tilting at windmills

61
1 Tilting at Windmills A Reading of a Wind Turbine By Charlotte Ebel

Upload: heidi

Post on 04-Jan-2016

54 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Tilting at Windmills. A Reading of a Wind Turbine By Charlotte Ebel. At the Teachers as Scholars Institute held at Princeton in 2005, Professor Michael S. Mahoney challenged the participants to engage in a process that he called “reading a machine.”. Introduction. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Tilting at Windmills

1

Tilting at Windmills

A Reading of a Wind Turbine

By

Charlotte Ebel

Page 2: Tilting at Windmills

2

Introduction

At the Teachers as Scholars Institute held at Princeton in 2005, Professor Michael S. Mahoney challenged the participants to engage in a process that he called “reading a machine.”

Page 3: Tilting at Windmills

3

In the opening paragraph of his article by that name, he quoted the title of a paper presented by R.W. Hamming at the International Conference on the History of Computing in 1976:

“We would know what they thought when they did it.”

Page 4: Tilting at Windmills

4

What I Thought When I Did It

“That notion,” I could say, parroting Mahoney, “took some time to penetrate my literary instincts.”

Page 5: Tilting at Windmills

5

It’s not that I feared objects. I have always been comfortable with them and collected far too many of them. I’m more mechanical than many women. I can change a tire, fix a vacuum cleaner or a washing machine, even open up the butterfly valve of my old Ford Mustang when it sticks. I am not afraid to tinker with my computer.

Page 6: Tilting at Windmills

6

But my literary instincts were so strong to overcome. My whole, long career has been explicating texts, parsing sentences, scanning poems, analyzing statutes, “mining” judicial opinions.

Page 7: Tilting at Windmills

7

Words are my nuts, bolts, transmissions, motors, governors, pulleys, ailerons, but when it comes to machines, my curiosity surpasses my ken. I suppose it would not be true curiosity if it were not so. What I mean is this is both my strength and my weakness.

Page 8: Tilting at Windmills

8

Mahoney goes on to elucidate in his article the point that the practice of science and the literature of science do not necessarily coincide. He avers that early in his career, he had “cast about for the primary sources of technology since the Renaissance,” a quest which he discontinued when he realized that “the great ideas we were seeking did not lie in books. They lay in objects.”

Page 9: Tilting at Windmills

9

Choosing an object was my first task.

Page 10: Tilting at Windmills

10

Having enjoyed a preview of the course, I had long thought about it and formulated the idea that I wanted to study the Lemieux brothers early work in film production. I later discarded the idea, thinking, because of the published title of the course, that we would be obliged to choose a scientist, inventor, or object more closely related to American history.

Page 11: Tilting at Windmills

11

I then thought of wind turbines since this alternative form of energy is a topic that has interested me for several years. And later, when the course had begun, a humorous aside by the professor planted the idea that I, a French teacher, might investigate the guillotine.

Page 12: Tilting at Windmills

12

So Many Ideas, So Little Time !

Page 13: Tilting at Windmills

13

I would choose the one for which materials were easily accessible, and eureka! The first trip to the library stacks produced what seemed to be just the right books to do the “reading” on the guillotine.

Page 14: Tilting at Windmills

14

They practically flew off the shelf into

my hands with titles promising answers to the central questions of the exercise. As I perused them, the characters, the drama, the history, the moral issues came spilling out and flooded my mind with scenes that I knew well. I would undoubtedly glean some juicy details to take back to my French classes.

Page 15: Tilting at Windmills

15

However, as I thought of it in the context of the “machine readings” we had done in class, the guillotine seemed less interesting. Where would I find a model this side of France? It lacked the myriad “quotations” that even I could recognize in the wind turbine, but would I ever be able to attribute them all? And I had no model for the wind turbine either.

Page 16: Tilting at Windmills

16No model, and yet I had experienced wind turbines

Page 17: Tilting at Windmills

17

It was in the summer of 1988 when my family on the return leg of a cross-country trip rolled from the top of a hill into the valley of Altamont in California and there they were, like so any sentinels.

Page 18: Tilting at Windmills

18

We were awed by their height, enchanted by their grace, mesmerized by their sound – a whir, a whoosh, a blade cutting air, but not as its sharp severance by a sword, rather like a graceful diver cutting through the surface of the water.

Page 19: Tilting at Windmills

19

 

I thought of a line in a book I used to read the children, Gilberto and the Wind: “Who has seen the wind? Neither you nor I. But when the leaves blow down the street, the wind is passing by.”

Marie Hall Ets, Gilberto and the Wind

Page 20: Tilting at Windmills

20

No leaves on this treeless plain, but still one knew the wind was passing by from the rhythmical cosmic whisper of these turbines.

Page 21: Tilting at Windmills

21

We wanted to think then that it was the wind telling us of some magical future when the production of energy no longer polluted our atmosphere but instead gave us elegant machines that through their rhythmic gymnastics unfurled a stream of wind-borne electricity to power our lives.

 

Page 22: Tilting at Windmills

22

Now in this course, I ask myself how they came to be, these turbines.

Their obvious antecedents were the windmills.

Page 23: Tilting at Windmills

23

What did I know of them?

Page 24: Tilting at Windmills

24

I thought about my childhood pinwheels.

Page 25: Tilting at Windmills

25

my fascination with Dutch windmills when I read Hans Brinker, or the Silver Skates.

I thought about . . .

Page 26: Tilting at Windmills

26

I thought about . . .

dear old Daudet writing in his windmill in Provence.

Page 27: Tilting at Windmills

27

I thought about . . .

Don Quixote

jousting with

Windmills.

Page 28: Tilting at Windmills

28

That is what I thought when I did this, that is …

Page 29: Tilting at Windmills

29

. . . when I tilted with windmills,

when I tried to “read” – from an image, no less –

a wind turbine, a modern windmill.

 

Page 30: Tilting at Windmills

30

The Reading

Page 31: Tilting at Windmills

31

A wind turbine is an impressive structure.

Page 32: Tilting at Windmills

32

A typical height for a commercial turbine tower is about 230 feet.

Page 33: Tilting at Windmills

33

There is a door in the base of the tower.

The door allows access to an interior ladder.

One may ascend the tower from the inside to perform maintenance.

Page 34: Tilting at Windmills

34

At the top of the tower is the nacelle.

It encases the engine.

It is about the size of a small school bus.

Page 35: Tilting at Windmills

35

On the front of the nacelle is the rotor.This model has three blades.The blades are very smooth so that the wind may pass easily over them.They are very strong so as not to break in the wind.They are aerodynamic in design.They are connected to a shaft that turns the dynamo inside the nacelle.

Page 36: Tilting at Windmills

36

Here we see the enormous size and the aeronautical design of a rotor and blades.

Page 37: Tilting at Windmills

37

The blades are routinely washed to keep them clean. Any cracks are filled to keep them smooth.

Page 38: Tilting at Windmills

38

Let’s look inside the nacelle.

Page 39: Tilting at Windmills

39

Page 40: Tilting at Windmills

40

What’s happening?The blades scoop up the wind and use its power to turn the gears.

The gears make the high speed shaft turn approx. 50x faster than the low-speed shaft.

The high-speed shaft turns the dynamo to produce electricity.

If the wind speed becomes too fast, the controller computer shuts down the turbine.

A cooling mechanism keeps the generator from overheating while it is working so fast.

The yaw mechanism orients the rotor to the wind.

Page 41: Tilting at Windmills

41

This model turbine is very expensive and complex.

It is intended for use by a commercial supplier, such as an electric company. It is part of a system.

Page 42: Tilting at Windmills

42

These large installations are called wind farms.

Notice that the wind turbines in this picture have lattice towers.

Page 43: Tilting at Windmills

43

The turbines connect to a grid that will transmit the electricity to the consumer.

Page 44: Tilting at Windmills

44

These high lines are part of the delivery system.

Page 45: Tilting at Windmills

45

Some consumers, especially in remote locations, install small wind turbines to serve their residence individually.

                                         

          

A 1,500-watt wind turbine provides this home in Colorado with electricity. Credit: Jim Green

 

  

Some of the documents on this page are available as Adobe Acrobat PDFs.Download Acrobat Reader

 

Page 46: Tilting at Windmills

46

Environmental Concerns

•Birds

•Noise

•Visual

•Climate

•Land Use

Page 47: Tilting at Windmills

47

Where’s wind energy going?

Page 48: Tilting at Windmills

48

ReflectionsOn reading a machine

Page 49: Tilting at Windmills

49

This project has undergone numerous transmogrifications during the two weeks of the Teachers as Scholars Seminar. Each day Aeolus seemed to release research winds from a different direction. I sometimes doubted the ability of my brain to yaw sufficiently in the right direction.

Page 50: Tilting at Windmills

50

On the last day of class before presentations, two remarks collided with a scene I had observed on the previous day’s field trip to the National Museum of History and created a spark that illuminated a creed I have long held.

Page 51: Tilting at Windmills

51

The first remark occurred when we were discussing the history of the computer. After detailing how memory systems were created, the professor commented that this mimicked some human brain functions, and he quoted Chomsky on the mysteries of language learning and the many cognitive secrets that lie embedded in our universal grammar. He concluded by observing that the human brain is

Page 52: Tilting at Windmills

52

the greatest machine of all.

The field trip to the National Museum of History intervened between the first and second remark. We were looking at an early machine. Someone identified a piston. Another remarked how the heavy leather belt moved from one wheel to another to shift gears. The professor stitched together our random

Page 53: Tilting at Windmills

53

observations on mechanisms and purpose, explaining the full operation of the machine . . ., but I was having trouble focusing on the discussion. My attention was diverted to “reading the machine” I saw in the top, back corner of the exhibit area: a video camera, its red, glowing eye trained on the spectator positions where we were standing.

Page 54: Tilting at Windmills

54

The second remark had a touching wistfulness. It grew out of a discussion between the professor and a student, a continuation actually, of our attention to the question of why women are not more successful as computer programmers. The comments were touching on interrupted careers, day care, maternity/paternity leave. It’s too bad,

Page 55: Tilting at Windmills

55

said the professor, and I paraphrase, that we haven’t been more creative, more successful at solving this problem in a way that is fair to all, because, after all, raising our children is probably the most important thing many of us ever do. These molecules of conversation kept bonding together as I sat for a while after class on a bench outside.

Page 56: Tilting at Windmills

56

Human brain = greatest machine

I wanted to stand before you today and say, “Here is my machine. Read it.” I thought of this together with the statement from Marx that the professor likes to quote to the effect that when the new first appears, it appears in the guise of the old. When one grasps what is new it takes a form more appropriate to it.

Page 57: Tilting at Windmills

57

Our children are like us until they realize what is new and unique about themselves and then many of our traits – and one hopes the bad ones – disappear. Are we able to read what is new and improved about each one’s machine?

Page 58: Tilting at Windmills

58

We have all of us often asserted in class that we will never afterwards look at objects the same. We shall always be analyzing, probing, touching them and asking: For what purpose are they made? Who is the intended user? But just as I shall be reading machines, I shall also look at my fellow man and woman, especially

Page 59: Tilting at Windmills

59

my students, analytically, searchingly, trying to read each “machine”, and I shall, through my actions, forever be imploring the parents of the children entrusted to me: “Read my machine at work. Observe all its moving parts. See how I am forever shifting gears, turning dynamos, transmitting energy to light up what is unique and glorious in this child.” After all, it’s our most important work!

Page 60: Tilting at Windmills

60

Mais, si tu m’apprivoises, nous aurons besoin l’un de l’autre. Tu seras pour moi unique au monde. Je serai pour toi unique au monde… St. Exupery,Le Petit Prince (45)

Page 61: Tilting at Windmills

61

The following are links to some excellent sites for teachers and students:

http://www.windpower.org/en/kids/index.htm?d=1

http://www.siue.edu/EDUCATION/AAM/lesson/parker/AAM%20webpage/WINDMILL/windmill%20lesson%20plan.htm