tmz - motion for fees - bilzerian v. dirty world

8/17/2019 TMZ - Motion for Fees - Bilzerian v. Dirty World

1/15

#AFC# J. = ($ B $>.: 12265)

211>= D. G= ($ B $>. 7360)

A J. ? ($ B $>. 13582)311A$DAA EGA G%+&, &C

3625 . *>= C= D, 150411 , $ 89135*?>=: 702-420-2001

5 F: 305-437-7662@=.>

6 Attorneys for Defendant

71 1 TMI Productions, Inc.

8

9

10

DISTRICT COURT

CLARK COUNTY, NEVADA

__j

IC)w __j

11" DA$ BA$D%$ BEA$, = =

12

13

&=,

.

< 1 :$

$

< 1 :oZ

< 1 :::

14" D*%D, C, D 1511 >?=, // *HED*.C%#;

H%%#A$ !AA#A$, = =,1611// $ ; *# &%D+C*%$,

$C., C>= C>?>>=; D%E -,1711=: = %E B+$EE$**E-,

=18

191 1

20

21

D==.

FILED

D E C 0 ' 2 0 \ 5

~~.~ . . . .C L E R K O F C O U RT

C $>.: A-15-722801-CD?. $>.:

DEFENDANT TMZ PRODUCTIONS,INC.'S MOTION FOR COSTS,ATTORNEYS' FEES,AND DAMAGESUNDER NRS 41.670

D==, *# &>>=, =. #>>= > C>,

22" A>=' F, = D += $ 41.670.

23 * #>>= ?>= >= > ?>= =

2411>, ?? = ?= >= =, = = > =

25 ? C>.

26

27

- 1 -

*##>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $41.670

A-1-722801-C

mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]


2/15

4

5

6

7

8C"

:=J9

0a = ! =, >= >

311 &= D= B=>= B=

=

& A. ?. >= >

D== D > C = $

&EAE*A!E $%*CE >>= #>>= > C>, A>=' F,

= D >= j J _ > JOIn U CU t.{, , 20 1!;_ _ i : C C -

J .., > >>= >= .

D 1 > D 2 015 .

A$DAA EGAG%+&, &C

// # J. =# J. =

Attorneys for Defendant ,TM I Product i ons, Inc .

- 2 -

*# #>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $41.670

A-1-722801-C


3/15

MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUT!ORITIES

2 11 1. 0 IN TR O DU C TIO N

3 &= D= B= ("B=") = D== *#

4 &>>=, =. ("*#") = >>= > $ A=-A&& . B>

511 >?= = D== D >, LL C = $ .,

611*#, = ?>= = F & > F

711A==, = == > >?= =

811?> >= . > ?> N>= >>

911 #. B= = > ?? *#' FA== .

10 $' A=-A&& , $41.635 O., =

JJN

IC)

E JJN

1111 B=' N > O = . B >=

12110= ? > > ?> F A== . * > ?

1311 ?>>= > , ?> > => =

14 >, = > > >= > ? > K10,000 = >

15 . A *# ? = >>= = A=-A&& , *#

1611> = > >=' = >. * ? = >

1711 = C>' > >= > > K10,000 =

18 > .

19112.0 FACTUAL ACKGROUND

< 1 : N

$

< 1 :oZ

== = ?>

2111>= >= L = = ?

2211 B= = = = ("*D")

2311. (See >= >= L, E$"$% 1.) %=

2411A 7, 2015, B= >= C>?= = D== D

25 >, LL C = $ > >= >= >=. %= A

26 10, 2015, *# ?> = >= , L, =

2711= O>= ?>>= > A 1 >= >=== >= 0

-3 -

*##>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $41.670 A-1-72280 1-C


4/15


5/15

2

3

4

5

6

7

8C"

:=J9

0a C>@= @@= = =@

' A=-A&&, C. C> C. &@>. 425.16. ??@>?@ >@

C>@ > @ ?>= C>@= = =@?@= A=-A&&. See

Jo&n . Dou%'as Cnty. Sc&. Dist., 125 $. 746, 756 (2009) (" >=

C>@= C>@=' =-A&&

= = > $' =-A&&").

* 9 C@ >=, = =@?@= C>@=' A=-A&&,

= = A=-A&&>= ?> > @ > >=, ??@>?@

> @ >@=' =@@ = >==>= , = => @

@ > A=-A&&>=, = "=@@

?= &= ? = @?>== > @ >@ >=

." !ra&aSuit . C'ainos, 738 F.3 1131, 1159 (9 C@ . 2013) (@=, = @ > A=-A&&> = = =@@

@ >= @=. See $an'and . #a) Offices > Masta%ni , "oistedt &

C&iura**i, 141 C. A??. 4 15, 21 (2006) (== @>@ =

C>@= A=-A&& = ?>->= , >= ,

= >==>= == = @ > , = >= ?? > =

1911>@@ @== = A=-A&&>=).

2011 * > => @O@ *#>


6/15

__j

IC)w __j

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

R * O > >; , @==, >=,

?@=, ?@>>= ==, = ;

R * @@ > >@ >=; , =@ , @=,

= =

?@> ?@ = @= 0

>=;

R * >@ ?@>@ >@; =;

R * @; @ >@= = =

@ @.

< 1 :$

$

< 1 :oZ

< 1 :::

1111 Sc&ou)ei'er . 0ancy C>, 101 $. 827, 833-34 (1985) (= run*e'' .

1-11!oden !ate /at+' an2, 85 $. 345, 349 (1969). = @@ @>= > @ ?@,

2211= @ =>= > @. * > = 3@B

2311 ?@ > *# >> @>< >.

24 4.2.1 T#* N3"*/ !3/ 5/* $ R*(-("+*

25 * =, = 2.9 >@

- 6 -

*# #>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $ 41.670

A-1-72280 1-C


7/15

__j

IC)

w __j

>>= C> == >>=. A>= >= D. G= ?= 6.

211> ?> > A=-A&& > , = 1.2 > >>= >. A>=

311A J. ? ?= 43.4 > >= > ?> > A=-A&& > , = 18.

411> >>= >. & * > ?= 11.7 > >= > ?>

511 A=-A&& > , = 1.8 > >>= >. & D= D

611?= 2 > >= > ?> > A=-A&& > . *#' >= ?= >

7110 72.9 > ?> > A=-A&& >, = 22.5 > . ??>

811 ?= > > 13.7 > ? > > > , = 1.8 > . *

911> > = > > ?= >= 95.4 > >=, =

101115.5> . * >= > > >= ?= > >=

11110 > > > ?, = = -? ? >=

1211= =.

13 A ?= *#' >= >= =. *#

< 1 :$

$

< 1 :oZ

< 1 :Q::

1411= = => ?? > A=-A&& >>= = 2

1511 > > B=' A= C>=?>= ' (=> O >):

1611A>= >= G= = >== >= >

1711? O > =. *# >= > ?? ?>=

1811B=' =-> ? > ?> = >> ? > >

1911 = >= B=' ??>= >

2011A=-A&& =, = *# > = N > >=O= 0

2111 > , C> = ,2

2211 * ?= *#' >= >= >

231 1 >=. (See D>= > = P" D."Q,

24

25111*# = C >@= = > => @@ >= = $. A@ @,*# ?= >@ == = =@ = ?>= >= >@ @==

2611#@ . =.

112* >@ = >= >@ =>, ?@, = *# @

27 @ ?>=.

- 7 -

*##>>= >@ C>, A>@=' F, = D


8/15

__j

«C)w __j

E$"$% 6, ~~12-17; D>= > # H=, P"H= D."Q,

211 E$"$% 7, ~~13-15; D>= > F. C>? A= P" A= D."Q.

311 E$"$% 8, ~~10-12; = D. ~~19-24.) * ==

411F A== ?>= > O >> = =

511??>= > ?>=. A>=, *#' >=

611 >= > > > ?>= > > = > =

711 *# =. ( D. ~16; see a 'so A= D. ~11.) A>

811 > > ?> >= ?=, # =, >>=

911? > >= >, A ?. *> > =,

1011# . = # . ? ? ?>= > =>=

1111>- > > = > , == =>=,

1211, = = >=, #. = ? > >=

1311 = >= > >>= = ?=.,

1511(See = D. ~24.)

1511 * = C>= > $ynn . C&onos, 2015 +. D. E80062,

1611S6 ($.D. C. M= 19, 2015) ?> ?>= > = >

1711>= > > *#' >= ?= >= . * >

1811>= >= > ==' >= > ?= 582.6

1911> = >==>= = A=-A&& >>=, ?

2011>= => = ? ? = FA== > A=-A&

21 >=. Id. *#' >= >= ?= >= > > =

2211>==>= = . * = > > >

< 1 : N

$

< CoZ

< 1 :::

2311>=.

2411 4.2.2 TMZ' A%%/-*' R(%* A/* R*(-("+*

2511 * > *#' >= *# >=, =

2611 > = ? ?. (See D. ~~12-17;'

2711H= D. ~~13-15; A= D. ~~10-11; = D. ~~1-17.)

- 8 -

*# #>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $41.670

A-1-722801-C


9/15

2

3

4

5

6

7

8C

:=J9

0a@, > > @? >@ F@

A@ @ > K520. (See

= D. ~~12, 18.) #@. G@= >@ @ 0

K475, >= @ >= K380. (See id. ~~13, 18.)

#@. ?@ >@ @ > K325, >= @

>@ K260. (See id. ~~14, 18.) #@ . > =>@@ , >= @ > K140 ?@ >@. (See id . ~~15, 18.) #. D

K50 ?@ >@. (See id. ~16.) @ > >=, >@, >@

@>= @ ? >@


10/15

~~5-7; H=@ D. ~6; A= D. ~3; = D. ~~8-9; =

211C>= $. B 286 (# 6, 2013)

3 1 1 E$"$% 9 .) = $' A=-A&& = >@ > @>

5 @?, = =@.

6 = D. ~9; see a'so #= >= A= B444, A?@ 24, 2015, E$"$% 10, 35-38.)

8 #@ . = =>= @>= ?@ >= A=-A&&>=

9 = @ ? , = N@ >= A=-A&&>=. (See E$"$% 910: see a'so

11 > > ? @= >= &=== = B 1095, A?@ 23, 2014, 32:30

12 43:47.3) H > >@ C$$ >= F@ ? . (See

13 = D. ~7.) A=, ?@> = >= F%

14 $ >@ F@A< G>@>= +=@ C=@ , #@ = #

16 C>< +=@> F>@ ( ), = =

17 =@=>= @ = >@< > = #@>< +=@ > *@=, . (See

18 curricu'u 4itae > #@ =, E$"$% 11.) #@ . =

19 = ?@= >@= >@ 13 @. (See = >

24 ?@= " > A=-A&&>=. (See E$"$% 9, 3.)

25

26

1 1

3 A : ?.>/=--1 095-??-/L ( 27 $> 25, 2015).

__j

IC)w __j

< 1 :$

$

< 1 :o

< C::

- 10-

*# #>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $41.670

A-15-72280 1-C


11/15

__j

IC)w __j

#@. = >@ @ > K650 . A>@= >

211 #@, @> E$"$% 12, =@ ? =

311 @ >@ = ?@= >@= K661 ?@ >@ . A>@=,

411 >?@ = = = > = ? ?@.

5 11 H>@, = ? ?@ = ?@= ,

611@ > >=@ > = >. (See @= ?@ @= MD @>< =>= +=@>> > ,

911 = > ?@ = > $ = C>@=, = > @ 0

1011 ?@= ?@@= >

1211 #@, =@ ? = @ >@ = >@= > ?@=

1 3 1 1 K 3 3 1 ?@ >@, (see E$"$% 12), = > K325 ?@ >@

1411 @>=. (See @= G@= MD @>< +=@> &@ >> > =

1611 $-= >@= 15 @ > >= ?@=, ==

1711 @ @ > ?@= = = F@A #@, =@

1911 ? = @ >@ = >@= > ?@= K661 ?@ >@ (

2011 E$"$% 12), = > K475 ?@ >@ @>=. (See

2111 ?@ 1 .5 @ > ?@=. +=@

2311 #@, > >@, = >@ @>=. (See @ @ > @>=. (See id . 6

2611 *@ @ ?@@ @>= = >


12/15

@>= >@ ==' =>@ >@= > @ = >@ @

211= K1,035 = K1,085. #@ . =' > K650 ?@ >@

311== >@ = , ? ? ?@ = @ >

411@ . * C&onos >@ >= >= >

511>@= @ > K570 > K710 ?@ >@ (>@ > >@ = @ 0

611?@=, @?) @ @>=. #@. ?@' >@ == >@ = . * >@ @ > *#'

811>@= @ @>=.

911 4. T#* C3/% S#3+ A=, > @= = @ >

__j 11 > K10,000 = >@ ?@= A=-A&& =.«C) 12 ?@>>= > == > ? ?@ >= A&& >@ =w __j 1311> >@=' . = ?= = =- > = > >= > >@ = @= > < 1 :$

$

< 1 :oZ

< CQ::

1511 = @' @>= > @= = ?= .

1711 B @ => =@?@= = = @ 0

1811 =>> ?@>>= = C>@=' A=-A&&,

1911=


13/15

O >> B=' = > > O

211> = >=. H ?> => = > ??> = > >=. H

311 => = > > *#' = 0

411=?. H => ? > = *#

511?> = >>= = ?. H => , = = > >

611=>= > >=. ? ?, #. B= = > => ?.

71* ? > A&& $' = > ?=

811> >= >.

9111 ?>? > C> > >= B=' >= = =

1011=>= . , = == ,

1111> = >= > ">== > " = >==

1211. = , ? ?> B= >= ?=

1311? > >= >>. (See, .., "D= B = D>? K650 %=

1411&= > ," *# (M 30,2015), E$"$% 1.)4

1511=> K10,000 => ?= > ? > B=,

1611 >= > = ?>>= > A=-A&& . & 0

1711 ??> > A=-A&& > ?> == == > >

1811 A&& ?=, = C> > == =

1911 > ?= >>. * C> > *# K10,000 = >

2011 = $41.670( 1)(). * ' > > @@=O

2111A&& = .

__j

IC)w __j

< 1 :$

$

< 1 :oZ

< C::

22115.0 CONCLUSION

2311 B= A&& = = ? > => ?, = $'

2411A=-A&& > == = = ==. *#

2511= > > > = >=' = = == >

264 A :


14/15

- 14-

*# #>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $41.670

A-15-72280 1-C

B=' . A= ?= = > ?

211=>? >= > ? >==, *# > > = > =

311 > > = >= > K10,000 > B= =

411> ?= > == = .

511 A>=, *# O = > K455.25 = >, K43,555 =

611>=' , = K10,000 = > , > > 0

711K54,010.25.

8

911D: 1 > D, 2015

~~

~~A

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

__j

<C)

w __j

// # J. =

# J. = ($ B $>. 12265)>= D. G = ($ B $>. 7360)

A J. ? ($ B $>. 13582)3625 .*>= C= D, 150

, $ 89135*: 702-420-2001E: @=.>

< 1 :$

$

< 1 :oZ

< C::

Attorneys for Defendant

TMI Product i ons, Inc .

mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]


15/15

2

3

4

5

6

7

8C"

:=J9

0a. A-15-722801-C

CE RTI FI CATE O F S E RV I CE

HEEB CE*F >= D 1, 2015, = >

>? > >>= >= >= = +.. # >:

H%E DGG ACH

F$E A &+E T *H%#&%$

B= . B>, EO..

! &. =, EO.

400 > F> , * F>>

, $ 89101

J95 J ~52@=J.:::J9 J

2 _ 2/2i+3 +2,5Q_4 J ,0

E BB%BGAAD T #*H &M> C> A=, EO.

& A. ?. EO.

6385 . => B., 600

, $ 89118

M>.A=@>.>

EM,~? J@~''U~::L~ ,:D

? ,

:::7~= G>?, &C

- 15 -

*##>>= > C>, A>=' F, = D += $41.670

A-15-72280 1-C
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]

tmz - motion for fees - bilzerian v. dirty world

Documents