T14 Argumentation for agent societies

Download T14	Argumentation for agent societies

Post on 11-May-2015

288 views

Category:

Education

0 download

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

14th European Agent Systems Summer School

TRANSCRIPT

<ul><li>1.Argumentation for Agent Societies Part I4%33(5()(%$/&amp;6(%7/5($&amp; !"#"$%&amp;())%*%&amp; 8$(9"#3(*%:&amp;;(&amp;, ?)70#,),1$"#&amp;"I,?)1,10=&amp;U&amp;J&amp;/(1f, +(,?)70#,1$"#&amp;"I,)7+0=1,?)70#,10=&amp;U&amp;J&amp;/(1f,, C?&amp;,?)70#,),/)/&amp;"@,?)70#,),1$"#&amp;"I,)7+0=1,5+11,+-,50-&amp;f, 0-,),H)*&amp;(,?)1,/)/&amp;",)=,?)1,+,1$"#&amp;"I@,(?&amp;,H)*&amp;(,C+$5=,5+1&amp;,?01, 50-&amp;f, (?&amp;,H)*&amp;(,?)1,/+5+0/,H+5IH1f, ?)70#,/+5+0/,H+5IH1,%)I,5&amp;)=,(+,/)/&amp;"f,g+)51,50,c+,10=&amp;,&amp;J&amp;/(1d,)=,c(+,+(,5+1&amp;,?01,50-&amp;dA,,;+"&amp;,0%H+"()(,-+",?0%,(+,+(,5+1&amp;,?01,50-&amp;,(?),(+,+(,?)7&amp;,10=&amp;,&amp;J&amp;/(1A, 82. 9?&amp;,-")%&amp;C+",, &amp;%H?)10P0#,0(1,)*7&amp;,/+1&amp;G$&amp;/&amp;1@,, %011&amp;=,#+)51@, /&amp;"()0,"&amp;i&amp;/*+1A, 85. 9C+,)5(&amp;")*7&amp;,)HH"+)/?&amp;1, !%#+$=@,2")=&amp;A,83($E&amp;%#E?5"$*3&amp;A/#&amp;5%C($E&amp; %$;&amp;"F0)%($($E&amp;;"7(3(/$3G&amp;!"*-A,3(&amp;55A,VWXDXUYE&gt;, YVXUYXZ,D[]EA, M),^^XU^]A, 86. M), 3(&amp;")/*+1,)%+#,=0J&amp;"&amp;(,%+=$5&amp;1@, 3(&amp;")/*+1,)%+#,(?&amp;0",1&amp;H)")(&amp;,=&amp;/010+1@, :&amp;508&amp;")*+,H"+/&amp;11,C0(?0,&amp;)/?,%+=$5&amp;A, 87. 9?&amp;,%+=&amp;5, !"#$%&amp;()*7&amp;,=&amp;508&amp;")*+,%+=$5&amp;A, k)"0+$1,=&amp;/010+,%), 0/+%H5&amp;(&amp;,0-+"%)*+,-"+%,&amp;70"+%&amp;(,!, )8=$/*+,C0(?0,)"#$%&amp;()*+,-")%&amp;C+", K0"1(,5&amp;7&amp;5&gt;,"$5&amp;1,9,(?)(,"&amp;-&amp;",=0"&amp;/(5I,(+,(?&amp;,1$8i&amp;/(, =+%)0,+-,(?&amp;,)#&amp;(,D678*-9:)*;*)+,*-./.01++9"*+&amp;5*19?+ .&amp;/+=,)=,(?0"=,5&amp;7&amp;5&gt;,"$5&amp;1,"&amp;5)(&amp;,(+,(?&amp;,H+50/I, $=&amp;",C?0/?,(?&amp;,)#&amp;(,$1&amp;1,?01,+8i&amp;/(U5&amp;7&amp;5, =&amp;/010+,"$5&amp;1,)//+"=0#,(+,"+5&amp;1,@AB+C+,?lHD"VD!@9@,![EE@,"VD!@9@,!VEE,m,(&amp;/?0/)5l()1&lt; D9E@&amp;OH&amp;"(D![E,,FV,&gt;,?lHD6V@6[E,m,%)"+9"*&gt;,, H"+70=&amp;,8)10/,)=,1$81()*)5,(&amp;/?0G$&amp;1,-+",(?&amp;,)"(,+-,"&amp;)1+0#@,)1,H&amp;"-+"%&amp;=,8I,?$%),8&amp;0#1,0,&amp;7&amp;"I=)I,50-&amp;,10($)*+1@, #+,-)",8&amp;I+=,5+#0/)5,=&amp;=$/*+A, 94. !"#$%&amp;()*+,-+",8&amp;50&amp;-,"&amp;7010+, !#&amp;(,&amp;70"+%&amp;(@, 4&amp;50&amp;-,"&amp;7010+,=&amp;1/"08&amp;1,, (?&amp;,C)I,0,C?0/?,),)#&amp;(,01,1$HH+1&amp;=,(+,/?)#&amp;,?&amp;",8&amp;50&amp;-1,C?&amp;,&amp;C,0-+"%)*+,)""07&amp;1@,+",/?)#&amp;1,0,(?&amp;,C+"5=,)"&amp;,+81&amp;"7&amp;=f,, !"#$%&amp;()*+,=&amp;)51,, C0(?,1(")(&amp;1,)#&amp;(1,&amp;%H5+I,-+",(?&amp;0",+C,"&amp;)1+0#@,, (+,/?)#&amp;,(?&amp;,8&amp;50&amp;-1,+-,+(?&amp;",)#&amp;(1@,8I,H"+70=0#,"&amp;)1+1,-+",1$/?,/?)#&amp;A, 95. !"#$%&amp;()*+,-+",8&amp;50&amp;-,"&amp;7010+, !"#$%&amp;()*+,)=,8&amp;50&amp;-,"&amp;7010+,)1,/+%H5&amp;%&amp;()"I,=01/0H50&amp;1A, T)/?,&amp;&amp;=1,(?&amp;,+(?&amp;"j1,1$HH+"(,(+,%+=&amp;5,1$//&amp;11-$5,=&amp;/010+,%),`O&amp;=,`0(&amp;,5)#$)#&amp;,p, C0(?,),/+%H5&amp;(&amp;,1&amp;(,+-,8++5&amp;),/+&amp;/*7&amp;1A, ;)I,=0J&amp;"&amp;(,-")%&amp;C+",-+"%)501%,0,C?0/?,8&amp;50&amp;-1,)"&amp;, "&amp;H"&amp;1&amp;(&amp;=@,)=,0,C?0/?,=0J&amp;"&amp;(,, 7*).*&gt;+/*9/&gt;,1&amp;(1,+-,1&amp;(&amp;/&amp;1,/5+1&amp;=,$=&amp;",5+#0/)5, /+1&amp;G$&amp;/&amp;@,+",, 7*).*&gt;+7&amp;/*/&gt;,1&amp;(1,+-,1&amp;(&amp;/&amp;1,+(,&amp;/&amp;11)"05I,/5+1&amp;=A, LH&amp;")(+"1,H"&amp;1&amp;(&amp;=,0,(C+,C)I1&gt;,, 8I,#070#,),&amp;OH50/0(,/+1("$/*+,D)5#+"0(?%E,-+",(?&amp;,+H&amp;")(+"@,+", 8I,#070#,),1&amp;(,+-,")*+)50(I,H+1($5)(&amp;1,(+,8&amp;,1)*1`&amp;=,D/+1(")0(1EA,, 98. !"#$%&amp;()*+,_,4&amp;50&amp;-,6&amp;7010+, 0B&amp;D01&gt;, &amp;C,0-+"%)*+,0,=0J&amp;"&amp;(,1?)H&amp;1,)=,-+"%1@,&amp;A#A@,3,01,),H"+H+10*+)5,-)/(f, 8)10/,!g;,(?&amp;+"I@,)11$%0#,(?&amp;,&amp;H01(&amp;%0/,1()(&amp;,+-,(?&amp;,)#&amp;(,(+,8&amp;,#07&amp;,8I,),8&amp;50&amp;-,1&amp;(f, 3,%0#?(,8&amp;,%+"&amp;,/+%H5&amp;O@,&amp;G$0HH&amp;=,C0(?,="&amp;&amp;,+-,H5)$108050(I@,+",?)7&amp;,-+"%,+-,),"$5&amp;@,+",), /+%H5&amp;(&amp;,)"#$%&amp;(@,+",+-,),1&amp;(,+-,1$/?,&amp;**&amp;1f, $;&amp;)=&amp;D15+1*!+.1&gt;0B&amp;D01&gt;,, -+",-$"(?&amp;",H"+/&amp;110#,3@,/"$/0)5,-+",(?&amp;,)#&amp;(,(+,*B*1-*&gt;,, K"+%,&amp;C,&amp;H01(&amp;%0/,1()(&amp;@,(?&amp;,)#&amp;(,=&amp;"07&amp;1,H5)$1085&amp;,8&amp;50&amp;-1,(?)(,#$0=&amp;,?&amp;",8&amp;?)70+$"f, 99. !"#$%&amp;()*+,_,4&amp;50&amp;-,6&amp;7010+, T%8&amp;==0#,0(+,/+%H5&amp;O,"&amp;)1+0#,H"+/&amp;11A, 9?&amp;,/+%H5&amp;%&amp;()"I,/?)")/(&amp;"1,+-,)"#$%&amp;()*+, )=,8&amp;50&amp;-,"&amp;7010+,8&amp;/+%&amp;,&amp;70=&amp;(&gt;, )"#$%&amp;()*+,%), C?)(,C+$5=,?)HH&amp;,0-,(?&amp;,&amp;C,0-+"%)*+,C&amp;"&amp;,(+,8&amp;,8&amp;50&amp;7&amp;=@,, 8&amp;50&amp;-,/?)#&amp;,0%H50/0(5I,"&amp;50&amp;1,+,5+#0/)5,50,+5I,+&amp;,)//&amp;H()85&amp;,1&amp;(,+-,)"#$%&amp;(1,0,(?&amp;,"&amp;701&amp;=,-")%&amp;C+",)==1,(?&amp;,&amp;C,)"#$%&amp;(,(+,(?&amp;,&amp;O01*#,&amp;O(&amp;10+1@, /*)*-D;*+B*;./.01&gt;,=&amp;/"&amp;)1&amp;,+-,(?&amp;,$%8&amp;",+-,/?+0/&amp;1@, L=*/D01.15+B*;./.01&gt;,")01&amp;,)%80#$0(I@,8I,0/"&amp;)10#,(?&amp;,$%8&amp;",+-,&amp;O(&amp;10+1@, 4*/9B=-D;*+B*;./.01&gt;,"&amp;%+70#,&amp;7&amp;"I,&amp;O(&amp;10+@, &amp;)9*B.15+B*;./.01&gt;,1+%&amp;,&amp;O(&amp;10+1,D)55,+-,(?&amp;%E,)"&amp;,)5(&amp;"&amp;=A, 111. 9?"&amp;&amp;,)5(&amp;")*7&amp;,)HH"+)/?&amp;1, K)5)HH)@,M&amp;"U318&amp;"&amp;"@,)=,.0%)"0A,, &amp;)/?,-+"%$5),0,(?&amp;,M4,01,)11+/0)(&amp;=,C0(?,0(1,5&amp;7&amp;5, +-,/&amp;"()0(I,/+""&amp;1H+=0#,(+,(?&amp;,5)I&amp;",(+,C?0/?,0(, 8&amp;5+#1A, 113. 9?&amp;,%+=&amp;5, 9C+,/5)11&amp;1,+-,)HH"+)/?&amp;1,(+,=&amp;)5,C0(?,0/+101(&amp;/I,0, M4&gt;,/+?&amp;"&amp;/&amp;,(?&amp;+"0&amp;1,)=,-+$=)*+,(?&amp;+"0&amp;1A,, K0"1(,0101(1,+,"&amp;7010#,(?&amp;,M4,)=,"&amp;1(+"0#,/+101(&amp;/I@, p)R&amp;",)//&amp;H(1,0/+101(&amp;/I,)=,/+H&amp;1,C0(?,0(A, F+?&amp;"&amp;/&amp;,(?&amp;+"0&amp;1,H"+H+1&amp;,, (+,#07&amp;,$H,1+%&amp;,-+"%$5)1,+-,(?&amp;,M4,0,+"=&amp;",(+,#&amp;(,+&amp;,+",1&amp;7&amp;")5,/+101(&amp;(,1$8U8)1&amp;1@, (+,)HH5I,/5)110/)5,&amp;()05%&amp;(,+,(?&amp;1&amp;,/+101(&amp;(,1$8U8)1&amp;1,(+,=&amp;=$/&amp;,H5)$1085&amp;,/+/5$10+1,+-,(?&amp;,M4A,, K+$=)*+,(?&amp;+"0&amp;1,"&amp;()0,, )55,)7)05)85&amp;,0-+"%)*+,, &amp;)/?,H5)$1085&amp;,/+/5$10+,0-&amp;""&amp;=,-"+%,(?&amp;,M4,01,i$1*`&amp;=,8I,1("+#,)"#$%&amp;()*7&amp;,"&amp;)1+1,-+",8&amp;50&amp;70#,0,0(A, 114. 9?&amp;,%+=&amp;5, F5)0%&gt;,, 0(,=+&amp;1,+(,)5C)I1,%)%#;3&amp; %$/*1"#&amp;%E"$*&amp;L&amp;%H/?*&amp;*1"&amp;H"1%9(/?#N%72/$&amp;%&amp; #")"9%$*&amp;A/#&amp;*1"&amp;E/%)&amp;EdA, g)%8&amp;R)&gt;,c*#?3*&amp;(3&amp;*1"&amp;3?HO"729"&amp;0#/H%H()(*L&amp; HL&amp;&gt;1(71&amp;%$&amp;($;(9(;?%)&amp;.&amp;"F0"7*3&amp;*1%*&amp;%$/*1"#&amp; ($;(9(;?%)&amp;1(71&amp; (*3&amp;&gt;")A%#"&amp;;"0"$;3dA,, 118. 9"$1(, p0)$&gt;,c(A&amp;%E"$*&amp;(&amp;H")("9"3&amp;*1%*&amp;%E"$*&amp;O&amp;1%3&amp;*/);&amp; 1(5&amp;*1"&amp;*#?*1&amp;/$&amp;0I&amp;%$;&amp;1"&amp;*#?3*3&amp;*1"&amp; O?;E"5"$*&amp;/A&amp;O&amp;/$&amp;0I&amp;*1"$&amp;1"&amp;&gt;())&amp;%)3/&amp;H")("9"&amp; 0dA,, F+%%+,&amp;5&amp;%&amp;(1,)"&amp;, /+101(&amp;(,="&amp;&amp;,+-,$/&amp;"()0(I@,)=,, /+b0/*#,0-+"%)*+,)11+/0)(&amp;=,C0(?,("$1(A,, 119. !"#$%&amp;()*+,)=,9"$1(, M&amp;I,)1H&amp;/(,+-,("$1(&gt;,0(,1(&amp;%1,-"+%,(?&amp;, "&amp;5)*+1?0H,8&amp;(C&amp;&amp;,0=070=$)51@,+",#"+$H1,+-, 0=070=$)51A, 9C+,%)i+",)1H&amp;/(1,&amp;&amp;=,(+,8&amp;,?)=5&amp;=,8I,)I, "&amp;H"&amp;1&amp;()*+,+-,("$1(&gt;, %&amp;)1$"&amp;1,+-,("$1(@,)=, H"+7&amp;)/&amp;,+-,("$1(,0-+"%)*+A, 120. !"#$%&amp;()*+,)=,9"$1(, 9"$1(,`&amp;5=,!,%&amp;(?+=+5+#0&amp;1,-+",/+%H$*#, ("$1(A, !"#$%&amp;()*+,`&amp;5=,!,%&amp;(?+=+5+#0&amp;1,-+", "&amp;)1+0#,)8+$(,("$1(A,!"#$%&amp;()*+,/),H"+70=&amp;,),%&amp;/?)01%,-+",?)=50#,%)I,+-,(?&amp;,)1H&amp;/(1,(?)(,C&amp;,&amp;&amp;=,(+, /)H($"&amp;,)8+$(,("$1(A, 121. !"#$%&amp;()*+,)=,9"$1(, !81(")/(,)HH"+)/?&amp;1,1$/?,)1,:$#,)=,0(1, =&amp;"07)*7&amp;1@,("&amp;)(,)"#$%&amp;(1,)1,)(+%0/,+8i&amp;/(1A, p0R5&amp;,+",+(?0#,)8+$(,0(&amp;")5,1("$/($"&amp;,+-, )"#$%&amp;(A, h+,%&amp;/?)01%,(+,"&amp;H"&amp;1&amp;(,(?&amp;,1+$"/&amp;,+-,(?&amp;, 0-+"%)*+,-"+%,C?0/?,(?&amp;,)"#$%&amp;(,01, /+1("$/(&amp;=A, F)+(,/)H($"&amp;&gt;, ),)R)/, K&amp;&amp;=8)/, &amp;&amp;=,-+",),0=070=$)5,(+,8&amp;,)85&amp;,(+,"&amp;701&amp;,(?&amp;, ("$1(,?&amp;,?)1,0,)+(?&amp;",8)1&amp;=,+,&amp;OH&amp;"0&amp;/&amp;A,, 9?01,)55+C1,(+,"&amp;H"&amp;1&amp;(,(?&amp;,/)1&amp;,0,C?0/?,+&amp;, 0=070=$)5,"&amp;701&amp;1,0(1,70&amp;C,+-,),1+$"/&amp;,)1,), "&amp;1$5(,+-,/+10=&amp;"0#,0-+"%)*+,H"+70=&amp;=,8I, )+(?&amp;",0=070=$)5A, 125. 9?"&amp;&amp;,)5(&amp;")*7&amp;,)HH"+)/?&amp;1, 2)"1+1@,9)#@,.(*1&amp; 9%#L($E&amp;;"E#""3&amp;/A&amp;*#?3*G&amp;3,2"+/1,+-,!!;!.,[VVA, =),F+1(),2&amp;"&amp;0")@,9&amp;R)%)P0@,k055)()A,F?)#0#, +&amp;j1,;0=&gt;,T")1&amp;,+",6&amp;C0=S,2+11080501*/,4&amp;50&amp;-, 6&amp;7010+,C0(?,K$PPI,!"#$%&amp;()*+,4)1&amp;=,+, 9"$1(A,3,2"+/1,+-,3rF!3,[VV@,H)#&amp;1,VZYUVWV@, [VVA, ;)R@,;+"#&amp;@,9+0A,Q/5H($($E&amp;3*%23273&amp;%$;&amp; %#E?5"$*3&amp;*/&amp;7/50?*"&amp;*#?3*G,3,2"+/1,+-,!!;!., [V@,H)#&amp;1,[]U[VZ@,[VA, 126. 2)"1+1,&amp;(,)5A,)HH"+)/?, !11$%&amp;,(?)(,)#&amp;(1,%)0()0,),("$1(,&amp;(C+",)HH"+)/?,(+,("$1(, $10#,:&amp;%H1(&amp;"U.?)-&amp;",8&amp;50&amp;-,-$/*+,=&amp;"07&amp;=, -"+%,1()*1*/)5,=)(),/+/&amp;"0#,()"#&amp;(j1, 8&amp;?)70+$"A, TO(&amp;10+,+-,z$,)=,.0#?j1,)HH"+)/?,8I, )55+C0#,&amp;7)5$)(+",(+,(),, &gt;0B*-&amp;/9+&amp;B5=*19/@,0,-)7+$",+",)#)01(,("$1*#, (?&amp;,()"#&amp;(@,)=,, .D5&amp;D01+&amp;B5=*19/@,)R)/</li></ul>