tins pulles tinus pulles guidebook revision state of play

Tins PUlles

Tinus Pulles

Guidebook revisionState of play

TFEIP/EIONET Dublin2

The Guidebook dilemma

Air pollution

What should be reported What shall be reported


Team members present here

Project team

TNO AEA

Tinus PullesEverything

Jeroen KuenenIndustrial processes

Fugitives

Wilfred AppelmanIndustrial Processes

Justin GoodwinGeneral Guidance

Nik BrophyStationary Combustion

John NorrisMobile Combustion

Jay WebbAgriculture


Guidebook: on our way to “ETOPIA” ?

• "ETOPIA" or "Emission data TO Practicably Incorporate All obligations“

• Development of Guidebook to further harmonize with IPCC Guidelines as used for UNFCCC

• Source categories: we moved from SNAP to NFR as determining the Table of Contents

• Tiers• Decision trees• Split between combustion ad processes


NFR 2 SNAP link


SNAP 2 NFR link


Guidebook:Structure of “Cross Cutting” chapters

Part ACross Cutting

General Guidance


Guidebook:Structure of “sectoral” chapters


2.C.1 Iron and Steel

Blast FurnacePig iron

productionIron Ore Add.

Coke oven gas

Steelmaking(Basic Oxygen

Furnace) Steel to Steel Processing

CokePlant

SinterPlant

PelletizingPlant

Coke breezeIron Ore Add.

Coking coal

Basic Oxygen Furnace Gas

Pig Iron to Iron Processing

Coal injection

Code

NFR Source Category 2.C.1

Fuel NA

Lower Upper

Particulates

Total suspended particulate 1.6 kg/Mg steel

PM10 1.0 kg/Mg steel

PM2.5 0.8 kg/Mg steel

Heavy metals

Arsenic 0.1 g/Mg steel

Cadmium 0.2 g/Mg steel

Chromium 0.9 g/Mg steel

Copper 1.2 g/Mg steel

Mercury 0.1 g/Mg steel

Nickel 0.5 g/Mg steel

Lead 7.9 g/Mg steel

Selenium 0.0 g/Mg steel

Zinc 6.0 g/Mg steel

Persistant Organic Pollutants

Dioxins and furans 24 μg TEQ/Mg steel

Hexachlorobenzene 51 μg/Mg steel

Polychlorinated biphenyls 0.32 mg/Mg steel

Polyaromatic hydrocarbons 2.8 g/Mg steel

Aromatic hydrocarbons (incl. benzene) 14.3 g/Mg steel

Benzene 0.45 g/Mg steel

Pollutant Value Unit

95% confidence interval

Tier 1 default emission factorsName

Iron and Steel production

not applicable


Where are we now

• Many “zero order drafts” are produced and uploaded on the project’s FTP site.

• We have discussed industrial processes and combustion chapters with active participation of industry experts in expert workshops (Utrecht and London)

• Non-road mobile is planned to happen here• Solvents / fugitives / waste & road transport still needed• Agriculture indicated not to need such a special workshop

• We also propose a workshop for the General Issues


Feedback from Technical WorkshopsIndustrial Processes

Participants• Tom Massey (TM) RWENpower/Eurelectric• Nadine Allemand (NA) CITEPA• John Stockdale (JS) Britglass• Neil Haines (NH) Corus Grp/Eurofer• Brian Smithers (BS) CONCAWE

Unfortunately London fog did prevent participation by others!

• Stationary combustion chapters were discussed

• Results of discussion will be incorporated into the drafts

• Industry promised to deliver text proposals


Feedback from Technical WorkshopsStationary Combustion

Participants• Carlo Trozzi (Expert Panel leader, Expert

Panel for Combustion & Industry)• Bart van Konijnenburg (Royal VNP, on

behalf of CEPI)• Ton Schrijvers (CORUS, on behalf of

Eurofer)• Claude Lorea (Cembureau)• Jose M. Adzet (AIICA, on behalf of

Cotance)• Fabrice Rivet (VGI-FIV)• Ruud Beerkens (TNO, also representing the

Glass Industry)• Guy Teckels (CPIV)

• A number of industrial process chapters were discussed

• Main issue: the split between combustion and process emissions

• Results of discussion will be incorporated into the drafts

• Industry promised to deliver text proposals, mainly on process descriptions


Where are we now

• The team has developed a draft table of contents• Cross cutting issues• Sectoral chapters

• The team has analysed the available emission factors in the present Guidebook• Problems• Gaps

• The team has developed a number of “zero order draft” chapters• Tiers• Standardized emission factor tables• Split between Combustion and Process emissions

• Discuss these with stakeholders and external experts• Improve zero order drafts towards first order drafts• Formal review process, including TFEIP and expert panels and Industry• Formal endorsement by TFEIP, EMEP for use in LRTAP• Application in national reporting

doneT

o do

tins pulles tinus pulles guidebook revision state of play

Documents