#&0$!g!&)**%4F/)-/#!*).(!0*)&$>%*0!

d#);J!K()$0b)&IF*)+.)I%&!+%%*$!%&!-&+#*/*%-&+!1%$>.0)(! nYG!+*.;#F01*-!/)((#*.#$!

Page 67: Underground Great Wall

=.'^'8S$R8F."S";G8F$@'2E$!.9('8.$2&"G$C,9Q$;:$R7.$

Page 68: Underground Great Wall

“Z#.�.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J!O1#!:#<*#0!O-&&#($!%9!01#!2)>.0)(@?N!<(+"2#3)F.,'G#jSS!:#>0#5K#*!A77Tk?!at < http://www.drben.net/ChinaReport/Beijing/Landmarks-Hotspots/ChongWen/Underground_City-Beijing_Air_Raid_Shelters/Beijing_DixiaCheng-Beijing_Underground_City.html> [accessed 7 Mar. 2010].

=.'^'8S$R8F."S";G8F$@'2E$

Page 69: Underground Great Wall

Z#.�.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J!O1#!e)*=!:.+#!

“Z#.�.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J!O1#!:#<*#0!O-&&#($!%9!01#!2)>.0)(@?N!<(+"2#3)F.,'G#jSS!:#>0#5K#*!A77Tk?!at < http://www.drben.net/ChinaReport/Beijing/Landmarks-Hotspots/ChongWen/Underground_City-Beijing_Air_Raid_Shelters/Beijing_DixiaCheng-Beijing_Underground_City.html> [accessed 7 Mar. 2010].

Page 70: Underground Great Wall

L21.&)x$!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.I#$!?!G*#>!9%*!a-=#!3)*?N!!e#9#&$#!P%*-5!Y&+.)?!jA7S7@7S@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb+#9#&<#9%*-5.&+.)@<%5b<1.&)F>)=.$0)&F+#9#&<#b]7SQF<1.&)$F-&+#*/*%-&+F<.I#$F>*#>F&-=#F4)*@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+![!r)&@!A7SSw@!

Page 71: Underground Great Wall
Page 72: Underground Great Wall

L21).*5)&!D)%q$!'&+#*/*%-&+!2.0J?N!m+-)A2"4?!jA77T@SS@S\k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@;.<#()&+@<%5bK(%/$b#&b0)/b1.++#&F<.I#$b!u!v)<<#$$#+![!r)&@!A7SSw@!

Page 73: Underground Great Wall
Page 74: Underground Great Wall
Page 75: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$5e5$

•  2faOh|Ol!X!+#0#*.%*)I&/!*#()I%&$1.>!4.01!01#!'::H!)_#*!01#!LÉ1#&K)%!Y$()&+!5.(.0)*J!<()$1!K)<=!.&!01#![7$!)_#*!01#!4)*!41#&!01#!:%;.#0!'&.%&!+#>(%J#+!%&!01#!K%*+#*!S!5.((.%&!0*%%>$!#J#.&/!21.&)@!X&I<.>)I&/!)!3)*!%9!X//*#$$.%&!)/).&$0!21.&)?!.0$!0%>!)-01%*.I#$!*#<%/&.V#+!)&!-*/#&0!&##+!0%!>*#>)*#!9%*!)&!.0!)&+!+#<.+#+!0%!K-.(+!)&!)&IF&-<(#)*!4)*!-&+#*/*%-&+!1#)+`-)*0#*$!.&!01#!<#&0*)(!1.&0#*()&+@N!

•  "#)+#*$1.>!%*+#*$!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!)!&-<(#)*!4)*!<%55)&+!<#&0#*!<%&$0*-<0#+!)$!)!$#*.#$!%9!-&+#*/*%-&+!K-&=#*$!9%*!01#!$#&.%*!>%(.I<)(!#(.0#!)&+!01#!G"X!<%55)&+!)&+!<%&0*%(!%*/)&$C!

•  '&+#*!01#!+.*#<0!<%55)&+!%9!M#&#*)(!d-)&/!}%&/$1#&/?!2#&0*)(!G%(.I<)(!Z-*#)-!5#5K#*!)&+!G"X!21.#9!%9!:0)W?!41%!>.<=#+!01#!(%<)I%&!9%*!(#)+#*$1.>!1.+#%-0!&#)*!1.$!1%5#!0%4&!%9!M)%`.)%!O%4&?!|.)&&.&/!2.0J?!d-K#.!G*%;.&<#C!

•  O%>!:#<*#0!>*%/*)5!$0)*0#+!ST[T!r)&-)*J!QS!!•  SFQS?!01-$!&)5#+!SQSC!<%&$0*-<I%&l!ST[TFST\S!!•  :0%>>#+!K#9%*#!<%5>(#0#+?!.&;#$05#&0!c!S@Q!K.((.%&@!

P%*!)!;#*J!-$#9-(!1.$0%*J?!$##l!LDJ$0#*J!SQS!3%*=$l![7!}#)*$!0%!Z-.(+!01#!X&IFa-<(#)*!'&+#*/*%-&+!d#)+`-)*0#*$?N!vL神秘SQS工程l[7�!*¢ĢƄêh�ÄÅźNw?!<(+"2#E)D0?!jS!f<0%K#*!A77\k?!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@<1.&)&#4$@<%5@<&b01*#)+FS67\[FSFS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!r)&@!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!GXowC!)&+!r.#�-&J-&?!NSQS!O%>F:#<*#0!G*%�#<0!F!|.)&&.&/!21#&/!O-&&#(!'&+#*/*%-&+!d#)+`-)*0#*$?N!vLSQSŀ��Į!ÄÄĂG^�ćôûh�ÄÅźNw?!<(+"2#?5F),#B,.C)-'!v��E?!=w!K(%/?!j\!r-(J!A77Tk?!)0!s!!u!v)<<#$$#+![!D)*@!A7S7w@!

*)()"&)+D)$%W)*+)V%OR$)++3;+#-.AMF<+#:>>0u--+#:>>F./+#:>,<-1+

Page 76: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$5e5$$B,;c7$*-;b.$D";G8F$f'((,$

•! "#)+#*$1.>!%*+#*$!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!)!&-<(#)*!4)*!<%55)&+!<#&0#*!<%&$0*-<0#+!)$!)!$#*.#$!%9!-&+#*/*%-&+!K-&=#*$!9%*!01#!$#&.%*!>%(.I<)(!#(.0#!)&+!01#!G"X!<%55)&+!)&+!<%&0*%(!%*/)&$C!

•! R?5,,.5"4)4#M9#;),42"'#=.5"'2+"0#2"4#/.,)0'0G#'()#A.-26."#+0#(2,4#'.#0))G#);)"#/,.=#A.Dd2A6'54)#,)-.""2+002"-)#2+,-,2tG#+0#+"4))4#2#8..4#FA2-)#/.,#'()#-."0',5-6."#./#(2,4#'.#H"4#=+A+'2,9#/2-+A+6)0IS#

P%*!)!;#*J!-$#9-(!1.$0%*J?!$##l!LDJ$0#*J!SQS!3%*=$l![7!}#)*$!0%!Z-.(+!01#!X&IFa-<(#)*!'&+#*/*%-&+!d#)+`-)*0#*$?N!vL SQS l[7������������Nw?!<(+"2#E)D0?!jS!f<0%K#*!A77\k?!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@<1.&)&#4$@<%5@<&b01*#)+FS67\[FSFS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!r)&@!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!!

"hPOl!h&0*)&<#!0%!0-&&#(!<%5>(#$!

HYMdOl!D)%q$!K#+*%%5!

Page 77: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$5e5$B,;c7$@;33,[email protected]."$

•! !"#244+6."#'.#'()#)W')"0+;)#'5"")A+"8G#'()#FA2"0#+"-A54)4#R2"#2+,F.,'G#,2+AD29G#(+8(D29G#2"4#.'(),#2"-+AA2,9#D.,:0IS#

•! V+'(#'()#/2AA#./#N+"#B+2.G#'()#RO\f\O#5"4),8,.5"4#-."0',5-6."#D20#".'#9)'#/5AA9#-.=FA)')4#2"4#-2=)#'.#2#,20(#)"4IS#m+0+6"8#'()#-.=FA)W#D(+-(#+0#".D#.F)"#'.#<(+")0)#'.5,+0'0#`M5'#".'#/.,)+8"),0a#2#,)F.,'),#".')4#'()#A2,8)#0-2A)#./#'()#.F),26."2A#()24L52,'),0#2"4#)W')"0+;)#/2-+A+6)0#4)0+8")4#0F)-+H-2AA9#/.,#<(2+,=2"#K2.G#D(),)#."-)#'()#D2,#M,.:)#.5'G#()#RD+AA#M)#(),)G#0',2')8+j+"8#<(+)/#./#'()#'(,))#2,=)4#/.,-)0G#-.==2"4+"8#'()#D2,#282+"0'#288,)00+."IS#

S2$T'=U9))$R'&""47'60$)"'5)2-%7'%"G")'6""J'?"5"3$%,EF'

V-%'U-2$T'W<.'0?"'X$)0?'-6'+$607'R"'3960'A9-+&'2%'-34)"5%2A+"'4$6-*$%'

-%'0?"'6$90?'R-0?'2%'9%&")5)$9%&'?"2&N92)0")6EW''

Page 78: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$5e5$R8F."S";G8F$=G8Q."$

i探秘湖北LSQSN�Įƥòú��õƑL���é!!!vy-#$0!d-K#.!iSQSi!>*%�#<0l!31)0!=.&+!%9!D)%!É#+%&/!)&+!r.)&/!y.&/!K#+*%%5w?i!׸ĢK�?!jA7SS@7]@7Qk?!)0!s!1t>lbbV1)&/1-.66A@K(%/@S[Q@<%5bK(%/b$0)I<b]7\S6AS[A7SS\Q7S\AA]6b!!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 79: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$5e5$R8F."S";G8F$=G8Q."$

YK.+@!

Page 80: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$5e5$!

i�ăhf~6\AR�ăhf~�ăhf!!!v".&B.)&/!D)>!~6\AR!~!".&B.)&/!D)>!".&B.)&/!D)>w?i!3fG':?!jA7SS@7\@7Qk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@/*%->%&$\@<%5b(.&B.)&/+.0-bA7SS7\7Qb\\6@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 81: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$5e5$R8F."S";G8F$=G8Q."$

YK.+@!

Page 82: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$[50H$$V.7."b.$?.,);87$%";FG92';8$@;3)(.Z!

Q".D"#20#o'()#D.,A4q0#A2,8)0'#2,6H-+2A#-2;)Go#'()#<(."8L+"8#J5A+"8#&\]#=+A+'2,9#-2;)#/.,#'()#H,0'#6=)#'.#.F)"#20#'.5,+0'#2>,2-6."0I#1()#F,.C)-'#0'2,')4#+"#\c]wG#'.#-."45-'#F,)d4,+AA)4#(.A)0#M9#'()#<.,F0#./#Z"8+")),0G#1()#!"0#2"4#n5'0#./#(5=2"#]%#%%%#F).FA)#0(2,)#'()#\c&g#A.-:.5'G#+"#7F,+A#$%%$#'.#4)-,9F'I##

&\]#=+A+'2,9#-2;)#+0#A.-2')4#+"#'()#0',))'0#./#J5A+"8#*+0',+-'G#i2+#12.I#!"#\c]]G#u(.5#Z"A2+G#<(+"2#2FF,.;)4#'()#-."0',5-6."#./#2#0)-."4#"5-A)2,#=2'),+2A#+"450',+2A#M20)#/.,#1(+,4dN+")#-."0',5-6."#dd#2'.=+-#,)2-'.,0#2"4#-()=+-2A#F.0'd',)2'=)"'#D.,:0G#'(2'#+0G#'.#F,.;+4)#"5-A)2,#M.=M#5"4),8,.5"4#"5-A)2,#FA2"'#=2'),+2A0G#2,)#-A200+H)4#20#'.F#0)-,)'#A);)A#=+A+'2,9#0)-,)'0I##

&\]#=+A+'2,9#'5"")A#/.,#M.49#'.'2A#-."0',5-6."#2,)2#./#\%gG%%%#0L52,)#=)'),0G#FA2"'#(.A)#4)F'(#./#g%%#=)'),0I#<2;)#2'#'()#'.F#./#'()#M)0'#-.;),#$%%#=)'),0#'(+-:G#'()#-.,)#F2,'0#./#FA2"'#-.;),#A29),#'(+-:")00#./#\h%#=)'),0I##

Z"',2"-)0#{#\cG#-.,,+4.,0#{#$\#:=#+"#'.'2A#A)"8'(I#

7F,+A#$gG#'()#'.5,+0'0#;+0+')4#'()#,)2-'.,#(2AAI#E5-A)2,#,)2-'.,0G#2A0.#:".D"#20#2'.=+-#,)2-'.,0#.,#,)2-'.,G#+0#)L5+FF)4#'.#2-(+);)#A2,8)d0-2A)#"5-A)2,#/5)A#H00+."#-(2+"#,)2-6."#-2"#M)#-."',.AA)4#4);+-)I#1()#(2AA#2"4#4.D"#2#'.'2A#./#"+")#A29),0G#5F#'.#wcI]#=)'),0G#'()#)L5+;2A)"'#./#$%#=5A6d0'.,)9#M5+A4+"8#()+8('G#0+j)#./#2#0'2"42,4#/..'M2AA#H)A4#+0#2A=.0'#'()#02=)I##

E5-A)2,#,)2-'.,0G#oM.>.=o#D)AA#F,)0),;)4I#7--.,4+"8#'.#,)F.,'0G#M.>.=#4+2=)'),#./#w&#-=#./#'()#$%%\#(.A)0G#/.,#"5-A)2,#=2'),+2A0G#"5-A)2,#)"),89#)W-(2"8)I#70#'()#F,.45-6."#(),)#(20#".'#0'.FF)4G#'(),)#+0#".#,24+26."I##

c#p..,0#+"#'()#=2+"#-."',.A#,..=G#2,)#FA2-)4#2'#'()#=.0'#24;2"-)4#-.=F5'),#M.49G#'()#-.=F5'),#-."0.A)#+0#."#'()#/.5,#4,.F0#./#2#4+2=)'),#./#2M.5'#$=#+"#'()#-."',.A#F2")AG#'()#(.A)0#D),)#HAA)4#D+'(#(5"4,)40#./#"5-A)2,#=2'),+2A#,.4#+0#+"0),')4#+"'.#'()#'()0)#(.A)0G#M5'#");),#,)2AA9#50)4#+"#'()#F,.45-6."I##

“816�ĮPŘďĒ [816 Project Photo Tour],” topic: 航天二炮及新概念武器 [Second Artillery Corps and the New Concept of Space Weapons] at ŧĺwßŐşj [Higher Headquarters Forum], (2010.04.26) at < http://bbs.cjdby.net/thread-917792-1-3.html > [accessed 20 May. 2010, translated IP-1011].

*)()"&)+D)$%W)*+)V%OR$)++4;+"=T<-FM+D-FTA:M+

Page 83: Underground Great Wall

Le#<()$$.E#+!21.&#$#!'&+#*/*%-&+!a-<(#)*!P)<.(.0J!f>#&!0%!G-K(.<?N!l.5'5M)G#jA7S7@7R@AAk!)0!f:2@!

RM:a-TA+p27+O:=.AF0.+

Page 84: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+).AMF.T-+

Page 85: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+!./-MYM:=./+"=T<-FM+D-FTA:M!

“816�ĮPŘďĒ,” op cit.

Page 86: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+!./-MYM:=./+"=T<-FM+D-FTA:M!

“816�ĮPŘďĒ ibid; and L深山L潜伏NQ[ŭ!Ž�ê�ĮÈĭ!vD%-&0).&$!i()0#&0i!Q[!:#<*#0!a-<(#)*!h&/.&##*.&/!21%&/`.&/!<%&0).&#+?N!Z#.�.&/!a#4$?!jA7S7@76@STk?!)0!s!1t>lbb<`@/54@<&bY0#5bR7]]7@)$>B!u!v)<<#$$#+!AS!D)*@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

h)*(J!<%&$0*-<I%&!

2%&0*%(!H%%5!-&+#*!*#>).*! G*#$$!0%-*!%9!9)<.(.0J!

Page 87: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+!./-MYM:=./+"=T<-FM+D-FTA:M!

“816�ĮPŘďĒ ibid.

“816�ĮPŘďĒ,” op cit.

Page 88: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+!./-MYM:=./+D-FTA:M+#:M-!

L]S[ê�N��ó£ÌûżÝ���Ʀ!v]S[!a-<(#)*!G()&0$!f>#&!0%!01#!G-K(.<!31)0!d%(#zw?N!<(."8L+"8#1+=)0#`v+2"a?!jA7S7@7R@A6k!)0!s!!1t>lbb&#4$@S[Q@<%5bS7b7RA6bSSb[6RRDTfe777SRXhh@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!A7!D)J@!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!YGFS7SSw@!

D#5%*.)(!>()`-#!j->>#*!*./10k!9*%5l!i欧美震惊:中国L地下长城N核力量远超想象!vh-*%>#!$1%<=#+l!21.&)x$!i-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((i!%9!&-<(#)*!>%4#*!9)*!K#J%&+!.5)/.&)I%&w?i!"#.O.&/77S?!jA7SS@7]@AQk?!s!1t>lbb444@(#.I&/77S@<%5b&#4$bA7SS7]bA67RR@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 89: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+!./-MYM:=./+D-FTA:M+#:.AM:<+RF.-<?!

“816�ĮPŘďĒ ibid.

Page 90: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+!./-MYM:=./+D-FTA:M+#:M-!

“816�ĮPŘďĒ ibid.

Page 91: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+!./-MYM:=./+D-FTA:M+#:M-!

Page 92: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+p27+&TB->FGT!

j#&0*)&<#$!c!ST?!<%**.+%*$!c!AS!=5k!

Page 93: Underground Great Wall

Me[5$%";^.92$,2$a,"-'8$

•  2faOh|Ol!LX_#*!01#!LÉ1#&K)%!Y$()&+!.&<.+#&0?!-&+#*!01#!/-.+)&<#!%9!01#!>#%>(#!01#!#&I*#!G)*0J!<%&<(-+#+!01)0!d)*K.&!).*!+#9#&$#!$J$0#5?!)&!.5>%*0)&0!>%$.I%&!Ç5-$0!K#!>*#>)*#+!0%!E/10q!>()<#+!01#!<.0Jx$@N!!

•  LP*%5!ST\7!0%!ST]7?!d)*K.&!<.;.(!).*!+#9#&$#!<%&$0*-<I%&!5%K.(.V#+!01#!5)$$#$!)&+!<%&<#&0*)0#+!%&!K-.(+.&/!)!>#*5)&#&0!5)$=#+!9%*IE<)I%&$?!5%K.(#!#;)<-)I%&!*%)+$!)&+!/*%->$!9%*IE<)I%&$@!O1.$!.&<(-+#+!0#&!&#4!*%)+$!%9!Q\[?[QS!$`-)*#!5#0#*$!Å!)&+!>*%0#<I%&!9%*!01%-$)&+$!%9!9)5.(.#$!.&!01#!-&+#*/*%-&+!0-&&#(!&#04%*=@N!

•  LY&!ST\Q?!0)=.&/!.&0%!)<<%-&0!d)*K.&!)$!)&!.5>%*0)&0!$0*)0#/.<!>%$.I%&!.0!4)$!*#<%/&.V#+!01)0!01#!%*./.&)(!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!01#!$5)((!0*-&=!$.V#!0-&&#(.&/!4)$!$5)((?!>%%*!`-)(.0J?!)&+!<)&!&%0!5##0!01#!#;)<-)I%&!%9!$0)W!)&+!%>#*)I%&)(!5%K.(.0J!&##+$!%9!01#!$.0-)I%&Å@N!

•  LÅ+#<.+#+!0%!K-.(+!-&+#*/*%-&+!#;)<-)I%&!0-&&#($!01*%-/1!01#!<.0J?!<%&&#<I&/!5%-&0).&$!)&+!01#!Ç6!<)&!K#q!()*/#!5%0%*.V#+!*%)+$!>*%�#<0@N!

•  LÅ%&!X-/-$0!S?!ST\Q!j\QF]FSk!KJ!01#!>*%;.&<.)(!)>>*%;)(?!01#!&)5#!Ç\Q]Sq!>*%�#<0@N!•  LX_#*!$.B!J#)*$!%9!<%&I&-%-$!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!01#!K-.(+.&/!0%!<%5>(#0#!01#!>*%�#<0!,!+#>01!%9!

AS!5#0#*$!KJ![!5#0#*$!4.+#!)&+!\@Q!5!%9!*#.&9%*<#+!<%&<*#0#!$0*-<0-*#$!FF!0*-&=!#&/.&##*.&/!SSS@]!01%-$)&+!$`-)*#!5#0#*$?!0*-&=!(#&/01!%9!T@6!=.(%5#0#*$@N!

•  Lq\Q]Sq!>*%�#<0!0%!>)*I<.>)0#!.&!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9![]!-&.0$?!01#!);#*)/#!+).(J!&-5K#*!%9!>#%>(#!.&;%(;#+!.&!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!01#!S@6!5.((.%&!>#%>(#?!4.01!)!0%0)(!.&;#$05#&0!;%(-5#!%9!5%*#!01)&!\A7!5.((.%&!4%*=.&/!5)&F+)J$!0%!K-.(+!)*#)!%9!SS!01%-$)&+!$`-)*#!5#0#*$@N!

S !G*%�#<0!\Q]S!.$!#B0#&$.;#(J!+.$<-$$#+!.&l!Ld)*K.&?!Ç\Q]Sq?!X!M.)&0!'&+#*/*%-&+!3%*=$!FF!'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((?!:->#*FX.*FH).+!:1#(0#*?N!N.;)#<(+"2#MA.8?!jAR!X-/-$0!A77]k!)0!s!1t>lbbK(%/@$.&)@<%5@<&b$bK(%/~6)6Q)9Q67S77)*\4@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!D)*@!A7S7w@!

A !O1#!L6!<)&!K#N!>*%�#<0$!4#*#!+#$./&)0#+!0%!K#!)K(#!0%l!vSw!>*#;#&0!v4)*w?vAw!E/10?!vQw!K#!5%K.(#?!vRw!)K(#!0%!(.;#?!)&+!v6w!<)&!>*%+-<#@N!!

*)()"&)+D)$%W)*+)V%OR$)++5;+!MUF.+*-H-.?-+H:M+"=T<-FM+`FM+

Page 94: Underground Great Wall

84p2+RM:a-TA+FA+SFMU0.+iT:.AZj+

•! LX_#*!$.B!J#)*$!%9!<%&I&-%-$!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!01#!K-.(+.&/!0%!<%5>(#0#!01#!>*%�#<0!,!+#>01!%9!AS!5#0#*$!KJ![!5#0#*$!4.+#!)&+!\@Q!5!%9!*#.&9%*<#+!<%&<*#0#!$0*-<0-*#$!FF!0*-&=!#&/.&##*.&/!SSS@]!01%-$)&+!$`-)*#!5#0#*$?!0*-&=!(#&/01!%9!T@6!=.(%5#0#*$@N!

•! i\Q]Si!>*%�#<0!#&I*#(J!%9!*#.&9%*<#+!<%&<*#0#!$0*-<0-*#?!01#!#&I*#!>*%�#<0!<%&$-5#+!SA?67S!0%&$!$0##(?!A7?6RT!<-K.<!5#0#*$!%9!4%%+?!S77?777!0%&$!%9!<#5#&0?!$)&+!)&+!AR\?777!<-K.<!5#0#*$?!)((!=.&+$!%9!$0%&#!R77!01%-$)&+!<-K.<!5#0#*$?!)!0%0)(!.&;#$05#&0!%9!6Q@7]!5.((.%&!J-)&!j&%0!.&<(-+.&/!()K%*!<%$0$!)&+!$>%*)+.<!0%%(!<%$0$k?!01#!);#*)/#!<%$0!%9!R7R!J-)&!>#*!$`-)*#!5#0#*@!

YK.+@!

Page 95: Underground Great Wall

84p2+RM:a-TA+FA+SFMU0.++iT:.AZj+

Page 96: Underground Great Wall

<&.$P].6T$Me[5$%";^.92$&=U\FQ+D-T:.?AM=TG:.+=?0.Y+2IL>+:H+:M0Y0.F<+A=..-<?+

Screen capture video from: “ Harbin subway line No.1 under construction],” (2008.08.30) at < http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CDhi1EcvviM&feature=related > [accessed 7 June 2010].

Page 97: Underground Great Wall

B;F."8$1&,8S&,'c7$R8F."S";G8F'

1 “31#&!Y!4)$!)!=.+!.&!:1)&/1).?!Y!-$#+!0%!>()J!.&!01%$#!-&+#*/*%-&+!K-&=#*$@@@@!O1#J!)*#!<)((#+!P)&/!o%&/!e%&/?!%*!)&IF).*!1%(#$ÅX($%?!.&!5J!#(#5#&0)*J!$<1%%(?!4#!<%&;#*0#+!>)*0!%9!01#!-&+#*/*%-&+!K-&=#*!.&0%!)!$>%*0$!<%5>(#B!41#*#!5J!$<1%%(x$!*.U#!0#)5!-$#+!0%!>*)<I<#@N!h-*%>#)&!Z-&=#*$!K(%/?!%>!<.0@

2 “Shanghai Constructs Underground Bunker Capable Of Sheltering 200,000 People,” Associated Press, (2006.07.31) at < http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1675268/posts > [accessed 15 April 2010].

?(2"8(2+#(20#-."0',5-')4#2#=200+;)#5"4),8,.5"4#M5":),#-.=FA)W#-2F2MA)#./#0()A'),+"8#$%%G%%%#F).FA)#/,.=#2#"5-A)2,#2>2-:G#2#A.-2A#")D0F2F),#,)F.,')4I#1()#=+AA+."d0L52,)d/..'#-.=FA)W#-."")-'0#'.#0(.FF+"8#-)"'),0G#.e-)#M5+A4+"80G#2F2,'=)"'#M5+A4+"80#2"4#'()#05MD29#090')=#;+2#=+A)0#./#'5"")A0G#'()#?(2"8(2+#K.,"+"8#B.0'#02+4#+"#2"#)W-A50+;)#,)F.,'I#1()#")D0F2F),#02+4#'()#-.=FA)W#(20#D2'),G#)A)-',+-+'9G#A+8(6"8G#;)"6A26."#2"4#F,.')-6;)#4..,0G#2"4#-2"#05FF.,'#A+/)#/.,#20#A."8#20#'D.#D)):0IA#

:1)&/1).q$!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!f^<#!)&&%-&<#+!<%5>(#I%&!%9!01#!<.0Jq$!()*/#$0!$-K0#**)&#)&!K-&=#*l!FF!T7?777!$`-)*#!5#0#*$C!FF!X<<%55%+)0#!A77?777!<.IV#&$C!FF!G*%0#<I%&!9*%5!&-<(#)*!*)+.)I%&?!>%.$%&%-$!/)$!*#(#)$#$?!%*!0#**%*.$0!K()$0$@!

FF!S6!0-&&#($?!#)<1!R?777!5#0#*$?!(.&=!5%*#!01)&!S7!0*)+.&/!<#&0#*$?!%^<#!K-.(+.&/$?!)&+!*#$.+#&I)(!K-.(+.&/$!01*%-/1%-0!<.0J@!!

FF!2%5>(#B!#`-.>>#+!4.01!.0$!%4&!>%4#*!$->>(J?!;#&I()I%&?!)&+!>%4#*!$0%*)/#!<)>)K.(.0J?!41.<1!.$!)K(#!0%!#&$-*#!)!+).(J!-&+#*/*%-&+!$->>(J!9%*!S,A!4##=$@!!

FF!:1#(0#*!.$!<%&&#<0#+!0%!*).(4)J!)&+!4%*(+q$!()*/#$0!$-K4)J@Q!

3 “ 20 ( ),” Shanghai Morning Post, (2006.08.08) at < http://news.xinhuanet.com/politics/2006-07/29/content_4890885.htm > [accessed 30 April 2010, translated by IP-2010.

!?2%5?2-'!94")'Y%&")5)$9%&'U9%J")'U9-+0'0$'(##$33$&20"'/II7III'-%':3")5"%#,'

���!jP)&/!o%&/!e%&/kS!

*)()"&)+D)$%W)*+)V%OR$)++6;+O:/-M.0h0.Y+#0E0<+*-H-.?-+

Page 98: Underground Great Wall

D-,F0M0.Y+l+D-T:.?AM=TG.Y+#0E0<+*-H-.?-+W=..-<?+

ih��ƄŠÒƄôoĄ!v3)0#*>*%%9!>(-//.&/!-&+#*/*%-&+!<.;.(!).*!+#9#&$#!9)<.(.I#$w?i!õōģm3ƎƄô�ĮÝƈ1W?!jA7SSk?!)0!s!1t>lbb�$B(9$@<%5bXK%-0FQQ@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!R!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 99: Underground Great Wall

%V@$1G-6,E$!.b.(;)3.82!23+P,-MFG.Y+&=U\FQ?+FF !X&$1)&!FF !Z#.�.&/!FF !21)&/<1-&!FF !e)(.&!FF !M-)&/V1%-!FF !d%&/!o%&/!FF !a)&�.&/!FF !:1)&/1).!FF !:1#&J)&/!FF !:1#&V1#&!FF !O.)&�.&!FF !3-1)&!

26+!./-M+#:.?AM=TG:.+FF !21#&/+-!FF !d)*K.&!FF !d)&/V1%-!FF !d#9#.!FF !o-&5.&/!FF !")&V1%-!FF !D)<)%!FF !a)&<1)&/!FF !y.&/+)%!FF !:-V1%-!FF !'*--`-.!FF !3#.1).!FF !|.q)&!FF !É1#&/V1%-!FF !É.K%!

24+R<F..-/+&=U\FQ?+FF !21)&/V1%-!D#0*%!FF !e)0%&/!D#0*%!FF !e%&//-)&!D#0*%!FF !P-V1%-!D#0*%!FF !M-.J)&/!D#0*%!FF !r.)B.&/!D#0*%!FF !")&V1%-!D#0*%!FF !a)&&.&/!D#0*%!FF !y-)&V1%-!D#0*%!FF !:1.�.)V1-)&/!D#0*%!FF !O).J-)&!D#0*%!FF !|.)5#&!D#0*%!FF !|-V1%-!D#0*%!

“Workers of the Revolution: Its Time to ride the People’s Subway,” China.net, (2010) at < http://www.subways.net/china/index.htm >; ; “Z-.(+.&/!X!:-K4)J!Y$!T[!G#*<#&0!21#)>#*!Y&!21.&)?N!Y&9*)$0*-<0-*#.$0?!jA77T@7Q@A\k!)0!s!1t>lbb444@.&9*)$0*-<0-*.$0@<%5bA77Tb7QbA\bK-.(+.&/F)F$-K4)JF.$FT[F>#*<#&0F<1#)>#*F.&F<1.&)b!u!see also: “:-K4)J!hƀ?N!<(+"2IB28)?!jA77Tk!)0!s!1t>lbb444@<1.&)>)/#@<%5b*%)+b$-K4)Jb$-K4)J@105(!u!v)((!accessed 8 June 2010].

#B0.Fq?+T:?A+:H+?=U\FQ?+s+v2II+>0<<0:.+,-M+>0<-+E-M?=?+v3Z5+U0<<0:.+,-M+>0<-+0.+"-\+X:ML++

Page 100: Underground Great Wall

D";62&$;:$%V@$V,'($I$V;,F7$F./+F??:T0FA-/+W=..-<?+

L21.&)x$!H%)+?!H).(!)&+!X.*!Y&9*)$0*-<0-*#!H-$1#$!f&?N!Z-.".=+0'G#jA77]@7A@SRk@

$-.YAB+:H+#B0.Fq?+WMF.?,:MA+D:=A-?+i0.+III?+L>j+

Page 101: Underground Great Wall

]G9(.,"$12;",S.$I$V,'($<G88.('8S$

y-%0#!9*%5l!:0%=#$?!<(+"2O0#E5-A)2,#V2,()24#?'.,28)#2"4#_2"4A+"8#?90')=?!%>!<.0l!>>@!Q?!]?!SRFS6C!5)>!9*%5!01#!Y&0#*&)I%&)(!O-&&#((.&/!)&+!'&+#*/*%-&+!:>)<#!X$$%<.)I%&!jYOXk@!

:.0-)0#+!+##>!.&!01#!y.&(.&/!v w!5%-&0).&!*)&/#!)K%-0!SR7!=.(%5#0#*$!4#$0!%9!01#!1.$0%*.<)(!<.0J!%9!|.)&?!)&!.&+#>#&+#&0!%*/)&.V)I%&!=&%4&!)$!01#!AA!Z)$#!.$!*#$>%&$.K(#!9%*!$0%*.&/!)&+!5)&)/.&/!5%$0!%9!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*Jq$!&-<(#)*!4)*1#)+!$0%<=>.(#Å@!

O).K).!D%-&0).&!.$!01#!1./1#$0!>#)=!.&!21.&)?!#)$0!%9!.0$!01*##!4#$0#*&F5%$0!>*%;.&<#$!%9!O.K#0?!y.&/1).?!)&+!|.&�.)&/@!O).K).!D%-&0).&!*#)<1#$!Q\[\!5#0#*$!jSA?Q6]!9##0k!.&!1#./10!)&+!.$!9%*5#+!%9!()*/#!/*)&.0#!*%<=@!G#*1)>$!0%!9)<.(.0)0#!(%/.$I<$?!AB-+R$%+DF0<+#:M,?+0.0GFA-/+T:.?AM=TG:.+:H+F+MF0<+<0.-+T:..-TG.Y+KF:a0+F./+#B-.Y/=+F..=T<-FM+,M:/=TG:.+HFT0<0G-?+.-FM+O0F.QF.Y+0.+AB-+2J7I?@!O1#!Z)%�.F21#&/+-!(.&#!4)$!<%&$.+#*#+!)!5)�%*!9#)0?!&%0!%&(J!K#<)-$#!.0!4)$!21.&)q$!E*$0!#(#<0*.<!*).(?!K-0!+-#!0%!0-&&#($!01)0!$(.<#+!01*%-/1!5%-&0).&$!$%-01!%9!Z)%�.@!f9!5%$0!$./&.E<)&<#!4)$!)!A@Q!=.(%5#0#*!0-&&#(!>)$$.&/!01*%-/1!y.&(.&/!D%-&0).&!)&+!F+?-M0-?+:H+?,0MF<+A=..-<?+a=?A+?:=AB\-?A+:H+KF:a0@!!

X(01%-/1!01#!O).K).!&-<(#)*!4)*1#)+!9)<.(.0J!1)$!#B.$0#+!9%*!R7!J#)*$?!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!#&/.&##*.&/!-&.0$!1);#!K##&!#&/)/#+!.&!)!&)I%&)(!#&/.&##*.&/!>*%�#<0!.&!01#!y.&(.&/!D%-&0).&!*#/.%&!K#04##&!O).K).!)&+!4#$0#*&!9%%01.(($!)+�)<#&0!0%!O.)&$1-.!<.0J!jM)&$-!G*%;.&<#k!%;#*!01#!()$0!S7!0%!S6!J#)*$Å@!

21.&)q$!0-&&#(.&/!0#<1&%(%/J!$.&<#!01#&!1)$!)+;)&<#+!$./&.E<)&0(J?!4.01!<%5>(#I%&!%9!)&!2pZ6+L0<:>-A-M+A=..-<+T=A+01*%-/1!01#!#)$0#*&!#+/#!%9!01#!y.&(.&/!D%-&0).&$!$%-01!%9!|.)&@!

H).(!".&#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!O-&&#(!H).(!".&#!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!O-&&#(!

Page 102: Underground Great Wall

@&'8,$V,'($<G88.('8S$O1#*#!)*#!5%*#!01)&!6N4II!*).(4)J!0-&&#($!4.01!)!0%0)(!(#&/01!%9!3N6II+L>@!

LO-&&#(.&/!.&!21.&)?N!Y&0#*&)I%&)(!O-&&#(.&/!)&+!'&+#*/*%-&+!:>)<#!X$$%<.)I%&?!jSTTTk!)0!s!1t>[email protected])F).0#$@%*/b<5$b.0)F).0#$F1%5#b5#5K#*$F)&+F(.&=$b5#5K#*F&)I%&$b*#()0#+F5#5K#*b+)0-5bbbb9%<-$F%&F<1.&)@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!AT!D)J!A7S7wC!->+)0#$!9*%5l!r.)&!ƒ1)%?!r@!a.<1%()$!:1.*()4?!H)�)&!o*.$1&)&?!O-&&#($!)&+!'&+#*/*%-&+!:0*-<0-*#$l!G*%<##+.&/$!%9!01#!Y&0#*&)I%&)(?!jfB9%*+?!'ol!O)J(%*!g!P*)&<.$?!A777k@!

DF0<\FQ+A=..-<?N+-FTB+<:.Y-M+ABF.+6+L>N+F?+:H+2JJJ+

1999

2000

Page 103: Underground Great Wall

_'8S('8S$<G88.($=,;^'X@&.8SFG$V,'($C'8.$

WKO+ K<F?A+l+K:M-+

LO-&&#(.&/!.&!21.&)?N!%>!<.0C!)&+!r@3@!3)&/?!LO-&&#(.&/!)&+!O#<1&%(%/.<)(!G*%/*#$$!.&!O-&&#(.&/!.&!21.&)?N!.&!r.)&!ƒ1)%?!a.<1%()$!:1.*()4?!)&+!H)�)&!o*.$1&)&!j#+$k?!15"")A0#2"4#T"4),8,.5"4#?',5-'5,)0G#`3.>),42=X#i2A:)=2#B5MA+0(+"8G#$%%%aG#FI#cwI!!

Page 104: Underground Great Wall

Wang J.Y., “Tunneling and Technological Progress in Tunneling in China,” in Tunnels and Underground Structures, op cit: pp. 96-106.

12,S.7$;:$%V@$<G88.('8S$<.9&8;(;SE$DF0<+W=..-<0.Y+)1F>,<-?;+2J66d3III+

OZD!c!O-&&#(!Z%*.&/!D)<1.&#!aXOD!c!a#4!X-$0*.)&!O-&&#(!D#01%+!

Page 105: Underground Great Wall

P],2';8,($[0e$%";^.92T!

L隧道股 ÄÄ/űŔs��ý�ĮĢ�E!vO-&&#(!$1)*#$!F!)+;)&<#+!#`-.>5#&0!)&+!E*$0F<()$$!.&0#*)<I;#!>*%�#<0$ww?!<(+"2)L5+FG#jA77]@7[@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb<1.&)&#)$0@B.&1-)&#0@<%5bV1-)&IbA77]F7[bS[b<%&0#&0~SQ667[]\@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!AR!X>*@!A7S7wC!)&+!Lŷ e ƀŊ�ĢĦäÄĺeƙTŊ�ĪRtX¤Ħä�Ľ'Ş!v21.&)!H).(4)J!5)+#!.0$!%4&!$1.#(+!F!21.&)x$!E*$0!$#(9F+#;#(%>#+!<%5>%$.0#!$1.#(+!%W!01#!)$$#5K(J!(.&#!:.+#(./10$w?N! e ƀ!v21.&)!H).(4)Jw?!jA77]@76@STk?!)0!s!!1t>lbb444@<0/@1)@<&b<0/~+4/V4b*#)+&#4$@)$>z&#4$.+c[T7S!u!v)<<#$$#+!AR!X>*@!A7S7wC!!

21.&#$#!M%;#*&5#&0!.&;#$05#&0!L年国家!][Q项目N!>*%/*)5!)<`-.*#$!4%*(+!<()$$!0-&&#(.&/!0#<1&%(%/J!)&+!$->>%*0$!+%5#$I<!#&0#*>*.$#!+#;#(%>5#&0!%9!+%5#$I<!-&+#*/*%-&+!#B>#*I$#@!

:1)&/1).!})&/0V#!H.;#*!O-&&#(!:1.#(+!Z%*.&/!D)<1.&#!

RV+'(#2#")D#,.5"4#./#05MD29#-."0',5-6."#+"#<(+")0)#-+6)0G#2"4#.'(),#'5"")A#-."0',5-6."#M..=#'()#;+8.,.50#4);)A.F=)"'#./#0(+)A4#'5"")A+"8#=2-(+")0#FA29#2#=2C.,#'20:#./#'()#0F)-+2A#=2-(+"),9#'.#M)-.=)#'()#/.-50#./#4.=)06-#-."0',5-6."#)L5+F=)"'IS#

Page 106: Underground Great Wall

@&'8,$V,'($<G88.('8S$*Fb,89.7$

LO-&&#(.&/!.&!21.&)?N!%>!<.0C!Ly.&/1).FO.K#0!H).(4)J!e).(J!e*).&)/#!n%(-5#!d.0$!a#4!H#<%*+?N!1+M)'n"A+")?!jA77T@SA@Q7k!)0!s!1t>lbb<1.&)IK#0@>#%>(#@<%5@<&b[]6[7RS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SA!r-&#!A7S7wC!)&+!Wang J.Y., “Tunneling and Technological Progress in Tunneling in China,” op cit.!

y.&/1).FO.K#0!H).(4)J!O-&&#(!c!0%0)(!(#&/01!%9![6@Q!=.(%5#0#*$!

:.&<#!01#!ST[7$?!aXOD?!)!&#4!0-&&#(.&/!<%&<#>0!%*!>1.(%$%>1J!9*%5!h-*%>#?!1)$!K##&!)<<#>0#+!KJ!21.&#$#!0-&&#(.&/!#&/.&##*$!K%01!.&!.0$!$>.*.0!)&+!9%*!01#!0#*5!.0$#(9@!aXOD!1)$!K#<%5#!)!>%>-()*!0%>.<!.&!$%5#!$J5>%$.-5$!%*!<%((%`-.-5$!%&!0-&&#(.&/!)&+!-&+#*/*%-&+!4%*=$!1#(+!.&!21.&)@!y-.0#!)!(%0!%9!0-&&#($!-&+#*!+.^<-(0!/#%(%/.<)(!<%&+.I%&$!)&+!.&!4#)=!*%<=!1);#!K##&!$-<<#$$9-((J!<%&$0*-<0#+!KJ!aXOD@!

e)J)%$1)&!H).(!O-&&#(!2%5>(#B!.&0*%+-<.&/!01#!a#4!X-$0*.)&!O-&&#(.&/!D#01%+!jaXODk!

Page 107: Underground Great Wall

B;F."8$%C*$<G88.($@;872"G92';8$隆拉隧道!gF<:.Y+$F+A=..-<+O-/:Y+B0YB\FQN+W0U-A$

ix 隆拉隧道x洞口!vixM)(%&/!")!0-&&#(x!#&0*)&<#w?i!".K#*)I%&!X*5J!e).(J?!jA77T@SA@S6k?!)0!s!1t>lbbIK#0@<&b�.)%0%&/~>+bBV($&�ÑVbJ5K<V11bA7SS7Rb0A7SS7RAA~S77\6QA@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!R!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 108: Underground Great Wall

!gF<:.Y+$F+A=..-<N+O-/:Y+B0YB\FQN+W0U-A$

YK.+C!)&+!i������������������!vO.K#0)&!<%&0*%(!>*%�#<0$!M)(%&/!")!O.K#0!D#+%/!1./14)J!0-&&#(!01*%-/1w?!d-)&`-.?!jA7SSk?!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@>-+-4@%*/b01*#)+F6\[RFSFS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!6!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 109: Underground Great Wall

P@G22'8S$YFS.T$<G88.('8S$

L|.)5#&!|.)&/x)&!O-&&#(?!S$0!-&+#*$#)!0-&&#(!.&!21.&#$#!5).&()&+!E&.$1#+?N!v+2=)"#E)D0?!jA77T@SS@7[k!)0!s!!uC!)&+!L21%&/5.&/!O-&&#(?!:1)&/1).?!21.&)?N!Xh2fD?!jA7S7k!)0!s!1t>lbb444@)#<%5@<%5@)-b31#*#…3#…X*#bX$.)b~<)*%-$#(b21%&/5.&/…O-&&#(?…:1)&/1).?…21.&)!u!!K%01!v)<<#$$#+!SA!r-&#!A7S7w@!!

O1#!21%&/5.&/!H.;#*!2*%$$.&/!<%5>*.$#$!04%!S6@Q!5#0#*$!+.)5#0#*!OZD!0-&&#($?!5)=.&/!.0!01#!<FMY-?A+A=..-<+0.+AB-+\:M</?!<%&&#<0#+!KJ!#./10!<*%$$!>)$$)/#$@!h)<1!0-&&#(!.$!)>>*%B.5)0#(J!\@6!=.(%5#0#*$!(%&/!)&+!(.&=#+!0%!)!S@6!=.(%5#0#*$!)>>*%)<1!*%)+@!O1#!0-&&#(!4.((!K#!)!+%-K(#F+#<=#*#+@!O1#!->>#*!>)*0!4.((!K#!)!01*##!()&#!*%)+?!41.(#!01#!(%4#*!>)*0!4.((!1%-$#!01#!-I(.I#$!)&+!)!(./10!*).(4)J@!X&!.&&%;)I;#!/*%-&+!9*##V.&/!0#<1&.`-#!4.((!K#!-$#+!9%*!<*%$$!>)$$)/#!<%&$0*-<I%&@!2)$0!.*%&!(.&.&/!$#/5#&0$!4.((!*#>()<#!01#![67!5.((.5#0#*$!01.<=!<%&<*#0#!)0!01#!�-&<I%&!K#04##&!01#!K%*#+!0-&&#(!)&+!<*%$$!>)$$)/#@!

X_#*!5%*#!01)&!9%-*!J#)*$q!<%&$0*-<I%&?!|.)5#&!|.)&/q)&!'&+#*$#)!O-&&#(?!01#!kM?A+=./-M?-F+A=..-<+0.+#B0.-?-+>F0.<F./?!4)$!+-/!01*%-/1!%&!f<0@!6?!A77T?!5)*=.&/!)!5.(#$0%&#!.&!21.&)q$!0-&&#(!<%&$0*-<I%&!0#<1&%(%/J!K#04##&!|.)5#&!Y$()&+!)&+!|.)5#&!.&!$%-01#)$0!21.&)x$!P-�.)&!>*%;.&<#@!O1#!>*%�#<0?!41.<1!)+%>0#+!01#!-&+#*$#)!K()$I&/!)&+!-&+#*5.&.&/!5#01%+$!0*);#*$.&/!01#!#)$0#*&!$#)!%9!|.)5#&?!1)$!)!0%0)(!(#&/01!%9!]@[T6!=5!4.01!01#!0-&&#(!(#&/01!)5%-&I&/!0%!6@T6!=5!)&+!\7!5#0#*$!K#(%4!01#!$#)!(#;#(!)0!.0$!+##>#$0!$#<I%&@!

21%&/5.&/!H.;#*!O-&&#(!|.)5#&!'&+#*$#)!O-&&#(!

Page 110: Underground Great Wall

344P'Q$?F'R$#'(#L1?F'!.#K'S$?1'5<0'CK#H0'

3I+*-T->U-M+3II8;+@"0.Y+V0F+*FH-.Y+#:F<+O0.-+K<F?G.Y+#BF>U-MZC!O%0)(!.&;#$05#&0l!67!5.((.%&!J-)&…C!G*%�#<0!>#*.%+l!A77[!,!A77\@!6?677!0%&$!%9!#B>(%$.;#$!#`-)(!$5)((!&-<(#)*!4#)>%&$?!#B>(%$.;#!>%4#*!#`-.;)(#&0!0%!S!b!R!01#!d.*%$1.5)!)0%5.<!K%5K?!O1#!4%*(+x$!()*/#$0!K()$I&/!.&!S\!J#)*$!c!SR!5.((.%&!0%&$!%9!<%)(!K*%-/10!0%!(./10!01#!4%*(+x$!*)*#N+H:M+AB-+kM?A+G>-+H:M+AB-+T0E0<+F0M+/-H-.?-+-.Y0.--M0.Y+?-0?>0T+/FAF+A:+,M:E0/-+U<F?A+M-?0?AF.A@N!

“ [The World's Largest Blasting],” Zhenghun Network, (2009.04.24) at < http://www.lnlt.cn/viewthread.php?tid=26484 > [accessed 7 March 2008, translated by IP-1011.

V.(,2.F$<G88.('8S$Y::;"27+

Page 111: Underground Great Wall

@,"(E(.$D";G)c7$:,'(.F$,22.3)2$2;$,9\G'".$$gG,;8,$a.,bE$Y\G')3.82$B,8G:,92G"."$

R!"#$%%&G#V20(+"8'."dM20)4#F,+;2')d)L5+'9#H,=#<2,A9A)#U,.5F#NIBI#2M2"4.")4#2#FA2"#'.#2-L5+,)#2#-."',.AA+"8#0'2:)#+"#v58."8#U,.5F#M)-250)#+'#/2+A)4#'.#,)-)+;)#2FF,.;2A#/,.=#'()#<(+")0)#8.;),"=)"'I#<2,A9A)#(24#FA2"")4#'.#M59#2#r#&h|#0'2:)#+"#'()#H,=IS#

31)0!#;#*!01#!*#)(!*#)$%&!9%*!01#!9).(#+!+#)(?!.0!.$!&%0!.**#(#;)&0!01)0!01#!|-)%&)!2%*>%*)I%&!>*%+-<#$!5%$0!%9!01#!#B<);)0%*$!-$#+!.&!01#!'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((!G*%�#<0@!

Page 112: Underground Great Wall

#0E0<0F.+!./-MYM:=./+'.HMF?AM=TA=M-+l+W-TB.:<:YQ$%,"2$;:$],2';8,($%;('9E$,8F$B,^;"$B'('2,"E$*77.2$

•  O1#*#!.$!5%*#!<.;.(.)&!0-&&#(.&/!/%.&/!%&!.&!21.&)!01)&!#;#*J41#*#!#($#!.&!01#!4%*(+!<%5K.&#+@!

•  21.&)!.$!K#<%5.&/!01#!(#)+.&/!K-J#*!)&+!)>>(.#*!%9!0-&&#(.&/!0#<1&%(%/J@!•  X!La#4!2#&0-*JN!:0*)0#/Jl!

–  (M:>+)>-MY-.TQ+D-?,:.?-+A:+$:.Y+DF.Y-;+#:.?AM=TG:.+:H+F+"-\+!./-MYM:=./+ogM-FA+`F<<eo!

–  (M:>+o&0.Y<-o+A:+oO=<Gd(=.TG:.o;+'.A-YMFG:.+:H+RM:A-TGE-+).Y0.--M0.Ye!–  (M:>+o&TFu-M-/o+A:+o"-A\:ML-/o;+o"-A\:ML0.Yo+:H+#:>>F./+&Q?A->?e!–  (M:>+#<:?-/+A:+P,-.;+'.TM-F?-/+K-.-kA?+:H+'.A-YMFG.Y+R-FT-G>-+F./+`FMG>-+

(=.TG:.?e!–  (M:>+oD=<-+:H+OF.o+A:+oD=<-+:H+$F\o;+D-Y=<FG:.+K-T:>0.Y+O:M-+&T0-.GkTe!–  (M:>+!./-MYM:=./+A:+AB-+&=MHFT-;+OFMM0FY-+:H+oW\:+*-H-.?-?o+K=0</?+F+

RM:A-TGE-+KFMM0-Me!–  $::L0.Y+A:+W:>:MM:\+HM:>+W:/FQ;+o*0YY0.Y+*--,+W=..-<?o+"-E-M+P=A+:H+*FA-@!

•  2*%$$%;#*!K#04##&!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!0-&&#(.&/!)&+!D.(.0)*J!-&+#*/*%-&+!0#<1&%(%/J!+#;#(%>5#&0!)&+!9%*<#!+#>(%J5#&0@!

"Civil Air Defense Striding Into the New Century,” Jiefangjun Bao Online [Beijing, in Mandarin], (2000.01.08): p.9, at [OSC translation CPP20001108000041: “Jiefangjun Bao Article on China's Achievements in Civil Air Defense;” accessed 8 June 2010].

Page 113: Underground Great Wall

Study #4!

R#3#1%,E()$*+,-,./$*(C+:3.EN+$1(S (]G9(.,"$O,9'('2'.7$

h $*"3E$i%C*j$<G88.('8S$

h $],b,($i%C*]j$<G88.('8S$h $*'"$O;"9.$i%C**Oj$<G88.('8S$

Page 114: Underground Great Wall

C;)$]G"$]G9(.,"$<.72$1'2.$$F./+W=..-<+`FMB-F/+&A:MFY-+iT0MTF+2J73dT=MM-.Aj++

R1()#H,0'#0'.,28)#'5"")A#,)F.,')4A9#D20#-.=FA)')4#+"#\c]gG#'()#02=)#9)2,#20#<(+"2O0#H,0'#"5-A)2,#')0'G#2"4#05M.,4+"2')4#'.#'()#E26."2A#*)/)"0)#?-+)"-)#<.==+00+."#+"#\c]hI#*)-A200+H)4#TI?I#+"')AA+8)"-)#-.==5"+'9#,)F.,6"8#/,.=#\cw\#+"4+-2')0#'(2'#2#-)"',2A#0'.,28)#/2-+A+'9#/.,#D2,()240#D20#A.-2')4#}+"#2#,+48)#2M.5'#\$"=#/,.=#'()#Q.:.#E.,#D)2F."0#/2M,+-26."#-.=FA)WOIS#

Quote from: Mark Stokes, China’s Nuclear Warhead Storage and Handling System, (monograph; Washington, DC: Project 2029 Institute, 12 March 2010): pp. 4, 14, cites source as: Communist China's Weapons Program for Strategic Attack, NIE 13-8-71 (declassified), October 28, 1971. It added that “some of this space is probably used for nuclear weapons inspection and retrofit.” Photo from: d)&$!D@!o*.$0#&$#&?!H%K#*0!:@!a%**.$?!)&+!D)t1#4!M@!D<o.&V.#?!<(+")0)#E5-A)2,#J.,-)0#2"4#TI?I#E5-A)2,#V2,#BA2""+"8?!j3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!PX:!g!aHe2?!a%;#5K#*!A77[kl!>>@!SAQFSA6@!

Page 115: Underground Great Wall

#=MM-.A+$:,+"=M+"=T<-FM+W-?G.Y+l+`FMB-F/+&A:MFY-+

Kristensen,Norris, and McKinzie, Chinese Nuclear Forces and U.S. Nuclear War Planning, op cit.

H./10l!<A.0)d5F0#./#)"',2"-)0#'.#H;)#(.,+j."'2A#'5"")A0#2'#'()#N.F#E5,#')0'#0+')#+"#'()#v+"C+2"8#F,.;+"-)I#<)"'),)4#2'#g\~g$O%\SEG##&&~$\Oh&SZG#'()#02')AA+')#+=28)#,);)2A0#;2,+.50#A);)A0#./#2-6;+6)0#2'#2AA#H;)#)"',2"-)0I#1,5-:0#2,)#;+0+MA)#2'#/.5,#./#'()#H;)#'5"")A#)"',2"-)0G#F2,6-5A2,A9#'()#)20'),"#r#2"4#.")#)"',2"-)#+0#-.;),)4#D+'(#2#,../I#"#_l!O1.$!$)0#((.0#!.5)/#!0)=#&!.&!A776!$1%4$!41)0!)>>#)*$!0%!K#!01#!5%$0!)<I;#!1%*.V%&0)(!0-&&#(!)0!01#!"%>!a-*!0#$0!$.0#@!:#;#*)(!A7F9%%0!j[F5#0#*k!0*-<=$!)*#!;.$.K(#!)5%&/$0!01#!K-.(+.&/$@!31)0!)>>#)*$!0%!K#!01#!+-5>.&/!)*#)!9%*!*%<=!#B<);)0#+!9*%5!01#!0-&&#(!.$!;.$.K(#!.&!01#!(#_!$.+#!%9!01#!.5)/#@!#B<);)0#+!9*%5!01#!0-&&#(!.$!;.$.K(#!.&!01#!(#_!$.+#!%9!01#!.5)/#@!

Page 116: Underground Great Wall

W=..-<+#:>,<-1+FA+"=T<-FM+W-?A+&0A-+

L�������������!vO1#!9%*5#*!&-<(#)*!0#$0!$.0#!.&!21.&)l!|.&�.)&/!D)()&w?N!:.&)?!jA77\@S7@S\k?!)0!s!1t>lbbK(%/@$.&)@<%5@<&b$bK(%/~R<9[<QK[7S777K6\@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!r)&@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!M%%/(#!21*%5#w@!!

Page 117: Underground Great Wall

C'8$%',;c7$%";^.92$0L45$+'=������F(

=>Y%&")5)$9%&'8)"20'Z2++'$.'1?-%2>'-%0")%2+'+2,$90'$.'1?-%2[6'

Y%&")5)$9%&'X9#+"2)'!"#$%&'!0)-J"'1242A-+-0,'<%69)2%#"F'

L��L������N!����!��������������!vH#)(!>.<0-*#$!%9!i'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((!%9!21.&)i!.&0#*&)(!()J%-0!%9!21.&)x$!'&+#*/*%-&+!a-<(#)*!:#<%&+!:0*.=#!2)>)K.(.0J!Y&$-*)&<#w?N!<J&?!jA7SS@7]@A6k?!)0!s!1t>lbb(<@<9]@<%5@<&b&#4$bA7SS7]A6b\\QT?A@$105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S]!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

)V%OR$)++5;+)FM<Q+O0??0<-+(FT0<0AQ_+

Page 118: Underground Great Wall

C'8$%',;c7$%";^.92$0L45$

R$%q?+<FMY-?A+L.:\.+>F.d>F/-+A=..-<+!

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程!vD.(.0)*J!%9!21.&)x$!()*/#$0!5)&F5)+#!<);#l!".&![67S!.$$-#!%9!$#<*#0!>*%�#<0w?N!ŻùƖŸ?!jA7SS@7T@7\k?!s!1t>lbb444@5TQ\@<%5b105(b>1%0%b()%V1)%>.)&bA7SSb7Tb]6TRT7T7Q676]@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S\!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

p !$0)*0#+!KJ!".&!G.)%!.&!ST[6!p !-&+#*/*%-&+!*).(*%)+!(.&=!

4.01!9%-*!0*)<=$!p !\!J#)*$!-&+#*!<%&$0*-<I%&!p !S\!=.(%5#0#*$!%9!0-&&#($!p !Q!()J#*$!p !5).&!/)((#*J!c!SA!B!SA!

5#0#*$!p !A6!()*/#!*%%5$!p !S]!()*/#!<.*<-()*!0)&=$!j9%*!

(.`-.+!9-#(!$0%*)/#zk!p !S\!;#&I()I%&!$1)_$!p !)K)&+%&#+!.&!ST\Q!

Page 119: Underground Great Wall

TN7+$#&)I7"U<2.$#G#)I2."V#$0+"/0%%")("-,&20W" #

Le5Ûw�ŷ6�ûį!林彪的[67S工程!vO1#!()*/#$0!5)&F5)+#!<);#!".&!Z.)%x$![67S!5.(.0)*J!<%&$0*-<I%&w?N!6�@ø?!jA7SS@7T@7\k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@`.)&J)&77S@<%5b(.$1.b<bA7SS7T7\bSQS6Q[[\\T~SS[][Q77@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S\!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 120: Underground Great Wall

C'8$%',;c7$%";^.92$0L45$!uĜś�L eh�ƁmN!

Ld).(#+!)$!01#!Ç-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((!%9!21.&)q@!

Le5Ûw�ŷ6�ûį!林彪的[67S工程?N!%>!<.0@!

P*%5!01#!.&9%*5)I%&!<-**#&0(J!);).()K(#?![67S!G*%�#<0!&)5#!<%5#$!9*%5!01#!2#&0*)(!D.(.0)*J!2%55.$$.%&!E(#!a%@!ST[6?!.$!<-**#&0(J!01#!()*/#$0!=&%4&!5)&F5)+#!5.(.0)*J!-$#!%9!01#!<);#!@!  2);#!<%5>(#B@!O1#*#!)*#!A6!*%%5$?!4.01?!S\!;#&I()I%&!$1)_?!(#&/01!%9!%;#*!S\?777!5#0#*$?!)!()*/#!1%(#!+#$./&#+!0%!>)$$!0*).&$?!1%(#!9%*!0*-<=!0*)^<@!O1#*#!)*#!S]!<.*<-()*!<#5#&0!U%%*?!>-0!01#!%*./.&)(!S]!()*/#!0)&=$@!  [67S!>*%�#<0!Å!1).(#+!)$!01#!i-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((!%9!21.&)@i!  !

}%-!<)&!4)(=!01*%-/1!01#!0*).&!9*%5!9%-*!0*-<=$!0%!#&0#*!01#!>)*)((#(?!01#!4.+01!%9!SA!5#0#*$?!SA!5#0#*$!1./1!.&!01#!<);#?!K-0!)&IFÉ1%&/!d-&)&!".&B.)&/!0%4&!i[67Si!5).&!1%(#@!  !

:.&<#!ST[6!.0!1)$!)!;#*J!$-K0(#!$0)0#!.&!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!]!J#)*$@!h)*(J!ST\Q?!$-++#&(J!)K)&+%&#+?!$I((!&%!%&#!-&+#*$0%%+!.0$!9-&<I%&?!*%(#!)&+!*#)$%&!)*#!)K)&+%&#+@!a%4?!01#!(%<)(!/%;#*&5#&0!1)$!1#*#!)&+!Q!=5!)4)J!O)%(.&!"#)+FÉ.&<!i)*IE<.)(!+#$#*0i!+#;#(%>5#&0!)$!0%-*.$0!$>%0@ !

".&B.)&/!01#!&%*01#*&!/)0#!%9!d-&)&?!.$!-&+#*!01#!�-*.$+.<I%&!%9!}-#J)&/?!9*%5!3-1)&?!21)&/$1)?!*#$>#<I;#(J!S6R!=5!)&+!S[S!=5?!S7\!:0)0#!H%)+!$.+#!$1%>!.&!".&B.)&/!2.0J?!Z#.�.&/FÉ1-1).!hB>*#$$4)J!".&B.)&/!5%-01!+%4&?!6!5.&-0#$!->!-*K)&!)*#)?!%&#!<)((#+!i21)&/i!<*%$$#+!01#!*.;#*!.&!01#!<.0J@![67S!h&/.&##*.&/!".&B.)&/!<.0J!)K%-0!S6!=.(%5#0#*$!)4)J!9*%5@!  !

Z()<=!1%(#!/)-V#!<%;#*!&#)*(J!1)(9!)!1%(#?!)$!01#!>*%�#<0!1)$!$%!9)*!&%0!9-((J!+#<*J>0#+@!P*%5!01#!.&9%*5)I%&!<-**#&0(J!);).()K(#?![67S!4%*=$!9*%5!01#!2#&0*)(!D.(.0)*J!2%55.$$.%&!.&!ST[6!&)5#+!01#!E*$0!+%<-5#&0?!.$!<-**#&0(J!01#!()*/#$0!=&%4&!5.(.0)*J!-$#!%9!5)&F5)+#!<);#$@!Y0!.$!01#!->>#*?!5.++(#!)&+!(%4#*!()J#*$@!O1#!#&I*#!5%-&0).&!1)$!K##&!1%((%4#+!%-0?!<%&&#<0#+!->!)&+!+%4&?!1%(#!<%&&#<0#+!0%!01%$#!#)*(J!1%(#?!$-<1!)$!K*#)=!5)V#?!()*/#!$<)(#!*)*#(J!$##&!.&!01#!%-0$.+#!4%*(+@!  !

d-/#!/*)&.0#!$0*-<0-*#!4)$!1%((%4#+!%-0!5%-&0).&?!5)+#!ÜÜ%9!*#.&9%*<#+!<%&<*#0#!->!)&+!+%4&!01*##?!<%(+!)&+!1-5.+?!01#!0#5>#*)0-*#!)K%-0!S]!+#/*##$!2#($.-$!J#)*!*%-&+@!  :-*>*.$.&/(J?!01#![67S!>*%�#<0!.&!)++.I%&!0%!S\!=.(%5#0#*$!%9!)*IE<.)(!<);#$?!K-0!)($%!01#!+.$0*.K-I%&!%9!01#!A6!*%%5$!%9!;)*.%-$!$.V#$!1)((?!()*/#!*%%5!0%!1-&+*#+$!%9!$`-)*#!5#0#*$?!)&+!S\!()*/#!1./1F4.+#!5.$$.(#F$1)>#+!<);#@!

Page 121: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$0L45+

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程?N!%>!<.0@#

XZfnhl!:#<-*#!#&0*)&<#!0%!01#!;)((#JC!!HYMdOl!O-&&#(!/-)*+!0%4#*C!Zh"f3l!D).&!*%)+@!Zh"f3l!X-B.(.)*J!#B.0@!

Page 122: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$0L45+W:AF<+s+2I+).AMF.T-?+H:M+DF0<+F./+WM=TL?Z+

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程!vD.(.0)*J!%9!21.&)x$!()*/#$0!5)&F5)+#!<);#l!".&!G.)%q$![67S!.$$-#!%9!$#<*#0!>*%�#<0w?N!E)'#Z20)#`MA.8aG#jA7SS@7T@7[k?!)0!s!1t>lbbB`J]]@K(%/@S[Q@<%5bK(%/b$0)I<b[6A[QTT[A7SS][]66QQQRAb!u!v)<<#$$#+!S\!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSwC!)&+!i神秘的[67S�Įƥ e6�U�ÛwĢĎ��Į!vDJ$0#*.%-$![67S!G*%�#<0l!21.&)x$!K.//#$0!-&E&.$1#+!>*%�#<0$!%9!5.(.0)*J!1.$0%*Jmw?i!Jrşj?!jA77]@7[@S]k?!)0!s!!1t>lbbKK$@;%<@<%5@<&b)*<1.;#*bI+FS6Q[77\@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@#

HYMdOl!D).&!#&0*)&<#C!"hPOl!f01#*!#B.0$@!

Page 123: Underground Great Wall

%";^.92$0L45+W:AF<+s+2I+).AMF.T-?+H:M+DF0<+F./+WM=TL?Z+

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程?N!%>!<.0@C!)&+!9%*!+#0).($!%&!*).(!(.&=$?!$##l!i代号x[67SxN!v2%+#!x[67Sw?i!H#+&#0?!jA77[@7\@S]k?!)0!s!1t>lbb1&@*#+&#0@<&b<bA77[b7]b76bS7SQ]A7@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@#

"hPOl!H).(!(.&#!9*%5!".&B.)&/!2.0JC!HYMdOl!H).(*%)+!h&0*)&<#!j0*)<=$!*#5%;#+k@!!

Page 124: Underground Great Wall

$0.+R0F:q?+&-TM-A+RM:a-TA+76I2!

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程?N!%>!<.0@!

Page 125: Underground Great Wall

L���������������[67S ?N!%>!<.0@!'>>#*!(#_!>1%0%!9*%5l!iv��w������������[67S !ve#$#*;.&/!0%!K#!(%%=#+!)_#*?!".&B.)&/!O)%(.&![67S!:#<*#0!2);#w?i!1+)W5)I")'?!jA77T@7\@S\k?!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@I#B-#@&#0b>%$0A~Q\SQ6]\~S@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S]!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

$0.+R0F:q?+&-TM-A+RM:a-TA+76I2+

Page 126: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+76I2+

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程?N!%>!<.0@!

*-?TM0U-/+F?+O0??0<-+KFQ+ P.-+:H+-0YBA--.+pI+>-A-M+B0YB+@&0<:?C+

&0<:+H:M+AF.L+?A:MFY-++:H+$0]=0/+(=-<_+

Page 127: Underground Great Wall

RM:a-TA+76I2+

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程?N!%>!<.0@!

Page 128: Underground Great Wall

+!.T:>,<-A-/+,FMA?+:H+RM:a-TA+76I2!

L eÛw�ŷ6�ûįƥå¬ķR[67S秘密工程?N!%>!<.0C!)&+!L神秘的[67S工程F eÛw6�Ď��Į!vDJ$0#*.%-$![67S!>*%�#<0!F!21.&)x$!()*/#$0!5.(.0)*J!-&E&.$1#+!>*%�#<0$!w?i!Z).+-?!jA77]@7S@QSk?!)0!s!1t>lbb1.@K).+-@<%5b#6A6TbK(%/b.0#5b)TT6RS9Q[TS9S#<97KR[#7SA@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 129: Underground Great Wall

+!.T:>,<-A-/+,FMA?+:H+RM:a-TA+76I2!

L��q������q!����!��������������!vH#)(!>.<0-*#$!%9!i'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((!%9!21.&)i!.&0#*&)(!()&+$<)>#!%9!21.&)x$!'&+#*/*%-&+!a-<(#)*!:#<%&+!:0*.=#!2)>)K.(.0J!Y&$-*)&<#w?N!<J&?!jA7SS@7]@A6k?!)0!s!1t>lbb(<@<9]@<%5@<&b&#4$bA7SS7]A6b\\QT?A@$105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S]!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 130: Underground Great Wall

X*5J!O-&&#(.&/!

Page 131: Underground Great Wall

Video screen shots from: @ C!jBeijing, PRC: Civil Defense Film, 2000), [accessed 1 Mar. 2010].

%C*$F.)(;E3.82$;:$*"3E$G8'27$'8$G8F."S";G8F$9;3)(.Z$$FA-+2J7I?w-FM<Q+2J8I?!

'&.0!#`-.>5#&0!$#0$!*#)+J!9%*!*)>.+!+#>(%J5#&0! O-&&#(!K)$#+!5%0%*!>%%(!

'&+#*/*%-&+!0*%%>$!5%;#5#&0!01*-!0-&&#(!<%5>(#B! G*%0#<0#+!)55-&.I%&!)&+!$->>(J!+#>%0$!

Page 132: Underground Great Wall

")0#!ST[7$!G"X!2*#)0#+!:#*.#$!%9!")*/#!!

Page 133: Underground Great Wall

%C*$IT.-#'1#5('1.,%-+(1/$$+3'U(((

Y((-$0*)I%&!9*%5l!i vG*%0#<I%&!G*%�#<0!)0!d%5#!)&+!XK*%)+!)&+!:0*)0#/.<!O1.&=.&/w?i!?(.D<(+"2?!jA77T@7Q@7[k?!)0!s!11t>lbb444@$1%4<1.&)@%*/bV/�K`=B(bV(41J�$V<bA77T7Qb0A\R[[6@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Z-.(0!.&!*#)<I%&!0%!01*#)0!%9!:%;.#0!&-<(#)*!>*##5>I%&!!

Page 134: Underground Great Wall

%C*$@;,72,($!.:.87.$V.S'3.82$

if>#*)I%&!H)>.+!H#$>%&$#i!:0)/#+!%&!}#((%4!:#)!Y$()&+$?N!<<1mdw!vZ#.�.&/!.&!D)&+)*.&w?!jA77T@SA@7\k?!)0!vf:2!PhXA7S77AS[77S6STl!Leneb3#K!G*%+-<0l!GH2!D.(.0)*J!X<I;.I#$!.&!e#<!7TCN!)<<#$$#+!A\!a%;@!A7S7w@!!

O:/-M.+M-AMFTAFU<-+FMG<<-MQ+U=.L-M+0.+0?<F./+A=..-<+T:>,<-1++

Page 135: Underground Great Wall

<G88.('8S$:;"$@;,72,($!.:.87.$i9'"9,$5NLLX5NMLj!-1F>,<-+:H+Z?-0"'<6+2%&'

P%*IE<)I%&!%9!2%)$0)(!>%$.I%&$!K#/)&!.&!01#!ST67$C!

e#<@!ST[\!ƒ1%-!h&().!>#*$%&)((J!/);#!%*+#*!9%*!L&-<(#)*!1)*+#&.&/CN!

S7!J#)*$!%9!<%&$0*-<I%&?!6?777!4%*=#*$C!

d./1!*.$=!,!L)(5%$0!#;#*J!5#0#*!#B<);)I%&?!01#!$)<*.E<#!%9!)!$%(+.#*!%*!<.;.(.)&Å!Q7!=.((#+!)&+!1-&+*#+$!.&�-*#+ÅN!

677!5#0#*!#&0*)&<#!1)((?!01#&!%>#&$!->!.&0%!-&+#*/*%-&+!&);)(!K)$#!A\!5#0#*$!1./1!KJ!\7!5#0#*$!4.+#?!#B.0!0-&&#(C!

S7!()0#*)(!0-&&#($!677!5#0#*$!(%&/C!Q7?777!$`-)*#!5#0#*$!.&$.+#C!Y&<(-+#+!L5.$$.(#!*#$#*;#!K)&=N!)&+!L!

5.$$.(#!1)&+(.&/!$0%*)/#CN!2)&!1%(+!)&+!*#>).*!5%*#!01)&!A7!K%)0$!

->!0%!A?SR7!0%&$C!:#)(#+!)&+!$#(9F<%&0).&#+!$0%*)/#!9%*!

S777!0%&$!%.(?!Q77!0%&$!9*#$1!4)0#*?!)&+!SR7!K(%<=$!%9!K)**)<=$@!

L�����j�k!vƒ1-=).!31.#!"#=!Y$()&+w?N!!h\w]]I-.=G#A77[@7[@AQk!)0!s!1t>lbb444@6S\[[@<%5bV1.&)&bSS77SbSS77S]T\]A@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!\!r-&#!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 136: Underground Great Wall

Z?-0"'<6+2%&'@;,72,($!.:.87.++

L�����j�?N!%>!<.0@!

Page 137: Underground Great Wall

@;,72,($O;"2'k'9,2';87$

“wÔþ6nh!vO1#!M*#)0!3%&+#*!a);)(!Z)$#w?N!_."84.5I8W")D0G#jA77[@7R@SAk!)0!s!1t>lbb1%&/+%-@/B&#4$@<%5@<&b;.#401*#)+FR6AAR76FS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!6!r-(J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSwC!L\[式の原型である[[式SQ755海岸炮!vD%+#(!\[!04.&!SQ755!2%)$0)(!e#9#&$#!M-&$w?N!日本周辺国の軍事兵器N+i3IIpZI7Z35j+FA+x+Bu,;ww\0L0Z<0E-/::MZa,w.F>FTBF3w/wyK5y#(yK%y*#y#Ky%5y%2y#%y#4y)7yKJy(2y%2y#K+z+{FTT-??-/+4+c=<Q+3I2I|Z

Page 138: Underground Great Wall

http://www.15630.com/haidao/zhhaidao/bl/200704/1741.html

@;,72,($O;"2'k'9,2';87$

Page 139: Underground Great Wall

@;,72,($O;"2'k'9,2';87$

L������!vO1#!M*#)0!3%&+#*!a);)(!Z)$#w?N!_."84.5I8W")D0G#jA77[@7R@SAk!)0!s!1t>lbb1%&/+%-@/B&#4$@<%5@<&b;.#401*#)+FR6AAR76FS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!6!r-(J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSwC!L\[ [[ SQ755 !vD%+#(!\[!04.&!SQ755!2%)$0)(!e#9#&$#!M-&$w?N!

?!jA77]@7[@ARk!)0!s!1t>lbb4.=.@(.;#+%%*@�>b&)5)<1)Ab+b8ZR82P8ZX8e282Z8XR8XS82X82Q8h[8ZT8PS8XS82Z!u!v)<<#$$#+!Q!r-(J!A7S7w@!

Page 140: Underground Great Wall

Z?-0"'<6+2%&'#:F?AF<+*-H-.?-+!

L������l!���������!!vƒ1-1).!31.0#!"#=!Y$()&+!O%-*l!D.(.0)*J!P)<.(.I#$w?N!!?.8.5G#`A77\@SS@A]k!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@$%/%-@<%5bS7T6[[ba:`6.$6->|%PZXXXX@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!\!r-&#!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 141: Underground Great Wall

V#%$--+P"/%$-(1G-$=,7.$

O.5!Z*%4&?!Lf;#*1#)+!g!'&+#*/*%-&+?N!(#<0-*#?!O#<1&%(%/J!g!:#<-*.0J?!M#%*/#0%4&!'&.;#*$.0J?!jQ7!a%;@!A776?!->+)0#+!A7!D)J!A7S7k@!

Page 142: Underground Great Wall

V#%$--+P"/%$-(1G-$=,7.$5NM47$2;$%".7.82$

O).(.&/$!-$#+!)$!E((!

2%W#*!+)5!O-&&#(!+./! e%<=!)&+!K)$#!

O-&&#(!!#&0*)&<#!

H#$.+-)(!+*.((?!#B.0!

O-&&#(!!#&0*)&<#!

O.5!Z*%4&?!Lf;#*1#)+!g!'&+#*/*%-&+?N!(#<0-*#?!O#<1&%(%/J!g!:#<-*.0J?!M#%*/#0%4&!'&.;#*$.0J?!jQ7!a%;@!A776?!->+)0#+!A7!D)J!A7S7k@!

Page 143: Underground Great Wall

R8F."S";G8F$1G-$=,7.j>*%K)K(J!Y+2"88)j(52"8 ,!1%5#!%9!)((!d)&F<()$$!OJ>#F7TSk!!

Kristensen,Norris, and McKinzie, Chinese Nuclear Forces and U.S. Nuclear War Planning, op cit.

Page 144: Underground Great Wall

1G-3,"'8.$C,G89&.F$=,(('72'9$B'77'(.7$$?A:M-/+F./+>F0.AF0.-/+=./-MYM:=./+\0AB+M-<:F/?+H:M+&=U?+

c$d2+

c$d3+

G1%0%!9*%5l!Lr"FA!j2::Fa|FR!:"ZD!r.&!2()$$!::Za!a-<(#)*!e#0#**#&0!D.$$.(#!:J$0#5?N!U)"),2A#i.5=2#MA.8G#`$%!

O'D9_+

Page 145: Underground Great Wall

A/3#$(R8F."S";G8F$1G-$=,7.!d).&)&!Y$()&+!

f*./.&)((J!+.$<%;#*#+!KJ!O.5!Z*%4&?!$##l!LM%%/(#!h)*01!.5)/#*J!*#;#)($!#&0*)&<#!0%!21.&)!$-K!0-&&#(?N!V.,A4#1,+M5')?!jA77[@7]@7\k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@4%*(+0*.K-&#@<%5b4%*(+0*.K-&#b7[b9*%&0AR6QT66@7\T][SSSS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!\!a%;@!A77Tw@!

R1()#'5"")A#+0#.")#./#\%#05-(#05M=2,+")#'5"")A0#<(+"2#(20#M5+A'#'.#2;.+4#4)')-6."#2"4#2>2-:#/.,#+'0#05M=2,+")#/.,-)0IS#

Page 146: Underground Great Wall

=<6'0?")"'2'X9#+"2)'Z"24$%6'!0$)25"'!-0"'$%'\2-%2%'<6+2%&BF'

y-%0#$!)&+!.5)/#$!9*%5l!d)&$!o*.$0#&$#&?!Lh$I5)0#+!a-<(#)*!3#)>%&$!"%<)I%&$l!A77T?N!J7?#?',2')8+-#?)-5,+'9#iA.8G!jA77T@SS@A\k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@9)$@%*/bK(%/b$$>bA77TbSSb(%<)I%&$@>1>!u!v)<<#$$#+!R!r-&#!A7SSw@!

RV(),)#4.)0#<(+"2#0'.,)#"5-A)2,#D2,()240#/.,#+'0#M2AA+06-#=+00+A)#05M=2,+")0k##1()#"2;2A#M20)#")2,#Y5A+"#."#_2+"2"#!0A2"4#(20#)W')"0+;)#5"4),8,.5"4#/2-+A+6)0I##7"#2A'),"26;)#'.#'()#M20)#+'0)A/#-.5A4#F.')"62AA9#M)#2#/2-+A+'9#)A0)D(),)#."#'()#+0A2"4G#05-(#20#J.A5.#7+,#i20)#D(),)#-."0',5-6."#./#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#/2-+A+'9#M)82"#H;)#9)2,0#M)/.,)#'()#H,0'#??iE#2,,+;)4#2'#_2+"2"I#n,#2,)#'()#D)2F."0#0'.,)4#."#'()#=2+"A2"4kS#

Page 147: Underground Great Wall

%C**O$R8F."S";G8F$a,8S."$@;872"G92';8$j<.*<)!ST[7$k!

Page 148: Underground Great Wall

%C**O$B;G82,'8$a,8S."$(:M>-M+&BFB-+%0MUF?-+

a%4!)!5-$#-5?!#)$0!>%*0)(!%9!5%-&0).&!1)&/#*!9%*!9%*5#*!:1)1#!X.*K)$#!E/10#*$!%-0$.+#!%9!Z#.�.&/@!L21.&)!X;.)I%&!D-$#-5!F!d)&/)*!h&0*)&<#?N!B2".,2=+.G#jA77T@7S!ASk?!)0!1t>lbb$0)I<@>)&%*)5.%@<%5b>1%0%$b%*./.&)(bS]7[]76\@�>/!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!e#<@!A7S7w@!Z()$0!>*%0#<I%&!+%%*$!*#>()<#+@!

Page 149: Underground Great Wall

%C**O$B;G82,'8$a,8S."!

L21.&)!X;.)I%&!D-$#-5!F!d)&/)*!h&0*)&<#?N!%>!<.0@!

%C**O$B;G82,'8$a,8S."

L21.&)!X;.)I%&!D-$#-5!F!d)&/)*!h&0*)&<#?N!%>!<.0@!

%C**O$B;G82,'8$a,8S."%C**O$B;G82,'8$a,8S."%C**O$B;G82,'8$a,8S."%C**O$B;G82,'8$a,8S."

`-?A+).AMF.T-+

#=ME-/+'.A-M0:M+

*M0E-dABM=+W=..-<+

6L>+U-A\--.+KF?-+F./

+!./

-MYM:=

./+SF.Y-M+

Page 150: Underground Great Wall

%C**O$IR.*+3(.<(;#,(W.,5+('1%1#.$U(������(

Y((-$0*)I%&!9*%5l!i vG*%0#<I%&!G*%�#<0!)0!d%5#!)&+!XK*%)+!)&+!:0*)0#/.<!O1.&=.&/w?i!?(.D<(+"2?!jA77T@7Q@7[k?!)0!s!11t>lbb444@$1%4<1.&)@%*/bV/�K`=B(bV(41J�$V<bA77T7Qb0A\R[[6@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

hB)5>(#!%9!O-&&#(!Z)$#+!X.*<*)_!:1#(0#*!

Page 151: Underground Great Wall

!"#<+$-(*'"$=,7.$$T??1%'S.?F.K$#'

!"$?#GH'U$%H0'?;@K1#%'"#%>1?1>';?>1%F%.;?>'#$%@%#L0'"#?F1%'

2B7V78'

“����” cited as PLAAF’s “first excavated underground hanger” at “����—— ������������“51” [New airport — Asia's largest military airport, China's "area 51”],” Overview of China's Super Projects, (2008.10.,24) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0187/ > [accessed 15 Jan. 2010, translated by P-1011).

O-&&#(!S=5!9*%5!*-&4)JC!O4%!1)*+#&#+!#&0*)&<#$!!!!!!!9)<.&/!%>>%$.0#!+.*#<I%&$C!".&=#+!KJ!-&+#*/*%-&+!!!!!!!!!!!>)$$F01*-!)&+!1)&/#*$C!"#&/01!c!\77!5#0#*$C!H#>%*0#+!).*<*)_!$0%*)/#!!!!!!!!!!!c!]7!rF\$!E/10#*$@!

a%*01!#&0*)&<#!

:%-01!#&0*)&<#!

*=F<+M:F/?+

W=..-<+

Page 152: Underground Great Wall

TM1%.(*'"$=,7.$2W#?H;'O%.X$?@18'$

J M'YZ0#.'+$%'C#H1'@ited with “underground hanger” at “����—— ������������“51” [New airport — Asia's largest military airport, China's "area 51”],” op cit; map from: “C^2,;$Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0125/ > [accessed 15 June 2010].

:0)&+)*+!).*K)$#!>)t#*&!K-0!4.01!1)*+#&#+!$1#(0#*!%*!0-&&#(!#&0*)&<#!K)<=#+!.&0%!#)*01!!j#&0*J!4)J!0%!-&+#*/*%-&+!<%5>(#Bzk!)0!#&+!%9!F+AM--+<0.-/+T:=.AMQ+M:F/+2Z3L>+HM:>+UF?-Z+d)*+!0%!E&+!#B<#>0!9%*!E/10#*!>)*=#+!%-0$.+#@!

d)*+#&#+!$1#(0#*b!0-&&#(!#&0*)&<#!K-.(0!.&0%!5%-&0).&!

Page 153: Underground Great Wall

X"%$-E+(1;G2&.,72$*'"$=,7.$2W#?H;'O%.X$?@18'$

J��N!["#?F\1'+$%'C#H1'@ited with “underground hanger” at “����—— ������������“51” [New airport — Asia's largest military airport, China's "area 51”],” op cit; map from: “Zhangye Southeast Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0143/ > [accessed 15 June 2010].

'&+#*/*%-&+!).*<*)_!$0%*)/#!.&!$.+#!%9!5%-&0).&!4.01!1)*+#&#+!9)<#!)&+!1#);J!K()$0!+%%*$C!K-0!&%!)>>)*#&0!K)<=!+%%*!

e-)(!%WF$#0!*-&4)J$!

f;#*()>>.&/!<#&0#*!)>*%&$!

Page 154: Underground Great Wall

]-%56?9-'*'"$=,7.$2W#?H;'O%.X$?@18'$H#<#&0!).*!K)$#!!<%&$0*-<I%&!4.01!&#)*(J!.+#&I<)(!+-)(!G)$$F01*-!$1#(0#*$!)0!3#$0!)&+!h)$0!#&+$!%9!y.&/$1-.!X.*!Z)$#@!h)<1!$1#(0#*!<%5>(#B!1)$!&#)*KJ!1)*+$0)&+!)&+!(%%>!)<<#$$@!":A-+M-<FGE-+?0h-+:H+kYBA-MZ+

J N!D$?FH";$'Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0143/ > [accessed 15 June 2010]; and JQT@66R\AA?T]@]]RS[\N!W..FK1'S#]H&'234B48'#0'^"00]_``/#]HAF..FK1A@./`/#]HaKKbc7A55dP33&7eAeedBVP-H]?b4A4c&4A4c-0b"-:b'c7A55dP33&7eAeedBVP''f'g#@@1HH1>'BB'S#\'34B4].

3#$0!Z-&=#*!2%5>(#B! h)$0!Z-&=#*!2%5>(#B!

Page 155: Underground Great Wall

]-%56?9-'*'"$=,7.$2@.?0A8'$

H#<#&0(J!<%&$0*-<0#+!04%!.+#&I<)(![77_!G)$$F01*-!$1#(0#*$!)0!y.&/$1-.!X.*!Z)$#!4.01!K()$0!+%%*$!)&+!%;#*1#)+!<%;#*@!a%0#!U=<</:h-M+AMFTL?+F//0.Y+-FMAB+T:E-M+)&+!M-<FGE-+?0h-+:H+kYBA-M@!

3#$0!Z-&=#*!2%5>(#B!h)$0!Z-&=#*!2%5>(#B!

Page 156: Underground Great Wall

J N!h%;/:$',.;0"'Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0132// > [accessed 15 June 2010]; and J��N!["#?F\1'+$%'C#H1'@ited with “caves built into hills” at “����—— ������������“51” [New airport — Asia's largest military airport, China's "area 51”],” op cit; map from: “Zhangye Southeast Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0143/ > [accessed 15 June 2010].

Y)93N-'&:=AB+*'"$=,7.$2R$?Z$#?F'+*8'$

D).&!%>#*)I&/!K)$#!

Q=5!(%&/!>-K(.<!)<<#$$!>);#+!*%)+!9%*!).*<*)_!5%;#5#&0!

O%4&!g!.&+-$0*.)(!<#&0#*!

3#$0F#&+!0-&&#(!<%5>(#B!4.01!1)*+#&#+!+%%*$!9%*!).*<*)_!)<<#$$!

G);#+!L*%)+!0%!&%41#*#lN!<%5.&/!%-0!%9!h)$0F#&+!0-&&#(@!

Page 157: Underground Great Wall

Y)93N-'&:=AB+*'"$=,7.$2@.?0A8'$

'&.`-#!<%5K.&)I%&!%9!3#$0!#&0*)&<#!9%*!).*<*)_!)&+!h)$0!#&0*)&<#!9%*!0#$0!)&+!5).&0#&)&<#!9)<.(.I#$!4.01!>);#+!L*%)+!0%!&%41#*#@N!G*#$-5)K(J!01#!04%!9)<.(.I#$!)*#!(.&=#+!KJ!%&#!%9!01#!(%&/#$0!).*K)$#!0-&&#($!.&!01#!G"XXP!)0!%;#*!]?777_!.&!(#&/01@!

L*%)+!0%!&%41#*#@N!G*#$-5)K(J!01#!04%!

(%&/#$0!).*K)$#!0-&&#($!.&!01#!G"XXP!)0!

h)$0F#&+!2%5>(#B!

3#$0F#&+!2%5>(#B!

O-&&#(!!!0).(.&/$!

h)$0!:#*;.<#!X<<#$$!3#$0!!

X.*<*)_!!h&0*)&<#!

:#<%&+)*J!Z-&=#*!

Page 158: Underground Great Wall

8#%$'"/#(*'"$=,7.$2W#?H;'O%.X$?@18'$

J M')$#?H";$'+$%'C#H1'@ited with “underground hanger” at “����—— ������������“51” [New airport — Asia's largest military airport, China's "area 51”],” op cit; map from: “)$#?H";$'Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0130/ > [accessed 15 June 2010].

G)$$F01*-!<%;#*#+!1)*+#&#+!$1#(0#*!677_!(%&/?!4.01!K()$0!+%%*$C!(%<)0#+!.&!)&!.&+-$0*.)(!)*#)?!)<*%$$!5)�%*!1./14)J!)0!#&+!%9!F+AM--+<0.-/+?AM--A+2NIII[+HM:>+M=.F\FQZ+!

a%*01!#&0*)&<#!

:%-01!#&0*)&<#!

Page 159: Underground Great Wall

2/D+#(*'"$=,7.$:;((;67$X"%$-E+(B;F.($2;?>1%'@.?H0%;@0$.?&'>#01';?<?.i?8'$

J M'N;i1$'+$%'C#H1'@ited with “underground hanger” at “����—— ������������“51” [New airport — Asia's largest military airport, China's "area 51”],” op cit; overhead imagery from: “Wuwei Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0136/ > [accessed 15 June 2010].

! ! ! !X.*<*)_!*)5>!! !d#);J!K()$0!+%%*$!

'&+#*/*%-&+!).*<*)_!%*!4)*1#)+!$0%*)/#z!

! ! ! !! !d#);J!K()$0!+%%*$!! ! ! !

d#);J!K()$0!+%%*$!! ! ! !

d#);J!K()$0!+%%*$!X.*<*)_!*)5>!

e-)(!fWF$#0!H-&4)J$! LrF<-*;#N!H)5>!g!h&0*J!e#$./&!

Page 160: Underground Great Wall

A#$5"/%$(*'"$=,7.$$"0.Y10F+%D+

iU=0<A+T0MTF+2JpI?j+9FM0-AQ+:H+W=..-<?+l++

!./-MYM:=./+#:>,<-1-?+

L}.&<1-)&!3#$0!X.*!Z)$#!:->#*F1)*+#&#+!'&+#*/*%-&+!Z-&=#*$?N!m+,'52A#UA.M)',.�"8G!jA7SSk?!)0!s!1t>lbb;.*0-)(/(%K#0*%‡&/@<%5b5)>bJ.&<1-)&F4#$0F).*FK)$#F$->#*F1)*+#&#+F-&+#*/*%-&+FK-&=#*$b;.#4bz$#*;.<#c7!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!:#>0@!A7SSw@!!

OF0.+KF?-+

!./-MYM:=./+%0MTMF[+SF.Y-M+

#:>,<-1+

(FT0<0G-?+\0AB+S0<<?0/-+W=..-<?++

`FMB-F/+&A:MFY-+K=.L-M?+

Page 161: Underground Great Wall

A#$5"/%$(*'"$=,7.'

O.5!Z*%4&?!Lf;#*1#)+!g!'&+#*/*%-&+?N!(#<0-*#?!O#<1&%(%/J!g!:#<-*.0J?!M#%*/#0%4&!'&.;#*$.0J?!jQ7!a%;@!A776?!->+)0#+!A7!D)J!A7S7kC!L}.&<1-)&!3#$0!X.*!Z)$#!$->#*F1)*+#&#+!-&+#*/*%-&+!K-&=#*$?N!m+,'52A#UA.M',.�"8?!jA77]@7S@AQk!)!s!1t>lbb;.*0-)(/(%K#0*%‡&/@<%5b5)>bJ.&<1-)&F4#$0F).*FK)$#F$->#*F1)*+#&#+F-&+#*/*%-&+FK-&=#*$b!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!r-&#!A7S7w@!

*M0E-dABM=+

S-<0T:,A-M?+

S}+U</Z+

R-M?:..-<+A=..-<+

":MAB+W=..-<?+

&:=AB+W=..-<?+

Page 162: Underground Great Wall

^-%#?92%'%0M+KF?-+j<%&0@k!

Photo of J-8Is entering tunnel from: Carlo Kopp, “PLAAF and PLAN Legacy Fighters,” (Technical Report APA-TR-2007-0104; Canberra, AUS: Air Power Australia, Jan. 2007) at < http://www.ausairpower.net/APA-PLA-Fighters.html > [accessed 10 Jan. 2010].

":MAB+W=..-<?!

Page 163: Underground Great Wall

19&.3,2'9$;:$@&'8.7.$!.7'S8.F$R8F."S";G8F$*'"-,7.$?0>0<FM+A:+^-%#?92%'%0M+KF?-++$

L'&+#*/*%-&+!H-&4)J$!)&+!d)&/)*!P)<.(.0J?N!B2:+0'2"#*)/)"-)#P%*-5?!jA7SS@7]@AQk?!)0!s!1t>lbb.5)/#$1)<=@-$b9b]QAbK-&=#*&Q$0%*@�>/b!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!:#>0@!A7SSw@!

GXP!Z)$#!&#)*!01#!G)=.$0)&!&);J!Z)$#!M4)+)*l!<%&$0*-<I%&!%9!01.$!<%5>(#B!1)$!K#/-&!.&!ST]7!4.01!01#!1#(>!%9!21.&)!)&+!.0!.$!*#>%*0#+!01)0!.0!<)&&%0!K#!+)5)/#+!+-*.&/!)&!#)*01`-)=#@!

Page 164: Underground Great Wall

A#D/(*'"$=,7.$+c0.F.+OD+

W=..-<+#:>,<-1+*-?0Y.+?0>0<FM+A:+A#$5"/%$(>:/-<+

L'&+#*/*%-&+!X<<#$$?N!m+,'52A#UA.M)',.�"8G!jA7SSk?!)0!s!1t>lbb;.*0-)(/(%K#0*%‡&/@<%5b5)>b-&+#*/*%-&+F)<<#$$FSbu!v)<<#$$#+!S7!:#>0@!A7SSw@!!2%*%%)!.5)/#*J!9*%5l!L}.4.!X.*K)$#!ATˆA7xa!SA7ˆ7Axh?N!UA.M2A#?)-5,+'9G#jA7SS@7\@SSk?!s!1t>lbb444@/(%K)($#<-*.0J@%*/b5.(.0)*Jb4%*(+b<1.&)b.=%&%$~J.4.~A777QAT!-&+#*/*%-&+@105!u!v)<<#$$#+![!:#>0@!A7SSw@!

&:=AB+).AMF.T-?+

":MAB+).AMF.T-?+

%0MTMF[+*M0E-dABM=+ R-M?:..-<+

W=..-<+

2J83+#:M:.F+0>FY-MQ+

Page 165: Underground Great Wall

W+#*.$-(*'"$=,7.+jXK1-.!G*%;.&<#k!!

S!5.!A!=5!

X(0#*&)0#!H-&4)J!!)&+!O)B.4)J!

:%-01F3#$0!O-&&#(!

a%*01Fh)$0!O-&&#(!

O-&&#(!!!0).(.&/$!

“��” Feidong Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/CN-0147/ > [accessed 15 June 2010]; and Kristensen, Norris, and McKinzie, Chinese Nuclear Forces and U.S. Nuclear War Planning, op cit.

Page 166: Underground Great Wall

W+#*.$-(*'"$=,7.+jXK1-.!G*%;.&<#k!!

Ibid.

:%-01F3#$0!O-&&#(!

a%*01Fh)$0!O-&&#(!

Page 167: Underground Great Wall

;$6#$-(*'"$=,7.+jX&1-.!G*%;.&<#k+

OF0.+KF?-+H:M+Sd7+K:>U-M?+!

dF[!Z%5K#*!(.&#$!

")*/#!).*<*)_!1)&/#*!

"%)+.&/!)*#)$!

O-&&#(!#&0*)&<#!

“����” Anqing Air Base,” Our Airports, (2010) at < http://www.ourairports.com/airports/ZSAQ/ > [accessed 15 June 2010]; and Kristensen, Norris, and McKinzie, Chinese Nuclear Forces and U.S. Nuclear War Planning, op cit.

Page 168: Underground Great Wall

;$6#$-(*'"$=,7.$2@.?0A8+

":MAB+W=..-<+

&:=AB+W=..-<+

Ibid.

Page 169: Underground Great Wall

PAB-M+W=..-<0.Y+T:E-MFY-+H:M+%.]0.Y+%0M+KF?-+dd+Sd7+K:>U-M?+Q7@Q6!a!!SS\@7A!h

GdfOfl!H)*#!.((-$0*)I%&!%9!0-&&#(!+#>(%J#+!dF[!Z%5K#*?!9*%5l!!!!"f3hH!"hPOl!o*.$0#&$#&?!a%**.$?!)&+!D<o.&V.#?!<(+")0)#E5-A)2,#J.,-)0#2"4#TI?I#E5-A)2,#V2,#BA2""+"8?!%>!<.0C!HYMdOl!LG"XXP!A77[?N!?+".*)/)"0-)J.,5=?!jA77[@7T@7[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@$.&%+#9#&<#9%*-5@<%5b).*F9%*<#b/%%/(#F#)*01F>())9FA77[F)FSTQR@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S\!r-(J!A7S7w@!O1#!()t#*!)($%!>*%;.+#$!)!(.$I&/!%9!5%$0!21.&#$#!X.*!Z)$#$!4.01!")0F"%&/!<%%*+.&)0#$@!

Page 170: Underground Great Wall

PO'S&2."T$7'd.F$<G88.(7$

:#)&!fq2%&&%*!)&+!2)*(%!o%>>?!LX$$#$$.&/!G"X!'&+#*/*%-&+!X.*!Z)$.&/!2)>)K.(.0J?N!j*#>%*0!A7SSF7SC!2)&K#**)?!X':l!X.*!G%4#*!X-$0*)(.)!X&)(J$.$?!S[!P#K*-)*J!A7SSk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@)-$).*>%4#*@&#0b$->>%*0@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!A]!X-/@!A7SS@!

Page 171: Underground Great Wall

=(,72$!;;"$!.7'S8$

YK.+@!

Page 172: Underground Great Wall

YZ,3)(.7$;:$C,"S.$R8F."S";G8F$a,8S."7$

YK.+@!

Page 173: Underground Great Wall

!./-MYM:=./+%0M+KF?-+SF.Y-M+'.A-M0:M+*-?0Y.

Kristensen, Norris, and McKinzie, Chinese Nuclear Forces and U.S. Nuclear War Planning, op cit.; and fq2%&&%*!)&+!o%>>?!LX$$#$$.&/!G"X!'&+#*/*%-&+!X.*!Z)$.&/!2)>)K.(.0J?N!%>!<.0@!

r.)&/!ƒ#5.&!2D2!.&$>#<I%&! U52"8j(.5#-&+#*/*%-&+!1)&/#*!

a-<(#)*!<)>)K(#!Y"FA]!.&!()*/#!1)&/#*!)0!U52"8j(.5#!!

Page 174: Underground Great Wall

!./-MYM:=./+%0M+KF?-+SF.Y-M+'.A-M0:M+*-?0Y.

fq2%&&%*!)&+!o%>>?!LX$$#$$.&/!G"X!'&+#*/*%-&+!X.*!Z)$.&/!2)>)K.(.0J?N!%>!<.0@!

<.=F2,26;)#)"',2"-)#0+j)0#/.,#BN7#5"4),8,.5"4#(2"82,0G#0-2A)4#/,.=#+=28),9I#?.=)#H8('),#M20)#)"',2"-)0#2,)#20#"2,,.D#20#\$#=)',)0G#D(+A)#0.=)#Ri248),d0+j)4S#M20)#)"',2"-)0#=29#M)#20#D+4)#20#g%#=)',)0I#1(),)#2,)#)+8('#:".D"##fh#d#g%#=)',)#D+4)#Ri248),d0+j)4S#(2"82,0G#.")#./#D(+-(#+0#4)-.==+00+.")4G#/.5,'))"#:".D"#€$$#=)',)#D+4)#Ri)28A)d0+j)4S#(2"82,0G#2"4#0);)"'))"#:".D"#\$#'.#\g#=)',)#D+4)#RK+Ud0+j)4S#(2"82,0I!

?+8"+H-2"'#+"-,)20)0#+"#+"'),"2A#0'.,28)#-2F2-+'9#2"4#05FF.,6"8#-2F2M+A+6)0#05-(#20#=2'),+)A#0'.,28)#2"4#F),0."")A#2--.==.426."#-2"#M)#2-(+);)4#M9#50+"8#-.=FA)W#,2'(),#'(2"#0+=FA)#+"'),"2A#'.F.A.8+)0I

Page 175: Underground Great Wall

"-\+)>,BF?0?+:.+SFM/-.-/+'./0E0/=F<+&B-<A-M?_+iT0MTF+3I2Ij++

L e¼ūSR原型机完美曝光!!v:->#*!=.((!01#!G"X!+#;.<#m!21.&)!<-0!01#!>#*9#<0!>*%0%0J>#!dFSR!#B>%$-*#w,N!J5A)+0?!jA7S7@SS@76k?!s!1t>lbb444@9-(#.$@<%5bB4bA7S7bSSb76bA[@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!\!P#K@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

G*%0%0J>#!5%+#(!%9!dFSR!$1%4&!4.01!()0#$0!).*<*)_!$1#(0#*!4.01!K()$0!+%%*$@!

Page 176: Underground Great Wall

Study #5!

=$*(;,1#33+,E()$*+,-,./$*(Y0,+%1(2%33U$

Page 177: Underground Great Wall

R*."8#J)"8S#FF!Z20'D2,4#V+"4#dd# .$!01#!%*./.&)(!&%5#&<()0-*#!9%*!G"X!K)((.$I<!5.$$.(#$!c!LeP@N! “Hu Inspects the Second Artillery Force,” Xomjia, (13 Dec. 2009), at < http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2006-06/29/content_628562.htm > [accessed 20 Feb. 2010]. Photos accompanied the website posting.

%".7'F.82$aG$'87).927$2&.$1.9;8F$*"2'((."E$O;"9.$).":;"3,89.$;:$P1;8S$;:$!;8S$O.8ST$l$Z%'1D%,*(2#$*$

R3)-)"'A9G# 0F."0.,)4# M9# '()# B).FA)O0# N+M),26."# 7,=9G# R<(+"2# E26."2A# *)/)"0)#E)D0GS#,);)2A)4#'()#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#=+00+A)#/.,-)0#'.#M5+A4#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#-2;),"#0+'526."rI#7"2A90'0#02+4#'(2'#'()#<(+")0)#=)4+2#42,)4#'.#F5MA+0(#'()0)#2,)#-2AA)4#RT"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AAS#./#'()#0',2')8+-#/2-+A+6)0#0(.D)4#'(2'#'()#<(+")0)#090')=#./#+'0#"5-A)2,#.F),26."0#D+'(#5"F,)-)4)"')4#-."H4)"-)#2"4#-.5,28)IS#

SQ!e#<@!A77T!

R3)-)"'A9G# 0F."0.,)4# M9# '()# B).FA)O0# N+M),26."# 7,=9G# R<(+"2# E26."2A# *)/)"0)#E)D0GS#,);)2A)4#'()#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#=+00+A)#/.,-)0#'.#M5+A4#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#-2;),"#0+'526."rI#7"2A90'0#02+4#'(2'#'()#<(+")0)#=)4+2#42,)4#'.#F5MA+0(#'()0)#2,)#-2AA)4#RT"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AAS#./#'()#0',2')8+-#/2-+A+6)0#0(.D)4#'(2'#'()#<(+")0)#090')=#./#+'0#"5-A)2,#.F),26."0#D+'(#5"F,)-)4)"')4#-."H4)"-)#2"4#-.5,28)IS#

<(+")0)# B,)0+4)"'# _5# Y+"'2.# +"0F)-')4# '()#()24L52,'),0# ./# '()# ?)-."4# 7,6AA),9# J.,-)#./# '()# <(+")0)# B).FA)q0# N+M),26."# 7,=9#`BN7a# ."# V)4")0429# '.# =2,:# '()# g%'(#2""+;),02,9#./#'()#/.5"4+"8#./#'()#-.5"',9q0#0',2')8+-#',..F0I#

!"#(+0#0F))-(G#_5#FA)48)4#'.#0')F#5F#=+A+'2,9#,)/.,=0G# -%0"%6-.,' 4)"42)2*$%6' .$)' 0?"'3-+-02),' 60)955+"7' 2%&' 60)"%50?"%' 0?"'

$G")2++' A9-+&-%5' $.' 0?"' !"#$%&' ()*++"),'

;$)#"rI#

E.6"8# '(2'# '()# ?)-."4# 7,6AA),9# J.,-)#0(.5A4),0#2#8A.,+.50#=+00+."#2"4# +=F.,'2"'#456)0# +"# '()# ")D# -)"'5,9# 2"4# '()# ")D#F),+.4G#_5#02+4#'()#B2,'9#<)"',2A#<.==+>))#2"4# '()# <K<# (2;)# 2>2-()4# 8,)2'#+=F.,'2"-)#'.#2"4#F+"")4#(+8(#(.F)0#."#'()#4);)A.F=)"'# ./# '()# ?)-."4# 7,6AA),9#J.,-)rII#

_5# 2"4# .'(),# =+A+'2,9# A)24),0# D2'-()4# 2"#2,'# F),/.,=2"-)# )"6'A)4# o?."8# ./# *."8#J)"8# _:260R2)&' Z-%&aG# D(+-(# ')AA0# 2M.5'#'()# g%d9)2,# )WF),+)"-)# ./# '()# ?)-."4#7,6AA),9#J.,-)#+"#2"#2,606-#D29I#

e-*.&/!1.$!$0)J?!01#!>*#$.+#&0?!41%!.$!)($%!/#&#*)(!$#<*#0)*J!%9!01#!2%55-&.$0!G)*0J!%9!21.&)!j2G2k! 2#&0*)(! 2%55.t##! )&+! <1).*5)&! %9! 01#! 2#&0*)(! D.(.0)*J! 2%55.$$.%&! j2D2k?! 1)+! )!5##I&/!4.01!$#&.%*!%^<#*$!%9!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!P%*<#?!4.01!01#!<%5>)&J!%9!.0$!<%55)&+#*!r.&/!ƒ1.J-)&!)&+!<%55.$$)*!G#&/!|.)%9#&/@!

Page 178: Underground Great Wall

1.9;8F$*"2'((."E$R8F."S";G8F$5N0KX/454+

•  P*%5!#)*(.#$0!+#>(%J5#&0?!-$#!%9!<);#$!)&+!0-&&#($!4)$!)!<%55%&!01#5#C!•  O1#!&)5#!L:#<%&+!X*I((#*JN!4)$!)!9%*5!%9!<%&<#)(5#&0!)&+!+.$.&9%*5)I%&C!•  G"X!:0*)0#/.<!a-<(#)*!9%<-$!9*%5!()0#![7$!0%!#)*(J!T7$!4)$!%&!01#!'::HC!•  :-*;.;)K.(.0J!%9!:OHXOhMY2!5.$$.(#$!,!+*.;#&!KJ!&)0-*#!%9!(.`-.+!9-#(!,!+#>(%J#+l!

–  P#4!&-5K#*!%9!EB#+!1)*+#&#+!$.0#$!,!&%0!L)<I;#N!4.01!9-#(b4)*1#)+!(%)+#+C!–  d.++#&!<);#!%*!0-&&#(!L&#$0$N!9%*!)$$#5K(J!)&+!*%((F%-0!0%!>*#F$-*;#J#+!()-&<1!$.0#$@!

•  :-*;.;)K.(.0J!%9!OX2OY2X"!5.$$.(#$!KJ!+.$>#*$)(!)&+!*#+-&+)&<Jl!–  '$#!%9!5%K.(.0J!)&+!#5>1)$.$!%&!5-(I>(#!*#(%)+!0*).(#*$!>#*!E*#!-&.0@!

•  S$0!L'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!K-.(0!.&!ah!)&+!%&!<%)$0!K#04##&!ST]6FSTT6C!•  Y&0*%+-<I%&!%9!$%(.+!9-#(!1)$!(#+!0%!5)�%*!K-.(+F->!.&!)<I;#!()-&<1!-&.0$!)$!4#((!)$!

5-(I>(#!*#FE*#$!9%*!L+-)(!<)>)K.(.0JN!4.01!ePFSS?!ePFS6!)&+!ePFASC!•  Y&0*%+-<#!#5>(%J5#&0!<%&<#>0!%9!L01#!$-*/#N!9%*!+#0#**#&<#!)&+!4)*E/1I&/C!•  A&+!L'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!$->>%$#+!0%!K#!K#04##&!STT6FA776!K-0!+#()J#+C!•  Y&0#&$#!<%&$0*-<I%&!.&!a3?!:h?!O.K#0!9%*!<%5>(#I%&!%9!A&+!'M3!KJ!A77T!9%*!ePFASbePFQSC!•  dJ>%01#$.$l!$0)*I&/!%9!&#4!Q*+!>1)$#!L'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((N!,!A7S7!0%!A7A7!,!9%*!

<%;#*!)&+!<%&<#)(5#&0!%9!&#4!/#&#*)I%&!%9!5%K.(#!Y2ZD!ePFQSÖ!)&+!ePF6!*#>()<#5#&0@!

Page 179: Underground Great Wall

<G88.($!'SS'8S$,7$],2';8,($12",2.S'9$@G(2G".$

\"2G"%>6'`$2)'

•! A77]!r%.&0!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!e#>0@!%9!O#(#;.$.%&!X*0$!2#&0*#!>*.5#FI5#!L#>.<N!$#*.#$!i,+AA+2"'#,)F,.45-6."#./#g%d9)2,#(+0'.,9#./#'()#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#'.#=2,:#'()#&w#2""+;),02,9#./#'()#/.5"4+"8#./#'()#<B<I#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#<.,F0G#'()#/5AA#"2=)#o1()#BN7#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#J.,-)Go#2FF,.;)4#M9#<(2+,=2"#K2.G#B,)=+),#u(.5#"2=)4I#K2"9#F).FA)#'(+":#+'#+0#C50'#2"#.,4+"2,9#/.,-)G#+"#/2-'#+'#+0#2#0)-,)'#/.,=#./#<(+"2q0#0',2')8+-#=+00+A)#/.,-)0I#

•! :1%4&!&)I%&!4.+#!%&!22OnFQ!4.01!1./1!*)I&/$!•! AR!>*%/*)5$!‰!RQ5.&!c!S\@A!1%-*$!•! hB0*#5#(J!)<<-*)0#!+*)5)IV)I%&!%9!01#!&%&F

E<I%&)(!#)*(J!1.$0%*J!%9!01#!A&+!X*I((#*Jl!1+Å"#v+‚.#!•! S$0!)<I;#!ePFA!:-*9)<#F0%F:-*9)<#!D.$$.(#!H#/.5#&0!•! e#>(%J5#&0!0%!M%K.!e#$#*0!•! :0%*)/#!(%<)I%&!.&!+##>!*);.&#$!•! h&/.&##*!Z)t)(.%&!+.//.&/!>*.5.I;#!1%*.V%&0)(!

0-&&#(!<%&$0*-<I%&!4.01!+#)+(J!<);#F.&$!J)D#9)2,0G#'()9#(2;)#".#F.D),/5A#=.4),"#-."0',5-6."#=2-(+"),9G#M5'#D+'(#MA..4#2"4#0D)2'#b#A.00#./#A+/)#F2',+.60=G#0',."8#=+A+'2,9#4,)2=0G#(),.+0=G#02-,+H-)G#dd#'()9#(.AA.D)4#.5'G#2"4#8)'#'(,.58(#'()#')"0#./#:+A.=)'),0#./#'()#-2;)G#20#'()#D)AA#M5+A'#=+00+A)#")0'0I##

•! P).(-*#!%9!.&.I)(!5.$$.(#!0#$0$!•! H#(.;#$!$-<<#$$9-(!5.$$.(#!+#(.;#*#+!&-<(#)*!

+#0%&)I%&!c!S]=0!•! ".;#!0#$I&/!.&<%*>%*)0#+!.&0%!2D2!2G|!)/).&$0!01#!

:%;.#0$!

“�� [Heavens Roar],” directed by missile brigade commander Gu Jin Yun, screen play by Chen, (Mandarin; Beijing, PRC: CCTV, 2008) at < http://dianshiju.cntv.cn/revolution/tianxiao/videopage/index.shtml > [accessed 11 Apr. 2010]; see also: TV series "Tian Xiao," Development of the Second Artillery Reproduction,” Liberation Army Daily, (2006.05.01) at < http://military.people.com.cn/GB/42968/57661/4346160.html > [accessed 21 May 2010].

Page 180: Underground Great Wall
Page 181: Underground Great Wall

Y,"(E$<",'(."$!.)(;E3.82$

Page 182: Underground Great Wall

<",'8'8S$:;"$<G88.($V;((X;G2$

LG"X!D.$$.(#!O1*#)+?N!?+".#*)/)"0)#J.,5=G!jA77[@7A@7Qk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@$.&%+#9#&<#9%*-5@<%5b4%*(+F5.(.0)*JF>.<0-*#$b>()F5.$$.(#F01*#)+F>.<0-*#$!F[F]QA@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!:#>@!A7SSw!

Page 183: Underground Great Wall

Y,"(E$.Z,3)(.7$;:$2;6.F$PV;((;G2T$

:<*##&!$1%0!9*%5!Y9#&/!On!vd%&/!o%&/wl!LG"X!D.$$.(#$!X.5#+!)0!Y&+.)?N!<(+")0)#K+A+'2,9#vK(%/w?!jA7S7@SS@SQk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@<1.&#$#F)*5J@<%5bz>c\!u!v)<<#$$#+!Q7!a%;@!A7S7w@!

Page 184: Underground Great Wall

Y,"(E$1'(;$!.)(;E3.82$

“��������������������� [CCTV Exposure of the PLA Second Artillery Corps Ground Strategic Nuclear Missile Silo Underground],” ���� Army Forum, at ������ [Blood & Iron International Forum], (2010.04.10) at < http://bbs.tiexue.net/post_4196029_1.html > [accessed 2 June 2010].

Page 185: Underground Great Wall

5N[47$1'(;$!.)(;E3.82!

“一口井 [A Silo],” topic: 航天二炮及新概念武器 [Second Artillery Corps and the New Concept of Space Weapons] at ŧĺwßŐşj [Higher Headquarters Forum], (2010.04.14) at < http://bbs.cjdby.net/thread-907903-1-5.html > [accessed 20 May. 2010, translated IP-1011]; and “eP6R��5źďĒ![DF5 silos within the photo],” China Picture, (2010.04.29), at < http://www.picturechina.com.cn/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=55644&extra=page%3D1 > [accessed 20 Sept. 2011, translated IP-1011].

Page 186: Underground Great Wall
Page 187: Underground Great Wall

a,8F('8S$I$!',S8;72'9$'8$O,9'('2'.7$

LP*#&<1!D#+.)l!21.&)x$!a-5K#*!%9!a-<(#)*!3#)>%&$Å@N! l ?!jQ7!a%;#5K#*!A77Tk?!)0!s1t>lbb5.(@<&4#$0@<%5b<%&0#&0bA77TFSSbQ7b<%&0#&0~A[S7SA6@105!!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!D)*@!A7S7w@!

Page 188: Underground Great Wall

!',S8;72'97$I$B,2'8S$V.X.82"E$f.&'9(.$;8$!OXe5$W@=B!

[Report by Peng Wei, Jiang Wu, Chen Shuangwei, and Li Jing]: “New Initiatives in Passing on Experience: 'Snowballing' Talent Cultivation -- Documentary Report of Certain Base of Secondary Artillery Promoting Contract-type' Mentoring,” Jiefangjun Huabao, [Beijing, in Mandarin], (2009.02.09) at [translated by OSC CPP20090428682002: “Second Artillery Base Promotes Personnel Mentoring To Foster Talent;” accessed 1 June 2010].

Page 189: Underground Great Wall

C,2.$5N[47$=G8Q."7$

Page 190: Underground Great Wall

B;F."8'd,2';8$;:$=G8Q."$@;33,8F$I$@;82";($

“zřÚ0ŚÌ6�Čźƃh�»Ğê�§R��,” op cit. !

Page 191: Underground Great Wall

W87'F.$C;,F'8S$V,'(7$

Page 192: Underground Great Wall

B,8G,($<G88.($V;(($UG2$

Page 193: Underground Great Wall

B'77'(.7$'8$R8F."S";G8F$12;",S.$

L�Č�Ŕse�Ðl¡ŲĐčQÙň»Ïź!v:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!1)$!#`-.>5#&0!5)+#!%9!&#4!)&+!.&0#((./#&0!4)*1#)+!#B>(%$.%&!+#()Jw?i!_52"L+5G#`$%%&I%gI%&aG#2'#É#(>FX^^=+AI(52"L+5I-.=^-(+"2^$%%&d%g^&]gh\I('=A#Ñ#y2--)00)4#f%#*)-I#$%\%zI!

Page 194: Underground Great Wall

%*)&/#!%*)&/#!%*)&/#!%*)&/#!<G88.(7$

5N[LX5NNL$

Page 195: Underground Great Wall

P1G"S.T$:";3$R8F."S";G8F$,7$],2';8,($12",2.S'9$@G(2G".$

'S-66-+"'U)-52&"'

•! A77A!r%.&0!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!e#>0@!%9!O#(#;.$.%&!X*0$!2#&0*#!>*.5#FI5#!L#>.<N!$#*.#$#

•! :1%4&!&)I%&!4.+#!%&!22On!4.01!1./1!*)I&/$!•! S]!>*%/*)5$!‰!R65.&!c!SQ@6!1%-*$!•! X<<-*)0#!+*)5)IV)I%&!%9!A&+!X*I((#*Jl!1+Å"#v+‚.#!•! :1%4$!5.B#+!Z*./)+#$!4.01!ePFA?!ePFQ?!ePFR!)&+!

ePF6!•! e#>(%J5#&0!.&!LO1#!h)$0N!j)+�)<#&0!0%!})&/0V#!

H.;#*k!•! :0%*)/#!(%<)I%&!.&!$.+#$!%9!5%-&0).&$!4.01!

5)&J!4.&+.&/!&)**%4!)<<#$$!*%)+$!•! P%((%4$!D.$$.(#!Z*./)+#!2%55)&+#*!01*%-/1!

$J$0#5!5%+#*&.V)I%&#•! :1%4$!D.(.0)*J!e.$0*.<0!-&+#*/*%-&+!<%55)&+!

<#&0#*!)$!K-.(0!->!%&!)!&)0-*)(!<);#!•! :1%4$!A&+!)&+!Q*+!/#&#*)I%&!0-&&#($!•! H#(.;#$!STT6FSTT[!&);)(!<*.$.$!%;#*!01#!O).4)&!

:0*).0$!•! ".;#!0#$I&/!.&<%*>%*)0#+!.&0%!2D2!2G|!)/).&$0!

':!P(##0!4.01!ePFAS$!0*)<=.&/!X5#*.<)&!<)**.#*$@!

“�� [Heavens Roar],” directed by missile brigade commander Gu Jin Yun, screen play by Zhang Rui, (Mandarin; Beijing, PRC: CCTV, 2002) at < http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XMzIwMzIwMzY=.html> [accessed 11 Apr. 2010]; see also: TV series "Tian Xiao," Development of the Second Artillery Reproduction,” Liberation Army Daily, (2006.05.01) at < http://military.people.com.cn/GB/42968/57661/4346160.html > [accessed 21 May 2010].

Page 196: Underground Great Wall

@;33,8F$@,b.$

Page 197: Underground Great Wall

5NN47$<G88.(7$

Page 198: Underground Great Wall

O,2&."7$;:$2&.$R8F."S";G8F$

OZg-.Z+}0=TB-.Y+$:.Y+ $AZg-.Z+~BF.Y+V0F.Y+vH#>%*0!KJ!e.&/!d).5.&/?!3#.!2-&*#&?!)&+!d#!ƒ1%&/wlL����������!€€!�����������������!�������������!vD.(#$F+)J!|.&�.)&/!+*)4!%&!21.&)x$!0*)�#<0%*J!F!Y&!D#5%*J!%9!01#!X*5Jx$!:0*)0#/.<!D.$$.(#!#B>#*0$!.&!01#!-$#!%9!#`-.>5#&0?!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!Y&$I0-0#!%9!01#!%*./.&)(!*#$#)*<1#*!y.-<1#&/!"%&/wCN!Y+)/2"8C5"#i2.#n"A+")!vZ#.�.&/?!.&!D)&+)*.&w?!jA7S7@76@S\kl!>@!S?!)0!vf:2!$-55)*J!2GGA7S776A67]]77Sl!LrPrZ!%&!")0#!G"X!D.$$.(#!hB>#*0!y.-!21#&/(%&/!jG)*0!SkCN!9-((!0*)&$()I%&!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!L�������������������!v2%55-&.<)I%&l!01#!-$#!%9!01#!G"X!:0*)0#/.<!D.$$.(#!hB>#*0$!y.-<1#&/!"%&/w?N!0%>.<l! !v:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!)&+!01#!a#4!2%&<#>0!%9!:>)<#!3#)>%&$w!)0!�������!vd./1#*!d#)+`-)*0#*$!P%*-5w?!jA7S7@76@S[k!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@<�+KJ@&#0b01*#)+FTQA\R[FSFA@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!ST!D)J@!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!YGFS7SSw@! “ : [Zhang Xiang: the two sides should jointly plan the future of the Chinese nation],” Ghongguo Pinglun Tongxun She, [Hong Kong-based Internet news agency (China Review News Agency, in Mandarin], (2010.06.03) at < http://www. Chinareviewnews. Com > [OSC summary CPP20100603707002: “Former PLA Commander Urges Cross-Strait Talks on Future of Chinese Nation;” translated in full by IP-1011].

Page 199: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8S$/44L$

7R!e#<!A77R !h5#*/#&<J!*#>%*0!FF!L0-&&#(.&/!4%*=!*)&!.&0%!)!/*%->!%9!Ç+*)/%&!v$0)()<.0#w!<);#$q@q!

76!P#K!A776 !")*/#!$<)(#!()&+$(.+#!)0!-&+#*/*%-&+!A&+!X*0J!<%&$0*-<I%&!$.0#C!7T!P#K !h&/*@!H#/0@!0-&&#(.&/!.&!5.&-$!Q7!+#/*##!2#&I/*)+#C!SQ!P#K !'&.0!4%*=$!&#)*!"%&/0)&!G%4#*!G()&0C!SQ!D)* !A&+!X*0J!*#>*#$#&0)I;#!<%5>().&$!0%!!Z#.�.&/!01)0!0*%%>$!.&!.$%()0#+!L9*%&0(.&#!

<%&$0*-<I%&@Å!+#$<*.K#+!<-(0-*)(!)&+!*#<*#)I%&)(!)<I;.I#$!.&!01#!-&.0!)$!5%&%0%&%-$@!S\!D)* !P%((%4.&/!)!<);#F.&!)0!)!<%&$0*-<I%&!$.0#!%9!A&+!X*0J!#&/.&##*.&/!*#/.5#&0!-&+#*!01#!

2%55)&+#*!L.55#+.)0#(J!*-$1#+!0%!01#!$.0#!0%!%*/)&.V#!<%&I&/#&<J!5#)$-*#$l!Ç1()#H,0'#0')F#+0#'.#,)=.;)#(2j2,40I#1()"#0F,29#-."-,)')G#0)'#5F#F,.F0G#0)-6."#M9#0)-6."G#2"4#F.5,#-."-,)')I#1()"#D)#0',)"8'()"#0'))A#05FF.,'I#1()"#D)#D+AA#F200#=50'),OIS#

S]!D)* !LP%-*!&#4$N!,!5#01%+%(%/J?!0#<1&%(%/J?!|||||?!}}}}}}!FF!0*).&.&/!<%-*$#!9%*!A&+!X*0J!h&/*!-&.0C!;.$.0!01#!|.)%()&/+.!)&+!O1*##!M%*/#$!+)5$!0%!(#)*&!<%&$0*-<I%&!0#<1&.`-#$!

A]!D)* !A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!'&.0!L1)$!.&;#$0#+!$#;#*)(!0#&$!%9!5.((.%&$!%9!J-)&!0%!$#0!->!E;#!&#4!5#<1)&.V#+!%>#*)I%&!(.&#$N!)&+!L&#4F5%+#(!*%<=F+*.((.&/!5)<1.&#!Å!<)&!<%5>(#0#!)!01*##F5#0#*F+##>!*%%9!K%(0!.&!E;#!5.&-0#$?!<%5>)*#+!0%!5%*#!01)&!%&#!1%-*!.&!01#!>)$0@!!

L2%5>.()I%&!ene!%9! GH2q$! :#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!X<I;.I#$! .&!A776?N! j2GGA77[7QAR7S\77SC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?! AT!D)*@!A77[kC! )&+! LGH2!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!X<I;.I#$! .&!A776?N! jf:2!H#>%*0! .&!21.&#$#!76!P#K!7[! F! 7R!e#<!7[l! PhXA77[7QAR7ASASSC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!AR!D)*@!A77[k@!

Be'H1]#%#01'?#0$.?#K')j']%.F%#/HI'B5'/$?;01H'.L'1>$01>'@.X1%#F1A'

Page 200: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44L$i9;82#j$

7[!X>* !H%<=!$-*9)<#!9*)/5#&0#+!)&+!<%(()>$#+!)0!A&+!X*0J!-&+#*/*%-&+!<%&$0*-<I%&!$.0#C!S]!X>* !:%(+.#*!)9*).+!%9!0-&&#($!K-0!&%4!L-&9)V#+!)$!1#!(#)+$!1)V)*+%-$!<%&$0*-<I%&!4%*=CN!7A!r-( !hB>#&$.;#!+*.((.&/!0*%((#J!$>)*#!>)*0$!>*%+-<#+!KJ!H#/0@!(%<)((J!0%!$);#!5%&#JC!7Q!r-( !X4)*+!9%*!L.*%&!5)&N!.&!0-&&#(.&/!>*%�#<0$!0%!$%(+.#*!4%*=.&/!$.&<#!ST]SC!7]!r-( !h&/*@!H#/0@!1)$!L)<<.+#&0!9*##N!&)I%&)(!+#9#&$#!<%&$0*-<I%&!5.$$.%&!9%*!>)$0!S\!J#)*$C!AS!X-/ !h&/*@!H#/0@!)$$./&#+!&#4!+#9#&$#!<%&$0*-<I%&!5.$$.%&!.&!#)*(J!X>*.(C!A6!X-/ !hB1.K.I%&!%9!0#<1&%(%/.<)(!)<<%5>(.$15#&0$!%9!A&+!X*0J!2%*>!h&/*@!-&.0$!,!)((!0-&&#(!*#()0#+C!SQ!:#> !D%K.(#!:gO!$#*;.<#!0#)5!<%5#$!0%!).+!-&.0!4.01!<);#F.&!+-#!0%!L4)0#*!>#*<%()I%&!.&!*%<=$C!S]!:#> !A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!H#/0@!,!L&)**%4?!$0-WJ!4%*=!$.0#$!4.01!0#5>!#B<##+.&/!67!+#/*##$!2#($.-$Å@N!A!f<0 !A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!H#/0@!,!L<)+*#$N!9*%&0!(.&#!0*%%>$!9%*!1%(.+)J!*#$0@!

Page 201: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8S$/440$

7A!P#K !A&+!X*0J!h&/.&##*!H#/@!4%*=.&/!%&!0-&&#(.&/!01*-!1%(.+)J$C!SS!P#K !Y&&%;)I%&!.&!+#;#(%>5#&0!%9!$0##(!5#5K*)&#!0-&&#(!<%)I&/!5)<1.&#C!AS!D)* !a#4!)>>*%)<1!0%!>*#;#&I&/!L<);#F.&$N!%;#*!04%!J#)*!>#*.%+C!

L:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$! .&!A77[?N! jPZ:A77\7A7Q]AT6[]C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!Q!P#K@!A77\kC! Lene!2%5>.()I%&!%9!GH2q$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$!.&!A77[?N!j2GGA77\7A7Q7Q677SC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!Q!P#K@! A77\kC! LGH2q$! :#<%&+! X*I((#*J! 2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/! .&! A77[?N! jf:2! H#>%*0! .&! 21.&#$#! 76! P#K! 7[! F! 7R! e#<! 7[l! PhXA77\7A767]\T][C!3)$1.&/0%&?! e2l! f>#&! :%-*<#! 2#&0#*?! 6! P#K@! A77\kC! )&+! L2%5>.()I%&! %9! G"Xq$! :#<%&+! X*I((#*J! 2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/! X<I;.I#$l!A77[?N!jY&0#*)<I;#!3#K!G*%+-<0C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!A77\k@!

BV'H1]#%#01'?#0$.?#K')j']%.F%#/HI'B7'/$?;01H'.L'1>$01>'@.X1%#F1A'

A!P#K?!22OnF\! SS!P#K?!22OnF\! AS!D)*?!22OnF\!

Page 202: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/440$i9;82#j$

7\!X>* !2D2!)4)*+!0%!A&+!X*0J!25+!X<)+#5J!G*%9#$$%*!,!(.&=.&/!>*%/*)5!%9!AMF0.0.Y+�+A=..-<0.Y+H:M+2I+QM?C!

7]!X>* !2D2!<.0#+!A&+!X*0J!25+!X<)+#5J!G*%9#$$%*!41%!5)+#!5)�%*!0#<1&.<)(!.&&%;)I%&$!FF!!;.$.0$!0-&&#(!$.0#?!.&$>#<0$!;#&I()I%&!…!).*!<%&+.I%&.&/C!

A7!X>* !X4)*+!9%*!A&+!X*0J!h&/*!H#/!25+*!9%*!S778!<%&$0*-<I%&!)<<#>0)&<#!)0!<%5>(#I%&!%9!0-&&#(!>*%�#<0C!

A[!X>* !hB>(%$.;#$!.&!0-&&#(.&/!,!<%&<#*&!%;#*!#&(.$0#+!0*%%>!5%*)(#!FF!>$J<1%(%/.<)(!>*%/*)5!.&.I)0#+!0%!)++*#$$!0*%%>!9#)*$C!

\!X>*?!22OnF\! A7!X>*?!22OnF\! A[!X>*?!22OnF\!

Page 203: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/440$i9;82#j$

7\!D)J?!22OnF\! AT!r-&?!22OnF\!

7\!D)J !A&+!X*0J!h&/*!H#/@!+#;#(%>$!%>I5-5!+*.((.&/!0#<1&.`-#$!9%*!(.&#)*!…!<-*;.(.&#)*!0-&&#(.&/!,!S7!9%(+!.&<*#)$#!.&!#^<.#&<JC!

AT!r-& !A&+!X*0J!h&/*!-&.0!L=&%4&!)$!‚.-?A+U=0</-M?q!9%*!5.$$.(#$?N!5)=#$!.&&%;)I%&$!.&!;.+#%!5%&.0%*#+!$)9#0J!…!#)*01!5%;.&/C!

7A!r-( !2%55-&.$0!G)*0J!2%55.t##!%)01!0)=.&/!9%*!0*%%>$!%9!LAB-+OFY0T+&\:M/?+:H+AB-+PM0-.AN!-&.0!.&!1./1!5%-&0).&!(%<)I%&!%&!Q?[775!>()0#)-C!

SA!r-( !A&+!X*0J!h&/*!-&.0!$>#<.)(.$0$!.&!).*!+-<0!4%*=!&#<#$$)*J!9%*!1-5.+.0J!<%&0*%(!)&+!).*!<%&+.I%&.&/!L)0!(%<)I%&$!$0%*.&/!5.$$.(#$CN!

Page 204: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/440$i9;82#j$

SA!r-(?!22OnF\!7\!D)J?!22OnF\!

Page 205: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/440$i9;82#j$

SS!:#> !LO:G!)+;)&<#!/#%(%/.<)(!9%*#<)$I&/!0#<1&%(%/JN!$-*;#J$!5)0#*.)(!S775!)1#)+!%9!+*.((.&/!0%!>*#;#&0!L<);#F.&$@N!

7[!f<0 !a%!9)((!1%(.+)J!9%*!A&+!X*0J!h&/*!<%&$0*-<I%&!>*%�#<0!L-.A-M0.Y+F+TM=T0F<+?AFY-CN!QS!f<0 !'$#!%9!01#!>1*)$#!,!L)$<#&+.&/b+#$<#&+.&/!0*)&$()I%&)(!>*%0#<I;#!<%&0).&5#&0!9%*!

=./-MYM:=./+MF0<\FQCN!A\!a%; !hB>#*0!*#$>%&$#!0#)5!<*#)0#+!0%!*#$>%&+!0%!0-&&#(.&/!>*%K(#5$!)0!LF+/:h-.+€+=.0A?+0.+

M->:A-+FM-F?CN!7R!e#< !A&+!h&/*!Z&!4%*=.&/!.&!L?>F<<+TFE-+/-,:ACN!)($%!-I(.V)I%&!%9!)+;)&<#+!L"-\+%=?AM0F.+

W=..-<0.Y+?Q?A->@N!!

7[!f<0?!22OnF\! A\!a%;?!22OnF\!

Page 206: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44M$

7S!P#K !Q*+!Z&?!A&+!X*0J!h&/.&##*!H#/@!L/)**.$%&#+!.&!)!<%(+!&%*014#$0#*&!*#/.%&?!*#<#&0(J!*#<#.;#+!)!Å!‚<%5>)&JF+#(.;#*Jq!v4-!B.)!(.)&w!<%&I&/#&0Å@!O%!1#(>!01#5!$%(;#!>*)<I<)(!>*%K(#5$?!$%!)$!0%!#(#;)0#!01#.*!$#(9FK-.(+.&/!<)>)K.(.0JCN!

Ll!D)J!A77n.+#%!%9!GH2!D.(.0)*J!X<I;.I#$!%9!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$\?N!j2GGA77\7[A[7Q677]C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!QS!D)J@! A77\kC! L:#<%&+! X*I((#*J! 2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/! X<I;.I#$! .&! A77[?N! jPZ:A77]7A7SA\QSQC!3)$1.&/0%&?! e2l! f>#&! :%-*<#! 2#&0#*?! S! P#K@!A77]kC!Lene!2%5>.()I%&!%9!GH2q$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$!.&!A77\?N!jf:2!:-55)*J!.&!21.&#$#?!D)&+)*.&!7S!P#K!7\!F!7Q!a%;!7\l! 2GGA77]7SQ77S\77AC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&! :%-*<#!2#&0#*?! Q7! r)&@! A77]kC! LGH2q$! :#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/! .&! A77\?N!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*!jf:2!:-55)*J!7S!P#K!7\!F!7Q!a%;!7\l!PhXA77]7A766ARAA]C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!6!P#K@!A77]kC!)&+!L2%5>.()I%&!%9!G"Xq$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$l!A77[?N!jY&0#*)<I;#!3#K!G*%+-<0C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!A77]k@!

S!P#K?!22OnF\! Q!P#K?!22OnF\! R!P#K?!22OnF\!

Page 207: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44M$i9;82#j$

7Q!P#K !X&!YOFK)$#+!<%55)&+!<#&0#*!#$0)K(.$1#+!4.01.&!)!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!-&.0?!L01)0!<%$0!5.((.%&$!%9!J-)&!0%!K-.(+?C!4)$!>-0!.&0%!%>#*)I%&!.&!()0#!r)&-)*J!FF!<#&0#*!4.((!K#!-$#+!A:+/0M-TA+AB-+T:.?AM=TG:.+\:ML+:H+.FG:.F<+/-H-.?-dM-<FA-/+,M:a-TA?@!

7R!P#K !A&+!X*0J!h&/@!H#/0@!L4%*=.&/!%&!)!>()0#)-N!<%&I&-#$!-&+#*/*%-&+!<%&$0*-<I%&!01*-!4.&0#*C!<%>.&/!4.01!>*%K(#5$!%9!L>.‡&/?!4)0#*!$##>)/#?!)&+!<*)<=.&/N!.&!01#!B0YBdF<GA=/-+HM0Y0/+h:.-CN!

7\!P#K !H%0)I%&!%9!A&+!X*0J!h&/@!H#/0@!0#<1&.<)(!>#*$%&&#(!j*#(.#;#+!KJ!G)*0J!<)+*#$kC!7]!P#K !]01!2%@?!A&+!X*0J!h&/@!H#/0@!<%5>(#0#$!F+4+Q-FM+,M:a-TA!.&!01#!L1)*$1N!M%K.!e#$#*0C!7T!P#K !G*%�#<I%&!5%;.#$!$1%4&!0%!0*%%>$!+.//.&/!-&+#*/*%-&+!.&!M%K.!e#$#*0CN!AS!P#K !'&+#*/*%-&+!A&+!X*0J!-&.0!L.&!%*+#*!0%!MFT-+FYF0.?A+AB-+G>-!Å!4%*=.&/!%;#*I5#CN!

\!P#K?!22OnF\! ]!P#K?!22OnF\! T!P#K?!22OnF\!

Page 208: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44M$i9;82#j$

7[!D)* !G0@!Sl!G()0#)-FK)$#+!L>%%*!*%<=!`-)(.0J!.&!01#!0-&&#(!.$!<*#)I&/!>*%K(#5$!9%*!K()$I&/CN!H#/0@!25+*@!L%&!)!>()0#)-!.&!01#!&%*014#$0N!$.&<#!A77RC!H#/0@!L%;#*!01#!>)$0!9#4!J#)*$Å@!*#$>%&$.K(#!9%*!LS\!&)I%&)(!+#9#&$#!>*%�#<0$CN!

7\!D)* !G0@!Al!25+*!.$!)!$>#<.)(.$0!.&!+.//.&/!01*%-/1!+.^<-(0!0#**).&!)&+!1)$!>-K(.$1#+!S[!>)>#*$!%&!L:5%%01F:-*9)<#!Z()$I&/!9%*!O-&&#(.&/CN!

SQ!D)* !LO1#!0-&&#(!.&!41.<1!01#!Q+!Z)t)(.%&!%9!01#!*#/.5#&0!4%*=$!.$!)!;#*J!0%-/1!#&;.*%&5#&0@N!A\!D)* !G)*0J!<%55.t##!5%K.(#!%^<#!j<%5>*.$.&/!<%55.t##!5#5K#*$!)&+!0#<1&.<)(!#B>#*0$k!

9%*5#+!0%!1#(>!$%(;#!>*%K(#5$!#&<%-&0#*#+!KJ!01#!/*)$$*%%0$!$#*;.<#5#&!)&+!>*#;#&0!01#!%<<-**#&<#!%9!<%&$0*-<I%&F*#()0#+!)<<.+#&0$@!

[!D)*?!22OnF\! \!D)*?!22OnF\! SQ!D)*?!22OnF\!

Page 209: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44M$i9;82#j$

7S!D)J !A!<%&$0*-<I%&!*#<%*+$!$#0!.&!1.$0%*J!%9!A&+!X*0J!2%*>$l!FF!*F0<Q+A=..-<0.Y+H::AFY-+:H+28Z6+>-A-M?+KJ!)!$.&/(#!0-&&#(#*!.&!)!<);#!+#>%0C!FF!O:.AB<Q+H-MM:T:.TM-A-+=?FY-+:H+:E-M+2INIII+T=U0T+>-A-M?@!

7T!D)J !LH#>%*0!%&!01#!$)9#0J!)$$-*)&<#!5#)$-*#$!)+%>0#+!KJ!)!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!*#/.5#&0!)0!.0$!<%&$0*-<I%&!$.0#CN!<%&<#*&!4.01!LTB-TL0.Y+F./+M-/M-??0.Y+F.Q+<=ML0.Y+,-M0<?CN!

SQ!D)J !LO%!)<I;#(J!<1)&/#!01#!4%*=!$0J(#!%9!.0$!<%55)&+!)&+!$0)W!<)+*#$?!01#!)-01%*.I#$!%9!)!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!*#/.5#&0!1);#?!$.&<#!01#!K#/.&&.&/!%9!D)J?!*#`-.*#+!01#!*#/.5#&0x$!<%55)&+!)&+!$0)W!<)+*#$!0%!/%!0%!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!$.0#$!%9!01#!=#J!&)I%&)(!+#9#&$#!>*%�#<0$!.0!1)$!-&+#*0)=#&Å@!f&#!$-<1!>*%�#<0!4)$!#&0#*.&/!01#!<*.I<)(!$0)/#!%9!<%&<*#I&/@N!

S!D)J?!22OnF\! T!D)J?!22OnF\! SQ!D)J?!22OnF\!

Page 210: Underground Great Wall

7\!D)J?!22OnF\! AT!r-&?!22OnF\! AT!r-&?!22OnF\!

SA!r-(?!22OnF\! 7[!f<0?!22OnF\! A\!a%;?!22OnF\!

* Niu Xiaoqi, Liu Baolong, and staff reporter Wang Hongxu: “Advancing With the Times; Satisfying the Need for Development -- Experiences of Unidentified Engineering Regiment Using Scientific Development Concept To Guide Comprehensive Future Development of the Regiment, Part 1,” d-%�.)&K.&/!Z)%G#vG)*0J!r%-*&)(!%9!01#!A&+!X*I((#*Jw?!jAQ!r-&@!A77\k?!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*!0*)&$()I%&l!2GGA77\7]7ARQ[77\@

3II8;+=:%5-%"")-%5'`"5-3"%0'Y4&20"6'!"#$%&'()*++"),'a)$b"#0'S"0?$&6SÖ#

#7t),#'()#F)2:#./#'()#A2')0'#,.5"4#./#"26."2A#4)/)"0)#-."0',5-6."G#2"#5"+4)"6H)4#)"8+")),+"8#,)8+=)"'#/2=.50#/.,#M,2;)A9#8.+"8# 2AA# .5'# 2A0.# 5"4),D)"'# -(2AA)"8)I# !"# =+00+."# 2t),# =+00+."G# D+'(# 6=)# A+=+'0# ,)F)2')4A9# =.;)4# 5F# 2"4# L52A+'9# 0'2"42,40#-."0'2"'A9#,2+0)4G#'()#,)8+=)"'2A#F2,'9#-.==+>))#24C50')4#'(.58('0#2"4#+4)20#'.#24;2"-)#D+'(#'()#6=)0G#24C50')4#')2=#M5+A4+"8#'.#0260/9#'()#"))4#/.,#4);)A.F=)"'G#2"4#0.58('#'()#M)0'#2;)"5)#/.,# +=F,.;+"8#'()#.;),2AA#-.=M2'#0',)"8'(#./#'()#2,=)4#/.,-)0I#7t),#0);),2A# 9)2,0# ./# )WFA.,26."G# '()# ,)8+=)"'#(20#8.>)"# +"'.# '()# /20'# A2")#./# -.=F,)()"0+;)#4);)A.F=)"'#5"4),# '()#85+42"-)#./# '()#0-+)"6H-#4);)A.F=)"'#-."-)F'I##

<%602++-%5'W1+$#J'\2%&6W'-%'0?"'U)2-%'

#70#'()#F2>),"#./#M2>2A+."0#H8(6"8#."#'()+,#.D"G#-.=F2"+)0#H8(6"8#."#'()+,#.D"G#2"4#);)"#0L5240#H8(6"8#."#'()+,#.D"#(20#)=),8)4G# F,.C)-'0# +";.A;+"8# '5"")A0G# ,);)'=)"'0G# 2"4# +"0'2AA26."# 2"4# ,)F2+,# (2;)# M)-.=)# M+88),# +"# 0-2A)I# 7'# '()# 02=)# 6=)G#+"-."0+0')"-+)0G#05-(#20#2#A2-:#./#=2+"#M2>A)#)L5+F=)"'#2"4#F,)00+"8#4)24A+")0#/.,#(2"4+"8#.;),#-.=FA)')4#F,.C)-'0G#D),)#F,);)"6"8#F,.C)-'0# /,.=# /5AA9# oMA..=+"8Io# i5'# +"# 4)FA.9+"8# '()#D.,:# /.,-)# .,82"+-2AA9G# (2;+"8#=.,)# F).FA)#D20# +"# /2-'# A)24+"8# '.# (.A45F0# +"#D.,:rI#

#1()#,)8+=)"'#,)-)+;)4#+"0',5-6."0#'.#5,8)"'A9#4+8#.5'#2#0()A'),#0);),2A#(5"4,)4#=)'),0#A."8I#oJ.,D2,4#-.==2"4o#',2"0/),,)4#)WF),'0# +"#=2-(+"),9# .F),26."G#=2+"')"2"-)G# 2"4# 4)=.A+6."# '.# /.,=#2# 0=2AA# 4+88+"8# /)"45+# y0L524# '.# M2>2A+."d0+j)# 5"+'zG# 2"4# +'#-."-)"',2')4# 05F),+.,# /.,-)0# '.# ,.AA# .5'# .F),26."0I# J.,# w]# 4290G# h]# o=.5"'2+"# =.;+"8# D2,,+.,0o# /.58('# M,2;)A9# '.# 0260/2-'.,+A9#-.=FA)')#'()#=+00+."G#0)�"8#2#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#0F))4#,)-.,4#/.,#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#/2-+A+'9I##

#1()#o8,))"#A+8('o#D20#8+;)"#2AA#'()#D29#'.#M,+"8#'()#/.AA.D+"8#'.#'()#',..F0X#K2"F.D),#05FF.,'#-.=)0#/,.=#'()#-."0',5-6."#-.=F2"9[# ,)0F."0+M+A+'9# /.,# )L5+F=)"'# 05FF.,'# +0# (2"4)4# .;),# '.# '()# =)-(2"+j)4# -.=F2"9[# ')-("+-2A# 05FF.,'# +0# F,.;+4)4# M9# '()#=2FF+"8# FA2'.."# 2"4# '()# ')-("+-2A# 8,.5F0[# A.8+06-0# 05FF.,'# 2AA.D0# /.,# '()# =2"28)=)"'# ./# '()# 05FFA9# ./# =2'),+2A0# 2'# M2>2A+."#()24L52,'),0I##

c?"'a2)0,'<6'X$0'U"?-%&'0?"'c-3"6'

#B,)0)"'A9G#0?"':^U'290$320"&'#$332%&'#"%0")G#D(+-(#'()#,)8+=)"'#+";)0')4#+"#2"4#4)0+8")4#2"4#M5+A'#."#+'0#.D"G#+0# 5"4),8.+"8# )W')"0+;)# ',+2A0# /.,# '()# H,0'# 6=)# +"# '()# )"8+")),+"8# -.,F0q# +"/.,=26j26."# M5+A4+"8I# 7t),# '()# 25'.=2')4#-.==2"4#-)"'),#+0#-.=FA)')4G#'()#0+'526."0#2'#'()#A.-26."0#./#'()#'5"")A+"8#.F),26."0G#'()#=)-(2"+j)4#)L5+F=)"'#0+')G#2"4#'()#4)'."2'.,#2"4#)WFA.0+;)0#0'.,)(.50)0#D+AA#-.";)"+)"'A9#2FF)2,#."#'()#0-,))"rI###

Page 211: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44M$i9;82#j$

7\!D)J?!22OnF\! AT!r-&?!22OnF\! AT!r-&?!22OnF\!

]!r-(?!22OnF\! AR!X-/?!22OnF\! S\!:#>?!22OnF\!

7]!r-( !f>#*)I%&)(!-&+#*/*%-&+!L)XK+%=A:>FA-/+#:>>F./+#-.A-MN!FF!)>>(.<)I%&!%9!YO!1)$!/*#)0(J!#&1)&<#+!01#!`-)(.0J!)&+!#^<.#&<J!%9!01#.*!<%&$0*-<I%&!4%*=CN!

S7!X-/ !2%&<#*&!%9!$5%=#!)&+!+-$0!.&!0-&&#($C!.&&%;)I;#!L*%((#*!$1-t#*N!)-0%5)0#+!$#(9F$#)(.&/!LgFA-+:H+S-F<ABN!+#;#(%>5#&0!KJ!A&+!X*0J!h&/@!H#/0@!

AR!X-/ !a#4!L#&/.&##*.&/!;#1.<(#!+#$./&#+!KJN!h&/@!H#/0C!L1%(+#*$!%9!+%V#&$!%9!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!*#<%*+$?!.&<(-+.&/!>:.AB<Q+A=..-<0.Y+H::AFY-+F./+/F0<Q+M-E-A>-.ACN!

SA!:#> !'&.0!K)$#+!<%$0!$);.&/$!.&.I)I;#$!9%*!*#<J<(.&/!%9!#B>#&$.;#!+*.((!K.0$C!S\!:#> !G*%E(#!%9!25+*?!Q*+!2%@?!A&+!X*0J?!>)*I<.>)0#+!.&!6+@L-Q+.FG:.F<+/-H-.?-+T:.?AM=TG:.+

,M:a-TA?C!%;#*!()$0!01*##!J#)*$?!)4)*+#+!01#!I0(#!%9!in)&/-)*+!2%5>)&J!.&!a)I%&)(!e#9#&$#!G*%�#<0!2%&$0*-<I%&i!)_#*!L5%$0!$#*.%-$!<);#F.&!*#<#&0(J@N !!

Page 212: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44M$i9;82#j$

Q!a%;?!22OnF\!7Q!a%;?!22OnF\!

7Q!a%; !A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!H#/0@!L$#‡&/!F+.-\+M-T:M/+:H+A=..-<0.Y+H::AFY-+0.+?:[N+\-FLN+F./+,M-TFM0:=?+M:TL+FM-F@N!Y&0#*;.#4!4.01!G%(.I<)(!2%55.$$)*?!"0@!2%(@!d-)&/!r.&>%l!L3#!5-$0?!-&+#*!01#!/-.+)&<#!%9!01#!S\01!2G2!a)I%&)(!2%&/*#$$!$>.*.0?!)+1#*#!0%!01#!$<.#&IE<!+#;#(%>5#&0!<%&<#>0!)&+!)<<%5>(.$1!%-*!+#9#&$#!<%&$0*-<I%&!0)$=$!0%!1./1!$0)&+)*+$?!4.01!F+?-.?-+:H+=MY-.TQ+ABFA+G>-+F./+G/-+\F0A?+H:M+.:+>F.@N!

Page 213: Underground Great Wall

7\!D)J?!22OnF\! AT!r-&?!22OnF\! AT!r-&?!22OnF\!

SA!r-(?!22OnF\! 7[!f<0?!22OnF\! A\!a%;?!22OnF\!

* ".-!Z)%(%&/?!a.-!|.)%`.?!)&+!*#>%*0#*!M#!:%&/: “X<1.#;.&/!G*%/*#$$!O1*%-/1!:<.#&IE<!G()&&.&/?!h&1)&<.&/!y-)(.0J!O1*%-/1!:<.#&IE<!)&+!O#<1&%(%/.<)(!Y&&%;)I%&$?!h&$-*.&/!:)9#0J!O1*%-/1!:<.#&IE<!G*#<)-I%&$!FF!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!d)$!X/).&!X<1.#;#+!H#5)*=)K(#!H#$-(0$!.&!Y0$!:.0#!h&/.&##*.&/!2%&$0*-<I%&C!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!e#>-0J!2%55)&+#*!É1)&/!}-I&/!Xt#&+$!)&+!X++*#$$#$!2%&9#*#&<#!%&! :#<%&+! X*I((#*J! :.0#! h&/.&##*.&/! 2%&$0*-<I%&!3%*=,” d-%�.)&K.&/! Z)%G# vG)*0J! r%-*&)(! %9! 01#! A&+! X*I((#*Jw?! jS6! r)&@! A77]k?! f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*!0*)&$()I%&l!2GGA77]7QSRR\]77\@

3IIp;+=!"#$%&'()*++"),'(#?-"G"6'`"32)J2A+"'`"69+06'-%'!-0"'1$%60)9#*$%SÖ#

#P*%5!01#!2%&9#*#&<#!%&!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!:.0#!vj()"#4+z#Z"8+")),+"8#<."0',5-6."#V.,:#'(2'#-."-A54)4#9)0'),429G#'()#,)F.,'),0#A)2,")4#'()#/.AA.D+"8X#

Å.0$!)<1.#;#5#&0$!4#*#!$>%=#&!1./1(J!%9!KJ!01#!v2#&0*)(w!D.(.0)*J!2%55.$$.%&!)&+!v01#!G"Xw!d#)+`-)*0#*$@!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!e#>-0J!2%55)&+#*! É1)&/!}-I&/!)t#&+#+!)&+!)++*#$$#+! 01#! <%&9#*#&<#!)&+!e#>-0J!21.#9!%9! :0)W!3)&/!É1.5.&! $-55#+!->! ()$0! J#)*x$!4%*=! )&+! %-0(.&#+! >()&$! 9%*! 01.$! J#)*@! ".-! d-)&5.&?! +#>-0J! +.*#<0%*! %9! 01#! "%/.$I<$! e#>)*05#&0! %9! 01#! :#<%&+! X*I((#*J! 2%*>$?!>*#$.+#+!%;#*!01#!<%&9#*#&<#@!

O1#!0)$=$! .&;%(;#+! .&! ()$0!J#)*x$!$.0#! vj()"#4+z#)"8+")),+"8#-."0',5-6."#D),)#9%4)"#"&"%0"&+,'R"-5?0,G# '()#F,.C)-'#&"2&+-%"6'R")"'9%4)"#"&"%0"&+,'*5?0G#2"4#'()#,)L5+,)4#0'2"42,40#D),)#(+8(),# '(2"#);),rI#7'# '()#F,.C)-'#-."0',5-6."#/,."'G# 0?"'G260'%93A")6'$.'

d!"#$%&'()*++"),e'$D#")6'2%&'3"%''2-:A)4#:)9#F,.MA)=0G#.;),-2=)#4+e-5A6)0rI#D(+A)#'()#R2)*3"'4)$b"#0'6944$)0'-2F2M+A+'9#./#+'0#',..F0#(20#M))"#/.,=)4#+"#2"#2AAd,.5"4#D29I#

1()#2-(+);)=)"'#./#05--)00#,)A+)0#."#'()#H,=#-.";+-6."#./#.5,#G260'%93A")6'$.'$D#")6'2%&'3"%'D(.#'..:#F2,'#+"#'()#0+')#yj()"#4+z#)"8+")),+"8#-."0',5-6."G#'()+,#-.AA)-6;)#D+04.=G#2"4#5"+')4#)P.,'0I#

r'()9# (24# )"05,)4# '()# 0260/2-'.,9# F,.8,)00# ./# '()+,# F,.C)-'0# 2"4# M,.:)"#=2"9# ./# '()# ?)-."4# 7,6AA),9q0# ,)-.,40# /.,# 5"4),8,.5"4#-."0',5-6."rI#1()9#(24#05--)00+;)A9# +"',.45-)4#=2"9#F+)-)0#./#-2F+'2A#-."0',5-6."#)L5+F=)"'#./# '()#D.,A4q0#=.0'#24;2"-)4# A);)A#2"4# ;+8.,.50A9# +=F,.;)4# 2"4# +"".;2')4# '()+,# -."0',5-6."# ')-(".A.8+)0I# !"# 0.# 4.+"8G# '()9# (24# ,)0.A;)4# 0);),2A# 4.j)"# -(2AA)"8+"8#F,.MA)=0#,)A2')4#'.# +$%5O&-602%#"'G"%*+2*$%'2%&'63$J"'&-6#?2)5"7'#2G"O&"4$0'#$%60)9#*$%'-%'2)"26'R-0?'9%.2G$)2A+"'5"$+$5-#2+'

#$%&-*$%67'2%&')$95?"%-%5'$.'#$%#)"0"'69).2#"I#70#2#,)05A'G#'()#L52A+'9#./#2#"5=M),#./#0+')#yj()"#4+z#-."0',5-6."#F,.-)00)0G#+"-A54+"8#09%%"+-%57' #$G")-%57' 2%&' -%602++2*$%7' ?2&' )"2#?"&' 0?"' ?-5?"60' 602%&2)&' -%' 0?"' d!"#$%&' ()*++"),[6e' ?-60$),' $.' 6-0"' df?"%' &-e'

#$%60)9#*$%I#

*)F5'9#<.==2"4),#u(2"8#F.+"')4#.5'#+"#(+0#244,)00X#T"+'0#2'#2AA#A);)A0#=50'rI#yDz+'(#2#-.=M2'd,)249#F.0'5,)#2"4#4)'),=+"26."#'.#=))'#'()#,)L5+,)=)"'#'.#D+"#D2,0G#2AA#5"+'0#=50'#8)'#2#8..4#8,20F#./#'()#4)=2"40#./#'()#0+'526."G#,)0.A5')A9#94?$+&'0?"-)'2#092+O#$3A20'602%&2)&6G#2"4#F50(#/.,D2,4G#+"#2#4.D"d'.d)2,'(#=2""),G#'()+,#0+')#yj()"#4+z#)"8+")),+"8#-."0',5-6."#2"4#4)"42)2*$%6'.$)'R2)*3"'4)$b"#0'6944$)0rI#1()9#=50'# /.-50# '()+,#2>)"6."#."#'()#8)"),2A#F,.0F)-'#./#.5,#$G")2++'%2*$%2+'A9-+&-%5'2%&'0?"' +$%5O0")3'&"G"+$43"%0'$.'$9)'!"#$%&'()*++"),'1$)46G#2"4#;+8.,.50A9#-,)2')#2#/2;.,2MA)#2'=.0F(),)#-(2,8)4#D+'(#'()#4)0+,)#'.#D.,:#(2,4G#'.#)-.".=+j)G#2"4#'.#,)2A+j)#M)")H'0G#0.#'(2'#=.")9#-2"#M)#F5'#'.#'()#M)0'#50)I##

Page 214: Underground Great Wall

AS!D)* !O-&&#(!<%&$0*-<I%&!$.0#!4.01!0#5>#*)0-*#!K#(%4!5.&-$!S7!2#($.-$!L*#9#**#+!0%!KJ!#B>#*0$!)$!01#!5%$0!+)&/#*%-$!)&+!5%$0!‚-&&#*;.&/q!>*%�#<0!.&!01#!1.$0%*J!%9!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$q!-&+#*/*%-&+!4%*=$@N!

AQ!D)* !Y&!0#5>#*)0-*#$!K#(%4!5.&-$!A7!+#/*##$!2#($.-$?!01#!L%^<#*$!)&+!5#&!)*#!-$.&/!)!$#(9F+#;#(%>#+!.&$-()0#+!5.B.&/!$0)I%&!0%!>#*9%*5!<%&<*#0#!<%)I&/@N!f01#*!.&;#&I%&$!KJ!01.$!0-&&#(.&/!!-&.0!.&<(-+#!5%K.(#!>%4#*!$4.0<1K%)*+!)&+!<%5>%$.0#!;#&I()I%&!$J$0#5@!

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44[$

L:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!2%&I&-#$!O-&&#(.&/!3%*=?N!jn.+#%!H#>%*0l!2GDA77]SSA]7S\77AC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!]!f<0@!A77]kC!L:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$! .&!A77]?N!jPZ:A77T7A7[AT[Q]6C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?![!P#K@!A77TkC!Lene!2%5>.()I%&!%9!GH2q$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$!.&!‚7]?N!jf:2!:-55)*J!.&!21.&#$#?!D)&+)*.&?!AS!D)*!7]!F!7\!e#<!7]l!2GGA77T7A7Q7S\77SC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?! Q! r)&@! A77TkC! LGH2q$! :#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/! .&!A77\?N!f>#&!:%-*<#! 2#&0#*! jf:2! :-55)*J! SSQ7!MDO! AS!D)*! 7]! F! 7\!e#<! 7]l! PhXA77T7A7[]SR66\C!3)$1.&/0%&?! e2l!f>#&! :%-*<#! 2#&0#*?! \!e#<@!A77]kC! )&+! L2%5>.()I%&!%9! G"Xq$! :#<%&+!X*I((#*J! 2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$l! A77]?N! jY&0#*)<I;#!3#K!G*%+-<0C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!A77Tk@!

AS!D)*?!22OnF\! AQ!D)*?!22OnF\! A6!D)*?!22OnF\!

Page 215: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44[$i9;82#j$

A6!D)* !LqY*%&!]01!2%5>)&J?!A&+!X*0J?!.&!-&+#*/*%-&+!)*#)!41#*#!L()&+$(.+#$!4#*#!;#*J!<%55%&?N!-$#+!&#4!0#<1&%(%/J!)&+!&#4!>*%<#$$#$!0%!%;#*<%5#!01#!+.^<-(I#$!.&!01#!0-&&#(.&/!%>#*)I%&!<)-$#+!KJ!>%%*!/#%(%/.<)(!<%&+.I%&$!)&+!01#!>*%�#<0!4)$!<%5>(#0#+!%&!I5#@N!

R!f<0 !LH)<.&/!)/).&$0!I5#!0%!#&$-*#!01)0!01#.*!>*%�#<0$!<)&!K#!<%5>(#0#+!K#9%*#!4.&0#*!$#0$!.&?!01#!$%(+.#*$!)*#!4%*=.&/!%;#*!SS!1%-*$!)!+)J!.&!01#!0-&&#($!41#*#!0#5>#*)0-*#!*-&$!->!0%!%;#*!R7!+#/*##$!2#($.-$@N!

SS!f<0 !LO1#!0-&&#(!.&!41.<1!01#!Q+!Z)t)(.%&!%9!01#!*#/.5#&0!4%*=$!.$!)!;#*J!0%-/1!#&;.*%&5#&0@N!\!e#< !G)*0J!<%55.t##!5%K.(#!%^<#!j<%5>*.$.&/!<%55.t##!5#5K#*$!)&+!0#<1&.<)(!#B>#*0$k!

9%*5#+!0%!1#(>!$%(;#!>*%K(#5$!#&<%-&0#*#+!KJ!01#!/*)$$*%%0$!$#*;.<#5#&!)&+!>*#;#&0!01#!%<<-**#&<#!%9!<%&$0*-<I%&F*#()0#+!)<<.+#&0$@!

R!f<0?!22OnF\! SS!f<0?!22OnF\! \!e#<?!22OnF\!

Page 216: Underground Great Wall

_'8S&,'X<'-.2$V,'(6,E$<G88.($$

LO-&&#(.&/!.&!21.&)?N!%>!<.0C!Ly.&/1).FO.K#0!H).(4)J!e).(J!e*).&)/#!n%(-5#!d.0$!a#4!H#<%*+?N!1+M)'n"A+")?!jA77T@SA@Q7k!)0!s!1t>lbb<1.&)IK#0@>#%>(#@<%5@<&b[]6[7RS@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SA!r-&#!A7S7wC!)&+!Wang J.Y., “Tunneling and Technological Progress in Tunneling in China,” op cit.!

c!0%0)(!(#&/01!%9![6@Q!=.(%5#0#*$!

Page 217: Underground Great Wall

B'('2,"E$a'S&6,E$@;872"G92';8$'8$<'-.2$

Ld./14)J!0-&&#(!0%!O.K#0x$!D#0%=!<%5>(#0#+?N!?+"2#Z"8A+0(?!jA7S7@SA@S6k?!)0!s1t>lbb#&/(.$1@$.&)@<%5b<1.&)b>bA7S7bSAS6bQ6AS]\@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S]!r)&@!A7SSw@!

Page 218: Underground Great Wall

O0<0AFMQ+S0YB\FQ+#:.?AM=TG:.+0.+W0U-A+

bƊÀ�ƌŸƔ>ŤŶ!�4�:ĈE!M)(%&/!")!2).*&!O-&&#(!$5%%01(J!01*%-/1!#B0*#5#(J!#B<.0#+!$%(+.#*$w?i!21.&)5.(?!jA7S7@SA@S6k?!)0!s!1t>lbb0>@<1.&)5.(@<%5@<&bV0bA7S7bA7S7FSAbS6b<%&0#&0~RQ6QTSQ@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S]!r)&@!A7SSw@!

Page 219: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44[$i9;82#j$

! !"# $%%wG# <.A.")A# u()"8q0# ,)8+=)"'# D20# '20:)4# '.# M5+A4# '()# H,0'# 0',2')8+-# =+00+A)# 0+')# +"# 1+M)'I# V+'(.5'#F,.;+4+"8#=5-(#+"/.,=26."#2M.5'#'()#")D#0',2')8+-#=+00+A)#0+')G#'()#4.-5=)"'2,9#=)"6."0#'(2'#'()#=+00+A)#0+')#+0#A.-2')4#+"#2#=.5"'2+".50#2,)2#2'#2"#2A6'54)#./#.;),#gG%%%#=)'),0I#

#1+M)'q0#(2,0(#)";+,."=)"'#2"4#0-2,-+'9#./#.W98)"#2'#2#(+8(#2A6'54)#F.0)4#2#=2C.,#-(2AA)"8)#'.#'()#=+00+A)#0+')#F,.C)-'I# !"# A+8('#./# '()# 0+'526."G#<.A.")A# u()"8#H,0'#M5+A'#2#D)AAd)L5+FF)4#D.,:# -2=FG#2"#.W98)"#8)"),26."#0'26."#2"4#2#D2'),#F5,+H-26."#0'26."I#nW98)"#D20#F+F)4#4.D"#'.#'()#F,.C)-'q0#D.,:#0+')0#4))F#+"'.#2#=.5"'2+"I#

! Y&! X>*.(! A77\?! 01#! 5.$$.(#!$.0#! >*%�#<0! $0)*0#+! )&+! 1)+!<%&I&-#+! 9%*! A77! +)J$! I((! .0!4)$!<%5>(#0#+@! O1#! >()&&#+! 5.$$.(#!$.0#! 4)$! <)*;#+! %-0! %9! )! 1.((!01*%-/1!()J#*$!%9!>#*#&&.)(!9*%V#&!$%.($@!O1#!>*%�#<0!-I(.V#+!)&!)**)J!%9! 5%+#*&! 0-&&#(! K%*.&/!5)<1.&#$@!O1#!$5%%01.&/!K()$I&/!0#<1&.`-#$! 4#*#! $-<<#$$9-((J!)>>(.#+?!41.<1!#;#&0-)((J!$>#+!->!01#!#&I*#!>*%�#<0@!

!O1#!+%<-5#&0)*J!.&+.<)0#$!01)0! ->%&! 01#! <%5>(#I%&! %9! 01#!>*%�#<0?! 01#!#&/.&##*.&/! *#/.5#&0!`-.<=(J! >-((#+! %-0?! 01-$! )((%4.&/!.55#+.)0#! 5.$$.(#! +#>(%J5#&0!%>#*)I%&$@!

A6!D)*!A77]?!22OnF\!

@K=0</0.Y+AB-+(0M?A+O0??0<-+&0A-+0.+W0U-Ao!

Played on PRC national CCTV, (25 Mar. 2008); from OSC (3 Feb. 2009): CPP20090203017001.

Page 220: Underground Great Wall

%V@$<.(.b'7';8$V.);"27$;:$B'77'(.$=G'(FG)$U));7'2.$W8F',$

:<*##&!$1%0$!9*%5!Y9#&/!On!vd%&/!o%&/wl!LG"X!D.$$.(#$!X.5#+!)0!Y&+.)?N!<(+")0)#K+A+'2,9#vK(%/w?!jA7S7@SS@SQk?!!)0!s!1t>lbb444@<1.&#$#F)*5J@<%5bz>c\!u!v)<<#$$#+!Q7!a%;@!A7S7w@!

H).(!5%;#5#&0!%9!D.$$.(#!'&.0$!!

D.$$.(#!e#>(%J5#&0!.&!O.K#0!

e-)(F<)>)K(#!ePFAS!YHZD!

e-)(F<)>)K(#!ePFSS!YHZD!

Page 221: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2E$O<g$b7#$W8F',$

L�����l���������������m!vY&+.)!0%!K#!2*)VJl!21.&)x$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!.&!Y&+.)!9%*!hB#*<.$#!:B>%$-*#w?N!7,=9#J.,5=G#jA77T@7\@7Ak!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@I#B-#@&#0b>%$0A~Q[]7A]]~S@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SS!D)J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

?--+.-1A+?<0/-+

Page 222: Underground Great Wall

!.)(;E3.82$;:$/8F$*"2'((."E$B'77'(.7$2;$<'-.2!

Page 223: Underground Great Wall

%&;2;7$;:$<G88.($@;872"G92';8$'8$<'-.2$

@M {�Ģ>Aƣ!中国建成重大国防工程!{Y&+.)&!d#)+!:4%*+m!21.&)!.&0%!)!D)�%*!e#9#&$#!G*%�#<0vw?N!15:5dK+A+'2,9?!jA7S7@SS@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb0-=-@5.(.0)*J@<1.&)@<%5b5.(.0)*Jb105(bA7S7FSSFS[bS6\]AA~S66T]TT@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

E.;)=M),#\hG#$%\%G#'()#<(+")0)#.e-+2A#=)4+2#(2;)#,)F.,')4#=2C.,#N2"j(.5#K+A+'2,9#3)8+."#<.,F0#./#Z"8+")),0#+0#'()#,../#./#'()#D.,A4#0'))A#0.A4+),0G#'()#")D0#0588)0')4#'.#<(+"2#/,.=#'()#9)2,#$%%g#2#'.'2A#./#0);)"#9)2,0#+"#'()#D)0'),"#s+"8(2+d1+M)'#BA2')25#2A6'54)#./#gGh%%#=)'),0#2M.;)#'()#FA2')25#+"'.#2M0.A5')#Y+#4)/)"0)#F,.C)-'0I##

Page 224: Underground Great Wall

RD#+OF,+&B:\.+\0AB+"-\?+D-,:MA+

@M {�Ģ>Aƣ!中国建成重大国防工程!{Y&+.)&!d#)+!:4%*+m!21.&)!.&0%!)!D)�%*!e#9#&$#!G*%�#<0vw?N!15:5dK+A+'2,9?!jA7S7@SS@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb0-=-@5.(.0)*J@<1.&)@<%5b5.(.0)*Jb105(bA7S7FSSFS[bS6\]AA~S66T]TT@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 225: Underground Great Wall

#:.?AM=TG:.+WM::,?+0.+(M:.A+:H+\BFA+F,,-FM?+A:+U-+*(d42+AQ,-+?<F.A-/+W=..-<+R:MAF<+F?+FA+Å=.>0.Y+

@��������! !{Y&+.)&!d#)+!:4%*+m!21.&)!.&0%!)!D)�%*!e#9#&$#!G*%�#<0vw?N!15:5dK+A+'2,9?!jA7S7@SS@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb0-=-@5.(.0)*J@<1.&)@<%5b5.(.0)*Jb105(bA7S7FSSFS[bS6\]AA~S66T]TT@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

_+

Page 226: Underground Great Wall

AR!r)& !a)I%&)(!+#9#&$#!>*%�#<0!L.$!.&!<*.I<)(!$0)/#N!4.01!A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!H#/0@!+#)(.&/!4.01!+)&/#*%-$!<);#F.&$@!!!e#>@H#/@25+*l!LO1.$!4%*=.&/!9)<#!.$!)!<()J!.&0#*<)()I%&@!Y9!.0!.$!&%0!>*%5>0(J!K-t*#$$#+?!.0!5)J!<);#!.&!)0!)&J!5%5#&0@!O1)0!.$!41J!4#!<)&&%0!)W%*+!0%!$0%>@N!

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$

AR!r)&?!22OnF\! AR!r)&?!22OnF\! AR!r)&?!22OnF\!

Ln.+#%!%9!GH2!D.(.0)*J!X<I;.I#$!%9!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$l!D)J!A77\?N!j2GGA77\7[A[7Q677]C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!QS!D)J@!A77\kC!LGH2q$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$! .&!A77T?N!jPhXA7S77A7T77SA\6C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!T!P#K@! A7S7kC! Lene! 2%5>.()I%&! %9! GH2q$! :#<%&+! X*I((#*J! 2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/! X<I;.I#$! .&! A77T?N! jL2GGA7S77A7T7Q677S?! f:2! :-55)*J! .&!21.&#$#?!D)&+)*.&!7S!P#K!7\!F!7Q!a%;!7\C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!T!P#K@!A7S7kC!!LGH2q$! :#<%&+! X*I((#*J! 2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/! .&! A77\?N! f>#&! :%-*<#! 2#&0#*! jf:2! :-55)*J! 7S! P#K! 7\! F! 7Q! a%;! 7\l! PhXA77]7A766ARAA]C!3)$1.&/0%&?! e2l! f>#&! :%-*<#! 2#&0#*?! 6! P#K@! A77]kC! )&+! L2%5>.()I%&! %9! G"Xq$! :#<%&+! X*I((#*J! 2%*>$! O-&&#(.&/! X<I;.I#$l!A77T?N!jY&0#*)<I;#!3#K!G*%+-<0C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!A7S7k@!

2%&$0)&0!+)&/#*!%9!<);#F.&$! '&+#*/*%-&+!4)0#*!(#)=)/#!>*%K(#5! hB0#*&)(!,!%-0$.+#!/*%-&+!(#;#(!FF!<%*#!$)5>(#*!!'&+#*/*%-&+!4)0#*!(#)=)/#!>*%K(#5!d#);J!#5>1)$.$!%&!2%55)&+!.&$>#<I%&!

Page 227: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$i9;82#j$

A[!r)& !3.;#$!K*.&/!L�.)%V.N!v+-5>(.&/$w!0%!0-&&#(!9%*!0*%%>$!0%!<#(#K*)0#!a#4!}#)*$!41.(#!4%*=.&/C!

A[!r)&?!22OnF\! A[!r)&?!22OnF\!d)>>J!d%(.+)J$m!3.;#$!>*#>)*#!a#4!}#)*$!L�.)%V.N!-&+#*/*%-&+!

A[!r)&?!22OnF\!O*%%>$!#)0!a#4!}#)*$!5#)(!.&!0-&&#($!

AR!r)&?!22OnF\! AR!r)&?!22OnF\! AR!r)&?!22OnF\!

Page 228: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$i9;82#j$

Q7!r)& !h&/*@!H#/0@!A&+!X*0J!,!L$%5#!%9!01#!<%&$0*-<I%&!$.0#$!*#`-.*#!01)0!4%*=!K#!+%&#!.&!%&#!$0*#0<1Å@!%^<#*$!)&+!5#&!)*#!$0)J.&/!.&!01#.*!*#$>#<I;#!>%$0$!+-*.&/!01#!9#$I;#!$#)$%&@N!!G%(.I<)(!2%55.$$)*!%9!A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!H#/0@?!3)&/!Z)%/-%!j(%4#*!(#_?!*#+!1)0k?!L1)$!K##&!4%*=.&/!.&!0-&&#($!9%*!%;#*!01*##!+#<)+#$@N!

AA!D)* !O-&&#(!0*%%>$!-$.&/!L)!&#4!0J>#!%9!>%*0)K(#!%BJ/#&!*#$>.*)0%*!0).(%*F5)+#!9%*!01.$!-&.0x$!+*.((!<)**.)/#!%>#*)0%*$?!9%*!01#!E*$0!I5#?!0%!#W#<I;#(J!>*%0#<0!01#5$#(;#$!9*%5!+-$0!>%((-I%&@N!!

A6!X>* !'&+#*/*%-&+!Lh&/.&##*.&/!Y&$0)(()I%&!H#/.5#&0N!$%(;#$!LK%t(#&#<=!>*%K(#5$@N!LH#<#&0(J?!)!<%*#!$)5>(#*!v(%4#*!*./10w!01)0!1)+!K##&!.5>*%;#+!KJ!01#!$%(+.#*$!%9!01.$!*#/.5#&0!4)$!)>>(.#+!)0!01#!$-*;#J.&/!>%.&0$!9%*!5-(I>(#!5.$$.(#!$.0#$@!O1.$!4)$!01#!A]01!.&&%;)I%&!%-0<%5#!%9!01#!*#/.5#&0!$.&<#!01#!.&0*%+-<I%&!%9!01#!iM%(+#&!Y+#)i!)4)*+@!

AA!D)*?!22OnF\! A6!X>*?!22OnF\!Q7!r)&?!22OnF\!

G%(.I<)(!2%55.$$)*!3)&/!Z)%/-%?!Q7!J*$!.&!0-&&#($! a#4!0-&&#(!*#$>.*)0%*! hB0#*&)(!,!%-0$.+#!/*%-&+!(#;#(!FF!<%*#!$)5>(#*!!

Page 229: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$

AA!D)J !G*%E(#!%9!2%55)&+#*!%9!A&+!X*0J!Lh&/.&##*.&/!Y&$0)(()I%&!H#/.5#&0N!)0!<%5>(#I%&!%9!+#9#&$#!>*%�#<0!FF!4.01!+.$<-$$.%&!%9!<*.I<)(!.5>%*0)&<#!%9!L`-)(.0JN!<%&$0*-<I%&!)&+!1#(>!%9!<.;.(.)&!*#K-.(+.&/!j.&!)++.I%&!0%!5.(.0)*J!+-I#$k!.&!>%$0F#)*01`-)=#!)*#)$l!

#RI#&2G"+,$"366?.0N"$0#+,XI0@$"#$%&$(")B$#0+&)27")("%07+"N$0#K"Y,02G"%$.",&7"$2+&#$"#$G&*$2+"+)"#$8I&%."&2(#07+#I'+I#$"02.",$%B"7)%;$"+,$"B#)8%$*7"(0'&2G");$#"Q66K666";&'+&*7"&2"+,$&#".0&%N"%&($"0+"

3Z"+$*B)#0#N"7$++%$*$2+7="

"10#%N"+,&7"N$0#K"9,$2"0"20+&)20%".$($27$"B#)F$'+"907"')*B%$+$.K"+,$"0*)I2+")("7+$$%"I7$."907");$#"

()I#"*$+#&'"+)27"%$77"+,02")#&G&20%%N"B%022$.="

":,)#+%N"0(+$#"+,$":B#&2G"[$7+&;0%"+,&7"N$0#K"+,$"$2G&2$$#&2G"#$G&*$2+"#$'$&;$."02"I#G$2+"

077&G2*$2+S="RI#&2G"0"7B)+"',$'@K"\+,$"12G#="M$G&*$2+0%"-)**02.$#]"S"2)+&'$."0"'#0'@")2"02"

$AB027&)2"7'#$9="^$"&**$.&0+$%N"&27+#I'+$."+,$")B$#0+)#7"+)".)I8%$?',$'@"0%%"+,$"7'#$97"&2"+,$"

70*$"80+',")2$"8N")2$=">;$#"_6"7&*&%0#"B#)8%$*7"9$#$"$AB)7$.K"9,$#$IB)2"S"\+,$"12G#="

M$G&*$2+0%"-)**02.$#]")#.$#$."')*B#$,$27&;$"#$9)#@&2G='

\!a%; !LY&!01#!$0*)0#/.<!5.$$.(#!9%*<#?!01#*#!.$!)&%01#*!-&.0!01)0!1)$!&#;#*!0)=#&!>)*0!.&!01#!()-&<1!%9!)&J!5.$$.(#!%*!#;#&!$##&!)!5.$$.(#@!O1.$!.$!01#!#&/.&##*.&/!-&.0!%9!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$?!5)+#!->!%9!)&!#&/.&##*.&/!1#)+`-)*0#*$!)&+!)&!#&/.&##*.&/!0#<1&%(%/J!/#&#*)(!-&.0@!O1#J!)*#!)($%!=&%4&!)$!&#$0!K-.(+#*$!9%*!5.$$.(#$@!O1#.*!1)*+!4%*=!)&+!`-.#0!+#+.<)I%&!1);#!<*#)0#+!01#$#!5%+#*&!i-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)(($i!*-&&.&/!01*%-/1!01#!K%4#($!%9!0)((!5%-&0).&$@N!

L:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!O-&&#(.&/!X<I;.I#$!.&!A77\?N!jSA!P#K@!A77]kC!PZ:A77]7ASA\QSQ[!

Page 230: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$i9;82#j$

AR!r)& !a)I%&)(!+#9#&$#!>*%�#<0!L.$!.&!<*.I<)(!$0)/#@N!A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!H#/0@!e#)(.&/!4.01!+)&/#*%-$!<);#F.&$C!3)&/!Z)%/-%?!>%(.I<)(!<%55.$$)*!%9!A&+!X*0J!h&/*@!H#/0@!j(%4#*!*./10?!*#+!1)0k?!L1)$!K##&!4%*=.&/!.&!0-&&#($!9%*!%;#*!01*##!+#<)+#$@N!

AA!D)J !G*%E(#!%9!2%55)&+#*!%9!A&+!X*0J!Lh&/.&##*.&/!Y&$0)(()I%&!H#/.5#&0N!)0!<%5>(#I%&!%9!+#9#&$#!>*%�#<0!FF!4.01!+.$<-$$.%&!%9!<*.I<)(!.5>%*0)&<#!%9!L`-)(.0JN!<%&$0*-<I%&!)&+!1#(>!%9!<.;.(.)&!*#K-.(+.&/!j.&!)++.I%&!0%!5.(.0)*J!+-I#$k!.&!>%$0F#)*01`-)=#!)*#)$l!

\!a%; !LY&!01#!$0*)0#/.<!5.$$.(#!9%*<#?!01#*#!.$!)&%01#*!-&.0!01)0!1)$!&#;#*!0)=#&!>)*0!.&!01#!()-&<1!%9!)&J!5.$$.(#!%*!#;#&!$##&!)!5.$$.(#@!O1.$!.$!01#!#&/.&##*.&/!-&.0!%9!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$?!5)+#!->!%9!)&!#&/.&##*.&/!1#)+`-)*0#*$!)&+!)&!#&/.&##*.&/!0#<1&%(%/J!/#&#*)(!-&.0@!O1#J!)*#!)($%!=&%4&!)$!&#$0!K-.(+#*$!9%*!5.$$.(#$@!O1#.*!1)*+!4%*=!)&+!`-.#0!+#+.<)I%&!1);#!<*#)0#+!01#$#!5%+#*&!i-&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)(($i!*-&&.&/!01*%-/1!01#!K%4#($!%9!0)((!5%-&0).&$@N!

AA!D)J?!22OnF\! 6!D)J?!22OnF\!

Page 231: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$i9;82#j$

X((!>1%0%$!9*%5!LG"Xq$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!0%!2*#)0#!)!DJ$0#*.%-$!‚'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((?N!%9!SQ!e#<@!A77T?!!%>!<.0@!

Page 232: Underground Great Wall

7\!a%;?!22On!

XK%;#! >1%0%l! D).&! D.$$.(#! Z)J!4.01! +%-K(#! 0*)<=! *).($! (%%=.&/!$%-01! 9*%5! &%*01! #&0*)&<#! U%%*@!H./10! >1%0%l! :)5#! D).&! D.$$.(#!Z)J! (%%=.&/! &%*01! 9*%5! $<)9%(+!)K%;#! $%-01! #&0*)&<#@! P.(5!$1%4&! %&! \! a%;@! A77T?! &)I%&)(!22OnF\@!:<*##&!$1%0$!9*%5l!LG"Xq$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!0%!2*#)0#!)!DJ$0#*.%-$! ‚'&+#*/*%-&+! M*#)0!3)((?N!%9!SQ!e#<@!A77T?!!%>!<.0@!

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$i9;82#j$

7\!a%;?!22On!

Page 233: Underground Great Wall

LG"Xq$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!2*#)0#$!)!DJ$0#*.%-$!‚'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((?N!%9!SQ!e#<@!A77T?!!%>!<.0@!

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/44N$i9;82#j$

7\!a%;?!!22On!

7\!a%;?!!22On!

7\!a%;?!22On!

XK%;#l! E&.$1#+! -&+#*/*%-&+!()-&<1#*! $0%*)/#! K)J! 4.01!+%-K(#!0*)<=!*).(C!(#_l!K)J!+%%*$!%>#&.&/C! *./10l! K)J! +%%*$!<(%$.&/@!

Page 234: Underground Great Wall

2JpJ+l+

3IIJ+

Page 235: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/454$

AS!f<0 !v3)&/!d).(%&/?!K)t)(.%&!<%55)&+#*!%9!)&!#&/.&##*.&/!-&.0?!:X2w!Y&!01#!>)$0?!0%!$->>%*0!$-<1!)!$#<I%&?!.0!-$#+!0%!0)=#!S6!>#%>(#!4%*=.&/!01*##!+)J$@!a%4?!4.01!%-*!.&+#>#&+#&0(J!+#;#(%>#+!K-t*#$$!;#1.<(#?!01#!�%K!<)&!K#!+%&#!KJ!#./10!>#%>(#!.&!%&#!+)J@!

SS!D)* !v3)&/!".>.&/?!>%(.I<)(!<%55.$$)*?!h&/.&##*.&/!e#$./&!X<)+#5J?!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$w!e-*.&/!01#!>#*.%+!%9!01#!SS01!P.;#F}#)*!G*%/*)5?!4#!0%%=!>)*0!.&!01#!-&+#*/*%-&+!*).(4)J!).*!+#9#&$#!$1#(0#*!>*%�#<0$!.&!Z#.�.&/?!a)&�.&/?!:1#&J)&/?!e)(.)&?!)&+!21)&/<1-&@!X!()*/#!&-5K#*!%9!)+;)&<#+!0#<1&%(%/.#$!)&+!%-0$0)&+.&/!+#$./&$!4#*#!)>>(.#+!

A\!f<0 !O%+)J?!M%&/!|.)%K.&!)&+!01#!0#)5!(#+!KJ!1.5!>#*9%*5#+!)!*#>#)0!$-*;#J!%9!)!&)I%&)(!+#9#&$#!>*%�#<0!%9!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!)&+!A-./-M-/+F+M-,:MA+T:.AF0.0.Y+AB-+/FAF+:H+>:M-+ABF.+2II+<:TFG:.?@!O1#!#&/.&##*.&/!0#)5!<1#<=#+!01#!+)0)!)&+!9%-&+!01#5!#**%*F9*##@!

AS!f<0%K#*?!22OnF\!

A\!f<0?!!22OnF\!

Leneb3#K!G*%+-<0!%9!GH2!D.(.0)*J!X<I;.0#$!.&!f<0!S7?N!jPhXA7SS7SAR7SQ[[[C!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!RFQ7!f<0@kC!)&+!!Ln.+#%l!GH2!G"X?!GXGP!O)=#!G)*0!.&!o#J!G*%�#<0$!e-*.&/!SS01!P.;#F}#)*!G*%/*)5?N!j2GGA7SS76767R]77S?!3)$1.&/0%&!e2l!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!S!D)*<1!SSk!

SS!D)*?!22OnF\!

Page 236: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/454$i9;82#j$

S6!D)J !O1#!*#>%*0!$)J$!01)0!01#!*#5%0#F<%&0*%((#+!0-&&#(.&/!5)<1.&#!1)$!)!*%K%I<!)*5!01)0!<)&!0-*&!Q[7!+#/*##$!)&+!<)&!K#!*#5%0#(J!<%&0*%((#+!9*%5!4.01.&!)!A77F5#0#*!*)+.-$@!O1#!5)<1.&#!<)&!K%*#!)!A6F5#0#*F+##>!1%(#!)0!%&#!I5#?!01#!*#>%*0!$)J$@!3%*=#*$!<)&!-$#!01.$!5)<1.&#!%&!1)V)*+%-$!0#**).&?!01#!*#>%*0!$)J$@!

S6!D)J?!22OnF|.&4#&!

S6!D)J?!22OnF|.&4#&!

S6!D)J?!22OnF|.&4#&!

S6!D)J?!22OnF|.&4#&!

S6!D)J?!22OnF|.&4#&!

La#4!O-&&#(.&/!D)<1.&#!.&!G"X!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!h&/.&##*.&/!'&.0?C+i2GGA7SS76S[7\A77SC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!S6!D)J!SSk!

S6!D)J?!22OnF:.&4#&!

Page 237: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$<G88.('8SH$/455$$

Leneb3#K!G*%+-<0!%9!GH2!D.(.0)*J!X<I;.I#$!.&!P#K!SS?N!jPhXA7SS7RA77S\7ARC!f>#&!:%-*<#!2#&0#*?!3)$1.&/0%&!e2l!7AFA\!P#K!SSk!

D)J?!!22OnFSQ!

D)J?!!22OnFSQ!

D)J?!!22OnFSQ!

D)J?!!22OnFSQ!

D)J?!!22OnFSQ!

D)J?!!22OnFSQ!

Page 238: Underground Great Wall

@;82",92$@;872"G92';8$;:$R8F."S";G8F$!.:.87.7$(

a%0!)((!O-&&#($!)*#!K-.(0!KJ!01#!G"X!

Y((-$0*)I%&$!9*%5l!i国防工程 ve#9#&$#!G*%�#<0$w?i!U).A.8+-2A#1)2=#./#u()C+2"8?!u()C+2"8#15"")A#Z"8+")),+"8#<.=F2"9G#!jA77T@7Q@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@+V`.+-.@<%5b&#4$:1%4@)$>z.+cR7Q!!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 239: Underground Great Wall

@;82",92$@;872"G92';8$;:$R8F."S";G8F$!.:.87.7$(

Y((-$0*)I%&$!9*%5l!i国防工程 ve#9#&$#!G*%�#<0$w?i!U).A.8+-2A#1)2=#./#u()C+2"8?!u()C+2"8#15"")A#Z"8+")),+"8#<.=F2"9G#!jA77T@7Q@S[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@+V`.+-.@<%5b&#4$:1%4@)$>z.+cR7Q!!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

a%0!)((!O-&&#($!)*#!K-.(0!01#!G"X!

Page 240: Underground Great Wall

P!"#$%(L/#3*'()$*+,-,./$*([0,+%1(2%33&(;-%#$'1(\/7+(;11%57W"(

1()#<(+")0)#7,=9#+0#M)A+);)4#'.#(2;)#A9-+0'2%'9%&")5)$9%&'W8)"20'Z2++W'0?20'60)"0#?"6'.$)'3$)"'0?2%'M7III'J3'+"#'()#_)M)+#,)8+."#./#".,'(),"#<(+"2I#<+6"8#'()#B).FA)q0#N+M),26."#7,=9q0#.e-+2A#")D0A)>),G#'()#12#Q5"8#B2.#42+A9#./# _."8# Q."8# ."# ?2'5,429# 02+4# <(+"2q0# 0',2')8+-#=+00+A)# 0L524,."G# '()# ?)-."4#7,6AA),9# *+;+0+."G# M5+A'# 2#=200+;)#5"4),8,.5"4#'5"")A#'.#-."-)2A#"5-A)2,#D)2F."0G#+"-A54+"8#'()#*."8/)"8#h#+"'),-."6")"'2A#M2AA+06-#=+00+A)#D+'(#2#,2"8)#./#\fG%%%#:=I##

!-%#"'HggM7'0?"'!"#$%&'()*++"),'C-G-6-$%'?26'3$A-+-f"&'0"%6'$.'0?$962%&6'$.'6$+&-")6'0$'A9-+&'2'%"0R$)J'$.'09%%"+6'

60)"0#?-%5' .$)'3$)"' 0?2%' M7III' J3'A"+$R' 0?"'3$9%02-%' )"5-$%6' $.'\"A"-7'<(+"2q0# 0'2')d,5"# <<1m# ,)F.,')4I# o7#=+00+A)#M20)#(20#M))"#M5+A'#(5"4,)40#./#=)'),0#5"4),8,.5"4#2"4#-2"#D+'(0'2"4#0);),2A#"5-A)2,#2>2-:0Go#<<1m#02+4I#oB).FA)#,)/),#'.#'()#")'D.,:#./#'5"")A0#-."")-6"8#'.#'()#=+00+A)#M20)#20#'()#qT"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AAIqS##

o1()#)2,A9#;),0+."#./#<(+"2q0#=+4d#'.#A."8d,2"8)#=+00+A)0#(24#2AA#M))"#4)FA.9)4#2M.;)#8,.5"4#2"4#D),)#;5A"),2MA)#'.#4)')-6."#M9#0F9#02')AA+')0#2"4#2>2-:0#M9#+"'),-)F'.,#=+00+A)0I#1(2'#F,.=F')4#'()#<(+")0)#=+A+'2,9#'.#=.;)#2AA#./#'()+,# =+00+A)0# (5"4,)40# ./# =)'),0# 5"4),8,.5"4Io# 70# 2# ,)05A'7' 0?"' 6N92&)$%6' $.' 0?"' aV(' &"4+$,"&' 0?")"' 2)"'#$34+"0"+,'9%&"0"#02A+"'A"#296"'0?",'2)"'A26"&'-%'69A0"))2%"2%'A9%J")6'2%&'3$G"'2)$9%&'A"%"20?'0?"'69).2#"E''

1()#F5,F.0)#./#'()#0)-,)'A9#-."0',5-')4#5"4),8,.5"4#U,)2'#V2AA# +0#'.#8+;)#<(+"2#2#0)-."4#-(2"-)#2t),#2#"5-A)2,#2>2-:G# =+A+'2,9# )WF),'0# 02+4I# 1()# =2+"# .MC)-6;)# ./# '()# ?)-."4# 7,6AA),9# *+;+0+."# +0# '.# M)# 2MA)# '.# A25"-(# 2#-.5"'),2>2-:#282+"0'#)")=9#'2,8)'0#2t),#)0-2F+"8#'()#H,0'#;.AA)9#./#2>2-:0I##

1()# 12# Q5"8# B2.# 42+A9# ,)F.,')4# '(2'# -0' R26' 9%4)"#"&"%0"&' .$)' 0?"' aV([6' %"R6+"h")' 0$' )"G"2+' #+266-i"&'-%.$)32*$%'2A$90'0?"'09%%"+6'2%&'0?20'0?-6'&"3$%60)20"6'U"-b-%5[6'#$%i&"%#"'-%'-06'3-+-02),'4$R")E ''

“China Builds Underground 'Great Wall' Against Nuke Attack,” Chosun Ilbo, [Seoul, ROK Daily], (14 December 2009), translated by OSC KPP20091214971047.

&:=AB+Å:M-F.+"-\?,F,-M+

&0>0<FM+T:E-MFY-+0.+cF,F.N+WF0\F.N+D=??0F+F./+RFL0?AF.N+U=A+.:A+AB-+!Z&ZZ+

Page 241: Underground Great Wall

OG2G".$W77G.7$

•! :->>%*I&/!)&!f>#*)I%&)(!'&+#*/*%-&+!–! "%/.$I<$!–! D).&0#&)&<#!–! O*).&.&/!–! D%K.(.V)I%&bP.#(+!:-$0).&)K.(.0J!

•! :-*/.&/!")*/#*?!"%&/#*FH)&/#!D.$$.(#$!–! 2)&!'&+#*/*%-&+!Y2ZD$!K#!:-*;.;)K(#!g!2*#+.K(#z!

•! :0*)0#/.<!2%&<#>0!9%*!G%(.I<)(!Y5>)<0!–! Y&0*)F4)*!e#0#**#&<#!)&+!h$<)()I%&!e%5.&)&<#!–! H#/.%&)(!e.$$-)$.%&!–! X*5$!2%&0*%(!4.01%-0!n#*.E<)I%&!

Page 242: Underground Great Wall

B;82&(E$*(."27$I$<",'8'8S$

:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!.$!%&(J!%&<#!)!5%&01!(.;#F)<I%&!$.5-()I%&!%9!K%5K!0-*&#+!%-0!0%!v��l������������������@@@w?!K+A+'2,9#<(+"2?!jA6!D)*<1!A7S7k!)0!s!1t>lbb5.(.0)*J@<1.&)@<%5bV1~<&b.5>%*0)&0bSS76A\\SbA7S77QA6bS6][T\[6@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!AT!D)*@!S7w@!

Page 243: Underground Great Wall

!1?0%#K$k1>'S#$?01?#?@1'

“PLA Second Artillery Brigade Conducts Year-End Assessment Exercise,” Military Report, CCTV-7 [Beijing, WMV in Mandarin 32 sec], (2009.11.29) at [translated by OSC CPM20100129017079, accessed 3 June 2010].

Page 244: Underground Great Wall

+;0./#01>'Y.F$H0$@H'

“Second Artillery Corps Logistics Department Improves Fast-Track Comprehensive Support Capability,” CCTV-7 [Beijing, WMV: 1 min 15 sec in Mandarin], (2009.11.27) at [OSC CPM20100129017042: “PLA Second Artillery Unit Conducts Comprehensive Logistics Support Exercise;” accessed 1 June 2010].

Page 245: Underground Great Wall

S$HH$K1'(1]K.\/1?0'X*#)$!%9!H#>%*0#+!O-&&#(.&/!:0)/#$+

Map from: Mark A. Stokes and Ian Easton, Evolving Aerospace Trends in the Asia-Pacific Region, (monograph; Washington, DC: The Project 2049 Institute, 27 May 2010), pp. 8, 39. Tunnel stages estimated on the basis of PRC reference and reporting.

!./-MYM:=./+&AFY-?;+2J78d2Jp5+++'.HMF?AM=TA=M-+

2Jp5d2JJ6+++'#KO+&0<:?N+&DwODKO+W=..-<?+

2JJ6d3IIJ+++*(d32+'DKO+W=..-<?+

3II6d3IIJ++*(d42+'#KO+W=..-<?+

3I2Id3I3I++DF0<wD:F/+*(d52+'#KO!

++'#KO+&0<:?N+&DwODKO+W=..-<?+

_+

_+

E2"92"8!0-&&#(!<%5>(#B!

Q5"=+"8!0-&&#(!!<%5>(#B!

Page 246: Underground Great Wall

(0M0.Y+R:?0G:.+44‚25q34Z72C"+223‚28q6IZJ5C+

(0M0.Y+R:?0G:.?+44‚23q56Z8pC"+223‚2pq67ZppC)+

!OXe5*$W@=B$@;3)(.Z$]?$;:$],8E,8S$$

(0M0.Y+R:?0G:.?+

(0M0.Y+R:?0G:.+44‚27q44ZIIC"+223‚3IqI7Z5JC+

W=..-<+#:>,<-1-?+44‚22q58Z53C"+223‚2pq48Z34C)+

&=,,:MA+(FT0<0G-?+

V+

(0M0.Y+R:?0G:.+

&=,,:MA+(FT0<0G-?+

V+V+(0M0.Y+R:?0G:.+44‚IJq54Z86C"+223‚26q57Z5JC)+

Page 247: Underground Great Wall

W=..-<+#:>,<-1+"`+:H+],8E,8S$+

WF<<+%.Y<-/+R:MAF<?+WF<<+%.Y<-/+R:MAF<?+

&-T:./FMQ+).AMF.T-+#:.TM-A-+gFMFY-+i�+R:MAF<_j+

D-,:MA-/+*(d42%+'#KO+*-,<:Q>-.A+0.+9F<<-Q+"`+:H+"F.QF.Y+

44‚22q58Z53C"+223‚2pq48Z34C)+

W)$+W=M.FM:=./+

Page 248: Underground Great Wall

!OXe5*$W@=B$$],8E,8S$<G88.($@;3)(.Z$

Page 249: Underground Great Wall

*(d42%+HFT0<0AQ+p24AB+KM0YF/-+FA+"F.QF.Y++++

DF0<+<:F/0.Y+FM-F+AQ,0TF<+H:M+<:F/0.Y+'.A-MT:.G.-.AF<++O0??0<-+WMF0.+

W=..-<+#:>,<-1+l+7+(0M0.Y+R:?0G:.?+26d3I+L>+A:+"`+

������������!!v21.&)x$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!D.$$.(#!"#/#&+)*J!O*).&zw!jA77]@SS@A[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb0-=-@5.(.0)*J@<1.&)@<%5b5.(.0)*Jb105(bA77]FSSFA[bSS6]7Q~S7S\\R[@105!u!@!

Page 250: Underground Great Wall

“PLA’s Second Artillery Corps to Create a Mysterious ‘Underground Great Wall’ Anti-Earth-Penetrating Nuclear Bombs,” China Military Report, (13 Dec. 2009), at <http://wuxinghongqi.blogspot.com/2009/12/plas-second-artillery-corps-to-create.html> [accessed 19 Feb. 2010]. Photos accompanied the website posting.

Q!P#K?!22OnF\!

R!P#K?!22OnF\!

I]T;^'(4+5.$*(;,1#33+,E(!.,:'(1.(!,+%1+(%(RE'1+,#./'([)$*+,-,./$*(0,+%1(2%33&U"

R3)-)"'A9G# 0F."0.,)4# M9# '()# B).FA)O0# N+M),26."# 7,=9G# }<(+"2# E26."2A# *)/)"0)#E)D0OG#,);)2A)4#'()#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#=+00+A)#/.,-)0#'.#M5+A4#2"#5"4),8,.5"4#-2;),"#0+'526."rI# 7"2A90'0# 02+4# '(2'# '()# <(+")0)#=)4+2# 42,)4# '.# F5MA+0(# '()0)#r# -2AA)4#RT"4),8,.5"4# U,)2'# V2AAS# ./# '()# 0',2')8+-# /2-+A+6)0# r# 0(.D)4# '(2'# '()# <(+")0)#090')=#./#+'0#"5-A)2,#.F),26."0#D+'(#5"F,)-)4)"')4#-."H4)"-)#2"4#-.5,28)IS#

SQ!e#<@!A77T!

Page 251: Underground Great Wall

21.&#$#!>1%0%!%9!LePFQS!'&+#*/*%-&+!e#>(%J5#&0N++G83'8S$W@=B$<G88.($@;3)(.Z$

ARˆQQq7S@\QNa!!!!!S7AˆQ6qS7@6RNh$

Y5)/#!)$!$1%4&!)0l!L����QS�������������!ve%&/9#&/FQS!5.$$.(#!)*5J!>%$.I%&$!$%!#)$J!0%!(./10!.0mw?!!?+"2#K+A+'2,9#J.,5=G#jA7S7@SS@S6k?!s!1t>lbb<(-K@5.(@&#4$@$.&)@<%5@<&b;.#401*#)+@>1>zI+cAR6]\[!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!a%;@!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

X<<#$$!M)0#!!0%!n)((#J!

2%55)&+!2#&0#*z!

�������������<(-K@5.(@&#4$@$.&)@<%5@<&b;.#401*#)+@>1>zI+

2%55)&+!

0%!n)((#J!dy!)&+!!

D).&0#&)&<#!

Page 252: Underground Great Wall

f,((.E$<G88.($@;3)(.Z$7;G2&$;:$+G83'8S!

X<<#$$!M)0#!!0%!n)((#J!

2%55)&+!2#&0#*z!

dy!)&+!!D).&0#&)&<#!

Lower Valley!

Upper Valley!

2%&$0*-<I%&!2)5>!

G1%0%$!9*%5!M%%/(#!h)*01!Qe!

O-&&#(!G%*0)($!

O-&&#(!G%*0)($!

H).(!".&#!

:#<-*.0J!H%)+!

Page 253: Underground Great Wall

%V@$V.(.,7.$;:$!OXe5$<G88.($@;3)(.Z$WF.82'k'9,2';8$j#KK1\'.L');??1KH'3dlccG4BAPcMQ'''''B43lc5GB4A5dM9'

A!e%%*!O-&&#(!G%*0)($!c!QA!Q!e%%*!O-&&#(!G%*0)($!c!R!

j#KK1\'.L');??1KH'3dlccG4BAPcMQ'''''B43lc5GB4A5dM9'

A!e%%*!O-&&#(!G%*0)($!c!QA!Q!e%%*!O-&&#(!G%*0)($!c!R!

Y5)/#!)$!$1%4&!)0l!L����QS�������������!ve%&/9#&/FQS!5.$$.(#!)*5J!>%$.I%&$!$%!#)$J!0%!(./10!.0mw?!!?+"2#K+A+'2,9#J.,5=G#jA7S7@SS@S6k?!s!1t>lbb<(-K@5.(@&#4$@$.&)@<%5@<&b;.#401*#)+@>1>zI+cAR6]\[!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!a%;@!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 254: Underground Great Wall

<6;$!;;"$<G88.($%;"2,(7$i2;2,($m$e/$);7'2';87j$

Page 255: Underground Great Wall

e$!;;"$<G88.($%;"2,(7$i2;2,($mK$);7'2';87j$

Page 256: Underground Great Wall

!O e5*$W@=B$*8'3,2';8$*-,<:Q>-.A+HM:>+!./-MYM:=./+l+&F<E:+$F=.TB+

:<*##&!$1%0$!9*%5!l!L aDe��ePQS������?N!1+)W5)?!jA7S7@SS@7Sk?!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@I#B-#@&#0b>%$0~R6]A]][~S@105(!!u!v)<<#$$#+!T!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw?!4.01!%&(J!9%-*!$<*##&!$1%0$C!)&+!9-((!$#0!%9!.((-$0*)I%&$!9*%5l!L aDe��!ePQS������!v21.&)!1.&0#+!ePQS!4.01!)&IFaDe!%*K.0)(!$>)<#!<)>)K.(.I#$w?N#<_E��������? A7S7 SS 7A !)0!s!1t>lbb444@<1&`.)&/@<%5b)*I<(#bA7S7bSS7Ab5.(~QSA6Q@$105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!S!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!n.+#%!5J!)<0-)((J!K#!)!21.&#$#!<%>J!%9!':!>*%+-<#+!)&.5)I%&@!

R:MAF<+

2?A+W)$++$F=.TB+

3./+W)$++D-F/Q+

R:MAF<+ R:MAF<+

*(d42%+

Page 257: Underground Great Wall

3IIp+`0.A-M+W=..-<+

#:.?AM=TG:.+

3IIJ+&=>>-M+'.A-M0:M+P=ƒ0„.Y+

Page 258: Underground Great Wall

o-&5.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2%5>(#B!

")0l!ARˆQAqST@6[Na!"%&l!S7AˆQRqR\@RTNh!

Page 259: Underground Great Wall

o-&5.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2%5>(#B!

")0l!ARˆQAqST@6[Na!"%&l!S7AˆQRqR\@RTNh!

Page 260: Underground Great Wall

o-&5.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2%5>(#B!X$$%<.)0#+!P)<.(.I#$!X$$%<.)0#+!P)<.(.I#$!

W=..-<+2+

W=..-<+3+

=\$)6"6?$"'

19)G"BF'

W=..-<+5+

WF0<0.Y+(0<<_+

#:.?AM=TG:.+(FT0<0AQ+

#->-.A+R<F.A_+

&-T=M0AQ+D:F/+

PHhh3X}!GXnhe!HfXe!!!:#<-*.0J!H%)+!!HXY"!!!O-&&#(!!!G%*0)(!:#<-*.0J!G#*.5#0#*!

#->-.A+#->-.A+R<F.A_+R<F.A_+R<F.A_+R<F.A_+R<F.A_+R<F.A_+

=\$)6"6?$"'=\$)6"6?$"'

19)G"BF'

W=..-<+5+19)G"BF'

W=..-<+6+

W=..-<+6+

Page 261: Underground Great Wall

W=..-<+WF0<0.Y?_+

2%55)&+!2#&0#*z!

Upper Valley!

2%&$0*-<I%&!2)5>!

:#<-*.0J!H%)+!

).:=YB+k<<+A:+T:>-+HM:>+F+p12I+>-A-M+A=..-<N++

2I+L>+<:.Y+

e.$/-.$#+!hB.0z!

Page 262: Underground Great Wall

<&.$B'77'8S$R8F."S";G8F$V,'(";,F$

V;,F$OF,+++i.:A+0.T<=/0.Y+U<=-j+++++E?+++++&FA-<<0A-+++++i.:A+0.T<=/0.Y+M-/j+++/$

W=..-<+3+

W=..-<+5+

W=..-<+4+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+ W=..-<+4+W=..-<+6+ W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+

W=..-<+3+

W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+

W=..-<+3+W=..-<+3+

W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+

_+

W=..-<+3+

W=..-<+5+

W=..-<+4+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+ W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+W=..-<+4+

W=..-<+3+W=..-<+3+

_+

W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+ W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+W=..-<+6+

Page 263: Underground Great Wall

o-&5.&/!'&+#*/*%-&+!2%5>(#B!e#$0)K.(.V.&/!dJ>%01#$.$z!

A:AF<+A=..-<?+s+2IL>_+

e#$0)K.(.V.&/!dJ>%01#$.$z!

A:AF<+A=..-<?+s+2IL>_+

W=..-<+2+

W=..-<+3+

WF0<0.Y+(0<<_+

*0?Y=0?-/+)10A_+

#->-.A+R<F.A_+

PHhh3X}!GXnhe!HfXe!!!:#<-*.0J!H%)+!!HXY"!!!O-&&#(!!!G%*0)(!:#<-*.0J!G#*.5#0#*!

#->-.A+#->-.A+R<F.A_+R<F.A_+

W=..-<+3+

*0?Y=0?-/+*0?Y=0?-/+

$0.L-/_+

$:.Y-M+W=..-<_+

A:AF<+A=..-<?+s+2IL>_+

$0.L-/_+

W=..-<+6+

W=..-<+4+

Page 264: Underground Great Wall

Study #6!

IZ$"%$5+*(R.O#3#1EU(_(!,#'#'(41%O#3#1E$

Page 265: Underground Great Wall

=c?"'!9)5"F'*-,<:Q>-.A+HM:>+!./-MYM:=./'

Page 266: Underground Great Wall

P<&.$1G"S.T$,7$U).",2';8,($!.)(;E3.82$#:-MT0E-+R:A-.GF<+U=A+S-0YBA-.-/+9=<.-MFU0<0AQ+F./+}=-?G:.FU<-+&=?AF0.FU0<0AQ$

Page 267: Underground Great Wall

1G"S.$!.)(;E3.82$

Page 268: Underground Great Wall

S-<0T:,A-M+&-T=M0AQ++F??:T0FA-/+\0AB++

"=T<-FM+*-,<:Q>-.A+

Page 269: Underground Great Wall

*(d32+=?-+:H+S0YB\FQ+W=..-<?+/=M0.Y+@,=<?-C++).BF.T-/+O:U0<0AQ+/=M0.Y+#M0?0?+*-,<:Q>-.A!

Page 270: Underground Great Wall

%",92'9.$;:$1,(b;$C,G89&.7$

Page 271: Underground Great Wall

China’s 2nd Artillery'

•! :0)*0#+!.&!()0#!ST67$!4.01!D)%q$!&##+!9%*!LA!K%5K$!g!)!$)0#((.0#N!!•! ST6Q?!ST66!g!ST6]!':!a-<(#)*!O1*#)0$!•! Z*#)=!4.01!:%;.#0$!%;#*!LG#)<#9-(!2%#B.$0#&<#N!!•! ST6T!,!o1*-$1<1#;!4.01+*)4)(!FF!()$0!a)I%&)(!G)*)+#!9%*!A6!J#)*$!•! S$0!X0%5.<!Z%5K!O#$0!.&!ST[R!!•! A&+!X*I((#*J!9%-&+#+!.&!ST[[!,!&)5#+!9%*!L+#<#>I%&N!•! S$0!dJ+*%/#&!Z%5K!O#$0!.&!ST[\!!•! :%;.#0!01*#)0!%9!>*##5>I%&!.&!ST[T!•! e.$*->I%&!%9!Q*+!(.&#!<%&$0*-<I%&!)&+!L2-(0-*)(!H#;%(-I%&N!•! G*%>%&#&0!%9!La%!P.*$0!'$#N!+%<0*.&#!•! S$0!Y2ZD!$1%4&!.&!ST]R!a)I%&)(!G)*)+#!•! :(%4!5.$$.(#!+#;#(%>5#&0!)&+!(%4!=#J!+#>(%J5#&0!•! e./.IV#+!21.&#$#!()&/-)/#!,!.&0*%+-<#+!Y&0#*&#0!!•! GH2!(#)+!.&!#B>#*.5#&0)I%&!4.01!2JK#*!g!:>)<#!3)*9)*#!•! ")0#!STT7$!L+-)(!<)>)K(#N!a-<(#)*b2%&;#&I%&)(!YHZD!#5>1)$.$!•! X&&%-&<#!Q?777!5.(#$!%9!O-&&#(!9%*!D.$$.(#$!)&+!3)*1#)+$!

Page 272: Underground Great Wall

%V@$R8F."S";G8F$!.b.(;)3.82!2J6Id3I2I+

#0E0<+*-H-.?-;+FF!G#%>(#q$!X.*!e#9#&$#!4%*=$!q67!FF!S$0!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!2%&9@!q6Q!FF!2%)$0)(!9%*IE<)I%&$!g!0-&&#(.&/!FF!D)%!<)(($!9%*!L'*K)&!X.*!e#9#&$#!Ç6[!FF!".&!Z)%!,!9#)*!)t)<=!%&!<%)$0!Ç[A!FF!LO1.*+!".&#!e#9#&$#N!+.$>#*$)(!q[R!FF!e.$*->I%&!%9!2-(0-*)(!H#;@!Çq[\!FF!P#)*!%9!:%;.#0!>*##5>I%&!Ç[T!FF!A&+!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!2%&9@!Ç\S!FF!Q*+!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!2%&9@!Ç\]!FF!)K)&+%&!#B>#&$.;#!>*%�#<0$!FF!9%<-$!%&!5.(.0)*J!1)*+#&.&/!

FF!G#%>(#q$!X.*!e#9#&$#!")4!ÇT[!FF!2.;.(FD.(.0)*J!.&0#/*)I%&!FF!R01!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!2%&9@!q77!FF!5#&I%&!%9!L.&+#$0*-<IK(#!

Ç'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((qN!FF!'*K)&!*#&#4b$-K4)J!+#9#&$#!FF!L:I5-(-$N!.&;#$05#&0!.&!$-K4)Jb*).(!

2J6I+

2J66+

2J7I+

2J76+

2J8I+

2J86+

2JpI+

2Jp6+

2JJI+

2JJ6+

3III+

3II6+

3I2I+

3./+%MG<<-MQ+

FF!G#%>(#q$!X.*!e#9#&$#!4%*=$!q67!FF!S$0!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!2%&9@!q6Q!FF!2%)$0)(!9%*IE<)I%&$!g!0-&&#(.&/!FF!D)%!<)(($!9%*!L'*K)&!X.*!e#9#&$#!Ç6[!FF!".&!Z)%!,!9#)*!)t)<=!%&!<%)$0!Ç[A!FF!LO1.*+!".&#!e#9#&$#N!+.$>#*$)(!q[R!FF!e.$*->I%&!%9!2-(0-*)(!H#;@!Çq[\!FF!P#)*!%9!:%;.#0!>*##5>I%&!Ç[T!FF!A&+!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!2%&9@!Ç\S!FF!Q*+!2.;.(!e#9#&$#!2%&9@!Ç\]!FF!)K)&+%&!#B>#&$.;#!>*%�#<0$!FF!9%<-$!%&!5.(.0)*J!1)*+#&.&/!

"=T<-FM+`-F,:.?+

FF!:.0#!$#(#<I%&!9%*!0#$0!g!$0%*)/#!Ç6]!

FF!S$0!X0%5.<!0#$0!Ö!0-&&#(!Ç[R!FF!ae:2!<%&0*%($!$0%*)/#!Ç![6!FF!S$0!O1#*5%&-<(#)*!0#$0!FF!3)*1#)+$!5%;#+!O).K).!Çq[T!

FF!3)*1#)+!<%&0*%(!A&+!X*0J!q\T!

Page 273: Underground Great Wall

7!

7@7S!

7@7A!

7@7Q!

7@7R!

7@76!

7@7[!

7@7\!

7@7]!

7@7T!

7@S!

7!

A6777!

67777!

\6777!

S77777!

SA6777!

S67777!

S\6777!

A77777!

AA6777!

A67777!

A\6777!

Q77777!

ST[7!

ST[A!

ST[R!

ST[[!

ST[]!

ST\7!

ST\A!

ST\R!

ST\[!

ST\]!

ST]7!

ST]A!

ST]R!

ST][!

ST]]!

STT7!

STTA!

STTR!

STT[!

STT]!

A777!

A77A!

A77R!

A77[!

A77]!

A7S7!

OF.,:\-M+

R-MT-.AFY-+:H+R$%+

/8F$*"2'((."E$B,8);6."$ST[[FA7S7!

Page 274: Underground Great Wall

/8F$*"2'((."E$12",2.S'9$!'".92';87$

Page 275: Underground Great Wall

7!

67!

S77!

S67!

A77!

A67!

Q77!

Q67!

R77!

R67!

677!

ST[7!

ST[A!

ST[R!

ST[[!

ST[]!

ST\7!

ST\A!

ST\R!

ST\[!

ST\]!

ST]7!

ST]A!

ST]R!

ST][!

ST]]!

STT7!

STTA!

STTR!

STT[!

STT]!

A777!

A77A!

A77R!

A77[!

A77]!

'.A-MT:.G.-.AF<+

#:.G.-.AF<+

WB-FA-M+

WFTGTF<+

/8F$*"2'((."E$B'77'(.7$-E$V,8S.$y-)&I0J!%9!")-&<1#*$l!ST[[FA77T!

a-5

K#*!%9!")-&<1#*$!

e)0)!+#*.;#+!9*%5!01#!)&&-)(!D.(.0)*J!Z)()&<#!*#>%*0$!j"%&+%&?!'ol!Y&0#*&)I%&)(!Y&$I0-0#!9%*!:0*)0#/.<!:0-+.#$?!ST[7FA7S7k@!

Page 276: Underground Great Wall

<,"S.2'8S$V,8S.$

*(d6+

*(d42%+

*(d5+

*(d42+

*(d5+

*(d42+

*(d6+

*(d42%+

`F?B0.YA:.+

O:?T:\

+

Page 277: Underground Great Wall

<,92'9,($=,(('72'9$B'77'(.$1E72.37$y-)&I0J!%9!")-&<1#*$l!ST[[FA77T!

7!

67!

S77!

S67!

A77!

A67!

ST[7!

ST[A!

ST[R!

ST[[!

ST[]!

ST\7!

ST\A!

ST\R!

ST\[!

ST\]!

ST]7!

ST]A!

ST]R!

ST][!

ST]]!

STT7!

STTA!

STTR!

STT[!

STT]!

A777!

A77A!

A77R!

A77[!

A77]!

*(d22+ *(d26+a-5

K#*!%9!")-&<1#*$!

e)0)!+#*.;#+!9*%5!01#!)&&-)(!D.(.0)*J!Z)()&<#!*#>%*0$!j"%&+%&?!'ol!Y&0#*&)I%&)(!Y&$I0-0#!9%*!:0*)0#/.<!:0-+.#$?!ST[7FA7S7k@!

Page 278: Underground Great Wall

<,92'9,($!G,(X@,),-(.H$!OX55$I$!OX5L$}=F.GAFGE-+F./+}=F<0AFGE-+)>,BF?0?+:H+$F?A+*-TF/-+

*(d22! *(d26!

Page 279: Underground Great Wall

<,92'9,($1V=B$.Z'2'8S$<G88.(7$

Page 280: Underground Great Wall

WFTGTF<+W)$?++0.+"-\+W=..-<?+

i�����!vD.(.0)*J!fK$#*;)I%&!H%%5?o#!/)"8#1m?!jS\!e#<#5K#*!A77Tk?!)0!s!1t>lbb;@.9#&/@<%5b5.(bA77TSAbA+7\QS#9FKR\[FR#]7F)#[#F<RT\KQ9QQ7\[@$105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!A]!e#<@!A77Tw@!

Page 281: Underground Great Wall

WFTGTF<+W)$?++0.+"-\+W=..-<?+

Page 282: Underground Great Wall

3./+%MG<<-MQ+WFTGTF<+WMF0.0.Y+)1-MT0?-+0.+W=..-<+

L ;����������{VVV|NC+1?-%2E#$3N+i3II8d22d26jN+FA+x++z+{FTT-??-/+2J+&-,AZ+3II2e+AMF.?<FA-/+UQ+'Rd2I22N+0>FY-+?=U?-]=-.A<Q+M-/FTA-/Z!

Page 283: Underground Great Wall

*:.YH-.Yd26+WFTGTF<+O0??0<-+M-<:F/+0.+&A:MFY-+

L�Č�Ŕse�Ðl¡ŲĐčQÙň»Ïź!v:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!1)$!#`-.>5#&0!5)+#!%9!&#4!)&+!.&0#((./#&0!4)*1#)+!#B>(%$.%&!+#()Jw?i!_52"L+5G#`$%%&I%gI%&aG#2'#É#(>FX^^=+AI(52"L+5I-.=^-(+"2^$%%&d%g^&]gh\I('=A#Ñ#y2--)00)4#f%#*)-I#$%\%zI!

Page 284: Underground Great Wall

%C*$IR.*+3(.<(1"+(4+5.$*(;,1#33+,E(G#,#$-(:.'#1#.$'U(��������(

Y((-$0*)I%&!9*%5l!i vG*%0#<I%&!G*%�#<0!)0!d%5#!)&+!XK*%)+!)&+!:0*)0#/.<!O1.&=.&/w?i!?(.D<(+"2?!jA77T@7Q@7[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb0*)&$()0#@/%%/(#@<%5b0*)&$()0#z1(c#&g$(cV1F2ag-c1t>lbb444@$1%4<1.&)@%*/bV/�K`=B(bV(41J�$V<bA77T7Qb0A\R[[6@105g#.cDV$>O#O|h}F-]XKT\$AAXyg$)c|g%.c0*)&$()0#g<0c*#$-(0g*#$&-5cSg;#+c72Z7y\/h4XXg>*#;cb$#)*<18QP`8Qe1t>lbb444@$1%4<1.&)@%*/bV/�K`=B(bV(41J�$V<bA77T7Qb0A\R[[6@1058A[1(8Qe#&8A[<(.#&08Qe$)9)*.8A[*($8Qe#&8A[>*5+8Qe.;&$!u!v)<<#$$#+!S7!e#<@!A7S7C!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

hB)5>(#!%9!O-&&#(!Z)$#+!H).(!e#>(%J#+!O)<I<)(!D.$$.(#!!!

p !:0)I%&#+!.&!-&+#*/*%-&+!9)<.(.0J!!

p !'&.0!+#>(%J#+!%&!$>#<.)(!0*).&!

p !3.01!$->>%*I&/!#`-.>5#&0!

p !ePFSSbePFS6bePFAS!Oh"$!%&!U)0!<)*!%*!L$>#<.)(!0*)&$>%*0!<)*N!

p !a%*5)((J!E*#+!9*%5!/*%-&+!>%$.I%&$!K-0!)($%!+.$<-$$.%&!%9!()-&<1!9*%5!L$>#<.)(!0*)&$>%*0!<)*N!9*%5!>*#F$-*;#J#+!$.+.&/!!

!%&!U)0!

Page 285: Underground Great Wall

<&.,2."$B'77'(.7$y-)&I0J!%9!")-&<1#*$l!ST[[FA77T!

7!

A7!

R7!

[7!

]7!

S77!

SA7!

SR7!

S[7!

S]7!

A77!

ST[7

!

ST[A

!

ST[R

!

ST[[

!

ST[]

!

ST\7

!

ST\A

!

ST\R

!

ST\[

!

ST\]

!

ST]7

!

ST]A

!

ST]R

!

ST][

!

ST]]

!

STT7

!

STTA

!

STTR

!

STT[

!

STT]

!

A777

!

A77A

!

A77R

!

A77[

!

A77]

!

*Sd2I+*(d32#+*(d32+*(d4%+*(d3+*(d4+

a-5

K#*!%9!")-&<1#*$!

e)0)!+#*.;#+!9*%5!01#!)&&-)(!D.(.0)*J!Z)()&<#!*#>%*0$!j"%&+%&?!'ol!Y&0#*&)I%&)(!Y&$I0-0#!9%*!:0*)0#/.<!:0-+.#$?!ST[7FA7S7k@!

Page 286: Underground Great Wall

Y,"(E$/8F$*"2'((."E$<'3.('8.+O0??0<-+*-E-<:,>-.AN+PMYF.0hFG:.+l+W=..-<0.Y+

D)*I&!O*%((#?!LO.5#(.&#l!21.&)q$!S$0!M#&#*)I%&!%9!a-<(#)*!D.$$.(#$?N!<(+")0)#K+00+A)0?!jA7SSk?!s!1t>lbb444@U.<=*@<%5b>1%0%$b5)*I&0*%((#b6[RQ7RQRA]b$.V#$b%b.&b$#0F\AS6\[A\[T6RTS]\Rb!u!v)<<#$$#+!A6!X-/@!A7SSw@!

'.0GF<+W=..-<0.Y+

#M-FG:.+:H+3./+%MG<<-MQ+2?A+O0??0<-+K.+

Page 287: Underground Great Wall

<&.,2."$]G9(.,"$B'77'(.7$

*(d3+ *(d4+

*(d32n+ *(d32#w*n+

*Sd2In+

n+s+*=F<+#F,FU<-+

Page 288: Underground Great Wall

Unclassified Google Earth imagery courtesy of Tim Brown, (1 April 2009).

*(d4+W=..-<?+0.+*F<0F.+R-..0?=<F+

Page 289: Underground Great Wall

'.A-M0:M+OFG.Y+:H+*(d3+#:>,:.-.A?+:.+DF0<?+

Page 290: Underground Great Wall

*(d4+W=..-<+'.A-M0:M?+?B:\.+:.+#B0.-?-+W9+

Page 291: Underground Great Wall

B;F."8$!OX/5$!.)(;E3.82$'8$<G88.(7$

LePFAS2����������!ve*)/%&x$!P.*#l!O1#!G"Xx$!A&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$w?N!����!vM(%K)(D.(w?!jA77T@SA@ATk?!)0!1t>lbb444@/(%K)(5.(@<%5bD.(.0)*Jba#4$b21.&)bA7S7bSSSRbA\S@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SR!X-/@!A7SSw@!

O1#!(%/.<)(!)$$-5>I%&!.$!01)0!01#!;)$0!&#04%*=!%9!'MP$!(%<)0#+!&#)*!01#!5.$$.(#!/)**.$%&$!)&+!()-&<1!$.0#$!)*#!-$#+!0%!>*%0#<0?!$0%*#?!)&+!0*)&$9#*!01#$#!.0#5$@!:0%*.&/!4)*1#)+$!)&+!5.$$.(#$!.&!'MP$!)((%4$!Oh"$!0%!K#!(%)+#+!)&+!)*5#+!-&+#*!>*%0#<0#+!<%;#*?!)&+!)4)J!9*%5!01#!>*J.&/!#J#$!%9!.&0#((./#&<#!$)0#((.0#$Å@!

Page 292: Underground Great Wall

<&.,2."$B'77'(.$<G88.(7$'8$2&.$?.72$

La-<(#)*!".#$!)&+!21.&)q$!O#**%*.$5?N!1+M)'1,5'(?!jA7S7@7R@SAk?!)0!s!1t>lbbIK#t*-01@<%5bA7S7b7RbSAb&-<(#)*F(.#$F)&+F<1.&)$F0#**%*.$5b!u!v)<<#$$#+!AS!r)&@!A7SSw@!

Page 293: Underground Great Wall

<6;$b,"',827$;:$2&.$!OX/5@$i!OX/Lnj$BV=B$

O1#!9-VVJ!>1%0%!)K%;#!4)$!*#(#)$#+!.&!a%;@!A77[!%&!01#!21.&#$#!Y&0#*&#0!<().5.&/!0%!$1%4!01#!ePFA6@!O1#!A77\!!>1%0%!%&!01#!*./10!$1%4$!01#!$)5#!ePFAS2!Oh"!)&+!5.$$.(#!K%%$0#*!4.01!+.W#*#&0!4)*1#)+$!,!K#(.#;#+!0%!K#!&-<(#)*!j*#)*k!)&+!<%&;#&I%&)(!j9%*#k@!

Page 294: Underground Great Wall

!OX/5$<YC$-.'8S$V.(;,F.F$'8$U).",2';8,($O,9'('2E$

Page 295: Underground Great Wall

fG(8.",-'('2E$;:$/8F$*"2E$<",87);"2$

L !vH#>-0)I%&!%9!21.&)x$!a-<(#)*!:0%*)/#!:.0#$!:)9#!O*)&$>%*0!".&=!.$!3#)=w?N!)0!L21.&)x$!D.(.0)*J?N!!<E3I<EG#jA7S7@7Q@STk!)0!s!1t>lbbASS@]T@AA6@Rl]Ab/)0#bK./6b5.(@<&*@<&bV/�+bA7S77Qb0A7S77QST~67[S\[Q]R@105(!5(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SA!D)J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 296: Underground Great Wall

!OX/L$BV=Bn!!OX/L$BV=Bn

$FMY-+]=F.GAQ+:H+*(d32?+>:E-/+UQ+MF0<+

Page 297: Underground Great Wall

“D.(.0)*J!a#4$l!O%!P*./10#&!01#!3#$0l!21.&)x$!d.+.&/!X>>#)*)&<#!%9!)!")*/#!a-5K#*!%9!Y&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!D.$$.(#$N!v����l!�������������������w!<(+"2#?.5A#y����w!K(%/!jAT!r-&#!A77Tk?!)0!!s!1t>lbb`-&@6S@<%5b(.1-)`.&/TTTb0%>.<@>1>z>.+c6AARS!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!D)*@!A7S7w@

L8.(W,#-"1+$(1"+(2+'1U(!(

!OX/5$;8$2&.$B;b.$W=..-<+#:.T-F<>-.A+T:>U0.-/+\0AB+)>,BF?0?+:.+O:U0<0AQ+

Page 298: Underground Great Wall

@;82'8.82,($B'77'(.7$y-)&I0J!%9!")-&<1#*$l!ST\]FA77T!

7!

6!

S7!

S6!

A7!

A6!

Q7!

ST[7!

ST[A!

ST[R!

ST[[!

ST[]!

ST\7!

ST\A!

ST\R!

ST\[!

ST\]!

ST]7!

ST]A!

ST]R!

ST][!

ST]]!

STT7!

STTA!

STTR!

STT[!

STT]!

A777!

A77A!

A77R!

A77[!

A77]!

A7S7!

*(d42+ *(d5+a-5

K#*!%9!")-&<1#*$!

e)0)!+#*.;#+!9*%5!01#!)&&-)(!D.(.0)*J!Z)()&<#!*#>%*0$!j"%&+%&?!'ol!Y&0#*&)I%&)(!Y&$I0-0#!9%*!:0*)0#/.<!:0-+.#$?!ST[7FA7S7k@!

Page 299: Underground Great Wall

@;82'8.82,($]G9(.,"$B'77'(.7$

*(d5+

#:.TM-A-+&B-/?+0.+K-M>?+l+&BF<<:\+W=..-<?+

F!DF.Y-+s++F!$0]=0/+(=-<+d+&<:\+RM-,FMFG:.+d+%TT=MFTQ+*-YMF/-/+UQ+O:E->-.A+

Page 300: Underground Great Wall

ePFQS!

Page 301: Underground Great Wall

!OXe5$@;82'8.82,($=,(('72'9$B'77'(.$A::+?B:MA+H:M+!&N+A::+<:.Y+H:M+D=??0F+

��������������! D.(.0)*J!$0*)0#/J!0%4)*+!)!5-(I>%()*!4%*(+!>)t#*&w?N!7,=)4#J.,-)0#*)F2,'=)"'0#?.5,-)?!j!A77]@7]@SRk!s!1t>lbb444@<1.&)77S@<%5b$1%4~1+*!@>1>zB&)5#cGGeeDn7g+&)5#cO6O![eRSgB>%$c[\!u!v)<<#$$#+!SA!P#K@!A7S7w@!!

<"');(,"'d,2';8$m$<,"S.2'8S$YG";).$

7!

A77!

R77!

[77!

]77!

S777!

SA77!

SR77!

S[77!

S]77!

A777!

%MGT<-?+0.+R-:,<-q?+*F0<Q+M-H-M-.T0.Y+@>=<G,:<FM0hFG:.C+

Page 302: Underground Great Wall

W82."9;82'8.82,($B'77'(.7$y-)&I0J!%9!")-&<1#*$l!ST[[FA77T!

7!

6!

S7!

S6!

A7!

A6!

Q7!

Q6!

R7!

R6!

67!

ST[7

!

ST[A

!

ST[R

!

ST[[

!

ST[]

!

ST\7

!

ST\A

!

ST\R

!

ST\[

!

ST\]

!

ST]7

!

ST]A

!

ST]R

!

ST][

!

ST]]

!

STT7

!

STTA

!

STTR

!

STT[

!

STT]

!

A777

!

A77A

!

A77R

!

A77[

!

A77]

!

*(d42%+

*(d6%+

*(d6+

a-5

K#*!%9!")-&<1#*$!

e)0)!+#*.;#+!9*%5!01#!)&&-)(!D.(.0)*J!Z)()&<#!*#>%*0$!j"%&+%&?!'ol!Y&0#*&)I%&)(!Y&$I0-0#!9%*!:0*)0#/.<!:0-+.#$?!ST[7FA7S7k@!

Page 303: Underground Great Wall

!OXL$W@=B$7&;68$'8$1'(;$(,G89&$,8F$2G88.($72;",S.$

G1%0%!9*%5l!Le%&/P#&/!6!j2::FRk!Y&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!Z)((.$I<!D.$$.(#?N!?+".*)/)"0)?!jA77T@7A@S6k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@$.&%+#9#&<#@<%5b$0*)0#/.<b5.$$.(#b+9QS@)$>!u!v)<<#$$#+!\!r-(@!A7S7w@!

ePF6!3)*1#)+!4.01!A&+!g!Q*+!:0)/#$!$1%4&!.&!ST]R!G)*)+#!

ePF6!A&+!g!Q*+!:0)/#$!.&!-&+#*/*%-&+!1%*.V%&0)(!$0%*)/#!

a%0#l!0*)<=$!)&+!*).(!5%-&0#+!<)**.)/#$!

:.(%!()-&<1!%9!ePF6!

Page 304: Underground Great Wall

*(d6+!./-MYM:=./+&0<:+

:#)&!fq2%&&%*?!Ld.++#&!2::FR!:.(%?N!!K!E1#@#7"2A90+0G#jA77]@SA@STk!)0!s!1t>lbb/#.5.&0@K(%/$>%0@<%5b!u!!v)<<#$$#+!S\!f<0@!A7S7w@!

Q76!

1()#+=28)#2M.;)#4)F+-'0#2#*Jdh#`<??dga#!<iK#0+A.#A.-2')4#+"#0.5'(),"#<(+"2#")2,#_5+'."8I#<(+")0)#!<iK#0+A.0#2,)#;),9#4+e-5A'#'.#+4)"6/9I#70#0))"#+"#'()#+=28)#2M.;)G#'()9#2,)#2AA.D)4#'.#M)-.=)#.;),8,.D"#D+'(#;)8)'26."#2"4#=29#2-'52AA9#M)#-2=.5p28)4I#1(+0#+0#F2,'#./#2#4)"+2A#2"4#4)-)F6."#)P.,'#+"')"4)4#'.#=20:#'()+,#A.-26."0#/,.=#.;),()24#+=28+"8#0)"0.,0I#T0+"8#)P)-6;)#-."-)2A=)"'#)P.,'0#-2"#=2:)#'2,8)6"8#'()0)#0',2')8+-#200)'0#;),9#4+e-5A'#+/#'()#0+')0#2,)#)P)-6;)A9#(+44)"I#70#0(.D"#(),)G#(.D);),G#'()0)#-."-)2A)4#=+00+A)#0+')0#-2"#06AA#M)#A.-2')4#+/#2"#.M0),;),#+0#2D2,)#./#'()+,#A29.5'#2"4#-.8"+j2"'#./#'()#,)A);2"'#/)2'5,)0#'(2'#"))4#'.#M)#+4)"6H)4I#

Page 305: Underground Great Wall

!OXe5*$W@=B$

Page 306: Underground Great Wall

W@=B$?,"&.,F$,8F$e"F$12,S.$XX$B,2'8S$6'2&$572o/8F$12,S.7$

G1%0%!$1%4$!A&+!X*I((#*J!+.)/&%$I<!0#$0!9)<.(.0J!)&+!>*%<#+-*#!9%*!<%->(.&/!$0)/#$@!a%0#!-$#!%9!0*)<=!)&+!*).(!5%-&0#+!<)**.)/#$!0J>.<)(!%9!0-&&#(!+#>(%J5#&0@!

G1%0%!9*%5l!Le%&/P#&/!QSX!j2::FTk!Y&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!Z)((.$I<!D.$$.(#?N!?+".*)/)"0)?!jA77T@7A@S6k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@$.&%+#9#&<#@<%5b$0*)0#/.<b5.$$.(#b+9QS@)$>!u!v)<<#$$#+!\!r-(@!A7S7w@!

Page 307: Underground Great Wall

P!.9(,",2';8$;:$?,"$7'S8,(7T$'22On!#B>%$-*#!%9!ePFQSX!.&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!K)((.$I<!5.$$.(#$!

L����l��������*(d42%����Z+�����������������+ZZZ+{e#<()*)I%&!%9!4)*!$./&)($l!22On!#B>%$-*#!:1)%J)&/?!d-&)&!ePFQSX!.&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!K)((.$I<!5.$$.(#$|NC+##W9d8N+i3I22ZIJZ27jN+FA+x+1t>lbb444@/%%/(#@<%5b.5/*#$z`c ePFRS�����������,…���g$0)*0/!u!v)<<#$$#+!ST!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

X&.5)I%&!%9!ePFQSX!Y2ZD!e#>(%J5#&0!9*%5!O-&&#(!0%!>*#F$-*;#J#+!E*.&/!>%$.I%&!

O#B0!<().5$!ePFQSX!Y2ZD!+#>(%J5#&0!.&!:1)%J)&/!)&+!d-&)&!>*%;.&<#$!!

Page 308: Underground Great Wall

!OXe5oK5$W@=B$<",'8'L22On!.&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!&-<(#)*!5.$$.(#!0*).&!)>>#)*#+mN!

LüƆê�§<ũ�ĥzř!v22On!.&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!&-<(#)*!5.$$.(#!0*).&!)>>#)*#+mw?!ƀŒł?!jA77\@7A@A]k?!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@I#B-#@&#0b>%$0A~S]R6[R]~S@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!ST!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

O#B0! $-//#$0$! 01)0! *).(F5%-&I&/! %9! Y2ZD$! .$!*#()0#+!0%!01.$!&#4!(.&#!)&+!0-&&#(!<%&$0*-<I%&@!

Page 309: Underground Great Wall

W7$2&.".$,$V;,F$B;-'(.$!OXK5n$::FA6!4.01!21.&#$#!21)*)<0#*.$I<$!d#);J!*%)+F5%K.(#!DYHn!Y2ZDz!

G1%0%$!0)=#&!.&!21.&)l!A77\!

'H+0A+-10?A?+b+\B-M-+0?+0A_+

Page 310: Underground Great Wall

3II7+W-<-E0?0:.+&B:A$W7$2&.".$,$V,'($B;-'(.$W@=Bn!

@D:TL-A+FMM0E-?+FA+<F=.TB+HFT0<0AQC+

LG"X!D.$$.(#!O1*#)+?N!?+".#*)/)"0)#J.,5=?!jA77[@7A@7Ak?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@$.&%+#9#&<#9%*-5@<%5b4%*(+F5.(.0)*JF>.<0-*#$b>()F5.$$.(#F01*#)+F>.<0-*#$FRF]QA@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!QS!X-/@!A7SSw@!

Page 311: Underground Great Wall

I`/,(!./$1,E(;,N'(W%51.,E(D#1"(%(J%#3D%E(!.$1%#$+,(8,%#$(.<(!%,'(1"%1(;51/%33E(H#*+(1"+(4+5.$*(;,1#33+,E(aN:.,1%$1(4+5,+1bU$

%+#B0.-?-+&&d35_+

R1(+0#',2+"#-2,#+0#".#A."8),#2FFA+-2MA)#+"#F)2-)6=)G#M5'#(.D#4.#!#H"4#(+0#-2,#,../#'.#M)#4)=.A+0()4G#'()"#+'#+0#0F)-+2A+j)4#)L5+F=)"'#A+:)#2,=0G#M5'#,2'(),#2#4+085+0)4#?)-."4#7,6AA),9#<.,F0#',2+"†#n5,#

5"+'0#50)4#'.#',2"0F.,'#2,=0#0))=#.,4+"2,9#',2+"0†S#

L��������������������������!vf-*!2%-&0*J!X*5$!P)<0%*J!4.01!)!H).(4)J!2%&0).&#*!O*).&!%9!2)*$!01)0!X<0-)((J!d.+#!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!Y5>%*0)&0!:#<*#0mw?N!u()"(52#K+A+'2,9#E)'D.,:G#jA7S7@76@7Tk!)0!s!1t>lbb444@V1�-&$1.@<%5b5.(bA7S7F76F7Tb<%&0#&0[~SQRQA@$105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SS!D)J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 312: Underground Great Wall

@&'8,p7$!;8S$O.8S$B'77'(.$<",'8$

L ePFQSbRS������������!�����QS RS����!!v:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!ePFQSbRS!.&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!&-<(#)*!5.$$.(#!0*).&!)>>#)*#+!22Onm!QSbRS!21.&)x$!e%&/!P#&/!D.$$.(#!O*).&$w?N!)0!LX.*!P%*<#!P%*-5?N!1)W5)IE)'G#jA77\@7A@S6k!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@I#B-#@&#0b>%$0~S]AT\S[~S@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SS!D)J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 313: Underground Great Wall

3O1�&�F�<�B!T?01%@.?0$?1?0#K'Q;@K1#%'S$HH$K1')%#$?'#]]1#%1>'!!)j$

L二炮ePFQSbRSüƆê�§<ũ�ĥzřƣ! eĢ�ƘQS/RS�§<ũ!!v:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2%*>$!ePFQSbRS!.&0#*<%&I&#&0)(!&-<(#)*!5.$$.(#!0*).&!)>>#)*#+!22Onm!QSbRS!21.&)x$!e%&/!P#&/!D.$$.(#!O*).&$w?N!)0!LX.*!P%*<#!P%*-5?N!1)W5)IE)'G#jA77\@7A@S6k!)0!s!1t>lbbKK$@I#B-#@&#0b>%$0~S]AT\S[~S@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SS!D)J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 314: Underground Great Wall

'#KO+DF0<+WMF.?,:MAw$F=.TB-M+

Page 315: Underground Great Wall

ePFRS!H).(!O*)&$>%*0!

LºeæƀŨũŮNżĢ6ĉţç<ũijƋő�ČŽŗĭ�ƣ!vf-*!2%-&0*J!X*5$!P)<0%*J!4.01!)!H).(4)J!2%&0).&#*!O*).&!%9!2)*$!01)0!X<0-)((J!d.+#!01#!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!Y5>%*0)&0!:#<*#0mw?N!u()"(52#K+A+'2,9#E)'D.,:G#jA7S7@76@7Tk!)0!s!1t>lbb444@V1�-&$1.@<%5b5.(bA7S7F76F7Tb<%&0#&0[~SQRQA@$105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!SS!D)J!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSw@!

Page 316: Underground Great Wall

ePFRS!H).(!O*)&$>%*0!

Page 317: Underground Great Wall

ePFRS!H).(!O*)&$>%*0!

Page 318: Underground Great Wall
Page 319: Underground Great Wall
Page 320: Underground Great Wall
Page 321: Underground Great Wall
Page 322: Underground Great Wall

GH2!A&+!O*).&!:0%*)/#!

Page 323: Underground Great Wall

•! BBB!• BBB!

Page 324: Underground Great Wall

U:$')2."!#+&%%$#N"8)*8"+#0&2"0BB$0#$.")2"--J`K""

-,&20a7"T&%&+0#N"8$G02"0":,)9.)92W""

'GGhH!HYMdOl!������������!!v21.&)x$!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!D.$$.(#!"#/#&+)*J!O*).&zw!jA77]@SS@A[k?!)0!s!1t>lbb0-=-@5.(.0)*J@<1.&)@<%5b5.(.0)*Jb105(bA77]FSSFA[bSS6]7Q~S7S\\R[@105!u!@!fOdhH:l!L��������������������!v:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!K%5K!0*).&!)>>#)*#+!22On?!21.&)x$!5.(.0)*J!K#/)&!)!$1%4+%4&w?N!YO����� A77SS@7[@76k?!)0!s!1t>lbb&#[email protected].&4#&@<%5bYO~(.9#bA7SSb7[A]bQS7]6A@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!\!:#>0@!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YG!S7SSw@!

Page 325: Underground Great Wall

Study #7!

)$*+,-,./$*(I0,+%1(2%33U(aN:3#5%1#.$'(<.,((C+1+,,+$5+(_(;,N'(!.$1,.3$

Page 326: Underground Great Wall

a-<(#)*!3)*1#)+$!)*#!a%0!X5#&)K(#!0%!a)I%&)(!D#)&$!%9!n#*.E<)I%&!

L':!)&+!'::H!&-<(#)*!$0%<=>.(#$?N!V+:+=)4+2#<.==."0?!jA7S7@76@S]k?!)0!s!1t>lbb<%55%&$@4.=.5#+.)@%*/b4.=.bP.(#l':~)&+~'::H~&-<(#)*~$0%<=>.(#$@!>&/!u!4.01!e)0)!9*%5!s!1t>lbb444@&*+<@%*/b&-<(#)*b&-+Kb+)0)KST@)$>!a)0-*)(!H#$%-*<#$!e#9#&$#!2%-&<.(!u!v)<<#$$#+!ST!e#<@!A7S7w@!

!G"'8S$2&.$@;(F$?,"$2&.$R#1#$B'77.F$/4>444$1;b'.2$]G9(.,"$?.,);87$$

!&+&A:TL,0<-+

!&&D+&A:TL,0<-+

!&+%??=>-/+!&&D+&A:TL,0<-+

!&&D+&A:TL,0<-+

O0??-/+3I

NIII

++"=T<-FM+`

-F,:

.?+

Page 327: Underground Great Wall

a;6$13,(($'7$@&'8,c7$]G9(.,"$*"7.8,(n+

ST\7! ST]7! STT7! A777! A7S7!

S777!

A777!

Q777!

LK+"+=5=#*)'),,)"'N!)*/-5#&0!

W:AF<+`FMB-F/?+

GX2fD!()0#!ST[7$!!!j>*%�#<I%&!9%*!‚\Qk!

eYX!ST]R!!!j>*%�#<I%&$!9%*!‚]T!g!‚TRk!

aHe2!‚TR!!!j<%&I&-#+k!XXXg:!q7\!

S77!

Q77!F!R77!

]S]!6TA!

RQ6!

R. Norris, A. Burrows, and R. Fieldhouse, British, French, and Chinese Nuclear Weapons, (NRDC: 1994): p. 359; and Jeffrey Lewis, The Minimal Means of Reprisal: China’s Search for Security in the Nuclear Age, (AAA&S: 2007): p. 54.

e%t#+!(.&#$!*#>*#$#&0!#B0*)>%()I%&!K)$#+!%&!<%&$0)&0!0*#&+@!

Page 328: Underground Great Wall

<G88.($YZ),87';8+&AFY-?+:H+!./-MYM:=./+*-E-<:,>-.A+

A677!

6777!

#=>=<FGE-+L0<:>-A-M?+

G"X!G-K(.<(J!H#(#)$#+!P./-*#$!

RBF?-+'+

RBF?-+''+

RBF?-+'''+

ST\7! ST]7! STT7! A777! A7S7!

Z#04##&!STT6FA7S7!01#!)&&%-&<#+!(#&/01!%9!A&+!X*0J!0-&&#($!+%-K(#+!9*%5!A?677=5!0%!6?777=5@!!!

RBF?-+''+Z#04##&!STT6FA7S7!01#!)&&%-&<#+!(#&/01!%9!A&+!X*0J!0-&&#($!+%-K(#+!9*%5!A?677=5!0%!6?777=5@!!!

Page 329: Underground Great Wall

V.);"2.F$]G9(.,"$@,),-(.$B'77'(.$W89".,7.7$0.T<=/0.Y+@*=F<C+WFTGTF<+&Q?A->?+F./+/-,<:Q>-.A+:H+.-\+'#KO+

677!

S?777!

O0??0<-?+

eP!AX!

ST\7! ST]7! STT7! A777! A7S7!

eP!Q!

eP!R!

eP!6!

eP!S6!

eP!AS!

21.&)!D.(.0)*J!G%4#*?!j;)*.%-$!#+.I%&$l!A77QFA7SSk@!

eP!QX!

eP!6X!

eP!QS!

O'D9?_+

X++.I%&!%9!S?777!!ePFSSbePFS6!:HZD$!)0!

*)0#l!S77!>#*!J#)*!$.&<#!qTT!)&+!)$$-5#$!)>>*%B.5)0#(J!

6!*#(%)+$!>#*!0)<I<)(!()-&<1#*!!K-0!af!*#(%)+$!9%*!&#4!5%K.(#!!

$%(.+!9-#(!ePFAS!YHZD!%*!ePFQS!Y2ZD!

*(+42%+

*(+52_+

S?677!

eP!SS!

c$+3_+

eP!ASX!

ed!S7!

Page 330: Underground Great Wall

@&'8.7.$12,2.3.827$;:$]G9(.,"$?,"&.,F$i%E-MFY-+%..=F<+RM:/=TG:.+H:M+F+Y0E-.+/-TF/-j+

R�������������������������!vM*#)0!3)((!#&/.&##*.&/!E/10!)&!%(+!&)5#!9%*!r)>)&!#)*01`-)=#!K#)-0Jl!&%!&-<(#)*!$-K5)*.&#$?!Z-$1!4#&0!0%!5%;#mmmwN!i2+45?!jA776@7]@A6k?!)0!s!1t>lbbI#K)@K).+-@<%5b9z=VcQRT7A\RS!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!r)&@!A77TC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSwC!L������A Q67����m!v21.&)!<-**#&0(J!1)$!A?Q67!&-<(#)*!4)*1#)+mw?N!?+"2?!jA77\@SA@ATk?!)0!s!1t>lbbK(%/@$.&)@<%5@<&b$bK(%/~RTRQT\[77S77]6/+@105(!u!v)<<#$$#+!R!D)J!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSwC!L������A Q67�����!v21.&)!<-**#&0(J!1)$!A?Q67!&-<(#)*!4)*1#)+$z!mwN!i2+45#MA.8G#jA7S7@7[@AAk?!)0!s!1t>lbbI#K)@K).+-@<%5b9z<0cQQ6[\6QTAg0&cK).+-G%$0Z*%4$#*g$<cTQSSQTTATTgVc\QQ\R6]]\!u!!v)<<#$$#+!R!D)J!A7SSC!0*)&$()0#+!KJ!YGFS7SSwC!)&+!L�������������������!vG"X!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!5.$$.(#!K*./)+#!$0)I%&#+!+.)/*)5w?N!jA77T@76@7Ak!)0!s!1t>lbbK.&$J$@<&b5.(.0)*Jb$0*)0#/.<b%*/)&.$)I%&b$)9%K@>1>!u!)&+!s!1t>lbbK.&$J$@<&b5.(.0)*Jb$0*)0#/.<b%*/)&.$)I%&b$)9%K@>1>!u!v)<<#$$#+!AA!D)J@!A7S7?!0*)&$()0#+!YGFS7SSw@!

ST\7! ST]7! STT7! A777! A7S7!

S77!

A77!

22Id23I+,-M+Q-FM+`FMB-

F/?+

3II+,-M+Q-FM+

25Id26I+,-M+Q-FM+

Page 331: Underground Great Wall

W7$P];$]G9(.,"$D";62&T$%(,G7'-(.n$01#*#!K#!)$!5)&J!)$!Q?777!&-<(#)*!4)*1#)+$!

R7M0)"-)#./#Z;+4)"-)#+0#".'#Z;+4)"-)#./#7M0)"-)S!

A677!

6777!

W=..-<+L0<:>-A-M?+

ST\7! ST]7! STT7! A777! A7S7!

S777!

A777!

Q777!

`FMB-F/?+

a-<(#)*!3)*1#)+!!a%!M*%401z!

677!

S777!

O0??0<-?+

A677!

6777!

a-<(#)*!3)*1#)+!!a%!M*%401z!a%!M*%401z!a%!M*%401z!

2)*(!:)/)&!

SAC Development!

Page 332: Underground Great Wall

aE);2&.7'd.F$@&'8.7.$!.2."".82$@"'2."',!UF?-/+:.+MFM-+T:>>-.A?+

•  Hold opponents values hostage;!•  Target 300 American cities;!•  Believable capacity to kill 200,000,000 Americans;!•  Reduce Vulnerability -- they can’t target what they can’t see --

hide and move;!•  Reduce cost of “high ready” systems with mobilization;!•  Discussion of 2nd and 3rd Strategic Strikes, with implied:!

–  Stored reserve;!–  Reloads;!–  Multiple launch positions.!

•  Demonstrate enhanced capability during a crisis.!

What would it take?"

Page 333: Underground Great Wall

Distribution of US Population!LG%>-()I%&!e#&$.0J!A777l!G#%>(#!>#*!$`-)*#!5.(#!KJ!2%-&0J?N!jH#+.$0*.<I&/!e)0)?!G"!TRFS\SC!3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!':!2#&$-$!Z-*#)-?!A777k@!

Page 334: Underground Great Wall

'>,FTA+O-YFA:.+\FMB-F/?+++s+3I+=MUF.+FM-F?++

S0YB+F<GA=/-+HF<<:=A++\-?A+A:+-F?A!

PRC Counter-Value Strike Against US Cities: 2000!

Page 335: Underground Great Wall

'>,FTA+Å0<:A:.+\FMB-F/?++s+437+T0G-?++

O-YFA:.+\FMB-F/?+++s+45+=MUF.+FM-F?++

S0YB+F<GA=/-+HF<<:=A++\-?A+A:+-F?A!

Counter-Value Strike Against US Cities with MIRV!

Page 336: Underground Great Wall

Distribution of US Electrical Grid!

Page 337: Underground Great Wall

Collateral Destruction of US Electrical Grid with City Attack

Page 338: Underground Great Wall

LD)*=#0!n)(-#!%9!X/*.<-(0-*)(!G*%+-<0$!:%(+!KJ!2%-&0J?N!78,+-5A'5,2A#7'A20#./#'()#T"+')4#?'2')0G!j3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!2#&$-$!%9!X/*.<-(0-*#?!STTAk?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@&)$$@-$+)@/%;b<#&$-$b<#&$-$TAb)0()$TAb105(b57AT@105!u!v)<<#$$#+!S6!e#<@!A77\w@!

Value Distribution of US Agriculture!

Page 339: Underground Great Wall

%??=>,G:.?;+#:=.A-Md9F<=-+#0AQ+%uFTL+!);#*)/#!=.(%0%&!J.#(+!c!A77oO!).*K-*$0!!);#*)/#!5#/)0%&!J.#(+!c!ADO!).*K-*$0!

Å0<:A:.+\FMB-F/?++s+437+\-F,:.?++

O-YFA:.+\FMB-F/?+++s+45+\-F,:.?++

S0YB+F<GA=/-+HF<<:=A++\-?A+A:+-F?A!

'>,FTA+

Residual Radiation Coverage of US Agriculture!

Page 340: Underground Great Wall

POL Pumping Stations and Pipelines!

Page 341: Underground Great Wall

Major Breaks in Distribution!

Page 342: Underground Great Wall

a)I%&)(!d./14)J!:J$0#5!National Highway System!

Page 343: Underground Great Wall

a)I%&)(!d./14)J!:J$0#5!Major Breaks in Highway System!

Page 344: Underground Great Wall

a)I%&)(!H).(!a#0!National Rail Net!

Page 345: Underground Great Wall

a)I%&)(!H).(!a#0!National Rail Net Traffic!

Page 346: Underground Great Wall

Major Breaks in Railway System!

Page 347: Underground Great Wall

•  Y5>)<0!%&!G%>-()I%&!–  67?777?777!)*#!(.=#(J!0%!K#!+.*#<0!<)$-)(I#$!j.55#+.)0#!+#)01$!)&+!$#;#*#(J!.&�-*#+!*#`-.*.&/!5#+.<)(!

)t#&I%&!0%!$-*;.;#kC!–  X!$.5.()*!&-5K#*!jÖbF678k!4.((!$-W#*!*)+.)I%&!$.<=&#$$!*)&/.&/!9*%5!+#K.(.0)I&/!0%!(.9#F$1%*0#&.&/C!!–  X0!(#)$0!AbQ!%9!01#!&)I%&$!\?6[T!1%$>.0)($!4.((!K#!+#$0*%J#+!%*!.&%>#*)K(#!)&+!1)(9!01#!>1J$.<.)&$b$-*/#%&$!

)&+!%01#*!1#)(01<)*#!>*%9#$$.%&)($!01#5$#(;#$!<)$-)(I#$@!

•  Y5>)<0!%&!h(#<0*.<)(!M#&#*)I%&!–  O1#!&)I%&)(!#(#<0*.<)(!/*.+!4.((!K#!K*%=#&!.&!%;#*!A77!5)�%*!)*#)$!)&+!)0!(#)$0!SbQ!%9!01#!/#&#*)I%&!<)>)<.0J!

+#$0*%J#+C!–  O1#!()<=!%9!#(#<0*.<.0J!9%*!9%%+!$-$0#&0)I%&?!4)0#*!>-5>.&/?!0*)&$>%*0)I%&!)&+!9%$$.(!9-#(!>*%+-<I%&!)&+!

+.$0*.K-I%&!4.((!5#)&!01)0!;.*0-)((J!)((!$-*;.;.&/!>%>-()I%&!.&!-*K)&!)*#)$!)&+!0%4&$!4.((!K#/.&!$0)*;.&/!4.01.&!)!4##=!%9!01#!)t)<=C!!

–  P%*!)0!(#)$0!A!J#)*$!9%((%4.&/!01#!)t)<=?!()<=!%9!#(#<0*.<.0J!4.((!.5>)<0!]78!%9!X5#*.<)&!1%-$#1%(+$@!

•  Y5>)<0!%&!X/*.<-(0-*)(!G*%+-<I%&!–  X0!(#)$0!R78!%9!01#!&)I%&)(!9%%+!>*%+-<.&/!)/*.<-(0-*)(!()&+!4.((!K#!#B>%$#+!0%!$./&.E<)&0!*#$.+-)(!*)+.)I%&C!–  P)*5.&/!>*%+-<I;.0J!4.((!+*%>!0%!(#$$!01)&!A68!+-#!0%!()<=!%9!4)0#*!>-5>.&/?!#`-.>5#&0!9-#(?!9##+?!$##+?!

9#*I(.V#*!)&+!5)&>%4#*C!$()-/10#*!%9!9##+!$0%<=!.&!01#!E*$0!$.B!5%&01$!%9!&)I%&)(!9)5.&#!4.((!0)=#!+#<)+#!0%!*#>()<#C!

–  :0)*;)I%&!4.((!K#!)!*#)(.0J!9%*!)0!(#)$0!S77?777?777!X5#*.<)&$!$-*;.;.&/!01#!.&.I)(!)t)<=@!

KPWWPO+$'");+3II+>0<<0:.+<:?AN+F./+?=ME0E0.Y+%>-M0TF.?+\0<<+U-+<0E0.Y+0.+AB-+/FMLN+:.+F+?=U?0?A-.T-+/0-AN+\0AB+F+<0H-+?AQ<-+F./+<0H-+-1,-TAF.TQ+-]=0EF<-.A+A:+AB-+/FML+FY-?Z+

T/]#@0'.L'!"$?1H1'!.;?01%6X#K;1'+00#@<'

Page 348: Underground Great Wall

12",2.S'9$*"37$@;82";($W3)('9,2';87$$;:$,$C,"S.$@&'8.7.$]G9(.,"$O;"9.$

•  R:?A+&W%DW+''+–  X!()*/#*!01)&!#$I5)0#+!21.&#$#!$0*)0#/.<!&-<(#)*!9%*<#!*).$#$!/*);#!`-#$I%&$!)K%-0!':!

&)I%&)(!$#<-*.0Jl!•  ':!&-<(#)*!9%*<#!(#;#($!&##+#+z!•  ':!&-<(#)*!9%*<#!*#(.)K.(.0Jb<)>)K.(.I#$b#W#<I;#&#$$z!•  ':!#B0#&+#+!+#0#**#&0!9%*!X$.)&!X((.#$!)&+!)$!&%&F>*%(.9#*)I%&!.&<#&I;#z!•  :#(9F+#0#**#+!KJ!01*#)0!%9!L-&)<<#>0)K(#!+)5)/#N!0%!X5#*.<)&!>%>-()I%&z!•  2%&$0*).&0$!%&!':!G*%5>0!M(%K)(!:0*.=#!<)>)K.(.I#$!

–  21.&)!.$!+#;#(%>.&/!)!$0*%&/!<%&;#&I%&)(!K)((.$I<!5.$$.(#!9%*<#!•  2%&$0*).&0$!%&!':!5.$$.(#!+#9#&$#$!

–  21.&)!.$!+#;#(%>.&/!.0$!%4&!&)I%&)(!5.$$.(#!+#9#&$#!

•  R:A-.GF<+H=A=M-+!&d#B0.F+?AMFA-Y0T+.=T<-FM+FM>?+T:.AM:<+0??=-?+–  d.$0%*J!%9!1./1(J!$-<<#$$9-(!21.&#$#!$#<*#<J!)&+!+#<#>I%&!–  e-)(!<)>)K(#!0)<I<)(b01#)0#*!K)((.$I<!5.$$.(#!$J$0#5$!,!':!<%&$0*).&#+!KJ!YaP!O*#)0J!–  R01!/#&#*)I%&!&-<(#)*!4#)>%&$!&%0!<%;#*#+!KJ!<-**#&0!0*#)I#$!–  ':!<)>)K.(.I#$!0%!;#*.9J?!.&!(./10!%9!21.&#$#!'&+#*/*%-&+!M*#)0!3)((!#W%*0!0%!*#+-<#!

#W#<I;#&#$$!%9!':!&)I%&)(!0#<1&.<)(!5#)&$!

Page 349: Underground Great Wall

/��%!=M$A-+"':@42%6-$%F'*-,<:Q>-.A+HM:>+!./-MYM:=./+0.+F+#M0?0?'

Rr#45,+"8#F)2-)6=)#."A9#0=2AA#L52"66)0#./#5"+'0#D+AA#M)#2AA.-2')4#+"#F,)d4)'),=+")4#.F),26."2A#2,)20#/.,#)=),8)"-9#50)G#2"4#'()#=2+"#.F),26."2A#5"+'0#D+AA#M)#2AA.-2')4#+"#2,)20#.5'0+4)#'()#.F),26."2A#2,)20#'(2'#2,)#',2"0F.,'26."#2--)00+MA)I'B,+.,#'.#D2,G#."A9#=+00+A)#5"+'0#'(2'#M)2,#'()#=+00+."#./#-."45-6"8#H,)#20025A'#2"4#0=2AA#L52"66)0#./#05FF.,'#5"+'0#`.,#)A)=)"'0a#R-++'A"'2++$#20"&'-%'0?"'#$%#"2+"&'09%%"+6'R-0?-%'0?"'$4")2*$%2+'2)"26G#D(+A)#'()#,)=2+"+"8#5"+'0#D+AA#M)#F.0+6.")4#+"#-."-)2A)4#2,)20#'(2'#2,)#/2,#/,.=#'()#'()2'),G#'(),)M9#,)45-+"8#'()#.;),2AA#)WF.0)4#/.,-)0I'*5,+"8#'()#D2,#+0#D()"#/.,D2,4#3$A-+"'

"@42%6-$%'+0#-."45-')4#2'#'()#2FF,.F,+2')#6=)IS!

中国人!óŚÌ6Ĵ�Č4!vO1#!:<.#&<#!%9!:#<%&+!X*I((#*J!2)5>)./&$w?!#+.0#+!KJ!}-!r.B-&!v�ƆŜw?!jZ#.�.&/?!GH2l!G"X!G*#$$?!A77Rkl!>@!S]A@!!

Page 350: Underground Great Wall

|!|!|!W:,+#:E-M+S-<0T:,A-M+&-T=M0AQ+s+"=T<-FM+`FMB-F/+*-,<:Q>-.A_'

Page 351: Underground Great Wall

Chinese Deterrence Terminology!

e%5.&)0# !威 !4ä. !5./10?!>*#$I/#!

X9*).+ !· !$1ã !<%4#*?!$<)*#+?!9#)*9-(!

:1)=#! !震 !V1ã& !`-)=#?!$J5K%(!%9!01-&+#*!

P%*<# !逼 !Kå !5)=#!$%5#%&#!+%!$%5#01.&/!

G%4#* !力 !(ç !$0*#&/01?!.&U-#&<#!

2)>)K.(.0J !量 !(.é&/ !<)>)<.0J?!`-)&I0J?!)5%-&0!

a-<(#)* !核 !1è !)0%5!

e#0#**#&<#! !威· !4ä.$1ã !+%5.&)0#!01*-!9#)*?!<%4#*!KJ!9%*<#!Y&I5.+)0# !震· !V1ã&$1ã !0%!K#!.&!)4#?!$1)=#b0*#5%*?!!2%5>#((#&<# !威逼 !4ä.Kå !01*#)0#&?!<%#*<#!

e#0#**#&0! !威·力量 !4ä.$1ã(ç(.)&/ !+%5.&)I&/!>%4#*!<)>)K.(.0J!

a-<(#)*!e#0#**#&<#! !核威·! !1è4ä.$1ã !&-<(#)*!+%5.&)I%&!01*-!9#)*!

a-<(#)*!e#0#**#&0! !核威·力量! !1è4ä.$1ã(ç(.)&/ !&-<(#)*!+%5.&)I&/!!>%4#*!<)>)K.(.0J!

Å)X+`PD*&+

Å)X+#P"&WD!#W&+

Page 352: Underground Great Wall

PRC View of Deterrence is neither Minimal nor Passive"!Warfighting and deterrence are two major basic functions of the armed forces. What is termed deterrence is the military conduct of a state or a political group in displaying force or showing determination to use force to compel the enemy to submit to one’s volition and to refrain from taking hostile actions or escalating the hostility.!!Strategic deterrence and strategic operations are dialectically unified. Strategic operations secure the strategic objective through direct engagement with the enemy on the battlefield, with a view to winning the war or to curbing the war by war, which the objective of strategic deterrence is to contain the outbreak of war or to limit the scope and the escalation of war, with a view to curbing the war, and its strategic objective is attained by non-fighting means or fighting a small war. Strategic deterrence and strategic operations are interacted, and their objectives are for attaining one’s strategic objectives by frustrating the enemy’s attempts. Peng Guangquian and Yao Youzhi, Science of Strategy, (Beijing: 2005): pp. 213-214.

!With regard to the Second Artillery conventional missile strike campaign, it will be carried out under nuclear deterrence conditions. Despite the fact that future wars primarily will be conventional local wars, in the global [community,] those that have nuclear weapons are primarily nations with strong militaries, and have not promised no first use of nuclear weapons; moreover local wars that erupt in the near future will implement nuclear deterrence many times. !!The Second Artillery must successfully handle preparations for nuclear strike and nuclear deterrence, and must be rooted in nuclear conditions or operations under nuclear deterrence conditions. Missile deterrence operations are the operational activities to contain enemy strategic intentions or major military risky operations through the specific use of forces and firepower from the Second Artillery conventional missile campaign large formation in order to demonstrate firm will and formidable actual strength against the enemy side’s implementation of containment.!!Missile deterrent operations are permeated with stratagem qualities and artistry. Their essence lies in the ingenious selection of targets, ingenious choice of timing opportunities, ingenious use of forces and firepower, and the ingenious application of operational methods. The campaign commander and the command organ must fully anticipate all the situations that might emerge during the campaign, while formulating multiple deterrence operational methods and advance plans. When implementing the missile deterrence operation, one should flexibly employ deterrence operational methods based on the strategic intentions of the higher-level authorities and the dynamic state of the enemy side and make every effort to achieve the goals of deterrence. Science of Campaigns, edited by É1)&/!}-(.)&/?!(Beijing: 2006): pp. 709-710, 727.

Page 353: Underground Great Wall

@&'8.7.$]G9(.,"$@,),-(.$$<,92'9,($I$<&.,2."$B'77'(.$1E72.37$

L21.&#$#!D.$$.(#$!a#4$!g!e.$<-$$.%&$?N!B2:+0'2"#*)/)"0)#J.,5=G#jA7SS@7S@F\k?!)0!s!1t>lbb444@+#9#&<#@>=b9%*-5$b<1.&)F+#9#&<#b]RAS6F<1.&#$#F5.$$.(#$F&#4$F+.$<-$$.%&$@105(!!u!v)<<#$$#+!AS!r)&@!A7SSw!

Page 354: Underground Great Wall

Rj%#"'"G"),0?-%5'-6'60$)"&'9%&")5)$9%&7'2%&'5-G"%'0?20'1?-%2'0"%&6'0$'&"#$94+"'R2)?"2&6'.)$3'0?"'3-66-+"67'-0'R-++'A"'%"@0'0$'-34$66-A+"'0$'N92%*.,'1?-%2[6'"%*)"'%9#+"2)'2)6"%2+I#E.'#."A9#D.5A4#hG%%%:=#./#0'.,28)#2AA.D#/.,#2#8,)2'A9#)WF2"4)4#2,0)"2AG#A90'0)2%64$)0'#242A-+-*"6'R-0?-%'0?"'09%%"+'#$9+&'2++$R'.$)'0?"'+29%#?'$.'%9#+"2)'R"24$%6'.)$3'2'%93A")'$.'+$#2*$%6'2+$%5'0?"'09%%"+rI#X&J!$-K$0)&I)(!.&<*#)$#!.&!.0$!)*$#&)(!4%-(+!5#)&!01)0!Z#.�.&/x$!(.5.0#+!+#0#**#&0!.$!j%*!<%-(+!K#<%5#k!9)*!/*#)0#*!01)&!41)0!4#!1);#!<%5#!0%!#B>#<0@!!/#'(+0#D),)#'.#=2'),+2A+j)G#'()#)"6,)#0',2')8+-#M2A2"-)#+"#70+2#D.5A4#M)#0(2:)"#2"4#D.5A4#+");+'2MA9#.$)#"'0?"'Y!7'0?"'6$+"'6"#9)-0,'592)2%0$)'-%'0?"')"5-$%7'0$')"266"66'?$R'-0'#2+#9+20"6'0?"')-6J6'2%&'#$606'$.'-%0")G"%*$%7'69#?'26'&9)-%5'2'#)-6-6rIS…#

2%(#?!r@!D.<1)#(@!i31)0!Y$!01#!G"X!d.+.&/!-&+#*&#)01!d#K#.zi!O).>#.!O.5#$@!Q7!X-/@!A7SS@!3#K@!SQ!:#>0@!A7SS@!s1t>lbb444@0).>#.I5#$@<%5ba#4$b#+.0%*.)($b)*<1.;#$bA7SSb7]bQ7bA77Q6SSTT\u@!DXG!9*%5l!LM#‡&/!Z#J%&+!01#!‚O*)&$>)*#&<Jq!e.$<-$$.%&?N!e.$<-$$.%&!K(%/?!':!a);)(!Y&$I0-0#?!jA7SS@7S@A[k?!)0!s!1t>lbbK(%/@-$&.@%*/bA7SSb7SbA[b/#‡&/FK#J%&+F01#F‚0*)&$>)*#&<JqF+.$<-$$.%&b!u!v)<<#$$#+!ST!r-(J!A7SSw@!

Page 355: Underground Great Wall

12",2.S'9$%,"'2E$I$<&.,2."$Y79,(,2';8$!;3'8,89.$

êD)�@M#&@!ƒ1#&/!:1#&B.)?!`-%0#+!.&l!<(+")0)#m+)D0#./#J5'5,)#V2,/2,)G#D@!G.(($K-*J?!j3)$1.&/0%&?!e2l!a)I%&)(!e#9#&$#!'&.;#*$.0J!G*#$$?!S77\kl!>@!B(.@!P%*!;)*.%-$!%01#*!;.#4$?!$##l!G#&/!M-)&/`.)&!)&+!})%!}%-V1.?!1()#?-+)"-)#./#K+A+'2,9#?',2')89G#!jZ#.�.&/?!GH2l!D.(.0)*J!:<.#&<#!G-K(.$1.$1.&/!d%-$#?!A776kC!)&+!y.)%!".)&/!)&+!3)&/!|.)&/$-.?!T",)0',+-')4#V2,/2,)G#!jZ#.�.&/?!GH2l!".0#*)0-*#!)&+!X*0$!G-K(.$1.&/!d%-$#?!STTTk@!

'"W)"

&'WX+:H+#P"($'#W+

&#PR)+:H+#P"($'#W+

"=T<-FM+++++++++++++++++++++++++++#:.E-.G:.F<+

"=T<-FM+WBM-?B:</+

g<:UF<!$:TF<+! WB-FA-M!

=k'%$'$%"'R2%06'0$'"6#2+20"'0?"'#$%l-#06'A90'"G"),$%"'-6'"25")'0$')"60)2-%'0?"'$0?")EFm'

#B0.F+

!&+l+%<<0-?+

O'$'W%DX+&WD)"gWS+ V+

Page 356: Underground Great Wall

^ +'A+0?+M-F<+b+FTA=F<+?0h-+=.L.:\.+U=A+?AM:.Y+-E0/-.T-+ABFA+0A+0?+AB-+<FMY-?A+.=T<-FM+=./-MYM:=./+T:>,<-1+-E-M+T:.?AM=TA-/+UQ+F.Q:.-e+

^ +%A+<-F?A+BF<H+i2N6II+>0<-?j+T:.?AM=TA-/+0.+AB-+<F?A+26+Q-FM?+A:+FTT:>>:/FA-+?:<0/dH=-<+>0??0<-?e!

^ +'A+0.E:<E-?+B0/0.Y+'#KO?+F?+\-<<+F?+WFTGTF<+F./+WB-FA-M+W)$&e+

^ +`-+/:+"PW+L.:\+\BFA+AB-Q+FM-+B0/0.Y+0.+AB-+W=..-<?+U=A+-E0/-.T-+?=YY-?A?+>=TB+<FMY-M+.=T<-FM+\FMB-F/+l+>0??0<-+M-<:F/+0.E-.A:MQe+

^ +!./-MYM:=./+gM-FA+`F<<+F,,-FM?+A:+U-+F??:T0FA-/+\0AB+0.AM:/=TG:.+:H+O'D9+'#KO+F./+&AMFA-Y0T+WMF0.?e+

^ +#:.G.=-/+WB-FA-M+&DKOw'DKO+-1,F.?0:.+/-?0Y.-/+A:+@*-A-M+AB-+*-A-MM-MNC+0H+.:A+M-E-M?-/+dd+\0<<+ABM-FA-.+!&dD=??0F.+'"(+WM-FAQe+

^ +(F0<=M-+A:+Y-A+#B0.Fq?+H:MT-?+T:.?AMF0.-/+E0F+.-Y:GFG:.+\0<<+,M:/=T-+>Fa:M+TBF<<-.Y-+A:+!&+T:=.A-Md,M:<0H-MFG:.+"=T<-FM+!>UM-<<F+0.+%?0FZ+

@&'8,c7$$PR8F."S";G8F$$D".,2$$?,((T$

12",2.S'9$W3)('9,2';87!

Page 357: Underground Great Wall

Y8F$;:$2&.$<G88.($;"$,$

].6$U).8'8Sn$