the housatonic river cleanup...the housatonic river cleanup p.l. defur, ph.d. esc, llc forum...

20
The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBR September 17, 2013

Upload: others

Post on 25-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

The Housatonic River

Cleanup

P.L. deFur, Ph.D.

ESC, LLC

Forum sponsored by

Housatonic River Initiative

HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBR

September 17, 2013

Page 2: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Tonight

www.erh.noaa.gov www.clu-in.org

Homepages.cae.wisc.edu Restoration.doi.gov

www.wikipedia.com

Tonight

Page 3: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Lessons from Leaving PCBs /

Persistent Contaminants in place

Kepone, James River, VA

PCBs, Hudson River, NY

PBBs, Pine River, MI

Dioxins, Tittawabassee, MI

Page 4: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Continued Kepone Contamination

Green shading represents present Kepone fish consumption advisory

James River Basin

Page 5: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

The residents of Saginaw Co., MI live with the contamination left behind

Photo by P L deFur 2009

Photo by P L deFur 2009 www.fws.gov

www.fws.gov

Page 6: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Pine River, St. Louis MI, park in foreground,

Velsicol site across the river.

Photo P L deFur 2009

The original plan failed

Fish [chemicals] rose

Sediment removal

required

Coffer dam in middle of

river

PBBs, DDT, more than

12 other chemicals

Velsicol Chemical Site

St. Louis, MI

Page 7: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Photo P.L. deFur 2013

This landfill in Nassau, NY

contains PCB wastes from GE

that are leaking into the

groundwater

•1952 first waste

•1974 first cover

•1980 first remediation

Dewey Loeffel Landfill

Timesunion.com

Page 8: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

www.timesunion.com

Historic photo courtesy of the Fort Edward Historical Association: A B&W photo of the Fort

Edward dam during reconstruction in 1949.

When the Ft.

Edward dam on the

Hudson R. was

removed, acres of

PCB contaminated

sediment remained,

then capped but

continue to leach

into the Hudson R.

Page 9: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Lessons

MNR does not work

Capping is uncertain at best

Leach

Leak

Erosion

Animals and plants disrupt

Natural disasters

Expensive

Weku.fm

Weblogs.baltimoresun.com

Page 10: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Leaving contaminants

Forever is a long time

Maintenance

Inspections

5 year reviews

Fish sampling

Expensive- who will pay:

GE, EPA, NY state?

Robertarood.wordpress.com

Page 11: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Landfills

Rocky Mountain Arsenal on-site hazardous waste landfill

www.rma.arny.mil

Page 12: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Hill 78 disposal of PCB wastes in Pittsfield

http://www.epa.gov/region1/ge/thesite/opca-photos.html

Page 13: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Removal works

Spokane R WA

Fox R WI

Lake Champlain, NY

Milwaukee River

Waterplanet.ws

Spokane River

Page 14: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Before and following restoration in West Virginia www.dep.wv.gov

Lessons and experience from river and stream

restoration around the country and world

Repairing a River?

Page 15: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Fairfax Co. VA www.TVA.com

From Tennessee to Northern Virginia

Page 16: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Restoring shoreline and vegetation on the Hudson River post dredging –

photo by P.L. deFur 2011

Page 17: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

www.threeforksranch.com

www.parsonshurdles.co.uk

Efforts around the

nation and the world

under many conditions

provide a wealth of

information and tools.

Page 18: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

New tools and methods

Biological

Bacteria

Bio Tech

Activated carbon

Phytoremediation

Washing, chemical oxidation

News-service.stanford.edu

Rydberg.biology.colostate.edu

Page 19: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Resources

http://www.doi.gov/restoration/index.cfm

http://www.erdc.usace.army.mil/

http://water.epa.gov/type/wetlands/restore/ind

ex.cfm

http://www.habitat.noaa.gov/

http://www.ser.org/ Soc. for Ecol. Restoration

Page 20: The Housatonic River Cleanup...The Housatonic River Cleanup P.L. deFur, Ph.D. ESC, LLC Forum sponsored by Housatonic River Initiative HEAL, BEAT, B-L EC, HVA, Stop Dumps, BNRC, CitizensfPCBRLessons

Questions?