study tours report (final)byt.cevre.gov.tr/pictures/files/editor/document/project...technical...
TRANSCRIPT
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
1
Service Contract Number: TR2010/0327.04-01
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large
Combustion Plant Directive
Study Tours Report (Final)
Turkey (May 2016)
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
2
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
3
Document Lead Sheet
Client Project No: TR2010/0327.04-01
FW Project No: 1-BH-0511A
Document No: BH0511A-00-16F
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive
STUDY TOURS REPORT
ISSUE DATE ORIG
APPROVED
FW / PM
APPROVED CLIENT
DISTRIBUTION DESCRIPTION
A 21/05/2016 RCF, RB PS, JM CFCU, MoEU, PSC
Draft for Client Comments
B 29/06/2016 RCF, RB PS, JM UF MoEU Final version
C
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
4
Project Title: Contract Identification Number: Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive
EuropeAid/132843/D/SER/TR
Service Contract Number: Contract Value: TR2010/0327.04-01 € 998,033.00 Date of Project Commencement: Date of Project Completion: 22 July 2014 24 months Contracting Authority: Contact Person: Central Finance & Contract Unit (CFCU) Eskişehir Yolu 4. Km 2. Cd. (Halkbank Kampüsü) No: 63 C-Blok 06520 Söğütözü-Ankara/TURKEY
Ms. Emine Döğer, PAO-CFCU Director [email protected]
Coordinating Body, Key Beneficiary: Contact Person: Ministry of Environment and Urbanization Ceyhun Atıf Kansu Cd. Ehlibeyt Mah.1271. Sok. No:13 06520 Balgat/ANKARA +90 312 5863056 (T) +90 312 4740335 (F)
Ms Betül Aydın [email protected]
Consultant: Contact Person: Consortium AMEC Foster Wheeler, Lead Partner Via Caboto 15 Corsico - Milan Italy - 20094 +39 02 44862175 (T) +39 02 44863112 (F) Project Management Ltd Killakee House, Belgard Square Dublin 24, Ireland +353 1 4040700 (T) +353 1 4599785 (F)
Mr Paolo Sammartino, Project Manager [email protected] Mr Jim McNelis, Project Director [email protected]
Project Office Address: Team Leader:
Ӧveçler Mahallesi 1314 Caddesi No: 18/6 Çankaya/ Ankara Turkey
Mr Rob Bakx +90 312 4961601 (T) +90 312 4961605 (F) [email protected]
Date of report: 21 May 2016 Author(s) of report: Russell Frost, Rob Bakx The content of this report is the sole responsibility of the Consultant and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the European Union. Adjustments imposed to the report – made during the consultations on the draft text – without the consent of the Consultant fall under the responsibility of those who imposed these adjustments.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
5
Table of Contents
GLOSSARY OF TERMS 7
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 9
1. CONTEXT OF THE STUDY TOURS 11
2. STUDY TOURS PREPARATION AND LOGISTICAL ASPECTS 13
3. STUDY TOUR PROGRAMMES 14
4. IMPLEMENTATION AND EVALUATION OF THE STUDY TOURS 17
5. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS 18
ANNEX A STUDY TOUR 1, ITALY (22 – 26 JUNE 2015) 19 PROGRAMME 19 PRESENTATIONS 23
EURAL Energy – New co-generation plant 23 IED Directive in Italy 32 Voghera Energia – 400 MW Combined Cycle Power Plant 41 Environmental data: public access to information 49 Emissions monitoring 53 Regulatory framework and environmental context in Lombardy 66 Liberalisation of the energy market in Italy and the role of Lombardy region 78 Sannazaro Refinery 84 ISPRA – Large Combustion Plants 119 Overview of IPPC/IED implementation in Italy 123
PARTICIPANTS 137 PHOTO IMPRESSION OF THE STUDY TOUR 138 EVALUATION 139
ANNEX B STUDY TOUR 2, FINLAND (22 – 26 FEBRUARY 2016) 143 PROGRAMME 143 PRESENTATIONS 147
AMECFW – Company Overview 147 EU environmental legislation changes and their effects 158 Air pollution Control in Finland 180 Environmental permit 188 LCP Directive and NERP – Implementation in Finland 192 General presentation of the Finnish Ministry of Environment 198 HELEN Ltd. Towards a carbon neutral future 201 Salmisaari Power Plants 209 Emission monitoring and reporting at HELEN 216 Reduction of NOx emissions in coal power plants 220 Information exchange role of SYKE – LCP BREF process 234 Integrated assessment modelling of particulate matter in Finland 241
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
6
Roles of SYKE 248 Finnish Environmental Administration 255 LCP Emission Inventory 268 Finnish Environmental Institute - SYKE 272 Vantaa Energy 277 Co-operation with authorities 285 VTT – Technical Research Centre of Finland 288 Utilisation of CFD modelling to design low NOx combustion 292 Combustion process development 297 Finnish Emission monitoring procedures 304
PARTICIPANTS 320 PHOTO IMPRESSION OF THE STUDY TOUR 321 EVALUATION 322
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
7
Glossary of Terms
Acquis Environmental Acquis – the collective body of EU Environmental Legislation
BAT Best Available Techniques
BREF BAT Reference Document
CCGT Combined Cycle Gas Turbine
CSCP Centre for Sustainable Consumption and Production
EEA European Environment Agency
E-PRTR European Pollutant Release and Transfer Register
EU European Union
EÜAŞ Electricity Generation Company Inc.
EV Emission Values
IED Industrial Emissions Directive
IPPC Integrated Pollution Prevention and Control
LCP Large Combustion Plant
LCPD Large Combustion Plant Directive
MENR Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources
MoEU Ministry of Environment and Urbanisation
MoEUA Ministry of Environment, Urbanisation and Agriculture (Finland)
MS Member State
NOx Nitrogen Oxides
RIA Regulatory Impact Assessment
SCR Selective Catalytic Reduction
SNCR Selective Non-Catalytic Reduction
SO2 Sulphur Dioxide
ToR Terms of Reference
VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
8
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
9
Executive Summary
This Report documents the implementation of the ‘Study Tours’ element of the project: ‘Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive’ in Turkey. Two five-day Study Tours were held to EU Member States, the Member States determined and agreed with the main Beneficiary in accordance with ToR criteria. One was to Italy in June 2015 and one was to Finland in February 2016. They were attended by a total of fifteen (15) participants from the Project Beneficiaries. The study tours were designed to expose participants to alternative institutional arrangements for implementing the EU’s Large Combustion Plant and Industrial Emissions Directives. Also, to provide an opportunity – assisted by LCP site visits - to see how LCPs may be operated in compliance with these Directives; and to enhance their technical understanding of emissions prevention and control technologies and monitoring / reporting systems. In addition, the programmes were designed to provide opportunities for participants to discuss LCPD / IED implementation arrangements, structures and issues with their EU counterparts – in the Ministries of Environment and Regional Agencies in particular. Participants evaluated both study tours. Overall, they gave ‘satisfactory’ to ‘good’ scores with the exception of scores for logistics and accommodation that received just ‘sufficient’ scores on average. The accommodation was selected in line with the criteria in the project Terms of Reference (ToR) but, according to the received evaluation forms, it was not to the satisfaction of all participants. The study tours were successful in achieving the objective of helping participants to understand the institutional structures in Italy/Finland for implementing legal requirements related to large combustion plants – scores of 8.8 and 9.0 out of ten respectively for Italy and Finland. But their success in helping participants to better understand the challenges to be faced by Turkish institutions was mixed: scores of 8.3 for the tour to Italy and 5.0 for the tour to Finland. The average conclusion of the participants who submitted evaluation forms scored ‘good’ on their perception that ‘the study tours were time well spent’. Observations made during the study tours will be kept in mind by the Consultant when preparing draft guidance materials, as part of project Component 3, that relate to implementing the LCP aspects of the Industrial Emissions Directive.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
10
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
11
1. Context of the study tours
The project ‘Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive’ aims to support Turkey in approximating towards the EU acquis in the sector of LCPs. The project’s overall objective is to improve the protection of human health and the environment in Turkey by implementation and enforcement of the EU’s Large Combustion Plant Directive. This overall objective will be reached through the project purpose that aims to support Turkey with establishing the necessary capacity to implement the LCP Directive in the country. In practical terms, this concerns the implementation of the new emission standards for LCPs, which under the EU’s new Directive on Industrial Emissions (IED) apply from the 1st of January 2016, replacing those previously applicable under the LCP Directive of October 2001. One of the project components (Result 3 as per ToR) is the definition of an institutional structure with procedural arrangements, and the development of technical capacity, for implementing the LCP Directive. To achieve this result four activities are being or have been implemented:
1. Suggest an institutional structure with procedural arrangements for LCPD implementation;
2. Implementation of a training programme;
3. Dissemination workshops;
4. Study tours.
This report refers to the work implemented under the fourth activity in the above list. For the work done under each of the other activities separate reports are prepared. The project ToR describe activity four (4) of component 3 as follows: ‘Consultant should organise two study tours to two different member states (in total) in which LCPD has been implemented for more than 5 years. The selected MSs should also be ones that report their emission inventory containing EVs of LCPs to the E-PRTR via Reportnet regularly for the last two years. For the selection of the MS to be visited, and other details, the main beneficiary will make the final decision. During the study, in order to increase the awareness regarding the LCPD, the participants could visit the department of the MS that is dealing with the environment (i.e. environment agency or equivalence) where they could be informed about the structure of the department, system established for the inventory of LCPs, reporting mechanism to EEA in scope of LCPD and so on. In addition, participants should be able to visit an LCP to identify how the LCPD is implemented, what and how the reporting is realised, the control mechanisms to meet the requirements of the LCPD, and so on.’ The ToR then refer to ‘Table 1’ for further workshops details. Table 1 includes the following text:
Study Visits
Two at least one-week long study tours should be organized to at least two different EU countries, which should
have been EU members since 2000, and where the EU LCP and IPPC Directives have been successfully
implemented (LCPD has been applied for more than 5 years and their emission inventory containing EVs of LCPs
has been reported regularly to the E-PRTR via Report.net for the last two years). The tours should occur at the
time of RIA preparation if possible. The participants should visit the authorities that are responsible for the
implementation of LCPD, IPPCD and, if available, cleaner production centres and organisations carrying out
practical activities in this field.
[The study tours should be attended by] two different groups of 10 persons involved in the implementation of the
project and the representing personnel of all the Beneficiaries, mostly in MoEU.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
12
Involved experts: 2 key experts
Locations: should be determined accordingly.
In ‘Table 2’ on page 23 of the project ToR, under 2.3, it is furthermore described that ‘It is expected that Consultant should prepare short report following each facilities like workshops, trainings and study tours including overall assessment of the related activities, important points to be noted, problems and appropriate solutions regarding the encountered problems, participants list, main aim of the activity and so on.’ In fulfilling this ToR requirement, two five-day study tours have been implemented:
1. Italy (Milan and Rome) 22-26 June 2015
2. Finland (Helsinki) 22-26 February 2016
This Study Tours Report collects and describes all information for the two Study Tours in a coherent and accessible manner to allow readers to have a full overview of the visits that were undertaken as an integral part of project component 3.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
13
2. Study tours preparation and logistical aspects
First drafts of the programmes of each of the two 5-day Study Tours were drawn up by the Consultant, submitted for comments to the main Beneficiary - the MoEU - and adjusted according to their comments received. At an early project stage the Consultant planned dates and locations for the project study tours which were submitted to the Beneficiary for approval. Based on their comments some adjustments were made to the planning. It was agreed that the Study Tours would be organised as per the table below.
Name workshop Date Location
Study tour 1 22 – 26 June 2015 Italy: Milan and Rome
Study tour 2 22 – 26 February 2016 Finland: Helsinki
As per project ToR the Consultant took care of all travel and accommodation arrangements. These arrangements were preceded by the following steps:
Suggestions of the Consultant to the main Beneficiary regarding possible study tour participants;
A List of Invitees compiled by the main Beneficiary, sent to the Consultant;
An Invitation Letter sent out by the main Beneficiary to all persons/institutions on the List of
Invitees, requiring the invitees to get administrative approval from their institutions if they wished to participate;
Administrative follow-up by the Consultant taking reactions with an interest to participate received
from invitees;
Final accommodation and travel arrangements were made by the Consultant for those invitees
expressing a wish to participate and having administrative approval to do so. The table below respectively shows the numbers of persons invited as per List of Invitees of the main Beneficiary, the number of invitees that reacted showing their positive interest to join the study tour, and the number of invitees that were actually present as per travel and accommodation lists. It furthermore shows the number of study tour participants coming from the various public institutions other than the main Beneficiary. Two officials from EÜAŞ, and one from MENR, were interested to participate in the study tour to Finland. However, they were unable to get official approval from their Ministry in time, so were not able to attend this study tour.
Name workshop
Number of invitees On List
of Invitees
Interested to
participate
Present at the Tour
From MoEU
From MENR
From EÜAŞ
Privatisation Authority
Study tour 1 - Italy
9 9 9 4 1 3 1
Study tour 2 - Finland
10 9 6 6 0 0 0
Total 19 19 15 10 1 3 1
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
14
3. Study tour programmes
For each study tour programme, the Consultant provided a proposal. Each of these proposals was adjusted in line with the comments received from the main Beneficiary. The workshop programmes are included at the beginning of Annexes A and B to this Report. The programmes comprised presentations and interactive sessions with speakers from the host organisations and visits to large combustion plants in the electricity generation sectors of the two countries. The participants in each study tour were accompanied by two project experts (Dr Russell Frost and Mrs Darinka Belić), who were present throughout. Staff of AMEC Foster Wheeler Milan and Helsinki also accompanied the study tours, in Italy and Finland respectively. The programmes of each study tour were designed with four main objectives in mind:
1. Gaining an understanding of the institutional structures in Italy and Finland for implementing legal requirements related to large combustion plants.
2. Improve the participants’ understanding of the institutional responsibilities and structures required for the transposition and implementation of the EU acquis regarding LCPs.
3. Help participants to better understand the potential challenges to be faced by Turkish institutional structures in control of LCP operations
4. Strengthening the participants’ technical understanding of how large combustions plants operate
in the EU. The programme for Study Tour 1 was supported by presentations and two site visits. See below for the institutions visited, speakers and topics/visits:
Speaker Organisation Topic
Mr. Massimo Zanasso AMEC Foster Wheeler Implementation of Industrial Emissions Directive (IED) in
Italy
Mr. Silvio Arienti AMEC Foster Wheeler Coal-fired cogeneration plant (steam and electricity) for
Eural Energy using circulating fluidised bed combustion and
SOx control technology: design experience
Mr. Franco Gasparino AMEC Foster Wheeler Voghera Energiia combined cycle gas turbine plant:
permitting aspects
Mr. Fabio Romeo ISPRA, on behalf of the Ministry of
Environment, Land and Sea
Large Combustion Plants: legislation and legislative aspects
Ms. Nicoletta Valeria
Trotta
ISPRA, on behalf of the Ministry of
Environment, Land and Sea
Overview on IPPC/IED implementation in Italy focused on
Large Combustion Plants (2001/80/EC – 2010/75/EU
(Chapter III – Annex V)
Mr. Mario Nova Director, DG Environment, Energy
and Sustainable Development,
Lombardia Regione
Welcome address
Mr. Fabio Colonna ARPA Lombardia (Environmental
Protection Agency of Lombardy),
on behalf of Lombardia Regione
The regulatory framework and environmental context in
Lombardy
Mr. Paolo Lopinto Innovhub, SSI Emission monitoring under 2010/75/EU (IED)
Mr. Roberto Canobio DG Environment, EESD Energy and
Grids Department, Lombardia
Regione
Liberalization of the energy markets in Italy and the role of
Lombardy Region
Ms. Maria Teresa
Cazzaniga ARPA Lombardia, on behalf of
Lombardia Regione
Environmental Data: Public Access to information
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
15
Mr. Claudio Zanelli Representative of Health, Safety
and Environment Department, ENI
Sannazzaro: petroleum oil refinery
Sannazzaro oil refinery: overview of the plant, its
combustion units and emissions performance
Mr. Marcello Pasquale
with the support of
AMECFW staff (Mr.
Silvio Arienti and Ms.
Rosella Cerioli)
Plant manager, Voghera Energiia
CCGT Plant
Verbal prese tatio o the CCGT pla t’s desig , operatio al performance and the challenges faced.
Facility Date of Site Visit
ENI Sannazzaro: petroleum oil refinery Wednesday 24 June 2015
Voghera Energiia: combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT) power
generation plant
Voghera Energiia: combined cycle gas turbine (CCGT) power
generation plant
A copy of the slideshows that were used during the above presentations can be found in Annex A to this Report. The programme for Study Tour 2 was supported by presentations and two site visits, the latter to coal-fired plants. A large pilot-scale facility for the thermal processing of biomass (Bioruukki) was also visited. See below for the institutions visited, speakers and topics/visits
Speaker Organisation Topic
Mr. Markku Kostamo AMEC Foster Wheeler, Espoo AMEC FW Global Power Group Company overview
Mr. Kalle Nuortimo AMEC Foster Wheeler, Espoo Environmental legislation changes & effect in Europe
Ms. Hannele Pokka Secretary General, Ministry of
Environment, Urbanisation and
Agriculture (MoEUA)
Welcome address: introduction to environmental legislative
developments in Finland
Ms. Oili Rahnasto Ministerial Councellor, Head of
Unit, Emissions and Risks, MoEUA
General presentation of the Ministry of the Environment
Mr. Jaakko Kuisma Senior Specialist, MoEUA Air pollution control in Finland
Ms. Anneli Karjalainen Ministerial Adviser, MoEUA LCP Directive (2001/80/EC) and NERP - implementation in
Finland
Mr. Teemu Lehikoinen Senior Adviser, Regional State
Administration Agency for
Southern Finland
Environmental permitting
Mr. Jyri Seppälä Director, Centre for Sustainable
Consumption and Production
(CSCP) of the Finnish
Environmental Institute (SYKE)
Finnish Environmental Institute (SYKE)
Mr. Kimmo Silvo CSCP, SYKE Pollution prevention and control roles of SYKE, Centre for
Sustainable Consumption and Production (CSCP)
Ms. Kristina Saarinen Air Emissions Team of CSCP, SYKE LCP emission inventory
Mr. Kaj Forsius SYKE Best Available Techniques (BAT) Information Exchange Role
of SYKE: LCP BREF process
Mr. Niko Karvosenoja Air Pollution and Climate Change
Mitigation group, SYKE
Integrated assessment modelling (IAM) of fine particulate
matter (PM) in Finland
Mr. Ilkka Hiltunen VTT, Technical Research Centre of
Finland
VTT in brief and Bioruukki Piloting Centre
Ms. Tuula Pellikka VTT, Technical Research Centre of
Finland
Finnish emission monitoring procedures
Mr, Matti Nieminen, VTT, Technical Research Centre of Combustion process development
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
16
presenting on behalf of
Mr. Toni Pikkarainen
Finland
Mr. Lars Kjäldman Research Team Leader, CFD
Modelling, VTT Technical Research
Centre of Finland
Utilization of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) modelling
to design low-NOx combustion
Mr. Markku Saukkonen HELEN, Salmisaari Welcome to HELEN (Helsinki Energiia)
Ms. Henrietta Lahti HELEN, Salmisaari Salmisaari A and B plants (coal-fired electricity and heat
generation)
Ms. Anna Häyrinen HELEN, Salmisaari Emission monitoring and reporting at HELEN
Mr. Reima Rynö HELEN, Salmisaari Reduction of NOx emissions in coal power plants: Salmisaari
SCR and Hanasaari SNCR
Mr. Pekka Karjalainen Vantaan Energia Vantaan Energia: introduction
Mr. Samuli Bjorkbacka Vantaan Energia Martinlaakso power plant (coal-fired, electricity and heat
generation)
Mr. Pekka Karjalainen Vantaan Energia Cooperation with public authorities
Facility Date of Site Visit
HELEN, Salmisaari B coal-fired generating plant Tuesday 23 February 2016
Vantaan Energia: Martinlaakso coal-fired generating plant Thursday 25 February 2016
VTT, Bioruukki Piloting Centre for biomass thermal processing Friday 26 February 2016
A copy of the slideshows that were used during the above presentations can be found in Annex B to this Report.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
17
4. Implementation and evaluation of the study tours The study tours were implemented according to schedule, although with some flexibility as concerns the timing of the different topics, to allow for putting accents and having more in depth discussion on topics of interest to the audience. During each of the study tours consecutive translation was provided. In general, question and answer sessions were held after each presentation, though in most cases spontaneous exchange of thoughts occurred during the presentations. The Consultant moderated sessions where helpful to stimulate discussion and raise pertinent questions on behalf of the participants. Each study tour commenced with a country and technical overview provided by AMEC Foster Wheeler’s country experts. These introductory sessions were helpful in providing a context for subsequent meetings with institutions and site visits. The study tours included meetings with the Ministries of Environment and subsidiary environmental regulatory institutions in both Italy and Finland. This helped the participants to understand and consider the arrangements for LCPD implementation in these countries. Site visits were also arranged (see the programmes), which enabled participants to exchange views with operators and obtain a broader understanding of the issues at stake. Both study tours were evaluated, receiving overall ‘satisfactory’ to ‘good’ scores with the exception of scores for logistics and accommodation that received just ‘sufficient’ scores on average. The accommodation was selected in line with the criteria in the project Terms of Reference (ToR) but, according to the received evaluation forms, it was not to the satisfaction of all participants. The study tours were successful in achieving the objective of helping participants to understand the institutional structures in Italy/Finland for implementing legal requirements related to large combustion plants – scores of 8.8 and 9.0 respectively for Italy and Finland. But their success in helping participants to better understand the challenges to be faced by Turkish institutions was mixed: scores of 8.3 for the tour to Italy and 5.0 for the tour to Finland. The average conclusion of the participants who submitted evaluation forms scored ‘good’ on their perception that ‘the study tours were time well spent’.
Study tour
Participants
Present on the
study tour
Evaluation forms
submitted
Av. score for study
objectives
Average score for quality
Average score for ‘Time well
spent’
Average score for logistics
Overall average
score
1 - Italy 9 9 8.1 6.6 7.1 5.3 7.4
2 - Finland 6 6 7.3 7.8 9.0 6.0 7.6
Total 18 15 7.7 7.2 8.1 5.7 7.5
Table. Overall evaluation results Study Tour. Scores represent numbers on a scale of 1 to 10
Detailed evaluation scores for each study tour have been included in Annexes A and B of this report and were also annexed to the project’s Progress Reports 4 and 7.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
18
5. Conclusions and recommendations
Conclusions 1. The study tours have contributed to a better understanding within public administrative institutions of
the institutional framework and responsibilities for the environmental regulation of large combustion plants in two mature EU Member States;
2. Participants observed how LCPs should operate in accord with LCPD / IED and of their emission reporting requirements;
3. The study tours have contributed to strengthened understanding on a range of technical aspects in practice related to LCPD / IED implementation including: BAT for NOx control, especially primary
NOx control measures under variable load conditions and the advantages / disadvantages of SCR and SNCR for secondary NOx abatement; flue-gas desulphurisation technologies; using biomass as a (partial) feedstock to LCPs; Transitional National Plans; underground storage facilities (for coal feedstock); the common-stack approach; other aspects of BAT selection; and the assessment of whether monitored emissions comply with ELVs;
4. Representatives of the different public administrative institutions (environment, energy and privatisation) entered into dialogue during the study tours and built on their network contacts;
Recommendations 1. Utilise the observations made on the study tours to develop guidance materials, as part of project
Component 3, that relate to the process of implementing the LCP Directive / IED, the Flexibility
Mechanism, ELV guidance and BAT for LCPs.
2. Participants are encouraged to disseminate the knowledge they have gained from these study tours to others in their respective public administrative institutions.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
19
ANNEX A Study Tour 1, Italy (22 – 26 June 2015)
PROGRAMME
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
20
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
21
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
22
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
23
PRESENTATIONS
EURAL Energy – New co-generation plant
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
24
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
25
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
26
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
27
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
28
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
29
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
30
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
31
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
32
IED Directive in Italy
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
33
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
34
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
35
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
36
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
37
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
38
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
39
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
40
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
41
Voghera Energia – 400 MW Combined Cycle Power Plant
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
42
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
43
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
44
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
45
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
46
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
47
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
48
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
49
Environmental data: public access to information
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
50
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
51
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
52
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
53
Emissions monitoring
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
54
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
55
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
56
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
57
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
58
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
59
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
60
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
61
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
62
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
63
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
64
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
65
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
66
Regulatory framework and environmental context in Lombardy
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
67
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
68
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
69
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
70
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
71
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
72
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
73
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
74
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
75
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
76
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
77
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
78
Liberalisation of the energy market in Italy and the role of Lombardy region
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
79
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
80
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
81
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
82
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
83
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
84
Sannazaro Refinery
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
85
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
86
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
87
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
88
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
89
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
90
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
91
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
92
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
93
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
94
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
95
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
96
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
97
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
98
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
99
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
100
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
101
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
102
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
103
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
104
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
105
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
106
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
107
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
108
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
109
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
110
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
111
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
112
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
113
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
114
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
115
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
116
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
117
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
118
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
119
ISPRA – Large Combustion Plants
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
120
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
121
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
122
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
123
Overview of IPPC/IED implementation in Italy
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
124
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
125
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
126
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
127
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
128
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
129
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
130
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
131
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
132
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
133
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
134
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
135
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
136
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
137
PARTICIPANTS
Name and Surname Title Institution Telephone
Number
E-mail Address
1 Ülkü Füsun ERTÜRK
Head of the Division
Ministry of Environment and
Urbanization
0312 586 30 32
2 Derya
SARIOĞLU
Chemist Ministry of
Environment and
Urbanization
0312 586 31 53
0530 281 45 24
3 Sezin ÇALIK
ÇEPE
Expert Ministry of
Environment and
Urbanization
0312 586 31 46
0505 811 81 48
4 Nazan ÖZYÜREK Expert Ministry of
Environment and Urbanization
0312 586 32 94
0530 284 04 15
5 Ayhan
KABAKTEPE
Head of the
1st Project
Department
Group
Privatization
Administration
0 312 585 83 25
0 532 714 38 44
6 Tolga YILDIZ Head of the
Department
Electricity
Generation
Company
0 532 473 85 72 [email protected]
7 Selma SEVGÖR Electricity Generation
Company
0 532 712 80 97 [email protected]
8 Ayberk KIRBIYIK Electricity
Generation
Company
0 537 306 37 44 [email protected]
9 Ergün KOÇ Engineer Ministry of
Energy and
Natural
Resources
0 312 212 64 20
/7615
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
138
PHOTO IMPRESSION OF THE STUDY TOUR
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
139
EVALUATION
Evaluation STUDY TOUR 1, 22 – 26 June 2015, Italy
Statistical Information
1.1 Workshop Study Tour 1 - Italy
1.2 Name and Surname of Participant (evaluator)
OVERALL SCORE
Your expectations
Please indicate to what extent specific expectations were met, or not met:
My Expectations
My expectations were met Scor
e Fully
(10 points) Partially
(5 points) Not at all (0 points)
(80)
8.8
1. Understanding of the institutional structures in Italy regarding development and implementation of legal requirements related to large combustion plants.
IIIII II (70)
II
(10)
(75)
8.3 2. The Study tour has helped
to better understand the institutional responsibilities and structures required for the transposition and implementation of the EU acquis regarding LCPs.
IIIII I (60)
III (15)
(75)
8.3 3. The Study tour has helped
to better understand the potential challenges to be faced by Turkish institutional structures in control of LCPs operations.
IIIII I (60)
III (15)
(65)
7.2 4. The Study tour has
strengthened the technical understanding on how large combustions plants operate in the EU.
IIII
(40)
IIIII (25)
8.1 AVERAGE TOTAL SCORE
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
140
Seminar and Presentations Please rate the following statements in respect of this study tour:
Score Aspect of Workshop Excellent
(10) Good
(8) Average
(6) Acceptable
(4) Poor (2)
Unacceptable (0)
(60)
6.6
1. The study tour achieved the objectives set
IIIII (40)
II
(12)
II
(8)
(56)
6.2
2. The quality of the study tour was of a high standard
IIIII (40)
I
(6)
II
(8)
I
(2)
(66)
7.3
3. The content of the study tour was well-suited to my level of understanding and experience
I
(10)
IIIII (40)
II
(12)
I
(4)
(56)
6.2
4. The study tour was interactive and networking could be achieved
II
(10)
III
(24)
III
(18)
I
(4)
(66)
7.3
5. The facilitators were well-prepared and knowledgeable on the subject matter
I
(10)
IIIII (40)
II
(12)
I
(4)
(66)
7.3
6. The duration of the different components of the study tour were neither too long nor too short
I
(10)
IIIII (40)
II
(12)
I
(4)
(48)
5.3
7. The logistical arrangements (accommodation, meals, refreshments, equipment) were satisfactory
IIII
(32)
I
(6)
I
(4)
III (6)
(64)
7.1
8. Attending this study tour was time well spent
I
(10)
IIIII (40)
I
(6)
II
(8)
6.6 AVERAGE TOTAL SCORE
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
141
Comments and suggestions
Study tour Sessions:
Duration of Question-Answer periods could be longer.
It is appropriate for studies, permits, evaluations, and those who prepare report, make decision on the issues to be present during trainings; in addition to that, it may be more beneficial for experts who conduct, examine these studies, take duty in decision making mechanism on the side of Turkey, to take part in direct applications for longer time for information and experience transfer.
Presentations related to issues were pretty successful.
Study tour sessions have been satisfactorily successful, especially those to LCP’s in Italy, and subjects on how and based on which directives they have been managed. Presentations were pretty explanatory and informative. Also, the matters on how existing institutions work and how they make their inspections were adequately understandable.
Meetings sessions with competent authorities, Ministry and Regional administrations could be longer.
We have learned from presentations what institutions are involved in IPPC applications (and how these institutions have been formed). However, it was observed that a procedure and time list do not exist as in Turkey, and this varies in accordance with the characteristics of the installation. It was understood that local, National authorities and committees forward the matter to Ministry in this order. However, there exist other issues such as; at what stage the unaccepted matters go to an upper institution, and if the application should be initiated from the beginning again or not. How does a plant owner follow these procedures? Maybe, permit application of an X company could be explained as an example. In Turkey, time and procedure standards can be seen in one chart. And this provides convenience for plant owner very much. Of course, Italy has developed the best system under all those experiences. However, through this example, we could better understand these transitions and the one that performs a more effective control. Note: I wrote these comments within a limited time. I apologize for grammatically incorrect and imperfect sentences. I would like to thank all of those who provided this experience to us and to all participants.
During sessions, more time could be reserved for question-answer periods. Allowing short period of time for questions or pressure on asking the questions at the end of presentations were not nice at all.
Trip to refinery was not efficient at all. Authorized staff of plant should be informed about the content and expectations. The presentation was away from our focus point and was in detail. As asking questions have insistently been prevented (by project expert) (by showing time limitation as an excuse), we did not have a chance to guide (direct) the subject and the time was used inefficiently.
Everything was OK about sessions. Hotel accommodations were strict for us. It was too far from central. We couldn’t manage time arrangement, in relax time.
Facilitators:
Facilitators were satisfactory in both accommodation and transfer issues. However, I
believe that it is beneficial to review the matters such as quality and vicinity to city center in the selection of accommodation places, once again.
Our hotel in Milan had surely been selected because of its close location to Amec
Foster Wheeler. However, service was very poor in all areas.
Since hotels in Milan and Rome were pretty away from city center, we have spent
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
142
most of our time on transportation. Hotels at central locations could be preferred.
The hotel in Milan was out of town and had hygiene problem. The third morning, I
woke up with bites of insects. I learned from the reception that it might be an insect coming from wood furniture in the room (I think it is chinch/bedbug). The receptionist changed my room with a reserved room for someone else who is going to start staying at the hotel, and this was a careless approach to continue to use the room
with insect. The hotel in Rome was clean and beautiful, but away from city center. „As the most important”, the other factors in the organization (food, payments etc.) should be shared with participants a week or weeks before the tour and necessary adjustments should be made in common sense. Otherwise, during site visit, it is dealt with making the decisions, changing, discussing, adjusting and uncertainty. This
steals from time and efficiency.
Facilitators have helped to better understand the EU practices. But, I have expected
to see thermal power plant facilities especially based on coal.
Study tour level and content:
Sufficient
I think the level and content of the study tour were satisfactory. However, I believe
that it is especially necessary that the study group should be supported with private sector.
As the tour was very fine, a site trip to a thermal power plant could also be arranged.
The presentations and sincerity during our site visits were very successful. Of course,
we had our experiences all on Thermal power plant area. A visit to a Thermal power plant could be useful, as well. It was understood that there wasn’t a Thermal power plant in close proximity geographically. I hope, this group may have a chance to visit
such a plant next time. May a regional competent authority officer, a plant owner accompanies our group? (During the visit)
I would like to talk especially about: When presentations and site visits are over, it
could be much more efficient to make a meeting (maybe for 1-1,5 hours) that our group members may share their opinions and suggestions, the experience they gained on the day’s activities. At the same time, we could be prepared prior to tomorrow’s (next day’s) presentation based on our branches.
More plant visits could be arranged.
Natural Gas Combined Cycle Plants are in the same condition in our country. We
have visited the sister plant of this one in Ankara, and the one with a very similar
technology in İzmit. If we could visit a solid fuel combustion plant using coal instead of natural gas, it could be more beneficial. On the other hand, visit to refinery was not efficient. Meetings with official institutions and the one at AMEC FW were very good, but the plant visits were not satisfying.
The study tour has helped to better understanding on how large combustion plants
operate in EU and especially in Italy with technical guys and samples.
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
143
ANNEX B Study Tour 2, Finland (22 – 26 February 2016)
PROGRAMME
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
144
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
145
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
146
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
147
PRESENTATIONS
AMECFW – Company Overview
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
148
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
149
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
150
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
151
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
152
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
153
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
154
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
155
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
156
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
157
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
158
EU environmental legislation changes and their effects
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
159
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
160
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
161
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
162
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
163
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
164
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
165
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
166
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
167
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
168
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
169
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
170
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
171
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
172
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
173
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
174
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
175
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
176
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
177
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
178
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
179
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
180
Air pollution Control in Finland
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
181
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
182
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
183
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
184
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
185
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
186
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
187
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
188
Environmental permit
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
189
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
190
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
191
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
192
LCP Directive and NERP – Implementation in Finland
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
193
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
194
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
195
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
196
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
197
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
198
General presentation of the Finnish Ministry of Environment
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
199
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
200
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
201
HELEN Ltd. Towards a carbon neutral future
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
202
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
203
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
204
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
205
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
206
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
207
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
208
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
209
Salmisaari Power Plants
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
210
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
211
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
212
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
213
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
214
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
215
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
216
Emission monitoring and reporting at HELEN
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
217
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
218
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
219
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
220
Reduction of NOx emissions in coal power plants
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
221
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
222
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
223
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
224
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
225
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
226
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
227
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
228
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
229
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
230
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
231
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
232
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
233
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
234
Information exchange role of SYKE – LCP BREF process
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
235
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
236
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
237
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
238
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
239
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
240
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
241
Integrated assessment modelling of particulate matter in Finland
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
242
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
243
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
244
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
245
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
246
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
247
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
248
Roles of SYKE
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
249
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
250
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
251
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
252
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
253
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
254
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
255
Finnish Environmental Administration
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
256
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
257
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
258
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
259
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
260
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
261
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
262
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
263
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
264
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
265
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
266
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
267
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
268
LCP Emission Inventory
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
269
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
270
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
271
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
272
Finnish Environmental Institute - SYKE
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
273
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
274
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
275
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
276
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
277
Vantaa Energy
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
278
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
279
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
280
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
281
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
282
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
283
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
284
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
285
Co-operation with authorities
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
286
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
287
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
288
VTT – Technical Research Centre of Finland
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
289
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
290
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
291
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
292
Utilisation of CFD modelling to design low NOx combustion
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
293
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
294
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
295
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
296
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
297
Combustion process development
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
298
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
299
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
300
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
301
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
302
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
303
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
304
Finnish Emission monitoring procedures
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
305
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
306
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
307
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
308
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
309
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
310
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
311
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
312
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
313
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
314
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
315
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
316
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
317
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
318
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
319
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
320
PARTICIPANTS
Name and Surname Title Institution Telephone
Number
E-mail Address
1 Mr. Mücahit
De irtaş
Deputy
Under-
secretary
Ministry of
Environment and
Urbanization
2 Mrs. Çiğde Bayrak
Deputy Chief of
Cabinet
Ministry of Environment and
Urbanization
3 Mrs. Ülkü
Füsun Ertürk
Head of
Division
Ministry of
Environment and
Urbanization
0312 586 30 32 [email protected]
4 Mrs. Sezi Çalık Çepe
Expert Ministry of
Environment and
Urbanization
0312 586 31 46
0505 811 81 48
5 Mrs. Nazan
Özyürek
Expert Ministry of
Environment and
Urbanization
0312 586 32 94
0530 284 04 15
6 Mrs. Elifcan
Ka atlı Apaydı Expert Ministry of
Environment and
Urbanization
0312 586 31 43 [email protected]
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
321
PHOTO IMPRESSION OF THE STUDY TOUR
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
322
EVALUATION
Evaluation STUDY TOUR 2, 22 – 26 February 2016, Finland
Statistical Information
1.1 Workshop Study Tour 2 - Finland
1.2 Name and Surname of Participant (evaluator)
OVERALL SCORE
Your expectations
Please indicate to what extent specific expectations were met, or not met:
My Expectations
My expectations were met Score Fully
(10 points) Partially
(5 points) Not at all (0 points)
(55)
9.2
5. Understanding of the institutional structures in Finland for implementing legal requirements related to large combustion plants.
IIIII (50)
I
(5)
(40)
6.7 6. The Study tour has helped
to better understand the institutional responsibilities and structures required for the transposition and implementation of the EU acquis regarding LCPs.
II (20)
IIII (20)
(30)
5.0 7. The Study tour has helped
to better understand the potential challenges to be faced by Turkish institutional structures in control of LCP operations.
IIIII I (30)
(50)
8.3 8. The Study tour has
strengthened the technical understanding on how large combustions plants operate in the EU.
IIII
(40)
II
(10)
7.3 AVERAGE TOTAL SCORE
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
323
Study tour and Presentations Please rate the following statements in respect of this study tour:
Score Aspect of Workshop Excellent
(10) Good
(8) Average
(6) Acceptable
(4) Poor (2)
Unacceptable (0)
(50)
8.3
9. The study tour achieved the objectives set
II
(20)
III
(24)
I
(6)
(44)
7.3
10. The quality of the study tour was of a high standard
I
(10)
III
(24)
I
(6)
I
(4)
(46)
7.7
11. The content of the study tour was well-suited to my level of understanding and experience
II
(20)
I
(8)
III
(18)
(42)
7.0
12. The study tour was interactive and networking could be achieved
I
(10)
II
(16)
II
(12)
I
(4)
(50)
8.3
13. The facilitators were well-prepared and knowledgeable on the subject matter
III
(30)
I
(8)
II
(12)
(52)
8.7
14. The duration of the different components of the study tour were neither too long nor too short
III
(30)
II
(16)
I
(6)
(36)
6.0
15. The logistical arrangements (accommodation, meals, refreshments, equipment) were satisfactory
I
(10)
III
(18)
II
(8)
(54)
9.0
16. Attending this study tour was time well spent
IIII
(40)
I
(8)
I
(6)
7.8 AVERAGE TOTAL SCORE
Technical Assistance for Better Air Quality by Transposing the Large Combustion Plant Directive, Contract no. TR2010/0327.04-01 – Study Tours Report (Final) This Project is co-financed by the European Union and the Republic of Turkey
324
Comments and Suggestions
Study tour Sessions:
There was some trouble about translation. Due to constant changing of project’s language assistants, translator had difficulty in some translations. Although this issue is indicated before, recruitment of an expert translator is not done. The sessions were good. Especially at VTT, really nice information was given.
The duration of the sessions was sufficient and relevant with the Study Tour. From the institutions and organizations which are visited, some evaluations relevant to project were taken. Pretty good.
Facilitators:
The team has comprehensive knowledge about the subject and they are eager.
Extremely successful.
The translator could be better. A better hotel could be arranged. The hotel rooms
were too small, cold and far away from the city.
There was some trouble about translation. Translation has not been made
completely. Some of the subjects were passed without completely translated- briefly. There was a brief translation in technical subjects which were explained in detail.
Logistic opportunities and organization should be more satisfying.
Generally, organization team has sufficient background relevant to study tour aims.
There were some minor flaws about car organization and translation.
Study tour level and content:
I took quite an advantage even if I don’t know the subject at all. Good.
Some technically useful facilities were visited.