ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/shalevthesisquerybymelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6...

57

Upload: others

Post on 31-Jul-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

� �������� ��� ��������������� ���������������! �"�#���%$&�#'( ��� ) �#�*�,+ - + ���.�"�/+

021

354*6�78354*6�9;:=<?>@3A4CBD6FEHGJI

KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV�QYXZT KJ[ X\VJV^]_Va`�bcV@M�d L QSTfe KJ[ OgT%h [ Tji k�hZlmOghZT%TfeSOnhZlOgh�dpoaeqQYOro^]=` L ]Rsp]n]gM�T&hmQcV^`tQYXZT�euT&v L OgeuT%M�T&hmQYw?`xV^ecQWXZT�UZTfl@euTfT�V^`

y o^wzQYTfe{V^`,bcV@M�d L QST%e KJ[ OgT%h [ ToHQ|QYXZT

} k?~��5k�� ��������kC� K �;�c� ��� �mkC��� KJ�*� k y� L ]R1"�a�@�2�

Page 2: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

� 4�7���B���E2� BD6�����6FE2E27�:_� �C�|GD�����A:_E�G\45:��Z�5�j:_Ea<57��Z7���� ���  E¢¡¤£¥��E¦6F§ 3A7��|¨�:_E�6F�©�   E¢¡�354�9���§ �   �5ª*�5��<

Page 3: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

« ¬®­°¯ ±³² ´Jµ�¶ ·!¸ µ³¯!¹»º

�*¼|V L ]gU�]gOg½@TPQYV/QWXNoahZ½¾M»1�w L d=T%eq¿ÀOnwuV^e®Á©e%Â���VaeWoaM K OghZl@Tfe»`xV^e�X\Onw»l@OÿmT%hXZT%]gd#o^]g]Äo^]nV^hZl®QYXZT�¼|oÅ1@Â�5¼�V L ]nU�o^]gwuV/]nOg½^TÆQYV�QYXNo^hZ½¥Á©e% K X\]gV@MPV"Á L 0Nh\VÇ¿�`xeSV@M QWXZT�UZT%dpoHeuQYM�T%hmQV^` [ V@M�M L h\O [ oÈQWOgV@h�T&hZl@OnhZTfT%eSOnhZl®Ogh/~�T&hJÉËÊ L eSOnV^h L h\OR¿mTfeYwuORQË18`xV^e|]ÃTÅo^U\OghZl�M�TQYXZeSV L lmX¤QWXZT�dpoHQYX\w|Va`ÌU\OglmORQWo^]ÍM L wSO [ d\eSV [ T%wSwuOghZlNÂ�;h�o^U\U\ORQYOnV@hÄÎÌ�5¼�V L ]gU�]gOg½@T8QYV�QWXNoahZ½¥Á©e%Â"�5OgeÐÏ\eSOÃT&U\M¤oah�`xV^eÑX\Onw�¿ao^] L oH0N]gTw L l@l@T%wzQWOgV@h\wfÂ�¤o^M l@eYoHQSTf` L ]©QYVÒkF`ÓeYoHQ"kFlmV^Ô%O�o^h\U � T%V!Õ�V@hmQYV^eSVÇ¿ÀOÃQ [ XÒ`ÖVae×QYXZT&OÃe L wqTf` L ][ V@MPM�T%h2QYw�V@h×QYXZT�M¤oah L w [ eYOÃdZQ&Â��¼{oah2Q*QYV¤QYXNo^hZ½"QYXZTÆMÆT&M�0¢TfeSw©Va`�QWXZT8M¤o [ X\OnhZTÐ]gT&oaeSh\OnhZlØ]roa0³`ÖVae*0¢T%OnhZl�ow L d\dÙV^eqQYOnhZl [ V@M�dpo^hm1@Â� h\U¾]ro^wzQÐ0 L Q®h\VaQ�]ÃTÅoawqQ&Î,��¼|V L ]gU�]nOg½^T�QYV#QYXNo^hZ½¥M»1�¼5Og`ÓT y V^eSOro K XNo^]gTÚ¿2ÉÕ�VaÛÍMPo^h/`ÖVae�XZT%e*w L d\d¢V^eqQ�U L eSOnhZl¤QYXZT8o [f[ V^M�dN]nOgwSX\MÆT&hmQAV^`FQYX\Ogw©¼|VaeS½"o^h\Uo^]gwSV®`xV^e{XZTfe{XZT%]gd/Ogh [ eST&oHQYOnhZl�QYXZTjv L TfeSOgT%w L wqT&U�Onh×QYXZT�T.ÜZd=T%eSOnMÆT&hmQYw%Â

ÝNÞÀßHà,ÝNÞÀß@áÃâ.ãÇä;ÝpÞmå�ßHæfçéèê â.æìëJífß@áÃâ.î�ï,ðuíWæSß2âfáê ëNáòñ¤óÀômôHó

Page 4: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe
Page 5: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

õ ±!¯Ò¹Ñµ�¯Ò¹»º

ö ÷ËøHùqúuûmüJý¦þWùuÿRûHø �� �����zÿÃþ���ûHø¦þ��2ù � �

����� ��������������� "!#��$%���&�� ('"��)*!#�+�,����+!-�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� 1������+� 23,����+)�4��,('5������������76��+�,����+!8�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� 1������9� :<;"=.$>),($>=%?"�3)�@BA�CD=%EF (=>,($>G �/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� H������JI 23,����+)���K)L�������+���M�ONP),RQ�=%C#!D��), �0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� S������UT A�) "C#��=>CV:WCK��,(!X@Y)C#�Z�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� [������91 \],(=>C#��G^�.�/�0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`_������JH ab�+,(=c��Cd6�;(�+@e�Xfhgh,RQM��C#����,R�d6�G�!D�#=%�L!i�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� ��������9S :<;"=j6�;()CD�d:<�+�k=0A�) (CD��=>CV:lC#��,(!X@Y)C#� �.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`I������Jm no (!#�+$c���W6�)� (,('qp0=>,(=%C#�M�K�+),r�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`H

���J� 6����s�K��!X�K�+$%!��.�/�.�.�/�0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`[���J���+� t]CD)u���u(�+�����hG8��,"'5vd��,('")�wQM��C#����u(�+=%!x�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`[���J���9� NP)�,('(�+�#��),(���7?(CD)u���u"�������hGy�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`[���J���JI NP)�,('(�+�#��),(���7gh,('"=%?z=%,('(=>,($%�+=%!x��,('5{V�cG=%!D�|��,5}3=~�h�P)�C#�F!��/�.�/�.�.� ��_���J���UT n5��C#�M) Q��L)�'(=%�+!��.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� ���

� ��úuû��l���� �7ÚùËùuÿgø&� ���I"��� 2��� (!D��$c�M�O�k=>��)�'"G��0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� ��I

I"����+� t]���K$�;��.�.�/�0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� ��II"����9� �� "CK�M�#��),��/�0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �MT

I"�J� 2�?�=>CD@Y)CD�i�M,($%= �/�0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �MT� �múSûz� ����Rûmü&�®ùqû��zÿY�aø&����������fø&fú �&ùqÿY�z-�ÑûmüW�� ���

T(��� :l=>�k?z)4�k)�'(=>����,"� �0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� ��mT(�J� 6�?z=%$>�#CK���&���+!D�#C#��u" "�K�+),�n5)�'(=%���.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� ��[

� ���gÿY�Høl��%øHù*�Çø¦ü��iÚùzúYÿYR�(��� ���1���� 2x�+���,(�L=%,R�^�/�.�.�/�0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� II

Page 6: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

1��J� vd=~�KCD��=>QM�����.�/�.�.�/�0�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� I�T  ¡x¢b�]ÚúSÿ£��%øHù`���¤�i��Ëýl� ù � ���� ¥Aÿ£�zþ.ýW�c�zÿRûHø ���� �8�l�]fø¦üJÿe¢]�/¦j§&-¨o�Åús�ÐûHøJÿÃþ8©�ÿ ù §8÷Ëø¦üWF�]fø¦üWføaù8ª©ûHÿ£�>-�Ðûmü&�� ����CÿY�B�ÃÿÃû��Èú �(�l§�� �O�

� g

Page 7: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

« ¬ º©¹ ±®­ ¯ ¬ ·±° ²»µ�º

� f�� \B³(�M�k?(�+=�)�@B��,o��,����+)�*!#�+,� "!#)�+'����O!D���,��M�´�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� H� fX� \B³(�M�k?(�+=�)�@B��������!#�+,(�(�µ�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� m� f�I 2�$�;(��CD?�!#����,����·¶e�K)?�¸º¹(�+�#!���AB:»��,�����G�!D��!< (!D��,(�4'�{�!D$c���+=i¶Y�k�+'('(�+=`¸¤�M,('5���K!

6�:�AB:¼��,�����G�!D��!<?(CD=%!D=%,R�K=>'-uRG�!#?z=%$~�KC#)��CK���½¶�uz)��#�#)�8¸º�¾�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �cT� fhT :<;(=0!#?z=%$~�KC# "�r)�@BCD=%$~����,(�� (�|��CV���+,('()`�0�*�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`H� fX1 :<;(=0=%�+=%�L=%,R�K!�)�@B�*$%=%�+��)(���.�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`m� f�H � �+u(CK�M�#��),i)�@¿�4!D�#C#�+,(�L�M�<�K;(=0;��MC#�L),(��$3@YC#=%EF (=>,($%�+=%!>���.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �`mIsf�� 2À�h�P=>�+Q�=~fÁ�#)MfÁ�#;(=~fÁ)�$~���cQ=.!#$%����=M���.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� �MTTMf�� :<;(=��+,('(=%?z=%,"'(=%,($>��=>!<u�=~�h�P=>=%,��K;(=�QM��CD�|��u(�+=%!>�B:<;(=�)u"!#=%CXQ=>'oQM��CD�|��u(�+=%!¤��C#=

?(��,"�i$%)���)CD=%'o��,('��K;(=0;(�+'('(=>,oQM��CD�|��u(�+=%!<�MC#=�G=>���+) �¼$%)�+)C#=>'O���0�/�.�/�.�.� ��mTMfX� :<;(=V!D?�=>$>�KCD (�Â)�@z�x!#�+,(��+=Ã@YC#���k=P����)�,(�d�����K;*�M,����L?( (�+!#=·�KCK�M��,j'"=%!#�+�,��M�#��,(�

�K;(=0;��MC#�L),(��$>!V)�@W�K;(=0!D)��)�+!D�%�q�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� I"�1 f�� :<;(=.�����+�,(�L=%,R�����+�)CD�+�K;"�5�Ä�.�.�/�.�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� I�THsf�� t]C#=%$>��!D��),�fÁC#=>$c���+��$% "CDQ=>!l$>)�L?���C#�+,(�V�K;"=Ã?z=%CX@Y)C#�k��,($>=])�@��K;(CD=%=]�K=>�k?z)��k)�'�f

=%�+!P@Y)CVEF (=>C#��=>!�$%),(!D��!X�K��,"�*)�@&Å(Q=0!#=>$%),"'(!/¶Y�K)�?�¸~¹"Å"@e�K=%=>,�!#=%$>),('�¶��L��'('"��=`¸º¹��,('��h�¤=%,R�hG�Å(Q=.!#=>$%),('"!*¶�uz)��D�K)�i¸~�d�/�.�0�/�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� Im

HsfX� t]C#=%$>��!D��),�fÁC#=>$c���+�$% (CXQ=>!¿$%)�L?���CD��,(�<�#;(=P?z=%CX@Y)C#�k��,($>=Ã)M@�=c��$�;/)�@(�#;(=Ã�#=%�L?�)�k)�'(=>��!P@Y)CV�#;(C#=>=0'(�+Æ�=%CD=%,R�dE� "=%CDG��+=%,(�M�K;(!>�µ�.�.�/�.�/�.�.�/�.�0�/�.�/�.�.� I[

Hsf�I 2x,������+ (!D�#CK�M�#��),�)M@V�K;(=k���+���,(�L=%,R�/��,('�!#=>��k=>,R���M�#��),�)�@P�#;(= � :Ç�k)�'(=%�£�:<;(=0?(�+�#$�;(=%!d)�@W�K;(=0,()M�K=%!��+,��#;(=0�k=>��)�'"Gi��C#=0)`Q=>C#�|�cG�=%'q�+,�!#)�+��'����+,(=%!>���.� TR_

� g#g

Page 8: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

� g#gDg

Page 9: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

È�ÉLÊ�Ë�ÌlÍÏÎÑÐ�Ò Ó�ÉLÔ·ÕjÖ^Õj×�Ø Ù�Ó�Ð�Ú<Í]Ô]ÕjÖ�Û É�Ø-Ð�ÖcÜc×-ÝÞ ÉkÔÄß®Ë-Ð�Ô¿à áâà Û Ð�Ö>É�Øqà

ã¤äåVæ.çlèiå<æ0çBé�ê�ëVìåVæ¤í^çBî�ï�ð

6� (u"�k���#�K=>'��K)*�K;(=/6�$�;")�)�b)M@]NP)�L?( "�#=%C36�$>��=%,"$%=.ñò\],(��+,(=%=>C#��,"�)�,-ó� (��G�I"��¹���__R��¹(��,�?���CX�K������@Y (��Å����+�k=>,R�V)�@W�K;(=

C#=>EF (��CD=%�L=%,R�K!�@Y)CV�K;"=.'"=%�CD=%=0)�@nq��!X�K=>C3)�@¿NP)�L?( "�#=%C36�$%�+=%,($>=

ô Ê�ÌlÍ]Ô]Õ�Ú<Í

õ�L T%eq1 021ØM�T&]gVJUÀ1�Onw?QWXZT�d\eSV^0N]ÃT&M V^`teuTfQSeSOgTÚ¿ÀOnhZl�M L wuO [ o^]=d=T%eu`xV^eSM¤o^h [ T%w`ÓeSV@M M�T%]nV¦U\OgT%wfÂt�|TfQSeSOgTÚ¿ao^]JV^`NeST&o^]¦d¢TfeS`xV^eSM¤oah [ T%wÌOnw [ V^M�dN]nO [ oHQST%UÐU L T?QWV5QWXZT]roHeSl^T×h L M�0¢Tfe�V^`{¿aoaeSOroÈQWOgV@h\w»Ogh d¢TfeS`xV^eSMPOghZl�o³M�T%]nV¦UÀ1 oah\U�QWXZTØd\euT&wqT%h [ TV^` [ V@]gV^euT&UÒo [f[ V@MÆdpo^h\OnM�T%hmQ8h\V@OnwqT^ ��T�UZT&w [ eYOÃ0¢T�o�wSOgM�dN]gT×1mTfQPTfÛ¢T [ QYOÿmTd\eSV^0poa0NOg]nOnwzQYO [ MPV¦UZT&]H`xV^e�QYX\Onw_Qìoawu½¢Â���T�UZT%w [ eSOg0=T?o{l^T&hZTfeYoHQYOÿmTFMPVJUZT%]aQYXNoHQOnweSO [ X¤T%h\V L lmX¤QYV [ oadZQ L euT©QYXZT�wqd=T [ QSeWoa]Ùo^h\U¤QST&M�d¢V^eYo^]\¿aoaeSOroHQYOnV^h\wCV^`tM L wuO [ o^]d¢Tfeu`xV^eSM¤o^h [ T&w®o^h\UÒo^]g]nVż5w�`ÖVae8QSeYo [ QìoH0N]gTØM�T%]nV¦UÀ1�euTÚQYeSOÃTf¿ao^] Â�� X\Og]gT�MPV@wzQV^`5d\euTf¿ÀOnV L w®wzQ L U\OgT%w�V@hDM L wuO [ euTfQSeSOgTÚ¿ao^]�`xeSV@M M�T%]nV¦U\OgT%wм�TfeuT�d¢Tfeu`xV^eSM�T&U¼5OÃQYX�T&ORQYXZT%e�wq1ÀM�0ÙV@]gO [÷ö T^ l\ y ��Á��cø×UNoHQWo�V^eؼ5OÃQYX îúùzûVùü=ÞBùzûNàKýâö wuOnhZl@]gTOnh\wzQSe L M�T%h2QRø�d=T%eu`xV^eSM¤o^h [ T&wfÎ^¼cT�d¢Tfeu`xV^eSM�T&U8TÚÜÀd¢TfeSOnM�T%hmQWwCOgh¤eSTÚQSeSOgTÚ¿ZOghZlÐ]gOÿmTo^h\UPwzQ L U\OnV�euT [ V^eSU\OnhZl@wFV^`ÍVad¢TfeWoaw�QYXNoHQ [ V@h2QWo^Ogh�o�]gT&o^U\OghZlj¿2V [ o^]nOgwqQ�o^h\U�eSO [ XOnh\wzQSe L M�T%h2QWo^]�o [f[ V@MÆdpo^h\OnM�T%hmQÅÂ�þ L e�eST%w L ]ÃQYw*wuX\Vż QYXNoHQ©QWXZT®d\eSV^0poa0NOg]nOgwqQYO [oad\d\eSVmo [ Xj¼cT?d\eSV^d¢V@wqT�OgwtTfÛ¢T [ QYOÿmTco^h\U [ o^h»0=T�w [ o^]gT%UÑQYV�M¤oawSwuOR¿mT�UNoHQWo^wqTfQYwfÂ:<;(=>!#��!x6� (?z=%CXQ���!#)�C%ÿ·��C%���Ã)�CK���÷6���,(�=>C���,('o��C%�Ã6�;(��)�L)4�� (u(,") Q

Page 10: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe
Page 11: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

õ � ��� ¹ÑµÂ² �� ¯!¹�²»± ¶ ° ¬P¹ ¬ ±!¯

2±,(�M�K (C#�����V�cGÑ@Y)Ck!D=c��CD$�;(��,"� ���� (!D��$%���d�� ('(�+)�'��M�K��u���!D=5@Y)Ci��!D),(�¾�+!k�K)���)�)�¾@Y)Ck�!#;")CD�¤�� ('"��)�!#=>��L=%,R�Ã$%),R���M��,(�+,(�0���k=>��)�'"G/@YCD)� �#;(=�!#),"�(�]n5)�!D�Ã)�@z�K;(=�=~³��+!D�K�+,(��!DG�!X�K=%�L!��CD=�u���!D=%'y),-�K=º³��# ����¿�+,"@Y)CD�i�M�#��),7¹z!D ($�;���!��K;(=/�K�+�#��=/)�@·�K;(=*!D),(����,('��#;(=*,����L=�)�@·�K;"=$%)��k?z)!#=>C%��3)`�¤=>Q�=%C%¹·?z=%)?"��=L)�@e�K=>,�'()5,()���CD=%�L=%��uz=%C0�K;"=i,����L=L)�@V�K;"=i$%)��k?z)!#=>Cj�M,('�K;"=.!D),(�� !<�K���K��=xu( "�d$c��,o=c�M!#����G8CD=%$c�M���7@YC#����L=%,R�K!V@YCD)�w�K;"=.!D)��)���!D��U!P�k=>��)�'"G�

:<;(=<����!D�j)�@� ������������������������V�s�#�K=>�k?��K!B�#)0�� "�K)��i�M�#=¤�#;(=<�� (!D��$VCD=>�KCD��=~Q��M�����M!#���¿gÁ�]�P��!Å�CD!D�Ã'(��!D$% (!D!#=>'i��,*�#;(=�$%),R�K=º³��P)�@�EF (=%CXG4uRG*;F (�k�L��,"� � � 1F¹��`["¹F�M_"¹F����!£�¿:<;(=>!#=��P)�C#�F!Ã@Y)�$% "!), $%)�,FQ�=%CX�K��,"��;F (�L�k=>' �k=>��)�'(��=>!j��,R�#)y!XG���u�)�����$�n5g���g.@Y)�C#�k�M�o¶´nog���g/�+!4��,Ñ��$%CD),RG��@Y)Ckn5 (!D��$%����gh,(!D�#C# (�L=%,R�����+��+�K���Pgh,R�#=%CD@��M$%=���gÁ�k��!L��!XG���u�)�����$8@Y)�C#�k�M�4@Y)C4C#=%?"C#=%!D=%,R�K�+,(��� (!D��$c¸~�#"�,($>=3�K;"=3EF (=>CDGk��!·$%),RQ�=%CD�#=%'��+,F�#)j�.!DG���uz)���+$<@Y)C#�k�M�]�K;"=x$�;����+��=>,(�=���!·�K)/!#=c�MC#$�;@Y)C��� (!D��$%���&?�=>CD@Y)CD�i��,"$%=%!<�#;��M�x��?(?(CD)`³��+�i�M�#=%��G8�k�M�K$�;o�K;(=.EF (=%CXG�3n5)!X�x)�@l�K;(=.C#=>!#=%��C#$�;!#)8@��MCx;���!xu�=>=%,�$%)�,('( ($~�K=%' ���+�#;-�� (!D��$/!D�K)�C#=%'��+, n5g���g<@Y)CD�i�M�$� �`m%!¿)�Cx��,&���(')�+*�,��('�-/.¶��£�U=M�¿!#�+,(��+=�Q�)�$%���z)C¤�+,(!D�#C# (�L=%,R��¸·CD=%$%)�C#'(�+,(�!x¶�!#=>=x@Y)CÃ��,(!X����,"$%=�� � ��¹�[(!O��,"'k�K;"=xC#=~@Y=%CD=%,($>=%!�K;"=%C#=>��,�¸º��gh,��K;"��!0�P)CD��¹B�P=k!# (���=%!X�*�5�L=>�#;()�'�@Y)C.EF (=%CXG�uRGy�L=%��)�'"G-��;"=%C#=k�K;(=kE� "=%CDG��!<?z)!D=%'o��,�!DG���uz)���+$x@Y)CD� ��!��*�L),()?(;"),(��$��L=%�+)�'�G8��,"'��#;(=0'��M�K��u���!D=.$>),(!D��!D�#!�)�@BCD=c���?z)�+G�?(;()�,(��$�CD=%$%)�C#'(�+,(�!%�0 ;(=%, '(=%�����+,(�5�����K; CD=c���¤?�)��G�?(;(),(�+$iCD=%$%)�C#'(�+,(�!j�¤=�,(=%=>' �K)���'"'(C#=>!#!*!#=~Q=>CK���<$>)�4f?(�+��$c�s�K��,"�q@���$>�#)C#!>� gh'(=c�M���+G�¹·�k=>��)�'(��=>!�$c��, uz=�C#=%?"C#=%!D=%,R�K=>'���!4!#=>EF (=%,($>=%!k)�@x,")��K=>!%¹P=%��$�;��!0��?����+C�)�@¤@YC#=%EF (=>,($>G���,"'y�#=%�L?�)C#���B'" (CK�M�#��),7�*gh,�C#=%���¿CD=%$%)�C#'(�+,(�!��h�P)5�i�21D)C�!#)� (C#$>=%!)�@P'(�43L$% "�+�hGy��CD��!#=M�8:<;(=LÅ�C#!X����!��#;(=i;(�+�; Q��MC#�|�Mu(���+�+�hGo)�@V�#;(=i�M$>�K (���·'( (CK�s�K��)�,(!/)M@V,()��#=%!>�2 �L=%�+)�'"Gy$%��, u�=�?z=%CX@Y)C#�L=%'�@���!D�#=%C*)C/!#��)`�¤=%C��#;���,¾�K;"=�),(=8'(�+$>�K�M�K=>' uFG��K;(=i�� (!#�+$c���!#$>)C#=M�/:<;"��!x�hG�?z=L)M@]Q��MC#�|�s�K��)�,q��!x)�@e�K=>,�C#=>@Y=>C#CD=%'��K)���!3�K=%�L?z)iQM��C#����u(���+�+�hG���A� (CD�#;(=%CD�k)�C#=�¹�K;"=i�K=>�k?z)-$c�M,¾Q��MCDGy���+�K;"��,¾�-!D��,(����=L?�=>CD@Y)CD�i��,"$%=�� A�)C/��,(!X����,"$%=�¹·�5?�=>CD@Y)CD�i��,"$%=8$%��,!D�K��CD�������K; ��!#�+)`� �#=%�L?�)8��;(�+$�; �CK��'" �������Go��,($>C#=c�M!#=%!>�*:<;(=4!#=>$%),('y$%)��k?(�+��$%�M�K�+,(�L@��M$>�K)�C��!·�K;"=3;(�+�;kQM��CD�|��u"�������hGj)M@7�K;"=x!#?z=%$~�KCD (�Z'" (=3�#)/�k��,RG4@���$>�#)C#!Ã!# ($�;��M!¤'(��Æ7=>C#=>,($%=>!P��,L�K),"=$%)���)CD!x¶e�K�+��u(C#=c¸·)M@O'(��Æ7=>C#=%,R�P!#��,"�=%CD!+5M�+,(!D�#C# (�L=%,R�K!>¹��#;(=d��,R�K=>,F�#��),(����Q��MC#�|�s�K��)�,*uFGL�K;"=3�+=c��'�f

I

Page 12: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

��,"�8Q)�$c���+��!D�#!L¶�=M�U�(�/Q��+u(CK�s�K)���,(' '"G�,��M�k�+$%!�¸��M,('�uRG76X!#?z=%$>�#CK���B�i��!D�F��,(�98�)M@¤�#;(=4��=c�M'(��,(�Q)�$c�M�buFGi�K;(=.��$>$%)�L?���,RG���,(�4Q)�$c�M��!���,('o)CD$�;(=%!X�KCK���0 =y?(CD)?�)�!#= �K) ����$��F��= �K;"=%!#=�'(�43L$> (�+�#��=%!�uRG� (!D��,(�^�Ñ��=%,(=>CK�M�#�+Q=y?(CD)u���u(�+���+!D�K�+$���?�f?(CD)R��$�;^�#;��M�4�L)�'"=%��!��#;(=��K=%�L?z)CK���V��,('Ñ!#?z=%$>�#CK���<QM��CD�|�M�#��),(!>� 0 =5��!D!#)�$%�|�s�K=�=c��$�;^,()��#=���+�#;q�L;(��'"'(=%,o�K=%�L?z)LQM��CD�|��u(�+=��¤:<;(=/�#=%�L?�)4QM��C#����u(��=>!<$c��?��K (CD=/�K;"=.�#=%�L?�)C#���OQM��C#���M�K�+),(!��,Ñ�K;(=5'( (C#�M�K�+),(!L)�@0,()��#=%!%��:W)¾=%,��Mu(��=5=:3L$%�+=%,R�8$>)�k?" "���M�#��),7¹P�K;(=5;(��'"'(=%,��#=%�L?�)�!#=ºfEF (=%,"$%=.��!<�L)�'(=>��=>'���!���Å�C#!X�3)�C#'(=>Cdnq��C#�M)`Q�?(C#)�$%=>!#!%�·gh,5��'('(���K�+),O¹��¤=0'(=%!D$%CD��uz=/��!D���L?(��=?(CD)u���u(�+���+!D�K�+$¤!D?�=>$>�#CK���('"��!D�#C#�+u( "�K�+),��L)�'"=%���#;��M�]�+!¿C#)�u( (!D�]�#)��K;(=<�k��!D���+,(��,()�+!#=V)M@z�#;(=���$ºf$%)��k?��M,FG��+,(����,"!D�KCD (�L=%,R�K!P��,('8!D��,(�=>C#!>�]:<;(��!V!D?�=>$>�#CK����'(��!X�KC#�+u( "�#��),L�k)�'(=>���+!P�/QM��CD�|��,R�¤)�@�K;"=�;���C#�L),(�+$����+��=>����;")�)�'i�L)�'"=%��@Y)�CV?(�+�#$�;�'(=>�#=%$>�#��),;� ��[%!£�ÃNP)��u(�+,(��,"���K;(=��#=%�L?�)C#���O�M,('!#?z=%$~�KC#���B?(CD)u���u"�����+!D�#��$�$%)��k?z),(=>,F�#!%¹7�¤=�)u������+,-�<1D)�+,R�x�L)�'"=%�&��;(��$�;-$%��,�uz=j$%)�,(!#�+'(=%CD=%'��!x�k'"G�,����L��$.{V�cG�=%!#����,�,(=~�h�P)CD�=� �`_>!´��:<;(�+!xC#=>?(C#=>!#=>,F�K�M�K�+),-=>,���u(�+=%!x=�3L$%��=>,R�����+���,(�L=%,R���,('oC#=~�KCD��=>QM���7 (!#�+,(�4'"G�,����L��$�?(CD)�CK�M�k�L��,(�"�

:<;(��!¤?(C#)�u���u(�+����!X�K�+$���?(?(CD)R��$�;8�+!PC#=>�|�M�#=%'L�K)j!D=>Q�=%CK�M�OC#=>$%=%,R�V�¤)CD��!¤�K;��M�P=%�L?(��)`G �d��'('(=>,nq��CD��)`Qqn5)�'(=%�+!j¶?��n-nq¸<@Y)C<�j (!#�+$.?"C#)�$%=%!D!#�+,(�(�Vvd��?(;(��=%�@� ��H%!& (!D=%!3�k=>��)�'"G8�+,"@Y)C#�k�M�#��),¶�?"�+�K$�;"=%!]��,"'*'( (CK�s�K��)�,(!B)�@�,")��K=>!�¸l�+,ju( (�+��'(�+,(���M,A��n-nZ@Y)�C¿�x!D$%)CD=V@Y)���+) ���+,(�d��?(?(�+��$%�M�K�+),O�2Ç!#�+�k�+�|��Cd��?"?(C#)R�M$�;y�+!� (!D=%' uRG �� (C#=~G-�M,('�NP��=%�L=%,R�#! � � �2!¿��;()� (!D=��K;(=*?(���K$�; ��,�@Y)C#�k�sf�K�+),Ñ)�@�,()��#=%!4@Y)CLu( (���+'(��,"�;�xn-n5!L@Y)C4�k=>��)�'"G C#=~�KCD��=>QM���£�B�3)`�¤=>Q�=%C%¹�uz)��K;���?(?(CD)R��$�;(=>!�¤=%C#=�'"=%!#�+�,(=>'�@Y)�C8��,('�=~Q��M�� ��M�#=%'ú)�,��k),")?(;(),"��$q�j (!#�+$-'��M�K��u���!D=%!%� n5)!X�8�¤)C#�^),?z)�+G�?(;()�,(��$8�j (!#�+$8?(C#)�$%=>!#!D��,(����'('(CD=%!D!#=%' ���M!#�F!4!# ($�;���!*�� (!D��$8!D=%��L=%,R���s�K��)�,Ñ�+,R�K)-�K=º³Ff�K "C#=%!C� H%!£¹�?�)��G�?(;(),(�+$�?(�+�#$�;��KCK�M$����+,(�D� I���!´¹��M,('5��=%,(CD=.$>�|��!D!#��Å�$c�M�#��),E� I_�¹b�cT�!£� 0 =0uz=%���+=>Q�=�K;(�M�*�K;(=��M?(?(C#)��$�; �P=�'(=>!#$%CD��uz=���,¾�#;(��!*?��M?�=>C*��!*��!D�#=%? �K)`�P��C#'^��, =>Æ�=%$~�K��Q=�C#=~�KCD��=>QM���?(CD)�$>=%'( (CD=.@Y)�C<�i��!D!#��Q=��� (!D��$%���O'��M�K��!#=~�K!>�

T

Page 13: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

õ � ��� ¹ÑµÂ² FG � º ¬ ¬ õ ±!¯ ¬ µ � ¹»º

2®!DG�!D�#=%� @Y)C4E� "=%CDGÑuRGÑ�k=>��)�'"G �M���L!4�#)�$>),(,(=>$>�iu�=~�h�P=>=%,�� �k=>��)�'"G ��,('^�+�#!L?z=%CX@Y)CXf�k��,($%=>!%�<:<;(=j!# (u(!X����,"$%=�)�@l�K;(�+!3$>),(,(=>$>�#��),5��!d!D���s�K��!X�K�+$c���£�Pgh,5�#;(=/@Y)�����)`���+,(�(¹"�¤=j=º³"?"�|���+,u���!D��$.$%),"$%=%?��K!�C#=>�R��CD'(��,(�4�h�¤)8��!D!# (=>!%�xgh,�6�=%$M�¿¶£���+�`¸��¤=j'(=>!#$%CD��uz=j;()`���¤=jC#=>?(C#=>!#=>,F�.�M,('��,��M�+GIH%=¤C#=c�M�"?z=%CD@Y)�C#�k��,($%=>!B (!D��,(���x$%)�L?( "�#=%C>�Bgh,L6�=>$���¶£���J�¸&�¤=VC#=~Q���=>�Ñ!D=>Q=>CK���"!D���s�K��!X�K�+$c���$%)�,($%=>?"�K!3��,('o�k=~�K;()�'(!>�

JLK2M N Ü%ÝLÜ>Í¿ÕjÖ�Ò Ë�ÌBÜcÚdÕjÖ^ÕjË�Ø�Ü%É Ì¿Ü%ÝL×-Õ�Ö%Ì

{V��!D��$%������G¹F�/�j (!#�+$c���z�� ('"��).!#����,�������!¤�/!D) (,('i�P�cQ=M¹"�L=c��,(�+,(�(¹F$�;���,"�=%!V�+,L�#;(=��M��C·'(=%,"!#�+�hG��!i��@Y (,($~�K��)�,ú)�@��K�+�k=M�»2��k�+$%CD)?(;(),"=5$%��,�$%),RQ�=%CD����!#) ",('ú�V�cQ�=���,R�K)��#;(=5@Y)�C#� )�@=%�+=%$~�KC#�+$·)!#$>�������M�K�+),(!>�&{P)��K;/)�@"�#;(=V�Mu�)`Q=Ã!#�+�,����+!W��C#=¤��,����+)�Vfz�K;(=>!#=V!D���,��M��!&��CD=¤$>),R�K��,F ()� (!@Y (,($~�K�+),(!V@YC#)��PO¼�#)AO3��2�$>)�k?" "�K=>C<��!<�*'(�+��+�K�����k��$�;(�+,(=��]:<;F (!>¹���,�)CD'(=%CV�#)4C#=%?"C#=%!D=%,R���,('Ñ��,(���+GIH%=8��,Ñ��,����+)�-!#�+�,����¤ (!#�+,(�y�-$%)�L?( "�#=%C>¹·�#;(=�!#�+�,����¤;���!��#)yuz=�'(�+��+�#��H%=>'O� gh,�K;"��!L!#=%$~�K�+),^�¤=qu(CD��=�Q(GÑ��,R�KCD)�'( "$%=��K;(=ou���!D��$o$%),($>=%?"�#!���,('^�k=~�K;()�'(!L)�@��#;(=5�#;(=%)CXG )�@'(�+��+�K���x!D���,��M��?(C#)�$%=>!#!#�+,(�(�r}3�M�K "CK���+�+G¹d�P=y@Y)�$> (!�),»�#;(=���!#?z=%$~�K!qCD=%�+=>QM��,R���K)Ñ�� (!#�+$c�����$>) (!D�#��$y!#�+�,����+!%�w2d@e�K=>Co�¤=����`G��K;(=��C#) ",('"�¤)C#��)�@�u���!#�+$�'"����������3!#����,����0?(C#)�$%=>!#!D��,(�(¹�¤=o'"=%!#$>C#�+u�=��K;"=o!D) (CD$%=~f´Å��+�#=%C4�L)�'(=>�P)�@3!#?z=%=>$�;�¶���,('^�� ('(�+)F¸/?(CD)�'( "$>�K�+),O� A�)C4���L)C#=?(CD)�@Y) (,('o?(CD=%!#=>,R���M�#��),o!#=>=�� �S�¹z�Mm�¹z��F¹z�MT"¹b�`H�¹O�`I"¹�S>!´�RTSVU@SVU WYX[Z#\^]@_PZ#X[`badce_fchgiZ#\jkc^_lX[Z#\^m2x,k��,��M��)�0!#�+�,����"��!Ã�.$>),R�K�+,� ") (!·Q��M�� (=<@Y (,($~�K�+),4)�@O$>),R�K��,F ()� (!Ã�#���L=��l2�'"�����������!#����,����(�+!��'(�+!#$%CD=>�#=VQ��M�� (=P@Y ",($>�#��),*)�@z'(�+!#$>C#=>�#=V�K�+�k=M�BA�)CD�i���+�+G�¹M�+=>�nO�'(=%,()M�K=V�K;"=<C#=c�M�(,F (��uz=%C#!>¹F��=>�o '(=%,()M�K=��K;"=�$%)�L?(�+=~³5,F (��uz=%C#!���,('���=~�[p�'(=%,")��K=j�#;(=j��;()���=j,F (�ju�=>C#!%�.ab=>� qò'"=%,()��#=��Å�,(���K=�!#=~�d)�@BC#�M�K�+),����z,F (��uz=%CD!j¶Y (!# (������G¹�rsqtr%u¼��v¿¹(��;(=%CD=�w �+!V�K;(=0,F (��uz=%C<)M@Bu(���K!V�¤= (!D=3@Y)C¤�/!D��,(��+=3,F (�ju�=>C�¸~�B2x,���,(����)�.!#�+�,�����xzy�¶|{D¸]��!¤�.@Y (,"$>�K�+),k@YCD)�}O��K) o �d6��+�k�+�|��CD�+G�¹

1

Page 14: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

A

T = 1/F

A cos(θ)

t

AB���� (C#=0�`f��ÿ·\B³"���L?(��=�)�@B��,5��,����+)��!D��,F (!#)���'����b!D���,(���´�

��,q��,����+)�k!D���,(���b)�@]CD=c���&QM���� (=>!3�+!x�4@Y (,($~�K��)�,o@YCD)�~O �#)tO��.2 '"����������b!D���,��M��xz��¶|�b¸<��!3�@Y (,($~�K�+),*@YC#)��p��K)�q/� 0 =< (!#=�!D (u(!#$>C#�+?"�@yP@Y)C]C#=>?(C#=>!#=>,F�#��,(�/��,��M��)��!D���,(������,('4!D (u(!#$>C#�+?"���@Y)CiCD=%?(CD=%!D=%,R�K�+,(� '(����������<!D���,(���´�»gh,ú�K;(=q@Y)�����)`���+,(�(¹P��;(=>,��+�k��������uz=-$%�+=c��CL@YC#)� �K;"=$%)�,F�#=~³��c¹z�P=.�����+�b)�k���<�K;(=/!# (u"!#$%CD��?"�%��2 !#�+�,����O�����K;q��C#� "�k=>,F��{<�����+�O'(=>,()��K=j��,���,(����)�!#�+�,����O��,('5�4!D���,(���7���+�#;o��C#� "�k=>,F�������+���7'"=%,()��#=j�*'(�+��+�K���z!#����,����´�RTSVU@ShR �=�[����]fX[�����kg�]@����������[��X[���A�C#=>E� "=%,($~Gú��!k$%�+)!#=>�+G C#=>�|�M�#=%'��#) ��!D?�=>$%��Å�$q�hG�?�=q)�@0?�=>C#�+)�'(�+$��k)��#��),Ñ$c�M����=>'�;��MC#�L),(��$)!D$%���+�|�M�#��),7¹F��;"��$�;���!<'(=>!#$>C#��uz=%'ouRG8!D��,F (!#)���'�����@Y (,($>�#��),"!%�]2�!#�+�k?"��=�;��MC#�L),(��$3)!#$>���+�|�M�#��),��!<�k�M�#;(=%�k�M�K�+$c���+�+G4'(=>!#$>C#��uz=%'ouRG��K;(=�@Y)�+��)`����,"�*��,����+)�*!#�+,F (!#)�+'����O!D���,(���´ÿ

xzy�¶|{D¸#uY��$>)!`¶£�(����{����¸�� {l ¡O:<;(�+!8!#�+�,�������!L@Y (����G $�;���C#��$>�#=%C#�4H%=>'�uRGÑ�K;(CD=%=-?(��CK���L=>�#=%CD!%ÿE�±��!L�K;(=-���k?"���+�# ('(=o)�@��K;"=!#�+,F (!#)�+'O¹��ò�+!V�K;(=£¢��¤�¥ ��z��').��k��,�$>G�$>��=%!�?z=%C�!#=>$%),"'q)C<;(=>CD�¥H8¶?�kH`¸º¹���,('�*��!V�#;(=0?(;���!D=/�+,CK�M'(�|��,"!%�]gh,5AB���(�O¶´� fK� ¸Ã�¤=/�+���+ (!D�#CK�M�#=3�K;"=%!#=.?���C#���L=>�K=>C#!>�

gÁ��$c��,�=%��!#�+�+GÑu�=�!D;()`��,O¹x�#;��M�8�#;(=�!#�+,� "!#)�+'����x!D���,(���x�+!8?�=>C#�+)�'(�+$�� 0 =�'(=%,")��K=��K;"=@Y (,('(���k=>,R�����¿?z=%CD��)�'-)�@·�K;"=*!#��,F (!D)��'(���B!D���,��M�BuRG§¦�u ¨© �.:<;(=4$%),($>=%?"�.)�@·@YCD=%EF (=%,"$>G��+!'(�+C#=%$~�K��G�C#=>�|�M�#=%'4�K)��K;"=d$>),($>=%?"�¤)�@7�#���L=��W2x$~�K ����+�+G�¹R�+�·;���!]�#;(=�'(���L=%,(!D��),4)�@���,RQ�=%C#!D=d�#���L=��

:<;(=xCD=%���M�K�+),(!#;"��?*�P=3;��cQ=�'"=%!#$>C#�+u�=>'i@Y)C·!#�+,� "!#)�+'�����!#�+�,����+!Ã$%��C#CXG4)`Q=%CÃ�K).�K;(=d$%����!#!Ã)�@$%)��k?(�+=~³8=~³�?�)�,(=%,R�K�����b!#�+�,����+!%¹

xzy¶ª{D¸@u«�[¬�­�®°¯²± ©�³s´�µ^¶ �H

Page 15: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

��;(=>C#=T·�u�¸ ¹/�R�l:<;(��!W$c�M,�=c��!D����G0u�=¤!#=%=>,*uRGj=º³"?"C#=%!D!#�+,(���K;(=¤!#�+�,����+!l�+,/�K=>C#�L!l)M@�!#��,F (!D)��'"! (!D��,(�*�K;"=/\] (�+=%C���'"=%,R�K���hG ¬ ­ µ u»$%)�!z����·R!#�+,��

2x$>$%)CD'(��,(���#)/A�) "C#��=>Cd¶X� SMHmsf��cmI_R¸º¹��L)!D�]!D���,(����!])�@�?(C#��$>�#��$c�M�"��,R�#=%C#=>!D�Ã$c�M,kuz=�'(=%$>)�4f?z)!#=>'k�+,F�#)0��!# (�ò)M@�$>)�L?(��=º³*=~³�?z),(=>,F�#�|���"!#����,�����!>�B:<;(=>C#=~@Y)C#=M¹F�¤=�$c��,LC#=>?(C#=>!#=>,F�P��!#�+�,������,k�K;(=��#���L=x'()�k���+, ¶£��!V�j@Y (,($>�#��),�)M@b�K���L=`¸·)CV�+,8�K;(=x@YCD=%EF (=>,($>G�'()��i���+,�¶���!<�j@Y (,($~�K�+),)�@·@YC#=>EF (=%,($~G"¸~�*:<;(=4C#=>?(C#=>!#=>,F�K�M�K�+), )�@¤�8!#�+�,����l (!#�+,(���K;(=*!D=%$%)�,('��L=>�#;()�'���!�$%�����+=%'-�K;"=º *��+.�»?���I�Ï)�@Ã�K;"=*!#����,����´�/:<;(=L��u(!D)�� "�#=�QM���� (=j)�@¤�#;(=*!#?z=%$~�KCD (�½��!�$%�����+=%'-�#;(=¼� ½2¾�'�-ª»¿�i�I�º *��+.�»?���I�*� 0 =. "!#=���)`�¤=%C�$c�M!#=0��=~�#�K=>C#!V@Y)CPC#=%?"C#=%!D=%,R�K�+,(�k�4!D���,(���7�+,8�K;(=��K�+�k=x'()�k����,��M,(' (?(?z=%C�$%��!#=*�+=>�D�K=%CD!x@Y)C3C#=%?"C#=%!D=%,R�K�+,(�5�8!#����,����W��,q�#;(=�@YC#=>E� "=%,($~G�'()�k����,7�.6����L������CV�K)�) "C,()��K�M�K�+), ��, �#;(=��K���L=8'()��i���+,O¹·��!#?z=%$~�KC# "�Ä���+�K;Ñ��CD� (�L=%,R�tÀ������+�P'(=>,()��K=�$>),R�K��,F ()� (!!#?z=%$~�KCD (� �M,('¾�o!#?z=%$>�#C# (�½�����K;¾�MC#� (�L=%,R�$Á ���+���]'(=>,()��K=L'(�+!#$%CD=>�#=i!#?z=%$~�KCD (�5� 0 =L���+���=~³�?(������,5;()`���K)8$>),RQ=%CX�.�i!#�+�,����b@YCD)�r�K;(=j�#���L=0'()�k����,o�K)i�#;(=/@YCD=%EF (=%,"$>G-'")�i�M��,-�M,('Q���$>=0Q�=%CD!K�k�+,o6�=%$M�l¶´������ TF¸~�

RTSVU@S²Â WYX[Z#\^]@_Ãgi]�adce_fchgiZ#\Ä&]lXTÅf����m�c^]lX:<;(=<?(CD)�$>=%!D!Ã)M@n½�'ƽ����¥¾�Çh»h�(Çe��-s¾�-ª»/½��B¶Y2�5��0¸&$%),RQ�=%C#!D��),L$%)�,(!#�+!D�K!])M@z�h�¤).!D�K=>?(!%ÿl!K���L?(�+��,(���M,('EF ���,R�K�4Hc�M�#��),7��7�����l�gÿÃøW�0 =x!K�M�k?(�+=d�#;(=��M,�����)��/!D���,��M�z?z=%CD��)�'(��$%������G�=~Q=%CXG�¦)È]!#=%$>),('(!>�@¦)È]��!Ã�K;(= º ½���*Æ�É-ª'I¾�*�����-/�����:<;F (!%¹��#;(=��-QM���� (=x)�@l�#;(=�!K�M�k?(�+=%'�!D���,��M�O=%EF ����+!V�K;(=�QM���+ (=�)�@&�K;"=0��,����+)�*!#�+�,����7�M�V�K�+�k=�ʦ)Ⱥ¹ xz�M¶?�b¸Ëu«xzy¶|�ʦ)È#¸ÍÌ:<;(= º ½���*Æ�É-ª'I¾t¢��¤�¥ �����').��Ñ�+!k�#;(=�,F (��uz=%C8)�@0!#���L?(��=>!i��,�),(=-!D=%$%)�,('O� 0 =q'(=%,()M�K=-�K;"=º ½���*Æ�É-ª'I¾�¢��¤�¥ �����').��8uRG¼��Ⱥ�ÃNP��=%��C#��G¹

��È#u �¦)È Ì:<;(=.�k=%��!# "C#=0 (,(������!<!K�M�k?(�+=%!<?z=%C�!#=>$%),"'O�¤:<;"= º ½���*Æ�É-ª'I¾�¢��¤�¥ �����').��i�+!���,5 "?(?�=>C�u�) ",('@Y)Cx�#;(=*@YC#=>E� "=%,($>��=%!��#;��M���K;"=L!#���L?(��=>'�!#����,����B$%��, =~³�?(CD=%!#!>�4gh,�)CD'(=%C��#)�$%����C#��@eG5�#;(��!>¹b��=>� (!�)u(!D=%CXQ=/�h�¤)k��,����+)�*!#�+,� "!#)�+'����O!D���,��M��!%ÿ

xzyR¶ª{D¸Ëu»$%)!c¶´�(��À>ÎÏ{D¸Í�ÑÐ�yM¶|{D¸#u�$%)! ¶£�(��À2Ò�{D¸ÍÌS

Page 16: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

t

AB�+� (CD=.� fX��ÿ¿\¿³"���L?(�+=�)�@¿�M���|�M!#��,"�(�

0 =k!#���k?"��=4�K;(=L!#�+�,����+!. "!#��,"� º ½���*Æ�É-ª'I¾�¢��¤�¥ �����').��Ó��Ⱥ� 0 =L$�;()�)!#=���È�!# ($�;¾�#;��M�C��È�uÀ>Ò�¹�À>Îo¶e���+�#;() "���+)!#!3)�@Ã�=%,"=%CK�M���+�hG¡À2ÒAÔÍÀ>Î ¸~� 0 =j'(=%,()M�K=j�#;(=*C#=>!# (���K��,"�i'(�+��+�K���&!#����,�����!uRG�xz�M¶?�O¸��M,('DÐ%�s¶?�O¸PC#=%!D?�=>$>�#�+Q=>�+G�� 0 =0$c��,o=c��!D����Gi?(CD)`Q=0�K;��M��xz�3=%EF ����+!�Ð%�`ÿ

Ð��s¶?�O¸Õu Ð�yM¶ ���È ¸u $%)!`¶´�(� À2Ò��È �b¸#u»$%)�!`¶´�>� ��È��ÖÀ>Î��È �O¸u $%)!`¶´�(��� �^�(� À>Î��È �O¸#u»$%)!c¶´�(� À>Î��È �b¸u xzy¶ ���È ¸#u«xz�M¶?�O¸×Ì

0 =L�+���+ (!D�#CK�M�#=/�K;"��!�?(;(=>,()�L=%,()�,��+, AB���(�¿¶´� f��¸~�j:<;(=%CD=>@Y)CD=�¹&@YC#=%EF (=>,($%�+=%!0�K;��s�.��C#=*;(�+�;(=>C�K;(��,/�#;(= º ½���*Æ�É-ª'I¾�¢��¤�¥ ��z��').��0�MC#=P�+,R�KC#)�'( ($>=%'/��,/�#;(=P!#���L?(��=>'/!D���,��M���M!B��)`�¤=%C&@YC#=>E� "=%,($>��=%!>�:<;(�+!b?(;(=%,")�k=>,(),.��!bCD=>@Y=%CDC#=>'0�#)d��!f½��É-?½ º -ª'I¾��b:<;(=Ã��u�)`Q�=Ã'"��!#$> (!#!D��),.��=%��'(!O�#)��#;(=]!K�M�k?(�+��,(��K;"=%)CD=%�oÿ¦j§&ÚûÈús�� ö=Ø��O�����B�Ãÿgø&�y��úSÿÃøJþ.ÿY�B�Y�Ù¡Ú ' ½�'ƽ����¥¾ º -s¾�'ƽ���xzy�¶|{D¸T.¥½�'Û���@�¤�+.+�(' º »¿����.�»^�¥��¢��¤�(�-ª» º�º ½���*Æ���¥� º -s¾�'ƽ���xz�M¶|�b¸Tudxzy�¶?�ʦ)ÈD¸C- ¢�»|,�� º ½���*Æ�É-ª'I¾k¢��¤�¥ ��z��').�����Èfu ¨Ü�Ý - º ¾��¤�¥½�»h���C»ª,i½�'»?ÞË-/.+��-ª» º ,I-s¾(,�� º »Ê¢��¤�¥ ��z��').��tÇl��ß>à�áT»ª,�����ÞË- º �$½��É-?½ º -ª'I¾�Þl�(�I�s���+� º �I�É»T-ª'Lxz�M¶?�O¸�àDâ�,�� º ½��AÇ*Æ�É-ª'I¾t�V½�»h�A�^¢3����ß$- º .¥½��ª���¥� »|,��[ã��� ��ä- º »f�¥½�»h��àå ý&�Çøaùuÿ|æR�&ùuÿRûHøgh,y)C#'(=>C��K)�C#=>?(C#=>!#=%,R�j=c��$�;yQ��M�� (=*)�@Ã�K;"=k!#���k?"��=%' !D���,��M�¿ (!#�+,(�w®u"�+�K!>¹b�P=LC#) ",('�=%��$�;QM���� "=j�K)�G���=>��' �8'(�+!#$%CD=>�#=*u(��,��MCDG-,F (�ju�=>C%� 0 =*C#=~@Y=%C��#)��#;(=*C#)� (,('(�+,(��=%CDC#)CD!0��! ���½�'�»?-ªÇ

m

Page 17: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ç ½�»?-/�('=')�(- º �~�$èd!# ����+�+G�¹7�P=L (!D=k�8,")C#�k�����4H%=>' IR�iu(�+��Q()R�M�K�+,(�8?z)��,R��@Y)CD�i�s�x���+�#;�Q��M�� (=>!CK�M,(���,"��@YC#)�é¹.�9ÌU_��K)��9ÌU_"¹���,('��K;F (!��K;"=� ��i½�'�»?- ç ½�»¿-/�('§')�(- º �.�+!<,(=%����=%$~�K=>'O�

RTSVU@S?ê �[]f�[�zce���«�t��Z#X[mä��]f�zë:<;(=�A�C#=%,"$�;¼�k�M�K;(=>�i�s�K��$>�|��,7¹xó�=%��,»{V��?"�#��!D�#=�ó�)!#=>?(;�A�) (CD��=%C�¶X� S�H�msf��`m�I_R¸~¹d'(=~Q=%�+)?z=%'!#=~Q=>CK�����k�M�K;(=>�i�s�K��$%���¤@Y)�C#�� (����!j@Y)C*$>),RQ=>CD�K�+,(�y!#����,�����!�@YCD)� �#;(=��K�+�k=8'")�i�M��,¾�K) �K;"=@YC#=>EF (=%,($~Gi'")�i�M��,k��,('kQ��+$%=�Q=%CD!K�"� 0 =3'"=%,()��#=3�#;(=x$>),RQ=%CD!#�+),i@YC#)��ò�K;(=��K�+�k=�'()�k���+,4�#)�K;"=3@YC#=>EF (=%,($~G8'()��i���+,kuRG§½�'ƽ��É� º - º =%EF ��M�#��),7¹"��,"'i�K;(=3)?(?z)!#���K=3$%),RQ=>C#!D��),�uRG º �%'�»ª,�� º - º=%EF ��s�K��)�,O��:<;(=i$>),RQ=>C#!#�+),�@Y)CD�� (�����+!0'(=%?z=%,('"=%,R�*),y�h�P)��M!#?z=%$>�#!j)�@P�K;(=L!#�+�,����£�8tl=>C#� f)�'(��$8¶Y���+�#;�?�=>C#�+)�'Ó�Æì ¸3Q�!%�/��?�=>C#�+)�'(�+$�¶e���+�K;-Å(,(�+�#=~fh=>,(=%CD��G¹7!#=%=k6�=>$��·¶£������91�¸#¸3!D���,��M��!��M,('$%)�,F�#��,F () "!XfÁ�#���L=dQ�!>�]'(��!D$%C#=~�K=ºfÁ�K�+�k=d!#�+�,����+!%�lgh,8����u(�+=�¶£����� ¸]�¤=�'(=>!#$>C#��uz=3�#;(=Û½�'ƽ��É� º - º �M,('º �('�»|,�� º - º =%EF ��M�#��),(!3@Y)C3�#;(=�'(��Æ7=>C#=%,R��$%��!#=>!%��:<;(=*)�,(�+Go$%����!#!3)�@·!#�+�,����+!3�¤=�$c�M,�!D�K)�C#=��+,�k$>)�L?( "�K=>C3�+!<�K;(=/?�=>C#��)�'(�+$�'(��!D$%C#=~�K=ºfÁ�K�+�k=0!D���,��M��!/¶Y�¤=j),"�+G�,(=>=%'q�#)i!D�#)C#=0�K;"=$í½Q��M�� (=>!)�@¤),(=4?z=%C#�+)�' )�@¤�K;(=4!D���,��M�e¸~� 0 =k����!D)�C#=~@Y=%C0�K)��K;(�+!0$%�|�M!#!0)�@¤!#����,�����!0�M!0Å(,(�+�#=~fh'" (CK�M�#��),'(�+!#$%CD=>�#=~fÁ�#���L=/!D���,(����!>�x:<;(=½�'ƽ��É� º - º =>EF ��M�K�+),-@Y)Cd�K;(�+!x$%����!#!3��!3)�@e�K=>,�C#=>@Y=>C#CD=%'-�K)8��!x�K;"=î - º .��¤��»h��ï��(�ä��-/����âi�¥½�' º ¢Ï�(���±¶£��AB:d¸º��6��+�k�+�|��CD�+G¹M�K;(= º �('�»|,�� º - º =%EF ��M�#��),�@Y)CP�#;(��!P$%�|�M!#!V�+!)�@e�#=%,oC#=>@Y=>C#CD=%'��K)L��!<�K;(=Cð�'�ñ���� º � î - º .��¤��»^�[ï��(�I��-/����âi�V½�' º ¢Ï�(���϶�g���AB:d¸º�

:<;(=y!#?z=%$>�#C# (� )�@j� ?�=>C#��)�'(�+$-'(��!D$%CD=>�K=ºfÁ�#���L=�!#����,��������+�#;��Ñ?z=%CD��)�'Yí ���+!#) @Y)CD� �?z=%C#�+)�'"��$�!D=%EF (=%,"$%=/�����K;o�4?�=>C#��)�'¼í�ÿ

ò ¶/Á<�Öíq¸@u �íôó#õ ¨ö ÷ ø ß xl¶?�O¸V¬ õ ­É¯²±)ùûú²ü%ýäþý÷ u �íôóËõ ¨ö ÷ ø ß xl¶|�b¸e¬ õ ­É¯²± úý

÷ u ò ¶/Á(¸�ÌgÁ@x�¤=o (!#=5�y!#���L?(���+,(�q@YC#=>EF (=%,($~GÖ��Ⱥ¹¤�K;"=oC#��,(�=o_�ÿéÁdÿéíÕ¹ �o$%)�C#C#=>!#?z),('(!4�K) �K;"=@YC#=>EF (=%,($~GyCK��,(��=4_§ÿÃÀÖÿ ��È~�*:<;(=>C#=~@Y)C#=M¹ ò ¶¿Á(¸x��!0��!K�M�k?(�+��,(�i)�@¤�#;(=4!#?z=%$~�KC# "�½CK��,(��=� _i�+��Èh!£�

:<;(=.$%)�L?(��=º³��+�hG�)�@W�K;"=.!X�KC#�����;R�D@Y)CD�P��C#'o���L?(�+=%�L=%,R���M�#��),i)�@l�#;(=/��AB:»�+! � ¶¿í ¯ ¸~�Ã{¤G���M���+,(����'�Q��M,F�K���=*)�@]�#;(=*?z=%C#�+)�'"��$%���hG�)�@·�K;(=4�M,����+G�!D��,(�8!D��,F (!D)��'(![¬ õ ­É¯²± úý

÷��,(' ��?"?(�+G���,"�

�K;"=o'"�+Q���'(=��M,('^$>),(EF (=>CL?"C#��,"$%��?"��=8)�@x!#?(�+�+�D�K��,"�q�K;(=�?(CD)u(�+=%� �+,R�K) !# ($>$%=>!#!#��Q=>�+GÑ!#�k�����+=%C!# "u(?(C#)�u(��=>�k!>¹·�qQ��MC#��=~�hGy)�@d�k)CD=i=�3k$>��=>,F�L�M���)CD�+�#;(�k!0)�@�$>)�L?(��=º³"���hG � ¶¿íÀ�+)�#í-¸j;(�`Q�=uz=%=%,�'"=>Q=>��)?z=%'-��;"��$�;�$c�M�k=.�K)8uz=��F,()`��,�$%)�+��=>$>�K��Q=>�+Go��!x�#;(=tï�½ º »@ï��(�ä��-/���â��V½�' º ¢Ï�(���¶£ABAB:d¸~�&:<;(=~G���=%,(=>CK���+�+G�CD=%EF (��CD=k�#;��M��í uz=8��?�)`�¤=%C/)�@V�h�¤)(��:<;(��!.C#=>E� "��C#=>�k=>,R�j�+!/,()M�$%CD�+�#��$c�M�´¹�!#�+,($%=/�P=�$%��,���'"'§H%=>C#)!x�#)k�#;(=�=%,"'-)�@]�K;"=/Å�,(���K=/!#����,����´��gÁ�x$c��,-uz=j!D;()`��,-�K;��s�H%=>C#)L?���'('"��,(�L�*!#�+�,����O)�,(�+Gi��,($>C#=c�M!#=%!��K;"=.!#���L?(���+,(��CK�s�K=0)�@W�K;(=�@YC#=>EF (=%,($~G�

[

Page 18: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

� hNo^]Ã1ÀwuOnw K 1ZhmQYXZT&wuOnw

�� ������� � ��

�� � ò ¶/Á(¸#u �¦äì ����������������� �"!$#&%('�()+* � ���,���.- /0% ø � /21 �435���6�"!$#6%7' ��)

8 9�:; <=>=

1 �?3@�A- BCED �GF0 H ø@I ���+JK����� �"!$# úýH ����JL�.- D �GF0 H ø@I 1 �?3@���6�M!$# úý H

N O= <9�P8 9 ; ;P Q

>9 QRP R:

1 �4SK�A- � /� / ���,������� �"!$#&T )+* � �������.- � /� / 1 �?SK���6�M!$#UT )+* S

8 9�:; <=>=

1 �4S��A- /0H ø � / ���+JK��� � �"!$#&T H ����JL�V- � #� # 1 �4SK���6�"!$#UT H * SW�XZY@[]\_^�`]Bba.cGdbe5f(gh\ifkj7f(XZl@m�n�dbf(opm6`

qsr�tVrvu wyx{z}|G~.��2���������U�+�����������}� ���G�������K�G�������� ?¡Z¢¤£¦¥¨§ª©Z«h¬U­� 7��®v��¯v®?«,°±�²¬�«³¡Z��§Z´ ���+JK� «h¬¨©���µ.���(©ª§�¬¶¸· /0H ø � /º¹ ���+JK� ¹ !» ¬�«³¡Z��§Z´ ���+JK� �5§�¬Aµ.�G«,®v�¼������ 4¡Z¢½« ¾¿¶ÁÀÃÂÅÄ

ÆÇm�eGXZ[h[³ÈbÉZÊË\ÌXZf�\sghl�j7\if(\im�j7\iͽghl�j7Î5\sf7X�j(ghd{Y�\ijvÊË\6\ilpjvÊËdÏ\6l@\if(ÐZȨÑ�XZ[he@\im6`�WÒÎ@\Ó©��Ô­�«+Õ���´�e@l@g]jghmsj(Î@\ÏÖ6dbopopdblªÊsX&È2n�dbfÒÖidbop×GXZf(g]l@Ð�j7Î5\Óf�\6[hX�j7g³Ñb\�\6l5\6f(ÐZgh\6mÌdZn�jvÊËdØm�ghÐblGX�[hm6`�2���������U�+���ÚÙÛ�(�2��Ü��+ÝA��Þ¦�,�¿�K�G�¨©��Ô­�«+Õ���´�«h¬_©���µ.���(©ª§�¬B * ß ·ÁBUàA[hdbÐ F I ¶ F¶ Iá �G�� 7�ⶠI «h¬Ï®��G�Ó 7��¥&�� 7����­Ô�������� ?¡Z¢ZÄã�\_Ö&XZläX�[hm(dØÖ&XZ[]Ö6e@[hX�j7\�j(Î@\�\6l5\6f(Ð�ÈådZnæj7Î@\¨m(×�\6Öij(f(e@oç`{èâdUÊk\�Ñb\6fiÉ}éæXZf�m(\�ÑZX�[4êëm{WÒÎ@\6dZf(\6o

BUà

Page 19: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

m�j7X�j7\im�j7ÎGX�j_j7Î5\±jvÊkdäÖ6XZ[hÖie@[�X�j7ghdZl@m¨[]\&XZÍìj7dåj(Î@\ªm7X�oØ\±Ñ�XZ[]e@\Z`íã�\ªm�jÔX�j(\±j7Î5\±j7Î@\idbf(\ioîn�dZfï l@g³j7\�ðvÍ@e@f(X�j7g]dbl2Í@g]m(Ö6f�\ij(\�ð$j(ghop\{m(g]ÐblGXZ[]m6`ñ_ò � ������ó Ùô��õ{ö@��÷6��ø@öGÞ¦���

D0 H ø@I ¹ ���+JK� ¹ !k- BC D0 % ø@I ¹ 1 �43@� ¹ !WÒÎ@\ÏXZY�dUÑb\�\iù�e@XZ[hg³jvȱÖ6XZl2Yú\²\&XZm�gh[]ÈpÑb\if(g ï \6ͤe@m�ghl@Ð_j(Î@\�ghÍ5\&X¨j(ÎGX�jÒdbf�j7Î@dZÐbdblGXZ[ú[hg]l@\&XZf.j7f(XZl@m¦ðn�dbf�o±X�j(ghdblØÍ@d½l@dZjÌÖÔÎGX�l@Ðb\�j7Î@\�l5dbf(oûdZn�X_ÑZ\6Ö�j7dbfiÉ�XZl@Í2j7Î@\Óü�cæWÃg]mÒghl@Í@\i\6ÍçXZl¤dbf�j7Î@dbÐZdblGXZ[[hg]l@\&X�fkj7f(XZl@m�n�dZf(oØX�j7g]dblK`qsr�tVr$ý þpÿ�x{z��A|�����ÿ���� � x����A|�ÿ��.x����Ì�����5z����� ¬�¢U¬�®v��°������ �æg]m{XØn�e5l@Öij(ghdblçn�f(dboEj7Î5\�m(g]ÐblGXZ[]mÇm�×GXZÖ6\�j(dØj(Î@\�m(g]ÐblGXZ[]mÇm�×GXZÖi\Z`{ãì\¼XZ[hm�d±e@m�\j7Î5\_j7\if(o µ.´"®¦�� ½n�dbfÇÍ@\6m�Ö6f(g]Y@ghl5бm�È�m�j7\6opm6`{ãì\¨ÊÌg][h[}oØXZghl@[³È2f(\�n�\6f²j(d±m�È m�j7\ioØm{j(ÎGX�j{dZ×ú\if7X�j(\dblÚÍ5ghÐbg³jÔXZ[Òm�ghÐblGX�[hm6`Ããì\åf(\�n�\6f±j(dìj(Î@\äXZf�Ðbe@op\6l�jªdZn²j7Î@g]mØn�e@l@Ö�j7g]dblÚXZmØj7Î@\ì«,�"!$# ®pdZn�j7Î5\m�È�m�j7\6oûXZl@Ípj7dÓj7Î@\ÌÑ�XZ[he@\ÌdZn�j7Î@\Ìn�e@l@Ö�j7ghdZlªXZm.j7Î@\¼£%#�®�!$#�®Ëd�n�j7Î5\²m�È�m�j7\6oç`�ãì\Çe@m�eGXZ[][]ȼ[]ghopg]jdbe@f�m(\i[]Ñb\imâj(dpX½m�×ú\iÖ6g ï Ö¨Öi[�XZm�mÒdZn�m�È�m�j7\ioØmÒð.j7Î5\'&�«,���(§Z )(@��« ¥�®+¯+*��-,�§Z �«+§Z�G® �+.0/21��3/ È�m�j(\6opm6`�2���������U�+���54Û�76V�?�}� ö@�98ú�}÷i�U��ó ÷Z��� » ©Z«h¬U­� 7��®¦�â¬�¢ ¬�®v��°:���;�<�A«h¬k[hg]l@\&X�f{« ¥Ï§Z��©±£��G´"¢�« ¥=�>�;�<�¬6§Z®+«h¬�µs�Ô¬{®,�G�?!� �«,��­�«@!�´h�Ï£¦¥Ì¬A#B!G�� C!G£U¬�«,®+«4£��ED���§Z°±��´"¢FD@¥&£� {§Z´,´ú® á £½©Z«³¡Z«,®4§Z´G¬�«³¡Z��§Z´ ¬ � F ��JL� G � ! �+JK�§Z��©â¥&£� ¨§Z´,´}§Z´,´L® á £¼¬A#B!G�� C!G£U¬�«,®+«4£��ì­Ô£U�IH ­�«4���G®�¬KJ F G J !�LNM D��� J F � F � � �PO J ! � ! � � � � - J F ��� � F � � � � O J ! ��� � ! � � � ��Q�2���������U�+���SRÚ�T8 ò �IU4�WV7X6��ø@ö@����öG�ú�å�T8YX �'8ú�}÷i�U��ó ÷��,�Z&}��®=[ % �;�<�ÇÕ��p§ª¬�¢ ¬�®v��° ®,�5§Z®k¬Ô��« ¥�®,¬p§¬�«³¡Z��§Z´ 3 ¬6§Z°\!�´h�Ô¬Dâ��§Z°±��´"¢FDâ« ¥^] � � �Ç- [ % � ��� � � �²®,�G���9_ J G ] �+JK�{- ����Ja`Ã3@� Ä » ©Z«h¬U­� Ô��®v�¬�¢U¬�®¦��°b����� �L«h¬�m�Î@g]n,j�ðvg]l Ñ�XZf�g�XZl�jk« ¥Ò§Z��©_£��G´"¢{« ¥.¬Ô��« ¥�®?«,��¡�®��G�k«,�"!$#�®æ£¦¥k®,�G�ˬ�¢U¬�®v��° «h¬â�7cW# «d,�§Z´h���G®®v£¼¬Ô��« ¥�®?«,��¡Ø®,�G�¼£%#�®�!$#�®â£¦¥Ï®,�G�{¬�¢U¬�®¦��°���<[ % � ��� � � �e� - [ % � �>� ��� � � �f��Q.0/21 m�È�m�j(\6opmÒÖ&XZl2Y�\²n�e@[][]Ƚf(\i×@f(\im(\il j(\6Íçe@m(g]l@Ð_j(Î@\6g]fkf(\im(×�dbl@m�\�Í@e@\²j(d¼X�e@l@g³jsm7X�oØ×@[]\²X�jj7g]oØ\{à5`�ã�\ÏÍ@\il@dZj(\Ój(Î@ghmÒg]l@×@e5jÌm�ghÐblGX�[KY�Èg �+JK�.-ih B Jí- àà j �lkG�nm o�prqU� Q

BbB

Page 20: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ãì\_Í@\il@dZj7\¨j7Î@\¨dbe5j7×5e5j{dZnAX±m�È�m�j(\6o Í@e@\¨j(d±j7Î5\ g �+JL� ghl@×5e5j²Y�Èçj7Î@\Ø«,°\!$# ´ ¬U�¨ 7�Ô¬r!G£��5¬U�¨dZnj7Î5\Óm�È�m�j7\io k}�+JK�V- �>� g �+JL� �sQãì\kl@dUÊ m(Î@dUÊ Î@dUʺj7dÇf(\6×5f(\6m�\6l�jAj7Î5\kdbe5j(×@e5jædZn�X²m�È�m�j7\6ot����� �5e5m(ghl5ÐÇj7Î5\sghop×@e@[]m(\.f(\im(×�dbl@m(\�`. \ij ���+JK� Y�\ÇXZlØg]l@×@e5jVm�ghÐblGX�[4`�ãì\ÌÖ&XZlpÊÌf(g³j7\ ���+JK� e@m�ghl@ÐÏj7Î5\ÇlGX�j7e@f(XZ[GYGXZm�ghm.dZnKm�Î@g]n,j(\6ÍØe@l@g]jm7X�oØ×@[]\�m(g]ÐblGXZ[]m ���+JK�.- /0% ø � / ���43@� g ��Ju`º3@�.- /0% ø � / ���435� [ % � g �+JL� �sQÆÇm�ghl@ÐÏj7Î5\²[hg]l@\&X�f.XZl@ͱm�Î@g]n,j�ðvg]l Ñ�XZf�g�XZl�j.×@f�db×�\6f�j(gh\im6É�Êk\ÇÖ&XZlpÊÌf(g³j7\Ìj7Î@\âdbe5j(×@e5jËdZnKj7Î5\Çm�È m�j7\ioXZm ] ��JL� - ��� ���+JL� �- �wv /0% ø � / ���435� [ % � g �+JL� �fx

- /0% ø � / ���435� �y�<[ % � g �+JK� �f�- /0% ø � / ���435� [ % � ��� g �+JK� �f�- /0% ø � / ���435�7k}�+Jz` 3@� Q � ^ `]B �

WÒÎ@\soØX�j(Î@\6oØX�j7g]Ö&XZ[Zdb×ú\if7X�j(ghdbl¨ghl�{.ù eK` � ^ `³B � ghm�Ö&XZ[][h\iÍ�XÇ[]ghl@\6XZfs­Ô£��-,Z£�´;# ®+«4£��ØXZl@Í�g]m�Í@\il@dZj(\6ÍY�È ] �+JK�A- /0% ø � / ���43@�lk}�+Ju`º3@� · ���+JK��|Kk}�+JK� QWÒÎ e@m6É@j(Î@\{g]oØ×@e5[hm(\Çf(\im(×�dbl@m(\{n�e5[h[]ȽÍ5\6m(Öif(g]Yú\imsj7Î@\�m�È m�j7\ioí`Aãì\{Ö&XZl2Í5\ij7\if(opghl@\âj7Î@\�dZe5j7×@e jdZn�j7Î@\âm�È�m�j7\6o Y�ȽÖ6dZl ÑZdb[]Ñ�g]l@Ð�j7Î@\âghl@×5e5j.m(g]ÐblGXZ[5ÊÌg³j7νj7Î@\Ìg]oØ×@e5[hm(\Òf�\6m�×údbl5m(\âdZn�j(Î@\Ìm�È�m�j(\6oç`

6�8PX}8ú�}÷i�U��ó ÷½�+�Û� ò �a~L� ���P������ÜZ�Ú�2��ó�öG�+�ãì\Øm(XUÊ j(ÎGX�jÓÊk\ØÖ&XZlìf(\i×@f(\im(\6l�j½X .0/21 m�È�m�j7\6oîe@m�ghl@Ðçg]j(m¨g]oØ×@e5[hm(\¼f�\6m�×údbl5m(\ZÉ k���JL� `2WÒÎ@\Í@g]m(Ö6f�\ij(\�ð$j(ghop\.cGdbe@f(g]\6f�j(f7XZl5m�n�dbf�o dZn�j7Î@\.ghop×@e@[]m(\Af�\6m(×�dbl@m�\Ëg]mLÖ&XZ[][h\iÍ{j7Î@\½�@ �§Z�5¬�¥&�� ��Y# ��­�®+«4£��

B ^

Page 21: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

dZn�j7Î@\Ïm�È m�j7\io X�l@Í2Êk\ÓÍ@\6l5dZj7\Ïg]jÌY�È� �4S�� · /0H ø � / k}�+JL����� �"!$#UT H QÆÇm�ghl@мj(Î@\ÏÍ@\ ï l5g]j7g]dbl@msd�n�j(Î@\Óc�dZe@f(g]\6fkj(f7XZl@m�n�dbf(o XZl@Í2j7Î5\ÓÖidbl�Ñbdb[]e5j7g]dbl2Êk\ÏÖ6XZlíÍ5\6f(g³Ñb\�j7Î5\n�db[][hdUÊÌghl@Ð_ghop×údbf�jÔXZl�jÒ×5f(db×�\6f�jvÈ2dZn�j7Î@\ÏÖ6dZl ÑZdb[he j7ghdZlKa� �4SK� - /0H ø � / ] �+JK��� � �"!$#&T H

- /0H ø � / /0% ø � / ���?3@�7k}��J�` 35����� �"!$#&T H- /0H ø � / /0% ø � / ���?3@�7k}��J�` 35����� �"!$#&Tn� H ��%��?��� �"!$#&TÔ%- /0% ø � / ���?3@����� �"!$#&TÔ% /0H ø � / k���Jz` 3@����� �M!$#UTW� H ��%�- /0% ø � / ���?3@��� � �"!$#&TÔ% /0� ø � / k}�+�ç��� � �M!$#UTW� � �- 1 �4SK� � �4SK�

� Ö6dbl�ÑZdb[he5j(ghdblºg]lºj(Î@\2j7g]oØ\2Í@dZo±XZg]l ghm¼\iù�e5g]Ñ�XZ[h\il�jpj(d o�e@[]j(gh×@[]ghÖ6X�j7g]dbl�g]lºj(Î@\2n�f(\iù�e5\6l@Ö�ÈÍ@dboØXZg]lK`�WÒÎ5\6f(\�n�dbf(\�É j(Î@\Ìm(×�\6Öij(f(e@o dZnúj7Î@\âdbe5j(×@e5jËX�j S dbl@[]È�Í@\6×�\6l@Í5mkdbl½j7Î@\âm(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@o dZnj7Î5\�m(ghÐZlGXZ[LX�j S X�l@ͤdblªj7Î@\�Ñ�XZ[]e@\{dZn�j7Î@\{j(f7XZl5m�n�\6fsn�e5l@Öij(ghdbl¤X�j S ` 1 jÌÍ@d \imÒl@dZjÌÍ@\i×ú\il@Íçdblj7Î5\¼m(×�\6Öij(f(e@o X�jÏdZj7Î5\6f{n�f(\iù e@\6l@Öigh\im6` 1 l dZj7Î5\6f²ÊËdbf(Í5m6ÉLj7Î@\½ÖidboØ×5[h\A�å\A� ×�dbl@\il j(g�XZ[æm(ghÐZlGXZ[hmXZf�\ç\ighÐb\il�Ñb\6Ö�j7dbf�m±dZn{XZl�È .0/21 m�È�m�j7\6o XZl5ÍÛj7Î5\çj(f7XZl@m�n�\6f¼n�e@l@Ö�j7g]dblÛg]m¼j7Î@\çÖ6dbf�f(\im(×�dbl@Í@g]l@Ð\6g]Ðb\6l�Ñ�XZ[]e@\6mi`qsr�tVrr� �y�{z����)�V|E��� ÿ�� z��\���{|�ÿ¦z}|b�Ø|-�.x)�E�T�V|��WÒÎ@\²c�dZe@f(g]\6f.W�f(XZl@m�n�dbf(o g]mËX�Í@\6ù eGX�j(\Çn�dbfËXZlGX�[]È��6g]l@Ð�j7Î@\Çm(×�\6Öij(f(e@o dZn�m(g]ÐblGXZ[]m.ÊÌÎ5dbm(\Ç×@f(db×�ð\6f�j7g]\6m�Í@dÇl5dZj�Ñ�XZf�È{ÊÌg]j(Ψj(ghop\ZÉUj7ÎGX�j�g]mLn�dbf�XZlGXZ[³È2�ighl@ÐÌm�jÔX�j(ghdblGX�f�È�m�ghÐblGX�[hm6`�èÇdUÊË\iÑZ\6f6ÉZo�e@m(g]Ö&XZ[m(g]ÐblGXZ[]m{XZf�\�l@dZjÏm�jÔX�j(ghdbl@XZf�ÈZ`ÓWÒÎ5\¼×@f(db×�\6f�j7g]\6m{dZnVo�e5m(ghÖ6XZ[æm�ghÐbl@XZ[hm � XZop×@[hg³j7e@Í5\6m6É�n�f(\iù�e5\6l@Ö�ÈXZl@Íç×@ÎGX�m(\6m � ÖÔÎGXZl@Ðb\ÏÊÌg]j(Î2j7ghop\Z`æWÒÎ@\6f�\in�dbf�\ZÉGÊk\ÓXZf�\Ïghl�j7\if(\6m�j7\iÍíg]l¤j(Î@\Ïm(×�\6Ö�j7f(e5oEdZnæm�Î@dbf�jm(\iÐbop\6l�j7mVdZn�j(Î@\Ìm(g]ÐblGXZ[?`�ãì\âÖ6XZ[hÖie@[�X�j7\sj7Î5\âj(ghop\�ðvÍ5\6×�\6l@Í@\il�jËm�×ú\iÖij(f(e@o dZn�j7Î@\âm(g]ÐblGXZ[5e@m(g]l@Ðj7Î5\�(@�G£� �®+¯&�}«,°±�)��£%#  �«4�� ª�@ �§Z�5¬�¥&£� �°¼`

BF�

Page 22: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

t

x(t)

0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5−60

−50

−40

−30

−20

−10

0

Frequency (Hz)

Mag

nitu

de S

pect

rum

(dB

)

−110

−100

−90

−80

−70

−60

−50

−40

−30

−20

−10

0

Time (Sec.)

Fre

quen

cy (

Hz)

0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

1.6

1.8

2

cæg]Ðbe@f(\±^ ðr�5a � ÖÔÎ@ghf�× m(g]ÐblGXZ[ � j(db× � Éæg]j(m�ü�cæWÁXZlGXZ[³È m�ghmÓe@m(g]l@ÐåÍ�� m(Ö6XZ[h\ � opghÍ@Í@[]\ � XZl@Íìg]j(m/ WÌcæW�XZlGXZ[³È�m(ghmÒ×5f(\6m�\6l�j7\iÍyY�È2m(×�\6Ö�j7f�dbÐbf7X�o � Y�dZj(j(dbo � `Bn�

Page 23: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

�2���������U�+���5�Û�T8 ò ���U� ñ �+ó���~L�$�}����� � ñ � öG��÷WU$����óô�����K�G� / Î5dbf�j�ðvWÒghop\ÒcGdbe@f�gh\if�W�f(XZl@m¦ðn�dbf�o � (A�P�{��¡±£¦¥¨§½¬�«³¡Z��§Z´ ����JL� «h¬Ó©���µ.���(©ª§�¬1 ��J G S��A- /0� ø � / ���+J¢O£�ç��o¼�I�ç����� �"!$#&T � G � ^ `M^ �

á �G�� 7� o¼��JL� «h¬¨§ á «,��©�£ á ¬�«³¡Z��§Z´³Ä{Aù eK` � ^�`M^ � Ö&XZl Y�\�ghl�j7\if(×@f�\ij(\6Í XZm{j7Î5\½ü�cæWÅdZn.j7Î@\¼m�Î@g]n,j(\6Íäm�ghÐblGX�[ ���+J¤O5�ç� ÉLXZm{Ñ�g]\iÊË\6Íj7Î5f(dbe@ÐZÎçj(Î@\ÓÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊ o��+�ç� ` 1 lçj7Î@\ / WÌcæW�ÉGj7Î5\ÓdZl@\�ð$Í@ghop\6l@m�ghdbl@XZ[Km(\iù e@\6l@Öi\ ���+JK� ghmÌÖ6dbl�ðÑb\if�j(\6Í ghl�j7d¤XpjvÊkd¤Í@g]oØ\il@m(g]dblGXZ[Ln�e@l@Ö�j7g]dblädZnAj7g]oØ\_XZl@Íyn�f�\6ù e@\6l5ÖiÈb` 1 läo�e@m�ghÖ�m�ghÐbl@XZ[hmiÉúj7Î5\j7g]oØ\pf(\im(db[]e5j7g]dblìn�dZfÓj(Î@\ / WÌcæW g]m_e@m�eGXZ[h[³È Yú\�jvÊk\i\6lÃBUà ��q j(dN¥bà ��q `íãì\ªe@m�\±j7Î5\í¬r!G�Ô­�¯®+ Ô£(¡Z �§Z° n�dbf½gh[][he@m�j7f7X�j7ghl5Ðyj7Î@\ío±XZÐZl@g]j(e@Í@\¤dZn{j(Î@\ / WÌc�WEÐbf7XZ×5Î@ghÖ6XZ[h[³Èb` 1 l c�ghÐ@` � ^ ð�� � ÊË\Ö6dZoØ×GX�f(\²j(Î@\Ïü�cæW¿XZl@Í2j7Î5\ / WÌcæW¿dZn�X½ÖÔÎ5ghf(×2m�ghÐbl@XZ[4`�WÒÎ5\{n�f(\6ù e@\il@ÖiȤd�n�j(Î@\�ÖÔÎ@g]f(פm(g]ÐblGXZ[ÖÔÎGXZl5Ðb\6mV[hg]l@\&XZf�[]ÈÓj7Î@f�dbe@Ðbμj(ghop\Z`æWÒÎ5\Çü�c�WÚXZlGX�[]È�m(g]mAm(Î@dUÊÌm.j7Î@\Ìop\&XZl¼n�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�ÈpÖ6dbl�j7\il�j7mdZn�j7Î@\Òm�ghÐbl@XZ[4`�WÒÎ@\ / WÌcæWÚX�lGXZ[]È�m�ghm�m�Î@dUÊÌmVj(Î@\ÌÖÔÎGXZl@Ðb\imËd�n�j(Î@\Òn�f(\iù�e5\6l@Ö�ȽÖ6dbl�j7\il�jËj(Î@f(dbe5ÐbÎj7g]oØ\�`¦ �?�0§}�2¨Ø�?�}�WÒÎ@\¼×@f�ghoØXZf�Ȥ×5e@f(×�dbm(\¼d�nAj7Î@\�ÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊ o¼�+JK� g]låj7Î@\ / WÌcæW¸ghm²j(dª[hg]oØg³jÒj7Î@\¼\T� j(\6l�jÏdZn.j7Î5\m(\iù e@\6l@Öi\âj(d�Yú\sj(f7XZl5m�n�dbf�oØ\iͼm(d�j7ÎGX�j�j7Î@\Òm�×ú\iÖij(f7XZ[@ÖÔÎ@XZf7XZÖ�j7\if(ghm�j7g]Ö6m.XZf�\ÒXZ×@×@f�dn�5g]o±X�j7\6[³ÈÓm�jÔX ðj7g]dblGXZf�ȱdUÑZ\6fsj7Î5\�Í@e@f7X�j7ghdZl2dZn}j7Î@\{ÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊÏ`.WÒÎ@\�oØdZf(\{f(XZ×@ghÍ5[]Èpj7Î@\�m�ghÐblGX�[�ÖÔÎGXZf(XZÖij(\6f�ghm�j(ghÖimÖÔÎGXZl5Ðb\ZÉ@j(Î@\Ïm(Î@dbf�j7\ifÌj(Î@\{ÊÌghl5Í@dUÊ m(Î5dbe@[hͤY�\Z`=©{l2j7Î@\ÏdZj(Î@\6fÒÎ@XZl@ÍKÉ�X¼o�e@[³j7g]×@[hg]Ö&X�j(ghdbl¼ÊÌg]j(ÎXíÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊ Y@[he@f�m¨j(Î@\ªm(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@o dZnÒj(Î@\ªm�ghÐblGX�[4`åW�dye@l5Í@\6f�m�jÔX�l@Í j7Î@g]m6ÉAf(\iÖ&XZ[][Vj(ÎGX�j�XåÖ6dbl�ðÑbdZ[he5j(ghdbl2g]l¤j(Î@\�j7g]oØ\{Í5dbo±X�ghlªg]mÒ\6ù e@g]Ñ�XZ[]\6l�jÌj7d½o�e@[³j7g]×@[hg]Ö&X�j(ghdblpghlªj(Î@\�n�f(\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈçÍ@dZo±XZg]lK`/ g]oØg][�XZf�[]ÈbÉVX�o_e@[]j(gh×@[]ghÖ&X�j7ghdZl ghlôj(Î@\íj(ghop\íÍ@dZo±XZg]lôg]mØ\iù�e5g]Ñ�XZ[h\il�j±j7d�Ö6dbl�ÑbdZ[he5j(ghdblÚg]lôj7Î5\n�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�È Í@dboØXZghlK`_WÒÎ@\6f�\in�dbf�\ZÉ}j7Î@\½dbf�ghÐbg]lGXZ[æm�×ú\iÖij(f(e@o dZnVj7Î5\pm�ghÐbl@XZ[�ghm�Öidbl�Ñbdb[³Ñb\iÍìÊÌg]j(Îj7Î5\ªm(×�\6Ö�j7f(e5o dZnÒj(Î@\ØÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊÏ` 1 l c�ghÐ@` � ^Uðr� � Êk\±m(Î@dUÊ j7Î@\±m(×�\6Öij(f(e@oîdZnâXåf�\6Ö�jÔXZl@ÐZe@[�XZfÊÌghl5Í@dUÊÏ` WÒÎ5ghm�m�ÎGXZ×�\2ghm_d�n,j7\6l f�\in�\if(f(\iÍ j7d XZmج�«,��­pn�e@l5Öij7g]dblK`«ªÌ\6Í@e5Ö6\6ͺf�\6m(dZ[he5j(ghdbl X�l@Í[h\6X"¬�XZÐb\ÇXZf(\Çj7Î@\âjvÊkd¼×@f�ghoØXZf�Ƚ\A­�\iÖij(msdbl±j(Î@\{m(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@o XZmkX_f(\im(e@[³jsdZn�X�×@×@[]È�g]l@Ð�X¨ÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊj7díj7Î@\2m�ghÐblGX�[4`åWÒÎ5\2f(\6m�db[he j7ghdZl�ghm_ghlE®Ge5\6l@Öi\6ͺ×@f(g]o±X�f(gh[³ÈyY�È�j(Î@\ªoØXZghlì[hdbY�\±d�nÒj7Î@\å¬�«,��­�ÉÊÌÎ@g][h\¨j(Î@\�Í@\iÐbf(\i\¼dZnV[h\6X"¬�XZÐb\_Í5\6×�\6l@Í@m�dZlyj7Î@\¼f�\6[�X�j7g]ÑZ\�XZop×@[]g]j7e5Í@\¨d�nAj7Î@\¼oØXZghlí[hdbY�\�X�l@Íj7Î5\Çm�ghÍ@\â[hdbY�\6mi`��kdZj(ÎØj(Î@\ÇoØXZg]lØ[]dbYú\ÒÊÌg]Í5j7ÎØXZl@Ípj7Î@\Çf(\6[hX�j7g³Ñb\âXZop×@[hg³j7e@Í5\ÒdZn�j(Î@\²oØXZghl½[]dbYú\XZl@ͤj7Î5\¨m�ghÍ@\Ó[hdbY�\6mâXZf�\ÏÍ@\6×�\6l@Í5\6l�j{dblçj7Î@\Ï[]\6l@ÐZj(Îíd�næj7Î5\ÓÊÌg]l@Í@dUʸXZl@Íçdblçg]j(mâm�ÎGXZ×�\Z`ÒcGdbfX¼oØdZf(\�×@f�dZn�dbe@l@Íç×@f�\6m(\il�jÔX�j(ghdblçm(\i\}�ë^b^ É�^%�5ÉLBF¯B�4`

BB°

Page 24: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

−1 −0.8 −0.6 −0.4 −0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1−60

−50

−40

−30

−20

−10

0

Frequency (π units)

Mag

nitu

de (

dB)

cæg]Ðbe@f(\Ó^Uðr�@a�WÒÎ5\¨m�×ú\iÖij7f�e@oEdZn�f(\iÖijÔX�l@Ðbe@[hXZfkÊÌghl5Í@dUÊÏ`qsr�tVrC± ² �)�5ÿ�³´�¶µ¤������x)·¹¸�z�x{z}|-���@ÿ��Ëx1 líj(Î@ghmâm(\iÖij(ghdblçÊk\¨Y@f(g]\º®@Ȥ\T�5×5[�XZg]lçj(Î@\¨×5Î È�m�ghÖ&X�[�YGX�m(\6mÇdZn�m�dbe@l@ÍåÐb\6l@\if7X�j(ghdblçe@m�ghl@Ðpj7f7X�Í@g³ðj7g]dblGXZ[Ao_e@m(g]Ö&XZ[.ghl5m�j7f�e@op\6l�j7mi` � [h[Aj7f(XZÍ@g³j7ghdZlGXZ[�g]l@m�j(f(e@op\6l�j7mÓÎGX&Ñb\ªXZl�dbm�Ö6g][h[�X�j7ghl5Ð2\6[h\ioØ\il�jXZl@ÍØm(dbop\ÌoØ\[email protected]Öidbe@×@[]ghl@Ð�j(Î@\Çm�dbe@l@Ípj7dÏj7Î@\âm(e5f(f(dZe@l@Í@g]l@Ð@`AcGdbf.\A�5XZop×@[]\ZÉ ghl¼j7Î5\âÑ�ghdZ[hghln+XZopgh[³ÈbÉ j(Î@\Ïdbm(Öigh[][�X�j(ghl@Ð�\i[h\ioØ\il jÌg]mâX½m�j7f�ghl@Ð@`VWÒÎ@\Ïm�j(f(g]l@ÐØg]mÒÖ6dbe5×@[h\iÍçj(d±X½m(dbe5l@Í@ghl5ÐpY�d�XZf�Íe@m�ghl@ÐpX½Y@f(g]Í@Ðb\ � m�\6\¨cæghÐ � ^ ð�° ��� `AWÒÎ@\Ïm�dbe@l@Í@g]l@ÐpYúd�X�f(ͤf(\iÖ6\6g³Ñb\im²op\6ÖÔÎGXZl5ghÖ&X�[KoØd�j7ghdZlªn�f(dboj7Î5\Òm�j7f�ghl@ÐÏX�l@ͼ×@f(dUÑ�ghÍ5\6m.Yú\�j(j(\6f.XZÖidbe@m�j(ghÖ6XZ[5Öidbe@×@[]ghl@вj(d{j7Î@\ÌX�ghfæj(ÎGXZl¼Ö&X�l½j(Î@\Òm�j(f(g]l@ÐÏXZ[hdZl@\ZÉÊÌg]j(Τg]j7msÑZ\6f�Ȥm(oØXZ[h[Km�e@f�n+X�Ö6\ÓXZf(\6X5`ÆÇm�ghl@Ð j7Î@\ím(ghÐZlGXZ[Ò×@f�d Öi\6m(m�ghl@Ð j7\if(opghl@db[]dbÐZÈZÉVj(Î@\ídZm(Ö6g][h[hX�j7g]l@Ðä\6[]\6op\6l�j±Ö6XZlôY�\íÑ�g]\iÊË\6ÍXZm_Xåm(dbe5f(Ö6\Øm(g]ÐblGXZ[ q ����� j7ÎGX�j_×GXZm�m(\6m¨j7Î@f�dbe@ÐbÎ Xím�È�m�j(\6o � \Z`ëÐ@`íghlìj(Î@\ØÑ�g]db[hg]l n+X�oØg][]ÈbÉ}j7Î5\m�È�m�j7\6o Í@\i×ú\il@Í@mkdZlØj7Î5\²m(dZe@l@ͱY�d�XZf�Í � `�ã�\âe@m(e@XZ[h[³ÈpXZm(m�e@oØ\Ìj7Î@X�jËj(Î@\âm�È�m�j(\6o ghm .�/�1 É X�l@Íj7Î e@mkghmkf�\6×@f�\6m�\6l�j7\iÍíe@m�ghl@Ð_g]j7mËghop×@e@[]m(\âf(\6m�×údZl@m(\ k}����� `�ã�\²l@dUÊ�\T� ×@[hdbf�\Çj(Î@\{×@f�db×ú\if�j(gh\6mËdZnj7Î5\�m(dbe5f(Ö6\_m(ghÐZlGXZ[4` 1 nAÊk\¼m�\ijÏXØm�j7f�ghl@бghl�j7dªopdZj(ghdblíX�j{g³j7mÇoØg]Í@×údZghl�j&É�g]jÇÊÌgh[][}Ñ�g]Y@f7X�j(\�X�j{Xn�e@l@Í@XZoØ\il�jÔXZ[Kn�f�\6ù e@\6l5ÖiȤÐbg³Ñb\6lçY�È

S I - B^ »¤¼ �� GÊÌÎ@\if(\>»ÛghmÒj7Î@\Ó[h\il@ÐZj(Îçd�næj7Î5\¨m�j7f(g]l@Ð@É��Åg]mÒg]j(mÌj(\6l@m�ghdblíXZl@Í � g]mâg³j7mÌoØXZm(mi`ËWÒÎ@g]mÇopd�Í@\�dZnÑ�ghY@f(X�j7g]dbl2ghmÌÖ6XZ[h[]\6ͤX½m�jÔX�l@Í@ghl5нÊkX&Ñb\�`sWÒÎ@\Ïm�j(f(ghl5ÐØÖ6XZlåX�[hm(d¼Ñ�ghY5f7X�j(\6mâX�jÌo�e@[³j7g]×@[hg]Ö&X�j(ghdblpdZnj7Î5\²n�e@l@ÍGX�oØ\il j7XZ[ún�f�\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈZ`ËWÒÎ@\im(\{n�f�\6ù e@\6l5Ö6gh\imâXZf(\�¬�l5d ÊÌlçXZmkÎGXZf(opdbl@g]ÖÇn�f�\6ù e@\6l5Ö6gh\im6É@dZfop\6f(\i[]ȱÎGXZf(opdbl@g]Ö6mi` 1 lçj(Î@\�Ðb\il@\6f(XZ[LÖ&XZm�\ZÉ@j(Î@\Ïm�j7f�ghl@нÖ6XZl2Ñ g]Y@f7X�j7\�ghlçXZ[][új(Î@\6m�\Ïn�f�\6ù e@\il@Ö6g]\6mBF¯

Page 25: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

X�j�j(Î@\Òm7X�oØ\sj(ghop\Z` � jVXZl�È_n�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�ȽdZj7Î5\6f�j7Î@XZl½X�ÎGXZf(opdbl@g]ÖËn�f�\6ù e@\6l5ÖiÈbÉ j7Î5\Òghl�j7\if�n�\6f�\6l@Öi\dZnúf(\A®G\6Ö�j7\6ÍØXZl@ͽg]l@Ö6g]Í@\6l�jAÊkXUÑZ\6mËf(\6m�e@[]j(mAghl½X�f(\im(e@[³j7g]l@Ð�Í@ghm�j7e@f�YGXZl@Öi\ÌdZn�j7Î@\Ìop\6Í@g]e@o ÊÌÎ5ghÖÔÎghmâghf�f(\iÐbe@[�X�fÇX�l@Íyl@dbl�ðvf(\i×ú\6X�j7g]l@Ð@` 1 läc�ghÐ@` � ^ ð�¯ � ÊË\�gh[][he@m�j7f7X�j7\{j7Î5\¨Ñ�ghY@f(X�j7g]l@ÐpdZnAj7Î@\¨m�j(f(ghl5ÐX�jÒj(Î@\ÏÎGXZf(opdbl@g]Ö6mi`WÒÎ e@m6É}j7Î@\½m�dbe@f(Öi\ q �,��� ghmÏX2×ú\if(g]d Í@g]Ö�m(g]ÐblGXZ[�j7ÎGX�jÏÖ&XZl Yú\¼\T� ×@f(\im(m(\iÍ e@m(g]l@Фg]j(m²n�e@l@ÍGX ðop\6l�jÔXZ[ún�f(\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈ q �����A- /0 ½ ø F qnp?JA� ^B¾ k�S I ��� Q

ÆÇm�ghl@Ðìj7Î@\íÍ@\ ï l5g]j7g]dblôd�n{j7Î@\yc�dZe@f(g]\6f¼j7f(XZl@m�n�dZf(o n�dbf±×�\6f�ghd�Í@ghÖ¤Öidbl�j7ghl e@dZe@m±m�ghÐblGX�[hm½n�f(dbo/ \iÖZ` � ^ `³Bb` � � É Êk\ÏÖ&X�líÖ6XZ[hÖie@[�X�j(\²j7Î5\Óm�×ú\iÖij(f(e@oEdZn�j7Î@\Ïm�ghÐblGX�[[ �?3@� - S I � FÀ¿vTÀÁà/0 ½ ø F qFp?JA� ^%¾ k�S I ����ÄÛ��� �M!$#UT Áv% ),* �

- S I � FÀ¿vTÀÁà/0 ½ ø F^Å � �"!$#½ TÀÁ ) `º� � �M!$# ½ T Á )^ p Æ Äº��� �"!$#UT Áv% )�* �

- S I^ p /0 ½ ø F � FÀ¿vT Á �6�M!$# � ½ ��%��]T Á )+* ��` � FÀ¿vT Á ��� �"!$# � ½AÇ %�³T Á )�* �- B^ p-PÈ _ 3 G ¹ [ �?3@� ¹ -�É j J´q6� J Jú� Q � ^ `@� �

WÒÎ@g]m�¬ g]l@ͤdZnæm�×ú\iÖij(f(e@oEg]mÒÖ&XZ[][h\6ÍçX�!$#�´ ¬U�Ó®? �§Z«,�G`� m}Êk\Vop\6l�j7g]dbl@\6Í�É j(Î@\.m(dbe5f(Ö6\Vm(g]ÐblGXZ[ q �,��� ghm ï []j(\6f�\6ÍÓe@m(g]l@ÐÒj7Î@\.m�È�m�j7\6o k}����� `æWÒÎ@\if(\�n�dbf(\�Éj7Î5\_o�e@m�ghÖ6XZ[}m(ghÐZlGXZ[}ghmÇXØÖidbl�Ñbdb[]e5j7g]dblådZnæj7Î@\¨m(dbe@f�Ö6\¨m(ghÐZlGXZ[LÊÌg]j(Îíj7Î5\_ghop×@e@[]m(\Ïf(\im(×�dbl@m�\�dZnj7Î5\Óm�È�m�j7\io k��,��� �������.-Êq �����0|3k}����� GXZl@Íçghlªj(Î@\�n�f(\iù�e5\6l@Ö�ÈíÍ5dbo±X�ghlKÉ

1 �?SK�A- [ �4S�� � �?SK� QcGf(dbo j7Î@g]mÏXZlGXZ[³È�m(ghm{ÊË\pÖ6dbl@Öi[he@Í5\½j(ÎGX�j 1 �?SK� ghmÏX2m(Ö6XZ[h\iÍì×5e@[hm�\½j(f7XZg]läÊÌg]j7Îän�e@l5ÍGXZop\6l�jÔXZ[n�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�È S I ` BBË

Page 26: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

cæghÐbe5f(\Ï^ ð�° aAWÒÎ@\Ï\6[]\6op\6l�j7mÌdZnæX½Ö6\6[][hd@`1st harmonic 2nd harmonic

3rd harmonic 4th harmonic

cæghÐZe@f(\Ï^Uð�¯5aÍ̲ghY@f(X�j7g]dbl2dZnæX½m�j7f�ghl@ÐpX�jÒj(Î@\ÏÎGXZf(opdbl@g]Ö²n�f(\iù e@\6l@Öigh\im6`BF¥

Page 27: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

JLK�J ΤÏ�ÐÃÏÍÑnÒ�Ï�ÑWÓ�Ò1 l j7Î5ghm_m�\6Ö�j7ghdZl�Êk\±Í@\ ï l5\ªj7Î@\ØYGXZm(g]Öªm�j7X�j7g]m�j(ghÖ&X�[.j(d dZ[hmÏÊk\ªe5m(\±n�dbf¨dbe@f¨f(\ij(f(g]\iÑ�XZ[Vm�È�m�j(\6oç`cGdbfÌX¼oØdZf(\�×@f�dZn�dbe@l@Íç×@f�\6m(\il�jÔX�j(ghdblçm(\i\}�Ô¥5É�^Õ° ÉLBUà ÉLBFË%�4`qsrvqsr�t Öì|-�?×)�¶×�ÿ�µ�ÿC�b���.x)·ÙØ��.x)·Ú��� ���A|�ÿ��¶×Úµ�z��ãì\±Í@\ ï l@\±×5f(dbYGX�Y@gh[]g]jvÈyg]lìj(\6f(opmÓdZnÌX ¬6§Z°\!�´h�_¬r!5§�­Ô�z[sÉ�ÊÌÎ@ghÖÔÎ g]mÓXím(\�j_ÊÌÎ@dZm(\ª\i[h\6op\6l�j(mXZf�\ÇÖ6XZ[h[]\6Íy��´h��°±���G®$§Z �¢½��´h��°±���G®�¬�`�{VX�ÖÔΪ\6[]\6op\6l�jÔXZf�Ƚ\6[]\6op\6l�jVÖ&XZlØYú\ÌÑ�gh\iÊË\6ͪXZmkXÓ×údZm(m(g]Y@[h\dbe5j(Ö6dbop\{dZn�XZl2\T� ×ú\if(ghop\6l�j6` � !� Ô£ZÕÔ§�Õ6«,´"«,®+¢Ø©Z«h¬�®? �«+ÕW#�®?«4£��aÛ m�Ü �eÝ�dZlíX�m(XZop×@[h\Çm(×GXZÖi\Ã[ºg]mÒXoØXZ×@×@g]l@Ð_n�f(dZoû\�Ñb\6l�j(mÇdZn�[ j7d½f(\6XZ[�l e@o_Yú\if(mÌm(e@ÖÔΤj7Î@X�jsj7Î5\{n�db[h[]d ÊÌg]l@ÐÞ!� 7£ZÕÔ§�Õ6«,´"«,®+¢p§nßb«4£�°_¬XZf�\Óm(X�j7g]m ï \iÍKaBb`�Û m�ÜBà ÝÞá�à�n�dbfÌX�l Ȫ\iÑb\il�j à `^ `�Û m�Ü [�Ý - Bb`�5`�Û m�ÜBàãâ ß Ý - Û m�ÜBà Ý O Û m�Ü ß ÝÏn�dbfÌXZl�È2\�Ñb\6l�j(m à XZl@Í ß m(e@ÖÔÎçj7ÎGX�j àåä ß -Êæ `�  �§Z��©�£�°Ù,�§Z �«+§�Õ6´h� 1 g]m¨X¤n�e@l@Ö�j7ghdZlìn�f(dZo j7Î@\pm7XZop×@[]\pm�×GXZÖi\±j7d¤j7Î@\Øf(\6XZ[.l�e5o�Yú\if(mi`1 j±XZm(m�d Öig�X�j(\6mpXìf�\&XZ[Òl e@o�Y�\6f½ÊÌg]j(ÎÛ\6XZÖÔÎÚdbe j7Ö6dZoØ\¤dZn{XZlÛ\T� ×ú\if(ghop\6l�j6ÉkÊÌÎ@ghÖÔÎôXZ[h[]dUÊÌm¼e@mj7dyÊËdbfl¬ìÊÌg]j(Î�j7Î5\2×@f(dbY@XZY@gh[]g]jvÈ Í@g]m�j(f(ghY5e5j7g]dbl�g]l@Í@e@Öi\6ͺdbl j7Î5\ªf(\im(e@[³j7ghl5Ðäm(\ij�dZnâl�e5o�Yú\if(mi`cGdbf¼Xäf7X�l@Í@dbo Ñ�XZf�g�XZY5[h\ 1 XZl5ÍôXäf(\6XZ[sl e@o�Y�\6f � É.Êk\¤Í@\ ï l@\2j7Î5\ç\�Ñb\il j 1 - � j7d Y�\Ü q L [ºa 1 � q �A-¿� Ý�ç j7Î e@m6É Û m5� 1 -¿�ú�.- 0èCérêFëÕì í � é � øEîºï Û m�Ü q ÝðQqsrvqsrvq ñy�Ëx)·ÏÿC�Gÿ��kx)�¶µ¢ò{|-��×)�¶×�ÿ�µ�ÿr�Z�/ dbop\ij(ghop\6mÒÊË\¨ÎGX&ÑZ\�m(dbop\Ï×@f(g]dbfK¬ l@dUÊÌ[h\6Í5Ðb\�XZY�dbe5jÌj(Î@\_dbe j7Ö6dZoØ\ÏdZn�XZlå\T�5×�\6f�ghop\6l�j&`ÌcGdbf\A�5XZop×@[]\ZÉæm�e@×@×�dbm(\pj7ÎGX�j¼Xçn�f�gh\il@Í�ÎGX�mîGg]×@×ú\iÍìjvÊËdån+XZg]fÓÖidbghl5m_XZl5Í ÎGXZmÓj7db[]Í ÈZdbe�j7Î@X�j�X�j[h\6XZm�j_dbl@\ØdZnsj7Î5\ªÖ6dbg]l@m_m�Î@dUÊk\iÍ XíÎ@\6XZÍK`åãÃÎGX�j�ghmÏj7Î5\ª×@f(dZYGXZY@g][hg]jvÈåj7ÎGX�j¨Y�dZj7Î Öidbghl5m�XZf�\Î@\6XZÍ@móåWÒÎ5\¨g]l5n�dbf(oØX�j(ghdblØÐbg]ÑZ\6lç\6[hg]oØg]lGX�j(\6mËj(Î@\Ï×údZm(m(g]Y@gh[]g]jvÈØdZn�jvÊkd½jÔXZg][hmi`ô dbl@Í@g³j7g]dblGXZ[G×@f�dbYGXZY5gh[hg³jvÈ_n�dbf�o±X�[hgõ�i\6m�j(Î@\²l@d�j7ghdZlØdZnKÎGX&Ñ g]l@ÐÓ×@f(g]dbf.×GXZf�j(g�XZ[-¬ l@dUÊÌ[]\6Í@Ðb\ÇdZnj7Î5\_dbe5j(Ö6dbop\_d�n.XZly\T�5×�\6f�ghop\6l�j&`âWÒÎ@\í­Ô£���©Z«,®+«4£���§Z´�!� 7£ZÕÔ§�Õ6«,´"«,®?¢2dZnAXZly\iÑZ\6l�j 1 -¸� ÐZg]Ñb\ilj7Î@X�jâXZl@dZj(Î@\6fÌ\�Ñb\6l�j\� - ]ªÎGXZmÌd�Ö6Öie@f(f�\6ÍçghmÒÍ@\ ï l@\6Íçj7d½Y�\Û m5� 1 -¿� ¹ � - ] �A- Û m5� 1 -¿� G � - ] �Û m5� � - ] � Q � ^ `<� �WÒÎ@\¼Öidbl@Í@g³j7ghdZlGXZ[�×@f(dbY@XZY@gh[]g]jvȤdZn 1 - � Ðbg³Ñb\il«� - ]çghm²j(Î@\¼f7X�j(ghdØdZn.j7Î@\¼×@f�dbYGXZY5gh[hg³jvȤdZnY�dZj7Τ\iÑZ\6l�j7m 1 - � XZl5Í�� - ]Øj7d¼j7Î@\Ï×@f�dbYGXZY5gh[hg³jvȱd�næ\�Ñb\6l�j\� - ]ú`

BFö

Page 28: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

cGf(dbo j7Î@\�Í5\ ï l@g³j7g]dblªdZn�Ö6dZl@Í@g]j(ghdbl@XZ[ú×5f(dbYGX�Y@gh[]g]jvÈ � {Aù eK` � ^ ` � �(� É5g]jËn�db[h[]dUÊÌmËj7Î@X�jÒn�dbfËjvÊËd\iÑZ\6l�j7m 1 -¿� XZl5Í�� - ]Û m@� 1 - � G � - ] � - Û m5� � - ] � Û m5� 1 - � ¹ � - ] �- Û m5� 1 -Ã�ú� Û m@� � - ] ¹ 1 -Ã�ú� Q/ db[³Ñ�ghl@Ð�n�dbfKÛ m5� 1 -Ã� ¹ � - ] � É5Êk\ÏdbY jÔXZg]lÛ m@� 1 - � ¹ � - ] � - Û m@� 1 -¿�ú� Û m@� � - ] ¹ 1 -¿�ú�Û m@� � - ] �- Û m5� 1 -¿�ú� Û m5� � - ] ¹ 1 - �ú�÷�øî Û m5� 1 -úù�ú� Û m@� � - ] ¹ 1 -úù��� GÊÌÎ@g]ÖÔÎíg]m3¬�l5d ÊÌlåXZm)ûǧZ¢��Ô¬-ü ¬Ï®��G�Ô£� 7��°pÄ.WÒÎ@\ÏÍ@\6l@dZoØg]lGX�j7dZfsghmÌX½l@dbf�o±XZ[]gõ�ighl@ÐÓn+XZÖij(dbf6`qsrvqsrCý ñy�Ëx)·ÏÿC�Gÿ��kx)�¶µþ� x)·�z0ò_z�x)·�z�x)³}ÿ¦z��s�.x)·Ùÿ£�L�kz��5ÿ��.x��ÅzP��� �Ë|��K�WsÊËdØf(XZl@Í@dboûÑZX�f(g�X�Y@[h\imÒXZf(\½«,��©��r!G����©����G®Ëg]n_ � G ] Û m@� 1 -¿� G � - ] �A- Û m5� 1 -¿�ú� Û m5� � - ] � Q � ^ ` ° �ãì\²XZ[]m(dÏe@m�\Çj7Î5\Çl@d�jÔX�j(ghdblþÛ m@� 1 G � �.- Û m@� 1 � Û m@� � � ÊÌg³j7Îpe@×@×�\6fVÖ&XZm�\²[]\ij(j(\6fiÉ j(d¨\T� ×@f(\im(mj7Î5\Óm(XZop\�\6ù eGXZ[]g]jvȤXZmÒg]l�{.ù eK` � ^ ` ° � ` � lç\6ù e@g³Ñ�XZ[h\il jÌÍ5\ ï l@g³j7g]dbl¤ghmÛ m5� 1 ¹ � �.- Û m5� 1 � GÊÌÎ@g]ÖÔÎåj7\i[h[hmÒe5mÇj7Î@X�j²g]l@Í@\i×ú\il@Í@\6l5Ö6\_g]m²X�[hm(dØXØl5dZj7g]dblíd�n�ghl n�dbf(oØX�j7g]dblK`���l@dUÊÌghl@нj7Î@\ÓÑ�XZ[he@\dZnÍ� j(\6[][hmÌe@mÌl@dZj(Î@ghl@ÐØXZY�dbe5jÌj7Î5\ÏÑ�XZ[]e@\ÏdZn 1 ` 1 líÐb\6l@\if7XZ[?ÉGg]n 1 F G QeQfQ G 1 H XZf(\Óghl5Í@\6×�\6l@Í5\6l�jf7X�l@Í@dbo Ñ�XZf�g�XZY5[h\6miÉ j(Î@\6l Û m@� 1 F G QfQeQ G 1 H �V- H� � ø F Û m@� 1 � � GÊÌÎ@g]ÖÔÎåXZ[][hdUÊÌmÒe@mâX¼Ö6dbop×GXZÖ�jÌf(\i×@f(\im(\6l�j7X�j7g]dblådZn�j7Î5\�dZghl�jÒÍ@g]m�j7f�ghY@e j7ghdZlK`ÆÇl5n�dZf�j7e5lGX�j7\i[]ÈZÉ@oØdZm�jÒdZn�f7X�l@Í@dbo ÑZX�f(g�X�Y@[h\imkdZn�ghl�j(\6f(\im�jÇXZf�\�Í@\6×�\6l@Í5\6l�jâdbl¤\&XZÖÔÎçdZj7Î5\6f6`WÒÎ@\if(\in�dZf(\ZÉ�Êk\sÍ5\ ï l@\kXÇopdbf(\Vf(\ ï l@\iͼl@dZj7g]dbl�ðË­Ô£���©Z«,®+«4£���§Z´ «,��©��r!G����©�����­Ô��` 1 jæXZ×@×5[hgh\im�ÊÌÎ5\6ljvÊËdÓÑ�XZf�g�XZY@[]\6mAX�f(\Ìghl@Í5\6×�\6l@Í@\il�jËÐZg]Ñb\ilpj(Î@\ÒÑ�XZ[he@\kdZnKX�l@dZj7Î5\6fAÑ�XZf(ghXZY@[h\�`æcGdbf�o±X�[h[]ÈZÉ�Ñ�XZf�g�XZY5[h\6m1 XZl@Í9� XZf(\±­Ô£���©Z«,®+«4£���§Z´,´"¢½«,��©��r!G����©����G®?É Ðbg]ÑZ\6l¤ÑZX�f(g�X�Y@[h\��ÓÉ@g]nÛ m5� 1 G � ¹ � �A- Û m5� 1 ¹ � � Û m@� � ¹ � � G^Zà

Page 29: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

j7Î@X�j{g]m6É�[h\&X�f(l@g]l@Ðpj(Î@\_Ñ�XZ[]e@\6mâdZn=�ûÍ5d \im{l@dZjÇÖÔÎGXZl@ÐZ\�dbe@fÇ×@f(\iÍ@ghÖ�j7ghdZlådZn 1 dbl@Ö6\¨Êk\>¬ l@dUÊj7Î5\ÏÑ�XZ[]e@\�dZn �¨`WÒÎ@\sÖidbl@Í@g³j7ghdZlGXZ[bg]l@Í@\6×�\6l5Í@\6l@Öigh\im�Yú\�jvÊk\i\6l�Ñ�XZf�g�XZY@[]\6m}Ö&X�l�Yú\.Ñ�ghm�eGXZ[hge�6\iÍ_e@m�ghl@вXÇm(×�\6Öig�XZ[Ðbf(XZ×@ΤÖ&XZ[][h\iÍíX}ûǧZ¢��Ô¬�«+§Z�y����® á £� ���¬�®? T#G­�®À#� 7��`�2���������U�+����� » �sX&Èb\im(g�X�l_l@\�jvÊkdbfl¬Ïm�j7f�e@Öij(e@f(\�� «h¬s§Ó©Z«, 7�Ô­�®v�(©Ï§�­�¢ ­�´"«4­æ¡Z �§A!G� á �G£U¬U�V��£6©��Ô¬ 7�r!� 7�Ô¬U���G®k �§Z��©�£�° ,�§Z �«+§�Õ6´h�Ô¬ 1 F G QfQfQ G 1 H ÄÞ&}��®�ÛÞJ í�� ©�����£�®v�¨®��G�K!5§Z 7���G®,¬Ø£¦¥ 1 � «,���'DÒ§Z��©C * í�� ©�����£�®¦�å®,�G�N,�§Z �«+§�Õ6´h�Ô¬y«,��®��G�¤¡Z �§A!G� ®,�5§Z®p§Z Ô�y��£�®p©��Ô¬U­Ô����©�§Z�G®�¬ £¦¥ 1 � Äî�K�G���������­Ô£6©��ԬϮ,�G�.¥&£�´,´h£ á «,��¡¼¬U��®Ò£¦¥�­Ô£���©Z«,®?«4£���§Z´ú«,��©��r!G����©�����­Ô�Ó§�¬Ô¬A#�°\!�®?«4£��5¬��_ 1 � G Û m5� 1 � G C * í�� ¹ ÛÃJ í�� �V- Û m5� 1 � ¹ ÛÞJ í�� � Û m5� C * í�� ¹ ÛÞJ í�� � G®,�5§Z®Ë«h¬D 1 � «h¬�«,��©��r!G����©����G®Ò£¦¥{«,®�¬Ó��£��G¯�©��Ô¬U­Ô����©�§Z�G®,¬â¡Z«d,Z���y«,®,¬3!5§Z 7���G®�¬6Äqsrvqsr�� ² �A|��=��������·�z0µ��� ©Z«h¬U­� 7��®¦�²¬�®¦£U­Ô�5§�¬�®+«4­�!� 7£U­Ô�Ô¬Ô¬ÓghmÌXZl¤g]l@Í@\A� \iÍím�\6ù e@\6l5Ö6\_d�n�f(XZl@Í@dZo Ñ�XZf(ghXZY@[h\im6` 1 l¤Ðb\il@\6f(XZ[4Éj7Î5\6f(\pÖ&X�lìY�\±X�l�XZf�Y@g]j(f7XZf�ÈyÍ@\i×ú\il@Í@\il@Ö6\±XZoØdZl@Ð2j7Î@\pf7XZl5Í@dbo Ñ�XZf�g�XZY@[]\6mi`pWÒÎ5\Ø×@f�d Öi\6m�m¨g]mÖÔÎGXZf(XZÖij(\6f�gõ�6\iÍíY�È2j(Î@\��dbghl�jÌ×@f�dbYGXZY@g][hg³jvÈpn�e5l@Öij(ghdbl@m�Û m@� 1 F G 1 ! G QfQfQ G 1 H � n�dbf Jí- B G ^ G QeQfQK`�2���������U�+����� » ©Z«h¬U­� 7��®v�̬�®¦£U­Ô�5§�¬�®+«4­?!� 7£U­Ô�Ô¬Ô¬²«h¬Ç¬6§Z«+©�®v£pÕ��Ïm�jÔX�j(ghdbl@XZf�Èå« ¥²®,�G�! &£�«,�G®A©Z«h¬�®? �«,¯ÕW#�®?«4£�� £¦¥_§Z�G¢Ø¬A#@Õ�¬U��®â£¦¥¨®,�G�Ó¬U�7cW#�����­Ô�½£¦¥Ó �§Z��©�£�° ,�§Z �«+§�Õ6´h�Ô¬Ó«h¬_«,�-,�§Z �«+§Z�G® á «,®,�å 7�Ô¬r!G�Ô­�®s®v£¬Ô��« ¥�®,¬Ó«,�y®��G�Ó®+«,°±�Ó«,��©��lß D.«+Ä+�6ÄfD_#" G Û m5� 1 F G QeQfQ G 1 H �A- Û m@� 1 F Ç%$ G QeQfQ G 1 H Ç%$ �

� m�ghop×@[h\¼\T�5XZoØ×5[h\½dZnÒX¤m�j(d ÖÔÎ@XZm�j(ghÖp×@f(d�Ö6\im(m¨ÊÌg³j7Î Í@\6×�\6l5Í@\6l@Öi\ªghmÏdbl5\pg]l ÊÌÎ5ghÖÔÎ�\6XZÖÔÎf7X�l@Í@dbo Ñ�XZf(ghXZY@[h\âÍ@\i×ú\il@Í@mÒdblªj(Î@\{dbl@\²×@f(\iÖ6\6Í5ghl@мg³jsXZl5Í2ghmÓ­Ô£���©Z«,®+«4£���§Z´,´"¢½ghl@Í5\6×�\6l@Í@\il�jÒdZnXZ[][æj7Î@\½dZj(Î@\6fÏ×@f�\6Öi\6Í@g]l@Ðíf(XZl@Í@dZo Ñ�XZf(ghXZY@[h\im6` / e5ÖÔÎ X¤×@f(d�Ö6\im(mÓghm�m7X�ghÍäj7dçYú\pX¼µ. 7¬�®�£� �©��� &ä§Z '��£%,\!� 7£U­Ô�Ô¬Ô¬�`�2���������U�+����( » ©Z«h¬U­� 7��®¦�A¬�®v£U­Ô�5§�¬�®+«4­P!� 7£U­Ô�Ô¬Ô¬ 1 F G 1 ! G QfQeQ «h¬A¬6§Z«+©Ç®v£{Õ��˧ ï f(m�j}dZf(Í@\if*)åXZf7¬�dUÑ×@f�d Öi\6m(m_« ¥A¥&£�  Jå- B G ^ G QfQfQ�DÛ m5� 1 H Ç F ¹ 1 H G 1 H �GF G QfQfQ G 1 F �.- Û m5� 1 H Ç F ¹ 1 H � Q1 l¤j7Î@g]mÒÖ&XZm�\ZÉGj7Î@\��dbg]l�jÒ×@f(dZYGXZY@g][]jvȱn�e5l@Öij(ghdbl¤Ö&X�líY�\{n+XZÖij(dbf(ge�6\iÍåXZmÛ m5� 1 F G QfQfQ G 1 H �.- Û m@� 1 F �

H� � ø ! Û m@� 1 � ¹ 1 �h�GF � Q^ B

Page 30: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

�2���������U�+����+ » µ. Ô¬�®Ì£� �©��� �&ä§Z ���£%,^!� 7£U­Ô�Ô¬Ô¬Ó«h¬Ï¬6§Z«+©ª®¦£2Õ���j(ghop\Óg]l�ÑZX�f(g�X�l j_« ¥_®,�G�½­Ô£���©Z«,¯®+«4£���§Z´2!� 7£ZÕÔ§�Õ6«,´"«,®?¢ÃÛ m5� 1 H Ç F ¹ 1 H � ©�£U�Ô¬Ï��£�®k©��r!G����©2£�� J DV«+Ä+�6ÄfDG¥&£�  Jí- B G ^ G QeQfQÛ m5� 1 H Ç F ¹ 1 H �A- Û m@� 1 ! ¹ 1 F � Qãì\ÏÊÌg][h[�XZm(m�e@oØ\�j(ÎGX�jÇX,)åXZf7¬�dUѤ×@f(d�Ö6\im(mâghmsj7g]oØ\�ðvg]l Ñ�XZf�g�XZl�jËe@l@[]\6m(mÌdZj(Î@\6f�ÊÌghm�\¨m�jÔX�j(\6ÍK`

^b^

Page 31: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

- . /10 24365 78 5:9<; =>3@? AB3C2D2FEHG I1 l½dbe@fAm�\ij(j(ghl@Ð5ÉbÊk\âXZf�\ÒÐbg]ÑZ\6lpX�oØ\i[hd�Í5È�X�l@ͽdbe@f�jÔX�m7¬_g]m�j7dÏf(\�j7f�gh\iÑZ\Òo�e@m�ghÖ&X�[@×ú\if�n�dbf�o±X�l@Ö6\imÖ6dZl j7XZghl5ghl@Ð�j(Î@\¨f�\6ù e@\im�j7\iÍyop\6[hd�Í5ȱXZl@ͤj7d ï l@Íçg]j(mâ[]d Ö6X�j7g]dbl±ÊÌg³j7Î@g]l¤j(Î@\Ïf(\�j7f(g]\iÑZ\6Íå×�\6f�n�dbf�ðoØXZl@Ö6\im6` 1 l�j(Î@ghmÓÖÔÎGXZ×5j(\6f_ÊË\±\T� ×@[�XZg]l�dbe5f¨m�\ij(j(ghl@Ðçn�dbf(oØXZ[][]Èb` 1 l / \iÖZ` � �5`³B � Êk\±n�dZf(oØXZ[h[³ÈÍ@\ ï l@\¼op\6[hd�Í5ÈZ`{ã�\¼Öidbl�j7ghl e@\¨ÊÌg]j7Î X±n�dZf(oØXZ[�Í5\ ï l@g³j7g]dblydZnVXª×�\6f�n�dbf(oØXZl@Öi\�ghl / \6ÖZ` � �5` ^ � `ãì\±XZ[]m(dç\A� ×@[hXZghläÊÌÎ�È j7Î@\½jÔXZml¬ädZnÒoØX�j7ÖÔÎ5ghl@ФY�\ijvÊË\6\6lºX¤op\6[hd�Í5ÈyXZl@Í X¤×�\6f�n�dZf(oØXZl@Ö6\½g]mÍ@gKJØÖie@[]j6`L¼KNM O P QNÒÍÑWÓ�ÐSR�P TUR�VXWZY� op\6[hd�Í5È�ghm¼Xäm(\iù e@\6l@Öi\ådZnÇl@dZj(\6m¼ÊÌÎ@\if(\ç\&XZÖÔÎ l@dZj(\çg]m½Xä×GXZghf_dZn{Xä×@g³j7ÖÔÎ Ñ�XZ[he5\¤XZl@Í XÍ@e@f(X�j7g]dbl2Ñ�XZ[he@\�`ýÒr�tVr�t Ö�ÿC�E³ �1 l�j(Î@ghmÏÊkdZf7¬�ÉæÊË\2XZm(m�d Öig�X�j(\Ø×5g]j7ÖÔÎ ÊÌg]j(Î�n�e@l@ÍGX�oØ\il j7XZ[An�f(\iù�e5\6l@Ö�ÈbÉ.XZ[³j7Î@dbe5ÐbÎìj(Î@\ØjvÊËdäXZf�\l@dZjÌù e@g³j7\�j7Î5\Óm(XZop\ � m(\i\Ón�dZfÒ\A�5XZop×@[h\ð� BF��É$Ë%� � `WÒÎ@\6f�\2\A� ghm�j7m¼XíÍ@ghm�Ö6f(\�j7\ªm�\ij¼d�nâXZ[h[.×�dbm(m�ghY@[]\pn�f�\6ù e@\6l5Ö6gh\im¼dZnÌl@dZj(\6mi` 1 lºcæghÐ5` � ��ðÔB � ÊË\m(Î5d Ê dbl@\2d�Öij7XUÑZ\2dZnâj7Î@\z¬�\iÈ�YúdbXZf(Í m(×GX�l@l@ghl5Ðyj7Î@\2l@d�j7\6m¼n�f�dbo ô j7däj(Î@\ ô g]l j7Î@\2l5\A��jd�ÖijÔX&ÑZ\Z`AWÒÎ@\Ìn�f(\iù�e5\6l@Ö�ÈØf�\6[hX�j7g]dbl¼Yú\�jvÊk\i\6lªl5dZj7\im.ÊÌg³j7ÎØXZlpghl�j7\if�Ñ�XZ[@dZn�dbl@\Ìd�ÖijÔX&ÑZ\Çg]m � BÏa�^ � `WÒÎ@\if(\yX�f(\¤jvÊk\i[]Ñb\íghl�j7\if�Ñ�XZ[]m½ÊÌg³j7Î@g]lºdbl@\çd Ö�jÔX&Ñb\�` WÒÎ@\åYGX�m(ghÖçghl�j(\6f�Ñ�XZ[Òg]m½Ö&XZ[][h\6ÍÛX m(\6opg³ðj7dZl@\Z` 1 lÃj7Î5\yÊk\i[h[³ð4j7\ioØ×�\6f�\6Í ã�\im�j(\6f(l¿o�e@m�ghÖyj(e@l@ghl5Ð m�È�m�j(\6oçɲj7Î@\än�f�\6ù e@\6l5ÖiÈÃf(\i[�X�j(ghdblY�\ijvÊË\6\6lÃÖidbl@m(\iÖ6e5j(g]ÑZ\ym(\ioØgÌj7dbl5\6m±g]mØÖidbl@m�jÔXZl�j&`¿WÒÎ@\if(\in�dZf(\ZÉÒj(Î@ghmpf(\i[�X�j(ghdblºghm � B a\[^]_ ^ � `cGe@f�j(Î@\6f�oØdZf(\ZÉúj7Î@g]m�f(\6[hX�j7g]dblåÍ5d \imÓl5dZj�Í@\i×ú\il@ÍìdZl j(Î@\¼o�e@m�ghÖ6XZ[æm�Ö&XZ[]\Z` � cGdbf{dZj(Î@\6f{j(e@l@ghl5Ðm�È�m�j7\6opmªm�\6\ã�"BF�5É?Ë%� � ` WÒÎ e@miÉÌg]n²ÊË\a¬ l@dUÊEj7Î5\ín�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�Èôd�nÏXìf�\in�\6f�\6l@Öi\yl@dZj(\ZÉkÊË\yÖ6XZlÖ&X�[hÖ6e5[�X�j(\�j7Î@\pn�f(\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈ dZnkdZj7Î5\6fÓl@dZj7\im¨e5m(ghl5Ðíj7Î5\Øg]l j(\6f�ÑZX�[AYú\�jvÊk\i\6l j7Î5ghmÏl@dZj(\±XZl5Íìj7Î5\f(\�n�\6f�\6l@Öi\2l@dZj7\ � g4`ë\Z`yj(Î@\ªl e@o�Y�\6f¼d�nÌm(\6opgËj(dbl@\im�Yú\�jvÊk\i\6lºj7Î@\2l5dZj7\im � ` cGdbf�o±X�[h[]ÈZÉ�[]\ijS`

^"�

Page 32: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

C D E F G A B C

C# F#D# G# A#

# ## # #

cæg]Ðbe@f(\)��ðÔBba � jvÊË\6[³Ñb\�ð$j7d�ð$j7Î5\�ðvd�Öij7X&Ñb\Óm(Ö&X�[h\Z`Í@\il@dZj7\íj7Î@\ym�\ij¤dZnÓX�[h[Ì×údZm(m(g]Y@[h\çn�f(\iù�e5\6l@Öigh\6m¤dZnÏl5dZj7\im6` 1 lÚj7Î5\åÊk\i[h[ ð$j7\ioØ×�\6f�\6Íôãì\6m�j7\if(lo�e@m�ghÖ{j(e@l@ghl5Ðpm�È�m�j7\ioíÉa` -�Ü�SNbdc T � ^ é ¿�F+! ¹ q LDe Ý É@ÊÌÎ@\6f�\ SNbdc T - �Õ�bàÕ�gf5`ÆÇm�ghl@мj7Î5\�Í@\ ï l5g]j7g]dbl2dZn>`ôÊË\ÓÖ6XZlçÍ@\ ï l5\¨X�×5g]j7ÖÔΤdZnæX¼l@dZj(\{n�dbf(oØXZ[h[³Èb` . \ijih Ç Í5\6l@dZj(\j7Î5\ ×�dbm�g]j7g³Ñb\äf�\&XZ[�l e@o�Y�\6f�m6` . \ij S $ G S ½ Lkj Ç Yú\än�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�ÈÃÑZX�[he@\im � ghl¿è�� � XZl@Í¿[h\ij� S $ G S ½ ��Yú\{X¤©Z«+§A!5§�¬U£��G` � ©Z«+§A!5§�¬U£��çdZn�X�m(g]l@Ðb\6f � dbfkXZl2ghl@m�j7f�e@oØ\il�j � g]mkj7Î@\²f7XZl@ÐZ\{dZn�×@g]j(ÖÔÎn�f(\iù e@\6l@Öigh\imËj7Î@X�jËXZf(\Ìghlpe@m�\ÇY�Ƚj7Î@\Ìm�ghl@Ðb\if � dbf.Y�ȼj7Î@\âghl@m�j7f�e@oØ\il�j � `�c�dZfAghl@m�jÔXZl@Öi\ZÉ XÏj(\6l@dZfm(g]l@Ðb\if�jvÈ�×@g]Ö&XZ[][]È�\ioØ×@[]dUÈ m�X¨©Z«+§A!5§�¬U£��pd�n��"BbBUàÕ�gf G °"�bàÕ�Zf �4` . \ij!l - � S $nmpo G S ½ �rq ½ � ä `ìÍ5\6l@dZj(\XZ[][�j7Î5\¼×údbm�m(g]Y@[h\�×5g]j7ÖÔÎ5\6m�dZnVl@dZj(\6mÏghlíj7Î@\í©Z«+§A!5§�¬U£��G` � ×@g]j(ÖÔÎädZnËX2l@dZj7\¼g]m�XZlä\i[h\6op\6l�jÏg]lj7Î5\Óm�\ijslA`ýÒr�tVrvq tÊ�{|-���@ÿ��Ëx/ g]oØg][�XZf�[]Ȳj(d{j7Î@\k×@g]j(ÖÔÎpù eGX�l j(gõ�6X�j7g]dblKÉ�j(Î@\6f�\ÒghmAX�[hm(d{X{Í@ghm�Ö6f(\�j7\sm�\ij.dZnúXZ[][ ×�dbm�m(ghY5[h\kÍ5e@f7X�j(ghdbl5mdZnâl@dZj(\6mi` èÇdUÊË\iÑZ\6f6ÉVn�dbf_m�ghop×@[hg]Ö6g³jvÈbÉæg]l j7Î@g]m_ÊËdbf7¬ Êk\çXZ[][hdUÊ XyÍ@e@f(X�j7g]dbl�j7däY�\¤XZl�È f�\&XZ[×�dbm(g³j7g]ÑZ\�l e@o�Y�\6f6`.WÒÎGX�jÇg]m6ÉGX¼Í@e5f7X�j(ghdbl¤dZnæX¼l@dZj7\Ïg]mÌX½l e@o_Yú\ifâg]luh Ç `WÒÎ@\¨XZYúdUÑZ\Ó[]\&XZÍ5mâe5mÌj(d¼j7Î@\�n�dbf�o±XZ[úÍ@\ ï l@g]j(ghdbl¤dZnæX¼oØ\i[hd�Í5Èb`�2���������U�+�����wv �yx¸��Þ��´§L�æ� » °±��´h£6©Z¢¤«h¬Ø©��Ô¬U­� �«+Õ��(©Ï¥&£� �°p§Z´,´"¢çÕ6¢å§¤¬U�7cW#G����­Ô�±£¦¥\!�«,®v­Ô�G�Ô¬Dz L l % Dç§Z��©ô§ ¬U�7cW#�����­Ô� £¦¥ ©"#  �§Z®+«4£��5¬D,{ L<j Ç % Dª«,�¸§ !� 7�(©���µ.���(© ®+«,°±� # �G«,®9���6Ä"¡�ĬU�Ô­Ô£���©�¬r¡ZÄL¼K�J O |4TU}H~�V,}�P ÐS�NÓ�T©{e@fÌÐbd�XZ[úghmÒj7d½f�\ij7f�gh\�Ñb\ÏoØ\i[hd�Í@gh\imkn�f(dZo XZe@Í5ghd½m(g]ÐblGXZ[]msf(\i×@f(\im(\6l�j(ghl@ÐØf(\&X�[K×ú\if�n�dbf�o±X�l@Ö6\im6`

^ �

Page 33: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ªâXZ[h[]\6l�jÔX�l@Í@d Bb` ^ªBb` ^¤Bb` ^Õ°±Bb`<�¤Bb`@�� Ö6Ö6\i[h\if7XZl@Í5d à5`@˼à5`<¯ °¼à5`@¯½à5`@°½à5` °W�XZY@[h\��5`³Bba9{��@X�oØ×@[]\6m½dZn²m(Ö&X�[hghl5Ð n+X�Öij7dZfpm�\6ù e@\il@Ö6\im6a 1 lÛj(Î@\ ï f(m�jØm�\6ù e@\il@Ö6\åj(Î@\çm(Ö&X�[hghl5Ðn+XZÖ�j7dbf�m�XZf�\±Ðbf(XZÍ@eGXZ[][]È g]l@Ö6f�\&XZm�ghl@ÐåXZl@Í�j(Î�e5m�j7Î@\pj7\6op×�dyghmÓÍ@\6Öif(\6XZm(g]l@Ð ��� ªâXZ[][h\6l�j7XZl@Í@d ��� `1 l2j7Î@\Ïm�\6Ö6dZl@Íí\T�5XZoØ×5[h\{j7Î5\�m(Ö&X�[hghl5Ð�n+XZÖij(dbf(mÌXZf�\�Í@\6Öif(\6XZm(g]l@ÐpXZl@ͤj7Î@\{j(\6op×úd¼g]mÒghl@Öif(\&X�m(ghl5Ð��� � Ö6Öi\6[]\6f7X�l@Í@d � � `�2���������U�+������� ��õ{� �%U4����ó�ö@��Üb�@� » !G�� ,¥&£� �°p§Z��­Ô�¼£¦¥�§ª°±��´h£6©Z¢Ø«h¬¼§¤©Z«h¬U­� 7��®v�_®+«,°±�Ϭ6§Z°¼¯!�´h�(©ª§"#5©Z«4£¼¬�«³¡Z��§Z´@D>� - j F G QfQeQ G j � Ä� ×ú\if�n�dbf�o±XZl5Ö6\¼ghm{n�dZf(oØXZ[h[³È¤\6l�j7g]f(\6[³ÈyÍ@\ ï l@\iÍ�Ðbg³Ñb\6l j7Î5\¼oØ\i[hd�Í5È�a{×@[�X&Èådbf�m(g]l@Фe@m(g]l@Ð×@g³j7ÖÔÎu� F n�dbf{j7Î@\ ï f�m�j * F m(\6Öidbl@Í@miÉ�j(Î@\6l ×@[�X&Èådbf�m(g]l@Ф×@g]j(ÖÔÎX� ! n�dbf{j(Î@\¼l@\T� j * ! m(\6Öidbl@Í@miÉXZl@ͤm�d¼dbl¤XZl@ͤm(d¼n�dbf�j7ÎK` 1 lçf�\&XZ[]g]jvÈZÉ@X�op\6[hd�Í5ÈpÍ@d�\6mÒl@d�jÒghop×údZm(\{X�f�ghÐbg]ͱn�f7X�oØ\�Êkdbfl¬�`AWÒÎ@\XZÖ�j7eGXZ[An�f�\6ù e@\6l5ÖiÈìÖ6dbl�j7\il�j�dZnsXçÐbg³Ñb\il�l@dZj(\pÑ�XZf�gh\imÓÊÌg³j7Î j7Î@\½jvÈ�×ú\ØdZnsg]l@m�j(f(e@op\6l�jÓj7ÎGX�jÓg]m×@[hXUÈZ\6ͽXZl5ͼY Ȩj7Î@\k×ú\if�n�dbf�oØ\if6`�{Í�5XZop×@[]\6mæn�dbf�m(e@ÖÔμÑ�XZf�g�X�j(ghdbl@m�XZf�\Ëj7Î5\kÑ�ghY@f(X�j7d�X�l@Í�j7g]o�Y@f(\\º­ú\6Ö�j7mi`¨WÒÎ@\½X�Ö6Ö6dZoØ×GX�l@ghop\6l�j�X�[hm(d±Ðbf(\6X�j7[³Èíg]lE®Ge@\il@Ö6\im�j7Î@\�m�×ú\iÖij(f7XZ[�Í5ghm�j(f(g]Y@e5j7g]dblK`²ãÃÎ5gh[h\×@[hXUÈ�g]l@Ð�X_l5dZj7\{e5m(ghl5Ð�×@g]j(ÖÔÎS�LÉ�Êk\�X�f(\{[]gõ¬Z\i[]ȼj(d�m(\i\�X_[hd�Ö&X�[�Öidbl@Öi\6l�j7f(X�j7g]dbl2dZn}\6l5\6f(Ð�ȱÖi[hdbm�\j7dØo�e@[³j7gh×5[h\6mÌdZnæj7Î@\Ón�f(\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈ��äghlçj7Î@\¨×údUÊË\6f{m�×ú\iÖij(f(e@o dZn�j(Î@\_m�ghÐblGX�[4`âèÇdUÊË\iÑb\if6É�j(Î@\6f�\oØXUȨY�\sdZj7Î5\6fAm(×�\6Ö�j7f(XZ[5f�\6Ðbg]dbl@mæÊÌg³j7μÎ@g]ÐbÎ�[h\�Ñb\i[hmAdZn�\il@\6f�ÐZÈb`æãì\sÊÌgh[][5X�Í@Í@f(\im(m�j(Î@ghm�×5f(dbY@[]\6o[�X�j7\6fAdZlpg]l¼j7Î@g]mAm(\6Ö�j7g]dblK` � l@dZj7Î5\6f.m(dbe5f(Ö6\âdZn�Ñ�XZf(ghX�j7g]dbl�ghmA[]d Ö6XZ[5m�Ö&XZ[]ghl@Ð�d�núj(Î@\ÌÍ@e@f7X�j7ghdZl@mAdZnl@dZj(\6mâXZmÌghl5m�j7f�e@Öij(\6ÍçY�È2j7Î@\Ïop\6[hd�Í5ÈZ`�WÒÎ@\Ó×ú\if�n�dbf�oØ\ifsjvÈ ×5ghÖ&X�[h[]ÈØe@m�\6mÇX¼j(\6op×úd¼j(ÎGX�jÌm(Ö6XZ[h\imj7Î5\�Í@e@f7X�j7ghdZl2XZl@ͤopd ÑZ\6msn�f�dboûdZl@\{j7\ioØ×�d_j7d½X�l@dZj7Î5\6f6É j7Î e@mÒe@m�ghl@нX�Í@gf­�\if(\il jÒj(ghop\²m�Ö&XZ[]\j7d¨×@[�X&Ƚj7Î5\Çl@d�j7\6mi`.WÒÎ@\6f�\in�dbf�\ZÉ ÊË\�XZ[]m(dÓl@\6\iͪj7d¨oØd�Í@\6[Gj(Î@\ÇÑ�XZf�g�X�j(ghdbl½ghlpj7Î@\âj7\ioØ×�dÓÊÌÎ5ghÖÔÎÊË\¨Í@\im(Öif(ghY�\Ïl@dUÊÏ`� j7\6op×�dÓm�\6ù e@\il@Ö6\ÇghmVX�m(\6ù e@\il@Ö6\ÇdZnKm�Ö&XZ[]ghl@Ð{n+X�Öij7dZf(m6Éw� Lgj Ç % `æWÒÎ5\²XZÖ�j7eGX�[GÍ@e@f7X�j7ghdZldZn5l@dZj7\ p É�Í@\il@dZj7\iÍ ù* � ghm * � m�Ö&XZ[]\6ͨY È � � É ù* � - * � � � ` / \i\6opghl@ÐZ[]ÈbÉ�XZ[][hdUÊÌghl5ÐÒÍ@ge­ú\6f�\6l�j�m(Ö&X�[hghl5Ðn+XZÖ�j7dbf�mKn�dbfKj7Î@\AÍ5ge­ú\6f(\il�j}l@dZj7\im�XZÍ@Í@m�XÒÍ@\6ÐZf(\6\.dZn n�f�\6\6Í5dbo�j7Î@X�j}o±X ¬Z\6mKj(Î@\.oØ\i[hd�Í5ÈÇÍ@e@f7X�j7ghdZlÑ�XZ[he5\6mÏf(\iÍ@e@l@ÍGX�l j6`±èâdUÊk\�Ñb\6fiÉAX2jvÈ ×5ghÖ&X�[�j7\6op×�dçm�\6ù e@\il@Ö6\ØÍ@d \im¨l5dZjÏÖÔÎGXZl@ÐZ\Øf(XZ×@ghÍ5[]ÈäX�l@Íj7Î e@mVf(\A®G\6Ö�j7mVoØdZm�j.dZn�j7Î@\Ìg]l5n�dbf(oØX�j(ghdbl�d�núj(Î@\Ìdbf(g]ÐbghlGX�[ Í@e5f7X�j(ghdbl@m � e@×½j7d¨XÏm�Ö&XZ[]ghl@Ð{n+X�Öij7dZf � `W�XZY@[h\>�5`]B½m�Î@dUÊÌmÏjvÊËdç\A�5XZop×@[h\im{dZnVj7\6op×�d2m(\6ù e@\il@Ö6\im6` � ×@g³j7ÖÔÎ���Í5e@f7X�j(ghdblw� j7\ioØ×�dØj(f(gh×5[h\ij� z G { G � � Ðb\il@\6f(X�j7\im²X�líX�Öij7e@XZ[L×@g]j(ÖÔÎ���Í@e5f7X�j(ghdbl¤×GXZg]f � z G ù { � `1 l2dbf(Í5\6fkj(d�Í@\6m�Ö6f�ghY�\{j7Î@\{ÐZ\6l@\if7X�j(ghdblªd�nLj7Î@\�X�Öij7e@XZ[�×�\6f�n�dbf(oØXZl@Öi\{XZe@Í5ghd_m�ghÐbl@XZ[��¤n�f(dbo� z G ù { � ÊË\�ghl�j7f�d Í@e5Ö6\²dZl@\²opdbf(\âÑ�XZf(ghXZY@[h\�É�� LZj Ç % ÊÌÎ5\6f(\ q � ghmVj7Î@\{m�jÔXZf�j7g]l@Шj(ghop\ � m7XZop×@[h\l e@o�Y�\6f � d�nKl@dZj(\ p g]l¼j7Î@\Ì×�\6f�n�dZf(oØXZl@Ö6\�`æãì\âÍ5\ ï l@\ q � - B O ÷ �h�GF� ø F ù* � n�dZf pæ- B G QnQnQ G 3=O Bb`�Çd�j7\6mÇÐb\6l5\6f7X�j7\ÓÖ6dbl@m�\6Öie5j7g³Ñb\�Y@[]d Ö¬ mâdZn�m�ghÐbl@XZ[}m7XZop×@[h\im6` . \�j j � - � j é�� G QeQfQ G j é�� ü [ �GF � Y�\¨j7Î5\Y@[]d Ö¬ØdZn�m(XZoØ×5[h\6mÒÐZ\6l@\if7X�j(\6ÍçY Ȥl5dZj7\ p `WÒÎ@\åoØXZÐbl5g]j7e5Í@\¤m(×�\6Öij(f(e@o dZn j � Ñ�XZf(g]\6mpm(ghÐZl@g ï Ö6XZl�j7[³È n�f(dbo ×ú\if�n�dbf�o±XZl5Ö6\¤j7d�×�\6f�n�dbf�ðoØXZl@Ö6\�É}XZÖ6Öidbf(Í5ghl@Ъj(dªÑZX�f(ghdZe@m²n+XZÖ�j7dbf�m�m(e@ÖÔÎìXZm{j7Î5\¼m(×�\6Öij(f7XZ[æ\6l�Ñb\i[hdb×�\½dZn.j7Î@\½m(dZ[hdbg]m�j�X�l@Í

^Õ°

Page 34: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

×@g³j7ÖÔÎ@\im±dZnÏX�Ö6Ö6dZoØ×GX�l@ghop\6l�jpghl@m�j7f�e@oØ\il�j7m6` / g]l@Ö6\ídbe@fpÐbd�XZ[Ìg]m½j(d�[]d Ö6X�j7\íXZl@ÍÛf(\ij(f(g]\iÑb\åXop\6[hd�Í5Ȥn�f(dZo XªÍGX�j7XZm(\�j�j7ÎGX�j�o±X&ÈåÖ6dbl�jÔX�ghlyj7Î5dbe@m7X�l@Í@mÏdZnV×ú\if�n�dbf�o±X�l@Ö6\im6É�ÊË\½f(\6m�dbf�j�j(d¤XÑb\if�È m(g]oØ×5[h\�m�×ú\iÖij7f(XZ[.oØd�Í@\i[AXZl@ÍìÍ@díl5dZjÓ\A� ×@[hg]Ö6g³j7[]Èíopd Í@\i[æj7Î5\6m(\pÑ�XZf(ghXZY@[h\im6`�ãì\Øe5m(\ØXZlXZ×@×5f(dn� ghoØX�j7g]dbl±j7d½j7Î5\Ó[]gõ¬�\6[hg]Î@d�d ÍØdZn�X¼Y@[]d Ö¬±m(×�\6Öij(f(e@oEÐZg]Ñb\il¤g]j7mÒ×5g]j7ÖÔÎ�`

^"¯

Page 35: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

- . /10 24365 �

� 5:9�? ? 3@=>9���� 249 �4E>I�G /�=��/ I�3@G 365F/�2FE���3 ? 9�� 3@=

W�d¼×údbm�\{j7Î@\²×@f(dbY5[h\6o ghlªX�×@f(dbY@XZY@gh[]ghm�j7ghÖÒn�f(XZoØ\�ÊkdZf7¬�É5ÊË\�l@\6\iͤj(d¼Í@\6m�Ö6f�ghY�\{j7Î@\{[]gõ¬�\6[hg]Î@d�d ÍdZnVX±×�\6f�n�dbf(oØXZl@Öi\_Ðbg³Ñb\ilyj7Î@\�op\6[]d Í ÈbÉ Û � � ¹ z G { � `{ãì\_Ö6XZm�j{j(Î@\_j(\6op×údªm�\6ù e@\il@Ö6\�� XZm²XÎ@g]Í@Í@\6lçf7X�l@Í@dbo ÑZX�f(g�X�Y@[h\�É j7Î e@mÌj7Î5\Ó[]gõ¬�\6[hg]Î@d�d ÍØÖ&XZlçYú\�ÊÌf�g]j(j(\6lçXZmiÉÛ � � ¹ z G { �A- 0�  Û � � G � ¹ z G { � Q � �@`]B �cGdbfâm(ghop×@[]ghÖ6g³jvÈbÉ@ÊË\¼XZm�m(e@op\_j7Î@X�j²j(Î@\¨j(\6op×údØm(\6ù e@\il@Ö6\½Í@d�\6m²l@dZj{Í5\6×�\6l@Íädblíj7Î@\¨oØ\i[hd�Í5Èb`ãÃÎ@g][h\Øj(Î@ghm_XZm(m�e@op×5j7g]dblKÉ�lGX�j7e@f(XZ[h[³ÈbÉ�Í@d�\6m_l@dZj¼X�[]ÊkXUÈ�m¼Î@dZ[hÍKÉæÊË\ªn�dbe@l5Í \6op×@ghf�ghÖ&X�[h[]Èíj7ÎGX�jj7Î5\6m(\�jvÈ�×�\6mâdZnæÖidbf(f�\6[hX�j7g]dbl@msÖ6XZl¤Yú\�g]Ðbl@dbf�\6ͤghl2m�Î@dbf�jâ×@g]\6Öi\6mÌdZn�×ú\if�n�dbf�o±X�l@Ö6\im6`AãÃg]j(Ϊj7Î@g]mXZm�m(e@op×5j7g]dblçXZl@ͤj7Î@\Ïg]Í@\6l�j7g³jvÈ ù { - {�� É-{Aù eK` � �@`³B � Ö6XZlíY�\�f(\�ÊÌf(g³j(j7\ilåX�m6ÉÛ � � ¹ z G { �A- 0   Û � � ¹ z G { � Û � � ¹ z G { G � �

- 0   Û � � � Û � � ¹ z G { G � �- 0�  Û � � � Û � � ¹ z G ù { � Q

ãì\²gh[][he@m�j7f(X�j7\sj(Î@\Çg]l@Í@\i×ú\il@Í@\6l5Ö6gh\imsY�\ijvÊË\6\6lªj(Î@\ÌÑZX�f(g�X�Y@[h\imVg]lªcæg]Ð@` � ��ðÔB � `æãì\Çl@dUÊÃl@\i\6ͱj(dm(×�\6Öig]n,Èyj(Î@\¼×@f�ghdbf{Í5ghm�j(f(g]Y@e5j7g]dblädUÑb\ifÏj(Î@\�j7\ioØ×�d@É�Û � � � É�XZl@Íäj(Î@\½×údbm�j7\if(ghdZf{Í@ghm�j7f�ghY@e5j(ghdbldZn�j7Î@\Ïm�ghÐblGX�[KÐbg]ÑZ\6l¤j7Î@\Ï×@g³j7ÖÔÎ@\imâXZl@ͤj7Î@\ÓXZÖ�j7eGXZ[�Í@e@f7X�j7ghdZl@mÌdZn�j(Î@\Ïl@dZj(\6m�Û � � ¹ z G ù { � `^ÕË

Page 36: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

Tempo

Actual Duration

Performance

PitchDuration

cæg]Ðbe@f(\þ��ð7Bba¼WÒÎ@\ªg]l@Í@\6×�\6l5Í@\6l@Öigh\im�Yú\�jvÊk\i\6l j7Î5\±Ñ�XZf(ghXZY@[h\im6`çWÒÎ@\ªdbY5m(\6f�Ñb\iͺÑ�XZf�g�XZY5[h\6m¨XZf�\×@g]l�¬±Öidb[hdbf�\6ÍçXZl@ͤj7Î5\ÓÎ5ghÍ@Í@\ilçÑ�XZf�g�XZY5[h\6msXZf(\�Èb\i[h[]d Ê�Ö6dZ[hdbf�\6ÍK`¡§KNM ¢£TUP |#V P VXWgT¤RnÑ¥�g¦ãì\{ÖÔÎ@dbm�\Ïj(d�opd Í@\i[új(Î@\²j7\ioØ×�d�m�\6ù e@\6l5Ö6\¨XZmÒX ï f�m�jÒdbf�Í@\6fi)åXZf7¬�dUÑ2×@f(d�Ö6\im(mi` � msÊk\�m�\6\�g]lj7Î5\{m(\iù�e5\6[Kj7Î5ghmkÖÔÎ5dbghÖi\{dblªdbl5\{ÎGXZl@ͤX�[h[hdUÊÌmkXZlª\§JpÖigh\6l�jÌX�[hghÐZl@oØ\il�jsXZl5Í2f(\ij(f(g]\iÑ�XZ[4É�XZl5Í2dblj7Î5\²dZj(Î@\6fËÎGXZl@ÍKÉ�ÊsX�mËn�dbe@l5ͪ\6op×@ghf�ghÖ6XZ[h[³È_j7d¨Yú\Çf(g]ÖÔα\6l5dbe@ÐbÎK`AWÒÎ5\6f(\�n�dbf(\�É5j7Î5\²[hge¬Z\i[hghÎ5d d�ͼdZn� ghmÒÐZg]Ñb\ilíY�ÈZÉ Û � � �A- Û �+� F � %� � ø ! Û �I� � ¹ � �]�GF � Qãì\²e@m�\²j7Î@\Ç[hdbÐ�ðvl@dbf�o±X�[@Í@ghm�j7f�ghY@e5j(ghdbl½j7d¨oØd�Í@\i[�j(Î@\²Öidbl@Í@g³j7ghdZlGXZ[G×@f�dbYGXZY@g][hg³jvÈ�Û �I� � ¹ � �h�GF � Éj7Î@X�j�g]m�[]dbÐ �+� � �©¨«ª � [hdbÐ �+� �h�GF � G�¬ � É�ÊÌÎ@\6f�\ ¬ ghmæXÇm(Ö6XZ[hg]l@в×@XZf7XZop\ij(\6f�dZn@j(Î@\kÑ�XZf(ghXZl@Öi\Z`�WÒÎ@\×@f�ghdbfÇÍ@ghm�j7f(g]Y@e5j(ghdblyd�nAj7Î@\ ï f�m�jÏm�Ö&XZ[]ghl@бn+X�Öij7dZfÚÛ �I� F � g]m�XZ[hm�d2XZm�m(e@op\6Íäj7d2Y�\¼[hdZÐ�ðvl@dZf(oØXZ[XZf�dbe@l@Í¢�6\6f�d¨ÊÌg³j7ÎØÑ�XZf�g�XZl5Ö6\ ¬ É []dbÐ �I� � �H¨«ª � à G�¬ � ` 1 l±dbe5fË\T�5×�\6f�ghop\6l�j7miÉ�j(Î@\â×GXZf7X�oØ\�j7\6f ¬ÊkXZm{Í@\�j7\6f�oØg]l@\6Íåo±XZl eGX�[h[]ÈçX�Ö6Ö6dZf(Í@g]l@ÐØj(dªo�e@m�ghÖ&X�[�¬ l@dUÊÌ[h\iÍ@Ðb\�`{WÒÎ@ghm²×GXZf7X�oØ\�j7\6fâÖ&X�l XZ[hm�dY�\â[]\&XZf�l@\6ͽn�f(dZo­) 1 ü 1 ï []\6mi`H�ÇdZj(\Òj7ÎGX�j.n�dbf�j(Î@\â[hdbÐ�ð$l@dbf�o±XZ[�Í@g]m�j7f�ghY@e j7ghdZlKÉZj7Î5\Ç×@f�dbYGXZY5gh[hg³jvÈj7d2ÖÔÎ@XZl@Ðb\_j(Î@\�j7\ioØ×�d±n�f�dboEÑZX�[he@\ � j(d±Ñ�XZ[he@\¯® � ghmÇ\6ù eGXZ[�j7d±j(Î@\¼×@f(dZYGXZY@g][hg]jvÈ2j(dªÖÔÎGXZl5Ðb\

^"¥

Page 37: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

j7Î5\Ïj(\6op×úd¼n�f�dboûÑ�XZ[]e@\ � j(d½Ñ�XZ[]e@\ î ° ÉÛ �+� � - ® � ¹ � �h�GF -Ã�ú�î- B_ ^%¾ ¬ � � []²± �´³¶µd·A� ° î �,� $nm q� î �f� ]- B_ ^%¾ ¬ � � []²± �´³¶µd·A� ° �e� ]- B_ ^%¾ ¬ � � []²± �³�!³¶µd·T� ° �f� ]- B_ ^%¾ ¬ � � []²± �´³¶µd·A��¸¹ ¸ �f� ]- B_ ^%¾ ¬ � � []²± �´³¶µd·A� ¸ ¹ ��� $nm q� î �f� ]- Û �I� � - � ® ¹ � �h�GF -¿�ú� Q¡§K»º ÎX|4TÚÓKÏ }�мR¾½¹ÑnÒ�ÏH}¶Ñ¥¿DQ�ÏÍÑ�V,� À VXWgTUR1 läj7Î@g]m{m(\iÖij(ghdblyÊË\½Í@\6m�Ö6f(g]Yú\¼dZe@f{m(×�\6Ö�j7f(XZ[�Í@g]m�j7f�ghY@e j7ghdZlyoØd�Í@\i[4`�WÒÎ@\if(\½\A� ghm�jÏù e@g]j(\¼X±n�\iÊopd Í@\i[hm}n�dbf}j7Î@\Ëm(×�\6Öij(f7XZ[ Í@ghm�j7f�ghY@e5j(ghdblÏdZn�m�ghl@ÐZghl@ÐÌÑbdbg]Ö6\im�XZl@Í_ÎGXZf(opdbl@g]ÖËg]l@m�j(f(e@op\6l�j(m6`�èâdUÊsð\iÑZ\6fiÉæopdbm�jÓdZnËj7Î@\im(\±opd�Í@\6[]mÏXZf(\pf7X�j(Î@\6fÓÐb\il@\6f(XZ[4`pWÒÎ@\6m�\ªopd Í@\i[hm{jvÈ�×@g]Ö&XZ[][]ÈäX�m(m(e5oØ\½j7ÎGX�jj7Î5\_o�e@m�ghÖ6XZ[�m�ghÐbl@XZ[}ghm²Öidbl�jÔXZopghl@X�j7\iÍíÊÌg]j(ÎåÊÌÎ@g³j7\_l5dbghm�\¨ÊÌÎ@dbm�\�\6l5\6f(Ð�Èåg]m²m�j7X�j7g]m�j(ghÖ&X�[h[]ȱghl ðÍ@\i×ú\il@Í@\6l�jâdZnLj(Î@\�m(g]ÐblGXZ[?` / \i\{n�dbfkg]l@m�j7XZl@Ö6\'��^"ö%�LXZl@ͪj(Î@\{f�\in�\6f�\6l@Öi\6mÒj7Î5\6f(\ighlK` 1 l2Öidbl�j7f(XZm�j6ÉÊË\½XZm(m�e@oØ\¨j7ÎGX�j²j7Î@\if(\�g]m{Xª[h\6XZÍ@g]l@бg]l@m�j(f(e@op\6l�j&É�dbf²m�db[hdbg]m�j6É�j(ÎGX�j�g]m{XZÖiÖ6dbop×GXZl@g]\6ÍyY�ÈyXZldbf�ÖÔÎ@\6m�j7f7XÏdbfAX{ÖÔÎ5dbf(e@mi`AWÒÎ@\Ò\6l5\6f(Ð�ȼdZn�j7Î@\ÌX�Ö6Ö6dZoØ×GX�l@ghop\6l�j�g]m�jvÈ�×@ghÖ6XZ[h[³È¨Î5ghÐbÎ@[³ÈÓÖ6dbf�f(\6[hX�j7\iÍÊÌg]j(αj7Î5\{\6l@\if(ÐZÈØdZnLj(Î@\{m(dZ[hdbg]m�j&`�é.e jÌXZl@dZj(Î@\6fVÊsX&ÈZÉ5j7Î@\²Í5È�lGXZopghÖ6mËdZnLj7Î5\�XZÖ6Öidbop×GXZl@g]oØ\il joØX�j7ÖÔÎ@\imâj(Î@\_Í È l@XZoØg]Ö6mÌdZn�j(Î@\Óm(db[]dbghm�j&`scGdbfÌg]l@m�j7XZl@Ö6\�É�ÊÌÎ5\6låj(Î@\¨m�db[hdZghm�jâm�ghl@Ðbmâ×@ghXZl@ghm�m(g]oØdj7Î5\âÖÔÎ5dbf([email protected]�db[][hdUÊÌm�Î@\if.ÊÌg³j7Îp×@g�X�l@ghm�m(ghopd²ÑZdbghÖi\6m6`�ã�\Òj7Î5\6f(\�n�dbf(\âÍ@\�Ñb\6[]db×�\6ÍØXÏm�ghop×@[h\Òopd�Í@\6[ÊÌÎ@dbm�\_×GX�f7XZop\ij(\6f(mâÖ&X�låY�\¨\ÁJØÖigh\il j([]Ȥ\im�j7g]o±X�j7\6Íçj7ÎGX�jÇÖidb×�\6mÇÊÌg³j7Τj7Î@\¨Ö6dbf�f(\i[�X�j(ghdbl¤ghlç\6l�ð\6f�ÐZÈçYú\�jvÊk\i\6läj7Î5\_[h\6XZÍ@g]l@бm�db[hdbg]m�jÇXZl@Ííj7Î@\_XZÖ6ÖidboØ×@XZl@ghop\6l�j6` 1 l c�ghÐ@` � ��ð�^ � ÊË\�m(Î@dUʸj7Î5\m(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@o d�nÒdbl@\pn�f7XZop\Ød�nÌXå×�\6f�n�dZf(oØXZl@Ö6\pm(g]ÐblGXZ[An�f�dbo dbe@f¨ÍGX�jÔX�YGXZm(\�`íWÒÎ5\ªÎGXZf�oØdbl5ghÖ6mdZnsj(Î@\±m�db[hdZghm�j¨XZf�\±Í@\im(g]ÐblGX�j(\6Í Y�ÈìÍGXZm(Î5\6Í []ghl@\im6` 1 j�g]m¨Öi[h\&X�fÓn�f�dbo j7Î@\ ï Ðbe@f�\Øj7Î@X�j¨j(Î@\6f�\ghmâX½[�XZf�Ðb\ÏÖ6dbl5Ö6\6l�j(f7X�j(ghdblçdZn�\il@\6f�ÐZÈíX�jÌj7Î@\ÓÍ@\im(ghÐZlGX�j7\iÍåÎGX�f(opdbl@ghÖim6`VWÒÎ@\Óf(\6m�ghÍ@e@XZ[}\6l@\if(ÐZÈZÉdbe5j(m(g]Í@\âj(Î@\²Î@XZf(opdbl@g]Ö6m6É�g]mËÖi\6f�jÔXZg]l@[]ȼl5dbl ðvl5\6Ðb[]ghÐbg]Y@[h\sY5e5jkg]mËÖi[h\6XZf([³È¼[hdUÊË\6f.j7ÎGXZlpj7Î@\Ç\6l@\if(ÐZÈdZnAj(Î@\�ÎGXZf�oØdZl@ghÖim6`âWÒÎ�e5m6ÉLdbe@f²XZm(m�e@op×5j7g]dbl@m6É�XZ[]j(Î@dbe@ÐZÎåm(g]oØ×5[hghm�j7g]ÖZÉ�m(\i\6o j7dªÖ6XZ×5j7e5f(\_j(d2X[�X�f(Ðb\{\T��j7\6l�jÇj7Î@\ÏÖÔÎGXZf(XZÖij(\6f�ghm�j(ghÖimÒdZn�j(Î@\Ïm(×�\6Ö�j7f(e5oEdZn�m�ghl@Ðbg]l@Ð�ÊÌg]j(ÎçXZÖ6ÖidboØ×@XZl@ghop\6l�j6`ÆÇm�ghl@Фj7Î@\pÍ@\ ï l@g]j(ghdbl dZnsXçY5[hd�Ö¬ j � n�f(dZo ÖÔÎGXZ×5j(\6f � � � ÉLj7Î@\p[hge¬Z\i[hghÎ5d d�ÍydZnËj7Î@\pm(g]ÐblGXZ[Ðbg³Ñb\6lìj7Î@\Øm(\6ù e@\il@Ö6\im¼dZnÌ×@g³j7ÖÔÎ@\im�XZl@Í�Í@e@f7X�j7ghdZl@m¨Ö6XZl Y�\ØÍ5\6Ö6dZoØ×�dbm(\iÍ ghl�j7díXå×@f�d Í5e@Öij¨dZn

^"ö

Page 38: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

[hge¬Z\i[hghÎ5d d�ÍØÑ�XZ[]e@\6mÌdZn�j7Î@\Ïg]l@Í@g]Ñ�g]Í@eGXZ[úY@[hd�Ö¬ m6ÉÛ � � ¹ ù { G z �A- %� � ø F Û � j � ¹ � � � Q

WÒÎ@\if(\in�dZf(\ZÉ�j7Î@\âÖ6dZf(\²d�nKdbe@fVopd Í@\i[hg]l@ÐÏXZ×@×@f�d�XZÖÔΪg]mVX¨×@f�dbYGXZY@g][hg]m�j7g]Ösopd Í@\i[@n�dbf.j7Î@\âm(×�\6Ö�j7f7X�[Í@g]m�j7f�ghY@e j7ghdZlØdZnLXÓÊÌÎ@db[]\ÇY5[hd�Ö¬¼Ðbg]ÑZ\6l±j(Î@\²e@l5Í@\6f�[]È�ghl@Ш×@g]j(ÖÔÎØn�f�\6ù e@\6l5ÖiȪd�nKj7Î@\Çm(db[]dbghm�j&`Í©�e5fm�j7XZf�j(ghl@н×�dbghl�jÌg]mâm�ghopgh[hXZfËj(dpj(Î@\ÏoØd�Í@\6[L×5f(\6m�\6l�j7\iÍyghlZ�ë^"ö �?`Vãì\¨XZm(m�e@oØ\�j(ÎGX�jÇXpl5dZj7\�ÊÌg]j(Î×@g³j7ÖÔÎu� � X�j(j7XZghl5m�Î@ghÐbÎä\il@\6f�ÐZÈ X�j�n�f�\6ù e@\6l5Ö6gh\imÓÊÌÎ5ghÖÔÎìXZf(\½o�e@[³j7g]×@[h\im²dZn*� � É}lGX�oØ\i[]ÈäX�ji� � kn�dbfVghl�j7\iÐb\6f k `AWÒÎ@\6m�\²n�f(\iù�e5\6l@Öigh\6mÌX�f(\âdZn,j7\ilªf(\�n�\6f(f�\6ͪj(d�XZmËÎGXZf(opdbl@g]Ö6mi`æã�\Ç\A� ×@[hXZghl@\iͱj7Î5\[hdZÐbghÖÒY�\6Î@g]l@ÍØj(Î@ghmVXZm�m(e@op×5j(ghdblØghl / \6Ö�` � ^ `]BZ`@¥ � ` / g]l@Ö6\âdbe@fVm(g]ÐblGXZ[Gg]mVY@XZl@ͪ[]ghopg]j7\iÍKÉ�ÊË\²dZl@[]Èl@\i\6Ííj(d½Ö6dbl@m�ghÍ@\ifâX ï l5g]j7\Ïm�\ijâdZn�ÎGXZf(opdbl@g]Ö6mÒÎKÉ k L Ü B G ^ G QfQfQ G � Ý `AcGdbfÒ×@f7X�Öij7g]Ö&XZ[L×5e@f(×�dbm(\imÊË\Øm�\ij�� j(díY�\Ø^ZàªÊÌÎ@ghÖÔÎì\6lGX�Y@[h\im¨Xªn+XZm�jÓ×GXZf7X�oØ\�j7\6fÏ\im�j7g]o±X�j7ghdZlä×@f(d�Ö6\iÍ@e@f(\�` . \�jS �ÄÃk�Í@\il@dZj7\Ëj7Î@\ËdbY@m(\if�ÑZ\6ͽ\6l@\if(ÐZȨdZn@j(Î@\sY@[]d Ö¬ j � X�jæn�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�È Ã ` . \ij¶[ �²Ãk� Í@\il@dZj(\kj7Î@\Ë\6l@\if(ÐZÈdZnúj7Î@\Ìm(dZ[hdbg]m�j.X�j.n�f�\6ù e@\6l5ÖiÈ Ã `æWÒÎ@\âÎGXZf�oØdZl@ghÖÒopd Í5\6[GXZm�m(e@op\6m.j7Î@X�j�[ � � � g]mËX�m�Ö&XZ[]\6ͱ×5e@[hm�\j7f(XZghl � m(\6\ / \iÖZ` � ^�`]Bb`<¥ ��� É@g?`�\�`]É$[ � � � ghmÒY@e5f(m�j(mÇd�næ\il@\6f�ÐZȤÖ6\il j(\6f�\6ÍäX�jÒj(Î@\ÏÎGXZf�oØdbl5ghÖ6mÒd�næj7Î5\×@g³j7ÖÔΤn�f(\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈZÉÅ� � k É�XZl@ͤÊË\Óopd�Í@\6[Kg³jâXZmâX�Êk\ighÐbÎ�j7\iÍím�e@oEdZn�Í@\6[³jÔX�n�e@l@Ö�j7g]dbl@m6É[ �ÄÃk�A- Æ0 ½ ø F à�� k�� g � � � k¢`4Ãk� G � �@`M^ �

ÊÌÎ@\if(\ à�� k�� ghmAj7Î5\âÑZdb[he@op\ÌÐ�XZg]l½n�dZf.j(Î@\ÌÎGXZf�oØdbl5ghÖsÊÌÎ@dbm�\²g]l@Í@\A�pg]m k `æWÒÎ@\Çf�\6m�ghÍ@eGX�[�d�n�j7Î5\m(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@o X�jÌn�f(\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈ Ã ghmÒÍ@\il@dZj7\iÍäC �²Ãk� XZl@ÍçghmÌ\6ù eGXZ[Lj(d±C �ÄÃk�V-  �²Ãk��` [ �ÄÃk� `.ãì\l@dUÊ Í5\6m(Öif(g]Yú\ÓX½×@f(dbY@XZY@gh[]ghm�j7ghÖâopd Í@\i[�j7Î@X�jâ[h\&X�Í@msj7d¼j7Î5\Ïn�dZ[h[hdUÊÌg]l@Ð�[hdZÐ�ðv[]gõ¬Z\i[hg]Î@d d�Ípm(Ö6dZf(\ZÉ[hdZÐ?Û � j � ¹ � � ��Ç []dbÐ£È [ È !È C È ! GÊÌÎ@\if(\ È � È Í@\6l5dZj7\imâj(Î@\¤É ! ðvl@dbf�oí`W�dçÍ@\if(g]ÑZ\¼j7Î@\pXZY�dUÑb\½\6ù eGX�j(ghdbläÊË\pXZm(m�e@oØ\¼j(ÎGX�jÏj7Î@\¼m�×ú\iÖij(f(e@o dZnVj7Î5\ p j7Î Y@[hd�Ö¬�É�ÂpÉghm¨Ö6dbop×@f�ghm(\iÍ dZnÒjvÊËd Ö6dbop×údZl@\6l�j7mi`yWÒÎ@\ ï f�m�j¼Öidbop×údbl5\6l�j¼ghmÓj7Î@\±\6l@\if(ÐZÈìdZnÒj7Î5\ªm(db[]dbghm�j&É[ �ÄÃk� XZmVÍ@\ ï l@\6Í2g]l}{Aù eK` � �@` ^ � `�WÒÎ@\²m�\6Ö6dZl@Í2Ö6dbop×�dbl@\6l�jËghmËXÓÐZ\6l@\if7XZ[�o±X�m7¬ ghl@ÐÓl@dbg]m(\Ìj7ÎGX�j\6l5Ö6dbop×GXZm�m(\6mªj(Î@\äm(g]ÐblGXZ[?ê�mp\6l5\6f(Ð�ÈÚÍ@e@\íj7d j7Î5\äXZÖ6Öidbop×GXZl@g]oØ\il j±XZl@ÍÃX%­�\iÖij7mªj(Î@\y\il j(ghf�\m(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@oí`çã�\ØÍ@\6l5dZj7\±j(Î@\±l5dbghm�\±\6l5\6f(Ð�È X�jÓn�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�È Ã X�mSÊ �ÄÃk� `¤WÒÎ@\±\6l@\if(ÐZÈìdZnÒj7Î5\m(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@o X�jÒn�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�È Ã g]msj7Î@\if(\in�dZf(\ÏoØd�Í@\i[h\6ͤX�m6É

 �ÄÃk��- Æ0 ½ ø F à¼� k��L� Ê �²Ãk�PO g � � � kþ`#Ãk��� Q � �@`@� �ãì\¼l@dUÊ g]oØ×�dbm�\�XZl@d�j7Î@\if{m(g]oØ×@[]g]n,È�ghl5бXZm�m(e@op×5j(ghdbläY�Èym�\ij�j7ghl5бj7Î@\¼l5dbghm�\¼Êíj(dªYú\½Xªo_e@[³ð�bà

Page 39: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 60000

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

ω (Hz)

F(ω

)

cæg]Ðbe@f(\Þ��ð¦^ asWÒÎ@\¨m(×�\6Öij(f(e@o dZnVXpm(ghl5Ðb[h\Ïn�f7XZop\¨XZ[hdbl5ÐpÊÌg³j7ÎyX�lyghop×@e@[]m(\�j7f(XZghlíÍ@\6m�ghÐblGX�j7ghl5Ðj7Î5\ÓÎ@XZf(opdbl@g]Ö6mÒdZn�j7Î@\Ïm�db[hdbg]m�j6`j7g³Ñ�XZf(ghX�j7\Çl@dbf(oØXZ[Kf(XZl@Í@dZoûÑ�XZf(ghXZY@[]\{XZl@ͤn�e@f�j7Î@\ifÌXZm(m�e@oØg]l@мj7ÎGX�jÒj7Î@\Ïl@dbg]m(\{Ñ�XZ[]e@\6mÌX�jÌ\6XZÖÔÎn�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�È Ã XZf�\sm�j7X�j7g]m�j7g]Ö&XZ[][]È�g]l@Í@\i×ú\il@Í@\6l�jAÊÌg³j7μ\6ù eGX�[ Ñ�XZf(ghXZl@Öi\Z`æWÒÎ e@miÉ�j7Î@\sl5dbghm�\sÍ@\6l5m(g]jvÈn�e@l@Ö�j7g]dbl¤ghm S�� Ê ¹ Ë �A- B� ^%¾ Ë �ÍÌ ¿$! ���©Î^ÏÐÎ ]]²ÑÊÌÎ@\if(\ Ë ghm½j7Î5\åÑ�XZf(ghXZl@Ö6\íXZl@Í5» g]mØj(Î@\ål e@o�Y�\6f±dZn�m(×�\6Ö�j7f(XZ[²×�dbghl�j(mØÖidboØ×5e5j7\iÍ Y È j7Î5\Í@g]m(Ö6f�\ij(\¤c�dZe@f(g]\6f_j(f7XZl@m�n�dbf(oç` � ãì\2ÖÔÎ@dbm(\�» - ^ F�Ò j(d Ðb\ij½XäÐbd�d�Í m(×�\6Öij(f7XZ[kf(\6m�db[he j7ghdZlK` �W�X"¬ ghl@мj7Î5\Ó[]dbмdZn�j7Î@\ÓXZY�dUÑb\ÓÍ@\6l5m(g]jvȱn�e@l@Öij(ghdbl2ÊË\¨ÐZ\ij&É

[]dbÐ S�� Ê ¹ Ë ��-�` » ^ [hdbÐ � ^%¾ Ë ��` È Ê È !^ Ë Q � �@`<� �WÒÎ@\�ÐbXZghlçÑZX�[he@\im à�� k�� XZf�\¨n�f�\6\�×GX�f7XZop\ij(\6f(mÌÊÌÎ@g]ÖÔÎyÊk\�l5\6\6Íyj(d±\im�j7g]o±X�j7\Ïn�f(dboEj7Î5\_m(×�\6Ö�ðj7f�e@oç` � m�m(e@opghl5Ð j(ÎGX�j�j(Î@\¤l@dbg]m(\2[h\�Ñb\i[sghm¼f�\6[�X�j7g]ÑZ\6[³È�m�o±XZ[][ËÖidbop×GXZf(\iÍ j7däj7Î@\2Y5e@f(m�j7m½dZn\6l5\6f(Ð�ȽX�j.j7Î@\ÒÎ@XZf(opdbl@g]Ö6mAdZn�j7Î@\Ì×@g³j7ÖÔμn�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�ÈbÉ�Êk\Ìm(\�j.j7Î@\ÒÑ�XZ[he5\ÒdZn à�� k�� j7dÏY�\� � � � k�� `ãì\½XZ[hm�d2Í@d¤l@dZj^¬ l@dUÊ j(Î@\½l@dbghm�\�Ñ�XZf(ghXZl@Ö6\ Ë `�c�dZf²j7Î@g]m²n�f(\i\½×GXZf7X�oØ\�j7\6fÇÊk\½e@m�\½j(Î@\½m(g]o½ð×@[]\±oØX%� gho�e@o []gõ¬Z\i[hg]Î@d d�Í � ) .�� \im�j(ghoØX�j7\pÊÌÎ@ghÖÔÎ Ö6XZl Yú\±\&XZm�gh[]È n�dbe5l@ͺXZm_n�db[][hdUÊÌm6`åWÒÎ@\oØX%� gho�e@o [hgõ¬�\6[]ghÎ@d�d Í_\6m�j(ghoØX�j7\ÌdZn Ë ghmAn�dbe@l5ͱY�ȽjÔX"¬ ghl5ÐÓj(Î@\ÇÍ5\6f(g³Ñ�X�j7g³Ñb\âdZnK[]dbÐ S�� Ê ¹ Ë � ÊÌg]j(Îf(\im(×�\6Ö�jÇj(d Ë É Ó [hdbÐ S�� Ê ¹ Ë �Ó Ë

-:` » ^ ^%¾^%¾ Ë O È Ê È !^ Ë !- à È Ë�Ô - È Ê È !» Q�5B

Page 40: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ªÌ\&XZf�f7XZl@ÐZghl@Ð�{Aù eK` � �@`<� � É5j7Î@\Ïl@dZghm(\{Ñ�XZ[]e@\ÏX�jÌn�f(\iù e@\6l@Ö�È Ã É%Ê �ÄÃk� É5Ö&XZlçYú\{ÊÌf�g]j�j7\6líXZmiÉÊ �²Ãk�A-  �ÄÃk��` ÷ ƽ ø F à¼�Àk�� g � � � kþ`#Ãk�÷ ƽ ø F à¼�Àk�� Q�ËÈåe@m(g]l@ФXZY�d ÑZ\¼\6ù eGX�j(ghdblyn�dZf�Ê �ÄÃk� X�[hdbl@ÐØÊÌg]j7ÎyÑ�XZ[]e@\6m²m(\ij�n�dZf à¼�Àk�� XZl@Íäj7Î@\_o±X%� g]o�e@o[hge¬Z\i[hghÎ5d d�ͱ\im�j7g]o±X�j7\ Ë Ô g]l�{.ù eK` � �@` � � Êk\ÓÐb\�j&É

[]dbÐ S�� Ê ¹ Ë |�� - ` » ^ � [hdZÐ � ^%¾ �´O [hdZÐ � È Ê È !Ô��` []dbÐ � » ��` B �- ÉÍO:» ^ []dbÐÖÕXÈ [ È !È C È !w× Q/ g]l@Ö6\Ïj7Î@\¨m�j(d ÖÔÎGX�m�j7g]Ö_g]l@Ðbf(\iÍ@gh\il�jÇd�nAdbe@fâm(×�\6Ö�j7f7X�[�opd Í5\6[}ghmÒj7Î5\�XZÖiÖ6dbop×GXZl�È�ghl@ÐØl@dbg]m(\ZÉ�j7Î5\l@dbg]m(\�[]gõ¬Z\i[hg]Î@d d�Í2XZY�dUÑb\ÓXZ[]m(d½Ö6dbl5m�j7g³j7e5j(\�j7Î@\Ï[hge¬Z\i[hghÎ5d d�ͱdZn�j7Î5\Óm�×ú\iÖij(f(e@oçÉ[]dbÐ=Û � j � ¹ � � �©Ç [hdbÐ Õ È [ È !È C È !w× Q � �@` ° �

Ø öGÞ+Ü ��Þ�ö5� �+��� � ò �ZÙ�� ��Ý�ö@Ý��?Þ+�,���ã��÷&�+�}��� ò � 8 ñ ~ ñãì\�l@dUÊ \A� ×@[hXZghl2Î5d Ê¿j7d½Ö6XZ[hÖie@[�X�j(\Çj(Î@\Ï×@f(dbY@XZY@gh[]g]jvȽg]lu{.ù eK` � �@`@° � `AWÒÎ@\Ïm�j7f7X�ghÐbÎ�j�ð4n�dbf�ÊkXZf�Íghop×@[]\6op\6l�jÔX�j(ghdblôghmíXZmçn�dZ[h[hdUÊÌmia ÐZg]Ñb\il Xºm(g]ÐblGXZ[�×�dbf�j(ghdbl j � X�l@Í Xº×@g]j(ÖÔÎ�Ñ�XZ[]e@\u� � É{ÊË\Ö&X�[hÖ6e5[�X�j(\¤j(Î@\åm�×ú\iÖij(f(e@o dZn j � e5m(ghl5Ð�j7Î@\åü�cæW�`VèÇdUÊË\iÑb\if6ÉÌY�\6Ö&X�e@m(\åÊË\äXZl@XZ[]È�m(\çdbl@[³È Xï l@g³j7\½×�dbf�j(ghdblädZnËj7Î@\½m�ghÐblGX�[4ÉKÊË\Øg]l n+X�ÖijÓÖ&XZ[]Ö6e@[hX�j7\¨j7Î@\pm(×�\6Ö�j7f(e5o dZnsX¤o�e@[³j7g]×@[hg]Ö&X�j(ghdblçdZnj7Î5\sm(g]ÐblGXZ[�ÊÌg]j(μX²f�\6Öij7XZl@Ðbe5[�XZf�ÊÌghl@Í@dUÊÏ`�WÒÎ@X�j�g]m6ÉZÊË\sÐb\�jæj7Î5\sÖ6dbl�ÑZdb[he5j(ghdbl_dZnGj7Î@\km(×�\6Öij(f(e@odZnúj7Î@\âm(g]ÐblGXZ[5ÊÌg³j7νj7Î@\âm(×�\6Ö�j7f�e@o dZnLXÏf(\iÖijÔX�l@Ðbe@[hXZfAÊÌghl@Í@dUÊ � m(\i\ / \iÖZ` � ^�`]Bb`@Ë ��� `�WÒÎ@\if(\�n�dbf(\�ÉÊË\yl@\6\iÍÚj7dìÖ6dbl@m�ghÍ@\if±j7Î5\íÊÌghÍ j7ÎÚdZn²j7Î@\ío±XZg]lô[]dbYú\çXZl5Íôj7Î@\å[h\&X ¬�X�Ðb\íd�n{j7Î@\åm(×�\6Öij(f(e@odZn�j(Î@\íÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊ n�e@l@Öij(ghdbl�` 1 l dbf�Í@\6fpj7d Í@\iÖ6f�\&XZm�\yj7Î@\y[]\&X"¬�XZÐZ\í\A­�\iÖij&ÉÒÊË\äÖ&XZlôo�e@[]j(gh×@[³Èj7Î5\äm(ghÐZlGXZ[ÇÊÌg³j7ÎÃm(opd�dZj7Î@\if±ÊÌghl5Í@dUÊ n�e@l5Öij7g]dbl@m � ghl dbe@f±\A� ×ú\if(g]oØ\il j(m2Êk\äe@m�\6ÍÅ�5§Z�G�G«,��¡ÊÌghl5Í@dUÊ���^%�5É�BF¯%� � ` 1 l±dbf�Í@\6f.j7dÓdUÑb\6f�Ö6dbop\Ìj7Î@\â×@f(dZY@[h\ioÁdZn�j(Î@\Ìo±X�ghl½[hdbY�\ZÉbÊË\²l5\6\6Ípj7dÓm(e@odUÑb\ifsj7Î@\{oØXZg]l±[hdZYú\âÊÌghÍ5j(ΤXZf(dbe5l@Í2\&XZÖÔΪn�f�\6ù e@\il@ÖiÈ2d�n�Î@XZf(opdbl�ÈbÉ ghl±j(Î@\{Ö&X�[hÖ6e5[�X�j(ghdbl@mVdZn�[XZl@ͪCì`AWÒÎ@\{×5f(db×�\6f�j7gh\imkdZn�j7Î@\Çm(×�\6Öij(f(e@o dZnLj(Î@\ÇÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊÃÍ@\6×�\6l5Í2dbl±j7Î5\ÇÊÌghl5Í@dUÊÃ[h\6l5ÐZj7ÎKÉm(d¼ÊË\Ïl@\6\iÍçj(dpÖ6XZ[hÖie@[�X�j7\²j(Î@\6m�\Ó×5f(db×�\6f�j7gh\imÌXZÖ6Öidbf(Í5ghl@Ð�j(d½j(Î@\�[h\il@ÐZj(Îçd�n�j(Î@\Ïf(\i[h\iÑ�XZl�jÌl@d�j7\Z`� l@d�j7Î@\ifìdb× j7ghdZl g]m ï f(m�jìj(dÃÖ&XZ[]Ö6e@[hX�j7\ j(Î@\ / WÌcæW n�dbf ï �5\iÍ ÊÌghl5Í@dUÊ [h\il@ÐZj(Î@m � m(\i\/ \iÖZ` � ^�`]Bb`@Ë ��� `ÁWÒÎ@\ilKɲÊË\ Ö&XZlÃm(e5o j7Î@\ m�×ú\iÖij7f�e@o dUÑb\if2j7Î@\ f(\i[h\�ÑZX�l j2ÊÌg]l@Í@dUÊÌm¤ghl j7Î5\/ WÌcæW¿n�dbfÒdbY5j7XZghl5ghl@Ð�j(Î@\Ïm(×�\6Öij(f(e@oEÖidbl�j7\il j(mân�dZfÌX½m�ghÐbl@XZ[K×�dbf�j(ghdblK`

��^

Page 41: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

- . /10 24365 ÚÛ =HE>I�G ? 3@G�2 /�G � Ü 3Ý2#5ÞE>3Ý�ß/k=. \ij½e@m½dUÑb\if�Ñ�gh\�ÊEdbe@f½X�×@×@f(dbXZÖÔÎ n�dZf¼f(\ij(f(g]\iÑ�XZ[4` ã�\¤X�f(\¤Ðbg]ÑZ\6l XäoØ\i[hd�Í5È � z G { � XZl@Í ÊË\ÊkXZl�jÒj7d ï l@ÍçXZl¤XZe5Í@ghd¼m�ghÐblGX�[à�íÊÌÎ@g]ÖÔÎçf�\6×@f�\6m�\6l�j7mÇX�×ú\if�n�dbf�o±X�l@Ö6\{d�n�j(Î@ghmkoØ\i[hd�Í5Èb`AÆâm(g]l@Ðdbe@fÇ×@f(dZYGXZY@g][hghm�j7g]ÖÏn�f(XZop\iÊËdbf7¬�É�ÊË\�Ö&X�m�j{j(Î@\�×@f�dbY@[h\io X�m²j7Î@\_×@f(dbY5[h\6o dZn ï l@Í@ghl5Ð2Xªm(g]ÐblGXZ[×�dbf�j(ghdblá�íÊÌÎ@dZm(\Ï[hge¬Z\6[]ghÎ@d�d�ͱÐbg³Ñb\6l2j(Î@\�oØ\i[hd�Í5ÈbÉEÛ � � ¹ z G { � É@g]mÒÎ@ghÐZÎK`¶©{e@fÒm(\6XZf(ÖÔÎçm�j(f7X�j(\6ÐZÈghm.X�mVn�db[][hdUÊÌm6`}ãì\ ï l5Ípj(Î@\ÇY�\6m�jËXZ[hg]Ðbl@op\6l�jAdZn�j7Î@\âm(g]ÐblGXZ[ j7dÏj7Î@\Ìop\6[hd�Í5È�XZmAÊk\âÍ@\6m�Ö6f�ghY�\Çg]lj7Î5\Ïn�dZ[h[hdUÊÌg]l@Ð_m�\6Öij(ghdbl�`VWÒÎ5\ÓÍ5\iÑ�ghm�\6Íçm(Ö6dZf(\ÏdZn�j7Î@\ÓXZ[]ghÐbl@op\6l�jk×@f(d�Ö6\iÍ@e@f(\Ïg]mÒdbe@fÒop\&XZl@msn�dZff(\�j7f�gh\iÑ�XZ[?`�ã�\¼j(Î@\6lìf7XZl�¬íj7Î@\pm(\iÐboØ\il�j7mÓdZnkm�ghÐbl@XZ[hm�g]lìX�Ö6Ö6dZf(ÍGXZl5Ö6\½ÊÌg]j7Î j7Î5\6ghf�[]gõ¬�\6[hg]Î@d�d Ím(Öidbf(\im²X�l@Ííf�\ij(e@f(l¤j7Î@\Ïm�\6Ðbop\6l�j7mâXZÖÔÎ5gh\iÑ�g]l@нÎ@ghÐbΤ[]gõ¬Z\i[hg]Î@d d�ͪm�Ö6dbf�\6m6`âLKNM OãRnÑ�¦,�DP TU�¤Ï� []ghÐbl5oØ\il j_dZnÇXäoØ\i[hd�Í5Èìj(d Xym(g]ÐblGXZ[sg]m�×�\6f�n�dZf(op\6Í Y�È ï l@Í5ghl@Ðyj(Î@\2Yú\im�jØXZm�m(ghÐZl@oØ\il�j¼dZnXçj(\6op×údçm(\iù e@\6l@Öi\Z`ícGdbf(oØXZ[h[³ÈbÉKÊË\ªXZf�\Ø[]d d"¬�g]l@Ъn�dbfÏj7Î@\pm(Ö6XZ[hg]l@Фn+XZÖij(dbf(mä�æåpj(ÎGX�j¨X�j�jÔXZg]lj7Î5\¨Î@g]ÐbÎ@\im�jÇ[hgõ¬�\6[]ghÎ@d�d Í2m�Ö6dbf�\ZÉç�æå - XZf�ÐËoØX%�   Û � � G � ¹ { G z � ` � []j(Î@dbe@ÐbÎçj7Î@\Ól e@o�Y�\6fâdZn×�dbm(m�ghY@[]\Òm(\6ù e@\il@Ö6\imkdZnúm(Ö6XZ[hg]l@Ð{n+XZÖ�j7dbf�m�� ÐZf(dUÊÌm.\A� ×údZl@\6l�j7ghXZ[h[³È¨ÊÌg³j7μj7Î5\âm�\6ù e@\il@Ö6\Ç[h\6l5ÐZj7ÎKÉj7Î5\_×@f�dbY@[h\io dZn ï l@Í5ghl@ÐÖ�Ýå¨Ö&X�läYú\¨\§JpÖ6g]\6l�j7[³Èím�db[]ÑZ\6Íye5m(ghl5ЪÍ5È�lGXZopghÖÓ×@f(dZÐbf7XZopopghl@Ð@É�X�mÊË\¨l@dUÊ�Í@\6m�Ö6f(g]Yú\�`. \ij�� � - �I� F G QeQfQ G � � � Í5\6l@dZj(\�j7Î@\¼m�Ö&XZ[]ghl@ÐØn+XZÖij(dbf(m{d�nVj(Î@\ ï f�m�j p l@d�j7\6m²dZnËXªoØ\i[hd�Í5Èb`. \ijZ� ) - � j F G QfQfQ G j ) � Í@\il@dZj7\äj(Î@\ ï f(m�j � m7XZop×@[]\6m¤dZn_Xºm�ghÐbl@XZ[4` . \�jgè Y�\ìX Í@g]m(Öif(\ij(\m(\�jpdZnâ×údbm�m(g]Y@[h\ªm�Ö&XZ[]ghl@Ðyn+X�Öij7dZf_Ñ�XZ[he@\im6`�c�dZf¼é L è ÉË[]\ij�è �^ê ) ê ë Yú\¤Xäm�\ij½dZn²XZ[h[Ë×údZm(m(g]Y@[h\m(\iù e@\6l@Öi\6mÌdZn p m(Ö6XZ[hg]l@ÐÓn+X�Öij7dZf(m6É�� � É m�e@ÖÔΪj7Î@X�j � � - é¨ghm.j7Î5\²m(Ö6XZ[hg]l@ÐÏn+XZÖij(dbfËd�nLl@dZj(\ p X�l@Í�.- ÷ �� ø F � � * � ghm�j7Î5\ÇX�Öij7e@XZ[@\6l5Í@ghl@ÐÏj7g]oØ\kdZn�l5dZj7\ p ` . \�j©ì �Ip G � G é � Y�\sj7Î@\!�dbg]l j.[]gõ¬�\6[hg]Î@d�d ÍdZn � ) XZl@ÍX� � L è �^ê ) ê ë

ì �+p G � G é �A- o±XB�  � ê¥í �ïî ð^î ñ Û � � ) G � � ¹ z G { ��Õ�

Page 42: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

òôó � x�ÿC�Gÿ��¶µ�ÿöõ´���@ÿ��Ëx ÷sø§ùàúdùàûiüþý ÿ � ü � ü ò���� ò�>ó Ø z�³��{|-�@ÿ��Ëx ý ÿ�þü

�ü� ���

�����������ý ÿ�

� ò ü ���ü�

� ��� ÿ�� � ��� ÿ

!ú� "ø ü

#$#%#ü!ú �

&(' �)+*-,�.�, � � � � �0/ '

ó1 ó�24365�798:<;>=?8A@B:

�DCE� F���øÁùGùàû

H �I��� Jÿ�K�ü

�ü� �

L>MONQP�RTSVUIWYXQZ-[]\$S_^a`OMbNQc$deSfchgi^a`bNajQRTM�gk\�d+l[]\�SVm�nTSfP�o�j4pqj�o�S�rsjQR]pqjadem�P%gkMbc$N¼ì-tsuTvTw�vyéhxBRTSfpqP�RynTM�zQSq`�{|Mbn]ny\�jI}~c�Mbc+L>MON�l�t�U�WYXIx�l[]\�S|d4jQnygE`OMb�aSf`O{�nTSf��P$Sqc�pfS�jar�nTpq^a`bMOc�NDr�^ap�gkjQRyn¯�æå�Mbn�jQ�$gk^aMbc$Sqo�rsRTjQd�gk\$S�^�`bNQjQRyMOgT\�d��h{nk^�z�Mbc$N�gk\�S�MOchgTSqRydeSfo�M�^�gTS�z�^a`OP�Sqn�gT\?^�g�d�^��%MOdeMO�qSVS�^apY\�S��%m�RySqnynTMbjac�MOc�gk\�S�RySqpfP�RTnyMbjQc�ngkSqm�l[]\�S�pfjQdem$`bS��%M�g�{�j�r�gT\�S�^a`ONQjQRyMOgk\$d�Mbn���t����E ¶è9  ¡Y¢�x�£>}~\�SfRTS��¤MbnVgk\�S�c�P$d��¥SfR�jar~c�jagTSqnf£�¦MbnVgk\�SechP�d��§SqR_j�r]nk^ad4m�`OSqn_MOc�gT\�S�o�MONQMOgk^a`-nyMbNQc?^�`�£~  è9 �Mbn�gk\�S�chP�d_�¥SfR_jar~^�`b`¨m¥janTnTMO��`bSgkSfdem§jEza^�`bP�Sfn�^ac$o�¢©MOn�gT\�SVd�^��%MOd�^a`�o�P�Rk^�gkMbjac�jar(^ec�jagTSal~ª�nTMbc$N�^em$RTS�W«pqjQd4m�P$gk^�gkMOjQc|jargk\$Se`OMb�aSf`bMO\�j%j�o�z�^a`OP�Sqn�}�Sepq^ac¤RySqo�P�pfS4gT\�SEgkMbd4S�pqjadem�`OS��%MOg�{��¬{­^|r�^ap�gkjQR�jari¢®^�c�o­gT\hP�ngk\$S_RTP$c�gkMOdeS�jar-gT\�S�^�`bNQjQRyMOgT\�d¯RTSfo�P�pfSqn�gTj���t����E  è9  ¡�x�l~°«g�Mbn�Mbd4m¥jQRgY^ac¬g~gkjepq`b^aRTM�r±{�gk\?^�ggk\$SVm$RTS�W«pqjQd4m�P$gk^�gkMOjQc|o�j�Sqn�c�jag~pqjadem�`OSfgTSq`O{�o�SfgTSqRydeMOc�SV^4nyMbc�NQ`OS�m�MOgTpY\+z�^a`OP�S<rsjQR�^�rsRk^ad4Sal°«g�p�^a`OpqP�`b^�gkSfnigk\�S�m�RyjQ�?^a�$Mb`bM�g�{4jar²gT\�S�rsRk^ad4S�NQM�zQSqc+S�^�pY\�m§jQnTnyMb��`OS�m�MOgTpY\�MOc�gk\�S�o�Mb^am?^anyjQc³lâLK»º ´ T¶µH}¨·�T�¸V¹¼Rº n_deSfchgTMbjQc$Sqo»^��¥jIzQS�£(jQP�R�m�RTMOd�^aR{�NQj¬^a`¨MOnVgTjDRTS�gkRTMOSfzaS�gk\�SenTSfNQdeSfc¬gkn�jar~nyMbNQc�^a`bnVRTSfm�RTS�WnTSfc¬gkMbc$NEgT\�S�d4Sq`bj�o${eNQMOzaSqc|�¬{�gk\$S���P$SqRy{al¨[]\�SqjQRySfgTMbp�^�`b`O{a£%}�S�c�SqSfo+gTjE^anTnyMbNQc+^�nTSfNQd4Sqc¬g��MOgTn~`bMb��Sq`OMb\�j�j%o�nypqjQRySa£¥¼�t��(  z v»{�xB½¿¾   ¼et��¦  z v»{Àx�l]Á�j�}�SfzaSqRf£¥gk\$Mbn~d�^�RTNQMOc?^a`³m�RyjQ�?^a�$Mb`bM�g�{Mbn]RT^�gk\$SqR]S��%m§Sqc�nyMOzaSVgTj4pfjQd4m�P$gkS�l(¤S<gT\�P$n�^am$m�RTj��%Mbde^�gkS¶gk\�MOn]m�RTjQ��^a��Mb`OMOg�{E}~MOgT\�gk\�SBÃyjQMOchgm�RyjQ�?^a��MO`bM�g�{�jar-gT\�S_nyMbNQc?^�`²^�c�oDd4jQnyg¶`bMO�aSq`�{�nTSf�hP�Sqc�pfSEjar(nTpq^a`bMOc�NEr�^apfgTjQRTnf£�¼etp�Àv�� å   z v»{�xVl[]\?^�g�MOnq£$}�S�P$nTS�gk\�S�`OMb�aSf`bMO\�j%j�o�nypqjQRySVj�r²gT\�SV^a`bMONQc�d4Sqc¬g]m�Ryj%pfSqo�P�RySV^an�^ERySfgTRTMbS�z�^a`³nTpfjQRTS�l

ÄaÅ

Page 43: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

Æ Ç ÈÊÉ Ë�ÌÎÍ Ï

Ð Ñ É ÌÎÍÓÒ(Ô ÌÖÕ×ˤÈÙØ Ú ÌÖÛ�Ü Ø�Ë»Û

[6jVS�z�^a`bP?^�gkS]jQP�R¨^�`bNQjQRyMOgT\�dÎ}�S~pqjQ`O`bSfpfgkSfoeUaÝ�o�MOÞ¥SqRySqc¬g¨deSf`bj�o�MbSfn>rsRTjadßr�^ad4jQP�n(jQm§SqRT^�^aRTMb^anq£^ac�o��hP�SfRTMbSfo�gk\�SfnTS�d4Sq`bj�o�MOSqn�MOc�^�o?^�gk^a�?^anyS�jaràRTS�^�`-RTSfpqjQRyo�Mbc�NanqlV[]\�S�RTSfpqjQRyo�Mbc�Nan�pqjQc�nyMbngjar6á ÄQâ m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqSfnijar�jam¥SfRk^�^aRyM�^anàm§SqRyrsjaRTd4Sqo��¬{edejQRyS¶gT\?^ac Å Ý�o�MOÞ¥SqRySqc¬gBgTSqc�jQRBnTMbc$NQSqRyn}~MOgT\�rsP�`b`³jaRTpY\�SfnygkRT^a`6^apqpfjQd4m?^ac�MOdeSfchgql¨ã¨^apY\�m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSVMOn]jQc�S�d4MbchP$gkS�l¨[]\�S�o�^�gY^�}B^anS���gTRk^ap�gkSqo�rsRyjQd®nySfzaSqcä^aP�o�MOj�åiæ<n+ç Ä £BXa£(U%£ â £ Å�è £¨^ac$o�nk^�zQSfoÓMOcFéàêaëDrsjQRTde^�gql�ì�jQng�jargk\$S_m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqSfn�t�^a�¥jaP$g<íaÝ�m¥SfRTpfSqc¬g�x�^�RTS_o$MbNQM�gY^a`³RySqpfjQRTo�MOc�NQn�t�æ�æ�æ�î º æ�æ�x�l%ïàS�g�£�nyjQd4Sm§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqSfn-^aRySBo�MONQMOgk^a`QRySqde^anygTSqRTMOc�N�j�r�jQ`bo�^ac?^a`OjQN�RySqpfjQRTo�MOc�NQnBt º¶º æ�x�l�[]\�MOn>Mbc¬gTRTj�o�P�pqSfo^ao�o$MOgkMOjQc?^a`¥pqjQd4m�`OS��%MOg�{egkj�gk\�S�RySfgkRyMbS�za^�`�gY^any��o�P�S�gTj4z�^aR{%MOc�N�`bS�zQSf`6j�r>c�jaMbnTS�l[]\�S�d4Sq`Oj%o�MOSqn]rsjQR~gk\�S_S��%m¥SfRTMOdeSfchgTn¶}�SqRyS�S���gkRT^apfgTSqoDrsRyjQdðì�°Aæ<°iñ?`bSfnql º �§jQP$g�\?^a`Or>jargk\$S�ì�°Aæ<°<ñ?`OSqnV}BSfRTS�o�jI}~c�`Oj¬^ao�Sfo¤rsRTjQdògT\�S�°�c¬gkSfRTc�S�g�óV^ac$o¤gk\�S�RTSqng�jarBgk\�S|ì+°Aæ<°<ñ?`bSfn}�SqRTSVm§SqRyrsjaRTd4Sqo|jQc+^�ì+°Aæ<°B�aS�{��¥j¬^�RTo�^ac�o+nk^�zQSfoD^an¶ì�°Aæ<°àñ?`bSfnql¤S¤pqjQd4m?^aRySqoôgT\�RTSfS»o�MOÞ¥SqRySqc¬gDgTSqd4m¥j�W«�?^anySqo¿^am$m�RTj¬^�pY\�Sqn�rsjaR�RTS�gkRyMbSfz�^a`�lð[]\$S¤ñ?RTngd4Sfgk\$j%o»nyMbd4m�`O{­P�nySqn�gk\$S�jQRTMONQMbc�^a`¨o�P�Rk^�gkMbjac�n_NQM�zQSfcÓMOc¤gk\$S��hP�SqR{»}~MOgT\�jQP$g�^ac¬{»nTpq^a`bMOc�N�lÂ�S�RTS�rsSqR_gTj�gk\�MOn_nyMbd4m�`bMOnygkMOp4^am�m�Ryj¬^apY\õ^an_gT\�S�ö¨÷ùø%úTûýü§ú�þ�ÿ��¤t�L>[�x�dej�o�Sq`�l�[]\�S�nySqpfjQc�o^am�m$RTj¬^apY\4P�nySqnà^�nTMbc$NQ`bSinyp�^a`OMbc�N<r�^�pfgkjaR-rsjQR¨^a`b`�gk\�S]o$P�Rk^�gTMbjQc$n(jar³^�NQM�zQSfc4d4Sq`Oj%o%{Ql-Á�jI}BS�zQSqRf£gk\$Mbn]nTpq^a`bMOc�N�r�^ap�gkjQR]MOnio�SfgTSqRydeMOc�Sqo|Mbc$o�Sqm§Sqc�o$Sqc¬gk`�{�rsjQR]S�^�pY\�nyMbNQc?^�`³nTj4^an]gkjEde^��%Mbd4Mb�fS¶gk\$SnTMONQc?^a`On~`bMb��Sq`OMb\�j�j%o�làÂ�S_RySfrsSqR~gkj4gk\�MOn¶d4j�o�Sq`À^an�gk\�S������Tê����4ö¨÷ùø%úTû¤ü§ú�þ�ÿ��+t �ÀL>[�x]d4j%o�Sf`�l[]\�SEgk\�MORTo­RTS�gkRTMOSfz�^a`(d4SfgT\�j%o­Mbn�jQP$R�z�^aRyM�^a�$`bS�gkSfdem§j|dej�o�Sf`-gk\?^�gV}�SeMOchgTRTj�o�P�pfSqo¤MOc�gk\�MOnm?^am§SqRfl�Â�S�gk\$SqRTS�rsjQRTS�RTSfrsSfR�gTj�gk\�MOn_d4SfgT\�j%o»^an�gT\�S��?ê���÷�ê����bú­ü¥ú�þ�ÿ���t�<[�x�d4j%o$Sq`�l���{gY^���MOc�ND^�m�RTS�ñ$�»nyP���nySfg�jar~Sq^apY\�d4Sq`bj�o${�P$nTSqo�MOc�^��hP�SfRy{�}BSeSfz�^a`bP�^�gkSfo¤gk\�RySqS�o$MOÞ¥SqRTSfc¬g`bSfc�NagT\�n~jar>d4Sq`Oj%o$MbSqnfZ(U�nTSfpqjQc�o$nq£ÀX�U�nTSfpqjQc�o$nq£¥^ac�o â U�nTSfpqjQc�o$nql[²j�^�nTnTSfnTn�gT\�S��hP?^a`OMOg�{­jar]gk\$S�nTm§Sqp�gkRk^�`Bo�MOnygkRyMb��P%gkMbjac¤d4j%o�Sf`�o$SqnTpfRTMO�¥Sfo�Mbc��%Sfpalit Å l â x�£}�S4MOdem$`bSqd4Sqc¬gTSqo�gT\�S�nTm§Sqp�gkRk^�`-o�MbngkRyMb��P$gTMbjQc�dej�o�Sq`²o�SqnypqRyMb�§Sqo­MbcÓç â í è l�Â�S�o�SqnypqRyMb�§S�gk\�MOn������� � �"!#!%$&$&$(' )+*-,.)+/102)+�-)435)46 74' 8:9#;=<�#� � �>�?!4!@$&$&$(' ;BA56 ,.8C6 8D94*-74' EF* 7C7C6 7D*-G474' 8:9H' A5I�<�#� � �>�?!4!@$&$&$(' 8DJ.)#6 6 ,K8D)+J.;L,.02,M' N494� �27C* 7#' A2IO' 8:9#;

Ä U

Page 44: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

�%m¥SfpfgTRk^a`Àæ<MOnygkRyMb��P%gkMbjac|ì�j�o�Sq`ÁP�RQ Á¶°:Qº z�N�S åBjIz T�SfRTR º z�N�S åBjIz T<SqRyR

U.VWKXYFZW V [\]^_`Vabc â U �<[ d&eMfhg d&eMi&j d&ekdml Ý$l í â Ý$l Å Ý Ý$l�XIÝ

�6L²[ Ý%l.nOn U%l íQÝ Ý%l Å n Ý$lon Ä U%l íQá Ý$l Å áL>[ Ý%l ÄaÅ â Ý$lonQí Ý%lKpOp Ý$l ÄQÄ âQâ l Å n Ý$l.paíX�U �<[ d&eMlhq j�e1rsg d&e�jtf Ý$l á Ä Ä l Ý â Ý$l�XIí

�6L²[ Ý%l.nOn á$l�XIÝ Ý%l ÅQÅ Ý$lonOn á$l�X�U Ý$l ÅhâL>[ Ý%l Ä á XIí$l á Ä Ý%lKp%X Ý$l Ä n XIí$l ÝQá Ý$l.p ÄU �<[ d&eMg�j j>d&euqmrvd&eMqhg Ý$l Å n XQXQl á Ä Ý$lonQí

�6L²[ Ý%l Å¬Ä X2p%l ÄQÄ Ý%l.nQí Ý$l Ä p X2p%l í Å Ý$l.pQUL>[ Ý%l Ä á âQâ l íOn Ý%l.nQí Ý$l Ä U â XQlon�pÖÝ$l.pQU[>^a�$`bSwn$l�XQZyx~SfgkRyMbS�za^�`³RTSfnTP�`�gkn

d4j%o�Sf`(Mbc�^am�m§Sqc�o$M�� t º x�l�[]\$MbnVdej�o�Sq`¨^�nTnTP$deSfn�gk\�^�g�gT\�S4\?^aRTd4jQc�MOpqn�jar�gk\�SenTMbNac?^a`¨^aRySpqjachgk^ad4Mbc?^�gTSqo�}~M�gk\ c�jQMOnTSD}~\�jQnyS�d4S�^�c Sfc�SqRyNa{FMOn�Mbc�o�Sfm¥Sfc�o�Sfchg+jarVgk\$S�Sqc�SfRTNa{ jarVgk\$S\?^aRydejac�Mbpfnql>Â�S�RTS�rsSqRigkj�jaP�Rid4j%o�Sf`³^anigT\�S{z�ê���þ|�5}?÷-�@~<é(÷���|���Tê��búTû�����÷u~Iúet�Á=�RQ<xBd4j�o�Sq`^ac�o|gkj�gT\�S�dej�o�Sq`¥rsRTjQdòç â í è ^an]gk\�S�z�ê���þ|�5}?÷-�@~�é(÷���|�+}§û�ú�ÿ?ú4}§û�ú4}�������÷u~Iú�t�Á¶°:Q�x]d4j�o�Sq`�l[²jES�za^�`bP?^�gTS<gk\�S�m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSqn]jar6gk\$S�deS�gk\�j�o�ni}�SVP$nTSqo|gk\$RTSqS�S�za^�`bP?^�gTMbjQc�deSq^anTP�RySqnfZ�5}�ú4�Tú4�+�%�5��£L�@��ëaú4�yê���ú4^ac$oFêaëaú4�yê���ú<ÿh�kú@��÷u~�÷-�5}?lE[²j+S��%m�`b^aMbc�gk\$SqnTSedeSq^anTP$RTSqn�}�SeMOchgTRTj�o�P�pfSgk\$SErsja`b`bjI}~MOc�N�c�jagk^�gkMOjQc³l���Sfg�� �¥S�gk\$S4chP�d_�¥SfR�jar�m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqSfn�Mbc­jQP�R�o?^�gk^a�?^anyS�^�c�o`bS�g{� �§S4gT\�SechP�d_�¥SfR�jarBdeSf`bj�o�MbSfn<gk\?^�gV}�S�nyS�^aRypY\¤rsjQRfl�t º n�d4Sqc¬gTMbjQc�Sfo¤^��¥jIzQS�£>MOc�jQP$RS��%m§SqRyMbd4Sqc¬gkn�� ½ á ÄQâ ^ac�o�� ½¦UaÝ$l x»L�jaR�^�deSf`bj�o${�Mbc�o�S���u]}�S4o$Sqc�jagTS��¬{����(gT\�S�nTS�gjar]gT\�S�m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSqn_pfjQc¬gY^aMOc�Mbc$N�d4Sq`bj�o${�uyl�[]\�S�m$RTjQ�?^���Mb`OMbnygTMbpEd4j%o�Sf`bMOc�N�}BS�o$MbnTpfP�nTnySqoMbc|gk\$Mbn~m?^am§SqR~Mbc$o�P�pqSfn�^Ec?^�gTP�Rk^�`6jaRTo�SfRTMbc$N4jIzaSqR¶gT\�S�m¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^�c�pqSfn�rsjQR~Sq^apY\�d4Sq`Oj%o${al���S�g����tM��x4o�Sfc�jagTS�gk\$S�RT^ac��hMbc�N�jar<gT\�S�m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfS�MOc�o�S��%Sfo��¤}~MOgT\ýRTSfnTm§Sqp�g�gkj�deSf`bj�o${õuTl�i^anySqo�jQc4gk\�S�^a�§j�zaS<o�S�ñ?c�MOgTMbjQc$nà}�S<c�jI} NQM�zQS¶gT\�S¶rsjaRTde^a`�o�Sfñ?c$MOgkMOjQc�nàjar³gT\�S�m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSd4S�^anyP�RTSfn~}�SVP�nTSfo�rsjQR]S�za^�`bP?^�gTMbjQc�l�����O�%�P�2�2 �� eD[]\�S�jac�S�W«SqRTRyjQRVdeSq^anTP�RySqnV\�jI}¦d�^�ch{�gTMbd4Sqn�gk\$Segkjam%W�RT^ac��aSfo¤m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSo�MOo¡}¢�5��pqjQc¬gk^aMbc¤gT\�S�d4Sq`Oj%o%{�m¥jQnySqo»MOc�gT\�S��hP�SfRy{Ql�[]\�P$nq£(MOr�gk\�S�NQj¬^a`¨jar]jaP�R_n{%ngkSfd®MOngkj_RTSfgTP�RTc|^�nTMbc$NQ`bS¶m¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^ac$pqS¶gT\?^�gBpqjQc¬gY^�Mbc�nàgk\�S<d4Sq`Oj%o%{Q£hgk\�S<jac�S�W«SqRTRyjQRBd4S�^�nTP�RySqni\�jI}de^ac¬{�gkMbd4Sqn�gT\�S�RySfgTRTMbS�zQSfo�m¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^�c�pqS+o�MboÓc�jagepqjachgk^aMbcÓgk\�S+d4Sq`bj�o${alFL?jQRTde^a`b`�{Q£(gk\$So�S�ñ?c�MOgTMbjQc|jar6gk\$SVjac�S�W«SqRTRyjQR]Mbnf£

T<SqRyRB½ X�

£¤��¥ ó

ç ç ^aRyN�d4Mbc¦ ���Atk�%x¨§© ��� è èyª}~\�SfRTS�ç ç"« è è ½ XVM�r>m$RTSqo$Mbp�^�gkS¨«­\�jQ`bo$n~^ac�o�ÝEj�gk\�SfRy}~MbnySal

Ä n

Page 45: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

¬� t­h�>�2®s¯�� e< \$Mb`bS�gT\�S_jQc$S�W�SfRTRyjQR~Sfz�^a`bP�^�gkSfn¶gk\$S�m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfS�jar(^eny{�ngkSqd }~MOgT\�RySqnTm§Sqp�ggkj»gT\�S�gTjQm%W�RT^ac���SqoFm§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqS�£]gk\�S�NQjQ^a`¶j�rVgT\�SDpfj�zaSqRT^aNQS�d4S�^anyP�RTS�MOnegkjõ^�nTnTSfnTn�gk\$Sm§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqS¨jar%gk\�Sàny{�ngkSqd¿rsjQR6^a`O`¬jar$gT\�Sàm¥jQnynTMO��`bS(m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSqn6jar?^~deSf`bj�o${QlÀ°�c$rsjaRTde^a`b`�{Q£åBjIzQSfRk^aNQS~d4S�^anyP�RTSfn-gk\�SBc�P$d��¥SfR(jar§S��%pqSfnTn�t�c�jac%W�RySq`bS�z�^ac¬g�x6m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSqn-}�S]c�SqSfo�gkj�nTpq^acP�c¬gkMO`�}�S�RySfgkRyMbS�zQSV^a`b`¥gk\�S�RTSf`bS�za^�chg~m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSqnfl�L?jQRyd�^�`b`O{a£%åBj�zaSqRT^aNQSVMbn]o�S�ñ?c�Sqo�^anq£åBjIze½ X

�£¤��¥ ó

t�de^��¦@°²±+³ �´�tM��x�µô  ���y  x ª

¶|­h�>�5®R¯h�¸·��2� ¹�º�»²º� h� e�[]\$S�^a�§j�zaS�d4S�^anyP�RTSfn�o�jDc�jag�nTPR¼4pqS�MOc»Sfz�^a`OP?^�gTMbc�N+gk\�S�m§SqRrsjQRWde^ac�pqSfn�j�riRTS�gkRyMbSfz�^a`(n{�nygkSfden_^an�jQc�S4p�^ac¤^apY\�MOSfzQSeNQj�j%oät�`OjI}¶x�pfjIzQSqRT^aNQSe��P$gVnTP$Þ¥SqR�\�MbNa\jQc�S�W�SfRTRTjaRàRT^�gkSfnq£�^ac�oEz�MbpfS�zaSqRTnT^$l(°�c4jQRTo�SfRàgTjV^anTnySqnTnàgk\�S�Rk^�c��hMbc�N�m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqS�^anà^�}~\�jQ`OS}�S�P$nTSigk\$S~rsRySq�hP�SfchgT`O{_P�nTSfo�^�zQSfRk^aNaS�m$RTSqpfMbnyMbjQc�d4S�^anyP�RTS�l(L?jQRTde^a`O`O{Q£�gk\$S~^IzaSqRT^aNQS~m�RTSfpqMOnTMbjacMbn]o$Sfñ?c�SfoD^anf£º z�N�Sõ½ X

�£¤�F¥ ó

X "���T  ¤¦+°�±4³ .½4�O¾ © ���y  ���Atk�O¾�x�¿����tk�%x@À? 

���AtM��x ª

°�c ^ao$o�MOgTMbjQc�}�S¤^�`bnTjõP�nyS�m$RTSqpfMbnyMbjQcFzQSfRTnyP�n�RySqp�^�`b`�NQRT^am�\�n�gkjÓMb`O`bP�ngkRT^�gkS�gT\�S�jIzQSqRT^a`b`m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqSfn�j�rigk\�Seo�MOÞ¥SqRySqc¬g_^am�m�Ryj¬^apY\�Sfn�o�MbnypqP�nynTSfo�Mbc�gk\�Sem?^am§SqRql º m�RySqpqMOnTMOjQc%W�RySqpq^a`b`NQRT^am�\�ny\�jI}~nigk\�S¶`bSfzaSq`¥jarÀm�RTSfpqMOnTMbjac�rsjQRào�MOÞ¥SqRySqc¬g]RTSfp�^a`O`?za^�`bP�Sfnql([]\�S<m$RTSqpfMbnyMbjQc�^�g~�eMOn�gk\$SchP�d��§SqR~jar²\�MOgTn]Mbc�gk\$S�ñ�RTnyg���m¥janTMOgTMbjQc$niMbc�gk\$SVRT^ac���Sqo�`OMbng]o�MOz�MOo�Sqo|�¬{+�¥làL?jQRTde^a`O`O{Q£¼wÁ�Â�Ã�u�Ä�uÆÅ2Ç(t���x(½ X

�£¤�F¥ ó

 .½5�´�AtM��x Z tM� © ���sx&È»t����Atk�%xL¿ ��x@À? � ª

[]\�S<RySqpq^a`b`¥^�gi��Mbn¨gk\�S<chP�d_�¥SfRBjarÀ\�M�gknàMbc�gT\�S¶ñ�RTnyg~�em¥janTMOgTMbjQc$n�MOcegk\$S�Rk^�c��aSfo+`OMbng�o$MOz�Mbo�Sfo�¬{�gk\$SVchP�d_�¥SfR�j�r(^a`O`¥gk\$SVRySq`OSfz�^ac¬g�m¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^ac$pqSqn]MOc�gk\�S�o?^�gk^a�?^anySalàL?jQRTde^a`O`O{Q£�¨Â�Ã#É>Ê�Êt���x¨½ X

�£¤�F¥ ó

 o½5���Atk�%x Z tk� © ���sx&È»t����Atk��xË¿ �$x+À?   ���y  ª

[]\�S~NQRT^am�\�n(m�RySqnySqc¬gkSfo�Mbc�gT\�Mbn(m�^am¥SfR¨^aRTS]c$jQc%W�MOc¬gkSqRym¥ja`�^�gTSqo³£�gk\?^�g¨MOnq£QgT\�Sf{�}�SqRyS~p�^a`OpqP�`b^�gkSfo�?^anySqo�jQc�gk\�SEm�RySqpqMOnTMOjQc­^ac�o­RTSqpq^a`b`-z�^a`OP�Sqn�^�pY\�MbS�zQSqo¤^�g�Mbc¬gTSqNQSfRVm§jQnyMOgkMOjQc�n<j�rBgk\$S4RT^ac���Sqo`bMOnygTnql°�c�gY^���`bS�n$l�X¶}�S<RTSfm¥jQRgBRySqnyP�`OgTn�}~MOgT\�RySqnTm§Sqp�gigkjVgk\�S¶m¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^�c�pqS�deSq^anTP$RTSqn�o�SqnypqRyMb�§SqorsjQR�gk\�S�L²[�£��ÀL>[�£¥^ac�oÌ�<[ d4j%o$Sq`bnfl<L?jQR¶S�^apY\DgTSqd4m¥j�d4j�o�Sq`À}BS_pqjQc�o$P�pfgTSqo�gk\�S_S��%m¥SfRTMùWd4Sqc¬gkn�}~M�gk\DgT\�S_g�}�j+nym¥SfpfgTRk^a`-o$MbnygTRTMO��P$gkMOjQc�d4j�o�Sq`On<Á¶°:QÖ^ac�o�ÁP�tQ�l³°«g�MOn�pf`bS�^�R�rsRTjQd gk\$SgY^���`bS�gk\?^�gBgk\�S��?ê���÷�ê����búeü¥ú�þ�ÿ��Vd4j%o$Sq`�}~MOgk\�gT\�S�z�ê���þ|�5}?÷-�@~<é(÷��Í���Tê��búTû{����÷u~Iú<nTm§Sqp�gkRk^�`

Ä p

Page 46: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 10

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

Recall

Pre

cisi

on

FT/5LFT/5VT/5

0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.10

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

Recall

Pre

cisi

on

FT/15LFT/15VT/15

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 10

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Recall

Pre

cisi

on

FT/25LFT/25VT/25

L>MONQP�RTSÎn�WYXQZÏS(RTSqpfMbnyMbjQc%W«RTSfp�^a`O`$pqP$RyzQSfnBpfjQdem�^aRTMOc�N<gk\�S~m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfS�j�r¥gT\�RTSfS~gTSqd4m¥j�d4j%o$Sq`bnrsjQR��hP�SfRTMbSfn�pfjQc�nyMbnygTMbc�N|jar�ñ�zQS4nTSfpqjQc$o�n�t±gkjQm?x�£�ñ�r±gkSfSqc�nTSqpfjQc�o�t�d4Mbo�o�`OSIx�£�^ac�o�g�}BSfc¬g�{�ñ�zaSnTSfpqjQc$o�n�ts�¥j�gTgkjad�x�l

Ä á

Page 47: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.90

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

0.25

0.3

0.35

0.4

0.45

0.5

Recall

Pre

cisi

on

FT/5FT/15FT/25

0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 10

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

Recall

Pre

cisi

on

LFT/5LFT/15LFT/25

0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1 1.10

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

Recall

Pre

cisi

on

VT/5VT/15VT/25

L>MONQP�RTS�n�W â ZÎS(RTSqpfMbnyMbjQc%W«RTSfp�^a`O`6pfP�RyzaSqn�pqjadem?^�RTMbc$N4gT\�S�m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqS�jar¨S�^�pY\�jar(gk\�S�gkSqd4m§jd4j%o�Sf`bnBrsjaRigk\�RySqSVo�MOÞ¥SqRySqc¬g���P$SqRy{�`bSqc$Nagk\�nfl

Ä í

Page 48: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

Fre

quen

cy

Time17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

L>MONQP�RTS�n�W Ä Z º c�Mb`O`bP�ngkRk^�gkMbjac�jar³gk\$S�^a`bMONQc�d4Sqc¬gà^ac�o�nTSqNadeSfchgk^�gkMOjQc�j�r�gk\�S´�<[Fd4j%o�Sf`�l²[]\�Sm�M�gkpY\�Sfn�j�r>gk\$SVc$jagkSfn�MOc�gk\�S�d4Sq`bj�o${�^aRTS�jIzQSfRT`b^I{aSqo�Mbc|nTjQ`OMbo�`OMbc�Sfnqlo�MOnygkRyMb��P%gkMbjac�jQP$gkm§SqRrsjQRTd4n]gk\�SVRTSfnyg¶jar>gT\�SVdej�o�Sq`On~^ac�o�^apY\�MbS�zQSfn�nTP$m¥SfRTMbjaR�RySqnyP�`OgTnql]ì+jQRTS�WjIzQSfRq£BgT\�S�m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfS|jar�gT\�S �?ê���÷�ê����bú�ü§ú�þ�ÿ���d4j%o$Sq`]pqjac�nTMOnygkSfc¬gk`O{õMOdem$RTjIzQSfn�^anEgk\$So�P�RT^�gkMOjQc|jar6gk\�S��hP�SqRyMbSfn�MOc�pqRyS�^anySqnfl�°�c+pqjQc¬gTRk^ang�£?gk\�S�ö¨÷ùø%úTû�ü¥ú�þ�ÿ��_o�j%Sfn~c�jag~S��%\�MO��MOg�^�ch{Mbd4m�Ryj�zaSqd4Sqc¬g�^�n�gk\$S�o�P�RT^�gkMOjQc¤j�rigk\�S���P$SqRTMOSqn�Mbc�pfRTS�^�nTSqn�^ac�o¤gT\�SÐ�����Tê����+ö¨÷ùø%úTûýü§ú�þ�ÿ��nT\$j�}~n�jQc$`O{�^|d4j�o�SqRT^�gkS�MOdem$RTjIzQSfdeSfchg�}~\�Sqc­P�nTMOc�N�ñ�r±gTSqSqc�nySqpqjac�o�`OjQc�N��hP�SfRTMbSfn�Mbc�ngkSq^aojar(ñ�zaS�nTSfpqjQc�o�`OjQc�Ne��P$SqRTMOSqn�^ac$oDMOg¶o�j�Sqn<c�j�g�Mbd4m�RTjIzaS�^an�gk\�S�o$P�Rk^�gTMbjQc�NQRTjI}~n�gTj�g�}�Sqc¬g�{ñ�zaS�nTSfpqjQc�o$nql º RyS�^anyjQc?^a��`OSeS��%m�`�^ac�^�gkMOjQc­rsjaRVgT\�SqnyS�m�\�Sfc�jQd4Sqc?^+Mbn�gk\?^�gVgk\$S�^ad4jQP�c¬gVjarz�^aRTMb^a��MO`bMOg�{EMOc+^�zaSqR{|nT\�jQRg���P$SqRy{|MOn]c?^�gTP�Rk^a`O`O{e`bMOdeM�gkSqo�^ac�o|gk\hP�n]gk\�S�`OSfzQSfRk^aNaSVNQ^aMbc�Sfo|�h{^apfpqP�RT^�gkS�gkSfdem§jEdej�o�Sf`bMbc$N�}~\�MOpY\+gk^a�aSfn¶MOchgTj4^apqpfjQP�c¬g~gk\�S�z�^aRTMb^a��MO`bMOg�{EMOc�gkSfdem§jEMbn]Rk^�gk\�SfRnTde^a`O`�l­[]\�P$nq£]^an�gT\�S|�hP�SqR{õo�P�Rk^�gkMbjac�NQRTjI}~n�gk\�S|m§jI}BSfR4j�r¶gT\�S�za^�RTM�^���`bS4gkSqd4m§j­d4j�o�Sq`Mbn_�¥S�gTgkSfR�S��%m�`OjQMOgTSqo³l­[]\�SÌ�����Tê�����ö¨÷ùø%úTû ü§ú�þ�ÿ���p�^ac�pq^am$gkP$RTS�gk\�S|^�zaSqRk^�NQS�gkSfdem§j�jar¶^m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqS��$P$gVpq`bSq^aRT`�{�r�^aMO`bn�gTj|p�^am$gTP�RTSEpY\?^�c�NQSqnVMbc�gT\�S�gkSqd4m§j�l��%Mbc$pqS�gk\�SEpY\?^�c�pqS4jar^4gTSqd4m¥j4pY\?^ac$NQS_NQRyjI}~n�}~M�gk\�gT\�SVo�P�Rk^�gkMbjac�jar²gk\�S��hP�SqR{+gT\�S�^IzaSqRT^aNQS�gTSqd4m¥j4nygTjQm�n�rsRTjQd�§SqMbc$N�^eNaj%j�o�^�m�m�RTj��%Mbde^�gTMbjQc+^ac�o+}BS_o�j�c�j�g�nySqS�rsP$Rygk\$SqR�MOdem$RTjIzQSfdeSfchg¶Mbc+gk\�SVRTS�gkRyMbSfz�^a`�hP?^a`OMOg�{Ql

°�c4L>MbN�l$t n�WYX�x�}BS~NQM�zQSim�RySqpfMbnTMOjQc%W«RTSqpq^a`b`�NQRT^am�\�n>gT\?^�g¨pfjQdem�^aRTSBgT\�SBgT\�RTSfSigkSqd4m§j�dej�o�Sq`Onqlã¨^apY\�NQRT^am�\epqjQd4m?^aRySqn�L>[�£ �6L²[�^ac�o��<[�rsjQR¨o�M�Þ�SfRTSfchg��hP�SqR{�o$P�Rk^�gTMbjQc$nql>[]\$S��<[Fd4j�o�Sq`pq`OS�^aRy`O{�jQP$gTm¥SfRyrsjQRyden¶�¥jagT\�gk\�SEL>[Î^ac$oÑ�ÀL>[ d4j%o$Sq`bnfl�[]\�SE`bjQc�NaSqR¶gT\�S��hP�SqR{Dgk\$S�}~Mbo�SfRgk\$S�N¬^ameMbc4m¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^�c�pqS�l-°�c�L>MON�l�t n�W â x>}�S<pqjQd4m?^aRyS]gk\�S¶m�RTSfpqMbnyMbjQc�W�RTSfp�^a`O`?NQRk^�m�\�n¨rsjQR�Sq^apY\d4j%o�Sf`]^an4^DrsP�c�p�gkMbjacäjar�gk\$S+�hP�SfRy{õo�P$Rk^�gTMbjQc³lõã¨^apY\ÓNQRT^am�\ÓnT\�jI}~nEgk\�S|m�RySqpqMOnTMOjQc%W�RySqpq^a`b`Å Ý

Page 49: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

pqP$RyzQSfn�rsjQR�U%£VX�U%£�^ac$o â U�nTSfpqjQc$o�n|��P$SqRTMOSqnfl Â�S�^aN¬^�MbcýnySqSDgT\?^�g�jQc$`O{Ógk\�SÒ��[ðd4j�o�Sq`pqjac�nTMOnygkSfc¬gk`O{�Mbd4m�RTjIzaSqni}~MOgT\�gk\�S�MOc�pqRyS�^anyS�Mbc�gT\�S��hP�SqR{�o�P�RT^�gkMOjQc³l¨ª�nTMbc$NE^�NQ`bjQ��^a`b`�{�ñ$�%SqogkSfdem§j­t�L²[�x�Mbn<pf`bS�^�RT`O{�Mbc�^ao�Sq�hP?^�gkSE^an�M�g<RTSfnTP�`�gkn�MbcDzaSqR{�m¥j�jQR<m§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfS�Ó�m�RTSfpqMOnTMbjacMbn�c�S�zQSfR_\�MONQ\�SqR�gT\?^ac�Ý$l Ä U|S�zQSqc�rsjQR�`bjI} `OSfzQSf`¨jarBRySqpq^a`b`�le[]\�S4m§SqRyrsjaRTde^ac�pqSEjar�gk\�SÔ�ÀL>[d4j%o�Sf`¥MOnid4jQRTS¶RTS�^�nTjQc?^���`bS�l º m�RTSfpqMOnTMbjac�jar6^a�§jQP$g~Ý$l U_p�^�c��¥S�^�pY\�MbS�zQSqo|rsjQRB^�RTSqpq^a`b`§z�^a`bP�Sjar-Ý$l U�l�Á�jI}BS�zQSqRf£¥gT\�S�rsP�`b`³m§jI}BSfR¶j�r-jQP�R�^am$m�RTj¬^�pY\�MOn�P%gkMb`OMb�fSqo�jQc�`�{�}~\�Sfc�}�S�P�nySVgT\�S¨�<[d4j%o�Sf`�l�Â�SE^apY\�MbS�zQS4^ac�^�zQSfRk^aNaS4m$RTSqpfMbnyMbjQc�jar�Ý$l í â }~M�gk\�^�RTSfp�^a`O`>jar�Ý$l.pQU%lV°«g�nTSfSqd4n<gk\?^�g}~MOgT\Dgk\�S���[ßd4j�o�Sq`6}BSERTSq^apY\­^ac�jIzQSfRk^a`O`-m¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^�c�pqS_gT\?^�g�pq^ac�nTSfRyzQS4^an<gT\�S��?^anyMbn�rsjaR`�^�RTNQS<nyp�^a`OS�d�P�nTMOp�RTS�gkRTMOSfz�^a`³n{�nygkSfdenfl�À^anygT`O{Q£%^an�^Vñ?c�^a`¥nT^ac�M�g�{EpY\�SqpY�ejar³gk\$S¶pfjQc�ÃySqp�gkP�RyS<jar¥gk\�S¶RTjQ��P$nygkc$SqnTnBjar³gk\$S��<[Fd4j�o�Sq`}�S�P�nySqo¤gT\�SÔ��[ ^ac�o��6L²[ dej�o�Sf`¨}~M�gk\�gk\�RySqSe`bjQc�N+d4Sq`bj�o${��hP�SfRTMOSqn�t�jQc�SedeMOchP$gkS�x�^�c�o^am�m$`bMbSfoýgk\$SDRTS�gkRTMOSfz�^a`�^ac�o ^a`OMbNQc�d4Sqc¬gem�RTj�pqSfnTnflÎÂ�SDgk\�SfcF`bS�g|^¤m�RyjarsSqnynTMbjac?^a`�d_P�nTMOpqM�^�c`bMOnygTSqc�gTj�gk\�S�nySqNQd4Sqc¬gk^�gkMOjQc�^ac�o��$RTjI}~nTS�gT\�S�nTSfNQd4Sqc¬gkSfo­nym¥SfpfgTjQNQRk^�d�l º c�S��$^ad4m�`bS�jarà^nTm§Sqp�gkjQNaRk^ad }~M�gk\e^�nTSfNQd4Sqc¬gY^�gTMbjQc4jar¥gk\�SÎ�<[�d4j�o�Sq`?MOnàNaMOzQSfc�MOc�L>MON�l�t�n�W Ä x�l>[]\�S�S��$^ad4m�`OSMbn_jar�^Dm¥SfRyrsjQRyd�^�c�pqS�}~\$SqRTS�gT\�S�Sqc$SqRTN�{»jar¶^apfpqjQd4m?^ac�MOdeSfc¬g�Mbn�\�MbNa\�SqR_gT\?^ac»gT\�S�Sqc�SfRTNa{jar�gk\�S|`OS�^ao�MOc�N�gkSfc�jQRqlÕQ�jQc�SfgT\�Sq`OSqnynq£i^�`bMOnygTSqc�MOc�N�S��%m§SqRTMOdeSfc¬g�zQSqRyMOñ?SfoägT\?^�gEjQP�REn{%ngkSfd}B^an�^a��`OS4gTj�m�RyjQm§SqRT`�{�nTSfNQdeSfc¬g�^ac�o»^a`bMONQc�gk\�S�d4Sq`Oj%o%{�m¥janTSqo¤�h{­gk\$S��hP�SqR{Ql º `OgT\�jQP�Na\gk\$SqnTS�m§SqRTpfSqm$gTP?^a`?`OMbnygTSqc�MOc�N<gkSfnygTn�^�RTS~nTP��hÃySqpfgTMOzaSa£hgk\�S~S��%m§SqRyMbd4Sqc¬gkn¨Mbc$o�Mbpq^�gkSfo�gk\?^�g¨gT\�SL�<[d4j%o�Sf`�^a`OnTjEm�RTjIz�Mbo$Sqn�^ac+^apqpfP�Rk^�gkS�^a`bMONQc�d4Sqc¬g]^ac$o�nySqNQd4Sqc¬gY^�gkMbjac³l

Å X

Page 50: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

Åhâ

Page 51: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

Æ Ç ÈÊÉ Ë�ÌÎÍ Ö

× Ò-ÛÙØ Ü Û�Û�ÒÏÚ×Õ

°�c�gk\�MOn�}BjaRT�¤}�S|m�RTSfnTSqc¬gTSqo�^DRyjQ��P�ng4m�RTjQ��^a��Mb`OMbngkMbp4d4j%o�Sf`�rsjQR��hP�SfRy{��¬{�d4Sq`Oj%o%{Ql­[]\�Sm�RyjQm¥janTSqo�^am�m�Ryj¬^apY\eMbn¨nTMOdem�`OSBgkjVMbd4m�`OSqd4Sqc¬gà^ac�oE}i^�n�rsjQP�c$o4gTjV}�jQRT��}�Sq`O`�jQcem§jQ`�{%m$\�jQc¬{¬WRTMOpY\�RySqpqjaRTo�MOc�NQn~}~MOgk\|z�^aRTMOjQP�n]g�{�m¥Sfn�jar(^apqpfjQdem�^ac�Mbd4Sqc¬gTnqlB[]\$S_m�RyjQ�?^a��MO`bMOnygkMOp<d4j%o�Sf`³gk\?^�g}�S+o$SfzQSf`bjQm§Sqoõrsj�pqP�nySqnEjQc»g�}�j�de^aMbc¤nTjQP�RypqSfn4j�r¶z�^aRyM�^a��MO`bM�g�{QlD[]\�S�ñ?RynygEMOn�za^�RTM�^�gkMbjac�n_MOcgk\$S�^ap�gkP?^a`ào�P�RT^�gkMOjQc�n�jar]c�jagTSqn�MOc¤RyS�^a`àRTSfpqjQRyo�Mbc�Nan�tsgTSqd4m¥j+z�^aRTMb^a��Mb`OMOg�{$x<^ac�o�gk\�S�nySqpfjQc�oMbn�gk\�S�za^�RTM�^���Mb`OMOg�{�j�r(gk\�S�nym¥SfpfgTRTP�dðd�^aMOc�`O{�o�P�S_gTj�gk\�SÜÛynTm§Sqp�gkRk^�`>de^anT�hMbc$NOÝ�jar(gT\�S�`OS�^ao%WMbc$N�zQj�p�^a`²�¬{�gT\�S�^apfpqjQd4m?^ac¬{�Mbc�NezQj�p�^a`On�^ac�oDjaRTpY\�SfnygkRT^$l�°�cDgk\�MOn¶}�jQRT�|}�SE^anTnyP�deSfoDgk\?^�ggk\$S�m�MOgTpY\ÓMOc$rsjQRyd�^�gTMbjQc�Mbcõ^��hP�SqR{�MbnE^�pqpqP$Rk^�gTS|^ac�oõjQc�`�{¤gk\$S�o�P�Rk^�gkMbjac�p�^acõ�§S|^a`OgTSqRTSfoMbc�gT\�Sem§SqRrsjQRTde^ac�pfSalE[]\�MOn�^�nTnTP$dem$gTMbjQc�MOnVRyS�^anyjQc?^a�$`bSEMOràgk\�SE�hP�SfRTMbSfn_^�RTSEm¥janTSqo�P�nTMOc�N+^ny{�d��§jQ`OMbp_MOc�m�P$g<deSfpY\?^ac�MOnTd×nyP�pY\�^an�^|ì�°Aæ<°��aSf{��§j¬^aRyo³l�Á¶jI}�SfzaSqRq£²^ac�Sq^anTMOSqR�^ac�o�d4jQRTSpqjachzaSqc�MOSqc¬gid4SqpY\�^ac�Mbnyd Mbn-gTj�\�P$d jQR-}~\�Mbngk`OS¶^�d4Sq`Oj%o${al>[]\�MOn(gY^any��Mbn(jar±gTSqc4p�^a`O`bSfo�Û��P$SqRy{�¬{¤\hP�d4d4Mbc�NOÝ$l�°�c�^ao�o�M�gkMOjQc­gTj�gk\$SegkSfdem§j�z�^aRyM�^a�$Mb`bM�g�{�^ac$o»nTm§Sqp�gkRk^�`�de^anT�hMOc�N�£-^���P$SqRy{�¬{�\hP�d4deMOc�N�n{%ngkSfdÙ^a`bnyj�c�SqSfo�nigkj�gk^a�aS�MOc¬gkjE^apfpqjQP�c¬g~MOdem§SqRrsSqpfgTMbjQc$nBMbc�gT\�S<m�M�gkpY\|jarÀgk\$S\hP�d4deSfoed4Sq`Oj%o${al>°�c�o$SqSqo�£$d�P�pY\ejar�gT\�S~}BjQRy��jQc4��P$SqRy{4�¬{4\hP�ded4Mbc$N�\?^�zQS��§SqSfc�o�S�zQjagTSqogkj4d�P�nyMbp�RTS�gkRyMbSfz�^a`�P$nTMbc$Nec�jaMbny{|m$MOgkpY\+Mbc%rsjQRTde^�gkMOjQc³l([]\�S�d�^IÃyjQRTM�g�{�jar²gk\�S�}BjaRT��jQc���P$SqRy{�¬{+\�P$ded4Mbc�NEgk\$jQP�NQ\³£§\?^�zQS�rsj%pfP�nTSfoDjQc�nyS�^aRypY\�jar(c�jaMbny{|�hP�SfRTMOSqn�MOc�n{%d_�¥jQ`OMbp�o?^�gk^a�?^anySqnfl�%MOc�pqS�gT\�S|d�^aMOc¤gk\$RTP�ngej�r�gT\�Mbn�RySqnyS�^aRypY\äMOn�nTS�^�RTpY\�SfneMOc�RTS�^�`im¥ja`O{�m�\�jQc$Mbp�RySqpqjaRTo�MOc�NQnq£àMOgpqjadem�`OSqd4Sqc¬gkn]gT\�S�RySqnyS�^aRypY\DjQc+��P$SqRy{+�¬{|\hP�d4deMOc�N4^ac�o+p�^ac�nTP�m�m$`bSqd4Sqc¬g¶chP�deSfRTjQP$n¶n{%nAWgkSfden¶gk\?^�g<nTS�^�RTpY\�MbcDn{�d��¥ja`bMbp�o?^�gk^a�?^anySqnql�Â�S�m�`�^�cDgkj�S��%gTSqc�o­jQP�R<^a`bNQjaRTMOgT\�d¯nyj+M�g<pq^ac�§S<pqjQd_��Mbc�Sfo�}~MOgT\�^_rsRTjQc¬g]Sfc�o�rsjQRB\hP�d4d4Sqo��hP�SqRyMbSfnql(°�c+^ao�o�M�gkMOjQc³£¬}BS�\�^IzaS�nygY^�RygkSfo�pqjQc�Wo�P�p�gkMOc�N�RTSfnTSq^aRTpY\­jQc�nTP$m¥SfRyz�MbnySqo�deS�gk\�j�o�n�rsjQR<d�P�nyMbpq^a`²NaSqc�RyS�pq`b^anTnyMOñ?pq^�gkMOjQc³l�Â�S��§Sq`bMOSfzaSgk\�^�g4�h{ÓpfjQd���MOc�Mbc�N�\�MONQ\�`�{�^apfpqP�RT^�gkS�NQSqc�RyS�pf`�^anynTM�ñ?p�^�gTMbjQc�}~M�gk\ä^�RTja��P�nygeRTS�gkRyMbSfz�^a`~^�c�o^a`OMbNQc�d4Sqc¬g]}�SV}~MO`b`³�§S�^a��`bS�gTjem�RyjIz%MOo�S�^ac�S�Þ�SfpfgkM�zQS�gkj�jQ`³rsjQR~nTSq^aRTpY\$Mbc�N�^ac�o��$RTjI}~nTMOc�N4rsjaR�§jagk\|m�RyjarsSqnynTMbjac?^a`bn~^�c�o�^�d�^�gTSqP�Rynql

ŬÄ

Page 52: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ÅQÅ

Page 53: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

Þ É É ÌÖÕ ß Ò Ñ Þ

à Ç Ì á ÈÊÍÓÔ Ú×Õ ÒâØ ã Ò�Ë�Ç ä�Õ ß ÌßÉ ÌÖÕ ß Ì ÕðËå ÚòÒ-Û�Ì Ô Úæß ÌÖØ

ç�è�é%êsëMì�í�îsîhï�èsðsëù�òñBïÐðRï�ìôó#õôëO�mïöé%êRïÐ÷�í�õôø�ùOèsëMó|ñÎëMéôê�ç�èsðsï�îhï�èRðsï�è�éöQ´ùOëuìCïÙú ÷´ç:QPû{ø�ùtðsï#ü-ýþËêsï�ùOõôëMÿOëuèsí�ü�ø�ùtðRï�üâñ�í�ì�ñÎõCëMéCé%ï�èÙëuè�é%êRï�éôëuø�ï�ðsùOøÔí�ëuè�ý�÷´ù2ñBï���ï�õ � ìôëMèsó�ï�ñBï|ëuè�éôõôù ð��só�ï#ðù��sõÏøÔù ðsï#ütëMè{é%êsï���õôï��sï#èsó���ðsùOøÔí�ëuè � ñBïÎí�üuìCùPëuè�é%õCùtð��só�ï é%êsïË÷´ç:Q¡ø�ùtðsï#ütëMè{é%êRï ��õôï����Rï�èsó��ðsùOøÔí�ëMè�ý���ùOõLé%êRï�ù�õôëuÿ�ëuè�í�ühîsõCï�ìôï#è�é@íHéôëuùOè�ëuèöé%êRïwéôëuø�ïPðsùOøÔí�ëMèöìôï�ïeç â í � â�� ����� è ý

�&ï#é��|ú���ûB�mï¨éôêsï�ìCîmï#ó#éôõ��sø ù��âí�èsù�é%ïwñÎëMéôê îsëMéôó@ê��&ý���ìCëuèsÿ�éôêsï�êsí�õôø�ùOèsëMóPøÔù ðsï#ü � ñBïí�ìCì��sø�ï¨é%ê�íHéËéôêsïwìôîhï�ó4é%õ��Rø ó²í�è+�mï¨ñÎõCëMéôéôï�è�í�ì ��|ú���û�� "!¤ #¥ ó%$ ú'&�û�(Rú)�*&�µ+��û-,/.10¢ú2��û43 ú65�ý � û

ñÎêsï#õôï87 � 0¢ú:9Kû�í�èsð $ ú:9�ûBí�õôïPéôêsï¨ì%í�ø�ïwí�ìËëMè �tï�óHý ú6;sý â û+ýyx´ï�í�õôõôí�èsÿOëMèsÿ�ã����ý ú65�ý � ûyñ�ïwÿOï4éé%êRï�ï��tîsõôï#ìôìôëMùOè<��ù�õLé%êsïwèsùOëMìôï �0¢ú2��û=�>�|ú���ûϵ !¤ #¥ ó $ ú'&�û�(Rú)�*&�µ?��û , ª ú65�ý â û

@ÑïBëMøÔîhùOìôï íÎìôëMøÔîsüMëA�2� ëuèRÿËí�ìôìB�sø�îRé%ëMùOè��C��ìôï4éôéôëuèsÿ´é%êsï èsùOëMìôïD0¨é%ù��mïBí´øE�süMéôëA�Hí�õôëuíHé%ï�èsùOõôøÔí�üõ%íHèsðsùOøF�Hí�õCë1ía�süMïwí�èsðG�H�sõCéôêsï�õ�í�ìCì��sø�ëuèsÿ�é%êsíHéÎé%êsï�èsùOëuìCïI��íHüJ�sï#ì=íHé´ï�í�ó@ê<��õCï��sï�èRó��G��í�õCïìCé%íHé%ëMìCéôëuó²íHüuüA��ëMèsðsï�îhï�èRðsï�è�é´ñÎëMé%ê ï����sí�üK�Hí�õôëuí�èsó�ïHý(þËê�sì � é%êsïwèsù�ëuìôï¨ðRï�èsìCëMé-�L�H�sèsó4é%ëMùOè ëuìM úH0sû�� �ú â «�NtûPO�QSR ÂUTDVAW�VJXX�YñÎêsï#õôïZN�ëuì�é%êRï[�Hí�õôëuí�èsó�ïÐí�èsð"\ ëMìÔéôêsïÒè�sø��hï�õ|ù��¨ìôîhï�ó4é%õôí�ü=îhùOëuè�éôìÔó#ùOøÔî��Ré%ï#ðF��Õé%êRï;]

Page 54: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ðsëMìôó�õCï#éôï^��ù��Rõôëuï#õLé%õôí�èsìB��ù�õôø�ýâþ�íU_ ëMèsÿ�é%êsïwüMùOÿ�ù���éôêsï�ía�hù`��ïwðsï�èsìCëMé-�L�H�sèRó#é%ëMùOèöñ�ïwÿOï4é �üMùOÿ M ú60ba Ntû�� µ \ â üuùOÿ�ú â «�NtûϵFc 0 c Râ N ª ú65�ý � û@Ñïd��ù��sèsðÍéôêsï¨ø|í��RëMøe�sø üuëA_�ï#üuëuêRùtù ðÔï#ìCéôëuøÔíHé%ëMùOèf��ùOõ�éôêsï¨ÿ�í�ëMèf�Hí�üJ�Rï�ì $ ú'&�ûB�C�|é@íU_ ëMèsÿ�é%êRï

ðsï#õôëA�HíHéôëA��ï¨ù���üMùOÿ M ú60RûBñÎëMéôê õôï�ìCîmï#ó#é´é%ù $ úg&�û �h üMùOÿ M úH0sûh $ úg&�û �ôÝ i $dj úg&�û��>�|ú)�*&�û ª

�tëMøÔëMü1í�õCüA� � ñBï^��ù��sèRðÒé%êsï�øÔí��tëuøe�sø üuëJ_Hï�üMëuêsù ùtðöï#ìCéôëuøÔíHé%ëMùOèL��ùOõËé%êsï8��íHõôë1íHèsó�ïkN��C� é@í�_>ëuèRÿé%êRï�ðRï�õôël�HíHé%ël�Oï¨ù��ÏüuùOÿ M úH0sûBñÎëké%ê õôï#ìôîhï�ó4é�éôù�N �h üMùOÿ M ú60ba Ntûh N �ôÝ i N j � c 0 c R\ ª

S(üJ�sÿ�ÿOëuèsÿ�éôêsï�ía�hù`��ï�øÔí��tëuøE�sø üMëJ_�ï#üuëMêsùtù ð|ï#ìCéôëuøÔíHé%ùOõCìm��ùOõ $ í�èsðnN|ëuè�éôùeã����ýÏú65�ý � ûÎíHèsð�sìCëuèsÿ�é%êRï�ï��tîsõôï#ìôìôëMùOè<��ù�õo0Íëuè+ã����ýÏú65{ý â ûBñBï�ÿ�ï#éüuùOÿ M úH0pa N�qC3 $ j ûr� µ \ â ú�üMùOÿ�ú â « û�.ÕüMùOÿ�ú c 0 c R û�µ�üuùOÿ�ú6\ û(µ � û� Ã�. \ â üuùOÿts �c � c Ru 3 ú65�ý.nOû

ñÎêsï#õôï��òú2��û�ëMìËðsïfñsèsï�ðÐëuèÐ�tï�óHý ú6;sý â û+ý

;�n

Page 55: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

v Ò=w Ø(ÒÏÚyx©Í�ÈÊÉ Ç{zç � è üuï#ìo;¬Ý�é%ï�èRùOõôì#ý�ãàìÐço]Op â ÝQÝOp â ú�þLñBù�åiæPì%û4ýç â�è 5=õCëuï�è¢ý���í�ø�ù��sìLé%ï#èsùOõÎí�õCë1í�ì#ý¨æPï�ó#ó²í|;]aÝ�ÝQÝC]~} â ýç ��è ��ï�ìDé´ù���ù�îmï#õ%íRý¨æPëMì�_C��paÝ � á � â ýç�; è ���só�ëuí�èsù�î�í��Hí�õôùHéôé%ë ýsèsï#ìôì��RèÒðsùOõCø|í � í�õôëuí�ìËí�èRðÐð��Rï#é%ì#ýBæPï#ó�ó�í|;On�pe;�n â } â ýç�] è þËêsïI�Où��RèsÿÔðRùOøÔëMèsÿOùsýâ�]ìZ� n � ] â p ú�þLñBù�åiæPì%û4ýç?n èE� ý�5��Ró�ù��Ré��sõôëMï�õ�í�èRð¡�tí�èsðsüMï�õ4ìÑý�� ï�ÿOø�ï�è�é@í5é%ëuù�èÕùU��øE�sìôëMó²í�üLìCëuÿOèsí�üuìe�RìôëuèRÿÙêRëuðsðsï#è

ø|íHõ�_�ù~�|øÔù ðsï�üMì�ý����$ûa÷-�e�B} �a÷}�úYú4��÷} ��������÷�ú4� � ìÒí�� â ÝaÝ � ýç p è æ�ý&� �Réôüuï#õ�ýäü��?ú�þ��>~�÷-��÷�ê�}�� ~�����÷�û�ú����4ÿ?ú4�%�Yú�ÿh��÷-�5}õê�}§ûÙ�@�ô��}?÷��÷-�5}�ýÍ�tó@êRëuõôø�ï�õ���ù ù�_>ì �� íQí â ýç á è þ¨ý ìÙý�å�ù~��ï�õPíHèsð � ý�5{ý�þËêsùOøÔí�ì#ý��B�bú�þ�ú4}���~��P���+}��²�5��þ4ê���÷-�5}ýü��?ú@�5�+5ý � ùOêsèn@�ëuüMï��G�

�tùOèsì ��� íQí � ýç í è x�ý§æ¨í�èRèsï�èh�hï�õôÿRý�5=èÒùOè�}�üMëuèsï�í�üMÿOùOõCëMé%êRø���ùOõ�õôï²íHül}Æéôëuø�ïwí�ó�ó#ùOø�î�í�èsëMøÔï#è>é�ýd���%������4}��~� �� ��þ�ÿ*�t��ú4���[�>~�÷-� � �5}���ú4�kú4}¢�Yú ��� íQá�;sý

ç � Ý è þ¨ýIæPï²íHè�íHèsð8��ý�wí�è�ía��í�ñ�íRý�5�ø�ù ðsï�ü���ùOõ&õôï�í�ìôùOèRëuèsÿÎía�hù��Ré�îmï#õôìôëMìCéôï�è�éÏí�èsðwó²í��Rì%íHéôëuùOè�ý� ��þ�ÿ*�t��ê���÷-�5}§ê����4}���ú4�� ÷k��ú4}¢�Yú � ]sú � û�� � ; â Ó � ]aÝ �*� íQáaíRýç ��� è ìÑý-æPï#ëuìCêsï�õ�íHèsð�5{ýâ�tî�í�èsëuí�ì�ý�÷´øÔø�}��sí�ìôï#ðòìôîhï�ï#ó@ê¸ï#èsê�í�èsó#ï�ø�ï�è�é��sìôëMèsÿÌê�íHõôø�ùOèsëuó

øÔù ðsï#üuëuèRÿsýâ� � �¨�����|� �������h�5�l�p����ÿ����C���`� ��� íQíOptýç � â�è 5{ý �mý�æd�sõCï���íHèsð�ìÑý5�ý�å�üuï�ø�ï�è�éôì�ýÀìÐï#üuù ð���ìCîmù�éCé%ëMèsÿ^�RìôëuèRÿ�êsëMðsðsï#èÔøÔí�õ�_Hù~��øÔù ðsï�üMì�ý

ç�èZ���%���YúYúTûa÷} �5~��P�w���?ú��+}��Aú4�+}§ê���÷-�5}§ê��¢���þ�ÿ���~�÷2�%þ �5}<�Z��~�÷-�=�4}��²�5��þ4ê���÷-�5}n�~ú4����÷�ú�ë�ê�� �î�í�ÿOï#ì � ÝQí2Ó ��� p � �Büuù ùOøÔëMèsÿ�éôùOè � ç:Q � TPó#éôùQ�hï�õ â ÝQÝ � ýç � ��èE� ý ìÙý�ã íHõôÿOüMï�ý��[�>~�÷-� �y����� }§û��Bê�}§û­ü§ú@�@� }¢�5�u�ô��Hý�� íHèÐQ´ùOìCéôõ%í�èRðÒxÎï�ëMèsêsùOüMð ��� íaíQÝRý;>p

Page 56: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ç � ; èE� ý~��ùtùHé%ï�ýU5=è�ù~�Oï�õ:� ëuï#ñòù��síU�sðsëuùËëMè���ùOõCø|íHéôëuùOè=õôï#éôõôëMï��Hí�ü-ýC�[�t����÷±þ�úTûa÷�ê=��2~4��ú�þ{~ � psú � û¡� â Ó� Ý �K� íQíQíRýç � ] è 5{ý¢�¨êsë1í�ì � � ýh��ù�ÿ�í�è � æ�ý¥å�ê�í�ø��hï�õCüuëMè � í�èsðÒ�=ý å=ým�tø�ëMéôê�ý¤£d�sï#õB�|�C��ê��RøÔø�ëuèsÿ��iì<��}

ìôëMó²í�ü´ëuè���ù�õôøÔíHé%ëMùOè�õôï#éôõôëMï��Hí�ü=ëMè í�è íU�sðsëuù�ð�íHé@í���í�ìôïHý ç�è¥� � � �[�t����÷±þ�úTûa÷�ê � î�í�ÿOï#ìâ�� � Ó â�� n �¢� íQíC]týç � n è ��ý¦��ý¡ç�èsÿOüMï í�èsð � ý§��ý¡S(õôù�í�_>ëMì�ý ¨�÷k�a÷��ê�� ��÷k��}§ê��©�B�@���Yú@~@~�÷} �ª�>~�÷} �ª��ê�� ��ê���ý

��õôù ù�_>ìYîaå�ùOüuï � â ÝQÝQÝtýç � p è æ�ý`�¨ùOüuüMï�õ�í�èsð{Q�ýU��õôëuï#ðsøÔí�è�ýOç�è�é%õCùtð��só#éôëuùOè�é%ù=îRõôùQ��í��sëuüMëuìCéôëuóâÿ�õ%í�îsêRëuó²íHü�øÔù ðsï�üMì � ê�í�èsð�}ù��Réôì�ý(ê�éôéôîK� îaî5ñËñËñwýoó#ì�ý ê��«Cë-ýoí�ó�ý ëuü�îb¬tîsøÔí�ë-ýç � á è ��ý���ï#øÔìDé%õCùOø í�èsð � ý�þ�íHõôêsëMùsýL� ï²í�õCó@êsëuèsÿ�ø�ùOèsùOîsêRùOèsëuówî�í5éôé%ï#õôèsìÎñÎëMéôêsëuè îhùOüA� îsêRùOèsëuó

ìôù��Rõôó�ï#ì�ý�ç�è­�B�%���� � �5}��Aú4}����'®¶ê5~IúTût�Z� ����÷±þ�úTûa÷�ê|�4}��²�5��þ4ê���÷-�5}[�=�@�Yú@~@~n¯g�L���e°±� ��²C²C² ³ �î�í�ÿOï#ì � â n � Ó � â paí � 5=îRõôëuü â ÝQÝQÝRýç � í è x�ý-ìÐó²Q�ía� � �(ý(�tø�ëMéôê � æ�ýâ��í�ëuèh�sõCëuðsÿOï � í�èsð�ç@ýp@�ëMéôéôï�è�ý�þËêsï èsï4ñÊ�#ï²í�üuí�èsð�ðsëMÿOëMé%í�ü

üuëO�sõ%í�õ:�|ø�ï�üMùtð��|ëMèsðsï�� ��� íaí�ptýç â Ý è x�ý � ý¬ì�ó²Q=í�� � �(ý�5{ýO�tø�ëMé%ê � ç@ýO÷�ýU@�ëkéôé%ï#è � å=ý��(ý�÷�ï�èRðsï�õCìôùOè � í�èRð��mý � ýO���sèsèsëMèsÿOê�íHøÐý

þÏù�ñ�í�õôðÑé%êsïÔðsëuÿOëké@í�ü(øE�sìôëMóÔüMëb�sõôí�õB�*��é��sèsïÔõôï#éôõôëMï��Hí�ü���õôùOø í�ó#ù��sìDé%ëuó�ëuèRî��Ré²ý ç�è©�B�%����� � �´¨�÷k�a÷�«ê��¢�²÷����yê���÷�ú@~ �K� íQí�nRýç â � è ìÑý�ìÐù�èsÿOï²íU�ÐíHèsð+æ�ý��Rí�è�_�ùaÞÏýàå�ùOø�î�í�õôëMìôùOèöùU�ÏøE�sìôëMó²í�ümìôï��sï#èsó�ï#ì�ý � ��þ�ÿ*�t��ú4�%~�ê�}§û

���?ú=zd��þ4ê�}?÷��÷�ú@~ ���~µ*¶2��·���¸t���`� �K� íQíQÝtýç âQâ�è 5{ý?��ýâT¨îRîmï#èsêsï�ëMøæí�èRð¸xwý¹@ ý(�tó@ê�í���ï�õ�ýº¨�÷k�a÷��ê�� ��÷k��}§ê����B�@���Yú@~@~�÷} ��ý�S(õCï�è�é%ëMó�ï�}�÷=í�üMü �� í�p�] ýç â���è �(ýsS�íHõôõ%í�íHèsðG��ý � íHëuè�ýp5=îsîRõôù��tëuøÔíHé%ïd_5í�üMø|íHèeñ�üké%ï�õCëuèsÿ^��ùOõ�é%êRïPê�í�õCøÔùOèRëuó=îRüJ�sìLèRùOëuìCï

øÔù ðsï#ü-ýH� �D�D�¼»Ì�5�¾½�~@���YÿÍ�5}8�Bÿ¬ÿh� ÷-�Tê���÷-�5}R~��P�(��÷k��}§ê��U�B�@���Yú@~@~�÷} �´�:�m���$ûa÷-�¶ê�}§ûo�P�@����~4���÷-�@~ � â ÝQÝ � ý

ç â ; èE� ý¿��ýHSyõCù�í�_>ëuìâí�èsð4æ�ý¿��ýaìÒí�èsùOüuí�_>ëuì#ý¢¨�÷k�a÷��ê��t��÷k��}§ê����B�%���Yú@~@~�÷} ��ý�S(õôï#è�é%ëuó#ï�}�÷=í�üMü ��� íQíOnRýç â ] è �(ý�xwý�x´ía�sëMèsï�õÏí�èsð��=ýO÷�ý � ��íHèsÿsý�5�è�ëuè�é%õCùtð��só#éôëuùOèwé%ùPêRëuðsðsï#è�ø|íHõ�_�ù~��ø�ùtðsï#üuì#ýs�¾���D��¨�����À��ê��¬ê~Áq÷}�ú � � ú � û���;5Ó � n � � í�è��í�õ:� � íQá�nRýç â n è å=ý�x´í�îsêsí�ï�ü ýn5��Ré%ù�ø|íHéôëuó�ìôï#ÿOø�ï�è�é@íHéôëuùOèÑù��Îí�ó#ù��sìDé%ëuóÔøe�sìCëuó²íHü ìCëuÿOèsí�üuìk�sìCëuèsÿÌêRëuðsðsï#è

ø|íHõ�_�ù~��øÔù ðsï�üMì�ýÕ�¾���D� ���yê�}R~qê �4��÷-�5}R~Ð�5}©�iê�� ��ú4�+}º�=}§ê���2~�÷u~+ê�}§ûÂ��ê �@��÷}�úÔ�4}���ú4�� ÷���ú4}¢�Yú � â � ú6;>û � 5=îsõCëuü � íQíQíRý ;¬á

Page 57: ttic.uchicago.eduttic.uchicago.edu/~shai/papers/ShalevThesisQueryByMelody.pdf021 354*6 78354*6 9;:=@3A4CBD6FEHGJI KJL 0NMPORQSQST%UPQWV QYXZT KJ[X\VJV^]_Va` bcV@Md L QSTfe

ç â p è þ¨ý�x´ùa�sëuèsìCùOè�ýy� îmï#ï�ó@êÜí�èsí�üA� ìôëMì � ù�èsüuëMèsï=é¾�té%ùOõCë1í�ü ýê�éôé%î�� îQî5ìB� õ:}-ñËñËñwýoï#èsÿsý ó²í�ø�ý.íHó�ý���_%îb¬�í~«CõYîO��5�íC]Qîtýç â á èE� ýKT�ý�� øÔëké%ê�ý¨ìn�sì �¬â Ý��yç�è>éôõôù ð��só4é%ëuù�è éôùÔðRëuÿOëké@í�ümí��sðsëMù�ìôëuÿ�è�í�ü�îsõCùtó#ï�ìCìôëuèRÿsý

ê�éôé%î�� îQî2ñËñËñm}�ó�ó#õôøÔíRý ìCé@íHè���ùOõôð¢ýoï#ð���îHó#ù��sõôìCï�ìkî �¬â ݬî`@�ï#üuó�ù�øÔïHýoê�é%ø�ü-ýç â í èE� ý�þÏía�sõCëJ_>ë1í�è � �mý(æd���sèRù`� � í�èsð»ï�ý-æPëuó _5í�üMù~�mýÑ�tîhï�ï#ó@ê¸ï#èsê�í�èRó�ï�ø�ï�è�é4�C�òê�íHõôø�ùOèsëuó

øÔù ðsï#üuëuèRÿE� ë1í�øÔí�î îsëMéôó@ê�éôõ%í�ó _>ëuèRÿsý � � �P��������²C²����¤°L�+��ê�}§û �~��Ãy�u�5��÷�û¬ê � â ÝaÝ â ýç � Ý è ��ý þ]�²íHèsï#é%í�_>ëuì�í�èsð�S ý(å�ù ù�_�ýÄ5��sðsëMùÜëuè���ù�õôøÔíHé%ëMùOè�õôï#éôõôëMï��Hí�ü¨ú�í�ëuõ%ûwéôùtùOüMì�ýÌç�èÅ�B�%����

�4}���ú4�+}§ê���÷-�5}§ê��h���þ�ÿ���~�÷2��þ �5}[�[�>~�÷-�=�+}��²�5��þ4ê���÷-�5}n�~ú4����÷�ú�ë�ê�� � â ÝQÝQÝRýç � � è SÏý � ý¢@�í�üuø�ìôüMï�� � �mý � ýb�¨ùtðsìCëuüMü � í�èsðÙSÏý � ý¹@ ý&x�í�� èsï#õ�ý�SÏùOül�tîRêsùOèsëMó�îsëMéôó@êÜé%õ%íHó _ ëMèsÿL�sìP}

ëuèsÿk«CùOëuè�é���í���ï�ìôëuí�èÙï�ìCéôëuøÔíHé%ëMùOèÌù�� øe�RüMé%ëMîsüuïk��õ%íHøÔï�îsí�õ%í�ø�ï#éôï�õCì�ý{ç�è­�B�%����m�C�C�C�|��úYúYú»Ì�5�¾½�~@���YÿÜ�5}f�iÿ¬ÿh� ÷-�Tê���÷-�5}R~¨�P�´��÷k��}§ê������%���Yú@~@~�÷} �����k���$ûa÷-��ê�}§û8�=�@����~4��÷-�@~ � TPó#é%ùa�mï#õ� íQíQítý

;’