surveys fl1999
DESCRIPTION
Surveys FL1999TRANSCRIPT
-
COURSE ON TRANSPORT SURVEY METHODS
! """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
# $% ! """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""&
!
' ( """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
'# !""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""")
' !!* """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""+
'& (!!( """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
' ,( """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#
"#$%&'
( % """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""&
# (""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-
(#%& )
. (/ ( """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""")
.# ($0.!, """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#
*#$# ++
$! ( """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""##
# 1!! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#
2%3*! !$0. % """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#
& % """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#4
###$%&,--.-%%//0
+)
1 /
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#)
1# !(!""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#+
1 (""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
1 -#-*0+
5 1! """"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""#
5# (!(""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""4
5 06*
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""+
. "#2(( '
! ("""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""&
# '((! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
7! ! """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""&
" 2#'3
-
./!((
*
Course on Transport Survey Methods
A Data requirement and collection in transport planning
- - % # #
%4#%&-&-&
#-%45#-$
-&
- % - 5% # - %&- %
-%5#4-&-4
-%4&6-5
- # & 7& # - &8 ##
-&%5-&4-6-5#
%5-&%%55
5%4---" #&6-
%54- $##5&
-# - # - # ,4 ##
-&4 - 9 - -
"---- #4
-&$--%-#-4#
# - - 5 % -
%%4&5
##-
-& -"%##
- %5 # - &4 # 5& %% # -
-
A1 State variables for the transport system
%5 -- 5 - # % & -&
5:%#---$
A1a The objectives and constraints of transport planning
&&5#5&,
4---#
#%4--$-
% 7 $8 - # -
&4 # - 5 # % ## 4 - 5
#:4
-
./!((
*
#
%-5:%#-4 % -
%5#
4-%
#-#%,-5%#-%--
%54-%#-%4-%5
% - #
%5&4 # 7- 4 #4 #&8 ##& - 9
5#
& 4 -5 5:% # #
# - ## 5 % 4 -96 # #
& 5 -% 5&6 - 96 - %4--
%#-5#-5-&
--& 4 - % 6 ,
-&5&&5&-
- & # - 5# # %
%##.%--#-
- # 4 # - 7
##5#84 $4-5-#
%,78478478-#47%8
47%8&-%%#
5&4-5
*-##-#7
# # # 5 # %- 8-
5:%96-%#5&6-%
5###--%&&4
% " #4
4 %- - % % #
$ - 5& $5# &4 -- %
5 &4 & - 5 -
%%#- -#&4%
--,-
5##
A1b Dimensions of analysis and of disaggregation
##9%;%%&
- # ## %%& -5#
-
./!((
*
---"#-&5#-
5%46&5%56
A1c A list of state variables
5 5 & %54 & %5 5-%
-5&%545#%#
-&54 %-4 #-4
# % - % & 5 5& -
&5-%# 4---&%5
- %5-$7$8,$
%5##%67#%8
%6-#%- -& 5
94 - - & 5 9 & &
&45758%#%%
#&
- - & %5, & - -
%5#&4#--&%5#
%-##-%&55&-
#-%#7=84#-9#&---
&%#--%5&-=&5
- 4 & - 6 #
%&4
5&%#4-
-$#" %&5&-#
6$9
#6,--#
% 6 5 # % , - -
%& % 5 # - -
4 - 6 64
$7$8
$9%#7%4%8-
$,&-6&-
6%& - #- - #
798798
- 5 -
5-%"-%#4-%###&4-
%64#
%%5#-$$-
- 5 - 5-% #
-5# %& -5#4
-&5-%&-
9 # - % & # # & 5-% & 5-%
-64-#%
----&45
-###"5
-84
-
./!((
*
&
A2 Overview of transport survey methods
- %& # %5 # # & 9
5 -& 5 - %5 4
&4 & % % # 4 5 #
%54##
- 5 # # %& - & 5 -4 5 -
--%&,# ;
% - ;
%% % % - # -
&-#
A2a Network data
-# -7-5#
8; -& % # ## % 4
- 5& # #
%- & - 5% %% - & 5% 7 ## 8
%5%7-4#8
A2b En-route surveys
$%&-$5%##
-#-5%7-%4-%84$#
#%#5"%%-
4-%5##-4-5#
-& # - # -#4# #
&
" % 7# & 84 $5 $
%&-#5
A2c Off-trip surveys
- %%##$ % 4 - 4
5 - # " -$5 %& -5& #
--4 #$5 %& - - # -
#>-
##$%&&&%-%#55
#-9#-%&-
- %& # - # - , #$$# %
- - - (-
%&&5#5#
& #% , 78 ; 7+8 #
445 455 ;708
# 5 # ; 7'8 5& -5; 7!8 9 5 - #$
95-&--
##$%&---6-##-&-
(#%&-(#4
2%(#5#45%-
-
2%3
B Network data
--# ## 9% 4 "
5&4%54--#&&75#%-8
##&78
-#-5##%55-
-"##%(#-5##%5
7# # 8 -
-4-&7#&87$#%8(+
(0-&5%--%5%--
%5#& % ('&4(! -
9
B1 Traffic variables
B1a Defining traffic
##
-
2%3
4
- # # # & & 7 8
%--%-%-&4#
=-878B7
B1c Speed and travel time
-- - # % %- 5 784 -
##4-
-45& % 4
,%@4A@"-%-%-,#
A-5-#%-,-
-45& % 4%@,4
,A,@"-%-%---5-#-%---
B1d Vehicle classes
5###-%-&,
## 7## %- -% ## % 84
&%7$# -$
#84####%54##&4 &
&& # & %- & 5, 5&4 5 4 &4 4
4 4 %4 B #- & 4 - 4
5444%
% - - # - & 5 # ## - &4 &
-
B1e Analytic relationships under stable flow
# - 5 % - 5
%54 - # 4 %
%&%--
5&! - ! 4 # !/ !3 &
% 4 5 - = ! !// = ! !33 -
##-4 = ! !!// % %3 = ! !!3
-5#4 !!! 3/ = 5-%-- ! ,
#A---D,$ ! 4,@4-
3/ !!! = - = ! !// = ! !!3 %3= ---
?-%#
-
2%3
-
& - = ! !33 = ! !! / B = ! !! /// 8B87B7 -
=/3 B =B% ! !! // 8B87B7 , ---#-
& - = ! !! // 8B7% + B%@8B7D= ! !! 33 , -
5 # ++
%8%7%@D%% +== - ?> #4
------
#%--%-
B1f Empiric relationships for uninterrupted flow
E#####5&9#7-:
- - 5 # 8 " 5:
4,----#%-%4
- ## % %-?- %& -- -
##9$-#?-
%& - ## #$# , - %-
###
-5-%####$4--:
5%#--##%#
#"%#4-5%#--4
----####
# & " - & 4 - # 9&
-&%&5&- ## -- -%-
--5%-#--
- 4 -- 5- # -
## -- - %- %& - - #
#-
Fig. a. Speed versus flow.
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
F +FFF 'FFF 3FFF
!
" !
2 # % # %
7 & 8&5 - %% -
$# - 79&8 5-% # - -
#---#$---
-
2%3
)
-4 - 9 # % - - $
9-5%
-%#-##4
%,-&-4-4-%-
4 - ##-
-
2%3
+
78 5 % %& ## -- -
75#44%8--4&%#
+F+%-%##
-%
B2c Concentration from local occupation time
&%-#-4 -
--,5&%-
5-#--
-% #-%-,-
- %- - - - - % - - 4 -
% - + - %
# C + B87 "#-5#%%--
4 - = +
= C @D87
/ + C @D8@7D
/ + -
%8@7D +=
/
38@7D += - 3 & 5 % #
+@D
B2d Local measurement of speed
- # %- 5 & 5& # 4 5 -
## 7- #& # % 5& - - - -
%#-%-4--5--%5 #
%-+8
*#-&-#%5&-
%--%-#-%--
- % - 5& -
5 %- - %
## 4 - . B - # - %-
5
- %% % 5% - %-
+ , 5& - 5 - % #
%-4- 8B7 + -#-%-# +
B3 Measurement by moving observer
" % 5% -4 - 5% - ## - %%
-#%-4#---%%-4
-%-4#---%&-%#%--
#5%
+ 5& - # - 9 - 94 5& - % # -
%---4--#&C+78B--%-
-
2%3
B3a Definitions for individual time and speed
- % # % % - # - %
##4-5# 8 B= -8-4- - . # %
%-%
"-5&%-%-
%- %-"7
-- -%- &8 7-- -%- 8
-#-#7%84
5
-##5-%-##%
B3b Floating car strategy
- # %-- -- - 5 -
%#-%&4--%#5
445##
-%5-#&-#%-
%##4 4-5#% %-4 + 4-
5#% %-4 - - 84 #
/ 3 -5# 83/
BB87 = + G / -
& 8
/3 B87 + += - 3/ B% = %B8 =
"# # / %54 - # %- % -
###&5
#%--
% # , - -
83/ BB += 5 -
-45 8B7@D
/ ++= + /
B87 + =
--5-5&-##!=-
# ! -% % ! 8 B - - %-4 --
-
2%3
-%-&5#--4
- # - & 5
-
B4 Traffic measurement devices
##%#-%-%4
%4#-478
-4-5&
? - 5#& % - % , - 4 54
% % --&4 ##&
455#--&-
%-
B4a Human counter
-5%5%4%#&.
- & 5 - 5& - . -
&7%84-#75#-
#4##84-##&--&
9--5%
B4b Pneumatic tubes
5- $5554--5
# ## 4 - 5& - % "
- - - # - %?- 5& -4
--4-%5
-455#&"
9:--455#
%5%-
B4c Inductive loops
- % 5& -##45
:5-# # -- -4
--#-#5&4
-%-4%--#4--
----#--
%&%-
& ## 4- - -
$## 5 %& -- $5- 94 & --
-%-5&:&-7
# 8 5F)F- 7 F+8 -##9#%-
%-5#
%&%-%4-%--
-
2%3
#
B4d Video camera
=###-#5##
%%& #4-
% : - % & -
5:4--56-5&--##%
- % -#%-%4 -- - &4
5-75
#4&65&%- 4%-%4
-#4-4--&
.%-%-4-4--#
%-
B4e Test vehicles
%-##-%&&&-
%5%-5%-5%-
* -& 55& - # #4 6
%7915(&8--5%%#-#
%&
B5 Exercises
B5a Macroscopic variables from microscopic data
- # 5 - % # %-
F = FF+ = -5&-#
#
=- ( ( +
+! 00
+ 03 '+
0 '! !H
' !0 33
! ' +0
3 3+ H!
H )) /!
) +0 +/
/ +'F +'0
F +)! +/'
?--%78&-I
+ %-%
0 %--4-0FF
-
2%3
' - # , 5& 4!FF # - # -5 != !%-#-
,7-,#-%-4A8"
--%-#
! -%#--
B5b Measurement from inductive loop
5 F % -& 5%4 -
#5
. &
7J8
!/! F! +
+ +H) '+ '
0 0'++ 3 F
' !!F' FH H
! !F) H0 +/
3 !/! /! /
H !H/F +F )
) !)/H !) )
/ !3)' ' 3
F !/'H 0+ H
-%-#-#-%&%-#%&-
+ %& ## # # +4 --
0 (---&
' 2%-#-&4-#F)F4
%-#'0% -#)!
! -#4--#&4%-#
B5c Travel time measurement
5##4& -%
- - C 0F - # - #-4 #
%&-46%--
6-% #,
-
+ --
0 &5%-#-
-
9( 0
&
C Instances of en-route surveys
C1 An instance of roadside interviews
"4 - 5 # - 5 & 4
-#&--&---#5--&
-5 & 7#--$4 ##84
- -- -#--& -#
5-#&--&
" ## # 5& % #4 - # -
4 .; - - & -
-##4#--$#
-$##--#%%&-
: 4-##-
?--5%&5-#
----%
-$%&&--
C1a Location and administration
# - -4 - # 6 - ($- - -
-&-:5& -"-#
#-#-%&
&*%%&4-
####-9%&-- ##-
% % # -$ 5 -: 5
--
-
9( 0
Fig. d. Map of French regions.
Fig. e. Roadway en-route surveys in the French region Poitou-Charentes.
$%&79&85&5
-
9( 0
4
C1b Objectives and contents of the questionnaires
- 5 5:% % - $ # 4--&
- $#$& 7 %&4 & #
(-%&-%--%&7--
98%&%4#- 4 5-
-& % #- & -
" - 5 5 - ;
& - 034FFF 4 # 5 3F
-& !!F4FFF " - & 4 - -
& 4 - 5 & 5
5% % 7 +F 6 # - 9 --
5 HFF4FFF -58 - & 4 - 5
- #& ,-5
5& # 6 7 6 # 64 # # 1&8
- - # 4 5& - %& -
#
1##&
-% 5-5#-4
-4-# -4--
% 9 % - & # % .4? 4
(
-% 5 - --# 4
- & # 4 - - % 9
C1c Data management
- # - %, - # - - %&
- - #4 - -
#54#-#
5-4--5
-#-%6--&
-5 #5 - #%&4 -
5#%&4-##675&%-&8
5 115
- & - # % %& 5 $ 94
%6-#-&-5-#"
##%-%#&$ 7-
###--5%$8
- $ &4 $& %&
$&-%%$&
C1d Statistical analysis
-#%&5-#-6-
-%& "&55& $#$&-& %
--5%55-
-
9( 0
-
-#6% 7%-#
%&8
% %-#- $%
%& -#---
9 # - 7# 5 %&8 ?- %
##-4#-5&-&4&55
-% 5 -
--&-%-$9
# $ # # $ #4 %
?-%%--
C2 Public transport surveys
-
( (
)
D Principles of interception surveys
2 % # %&
-5%#% 4-%-%#
#-5%4---#
%& ##4$5$5%&
%&&5%&4
&5%&4--5%% &
$955%
-%--#5%&
-%4 #",#%%
#--4%#-%#$9
D1 Techniques for interception surveys
%& -# #4-- -
%5%%
--
& 5 - 5& 5% $ %
7- $5 $8 5 & 5 # 5&
-#5# 4--
D1a Mere local observation
#$%% 7 % 84 5% %
--%%--5%%"5-%
, - # -4 # - #
-5%5&4--
%----
-#5%%495#-%-,-
94 - 5 # 4 - & #- 54 - 5
-#&%-4-%-:
= 5% 5& - - - -
- 4 -
#5%&5-#&
- - - 5% 4 4 - 4 -
-&:;#5%5# -# -5#
-544-5#-5
%&45-:(&5
65#
-
( (
+
D1b En-route interviews
-#%,%4$5$
%-5#"-&
--
&5#%%$
4#-$758
-4-$#$&4-#&4-5#
-4-%9%#-
2 %& 5 $5 5 %&& 5
#4"5$57-
- 8 $ %&& 5- 5 -
--4-4-5&7##$%&8
- #-$44
%& 5% 7 -4
87-84%-5
D1c Number plate matching
-5- %% 5%
4-%-&45*--
5%&$$$5&%-&4%$
-5&5&&5%
55%5%--
#&-6#
-75%-&8-&5&
%5&6$
5%-5##
-
( (
#
---5#
--%&&4--% -
- -- # % - 7 +F 8
5%- 5#%-4-
--##
D2 Potential contribution to O-D matrix
D2a Comparison of techniques
- % # - 5 $ 9
#--E%----
4 - #% #, # $ %&4
5%&4- --%&4&
$ %% $94 -9
9& # - % ##
6## %
5%&&$#-%"%
%5-4#
-&%-
--%&&5##5
%&4#
& % # $ #4 &6 -
# $ - # & % - #
-%&4###
D2b Guidelines for cordon design
55-#
&4---%
- -5 -4---
- - 5 - & 7 -
5#-8%$#
5,
78 94-- --
7+8 ---5&
708 9- -9 78 78
7'8 "---
7!8 ($ - 5&
?--%&--9-4--%
- 5 - $ - # -- - %&
-5%4 6 -5#
-
( (
#
"-#:4#55%
-%&7-#%8
- % $## - ##& % $
#--4#&#
9-#--
Fig. f. Types of trips.
9-##
-9
9-##
-
"
##
($
##
($9
##
9
##
-
! $0. %
##
E Model estimation of O-D flows
-#$9&55% #5%
##5-$#-#
#4#----5#-
# - - - 5 -
#-#4--5-&-#
#
-##--#9
# - - 5#& 5 - 4 #
55#5%#9--
- &-
6#
E1 On demand function
E1a General
5 %#$45
--5# -6# - &-
5:%# #,#&5-$%4--
;&9-4
-5# -5%5&&-5%45-
5-9%#4
--9&,---%-
9 .% # & # 4-
%5---
5 9 - 5-% -
%-&-###%
E1b Generic formula
5:%5-#5?
-%5
-##
847K87 =/// 9 ==
--9-#$95&4/-9#$%4%=
5#-6#-&4 /K
-# %#
5:% 9 - & # % 4 5 -
%55%-45-$% / --#4
# #& # /K - - -- &
-
! $0. %
#
E1c The gravity model as an instance of demand function
-%7-&&-L#
%&-"-5##-%&4%&$#
- # - 64 - # - 6 -
#-,
+8B7 >/ = 4
-->#&4 -#6:;4 -
#6:; -#66
&94##$##%5-
6 -$% %&- -
#$
87897 44 ! !!
5 ==>/ += 4
-- -%5 = 4 54 != 4 54 !
4 5 - 6 #
#7#8
# # - - 4 - 6
" & 4 & - 6 7
8 #94 - 5& 5-
#9--## pi -$
##,
87 5 / pi=
-%&%44-$
#-5-
E2 From observations to estimators
E2a Observations
*%55%##45
#$#,
= 9 /, 4
--5%7# 8 -#-$-
$--5-$-###
-#%%#5-$
#-#"-2= , -2= /
- 5% 5: 5% 4 #
%4--#
9 /, ++= 8K7 4
-
! $0. %
#&
---# /K -# -$
# @D / - #
%
5 - # -
4---%###-#
- $ # @D / - #
%- - %5& , @D // 4
-5%-&-
?- - # #4 & % - ( # #
5% , # ,5& -(# 4-(# ,
8K7 9 /, -- %% - % , 4 - /K - #
- - ## (2=- & ,K C
9 /K --55.#
M
8K78K978K4(7
,.,.,.
=
---##2=-&
,K %
K 4-#(
8978K4K(7 K8K7
+
K+
+
,,
,,
pi=
?-$%&%54%-#5%
// +=K
-- / -%% -5%4-%
K --#59(#
8978K4K(7 K8K7
+
K+
+
//
//
pi=
E2b The composition of observations
- % # # % 5%4 -- - 5
5&
#--%5%-- -
# # - % # - # - # - % 5%4
-- # - - :# -
5%#####
?--5%%#$$%&4-&5
5 - & 5 5& :
% 54 - % 9 9
-
! $0. %
#
//////
9
K8+7
88K7K
8K7978
K4K(7
+
pi
=
E2c Estimation
- % # 5 5& # - -49 - 7*8 78 - - %
-6-##
- 4 % # - # N -- - 5% " -#*4
& 5 & 5 % # %
%#
?--# 4--#5#5%$5%
$455%#%%#$
#--5%455%5#6
#-&
E3 Network assignment of estimated O-D flows
* # $ 9 4 5 %
"--#-#-5&
- - 4 - > % 5&
#5% #-,-
%
E3a Assignment of estimated values and variances
- - $ # % /N C 9/ 8N7
%?N C 9/ 8N7% -9## /N 5-
4% 5%5-& #
= 9 /, NN
& -9 # # %4 ?N 4 - $ 94 5
- $$## 4#-#
= 9 / N%N
-%# # ,N &5%
,N% C +
-
! $0. %
#4
E3b Validation again test link flows
-#-555&- %
## # % - # # %
, NN +B 45$#- --
# % , , N+B N % # - 5% #
#- #
-55##-
-%-5 ,N 4-#
# 8NN;N7 +B ,, 8NN;N7 +B ,, + -
# 8N;N7 N+B
, ,, 8N;N7 N+B
, ,, + &
# - % 5&55% -$#%#-
?--5%#- #5-4-%
9 - - - 5%
5-,-#%
E4 About software
E4a General
6 # $ # -
5 - # # # - 7# 5& $ 4
4 $8-6#--
* #9#
$456748
4 - $ %5 & %5
#4%--#9-%#-
E4b Instance: the TRIPS package
-2"( 4*=4-#$
9-5#-##,
(94
44
57#5%&84
###%%
-5%##%4#95&-&-
--$#45%4(2=-
= 3
33= 87
-- -4 -4 3= &--
5 # # 6 4 3 - & # - $-
-
! $0. %
#-
5 - $ 74 84 - $ # - #
# C 897 (( 7- ( -$6
8
# 5&9 -4 5% -
&%5&4--5$#
-%5&%5
-
9( 0
#)
F An instance of off-trip survey: the French nationwide
Household Travel Survey of 1993
"4%&-&4%&%-%#
----4--#//0$//'4-
%& 5
?---
.-%%##$
%& " 5 - 6 - #$-
- ---5-
%&&-%%
F1 Survey questionnaire
- %& # # , -- 4
4 %- # - -
% - # - %& & 5& -
%---
F1a Household description
1-- # - 7&84 - 5#
- --4 - 5 # & 4 - 5 # -
%4-#-#
--%&55&
- # - -- 5 - 5 # 5 # 4 5 #
5&45 &4-
5 # 7J # 4 -
5!J#-%84&
F1b Person description
%&9&--5%
5$545&-5
-%&$5-944%#4#
"% -6 # % 7
&84%55
*5& -5 # % 4 #& - 4
--4-&
F1c Vehicle description
#-#-#%-&,
- 70!84&45 5&?-%%-
#%&,
-
9( 0
#+
4
#7%84
1&4#4
E- 4
* 4 % 4 % % - % & # #%##
F1d Trip description
- -6 # 5& - 5 %& -
&5&4-%-%
- & 5& & - --4
&-55&--5--&
5#-%&>%4-6#-% $
-%&---4
& - 55, - 5 - --
#---5-%-
%--
- % - 6 --4
&-5--#-%
5
?-% - 4 - %& 5 5& & -
54&,
-75&&84
-7#84
-%4
-4-9##54
-4
-6#-%4
-%#--
F2 Sample selection and survey administration
F2a Sample size and response rates
#+F4FFF--#-##-#-
//F5+4HFF--%&-4
H40FF%--)+J#- -%&4
#'4+FF--
-'4+FF--40)4!FF4/34FFF&4
+04FF:7'4)FF84/40FF%-/H4FFF
%
-
9( 0
F2b Optimization of sampling plan
-#--7Ɉ
-&7-#*&//0//'845#
---4-#%5#--
-#%-6--
" --4 - # -
#%-5
"--#55-5#
5&5+0J
F2c Correction of non-response and sample fluctuation
-5#$5& $ & - ##
$ &6 75 O 4 $
--4 6 --4 # 84 #
&-$#,-%
9 ## - 9 ## % 5& - &
- # 5& : - 9 ## -
5 # 9 4 -
55 & 75 -8
-9-#,#459%54
--64--Ɉ&
- %&
-##-
F3 Results and applications
- # -//0-
%%&-%5 & 4
#-$#-6#
F3a On motorized mobility
-# 5 4-#4-
7#9&8
Tab. B. Aggregate vs. Personal motorized travel consumption in France, 1993.
" --
* )'H + ' ))+
5# !/ F' F0 33
%-7 8 /) +' 0)0 3
G !H ) F+ +3H
%78 / 0+ +!' +0
%7 B-8 0' 'F /F! '+F
*=& 4 )0FF '!F !'F '3F
-
9( 0
- --#7
- - -FF 4 -)F -84--
7---FF 84
F3b On modal shares
-#5-%-79
#8"%--#4-%-
5#-75&458
Tab. C. Weekly usage of motorized transport modes by French household.
--
J
& H) + )F F3
*5 '! '! F0
*& ') ' 30 F'
% '3'! '// ')0 30+H ''H
'++ HH /3' +'30 H'
#-- F F! '30 3H) /
4- '! 0! +0F H3 !
*4& +0 / +'F H
+'F / 033 3! '0
.- F +) +) +F
( F 'H+ 'H+ F'
- +) ) '' )F 0
)+// ''3 !'! '3F FF
7"# 8
F3c Derivation of O-D flows
0) 6 #4 - ++ - 3 6
%-#-E&&4-5#$H'4
--!/)&-FF## $)+J#
2 ##4 - 4 +J# 5
94 - #
5 - ( - -5 6, 0)J- 4 -
&%F+J--$#
F3d Comparison to external data sources
&--//F#5&-%&4#
:
- - -%& ## HFJ# -
%&4)FJ5)!J
%
-
1! .((
#
G The Formulation of Discrete Choice Models
-* 7*8 # - # % % -
55-%%-#--5
#-%#-$ --%%-##
*-##--#
4-%--5#
5%
- # - # # * " # -
# - %5 9
%54 - - % - #
5-% & 96, - #4 5
4%#-&
-#-5&-#-($P
G1 Formulation
G1a Terminology
"-4-##-Q>Q->#
-:%Q>--#7585#4
#--&9%"-4-74&84
- - -Q-> #
5&$ "-9#*-%4
:##5##-
& ; & %& -
&4*%#4
%-5-#--#&,
- % 55 # - # #
- -4###-5#
-#-
5&3 4( # &4= % # 5 7# #
8%#- -##3#(
#45& (31 4 -#,
8474B =1 (3(3 =
"-%4#55=4#
(31 4 %- - (3 B
"-%4#5%# (3 B =
(31 4 4 - - %# -%4
--
-
1! .((
G1b Generic formulae
--#(%3%%5&%5
3(3 @D -- =(3 #(-%3F-- =3 (3 "#
#2 87( 4 { }2 +4 4 - 2 % # %5 33( @D 847 -%#&7 -8#%3
2
2 3(
(3 == 87B
(3 B %54&5&6&--%5&
%5 (3
& * # # - 5 (3 B 9
%5=--5%5,
8474B =1 (3(3 = 4 78
--%# (31 4 %-#5
-6 8474 =3 (3 =1
78 #, - #
4
- & 5 - %
&,-
= ((
(332
2 BB 4 7+8
-- - # 4 (2 - 5 # (
= ( (22 -5#?--5#(4--7&:(;4-#
= ( (33 ( 87BB 7+>8
- 5 # & # L ,
-- 22( B "-4
-&
G1c Discrete choice model under quotient form
"-#4-9# (35 4 --
8474B =1 (3(3 =
=
3 (3
(3
=5
=5
847
847
4
4 708
--6 8474 =3 (3 =1
$ - 4 -- @9D8474 =
(3 ==5 -
= -$-5#-$-#- $-% -$-
#-%
-
1! .((
&
5& # - 3R4+S-
5 3= - % & 7 # 6 8 -
8474 =5 (3 C97 3= 8 =(3 B897897
897
33
3
==
=
+
C
88797
33 == +
-%# - 3 -# 33 == ,
-- -&- 33 == 4--
- --&
Fig. g. Market share of mode k as a function of and 33 == .
F
F!
= 0
=3@=3A
- 4%--
-# (35 4 &-5#-%
-9----
-- ## - 9$9 9$ & -- 9 -
3( - -#%3
#(7# 3( F 3 3( 8,
=(3 B 3( A
>3 (3
3(>3 (3 5
587 7'8
" )*+* )*% 4 - # 3(5 C 3
=' 87@D
5# @D' --&5(&4
9$9- = @D 87 , ,' # F> ,,' 87@D = # F=
9$ &-
+ 87,# F> 87 +, # F=
G1d Discrete choice model under distribution form
* 5 # 5 %5 3(B -
%3-(4-# -#
-
1! .((
=(3 B 8(7 >3BB (33( 7!8
- -4 --(-%$#$7=8
( 3- 3(33( B = - 3 - 3
-%"--%5 333 B = %#
-#4%-(-#-=,
=3 8(7 33 BB C 88(77 3333 738
- 33 < 4-3-#33
33
= $
##4&$%$#$45-
=3 87 7H8
- 4-%-
#
- - 4 -- 3(B
5 # 5 = C + ! (!! 3
== %5 3( -
--% 33( 87 %"-5&4-## C
(3 $ 3( - % 4-
=3 8F(7 33 BB C 887(7 33 == C 887
7
33
== 7)8
- -#57-%8
G1e Compound distribution DCM
5*--%5 3(B #%
&%5
87847 B += 3333 B 7/8
-- 847 %4%5 3 B
%5
-&5$### 3 -"-5&4-
- C (3 $ 3( - C 4 3B 3B %
--
3 C C 8787 7F8
?-#&5D4'@7 '
= 87 D4'@F-8
C %# CK
$#45$##
3 C '
'C 87 C
'
C'C
87
87K
87K
78
-
1! .((
4
G1f Hierarchical DCM
" *4 -# % $
?--%45&5#&5#%
-$4##5-
#%-5
$ -5-4#5%-
55-5-5$ -##5
-&5%#--5-5-55-
&55&5#
-
1! .((
-
%3 (3E 4 --%3%&--
(3(3 EE 44 #%&%3A
-- -#%3( 8(7 44 3EE (3(3 4--%
--5--
(3E 4 & 5 # - % # - * # -
#-%%4&
##
878787 44 ++= (37! !!9
(3 (=3=E
--97:5##45 873= %34
5 87(=! (4&% (3 4
%5
-#-%##%4
% & ? =(3E 4 = @D 4(3E
(37! !!9
(=3= 48787 ++ 64(%
-- 3 - 3 -## (3E 4 4- B #
- ##& 5 - %$#$ # (.%
- 5 # -
---#4%-#
- B 5%%78%$#$
%5 (3 4 # (3 4 = 874(3
(3(3 44 87 --#%3&
- # - & # 5& & # & %5, # -
## # 5% # - 5 -
&> & 9 5 =4 - & - >
%#-%"-#-5&%4-
&5%7#-%58
G2c Derivation of logit and probit model
- 5 5 5 & #
" - 4 & # -- - %5
(3 4 -%155-% 83B7++ pi -
- % 5 # 88979787 += ,,5 -
!HHF > -4 5& (3E 4 - # - &
#4--
8(7 44 3EE (3(3 C
3 (3
(3
E
E
897
897
4
4
"-4---%5
(3 4 %-9#%*-5:
-
1! .((
)
%#- (3 4 "-5&4 (4 (4+ -
% + ++ %&4-#%--55& 8(7 4+4 (( EE
8(7 ++ ++= ?? 8(7 ++ ?? = 8B877++
++ += ?? ---
# %5 +++ + - % # -
%5 +
G2d Derivation of varying parameter DCM
=& * % # & -& -
#-5%5#-
G2e Derivation of nested logit
2-4-%35-$%
- - 5 %% & # 873E C
87B + 33E - 3E 87B 3 7--
--#58
-$%-5%% 8787 += EE
- # &4 - E
879 33 E # # 5 # - $ # - 5 &
4 & 5 15 %5 3 B - %
83B7 +++ pi= 4--
879 33 E C 3 3E 897 4 708
---$#
& 5#-%#-
%5
G2f Economic outreach
- - # - - 9
# - - - 9 - 9
#&4$445&="&
---#&-%-##7=
#-8----
##%$ 7-5--9#%
-8
-
1! .((
+
G3 Case study of the Prado-Carnage tunnel
- ($P * 4 4 $&& -
-*%5&- &6 -
5--%4$#?-
#%-#4-5%#
G3a The economic model and its interpretation
- 5-% 5 - 9 # &, - - -
$ - 5 - %5 - 5 # - -
# " -9# - -$ %
---- ,-&-%-4-
- 9% - 4 - &4 - --
5---
--&-#%#--##$ 5
95&%---$ -
%5- - - # -% 5&
E 7 8 -#-$#5& E 7 8# --&-#&9
#, # E E #7 8 7 8 - % - - 5 #
E E #7 8 7 8 < -%--$#%&--#
--##E7 8 7 8 7 8 = E E# #
?--##&5-$#-5&
#-##4-- -=#%7#-84 .
%$#$4 (# ( -#-4# -
%4 #. . - = # -##5
-#-,
+= 87878(7(8E7 ### .. . 7'8
7'8 # -% $##5 :& -
= - - %5 - -- 9&
G3b Simplified models
-#55##-5
=5& $=-4&
- % #-%5 --$
= - 4 - - 8B787 , += 4 & #
8B7
BB
pi
pi%# +BB 8877
8B7
B
pi
pi pipi
-
1! .((
&
* (
-= 4 4 47 8
(5-= 4 4 47 8
$=4 CF 4 47 8 F
$=4 CF 447 8 F4F
-$= 4 4 4 47 8 F4 F
-$= 4 4447 8 F4F4F
-#= 4 44'47 8 F4'TF
(5-$= 4 4 4 47 8 F4 F
(5-$= 4 4447 8 F4F4F
(5-#= 4 44'47 8 F4'TF
-
9*
&
H Integration of RP and SP data
-#%#(%&55&5&4-&
-&-%-5 4(&552(
5#&
-5%&5(2("#-
- # % % # 2( ( -6 -
-554&-4
#-:#2((-4---
55
H1 An assessment of Revealed and Stated Preferences
H1a The interpretation of RP observations
" &4 2( 5% # ## %5
7#4 % 84 %& $ 4 4
--6-#-&
" - -& #
-4 - 5 # 2% (# - # , - -
5% 5-% # % $ - # 4 $
6-5--%-&5
--%---$ #
# - - - 5% # % -
#%4--&---%$
%#%#5%
- % # 2( - 5% # 5 5 .% -
##&,
#-554
+ - 5:% # 5 5& % $ & ## #-5%4
0 & 5 - - # 5& - & - 9 5& -%$ 4
' 5&5--&7%%84
! 5& %-
-#&--#-
-5-#%#"#
& 9 # - %> - 4 - -
5-%&&-%.%4--%
9&5%42(&45&-&
-5#&5:%5&
-
9*
H1b Evaluation of SP data
( % - 7 4 8 # & &-
--##,
&-4
+ %5-57%5&%4%#&84
0 & 5 %4 # #% %5 #%4
'
.%-%#55&-##5,
#5-&--&-#5%54
+ 5 5 > 5 & 5 5 & - ( %& 7
%5#5-84
0 555%5&-$ 5%5$#
-54-&5---
#-&95&-%
%&4 - #%5&(4 - #
5&55&%-%#4--
5&55&-(#
H2 Basic combinations
- 5 & 5 # # ## 4
&2((%&
H2a Sample weighting
&&5--5#45%4-
#-$5%#
---4-:#
%--%#7-94
4 # 4 5 # --84 & 9
##
-5-#-:-5%---
45:&7%#-8
- #6- ##
5-45:&
$ -#-&
#$95: 4 ---- # -
-
9*
&
H2b Constrained estimation of a statistical model
-#72((8&55:&
# 7 % # %4 6 # #
55854#5% -
-# 9 # - # -4
&5-9#5,-%--#-
.%9# --#
45-&&&%%-#
-#-
H2c Pooling the results of several models
%!%% ! -
#5% 7% 8 -5%
4- !N #-
- 2= !N & 5 & % N 5
5%4 - 6 - # 6 !
&--
6 ! 4 - !N 9&
2=-%9 ! 45&-%
9 !N %-$-
5& @NND@NDN = ! !!! ! - %
9 @ND ! ! .
.% - # - % #
H3 Joint estimation of RP and SP models
-5--##
5%42((
H3a Model specification
# % -5& #
$ 9 5& 34 - % $
95&-5#$ 35&-%, 3*
#52((4 3 #2( 3, #(-%#
-5 3* &%&5%5%4--5&
2
- $## 74 4 8 5 *4 ,%&-#-#3%5&23
3
-
9*
&&
-2(# 222 3333E ++= * #34--(
# 3333
E ++= ,*
"5-4-#5%5&-#-#,
###5%542=4
#-%5 *3 #34*R24S4
155#%5 23 #344
155#%5 3 #34
?&--%##-# 3 5U
F-- +2 %%33
=
- % # C 744 48 - > - #,
(73428C +
+
22
2
897
897
3 33
33
*
*
(7348C +
+
897
897
3 33
33
*
*
H3b Estimation procedure
- - 5 5& -9 --4- -
#-#-2(( -
5%4 - ##4
- # -5% - - 5& -
%9#
-# -ǰ#- -##--
4-#-,
*96-( -5*
*
+ *96 - 2( - - & 22*2 3333E ++=
* 4
& *N *N *N C ** NB *N C *
* NB
0 (-2((5%#% 3
* 3, 5&*N 4NN 4
NN
NN
-
9*
&
H3c Prediction with the joint model
(&55-5--2(((&4-
#-2(4--5#%#
-:
--#3%
22 NNNN 33333E +++= ,*
H3d Discussion
% - 5% # : %
-
--%78& # -5
%5& # - # 5 , 7 # % 5 8I "#
% - - - % # - -
#5
" - & # 4 - - 5
4#5-I-#- -%5# - # %5 4 -# -
#5--5--4-
# # 5 - % & # & 5
--%
-4:&2((&-
5-2(5-(45-(
& - & & 5 - 5& - # - 45&-#-2(5-(
-
(
&4
I References
I1 In English
%VG5&.7//98&%T
# (* 1!4 30$H' (24
1 4 . ( 25 1 7/)'8 & # 1-
= =- # ( (4 =
/)H4+$+)
.4=.V. 7//+8 (F32
01% 1%0$((( 1% ( - H-
*#-27#/+F!382-4?-4
+!
.-&&*7/)!8'(#+42-4
?-
4 7//38 & # 4- ##
- & 5 % # 4 (* #&
1!G
*4-4(24
47//)8
( (*!!
2-4./B04)/$+F'
*&4. &*4##7//+8%#="
( & ###((4= 03F4
'3$'/
* 4 4 $ % * W G 7//8 1(* (
* ( ( ( - HF-
*#-2-4?-
4 . *4 G5 G? - 1 7/H)8 * - #
%&((4=3HH4H0$H3
=V 5 V 7//)8 & - #:
#((:((4=3H4!3$30
2? -$-% 7/)/8 " # "&$
%&((4=+034+0$00
&4*(4XW4? 7/))8 (G% (*%
.4=4
2 7/)08 1(* 9
* .2( 2 /00 24
?-
? ? 7/)/8 *- &-6 *9 # " .-& %
#V&$$? ((4=+034
!F$!)
-
(
&-
?4(4X*-4*V 7//+8 # $
9 #%&('4/0B04
H$/0
?&&4 ?V4 .4V 4 X 4 V 7/)8 ## %5&
% ( **
:*!;4'H0$'HH
I2 In French
4V*4V7//)8!A/HA!
!(*02--"2Y++0"24
644*-4(4*4&47//H8%4##Z
%&[P#!34'0$3F
- 7//F8 9*6 ( ( L
(
-P4(
.%4 7//08- %4 PP P P8
( /4+)4)$/)
.%47//)88(!!6*I6 A
6++4J
(($12%"2>*
7//08K(!(6(!/(((
6I(66/++#"22-
2\3H"247!FA8
*4V7//H8>]4!343$)
*4 V *##4 V 7//H8 5P P #Z4 ( PP
P%!34/$+3
417//F86I
6/-4(
?4.4X?42V7//8/4(
2 7//H8 % !3 !H 2% PP >]
PP //0$/' >P V(
#P:[P