the fourth international gas chromatography symposium
TRANSCRIPT
ANALYTICAL C H E M I S T R Y
The Fourth International Gas Chromatography Symposium Hamburg, G e r m a n y — A 10-Year Anniversary
by Richard S. Juvet, Jr. Department of Chemistry, and Chemical Engineering University of Illinois, Urbana, Ill.
TEN YEARS AGO in 1952, A. T. James and A. J . P . Mar t in published a
paper entitled, "Gas-Liquid Part i t ion Chromatography." This paper was destined to initiate one of the most actively investigated areas of analytical chemistry and to influence the research of scientists in all fields of chemistry. The Four th International Gas Chromatography Symposium, marking the tenth anniversary of this impor tant discovery, was held June 13-16 in the beautiful new Auditorium Maximum of Hamburg State University. This is the newest University in t h e German Federal Republic and is situated in the largest industrial city in Federal Germany. The symposium at t racted 694 registrants, an increase in a t tendance of 24 per cent over the previous International Symposium. Of these, 326 were from Germany and the Netherlands, 154 from Great Britain, 32 from the United States, and 14 from the Soviet bloc. F o u r registrants came from as far away as Australia.
T h e symposium was organized by the Analytical Chemical Division of the Gesellschaft Deutscher Chemiker and the Gas Chromatography Discussion Group under the auspices of the Hydrocarbon Research Group of the British Ins t i tu te of Petroleum. Previous European symposia have been held in London (1956), Amsterdam (1958), and Edinburgh (1960).
Welcoming addresses were presented by Dr . H. Kienitz, Chairman of the Analytical Chemistry Division of the Gesellschaft Deutscher Chemiker; Dr . W. Drexelius, representative of the Senate of the City of H a m b u r g ; and Dr . R . Sieverts, Rector of Hamburg State University. Following these addresses, opening lectures were presented b y early workers in the field of chromatography, R. Kuhn , A. J . P . Mar t in , and A. "V. Kiselev. K u h n discussed the development of a separation process; Mar t in , in keeping wi th his reputat ion as a prophet of future developments, discussed future possibilities in microanalysis and pointed out the
Dr. A. J. P. Martin, Nobel Prize winner for his discovery of partit ion chromatography, is shown speak ing on futu re possibil i t ies in microanalysis a t t he 4 th International Gas Chromatography Symposium
need to develop micro hands and other micro instrumentation to handle the micro samples with which chemists of the future may be called upon to deal ; and Kiselev reviewed some adsorption studies, most of which had been carried out in Russia.
One day each was devoted to sessions on Theory, Appara tus and Technique, and Applications. Th i r ty minutes were allowed each paper for presentation and discussion. The 30 papers were ap proximately evenly distributed between the German and English languages. English prepr ints were mailed to all registrants prior to the symposium allowing t ime for preparat ion of considered contributions to the discussion; however, spontaneous contributions were also encouraged. An hour-long panel discussion, opened by two short introductions, was also presented each afternoon. These included sessions on qualitative and quant i ta t ive aspects of GC and preparative-scale GC. Both the regular sessions and t h e panel discussions will appear in the "Proceedings," of the H a m b u r g Symposium to be published by the end of this year.
Several informal discussions of 1 to 2 hours duration were organized to run concurrently with the regular scheduled sessions. Although these discussions will not appear in the Symposium Pro ceedings, the free exchange of ideas given at these sessions was often particularly valuable. Informal discussions were scheduled on trace analysis, inorganic analysis including transit ion metal halides, programmed temperature GC, theory, flavor and essential oil analysis, the design and operation of detectors, and capillary column technology.
Theory The session on theory was opened by
K h a n who presented a nonequilibrium theory of capillary columns and derived an equation for H E T P having identical form to the - Golay equation b u t including an additional te rm accounting for interfacial resistance, thus eliminating the restriction assuming dynamic equilibrium at all points within the column.
Several papers on adsorption chromatography and the measurement of heats of adsorption and adsorption isotherms were presented. Petrova, Khrapova and Shcherbakova reported a s tudy of physico-chemical adsorption characteristics b y G C methods. T h e rapidity with which heats of adsorption can be measured b y G C compared wi th the classical calorimetric method was emphasized. Huber and Keulemans compared the theoretical separating efficiency of gas solid and gas liquid chromatography in a paper- on nonlinear ideal chromatography and the potentialities of linear gas solid chromatography. Adsorption isotherms were constructed directly from chroma-tograms obtained with adsorption columns demonstrating the validity of the theory developed. C. G. Scott measured the heats and s tandard entropies of adsorption for η-heptane, iso-octane, cyclohexane, and benzene on alumina modified b y heating a t elevated temperatures with u p to 40 weight per cent sodium hydroxide. The alumina-sodium hydroxide mixture, when used as a column packing material , gave symmetrical peaks for hydrocarbon
NEWS
VOL. 34, NO. 10, SEPTEMBER 1962 · 7 7 A
AUTOMATIC KARL FISCHER *
MOISTURE D E T E R M I N A T I O N The Karl Fischer method is now run on Technicon Auto Analyzer... Continuous / Automatic. Applicable wherever Karl Fischer reagent is used. In the plant... AutoAnalyzer monitors and continuously controls moisture in process streams. In the laboratory... AutoAnalyzer provides up to 40 determinations an hour automatically.
Technicon® AutoAnalyzer® measures many other substances as well. Send for your free methodology literature kit KF2.
T E C H N I C O N C O N T R O L S , I N C . R E S E A R C H P A R K · C H A U Ν C Ε Υ, Ν . Y.
Circle No. 194 on Readers' Service Card
No sur face p r o t e c t i o n n e e d e d
for 75 years the only permanently satisfactory material
for chemical laboratory table tops , shelving, sinks, splash backs, drain boards and fume hoods. Prompt delivery. ALBERENE STONE-A DIVISION OF THE GEORGIA M A R B L E COMPANY. For FREE l i t e r a t u r e a n d t e c h n i c a l a s s i s t a n c e a d d r e s s : THE ALBERMAR COMPANY, 386 PARK AVE. SOUTH, NEW YORK 16, N. Y., DEPT. C
Circle No. 1 on Readers' Service Card
NEWS
Main e n t r a n c e t o t h e Aud i to r ium M a x i m u m , H a m b u r g S t a t e Univers i ty
solutes. Partition and adsorption of these hydrocarbon solutes on a benzo-phenone-Celite column above and below the melting point of the benzo-phenone was also studied. Vast differences were observed not only in retention volume, but also in elution order over small temperature changes near the melting point of the stationary phase.
Desty, Swanton, and coworkers reported that variations of solute retention with choice of carrier gas and column pressure are accounted for by changes in gas phase imperfections. Retention of a hydrocarbon solute on a particular stationary phase maintaining a constant column temperature and average column pressure decreases with carrier gas in the order helium, hydrogen, nitrogen, argon, oxygen, carbon monoxide, and carbon dioxide.
The application of capillary columns for the accurate measurement of specific retention volumes and certain other fundamental thermodynamic quantities was compared by Adlard, Khan, and Whitham with similar measurements carried out on packed columns. It was found that a reproducibility of about ± 1 % was obtained for retention volumes, similar to results found for packed columns. It was pointed out that in certain respects capillary colums are more convenient for retention volume measurements.
Freeguard and Stock discussed the advantages and disadvantages of a static method for measurement of activity coefficient data at infinite dilution and made measurements with a Mc-Bain-type balance for comparison with gas chromatographic data. Studies of the partition isotherm and the effect of mixtures of liquid phases on the absorption of solute vapors were also reported.
first cost is last cost
ALBERENE STONE
7 8 A · ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY
NEWS
Rotzsche prepared a series of cyano-alkyl substituted silicone oils and showed that the polarity, and hence the selectivity of these oils, could be changed by varying the number of ni-trile groups in the molecule.
Apparatus and Technique
An integrator making use of an analog digital converter coupled to the detector and the errors found for this arrangement were described by Kelker, Rohleder, and Weber.
Golay, Ettre, and Norem presented a theoretical treatment for a programmed temperature gas chromatographic system operated at constant inlet and outlet pressures as well as a nomographic solution for certain problems involved. Subambient programmed temperature techniques were discussed by Baumann, Klaver, and Johnson. An instrument useful from - 7 5 ° to +400° C. was described. Of the several liquid phases studied for application over wide temperature ranges, the nonpolar phase, silicone oil SF 96 (50) and polar phase, nitrile silicone fluid XF-1112 [both General Electric Co., Willoughby, Ohio], were found most useful at reduced temperatures of —40° C. or below and yet were also useful at temperatures of 200° C. or above. Procedures for applying pressure drop corrections in PTGC were evaluated and the calculation of retention temperature from isothermal data was illustrated.
The performance of small diameter (1.5 mm.) columns packed with 3-6% hexanedione on 75- to 85-mesh firebrick and operated at high inlet pressures (up to 200 lb./sq. in.) was described by Amos and Hurrell. The columns prepared had efficiencies of the order of 1000 plates per meter. Sample size for a C3-C5 hydrocarbon blend was restricted to less than 0.5 μΐ. to prevent overloading the column.
The application of a catalytic combustion cell as a sensitive detector was suggested in a paper prepared by Schay, Székely, and Traply. These authors point out that the sensitivity of a katharometer cell should be increased several orders of magnitude by running the cell at such a temperature that combustion takes place and advantage may be taken of the heat of combustion rather than simply the conductivity of the gas mixture. The cell was a 10-cm. glass capillary of 0.18 ml. volume containing an axial mounted platinum wire, 50 μ in diameter. When the wire was treated so that a catalytic coating was produced, a temperature of 200° in the presence of air as carrier gas was suf-
RADIATION INSTRUMENTS AND DETECTORS Liquid Scintillation Paper
Chromatographic Scanner Density/Moisture Analyzers Transistorized Scalers Ratemeters 4TT Counter X-ray Proportional Counter Single Channel Spectrometer Laboratory Petroleum Sulfur Analyzer Portable Fast Neutron Monitor High Pressure Ion Chambers Area Radiation Monitoring Systems Personal Radiation Monitor Semi Conductor Nuclear Particle Detectors
NBCLEONIC PROCESS CONTROL EQUIPMENT Fixed Level Detector Systems Varying Level Detector Systems Density Analyzer Systems On-stream Petroleum Sulfur Analyzer Density/Moisture Gtfuges
RADIOACTIVE SOURCES AND COMPOUNDS Sealed Industrial Sources Research Sources Carbon-14, Tritium, Sulfur-35
Labelled Compounds
SHIELDING Isotope Shipping Casks Lead Disposal and Handling Containers Custom Lead Products Lead Bricks
SMALL PARTICLE SURFACE AREA APPARATUS All Metal Flow-type System All Metal Semi automatic B.E.T! System
ELECTROCHEMICAL ANALYTICAL INSTRUMENTS Controlled-Potential Coulometric
Titrator (ORNL design) Controlled-Potential and Derivative
Polarograph (ORNL design)
EDUCATIONAL MASS SPECTROMETI
LOW VOLTAGE TRANSISTORIZED REGULATED POWER SUPPLIES
Apollo. Pennsylvania GRover 2-8411
NUMEC Instruments and Controls Corporation
Numinco Circle No. 205 on Readers' Service Card
VOL. 34, NO. 10, SEPTEMBER 1962 · 7 9 A
Ins t rument exhibition in the Lobby of the Auditorium Maximum, Hamburg State University
MINI MONITOR THE ECONOMY TOOL
FOR ULTRA-VIOLET ANALYSIS OF COLUMN EFFLUENT
A great new labor-saver!
Watches and records UV absorption of column effluent before the fraction collector, producing absorption peaks on a strip chart to tell you which fraction tubes contain material of interest.
Entire instrument, including recorder, is self-contained in one cabinet only 7" cubed and weighing only 10 pounds. Mounts directly on the stand of any fraction collector. % T recording; 254 mu peak radiation; event m a r k e r t o r e c o r d f r a c t i o n changes; range expander for sensitivity adjustment. For use with proteins, nucleic acids, or other materials having reasonable absorption at 254 mu.
ORDER NOW FOR IMMEDIATE
DELIVERY... ONLY $ 7 9 0 f.o.b. Bethesda, Md.
C A N A L C O
CANAL INDUSTRIAL CORP. DepL A-J 4935 Cordell Avenue
Bethesda 14. Maryland
NEWS
ficient for the combustion of even the slowest burning compounds. The sensitivity of detection was 12.5 mv. ju.gr1
seer1 for amyl alcohol and was proportional to the heat of combustion of the solute.
The combination of a conventional mass spectrometer with a gas chroma-tograph was shown to be useful for the identification of 37 components in a gasoline cut by Henneberg and Schom-burg. The application of characteristic masses for class identification, such as mass 91 for alkylbenzenes, was reviewed.
Jentzsch and Hôvermann, in a study of relatively large diameter (0.5 mm. i.d., 100 m. long), coated capillary columns, showed that samples as large as 50 jul. could be injected, allowing the use of thermal conductivity detectors and eliminating the need for sample splitters. Two methods for reducing tailing in capillary columns were suggested: (1) coating the capillary with an inert, temperature-stable "intermediate phase" such as silicone rubber SE-52 [General Electric Co.] prior to application of the stationary phase and (2) the addition of a corrosion inhibitor such as "Alkaterge T," as originally proposed by Averill at the 1961 Michigan State Symposium.
The hydrogen isotopes and nuclear spin isomers, ortho- and parahydrogen, ortho- and paradeuterium and hydrogen deuteride were completely separated by Mohnke and Saffert by adsorption chromatography using capillary columns operated at 77.6° K. A 20 μ thick adsorptive layer on the inner wall of a glass capillary 80 m. in length
was prepared by etching the sealed capillary with a 17% aqueous ammonia solution at 170° for 70 hours. Neon was used as carrier gas.
Schulz presented a quantitative discussion of the continuous countercur-rent separation of a number of binary mixtures. A feed mixture of isobutene (b.p., —6.9°) and n-butene-1 (b.p., —6.26°) was separated, with both components being reclaimed in greater than 99% purity, by continuous feeding of the mixture into the center of the column while allowing a sorption material of silver nitrate in benzyl cyanide on Sterchamol to move in a countercurrent direction to the carrier gas flow.
Kaiser and Kienitz pointed out that gas chromatographic equipment could pay for itself within a period of 10 days to 1 month when used under the right conditions in process control systems. The application of a process control unit to distillation problems was reviewed.
Applications
T. R. Phillips and D. Neylan presented a statistical study of factors affecting column performance in the separation of halogen and interhalogen compounds on Kel-F oils. One observation, not in accordance with established theory, was that a liquid phase loading of 20% Kel-F oil on Kel-F Grade 300 molding powder gave better column performance with 50-70 mesh particles than with finer size particles while a high loading of 80% gave better
Circle No. 152 on Readers' Service Card
8 0 A · ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY
NEWS
performance on finer particles of 70-to 80-mesh. The authors explained this result by pointing out that the support was chemically similar to the liquid phase in these experiments and cannot be regarded as inert.
A method for the determination of separation factors from unresolved two-component peaks was developed by Sideman and Giladi. A study of nitrogen isotope enrichment was used as an application of this method. A separation factor of 1.0011 for a 28/29 nitrogen isotope mass ratio obtained experimentally was in good agreement with the value 1.0007 calculated from vapor pressure measurements.
A detailed description of a GC apparatus useful for the qualitative and quantitative analysis of microgram amounts of flavor volatiles from edible fats was given by Swoboda. Individual peaks were identified with the aid of Kovats' retention index method and the determination of the carbon skeleton by catalytic reduction of the component to its corresponding hydrocarbon followed by GC identification of the product formed.
Schomburg reviewed the chemistry of boron alkyls and hydrides and demonstrated the value of GC for determining equilibrium concentrations of products formed in the transalkylation of boron alkyls, boracyclanes, and bis-borolanes.
Grant and Vaughan prepared tri-methyl silyl ethers of phenols with hexamethyldisilazane for the separation of complex phenolic mixtures. Glass capillary columns coated with silicone oil MS 550 [Midland Silicones Ltd.] gave well defined symmetrical bands for silylated phenols, cresols, and xylenols boiling in the range 190-300° C.
The analysis of millimicroliter quantities of the permanent gases hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, argon, methane, carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, krypton, xenon, and neon was described by Berry. An ionization detector with high purity helium used as carrier gas was employed [metastable (23S) helium atoms, 19.8 eV energy]. The limit of detection ranged from 5 X 10~8
to 5 Χ 10-7 cc. of the permanent gases. A method for adequately purifying the helium carrier gas and the variation of detector signal with flow rate, gas pressure, and detector temperature were discussed in detail.
Trace analysis of hydrocarbons (up to Ce) was performed by Huyten, Rijnders and van Beersum on alumina columns containing ca. 2% water. Apparatus was described which is useful for direct quantitative analysis in concentrations down to ca. 0.003 p.p.m.
Pt STANDARD LAB APPARATUS: a complete line of quality ware
SPECIAL LAB EQUIPMENT . send us your specifications
CHEMICALS: over 40 salts, solutions, powders in stock
Whatever your need for platinum, take advantage of BISHOP'S long experience (since 1842) and complete facilities for the fabrication, refining and recovery of the platinum group metals.
And don't forget that your used lab ware and other platinum material has a high scrap value toward the purchase of new products.
Send for our catalog PLATINUM M E T A L S PRODUCTS N O . P-6.
BISHOP J . B I S H O P & C O . platinum works
M A L V E R N , P E N N S Y L V A N I A A J O H N S O N M A T T H E Y A S S O C I A T E
Circle No. 51 on Readers' Service Card
for the lab
HMWJ* METMS wwooers
VOL. 34, NO. 10, SEPTEMBER 1962 · 81 A
NEWS
CALENDAR OF EVENTS Aug. 29 to Sept. 5
Fifth International Congress for Electron Microscopy, Philadelphia, Pa. Host: Electron Microscope Society of America. Contact: Fifth International Congress for Electron Microscopy, 7701 Burholme Ave., Philadelphia 11, Pa. Page 50 A, Nov.
Sept. 5 to 7
Symposium on Measurement of Thermal Radiation of Solids. Biltmore Hotel, Dayton, Ohio. Sponsors: U. S. Air Force, National Bureau of Standards, National Aeronautics and Space Administration. Contact: C. R. Andrews, University of Dayton, Dayton 9, Ohio. Page 53 A, June.
Sept. 9 to 14
American Chemical Society, 142nd National Meeting, Atlantic City. N . J . Page 39 A, Aug.
Sept. 10 to 15
International Symposium on Molecular Structure and Spectroscopy, Tokyo, Japan. Sponsor: International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry and Science Council of Japan. Contact : Secretary, International Symposium on Molecular Structure and Spectroscopy, Science Council of Japan, Ueno Park, Tokyo, Japan. Page 105 A, Feb.
Sept. 16 to 20
Second Annual Conference on Pharmaceutical Analysis, Kings Gateway, Land O'Lakes, Wis. Contact: R. S. Strommen, University of Wisconsin, Madison 6, Wis.
Sept. 16 to 22
Eighth Latin American Congress of Chemistry, Buenos Aires. Contact: Secretaria, Octavo Congreso Latino-Americano de Quimica, Casilla Correo 2153, Buenos Aires, Argentina. Page 105 A, Feb.
Sept. 17 to 19
Sept. 26 to 28
Ninth Ottawa Symposium on Applied Spectroscopy, Ottawa, Canada. Sponsor: Canadian Association for Applied Spectroscopy. Contact: Ben Farrar, J . T. Donald & Co., Ltd., 1181 Guy St., Montreal 25, Quebec. Page 63 A, March.
Practice of Gas Chromatography. Michigan State University. Sponsors: ASTM Committee E-19 and Michigan State University. Contact: Nathaniel Brenner, The Perkin-Elmer Corp., Norwalk, Conn. Page 46 A, April.
Drawert reviewed several applications of chemical reactors positioned just ahead of the chromatographic column. The analysis of the lower fatty acids in the stomach of Colo-binae monkeys was carried out· by esterification with methanol/boron tri-fluoride reagent. The esterified fraction was then injected directly into a calcium hydride reactor for removal of water and acids without need for prior isolation of the esters. C14-labeled alcohols in aqueous solution were analyzed by dehydration to C14-olefins in an appropriate chemical reactor and detection of the olefins at the column outlet with proportional counting equipment.
The partial thermal decomposition and cracking patterns of some 23 hydrocarbons up to C10 were studied by Keulemans and Perry. For controlled decomposition the sample was exposed for 20 sec. to temperatures of approximately 500° C , and quantitative measurements of the decomposition products were made. Stability to thermal decomposition decreases in the order: double bonds, single bonds adjacent to
double bonds, single bonds. The reproducibility of cracking pattern and the influence of cracking temperature and sample size were briefly discussed.
The symposium was adjourned following closing addresses by W. W. Brandt and C. S. G. Phillips. Although some were heard to say that much of the work presented at this symposium represented important improvements of existing technology rather than major new developments or breakthroughs, still interest remains high as judged by continually increasing attendance. Gas chromatography will undoubtedly maintain a leading position in the interest of analytical chemists for many years to come.
X-Ray School
The 43rd Norelco X-Ray Analytical School will be held at the Sir Francis Drake Hotel, San Francisco, during the week of September 10-14, 1962. Write to: Philips Electronic Instruments, 750 South Fulton Ave., Mount Vernon, Ν. Υ.
HOW IWfflffillll
DIETERT-DETROIT ( B A H C 0 )
MICRO-PARTICLE CLASSIFIER
4principal uses are: Π CLASSIFYING laboratory quantities of fine
materials for product or new material research.
Q CONTROLLING industrial processes using or producing fine materials.
0 DETERMINING the separating efficiency of air cleaners.
E l PRE-TESTING dust collector requirements.
DETERMINE PARTICLE SIZE DISTRIBUTION below 60 microns, in materials such as: Beryllium Powder Grinding Sand Catalysts Metal Oxides Ceramic Powders Penicillin Chemicals Polymers Diatomaceous Earth Powdered Metals Drugs Milk Solids Dry Powders Standard Dust Fly Ash Samples
HARRY W. DIETERT CO. CONTROL EQUIPMENT
9330 R o s e l a w n · D e t r o i t 4, M i c h .
Send me details on Micro-Particle Classifier
Name ,
Address
Company
City State
Circle Να. 63 on Readers' Service Card
8 2 A · ANALYTICAL CHEMISTRY