this design guideline is only valid until march 18, 2016...
TRANSCRIPT
This design guideline is only valid until March 18 2016 if revised version is posted
Please check the website
Table of contests
1 Design Competition Rules11 Competition Title 0812 Competition Goal 0813 Project Outline 0814 Competition Type 0815 Language and Unit Standards 0816 Eligibility 0917 Competition Schedule 0918 Registration 0919 Queries 10110 Reference Materials 10111 Submission 10112 Anonymity 11113 Client 11114 Competition Administration 11115 Technical Committee 12116 Jury Committee 12117 Selection of Winners 13118 Design Contract 14119 Copyright and PublicationExhibit 14120 Dispute 14
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal 1622 Design Area and Subject 1623 Site Existing Condition 1724 General Guide and Consideration 1925 Detailed Guideline of Facilities 2326 Cost Estimation 28
3 Book Submittal and Standard Format31 Submission Documents 3032 Pin and Numbering of Panels 3233 Document Guideline 3334 List of Forms 3335 List of Reference Materials 33
4 Appendix41 Project Overview 4142 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island 4243 Foundation Construction Plan 4844 Space Program Proposed by Selected Operator
58
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area 6246 History of Nodeul Island 63
Nodeul Dream Island Where We Create Together
Island of City
There is an island When trams had run in the heart of Seoul the name of
the island was Jungjido The image of the island is little bit different in our
memories Sandy beach where people enjoyed river bathing quiet dating
place for couples place where parade marches through on Armed Forces
Day the island which gets crowded all of a sudden when Seoul Firework
Festival is held the name of this island is Nodeul Island A beautiful name
with meaning of stepping stone where white heron paddled
Nodeul Island is in the middle of Seoul just like the expression but this is an
island we look at from distance and slide by This is a place where we can
meet beautiful sunset and basic nature which we can hardly imagine from
the city Nodeul Island is a place where we can meet unusual scenery and
sometimes surrealistic situation
Han River Art Island
Nodeul Island used to be a private property In 2005 the Seoul city government
purchased it to develop a cultural complex and they held three competitions
over three years (2005~2009) It was a process to find specific appearance of
the Han River Art Island Project including opera house youth music hall art
gallery and so on It was a monumental project that proves we moved on from
days dominated by economic logics and shows cultural values are much more
important to us
Music and art are very important values which will go along with our daily
lives Thus concert hall and art gallery should be located where we can
easily approach However Nodeul Island is still an island of a city Additional
transport infrastructure was required to allow daily access of citizens The
budget required for island connecting transportation facilities construction was
an enormous amount of money Han River Art Island Projectrsquos estimated
amount for facility investment was over 600 billion KRW Public cultural
facility with difficult access is obviously hard to operate Public facility with
lack of operational continuity will end up demanding continuous operating
expense support besides initial facility investment cost
Public Cultural Facility should function as catalyst for city It should play a role
of changing surrounding area as cultural spaces and restructuring city
structures It should return cultural values and economic compensation in larger
reproduction to the citizens Thus cultural facility should be located in
downtown We have some cases such as ARCO Art Center which improved
Deahak-ro and National Museum of Contemporary Art (Seoul) which changed
Bukchon There is a negative lesson of large cultural facility which is located far
away from the city and isolated in the forest However the island is even
further away than forest
Starting the project was possible as fund of 200 billion KRW is already
prepared However budget deficit problem of Seoul rose in 2010 and
ltNodeul Island Art Center Construction Fund Ordinancegt was repealed
Thus the fund was used for reducing debts of Seoul In addition municipal
assembly repealed ltHan River Art Island Establishment and Management
Ordinancegt As actual project initiative power and basis disappeared Han
River Art Island Project has aborted
Part of fund in approximate amount of 277 billion KRW which was executed
for field study and design fee sank They could request to resume the
project in order to restore the sunken cost But the part we need to pay
attention on is additional budget not the sunken cost Opportunity cost which
should be continuously invested could be turn into sunken cost and it might
require endless support on operating expense to resume this project This
was a very important matter which requires citizenrsquos insight and agreement
In 2013 the Seoul Institute worked on lsquoExpert Opinion Survey Research on
Nodeul Island Utilizationrsquo Majority of experts did not opposed to Cultural
Facility Construction The part they opposed to was lsquolarge scalersquo cultural
facility construction of lsquoNodeul Islandrsquo The conclusion was it is recommended
to seek for methods to utilize the space instead of neglecting it due to its
large potential value For thorough discussion Nodeul Island Forum has
formed and the necessity of accepting various citizenrsquos opinion was brought
up
As opinion acceptance process Seoul city held online public opinion survey
student design camp citizenrsquos idea contest idea sketch of localoversea
professional exhibition and open forum for citizens Organizing various and
valuable opinions and suggestions Nodeul Islandrsquos construction direction could
converged into two values this should be a place where all citizen should
cultivate together and enjoy and it should be completed in steps When we
integrate this sentence the key words converge into citizen and history
노들섬 전경 (노들섬 사진공모전 1회 후보작 lsquo한강의 중심rsquo)
Dreams of Citizen
화산남(華山南) 한수북(漢水北) 천년승지(千年勝地)
광통교(廣通橋) 운종가(雲鍾街) 건나드러
낙락장송(落落長松) 정정고백(亭亭古柏) 추상오부(秋霜烏府)
위 만고청풍(萬古淸風)ㅅ경(景) 긔 엇더니잇고
(Mean South of Bukhan Mountian north of Han River famous scenic land
from old times crossing Gwanggyo and Jongno majestic Saheonbu with
drooping pine tree and towering nut pine (elder minister of the court)
This is the beginning of Sangdae byeol-gok of Kwon Geun The image of
dream and hope foreseeing thousand years of the city from Cheonggye
Stream Kwangtong Bridge which is located in the middle of Hanyang (old
name of Seoul) of early establishment of Joseon Dyansty is drawn in this
poem Seoul should still be a place like that We put healthy society which
we can dream in and shape the future together in Seoul and expect that
such a society will build Seoul However we must admit the spaces of
dissatisfaction by compromising with reality and frustration are blended in
Seoul But surrealistic place lsquoIsland of Cityrsquo is a different place
Currently Han River Nodeul Island located in the heart of Seoul wants to be
a Nodeul Dream Island where we can draw our dreams Yul-do a country
that Hong Gil-dong child of a concubine who was discriminated established
or Binseom (Empty Island) place where a poor scholar Heo Saeng dreamt
of might be one of the places like that Neverland from Peter Pan might be
one of them as well The theme this island still needs is citizen and history
1 Citizen
If society is a group of citizens in what method free and equal civil society
can be represented It should be a social system or operating system First
operating system of Nodeul Dream Island will be established by inventive
project idea of creative proposer Empathic value about a civil society that we
expect should be magnified in this island operation system But what
completes the island is citizenrsquos participation Elaborate rules and scenario
that narrate how citizen will participate on completion of the society and
establish the form of island should be included
2 History
Society and city do not get completed by great elite and in fact the moment
of completion does not exist What would be the plan to draw active
intervention of our next generation and accumulate their traces on this
island Nodeul Dream Island should be a place where citizenrsquos experience
and memory accumulate Required space for realizing the project and first
facility plan should start in reasonable scale Also in background of the plan
it should enable future citizenrsquos spatial participation while flexibly responding
to their behavior and demands
New Style Competition
Democratic society judge value through the process of reaching a conclusion
rather than the value that conclusion embodies Sound society maintains and
develops through keen competition and impartial judgement The institutional
strategy of these competition and judgement is competition Future shape of
Nodeul Dream Island will be selected by competition
All of operational planning of Nodeul Dream Island Space Planning and first
operator will be selected by competition This competition wants to be a
monumental project for proceeding through the most democratic process
rather than being the most glamourous and enormous structure This project
is meaningful as it even select proposal on how to utilize Nodeul Island
through competition Of course that proposal projects our dreams yet
premised on practical possibility in reality
The difference between this competition and other existing architecture
competition is that island planning and operation method competitions are
preceded Required facility programs and scale will be proposed per the result
The difference of this competition from other existing cosign operator selecting
competition is that we do not nominate the 3rd operator after building the
structure The operation system will be decided based on the best proposal and
the structure will be constructed according to the result and it will be operated
by the proposer If the selected proposal does not require structure building
may not be constructed This competition is different from existing business
investment competition as it creates necessary facility and space with Seoul
resources Thus operator who can balance between retrieving reasonable
operating expenses and realization of public value and have a sense of
responsibility on citizen and history will be nominated rather than business
operator who needs to retrieve investment cost with business profits
Competition Process
This competition will be proceeded in three parts the first Operation Concept
Competition the second Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition and
the third SpaceFacility Construction Competition
The Operation Concept Competition (1st competition) takes place to select
various and creative proposals This stage asks what kind of dream of society
we image and in what form the society can be realized in this island As our
society is not consist with specific professions it is opened to everyone who
is interested in humanities society and environment and their cooperation
organization This is a phase which requires imagination of Gyun Heo
Ji-won Park or Gil-dong Hong of our time Multiple proposals will be
selected to advance to the next phase Operation PlanningFacility Concept
Competition
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd competition) is in a format that
architecture landscape and urban related experts involve and proceed The
purpose is to select a reasonable and specific space utilization proposal which
realize selected proposal from Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition
while fully satisfy expected level for scenery required for the city The most
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
Table of contests
1 Design Competition Rules11 Competition Title 0812 Competition Goal 0813 Project Outline 0814 Competition Type 0815 Language and Unit Standards 0816 Eligibility 0917 Competition Schedule 0918 Registration 0919 Queries 10110 Reference Materials 10111 Submission 10112 Anonymity 11113 Client 11114 Competition Administration 11115 Technical Committee 12116 Jury Committee 12117 Selection of Winners 13118 Design Contract 14119 Copyright and PublicationExhibit 14120 Dispute 14
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal 1622 Design Area and Subject 1623 Site Existing Condition 1724 General Guide and Consideration 1925 Detailed Guideline of Facilities 2326 Cost Estimation 28
3 Book Submittal and Standard Format31 Submission Documents 3032 Pin and Numbering of Panels 3233 Document Guideline 3334 List of Forms 3335 List of Reference Materials 33
4 Appendix41 Project Overview 4142 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island 4243 Foundation Construction Plan 4844 Space Program Proposed by Selected Operator
58
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area 6246 History of Nodeul Island 63
Nodeul Dream Island Where We Create Together
Island of City
There is an island When trams had run in the heart of Seoul the name of
the island was Jungjido The image of the island is little bit different in our
memories Sandy beach where people enjoyed river bathing quiet dating
place for couples place where parade marches through on Armed Forces
Day the island which gets crowded all of a sudden when Seoul Firework
Festival is held the name of this island is Nodeul Island A beautiful name
with meaning of stepping stone where white heron paddled
Nodeul Island is in the middle of Seoul just like the expression but this is an
island we look at from distance and slide by This is a place where we can
meet beautiful sunset and basic nature which we can hardly imagine from
the city Nodeul Island is a place where we can meet unusual scenery and
sometimes surrealistic situation
Han River Art Island
Nodeul Island used to be a private property In 2005 the Seoul city government
purchased it to develop a cultural complex and they held three competitions
over three years (2005~2009) It was a process to find specific appearance of
the Han River Art Island Project including opera house youth music hall art
gallery and so on It was a monumental project that proves we moved on from
days dominated by economic logics and shows cultural values are much more
important to us
Music and art are very important values which will go along with our daily
lives Thus concert hall and art gallery should be located where we can
easily approach However Nodeul Island is still an island of a city Additional
transport infrastructure was required to allow daily access of citizens The
budget required for island connecting transportation facilities construction was
an enormous amount of money Han River Art Island Projectrsquos estimated
amount for facility investment was over 600 billion KRW Public cultural
facility with difficult access is obviously hard to operate Public facility with
lack of operational continuity will end up demanding continuous operating
expense support besides initial facility investment cost
Public Cultural Facility should function as catalyst for city It should play a role
of changing surrounding area as cultural spaces and restructuring city
structures It should return cultural values and economic compensation in larger
reproduction to the citizens Thus cultural facility should be located in
downtown We have some cases such as ARCO Art Center which improved
Deahak-ro and National Museum of Contemporary Art (Seoul) which changed
Bukchon There is a negative lesson of large cultural facility which is located far
away from the city and isolated in the forest However the island is even
further away than forest
Starting the project was possible as fund of 200 billion KRW is already
prepared However budget deficit problem of Seoul rose in 2010 and
ltNodeul Island Art Center Construction Fund Ordinancegt was repealed
Thus the fund was used for reducing debts of Seoul In addition municipal
assembly repealed ltHan River Art Island Establishment and Management
Ordinancegt As actual project initiative power and basis disappeared Han
River Art Island Project has aborted
Part of fund in approximate amount of 277 billion KRW which was executed
for field study and design fee sank They could request to resume the
project in order to restore the sunken cost But the part we need to pay
attention on is additional budget not the sunken cost Opportunity cost which
should be continuously invested could be turn into sunken cost and it might
require endless support on operating expense to resume this project This
was a very important matter which requires citizenrsquos insight and agreement
In 2013 the Seoul Institute worked on lsquoExpert Opinion Survey Research on
Nodeul Island Utilizationrsquo Majority of experts did not opposed to Cultural
Facility Construction The part they opposed to was lsquolarge scalersquo cultural
facility construction of lsquoNodeul Islandrsquo The conclusion was it is recommended
to seek for methods to utilize the space instead of neglecting it due to its
large potential value For thorough discussion Nodeul Island Forum has
formed and the necessity of accepting various citizenrsquos opinion was brought
up
As opinion acceptance process Seoul city held online public opinion survey
student design camp citizenrsquos idea contest idea sketch of localoversea
professional exhibition and open forum for citizens Organizing various and
valuable opinions and suggestions Nodeul Islandrsquos construction direction could
converged into two values this should be a place where all citizen should
cultivate together and enjoy and it should be completed in steps When we
integrate this sentence the key words converge into citizen and history
노들섬 전경 (노들섬 사진공모전 1회 후보작 lsquo한강의 중심rsquo)
Dreams of Citizen
화산남(華山南) 한수북(漢水北) 천년승지(千年勝地)
광통교(廣通橋) 운종가(雲鍾街) 건나드러
낙락장송(落落長松) 정정고백(亭亭古柏) 추상오부(秋霜烏府)
위 만고청풍(萬古淸風)ㅅ경(景) 긔 엇더니잇고
(Mean South of Bukhan Mountian north of Han River famous scenic land
from old times crossing Gwanggyo and Jongno majestic Saheonbu with
drooping pine tree and towering nut pine (elder minister of the court)
This is the beginning of Sangdae byeol-gok of Kwon Geun The image of
dream and hope foreseeing thousand years of the city from Cheonggye
Stream Kwangtong Bridge which is located in the middle of Hanyang (old
name of Seoul) of early establishment of Joseon Dyansty is drawn in this
poem Seoul should still be a place like that We put healthy society which
we can dream in and shape the future together in Seoul and expect that
such a society will build Seoul However we must admit the spaces of
dissatisfaction by compromising with reality and frustration are blended in
Seoul But surrealistic place lsquoIsland of Cityrsquo is a different place
Currently Han River Nodeul Island located in the heart of Seoul wants to be
a Nodeul Dream Island where we can draw our dreams Yul-do a country
that Hong Gil-dong child of a concubine who was discriminated established
or Binseom (Empty Island) place where a poor scholar Heo Saeng dreamt
of might be one of the places like that Neverland from Peter Pan might be
one of them as well The theme this island still needs is citizen and history
1 Citizen
If society is a group of citizens in what method free and equal civil society
can be represented It should be a social system or operating system First
operating system of Nodeul Dream Island will be established by inventive
project idea of creative proposer Empathic value about a civil society that we
expect should be magnified in this island operation system But what
completes the island is citizenrsquos participation Elaborate rules and scenario
that narrate how citizen will participate on completion of the society and
establish the form of island should be included
2 History
Society and city do not get completed by great elite and in fact the moment
of completion does not exist What would be the plan to draw active
intervention of our next generation and accumulate their traces on this
island Nodeul Dream Island should be a place where citizenrsquos experience
and memory accumulate Required space for realizing the project and first
facility plan should start in reasonable scale Also in background of the plan
it should enable future citizenrsquos spatial participation while flexibly responding
to their behavior and demands
New Style Competition
Democratic society judge value through the process of reaching a conclusion
rather than the value that conclusion embodies Sound society maintains and
develops through keen competition and impartial judgement The institutional
strategy of these competition and judgement is competition Future shape of
Nodeul Dream Island will be selected by competition
All of operational planning of Nodeul Dream Island Space Planning and first
operator will be selected by competition This competition wants to be a
monumental project for proceeding through the most democratic process
rather than being the most glamourous and enormous structure This project
is meaningful as it even select proposal on how to utilize Nodeul Island
through competition Of course that proposal projects our dreams yet
premised on practical possibility in reality
The difference between this competition and other existing architecture
competition is that island planning and operation method competitions are
preceded Required facility programs and scale will be proposed per the result
The difference of this competition from other existing cosign operator selecting
competition is that we do not nominate the 3rd operator after building the
structure The operation system will be decided based on the best proposal and
the structure will be constructed according to the result and it will be operated
by the proposer If the selected proposal does not require structure building
may not be constructed This competition is different from existing business
investment competition as it creates necessary facility and space with Seoul
resources Thus operator who can balance between retrieving reasonable
operating expenses and realization of public value and have a sense of
responsibility on citizen and history will be nominated rather than business
operator who needs to retrieve investment cost with business profits
Competition Process
This competition will be proceeded in three parts the first Operation Concept
Competition the second Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition and
the third SpaceFacility Construction Competition
The Operation Concept Competition (1st competition) takes place to select
various and creative proposals This stage asks what kind of dream of society
we image and in what form the society can be realized in this island As our
society is not consist with specific professions it is opened to everyone who
is interested in humanities society and environment and their cooperation
organization This is a phase which requires imagination of Gyun Heo
Ji-won Park or Gil-dong Hong of our time Multiple proposals will be
selected to advance to the next phase Operation PlanningFacility Concept
Competition
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd competition) is in a format that
architecture landscape and urban related experts involve and proceed The
purpose is to select a reasonable and specific space utilization proposal which
realize selected proposal from Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition
while fully satisfy expected level for scenery required for the city The most
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
Nodeul Dream Island Where We Create Together
Island of City
There is an island When trams had run in the heart of Seoul the name of
the island was Jungjido The image of the island is little bit different in our
memories Sandy beach where people enjoyed river bathing quiet dating
place for couples place where parade marches through on Armed Forces
Day the island which gets crowded all of a sudden when Seoul Firework
Festival is held the name of this island is Nodeul Island A beautiful name
with meaning of stepping stone where white heron paddled
Nodeul Island is in the middle of Seoul just like the expression but this is an
island we look at from distance and slide by This is a place where we can
meet beautiful sunset and basic nature which we can hardly imagine from
the city Nodeul Island is a place where we can meet unusual scenery and
sometimes surrealistic situation
Han River Art Island
Nodeul Island used to be a private property In 2005 the Seoul city government
purchased it to develop a cultural complex and they held three competitions
over three years (2005~2009) It was a process to find specific appearance of
the Han River Art Island Project including opera house youth music hall art
gallery and so on It was a monumental project that proves we moved on from
days dominated by economic logics and shows cultural values are much more
important to us
Music and art are very important values which will go along with our daily
lives Thus concert hall and art gallery should be located where we can
easily approach However Nodeul Island is still an island of a city Additional
transport infrastructure was required to allow daily access of citizens The
budget required for island connecting transportation facilities construction was
an enormous amount of money Han River Art Island Projectrsquos estimated
amount for facility investment was over 600 billion KRW Public cultural
facility with difficult access is obviously hard to operate Public facility with
lack of operational continuity will end up demanding continuous operating
expense support besides initial facility investment cost
Public Cultural Facility should function as catalyst for city It should play a role
of changing surrounding area as cultural spaces and restructuring city
structures It should return cultural values and economic compensation in larger
reproduction to the citizens Thus cultural facility should be located in
downtown We have some cases such as ARCO Art Center which improved
Deahak-ro and National Museum of Contemporary Art (Seoul) which changed
Bukchon There is a negative lesson of large cultural facility which is located far
away from the city and isolated in the forest However the island is even
further away than forest
Starting the project was possible as fund of 200 billion KRW is already
prepared However budget deficit problem of Seoul rose in 2010 and
ltNodeul Island Art Center Construction Fund Ordinancegt was repealed
Thus the fund was used for reducing debts of Seoul In addition municipal
assembly repealed ltHan River Art Island Establishment and Management
Ordinancegt As actual project initiative power and basis disappeared Han
River Art Island Project has aborted
Part of fund in approximate amount of 277 billion KRW which was executed
for field study and design fee sank They could request to resume the
project in order to restore the sunken cost But the part we need to pay
attention on is additional budget not the sunken cost Opportunity cost which
should be continuously invested could be turn into sunken cost and it might
require endless support on operating expense to resume this project This
was a very important matter which requires citizenrsquos insight and agreement
In 2013 the Seoul Institute worked on lsquoExpert Opinion Survey Research on
Nodeul Island Utilizationrsquo Majority of experts did not opposed to Cultural
Facility Construction The part they opposed to was lsquolarge scalersquo cultural
facility construction of lsquoNodeul Islandrsquo The conclusion was it is recommended
to seek for methods to utilize the space instead of neglecting it due to its
large potential value For thorough discussion Nodeul Island Forum has
formed and the necessity of accepting various citizenrsquos opinion was brought
up
As opinion acceptance process Seoul city held online public opinion survey
student design camp citizenrsquos idea contest idea sketch of localoversea
professional exhibition and open forum for citizens Organizing various and
valuable opinions and suggestions Nodeul Islandrsquos construction direction could
converged into two values this should be a place where all citizen should
cultivate together and enjoy and it should be completed in steps When we
integrate this sentence the key words converge into citizen and history
노들섬 전경 (노들섬 사진공모전 1회 후보작 lsquo한강의 중심rsquo)
Dreams of Citizen
화산남(華山南) 한수북(漢水北) 천년승지(千年勝地)
광통교(廣通橋) 운종가(雲鍾街) 건나드러
낙락장송(落落長松) 정정고백(亭亭古柏) 추상오부(秋霜烏府)
위 만고청풍(萬古淸風)ㅅ경(景) 긔 엇더니잇고
(Mean South of Bukhan Mountian north of Han River famous scenic land
from old times crossing Gwanggyo and Jongno majestic Saheonbu with
drooping pine tree and towering nut pine (elder minister of the court)
This is the beginning of Sangdae byeol-gok of Kwon Geun The image of
dream and hope foreseeing thousand years of the city from Cheonggye
Stream Kwangtong Bridge which is located in the middle of Hanyang (old
name of Seoul) of early establishment of Joseon Dyansty is drawn in this
poem Seoul should still be a place like that We put healthy society which
we can dream in and shape the future together in Seoul and expect that
such a society will build Seoul However we must admit the spaces of
dissatisfaction by compromising with reality and frustration are blended in
Seoul But surrealistic place lsquoIsland of Cityrsquo is a different place
Currently Han River Nodeul Island located in the heart of Seoul wants to be
a Nodeul Dream Island where we can draw our dreams Yul-do a country
that Hong Gil-dong child of a concubine who was discriminated established
or Binseom (Empty Island) place where a poor scholar Heo Saeng dreamt
of might be one of the places like that Neverland from Peter Pan might be
one of them as well The theme this island still needs is citizen and history
1 Citizen
If society is a group of citizens in what method free and equal civil society
can be represented It should be a social system or operating system First
operating system of Nodeul Dream Island will be established by inventive
project idea of creative proposer Empathic value about a civil society that we
expect should be magnified in this island operation system But what
completes the island is citizenrsquos participation Elaborate rules and scenario
that narrate how citizen will participate on completion of the society and
establish the form of island should be included
2 History
Society and city do not get completed by great elite and in fact the moment
of completion does not exist What would be the plan to draw active
intervention of our next generation and accumulate their traces on this
island Nodeul Dream Island should be a place where citizenrsquos experience
and memory accumulate Required space for realizing the project and first
facility plan should start in reasonable scale Also in background of the plan
it should enable future citizenrsquos spatial participation while flexibly responding
to their behavior and demands
New Style Competition
Democratic society judge value through the process of reaching a conclusion
rather than the value that conclusion embodies Sound society maintains and
develops through keen competition and impartial judgement The institutional
strategy of these competition and judgement is competition Future shape of
Nodeul Dream Island will be selected by competition
All of operational planning of Nodeul Dream Island Space Planning and first
operator will be selected by competition This competition wants to be a
monumental project for proceeding through the most democratic process
rather than being the most glamourous and enormous structure This project
is meaningful as it even select proposal on how to utilize Nodeul Island
through competition Of course that proposal projects our dreams yet
premised on practical possibility in reality
The difference between this competition and other existing architecture
competition is that island planning and operation method competitions are
preceded Required facility programs and scale will be proposed per the result
The difference of this competition from other existing cosign operator selecting
competition is that we do not nominate the 3rd operator after building the
structure The operation system will be decided based on the best proposal and
the structure will be constructed according to the result and it will be operated
by the proposer If the selected proposal does not require structure building
may not be constructed This competition is different from existing business
investment competition as it creates necessary facility and space with Seoul
resources Thus operator who can balance between retrieving reasonable
operating expenses and realization of public value and have a sense of
responsibility on citizen and history will be nominated rather than business
operator who needs to retrieve investment cost with business profits
Competition Process
This competition will be proceeded in three parts the first Operation Concept
Competition the second Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition and
the third SpaceFacility Construction Competition
The Operation Concept Competition (1st competition) takes place to select
various and creative proposals This stage asks what kind of dream of society
we image and in what form the society can be realized in this island As our
society is not consist with specific professions it is opened to everyone who
is interested in humanities society and environment and their cooperation
organization This is a phase which requires imagination of Gyun Heo
Ji-won Park or Gil-dong Hong of our time Multiple proposals will be
selected to advance to the next phase Operation PlanningFacility Concept
Competition
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd competition) is in a format that
architecture landscape and urban related experts involve and proceed The
purpose is to select a reasonable and specific space utilization proposal which
realize selected proposal from Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition
while fully satisfy expected level for scenery required for the city The most
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
Public Cultural Facility should function as catalyst for city It should play a role
of changing surrounding area as cultural spaces and restructuring city
structures It should return cultural values and economic compensation in larger
reproduction to the citizens Thus cultural facility should be located in
downtown We have some cases such as ARCO Art Center which improved
Deahak-ro and National Museum of Contemporary Art (Seoul) which changed
Bukchon There is a negative lesson of large cultural facility which is located far
away from the city and isolated in the forest However the island is even
further away than forest
Starting the project was possible as fund of 200 billion KRW is already
prepared However budget deficit problem of Seoul rose in 2010 and
ltNodeul Island Art Center Construction Fund Ordinancegt was repealed
Thus the fund was used for reducing debts of Seoul In addition municipal
assembly repealed ltHan River Art Island Establishment and Management
Ordinancegt As actual project initiative power and basis disappeared Han
River Art Island Project has aborted
Part of fund in approximate amount of 277 billion KRW which was executed
for field study and design fee sank They could request to resume the
project in order to restore the sunken cost But the part we need to pay
attention on is additional budget not the sunken cost Opportunity cost which
should be continuously invested could be turn into sunken cost and it might
require endless support on operating expense to resume this project This
was a very important matter which requires citizenrsquos insight and agreement
In 2013 the Seoul Institute worked on lsquoExpert Opinion Survey Research on
Nodeul Island Utilizationrsquo Majority of experts did not opposed to Cultural
Facility Construction The part they opposed to was lsquolarge scalersquo cultural
facility construction of lsquoNodeul Islandrsquo The conclusion was it is recommended
to seek for methods to utilize the space instead of neglecting it due to its
large potential value For thorough discussion Nodeul Island Forum has
formed and the necessity of accepting various citizenrsquos opinion was brought
up
As opinion acceptance process Seoul city held online public opinion survey
student design camp citizenrsquos idea contest idea sketch of localoversea
professional exhibition and open forum for citizens Organizing various and
valuable opinions and suggestions Nodeul Islandrsquos construction direction could
converged into two values this should be a place where all citizen should
cultivate together and enjoy and it should be completed in steps When we
integrate this sentence the key words converge into citizen and history
노들섬 전경 (노들섬 사진공모전 1회 후보작 lsquo한강의 중심rsquo)
Dreams of Citizen
화산남(華山南) 한수북(漢水北) 천년승지(千年勝地)
광통교(廣通橋) 운종가(雲鍾街) 건나드러
낙락장송(落落長松) 정정고백(亭亭古柏) 추상오부(秋霜烏府)
위 만고청풍(萬古淸風)ㅅ경(景) 긔 엇더니잇고
(Mean South of Bukhan Mountian north of Han River famous scenic land
from old times crossing Gwanggyo and Jongno majestic Saheonbu with
drooping pine tree and towering nut pine (elder minister of the court)
This is the beginning of Sangdae byeol-gok of Kwon Geun The image of
dream and hope foreseeing thousand years of the city from Cheonggye
Stream Kwangtong Bridge which is located in the middle of Hanyang (old
name of Seoul) of early establishment of Joseon Dyansty is drawn in this
poem Seoul should still be a place like that We put healthy society which
we can dream in and shape the future together in Seoul and expect that
such a society will build Seoul However we must admit the spaces of
dissatisfaction by compromising with reality and frustration are blended in
Seoul But surrealistic place lsquoIsland of Cityrsquo is a different place
Currently Han River Nodeul Island located in the heart of Seoul wants to be
a Nodeul Dream Island where we can draw our dreams Yul-do a country
that Hong Gil-dong child of a concubine who was discriminated established
or Binseom (Empty Island) place where a poor scholar Heo Saeng dreamt
of might be one of the places like that Neverland from Peter Pan might be
one of them as well The theme this island still needs is citizen and history
1 Citizen
If society is a group of citizens in what method free and equal civil society
can be represented It should be a social system or operating system First
operating system of Nodeul Dream Island will be established by inventive
project idea of creative proposer Empathic value about a civil society that we
expect should be magnified in this island operation system But what
completes the island is citizenrsquos participation Elaborate rules and scenario
that narrate how citizen will participate on completion of the society and
establish the form of island should be included
2 History
Society and city do not get completed by great elite and in fact the moment
of completion does not exist What would be the plan to draw active
intervention of our next generation and accumulate their traces on this
island Nodeul Dream Island should be a place where citizenrsquos experience
and memory accumulate Required space for realizing the project and first
facility plan should start in reasonable scale Also in background of the plan
it should enable future citizenrsquos spatial participation while flexibly responding
to their behavior and demands
New Style Competition
Democratic society judge value through the process of reaching a conclusion
rather than the value that conclusion embodies Sound society maintains and
develops through keen competition and impartial judgement The institutional
strategy of these competition and judgement is competition Future shape of
Nodeul Dream Island will be selected by competition
All of operational planning of Nodeul Dream Island Space Planning and first
operator will be selected by competition This competition wants to be a
monumental project for proceeding through the most democratic process
rather than being the most glamourous and enormous structure This project
is meaningful as it even select proposal on how to utilize Nodeul Island
through competition Of course that proposal projects our dreams yet
premised on practical possibility in reality
The difference between this competition and other existing architecture
competition is that island planning and operation method competitions are
preceded Required facility programs and scale will be proposed per the result
The difference of this competition from other existing cosign operator selecting
competition is that we do not nominate the 3rd operator after building the
structure The operation system will be decided based on the best proposal and
the structure will be constructed according to the result and it will be operated
by the proposer If the selected proposal does not require structure building
may not be constructed This competition is different from existing business
investment competition as it creates necessary facility and space with Seoul
resources Thus operator who can balance between retrieving reasonable
operating expenses and realization of public value and have a sense of
responsibility on citizen and history will be nominated rather than business
operator who needs to retrieve investment cost with business profits
Competition Process
This competition will be proceeded in three parts the first Operation Concept
Competition the second Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition and
the third SpaceFacility Construction Competition
The Operation Concept Competition (1st competition) takes place to select
various and creative proposals This stage asks what kind of dream of society
we image and in what form the society can be realized in this island As our
society is not consist with specific professions it is opened to everyone who
is interested in humanities society and environment and their cooperation
organization This is a phase which requires imagination of Gyun Heo
Ji-won Park or Gil-dong Hong of our time Multiple proposals will be
selected to advance to the next phase Operation PlanningFacility Concept
Competition
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd competition) is in a format that
architecture landscape and urban related experts involve and proceed The
purpose is to select a reasonable and specific space utilization proposal which
realize selected proposal from Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition
while fully satisfy expected level for scenery required for the city The most
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
Dreams of Citizen
화산남(華山南) 한수북(漢水北) 천년승지(千年勝地)
광통교(廣通橋) 운종가(雲鍾街) 건나드러
낙락장송(落落長松) 정정고백(亭亭古柏) 추상오부(秋霜烏府)
위 만고청풍(萬古淸風)ㅅ경(景) 긔 엇더니잇고
(Mean South of Bukhan Mountian north of Han River famous scenic land
from old times crossing Gwanggyo and Jongno majestic Saheonbu with
drooping pine tree and towering nut pine (elder minister of the court)
This is the beginning of Sangdae byeol-gok of Kwon Geun The image of
dream and hope foreseeing thousand years of the city from Cheonggye
Stream Kwangtong Bridge which is located in the middle of Hanyang (old
name of Seoul) of early establishment of Joseon Dyansty is drawn in this
poem Seoul should still be a place like that We put healthy society which
we can dream in and shape the future together in Seoul and expect that
such a society will build Seoul However we must admit the spaces of
dissatisfaction by compromising with reality and frustration are blended in
Seoul But surrealistic place lsquoIsland of Cityrsquo is a different place
Currently Han River Nodeul Island located in the heart of Seoul wants to be
a Nodeul Dream Island where we can draw our dreams Yul-do a country
that Hong Gil-dong child of a concubine who was discriminated established
or Binseom (Empty Island) place where a poor scholar Heo Saeng dreamt
of might be one of the places like that Neverland from Peter Pan might be
one of them as well The theme this island still needs is citizen and history
1 Citizen
If society is a group of citizens in what method free and equal civil society
can be represented It should be a social system or operating system First
operating system of Nodeul Dream Island will be established by inventive
project idea of creative proposer Empathic value about a civil society that we
expect should be magnified in this island operation system But what
completes the island is citizenrsquos participation Elaborate rules and scenario
that narrate how citizen will participate on completion of the society and
establish the form of island should be included
2 History
Society and city do not get completed by great elite and in fact the moment
of completion does not exist What would be the plan to draw active
intervention of our next generation and accumulate their traces on this
island Nodeul Dream Island should be a place where citizenrsquos experience
and memory accumulate Required space for realizing the project and first
facility plan should start in reasonable scale Also in background of the plan
it should enable future citizenrsquos spatial participation while flexibly responding
to their behavior and demands
New Style Competition
Democratic society judge value through the process of reaching a conclusion
rather than the value that conclusion embodies Sound society maintains and
develops through keen competition and impartial judgement The institutional
strategy of these competition and judgement is competition Future shape of
Nodeul Dream Island will be selected by competition
All of operational planning of Nodeul Dream Island Space Planning and first
operator will be selected by competition This competition wants to be a
monumental project for proceeding through the most democratic process
rather than being the most glamourous and enormous structure This project
is meaningful as it even select proposal on how to utilize Nodeul Island
through competition Of course that proposal projects our dreams yet
premised on practical possibility in reality
The difference between this competition and other existing architecture
competition is that island planning and operation method competitions are
preceded Required facility programs and scale will be proposed per the result
The difference of this competition from other existing cosign operator selecting
competition is that we do not nominate the 3rd operator after building the
structure The operation system will be decided based on the best proposal and
the structure will be constructed according to the result and it will be operated
by the proposer If the selected proposal does not require structure building
may not be constructed This competition is different from existing business
investment competition as it creates necessary facility and space with Seoul
resources Thus operator who can balance between retrieving reasonable
operating expenses and realization of public value and have a sense of
responsibility on citizen and history will be nominated rather than business
operator who needs to retrieve investment cost with business profits
Competition Process
This competition will be proceeded in three parts the first Operation Concept
Competition the second Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition and
the third SpaceFacility Construction Competition
The Operation Concept Competition (1st competition) takes place to select
various and creative proposals This stage asks what kind of dream of society
we image and in what form the society can be realized in this island As our
society is not consist with specific professions it is opened to everyone who
is interested in humanities society and environment and their cooperation
organization This is a phase which requires imagination of Gyun Heo
Ji-won Park or Gil-dong Hong of our time Multiple proposals will be
selected to advance to the next phase Operation PlanningFacility Concept
Competition
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd competition) is in a format that
architecture landscape and urban related experts involve and proceed The
purpose is to select a reasonable and specific space utilization proposal which
realize selected proposal from Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition
while fully satisfy expected level for scenery required for the city The most
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
2 History
Society and city do not get completed by great elite and in fact the moment
of completion does not exist What would be the plan to draw active
intervention of our next generation and accumulate their traces on this
island Nodeul Dream Island should be a place where citizenrsquos experience
and memory accumulate Required space for realizing the project and first
facility plan should start in reasonable scale Also in background of the plan
it should enable future citizenrsquos spatial participation while flexibly responding
to their behavior and demands
New Style Competition
Democratic society judge value through the process of reaching a conclusion
rather than the value that conclusion embodies Sound society maintains and
develops through keen competition and impartial judgement The institutional
strategy of these competition and judgement is competition Future shape of
Nodeul Dream Island will be selected by competition
All of operational planning of Nodeul Dream Island Space Planning and first
operator will be selected by competition This competition wants to be a
monumental project for proceeding through the most democratic process
rather than being the most glamourous and enormous structure This project
is meaningful as it even select proposal on how to utilize Nodeul Island
through competition Of course that proposal projects our dreams yet
premised on practical possibility in reality
The difference between this competition and other existing architecture
competition is that island planning and operation method competitions are
preceded Required facility programs and scale will be proposed per the result
The difference of this competition from other existing cosign operator selecting
competition is that we do not nominate the 3rd operator after building the
structure The operation system will be decided based on the best proposal and
the structure will be constructed according to the result and it will be operated
by the proposer If the selected proposal does not require structure building
may not be constructed This competition is different from existing business
investment competition as it creates necessary facility and space with Seoul
resources Thus operator who can balance between retrieving reasonable
operating expenses and realization of public value and have a sense of
responsibility on citizen and history will be nominated rather than business
operator who needs to retrieve investment cost with business profits
Competition Process
This competition will be proceeded in three parts the first Operation Concept
Competition the second Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition and
the third SpaceFacility Construction Competition
The Operation Concept Competition (1st competition) takes place to select
various and creative proposals This stage asks what kind of dream of society
we image and in what form the society can be realized in this island As our
society is not consist with specific professions it is opened to everyone who
is interested in humanities society and environment and their cooperation
organization This is a phase which requires imagination of Gyun Heo
Ji-won Park or Gil-dong Hong of our time Multiple proposals will be
selected to advance to the next phase Operation PlanningFacility Concept
Competition
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd competition) is in a format that
architecture landscape and urban related experts involve and proceed The
purpose is to select a reasonable and specific space utilization proposal which
realize selected proposal from Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition
while fully satisfy expected level for scenery required for the city The most
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
Competition Process
This competition will be proceeded in three parts the first Operation Concept
Competition the second Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition and
the third SpaceFacility Construction Competition
The Operation Concept Competition (1st competition) takes place to select
various and creative proposals This stage asks what kind of dream of society
we image and in what form the society can be realized in this island As our
society is not consist with specific professions it is opened to everyone who
is interested in humanities society and environment and their cooperation
organization This is a phase which requires imagination of Gyun Heo
Ji-won Park or Gil-dong Hong of our time Multiple proposals will be
selected to advance to the next phase Operation PlanningFacility Concept
Competition
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition (2nd competition) is
holding to select the most outstanding and realizable proposal and the
operator who will run this proposal based on the multiple selected proposals
from the previous competition Specific programs which can discover the
value of Nodeul Island and realize it realistically operable organizational
system and financial plan needs to be proposed The operation plan proposal
needs to be confirmed that it is financially self-sufficient and sustainable plan
as additional investment from Seoul should be none or minimized after the
completion In addition basic space utilization concept plan should be
reviewed and verified
The SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd competition) is in a format that
architecture landscape and urban related experts involve and proceed The
purpose is to select a reasonable and specific space utilization proposal which
realize selected proposal from Operation PlanningFacility Concept Competition
while fully satisfy expected level for scenery required for the city The most
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
outstanding proposal which translate social imagination into spatial imagination
will be the prizewinner and Nodeul Island will be constructed per that
proposal And that will be our Nodeul Dream Island
Nodeul Dream Island Competition
This competition requires spatial and facility construction design which can
contain an operation strategy that flexibly change and contain trace of the
time and sedimentation However this does not mean it is an incomplete
proposal The proposal need to design infrastructure and necessary facilities
for the entire island to operate in sufficient completeness even in case of no
additional services
Nodeul Dream Island anticipates to be our hope We hope the process and
result and everything of value and formality to be the ambition of our time
spreads out Therefore we hope the entire island not just specific structure
or portion of the island to be evaluated as a place filled with historical and
artistic values by our future generation The real juries of this competition will
be the citizens of our next generation
Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
1 Competition Regulation
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 8 -
1 Competition Regulations
11 Competition title
Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition
(3rd Stage)
12 Design Goal(Competition Goal)
The objective of Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and SpaceFacility Design
Competition is to select the appropriate spatial design proposal to realize
reasonable operation and facility plan that was selected at the 2nd stage of
the Competition In addition the proposal should satisfy high level of urban
scenary expectation
13 Project Outline
Client Seoul Metropolitan Government
Location area 302-6 146 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul SKorea
(Nodeul Island)
Site Area Upper Area 608184(Except Road Area 7153)
Island Lower Area(the riverbed) 59036
Estimated Construction Cost 195billion KRW(earthwork and VAT incl)
Infrastructure construction cost 241billion KRW
(CivilLandscapeSurveyRetaining wallConnecting construction of the east
and the west areasVAT incl)
Estimated Design fee 1969billion KRW (VAT incl)
Duration of Design Approx eight(8) months after the design contract
14 Competition Type
This competition is an open international competition for all professionals
15 Language and Unit Standards
The official languages of the competition are both Korean and English Official
documents will be published and distributed in Korean and English In case
disputes should occur regarding the interpretation of regulations guidelines
queries and other documents the Korean version will prevail over the English
version All submitted documents shall be written in Korean or English In
case of interpretative dispute of English the ordering agencys (clients)
interpretation overrules any other interpretation
All measuring units should follow the metric system
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 9 -
16 Eligibility
All professionals in architecture landscape and urban design can enter in
this competition In the case of joint application a team can have up to
five(5) members at maximum
In the case of joint application one(1) member of the team must be
registered as team representative The team representative must be in
charge of the submittal of construction documentation for the contracted
project
The team must include at least one licensed architect whose license should
be current and valid at the time of registration The copy of license should
be provided with other submission documents
A juror a professional manager a member of the companyorganization that
juror belongs to or other persons concerned cannot enter this competition
17 Competition schedule
Competition Announcement
Registration
Questions Posted by Entrant
Answers Posted by PA
Briefing Session on Site
Submission of Entries
Technical Evaluation
Main Evaluation and Selection
Announcement of Winners
Award Ceremony
Exhibition
2016 02 29
2016 02 29 ~ 05 06 1700 (Online)
2016 03 14 ~ 18 1700 (Online)
2016 03 25 (Online)
2016 03 31
2016 05 27 1000 ~ 1800
2016 06 14
2016 06 15 ~ 17
2016 06 20 (Online)
2016 07 07
2016 07 04 ~ 17
The above times are based on Korean Mean Time and the schedule is
subject to change The notice for change will be posted on the competition
website and all entrants will be notified by e-mail
18 Registration
Entrants or team representatives can check the competition guidelines
through the website(nodeulorg) and once the account is made entrants can
pay the registration fee
Registration will be completed once the transfer of registration fee to the
bank account guided on the website is confirmed (Foreigners may send the
proof of bank transfer to quicken the process)
Entrants can check the registration status by logging in the web site Once
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 10 -
the registration is done entrants can download reference materials and post
questions
Once registered the entrant cannot add or change team members or
change the team representative To do any of the above the entrant must
close their account and register a new one In this instance the registration
fee is non-refundable
Registration fee is USD 100(KRW 100000)
The remitter shall pay all the charges related to the wire transfer Payment
must be made in the exact amount in KRW or USD
The remitter should be the team representative
19 Queries
An entrant can ask questions regarding the competition through logging-in
the website(nodeulorg) where they have already completed to register but
not by e-mail or phone Questions should be written in either English or
Korean and answers will be provided to entrants in both English and Korean
Answers to questions should be regarded as revisions or addenda of the
competition rules
110 Reference Materials
Reference materials for design can be downloaded directly from the
website(nodeulorg) after logging in with a registered account
All or part of provided documents and materials cannot be used for other
purposes but this competition
111 Submission
Only one submission per entrant is allowed Dispatch of entries must be
made by post or hand delivery
All submitted documents should arrive as one package and loss or damage of
the package is not the responsibility of the client The entrant can check on
the competition website(nodeulorg) whether the package has been received
The submitted documents will not be returned and the period of submission
is as follows
By hand May 27 2016 1000 am ~ 600 pm (Korean time) All submitted
document should arrive at the Submission desk
By Mail (Including International Courier) The submission package must be
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 11 -
postmarked by May 26 2016(local time of entrants country) and should arrive
at the submissions address below between May27 2016 and June03 2016
600 pm(Korean time) Entrant should be responsible for contacting hisher
courier to manage the delivery time Any delivery before of after this period will
not be accepted The postmark of the package should be legible to confirm the
date of submission In order to avoid unexpected delay in delivery or taxes the
package should be clearly marked as No Commercial Value
Reception 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul Cityhall 1F Lobby
Mail (04524) 110 Sejong-daero Jung-gu Seoul SKorea
(Urban Regeneration Headquarters Public development center)
112 AnonymityAnonymity will be guaranteed until the announcement of winners For this all
information registered in the website(nodeulorg) will not be disclosed until
the announcement and all documents with the entrants information should
be sealed separately Entrants should create and use their won unique
Personal Identification Number(PIN) out of alphabets and numbers to identify
their submission documents Any other indications except for PIN revealing
entrants identity will be considered violation and reported to jury This PIN
will be covered again with serial reception number upon arrival For fair
review and assessment entrants cannot reveal their works submitted in the
competition through media like SNS until the result is announced
113 Client
The client of the competition is the Seoul Metropolitan Government which
has the responsibility of financing and overseeing all issues related to the
competition The client approves the juryrsquos final decision and follows up on
the outcome of the competition
114 Competition Administration
The Professional Advisor and Competition Administration nominated by the
client to manage the competition is as follows
Professional Advisor Professor Seo Hyun (Nodeul Island Chief Planner)
Project Manager Professor Saehyung Sohn (Sungkyunkwan University)
Contact Urban Design Institute of Korea 02)2061-4146 infonodeulorg
The project manager and his team will adhere to the schedule and
regulations of the competition The professional advisor will supervise the
entire process of the competition convene with the technical committee in
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 12 -
order for the technical evaluation to proceed and support the entire process
of selecting winners
115 Technical Committee
The technical Committee consists of 6 experts from relevant fields
(architecture landscape civil engineering building service performance etc)
According to the competition regulations and guidelines as well as related
laws the committee judges violations in submissions draws up violation
reports and turns in to the jury committee
116 Jury Committee
The jury consists of seven(7) jurors and one(1) deputy juror as follows
Jurors
Min Hyunsik (South Korea)
Ohn Yeongte (South Korea)
Jeong Wookju (South Korea)
Choi Moongyu (South Korea)
Choi Shinhyun (South Korea )
Florian Beigel (United Kingdom)
Riken Yamamoto (Japan)
Deputy Juror
Cho Namho (South Kroea)
The opening of the Jury Committee is announced in the presence of all
jurors deputy jurors and professional advisor The Committee will elects a
chair at the first meeting
The Chair of the Committee decides the evaluation and selection criteria by
hearing the opinion of the jurors draws up the evaluation report and turns in
to the client
The deputy juror participates in the judging with the jurors as an equal but
heshe is not given a vote except in the following situations
- If a jury member is absent at the first meeting heshe loses juror status and will be
replaced by the deputy juror
- When a juror is temporarily absent the deputy juror will be a proxy
Professional advisors can participate in the selection process but does not
have a vote
The jurors can agree to drop submissions in the following categories
regardless of the evaluation process and the jurors can cancel an award at a
later date if such conduct comes to light
- An entrant submits more than one proposal
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 13 -
- The submission does not follow the competitions regulations or guidelines
- The rule of anonymity is ignored
- The image of a proposal is released prior to the announcement of the final selection
(including SNS mentions)
- A submission is the same or similar to works previously designed by the entrant or
someone else
- An entrant does not meet the eligibility criteria
117 Selection of Winners
The results will be posted on the official website(nodeulorg) right after the
jury session and winners will be individually informed
The winning entries and prizes are as follows
First Prize(One entey) Design Contract
Second Prize(One entry) KRW 50 million
Third Prize(One entry) KRW 30 million
Honorable Mention(No more then four(4) entries) KRW 5 million each
If a foreign entry wins the equivalent of the prize money will be awarded in
USD at the current exchange rate(within 30days of the award ceremony) In
the case of joint application the money will be awarded to the team
representative
Fees for the copyright tax wire transfer etc are included in the prize
money and Koreas Tax Law will be applied to calculate the tax
The First Prize winner has the right to negotiate the design contract with
client The contract should be signed within thirty(30) days of the
announcement of the winner
If the First Prize winner gives up hisher right to negotiate the contract or an
agreement cannot be reached the client can grant the right to the next
winner in line In this case the next winner must return the prize money and
the client will award this to the First Prize winner
If the client suspends the project after having sealed the contract
reimbursement will be paid for service and expenses executed until the
moment of suspension
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 14 -
118 Design Contract
The design contract shall conform to the related laws of Korea The scope of
the contract includes schematic design and construction documentation The
contract should be written in Korean reflecting the design brief based on the
regulations of the client organization
The contract will be made with the competition winner who has the right to
negotiate the design contract with client However if there is no one in the
winner satisfying given conditions below the winner shall bring in personnel
who satisfies each or all of conditions as a member of contractor and seal
the contract with them This is to conform to the building laws of Korea and
proceed the approval process smoothly
- A person at the time of contract who has an architect qualification certified under the
certified architects act and who has completed the registration of hisher architectrsquos
office under the same law and who has no reason for disqualification stated in Article 9
of the same law
The design fee for the project includes all costs for conducting survey
schematic design construction document building permit and architectural
board review and transportation as well The winner must cooperate with a
engineer when heshe proceeds Master plan Alteration of Urban Planning
Facilities or Establishment of Park Planning The client may demand certain
modifications on the winning design according to circumstantial changes and
the winner must accept such demands as deemed reasonable
119 Copyright and PublicationExhibition
The copyright of the winning designs belongs to the entrant(s) The
ownership and the right of use belong to the client The client reserves the
right to use the submitted proposals free of charge for publication exhibition
internet or for advertising in newspapers or broadcasting etc
Entrants should not infringe intellectual property rights of third parties (If
entrants use a third partys intellectual property heshe must submit a
document such as a letter of accreditation to prove proper use of intellectual
property) If any dispute related to copyright arises the entrant shall hold all
responsibility and if the case claims the winning submission the prize may
be canceled
120 Dispute
This competition is based on the law of the Republic of Korea if any dispute
related to the competition arises it will be resolved in Koreas court of law
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
2 Design Guide
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 16 -
2 Design Guide
21 Design Goal
The goal of this design is to create a facility that can contain selected
operational program through the 2nd stage competition proposed by operator
Design subject is to create music-led cultural platform where the
collaboration between various fields occur such as music cultural art
ecologyenvironment eco-friendly commercial new media and development
model cooperate and a complex cultural space that any citizen can visit any
time
Basic Principle of Nodeul Island
Consider the use of physical facilities
Propose in appropriate scale and to avoid mega structure facilities
Respect historicity of Han River and Nodeul Island
Promote ecological value of Nodeul Island
Consider landscape value of Nodeul Island
Consider the context of surrounding area
Propose an environment-friendly transportation system including public
transportation and pedestrian
22 Design Area and Subject
[Image 1] Design Area
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 17 -
Design area of the competition is upper part (53665 excluding road 7153)
and lower part (riverbed 59036) of Nodeul Island
Competition participants should provide a plan for architecture landscape
connection road of east and west and facility related civil structure MEP
eco-friendly plans for upper possible building area based on the program provided
at 25 Detail Guideline of Facilities
Based on the principle that biotope area should be preserved minimum design for
the area can be proposed if applicable which does not damage the biotope
Site construction (existing surveycivil engineering) landscape and retaining wall
repairreinforcement plan for upper area should be proposed
Conceptual design spatial plan for lower part of Nodeul Island should be proposed
This includes berth facility connection road to upper area and idea can creatively
be proposed The design for lower part is not included in the construction budget
for the Nodeul Island development for current stage
Design area is listed below
Facilities-Music concert hall officecommercial facilities multi-purpose facilities
connection road between East and West parts of the island
Outdoor Area
-Site construction Landscape (Nodeul Yard Nodeul Forest architecture
extension area etc) retaining wall parking facilities existing facilities
- Lower area including berth facilities (construction cost not included in
this time)
23 Site Existing Condition
1) Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper part 608184 Lower part 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot Ratio less than 60 Building
Coverage Ratio Less than 200 Height Limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facilities Cultural Facilities
Note The island is divided into Upper part and Lower part (Type 2 General
Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only apply to Upper Area)
2) Upper Part and Lower Part
Nodeul Island consists of upper part and lower part including public water
Upper part Some area of upper part is always available for fixed facility
installation and constant use (possible building area based on current law is
approximately 29394) Upper part also includes road and biotope area
Lower part Flexible and temporary operational program is appropriate for
lower part as flood area The design area includes the water surface area
within which any new structure does not interfere with Han River stream
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 18 -
3) Possible Construction Area
Possible construction area is 29394 out of total 60818 of upper part of
Nodeul Island excluding road (Yangnyeongno) 7153 and class 1 biotope
area (Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis) 24271
[Image 2] Possible Construction Area and Biotope Area
4) Retaining Wall
Upper part of the Island is surrounded by approximately 50~94m high and 9470m
long internal retaining wall Approximately 25m high and 707m long external
retaining wall are constructed at both east and west ends Some part of West
retaining wall is utilized as corridor External retaining wall at east lower part is used
as heliport facility
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
5) Biotope
According to the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015
most of east hill area and west wet land of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in
Biotope Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
6) Existing Facilities
Current existing facilities in Nodeul Island are heliport military amp police joint
checkpoint and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung (Appendix 42 Existing
Condition of Nodeul Island)
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 19 -
24 General Guide and Consideration
1) General Consideration
Design reasonable scaled buildings and facilities according to proposed
contents and programs
Design landscape and outdoor area for upper area of the island
Propose pedestrian and vehicular circulation
Spatial plan for lower area of the island can be proposed in idea level
Avoid any fixed facilities in lower area as it is a flooded area and consider
flood for landscape design
Rainwater sewerage and release design should calculate the whole upper
area
Sewerage and septic tank facility should consider discharging to Han River
after treatment
Heliport is not allowed to be relocated while the re-location of military and
police joint checkpoint substation facility and statue of first sergeant Lee
Won-Deung should be discussed with related department on construction
document phase
2) Layout Design
For buildings and outdoor area layout consider future horizontal expansion
and secure large space (Nodeul Yard) where is variable for various activities
Minimize vehicular access to Nodeul Island and maintain current location of
Nodeul Forest and retaining walls Building and outdoor area layout
considering points above should follow principles listed below
① Facility Layout
Concentrate buildings near Yangnyeongno as much as possible
Locate music concert hall and officecommercial facilities with more activities in
west side of Yangnyeongno and locate multi-purpose facilities with relatively
less activities on east side of Yangnyeongno
Layout functions considering facilities and visitors per programs
Layout commercial area considering visitor access to avoid interference by
music concert hall circulation
Music concert hall and multi-purpose facility should be connected to connection
road of east and west considering functional relationship
Building height should harmonize with landscape scenery of Nodeul Island and
Han River
For facility layout secure proper distance from biotope area
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 20 -
② Outdoor Space Layout
In principle biotope area should be restored and preserved and retaining walls
shall remain in its current location
Layout outdoor space while minimizing development effects on ecological
environment of Nodeul Island and the first class biotope area
For lower area idea can be freely proposed considering connection to upper
area and biotope class
Locate berth facility in southwest of Nodeul Island
Locate general parking facility on the side of Yangnyeongno separating from
pedestrian circulation
3) Circulation Design
Internal circulation of Nodeul Island prioritizes pedestrian and follows
principles listed below
① Pedestrian Circulation
Design main pedestrian circulation of west of Nodeul Island to allow small
musical performances
Design circulation of Nodeul Forest for people to view and walk in the forest
Design circulation to conveniently walk around through upper and lower area of
Nodeul Island
Design vertical circulation for disabled
② Vehicular Circulation
Pursue vehicular circulation and parking facility in Nodeul Island without violating
pedestrian priority principles and layout and design without ruining landscape
scenery
Design EVA lane circulation for fire truck or ambulance etc (including vehicular
circulation for administration and heliport)
Provide supporting vehicular circulation which allows moving equipment and
supply for each facilities
Locate loading zone for taxi and tour bus on the side of Yangnyeongno for
convenience
Design turn space for vehicle(10t size) for music concert hall special equipment
transportation
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 21 -
4) Landscape Design
Landscape facilities of Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
Make it possible to operate in low cost
Avoid temporarily completed landscape design upon completion of the
construction and provide phased landscape design considering ecological
succession
Properly maintain existing trees shrubs and natural green while establishing
purification plan to remove invasive species and harmful species and utilize
natural soil in maximuim
Design outdoor activity places such as pedestrian walk and decking and
natural environment to harmoniously merge and actively use permeable
pavers for paving design
5) Civil Engineering
Civil engineering for Nodeul Island should follow principles listed below
① Flood Prevention and Flood Protection
Design with 200-year flood frequency (1533ELm) as standard
Secure drain system that water can rapidly drain with intensive rainfall in
Nodeul Island
Consider healthy water circulation (utilize rainwater and heavy water reuse of
waste water) in Nodeul Island
Avoid facility or form that cause water level elevation of waterside flood zone
by disturbing water flow during flood
Design related facilities around Nodeul Island considering contradiction with
River Act
② Civil Base
Fully reflect existing geotechnical report (layer structure) result (Appendix 43
Foundation Existing Condition and Plan) on buildings of Nodeul Island
Minimize soil excavation and filling of Nodeul Island ground and use excavated
soil as much as possible for filling
When improving retaining wall design the structure that can respond to rapid
water level change of Han River (especially responding to residual water
pressure occurring inside of the retaining wall when lowering flood elevation)
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 22 -
6) Environment-Friendly Design
Environment-friendly design of Nodeul Island follows the principles listed
below
Design for preserving ecology in Nodeul Island operational independency
reducing carbon emission and minimizing environmental impacts
Satisfy regulation ordinance and standard on environment and energy
performance of corresponding area
Propose plan to reducing heat island effect fully considering Passive Design
responding to site environment condition through minutely climatic analysis of
corresponding site
Reflect 3R principles to improve resource recycling ndash Reducing resource waste
Reuse resource and Recycle resource
Design to save water resource to minimize required water usage of facilities
and outdoor area
Establish concept and goal for energy independency of Nodeul Island
Propose energy reducing plan according to shortmidlong term prediction to
realize energy independent facility in phases
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 23 -
25 Detailed Guideline of Facilities
Proposed facilities listed below must be included in design and additional
proposal of various and creative programs that fit within total construction cost
is allowed Total area of proposed programs is 9900 and referring to
information below it can be enlarged within budget
(1) Music concert hall
This is mid-scale music concert hall facility in form of live house specialized in pop
music concert with approximately 400~500 seats (1000~1500 standing)
Reverberation design should be planned uniformly for pop music concert and
increase turnover of music concert hall renting by installing standard equipment
Total Floor Area 1800
Programs
Performance
Programs
- Pop music related performance (renting) self-organizing performance
- Major performance other musical play performance of festival in
Nodeul IslandCommercial
Programs- self-operating FampB sales for performance related products
Follow music concert hall requirements for other detailed area and functions
(Appendix 44 Administratorrsquos Suggestion)
Comply minimum budget of 858 billion KRW (including sound equipment and
tax) for smooth performance of function
Design space and circulation which can increase performance turnover
considering convenience of equipment installation
Design space considering waiting audience before performance
For music concert hall main entrance consider connectivity with
officecommercial facility and major pedestrian circulation
(2) OfficeCommercial Facilities
These facilities include commercial area where small agency cultural group
creative industry related field gather and provide various foods and
attractions
This facility is divided into two types of spaces Completed Space (approx
60) which gets completed by design through this competition and
Participatory Design Space (approx 40) which gets completed by users
Completed Space and Participatory Design Space can be proposed as
combined or separated building but it is required to consider connectivity of
these spaces
Meaning of Completed Space and Participatory Design Space is following
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 24 -
Completed Space- Space where proposer designs up to finishing of the space
same as general architecture design
Participatory
Design Space
(Appendix 44
Administratorrsquos
Suggestion)
- Space where provider does not complete everything but users
of correspondence part complete themselves
- Provide open system which users finally complete the space
based on the design like basic structure system that
3rdcompetitionproposerdesigned
- Construction cost for the portion where gets completed by
users is funded by users
Total floor area 7000
Office facility is 4000 and commercial facility is 3000 and apply approx
60 on Completed Space and 40 on Participatory Design Space
Programs
Office
Programs
- Office space for artmusic related fields
- Interaction space between fields and occupants
- Management office of Nodeul operator
Commercial
Programs
- Resident sales facility (including part of start-up merchants)
- Public space for possible small performance and event
Design Scope
Completed
Space
Officecommercial standard space design including infrastructure public
space indooroutdoor spaceParticipatory
Design SpaceInfrastructure public space
Secure exclusive area of Completed Space as minimum 3100 and Participatory
Design Space as 1600 (total exclusive area minimum 4700)
Exclusive area must be comparted per following standards
- Floor area (exclusive area) of individual unit should be min 48
- Total number of individual unit should be min 75 units
Design enough public space for Participatory Design Space to secure design
independency of individual unit and various activity spaces
Design to receive architecture permission and completion once completed in
this construction (scheduled to be in early 2018) (Required to provide related
legal review data)
Design the space with connectivity of Nodeul Yard and programs
Secure space for small public programs within commercial facility area
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 25 -
(3) Multi-purpose facilities
Create facilities for various activities such as music concert showcase
cultural performance and event conference and so on
Floor Area 1100
- Multi-purpose hall 500
- Lecture room 260
- Other public facilities 340 (including service facilities such as corridor stairs and
restroom)
Programs
Music Related
Programs
- Pop music related performance (rented) and self-organizing
performance such as small concert and showcase
- Support festival sub-performance in Nodeul Island
Non-music related
programs
- Exhibit and hands-on experience event of other non-music
culturalart fields
- Business support function for meeting conference and event of
occupying businesses in officecommercial facilities
Design multi-purpose hall in size of 200 seats for various programs such as
performance exhibit and hand-on experience event
Secure minimum1 large lecture room for 30 people and 2 lecture rooms for
20 people
Design space with distinct characteristics that can harmonize with nature of
Nodeul Island
(4) Connection Road of East and West
Connection road of east and west functions as intimately interlocking
operational programs and each facilities while physically connecting severed
east and west This road is a symbolic gateway of Nodeul Island as it is the
facility which visitors encounter first and actively exposed to passing vehicle
of Han River Bridge
It actively connect surrounding facilities and programs while seeking for
harmony with facilities and natural environment
Design the road considering traffic and handicap access
(5) Landscape and Outdoor Space
① Nodeul Yard
This is a semi-permanent space where can hold large scale outdoor event as it
will not have any buildings even after facility expansion of Nodeul Island
Secure single compartment flatland with minimum area of 6000
For landscape and structure layout consider variability during design phase to
allow large events
Consider connectivity of pedestrian circulation of facility users such as
mainsecondary entrances of adjacent buildings
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 26 -
Design by considering architecture expansion area
② Nodeul Forest
Nodeul Forest located east of Nodeul Island is rated Class 1 in Biotope
Analysis and Individual Biotope Analysis and it is consisted with passive
programs which do not harm nature such as walking in Nodeul Forest trail and
small music performance
It should follow related regulations like Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance per
Biotope Classes development activity that does not require additional
permission is allowed
Minimize effects on land during facility construction like trails
Install base space for small activities
③ Architecture Expansion Area
This is preparatory space where facility can expand in phase according to future
demand This prevents indiscriminate development of the island and contain
various temporary programs
This area can be utilized as space for temporary programs and various
outdoor activity like ecological experience
Architecture expansion area near the side of Yangnyeongno can be used as
parking lot
Minimize landscaping for future expansion
④ Retaining Wall
Repairreinforce retaining wall section near bridge (Safety Inspection rated
Class E in rsquo09 and Class C in rsquo12) considering safety for new facility plan
Design with 200-year flood frequency and refer to appendix for existing
retaining wall grading but existing condition survey such as Safety
Inspection needs to be re-performed during Design Development and
Construction Document phase and reflect the result into the design
(Appendix 43 Foundation Existing Condition and Plan)
Various design proposal is allowed if retaining wall is fully functioning once
repairedreinforced
⑤ Berth Facility
Propose spatial plans for berth facility and connection road to berth facility in
conceptual design format and it shall not be included in construction cost this
time
(Appendix 43 Foundation Condition and Plan)
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 27 -
⑥ Parking Facility
Pedestrian access is the basic principles for visiting and accessing to Nodeul
Island and allow vehicular access up to Nodeul Island entrance around
Yangnyeongno Moreover consider loading zone for vehicle on the side of
Yangnyeongno (Facility support vehicle and fire truckemergency vehicle are
exception)
Separate parking facilities and road from pedestrian circulation
Calculate total number of parking lot based on related regulation such as
Parking Lot Act
Layout the parking lots except disable parking lots on the side of
Yangnyeong Road as single section ground level drive-in parking
Scale of general and handicap parking facilities for the maintenance and
operating is following and they locate near each facility Consider the
accessibility of service and emergency vehicle circulation for each facility
such as music concert hall officecommercial multi-purpose facility etc And
establish the circulation system to avoid interference pedestrian movement
Special service vehicles should be able to efficiently access to loading bays
of the music concert hall and multi-purpose facility
Recommend to design environment-friendly parking lot using permeable
pavers and allow to convert into pedestrian space in case of no parking
demand
⑦ Eixisting Facilites (Appendix 42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island)
Heliport will be remained as is at current location
Military and Police Joint Checkpoint can be moved within Noduel Island
through discussion with related department in design phase
Relocate the statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung to place with better
recognition and access of Nodeul Island visitors and locate and construct to
harmonize with overall design
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 28 -
26 Cost Estimation
Estimated cost for this project is 195 billion KRW for architecture
construction cost (including civil engineering and tax) and 241 billion KRW for
foundation construction cost (including civil engineeringlandscapeexisting
surveyretaining wallconnecting east and west and tax) and it must be
complied
Pricing must be realizable considering cost per architecture area guideline
while construction cost distribution fulfills the minimum construction cost
proposed below
Division Area()
Minimum
Constructi
on Cost
Note
Music
concert
hall
Total 1800858billion
KRW- Including tax
Upper
Area
Landscape
Total 51200
- General
30700
- Biotope
20500
528billion
KRW
- Including tax
- (Reference) General area construction
cost per 33 approx 360000 KRW
- (Reference) Biotope area construction
cost per 33 approx 230000 KRW
Proposer should submit brief construction cost statement (Form 5) If selected design exceed construction cost range the proposer is obligated to
revise design after discussion with ordering agency In case of failure in obligation it shall be deemed to have renounced the right of design
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 30 -
3 Submission Documents and Requirements
31 Submission Documents
1) Drawing Panels
Drawing panels consist of six(6) A1-size(841mmx594mm) sheet mounted on
10mm thick foam boards in landscape orientation without frame
The site plan should mark north following the orientation information of the
CAD file distributed on the official website The scale of masterplan shall be
11000 the scale of the site plan 1400(recommended) and scale of schematic
design plan 1200
The panels will be displayed as follows
1 2 3PIN
3
PIN
2
PIN
1
4 5 6PIN
6
PIN
5
PIN
4 [front] [back]
2) Design Report
The design report should include the following items
- Title of the project on blank cover page(Arial 24 point black center aligned)
- Content
- Three-dimensional Image (Main Shot)
- Design overview design description and facility area schedule(Form4)
- Site plan Plans elevations and sections of main design
- Repairreinforcement work for retaining wall landscape design and outdoor
space planning for the upper part of the island construction plan connecting
the east and the west areas
- Space planning for the lower part of the island (Constructing a pier and its
access route)
- Civil engineering structure mechanic amp electric equipment design
principle or direction regarding sustainability
- Other necessary details or contents that are not expressed on the panels
- Cost estimation for retaining wall repair amp reinforcement work landscape
connecting construction of the east and the west rainwater and
sewage system structure sustainability (3~5 pages)
- Construction Cost Estimation
- Relevant Regulations Review
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 31 -
The Submission documents must be 25 pages or less(cover content and blank
pages are not counted) as A3-size(420mm x 297mm landscape orientation)
papers Ten(10) copies must be handed in
No restrictions on scale and orientation of the drawings
The submission document must be made in landscape orientation with
left-sided binding (portrait orientation or folding paper will not be accepted)
3) DVD
DVD should contain image files of panels(300 dpi or more jpg) design
description(pdf high quality print) other required forms(scanned in pdf) and
three-dimensional images The DVD should be submitted within a case
Create a new folder rename the folder name following A-000_name of the
representative format and put all files under it
3D images (perspective or aerial view images) used in drawing panels or
design descriptions must be submitted as separately saved files (300dpi or
higher in jpg format) If the perspective images including arbitrary modification
are different from the images of submission documents it will be considered
as regulation violation which will be reported to the jury and the jury can
decide upon possible elimination fo the entry for that reason
Specify file names following lsquoA-000_PANEL1jpg A-000_PANEL2jpgrsquo format by
using PIN numbers and panel numbers Submit total 7 image files including
lsquoA-000_descriptionpdfrsquo format files along with other document files
(A-000_document namespdf) Specify 3D image files names following
lsquoA-000_image1jpgrsquo format for submission
4) Submission Documents
Entry form - Printable from the website
Power of Attorney ndash Form 1 (if applicable)
Joint Application Agreement ndash Form 2
Pledge ndash Form 3
Design outline - Form 4
Construction Cost Estimate - Form 5
Relevant Regulations Review- Form 6
Design drawings six(6) panels (A1)
Design report ten(10) copies
DVD [Including Design drawings panels(jpg) Design report(pdf) Other
forms(pdf) three-dimensional images(jpg)]
A copy of Business Registration Certificate of team representative(if applicable)
A copy of Architect License(If entrants nation does not issue a license please
provide a copy of Architecture Association membership)
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 32 -
32 PIN and Numbering of Panels
In order to secure anonymity a PIN(Personal Identity Number) selected by the
entrants is used to mark the upper right corner on the back of the panels
design report and DVD case(See the image below)
The PIN consists of one uppercase alphabet and three Arabic numerals
The numbering of the panels(indicating the order of panel layout) should be
attached on the lower righthand corner on the back of each panels as follows
The PIN and panel numbering is ARIAL 24 point black center aligned
Once the submission is completed the PIN will be covered with an opaque
paper Instead a serial reception number will be given by the client to be used
during the competition
ltPINgt Unit mm
10 10 10 10 10 30
30
A - 0 0 0 10
ltPanel Numberinggt Unit mm
30 20
1 30
20
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 33 -
33 Documentation Guideline
Use of color is allowed(No restriction in panel expression)
Any mark indicating the identity of entry is prohibited Violation of this may
result in elimination of the entry
Unless otherwise noted entrants can decide the scale of the drawings Scale
and orientation should be precise
Note the territory and name of the space on the drawings In particular the
proper names in English like the site and surroundings street names and
buildings names are prohibited marked temporarily by entrants if used in the
combination of Korean names Write the same names in confirmation of
English guideline
All documents should be written in Korean or English and Arabic numerals And
all measuring units should follow the metric system
Violation of the above items including arbitrary modification of perspective
images resulting in being much different from the drawings will be reported to
the jury and the jury can decide upon possible elimination of the entry for that
reason
34 List of Forms
Form 1 Power of Attorney
Form 2 Joint Application Agreement
Form 3 Pledge
Form 4 Design Outline
Form 5 Construction Cost Estimate
Form 6 Relevant Regulations Review
35 List of Reference Materials
Architectural Drawing Set(dwg)
Photos
The provided documents might be different from the real situation Thus the
first prize winner should adjust construction documents after the contract
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 34 -
[Form1]
Power of Attorney
I mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) of mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (Firm name) hereby
appoint mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash (name) to be a representative of the
competition and delegate all rights to the representative for the
works produced for the Nodeul Dream Island Master Plan and
SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage)
2016
Co-Representative mdashmdashmdashmdashmdashmdash(Signature)
Submit only when there are two or more representatives(partners) within a firm Each representative should sign on each form
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 35 -
[Form2]
Joint Application Agreement
Article 1(Goal)
Article 2
Article 3(Team Members)
Article 4(Rights of the representative firm)
Article 5(Period fo agreement)
Article 6(Obligations)
Article 7(Responsibilities)
Article 8(Responsibilities among members)
Article 9(Limits on transfer of rights and responsibilities)Article 10
Article 11(Agreement documentation)
This agreement is to establish the rules between each firm and each individual s part of the subject joint application for Nodeul Dream Island Maste Plan and SpaceFacility Design Competition (3rd Stage) The name and address of the firm of team representative entering the competition is as follows1 Name of Firm 2 Address 3 Name of Team Representative The team members excluding the team representative are as follows1 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )2 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )3 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative )4 Name of Member(Firm) (Location Representative ) If the member is a firm complete blanks in parenthesis The representative firm has the authority to express the will of its team regarding the reception and submission of documents and acquisition and abandonment of rightsThis agreement shall come into effect as of the signing date of this document and shall be automatically invalidated as of the submission to the competition As for the winner of the competition the agreement shall be invalidated as of the termination of the design contractMembers of the team promise to apply all knowledge and skills necessary in good faith to achieve the goal as stated in article 01Members of the team shall share all responsibilities in relation to the performance of the work submitted to the competitionMember of the team shall discuss and provide compensation for damages to third parties andor other members within the team that may be cause by the performance of their works Member of the team including the representative cannot transfer their rights and responsibilities as stated in this agreement to a third party① Entrants cannot submit their work if the representative firm withdraws from the competition andor if a member withdrawn from the team causes disqualification to enter the competition② f a team member withdraws from the team the representative firm shall immediately report to the Seoul Metropolitan Government Members of the team cannot be replaced once this agreement is submittedEach member of the subject Joint Application Agreement agrees to abide by all artivles stated above Each member shall sign and submit the subject agreement and also retain a copy for their records
Firm
Representative (signature) DATE 2016
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 2 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 36 -
[Form3]
PledgeDear Mayor of Seoul
I(We) the undersigned entrant(s) will faithfully follow the
regulations and guidelines of the Client Seoul Metropolitan
Government If any violation occurs I(We) am willing to accept any
incurring disadvantage
I (We) hereby submit the pledge confirming that I (We) will take
legal financial and administrative responsibility for our proposals and
will not contest the process or the result of the competition such as
the submission evaluation selection of the winners
2016
Firm
Representative (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 2 (signature) Entrant 3 (signature)
Firm Firm
Entrant 4 (signature) Entrant 4 (signature)
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 37 -
[Form4]
Design outline and Area
Item Description Notes
BuildingOutline
N a m e
L o c a t io n
Z o n in g d is tr ic t
S ite a re a
Building Area
Total Floor Area
Ground
Basement
Building coverage ratio
Floor area ratio
Structure
Number of Stories
Max Height
Exterior Finishing
Facility Outline
Parking
Landscape outline
Connecting road outline
Other notes
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 38 -
[Form5]
Estimated construction cost
project name 『Nodeul Island Development As Culturally Attractive Place』(Units1000KRW)
ItemMaterial
EquipmentPrice
Labor Expenses SubtotalEstimated Cost
Ratio
Architectural
work
Subtotal
Temporary dismantling work
Frame work
Masonry Waterproofing
workDoors and windows
Interior finishing work
Finishing work
Other miscellaneous work
Site Work(Earthwork incl)
Mechanical works (Fire work incl)
Electric works (Fire work incl)
ElectricCommunication work
Civil Engineering (the entire site including retaining wall
construction)
Landscape
Connecting Construction of the east and the west areas
Waste disposal
etc(including infrastructure)
Total
Overhead cost
Total estimated construction cost
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 39 -
[Form 6]
Relevant Regulations Review
Regulation and Article
Subject Legal Standard Design Standard Note
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
4 Appendix
1 Project Overview
2 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
3 Foundation Construction Plan
4 Space Program proposed
by Selected Operator
5 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
6 History of Nodeul Island
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 41 -
4 Appendix
41 Project Overview
1) Project Name Nodeul Island Development
As Culturally Attractive Place
2) Project Background
After postponement of Han River Art Island Development Project in 2012 it was
utilized as temporary vegetable garden however the necessity of reconsideration
on the islands development for public interest application plan was continuously
brought up
Accordingly the investigation of specialists opinion on related field (Seoul
Institute 2013) was proceeded and it was advisable to utilize Nodeul Island with
high potential value of the Island As thorough discussion on development plan
was required there have been various publicizing processes such as Nodeul
Island Forum and participation program of citizens and experts
As a result of the public opinion hearing it was required that new approach with
new program and its development methods
3) Ordering Agency
Seoul Metropolitan Goverment
(Urban Renewal Division Public and Development Center)
Address 110 Sejong-dearo Jung-gu Seoul Seoul City Hall New Office 11 Floor
Contact 02)2133-8362
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 42 -
[Image 3] Regional Condition around Nodeu Island
42 Existing Condition of Nodeul Island
1) Project Site Summary
Location Area 146 302-6 Ichon-dong Yongsan-gu Seoul (Nodeul Island)
Area 1198545 (Upper Area 608184 Lower Area 590361)
Zoning Type 2 General Residential Zone (Plot ratio less than 60 Building
coverage ratio Less than 200 Building height limit maximum 12 stories)
Urban Planning Facility Cultural Facilities
Note Divided into two areas Upper part and lower part of the Island (Type 2
General Residential Area and Cultural Facilities only applies to the upper part)
2) Regional Condition
Northern Area of Nodeul Island is called Young-san and National Museum of
Korea National Hangeul Museum Yongsan Family Park and Yongsan Park
which is scheduled to be constructed are located in Ichon Station area
Southern Part of Nodeul Island is adjacent to Dongjak-gu and it has easy
access to Noryangjin and Yeouido
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 43 -
3) Transportation Condition
① Vehicular Access System
Currently due to absence of parking space in Nodeul Island the visitors of
the island use the parking space of Hangang Citizens Park in Ichon area It
takes approximately 10~20 minutes from parking space to Nodeul Island by
walk
② Pedestrian Access System
Pedestrian can access Nedeulseom through Hangang Bridge by public
transportation For convenience pedestrian walk is constructed on upper
portion of Hangang bridge and facilities such as ramp and elevator are
constructed on northern end for pedestrian access from Hangang Park
Bus station is constructed on both sides of Hangang Bridge which runs through
Nodeul Island and currently 13 main lines and 1 local line are in operation
The closest subway station is Nodeul Station of Line No 9 on Southern end
and it takes approximately 10~20 minutes to Nodeul Island by walk
[Image 4] Transportation Diagram
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 44 -
4) Vegetation Condition
According to Seoul Vegetation Distribution Chart most of the project site
excluding east hill area and lower west forest is indicated as landscape planting
area farmland and bare soil
East hill area is filled with the forest of mixed undistinguished plants and lower
west area is filled with willow habitat and grassland
Most of existing plants are mixed with undistinguished and plantation forest
which has low conservative values however the actual visual condition of the
plants is relatively good
[Image 5] Seoul Existing Vegetation Map (2015)
5) Biotope Condition
As the result of Urban Ecological Condition Investigation in 2015 most of east
hill area of Nodeul Island and lower west wetland are rated Biotope type 1 on
biotope analysis According to Seoul Urban Planning Ordinance Article 24 Annex
1 land rated Class 1 on both biotope analysis and individual biotope analysis
the entire site of Biotope type 1 should be preserved
In case that the design proposal include the area of Biotope type 1 of the
island for certain spatial use with specific program consult with the relevant
city departments is required when detail design phase
[Image 6] Nodeul Island Current Urban Ecology Condition Diagram Biotope analysis
(2015 gisseoulgokr)
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 45 -
6) Existing Facilities
There are 3 main existing facilities Heliport Military amp Police Joint Checkpoint
and statue of first sergeant Lee Won-Deung in Nodeul Island
[Image 7] Major Facilities in Nodeul Island
7) Noise and Vibration Measurement
For the previous development plan for Nodeul Island Han River Art Island
Development noise and vibration survey was proceeded
Noise and vibration was measured during typical weekday September 19
2009 on development site and adjacent areas
Weather condition is referenced from AWS (Automatic Weather Station) and
each measurement took place every hours from 3pm to 11pm
Measurement took place twice during rush-hour in 6 locations and duration of
each measurement was 15 minutes
[Image 8] Noise and Vibration Measured Locations
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 46 -
Measured data - Leq
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Leq [dB]1 582 522 582 576 586 581 582 577 581 571 575 581
123 556 504 558 555 560 556 560 557 558 553 562 550
16 534 486 533 543 540 533 544 534 534 537 545 534
2 518 465 522 519 516 518 518 521 517 512 519 515
25 515 449 520 527 519 516 521 515 514 516 521 515
314 489 427 525 517 585 528 497 480 583 511 489 499
4 536 415 585 563 626 569 522 488 593 560 547 554
5 530 393 637 638 625 595 516 512 588 582 561 550
63 640 385 789 784 719 710 614 624 675 664 665 630
8 702 418 802 812 747 749 676 704 716 732 665 674
10 742 353 868 874 786 798 712 735 732 750 695 722
125 731 336 873 870 789 796 705 726 746 748 681 690
16 689 325 857 850 774 757 689 698 719 718 657 646
20 647 304 806 793 705 691 635 641 662 655 608 600
25 614 300 750 752 658 650 572 578 612 606 552 540
315 612 280 702 703 629 619 511 518 560 549 497 484
40 613 269 648 646 596 584 470 480 488 484 423 431
50 614 261 602 602 558 541 453 451 426 439 409 450
63 665 252 551 554 511 499 430 428 392 398 425 428
80 468 235 558 544 448 451 424 395 370 349 407 374
100 433 226 507 525 436 417 460 434 332 306 404 382
125 403 218 481 521 417 437 527 506 348 320 396 434
160 400 204 487 524 415 378 453 438 453 412 371 447
200 421 195 551 544 434 406 343 289 424 369 381 346
250 400 185 501 522 310 378 235 222 284 292 356 244
315 353 174 362 367 258 270 220 209 238 253 341 238
400 283 164 277 275 214 217 202 198 209 210 276 210
500 216 153 211 201 194 193 188 186 188 189 221 192
630 190 140 210 190 185 184 176 174 176 175 212 175Overall 792 570 924 923 844 845 765 784 798 804 751 759
[Table 1] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 1
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 47 -
Measured data - Lmax
point1 2 3 4 5 6
1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2nd 1st 2ndHz Lmax [dB]1 656 659 652 670 646 662 651 655 652 651 696 647
123 632 643 635 642 633 637 635 644 629 625 680 632
16 601 612 605 621 615 634 617 625 611 609 674 607
2 597 588 591 622 599 609 599 583 583 594 656 595
25 584 580 603 621 610 590 597 590 585 581 605 593
314 589 565 626 627 706 651 637 553 689 595 590 589
4 719 660 762 682 800 737 673 594 768 689 681 725
5 642 628 777 764 768 693 628 597 734 741 655 648
63 758 791 919 949 859 873 761 735 830 794 802 731
8 941 884 936 962 884 911 866 844 887 930 772 806
10 953 913 1022 1061 959 969 866 879 873 915 817 877
125 873 892 990 1014 919 956 838 826 856 890 795 793
16 831 835 997 997 883 848 779 795 820 820 749 740
20 809 781 934 933 802 785 772 789 795 764 698 692
25 777 714 888 903 746 747 688 663 718 720 654 619
315 752 707 818 871 742 707 607 619 644 644 581 557
40 776 629 732 757 674 670 528 551 577 580 527 517
50 735 675 694 709 613 606 511 539 508 518 506 533
63 698 671 647 672 639 610 535 500 462 482 525 496
80 632 587 685 670 538 633 561 596 432 434 569 516
100 607 565 612 693 525 579 710 690 423 402 601 591
125 561 556 576 731 523 575 817 789 539 476 572 652
160 551 564 700 663 515 571 782 731 625 551 571 685
200 602 549 623 682 528 610 671 561 590 499 519 502
250 521 464 568 673 394 543 431 348 404 423 486 500
315 453 366 444 516 319 398 286 246 304 466 419 425
400 404 315 342 410 274 284 234 216 237 366 347 367
500 330 243 256 337 225 219 204 204 215 277 283 259
630 287 205 279 272 238 218 187 184 189 226 304 199Overall 985 952 106 109 988 100 920 914 934 966 868 895
[Table 2] Noise and Vibration Measurement Result 2
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 48 -
43 Foundation Condition and Plan
1) Geotechnical Survey
Survey items Standard penetration test field permeability test field hydraulic
test down hole test basic physical property test uniaxial compression test
triaxial vibration test soil and water quality test
BH-1
BH-2
BH-4
BH-3
BH-5
BH-6NH-5NH-10
NH-11
NH-9NH-12
NH-4
NH
NH-7
NH-8
[Image 9] Geotechnical Survey Soil Test Location Diagram
[Image 10] Geological Condition Diagram 1
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 49 -
[Image 11] Geological Condition Diagram 2
borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth borehole depth
BH-1 -71 BH-6 -125 NH-1 -132 NH-6 -130
BH-2 -118 BH-7 -119 NH-2 -133 NH-7 -156
BH-3 -116 BH-8 -126 NH-3 -130 NH-8 -157
BH-4 -118 BH-9 -126 NH-4 -130 NH-9 -133
BH-5 -122 BH-10 -162 NH-5 -150 NH-10 -128
[Table 3] Underground Water Level (GL-m)
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 50 -
Depth and N-value
-20
-10
0
10
20
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
N-Value
Depth
(ELm
)
모래(SM)모래(SP)실트(ML)자갈(GP)풍화암
5030 5020 5010 500
Buried Layer 430 ~ 5027
Sedimentary Layer 730 ~ 502
Field Permeability Test Result Unit Weight
4
6
8
10
12
00E+00 50E-04 10E-03 15E-03 20E-03K (cmsec)
Dep
th (
ELm
)
모래(SM)
모래(SP)
자갈(GP)
-20
-15
-10
-5
25 26 27 28 29
Unit Weight (gr)D
ep
th (
ELm
)
연 암
경 암
Sand Base 1153E-03 ~ 8404E-04
Gravel Base 1159E-03 ~ 1882E-03
Soft Rock 2663 ~ 2765
Sound Rock 2714 ~ 2783
[Table 4] Geotechnical Survey Test Result Analysis
Stratum TypeUnit Weight
(tm3)
Internal Friction Angle
(deg)
Viscosity(tm2)
Coefficien of Subgrade Reaction
(tm3)
Buried Layer 1 18 24 0 1400
Buried Layer 2 18 28 0 1850
Sedimentary Layer 1 19 32 0 2300
Sedimentary Layer 2 20 34 0 2700
Sedimentary Layer 3 20 38 0 3200
Basement Rock 23 35 50 6000
[Table 5] Design Ground Calculation
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 51 -
2) Retaining Wall
For the construction of Nodeul Island the re-investigation of existing condition
including Safety Diagnosis of existing retaining wall should be proceed The
retaining wall repairreinforcement is required on the basis of the result of the
investigation For design phase retaining wall structure must be maintained but
proposing additional structure is acceptable
The results of lsquoHan River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in
2009 and lsquoEmergency Inspectionrsquo are listed as followings
Han River Art Island Construction Precision Safety Diagnosisrsquo in 2009 (Safety
Class Class E)
- The repairreinforcement for Upper retaining wall of Type A Section is
urgent
- There is no critical defect such as subsidence conduction basic erosion
of retaining wall detected
- Many defect items including deterioration partial damage crack and
efflorescence of overall facility due to long performance period was
detected
[Image 12] Existing Condition of Nodeul Island Retaining Wall (October 2009)
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 52 -
Facility Name Han River Art Island Retaining Wall
Evaluation Classification Retaining Wall Defection Level Rating
Condition Evaluation022(Internal Retaining Wall)
019(External Retaining Wall)Class B
Safety Evaluation A-Arsquo Section Upper Retaining Wall Class E
A-Arsquo Section Lower Retaining Wall Class A
B-Brsquo Section Class A
C-Crsquo Section Class A
Overall Evaluation Class E
Overall Evaluation Result Overall Retaining Wall Evaluation Result = Class E
[Table6] Overall Retaining Wall Precision Safety Diagnosis Evaluation Result October 200910
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 53 -
Existing Retaining Wall Condition Diagram
A-Type B-type
C-type D-type
[Image 13] Existing Retaining Wall Diagram per Types (October 2009)
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 54 -
Performed Emergency Inspection in 2012 (Safety Class Class C)
- Structural Problem is not found Minor defects on retaining wall framework
member No problem on safety
- Repairreinforcement on framework member is necessary to prevent decline
of durability and functionality
Name of Facility
Length (m) Height (m) Year of Construction
Nodeul
Island
Retaining
Wall
Type A 4000 89~94
1968 ~ 1973Type B 5470 50~62
Type C 7070 25
[Table 7] Retaining Wall Existing Condition Special Inspection Report 2012
[Image 14] Nodeul Island Retaining Wall Existing Condition 2012
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 55 -
Location and
Damage DetailMaintenance List
Sta 200~265m
Sta 325~408m
Horizontal crack on
front retaining wall
- Observation of load change within 40m on the back
of retaining wall and its maintenance
- Quality management on injection repair of crack
- Observation of additional crack and its maintenance
after the repair
Sta 325~408m
Sta 915~930m
Retaining wall
subsidence and tilt
- To maintain current condition needs the observation
of displacement or measurement procedure
through regular safety inspection
- To repair ultimately When progressive additional
displacement occursSta 915~930m
Bottom Slab Crack
Maintenance of
drainage on back of
the retaining wall
- Maintenance of drain and manhole (Sta 420~780m)
[Table 8]Maintenance List Special Inspection Report (Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
[Image 15] Maintenance Section Special Inspection Report
(Nodeul Island Retaining Wall) 2012
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 56 -
3) Site Condition
Upper east part of the island is hill land and lower west part of the island is
wetland
The topographical condition of Nodeul Island should be considered for
participants design proposals of spaces facility locations and circulation
[Image 16] Existing Topological Condition of Nodeul Island
[Image 17] Building Location Layout Example
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 57 -
4) Berth Facility
To design berth facility in order to provide easy access to Nodeul Island from
surrounding areas Because Nodeul Island is isolated from the surrounding
areas although located on the center of Seoul and Han River
To design a berth facility for Water Taxi and Han River Cruise on Southwest of
the island considering water level and water transportation route
Vessels smaller than 450ton shorter than 60m and with 300 or more
passengers should be able to park
Berth Facility should be accessible to important facilities of the island
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 58 -
44 Space Program proposed by Selected Operator
1) Band of Nodeul
The operator of Band of Nodeul which is a music activity led cultural complex
is Nodeul Island Operation Corporation that consists of 8 companies and the
operator proposed total 7 operating programs
Nodeul Culture
Project
Nodeul music
embracing sings
culture
Collaboration between music and cultural art on the
Nodeul Island as a background
Nodeul MusicMusic awakens
Nodel Island
Nodeul Island the music sharing base and music
place that artist and citizen creates together
Healing in
Nodeul Forest
Healing together
with Nodeul
becomes a festival
Phased Healing Strategy of Nodeul Forest and
biotope area with music and forest
Nodeul
Spreader
Nodeul connected
to the world
Nodeul New Media telling the story of Nodeul Island
and communicating with citizens
Nodeul Market
Nodeul Food
Staying in Nodeul
Island
Staying by Visiting
Food and entertainment for Nodeulian and New
Experiment for start-up merchants
Nodeul
Self-supproting
Island of
Energy
Nodeul Island
became a light
Birth of Nodeul self-supporting island of energy and
test-bed of enviro-friendly energy technology
Nodeul InitiativeNodeul a dream
begins at
Excavating new development model operating
model and revenue model though an experiment on
sustainable operation and expansion of the platform
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 59 -
2) Auditorium Requirements
To Install and operate 6 of 18m long 400H trusses at every 1m on which total 30
points (3x10) for stage lighting and hoist for sets are rigged
To utilize some of other points for sets and to use additional truss for the rest
of them
Total 9 points (3x3) for seats lighting hoist at 4m oc and rigging by 400H
truss catwalk is required for users to focus on W12m upper portion
Sound hoist for seats total 3 points minimum 1t on both sides minimum
500kg for center is required
Electricity(3phase 4wire) Sound amp Instrument 250A(separateness) Lighting
250A Video 200A Stage mechanics amp Spare 200A etc
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 60 -
Section
Area Guidelines()
Subdivision
Required Area()
Detailed Features and Required Area
1F 2F ETC
Seats 504
FOHConsole Room
240 180
- Seats Ceiling Height Min 12m- 1st floor Seats(for both Standing and Seats)
20mx15m(per Affective Width)- FOH Console middot Height Match Center of Stage
+400mm from +FF 0 of Seating Area middot Area At Finish Surface Maximum 27m Depth x
(82m+04m) Width(Required Width 82m = Sound 25m + other back up 09m + Lighting 21m + Effect 09m + Screen and back up 18m)
middot Construct in 1 or more than 2 tiers (in the case of 2 or more tiers each tier should be at least 36m depth) - 2nd Floor middot Height Tiers of seats 200mm risers from +FF 5m middot Construct in minimum 5 tiers design in round shape middot On plan drawing seats should be exposed
minimum 1m toward the center(sound equipment) of 1st floor FOH Console Stage
Balcony Seats
(Lighting)24
- Middle floor on both sides of Seats16m x 24m x 36m minimum 2 rooms each- lighting bar(dia 50 circle 2800m interval 3steps or more)
Air Handling Unit Room
24
Storage 2 36Storage for seats chair(stacking assembled(one bundle of 10 chairs) or folded total 500 chairs)
Stage 581
StageSide Stage
320 16mtimes(10m+1m) Proscenium (changeable in 6~8m)
Side Stage 192 One side to be connected to loading dock (outside)
Lighting Electrical
Room and
Storage
60
- Electrical Connector Room and Electrical Room Lighting Dimmer Room to be connected by gondola on the bottom of stage
- Located within 1m from 2nd Floor Seats Standard Height- It is recommended to be connected with the lobby on the
second floor
Stage Tech Room
- Locate on the opposite side of loading dock and upper portion of stage and connect to 2nd floor lobby or backside
- temporarily construct in box form after completion
Stage Directing
Room9 Locate on right side of the stage
Supporting
45
Storage 18 Instrument Storage
StageBack gondola
12- Connect to Lighting Electrical Room and Storage at the bottom of the stage- Weight 15t maximum (1t motor 2points or more)
Loading Area
15
- Match Stage FF for convenient transportation of instrument
- Install canopy or design as semi-open space to allow loadingunloading while raining
PublicSpace
670 Public Space
- Waiting room for performers restroom corridor- Ticket Booth for visitors restroom lobby and other spaces- Commercial Facilities- office (5 users) meeting room (10 users)
Total 1800
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 61 -
3) Participatory Design Approach Reference Cases
Participatory Design Approach is one of the upward urban development methods
and it is an open system which tenants finally completes the space by reflecting
their own personalities once architect creates a basic architectural platform
Through Participatory Design Approach tenants are encouraged to actively
participate in creating their own space so as to increase their responsibility for
creating the space and also to increase diversity of the exterior of facilities
Some of the cases that adopted Participatory Design Approach are listed below
NDSM (Amsterdam Netherlands) de dichterlijke vrijheid 07 (Rotterdam
Netherlands) and Participatory Design (Santiago Chile)
Amsterdam Netherland NDSM
Source Urban Transformer
- Eva de Klerk an artist as well as an initiative reused abandoned and polluted industrial heritage facility in NDSM and created lsquoCultural Art Incubatorrsquo Approximately 500 tenants from creativesocial enterprise and various cultural artists created the working spaces and developed cluster along with other tenants from similar fields
- Stad als Casco method was adopted to restore polluted area and create spaces on a budget In order to reduce supply cost administrator provided basic framework and infrastructure and tenants paid inexpensive rent and completed the space themselves This method allowed the users to have responsibility and attachment to the space sequently user-society and network naturally formed Also it created diverse spaces which reflected characteristics of each tenant
Rotterdam Netherland de dichterlijke vriheid 07
Source wwwfrankhanswijknl
- By renting residential block located in lagging region with serious criminal and cultural issues for 1 euro and recruiting people from various fields and classes it allowed people to involve in the rebuildingregenerating project Tenants created their spaces with their own funds and public space like courtyard was constructed through long discussion among tenants
- Various spaces which reflected each tenantrsquos demand and characteristics were created through this process and it also helped improving regional level by reducing local social problem and increasing property value
Santiago Chile Lo Barnechea Housing Project
Source wwwelementalchilecl
- In order to provide house and infrastructure for low income families with limited support fund only land infrastructure and half residential facility were provided to each family
- Within limited budget partial unit was designed and provided to each family and the rest was designed to be gradually fulfilled by themselves
- Elements that should be provided at first and elements to be filled by themselves according to future conditions and circumstances were decided through discussion with each family Limited budget and realistic conditions were fulfilled through user-centered approach and participatory design process
- Alejandro Aravena known for participatory design received 2016 Pritzker Architecture Prize for social participatory architecture
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 62 -
[Image 18] Existing Hub Condition of Adjacent Area
45 Existing Condition of Surrounding Area
1) Historical Culture Resource of Surrounding Area
Yongyangbongjeojung A pavilion that Jungjo (reigned 1776~1800) king of
Joseon Dynasty used for his rest while construction of pontoon bridge to cross
Han River when he visited Hyunryungwon of Hwasan Suwon where the grave
of his father Crown Prince Sado is located It has been designated as tangible
cultural properties 6 of Seoul
Sayuksin Historic Park This is a historic park located on a high hill in the middle
of Han River pedestrian bridge and Noryangjin Station This is a graveyard of
seven loyalist who defied to Sejo who usurped the throne from Danjong in
Joseon Dynasty Total area is 49401 and many citizens utilize it as community
park for resting as various landscape planting is planted It has been designated
as tangible cultural properties 8 of Seoul
2) Existing Condition of Adjacent Area
Many of park and important facilities are located near Nodeul Island which is a
in the middle of Han River
- Park Ichon Han River Park (Yongsan-gu) Yongbong Community Park
Nodeul Naru Park Sayuksin Historic Park
- Facilities Noryangjin Fish Market Material yard
Currently there are many ongoing related project plans such as nature
restoration of Han River and tourism resource business targeting adjacent
areas of Han River
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 63 -
46 History of Nodeul Island
Nodeul Island Before 20thCentury
18C his was a place where pontoon bridge
was constructed when Jeong-jo the
Great crossed the river to visit Hwasung
in Joseon Dynasty As it is shown on lsquoNeunghaeng Do of
Jeong-jo the Greatrsquo it was the location
where Jeon-jo the Great crossed the river
on top of pine-board paved bridge installed on
top of row of floating boats Even though
lsquoNoryang Temporary Palacersquo where Joen-jo
had rested after he crossed the river is
mostly disappeared a pavilion called
lsquoYongyangbongjeojeongrsquo meaning dragon romp
around and phoenix fly high still remains
19C Location labeled in lsquoSachonrsquo on Kyungjo
ohbudo (1861) of Kim Jung-ho is current
Nodeul Island
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 64 -
Nodeul Island Before Han River Development Plan
1912 Village lsquoSinchorirsquo
We assume the existence of the village by
old map drawn in 1912 The village was called
lsquoSinchorirsquo and most likely it was naturally
developed as large volume of people living
in-between the capital and Han River was not
encouraged in Joseon Dynasty
1917 Han River Pedestrian Bridge
This was the first pedestrian bridge for Han
River that the Japanese Government General
in Korea constructed in October 1917 When
they constructed the Han river pedestrian
bridge they mounded sand hill in oval shape
to support the bridge and named it as
lsquoJungjidorsquo
1936 Jungjido Minipark
They created mini park on oval shaped mound
and extended train line from Yongsan to
Jungjido Jungjido area was a popular dating
course for couples at that time
In50rsquos Summer Resort of Seoul
Until 50rsquos and 60rsquos people called the east
sand of the island as lsquoHan River Sandy Beachrsquo
and utilized as summer resort during summer
and as a skating rink during winter
In addition this island was overcrowded every
Armed Force Day to watch Air Show
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 65 -
Nodeul Island after Han River Development Master Plan
1968 Sandy beach is disappeared and current
Ichon-dong is createdIn order to construct Han River Embankment
Road (Current Gangbyeon Expressway) new
embankment is constructed on the outer side
of existing embankment along the Gyeongwon
line and infilled the gap of those two
embankments with sand from Han River Sandy
Beach As a result sandy beach is almost
disappeared and current Ichon-dong is
created
1973 Isand Reclamation Work
Nodeul Island which was less than 10000
pyeong (33058) was expanded to 45000
pyeong (148760) through island reclamation
work Also as they used sand from sandy
beach to reclaim the island the river ran
through the empty sandy beach and current
figure of Nodeul Island has formed
1973 Transferred the ownership to Chinhung
International Inc
1982 Shore Maintenance Project
Due to maintenance of low water channels as
part of shore maintenance project sand beach
disappeared and this island is surrounded by
Han River After that the total area of Nodeul
Island increased to 12000 and cement
waterfront has constructed around the island
1989 Transferred ownership to Kunyoung co ltd
1995 `Nodeul Island
Per governmentrsquos lsquoJapanese Style Place Name
Reinstatement Projectrsquo Jungjido is renamed as
lsquoNodeuleomrsquo This name came from old times
when people called the opposite side of
Yongsan as lsquoNodeul (or Nodol)rsquo and Han River
in front of it as Nodeul River According to
one view lexical semantic of lsquoNodeul (or
Nodol)rsquo means stepping stone where white
heron paddled and the name of Nodeul dock
has spread when they constructed the dock in
this location in the 14th year of Taejong
(1414)
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-
- 66 -
Han River Art Island Plan
2005 Construction of Nodeul Cultural Complex has decidedTransferred ownership to Seoul
2006 1st Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Jean Nouvel
2008 2nd Nominated Guest Design Competition
for Nodeul Art Center 1st Place Park Seung Hong
2009 Started Design Outsourcing on Han River Art Island Construction
2012 Han River Art Island Construction Project
has postponed Temporarily utilized it as
vegetable gardenThe project had postponed for long-term
until securing reasonable finances and forming
a social consensus
Rediscussion on Nodeul Island Utilization2013 Started Expert Opinion Survey Research
2013 Ran Nodeul Island Forum to establish basic principles on utilization
2014 Ran Participatory Program to form social consensus
Visit official Nodeulggunseom (Nodeul Dream Island) competition homepage or httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom for more details
Image source e-Nodeulseom (httpcitybuildseoulgokrenodeulseom)
- 노들섬 3차 지침서_영문 ver1(표지)
- 20160229_노들꿈섬 공간 시설조성 3차 공모 지침서_번역최종 통합pdf
-