Subproject II: Robustness in Speech Recognition

Members (1/2)Hsiao-Chuan Wang (PI)National Tsing HuaUniversity

Jeih-Weih Hung (Co-PI) National Chi Nan University

Sin-Horng Chen National Chiao Tung University Jen-Tzung Chien (Co-PI) National Cheng Kung University

Lin-shan LeeNational Taiwan University

Hsin-min WangAcademia Sinica

Members (2/2)Yih-Ru WangNational Chiao Tung University

Yuan-Fu LiaoNational Taipei University of Technology

Berlin ChenNational Taiwan Normal University

Research Theme Lexical level

Signal Level

Model LevelSignal ProcessingFeature Extraction & TransformationSpeech Decoding including Word Graph RescoringAdaptive Language ModelsAdaptive Pronunciation LexiconAdaptive HMM ModelsOutput Recognition ResultsInput speech

Research RoadmapCurrent Achievements Future Directions & ApplicationsSpeech enhancement & wavelet processingSpeech recognition in differentadverse environments, e.g. car, home, etc.Microphone array and noise cancellation approachesRobust broadcast news transcriptionLecture speech recognitionSpontaneous speech recognitionNext generation automatic speech recognitionPowerful machine learning approaches for complicated robustness problemsCepstral moment normalization & temporal filtering &Discriminative adaptation foracoustic and linguistic modelsMaximum entropy modeling &data mining algorithmRobust language modeling

Signal Level ApproachesSpeech EnhancementHarmonic retaining, perceptual factor analysis, etc.

Robust Feature RepresentationHigher-order cepstral moment normalization, data-driven temporal filtering, etc.

Microphone Array ProcessingMicrophone array with post-filtering, etc. Missing-Feature ApproachSub-space missing feature imputation and environment sniffing, mismatch-aware stochastic matching, etc.

Higher-Order Cepstral Moment Normalization (HOCMN) (1/3)Cepstral Feature Normalization Widely UsedCMS: normalizing the first momentCMVN: normalizing the first and second momentsHEQ: normalizing the full distribution (all order moments)How about normalizing a few higher order moments only?Disturbances of larger magnitudes may be the major sources of recognition errors, which are better reflected in higher order moments

Higher-Order Cepstral Moment Normalization (HOCMN) (2/3)Experimental results : Aurora 2, clean condition training, word accuracy averaged over 0~20dB and all types of noise (sets A,B,C)(a)(b)CMVN(1st and N-th moments normalized)

Energy TermMFCCDeltaAcceleration

BaselineBaselinelogE

1HOCMN_Even OrderC0HOCMNchange Order

2HOCMN_Even OrderlogEHOCMNchange Order

3HOCMN_Odd(3) + Even OrderC0HOCMNchange Order

4Segmental HOCMNC0SegHOCMNchange Range

5Segmental HOCMN_Even OrderC0SegHOCMNchange Order

6Segmental HOCMN_Odd(3) + Even OrderC0SegHOCMNchange Order

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean0.00clean0.00clean0.000.000.00%

20db0.0020db0.0020db0.000.000.00%

15db0.0015db0.0015db0.000.000.00%

10db0.0010db0.0010db0.000.000.00%

5db0.005db0.005db0.000.000.00%

0db0.000db0.000db0.000.000.00%

-5db0.00-5db0.00-5db0.000.000.00%

Avg.0.000.000.000.000.00Avg.0.000.000.000.000.00Avg.0.000.000.000.00

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean0.00clean0.00clean0.000.000.00%

20db0.0020db0.0020db0.000.000.00%

15db0.0015db0.0015db0.000.000.00%

10db0.0010db0.0010db0.000.000.00%

5db0.005db0.005db0.000.000.00%

0db0.000db0.000db0.000.000.00%

-5db0.00-5db0.00-5db0.000.000.00%

Avg.0.000.000.000.000.00Avg.0.000.000.000.000.00Avg.0.000.000.000.00

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

4.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.54.56.56.5

11

119

11

11

11

11

11

poseidons:MIRS

poseidons:MIRS

poseidons:

poseidons:

poseidons:

poseidons:MIRS

poseidons:MIRS

Baseline

11111

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

22222

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

33333

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

44444

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

55555

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

66666

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

77777

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

88888

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

99999

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%

0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%0db26.019.2814.4618.0516.950db10.9617.8414.4111.5713.700db25.4222.9124.1717.090.00%

-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%-5db11.181.579.399.607.94-5db3.4710.468.238.457.65-5db11.8211.1511.498.530.00%

Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06Avg.69.4949.8960.6065.3961.34Avg.52.5961.5253.2555.6355.75Avg.66.1666.1166.1460.06

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

BaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_ABaselineMFCC_E_D_A

Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.Multi Set_AMulti Set_BMulti Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.6898.5298.3998.4998.52clean98.5098.5898.5498.520.00%

20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%20db97.6197.7398.0397.4197.7020db96.8797.5897.4497.0197.2320db97.3096.5596.9397.350.00%

15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%15db96.4797.0497.6196.6796.9515db95.3096.3196.1295.5395.8215db96.3595.5395.9496.290.00%

10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%10db94.4495.2895.7494.1194.8910db91.9694.3593.2992.8793.1210db93.3492.5092.9293.790.00%

5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%5db88.3687.5587.8087.6087.835db83.5485.6186.2583.5284.735db82.4182.5382.4785.520.00%

0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%0db66.9062.1553.4464.3661.710db59.2961.3465.1156.1260.470db46.8254.4450.6359.000.00%

-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%-5db26.1327.1820.5824.3424.56-5db25.5127.6029.4121.0725.90-5db18.9124.2421.5824.500.00%

Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39Avg.88.7687.9586.5288.0387.82Avg.85.3987.0487.6485.0186.27Avg.83.2484.3183.7886.39

Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%Impro.0.00%0.00%0.00%0.00%

1010101010

Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.Clean Set_AClean Set_BClean Set_CAvg.Imp.

SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.SubwayBabbleCarExhibitionAvg.RestaurantStreetAirportStationAvg.SubwayStreetAvg.

clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean98.9399.0098.9699.2099.02clean99.1498.9799.0699.030.00%

20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%20db97.0590.1597.4196.3995.2520db89.9995.7490.6494.7292.7720db93.4695.1394.3094.070.00%

15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%15db93.4973.7690.0492.0487.3315db76.2488.4577.0183.6581.3415db86.7788.9187.8485.040.00%

10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%10db78.7249.4367.0175.6667.7110db54.7767.1153.8660.2959.0110db73.9074.4074.1565.520.00%

5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935db51.2749.2150.2438.610.00%5db52.2026.8134.0944.8339.485db31.0138.4530.3327.9231.935d