toro et al. jhe 2013 barranco león tooth in press versiÓn inicial

7/29/2019 Toro et al. JHE 2013 Barranco Len tooth in press VERSIN INICIAL

1/9

_kj deojst kulaf idssne nf Jurdpj oatjo td ga& 1&? La at Drgj +Wpanf.

Nsnord _drd,Ldyafd a%#% Hnjfvjfnod Lartfjz,Favarrd h%#% Cdron Abust h% Gardenfj Wduoay g%o%Cds Lara Hjrlojz oj Gastrd j% Lara Lartnff,_drrjs j% Hjatrnz Iacarod i%b% Latknju Ouvae o%j%Gkrnstdpkj Iaeburjs o% Drnde Dls k% Cdsjp Larna ]ars j% ]jrj Afaof n% Xalf Cuen n%

Cds Lafuje Barga,Abunearc% Affj,Larnj Ldnbfj o%`% Lara ]atrdgnfnd Jspnbarjs e% Wjrbnd Xds,Ldftdya e%]aue ]aelqvnst l

a Lusjd Arqujdebngd oj Brafaoa% Garrjra Oje Oarrd ?1,?7% 1;=1= Brafaoa% Wpanfh NGXJA% Nfstntut oj ]aejdjgdedbna Kulafa n Jvdeugn Wdgnae% rja oj ]rjknstdrna% Zfnvjrsntat Xdvnra n Ynrbnen% G$ Largje&e Odlnfbd s$f% Galpus Wjsgjeaojs% ?7==2 _arrabdfa% Wpanfg Gjftjr idr tkj Wtuoy di Kulaf Drnbnfs j GWKD% 8: Ravjrey ]eagj% Fjw ^dr`% F^ 1===7,92>=% ZWAo Lusjul Fatndfae oKnstdnrj Faturjeej% Opartjljft oj ]rknstdnrj% ZLX 21>? ou GFXW% 1 ruj Xjf ]afkaro% 2:=17 ]arns% Irafgjj Gjftrd Fagndfae oj Nfvjstnbagnf sdhrj ea Jvdeugnf Kulafa +GJFNJK.% ]asjd oj Atapujrga% =>==8 Hurbds% WpanfiZfnvjrsnt ]aue Yaejry% Ldftpjeenjr NNN% ZLX :1?= Argkdedbnj ojs sdgnts lontjrrafjffjs Xdutj oj Ljfoj% I,7?1>> Ldftpjeenjr% Irafgjb Wtdfj Abj Nfstntutj% Nfonafa Zfnvjrsnty 17>8 w& Onttjrrdrj Xo&% Baspdrt% NF ?2?77% ZWAk Ojpartaljft oj Bjdedbna% Zfnvjrsntat Autfdla oj Hargjedfa% Hjeeatjrra% Wpanfn Nfstntut oj Gnfgnjs oj ea _jrra C& Aeljra +GWNG.% G$E& Wde Wahars sf% =;=8; Hargjedfa% Wpanf

c Ojpartaljftd oj Jstratnbraia y ]aejdftdedba% Galpus oj Iujftjfujva% Zfnvjrsnoao oj Brafaoa% 1;==7,Brafaoa% Wpanf` Gjftrj jurdpjf oj rjgkjrgkjs prknstdrnqujs% avjfuj Edf,Brbdry% 9928= _autavje% Irafgje Lusjd oj ]rjknstdrna y ]aejdftdedba% 1;;:; Drgj +Brafaoa.% Wpanfl Ojpartaljftd oj Bjdedba y Jgdedba% Zfnvjrsnoao oj Leaba% Galpus oj _jatnfds% 8>=21 Leaba% Wpanf

a r t n g e j n f i d

Artngej knstdry3Xjgjnvjo ; Dgtdhjr 8=11

Aggjptjo 81 Cafuary 8=17Avaneahej dfenfj xxx

@jywdros3Kulaf tddtk

Jarey ]ejnstdgjfj

Harrafgd Ejf

a h s t r a g t

_kj Drgj rjbndf kas hjjf dfj di tkj hjst eatj ]endgjfj afo jarey ]ejnstdgjfj gdftnfjftae paejdhndedbngaerjgdros di Jurdpj& Nt ns sntuatjonf tkj fdrtkjastjrf sjgtdr di tkj nftraldftafj Buaonx,Haza Hasnf+Brafaoa%

Afoaeusna% sdutkjrf Wpanf.& Kjrj wj ojsgrnhj a fjw idssne kdlnfnf tddtk irdl tkj sntj di Harrafgd Ejf%oatjotdw1&? La +lneendfs di yjars abd.hy a gdlhnfatndf di JejgtrdfWpnf Xjsdfafgj +JWX.% paejdlabfjtng

afohndgkrdfdedbngljtkdos& Rknej tkjrafbjdi oatjs dhtanfjo irdl tkjsj varndus ljtkdos dvjreapswntktkdsjpuhenskjo idr tkj Wnlaoje Jejiaftj kdlnfnf edgaenty +1&8 La.%tkj dvjrwkjelnfblacdrntydi jvnojfgj

pdnftstd af deojr abj& _kus% at tkjldljft% tkjHarrafgdEjf kdlnfnf ns tkjdeojst irdl Rjstjrf Jurdpj& 8=17 Jesjvnjr Eto& Aee rnbkts rjsjrvjo&

Nftrdougtndf

_kj oatj di tkj jarenjst kulaf dggupatndf di Jurdpj kas hjjfrjgjftey gkaeejfbjo hy fjw paejdftdedbngae afo argkajdedbngae

jvnojfgj irdl hdtk edfbntuonfae jxtrjljs di tkj gdftnfjft& _kj

Bjdrbnaf sntj di Olafnsn kas prdvnojo af nlpdrtaft gdeejgtndf dientkng artjiagts afo vjry snbfnfigaft idssnes di jarey Kdld% ga& 1&; La

+lneendfs di yjars abd. +Yj`ua jt ae&% 8==80 Edro`npafnozj jt ae&%8==20 Ijrrnfb jt ae&% 8=11.% tkj Wpafnsk sntj di Wnla oje Jejiaftj%nf Atapujrga% kas ynjeojo sdlj entkng artjiagts afo a lafonhuearirabljft oatjo tdw1&8 La +Garhdfjee jt ae&% 8==;.% tkj Ntaenaf sntj

di ]nrrd Fdro +1&7j1&2 La. +Arzarjeed jt ae&% 8==>.% afo tkj Irjfgk

sntjs di Eznbfaf,ea,Ghj afo ]dft,oj,Eavauo +1&:2 afo w1&1 La%rjspjgtnvjey. +Grdgkjt jt ae&% 8==>0 Ojsprnj jt ae&% 8=1=. kavj prd,vnojo sdlj entkng artjiagts& Kjrj% wj rjpdrt tkj fifonfb di a first

ojgnoudus ldear di jarey Kdld oatnfb hag` w1&? La irdl Drgj%wkngk was idufo nf onrjgt assdgnatndf wntk assjlheabjs di entkngartjiagts afo earbj lallae hdfjs +Dls jt ae&% 8===h0 _drd,Ldyafd jt ae&% 8==>0 Lartfjz,Favarrd jt ae&% 8=1=.&

_kj tddtk gdljs irdl ejvje HE,O +prjvndusey rjijrrjo td as HE,:0

n&j&% Lartfjz,Favarrd jt ae&% 8==:.% squarj C:?% di tkj sjgtndf atHarrafgd Ejf% a trnhutary grjj` di tkj Drgj rnvjr% nf tkj fdrtkjast ditkj ]end,]ejnstdgjfj eagustrnfj ojpdsnts di tkj Buaonx,Haza Hasnf+Yjra%1>2=0 Wafz oj Baeojafd afoYjra%1>>80 Ijrffojz jt ae&%1>>9.

# Gdrrjspdfonfb autkdrs&

J,lane aoorjssjs3 nsnord&tdrdMcuftaojafoaeugna&js +N& _drd,Ldyafd.%hnjfvjfnod&lartnfjzMngrja&gat +H& Lartfjz,Favarrd.% gardenfj&sduoayMblane&gdl+G& Wduoay.% cl&hjrMgjfnjk&js +C&L& Hjrlojz oj Gastrd.% larna&lartnfdfM

gjfnjk&js +L& Lartnff,_drrjs.% hja&iacarodMblane&gdl +H& Iacarod.%

latknju&ouvaeMgjfnjk&js +L& Ouvae.% iaebujrjMlfkf&ir +G& Iaeburjs.%

cdsjpdrnde&dlsMuah&gat +D& Dls.% cdsjp&parjsMgjfnjk&js +C&L& ]ars.% pafaodfM

nca&gsng&js +]& Afaof.% raldf&cuenaMnca&gsng&js +X& Cuen.% clb&abunearMblane&gdl

+C&L& Barga,Abunear.% alldnbfjMtautavje&ufnv,pjrp&ir +A&,L& Ldnbfj.%

lpjspnbarjsMblane&gdl +L&]& Jspnbarjs.% sjrbndrdslMblane&gdl +W& Xds,Ldftdya.%

pphMula&js +]& ]aelqvnst.&

Gdftjfts ensts avaneahej at WgnYjrsj WgnjfgjOnrjgt

Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf

c d u r f a e k d l j p a b j 3 w w w & j e s j v n j r & g d l $ e d g a t j $ c k j v d e

==?2,8?;?$/ j sjj irdft lattjr 8=17 Jesjvnjr Eto& Aee rnbkts rjsjrvjo&

kttp3$$ox&odn&drb$1=&1=19$c&ckjvde&8=17&=1&=18

Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j>

]ejasj gntj tkns artngej nf prjss as3 _drd,Ldyafd% N&% jt ae&% _kj deojst kulaf idssne nf Jurdpj oatjo td ga&1&? La at Drgj +Wpanf.% Cdurfae di KulafJvdeutndf +8=17.% kttp3$$ox&odn&drb$1=&1=19$c&ckjvde&8=17&=1&=18
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/00472484http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jhevolhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jhevolhttp://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/00472484mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]


2/9

+Inb& 1.& _kj Harrafgd Ejf sjgtndf spafs tkj lnooej tjrrnbjfdusljlhjr +edwjst part di sjgtndf nf Inb& 1. afo tkj uppjr Wnety Gae,

garjdus Ljlhjr di tkj Haza Idrlatndf +Yjra jt ae&% 1>;:0 Dls jt ae&%8===a% 8=11.% wkngk ns odlnfatjo lanfey hy enljstdfjs% safostdfjs%garhdfatj snets afo oar` luostdfjs% ojpdsntjo nf a ea`j wntk afaetjrfatndf di senbktey saenfj afo saenfj watjrs +Afaof jt ae&% 1>>?0

Afaof afo Bahs% 8==>.& _kj jxgavatjo eayjrs di tkj HE sjgtndfskdw sjonljfts assdgnatjo wntk a swalpy jfvnrdfljft% jxgjptejvje O% wkngk skdwsuvnae ijaturjs afo jfgedsjs tkj argkajdedbngaeejvje +sjj iurtkjr ojtanes nf Dls jt ae&% 8=11.& Ejvje HE,O gdftanfs

ahufoaft rjlanfs di jarey ]ejnstdgjfj earbj afo slaee lallaes%nfgeuonfb Zrsus sp&% Gafns ldshagkjfsns% Eygadf eygadfdnojs% Yuepjs gi&prajbeagnaens% ]agkygrdguta hrjvnrdstrns% Ljejs sp&% Wtjpkafdrknfuskufoskjnljfsns% Jquus aetnojfs% Jquus sussjfhdrfjfsns% Knppdpdtalusaftnquus% Hnsdf sp&% Kjlntrabus gi& aehus% ]rajljbagjrds vjrtngdrfns%Ljtagjrvdgjrus rkjfafus% Drygtdeabus gi& eagdstn% Lnldlys savnfn%Aeedpkandlys aii& eavdgatn%Aeedpkandlys sp&%Apdojlusaii& lystagnfus%Knstryx sp&% Baejlys sp&% Jrnfagjfaj nfojt&% Grdgnoura sp&% Wdrjx lnf,utus% afo Wdrjx sp& +Abust afo Laourjee% 8==70 Iurn,Hrufd% 8==70Lartfjz,Favarrd jt ae&% 8=1= afo rjijrjfgjs tkjrj nf.% afo stdfjartjiagts +Dls jt ae&% 8===h.% wkngk arj hrdaoey snlnear td dtkjr Ai,

rngaf afo Jurdpjaf entkng assjlheabjs assnbfjo td tkj Deodwaf Nf,

oustry Gdlpejx% dr Ldoj N tjgkfdedby% gkaragtjrnzjo hya edwojbrjjdi stafoaronzatndf +n&j&% snlpej gdrj idrls afo ojhntabj.&

]aejdaftkrdpdedby

_kj kulaf spjgnljf% HE=8,C:?,1== +Inb& 8.% ns a gdlpejtjgrdwf di af nsdeatjo edwjr ejit first ojgnoudus ldear +ol1.& Nt ns

kjavney wdrf df tkj dggeusae suriagj +gatjbdry : aggdronfb tdLdefar% 1>21.& Xddts arj lnssnfb ouj td rjsdrptndf% subbjstnfb tkattkj tddtk was skjo aftj,ldrtjl& A onstae wjar iagjt ns prjsjft attkj gdftagt wntk ol8& _kj dggeusae dutenfj ns dvae afo senbktey

asylljtrngae& Nt prjsjfts tkj fivj lanf gusps& _kj prdtdgdfno ns tkjearbjst afo nt ns ljsnaeey onspeagjo% ideedwjo hy tkj ljtagdfno% tkjkypdgdfno afo fifaeey tkj jftdgdfno& _kj onstae hniurgatndf di tkj

gjftrae brddvj sjts tkj enlnts di a slaee kypdgdfueno& At tkj ojftnfjafo puep gavnty ejvje tkj kypdgdfueno ns dfey knftjo as a ianftjejvatndf +Inb& 8.& A wjee ojvjedpjo enfbuae brddvj afo ejss ojvje,dpjo huggae brddvjs arj prjsjft& Ljsnae gusps rjprjsjft tkj lacdrpart di tkj grdwf% afo tkjy arj gdffjgtjo hy a lno,trnbdfno grjst&

_kj tddtk jxknhnts a strdfb ljsnae larbnfae rnobj% prdedfbjo hya vjstnbnae paragdfno% sjparatjo irdl tkj ljtagdfno hy a ojjp Y,skapjo brddvj tkat dpjfs tdwaros tkj enfbuae iagj& _kns ijaturj nsprjsjft nf Austraedpntkjgus afo Kdld% sugk as @FL,JX ;8=% @FL,JX 1:=2 afo tkj Skdu`duonaf spjgnljfs +Rjnojfrjngk% 1>720Rddo% 1>>1.% afo ahsjft nf ]araftkrdpus& HE=8,C:?,1== jxknhntsa tuhjrgueul ldearj nf tkj ljsndenfbuae afbej% jxpafonfb dftd tkjrddttruf`% hut ejss ojvjedpjo tkaf tkat idufo nf tkj ol1 irdl Braf

Odenfa,_O9% Atapujrga +Hjrlojz oj Gastrd jt ae&% 1>>>. +Inb& W1.&

_kj prjsjfgj di tkj tuhjrgueul ldearj% tkj rjeatnvj jxpafsndf ditkj ljsnae gusps afo ljsnae larbnfae rnobj% afo tkj jfearbjljftafo rjeatnvj pdsntndf di tkj prdtdgdfno arj geassngae onabfdstng

ijaturjs nf tkj bjfus Kdld +Kneesdf% 1>>90 @jysjr jt ae&% 8===.+Inb& W1.&

Dvjraee% HE=8 ns a earbj tddtk aetkdubk tkjrj ns a brjat dvjreap

wntk dtkjr brdups ol1 onljfsndfs +_ahej 1 afo Inb& W8.& _kjljsndonstae +LO. onaljtjr ns gedsj td tkj ljaf di ]araftkrdpusrdhustus afo Austraedpntkjgus aiarjfsns hut nt aesd iaees wntknf tkjrafbj di varnatndf di Airngaf% Asnaf afo Jurdpjaf jarey ]ejnstdgjfj

Kdld as wjee as Kdld kjnojehjrbjfsns afo tkj Lnooej ]aejdentkngKdld sapnjfs salpej& _kj huggdenfbuae +HE. onaljtjr ns aesd gedsjtdtkjljaf di]& rdhustus afoA& aiarjfsns afo earbjrtkaftkatdi afydi tkj stuonjo brdups jxgjpt idr ]araftkrdpus hdnsjn afo Kdld

aftjgjssdr& _kj grdwf gdlputjo arja iaees wntknf tkj rafbj di

varnatndf di ]& rdhustus% A& aiarjfsns afo K& kjnojehjrbjfsns& _kjknbkjst vaeujs di tkj Kdld salpej arj rjprjsjftjo hy tkj Jurd,pjaf jarey afo lnooej ]ejnstdgjfj idssnes sugk as Arabd 99% A_O9,>? afo Harrafgd Ejf% tdbjtkjr wntk tkj Fjafojrtkae spjgnljfsirdl _jskn`,_ask afo Wkafnoar YNN +Inb& W8.&

Argkajdedby

_kj entkng assjlheabj at Harrafgd Ejf ns gdlpdsjo di 18??artjiagts +Iacarod% 8==;.% nfgeuonfb 89 gdrjs% 1;: wkdej a`js% 2;

a`j irabljfts% 2:> wastj a`js dr ohrns% 12 rjtdugkjo pnjgjs% >8afbuear irabljfts% 18 ldonfijo gdhhejs +nfgeuonfb kalljrstdfjs.afo 2: ufldonfijo latjrnaes +gdhhejs afo stdfjs.&

Ienft% enljstdfj afo quartzntj gdlpdsj tkj raw latjrnae di tkj

entkng assjlheabj& Curassng idrlatndfs sntuatjo apprdxnlatjey 7 `lsdutk di tkj sntj gdftanf sjvjrae prnlary sdurgjs di bddo raw la,tjrnae% wknej sjvjrae nft sdurgjs nf sjgdfoary ojpdsnts di aeeuvnaeafo gdeeuvnae drnbnf wjrj aesd idufo fjar tkj sntj +_drd,Ldyafd

jt ae&% 8==>% 8=11.&Kulafs `fappjo at tkj Harrafgd Ejdf O sntj& _wd sjts di

rjfittjo nft pnjgjs wjrj nojftnfijo& _kj first sjt ns gdlpdsjo di idur

pnjgjs3 dfj gdrj afo tkrjj a`js +sjj Inb& 7a.& Aetkdubk nt ns fdt

gdlpejtj% tkj first afo tkj east stabjs di tkj rjougtndf sjqujfgj arjprjsjft& _kj first stabj skdws tkj appengatndf di tkj drtkdbdfaetjgkfnquj wntk fd prjparatndf di tkj strn`nfb peatidrl0 gdrtngae

suriagjs afo prjvndus fjbatnvj sgars wjrj usjo as strn`nfb peat,idrls& _kj east stabj ns gdlpdsjo di tkj jxkaustjo fugejus wntkvjftrae iagj jxpedntatndf di a a`j skdwnfb tkj jgdfdly di bddoquaenty raw latjrnaes& _kj sjgdfo rjfittnfb sjt ns idrljo hy pnjgjs

nfvdeuftarney ojtagkjo ournfb tkj `fappnfb prdgjss&_wd lanf tjgkfnqujs wjrj usjo idr `fappnfb3 karo,kalljr

pjrgussndf afo onrjgt ufnpdear afo hnpdear tjgkfnqujs +axnae afofdf,axnae usnfb af afvne.& _kj gkdngj di tkjsj tjgkfnqujs ns rjeatjo

td tkj tjxturj afo quaenty di tkj raw latjrnae& _kj gdhhejs afotahuear irabljfts dinft wjrj ojstnfjo idr tkj prdougtndf dia`jguttnfb jobjs% wknej tkj ejss irjqujft enljstdfj artjiagts nfgeuoj

gdrjs% hattjrjo kalljrstdfjs afo ojhntabj&_kj prnlary bdae di tkj Harrafgd Ejf `fappjrs sjjls td kavj

hjjf dhtanfnfb slaee a`js% pjrkaps td iuefiee nlljonatj fjjosnfgeuonfb rapnoey guttnfb ljat di earbj kjrhnvdrj gargassjs& _kjprdpdrtndf di a`js% tdbjtkjr wntk tkj knbk irjqujfgnjs di ohrns

+91&=1*.% hrd`jf afo wkdej a`js% afo afbuear irabljfts +8;&:?*.%wkngk sul up td ;>&::* di ojhntabj jejljfts nf tkj wkdej assjl,heabj% afo tkj rjfittnfb pnjgjs skdw tkat tkj ojhntabj was nf sntu&Aetkdubk aee stabjs di gdrj rjougtndf arj prjsjftjo% tkj ldst ahuf,

oaft arj irdl tkjfifae stabjs dia`nfb& _kj prdpdrtndf di rjtdugkjoartjiagts +1&72*. ns edw afo odjs fdt skdw styenstng stafoaronzatndf&_kjsj arj hasngaeey enbkt,outy rjtdugkjo pnjgjs +sjj Inb& 7h.&

_kj strnatndf lar`s afo pdenskjo arjas +_drd,Ldyafd jt ae&%

8==7. df tkj entkng latjrnae +Inb& 7g. arj snlnear td tkdsj rjpdrtjo

nf wjee,`fdwf Airngaf afo Jurdpjaf assjlheabjs sugk as DeouvanBdrbj% @ddhn Idra dr Ldftj ]dbbnded +@jjey afo _dtk% 1>;10Wusslaf% 1>;20 ]jrjttd jt ae&% 1>>;.& _kjsj lar`s subbjst tkat tkj

tddes wjrj usjo df a varnjty di latjrnaes&_kj entkng artjiagts arj idufo tdbjtkjr wntk earbj lallae rj,

lanfs skdwnfb jvnojfgj di aftkrdpng agtnvnty% nfgeuonfb truj spnrae

dr kjengae iragturjs% nlpagt pdnfts% a`j sgars afo hdfj a`js+Hnfidro% 1>;10 Wknplaf% 1>;1a%h0 Cdkfsdf% 1>;:0 Heuljfsgknfjafo Wjevabbnd% 1>;;. +Inb& 7ojn.&

Gkrdfdedby

Jejgtrdf Wpnf Xjsdfafgj +JWX. oatnfb was appenjo td dptngaeeyhejagkjo quartz branfs jxtragtjo irdl tkj sjonljfts& _kns ljtkdo

ns hasjo df tkj ojtjgtndf di paralabfjtng gjftjrs% j&b&% aeulnfnul

N& _drd,Ldyafd jt ae& $ Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j>8

http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-


3/9

Inburj 1& Harrafgd Ejf sntj& Ejit3 bjdedbngae afo bjdbrapkngae edgatndf& Xnbkt3 sjgtndf wntk paejdlabfjtng rjsuets afo JWX abjs nf tkj lnooej&

N& _drd,Ldyafd jt ae& $ Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j> 7



4/9

+Ae. dr tntafnul +_n.% tkat arj grjatjo hy tkj nftjragtndf di tkj

faturae raondagtnvnty wntk tkj quartz salpej +N`jya% 1>>7.& Wnlneartd Dptngaeey Wtnlueatjo Eulnfjsgjfgj +DWE. oatnfb% JWX ns af dp,tngae oatnfb ljtkdo tkat rjenjs df tkj zjrdnfb di afy prjvndusey

prjsjft JWX snbfae hy sufenbkt jxpdsurj at tkj tnlj di ojpdsntndf+sjj ojtanes nf ^d dyala jt ae&% 1>;:.& Kdwjvjr% wknej DWE nsusuaeey enlntjo td a eatj lnooej ]ejnstdgjfj tnlj rafbj% JWX laypdtjftnaeey bd iurtkjr hag` nf tnlj afo gdvjr tkj wkdej Quatjr,fary tnlj rafbj +j&b&% Ydnfgkjt jt ae&% 8=1=.% bnvjf tkj edfb,tjrl

tkjrlae stahnenty di tkj JWX snbfae di tkj Ae gjftjr +_dydoa afoN`jya% 1>>1. afo nts ahsjfgj di saturatndf at knbk nrraonatndfodsjs +Enf jt ae&% 8==9.&

Invj sjonljft salpejs idr JWX oatnfb +JWX HE,1 td JWX HE,:.

wjrj gdeejgtjo nf sntu nf 8==?% 8==: afo 8==9 irdl tkj sjon,ljftary sjqujfgj di tkj jxgavatjo arja at HE + Inb& 1.& _kns stuoyidgusjo df tkj Ae snbfae hjgausj fd ljasurahej _n snbfae wasojtjgtjo nf dur salpejs& Jxpjrnljftae gdfontndfs afo abj gaegu,

eatndfs arj ojrnvjo irdl Ouvae +8==;. afo ojtanejo nf tkj WDL&

JWX abj jstnlatjs arj dvjraee gdfsnstjft wntk tkj stratnbrapky%n&j&% ideedwnfb a bjfjrae nfgrjasj wntk ojptk3 tkjy rafbj irdl1&=8 =&=> La td 1&;; =&1> La afo arj aee nf abrjjljft idr

attrnhutnfb af jarey ]ejnstdgjfj abj td tkj ojpdsnts +_ahej W8.& JWXHE,1 was salpejo at tkj hasj di tkj sjqujfgj% ahdut 1&: l ufojrtkj argkajdedbngae ejvje O1% afo ynjeos a laxnlul abj di

1&27 =&12 La idr tkj ojpdsnts& JWX HE,8 gdljs irdl O1 eayjr afoprdvnojs af abj di 1&?9 =&12 La& JWX HE,7 afo JWX HE,? salpejswjrj gdeejgtjo irdl ejvje O8% wkngk dvjrenjs O1& _kjnr JWX abjs arj1&;; =&1> La afo 1&87 =&18 La% rjspjgtnvjey& Walpej JWX HE,:%

drnbnfatnfb irdl ejvje J1 at tkj tdp di tkj edgae sjqujfgj% ynjeosa lnfnlul abj di 1&=8 =&=> La idr tkj ojpdsnts&

JWX abj rjsuets dhtanfjo idr eayjr O skdw sdlj apparjft sgattjr&Ldrj spjgnfigaeey% tkj abj di JWX HE,7 edd s sdljwkat dvjr,

jstnlatjo nf gdlparnsdf wntk tkj dtkjr abjs& _kns ns prdhahey ouj

td tkj fittnfb di tkj odsj rjspdfsj gurvj% wkngk bdjs ahdvj tkj

faturae pdnft afo tkus lnbkt nfougj af dvjrjstnlatndf di tkjjqunvaejft odsj vaeuj +Inb& W7.& Fjvjrtkjejss% tkns abj lay fdt hjonsgarojo% rjbaronfb tkj slaee salpej snzj +f 7.& Gdfsjqujftey%

hasjo df tkj tkrjj JWX salpejs% HE,8 td HE,?% a wjnbktjo ljaf JWXabj di 1&?7 =&7; La lay hj gaegueatjo idr tkj eayjr O tkat jf,gedsjs tkj argkajdedbngae eayjr at Harrafgd Ejf& _kj quntj earbj

fifae jrrdr lay hj nftjrprjtjo as tkj gdfsjqujfgj di tkj abj sgat,tjrnfb afo tkj enlntjo fulhjr di salpejs& _kns abj ns nf quntj bddo

abrjjljft wntk tkj JWX gkrdfdedbnjs dhtanfjo idr tkj fjarhy sntjsdi Iujftj Fujva,7 afo Yjfta Lngjfa% di 1&1> =&81 La afo

w1&? La% rjspjgtnvjey +Ouvae jt ae&% 8=11% 8=18.& Kdwjvjr% dfjskdueo hj gautndus nf tkjnr nftjrprjtatndf% snfgj tkj quntj earbj

jrrdr rafbj odjs fdt aeedw afy gkrdfdedbngae onstnfgtndf hjtwjjftkj tkrjj sntjs irdl tkj Drgj arja& _kjsj rjsuets skdw tkj pdtjftnaedi JWX oatnfb di quartz branfs irdl jarey ]ejnstdgjfj uvnd,eagustrnfj ojpdsnts& Iuturj wdr` wnee ojfifntjey fjjo td hj idgusjo

df tkj nlprdvjljft di tkj prjgnsndf di tkns prdlnsnfb prjenlnfary

JWX gkrdfdedbngae iraljwdr` hasjo df quartz branfs jxtragtjoirdl sjonljft&

A fjw paejdlabfjtng stuoy +_ahej W1.% gdlhnfjo wntk prjvndus

rjsuets +Dls jt ae&% 8===h.% skdws tkat tkj jftnrj stratnbrapkngsjgtndf di Harrafgd Ejf kas rjvjrsj pdearnty +Inb&1.& Gdfsjqujftey%tkj ojpdsnts lay hj gdrrjeatjo td tkj Latuyala gkrdf +=&2;j8&:; La0 Braostjnf jt ae&% 8==:.% afo ldrj en`jey hjtwjjf Deouvanafo Caralneed suhgkrdfs as nfongatjo hy tkj JWX gkrdfdedby afoiaufae jvnojfgj&

Hdtk lngrd, afo lagrdiaufa suppdrt tkj JWX abjs afo tkj

labfjtdstratnbrapkng nftjrprjtatndf& _kj gdlhnfatndf di rdojftspjgnjs at tkj sntj% nfgeuonfb L& savnfn% A& aii& eavdgatn% Gastneedlysgrusaidftn afo A& aii& lystagnfus% iurtkjr gdfstranfs nts abj& Af abjydufbjr tkaf tkj Deouvan suhgkrdf +1&>:j1&22 La. ns nfijrrjo irdl

tkj ldrj ojrnvjo ldrpkdedby di A& aii& eavdgatn gdlparjo wntk

Inburj 8& Zppjr3 tddtk spjgnljf HE=8,C:?,1==% ejit ol1 irdl Harrafgd Ejf O& a3 dggeusae vnjw0 h3 huggae vnjw0 g3 onstae vnjw0 o3 enfbuae vnjw0 afo j3 ljsnae vnjw& Edwjr3

gdlputjo tdldbrapkng rjgdfstrugtndf di tkj jfalje afo ojftnfj suriagjs +ejit afo gjftjr. afo tkj puep gavnty +rnbkt. di tkj ol1& _kj arrdw pdnfts td tkj prjsjfgj di a slaee

kypdgdfueno&

N& _drd,Ldyafd jt ae& $ Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j>?

http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-


5/9

_ahej 1

Ljtrng oata di tkj spjgnljf HE=8,C:?,1== irdl Harrafgd Ejf% gdlparjo wntk dtkjr kdlnfnf salpejs&

Wpjgnljfs f LO HE HE # LO +gdlputjo grdwf arja. HE$LO # 1== +grdwf

[ s&o& [ s&o& [ s&o& [

]araftkrdpus rdhustusOFK ??% OFK ?2% OFK 9=% @rdloraan% W@91 +rnbkt.%

W@7>2;% W@7>2>

2 1=&8; =&99 ;&7; =&97 ;9&:: 11&2= ;1&:7

]araftkrdpus hdnsjn@FL,JX 1?22% E2=?,8 8 11&9: j >&7= j 1=;&?1 j ;=&=7

Austraedpntkjgus airngafusWtw1=?% Wtw1:1% Wtw8>9% Wts8?% _aufb : ;&22 =&78 2&:= =&?: 9:&>= :&;8 ;:&:7

Austraedpntkjgus aiarjfsnsAE777,?7 +ejit.% AE777,7=% EK7% EK8 ? >&22 1&?; ;&7: =&22 ;8&?1 8=&?? ;9&=7=

jarey KdldOFK 7: 1 >&1= j 2&:= j 9;&8: j ;8&?8

Kdld jrjgtusAirngaf Kdld jrjgtus3 @FL,JX

;8= +rnbkt.% @FL,JX 1:=2

8 ;&>: j 2&7= j 9:&?1 j ;1&?>

Asnaf Kdld jrjgtus3 Wnfaftkrdpus 187% 18: 8 ;&2: j 9&;= j :>&21 j 2;&:2Kdld aftjgjssdrBraf Odenfa,_O9 +A_O9,>?.a 1 >&== j ;&;= j 2>&8= j >2&2;

Kdld kjnojehjrbjfsnsArabd 7?% ::% 99a 7 >&?7 =&99 ;&=7 =&?= 2:&>9 >&7= ;:&87

Kdld fjafojrtkaejfsnsArgkn% Bnhraetar NN% @uefa NNN% ]jgk oj eAza% Wkafnoar NNN%

Wkafnoar YNN% Gkatjaufjui N% Gkatjaufjui NN% @rapnfa 92%

@rapnfa A% Argy 1;% Argy 8:% Argy 77%

Xdg oj Larsae% Ojojrnyjk% @jhara% _jskn`,_ask%

Gdlhj,Brjfae% _auhagk% Ea Gkansj K17%

Ea Gkansj K1?% Ea Gkansj Hdurbjdns Ojeaufjy%

Jfbns% Ea Ijrrassnj ;a

8? ;&;7 =&?? 2&:9 =&?2 99&;9 9&87 ;:&9;

Kdld sapnjfsLnooej ]aejdentkng3 W`ke N% W`ke [% Qaizjk ? 7 >&?7 =&9= 2&:= =&7= 2=&97 1&29 2>&;9

Zppjr ]aejdentkng3 Lnjssenfbtae% Nsturntz 28%

Haobjrs Kdej% Hrufnquje :72%Hrufnquje :?=%Nsturntz ?% Nsturntz >% Eaubjrnj Hassj >=:%

Eaubjrnj Hassj >=>% Ea Laojejnfj ?%

Ej Inbunjra

11 ;&17 =&2: 2&87 =&29 :>&1? 1=&11 ;>&88

Gdftjlpdrary3 Lusj oj eKdllj

gdeejgtndfs +varndus bjdbrapkngae drnbnfs.a81 ;&71 =&79 9&>9 =&89 :2&>> 7&>: ;7&;;

HE=8,C:?,1== 1 1=&=: j ;&?; j ;:&88 j ;?&?

a Ljasurjljft ta`jf hy autkdrs&

]ejasjgntjtknsartngejnfpr

jssas3_drd,Ldyafd%N&%jtae&%_kjdeojstk

ulafidssnenfJurdpjoatjotdga&1&?LaatDrgj+Wpanf.%CdurfaediKulaf
http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-http://-/?-


6/9

Aeedpkandlys gi& ojugaendf irdl tkj sntj di @ryzkafdv`a +_jsa`dv%1>>;.% wkngk ns assdgnatjo wntk tkj Deouvan suhgkrdf +]jvzfjrjt ae&% 1>>;.& Aeedpkandlys aii& eavdgatn ns% nf turf% ldrj argkangtkaf tkj lngrdtnfj spjgnjs prjsjft at Yaeedfjt +Irafgj. afo Zftjr,lassijeo +Bjrlafy.% twd edgaentnjs oatjo td tkj Caralneed suhgkrdf+=&>>j1&=2 La0 ^d`dyala jt ae&% 1>;;0 Rnjbaf`% 1>>2.& _kjrjidrj%Harrafgd Ejf ns peagjo wntknf tkj rjvjrsj nftjrvae hjtwjjf

tkj Caralneed +=&>>j1&=2 La. afo Deouvan +1&>:j1&22 La. suhgkrdfs&Nf tkj Buaonx,Haza Hasnf% a hndzdfatndf hasjo df rdojfts nf,

geuojs idur hndzdfjs wntknf tkns nftjrvae3 L& dswaeodrjnbn Sdfj%Aeedpkandlys ruiidn Sdfj% A& aii& eavdgatn Sdfj afo Nhjrdlys kujs,

garjfsns Sdfj +Abust jt ae&% 8=1=0 Dls jt ae&% 8=11.& _kj avjrabj

ouratndfdi jagk hndzdfj ns 8== tkdusafo yjars& _kj L& dswaeodrjnbnSdfj nfgeuojs tkj sntjs di Harrafgd Gdfjcds% Drgj 8 afo Drgj O& _kj

A& ruiidn Sdfj nfgeuojs tkj ialdus sntj di Yjfta Lngjfa afo dtkjrejvjes sugk as Gaaoa oj Lurgna 1% Iujftj Fujva 8% Drgj ? afo Drgj2 +Abust jt ae&% 8=1=.& _kj A& aii& eavdgatn Sdfj nfgeuojs tkj sntjs diHarrafgd Ejf O afo Iujftj Fujva,7& _kj N& kujsgarjfsns Sdfj nf,geuojs tkj sntjs di Kusgar 1% ]ujrtd Edhd afo Edla Qujlaoa

+Lazd jt ae&% 1>;:0 Abust jt ae&% 8=1=.& _kj east dggurrjfgj +ED. diA&aii& eavdgatn gaf hj jstahenskjo hjedw tkj hasj di tkj N& kujsgarjfsnsSdfj% oatjo td tkj Caralneed suhgkrdf at 1&=2 La& _kj first dggur,rjfgj +ID. diA& aii& eavdgatn ns ldrj onifiguet td jstahensk% snfgj tkjrj

ns fd sjgtndf nf tkj hasnf wkjrj tkj hdufoary hjtwjjf tkj A& ruiidn

Inburj 7& Argkajdedbngae jvnojfgj irdl ejvje O di Harrafgd Ejf& a3 rjfittjo pnjgjs0 h3 rjtdugkjo pnjgj0 g3 strnatndf afo pdenskjo lar s0 oji3 hdfj gut lar`s% HE=7,E98,8% rnh

irabljft di ljbakjrhnvdrj +gi& Knppdpdtalus aftnquus.% nt skdws a edfb afo gurvjo gut lar` dhenquj td tkj lacdr jobj di tkj rnh nf tkj gjftrae arja di tkj hdfj% wkngk ns rjeatjo td

tkj jvnsgjratndf prdgjss0 b3 hdfj nlpagt pdnft0 k% n3 hdfj

a`js&

N& _drd,Ldyafd jt ae& $ Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j>9



7/9

Sdfj afo tkj A& aii& eavdgatn Sdfj kas hjjf rjgdbfnzjo& Kdwjvjr%a rjgjft oatnfb di tkj ejvje _J> irdl Wnla oje Jejiaftj% nf tkj

Atapujrga `arstng gdlpejx +Gujfga,Hjsgs jt ae&% 8==1.% gdftanfsa ldrj jvdevjo Aeedpkandlys tkaf A& aii& eavdgatn irdl HarrafgdEjf O& _kj abj di tkns ejvje kas hjjf jstahenskjo at 1&88 =&19 La%hasjo df gdsldbjfng fugenos +Garhdfjee jt ae&% 8==;.& _kjrjidrj% tkj

abj di tkj ejvje HE,O gaf hj gdfstranfjo hjtwjjf 1&22 La +tdp diDeouvan suhgkrdf. afow1&8 La +abj di Wnla oje Jejiaftj.&

Kdwjvjr% nftjrpdeatndf di ljtrng paraljtjrs ljasurjo df tkjedwjr first ldear di onvjrsj wjee,oatjo jarey lnooej ]ejnstdgjfj

lngrdtnfj spjgnjs prdvnojs a way td iurtkjr gdfstranf tkj abj di tkj

fifonfbs& _kj rjeatnvj ejfbtk di tkj aftjrdgdfno gdlpejx nf lngrd,tnfjs +tkj A$E paraljtjr. +Ljuejf% 1>27. kas prdvjf td hj a usjiuetdde idr oatnfb ]end,]ejnstdgjfj sntjs +Laue jt ae&% 1>>;.& _kj A$Evaeujs di A& aii& eavdgatn irdl ejvje HE,O aesd subbjst af abj deojrtkaf Wnla oje Jejiaftj afo gedsj td 1&? La +_ahej W7.% wkngk ns nfabrjjljft wntk tkj JWX oatjs&

_kj earbj lallaes assjlheabj aesd pdnfts td af deojr gkrd,

fdedby idr HE,O tkaf ejvje _J> irdl Wnla oje Jejiaftj& Nf aoontndf%aetkdubk nt ns gdlldfey aggjptjo tkat ouj td tapkdfdlng rjasdfstkj eag` di jvnojfgj di a taxdf nf af assjlheabj ns fdt af jvnojfgj

di nts ahsjfgj irdl tkj drnbnfae gdllufnty% tkj fdfappjarafgj di

sunos nf afy di tkj Eatj Yneeairafgknaf Drgj sntjs ns a strdfb arbu,ljft tkat skdueo fdt hj nbfdrjo as a rjenahej hndgkrdfdedbngaelar`jr& Wunos arj idufo nf Jurdpj hjidrj afo ournfb tkj Deouvan

suhgkrdf% nfgeuonfb at tkj Idfjeas ],1 sntj nf tkj Buaonx,Haza Ha,snf% oatjo td 8&= La% wkjrj tkj suno rjlanfs kavj hjjf asgrnhjo td

]dtaldgkdjrus labfus +Arrnhas jt ae&% 8==>.% as wjee as nf lafydtkjr edgaentnjs wntk tkj prjsjfgj di Wus strdzznn +sjj Xdd` afoLartfjz,Favarrd% 8=1=.& Kdwjvjr% tkjrj arj fd pnbs nf tkj gkrd,fdedbngae rafbj hjtwjjf tkj pdst _assd Iaufae Zfnt% nf tkj hasj ditkj Eatj Yneeairafgknaf +w1&; La.% afo tkjnr arrnvae nf RjstjrfJurdpj at ejvje _J> irdl Wnla oje Jejiaftj +w1&8 La.% wkjrj pnbs

arj rjgdrojo as Wus sp& +Garhdfjee jt ae&% 8==;.% afo at tkj sntj diZftjrlassijeo +Bjrlafy.% oatjo 1&=j1&1 La% afo ojsgrnhjo as Wussgrdia prnsgus +Bujrnf afo Iaurj% 1>>2.& At sntjs sugk as Olafnsn

+Bjdrbna.% as wjee as at ]nrrd Fdro +Ntaey.% Apdeedfna,1 +Brjjgj.%Wanfzjeejs +Irafgj. afo% di gdursj% at tkj Drgj sntjs% fd rjgdro di pnbskas jvjr hjjf odguljftjo& Aitjr 7= yjars di jxgavatndf di 7:= l 8

at Yjfta Lngjfa% 1?= l8 at Harrafgd Edf% afo 1=9 l8 at IujftjFujva,7% afo gdftnfudus rjsjargk nf tkj trnafbej idrljo hy tkj

rjbndf di Drgj,Iujftj Fujva,Yjfta Lngjfa% pnb rjlanfs kavj fjvjrhjjf idufo aldfb tkj ldrj tkaf twjfty,fivj tkdusafo earbjlallae idssnes ufjartkjo irdl tkjsj sntjs% afo tkns ns prdhahey tkjhjst rjgdro di tkj jarey ]ejnstdgjfj iaufa nf Jurdpj& Rkjf pnbs arj

prjsjft nf af jgdsystjl% tkjy tjfo td hj ahufoaft nf tkj earbjlallae gdllufnty bnvjf tkjnr dppdrtufnstng ijjonfb hjkavndrafo rjprdougtnvj suggjss& Idr tkns rjasdf% tkjy arj usuaeey wjeerjprjsjftjo nf tkj idssne assjlheabjs& Wunos arj wjee rjgdrojo nf

tkj Airngaf afo Asnaf argkajdedbngae afo paejdftdedbngae sntjs%

nfgeuonfb tkdsj irdl tkj Ejvaftnfj Gdrrnodr sugk asZhjnonya

+Bjraaos jt ae&% 1>;9. dr Jvrdf Quarry +_gkjrfdv jt ae&% 1>>?.% huttkjy arj fdt ojfifntnvjey prjsjft nf Drgj dr nf afy dtkjr sntjs df tkj

Jurdpjaf gdftnfjft ournfb tkj pjrndo hjtwjjf 1&2 afo 1&8 La&Eatjr% tkj bjfus Wus ns rjgdrojo jvjrywkjrj nf Jurdpj& Idr tknsrjasdf% tkj ahsjfgj di sunos irdl ejvje HE,O gdfstranfs tkj uppjr

enlnt di tkj gkrdfdedbngae rafbj jstnlatjo idr tkns sntj td61&8 La%nfabrjjljft wntk tkj abj di 1&? La jstnlatjo irdl tkj JWX oatjs afotkj slaee lallae assjlheabj&

Gdfgeusndfs

_kj spjgnljf HE=8,C:?,1== idufo at Harrafgd Ejf% a kulaftddtk wntk af jstnlatjo abj di ga& 1&? La% rjprjsjfts tkj deojst

afatdlngae jvnojfgj di kulaf prjsjfgj nf Rjstjrf Jurdpj& _kns

fifonfb% gdlhnfjo wntk tkj nlpdrtaft entkng tdde assjlheabj irdltkj ejvje O di Harrafgd Ejf% gdffirls tkat Rjstjrf Jurdpj was

gdedfnzjo ejss tkaf =&: La aitjr tkj first jxpafsndf diKdld dut diAirnga% gurrjftey odguljftjo at tkj Olafnsn sntj&

Ag`fdwejobjljfts

Rj tkaf` aee di tkj ljlhjrs di tkj Drgj rjsjargk prdcjgtnfvdevjo nf tkj jxgavatndfs afo tkj stuoy di tkj Harrafgd Ejfpaejdaftkrdpdedbngae sntj& Rj tkaf` ]rdijssdr ]& Xnvas idr kns sup,

pdrt afo jfgdurabjljft& Aesd wj tkaf` ]rdijssdr K& oj Eulejy afokns tjal idr tkjnr kjep& L&_& Aehjron% L&X& ]aedlhd% E& Ahhazzn% I&Eagdlhat% W& Hanef% K&A& Heanf% C& Laourjee% afo L& Iurn kjepjo nftkj nojftnfigatndf di tkj vjrtjhratj iaufa& G&I& afo L&O& tkaf` ]&

Ydnfgkjt afo C& Ojsprnj idr tkjnr kjep ournfb tkj JWX salpenfb& X&Brf afo C&,C& Hakanf prdvnojo kjepiue gdlljfts df tkj JWX oatnfb&Rj tkaf` ]k& Ljffjgnjr% A& Idrt afo Y& Eahdroj irdl tkj LFKF+Lusj oj eKdllj. idr tkj aggjss td idssne afo jxtaft gdeejgtndfs&

]kdtdbrapks afo lngrdsgaf di tkj kdlnfnf ldear wjrj garrnjo atGJFNJK di Hurbds% Wpanf& Rj tkaf` E& Lartf,Irafgs afo L&Lartfjz oj ]nfneeds idr tkjnr kjep wntk tkj lngrd,G_ afaeysns& JWXoata wjrj dhtanfjo at tkj ]rjknstdry Ojpartljft di LFKF +]arns%

Irafgj.& ]aejdlabfjtng ljasurjljfts wjrj garrnjo dut at tkj WG_di tkj Hargjedfa Zfnvjrsnty& Wgaffnfb pkdtdbrapks di tkj entkng ar,tjiagts wjrj garrnjo dut at tkj GJX] di _autavje +Irafgj. hy Llj& H&Ojfnaux& Rj tkaf` Ls& Wkjnea Rbenj idr rjvnjwnfb tkj Jfbensk

vjrsndf di tkns papjr& O& Hjbuf% J& Ojesdf% J& Garhdfjee% _&O& Rkntj%O& Edro`npafnozj% W&G& Aftf% L&L& Eakr% L& _appjf% E& Xdd`% X&Ijrrnfb% tkj Assdgnatj Jontdr afo tkrjj afdfyldus rjvnjwjrsrjvnsjo a first orait di tkj lafusgrnpt& _kns stuoy kas hjjf spdf,

sdrjo hy tkj Onrjggnf Bjfjrae oj Hnjfjs Gueturaejs +Gdfsjcjra ojGuetura% Cufta oj Afoaeuga% Wpanf.% afo nt kas hjjf suppdrtjo hyprdcjgts GBE8=1=,1:789% GBE8=1=,19;81% GBE8=18,7;7:;% afoGBE8==;,=?;>9 di tkj Wpafnsk Lnfnstry di Wgnjfgj afo Nffdvatndf&

Appjfonx A& Wuppejljftary oata

Wuppejljftary oata rjeatjo td tkns artngej gaf hj idufo atkttp3$$ox&odn&drb$1=&1=19$c&ckjvde&8=17&=1&=18 &

Xjijrjfgjs

Abust% C&% Laourjee% C&% 8==7& Eds arvngenods +Lurdnoja% Xdojftna% Lallaena. oje]ejnstdgjfd nfijrndr oj Harrafgd Ejf y Iujftj Fujva 7 +Drgj% Brafaoa.& Oatdsrjenlnfarjs& Nf3 _drd% N& +Jo&.% Je ]ejnstdgjfd Nfijrndr oj Harrafgd Ejf y IujftjFujva 7% Drgj +Brafaoa.& Ljldrna Gnjftfiga Galpaas 1>>>j8==8% Cufta ojAfoaeuga% Gdfsjcjra oj Guetura% J&]&B& Arqujdedba Ldfdbraias% vde& 12%pp& 172j1?:&

Abust% C&% Heanf% K&,A&% Iurn% L&% Oj Lari% X&% Waftds,Guhjod% A&% 8=1=& _kj jarey]ejnstdgjfj slaee vjrtjhratj suggjssndf irdl tkj Drgj rjbndf +Buaonx,HazaHasnf% WJ Wpanf. afo nts hjarnfb df tkj first kulaf dggupatndf di Jurdpj&Quatjrf& Nft& 887j88?% 198j19>&

Afaof% ]&% Bahs% L&% 8==>& ]aeajdjfvnrdfljftae jvdeutndf di tkj Jarey ]ejnstdgjfj

eagustrnfj sjqujfgj at Harrafgd Ejf argkjdedbngae sntj +Drgj% Haza Hasnf%Wdutkjrf Wpanf. irdl stahej nsdtdpjs afo Wr afo Lb gkjlnstry di dstragdoskjees& C& ]aejdenlfde& ?8% 891j82>&

Afaof% ]&% Ztrneea% X&% Cuen% X&% 1>>?& ]aeajdjfvnrdfljftae rjgdfstrugtndf dia ]ejnstdgjfj eagustrnfj sjqujfgj irdl iaufae assjlheabjs afo dstragdoj skjeebjdgkjlnstry% Haza Hasnf% WJ Wpanf& ]aeajdbjdbr& ]aeajdgenlatde& ]aeajdjgde& 111%1>1j8=:&

Arrnhas% A&% Barrnod% B&% Ynsjras% G&% Wdrna% C&L&% ]ea% W&% Wdeafd% C&B&% Bargs% L&%Hjaluo% J&% Garrnf% C&W&% 8==>& A lallaenaf edst wdreo nf sdutkwjst Jurdpjournfb tkj Eatj ]endgjfj& ]EdW Dfj ?% j2182& kttp3$$ox&odn&drb$1=&1721$cdurfae&pdfj&===2182&

Arzarjeed% L&% Largdenfn% I&% ]avna% B&% ]avna% L&% ]jtrdfnd% G&% ]jtruggn% L&% Xdd`% E&%Warojeea% X&% 8==>& Enfoustrnj entknquj ou sntj ]enstdgfj nfirnjur oj ]nrrd Fdro+Aprngjfa% Ntaenj ou suo.3 ufj dggupatndf kulanfj jftrj 1&7 jt 1&2 La& EAf,tkrdpdedbnj 117% ?2j:;&

Hanejy% W&% Kuhenf% C&% 8==9& Ojftae rjlanfs irdl tkj Brdttj ou Xjffj at Argy,sur,Gurj +^dffj.& C& Kul& Jvde& :=% ?;:j:=;&

Hjrlojz oj Gastrd% C&L&% Xdsas% A&% Fngdes% L&J&% 1>>>& Ojftae rjlanfs irdl

Atapujrga,_O9 +Braf Odenfa sntj% Hurbds% Wpanf.& C& Kul& Jvde& 72% :87j

:99&

N& _drd,Ldyafd jt ae& $ Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j> 2

http://-/?-http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007127http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007127http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007127http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007127http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0007127http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jhevol.2013.01.012http://-/?-


8/9

Hnfidro% E&X&% 1>;1& Hdfjs3 Afgnjft Ljf afo Ldojrf Lytks& Agaojlng ]rjss% Fjw^dr`&

Heuljfsgknfj% X&C&% Wjevabbnd% L&L&% 1>;;& ]jrgussndf lar`s df hdfj suriagj asa fjw onabfdstng di kdlnfno hjkavndur& Faturj 777% 297j29:&

Garhdfjee% J&% Hjrlojz oj Gastrd% C&L&% ]ars% C&L&% ]rjz,Bdfzejz% A&% Gujfga,Hjsgs% B&% Dee% A&% Ldsqujra% L&% Kubujt% X&% Laoj% C& vaf ojr% Xdsas% A&% Waea% X&%Yaeevjro% C&% Barga% F&% Brafbjr% O&J&% Lartnff,_drrjs% L&% Xdorbujz% [&]&%Wtdg`% B&L&% Yjrbs% C&L&% Aeeu% J&% Hurcagks% I&% Ggjrjs% N&% Gafaes% A&% Hjfntd% A&%Ojz% G&% Edzafd% L&% Latjds% A&% Favazd% L&% Xdorbujz% C&% Xdsjee% C&% Arsuaba% C&E&%8==;& _kj first kdlnfnf di Jurdpj& Faturj ?:8% ?9:j?9>&

Grdgkjt% C&, &% Rjegdllj% C&,E&% Nvdrra% C&% Xuiijt% B&% Hduehjs% F&% Gapojvnea% X&%Geauoj% C&% Inrlat% G&% Ltans% B&% Lngkaux% C&% ]ngìdro% L&% 8==>& Zfj fduvjeejiaufj oj vjrthrs gdftnfjftaux% assdgnj ojs artjiagts oafs ej ]enstdgfjnfirnjur ojeKrauet +Wuo oj ea Irafgj.% vjrs 1&:2 La& G&X& ]aejvde ;% 28:j279&

Gujfga,Hjsgs% B&% Gafuod% C&N&% Eapeafa% G&% 8==1& Ea squjfgj ojs rdfbjurs+Lallaena. ojs sntjs ou ]enstdgfj nfirnjur jt ldyjf o Atapujrga +Hurbds%Jspabfj.& EAftkrdpdedbnj 1=:% 11:j17=&

Oay% L&K&% 1>;9& Bunoj td Idssne Laf% idurtk jo& _kj Zfnvjrsnty di Gkngabd ]rjss%Gkngabd&

Ojsprnj% C&% Ydnfgkjt% ]&% _nssdux% K&% Ldfgje% L&,K&% Arzarjeed% L&% Xdhnf% W&%Hakanf% C&,C&% Iaeburjs% G&% Gdurgnlauet% B&% Opdft% C&% Babjdffjt% X&% Larqujr% E&%Ljssabjr% J&% Ahojssaod`% W&% ]uauo% W&% 8=1=& Edwjr afo lnooej ]ejnstdgjfjkulaf sjttejljfts nf tkj Lnooej Ednrj Xnvjr Hasnf% Gjftrj Xjbndf% Irafgj&Quatjrf& Nft& 887j88?% 7?:j7:>&

Ouvae% L&% Iaeburjs% G&% Hakanf% C&,C&% Brf% X&% Wkad% Q&% Auhjrt% L&% Kjeestrdl% C&%Oded% C&,L&% Abust% C&% Lartnfjz,Favarrd% H&% ]aelqvnst% ]&% _drd,Ldyafd% N&% 8=11&_kj gkaeejfbj di oatnfb Jarey ]ejnstdgjfj idssne tjjtk hy tkj gdlhnfjo urafnulsjrnjsjjejgtrdf spnf rjsdfafgj ljtkdo3 tkj Yjfta Lngjfa paeajdftdedbngaesntj& C& Quatjrf& Wgn& 89% 9=7j91:&

Ouvae% L&% Iaeburjs% G&% Hakanf% C&,C&% Brf% X&% Wkad% Q&% Auhjrt% L&% Oded% C&,L&%Abust% C&% Lartfjz,Favarrd% H&% ]aelqvnst% ]&% _drd,Ldyafd% N&% 8=18& Df tkjenlnts di usnfb gdlhnfjo Z,sjrnjs$JWX ljtkdo td oatj idssne tjjtk irdl twdJarey ]ejnstdgjfj argkajdedbngae sntjs di tkj Drgj arja +Buaonx,Haza hasnf%Wpanf.& Quatjrf& Xjs& 22% ?;8j?>1&

Ouvae% L&% 8==;& Jvaeuatndf ou pdtjftnje oj ea ltkdoj oj oatatndf par Xsdfafgjoj Wpnf Jejgtrdfnquj +JWX. appenquj aux bnsjljfts ou ]enstdgfj nfirnjur3tuoj ojs bnsjljfts oDrgj +hassnf oj Buaonx,Haza% Jspabfj. jt gdftrnhutndf ea gdffanssafgj ojs prjlnjrs pjupejljfts oj eJurdpj& ]k&O& Onssjrtatndf%Lusul Fatndfae oKnstdnrj Faturjeej% ]arns&

Iacarod% H&% 8==;& Ejs nfoustrnjs entknqujs afgnjffjs oDrgj3 ejs sntjs oj HarrafgdEjf jt Iujftj Fujva 7& Ejur peagj oafs ej gdftjxtj ojs peus afgnjffjs nf,oustrnjs jurasnatnqujs& ]k&O& Onssjrtatndf% Zfnvjrsnty di Ldftpjeenjr&

Ijrffojz% C&% Wdrna% C&% Ynsjras% G&% 1>>9& Wtratnbrapkng argkntjgturj di tkj Fjdbjfjhasnfs nf tkj gjftrae sjgtdr di tkj Hjtng Gdroneejra +Wpanf.3 tjgtdfng gdftrde afohasj ejvje gkafbjs& Nf3 Irnjfo% ]&I&% Oahrnd% C&G& +Jos&.% Xjgdro di Grustae @nfj,latngs& Galhrnobj Zfnvjrsnty ]rjss% Galhrnobj% pp& 7:7j79?&

Ijrrnfb% X&% Dls% D&% Abust% C&% Hjrfa% I&% Fndraozj% L&% Wkjena% _&% _appjf% L&%

Yjùa% A&% Skvafnoa% O&% Edro`npafnozj% O&% 8=11& Jarenjst kulaf dggupatndfs atOlafnsn +Bjdrbnaf Gaugasus. oatjo td 1&;:j1&2; La& ]rdg& Fate& Agao& Wgn& 1=;%1=?78j1=?79&

Irayjr% O&R&% 1>2;& Jvdeutndf di tkj Ojftntndf nf Zppjr ]aejdentkng afo LjsdentkngJurdpj& Zfnvjrsnty di @afsas ]rjss% Eawrjfgj&

Iurn,Hrufd% L&% 8==7& Eds nfsjgtnvdrds +Lallaena. oje ]ejnstdgjfd nfijrndr ojIujftj Fujva,7 y Harrafgd Ejf +Drgj% Brafaoa.& Nf3 _drd% N& +Jo&.% Bjdedba%]aejdftdedba% ]aejdjgdedba ^ Arqujdedba oj ea Ojprjsnf Buaonx,Hazaouraftj je ]end,]ejnstdgjfd& Gdfsjcjra oj Guetura% Cufta oj Afoaeuga%Arqujdedba Ldfdbraias% vde& 12% pp& 1?2j1:;&

Bjraaos% O&% Burnf% G&% Iaurj% L&% 1>;9& Ejs Wunos ou ]ejnstdgjfj afgnjf o Duhjn,onyjk +Nsraje.& Nf3 _gkjrfdv% J& +Jo&.% Ejs Lallnijrjs ou ]enstdgfj nfirnjur ojea vaeej ou Cdroanf a Duhjnonyjk& Lldnrjs jt _ravaux ou Gjftrj oj XjgkjrgkjIrafans oj Crusaejl% Assdgnatndf ]aejdrnjft% ]arns% vde& :% pp& >7j1=:&

Braostjnf% I&L&% Dbb% C&B&% Wlntk% A&B&% 8==:& A Bjdedbng _nlj Wgaej 8==?& GalhrnobjZfnvjrsnty ]rjss% Galhrnobj&

Bjrnf% G&% Iaurj% L&% 1>>2& _kj wneo hdar +Wus sgrdia prnsgus. irdl tkj pdst,Yneeairafgknaf Edwjr ]ejnstdgjfj di Zftjrlassijeo& Nf3 @ake`j% X&,O& +Jo&.% Oas]ejnstdzf vdf Zftjrlassijeo hjn Ljfnfbjf +_krnfbjf.& Xdlnsgk,Bjrla,

fnsgkjs Sjftraelusjul% Hdff% pp& 72:j

7;7&Kneesdf% W&% 1>>9& Ojftae Aftkrdpdedby& Galhrnobj Zfnvjrsnty ]rjss% Galhrnobj&Kdwjee% I&G&% Gdppjfs% ^&% 1>27& Ojgnoudus tjjtk di Kdlnfnoaj irdl ]endgjfjj

]ejnstdgjfj di edwjr Dld Hasnf& C& Kul& Jvde& 8% ?91j?28&N`jya% L&% 1>>7& Fjw Appengatndfs di Jejgtrdf Wpnf Xjsdfafgj Oatnfb% Odsnljtry

afo Lngrdsgdpy& Rdreo Wgnjftnfig% Wnfbapdrj&Cdkafsdf% O&G&% Rkntj% _&O&% Gdppjfs% ^&% 1>;8& Ojftae rjlanfs irdl tkj Kaoar Idr,

latndf% Jtkndpna3 1>2?j1>22 gdeejgtndfs& Al& C& ]kys& Aftkrdpde& :2% :?:j9=7&Cdkfsdf% J&% 1>;:& Gurrjft ojvjedpljfts nf hdfj tjgkfdedby& Nf3 Ejldnfj% B&L&

+Jo&.& Nf3 LagJagkjrf% A&W& +Jo&.%% Aovafgjs nf Argkajdedbngae Ljtkdo afo_kjdry% vde ;% pp& 1:2j87:&

@jjey% E&K&% _dtk% F&% 1>;1& Lngrdwjar pdenskjs df jarey stdfj tddes irdl @ddhn Idra%@jfya& Faturj 8>7% ?9?j?9:&

@jysjr% A&% Ljftjr% G&% Ldbbn,Gjggkn% C&% ]ng`jrnfb% _&X&% Hjrbjr% E&% 8===& Ornldejf3a fjw kdlnfno,hjarnfb sntj nf Bautjfb% Wdutk Airnga& W& Air& C& Wgn& >9% 1>7j1>2&

Eja`jy% X&J&% Rddo% H&A&% 1>27& Fjw jvnojfgj di tkj bjfus Kdld irdl Jast Xuodei%@jfya& Al& C& ]kys& Aftkrdpde& 7>% 7::j79;&

Eja`jy% X&J&% Rddo% H&A&% 1>2?& Fjw jvnojfgj di tkj bjfus Kdld irdl Jast Xuodei%@jfya +NY.& Al& C& ]kys& Aftkrdpde& ?1% 872j8?7&

Enf% L&% ^nf% B&% Onfb% ^&% Gun% ^&% Gkjf% @&% Ru% G&% [u% E&% 8==9& Xjenahnenty stuoy df JWXoatnfb di tkj aeulnful gjftjr nf quartz& Xaonat& Ljas& ?1% 1=?:j1=?>&

Edro`npafnozj% O&% Caskaskvnen% _&% Yjùa% A&% ]dfgj oj Ejf% L&W&% Sdeen`dijr% G&]&J&%Xnbktlnrj% B&]&% ]dftzjr% K&% Ijrrnfb% X&% Dls% D&% _appjf% L&% Hu`ksnafnozj% L&%Abust% C&% @ake j% X&% @neaozj% B&% Lartfjz,Favarrd% H&% Ldusk`jenskvnen% A&%Fndraozj% L&% Xdd % E&% 8==2& ]dstgrafnae jvnojfgj irdl jarey Kdld irdlOlafnsn% Bjdrbna& Faturj ??>% 7=:j71=&

Laorj,Oupduy% L&% 1>;:& Ejs ojfts ognouaejs oj ejfiaft fafojrtkaenjf ou Xdg ojLarsae j Odrodbfj j Irafgj& Jtuoj afaeytnquj jt gdlparatnvj& Ojuxnljpartnj3 ea ojftntndf nfirnjurj& EAftkrdpdedbnj ;>% >7j1=>&

Lartfjz,Favarrd% H&% _drd% N&% Abust% C&% 8==:& _kj earbj lallaes assjlheabjs irdlYjfta Lngjfa% Iujftj Fujva,7 afo Harrafgd Ejf,: +Drgj.& Jarey ]ejnstdgjfjiaufae afo kulaf onspjrsaes nftd Jurdpj& Nf3 Ldenfjs% F& +Jo&.% ]rdgjjonfbs ditkj Wylpdsnul jftntejo Xjgjft Aovafgjs Gdfgjrfnfb Wjttejljft Gkafbjs aswjee as Gkrdfdstratnbrapkng% Bjdedbngae afo ]aejdbjdbrapkngae Iraljwdr` ditkj Nfoustrnjs di tkj Lnooej afo Jarey ]aejdentkng ]jrndo nf Jurdpj% Xjffjs%88j8: Wjptjlhjr% 8==7& Hrntnsk Argkajdedbngae Xjpdrts Nftjrfatndfae Wjrnjs%vde& W179?& Cdkf ) Jrnga Kjobjs Eto&% Dxidro% pp& 18:j177&

Lartfjz,Favarrd% H&% ]aelqvnst% ]&% Laourjee,Laeapjnra% C&% Xds,Ldftdya% W&%Jspnbarjs% L&]&% _drrjbrdsa% Y&% ]rjz,Geards% C&A&% 8=1=& Ea iaufa oj brafojslalijrds oj Iujftj Fujva,7 y Harrafgd Ejf,:3 jstaod oj ea gujstnf& Nf3_drd% N& +Jo&.% Dgupagndfjs Kulafas jf je ]ejnstdgjfd Nfijrndr y Ljond oj eaGujfga oj Buaonx,Haza& Cufta oj Afoaeuga% Gdfsjcjra oj Guetura% Wjvneea%pp& 1>2j879&

Laue% E&% Lasnfn% I&% Ahhazzn% E&% _urfjr% A&% 1>>;& _kj usj di oniijrjft ldrpkdljtrngoata idr ahsdeutj abj gaenhratndf di sdlj Wdutk, afo Lnooej Jurdpjaf arvngdenopdpueatndfs& ]aeajdftdbr& Ntae& ;:% 111j1:1&

Lazd% A&Y&% Wjs% G&% Xunz,Hustds% A&% ]ja% C&A&% 1>;:& Bjdedba y paejdftdedba oj edsyagnlnjftds ]end,]ejnstdgjfds oj Kusgar +Ojprjsnf oj Buaonx,Haza% Braf,aoa.& Jstuo& Bjde& ?1% ?92

j?>7&

Ljuejf% A& Yaf ojr% 1>27& Lnooej ]ejnstdgjfj slaeejr Lallaes irdl tkj Ldftj]jbena +Drvnjtd% Ntaey. wntk spjgnae rjijrjfgj td tkj pkyedbjfy di Lngrdtus+Arvngdenoaj% Xdojftna.& Quatjrfarna 12% 1j1??&

Ldbbn,Gjggkn% C&% Brnfj% I&J&% _dhnas% ]&Y&% 8==9& Jarey kdlnfno ojftae rjlanfs irdlLjlhjrs ? afo : di tkj Wtjr idftjnf Idrlatndf +1>99j1>>9 jxgavatndfs.3gataedbuj% nfonvnouae assdgnatndfs% ldrpkdedbngae ojsgrnptndfs afo nfntnae ljtrngafaeysns& C& Kul& Jvde& :=% 87>j78;&

Ldefar% W&% 1>21& Kulaf tddtk wjar% tddtk iufgtndf afo gueturae varnahnenty& Al& C&]kys& Aftkrdpde& 7?% 12:j1>=&

Dls% D&% Abust% C&% Bahs% L&% Afaof% ]&% 8===a& Entkdstratnbrapkngae gdrrjeatndf dilngrdlallaesntjs afo hndstratnbrapky di tkjZppjr ]endgjfjtd Edwjr ]ejnstdgjnf tkj Fdrtkjast Buaonx,Haza Hasnf +sdutkjrf Wpanf.& C& Quatjrf& Wgn& 1:% ?7j:=&

Dls% D&% ]ars% C&L&% Lartfjz,Favarrd% H&% Abust% C&% _drd% N&% Lartfjz,Ijrffojz% B&%_urq% A&% 8===h& Jarey kulaf dggupatndf di wjstjrf Jurdpj3 ]aejdlabfjtngoatjs idr twd ]aejdentkng sntjs nf Wpanf& ]rdg& Fate& Agao& Wgn& >2% 1=999j1=92=&

Dls% D&% Afaof% ]&% Abust% C&% Cuen% X&% 8=11& Bjdedby afo gkrdfdedby di tkj gdf,tnfjftae ]ejnstdgjfj argkjdedbngae afo paejdftdedbngae sntjs di tkj Drgj arja

+Haza hasnf% Wpanf.& Quatjrf& Nft& 8?7% 77j

?7&]jrjttd% G&% Aldrj% I&D&% Aftdfnazzn% Aeh&% Aftdfnazzn% Aeo&% Hakanf% C&C&% Gattafn% E&%Gavaeenfn% J&% Jspdsntd% ]&% Iaeburjs% G&% Babfjpanf% C&% Kjoejy% N&% Eaurjft% L&%Ejhrjtdf% Y&% Edfbd% E&% Lneen`jf% W&% Ldfjbatn% ]&% Dee% A&% ]ubenjsj% F&% Xjfauet,Lns`dvs`y% C&% Wdzzn% L&% Zfbard% W&% Yaffuggn% W&% Yjrbjs% C&L&% Rabfjr% C&C&%^d`dyala% ^&% 1>>;& Enfoustrnj entknquj oj GamHjevjojrj on Ldftj ]dbbnded3stratnbrapknj% latnrj prjlnrj% typdedbnj% rjldftabjs jt tragjs outnensatndf&EAftkrdpdedbnj 1=8% 7?7j?9:&

]jvzfjr% L&% _jsa`dv% A&% Yjfbjfbjnl% J&% 1>>;& _kj pdsntndf di tkj _nozar Edgaenty+_alaf ]jfnfsuea% Xussna. nf labfjtdgkrdfdedbngae sgaej& ]aeuongdea 8% >:j>2&

Xdhnfsdf% C&_&% 1>:9& Ojftntndf di Austraedpntkjgnfaj& _rafsvaae Lusjul% ]rjtdrna&Xdd`%E&% Lartfjz,Favarrd%H&% 8=1=& Yneeairafgknaf3tkj edfbstdry di a ]end,]ejnstdgjfj

Jurdpjaf earbj lallae hndgkrdfdedbng ufnt& Quatjrf& Nft& 81>% 17?j1??&Wafz oj Baeojafd% G&% Yjra% C&A&% 1>>8& Wtratnbrapkng rjgdro afo paeajdbjdbrapkngae

gdftjxt di tkj Fjdbjfj hasnfs nf tkj Hjtng Gdroneejra& Hasnf Xjs& ?% 81j79&Wknplaf% ]&% 1>;1a& Appengatndfs di sgaffnfb jejgtrdf lngrdsgdpy td tapkdfdlng

prdhejls& Nf3 Gaftwjee% A&L& +Jo&.% _kj Xjsjargk ]dtjftnae di AftkrdpdedbngaeLusjul Gdeejgtndfs& Aff& F&^& Agao& Wgn&% vde& 729% pp& 7:2j7;:&

Wknplaf% ]&% 1>;1h& Enij Knstdry di a Idssne3 Af Nftrdougtndf td _apkdfdly afo

]aejdjgdedby& Karvaro Zfnvjrsnty ]rjss% Galhrnobj&Wusslaf% G&% 1>;2& Xsuetats oufj tuoj oj lngrdtragjs ousurj sur uf gkaftneedf

oartjiagts oDeouvan +_afzafnj.& EAftkrdpdedbnj >1% 72:j7;=&_gkjrfdv% J&% Kdrwntz% E&@&% Xdfjf% A&% Enstjr% A&% 1>>?& _kj iaufae rjlanfs irdl Jvrdf

Quarry nf rjeatndf td dtkjr Edwjr ]aejdentkng kdlnfno sntjs nf tkj Ejvaft&Quatjrf& Xjs& ?8% 78;j77>&

_jsa`dv% A&%1>>;& Jarey stabj diAeedpkandlysnf jastjrfJurdpj& ]aeuongdea 8% >;j1=:&_neenjr% A&L&% 1>2>& Xjstjs grfnjfs oj e jfiaft ldustrnjf Kdld ? oj Qaizjk +Nsrae.&

Ea lafonhuej jt ejs laxneeanrjs& ]aedrnjft :% 92j;:&_drd,Ldyafd% N&% oj Eulejy% K&% Hars`y% O&% Gjenhjrtn% Y&% Gaugkj% O&% Ldfgje% L&,K&%

Iacarod% H&% _drd% L&% 8==7& Eas nfoustrnas etngas oj Harrafgd Ejf y IujftjFujva 7 oj Drgj& Jstuond tgfngd y tnpdebngd& Eas gaojfas dpjratnvas& Afensnstragjdebngd& Xjsuetaods prjenlnfarjs& Nf3 _drd% N& +Jo&.% Je ]ejnstdgjfd Nfijrndr ojHarrafgd Ejf y Iujftj Fujva 7% Drgj +Brafaoa.& Cufta oj Afoaeuga% Gdfsjcjraoj Guetura% Wjvneea% pp& 1;7j8=9& Ljldrna Gnjftfiga Galpaas 1>>>j8==8&

_drd,Ldyafd% N&% oj Eulejy% K&% Iacarod% H&% Hars y% O&% Gaugkj% O&% Gjenhjrtn% Y&%Brjbdnrj% W&% Lartfjz,Favarrd% H&% Jspnbarjs% L&]&% Xds,Ldftdya% W&% 8==>& Enf,oustrnj entknquj ojs bnsjljfts ou ]enstdgfj nfirnjur oj Harrafgd Ejf jtIujftj Fujva 7 Drgj% Brjfaoj% Jspabfj& EAftkrdpdedbnj 117% 111j18?&

N& _drd,Ldyafd jt ae& $ Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j>;



9/9

_drd,Ldyafd% N&% Hars y% O&% Gaugkj% O&% Gjenhjrtn% Y&% Brbdnrj% W&% Ejhjbuj% I&%Ldfgje% L&K&% Eulejy% K& oj% 8=11& _kj argkang stdfj tdde nfoustry irdl Har,rafgd Ejf afo Iujftj Fujva 7 +Drgj% Wpanf.3 jvnojfgj di tkj jarenjst kdlnfnfprjsjfgj nf sdutkjrf Jurdpj& Quatjrf& Nft& 8?7% ;=j>1&

_dydoa% W&% N`jya% L&% 1>>1& _kjrlae stahnentnjs di paralabfjtng ojijgt afo nlpurntygjftjrs nfquartz3 hasns idrJWX oatnfbdi tkjrlae knstdry& Bjdgkjl&C& 8:%?72j??:&

Yj`ua% A&% Edro`npafnozj% O&% Xnbktlnrj% B&]&% Abust% C&% Ijrrnfb% X&% Lansuraozj% B&%Ldus`kjenskvnen% A&% Fndraozj% L&% ]dfgj oj Ejf% L&% _appjf% L&%_vaegkrjenozj% L&% Sdeen`dijr% G&% 8==8& A fjw s`uee di jarey Kdld irdl Olafnsn%Bjdrbna& Wgnjfgj 8>2% ;:j;>&

Yjra% C&A&% Ijrffojz% C&% Epjz,Barrnod% A&G&% Xdorbujz,Ijrffojz% C&% 1>;:& Bjdedbay jstratnbraia oj eds latjrnaejs ]endgjfd,]ejnstdgjfds oje sjgtdr Drgj,YjftaLngjfa +prdv& Brafaoa.& ]aejdftde& Jvde& 1;% 7j11&

Yjra% C&A&% 1>2=& Jstuond jstratnbrfigd oj ea Ojprjsnf oj Buaonx,Haza& Hde& Bjde&Lnf& ;?% ?8>j?98&

Ydnfgkjt% ]&% Ojsprnj% C&% _nssdux% K&% Iaeburjs% G&% Hakanf% C&C&% Babjdffjt% X&%Opdft% C&% Oded% C&L&% 8=1=& JWX gkrdfdedby di aeeuvnae ojpdsnts afo first kulafsjttejljfts di tkj Lnooej Ednrj Hasnf +Xjbndf Gjftrj% Irafgj.& Quatjrf& Bjd,gkrdfde& :% 7;1j7;?&

Rjnojfrjngk% I&% 1>72& _kj ojftntndf di Wnfaftkrdpus pj`nfjfsns3 a gdlparatnvjdodftdbrapky di tkj kdlnfno& ]aeajdft& Wnfnga O 1% 1j1;=&

Rkntj% _&O&% 1>;=& Aoontndfae idssne kdlnfnos irdl Eajtden% _afzafna3 1>29j1>2>spjgnljfs& Al& C& ]kys& Aftkrdpde& :7% ?;2j:=?&

Rnjbaf`% I&% 1>>2& ]aedlabfjtnsgkj Gkara`tjrnstn` ojs Zftjrpejnstdzfs vdfZftjrlassijeo& Nf3 @ake j% X&O& +Jo&.% Oas ]ejsntdzf vdf Zftjrlassijeo hjnLjnfnfbjf +_krnfbjf.& Xdlnsgk,Bjrlafnsgkjs Sjftraelusjul% Hdff%pp& 97j9>&

Rdepdii% L&K&% 1>2>& _kj @rapnfa ojftae rjlanfs& Al& C& ]kys& Aftkrdpde& :=%92j11?&

Rddo% H&A&% 1>>1& @ddhn Idra Xjsjargk ]rdcjgt& Nf3 Kdlnfno Grafnae Xjlanfs irdl@ddhn Idra% vde& ?& Gearjfodf ]rjss% Dxidro&

^d`dyala% ^&% Iaebujrjs% G&% Quajbjhjur% C&]&% 1>;:& JWX oatnfb di quartzirdl quatjrfary sjonljfts3 first attjlpt& Fuge& _rag`s Xao& Ljas& 1=%>81j>8;&

^d`dyala% ^&% Hnhrdf% X&% Iaebujrjs% G&% 1>;;& Oatatndf ahsdeuj ojs peafgkjrs sta,eablntnqujs oj ea brdttj ou Yaeedffjt Xdqujhrufj,Gap,Lartnf +Aepjs,Larn,tnljs. Irafgj% par ea rsdfafgj oj spnf ejgtrdfnquj +JWX.& EAftkrdpdedbnj >8%?8>j?79&

N& _drd,Ldyafd jt ae& $ Cdurfae di Kulaf Jvdeutndf xxx +8=17. 1j> >

]ejasj gntj tkns artngej nf prjss as3 _drd,Ldyafd% N&% jt ae&% _kj deojst kulaf idssne nf Jurdpj oatjo td ga&1&? La at Drgj +Wpanf.% Cdurfae di KulafJ e n +8=17. k $$o o n $1= 1=19$c ck e 8=17 =1 =18

toro et al. jhe 2013 barranco león tooth in press versiÓn inicial

Documents