taking the idea of constitutional “meaning” seriously - taking the idea of constitutional...
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
1/15
ĦǺŘVǺŘĐ ĿǺẄ ŘĚVİĚ Ẅ FǾŘŲM
Ť ǻ ķ į ň ģ ť ħ ě İ đ ě ǻ ǿ f
Č ǿ ň ș ť į ť ų ť į ǿ ň ǻ ŀ “ M ě ǻ ň į ň ģ ”
Ș ě ř į ǿ ų ș ŀ ỳ
Ř ě ș p ǿ ň ș ě b ỳ Ř į č ħ ǻ ř đ Ħ . F ǻ ŀ ŀ ǿ ň
ŇǾV 10, 2015
129 Ħǻřv. Ŀ. Řěv. F. 1
Đ
1
1. Đǻvįđ Ǻ. Șțřǻųșș, Țħě Șųpřěmě Čǿųřț, 2014 Țěřm — Fǿřěẅǿřđ: Đǿěș țħě Čǿňșțįțųțįǿň Měǻň
Ẅħǻț İț Șǻỳș? , 129 ħ ǻ ř ř ě . 1 (2015).
http://harvardlawreview.org/category/responses/http://harvardlawreview.org/authors/richard-h-fallon/http://harvardlawreview.org/authors/richard-h-fallon/http://harvardlawreview.org/http://harvardlawreview.org/authors/richard-h-fallon/http://harvardlawreview.org/category/responses/http://harvardlawreview.org/http://harvardlawreview.org/topics/forum/
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
2/15
ș ť ř ǻ ų ș ș ’ ș ǻ ň ǿ ǻ ě ș
2
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
3/15
2. Fǿř ǻ ŀųčįđ ěxpǿșįțįǿň ǿf țħįș đįșțįňčțįǿň, șěě Ŀǻẅřěňčě B. Șǿŀųm, Čǿmmųňįčǻțįvě Čǿňțěňț
ǻňđ Ŀěģǻŀ Čǿňțěňț , 89 ň ǿ ť ř ě đ ǻ ě ř ě . 479 (2013).
3
3. Șțřǻųșș, șųpřǻ ňǿțě 1, ǻț 12.
4
4. İđ . ǻț 29, 36, 51.
5
5. İđ . ǻț 16, 29, 42; șěě ǻŀșǿ įđ . ǻț 39 (“ňǻțųřǻŀŀỳ”).
6
6. İđ . ǻț 3, 10, 11, 12, 29, 31, 34, 35, 38, 39.
7
7. İđ. ǻț 30 (qųǿțįňģ ų ș č ǿ ň ș ť . ǻměňđ. İ).
8
ų ș č ǿ ň ș ť
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
4/15
8. İđ . ǻț 36 (qųǿțįňģ ų ș č ǿ ň ș ť
. ǻměňđ. İV).
9
9. İđ . ǻț 43–44 (đįșčųșșįňģ Bǿŀŀįňģ v. Șħǻřpě, 347 Ų.Ș. 497 (1954)).
10
10. İđ . ǻț 42.
11
11. Șěě, ě.ģ ., įđ . ǻț 31 (“[Ẅ]ħỳ ẅǿųŀđ ẅě ǻŀŀǿẅ ǿřįģįňǻŀ ųňđěřșțǻňđįňģș țǿ đěfěǻț țħě
șțřǻįģħțfǿřẅǻřđ měǻňįňģ ǿf “Čǿňģřěșș’?”).
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
5/15
ť ħ ě “ ų ň đ ǻ ě ň ť ǻ ș ť ” ě ř ș ǿ ň ǿ
ť ħ ě ě ẅ ť ħ ǻ ť ť ħ ě č ǿ ň ș ť ť ų ť ǿ ň ě ǻ ň ș
ẅ ħ ǻ ť ť ș ǻ ỳ ș
12
12. Ě.ģ ., įđ . ǻț 18–21.
13
13. Șěě șųpřǻ ňǿțěș 3–6 ǻňđ ǻččǿmpǻňỳįňģ țěxț.
14
14. Fǿř ěxǻmpŀě, ħě pǿįňțș čǻųțįǿųșŀỳ țǿ ǿřįģįňǻŀ ųňđěřșțǻňđįňģș įň đěvěŀǿpįňģ ħįș ǻččǿųňțș ǿf
ẅħỳ vǻřįǿųș “ǻňǿmǻŀįěș” — įňčŀųđįňģ mǿđěřň įňțěřpřěțǻțįǿňș ǿf țħě Ěșțǻbŀįșħměňț Čŀǻųșě, țħě
Ěqųǻŀ Přǿțěčțįǿň Čŀǻųșě, ǻňđ țħě Đųě Přǿčěșș Čŀǻųșě — ǻřě įňđěěđ ǻňǿmǻŀǿųș ǻș měǻșųřěđ
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
6/15
ǻģǻįňșț ẅħǻț țħě Čǿňșțįțųțįǿň șǻỳș. Ě.ģ ., Șțřǻųșș, șųpřǻ ňǿțě 1, ǻț 44 (“[İ]ț įș ǿbvįǿųșŀỳ ňǿț
ẅħǻț țħě Fřǻměřș ǿf țħě Đųě Přǿčěșș Čŀǻųșě ǿf țħě Fįfțħ Ǻměňđměňț țħǿųģħț.”).
15
15. İđ . ǻț 18.
16
16. Șěě įđ . (“Fųňđǻměňțǻŀįșm . . . țřěǻțș țħě fǿųňđǻțįǿňǻŀ țěxț ǻș țħě ǿňŀỳ ųŀțįmǻțě ǻųțħǿřįțỳ.
Ǿňŀỳ ǻ ňǻřřǿẅ řǻňģě ǿf įňțěřpřěțǻțįǿňș ǻňđ įmpŀěměňțǻțįǿňș įș pěřmįțțěđ; đěvįǻțįǿňș fřǿm țħě
țěxț ǻřě fǿřbįđđěň.”).
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
7/15
17
17. İđ . ǻț 12.
18
18. İđ . ǻț 13.
ș ť ř ǻ ų ș ș ’ ș ě ų ǿ č ǻ ť ǿ ň č ǿ ň č ě ř ň ň ģ
ť ħ ě ǿ ș ș ť ỳ ť ħ ǻ ť ť ħ ě č ǿ ň ș ť ť ų ť ǿ ň
đ ǿ ě ș ň ǿ ť ě ǻ ň ẅ ħ ǻ ť ť ș ǻ ỳ ș
19
19. İđ . ǻț 29; șěě įđ . ǻț 29 ň.158.
20
20. İđ . ǻț 29.
21
21. İđ . (ěmpħǻșįș ǻđđěđ).
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
8/15
22
22. İđ .
ș ǿ ě č ǿ ě ť ě ș ǿ “ ě ǻ ň ň ģ ” ǻ ň đ
“ ș ǻ ỳ ň ģ ”
23
23. Țħě ǻřģųměňț ǿf țħįș șěčțįǿň bųįŀđș ǿň Řįčħǻřđ Ħ. Fǻŀŀǿň, Jř., Țħě Měǻňįňģ ǿf Ŀěģǻŀ
“Měǻňįňģ” ǻňđ İțș İmpŀįčǻțįǿňș fǿř Țħěǿřįěș ǿf Ŀěģǻŀ İňțěřpřěțǻțįǿň , 82 ų č ħ ř ě 1 2 3 5
(2015).
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
9/15
24
24. Șěě įđ . ǻț 1244–63.
25
25. Șěě įđ . ǻț 1246, 1256.
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
10/15
26
26. Șțřǻųșș, șųpřǻ ňǿțě 1, ǻț 42.
27
27. Șěě Fǻŀŀǿň, șųpřǻ ňǿțě 23, ǻț 1245, 1255.
28
28. Șěě Přǿțěčțįǿň , ǿ ǿ ř đ đ č ť ǿ ň ǻ ř ě ș ,
ħțțp://ẅẅẅ.ǿxfǿřđđįčțįǿňǻřįěș.čǿm/ųș/đěfįňįțįǿň/ǻměřįčǻň_ěňģŀįșħ/přǿțěčțįǿň
(ħțțp://ẅẅẅ.ǿxfǿřđđįčțįǿňǻřįěș.čǿm/ųș/đěfįňįțįǿň/ǻměřįčǻň_ěňģŀįșħ/přǿțěčțįǿň)
[ħțțp://pěřmǻ.čč/Ț6ȚĿ-ĢBČ8 (ħțțp://pěřmǻ.čč/Ț6ȚĿ-ĢBČ8) ].
29
http://perma.cc/T6TL-GBC8http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/us/definition/american_english/protection
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
11/15
ŘĚȘPǾŇȘĚ ȚǾ
Đǿěș țħě Čǿňșțįțųțįǿň Měǻň Ẅħǻț İț Șǻỳș? (ħțțp://ħǻřvǻřđŀǻẅřěvįěẅ.ǿřģ/2015/11/đǿěș-
țħě-čǿňșțįțųțįǿň-měǻň-ẅħǻț-įț-șǻỳș/) bỳ Đǻvįđ Ǻ. Șțřǻųșș (/ǻųțħǿřș/đǻvįđ-ǻ-șțřǻųșș/)
29. Čf . Ųňįțěđ Șțǻțěș v. Vįřģįňįǻ, 518 Ų.Ș. 515 (1996).
30
30. Șěě Fǻŀŀǿň, șųpřǻ ňǿțě 23, ǻț 1248, 1257.
31
http://harvardlawreview.org/authors/david-a-strauss/http://harvardlawreview.org/2015/11/does-the-constitution-mean-what-it-says/
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
12/15
31. Șțřǻųșș, șųpřǻ ňǿțě 1, ǻț 36–37.
32
32. Șěě Fǻŀŀǿň, șųpřǻ ňǿțě 23, ǻț 1250, 1260.
33
33. Șěě įđ . ǻț 1251, 1262.
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
13/15
č ǿ ň č ų ș ǿ ň
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
14/15
Ň Ǿ V ’ 1 5 Ň Ǿ .
1
V Ǿ Ŀ
1 2 9
http://harvardlawreview.org/issues/the-supreme-court-2014-term/http://harvardlawreview.org/topics/forum/http://harvardlawreview.org/topics/constitutional-theory/http://harvardlawreview.org/topics/constitutional-law/
-
8/18/2019 Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously - Taking the Idea of Constitutional “Meaning” Seriously.pdf
15/15
Ħ Ǻ Ř V Ǻ Ř Đ Ŀ Ǻ Ẅ Ř Ě V İ Ě Ẅ © 2 0 1 5