7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

1/27

"

#$%&'() *+,-%.

/+0+1 2%+3-1 +(3 4%$506

/%7 8'96+-: 8+(3-:*%$)%-;;' 06+(& /'+(+ N+%-5 $M**>1 C:+( 8+?:3'( $M 2-:-4-$)%+,6=1 L0-

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

2/27

E

!" $%&'()*+&,(%

C; R7L7 0%+3- (-)$0'+0$%; -@J+%& $( 3';9?;;'$(; $*T +(3 06- 2%+(;U*+9'M'9 *+%0(-%;6', S2**T1 '0 '; ;-:MU

-(

4$$3; C(3 L-%

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

3/27

G

+J$?0 '(0-%(+0'$(+: 0-:-9$@@?('9+0'$(; ;-%2R $(:=

9$::-90 M%+)@-(0+%= ;0+0';0'9; $( 9%$;;UJ$%3-% 3+0+ M:$5;1 06$?)6 06-= +%- ,?00'()

@$%- -MM$%0 '(0$ -;0'@+0'() ;?96 M')?%-;7 "

N%$;;UJ$%3-% 3+0+ M:$5; 6+(0-%(+0'$(+:2-:-9$@@?('9+0'$(; R('$(1 EF"E1 600,.cc5557'0?7'(0c>2RU/c'90c,?J:'9+0'$(;c'3'c@+0-%'+:cEF"Ec8>LEF"Ed5'06$?0dC((-Yd[7,3MEV4:$J+: O+(35'306 B-;-+%96 L-%

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

4/27

[

EF"E1 +99$%3'() 0$ M')?%-; M%$@ 2-:-4-$)%+,6=7 8-+(56':- '@,$%0; +(3 -Y,$%0; $M

)$$3; +(3 ;-%(;0'0?0'$(7G VI$% '(;0+(9-1 06- +J':'0= 0$ 3$5(:$+3 ,?%96+;-;

$(0-%(-0 +(3 06- 3-

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

5/27

D

$%')'(+:

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

6/27

i

-" ./01*'/2/%& $11*/1 3,&4 5'(1167(')/' 80&0 9:(31

26- R7L7 O?%-+? $M _9$($@'9 C(+:=;'; SO_CTh06- ;0+0';0'9+: +)-(9= '( 96+%)- $M

0%+9&'() ;-%

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

7/27

n

I')?%- "7 L-%

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

8/27

K

C _?%$,-+( 0--(+)-% (0-%(-0 ;-%

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

9/27

`

'(0-%96+()- J-05--( 06- R7L7U$5(-3 (-05$%& +(3 M$%-')( (-05$%& ,6=;'9+::= $99?%;

'( 06- RQ7 i

>; 06-%- +( -Y96+()- $M @$(-= J-05--( 06- R7L7p$5(-3 +(3 06- M$%-')(U$5(-3

(-05$%&j ^$0 (-9-;;+%':=7 P+%)- (-05$%&; +%- $M0-( 9$((-90-3 J=7##'()*1 56'96 ';

+( +)%--@-(0 0$ -Y96+()- 0%+MM'9 5'06$?0 -Y96+()'() @$(-=7 *--%'() +)%--@-(0;

+%- ;$ ?J'f?'0$?; 06+0 06-= +%- J+;'9+::= 9$(3?90-3 $( + 6+(3;6+&-1 +; $(-

+?06$%'0+0'IBL.2-:-9$@;W1 Q*841 X+(?+%= EF"F7

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

10/27

"F

^$5 :-0b; 0?%( 0$ 06- ;-9$(3 -Y+@,:-1 06- _?%$,-+( 0--(+)-% +99-;;'() + 0 '; f?'0- ,$;;'J:- 06+0 06- _?%$,-+( 0--(+)-% 5':: J- 3$5(:$+3'() + 9$,=

$M 06- ( 06+0 9+;-1 +0 ;$@- ,$'(0 06- (0-%(+: 0%+3-7 8?:0'(+0'$(+:; @+'(0+'( + 9$(;0+(0 M:$5 $M 3+0+ +@$() 06-'%

:$9+0'$(;1 ;?,,:'-%; +(3 9?;0$@-%; '( 3'MM-%-(0 9$?(0%'-;7 I'(+(9'+:

9$@,+('-;1 M$% -Y+@,:-1 +%- 9$(0'(?$?;:= -Y96+()'() 3+0+ J-05--( ^-5

`L-- +:;$ B=+( L'()-:1 V\$?2?J-b; O+(35'306 O':: >; q-%$7 #-:9$@- 0$ 06- ^-5 ^-01W"Fc"icEFF`1 600,.cc55575'%-379$@cJ?;'(-;;cEFF`c"Fc=$?0?J-UJ+(35'306c

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

11/27

""

\$%&1 P$(3$(1 +(3 $06-% M'(+(9'+: 9-(0-%;7 /-,-(3'() $( 06- ;-0?,1 06-;-

9$((-90'$(; @+= -'06-% ?;- 06- ,?J:'9 >(0-%(-0 $% + 9$(0%+90 5'06 + @+e$%

,%$

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

12/27

"E

( 06- R('0-3 L0+0-;1 06- $%')'(+0$% $M +( '(0-%(+0'$(+: ,6$(- 9+:: ,'9&-3?, + 0-:-,6$(-1 3'+:-3 F""1 06- 9$?(0%= 9$3- +(3 ,6$(- (?@J-%1 +(3 ,+'3 +('(0-%(+0'$(+: 96+%)- 0$ 6'; $% 6-% ,6$(- 9$@,+(=7 26- ,%$(3?;0%=W INN1 C?)?;0 "``K600,.cc0%+(;'0'$(7M997)$(0:c'0:0%3`K7,3MT

B-+3'() 06'; -Y,:+(+0'$(1 6$5-

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

13/27

"G

C" D%(&4/' E0= (@ ./01*',%? 5'(1167(')/' 80&0 9:(31

#- 9+( ;-- M%$@ 06- ,%-2R ($0-;.

R;'() 06- ?('M='() @-0%'9 $M J'0; ,-% ;-9$(31 -@,:$=-3 M$% @-+;?%'() ):$J+:0-96($:$)'9+: 9+,+9'0= 0$ 9$@@?('9+0-1 '0 '; ,$;;'J:- 0$ 9$@,+%- 3'MM-%-(09$@@?('9+0'$( 0-96($:$)'-;7 >0 '; +:;$ ,$;;'J:- 0$ +(+:=g- J'0; ,-% ;-9$(3 ,-%

9+,'0+1 ,-% 0-96($:$)=1 ,-% 9$?(0%= $% ,-% +(= $06-% %-:-2RU/c'90c,?J:'9+0'$(;c'3'c@+0-%'+:cEF"Ec8>LEF"Ed5'06$?0dC((-Yd[7,3M

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

14/27

"[

I$% 06- ,?%,$;-; $M 06'; ,+,-%1 3+0+ M:$5 '; @-+;?%-3 '( 0-%+J'0; ,-% ;-9$(3 S2J,;T7

L?J@+%'(- 9+J:- '; ?;-3 0$ 9+%%= 9%$;;UJ$%3-% 3+0+ M:$5 +9%$;; $9-+(; J?0 +:;$ $M0-(

J-05--( 9$?(0%'-; $( 06- ;+@- 9$(0'(-(01 J-9+?;- '0b; $M0-( -+;'-% +(3 ;+M-% 0$

@+'(0+'( 9+J:-; 06+0 %?( +:$() 06- 9$+;0 ?(3-%5+0-% 06+( +9%$;; 3'MM'9?:0 0-%%+'(7

N+J:-; +%- 0=,'9+::= :+'3 5'06 @?:0',:- ;0%+(3; $M $,0'9 M'J-%1 ;$@- $M 56'96 +%- l:'0b

+(3 6+(0-%(-0 9+,+9'0= '( EF"E1 5'06

+( +; 06'; (0-%(-0 +(3 >*0%+MM'9 '( 06- R('0-3 L0+0-; +0 K -Y+J=0-; ,-% @$(06 +(3 "G -Y+J=0-; ,-% @$(061

%-;,-90'

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

15/27

"D

"ia $M R7L7 >(0-%(-0 +(3 >* 0%+MM'91 %-;,-90'

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

16/27

"i

2+J:- ". N%$;;UO$%3-% /+0+ I:$5;

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

17/27

"n

^$51 06-;- (?@J-%; +%- +99$@,+('-3 J= ;?J;0+(0'+: +(3 5$%%';$@- 9+(0-%(+0'$(+: >(0-%(-0 9+,+9'0=1 +; -;0'@+0-3 J= 2-:-4-$)%+,6=1

6+; J--( )%$5'() +0 +:@$;0 DFa ,-% =-+%7 /$@-;0'9 R7L7 >(0-%(-0 0%+MM'9 +;

,%$e-90-3 J= N';9$1 6+; J--( )%$5'() %$?)6:= +; M+;07 C; + %-;?:01 9+:9?:+0'()

9%$;;UJ$%3-% 3+0+ M:$5; +; + ;6+%- $M >(0-%(-0 0%+MM'9 9+( J- 6-+'/11,(% 20= ),1&('& &4/ 1&0&,1&,+1. #'3-;,%-+3 +(3 )%$5'() ?;- $M

9$@,%-;;'$( @-+(; 06+0 V5- 9$@@?('9+0- +%$?(3 06%-- 0'@-; @$%-

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

18/27

"K

'(M$%@+0'$( 06%$?)6 06- ;+@- '(;0+::-3 '(M%+;0%?90?%- +; 5- 3'3 '( "`Ki7WE"

26- 3'%-90'$( $M J'+; '; ?(9-%0+'(7

#- 9+( 9+:9?:+0- '(0-%%-)'$(+: 9%$;;UJ$%3-% 3+0+ M:$5; +; + ;6+%- $M >(0-%(-0 0%+MM'9

M$% _?%$,-7 2-:-4-$)%+,6= -;0'@+0-3 06+0 '(0-%(+0'$(+: J+(35'306 '( _?%$,- 5+;

Di7D 2J,; '( EF"E1 J?0 06+0 nK ,-%9-(0 $M 06+0 J+(35'306 5+; J-05--( 9'0'-; '( 06-

;+@- %-)'$(7 C; + %-;?:01 V'(0-%%-)'$(+: '(0-%(-0 9+,+9'0= 9$((-90-3 0$ _?%$,-W

-f?+:-3 "E7i 2J,; '( EF"E7 O+;-3 $( 06'; M')?%-1 5- 9+:9?:+0- 06+0 9%$;;UJ$%3-% 3+0+

M:$5; J-05--( _?%$,- +(3 06- %-;0 $M 06- 5$%:3 -f?+:-3 "ia $M 06- %-)'$(b;

>(0-%(-0 0%+MM'9 +(3 "Ga $M 06- %-)'$(b; >* 0%+MM'97

26-;- %-;?:0;1 56'96 ;6$?:3 J-

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

19/27

"`

O?0 9%$;;UJ$%3-% 3+0+ M:$5; 3$(b0 5$%& 06- ;+@- 5+=7 /+0+ 9+( J- 3?,:'9+0-3

%-:+0'M + R7L7 ?('@,%$

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

20/27

EF

26- ;-9$(3 '; 06- @+Y'@?@ ,%'9- *9+0 06+0 +( C@-%'9+( 5$?:3 ,+= M$%

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

21/27

E"

56-%- * '; 06- ,%'9- $M 9+0 ( M+901 + J-00-% +,,%$+96 '; %$?)6:= +(+:$)$?; 0$ 06- ,%$9-3?%- ?;-3 0$ 9+:9?:+0-

96+'(U5-')60-3 4/* )%$5067 #- 0+&- 06- )-$@-0%'9 +

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

22/27

EE

>( %-+:'0=1 +:: 06'(); J-'() -f?+:1 06- ;+@- 3+0+ 6+; + 6')6-% %-:+0'

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

23/27

EG

L$ 06- %-;,$(;- 0'@-1 M%$@ 4-%@+(= 0$ 06- I-3-%+: B-;-%( /-9-@J-% EF"E1 :+0-(9= +(0-%(-0 +%- @$%- $% :-;; '@@?(- 0$ :+); +(3 3';0+(9-7 I$%

-Y+@,:-1 -@+':h$(- $M 06- -+%:'-;0 >(0-%(-0 +,,:'9+0'$(;UU'; +;=(96%$($?;7 26+0

@-+(; =$? 9+( ;-(3 '01 +(3 =$? 3$(b0 -Y,-90 +( '@@-3'+0- %-,:=7 H( + (-05$%&

E[600,.cc5557

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

24/27

E[

:-(0-%(-0 56-%- :$5 :+0-(9= +(3

6')6 %-:'+J':'0= +%- 3-;'%+J:- 96+%+90-%';0'9;7 I$% -Y+@,:-1 ;0%-+@'()

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

25/27

ED

P+0-(9= 9+( J- %-3?9-3 'M 9$@,+('-; '(2 M+9':'0'-;W

+%$?(3 06- ):$J-h9$(0-(0 3-:'

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

26/27

Ei

L-9$(31 '0b; ($0 (-9-;;+%= 0$ 9$(;0%?90 06-;- >2 M+9':'0'-; '( -( M+901 '0

@+= J- '(-MM'9'-(0 J$06 -9$($@'9+::= +(3 '( 0-%@; $M 06- (-05$%&1 ;'(9- ;?96 +

;0%+0-)= 5$?:3 J$06 %-f?'%- @$%- '(0 '; +:;$ 06- 9+;- 06+0 %-)?:+0'$(; 06+0 +%- ($0 -Y,:'9'0:= '(0-(3-3 0$ +,,:= 0$>(0-%(-0 0%+MM'9 -Y96+()- @+= 6+(0-%(-0 J?;'(-;;-; +%- :'&-:= 0$ +MM-90 06- 96$'9-$M 06- :$9+0'$(; M$% '(

7/27/2019 SSRN-id2241302

27/27

5+::'() $MM 06-'% (-05$%&; M%$@ 06- %-;0 $M 06- 5$%:37 8$%-$0 J$$;0; J$06 9$(;?@-% 5-:M+%- +(3 '((3--31 06- )+'(; M%$@ 0%+3- '( 3+0+ +%- 06- ,?%-;0 M$%@ $M + J%$+3J+(3 J$(?;1 ;'(9-

9$?(0%'-; 06+0 -Y96+()- 3+0+ 9+( 5'( 5'06$?0 +(=$(- :$;'()7

I%$@ 06+0 ,-%;,-90'