turning enemies into adversaries - t-tip negotiations and the quest for a new westphalia momentum -

22
TURNING ENEMIES INTO ADVERSARIES TTIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum

Upload: emanuela-matei

Post on 21-Apr-2017

440 views

Category:

Law


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

TURNING ENEMIES INTO ADVERSARIES TTIP Negotiations and

the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum

Page 2: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

THE PAST IS PROLOGUE …

Page 3: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

A ‘BIT’ OF HISTORY: INVESTMENT LAW THROUGH THE AGES (1/4)

Page 4: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

A ‘BIT’ OF HISTORY: INVESTMENT LAW THROUGH THE AGES (2/4)

Page 5: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

A ‘BIT’ OF HISTORY: INVESTMENT LAW THROUGH THE AGES (3/4)

Page 6: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

A ‘BIT’ OF HISTORY: INVESTMENT LAW THROUGH THE AGES (4/4)

Page 7: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

THE TTIP MOMENT: TO ISDS OR NOT TO ISDS? (1/2)

Page 8: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

THE TTIP MOMENT: TO ISDS OR NOT TO ISDS? (2/2)

Page 9: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

ELEMENTS OF CLASSICAL ISDS: THE PATH TO SUCCESS

Page 11: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

ISDS REFORMATION IN THE VISION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION

Security of tenure

A set salary

Objective method of assignment

Prohibition on outside lawyering

Judicial procedure to solve conflict of interest claims

Page 12: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

FIRST CLASH: HUNGARIAN PPA CASES (I)

Page 13: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

FIRST CLASH: HUNGARIAN PPA CASES (I)

Page 15: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

UNITED IN DIVERSITY

Paul Schiff Berman 2013

Page 16: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

FIRST CLASH: HUNGARIAN PPA CASES (II)

Page 17: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -
Page 18: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

HYBRID JUSTICE

Page 19: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

CONCLUSIONS: AFTER THE DELUGE?

Page 20: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

CONCLUSIONS: AFTER THE DELUGE?

Page 21: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

CONCLUSIONS: AFTER THE DELUGE?

Page 22: Turning Enemies into Adversaries - T-TIP Negotiations and the Quest for a New Westphalia Momentum -

EPILOGUE The conflicting nomoi in our essay may be

represented as two tectonic plates moving away from each over.

The point of departure is described by the term “divergent boundary”.

In nature as in law, divergence may stimulate the creation of new material.

Avoid the dilemma of choosing between automatic subordination and insistence on jurispathic autonomy!

Allow divergence to function as a catalyst of jurisgenesis!