strunk second supplement declaration w exhibits 11 thru 12 dcd 08-cv-2234 082510

8/9/2019 Strunk Second Supplement Declaration w Exhibits 11 Thru 12 DCD 08-Cv-2234 082510

1/35


2/35

StrunkSecondSupplementalDeclarationPage1of7

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURTFOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA---------------------------------------------------x )Christopher-Earl:Strunkinesse,)593VanderbiltAve.281BrooklynN.Y.11238 )Telephone(845)901-6767 )

Plaintiff,))

v. )Civil Action No.: 08-2234 (RJL))

U.S.DEPARTMENTOFSTATEetal.) )

Defendants.))

---------------------------------------------------x PLAINTIFFS SECOND SUPPLEMENT DECLARATION IN OPPOSITIONTO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT TO DISMISSI,Christopher-Earl: Strunk in esse,declareunderpenaltyofperjury,pursuantto28U.S.C.1746:

1.ThisisthesecondandfinalsupplementdeclarationwithExhibits11

through12annexedthataresubmittedinaccordancewithandbyleaveof

theCourtsorderofAugust9,2010thatPlaintiffrespondbyAugust26,

2010toDefendantsMotionforSummaryJudgment;andthisdeclaration

supplementstheAugust8,2010PlaintiffresponseDeclarationwithExhibits

1through5includingthesupportingaffidavitofPhilipHansJacobsenwith

ExhibitAthroughFaffirmedAugust5,2010andPlaintiffsSupplement

DeclarationwithExhibits6through10annexedofAugust18,2010in


3/35


oppositiontoDefendantsNoticeofMotionandMemoranduminSupportof

DefendantsMotionforSummaryJudgmenttoDismissbyAssistantU.S.

AttorneyBrighamJ.Bowen(Counsel)withDepartmentofStatesupporting

declarationsofAlexGalovichActingDirectoroftheOfficeofInformation

andProgramsandServicesoftheUnitedStatesDepartmentofState

(DOS)andDorothyPulloDirectoroftheFreedomofInformationDivision,

OfficeofinternationalTrade,U.S.CustomsandBorderProtection(CBP)

datedJuly29,2010.

2.ThatonAugust21,2010PlaintiffwascontactedbyWilliamA.RichardsonofChattanoogaTennesseeinregardstohisindependent

researchdoneinregardstotheallegationthattheGeneralServices

Administration(GSA)gavedirectiontoDOStodestroypassportrecords

statedbyJonathanM.Rolbin,DirectoroftheOfficeofLegalandLaw

EnforcementLiaisonBureauofConsularAffairsPassportServicesinthe

matterwithCaseControlNumber200807238withtwelvepagesof

documentsattachedintheJuly29,2010DOSFOIAresponseletter(the

Letter)withthepartialreleaseofdocumenttoPlaintiffsFOIArequestfor

StanleyAnnDunham.

3.ThatMr.RichardsonproducedaswornAffidavitwithExhibitAthroughDannexedtheretoexplaininghisresearchdonewithGSAand


4/35


NARAinregardstotheLetter,andreceivedAugust25,2010thatPlaintiff/

DeclarantincorporatesafaxcopyinthissecondsupplementseeExhibit 11with Sub-exhibits A through D;andthatwhenPlaintiffreceivestheoriginalbymailitwillbeforwardedseparatelybyjudicialnoticetotheCourt.

4.ThataccordingtotheinvestigationdonebyMr.RichardsontheGSAofficiallydeniesgivinganyGSAdirectivetoDOStodestroyDOS

documents,andthatasaresultofMr.RichardsoneffortsfromAugust2,

2010throughAugust21,2010hadbeenincorrespondencewithGSA

representativeElizabethKelley(seeExhibit 11 sub exhibit C)GSAProgramManagementOfficerfromAugust3,2010throughAugust12,

2010;

5.ThatMr.RichardsaffidavitanddirectinvestigationwiththeGSAsElizabethKelleyinregardstowhatGSAcontrollingauthorityaretoissue

directivestoDOSisquiteclear,GSAhasnosuchauthorityandthatthe

GSAcounselisdiscussingtheDOSLetterallegationofsuchdirective

accordingly;andgoestotheDOSfrauduponthisCourtherein.

6. ThatonAugust22,2010PlaintiffwascontractedMr.JacobsenasanexpertwitnesstocorroboratethepossibilityofsuchaDOS/GSAdirective

todestroyrecordsandwasunabletofindany.

7.ThatAugust16,2010,infurtheranceoftheinvestigationofthefraud


5/35


uponthecourtherein,Mr.JacobsenrequestedanexpeditedFOIArequest

oftheNationalArchivesinCollegeparkMarylandinfurtheranceof

discoveryofevidenceofDefendantsfraudupontheCourt(seeExhibit 12).8.TheFOIArequestsallPassengerandorCrewlists,BOTHArrivaland

DepartureinformationforBOTHvesselsandairplanesidentifiedasRecord

Group85attheNationalArchives,recordsoftheImmigration&

NaturalizationService,1787-2004forpartiesshownonExhibit12,quote:

Therecordssoughthereinmeetthree(3)generalclassifications:1.Thoserecordsoutsideofthe50yearrestrictionwindowand,assuch,theserecordsshouldbeavailableforunrestricteduse.2.Thoserecordswithinthe50yearrestrictionperiodbutthatpertaintodeceasedindividualsand,assuch,theserecordsshouldbeavailableforunrestricteduse.3.Thoserecordswhichfallwiththe50yearrestrictionperiodandrelatetoalivingperson.Whiletheserecordsareordinarilyexemptfromdisclosure,Ihereinclaimapublicinterestandcompellingneed

toverifygovernmentintegrityandthateachoftheseconcernsout-weighstheaforementionedrestrictionsTheDOJFreedomofInformationGuide,Exemption6,statesthat:

"OnepurposethattheFOIAwasdesignedforisto"checkagainstcorruptionandtoholdthegovernorsaccountabletothegoverned.Indeed,informationthatwouldinformthepublicofviolationsofthepublictrusthasastrongpublicinterestandisaccordedgreatweightinthebalancingprocess...DOJGuidecitationsomitted.

IrequestEXPEDITEDPROCESSINGofthisrequest.Inaccordancewithlaw,whenthesubjectisofwidespreadandexceptionalmediainterestandtheinformationsoughtinvolvespossiblequestionsaboutthegovernment'sintegritythataffectspublicconfidenceExpeditedProcessingispermitted.Inthisinstantcasethe


6/35


overwhelmingconcernoftheAmericanpublicconcerningboththeeligibilityofBarackObamatobePresidentaswellasthelargenumberofquestionsaboutthegovernment'sintegrityinvettingPresidentObama.Inadditiontherecent(andapparentlywellfounded)allegationsthattheUSGovernmenthas"Spoliated"recordsfromtheUSStateDepartmentpassportrecordsofthePresident'smother,StanleyAnnDunhamhasputthepublictrustandintegrityofitsgovernmentintoquestion

9.ThatPlaintiffbaseduponinformationbycertainproofhasshownthereisamatterofspoliationofevidence,publicrecordsandmisstatement

inanegregiousfrauduponthisCourtsupportedbyMr.Jacobsensand

otherpartiesrequestforrecordsthatshouldbetheinterestofthisCourt

thattheybereleasedbecausetherecurrentlyexistsanoverwhelming

publicinterestinobtainingtheinformationrequestedaboveandadesireby

meandthegeneralpublictoknowwhothePresidentis.Plaintiffbelievesit

isunprecedentedinthehistoryoftheUnitedStatesthatthelife,historyand

backgroundofasittingpresidenthasbeensowellhidden,sealedand

obfuscatedasithaswiththisPresident;andfurther,asCommander-in-

Chiefofthemostpowerfulmilitaryintheworldtoday,andasaPresident

whoopenlydeclaresthathewantsto"fundamentallychangetheUnited

States,"thepublicinterestfaroutweighshispersonalprivacyinterest.

ThereisnoverifiableevidenceinthepublicrecordthatPresidentObama


7/35


wasevervettedtoholdtheofficeofPresident;andthattheinformation

requestedhereinmayshedlightontheextentandscopeofthefraudupon

thisCourtastothespoliationandcover-upthathasoccurredduringthis

FOIAactionhereinastotheeligibility,orineligibilityofMr.Obarnatobe

PresidentoftheUnitedStates;andPlaintiff/Declarantbelievesthe

balancingprocessweighsheavilyforreleaseofhisrecords,andthatthe

informationrequestedcouldprovethatthisPresidentisineligibletohold

theofficeofPresidentandprovethatthepublictrusthasbeenviolated,and

continuestobeviolated,nowrestswiththisCourtaloneherein.

10. WhereforePlaintiffaswiththeprecedingDeclarationandSupplementwithMOLandbaseduponalltheexhibits1through12wishes

anexpandedorderoftheCourtdenyingDefendantsmotionforsummary

judgmenttodismisssubjecttoamoredefinitestatementoffactsincluding

grantofasecondamendedcomplaintexpandingthesearchofyearsfrom

November29,1942throughNovember7,1995byorderofDefendantsand

theiragenttoprovideinthematteroffurtherdiscoveryofevidenceofthe

frauduponthiscourt:

(a)anylegalcontrollingauthorityfortheallegeddestruction;

(b)anychainofcustodyofanyofthedocumentstobeprovidedand

orallegeddestroyed;


8/35


9/35

Strunkv.U.S.DepartmentofStateetal.DCD08-cv-2234(RJL)

STRUNK DECLARATION IN OPPOSITION TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT

SECOND SUPPLEMENT DECLARATION

Exhibit 11


10/35


11/35


12/35


13/35


14/35


15/35


AFFIDAVIT of William Richardson

Exhibit A


16/35

Print | Close Window

Subject: Fwd: RE: gsa.gov Response [T201008020027]

From: william richardson

Date: Sat, Aug 21, 2010 10:59 am

To: [email protected]

---------- Forwarded message ----------From:

Date: Aug 2, 2010 1:32 PMSubject: RE: gsa.gov Response [T201008020027]To:

[GSA8000][GSA2008]

Thank you for contacting the General ServicesAdministration (GSA).

We have received your inquiry regarding GSA's directivespertaining to passport during January 1980 to December1989.

We are forwarding your message to another member of ourteam who will respond to the questions raised in your

message. You should receive a response within two to fivebusiness days.

We hope you find this information helpful.

Regards,gsa.gov Response Team=======================================We regret that we are unable to accept replies sent to ourmailbox. If you have any further questions about thegovernment, please do not hesitate to call our NationalContact Center at 1.800.FED.INFO (1.800.333.4636), Mondaythrough Friday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. ET, or send usanother message through our web form at:http://www.gsa.gov/contactus/

-----------------------------------------------------------Sender : [email protected] Number : T201008020027Z1047934Pool : GSA.govSent to : [email protected] : 8/2/2010 10:44:38 AM-----------------------------------------------------------Failed search and need assistance. I am seaching for all GSA directives pertaining to passports from Jan.1980 to Dec. 1989. These directives would include but not limited to, policy retention changes, managementand handling of passport records, destruction of passport records policy, derived from the GSA during theaformentioned time frame. You may send me the link for such review and/or email me the GSA Directivespertaining to the said date and timeframe requested. Sincerely, William [FORMGEN]

Copyright 2003-2010. All rights reserved.

Page 1 of 1Web-Based Email :: Print

8/21/2010http://email06.secureserver.net/view_print_multi.php?uidArray=3...


17/35



Exhibit B


18/35


Subject: Fwd: Re: your inquiry


Date: Sat, Aug 21, 2010 11:01 am


---------- Forwarded message ----------From: "william richardson"

Date: Aug 3, 2010 12:32 PMSubject: Re: your inquiryTo:

Thankyou Eleni,

I was having difficulty identifying the approprate department for my request as it is not listed on the GSAwebsite.

If you have any questions please feel free to contact me.

Thank you for your continued efforts.

William

> > On Aug 3, 2010 9:24 AM, wrote: > > Greetings, I wanted to let you know t...





19/35



Exhibit C


20/35


Subject: Fwd: Re: Your voice message re: your request for information


Date: Sat, Aug 21, 2010 11:03 am


---------- Forwarded message ----------From: "william richardson"

Date: Aug 11, 2010 2:22 PMSubject: Re: Your voice message re: your request for informationTo:

Hi Beth,

I originally received your email response after our phone call. Once read, it is no longer available and I cannot find it inmy email.

Also, I responded back to your email information, and that too is lost, not showing a send.

Could you please resend your responce information to me, I dearly appreciate it Beth.

Sincerely,

William

> > On Aug 10, 2010 3:11 PM, wrote: > >

> Good afternoon, Mr. Richardson -- I apologize -- I must have written your phone number down incorr...





21/35



Exhibit D


22/35


Subject: Fwd: Re: GSA Info on passports


Date: Sat, Aug 21, 2010 11:13 am


---------- Forwarded message ----------

From: "william richardson" Date: Aug 11, 2010 11:41 AMSubject: Re: GSA Info on passportsTo:

Thankyou Beth,

Yes, I am aware of the site and information you sent, I appreciate your efforts and conversation to clarify.

The website I am refering too, and promised to send, is:

http://www.archives.gov/genealogy/passport/

Part 1: Introduction

Passport applications can be an excellent source of genealogical information especially about foreign-born individuals.The National Archives and Records Administration (NARA) has passport applications from Oct. 1795-Mar. 1925; the U.S.Department of State has passport applications from Apr. 1925 to the present

As quoted from their website.

As stated in our phone call, I do have access and have done research over the years with my family history and theirimmigration. I am amazed that I had no problems in the past obtaining records from the latter 1920's when part of myfamily immigrated to the U.S., but ran into a barrier for the 1950, 60 and 70 era, but have the 80's to present. This makesno logical sense, least to me.

Of course as I pointed out, blamed the GSA directive given sometime in the 80's, but could not specify.

I may have to turn my search over to a professional geneologist at some point. For now, I am simply looking for thatdirective to destroy records.

Thank you so much Beth for your assistance and directions.

Sincerely,

Wiliam

On Aug 11, 2010 10:16 AM, wrote:

Good morning, William -- great to speak to you a few minutes ago andhave you clarify your request for me! After we spoke, I went on theDepartment of State website and found the information below on howto request passport records (from 1925 to present or before 1925) (youmay have already been on that site). I've also included some NationalArchives and Records Administration (NARA) websites for yourinformation! The "National Archives" was part of GSA from 1949 to




23/35

1985, when it become NARA. Hope to talk to you later! Thanks, BethKelley

REQUESTING PASSPORT RECORDS:http://www.travel.state.gov/passport/npic/npic_872.html

There are two options for obtaining copies of your passportrecords:1. Passport Records for Issuances 1925 Presenta. Requesting Your Own RecordPassport Services maintains United States passport recordsfor passports issued from 1925 to the present. These recordsnormally consist of applications for United States passportsand supporting evidence of United States citizenship, and are

protected by the Privacy Act of 1974, (5 USC 552(a)).Passport records do not include evidence of travel such asentrance/exit stamps, visas, residence permits, etc., since thisinformation is entered into the passport book after it is issued.

The Privacy Act allows you to obtain copies of records in yourown name and the records of your minor children. To requestthese records, please submit a typed or clearly printedNOTARIZED request that provides:

1. Your full name at birth and any subsequent namechanges and/or the full name of your minor child or children, ifyou are requesting their records;2. Your date and place of birth and/or those of your minorchild or children;3. Your current mailing address;4. Your current daytime telephone number;5. Your current e-mail address, if available;6. Your reason for the request;7. The dates or estimated dates your passports wereissued;8. Your passport numbers or any other information that willhelp us locate your records; and9. A copy of requestor's valid photo identification




24/35

There is a $50.00 fee to search for your passport record. Acheck or money order made payable to Department of State"must be included with your request.b. Certified Passport RecordsCertified copies of passport records may be requested. If you

would like a certified copy of a passport record, thecertification fee is $50.00. Checks or money orders should bemade payable to Department of State".c. Third-Party RequestsThird party requests must include one of the following:1. Notarized consent from the owner of the passportrecords,2. Proof of guardianship,3. Death certificate, or4. Court order signed by a judge of competent jurisdictionrequesting the Department of State to release passportrecords.The only exception to this requirement is when the owner ofthe passport records was born 100 years or more ago. Yourthird party request does not have to be notarized but shouldinclude the information described in the section above thatcovers requesting your own record and a $150.00 search fee

for each individual for whom a record search is requested.Checks or money orders should be made payable toDepartment of State".d. Mailing AddressAll requests for passport records issued from 1925 to presentshould be mailed to:Department of StatePassport ServicesResearch and Liaison Section

Room 5001111 19th Street, N.W.Washington, DC 20524-1705 (202) 955-0447

2. Passport Records for Issuances Prior to 1925




25/35

The National Archives and Records Administration maintainrecords for passport issuances prior to 1925. You may write tothem at the following address:

National Archives and Records Administration

Archives 1Reference Branch8th & Pennsylvania Ave. NWWashington, DC

ABOUT NARA:

http://www.archives.gov/publications/general-info-leaflets/1.html

Passport Controls (this provides federal agencies with theretention requirements for passport registers, applications filesand reports to Department of State):

http://www.archives.gov/about/records-schedule/chapter-07.html

702 Passport Controls

Documents, accumulated by the

officially designated custodian,relating to the issuance of officialpassports and visas for NARA

employees. Included are themaster register, requests forpassports, transmittal letters,

copies of covers of passports,receipts, and related records.

702-1

Master register. Cut offannually.

Destroywhen 10years old.




26/35

Passport Statistics (numbers of passports issued) (I found thisinteresting!):

http://travel.state.gov/passport/ppi/stats/stats_890.html

Elizabeth I. KelleyProgram Management Officer

Office of Program Performance (CD)Office of the Chief People Officer (C)General Services Administration1800 F Street, N.W., Room 3133Washington, D.C. 20405Phone: (202) 208-2963Blackberry: (202) 527-3040

(N1-64-87-1)

702-2

Application files. Destroywhen 3

years old ORuponseparationof the

bearer,whichever isSOONER.(GRS 9,

item 5a)

702-3

Reports to the Department of Stateconcerning the number of official

passports issued and relatedmatters.

Cut offannually.

Destroywhen 1 yearold. (GRS 9,item 5b)




27/35

Fax: (202) 219-1141e-mail: [email protected]





28/35


STRUNK DECLARATION IN OPPOSITION TO SUMMARY JUDGMENT

SECOND SUPPLEMENT DECLARATION

Exhibit 12


29/35

August 16,2010

Philip H. Jacobsen1158 Thalia StreetSan Diego, CA 92 154- 1955(619) 424-3385jacobsen2@,cox.net

VIA email to: specialaccess FOIA@,nara.gov

Freedom of Information Act OfficerNational Archives860 1Adelphi Road Room 3 110College Park, MD 20740-600 1

RE: FOIA REQUEST-EXPEDITED PROCESSINGDear FOIA Officer:This is a request under the Freedom of information Act.I request that I be provided with a copy of the documents (or documents that contain thefollowing information) as follows:Passenger andlor Crew lists, BOTH Arrival and Departure information for BOTHvessels and airplanes identified as Record Group 85 at the National Archives, records ofthe Immigration& Naturalization Service, 1787-2004.According to the NARA description these documents are further described as follows:

This series of ship passenger and crew lists consists of orms provided to theImmigration and Naturalization Sewice (INS) by shipmasters ofvessels.. arriving or departing various sea and airports.. On both shippassenger and crew lists, the typical information includes: name of the vesseland shipmaster, ports of arrival and embarkation, and dates of arrival (andoccasionally of departure). Passenger lists provide the full name, age, sex,marital status, occupation, citizenship (nationality), last place of residence,final destination, and, ifan immigrant were going to oin a relative, thatperson's name, address, and relationship to the passenger. Some manifestsindicate the cabin number and class. Crew lists provide the ull name of eachcrew member, position, length of sewice at sea, citizenship (nationalityl,literacy, age, sex, height and weight, any physically distinguishing marks, thedate andplace of employment, and whether the crew member was to be


30/35

discharged or paid off at the port of arrival. Later lists or both passengersand crew may include passport numbers andor types of visas.Besides vessel passenger and crew lists, this series contains orms for airlinepassenger and crew manifests. These orms were submitted to the INS by thecaptain of each airplane that last departedfiom a US.airport. Both theairline passenger and crew manifests contain the aircra.ft identification,captain's name, and dates and airports of departure and arrival. For eachalien or citizen passenger, the record usually provides the person's name;citizenship; US. address; passport, visa, or other immigration documentnumber; and may note the person's date and place of birth, destination, andbaggage details. For each crew member, the record usually provides theperson's name; position on the airplane; citizenship;passport, visa, or otherimmigration document number; and may note age and gender.

The records sought herein meet three (3) general classifications:1. Those records outside of the 50 year restriction window and, as such, these recordsshould be available for unrestricted use.

2. Those records within the 50 year restriction period but that pertain to deceasedindividuals and, as such, these records should be available for unrestricted use.

3. Those records which fall with the 50 year restriction period and relate to a livingperson. While these records are ordinarily exempt from disclosure, I herein claim apublic interest and compelling need to verify government integrity and that each ofthese concerns out-weighs the aforementioned restrictions.

Therefore, I am requesting all records described hereinabove for the following persons,including all AKA'S.

1. Stanley Ann DunhamDOB: 11/29/1942SSN: 535-40-8522Aka Stanley Ann Obama

Stanley Ann Dunham SoetoroStanley Ann SoetoroDr. StanleyAnn Dunham SoetoroAnn SoetoroAnn Dunham Sutoro

Time period requested: 01/01/1960 through 07/01/1983.Stanley Ann Dunham- Obama is the deceased mother of the President of the UnitedStates, Barack Obama. It is common knowledge that she is deceased and she is listed inthe Social Security Death Index as deceased under her Social Security Number.

2. Madelyn Lee Payne DunhamDOB: 10/26/1922


31/35

SSN: 558-20-7458Time period requested: 0 110 111960 through 0710 1/1983

Madelyn Payne Dunham is the grandmother of the President of the United States, BarackObama. It is common knowledge that she is deceased and she is listed in the SocialSecurity Death Index as deceased under her Social Security Number.

3. Stanley Amour DunhamDOB: 03/23/1918SSN: 5 14-03-4824Time period requested: 0110 1/1960 through 0710 111983

Stanley Amour Dunham is the grandfather of the President of the United States, BarackObama. It is common knowledge that he is deceased and he is listed in the SocialSecurity Death Index as deceased under his Social Security Number.

4. Barack Hussein Obama SeniorDOB: 0410411 936SSN: None knownAka: Barack Hussein Obama.Time period requested: 0 110 111 959 through 12/24/1982

Barack Obama Senior is the father of the President of the United States, Barack Obama.It is common knowledge that Barack Hussein Obama Senior is deceased as he died in acar crash in Nairobi, Africa on 11/24/1982.

5. Barack Hussein Obama I1DOB: 08104/6 1SSN: VariousAka: Barack Hussein Obama, Barry Soetoro, Barry Obama, Barry Soebarkah.Barack SoebarkahTime period requested: 0 110 111 96 1 through 0710 1/1983

Barack Hussein Obama is the living President of the United States and I do not have athird party privacy act release fi-om him.I believe his records should be released because there currently exists an overwhelmingpublic interest in obtaining the infomation requested above and a desire by me and thegeneral public to know who the President is. I believe it is unprecedented in the history ofthe United States that the life, history and background of a sitting president has been sowell hidden, sealed and obfuscated as it has with this President.Further, as Commander-in-Chief of the most powerful military in the world today, and asa President who openly declares that he wants to "fundamentally change the UnitedStates," the public interest far outweighs his personal privacy interest. There is noverifiable evidence in the public record that President Obama was ever vetted to hold the


32/35

office of President. The information requested herein may shed light on the eligibility, orineligibility of Mr. Obarna to be President of the United States. I believe the balancingprocess weighs heavily for release of his records. The information requested could provethat this President is ineligible to hold the office of President and prove that the publictrust has been violated, and continues to be violated, What greater public interest couldpossibly exist than the possibility that a fkaud has usurped the Office of President, whonow has control over the greatest military on earth and has his finger hovering over thebutton that could release the most powerful nuclear holocaust ever known to man andwho now controls the destiny of each and every American citizen?The DOJ Freedom of Information Guide, Exemption 6, states that:

"One purpose that the FOIA was designed for is to "check against corruptionand to hold the governors accountable to the governed. Indeed,information that would inform the public of violations of the public trust has astrong public interest and is accorded great weight in the balancing process.0 ' 9 . DOJ Guide citations omitted.

I request EXPEDITED PROCESSING of this request.In accordance with law, when the subject is of widespread and exceptional media interestand the information sought involves possible questions about the government's integritythat affects public confidence Expedited Processing is permitted. In this instant case theoverwhelming concern of the American public concerning both the eligibility of BarackObama to be President as well as the large number of questions about the government'sintegrity in vetting President Obama.In addition the recent (and apparently well founded) allegations that the US Governmenthas "Spoliated" records from the US State Department passport records of the President'smother, Stanley Ann Dunham has put the public trust and integrity of its government intoquestion.The public had been waiting for over 1?h ears for a response to a FOIA request byChristopher Strunk to the State Department and Homeland Security. The request toHomeland security is similar to the above request, but produced a response fkom CBPthat the travel records and documents prior to 1982 were destroyed and not archived.(Attachment 1 - Pullo Declaration) Additionally the State Department unbelievably statedthat they were unable to locate Stanley Ann Dunham's passport applications prior to1967 and that they were likely destroyed in the 1980's. Incredulously, as the keeper ofthe records, and they don't know if they were destroyed or not?!? This, in and of itself,raises serious questions of trust and integrity in the government. See Roblin letter as well


33/35

as 1984 memo referencing "purging" and destroying passport applications prior to 1968.(Attachment 2 - Roblin letter)Ironically the State Department on their website advertises Passport services to "search"their records from 1925 to the present for you for a fee of either $50 for your own recordsor $150 for third party records. (The price was just increased on or about 08/13/10) TheState Department has no notice that records before 1968 "may" have been destroyed in apurge in the 1980's and it seems either they maintain the records they claim (and theNational Archives also claims the State Department has) or they are unfairly advertising aservice for sale that they likely don't have. Who is one to believe? On one hand the StateDepartment makes the claim that passport records before 1968 don't exist and aredestroyed. On the other hand the National Archives, Passport Services of the StateDepartment, the Federal Register claim that passport records prior to 1968 do exist and infact are held by the State Department. My own experience in requesting passport recordsunequivocally support the fact that passport records before 1968 do in fact exist and areheld by the State Department. (Attachment 3 - Jacobsen affidavit)In addition he public trust in FOIA had been diminished by the recent revelation thatthese requests are being monitored and appear to be delayed and in some cases therequestors are vetted before hlfilling the request. (Attachment 4 - AP article)The President of the United States is a public figure and a recent CNN poll taken July20 10 showed that 27% of the Americans polled probably or definitely believe PresidentObama was born in another country. In addition the poll showed 29% of those polledbelieved Obama was probably born in the US and only 42% believed Obama wasdefinitely born in the US, (Attachment 5 - CNN poll)It is apparent that the public has serious questions about the integrity of the USGovernment relating to the eligibility of President Obama and the possible destruction ofthe few documents available that could shed light on the President's eligibility and familyhistory. The documents I have requested herein all concern his family and are believed tocontain information that could help determine his eligibility or ineligibility to the officeof President. In addition, by Expedited Processing of my request, it will quickly helpshow the American public that the above records have not been destroyed, tampered withor compromised and that the integrity of the National Archives is intact and free fromunlawhl political tampering. The records I am requesting were collected by ImmigrationOfficers paid for by taxpayers and the records are in the National Archives which wasfounded and paid for by taxpayers. These records belong to the people of the UnitedStates and not to the government. Additionally, many of these records are alreadyunrestricted and many are fast approaching the 50 year time limit for release fromrestricted to unrestricted. Expedited Processing of this request will of course put therequest to the head of the FOIA list, but it will eliminate what I believe will be a flood ofrequests and scouring of the National Archives in the near w r e n a mob scene


34/35

compared to the storming of the Bastille. The American people have waited for over 1?4years to obtain similar information and should not be expected to wait any longer. Justicedelayed is justice denied.In addition I believe the future savings in time and cost to the government will besubstantial by promptly processing this request and allowing this information toexpeditiously be released to the public.If ever a FOIA request deserves expedited processing this request does or the procedureis meaningless and merely a regulation to be ignored.I am willing to pay up to $100.00 for the requested records, if the estimate should behigher please contact me. I am an individual seeking information for non-commercial useand it is my intent to widely and publicly publish the response(s) I receive.I am requesting a waiver of fees for the following reasons:1. I will release the records publicly upon receipt. They are being requested for non-commercial reasons, but for public consumption.2. The release of these records goes to the core of the integrity of the government tomaintain and keep free from tampering nationally important documents.3. I have expertise and a thorough understanding of these documents and canproperly present them to the public. (see Jacobsen affidavit)4. Disclosure will lead to a better understanding of the government, its variousoperations, including the Immigration and Naturalization Service (CBP) and includingthe function, necessity and importance of the National Archives. It will bring the NationalArchives to the forefront of the current public debates and hopefully that attention will befavorable.In accordance with FOIA requirements, I certify that my statements concerning the needfor expedited processing are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief.Thank you kindly for your diligent consideration of my request.

P-$,.Philip H. acobsenAttachment 1- Pullo declarationAttachment 2 -Roblin letterAttachment 3 - Jacobsen AffidavitAttachment 4 -AP articleAttachment 5 - CNN poll


35/35

U.S.DistrictCourtfortheDistrictofColumbia

Strunk v DOS et al.DCD08-cv-2234(RJL)CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

OnAugust26,2010,I,ChristopherEarlStrunk,underpenaltyofperjury

pursuantto28USC1746,causedtheserviceofacopyofthePlaintiffsSECOND SUPPLEMENT DECLARATION IN OPPOSITION TODEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT TO DISMISS signedAugust25,2010withsupportingexhibits11through12annexedtheretothat

asacompletesetwasplacedinasealedfolderproperlyaddressedwith

properpostageservedbyUSPSmailupon:

BrighamJ.BowenTrialAttorneyUnitedStatesDepartmentofJustice

CivilDivision,FederalProgramsBranchP.O.Box883,20MassachusettsAve.,N.W.Washington,D.C.20044

Idodeclareandcertifyunderpenaltyofperjury:Dated:August____,2010AlbemarleCountyVirginia__________________________

Christopher-Earl:Strunkinesse593VanderbiltAvenue#281BrooklynNewYork11238

(845)901-6767Email:[email protected]