state-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, and ... · why arrays? techniques...

28
State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, Nick Smith PassiveX Pty. Ltd. And useful application for mineral exploration

Upload: others

Post on 30-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology,

Nick Smith PassiveX Pty. Ltd.

And useful application for mineral exploration

Page 2: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

l  Microtremor wavefield l  Why use arrays? l  Array techniques l  State of the art methodology l  Applications

Overview

Page 3: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Microtremor Wavefield

Microseism

Microtremor

Central Australia North Chile Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Page 4: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Surface Waves

Time

Offset

Surface waves Decay = 1/r

Body waves Decay = 1/r2

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Page 5: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Surface Waves

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Bensen et.al. (2007)

Page 6: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Surface Waves

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Love Waves Rayleigh Waves

Depth

Sensitivity

10 Hz

5 Hz

1 Hz

Page 7: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Surface Waves

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Surface wave phase velocity sensitive to seismic

velocity structure (Vp, Vs and Density) l  Most sensitive to Vs l  Vs insensitive to fluids (e.g. groundwater)

Page 8: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Why Use Arrays?

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

l  Fundamental information on cover! −  Cover +/- bedrock velocity structure −  Stratigraphic variability

Page 9: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Array concepts: l  Seismic interferometry

—  Retrieve coherent wavefield propagating between

two sensors —  Greens function

l  Array beamforming —  Delay and sum, power distribution

—  Wavefield composition, directionality and velocity

Page 10: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

SPAC l  Circular array, 4+ sensors l  Ave. coherency for sensor pairs l  Independent of wavefield directionality l  Surface wave dispersion

l  Shear-wave velocity vs depth.

Page 11: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

SPAC l  Cross correlation / coherency

l  Isotropic wavefield OR azimuthal average

Azim. Ave. coherency

Coh

eren

cy

Frequency

Coherency

Page 12: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

SPAC

l  Sensor separation → wavelength sensitivity

r1 r2

r3 r4

Page 13: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

FK

l  Complex array design, 10+ sensors

l  Array beamforming

l  Wavefield characterisation

l  Velocity vs depth

Page 14: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

FK

l  Array design and array response

Kennett, et.al. (2015)

Page 15: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

FK

l  Array response steering by coherent signal

— Basic concept: delay and sum of signals

—  In practise: calculate power for different

combinations of back azimuth and slowness

Page 16: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

PSAR SQspa

Kennett, et.al. (2015) FK

Page 17: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Gal, et.al. (2014)

FK

Page 18: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

State of the art methodology

l  Three component constraints

Love Waves Rayleigh Waves

Depth

Sensitivity

Page 19: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

State of the art methodology

l  Inversion techniques

—  e.g. Neighbourhood Algorithm

—  e.g. Markov Chain Monte Carlo NA Velocity versus Depth

Page 20: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

State of the art methodology

l  Markov Chain Monte Carlo

—  Bayesian inference

—  Correct propagation of uncertainty into modelling

result

—  Does not require explicit regularisation or

parameterisation

—  Trans-dimensional

Page 21: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Array Techniques

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

State of the art methodology

l  Markov Chain Monte Carlo

Bodin, et.al. (2012)

Page 22: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Applications

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Turning noise into signal is really interesting

BUT….. Why is this important for mineral exploration?

Page 23: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Applications

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

1.  Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for

greenfields passive seismic work

2.  Assessment of the changeability of “1)” throughout the project area

3.  Assessment of complex geology

4.  Assessment of complex wave propagation phenomena for best modelling results

Page 24: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Applications

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

1) and 2): Average Vs variation

- H/V resonance frequency depth conversion

- Geological structure

Page 25: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Applications

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

3) Complex geology

- Multiple large impedance contrasts

- Velocity inversion El

liptic

ity

Azi

. Ave

. Coh

Depth (m

)

50

150

Stra

tigra

phy

500 1500

SPAC SPAC + H/V

Vs (m/s) Frequency (Hz)

Page 26: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Applications

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

4) Complex wavefield - Higher modes - Sites with large Vs contrasts, or velocity reversals - Source characteristics

n = 1 n = 2 n = 4

niV < ni+1

V < ni+2V...

Page 27: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Applications

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Higher modes SPAC using model based “effective mode” and amplitude response for assumed harmonic vertical point sources

Ikeda, et.al. (2012)

Page 28: State-of-the-art in passive seismic array methodology, And ... · Why arrays? Techniques Applications 1. Shear wave velocity vs depth profiles for greenfields passive seismic work

Summary

Overview Wavefield Why arrays? Techniques Applications

Passive seismic arrays are not just interesting... They are also useful for: l  Characterising the wavefield l  Characterising the geology l  Validating assumptions And are critical for l  Accurate and adaptive large scale passive seismic

surveying