title 〈論文〉芸術作品の存在論における曖昧なタイ …- 59 - ¥ô2 @0 e /_mp ;2...
TRANSCRIPT
Title 〈論文〉芸術作品の存在論における曖昧なタイプ説の批判的検討
Author(s) 西條, 玲奈
Citation 哲学論叢 (2014), 41: 59-70
Issue Date 2014-11
URL http://hdl.handle.net/2433/200736
Right
Type Departmental Bulletin Paper
Textversion publisher
Kyoto University
- 59 -
ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀ0��EƉƆ/_MpȻ2şÆǍƞȭ
ȣƛƾđ
�����
� ƴÏ@ɷƠ2B�0�ȑȘZ{��2�03í�¥ô�ȡź2lj/E�ƀ,�ƴ�FE
�-��E�YOMU[mK� 17�ǭÅɼ0Ąǥ�%őÏwUr[�I§0�B��R
�^��NO�\� 1948ĵ0É¥�%Kz�Sƅdž2wUr[�,3�wUr[Ď��
`�S�ƽ0-.>IÊ��ȖĮĶɱ� 1980ĵ0Ȏè0��%NINAGAWAwUr[�
3�ƂƐȺ2ȉƐIǂ +�Ȏèȝǻ?Țȝ?���2[Wad~�e�CĝÿƙĭƇ�
2ƂƐ2?20ĉƋ�FE��ƴ2ƻʼn�Č 0lj/E0?ɫHC �#FC�í�¥ô
2?2,�E�-IȩĢ3ǀȪ�E�í�¥ô2ɞ��ƴ-H�E�C�#�#2ƴÁ@
ƴĒ0Ħ�+�Žſ,�E�å¼Ǎ,�E- (%ȳª@ƪɎ�çȈ0/E2&�
� �)2¥ô�íƇ0ȡź2�ƴI?'�E�- �ƻʼn3âňçȈŏ-ò4FE��F
3ɔĴ2®¢03/ ƻʼn,�E��ɪ2®¢,�E^U~b[@Ǜ�Ąǥ0Èǂ�+
E~apdapW�m}�_3�íƇ0ȡź2Âɳ�%Ćř0ĚĀ��/ �ƻĠ2ƇƵ
0ƻĠ2Ćř2<0¡ǻ�E- �ƻʼn3�âňçȈŏ0Ħ�+īřŏ-ò4FE�âň
çȈŏ- �ƻʼnIƎ�EȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀǍɋÂIÂƓ�Eɂɀ,3�Č��_MpȻ
-öîɀ- ��)2ǢĆ��E(1)�_MpȻ-3�¥ô-�ƴ2ɫ«I_Mp�d�U
�ɫ«,ÂƓ�EǢĆ,�D(cf. Currie, 1989; Dodd, 2000, 2002, 2004, 2007; Kivy, 1993;
Levinson, 1980; Wolterstorff, 1975)�öîɀ3¥ôIâňçȈ/ĦɄ-</�/ ǢĆ2Ƕǝ
,�E�öîɀ2�țǍǢĆ,3�¥ô3®�2�ƴ2�);D&-ȁ�CFE(cf.
Goodman,1976; Caplan & Matheson, 2006)�ƐǠ,3�ȑȘ¥ô2_MpȻ2�,?-DH
�ƎÐ/Z}�K��eae2ƉƆ/_MpȻ��_MpȻ2ƥɯIȟ��HD0Ɛƒ³
�+ %ÈƵIď��-IƃC�0�E�
������9�"1�
� âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ô2_MpȻ-3�¥ô-�ƴ2ɫ«I_Mp-d�U�,ÂƓ�E
ǢĆ,�E�ĚĀɀǍ/œñ,2_Mp-d�U�2ÙÇ-3��ȏǍ/ǟ-#2�§2
ÙÇ- �E�%-�4�ɪ- �ǟ�_Mp,�F4p~d�@K�[db�[- (
%®¢3#2d�U�- HFE��2-�_Mp-�+3 1)2ĚĀȂ�� / ��
- 60 -
d�U�-�+3 2)2ĚĀȂ� E�-0/E��2B�0�_Mp-d�U�2ĚĀ
ɀǍɋÂ2ɞ 3��)2_Mp0Ħ�+#2d�U�3ȡźĚĀ��E�- �Ƶ0�
E�Ò�+��4�4_Mp3ŤɄǍĚĀȂ,�E20Ħ�+d�U�3ƇǡǍ¡ǻI?
)»¢ƺ-</�FE�âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ô2_MpȻ-3�¥Ȃ�É¥�EɷƠ@ƴÏ
2¥ô3ŤɄǍ_Mp&-�Ľ�EǢĆ,�E�
_MpȻ0BEÂƓ2ÈƵ-�+�ȑȘ¥ô0ɫHE��2 4)2ƿɄIĤƄ0Ȼƃ,�
E�-���CFE�(1) ¥ô2âňçȈŏ�(2) lj/E�ƴ2ɆǍɾ ŏ�ƴĒģ@ƴÁ
ģ�ɞ(+?í�¥ô2�ƴ,�F4� 0ºɔ2ȤǯI?)�(3) ¥ô-�ƴ2ĚĀ©
Ě2ɫ«�¥ô�ĚĀ�/�F4#2�ƴ3�D�/ ��.2B�/�ƴ�ĚĀ�E�
0��HC ¥ô3ĚĀ�E�);D¥ô3�ƴBDĚĀɀǍ0µ¡,�E�(4) ȑȘZ
{��2ȌƸ/Âɾ�Dzdž@ŁË�ĹǪ2B�0É¥�F%?2-�ƴ�ÙÇ�F/ ȑ
ȘZ{��-âňçȈ/ȑȘZ{��IÙÇ,�E��ƴ�FEǟɾ2ȑȘ¥ô2?)�
FC2ƻʼn3_MpȻIÕƤ*�E?2- �B��
� £BD_MpȻ,3�(1) ¥ô2âňçȈŏI_Mp2âňçȈŏ�CÂƓ,�E�%
-�4 “Words, words, words.” - �jy�ad2èȴ3�1)2Ⱥ_Mp- 3)2Ⱥd�
U��C/E�ǺDɑ�0/E��_Mp3ȡź2d�U�I?'�E- �ƻʼnI?)�
�F3Ⱥ�âňçȈ/?2,�E�-Iœñ�E�âňçȈŏ3�ƴÏ@ɷƠ0³HEƻ
ʼn&(%�#�&-�F4�¥ô3_Mp�#2�ƴ3d�U�,�E-</�23ȌƸ
/�-&�R�^��NO�\��ƴ-ǎǓIÖ>%wUr[�?�ȖĮĶɱ�ƂƐɿ
2Țȝ-Ȏèȝǻ,ƴÁ�%NINAGAWAwUr[�?í�¥ôwUr[�_Mp2
lj/E�ƴd�U�,�E�words ��ɵ2M�U2Ȇǥ,Ȯ�F+?�ɦč Ĉ2Džŏ
�NJȶ�+?í� words_Mp2d�U�,�EB�0��ƴ#F$F0lj/EƵ��(
+?�í�_Mp,�E%>2ŏɆI³�+ F4í�¥ô0ijĬ�E�
� #?#?�_Mp-d�U�2ɫ«3.2B�/?2��_Mp2?)ŏɆ P1…Pn3£
��#2d�U�,�E%>2ŋȤÚÂƑ�,�E(Wolheim, 1968, pp. 64-65)�»¢Ǎ0
P1…Pn0ǐĿ�EŏɆ�£,�E�3ȑȘZ{��0Ō�+lj/E&G��§�4�å¼
Ǎ/ɷƠ¥ô,�F4¥Ɗģ�É¥�%ŤɄǍ/ɷƢɖ-í�ȧ�FE�?�F/ �;
%í��å¼Ǎ/ƴÏ¥ô,�F4�Ï¥ģ2Ąǥ�%ȉƐ0ŭ¿�F%Áƒ�2ɗ/D
�ǐĿ�E�?�F/ �_Mp2?)ŏɆ�£,�G�-?��E�ƴ�£C�2¥ô
0ijĬ�E23�Ŀȷ¥ô2?)ŏɆI#2�ƴ�?)�C,�E��2œñ,�_Mp
2?)ŏɆ3#2d�U�-/E%>2Ȧǩ,�E (Wolterstorff, 1975, p. 129)�?��ƴĒ
2x[@èȴ2ȫ ɪɞ /.0B(+�_Mp2?)ŏɆIƱ%�/�F4�#F3Ŀ
ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀ0��EƉƆ/_MpȻ2şÆǍƞȭ
- 61 -
ȷ¥ô2d�U�-�+3ďŹ/ ��ƨǖ/2,�E��2œñ,�âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥
ô3Ȧǩ_Mp-�+ǀȪ�FE�
� �C0�_MpȻ,3�(2) lj/E�ƴ�#2İlj0?ɫHC �� 0ɆǍ0ɾ �
E�-?Ȼƃ,�E��F3�âňçȈŏ2?��)2²ɶ-ȫ(+?B &G��_M
p-#2d�U��ŏɆIºƎ�E/C4�d�U�íć?;%ºɔ�E?2��E3
,�E��/H'�_Mp2?)ŏɆ PI�œ2lj/E 2)2d�U� x- y�?)/C
4�d�U� x-d�U� y3º0 PIºƎ�E- �Ƶ,ɾ �E�.2ƴÁģ�Ȏè
0��%?2,�F�ȩĢ3wUr[�2�ƴIǏ0�+��2őÏ��[Wad~�
e2ĨɌwUr[2ɦŊ-ƽ¡ǫē�#�+ƭȔIŭ %?2,�E�-IǀȪ��ɛó
0Ȁĺ�FEĘ0ŊŜ%FE�?�F/ ��F3�ƴÁ0İlj��(+?�wUr[�
-�+íĠ,�EƺȺ-�+2Ƣɖ��D�#FA��ȩĢ0�Ġ2ÓƔIļ�ɇ���
-�,�E�C,�E�?�� 0ɾ �%-�G�/�F4�lj/Eȡź2�ƴ��í
�¥ô0ijĬ�E�-3ȩĢ0ǀȪ�F/ &G���2B�0�_MpȻ3í�¥ô2
lj/E�ƴ�� 0ɆǍ0ɾ �E�-IĤƄ0ÂƓ,�E2,�E�
� Ò�+�(3) ¥ô-�ƴ2ĚĀ©Ěɫ«0) +?_MpȻ3ĖĿ/ȻƃI٨�E�
��, A� B0ĚĀ©Ě�E-3�B/�0 A3ĚĀ��/ - ��-,�E��2
œñ,�d�U�3_Mp2ĚĀ0©Ě�E��ɓ3ŕDǢ%/ �%-�4�“words”
- �ȺI�Ǜ�âňçȈ/Ⱥ_Mp2�§-�+¦H/�(%-�+?�words _Mp
2ĚĀ03łɸ�/ �_Mp�ĚĀ�E�--�.2B�/d�U��ġɰ0ĚĀ�E
��- �øɽ3Ʒɫ«/2,�E�
� _Mp-d�U�2ĚĀ©Ěɫ«-2Kf�Z�3¥ô-�ƴ2� &0?ŕDǢ)�
%-�4��M|�YOMU[mKS�lg�2ƒƂ��Ƨ�F�q���ú��2�ƴ
�/�/(%-�+?�q���ú��- �¥ô�ưƳ�E�-3/ &G��;%�
%-�d�U���)?ĚĀ�/ -�+?_Mp3ĚĀ�E�PN�mc[�Ąǥ�%
-�FEďHF%Y�Y}v[2őÏ3��@�ƴ�FE�-3/ ����Y�Y}
v[�_Mp�ĚĀ�EɭD�PN�mc[��2¥ôIÉ¥�%- ��ġ3ŲE�/
2,�E��2B�0��ƴ3¥ô0©Ě�E��¥ô��ƴ0©Ě�/ �-3�_
Mp-d�U�2ɫ«-ɾƪǍ,�E��%�(+�_MpȻ,3�¥ôI_Mp-</
��-,��ƴBD?¥ô�ĚĀɀǍ0µ¡,�E�-IĤƄ0ÂƓ,�E- �ÈƵI
?)�
� ƍņ0ũ�E_MpȻ2ÈƵ3�(4) ȑȘZ{��2ȌƸ/Âɾ�çȈ-/E�- �
?2&��F�çȈ0/E23�_Mp�ŤɄǍĦɄ,�E�-0DŽƒ�E�ȑȘZ{�
- 62 -
�2�03�ɷƠ@ƴÏ&�,3/���0?Dzdž�ŁË�ĹǪ/.��D�Dzdž@ŁË
¥ô2Ćì��4�4É¥�F%»¢ƺ�¥ô#2?2,�E�»¢ƺ3īřǍ,�D�
âňçȈŏI?%/ �%-�4wi2�R~�mK��íƇ0ȡź2Ćř0ĚĀ�E�
-3/ &G��%-�#2ȡȠdž�É¥�F%-�+?�#F3�R~�mK�,3/
���R~�mK2ȡȠ�-,?ò8EÇ2¥ô,�E�ȑȘ03����%ö�ŏIƻʼn
-�EZ{��-�âňçȈŏIƻʼn�EZ{��-��E�ÍȂ2ǟɾ2ȑȘ0Ĭ�E
¥ô3%&�)2»¢ƺ,�E�_MpȻ,�F4�ņȂ2Z{��2¥ô3ŤɄǍ_M
p,�D�ö�ŏ2ȑȘ-3ĚĀȂ2ǟɾ0� +ÙÇ,�E�_MpȻ3���%ȑȘ
Z{��2Âɾ0ĚĀɀǍąǗI��CFE2,�E�
� ��,ŨŴ�%_MpȻ2ÈƵI;->E-�(1) ¥ô2âňçȈŏ�(2) í�¥ô2lj
/E�ƴ�?)ɆǍɾ ŏ�(3) ¥ô-�ƴ2Ě©Ěɫ«�(4) ȑȘ¥ô2ÂɾIÂƓ,�
E�-,�E�¥ôIŤɄǍ/_Mp-í�ȧ�EƀɧIŬǂ�EÕƤ3�ȡź�E-
(+B &G��
������9�/1���#;����� �!,
� ���/�C�_MpȻ03 �)�2ýɴ�ŨŴ�F+ E�ƐǠ?;%_MpȻ2
şÆIǏǍ-�E��ƁĚ2_MpȻ72şÆ��ŋ �?ǍIħ%?2-3ȁ�/ �
#�,ƐǨ,3�_MpȻ2ýɴ-�FE?22�'�(5) É¥ȗƶ��çȈ0/E-
�Îɖ2l\�I�ƦǨ,3 (6) ¥ô�Çƣ2çȈŏI?'�/ - �ƣǐǍƖɍ�2
øɽIƞȭ�E(2)�ƐǨ,3�; (5) Îɖ2l\��_MpȻ0-(+ƬĠǍ/şÆ,
3/ �-Iǘ��#2�,�ƦǨ,3�Z}�K��ead� (6) ƣǐǍƖɍ�IȻƃ
�8�Ůǘ�%ȪƬǧ��ġ3_MpȻ2ÈƵIų1+ E�-IŨŴ�E�
� (5) Îɖ2l\�-3�_MpȻ2ðœ�E�Ľ3�¥ô�¥Ȃ0B(+ǁ<Á�FE
- ��ġ-�Ǣ�çȈ0/(+�;��- �?2,�E(3)��F3_MpIŤɄǍĦ
Ʉ-</�Ƶ0DŽƒ�E�ŤɄǍ/?23ƇǡǍ¡ǻI?% �üƔɫ«I?% ���
łɸIá:��-3,�/ �#�&-�F4ŤɄǍ/?2I�ſ%0��ÎDÁ��-
3,�/ �����YOMU[mK�ŗƊIĄǥ�V��oĸ,�ƴ�FE;,wU
r[�3ĚĀ�+ /�(%3 ,�E��%�(+�¥ô�¥Ȃ0B(+Îɖ�FE?
2/C4�¥ô3ŤɄǍ_Mp,3/ �l\�2½Ĥ3���%?2,�E�
� �2l\�2ɂɀIƦ2B�0Żǀ,�E�
ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀ0��EƉƆ/_MpȻ2şÆǍƞȭ
- 63 -
(7) �3âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ôIÎɖ�E�-�,�E�
(8) âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ô3_Mp,�E�
(9) _Mp3ŤɄǍ,�E�
(10) �3ŤɄǍ/?2IÎɖ�E�-�,�/ �
(11) �3âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ôIÎɖ�E�-�,�/ �(8�9�10BD)
(7) - (11) IíƇ0�Ľ�E-��3âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ôIÎɖ�E�-�,���)Î
ɖ,�/ - �ǔǑ0ɯE�ǔǑIûɡ�E03ɂɀ2[bap2�'�_MpȻ2�
Ľ#2?2,�E (8) Iɮ��(7)�(9)�(10) 2 F�IïĠ�F4B �(10) ŤɄǍ
ĦɄI��¥DÁ!/ 23�ŤɄŏ- �ơō2ĠǾ�ĖĿ0Ŏ�E�ŤɄƺ-3Ƈǡ
Ǎ0¡ǻ�/ ?2,�E�¥Ȃ�ƺǀǍ�LJ0¡ǻ�E���ŤɄƺ0.2B�0KU
][��#FIÎɖ�E�IȻƃ�E23ýɴ�)�;-��#F,3 (9) IïĠ�_M
pI»¢ǍĦɄ-�Eɠţ3çȈ&G��(4)�����âňçȈŏ- �ƻʼnI�»¢ƺ
0ijĬ�!E�-3Đĕ�����- �2?�ƇǡǍ¡ǻI?'üƔǍłɸ2ǵ2Ǐ0
ǰ<ɐ;F%ĦɄ3��ȏ0�íƇ0ȡź2Ćř0ĚĀ��/ �C,�E�#2%>�
ƐǠ,3 (7) IïĠ��âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ô3Îɖ�çȈ,�E- ��ĽIŵɃ�%Z
}�K��eae2ɈǸIɊȢ�E�
� ���/�CâňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ô�Îɖ�çȈ,�E- ��Ľ3�¸��ġ0â�E
B�0Ŏ�E�£�IÎɖ�E-3��F;,ĚĀ�/�(%?2Iſ%0ǁ<Á��-
,�E�_Mp�ŤɄǍ/C�#FIÎɖ�E�-3�çȈ0/E������F3��
2ŖLj�ÎɖŏIи0ŸƜ�E�-Iœñ�/ ��¥Ȃ a�¥ô bIÉ¥�E�-3�
�a � b INJȥ�E�-&-ȁ�CFE�C&�);D�ÎɖINJȥ2�ǟ--C�E
2,�E�¥ô�Îɖ�FE2,3/�NJȥ�FE-�F4�¥Ɗģ@Ï¥ģ�ƴÁģ�
¥ôIÉ¥�Eȗƶ3�ĠǀIȲƃ�EźěȂ@�ȌƸ2�0ŕǢ�E�ƕINJȥ�EȌ
ƸǜěȂ2#F-ɾ �%?2-�+ǀȪ,�E�
� ǜěǍ�ġINJȥ�EB�0ȑȘ¥ôINJȥ�E-ȁ�E23�¥Ȃ2ÎɖŏIÚ¸0
Ȼƃ�+ / B�0ƅE�?�F/ �MwhP��S�d3ȌƸǜěȂ-ȑȘģIƦ
2B�0Ħƪ�E�g}�d�2NJȥ�%ɛÕƀǞĻ3�ěǿ0B(+g}�d��Ċ2
�ƺ,?ĩ��-�,�E��ěǿ0B(+tz�[2ǁ<Á�B�/ȵæI)=��-
3ýɴ,3/ �(S�d, 1965, 47Ǩ)�?�?Îɖ�Û/ENJȥ0ɝ�/ -�%C�#
2ŚǴ���ěǿ�F4�Ƚ?�#2B�/¥ôIÉ¥,�E�-0/E�#�&-�F
4�#2¥Ȃ�ÎɖǍ- �ŏɆI?)-3ȫ 0� B�0Ŏ�E�
- 64 -
� ÎɖINJȥ-�ǟ-</�-Îɖŏ�ďHFE- �şÆ0Ħ�+�eae3�NJȥ?
;%ÎɖǍ,�D�E-âɀ�E�
ÎɖǍŎȁ-3ċ�2�03)�<ãF/ óɽIšů��ǀȪ,�/ óɽɪ2)
/�DIȥ &��-,�E�í��-3�#C�ɷƠ2ɻă0��EÎɖŏ0?Ŀ
+3;E�¥Ɗģ�ÎɖǍ/23�¥ôIĚĀ�!E�C,3/��¥ôIǹ<Á�
ɰ0Œ´ÐINJŰ�EŋȤ��E�C/2&�(Dodd, 2000, p. 428)
£�INJȥ�EĆì0?�Ƚ0,?ĤƄ0,�ENJȥ-�#�,3/ ?2��E�ș2
�Ŋ0�EIJŃřIȥ)�E�-3Ƚ?�,�E�?�F/ ��ǼǍª°I��ɷ2ɗ
/D@ȫȕ2ÄIȥ)�Á��-3ĤƄ-3ȫ �% �ýɴ/NJȥ2¥Ɵ3ŠȘ@śȨ
�ŋȤ�?�F �Ƚ?�Ň,�E-3ɭC/ �ȑȘ¥ô2É¥IÎɖǍNJȥ--C
�F4�¥Ȃ2ÎɖŏIȻƃ,�EB�0ŎHFE��/H'�_MpȻ0� +�Îɖ
-3�NJȥ2�-09�/C �ýɴ/NJȥ0� +¥Ȃ2Îɖŏ3NJŰ�FE2,�E�
������9�/1���.43-:��%<� �(5�
� Îɖ2l\�0Ò�+�?�?¥ô�_Mp/C4�¥ô�ġɰ-lj/(+ %çȈŏ
Iūɮ�+�;�- �şÆ��E(5)�Rohrbaugh(2003, p. 178)0¯ �£��ġɰ-3lj
/EçȈǍŏɆI?)�-IĿȷ2�ƺ�ƣǐǍ0Ɩɍ,�E- ���%-�4�K�
[db�[3ġɰ-3lj/DĔŏ&(%�?�F/ ��2-�K�[db�[3�Ĕŏ
,�D�E- �çȈǍŏɆI?)�íƣ0ȑȘ¥ô?çȈǍŏɆI?)�%-�4�w
Ur[�2k�UQ�3Őɏ/�ƺ-�+ŭ�F+ %�?�F/ ��Y}�r�d2
�ƏĞŕ�ɸƊ�3Ǥ 4ǣ;,¥Ɗ�F+ %�?�F/ ��ȏ0�ȑȘ¥ô3ġɰ-
lj/EŏɆIŧ'�E�
� ����_MpȻ3¥ô�ƣǐǍ0Ɩɍ,�E�-IȯĤ,�/ �_Mp3ġɰ-3
ɞ�ŏɆI?'�/ �C,�E�1 Ǩ,ɒ8%B�0�_Mp2?)ŏɆ3#2d�U
�,�E%>2ŋȤÚÂƑ�,�E� H4�.2B�/ŏɆI?)�,_Mp3ĠǾ�
FE�%-�4�ȋƇȬ_Mp03�Ƈɪ2DZɝIǕC!E�ȋ0ı���CFE- �
ŏɆ��E��2ƻʼnIƥ %?23�?3@ȋƇȬ-3ò4F/ ��ȏ0�_Mp T
� F- �ŏɆI?)/C�#2d�U�3 FIƥ��-3�D�/ �#2%>¥ôI
_Mp-í�ȧ�E���¥ô?;%ġɰ-ɞ�ŏɆI?'�/ ��F3¥ô�çȈǍ
ŏɆI?)�-2ťdzIœñ�E��2B�0_MpȻ3¥ô�çȈǍŏɆI?)�--
ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀ0��EƉƆ/_MpȻ2şÆǍƞȭ
- 65 -
�Ǣ�çȈ/2,�E�
� _MpȻ�ƣǐǍƖɍ�2øɽ0ĦÀ�EƀƯ3ȡź�E��)3�¥ô�ƣǐǍƖɍ
�I?%/ �-�Ľ�E�-&�?�Ī�,?Ç2�DƀI�+ F4�#F3?3@
Ç2¥ô&-ȁ�E2,�E��wUr[�,3k�UQ��Őɏ0ŭ�F+ %�?�
F/ - �çȈŏIɒ8E�-3ǖ�0ȌƸ,�E������2B�/ȺDƀ3=
�Gßĥ03ɪɞ &-ȁ�E�-?,�E��2-�ȫá�+ E23wUr[�-
�ƿġ2¥ô,3/��wUr[�-B� %Ç2¥ôwUr[*�0��/ �#
?#?â�ġǍ/çȈǍŏɆI¥ô0ȹ>E-�3�.2B�/çȈǍŏɆ/C4¥ô0
ijĬ,�E��#2ąƲIÆž�/�+3/C/ �%-�4¸ż�Xe�IŅ'/�
C�2n~�[Ⱥ,�EB�/çȈǍŏɆIwUr[�0ijĬ�!E�-3ʀʄ�+
E�#�&-�F4�ƣǐǍƖɍ�Iȹ>/ ƀɧ?�%&'0Ý��FE8�,3/ �
� �E 3�@3D_MpȻI�Ľ�/�C�¥ô2ƣǐǍƖɍ�Iȹ>EƀɧI-E�
-?,�E�%-�4Z}�K��eae3ƉƆ/_Mp- �KMcLK0ȱ�+�F
Iŕ�ɚ�B�-�E(Dodd, 2004, pp. 349-350)�%&����,3ƉƆ/_MpȻ0BE
ŌǦIƞȭ�EÍ0�ƣǐơō0ȱ�/ íǟ2ýɴIŮǘ�E�#F0BD�ƉƆ/_
Mp- �ơō�ýɴIȪƬ�E20/"ŋȤ-�FE�Iƃǖ0�E�#2ýɴ-3¥
ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽ,�E�
������9�/1��� $'&�+*��%<�����706�
� ƣǐǍƖɍ�2øɽ3�¥ô�Çƣ2çȈŏI?%/ -ȹ>E¤ā?Ʃ�F+ %�
#�,�ƣǐơō0ȱ� �_MpȻŶŧȂ0ƉƆ/_MpIȤȿ�Eøɽ-�+�¥ô
ijĬ2ƉƆ�- �øɽIſ%0Ůǘ�% �¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽ0ĦŌ�B�-�
E-�_MpȻ3�Ɛƒ³�+ %ÈƵ (2) �ƴíć2ɆǍɾ ŏ2ȻƃIų/��-0
/(+�;��£C�2ýɴ0ĦŌ�B�-�+�2ÈƵIď�-�F4�#F3_Mp
Ȼ0-(+ǒɝ,�/ øɽ&- �E&G��
� ¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�-3��E�ƴ�ƻĠ2¥ô2�ƴ,�E%>0Ʊ%�8�Ƒ�3Ɖ
Ɔ&- ��-,�E�1Ǩ,3_Mp�?)�ǽ2ŏɆ P1…Pn3#2d�U�,�E%
>2ŋȤÚÂƑ�&-ɒ8%�¥ô2ijĬ�ƉƆ,�F4��E�ƴ�ƻĠ2¥ô2d�
U�,�E%>2ŋȤÚÂƑ�,�EŏɆ��œ0Ġ;C/ �-Iœñ�E�
� %-�4�YOMU[mK2Ąǥ�%wUr[�2ÞǠ�wUr[�_MpIțƿ
�+�D�#2d�U�3#2ĄǥÞǠ0Ȯ�F%�--ɟì�/�F4/C/ -�B
������ġɰ03YOMU[mK2bT[d�Cƣ�/Ƶ,əȊ�%�ƴ�wUr
- 66 -
[�2î2�,�ƴ�F+ E�%-�4R�^��NO�\2ƅdž¥ôwUr[�3�
YOMU[mK2Þ¥0p�ad�2ĉƋIÒ�E�NO�\3ȃȅȂ2T{~U_�I
ſ%0NjĆ�!�wUr[Ď��`�S�ƽ0-.>IÊ��;%ȖĮĶɱ3���2[
Wad~�e�Ȏè2�2¥ôIĝÿƙĭƇ�2ƂƐ0ĉƋ��YOMU[mK2ȒȺI
¸+ƂƐȺ,Ȏè0��E�NO�\-ȖĮ2wUr[�Iƪ8%&�,?�ɘȗ�E
Áƒ��NjĆ�E�ƺ�¦ǂȫȺ�Ȏèȝǻ@Țȝ�.F?lj/E0?ɫHC �#2�
ƴ3í�wUr[�0ijĬ�+ E2&��F3d�U��Ʊ%�8�ŏɆ P1…Pn��
œ0Ġ;E?2,3/ �-Iǘ�+ E�
� _MpȻ0-(+¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽ3Ʀ2B�/ƢɖI?)ɂɀ,�E�
(12) x3¥ô_Mp T2d�U�,�E�
(13) �œ2�ƴ x�_Mp T2d�U�/C4�T2?)ŏɆ P1…PnI x3?)�
(14) x3 P1…Pn2�'Ī/�-?�)Iƥ��;%3Ç2ŏɆQI?)�-��E�
(15) x3¥ô_Mp T2d�U�,3/ �
ȖĮ2Ȏè3ȒȺ2ȵæ�?)ȫȺǍƢɖI�Ã?%/ ��NO�\2ƅdž03Þ¥0
NjĆ�/ ſ%/T{~U_��ĚĀ�E�#�&-�F4wUr[�2d�U�-<
/�FE3 2�FC2�ƴ3�_Mp-d�U�2ɫ«IȁŔ�E-�.'C?wU
r[�,3/ �-0/E�
� ¥ô_MpIȦǩǟ-</�gW~[�NQ�_�[d�n2ǢĆ��ƉƆ�2øɽI
Ȫư�E20ŃǢ)B�0ȥ�E�?�F/ (Wolterstorff, 1975, p. 127)�ń0BF4�¥
ô-3�ƴ0-(+2Ȧǩ,�E��ƴ�_Mp2ŏɆI¸+ºƎ�+ F4ɟÃ/�§�
#�,/�F4�ɟÃ/�§-/E����¥ôIȦǩǟ-ǀȪ�+?�ƉƆ�2øɽI
Ȫư,�E-3ȫ �% ��2ąƲ0�%��4�NO�\@ȖĮ2�ƴ3�.'C?
wUr[�2�ɟÃ/�§0ǐĿ�E�ɟÃ/�ƴd�U�0/(+�;��&��ń
C2wUr[�2�ƴ3�ɔĴ�ŃȂ�èȴIȫ ɪɞ�EĆì-3lj/D��ɟÃ/
�ƴ-3</�F+ / �.'C2�ƴ?�¥ô2�ɟÃ/�§-ǀȪ�EBD�ƴÁ
ģ0BE¥ô2ſ%/Ȫɤ2ġɉ-</�ƀ�6�H� B�0Ŏ�E�
� �2B�0�¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽ3�_Mp�d�U�0ßƘ/Ƒ�IȾ��A�
0��;�;/�ƴ2İljIȻƃ��% - �şÆ-�+_MpȻ0ɬD��E�ƴÏ
@ɷƠ¥ô2�ƴ�-2ɞ I.2B�0ȯĤ�E��_MpȻ2Ⱦɽ- �E&G��
� �2şÆ3�¶0ũ�%ƣǐǍƖɍ�2øɽ-ɾ �%Ƶ��E�.'C?�_Mp�
ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀ0��EƉƆ/_MpȻ2şÆǍƞȭ
- 67 -
d�U�0Ⱦ�EƑ��ßƘ��+�ġɰ2ȑȘ¥ô2�Dƀ0ɟì�/ - �ŨŴ&
�C,�E�����ƣǐǍƖɍ�2øɽ0Ħ�+3�%-�4�ȑȘ¥ô3Ç2�Dƀ
I?'�/ 2&�CƖɍ,/�-?�;H/ �-Ō�E�-?,�E��KuN2ƣ
ǐǍƖɍ�0BEşÆ-ɞ �¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽ3�ƣǐơō0ȱ�E�-/�_
MpȻ2øɽIƃC�0,�EƵ,şÆ-�+BDÛǮ�2Ƶ,×E2,�E�
��+*����9���(5� �%<1�
� Z}�K��eae2Ů÷�EƉƆ/_MpȻIűǂ�F4�ɀȲ2[bap (14) x3
P1…Pn2�'Ī/�-?�)Iƥ��;%3Ç2ŏɆQI?)�-��E�IïĠ�E�
-,�¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽIȪƬ,�E�);D��ȥ_Mp2ŏɆ-�ȍ�/ B
�0ȥ�E�ƴ?�#2Ƒ�IƱ%�-�Ľ�E2&���,ÈǂçȈ/KMcLK��
ƉƆ/_Mp,�E(Dodd, 2004, pp. 349-350)�eae?;%_Mp2?)ŏɆ3�#2d
�U��Ʊ%�8�ŋȤÚÂƑ�&-ȁ�E�%&�_Mp03ƉƆ/?2-#�,/
?2��E�ƉƆ,/ _Mp-3%-�4 α- �żę,�E�αd�U�3Č��@
ę¢�lj/(+?�#2ƢɖǍŏɆ3ƉƆ,3/ �C&�Ħ�+�ƉƆ/_Mp-3�
_Mp2?)ƢɖǍŏɆ��/H'#2_Mp,�E%>2ŋȤÚÂƑ��ƉƆ/?2,
�E�);D�¥ô_Mp T 2?)ŏɆ P1…Pn 3ǖĠ�%?2,3/��ƉƆ&-ȁ�
E2,�E�
� %-�4�ƴÏ¥ô2Ćì�èȴI.2Ǟķ2ɕ�,ȼ<��E2��dƌ�0£?ƌ
�ɐ;F+ / ĆìŃȂ3.2B�/ɋŪDI�E2��- (%?2&�¶0ũ�%
NO�\@ȖĮ2�ƴI§0�E-�ƌ�F+ / Áƒ����ÒHE�¦ǂȫȺ�ĉ
Ƌ�FE- (%�¥ôIƢŕ�EƬĠǍŏɆ0ĉƋ��E�eae2ƉƆ/_MpȻ,
3����%�¥ô2ƢɖǍŏɆ0ɫ�EĉƋ��(%-�+?�d�U��ÚÂ0ɾ
�+ F4�í�_Mp0Ĭ�E3 &-ȁ�E�
� eae3ɷƠ¥ôI§0��ġɰ2ƠɁ-#2â�ġǍ/ƠɁ�.'C?í�¥ô2ƠɁ
-</!E�.��Ƭ>EĆì�®Ç2�§�.F&�ƨǖ0¥CF%�0įé�FE
(Dodd, 2004, p. 350)-ɒ8E�¥ô�É¥�FEĆɶ,�ġɰ-ċĪɞ(%ƠɁ�Ąǥ�F
+ %-�+?�%-�4r�d��O���b�s[d�I¥Ɗ�%�-3ĉHC/ �
í�B�0��)2ƴĒ�#F$Fɞ(%�ƀ,Ɂɶ0�ȍ�/�(%-�+?�ÚÂ0
ɾ �EɭD�í�¥ô2ƴĒ-</�FE�í�¥ô2�ƴ--</�FE%>0�.
2Ǟķ2ɾ ŏ�ƫ>CFE�3;%Ç2øɽ&�ƉƆ/_MpȻ2ȤƵ3�%-�_M
p2?)ŏɆ�#2d�U�,�E%>2ŋȤÚÂƑ�&-�+?�Ƒ�#2?2�ƉƆ
- 68 -
,�F4��ƴd�U�2İljIȯĤ,�E�-0�E��%�(+��œ2�ƴ x�_
Mp T2d�U�/C4�T2?)ŏɆ P1…Pn I x3ƥ��-?/�F4��2ŏɆ Q
I?)�-?/ �P1…Pn3 F?ǖĠ�%?2,3/�ƉƆ&�C,�E�_Mp2
ŏɆ�#?#?ƉƆ/C��ƴ�ƻĠ2¥ô0ijĬ�EƑ�?;%ƉƆ,�E��2B�
0�ƉƆ/_MpȻ3�ɀȲ2 (14) _Mp-d�U�2ŏɆ2��ȍIïĠ�E�-,�
¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽIȪư,�E�ÍǨ,Ş(%ƣǐǍƖɍ�I_MpȻ,Ş�E2
?íƣ2ǀDŽ0BE�â�ġǍ/ŏɆI¥ô�?'�E�-3�_Mp�?)ŏɆIƥ�
�-,3/ �#?#?_Mp2?)ŏɆ3ƉƆ/2,�#2ƉƆ�2ķì 2�0�â
�ġǍŏɆ?ð;F+ E�#F3ǷȐ2d�U�03�ɵ<��(%Ȑ?�F4�ʅñ
2ľ ?2?�E2-íƣ/2,�E�
� ���/�C�ƉƆ/_MpȻ3�¥ôijĬ2ƉƆ�2øɽIûɡ�E�-,�_Mp
Ȼ0Ɛƒ³HEÈƵIų/��-0/E�ų/HFEÈƵ-3 (2) lj/E�ƴíć2ɆǍ
ɾ ŏ2Ȼƃ,�E�í�_Mp0Ĭ�E�§3�í�ŏɆIºƎ�E�α - �żę2
d�U���.2B�/Č��@Ȑ&-�+?í� α,�E23ƻĠ2ŀƼ PIŧ)�C
,�E�
� ?�_Mp2?)ŏɆ�ƉƆ/?2&-�%C�d�U�íć2ɆǍɾ ŏIȻƃ�E
�-3,�/ �%-�4�Ȑ3ķì IȯĤ�EƉƆ/ŏɆ2¼Ă,�E�Ƿ_Mp2
d�U�03�ƃE�ʃ@�,ɵ<��(%?2?�F4���J,ʅñ2ľ ?2?�
E�ÍȂ2ȐI?)?23�ņȂBD?��2ɵ2d�U�0ɾ �E�?�F/ �Ɖ
Ɔ/ŏɆ2Ćì�.'C?Û0.'C?Ƿ,�E- �&�,�� 0ɆǍ0ɾ �E-
3ɭC/ �
� ƴÏ2�§I��B��%-�4�R]���_Mp03���¹3ȇ2ʆ Džŏ-
�ŏɆ��E�R]���d�U�2�03�żęɔDȇ2ʆ Džŏ�ƴ�%?2�nj�
Džŏ�ƴ�%?2�Ȑʆ2ȇIØǬ,¾ƿ�%?2��E 3Ȑnj2Ĕŏ��ƴIÖ>%
?2?�E��FC2�ƴ3���¹2Ċȥ��B5#��CȩĢ0��EÜɄ0ɞ �
ǁ�E����¹3ȇ2ʆ Džŏ- �ŏɆ�ƉƆ,�D��FC2�ƴ¸+0�+3;
E-�B���2-���ƴd�U�2� &03�ƴ2ŃȂ2ŏÇ@ȇ2Ȑ- (%ƻ
ʼnIºƎ�/ ��F3�í�_Mp2d�U�,�E�-IƗŦ0��ƴíć�ɾ �
E- �Ȼƃ0ďŹ�%Ćì&- �B��
� �2B�0�ë�ƴ�� 2İlj0?ɫHC �í�_Mp2d�U�,�E�A�0
ºɔ2ŏɆI?)2&-�%C�ƉƆ/_Mp2ĩ·3�#2Ȟ��IŚŸ��-0/D
�1/ �);D�ƉƆ/_MpȻIŬǂ�E�-3�d�U�ɪ2ɆǍɾ ŏIȻƃ�
ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀ0��EƉƆ/_MpȻ2şÆǍƞȭ
- 69 -
E_MpȻ2ÈƵIų/��-0/E2,�E��2ŨŴ�ƨ��F4�ƉƆ/_MpȻ
3ýɴIȪƬ�E�HD0�#2ÈƵIď��-0/D�_MpȻ2ŷùƚ-�+3�;
DʂÐǍ,3/ �#FA��ƉƆ/_MpȻ3�ŋ �?�âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀ
ɀǍɋÂIÂƓ�E20µF%ǀɀ,3/ &G��
���
� ƐǠ,3�âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ôI_Mp-�+ÂƓ�EǢĆ��ýɴIȪƬ�B�-�
+Ɛƒ2ÈƵIų/��#F��E�-IŨŴ�%�_Mp2?)ŏɆ3#2d�U�0
-(+ŋȤÚÂƑ�,�E�����ġɰ03�í�¥ôd�U�3�ƣ�/İljI?'�
-�0¥Ȃ2ŨǘIƷȧ��ŷĉ�E�-�C�E��2İljIȻƃ�E%>03�_M
p2ŏɆ�ƉƆ,�F4B �ŏɆ2ƉƆ�2ǩþ-�+ȯĤ�FEɭD0� +�ƉƆ
/_MpȻ3ȡź2¥ôd�U�2� &0İljIȹ>E�-�,�E������ķ_
Mp2ŏɆ�ƉƆ,�E�-Iȹ>+�;�-�í�¥ô2d�U��� 0ɾ �E�
-IȻƃ�E- �_MpȻ0³H(%ÈƵIų/HFE�ƉƆ/ŏɆIºƎ�Eȡź2
�ƺ�� 0ɆǍ0ɾ �E-3ɭC/ �C,�E�#FA��âňçȈ/ȑȘ¥ô2
ǀɀ-�+ƉƆ/_MpȻ3�ýɴIȪƬ�E%>2�ªIŶŝ����ƉƆ�IȯĤ�
/ _MpȻBD?µF%ǢĆ,3/ 2,�E�
8�
(1) ȑȘ¥ô2ĚĀɀǍɋÂI>�Eɀ�Iơȩ�E�,Stecker(2010, Ǥ6ǣ)�B5Livingston(2013)Iàƹ�%� (2) #2�0?�_MpȻ0-(+ɥČ/øɽ-�+�ȹǕǍKU][2ýɴ���E�?�¥ô�_Mp,�D��%�(+ŤɄǍĦɄ/C4�ơō�ǕȨ2ĦɄ03/D�/ �ƇǡǍ¡ǻ??% »¢ƺ
-üƔɫ«??%/ �-�ŤɄǍĦɄ2ĠǾ&�C,�E����ȑȘ¥ôIɨɅ�E�-0-(+�
ȧȨ@ȄȨ0ȱ�CF%ǕȨDZʁ3�çƥ2?20ŎHFE��2-�ȩĢ�ŤɄǍ/¥ôIɨɅ�E2
&-�%C�#F3.2B�0KU][�F+ E2���2ȹǕǍKU][2DZɈIǘ��-�_Mp
Ȼ03øɽ-/E��2øɽ0) +3ǃɢ(2012)�ȸ� � (3) _MpȻIŶŧ�EZO~�e���L�^�3�2l\�Iɥ�ä�Ƨ>�¥Ȃ2ÎɖŏIǖ¬�E%>0�¥ôI_Mp,3/��¥Ȃ-_Mp2É¥ƇƵ2�ɺɫ«&-ȁ�E(Levinson, 1980, p. 20)��2�ɺɫ«�ŕǢ�E;,3�¥ô�ĚĀ�/ %>�¥Ȃ0B(+¥ô�ſ%/ĚĀȂ-�+�LJ0
?%C�F%-ȫ��-�,�E� (4) _MpI»¢ƺ-�Ľ�EǢĆ0-(+?(-?àȁ0/E23ŏɆ2ƈɜȂġĀɀIŮ÷�%cM�Lae�K�y[d��V,�E(Armstrong, 1978)�ń�ɀ�%23ȑȘ¥ô,3/��ɪ@nj�- (%ŏɆ,�E�ŏɆ3âňçȈŏI?)ƈɜȂ,�D�®¢0Ƭ;(%ƐŏI����ȌƸƯÌIƢŕ�
E�ƈɜȂ3p~d�ǍĜğ,3/�HFHF�ĚĀ�EƇǡ½0�E»¢ƺ&��%�(+ǜě0BE
DZʁǍNJȥ2ĦɄ0/E�ƈɜȂ-_Mp- �ơō�2ɞ �#�F�K�y[d��V2ŖLj3ȑȘ
¥ô2_MpȻ0-(+?ǘõǍ,�E� (5) Rohrbaugh(2003, p. 183)0BE��KuN3ƣǐǍƖɍ�2</C �ȑȘ¥ô3ƇɪǍ,�D�)ƇɪǍƖɍ�?³�+ E-�Ľ���F�_MpȻ72şÆ0)/�E-ɀ�+ E�ƇɪǍ,�E-3ǁ
- 70 -
ŕưƳ�E��/H'ĚĀ�ė>EƇƵ-ĚĀ�/�/EƇƵI?)- ��-,�D�ƇɪǍ0Ɩɍ,
�E-3�ƇɪIɔ�+½ĀǍĉØIȜE- ��-,�E�?�?���%ƿɄ�ȑȘ¥ô0�+3;
E/C4�_MpIŤɄǍ-ɀ�EǢĆ3Ȼƃ2ŋȤ�ǁ�E&G�����/�C�ƇɪǍƖɍŏ0)
+33%�+ȑȘ¥ô0) +ŕǢ�E2�ɂɀ2¤ā��E�;%ƇɪǍ,�E�-3�_MpȻ2
ǢĆ,?�¥Ȃ0BDNJȥ�F%Ƈ�ǁŕ2ƇƵ,�D��Ã2¥ôd�U��ŕǢ��/ ƼƮ0/(
%-��ưƳ2ƇƵ&- �E&G��#2%>��KuN2ɂɀ0_MpȻ�Ţ�E¤ā3Ʃ�F+
EB�0Ŏ�E� �
)2�
S�d (1965).ÆžÐşÆʇS�d¸ɲ 8ʈ�, ÞǚȰ, ǀŒǙ. ǃɢ±čɣ (2012).�Z}�K��eae2ɷƠ¥ô2ĚĀɀI¾ƞȭ�E��ȄãçȈŏ2øɽI�Ŋ0,
Core ethics : WK�PYaU[�, Ǥ 8ê, 267-278ɹ Armstrong, D. M. (1978). Universals and Scientific Realism, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Caplan, B. & Matheson, C. (2006). ‘Defending Musical Perdurantism’, The British Journal of Aesthetics, 46 (1),
59-69. Currie, G. (1989). An Ontology of Art, London: Macmillan. Dodd, J. (2000). ‘Musical Works as Eternal Types’, The British Journal of Aesthetics, 40 (4), 424-440. ��� (2002). ‘Defending Musical Platonism’, The British Journal of Aesthetics, 42 (4), 380-402. ��� (2004). ‘Types, Continuants, and the Ontology of Music’, The British Journal of Aesthetics, 44 (4), 342-360. ��� (2007). Works of Music: An Essay in Ontology, Oxford: Oxford University Press. Goodman, N. (1976). Languages of Art: An Approach to a Theory of Symbols, 2nd edition, Hackett Publishing. Kivy, P. (1993). The Fine Art of Repetition: Essays in the Philosophy of Music, Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press. Levinson, J. (1980). ‘What a Musical Work Is’, The Journal of Philosophy, 77 (1), 5-28. Livingston, P. (2013). ‘History of the Ontology of Art’, E.Zalta (Ed.), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy,
Summer 2013 edition. Retrieved September 1, 2014, from http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2013/entries/art-ontology-history/
Rohrbaugh, G. (2003). ‘Artworks as Historical Individuals’, EuropeanJournal of Philosophy, 11 (2), 177-205. Stecker, R. (2010). Aesthetics and Philosophy of Art: An Introduction, 2nd edition, Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield
Publisher, Inc. (2013, ƝÑƦȰÂƓǼě·ɩ�, ÔȓƌŘ.) Wollheim, R. (1968). Art and its Objects, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Wolterstorff, N. (1975). ‘Toward an Ontology of Art Works’, Noûs, 9 (2), 115-142.