8/2/2019 Technology Innovations, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., C.A. No. 11-690-SLR

1/7

HFZKM ]FHZMJ UZBZMU JHUZPHEZ EO]PZ

LOP ZKM JHUZPHEZ OL JMABWBPM

ZMEKFOAOGX HFFO\BZHOFU! AAE! ((

Tabhfzhll! ((

|& ( Eh|& Fo& 22)

2& @becgpo}fj& Of B}g}uz ;! 0422! Zmekfoaogx Hffo|bzhofu! AAE +"tabhfzhll'(

lhamj zkm tpmumfz tbzmfz hflphfgmimfz ahzhgbzhof bgbhfuz Bib~of&eoi! Hfe& +"jmlmfjbfz"(&

+J&H&2( Tabhfzhll baamgmu hflphfgmimfzol zwo tbzmfzu> ]&U& Tbzmfz Fou& =!=27!:47 +"zkm

':47 tbzmfz"( bfj 7!:08!8

8/2/2019 Technology Innovations, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., C.A. No. 11-690-SLR

2/7

Tpoemj}pm 20+` +

8/2/2019 Technology Innovations, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., C.A. No. 11-690-SLR

3/7

LHG)2

5& Uzbfjbpju& Hf pm|hmwhfg b iozhof zo jhuihuu lhamj }f jmp Lmj& P& Eh|& T&

20+` +

8/2/2019 Technology Innovations, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., C.A. No. 11-690-SLR

4/7

m{tmphmfem bfj eoiiof umfum&" +"j&(

:& Bz zkm tambjhfg uzbgm hf b tbzmfz ebum! zkm hflopibzhof pmr}hpmj `x Lopi 2;

kbu `mmf jmmimj bjmr}bzm fozhem zo tbuu i}uzmp }fjmp P}am ;& Umm Ie^mba |& Utphfz

Fm{zma Eopt&!=42 L&5j 25=:! 25=7 +Lmj& Ehp& 0447(& Hf zkhu pmgbpj! Lopi 2; pmr}hpmu

zkbz zkm loaaowhfg hflopibzhof `m tpo|hjmj hf b eoitabhfz lop jhpmez hflphfgmimfz> +2( bf

baamgbzhofol n}phujhezhof3 +0( b uzbzmimfz zkbz tabhfzhll owfu mbek tbzmfz bz huu}m bfj!

lop mbek u}ek tbzmfz! hzu f}i`mp! jbzm ol huu}bfem! bfj zkm gmfmpba hf|mfzhof jmueph`mj

zkmpmhf3 +5( lop mbek jmlmfjbfz bee}umj ol hflphfgmimfz! hjmfzhlhebzhofol zkm bee}umj

tpoj}ez! tpoemuu op imzkoj2

"zkbz mi`ojShmuY zkm tbzmfzmj hf|mfzhof3" bfj +:( b

jmibfj lop pmahml! hfea}jhfg hfn}fezh|m pmahml bfj/op bf beeo}fzhfg lop jbibgmu&

=& Jhue}uuhof& Jmlmfjbfz ekbpbezmph~mu zkm huu}mhf zkhu ebum bu "wkmzkmp b

Chfjam m)pmbjmp0 hu b `ooc! bu ofm ol opjhfbpx uchaahf zkm bpz wo}aj }fjmpuzbfj zkbz zmpi

hf zkm ':47 tbzmfz&" +J&H&; bz 5( Jmlmfjbfz bpg}mu zkbz zkmpm hu fo touuh`am

eofuzp}ezhof lop "`ooc" zkbz wo}aj eo|mp b Chfjam bfj! zkmpmlopm! eabhi eofuzp}ezhof

tpoemmjhfgu bpm foz fmemuubpx bfj zkm ':47 tbzmfz uko}aj `m jhuihuumj lpoi zkm ebum&

+/j&(

8/2/2019 Technology Innovations, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., C.A. No. 11-690-SLR

5/7

mamezpofhebaax&&&}u}baax uibaa kbfj kmaj eoit}zmpu cfowf bu mamezpofhe `oocu&" +J&H&

2 bz 2N00( Tabhfzhll bpg}mu zkbz zkm zmpi "tphfzmj wopc"hf zkm ':47 utmehlhebzhof hu "b

wopc ol bfx eoflhg}pbzhof hf wkhek hflopibzhof hu tpmumfzmj lop jhpmez k}ibf

tmpemtzhof!" bfj zkm zmpi "`ooc" mfeoitbuumu "foz ofax eof|mfzhofba `oocu! `}z ozkmp

lopiu ol tphfzmj hflopibzhof&" +/j&bz 2N2a0=! 0

Hfu}pbfem Eo&! Eh|& Fo& 24)2574! 0424 WA :Zkm eo}pz ibx bjjpmuu whzk zkm tbpzhmu bf mbpax eabhi eofuzp}ezhof ol jhutouhzh|m

ahihzbzhofu ofem b l}aa bfj lbhp m{ekbfgm ol l}fjbimfzba joe}imfzu kbu `mmf

beeoitahukmj& +Umm zkm eo}pz'u "Jmlb}az Uzbfjbpj lop Jhueo|mpx! Hfea}jhfg Jhueo|mpx ol

Mamezpofhebaax Uzopmj Hflopibzhof +"MUH"(!"2N:(&

;& Zkm eo}pz eofea}jmu zkbz jhuihuuhfg zkm eoitabhfz of zkm gpo}fju zkbz hz lbhau

zo uzbzm b eabhi lop jhpmez hflphfgmimfz wo}aj `m tpmibz}pm& Tabhfzhll kbu tamj bjmr}bzm

fozhem lop jhpmez hflphfgmimfz pmr}hpmj `x Lopi 2;& Umm Ie^mba! =42 L&5j bz 25=7& Zkm

eoitabhfz tpo|hjmu bf baamgbzhof ol n}phujhezhof& +J&H& 2 bz2N=( Tabhfzhll uzbzmu zkbz hz

owfu zkm ':47 tbzmfz! ahuzu zkm tbzmfz f}i`mp! jbzm ol huu}bfem! bfj `phmlax jmueph`mu

zkm hf|mfzhof& +/j& bz 2N2N7! 8! 22! 20( Tabhfzhll jmueph`mu hf jmzbha jmlmfjbfz'u tpoj}ezu

:

8/2/2019 Technology Innovations, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., C.A. No. 11-690-SLR

6/7

zkbz hflphfgm zkm ':47 tbzmfz bfj kbu jmibfjmj pmahml hf zkm lopi ol jbibgmu bjmr}bzm

zo eoitmfubzm lop zkm hflphfgmimfz& +/j& bz 2N2N08! 50! 55! ::( Hf ahgkzol zkm b`o|m!

tabhfzhll'u eoitabhfz tbuumu i}uzmp }fjmp P}am ;&

8& Iozhof lop ubfezhofu& P}am 22 ol zkm Lmjmpba P}amuol Eh|ha Tpoemj}pm

baaowu b eo}pz zo ubfezhof b tbpzx op bzzopfmxu }fjmp ahihzmj ehpe}iuzbfemu& B eo}pz ebf

bwbpj ubfezhofu hl b tbpzx op bzzopfmx kbu tpmumfzmj b iozhof lop bf "hitpotmp

t}ptoum!" zkm eabhiu op jmlmfumu t}z lopzk hf b iozhof bpm lph|oao}u! zkm eabhiu hf b

iozhof bpm foz ahcmax zo `m u}ttopzmj `x zkm m|hjmfem blzmp hf|muzhgbzhof! op b tbpzx

wpofgl}aax jmfhmu b lbez}ba baamgbzhof&@powf |& afzmp`bx L}fjhfg! AAE! Eh|& Fo& 4:)

22 +`(&

24& Jmlmfjbfz io|mu lop ubfezhofu of zkm `buhu zkbz zkmpm hu fo touuh`hahzx ol

hflphfgmimfz ol zkm ':47 tbzmfz `x zkm Chfjam! mhzkmp ahzmpbaaxop }fjmp zkm joezphfm ol

mr}h|bamfzu& +J&H& 2= bz =( Zkm eo}pz jmeahfmu zo bwbpj ubfezhofu bz zkhu uzbgmol zkm

tpoemmjhfgu! hf ahgkzol zkm eo}pz'u lhfjhfgu zkbz tabhfzhll kbu tpotmpax tamj baamgbzhofu lop

jhpmez hflphfgmimfz& Kowm|mp! bu hz bttmbpu lpoi b tabhf pmbjhfg ol zkm ':47 tbzmfz zkbz

b imiopx jm|hem "bzzbekmj zo b `ooc" op "tphfzmj ibzmphba" hu eabhimj! 5 zkm eo}pz whaa

mfzmpzbhf b pmfmwmj iozhof hl hz hu abzmp jmzmpihfmj! blzmp jhueo|mpx bfj b l}aa eabhi

eofuzp}ezhof pmeopj! zkbz tabhfzhll'u buumpzhofol zkm ':47 tbzmfz bgbhfuz jmlmfjbfz'u

tpoj}ezu wbu uo abechfg hf imphz zkbz zkm hitouhzhof ol ubfezhofu hu wbppbfzmj&

22& Eofea}uhof& Lop zkm blopmimfzhofmj pmbuofu! jmlmfjbfz'u iozhofu bpm

5 Bfx ekbpbezmph~bzhofu ol zkm ':47 tbzmfz jhue}uumj b`o|m ukbaa foz `m `hfjhfg|hu)b)|hu zkm eabhi eofuzp}ezhof tkbum ol zkhu ebum&

=

8/2/2019 Technology Innovations, LLC v. Amazon.com, Inc., C.A. No. 11-690-SLR

7/7

jmfhmj whzko}z tpmn}jhem&

]fhzmj Uz u J2uzfez N}jgm