From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

Hi Amy,

Bruce Sounes <bruce@studioe.co.uk>

16 May 2014 12:29

Amy Peck; philip.booth@uk.arteliagroup.com; Claire Williams

Marc Watterson; Paul Sheppard; Simon Lawrence; Kai Fabiunke

RE: Grenfell - Meeting attendees

I have discussed with Si m on Lawrence at Rydons and my view is the obvious next step is to go ahead with the large scale samples of the aluminium because I don't think we have exhausted our arguments for composite panels.

I have just spoken to Sarah Scannel to get a steer on the sample we should be preparing.

• She re-iterated the request for an finished example of a brushed appearance.

• She did only look at Chalcott Estate and conceded that the vast expanse of flat panel used there is unlike Grenfell.

• She is interested to see the detail and junctions: window head, window cill, and particularly the pilasters.

• She re-iterated the concern about the exposed fixings and the overall quality of appearance.

Sarah agreed with me that the visual interest of the interfaces/junctions will be important and it was in the back of

her mind but not mentioned in the email. As such I would suggest a sample at least as big as the crop below.

I will be meeting Si m on on site on Wednesday to discuss selection. There are options which are steps up the cost

ladder which will also be discussed with the client

Regards

Bruce Sounes

TM01 0005924_0001 TMO10005924/1

For and on behalf of

STUDIO E LLP

Palace Wharf, Rainville Road, London W6 9HN T I F I www.studioe.co.uk

From: Amy Peck [mailto:amy.peck@ibigroup.com] Sent: 16 May 2014 10:35 To: philip.booth@uk.arteliagroup.com; Bruce Sounes; clwilliams@kctmo.org.uk Cc: Marc Watterson; Paul Sheppard Subject: RE: Grenfell - Meeting attendees

Dear all

Do you have any observations on Sarah's email?

She seems to be commenting on appearance of material and the manner of fixings- in Marc's absence, can you

advise on whether the materials you have identified can be seen in a better light elsewhere? Is it more a question of

how they have been fitted?

Do we have examples oftextured I brushed fixings which would be suitable?

Kind regards

Amy

Amy Peck Town Planner- 181 TaylorYoung Studio Associate

181 TaylorYoung Chadsworth House Wilmslow Road Handforth Cheshire SK9 3HP United Kingdom

email amy.peck@ibigroup.com web www.taylorvoung.co.uk

NOTE: This e-mail message and attachments may contain privileged and confidential information. If you have received this message in error, please immediately notify the sender and delete this e-mail message.

From: Sarah.Scannell@rbkc.qov.uk [mailto:Sarah.Scannell@rbkc.qov.uk] Sent: 16 May 2014 10:02 To: Marc Watterson Cc: philip.booth@uk.arteliaqroup.com; bruce@studioe.co.uk; Amy Peck; clwilliams@kctmo.orq.uk Subject: RE: Grenfell - Meeting attendees

Marc,

I have now had an opportunity to visit the buildings we discussed in the meeting . Unfortunately, we remain unconvinced that the panels would provide a long term quality required for such a high profile building. Overall the buildings have a flat, almost dull , appearance. The fixings are clearly visible and on many of the panels. In some cases the fixings have not be aligned , resulting in a random and un-uniform appearance. In addition, many of the panels had not weathered well , with water damage and accumulation of dirt around ledges, pipes etc.

2

TM01 0005924_0002 TMO10005924/2

I am interested to understand if the more textured or brushed finish would alleviate some of these issues. Do you have any examples of where a more textured panel has been used on a building that we could go and visit?

Regards,

Sarah Scannell Senior Planner 1 Strategic Developments 1 Development Management Planning and Borough Development The Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea The Town Hall, Hornton Street, London, W8 7NX

Tel: Email: sarah.scannell@rbkc.gov.uk 1 Website: www.rbkc.gov.uk

Register at MyRBKC to receive updates about planning, parking, news and more: www.rbkc.gov.uk/myRBKC Web I Twitter I Facebook I Youtube

From: Marc Watterson [mailto:marc.watterson@ibiqroup.com] Sent: 08 May 2014 16:47 To: Scannell, Sarah: PC-Plan Cc: BOOTH Philip; bruce@studioe.co.uk; Amy Peck Subject: Grenfell - Meeting attendees

Dear Sarah

Thanks for the meeting today. Attendees were as follows -

Claire Williams, KCTMO Steve Slake, Rydons (contractor) Bruce Sounes, Studio E Architects Philip Booth, Artelia Peter Blythe, Artelia

I would be grateful if you could copy Philip and Bruce into any emails (as per cc) whilst I am on leave (back 27'h May) as well as my colleague Amy Peck who is the first port of call (for KALC and MR too) in my absence.

Kind regards

Marc Watterson Town Planner- 181 TaylorYoung Senior Studio Associate

181 TaylorYoung Chadsworth House Wilmslow Road Handforth Cheshire SK9 3HP United Kingdom

NOTE: This e-mail message and attachments may contain privileged and confidential information. If you have received this message in error, please immediately notify the sender and delete this e-mail message.

3

TM01 0005924_0003 TMO10005924/3

*********************************************************** The Royal Borough ofKensington and Chelsea. This e-mail may contain information which is confidential, legally privileged and/or copyright protected. This e-mail is intended for the addressee only. If you receive this in error, please contact the sender and delete the material from your computer.

************************************************************

4

TM01 0005924_0004 TMO10005924/4