tuesday-1245-stgec2019 chattanooga-challenge accepted i-24 ... 7.pdf · • limited row •...

23
CHALLENGE ACCEPTED: A PROJECT REVIEW OF TDOT’S I‐24 INTERCHANGE AT BROAD AND MARKET STREET

Upload: others

Post on 11-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

CHALLENGE ACCEPTED:A PROJECT REVIEW OF TDOT’S I‐24 INTERCHANGE AT BROAD AND MARKET STREET

�������������� � ��� � ���������������������� �������

��� ���������������� � ��� ������������������ ����� ���!

Page 2: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

PROJECT TEAM

TDOT Structures Division Roadway Design

Geotechnical

Page 3: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

TODAY’S AGENDA

1. Project Overview2. Challenges throughout the Design 

Process• Geology• Field Exploration• Design Decisions

3. Project Communication4. Questions

3

Page 4: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

4

PROJECT OVERVIEW

Page 5: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

CHALLENGES

5

GEOLOGY

Page 6: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

6

GEOLOGY

Page 7: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

7

GEOLOGY

Page 8: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

8

BRIDGE #1

Page 9: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

CHALLENGES

9

FIELD EXPLORATION

• Interstate Traffic• Night Drilling• Foundry Sand• Other Rehabilitation Projects

Page 10: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

10

Page 11: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

CHALLENGES

11

BRIDGE / RETAINING WALL DESIGN

Page 12: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

Retaining Wall #1

Bridge #1

Riverwalk

Railroad

Page 13: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

Retaining Walls

Challenges:

• How many retaining walls do we have?

• Large Wall Heights

• Soft Soils – Settlement Concerns

• Limited ROW

• Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme Limit State)

Page 14: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

14

RETAINING WALL #1 Height: 25‐26ft 

Page 15: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

RETAINING WALLS 2, 2A, 2B, AND 3A2

Page 16: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

Slide 15

A2 add profiles of RW 2, 3, calloutAuthor, 10/27/2019

Page 17: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

16

RETAINING WALLS

Design Decisions:

• MSE Retaining Wall #1

• MSE / CIP for Other Walls

• Gravity Walls added later

• Excavation of Material and Replacement with Graded Rock

Page 18: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

Bridge #1

• Geology –voids

• Difficult Driving

• Tip Elevations?????? 

Page 19: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

18

BRIDGE #1

Page 20: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

19

Page 21: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

20

BRIDGE #1

• TDOT Loading Information• LRFD Bridge for Driving Conditions

R = 0.60 x 50 ksi x Area of the Pile (Good Driving Conditions)R = 0.50 x 50 ksi x Area of the Pile (Severe Driving Conditions)

• Based on the Geology and Material encountered assumed Severe Driving Conditions

• Discussion with Structural Engineers on Project adjacent 

Solution:• Decision to increase the pile size to HP 14x73 but keep the loading of an HP 12x53

• Sequence of Construction considering proposed embankments

Page 22: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

PROJECT COMMUNICATION

9

• Open Communication ‐ Decisions should not be made in a vacuum

Structural Engineers

Roadway Engineers

Other Engineers in your field of Expertise

TDOT

• Design Process – Plan Reviews

• Constructability Reviews with Contractors

Page 23: Tuesday-1245-STGEC2019 Chattanooga-Challenge Accepted I-24 ... 7.pdf · • Limited ROW • Conditions for Seismic Design (Extreme ... Structural Engineers Roadway Engineers Other

QUESTIONS?