unconfirmed minutes - performance review...

20
COMPOSITES TASK GROUP OCTOBER 2007 UNCONFIRMED MINUTES 22-26 OCTOBER 2007 PITTSBURGH MARRIOTT CITY CENTER PITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA These minutes are not final until confirmed by the Task Group in writing or by vote at a subsequent meeting. Information herein does not constitute a communication or recommendation from the Task Group and shall not be considered as such by any agency. MONDAY, 22 OCTOBER 2007 (CLOSED SESSION) A Closed meeting was held with only Primes attending. During this time the following items were addressed… Audits in Task Group and Staff Engineer Review were reviewed and discussed. A succession plan for the Task Group Chair, Vice Chair and Secretary was reviewed and approved (See attached presentation for details.). Auditor statistics were reviewed to establish auditor performance since July 2007. Staff Engineer Delegation status and maintenance data was reviewed. MONDAY, 22 OCTOBER 2007 (OPEN SESSION) 1.0 OPENING COMMENTS 1.1 Call to Order/Quorum Check The Composites Task Group Meeting was called to order by David Watson at 1:00 pm. A quorum of qualifying members was established. 15 primes 1.1.1 Introductions 1.1.2 Routing of Attendance List The attendance list was routed for signatures. User Members Present Name Company Peter Atwell Airbus Mike Bemis Goodrich Aerostructures Page 1 of 20

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jan-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

UNCONFIRMED MINUTES22-26 OCTOBER 2007

PITTSBURGH MARRIOTT CITY CENTERPITTSBURGH, PENNSYLVANIA

These minutes are not final until confirmed by the Task Group in writing or by vote at a subsequent meeting. Information herein does not constitute a communication or recommendation from the Task Group and shall not be considered as such by any agency.

MONDAY, 22 OCTOBER 2007 (CLOSED SESSION)

A Closed meeting was held with only Primes attending. During this time the following items were addressed…Audits in Task Group and Staff Engineer Review were reviewed and discussed. A succession plan for the Task Group Chair, Vice Chair and Secretary was reviewed and approved (See attached presentation for details.). Auditor statistics were reviewed to establish auditor performance since July 2007. Staff Engineer Delegation status and maintenance data was reviewed.

MONDAY, 22 OCTOBER 2007 (OPEN SESSION)

1.0 OPENING COMMENTS

1.1 Call to Order/Quorum Check

The Composites Task Group Meeting was called to order by David Watson at 1:00 pm. A quorum of qualifying members was established. 15 primes

1.1.1 Introductions

1.1.2 Routing of Attendance List

The attendance list was routed for signatures.

User Members PresentName CompanyPeter Atwell AirbusMike Bemis Goodrich AerostructuresPeter Bonarrigo BombardierSharon Bull Rolls RoyceJeff Conrad Cessna Aircraft Co.Marty Couey Hawker BeechcraftLucia Cutillo Alenia AeronauticaMarsha Davis Lockheed MartinKevin Dowling Spirit AeroSystemsJoe Dwyer Rolls RoyceM’hamed El Haouari Bombardier Aerospace (Canada)Marcel Francois SAFRAN GroupArceli-Angelina Gabriel The Boeing Company

Page 1 of 16

Page 2: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

Udo Goessler Eurocopter Olivier Goupillon EurocopterBrett Hemingway BAE SystemsMark Jackson VoughtJamar Johnson Bell HelicopterBetty Kocsis HoneywellDoug Ladd The Boeing CompanyEric LeFort SonacaFrank Lennert The Boeing CompanyLance Loeks The Boeing CompanyWilliam Macias GoodrichLeah Markowitz HoneywellAndreas Mastorakis GE AviationPatricia Matkowski The Boeing CompanyAngelina Mendoza GoodrichRick Ouellette The Boeing CompanyKeith Panuska Lockheed MartinDoug Prenovost Northrop GrummanEngin Sabuncu Cessna Aircraft Co.Gregory Sayler MD HelicoptersFrank Thomas BombardierDavid Watson Bombardier

Other Participants/Members PresentName CompanyRichard Alkire Hexcel, WAFrank Anderson The M&P LabMichael Ashton HexcelBryon Ater BG & S Peening and ConsultingJohn Augsback Parkway ProductsMitch Birzer General DynamicsRobert Bragg General DynamicsPaul Braun Cincinnati Testing LaboratoriesJohn Brunet OCM Test LabsElmer Cardwell General DynamicsMichelle E. Colunga OOALC Hill AFBEric Dirats Dirats LabsBen Flores AASCBrian Gallagher HenkelMiguel Gerdel Thermal StructuresPhillip Gill Royal Plastic MfgNiko V. Gjaja The M&P LabDane Gowryluk Bristol AerospaceDave Gray Mitchell LabsJohn Graham DACA Machine and ToolJames Kernan Corpus Christi Army DepotDave Kimber ATK Aerospace StructuresJ.F. Lemmen Denel SAAB AerostructuresJessica Mager Avcorp Industries

Page 2 of 16

Page 3: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

Mary Marshall Albany Engineered CompositesJune Mason Albany Engineered CompositesBrian McCrory Delsen Testing LaboratoriesT.W. Newton Aircraft X-Ray LabsW.F. Newton Aircraft X-Ray LabsYeow Ng NCAMPKrish Patni D-J EngineeringArt Pecant DACA Machine and ToolSteve Peery CHIDuane Praymayer Bristol AerospaceJim Rossi Westmoreland Mech Testing &

ResearchDon Russell Toray CompositesVictor Schonberger Israel Aerospace IndustriesSteve Schrameyer Cytec Engineered MaterialsDave Scott Hitco Carbon CompositesJean Scott OO-ALC Hill AFBJeff Sharp General DynamicsAndy Sinclair Bodycote Testing GroupSteve Stafford General DynamicsGene Stupin General DynamicsGary Thompson Darotem EngineeringDavid Tomasitis PTI IndustriesDennis Walmsley Brookhouse Composites Ltd.Fritz Watson AASC

PRI Staff PresentRebekah Foutz PRI Staff (Warrendale, PA)

1.1.3 Review of Agenda

The Staff Engineer (Rebekah Foutz) reviewed the agenda for this Composites Task Group, October 2007, Nadcap meeting in Pittsburg, PA with the Task Group members present.

1.1.4 Approval of Previous Meeting Minutes

The minutes from the 16-20 July 2007 Composites Task Group Meeting were reviewed. A motion was made for approval of the minutes, seconded, and all were in favor with no disapprovals. Therefore, the minutes were approved as written. All meeting minutes will be available on the PRI web site at www.pri-network.org.

1.1.5 Secession Planning Announcement

1.1.6 Succession plan for the Task Group Chair, Vice Chair and Secretary was reviewed and approved.

1.1.6.1 Each position will have a term of two years minimum. The vice chair moves to chair position and a new vice chair will

Page 3 of 16

Page 4: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

be selected. The secretary position will be asked to alternate among volunteers.

1.1.6.2 The following are the members who will be transitioning into each position:

Mike Bemis – Composites Task Group Chair

Kevin Dowling – Composites Task Group Vice Chair

Leah Markowitz – Task Group Secretary

1.1.6.3 The transition will be as follows:

During the February 2008 meeting, Mike Bemis will transition the Secretary role to Leah Markowitz. During the October 2008 meeting, David Watson will transition the chair to Mike Bemis and Andreas Mastorakis will transition the vice chair to Kevin Dowling. The two year term period begins in October 2008.

2.0 STAFF/AUDITOR REPORT

2.1 Specific items of interest to the Composites Task Group since July 2007 included:

2.1.1 11 Primes have mandated AC7118 Rev A

2.1.2 Conducted annual Auditor Training

2.1.3 2007 Audit Projections

150 Projected

125 scheduled/conducted 66/36/23 in America/Europe/Asia respectively

83% of plan

73 certifications issued

2.1.4 Pareto of Nonconformances

An updated NCR Pareto chart was presented which detailed the most recurring findings to date for Composites audits conducted in 83 past audits. The Paragraph in which findings were most prevalent was 11.3.2 – Are document work instructions

Page 4 of 16

Page 5: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

available to operator and does the procedure(s) accurately reflect the manufacturing process?

This presentation, including the specific questions, can be viewed on www.eauditnet.com under Public Documents – Composites.

2.1.5 Auditor Base Status

2.1.6 The current auditor base status was presented to the Task Group. There are currently 6 auditors with one located in the Europe Sector and 5 located in the Americas Sector.

2.1.7 ITAR/EAR

2.1.7.1 125 composite audits

2.1.7.2 53 of them (46%) have no ITAR/EAR restrictions

3.0 METRICS

3.1 PRI presented the Composites Task Group metrics and reviewed the status of each.

Year to date audits – Green

- Goal is to have excess capacity of 30%

- Actual excess capacity is 57%

Certs issued – Green

- Goal is to have <=10% expired certs

- Actual is 0% expired certs

Total Supplier cycle time - Initial audits – Yellow

- Goal is to have an average cycle time <=27 days

- Actual average cycle time is 28

Total Supplier cycle time – Reaccreditation audits – Green

- Goal is to have an average cycle time <=28 days

- Actual average cycle time is 28

Staff engineer cycle time – Initial audits – Green

- Goal is to have an average cycle time <=18 days

Page 5 of 16

Page 6: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

- Actual average cycle time is 12

Staff engineer cycle time – Reaccreditation audits – Green

- Goal is to have an average cycle time <=11 days

- Actual average cycle time is 10

Task Group cycle time – Initial audits – Yellow

- Goal is to have an average cycle time <=14 days

- Actual average cycle time is 15

Task Group cycle time – Reaccreditation audits – Green

- Goal is to have an average cycle time <=14 days

- Actual average cycle time is 7

Suppliers on merit – Red

- Goal is to have 80% of Suppliers eligible, on Merit

- Actual percentage is 68% (lower result due to going beyond 3 cycles)

Prime Audit Balloting charts presented for initial and reaccreditation

4.0 SUPPLIER SUPPORT COMMITTEE REPORT – (MIGUEL GERDEL)

The Nadcap Supplier Support Committee (SSC) update was presented, including the mission and purpose of this committee. An update was given on the activities of the Communications and Mentoring Team, Metrics Team, Supplier Survey Team, 25 Mile Rule and Pilot Checklist Review. Further details on these topics can be reviewed in the attached SSC Report.

A proposal was made for the Composite Task Group to not adopt the flow down requirements document. Motion made to accept the proposal, seconded, and accepted.

The minutes from the SSC meeting conducted on Tuesday, 23 October 2007 will be available on www.pri-network.org.

5.0 ACTION ITEM LIST REPORT OUT

Page 6 of 16

Page 7: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

The action items from the previous meetings were reviewed during the meeting as follows:

5.1 Action Item status

January Action Item #7 – Closed

January Action #11 – Closed – There was no consistency of auditors using this paragraph during the audit.

January Action #17 – Closed – Task Group voted during the October 2007 Nadcap meeting and agreed to not go forward with the flow-down template.

January Action #18 – Closed – No further clarification was added to the Audit Handbook.

January Action #24 – Closed – Reviewed and addressed during Agenda Item #7.

April Action #5 – Closed

July Action #1 – 15 – Closed

6.0 AC7118 REVIEW FOR IMPROVEMENTS

6.1 This marks the beginning of a review of the AC7118 Rev A to identify areas for improvement. Significant discussion took place on a variety of topics such as redundant Quality System questions, requirements for documented procedures and the addition or modification of job audits. As a result of these discussions, action items have been assigned and will be reported out at the next Nadcap meeting in addition to a review of any proposals for Audit Handbook clarification. All proposed checklist changes were captured and will be formally balloted at a later date.

Action Item – Review sections 3 - 11 of the AC7118 Rev A to determine if there is duplication between these sections and the job audits (sections 12 – 23), Lance Loeks (Lead), Miguel Gerdel, Kevin Dowling, Dave Tomasitis, Dave Kimber, Pete Atwell, June Mason & a Composites Auditor (Due: 28 December /2007)

Action Item – Provide Audit Handbook Clarification for AC7118 Rev A paragraph 8.1.6 to better define its intent regarding ply trimming requirements, Lance Loeks (Lead), Miguel Gerdel, Kevin Dowling, Dave Tomasitis, Dave Kimber, Pete Atwell, June Mason & a Composites Auditor (Due: 28 December 2007)

Page 7 of 16

Page 8: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

Action Item – Provide Audit Handbook Clarification for AC7118 Rev A paragraph 3.3.1, Peter Atwell (Lead), Sharon Bull, Dave Kimber (Due: 28 December 2007)

Action Item – Revise wording for AC7118 Rev A paragraphs 4.3.1 and 4.3.2, Generate a question in each of the relevant job audit sections to replace general section question 4.2.1, Pete Atwell (Lead), Dave Kimber, Miguel Gerdel, and Sharon Bull (Due: 28 December 2007)

TUESDAY 23 OCTOBER 2007 (OPEN SESSION)

6.0 AC7118 REVIEW FOR IMPROVEMENTS (CONTINUED)

6.2 The action of reviewing the Quality System related paragraphs in the AC7118 has been completed at this meeting. Discussion has taken place and agreements have been made as to what questions are to be maintained in the AC7118. This action will not be repeated unless circumstances warrant further review.

Action Item – Provide Audit Handbook Clarification for the newly created section 11.5, Lance Loeks (Lead), Kevin Dowling, Miguel Gerdel, and June Mason (Due: 28 December 2007)

Action Item – Review the rest of section 12 and remove Question 2.9 as required, PRI (Due: 28 December 2007)

Action Item – Clarify the intent of AC7118 Rev A job audit 12.b to the Auditors. Order of precedence has been set for what materials are to be audited. Details have been added to the Audit Handbook, PRI (Due: 26 October 2007)

7.0 AC7118 AUDIT HANDBOOK REVIEW FOR IMPROVEMENTS

7.1 This Audit Handbook is an active working document. Suggestions for additions to the Audit Handbook since the July 2007 Nadcap were collected and reviewed. Some of the topics that were discussed were software quality control and EMA procedures. An EMA presentation was given to help clarify the intent of an EMA. This presentation is attached above and can be viewed on www.eauditnet.com under Public Documents – Composites.

Any revisions to the Audit Handbook that were discussed during the meeting were accepted by voice vote. Revisions to the Audit Handbook will now be identified in a Revision Table at the end of the document that will identify the paragraph number of the clarification that was revised.

Action Item – Provide Audit Handbook Clarification for AC7118 Rev A paragraph 4.4.4 to better define its intent (e.g. difference between Firmware and Software and what to

Page 8 of 16

Page 9: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

do when there are no automated controls), Lance Loeks (Lead), Miguel Gerdel, Kevin Dowling, Dave Tomasitis, Dave Kimber, Pete Atwell, June Mason & a Composites Auditor (Due: 28 December 2007)

Action Item – Provide Audit Handbook Clarification for AC7118 Rev A paragraph 10.1.6 (protection of test specimens), Mike Bemis & Andreas Mastorakis (Due: 28 December 2007)

Action Item – Provide Audit Handbook Clarification for AC7118 Rev A paragraph 11.3.2 (documentation of ply lay-up, inspection steps), Joe Dwyer (Lead), Miguel Gerdel, Fritz Watson (Due: 28 December 2007)

Action Item – Post the updated Audit Handbook on eAuditNet, PRI (Due: 9 November 2007)

Action Item – Post the EMA presentation on eAuditNet, PRI (Due: 9 November 2007)

Action Item – Circulate all report-outs for Action Items to the Task Group rosters, PRI (Due: 18 January 2008)

WEDNESDAY 24 OCTOBER 2007 (OPEN SESSION)

THE FUTURE OF THE COMPOSITE TASK GROUP (This item was added to the agenda during the meeting.)

Andreas Mastorakis (Task Group Vice Chair) and Rebekah Foutz (Task Group Staff Engineer) presented a request to the Nadcap Management Council (NMC) Steering Committee to allow the Composite Task Group to ballot documents (NIP 4-03) to different technical groupings. This proposal was approved by NMC.

Two rosters will be established. One roster will identify the Voting Members for AC7118 or Composite Parts. The second roster will identify the Voting Members for AC7122 or Composite Materials.

The NTGOP-001 Appendix 14 will be revised to clarify this.

The NMC also approved the Task Group to begin developing audit criteria for Prime Process Control Documentation (PCD).

8.0 NMC SUB-TEAMS AND PLANNING AND OPS MEETING REPORT-OUT

The minutes from the Planning and Ops, Nadcap Management Council and NMC Standardization Sub-Team meetings are available on www.pri-network.org/Nadcap.

9.0 TASK GROUP STANDARDIZATION

9.1 Reviewed the revisions that were made to the NTGOP-001. The Task Group was concerned that there are no words to detail the number of

Page 9 of 16

Page 10: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

Supplier voting members on a Task Group. Will approach the NMC and propose that the following be considered:

9.1.1 Set the total number of Supplier Voting Members to ½ of the total number of Task Group Voting Members.

9.2 Task Group agreed that Auditors are to go back one audit to verify implementation of corrective action.

Action Item – Identify the number of reaccreditation audits that close in two (2) days and five (5) days, PRI (Due: February 2008 Nadcap Meeting)

10.0 NTGOP-001 APPENDIX 14 REVIEW

10.1 The appendix was reviewed to eliminate redundant requirements that are already specified in governing documents and to remove items that have been standardized by NMC. All proposed changes were captured and will be formally balloted.

Action Item – Determine how individual Task Groups are to make changes to the NOP-011 appendix, PRI (Due: 2 November 2007)

11.0 OPEN DISCUSSION/NEW BUSINESS

11.1 July Auditor Training

11.1.1 Training will be focused around four (4) topics. Case studies/scenarios will be developed and auditors will be asked to identify nonconformances. Auditors will be broken into separate groups and then brought back together to share their points.

11.1.2 A working session will be scheduled for the February 2008 Nadcap meeting. Identified teams are to brainstorm their topics and bring any supporting resources they may have. The following teams were organized:

Receiving Inspection Area (Sharon Bull and Brett Hemingway)

Lay-up, CCA and EMA (Joe Dwyer, Keith Panuska, Pete Atwell, Lance Loeks, Marty Couey, and Kevin Dowling)

Testing (Eric LeFort, Andreas Mastorakis & Betty Kocsis)

Liquid Resin Processing (Mike Bemis, Mark Jackson, Jeff Conrad and David Watson)

12.0 MEETING CLOSE OUT

12.1 Next meeting date and location

Page 10 of 16

Page 11: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

The next Nadcap meetings are scheduled for the week of 25 - 29 February 2008 in Rome, Italy.

The formal agenda will be developed, distributed and will be available on www.pri-network.org.

ADJOURNMENT – The meeting was adjourned at 5:00 p.m.

Page 11 of 16

Page 12: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

THURSDAY 25 OCTOBER 2007 (OPEN SESSION)

Non Metallic Materials Testing (NMMT) Sub-Group

1.0 OPENING COMMENTS

1.1 Call to Order/Quorum Check

The NMMT subgroup Meeting was called to order by Andrea Mastorakis at 8:00 a.m. A quorum of qualifying members was established; 13 voting primes were present.

1.2 Introductions

1.3 Routing of Attendance List

The attendance list was routed for signatures

2.0 NMC SUB-TEAMS AND PLANNING AND OPS MEETING REPORT-OUT

The minutes from the Planning and Ops, Nadcap Management Council and NMC Standardization Sub-Team meetings are available on www.pri-network.org/Nadcap.

3.0 STAFF/AUDITOR REPORT

3.1 Specific items of interest since to the NMMT sub-group since April 2007 included:

3.1.1 Prime mandates of AC7122:

3.1.1.1 BAE Systems

3.1.1.2 GE Aviation – Mandate effective May 1, 2008. GE supplier approvals that expire after that date must obtain PRI AC7122 accreditation.

3.1.1.3 Goodrich – All Nadcap checklists are mandated, but a specific letter will be distributed to appropriate testing suppliers pertaining to AC7122.

3.1.1.4 SAFRAN Group

3.2 Andreas Mastorakis (Task Group Vice Chair) and Rebekah Foutz (Task Group Staff Engineer) presented a request to the Nadcap Management Council (NMC) Steering Committee to allow the Composite Task Group to ballot documents (NIP 4-03) to different technical groupings. This proposal was approved by NMC.

Page 12 of 16

Page 13: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

3.2.1 Two rosters will be established. One roster will identify the Voting Members for AC7118 or Composite Parts. The second roster will identify the Voting Members for AC7122 or Composite Materials.

3.2.2 The NTGOP-001 Appendix 14 will be revised to clarify this.

3.3 The NMC also approved the Task Group to begin developing audit criteria for Prime Process Control Documentation (PCD).

4.0 RELEASE OF AC7122 – NEXT STEPS

4.1 The AC7122 and AC7122/1 were released on 1 October 2007 and have an effective date of 31 December 2007.

5.0 ACTION ITEM REPORT-OUT

The action items from the previous meetings were reviewed during the meeting as follows:

5.1 Action Item Status:

April Action Item #19 – Closed

July Action Item #1 – 11 - Closed

6.0 AUDIT HANDBOOK DEVELOPMENT

6.1 This Audit Handbook is an active working document. Suggestions for additions to the Audit Handbook since the July 2007 Nadcap were collected and reviewed.

Any revisions to the Audit Handbook that were discussed during the meeting were accepted by voice vote. Revisions to the Audit Handbook will now be identified in a Revision Table at the end of the document that will identify the paragraph number of the clarification that was revised.

7.0 IPT PROGRAM REVIEW AND DEVELOPMENT

7.1 The MTL Task Group’s IPT program was reviewed and discussed. The NMMT sub-group will use as much of the already developed MTL IPT program when organizing an IPT program for NMMT. The NTGOP-001 Appendix 14 will be revised to detail general IPT requirements for the NMMT sub-group. Further details of the IPT program will be developed at the February 2008, Nadcap meeting.

7.2 The results of the pilot IPT were reviewed and discussed.

Page 13 of 16

Page 14: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

7.2.1 24 labs participated throughout the world. Both independent and captive.

7.2.2 Samples were prepared by Toray and cut randomly from 22 panels

7.2.3 Tensile strength, modulus, Compressive strength and Tg by DMA were included

7.2.4 Used ANOVA with P-value of Leven’s test of <0.05 (must be >0.05 to be significant.

7.2.5 Thirteen labs were shown to have equivalent values for tensile. Variation was partially attributed to thickness variation and the measurement thereof.

7.2.6 When examining modulus there was variation between labs that used extensometers and those that used strain gages. In the future the method should be specified when performing IPT.

7.2.7 Compressive strength results are affected by tightening of bolts. ASTM says finger tighten. In future IPTs, torque should be called out.

7.2.8 Tg by TMA - Two distinct data populations were reported; those that used expansion mode (ASTM E 1545 procedure A) and penetration mode (ASTM E 1545 procedure B). One lab was outside of acceptable results. Expansion probe yields less variation and should be performed for future IPTs. Also probe weight and probe diameter must be specified.

FRIDAY 26 OCTOBER 2007 (OPEN SESSION)

8.0 DEVELOPMENT OF NEW AUDIT CRITERIA

8.1 Yeow Ng from Wichita State University gave a presentation to the Task Group about NCAMP. Also presented was a preparation and maintenance guide for Prepreg PDCs.

8.2 A round table discussion took place regarding what each prime expects from PCD checklist. The following was agreed to:

8.2.1 No audit shall exceed 5 days.

8.2.2 AC7122 shall be used in addition to the PCD checklist. If needed, the audit duration shall be changed for Raw Material Suppliers.

Page 14 of 16

Page 15: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

8.2.3 Accreditation will be based on class of material and job audits will be structured around processes that could apply to multiple classes.

In Scope Out of ScopePCD Maintenance Material QualificationMaterial Receiving Incoming Receipt Testing of Materials

Process Control (Procedures) Process Control TestingProduction Equipment

Quality System Requirements

8.2.4 Processes to be included:

8.2.4.1 Resin Manufacturing8.2.4.1.1 Mixing

8.2.4.1.1.1 Reactor Mixing8.2.4.1.1.2 Compounding

8.2.4.1.2 Blending8.2.4.2 Filming8.2.4.3 Prepregging

8.2.4.3.1 Hot Melt8.2.4.3.2 Solution

8.2.4.4 Slitting

9.0 OPEN DISCUSSION/NEW BUSINESS

9.1 No items were brought to open discussion.

10.0 MEETING CLOSE OUT

10.1 Next meeting date and location

The next Nadcap meetings are scheduled for the week of 25-29 Feb 2008 in Rome, Italy.

The formal agenda will be developed, distributed and made available on www.pri-network.org.

FRIDAY, 20 JULY 2007 (CLOSED SESSION)

Non Metallic Materials Testing (NMMT) Sub-Group

A Closed meeting was held with Primes attending. Pilot audit results were reviewed.

ADJOURNMENT – The meeting was adjourned at 4 pm

Page 15 of 16

Page 16: UNCONFIRMED MINUTES - Performance Review Institutecdn.p-r-i.org/.../10/12111443/CompandNMMTMeetingMinutesOcot…  · Web viewOn review of PO#156439B for material A0352 (3M EC2216

COMPOSITES TASK GROUPOCTOBER 2007

***** For PRI Staff use only: ******

Are procedural/form changes required based on changes/actions approved during this meeting? (select one)

YES* NO

*If yes, the following information is required:

Documents requiring revision:

Who is responsible: Due date:

Page 16 of 16