stage metalevel subjekt mind rules friedrich lachmayer ljubljana, 15th march 2007 structural...
TRANSCRIPT
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Friedrich LachmayerLjubljana, 15th March 2007
Structural Visualization of
the Pure Theory
of Law
Structural Visualization of
the Pure Theory
of Law
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
HistoricalPosition
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheory
19341
19602
19341
19602
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
very relevantParadigmatical
Change
of Legal Theoryand
Juridical Methodology
PureTheory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheory
NewJuridical
Methodology
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheory
New Termsand Concepts
NormBasic Norm
Hierarchy of NormsLegal Act
….
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheory
a great Intensityof the Text
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheory
a great Intensityof the Text
combined with a very clear Pre-textual
Imagination
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheoryNLD
Natural LawDoctrineNatural LawDoctrine 1970 Rene Marcic
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheoryNLD
Natural LawDoctrineNatural LawDoctrine 1970 Rene Marcic
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheory L Log.
LegalLogicLegalLogic
1951 Deontic Logic
Georg Henrik von Wright
Ilmar TammeloOta Weinberger
Jürgen RödigHajime Yoshino
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
PureTheory L Inf.
LegalInformatics
LegalInformatics
1970 Herbert FiedlerLeo Reisinger
Alfred SchrammErich Schweighofer
Roland TraunmüllerMaria Wimmer
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
of Lawof Law
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Stage
Metalevel
Rules
„Ought“(Sollen)
„Ought“(Sollen)
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Stage
Metalevel
Rules
„Is“(Sein)
„Is“(Sein)
„Ought“(Sollen)
„Ought“(Sollen)
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Stage
Metalevel
Rules
StageStage
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Stage
Metalevel
Facts
Rules
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Facts
HumanAction
Rules
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Facts
Rules
HumanAction
ConditionsBehavior
Consequences
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Is (Sein)
3 Kinds of Interpretation:
•Facts•Norms•Texts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Is (Sein)
1.Interpretation
of Factual Reality
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Interpretation
Situation, Facts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Terms
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Terms
Modal Indifferent Substratum
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Impositionof Meaning
Deutung
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Is/Sein
FactsFacts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Is/Sein
Legal Interpretationof Facts
Legal Interpretationof Facts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Facts
not interpreted Facts(only colour, no lines)
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
subjectiveinterpreted Facts
subjektive Meaning/Sinn
subj. Interpretation/
Deutung
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
objektive Meaning/Sinn
Seinobjective
interpreted Facts
Basic Norm
Legal Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Facts
not interpreted Facts(only colour, no lines)
subjectiveinterpreted Facts
subjektive Meaning/Sinn
subj. Interpretation/
Deutung
objektive Meaning/Sinn
Seinobjective
interpreted Facts
Basic Norm
Legal Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Is (Sein)
2.Interpretationof Legal Acts
(„Container“)
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Substratum: Normative Content
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Interpretation
Substratum: Normative Content
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Interpretation
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Interpretation Reaction
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Interpretation Reaction
Norm
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Basic Norm
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Basic Hipothesis
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Concept of Basic Norm
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
1. Interpretation of Facts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Basic Norm
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
2. Interpretation of Norms
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Is (Sein)
3.Interpretationof Legal Texts
(„Content“)
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Legal TextLegal Text
§§§§§§§§§
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Legal TextLegal Text
§§§§§§§§§
Interpretation of the Content
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Legal TextLegal Text
§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
Interpretation of the Content
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Is (Sein)
Synthesis of the3 Kinds of Interpretation:
Subsumption
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Sein
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Sein
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
§§§§§§§
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Sein
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
§§§§§§§
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Sein
Su
bsu
mp
tion
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
§§§§§§§
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Sein
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
§§§§§§§
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Decisio
n
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Conceptof Norm
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
pre-scriptive
Human Being
Norm: To Do
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Behavior: To Do
Norm: To Do
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Status: To Be
Norm: To Be
Giovanni Sartor
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Double-Norm
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Condition
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
ReactionCondition
Hypothetical Norm
if then
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
To Do
Kategorical Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
FinalityReactionCondition
another Concept (Luhmann)
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Hierachyof Norms
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Constitution
Law
Statute
Decision
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Constitution
Law
Statute
Decision
Basic Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Constitution
Law
Statute
Decision
International Law
Basic Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Constitution
Law
Statute
Decision
EU Secundary Law
EU Primary Law
International Law
Basic Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Constitution
Law
Statute
Decision
Private Treaty
EU Secundary Law
EU Primary Law
International Law
opinio iuris
Concept of Basic Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Constitution
Law
Statute
Decision
Private Treaty
EU Secundary Law
EU Primary Law
International Law
Basic Norm
Hegemonial Law
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Norm-Monism
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
The legal order exclusively consists
of norms
Norm
Norm Norm Norm
Norm Norm
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Legal definitions are only part of other
norms
Norm Definition
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
another Concept:it is possible, that
there are other Legal Elements too
Legal Norm
IndicativeLegal Sentences
Legal Signs
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Purification(Deconstruction)
of Ideology
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Situation, Facts
Meaning („Sinn“)
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
1. Interpretation of Facts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Basic Norm
Interpretation Reaction
NormScheme ofInterpretation
Meaning:Valide Legal Act
2. Interpretation of Norms
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Legal TextLegal Text
§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§§
Interpretation of the Content
3. Interpretation of Texts
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Approachof Purification
Deconstruction
Traditional Concepts of
Law
4. Critical Interpretation of other Theories
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Approachof Purification
deconstructed
Traditional Concepts of
Law
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Traditional Concepts of
Personality
Person
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Approachof Purification
Person
Person: only a Quantityof Rights and Duties
deconstructed
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Traditional Concepts of
Institutions
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Institutions: only Norms
Norm
Norm
Norm
Norm
Norm
Norm
Norm Norm
deconstructed
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Traditional Concepts of
State
State
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
State
Approachof Purification
State = Personification
deconstructed
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
but on the contrary
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Personificationof JurisprudencePersonification
of Jurisprudence
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Pure TheoryPure Theory
Personificationof JurisprudencePersonification
of Jurisprudence
Approachof Purification?
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Thank youfor your Attention
Lachmayer @ chello.at
Stage
Metalevel
Subjekt
Mind
Rules
Lachmayer @ chello.at