tu wien, april 2014 chiral primaries in strange metals ingo kirsch desy hamburg, germany ` m....
TRANSCRIPT
TU Wien, April 2014
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Ingo Kirsch
DESY Hamburg, Germany
`M. Isachenkov, I.K., V. Schomerus, arXiv: 1403.6857
Based on work with
V. Schomerus, M. Isachenkov
A compressible quantum matter is a translationally-invariant quantum system with a globally conserved U(1) charge Q, i.e. [H, Q]=0. The ground state of the Hamiltonian H-mQ is compressible if <Q> changes smoothly as a function of the chemical potential . m (excludes: solids, charge density waves and superfluids)
Options:
i) Fermi liquids (d>1): quasi-particles above Fermi surface which is given by a pole in the fermion Green’s function
ii) Non-Fermi liquids:
• Luttinger liquid (d=1): Fermi surface but no weakly-coupled quasi-particles above FS
Any other realization is referred to as …
• Strange metals: Fermi surface is hidden (since Green’s function not gauge invariant), and characterized by singular, non-quasi-particle low-energy excitations
Dispersion relation:
Motivation: Compressible quantum matter at T=0
2 Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
EtMe3Sb[Pd(dmit)2]2 Yamashita et al, Science (2010)
Triangular lattice of S=½ spins
beyond nearest-neighbor interactions destroy the antiferromagnetic order of the ground state
charge transport is that of an insulator
But: thermal conductivity is that of a metal!
Þ thermal transport of fermions near a Fermi : surface
Þ ground state: spinons (carry spin half but no charge)
An example of a strange metal at T=0
3 Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Outline:
I. Motivation: Strange metals at T=0
II. Strange metal model in d=1 spatial dimensions: Coset CFT
III. Partition function ZN (for higher N)
IV. The characters of the coset theory
V. Chiral ring of chiral primaries
Conclusions
Overview
ETH Zurich, 30 June 2010
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
4 Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
A very promising candidate of a strange metal is a model of fermions at non-zero density coupled to an Abelian or non-Abelian gauge field.
Gopakumar-Hashimoto-Klebanov-Sachdev-Schoutens (2012):
• UV: 2d SU(N) gauge theory coupled to Dirac fermions
• strongly-coupled high density regime:
• approximate the excitations near the zero-dimensional Fermi surface by two sets of relativistic fermions:
• currents generate an SO(2N2-2)1 affine algebra
Strange metal model in d=1 spatial dimensions
5
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
• effective low-energy theory Lagrangian:
• integrate out gauge fields A:
generate an SU(N) at level 2N, SU(N)2N.
• low-energy coset CFT:
• emergent SUSY in the IR - not present in the UV theory (with an emergent U(1) x U(1) global (R-)symmetry rotating the left- and right-moving ferminons separately!)
• central charge:
Strange metal model in d=1 spatial dimensions (cont.)
6
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
• coset studied only for N=2, 3:
• equivalence to minimal models:
• barrier:
For the coset CFT cannot be related to
a supersymmetric minimal model anymore.
New techniques required to study the coset for higher N!
Strange metal model in d=1 spatial dimensions (cont.)
7
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Part III: Partition function ZN
4 University of Chicago, 23 April 2007Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
GKO construction: The partition function of the coset theory follows from the numerator and denominator partition functions, and .
Numerator:
group:
representations: A = id, v, sp, c
numerator partition function:
with
Numerator partition function ZN
9
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
group:
representations:
conformal weights:
identification current:
monodromy charge:
denominator partition function (D-type):
Denominator partition function ZD
10
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Example: N=2
So,
and
Denominator partition function ZD (cont.)
11
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Total partition function:
Substituting the matrices and , we find
Ex: N=2
Problem: The modular invariant possesses non-integer coefficients. This can be fixed by a procedure known as fixed-point resolution (Schellekens, Yankielowicz).
Modular invariant partition function
12
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Part IV: The characters
4 University of Chicago, 23 April 2007Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
The coset characters are defined by
can be computed from
and are known, e.g.
For orbits {a} of maximal length, the branching functions are identical to the characters . For short orbits, they split into a sum of characters.
Branching functions and characters
14
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
The partition function is given by
and the branching functions are
N=2: Characters
15
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
After fixed-point resolution, the partition function becomes
with
and similarly, sp and c.
This can be rewritten as (the partition function of a compactified free boson)
N=2: Characters (cont.)
16
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Fixed-point resolutione.g. for x=1:
The partition function is given by
and the branching functions are
N=3: Characters
17
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Part V: Chiral Primaries and Chiral Ring
4 University of Chicago, 23 April 2007Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Chiral primaries O are superconformal primaries ([S a , O] ~ 0) that are also annihilated by some of the supercharges:
[Qa, O] ~ 0
chiral primaries:
bound on chiral primaries:
They can be read off from the characters… find terms with .
Chiral primaries
19
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
There is a large set of chiral primaries which Y’ Y N=4 can be constructed for any N:
Consider all Young diagrams Y’ with
Then we can construct a Young diagram Yas follows (graphical construction):
• complete to matrix
• rotate complement and attach from left
• remove those which are in the same orbit , appear only once
(e.g. N=4 )
Regular chiral primaries
20
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
(2x)
N=4: Characters
21
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Necklaces for N=4:
(h, Q) of the ground states in the NS sectors (id, a) and (v, a)
Regular and exceptional chiral primaries at N=4
22
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
exceptional chiral primary
Regular and exceptional chiral primaries at N=5
23
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Three exceptional CPs
A particular feature of superconformal field theories is the chiral ring of NS sector chiral primary fields. These fields form a closed algebra under fusion.
Let us check that the previously found chiral primaries indeed form a closed algebra under fusion…
Generator of the chiral ring (h=Q=1/6):
Claim: Repeatedly act with x on the identity. This generates the chiral subring of
regular NS chiral primary fields.
Chiral Ring
24
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Visualization of the chiral ring by tree diagrams:
An arrow represents the action of x on a field, e.g. OPE (N=3)
Chiral Ring for N=2, 3
25
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
N=4:
Chiral Ring for N=4
26
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
N=5:
In the large N limit, the number of chiral primaries is governed by the partition function p(6h).
Chiral Ring for N=5
27
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
I discussed coset theories of the type
Gopakumar et al. studied this space for N=2, 3, for which the coset can be related to supersymmetric minimal models.
I developed new techniques to study the coset for higher N:
• N=4, 5: - I explicitly derived the q-expansion of ZN (up to some order) - identified the chiral primary fields - established a classification scheme for CPs (regulars vs. exceptionals) - found a representation of CPs (and orbits) in terms of necklaces
- argued that they form a chiral ring under fusion
Outlook (work in progress):
• Large N limit + AdS dual description
Conclusions
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
28 Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch
Spectrum: coset elements and their conformal weights
Parallel computing on DESY’s theory and HPC clusters
N=2 N=3N=4
29
Chiral Primaries in Strange Metals
we also have N=5 ...
Technische Universität Wien -- Ingo Kirsch